Brigitte Macron awarded damages over false trans claim • FRANCE 24 English
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2024
- A court has ordered two women to pay €8,000 in damages to French First Lady Brigitte Macron, after they made false claims that she was transgender. Macron filed a libel complaint against two women who posted footage alleging that she'd once been a man named 'Jean-Michel'. FRANCE24's Sharon Gaffney speaks to Flora Bolter, Co-director of the LGBTI+ Observatory at the Fondation Jean Jaures about Brigitte Macron's legal response.
#France #transphobia #Macron
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.c...
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on X (Twitter): f24.my/Xen
Browse the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
Discover our TikTok videos: f24.my/TKen
Get the latest top stories on Telegram: f24.my/TGen
Was Brigitte's brother in court to support his sister?
@@Aminah6623 He was suddenly announced dead and had a private funeral.
A simple DNA test would put the whole thing to rest! Would have put all these conspiracies to rest in minutes!
why should she play along and prove a buncho idiots wrong by succumbing to such humiliation as a dna test
How about Candace Owen? She is the loudest one out there saying it. Even made 100 000 pounds bet against Piers Morgan 😮
Like seriously. The evidence is so clear that she is transgendered. Take the time to read all the facts. He is a man. And it will literally take 2 seconds to prove she is not a man. Make a press conference with her and her brother. And everybody will shut their mouth. Where is her brother anyway? No trace of him so far? Sounds fishy
This is clearly a man
What about. Candace? She hasn't broken any laws in France and being awarded damages doesn't prove that Brigitte is not a man.
"She" is all man. They are evil.
@Aminah6623 true. Just as the ability to leave a comment is not proof of any intellectual capacity.
Far right, far right, far right. Change your record will you ffs.
She is a transgender . Not up for debate. The far left are strong supporters of transgender folks. The far left in the US are urging the American youth to CHANGE their gender. You need to due your due diligence, my friend.
Did the brother appear in any way at any time?
@@donjohnson5123 He suddenly announced dead and had a private funeral.
How did the court prove otherwise?
Brigitte Macron has children, she was born a woman (easy to prove from her birth certificate), then was pregnant and delivered children (easy to prove from their birth certificates, DNA and the countless witnesses). How can you say something so stupid?!
@@VioletteToussaint C'est le niveau ici.
why do you care pervert
Good move!
Take them all to court.
He is a transgender person. Deal with it, people. Real due diligence has ALREADY been done. Catch up!!!
This has nothing to do with trans rights. They lied with intent to harm publicly, the criminals got off too light with 8k euros.
That is a man. No matter what this kangaroo court says
Transvestigations hurt cis women too. Slander doesn't work without obsessive haters and they are everywhere now.
She birthed babies, you unredeemable moron... @@RUTHLESSambition5
@@Scully331 she is trans. Everyone talks about it in the cafes of Paris.
they haven't been found guilty of saying Macron is a man as this court case wasn't about their claims of transgenderism !
I’m so glad she won this case! They did the same thing to Michelle Obama.
Big Mike?
@@sorayaassar1602 Don’t be confused. Not at all the same thing. She a woman and her DNA shows that. Why not just DNA TEST and that’s all.
@@IbaDoumbia-q2p
Why would anyone do a DNA test to prove to strangers their sex?
@@IbaDoumbia-q2p If you are accused of something it is incumbent on the accuser to prove their claims against you.
@@jnyfumare it is not your business if she is or she isn't. Live and let live. AKA mind your own business.
Fair play to her. Calling her trans was slander.
So, trans is a derogatory term? Isn't a trans woman basically a woman?
@@orca_ball No.
@@orca_ballno
@@orca_ball nope
Even if true?
Fake lawsuit:
Fake comment.
@@bootstrappedfriend1752 how is my comment fake if you are reading it? Are you slow?
@msstern3056 How is a lawsuit fake if it was filed and the plaintiff prevails?
