Not long ago I saw an MSM review saying Tribal Island should have a chat so you can communicate with other Tribal members, and I couldn’t agree more bc I recently got kicked from a really good Tribe for forgetting to feed for a few weeks. If communication was a thing I could’ve told my Tribe I had exams and couldn’t guarantee I’d be able to participate for a few weeks.
legitimately the one thing I might want most is a gifting system. If you could by friend code send any person any amounts of different currencies. Big youtubers would ACTUALLY have a use for their thousands of keys and I'd be able to greatly help my own friends and viewers too who are either just starting or even a good way into the game.
I love love love the idea of a 15 minute songs featuring literally every monster! I’d like to think you’d be able to scroll through or skip parts to hear a certain section. Maybe some kind of menu like a hotel where you can turn on and off certain verses to customize the song even more?
I agree with an island with every monster and even cooler would be having to breed Every monster instead of teleporting and also the mess with epic wubboxs
The tiles do make the islands look nicer, and I hope they do add a feature were you can place mutiple tiles at once. That would be a life changer. And nice vid 👌
Im a bit late, but i personally think one of the bigger problems is feeding in general, DOF got the feeding mechanic done really nicely, besides the storage unit being a thing. If Msm just did a overhaul of the feeding mechanic in general itd be nice, since getting monsters to higher levels (especially on tribal) can take forever, and i heavily agree with gold island making currency, even thought it goes against the lore, if they do, do it then they should act like wublins.
Since you brought up rares and epics, I think the monster handlers should make them permanently breedable, but just make the chances for them much smaller. It sucks having to wait a long time in-between sales to breed certain monsters, so I feel that could fix that problem
One idea I had is that what if using a rare monster in a breeding combo had the chance to give you another rare? This way you could get as many rares as you want, but only after you get the first one through a sale.
I like your idea about using medals for breeding epics. The Collosingum just misses the mark. Also, do something with Shugabush Island! Rare Shugas would be nice, or some sort of Wubbox for the Shugasquad!
Anyone else think they should just get rid of the nursery? At this point all it does it wastes time. You should be able to breed a monster and instantly place it down, zap it, or sell it. Not that I see this happening though.
An Idea for the next MSM island(s) could be more magicals since air hasn't gotten a chance with the magical islands where just like Light Psychic Faerie and Bone Island, there would be 4 more islands with the fire triples opposite's elements so for example the opposite of Sooza is Scups like how the opposite of Mimic is Kayna. Because Light Island doesn't have Air Earth and Water the new Light Island would have Air Earth Water and Light instead of Plant Cold and Light. And this would continue with the other magical islands: Air Earth Cold Psychic Air Plant Water Faerie Air Plant Cold Bone
they should make paths change depending on the island skin since sometimes the bright grass and flowers don’t really match with a brown floor or the very daek green on spooktacle
I definitely think they should have another way to get Epics besides breeding or Diamonds. I have literally given up on expecting to get Epic Ethereals when I lost over 3k diamonds trying to breed Epic Jellbilly (and I didn't even get it). However, something they NEED to change is either breeding chances of Epics, or time they're available. More recent Epics have only been available for about 4 days which is not enough time to get an Epic considering their low chances. Especially when a failed Epic Ethereal breeding time is over a day. I also think Rare and Epic Seasonals need to be available for longer spans during their events. Like the Rare being available for the first half, and the Epic being available for the second. Seasonal variants aren't like other variants, if you don't get them, you have to wait 6 months where you have a weekend sale then you have another 6 months before you get another chance (there's also the short span during Anniversary Month, but you're probably preoccupied with the 100 other stuff that's available).
10:07 i think they could do the same thing with dipsters with the mirror island prices like 100x of the dipsters prices which would be like 300 diamonds for mirror haven and oasis each 600 diamonds for mirror magical islands(excluding sanctum) each 700 diamonds for mirror ethereal and sanctum each
I came up with the idea of every monster on one island, but i think the reason no one has done it is because it would take so much time, and to first compose something for such a monumental island is hard too, I’ve tried.
I'm working on one. The original version stopped being updated during Seasonal Shanty because I've improved a lot since then and I wanted to have more accurate sounds. But we're very slowly getting through the new version
The island with every monster on it is for sure something they’d do when the game reaches the end point before msm shuts down (heard it was shutting down on its 18th year but I hope it was just a false rumor ;-;)
At this point in the series, there’s not much they can really do with existing monsters. I’m hoping the next island is something completely brand new. Like, if they just kept reusing the same monsters over and over, it’d get old. I’d love to see them return, but only if it feels justified in some way. The pathing mechanic though does need to come, and having Gold Island produce currency would be great. Maybe the Crystal Castle could work like the Nexus Nebula, with each group of naturals and the Wubboxes increasing how many coins/diamonds you can earn.
