I feel you Jim. The ones that we have as architects are really kids rather than real ones that grew up in the era when we had truly reliable elevators. When I was a kid, the vintage gated Rotary Dover in Kirkwood was what I rode, and the building at 777 South New Ballas Road had Long elevators with white buttons. I wish I was a lead elevator tech that would travel the country. Then if I had that job, I would be traveling the country showing these people how to modernize these elevators right.
Watching this nearly 2 years later so bring a tear to my eye. On the brightside, I kinda like the new mod, especially how the arrow on the hallway lantern changes color. UP = Green DN = Red
My childhood elevator was the great Montgomery kone glass elevator in galleria mall in Ft Lauderdale Sadly they modernized it to an MEI in January 2019. also that makes me want to cry why did they have to modernize that beautiful old dover elevator
I Had A Childhood Elevator I’d Ride All The Time. It Was The Westinghouse Elevators At Hawthorn Mall In Vernon Hills IL. Sadly They Got Modernized By Schindler HXPRESS In 2020
An elevator in our hotel is being modernized! I hope it dosen't turn out as bad as this! That classic 1983 Dover elevator was better with the original COP (circuit operating board) and the original fixtures.
I like the old fixtures, indicator and lanterns better! This modded elevator is already running terribly, the jolting is hard, and it broke down twice?! This is why I also hate modernization. Same to you!
To be very honest, mods like these can be very disappointing. But here’s something cool to think about - Imagine this newly modded elevator a couple decades (or even over 60 years) into the future (if the elevator is still in service)! I’d always wonder how that would be. Modern day elevators, 50-60 years into the future.
Sadly either this elevator will be modernized again by then given typical low reliability trends of modern parts and company trends and interests. Perhaps by then though they'll plan to demolish the building itself
One time I was riding in a 1989 elevator at my job. That waiter was very very fast and every time it stopped a floor it would do a jerk which I call it a bit of annoying
That hole in the wall that you see with black duct tape the wires right behind in the junction box behind I don't think those wires are live though I doubt they're even live if they were alive they would actually caught a fire by now.
What would be nice is if the original COP was kept original and they only put new stainless over the brass. Same with the doors and lanterns. THEY COULD HAVE DONE WHAT I MENTIONED OR EVEN HAVE JUST DONE A PARTIAL MODERNIZATION.
Ive seen those newer fixtures on a Marcato elevator in NYC, i really wanna know what they are.! I know the LED ring is too big and button is too round to be MAD BS
Yes, that is exactly what I was referring to. They let me look at it for photographing purposes as long as I don’t take them out and return it back after I’m done.
No clue, but at least the mod on the Dover was working fine when it was put into service unlike the mod on the Westinghouse where it already starts with a big jolt going up and when it comes to a complete stop going down.
It made the buzz (or hiss sound) because both the SmartRise and Dover were run by hydraulic. It makes 2 noises when the elevator goes up, and 1 noise when it goes down. Cable elevators happen to make a silent noice.
As disappointed as you may be, you have to remember that everything ages through gradual wear-and-tear. When a machine begins to show its age (e.g. constant breakdowns or creaking) it’s more justifiable in the long run to replace it because maintenance costs will rise significantly. They did this for a reason
You do have a point though. I have also heard that parts are also harder to find which is another reason why elevators get modernized on a regular basis.
The problem isn't elevators being modernized, its building owners installing cheap junk like this. Replacing an old elevator with something high quality (say, a Kone with the Ecodisc motor or a Schindler 5500 or the latest Thyssenkrupp or even an Otis Gen2) can turn out great. Replacing an old elevator with cheap/boring generic stuff (in Australia the Dewhurst US95 with blue LEDs seems to be the default choice for basically every mod)
I think the mod for the Dover is more pointless than the Westinghouse cuz the Westinghouse had big jolts, dinner bell didn’t work, and the motor didn’t sound good. However the Dover ran better than the Westinghouse. It had a good motor, the bell worked, and there were no jolts
Nice video I work at Nashville International Airport they modified a Dover elevator replaced the call buttons and indicator and the buttons inside it Kone modified it and it stays broken all the time. Then they installed a brand new Kone elevator beside it. And that elevator has stayed broken too. I’m afraid to ride them. Cause of this
@@JimLiElevators That's funny to hear, because I have a hypermarket (not a mall, it is only 2 stories) that is having one Kone elevator, which has poor maintenance. But it is really efficient!