@@l.w.paradis2108 she paid an 8,000 fine. Why isn’t France suing Xavier Poussard? Hes the man who OWNS the publication that printed the story Zavier worked on for over 3 years.
Xavier Poussard spent 3 years investigating the Macrons. Study photos, timelines. News articles. Yearbooks. He is the one who studied the macrons and published that she’s not a man.
Why do YOU think not one single person is suing Xavier Poussard????
@@l.w.paradis2108why aren’t they suing Xavier Poussard.
Also, this was a fine. Not a settlement. HUGE difference. 🤣🤣😂😂
Conspiracy theory = the predicted future denied by those leading the deception.
Far right = the average person with reasonable expectations in life.
Don’t they say the same about Obama’s wife.
Yep, they do.
What? Really? Ridiculous 😂 why would they think both women are trans? Cause they look masculine? They didn't tho.
@@naomiishida7366 Yeah they did, and they do the same for any perceived political enemies that don't fit their "beauty" standards. Meanwhile... Don Jr Trump, has a Drag Queen girlfriend, and they are totally fine with it!
Big Mike?
Yeah, y’all don’t know about Big Mike??
How did they PROVE the accusations wrong?
A birth certificate should do.
@@Sarappreciates that's not what I said.... How did they PROVE THE ACCUSATIONS WRONG? not what you think what did they SHOW IN COURT is way more important.
@@brandiclark7117 Like I said... A birth certificate in court should appease most normal people. What more proof could you want? Do you need an upskirt shot?
@@Sarappreciates clearly you have no idea what I'm saying. Who cares what YOU are giving as an example. Because that's obvious about a birth certificate. I want to know what Macron's attorneys showed for proof. Actual court recorded documents. Not you guessing.
@@brandiclark7117Then do the research. Go to a major law school library and ask for assistance.
This is about lying to the public. Show us ANY PHOTOS of you as a teenager or young adult. And also, why are you dating a 14 year old? This is what people want to know.
She birthed children....... Don't be lazy, go get the information yourself instead of asking to be spoonfed private information.
@@VioletteToussaint im assuming you delivered them then, how do you know she birthed them, surrogates do exist you know
She's a pedophile but that's allowed in France if you are amidst the powerful.
@@VioletteToussaintDid you deliver the babies or are you swallowing the lie ? The birth mother is probably dead. You are complicit by defending this pedopophile freak.
What rebuttal evidence did she provide to the court?
What evidence was presented to the court that she is trans?
I can assure you that she did not present a single pic of her brother that seems to have vanished from the planet when she came to be
it is not your business if she is or she isn't. Live and let live. AKA mind your own business.
@@gee_emm You have to prove something is false. The political court did not
@@KongSunWu Nope. You have to prove what you claim is NOT false, which they clearly failed to do. You can’t be found guilty of libel or slander if you can prove truth. You can have an opinion, but claiming your opinion is a fact is why people end up in court.
Is it a conspiracy theory that Bridgette was 40 years old when found to be having a relationship with a 15 year old student
No, but they haven’t denied that was when they met, when she was the advisor for the drama club he joined. Macron’s parents found out that he was pursuing her, and transferred him to another school and asked her not to see him until he was 18. His parents later accepted the relationship, which has been covered in many news articles and didn’t stop him from being elected president. But neither the couple nor Macron’s parents have ever said when their relationship became intimate. Although they met in the 1990s, they didn’t marry until 2007, a few years after she divorced the man she had been married to. The whole trans conspiracy theory is ridiculous, considering that she gave birth to 3 children with her first husband.
In France of course.
And then she left her husband and children to marry him 😐
So is a conspiracy theory that her brother Jean Michel is no where to be seen ..
Maybe he moved to Mars !
😂😂😂
@@herrschmitt9015 Is it also a conspiracy that she/he can't show old Photos of her when she was young?
Bravo, Madame Macron ! And down with all the sick minds of this country and others who create and spin such despicable rumours!
Sir, Macron
@@orca_ball Have you been to bed with her? Pathtic!!!