The purchasing epics with medals idea is actually really good! When a Fire expansion monster gets an Epic variant they will have to pick/make a currency for them so we will just have to wait and see
Honestly, Idea I want to see would be the Mirror Fire and 'Magical' islands, but with the islands being actually unique islands So like in the mirror timeline, the magicals arent there, and instead we get the original fire islands (Yelmut, Edamimi, Krillby, Flum Ox) and then the fire islands become different Quad Islands, so like either Bisonorus and Tiawa if they want to use actually good quads, or PongPing and Incisaur if they want the fire islands to keep Tring-impact level Quads
I literaly managed to breed an epic entbrat on my 2nd try with no torches lit and I only used only rare versions of the monsters used to breed epic entbrat (also the same thing for epic scups and toe jammer)
The last time we got one was the dreamythicals. And those are just mythicals but more So the last time we got an actual class are magicals... And that was 5 years ago
I thinking abt making a post like this if I ever start a channel. But I you hit most of the bases I want. I want there to be an editing mode for tiles and decorations. Kinda like Bloons monkey city if you’ve ever played it. So like a mode where you can make monsters invisible (or less opaque ), temporarily store all of your decorations, and decorate as you please. And you won’t be able to buy decor in this mode so you’ll need to have it all out before you activate it. Also from my end you have a pretty good sub to like ratio. I think I was ur 200th subscriber so keep it up 👍🏾
Hey thanks man 😎. I didn't say in the video but I would hope they kind of do it like the base designer in Clash of Clans. Because thats how ive always imagined it! 🤷♂️
The island would have to be absolutely COLLOSAL (pun intended) and including rares and epics there would be well over 700 unique monsters on the island If you could breed monsters the island could be practically infinite 😨
yeah but I don't think breeding would work for an island like this, it means that new monsters will be created and I don't wnat them to be exclusif to this island I was thinking about teleportation like for gold island, and only with all the existent monsters in the game, all the naturals, fire monsters, ethereal, magical, wublins, mythical, celestials, just EVERY monsters and no rares or epics exept for the wubbox, this island would be all about the song I know this never gonna exist but that just would be AWSOME 5sorry for my bad english lol I'm french)
Here’s my ideas 1. Make new monsters fire expansion but bigger. 2. You guys want mimic on tribal Island but put him on Amber Island 3. Have a fan made monster contest.
They should make feeding monsters eaiser. Like feeding a tribal island monster to level 100+ is so tedious, and can take full minutes of spamming. Maybe by adding a slider, so you can skip straight to the level you want to feed them too.
I'VE GOT A THEORY every seasonal could be on 2 islands Not including Shanty Hoola: Air and Earth Gobblygourd: Haven and Oasis Vivine: Amber and Shugabush Jam boree is technically the seasonal of Shanty, Bro is on Gold too. But i wouldn't mind seeing Jam Boree again Anyway my point is The Magical Seasonals can go to Nexus, which would give them 2 islands AND If Ethereal Singular Islands come, then their seasonals could be the Core Seasonals (minus hoola) Plasma Island: Smoochle Shadow Island: Punkleton Mech Island: Blabbit Crystal Island: Yool? Poison Island: Carrillong, Spurrit, Or Jam Boree (could be swapped with blabbit) Sorry for yapping but thats my theory
To be honest, I interest to the addition monsters cause another monsters has arrived on Gold Island resolve for the conflict. Thank you for telling me about it.
I think they should keep both, colossingum gives a new way to play MSM, and tribal island has a nice song along with being able to get 20 diamonds and star power each week! (That’s if you decide to actually level up your monsters and you’re in a good tribe)
diamonds for epics would be way more reasonable since epic wubbox costs 1 gem similarly rare wubbox is one starpower and common wubbox is coins, making epics cost medals would break the pattern and medals should be used for something else
My editing software messed up my camera footage a bit! Will work on a fix, hopefully its not too distracting!!!
With that last idea, I've actually been thinking about doing this! I might attempt doing this sometime lol.
Not long ago I saw an MSM review saying Tribal Island should have a chat so you can communicate with other Tribal members, and I couldn’t agree more bc I recently got kicked from a really good Tribe for forgetting to feed for a few weeks. If communication was a thing I could’ve told my Tribe I had exams and couldn’t guarantee I’d be able to participate for a few weeks.
