Hopefully the lad stays at Palace and runs his contract down over the next two years and Mr Parish has cause to regret not accepting a very fair bid from the toon and his unfortunate spoutings in public.....hope the kid leaves Palace in the next couple of years on a free or a vastly reduced transfer fee than our offer....
@@rabcnesbitt5736Oh dear. You thought Saudi money was going to get you everything lol. If he runs down his contract then Palace have the England starting centre back for two years for nothing. You'd have to pay £65m for that 😂😂
Walk away don't be held to ransom they won't get anywhere near that amount with only two years on his contract left his price will only go down year after year till it runs out and palace will be left with nothing good for them greed is not a good look parish
When Parish came out with that if anyone wants him they should be prepared to pay superstar money, it would have been nice for the reporters to have challenged that and asked whether that equally means increasing Guehi's wages to superstar levels to keep him at the club... I would wager that Palace wouldn't. It would be a bit rich of Parish to almost insinuate that Newcastle don't value the player high enough to reflect his quality, while Palace are happy to pay him below "superstar" wages
Reporters don't challenge owners because they are scared if they offend the owners will have them banned from press conferences etc. It's fking stupid, it just causes reporters to ask simple boring questions like they're up their assets.
Yeah I don't know but most players that are worth daft money weren't that originally so you hope you get them before they are worth that like we did with minteh
@@hydrohobbyist so why should a club accept less than their market value, just because we ask? They don't have psr pressures because Olise's sale cleared their losses from 21/2 & 22/3 so we don't have leverage.
Ask yourself this, if Arsenal came in for Bruno with 75 mill and got him we'd be kicking right off! So we can't twist when another club want top dollar for their player can we. If that's the price they have set then either pay it or walk away. We can't have it both ways.
@@RobBuglass-k6d Fine - the simple fact is that Guehi isn't worth the money Parish wants so he can stay. Parish can then have the worry of Marc not signing an extension to the 18 months left on his contract & then leaves on a free - simples!
If Newcastle don't get him I think he should be banging on the palace board room door asking for his superstar pay rise then see how long they want to keep him on the books. Take care people 👍
We’re not fed up about updates on the story. We’re just fed up with the lack of apparent progress on this or alternate deals. I liked Guéhi’s comment on the superstar label, though. Seems like a humble and good personality that would fit well in at SJP if he were to join.
The insight you provide on the why, how and what of the interview - brilliant. Really appreciate it as a fan of NUFC and as a fan of football in general. Honestly, it was quite aggravating seeing both of those interviews, but the pinch of salt and the understanding provided here have really helped to understand and alleviate the frustration of it. Top notch as always Keith, much appreciated from all of us i'm sure.
Back in the day, we broke the [then] transfer record to buy Alan Shearer from Blackburn Rovers. We weren’t bending over then. We were showing intent. If we want you to improve, as a club, then we need top players (better than what we have). 14 clubs in the prem wheel and deal just to hang in there. History has shown us that top clubs make marquee signings.
im with you that we are so close and hes clearly the outstanding number 1 choice from the manager and if we didn't get it over the line it would be disappointing with all the work that has gone into it
Thank you Keith. I think you've spoken for most Newcastle fans in that summary. My view is that we MUST walk away from this. Steve Parish can keep his superstar - though I doubt he's getting paid the going rate for superstars at Palace.
Thanks Keith for keeping us updated, I think it will just come out soon that we have agreed a fee, if we don't in the next week or so we need to move on and find an alternative.
It couldn’t be more obvious, the premiership is totally corrupt. When the takeover happened the top six clubs were stunned that Newcastle were going to be a major force in football. Panic stations….So meetings were held behind closed doors, with Newcastle representatives not welcome to discuss how they could stop Newcastle from challenging them. New rules were made up, along with don’t buy any players from Newcastle & don’t sell any of their best players to them unless they are prepared to pay monumental sums of money. Unsettle Newcastle’s players & club with constant rumourmongering of our best players moving on. Games fixed through VAR etc. Watching Guehi play in the Euro’s, I thought ‘wouldn’t he be a great player to sign’ but to be honest didn’t think we would try. I would love him at Newcastle, but we are being held to ransom, the figures involved now are repulsive 🤮 Walk away from the deal, as this is going to have real repercussions in the future with ffp. Palace are living in dreamland.