Mr.
The sick minds seem to be in your country more than in mine Monsieur or Madame micade. It was never about trans phobia .
@@pastqr Sure, Madam, sure! Which you, of course, could verify the last time you went to bed with her/him?
Awful blonde wig. I wear wigs from Temu & they look better than that blonde wig.
Agree
That’s something wrong about her or him choosing that wig now days, where there are ones incredible natural
Brigitte Macron look amazing!
She looks great .. .envi anyone😂 ?
@@gudrungarzon7083I enjoyed his performance in Planet of the Apes
It would have been bizarre for Madame Macron to work with a trans rights group on this lawsuit since she does not identify as trans. To do so would have been taken as confirmation of the accusation. People like Flora Bolter can sometimes be their own worse enemy. She should be more concern with the people who throw trans around as a slur.
She is a man.
She should be more concerned about children being influenced by such ideologies because children lack the capacity to understand such emotionally charged complicated biological/physiological issues, let alone removing genital body parts, stoping development, sterilization , being dependent on pharmaceuticals for life, right?
In that same line of thinking, heaven forbid any person would dare working for the rights of any group different than theirs because me or you or anyone involved is not actually or belongs to the segment or group of people we're fighting with or for ..
Oh boy your statement is so wrong !
Her going that far to defend herself as a female says actually quite the opposite 😉
How crazy are you? No limit?
Dude I don’t know who’s paying but it’s not working at all boy......
I am glad because it is wrong to pry into people's marriage, especially a head of state. They are legally married many years and appear happy. Human nastiness has gone overboard. It is just not civil or decent to make public gossip like that.
Like Brigitte left their family and pried into young Macron’s life?
@@bellejour559 Exactly, just a 14 year boy and she was in her 30s and his teacher! Disgusting.
Him vs Michael
Battle of the bulge
😂
Candace Owens should be the third woman sued for slander because, she interviewed and aired on her show, the French author who wrote about the allegations.
Show me a photo for her when she was young...
They will give you AI@@JolexHopeAlfanta
they haven't been found guilty of saying Macron is a man as this court case wasn't about their claims of transgenderism !
She just looks like her hair is taking over her body. There is too much of it.
I am glad. Prying and ripping at anyones wife is hideous behavior.
Absolutely not ! The court case was never about a claim about Brigitte Macron's gender !! That's plain bad journalism
Candace Owens left the chat.
Candace was willing to stake her career on this case. So her career is over?
@@Rogergirard03 no, not at all. Her career is based on controversies and forbidden truths.
@@enoughofthis She's a Trump supporter, isn't ? I fear she'll be disappointed again on November 5th.
@@enoughofthis There was nothing truthful about the video that was released about Mrs. Macron.
@@janegardener1662 maybe, but it was a controversial subject.
How does this proof anything without gyn doctor and dna test?
And also the whereabouts some of her brother Jean Michel ,that seemly vanished from the planet when she came to be …😅
This should stand as a warring to all those who insist on spreading false or misleading information That there's a price to pay
It is not false accusations
Why the couple Macron didn t say the truth?
If Brigitte Macron etait trans ,he/ elle must have said he / she is trans
8000 euro's is piss all
What's the warning?
they haven't been found guilty of saying Macron is a man as this court case wasn't about their claims of transgenderism !
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ludicrous !@@nildaaimini1954
I’m so glad she did it! As for LGBTQ rights, then Mrs Macron is a human, too, and as such is not a second class to them. If she does not want to be called by a particular word, her desire should be respected in the same way as LGBTQ activists expect their requests to be respected.
Candace Owen’s is on a serious downward spiral.
But nobody has disproven anything Candice has said. All y'all do is say baseless things like this.
No she's far from that.
@rahmanjoki9938 True. Anyone who can make money like she does is one of life's winners all right. Billions have to work to live. Not her.