SmartRise? Such an UNPOPULAR generic brand. I've never been hearing that brand ever… Here in Indonesia, the same goes for us in Jakarta. Many old elevators especially the ones in The Sultan Hotel in Jakarta got a semi-generic Korean modernization. From American Otis turned into Samil. Many of our old elevators got modernized into crap, terrible, and unsafe generic elevators.
At least, the elevators now have EPIC MOTOR, but I don't like those buttons as they look so cheap & generic rip off of MAD BS. Also, wiring two completely different elevators to a common controller doesn't make sense, as they are different brands, different doors types and they have different capacities (The DOVER is more bigger than the Westinghouse).
Dude... really, are you kidding me? Clearly you did not watch the entire video nor even pay any close attention. You need to pay more attention before you jump into conclusions like that. I clearly stated what the brand that the elevator is modernized by, and it even says it on the binder at 14:39 located in the machine room on top of the pump lid.
I feel you Jim. The ones that we have as architects are really kids rather than real ones that grew up in the era when we had truly reliable elevators. When I was a kid, the vintage gated Rotary Dover in Kirkwood was what I rode, and the building at 777 South New Ballas Road had Long elevators with white buttons. I wish I was a lead elevator tech that would travel the country. Then if I had that job, I would be traveling the country showing these people how to modernize these elevators right.
Looks like MAD had a little fun with these.
This makes me want to cry :-(
That's the sound when the elevators in my school! I love Dovers, Schindler, and mostly KONE, not forgetting hydraulic elevators.
ElevatorFan1939 Meiying Longoria Jo Go Go Media Markt they have Beatiful hydraulics
Those hall lanterns are very rare! Glad you saved them!
Watching this nearly 2 years later so bring a tear to my eye. On the brightside, I kinda like the new mod, especially how the arrow on the hallway lantern changes color.
UP = Green
DN = Red
Im watching 3 years after (in 2021)
@@mantinecraft7055 me 6 years
That is so sad to see them modernize these cool Dover elevators. Makes me want to cry.
RIP 1981 Westinghouse and 1983 Dover
well at least you got the dover parts that will help you remember this elevator
Its a good place for DieselDucy's elevator museum.
before it was an beatiful elevator..
So sad. I love the Dover buttons. It will never be missed. RIP.
21:45
Memco Panachrome on the other one. They should put it on the other one. Epic motor as well.
The Dover’s nice leveling and fast going down speed will be missed, as well as the traditional fixtures.
I like the Spider Box airplane for sale
My childhood elevator was the great Montgomery kone glass elevator in galleria mall in Ft Lauderdale
Sadly they modernized it to an MEI in January 2019. also that makes me want to cry why did they have to modernize that beautiful old dover elevator
This was uploaded on my birthday.
It was premiered on your birthday
10:47 this further proves my point that old stuff is better and more reliable
:( Your childhood elevator is now ruined. R.I.P Dover hydraulic elevator at Sugar Land Medical Building 1983 - 2018
Did they modernize them for a reason?
@@elevcarwashsirensandmore21 i think they modernized it because they wanted the place to look more modern
I Had A Childhood Elevator I’d Ride All The Time. It Was The Westinghouse Elevators At Hawthorn Mall In Vernon Hills IL. Sadly They Got Modernized By Schindler HXPRESS In 2020
Farewell Dover 1980s, you will be remembered by people who lived with you.
Goodbye 😢😢😢😢
There's an elevator under modernization right now in my town and I hope it doesn't turn out as bad as this!
What new fixtures will it have?
An elevator in our hotel is being modernized! I hope it dosen't turn out as bad as this! That classic 1983 Dover elevator was better with the original COP (circuit operating board) and the original fixtures.
5:02 Why you shouldn't mod elevators
And 5:59,
AND 7:28
FYI at 5:09 the elevator did a big jolt like that when it was a westinghouse
Yeah, but the modernized one jolted a lot harder than the original.
same a youtube user called BENO told me that modernisation does not make an elevator better. They should just keep things original.
Yes... only but if you use companies like Mitsubishi’s
In some cases a modernization is needed to make the elevator more ADA compliant or if the elevator is a piece of junk.
The one where a Schindler M Series got modernized by leister controls?
I like the old fixtures, indicator and lanterns better! This modded elevator is already running terribly, the jolting is hard, and it broke down twice?! This is why I also hate modernization. Same to you!
I like them better when they were original. I hope the elevator mod isn't as bad as this!
Sad Because That Elevator Is Been Gone
So Sad Because The Elevator Is Now Gone
I like the SmartRise buttons :D
The buttons are DMG BS third party buttons
It makes me sad how such awesome elevators have to be modded. I was very upset when an epic Schindler M Series got modded by a Otis Gen2.