This would actually be an amazing feature!
@@BrockTalksMSM Yep! I’d personally also like to be able to visit the islands of other tribe members who aren’t in your friends list
Discord would have solved that, but in case you are not able to get it, that would be a fantastic idea
POV 12am: *Notification From MSM: Chat From MSMLover223*
Me: *Checks it*
The Chat: “Yo Which Of Yall Idiots Ain’t Feeding Yo Monster”
@@axen2yeah but how would you know that your tribe had a discord? I’ve been in the same tribe for 3 years and I know absolutely no one
"I'm not gonna take credit for the idea, but..."
*instantly takes credit for the idea*
According to lore stuff, gold island monsters do not produce currency because they don't care about material stuff, they just want to sing forever
That’s actually such a good excuse from the monster handlers
I think it is because when monsters dream they go their
legitimately the one thing I might want most is a gifting system. If you could by friend code send any person any amounts of different currencies. Big youtubers would ACTUALLY have a use for their thousands of keys and I'd be able to greatly help my own friends and viewers too who are either just starting or even a good way into the game.
I love love love the idea of a 15 minute songs featuring literally every monster! I’d like to think you’d be able to scroll through or skip parts to hear a certain section. Maybe some kind of menu like a hotel where you can turn on and off certain verses to customize the song even more?
I agree with an island with every monster and even cooler would be having to breed Every monster instead of teleporting and also the mess with epic wubboxs
Natural island
I wish there was a way to just light someones highlighted torches without having to go to the island
The tiles do make the islands look nicer, and I hope they do add a feature were you can place mutiple tiles at once. That would be a life changer. And nice vid 👌
Just steal it from TLL they already did it perfectly
Im a bit late, but i personally think one of the bigger problems is feeding in general, DOF got the feeding mechanic done really nicely, besides the storage unit being a thing. If Msm just did a overhaul of the feeding mechanic in general itd be nice, since getting monsters to higher levels (especially on tribal) can take forever, and i heavily agree with gold island making currency, even thought it goes against the lore, if they do, do it then they should act like wublins.
Since you brought up rares and epics, I think the monster handlers should make them permanently breedable, but just make the chances for them much smaller. It sucks having to wait a long time in-between sales to breed certain monsters, so I feel that could fix that problem
didn't rares used be i feel like i did breed a few a few years back
i personally disagree because it would be kinda unfair
@@BrandonIzCool3356why? Rares and epics grant no competitive advantage or anything 😭
I dont know about permanent but I would like to seem them more often!
One idea I had is that what if using a rare monster in a breeding combo had the chance to give you another rare? This way you could get as many rares as you want, but only after you get the first one through a sale.
Hope your channel explodes in popularity 😊
awesome video!! I loved the ideas
I like your idea about using medals for breeding epics. The Collosingum just misses the mark. Also, do something with Shugabush Island! Rare Shugas would be nice, or some sort of Wubbox for the Shugasquad!
Anyone else think they should just get rid of the nursery? At this point all it does it wastes time. You should be able to breed a monster and instantly place it down, zap it, or sell it. Not that I see this happening though.
An Idea for the next MSM island(s) could be more magicals since air hasn't gotten a chance with the magical islands where just like Light Psychic Faerie and Bone Island, there would be 4 more islands with the fire triples opposite's elements so for example the opposite of Sooza is Scups like how the opposite of Mimic is Kayna. Because Light Island doesn't have Air Earth and Water the new Light Island would have Air Earth Water and Light instead of Plant Cold and Light. And this would continue with the other magical islands:
Air Earth Cold Psychic
Air Plant Water Faerie
Air Plant Cold Bone
Would be cool!
I thought of that too! The names I thought of aren't very good, but:
Light Geode
Psychic Citadel
Faerie Swamp (NOT EVERGREEN MARSH BTW!)
Bone Taiga
@@CringusMcDingus psychic citadel... That sounds very familiar... Like from an expansion of the magicals... Hmmm
@@DragonTheOneDZA oh no, did I rip off something without knowing?
@@CringusMcDingusexact same roster of monsters too, what a coincidence!
Imagine a "faster UI" setting do you don't have to wait like 15 seconds to press a button whenever you want to move things.
they should make paths change depending on the island skin since sometimes the bright grass and flowers don’t really match with a brown floor or the very daek green on spooktacle
"There's no point to go to gold island"
Well brock, it's called "this is a game about music", you could try listening to the island's song
Yeah with that logic there’s no point in shugabush and mythical either considering the low amount of resources they yield
@Chuckles-9838 I agree for mythical but shugabush has a gem mine atleast
I definitely think they should have another way to get Epics besides breeding or Diamonds.