@@hazelem1266 I can't provide a Photo so I'll sue you. 🤣
Suing was the perfect response
they haven't been found guilty of saying Macron is a man as this court case wasn't about their claims of transgenderism !
just goes to show how dumb and gullible a lot of people are to believe silly 2nd hand conspiracy theories
Only €8000? It should have been €8 million.
@@nsnopper It's France, not America, but I agree.
Because he IS transgender!!
Dude look like a lady 🎵🎵🎵🎵
It's clearly a dude.
She won on a technicality the woman wasn't sued for LYING read the court documents
Fake lawsuit!!!🤣😂😂😂😂😂
Well done!! Mrs Macron!!
Michelle Obama went through the same thing. How horrible...
Sue them all Mrs Macron!! People should never get away from spreading lies!
The new 1 - 8
OK the monkey is a female? It's an easy mistake to make with that thing.
HER HUSBAND DOES.
@@vicgallimore6756she is not responsible for her husband.
But the government is allowed to spread lies..... ?
Happy for Mme Macron. People should not be allowed to get away with abusing others. LGBQT communities should not be hurt by this. Mme Macron is correct to protect herself..
they haven't been found guilty of saying Macron is a man as this court case wasn't about their claims of transgenderism !
Lol! That is 100% a man! If she/he would just be honest, then the people wouldn't have an issue with him/her. When are y'all going to realize that the public is smarter than you give us credit for?? Sheesh! Just be honest!
The same type of people who spread rumors about people eating cats
So how did she debunk the conspiration theory? DNA test?
Why would they?
And how would they force a private citizen to do such a test?
Her birth certificate is more than enough proof, and there are plenty pictures and other pieces of evidence available of that woman throughout her life.
Ah ah ah... We believe you
What if I said I believe you're a trans man?How would you feel about it?
Where is her brother Jean Michel that seemly vanished from the planet when she came to be ?!?
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@surijosuperbabyicing. He won damages, too.
Awesome...the fact other people think and obsess over what's in or not in your pants, others bodies and what goes on in others bedrooms shows the true level of monkey in those who obsess....
It's a sickness really, that like any illness has to be treated...
Sweetie, he IS transgender.
Very intelligent people have ALREADY done the due diligence.
YOU just don’t know anything about it.
Good for her.
Well done, Brigitte ❤❤
Why not show DNA TEST??????
In France, DNA testing is only authorized for criminal cases and paternity investigations.
Exactly 💯
Because it would be labeled "a male ape that identifies as a human woman".
We want a DNA test for you too then. She doesn't owe you anything.
@@VioletteToussaint I’m not hiding or lying to myself and my people. Just show us as people we have a right to know. Why not are you scared 😱
Did she do a DNA test?
But why sue? If someone put out information to say I was born male, I can easily prove that is not the case. These rumours could have been put to rest a long time ago, no? Not sure how courts work, but I hope this court case wasn't funded by the taxpayer, when it could have easily been resolved.
Exactly, the discovery process should have had all kinds of historical evidence brought to light.
Birth announcement, child hood pictures, 3 children. What more proof do you need
No matter what you do, someone can say it's faked.
@@l.w.paradis2108 So is it also fake that she can't show Photos of her when she was young?
they haven't been found guilty of saying Macron is a man as this court case wasn't about their claims of transgenderism !
Free speach you say 😄
It left one person 😂😂 sue them all....
Just show the evidence to shut the rumors. Show the evidence, talk less.
Ok…
But after all when is her brother Jean Michel that seemly vanished from the planet when she came to be ?!?
He didn't vanish, he's simply not a public figure.
He was also awarded damages.
💯 this was Candice Owen’s.
Good news.
Pdf-file transferred
looks like a guy
Lol
So what? Appearance does not make sex.
@@Rogergirard03 The effects of testosterone are quite evident on male bodies and faces.
@@janegardener1662 Testosterone is not unique to males neither is estrogen to females
@@psylentrage They are at much different levels in males and females. The commenter also said nothing about estrogen, just that the effects of testosterone is evident on males bodies-was that incorrect?