Wow brand new elevator 1983 is clean they've done it
Almost 100 views! I love your knowledge on elevators! Thanks for being my inspiration!
They done elevator 1981 Washington look clean and fan wow elevator they are fix 1983
lord and Taylor had an EPIC Westinghouse but got modernized with kone kss 500 0r kss 570
To be very honest, mods like these can be very disappointing. But here’s something cool to think about - Imagine this newly modded elevator a couple decades (or even over 60 years) into the future (if the elevator is still in service)! I’d always wonder how that would be. Modern day elevators, 50-60 years into the future.
Sadly, I imagine most of them aren't built to last quite like the older elevators are. Most will not likely last 50-60 years.
Sadly either this elevator will be modernized again by then given typical low reliability trends of modern parts and company trends and interests. Perhaps by then though they'll plan to demolish the building itself
One time I was riding in a 1989 elevator at my job. That waiter was very very fast and every time it stopped a floor it would do a jerk which I call it a bit of annoying
I'm so sad the 1983 Dover is gone in heaven #goodbye1983Dover
I love the old dover
That hole in the wall that you see with black duct tape the wires right behind in the junction box behind I don't think those wires are live though I doubt they're even live if they were alive they would actually caught a fire by now.
Wow. The smart rice made even more noise then the dover when it was installed.
Wow this elevator is legend
for new modernisations those have good motors
ZZ9 Productions yea they do I like the the good motors
Sad And I Hate To See These Elevators Go
Say goodbye to the Dover elevator
But I got the parts thankfully.
I like new mod very much than the old one
The old one worked perfectly fine as well also.
Those new buttons look like ThyssenKrupp elevator buttons
My old elevator replaced from June 19 to September 24
R.I.P 1983 Dover
RIP 1983 Dover elevator
Its 1 year ago still not 1k likes what a shame
These were modded almost 2 years ago now.
In Singapore,some Fujitech lifts broke down,some of it crashed,some of it's indicator broke.
A Final Farewell Ride On The 1983 Dover Elevator
i found one with orginal fixtures
What would be nice is if the original COP was kept original and they only put new stainless over the brass. Same with the doors and lanterns. THEY COULD HAVE DONE WHAT I MENTIONED OR EVEN HAVE JUST DONE A PARTIAL MODERNIZATION.
Ive seen those newer fixtures on a Marcato elevator in NYC, i really wanna know what they are.! I know the LED ring is too big and button is too round to be MAD BS
These are actually some sort of PTL.
@@JimLiElevators really.!? Wow.!
5:12 what happened to the door?
They should have kept the old ones until they died
Nice.
I did some updates video of the former 1987 Dover Impulses at the City of Wilmington 305 Chestnut Street in Wilmington NC just like you.
R.I.P 1983 Dover and 1981 Westinghouse elevators
Typical Oracle being slow at the process!
May I ask, what is Sugarland? I don’t live in America.
Sugar Land is a suburb of Houston located southwest.
wait did you ask him to take the new part out of the machine room?
No, because they needed to have those to put them in the existing spot for installations.
@@JimLiElevators I am referring to the new lantern you were showing
Yes, that is exactly what I was referring to. They let me look at it for photographing purposes as long as I don’t take them out and return it back after I’m done.
SmartRise is by OTIS
Really? I didn’t know that. I thought SmartRise and Otis both are separate elevator company brands.
JimLiElevators According to Dan & Mark from OTIS, They said SmartRises are on OTIS Hydros. Not HydroFits & MRL's tho
Why would they scrap a working elevator?
No clue, but at least the mod on the Dover was working fine when it was put into service unlike the mod on the Westinghouse where it already starts with a big jolt going up and when it comes to a complete stop going down.
are theese ptl buttons
What a waste of money!
I agree
Same
@@Mark1-l6oAgreed. But in 2022. They seem to run a lot better.
Traditional Dover with a *BUZZ* ???
It made the buzz (or hiss sound) because both the SmartRise and Dover were run by hydraulic. It makes 2 noises when the elevator goes up, and 1 noise when it goes down. Cable elevators happen to make a silent noice.
I’m so sick of generic indicators and generic garbage in general
Me too!
Generic elevators could have some great motors though. joevator 3219 did a hydro motor complication and it included some generics with great motors
Same here! I'm so sick of this elevator having this generic garbage, being have to be modded, and the jolting is so hard!!
@@JimLiElevators Same to me! I hate these basic, plain and generic garbage mods!!