I have literally given up on expecting to get Epic Ethereals when I lost over 3k diamonds trying to breed Epic Jellbilly (and I didn't even get it).
However, something they NEED to change is either breeding chances of Epics, or time they're available. More recent Epics have only been available for about 4 days which is not enough time to get an Epic considering their low chances. Especially when a failed Epic Ethereal breeding time is over a day.
I also think Rare and Epic Seasonals need to be available for longer spans during their events. Like the Rare being available for the first half, and the Epic being available for the second. Seasonal variants aren't like other variants, if you don't get them, you have to wait 6 months where you have a weekend sale then you have another 6 months before you get another chance (there's also the short span during Anniversary Month, but you're probably preoccupied with the 100 other stuff that's available).
10:07 i think they could do the same thing with dipsters with the mirror island prices
like 100x of the dipsters prices
which would be like 300 diamonds for mirror haven and oasis each
600 diamonds for mirror magical islands(excluding sanctum) each
700 diamonds for mirror ethereal and sanctum each
Hopefully!
I came up with the idea of every monster on one island, but i think the reason no one has done it is because it would take so much time, and to first compose something for such a monumental island is hard too, I’ve tried.
👀
I'm cooking aren't I.
It's not released yet and probably won't for a while but...
That, without a doubt, won't happen. That's way too many monsters, and clashes with the lore.
I'm working on one. The original version stopped being updated during Seasonal Shanty because I've improved a lot since then and I wanted to have more accurate sounds. But we're very slowly getting through the new version
The island with every monster on it is for sure something they’d do when the game reaches the end point before msm shuts down (heard it was shutting down on its 18th year but I hope it was just a false rumor ;-;)
I had the idea for this use of the metals same as you the video was out first but I haven’t seen it also just bring the cool decor from the metal shop
At this point in the series, there’s not much they can really do with existing monsters. I’m hoping the next island is something completely brand new. Like, if they just kept reusing the same monsters over and over, it’d get old. I’d love to see them return, but only if it feels justified in some way. The pathing mechanic though does need to come, and having Gold Island produce currency would be great. Maybe the Crystal Castle could work like the Nexus Nebula, with each group of naturals and the Wubboxes increasing how many coins/diamonds you can earn.
The purchasing epics with medals idea is actually really good! When a Fire expansion monster gets an Epic variant they will have to pick/make a currency for them so we will just have to wait and see
I unfortunately think epic fire expansion will cost diamonds but they shouldn't and should cost meadlas
I agree with the final one! Like having all 300+ monsters from Naturals To Seasonals would be soooo cool! (it is a dream of mine too!)
Honestly, Idea I want to see would be the Mirror Fire and 'Magical' islands, but with the islands being actually unique islands
So like in the mirror timeline, the magicals arent there, and instead we get the original fire islands (Yelmut, Edamimi, Krillby, Flum Ox) and then the fire islands become different Quad Islands, so like either Bisonorus and Tiawa if they want to use actually good quads, or PongPing and Incisaur if they want the fire islands to keep Tring-impact level Quads
MSM obstacles should be instantly removed like DOF, just using diamonds or a little bit more expensive
I literaly managed to breed an epic entbrat on my 2nd try with no torches lit and I only used only rare versions of the monsters used to breed epic entbrat (also the same thing for epic scups and toe jammer)
Luck
I’m a huge fan of your videos you deserve the more subscribers!
Wow! You deserve more respect!
The main thing i want in msm is a new class its been years since we got one
That would be really cool, I wonder what that could be though!
The last time we got one was the dreamythicals. And those are just mythicals but more
So the last time we got an actual class are magicals... And that was 5 years ago
I thinking abt making a post like this if I ever start a channel. But I you hit most of the bases I want. I want there to be an editing mode for tiles and decorations. Kinda like Bloons monkey city if you’ve ever played it. So like a mode where you can make monsters invisible (or less opaque ), temporarily store all of your decorations, and decorate as you please. And you won’t be able to buy decor in this mode so you’ll need to have it all out before you activate it.