France,journalists
A .edical examination for Brigitte Macron
@@nildaaimini1954 Why? Can we get a medical examination of you too? I'm sure you won't mind.
@@VioletteToussaint non ,it won t mind because Im not trans
LGTB are wrong
A man is born a man
A woman is born a woman
It s a desviation ,it isn t human nature
Pervesion
Why are there so many hateful comments here? I suspect Russian bots.
Truth hurts.
@@bellejour559
Yet they're spreading lies.
*Amazing video, you work for 40yrs to have $1M in your retirement, meanwhile some people are putting just $10K into trading from just few months ago and now they are multimillionaires*
Waking up every 14th of each month to 210,000 dollars it’s a blessing to I and my family… Big gratitude to Maria Frances Hanlon🙌
Same, I operate a wide- range of Investments with help from My Financial Adviser. My advice is to get a professional who will help you, plan and enhance your management skills. For the record, working with Maria Frances Hanlon, has been an amazing experience.
YES!!! That's exactly her name (Maria Frances Hanlon) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her 😊from Brisbane Australia🇦🇺
Hello how do you make such monthly?? I'm a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down 🤦♀️of myself because of low finance but I still
believe in God
I'm favoured, $290K every week! I can now give back to the locals in my community and also support God's work and the church. God bless America,, all thanks to Ms Maria Frances 😊🎉
Lol. Lol. All the comments are the same. Lol. Please. Now lol.
It would be very easy to disprove. Just have DNA tests on Brigitte's children to see if Emmanuel and Brigitte are their biological parents.
She refused
In French law, it is the accuser who must prove that the accusation is true, it is not up to the accused to prove that it is false.
Why the hell should their children have to do that? The person who accuses/claims something has to prove it.
Emmanuel is not the father, they're from her previous marriage.... You don't know much, do you?
@@benu_bird your acting like its a massive thing to send a hair, pee or spit in the post, if someone accused me of being the wrong gender i think its easier to disprove them rather than sue
Bravo, Madame Macron! Well done.
She is So cute 😘
I still believe it could be a he/she.
💯
@anaraquelmendoza4087 you sound like the maga cult, so sad.
If you pay attention in what they are saying , you realize that the lawsuit is about the invasion of her/ his privacy , and not about proving she is a woman .
Needless to say that also there is no mention about the whereabouts of her brother Jean Michel seemly vanished from the planet when she came to be…
Qu'est-ce qui ne va pas avec ça, pourquoi a-t-il été offensé ?
He/she that thing 😅
They
What has the far right got to do with this? 😂
It was the far right that spread the false information, otherwise it would have been known to only a few people.
Tres bien! Leave Brigitte alone!! She is such a beautiful, intelligent and class.
Is a really man
She is a woman.
She did not sure the author of the book that shows/claims she would be her own brother. Why did not she?
Love 😘❤️🔥💎🦁🤟
Why do you say far right it’s probably far left
No, it was far-right publications that spread the rumor.
@@Rogergirard03 Nobody should say those things about this woman
🙏
Cougar going after young kids
That's not what happened. He courted her, she refused, then he came back later as an adult when she was divorced and she finally accepted.
@@VioletteToussaint that’s still disgusting!!! How does that make it right knowing he was her student at some point🤢🤢that’s a pedophile
@ButterflyG673 No it isn't. Just like it isn't assault, it isn't murder, it isn't fraud.
You may consider it morally wrong. That doesn't make it p______lia.
She's not even beautiful 🤯🤠
Everyone has their own preferences.
She's 71 years old. Her early beauty has faded and she has a more mature look now.
Some women may find you unattractive. That's the problem with humanity ,I guess when you may think you are God's gift to women huh? Until one of them tell uh no thanks.
@@janegardener1662 according to you 71 years old married to a young man of 39 years this is a witchcraft that so menu abomination sexuality happening in france
@@Rogergirard03 wich preference Macron maybe he got a brand issues to married her old woman 👵 age of her grandmother ,,,,
Free democratic countries