This is just sad. These DID NOT need to be modernized!
Nice
As disappointed as you may be, you have to remember that everything ages through gradual wear-and-tear. When a machine begins to show its age (e.g. constant breakdowns or creaking) it’s more justifiable in the long run to replace it because maintenance costs will rise significantly. They did this for a reason
You do have a point though. I have also heard that parts are also harder to find which is another reason why elevators get modernized on a regular basis.
5:02/5:59/7:28 BOUNCY ELEVATOR
The problem isn't elevators being modernized, its building owners installing cheap junk like this.
Replacing an old elevator with something high quality (say, a Kone with the Ecodisc motor or a Schindler 5500 or the latest Thyssenkrupp or even an Otis Gen2) can turn out great.
Replacing an old elevator with cheap/boring generic stuff (in Australia the Dewhurst US95 with blue LEDs seems to be the default choice for basically every mod)
That is fairly true.
Big doors!!
Why did they modernize that?
No idea.
These were truly beautiful lifts and not only they look good, their motors also sounded great.
I think the mod for the Dover is more pointless than the Westinghouse cuz the Westinghouse had big jolts, dinner bell didn’t work, and the motor didn’t sound good. However the Dover ran better than the Westinghouse. It had a good motor, the bell worked, and there were no jolts
I wish it would say
Nice video I work at Nashville International Airport they modified a Dover elevator replaced the call buttons and indicator and the buttons inside it Kone modified it and it stays broken all the time. Then they installed a brand new Kone elevator beside it. And that elevator has stayed broken too. I’m afraid to ride them. Cause of this
OMG Kone is terrible. I have heard numerous rumors that Kone elevators are known for breaking down, and THEY RIGHTFULLY DO!
And that’s who services all our elevators at the airport is Kone
@@JimLiElevators That's funny to hear, because I have a hypermarket (not a mall, it is only 2 stories) that is having one Kone elevator, which has poor maintenance. But it is really efficient!
Cool
After the mod on the Dover, why did the Westinghouse go back out of service?
It’s because they were replacing the cab walls so they had to deactivate the former Westinghouse elevator for a bit.
Do you still like the new smart rise lift
It’s okay I guess, but I still like it better when they are original though.
@@JimLiElevatorsI agree. The original ones are very nice. 😊
Why was i hearing beeping in the background
I think the alarm panel in the lobby is not reset and probably in trouble mode I believe.
The mod may be upsetting, but the motor should be a win.
COOL 😎
Sad that it got modernized
R.I.P
I Like modded elevator
SmartRise? Such an UNPOPULAR generic brand. I've never been hearing that brand ever…
Here in Indonesia, the same goes for us in Jakarta. Many old elevators especially the ones in The Sultan Hotel in Jakarta got a semi-generic Korean modernization. From American Otis turned into Samil. Many of our old elevators got modernized into crap, terrible, and unsafe generic elevators.
No mentioning about Pillar Elevator?
Maybe you can do a 2022 take
Modernized Westinghouse elevator that door it does not open all the way
I thought it was Montgomery SmartRise but it’s Otis SmartRise
No, the actual brand is definitely SmartRise; I promise. Otis did NOT make SmartRise products.
Ok I just got confused for a min
If it is tell me if they make mid rise elevators
#R.I.P Dover
I feel bad to Jim elevators because he really liked this old 1983 Dover RIP Dover 1983-2018😢
Well don’t feel bad now because parts have already been saved!
You are so great Jim elevators 😊
I also like the indicator and the door opening but I did not like the bump
IMO, the mod on the Dover is better.
At least, the elevators now have EPIC MOTOR, but I don't like those buttons as they look so cheap & generic rip off of MAD BS.
Also, wiring two completely different elevators to a common controller doesn't make sense, as they are different brands, different doors types and they have different capacities (The DOVER is more bigger than the Westinghouse).
It’s not good that it’s going to be a rest in peace
That Dover elevator will be missed😭
only america has a vending machine in a medical centre
No i saw a vending machine in a hospital in Poland
That elevator sounds like a violin when it changes floors
Fun fact: Dover is also a city in the United Kingdom.
I hate that my favorite Dover impulse might be getting modded soon hope not though
The mod is by thyssenkrupp
Dude... really, are you kidding me? Clearly you did not watch the entire video nor even pay any close attention. You need to pay more attention before you jump into conclusions like that. I clearly stated what the brand that the elevator is modernized by, and it even says it on the binder at 14:39 located in the machine room on top of the pump lid.
@@JimLiElevatorsYou're right. It's modded to SMARTRISE