Also from my end you have a pretty good sub to like ratio. I think I was ur 200th subscriber so keep it up 👍🏾
Hey thanks man 😎. I didn't say in the video but I would hope they kind of do it like the base designer in Clash of Clans. Because thats how ive always imagined it! 🤷♂️
omg an everything monster island with every monster thats what i was thinking
There’s an island named “Monster Mongrove” that has around 200 monster
I loved watching this style of video! Maybe if you have more ideas or other do you can mention them in a part 2 :)Keep it up!
i always wanted an island with EVERY monsters on it, glad to see I'm not the only one who thinking about it
The island would have to be absolutely COLLOSAL (pun intended) and including rares and epics there would be well over 700 unique monsters on the island
If you could breed monsters the island could be practically infinite 😨
yeah but I don't think breeding would work for an island like this, it means that new monsters will be created and I don't wnat them to be exclusif to this island
I was thinking about teleportation like for gold island, and only with all the existent monsters in the game, all the naturals, fire monsters, ethereal, magical, wublins, mythical, celestials, just EVERY monsters
and no rares or epics exept for the wubbox, this island would be all about the song
I know this never gonna exist but that just would be AWSOME
5sorry for my bad english lol I'm french)
@@buzzingzzap I think without the monsters that don't change the music, this is totally plausible (:
Also don't worry your English is good
Here’s my ideas
1. Make new monsters fire expansion but bigger.
2. You guys want mimic on tribal Island but put him on Amber Island
3. Have a fan made monster contest.
3 already happened with Buzzinga
They should make feeding monsters eaiser. Like feeding a tribal island monster to level 100+ is so tedious, and can take full minutes of spamming.
Maybe by adding a slider, so you can skip straight to the level you want to feed them too.
When I was watching this video, I was like, “oh this dude must have more than 1k” BUT 124 SUBS?! DUDE YOU’RE SO UNDERRATED!!
Ethereal Elemental Island's
(Plasma Island, Shadow Island, etc)
I'VE GOT A THEORY
every seasonal could be on 2 islands
Not including Shanty
Hoola: Air and Earth
Gobblygourd: Haven and Oasis
Vivine: Amber and Shugabush
Jam boree is technically the seasonal of Shanty, Bro is on Gold too. But i wouldn't mind seeing Jam Boree again
Anyway my point is
The Magical Seasonals can go to Nexus, which would give them 2 islands
AND
If Ethereal Singular Islands come, then their seasonals could be the Core Seasonals (minus hoola)
Plasma Island: Smoochle
Shadow Island: Punkleton
Mech Island: Blabbit
Crystal Island: Yool?
Poison Island: Carrillong, Spurrit, Or Jam Boree (could be swapped with blabbit)
Sorry for yapping but thats my theory
I’m actually working on a msm island with every monster ever and it called the continent ruins with every island connected
I agree we need these changes
To be honest, I interest to the addition monsters cause another monsters has arrived on Gold Island resolve for the conflict. Thank you for telling me about it.
Wow, you thought of all this in just one day?!
Watching this at work!
Keep doing what you do the best
i’d consider myself the spawn of costumes on all islands lol
but idk!
I will like a hex monster, not just Wubbox but a new one
idea give us a hex and quint on workshop
Getting gold on gold island won't happen due to the lore unfortunately :(
Cool vid
Bro i have a Plan for a island with every Monster called celebration island
If medals are with epics epic wubbox will cost 1 medal
React to gold island played by magical nexus monsters El chaifadory my friend
Only 108 subs?!?!
Watching this not at work!
whats your opinion on almonds
no comment
My favorite change for my singing monsters is when they remove Colosseum and tribal Island, I’m still waiting
Maybe just the Collosingum. At least Tribal Island has a good song.
I don’t like tribal island at all
I think they should keep both, colossingum gives a new way to play MSM, and tribal island has a nice song along with being able to get 20 diamonds and star power each week! (That’s if you decide to actually level up your monsters and you’re in a good tribe)
How are you going to get starpower
@@Beanz12-165then you can't get starpower
I just hope your not being serious about the thing with the medals, because the collosingum sucks really bad 😅
It does lol, I just wish the system was more balanced and less boringly basic tbh
diamonds for epics would be way more reasonable since epic wubbox costs 1 gem similarly rare wubbox is one starpower and common wubbox is coins, making epics cost medals would break the pattern and medals should be used for something else
@@sskjppyagree, it would be like one of the only motivating factors to play Colossingum.
@@sskjppy but, you can already buy epics with diamonds
@@sskjppybruh they can change it plus epics won't always cost meadlas they switch to diamonds to medals
Dawg you aint special everybody said they wanted a seasonal island💀
shhhhh so rude bfdia 12 reference
haters gonna hate