Thanks for the frank update Keith. There is a reason you are my fav reporter. Regarding the fee, personally I dont want our club record signing to be a defender. We are famous for our #9s, Attacking entertaining football. Am I a bit weird for that stance? probably.
@@steveoram1there squad is not mid table no more . They took 3 English players to the euros . Best palace team I can remember . Fancy them top 8 if they keep Guehi & getting top dollar for Olise & buying Sarr for 1m was top notch business, plus we got isak at a bargain , his price has doubled
You've lost Olise, potentially losing Guehi and Eze. You've brought in Sarr for £15m, an under 21 for the same amount and got half a dozen loans back. Think 14th/15th is probably respectable for Palace this season.
While I agree 65 is a lot of money I think it’s important to remember how many goals we shipped last year. Even when Botman was in the team he looked a different player than the previous year. I would prefer spending more on Guehi as he’s less of a risk than getting in a centre back with zero prem league experience. He is also the type of character Eddie Howe loves. If he’s their number one target they should just cough up the extra 5 mil.
i hope we pull out. We went in too low, Mitchell is not looking great right now, but in all honesty it's too much. I would rather we look for a more reasonable deal and get the RW in, get some bodies out. Cheers Keith, great update but enough is enough. We need to walk.
Why not im sure were gonna break a lot of our transfer records over the next few years if we want to win the prem we gotta get used to spending our owners money people complaining like theyve gotta put their hand in their own pockets get real winning nothing on budget buys as we saw during cashleys tenure
My first reaction was that we should walk away, but it does sound like all the stuff played out in the media was Palace's attempt to bring other clubs into a bidding war. Now that hasn't happened I feel like we could still get this over the line
It’s a clear ‘statement’ signing opportunity. We’re now mixing it with the ‘so called’ top six. If we walk away, it’s either because we’ve lined up someone just as good (but from abroad maybe) or, we walk away and look like berks.
Only now our fans are realising that the Guehi deal is overpriced! Hes not worth half of what we offered! Mitchell needs to give his head a wobble big time if he’s thinking about going BACK for him! Move on and get a RW and a young CB that will be good cover till Botman gets fit and be willing to learn from who we have now
Keith, I’m fed up of these NUFC fan channels telling us what we already know as if they’re in the know. They should leave it to the legit pro’s like you guys. Thanks for the video.
I get your point totally. They just spout the bleedin’ obvious very confidently and it’s nothing but old fish wives blether. I’m sure they mean well but it creates too much noise and you can’t see the facts sometimes.
Cracking up to date report keith, thankyou. Guehi is obviously a very decent man aswell as being English both of which eddie howe holds in high regard. I think we might get this done as he'll be worth less next year as his contract unwinds.
Thanks for clarifying the Guehi interview Keith. Also you must be as sick as us Newcastle fans about hearing about the Guehi saga. But I think personally he is worth the money by what I've seen of him at Palace. Look forward to the next update, ha.
Different type of defender unfortunately . guehi is a ball playing CB with lots of pace and recovery . Chalobah is a more conventual CB, Still a really good defender but not what Newcastle are after
If our expert professionals are willing to pay over £50 million for this lad then they see something special and therefore I “trust the process” and if we’re that close then let’s get him over the line.
If we can get Madueke on loan with an option to buy pay the Guehi money. Right wing is the most important transfer. Guehi is class but we have Schar who is class and Kelly and Burn decent with Botman to come back. Otherwise Mbeumo around 40-50mill and a young CB to learn would be perfect 🤞
Some suggestions - Its windy - get in doors. You're bidding for a player - do it privately. Your shopping at Palace - chuck 100 mil on the table and get Eze as well......
Nothing against Palace - they have a player they like and want to keep - but the money on the table is already too much of our permitted budget, so I'd wish them good luck and farewell and walk away. If I was looking to spend that amount on a single player I'd expect them to be bringing regular goals or assists to the team in advance of what we already have. We aren't 60mill desperate for a central defender.
I think 60 million is about what he is worth. I don't think Newcastle should pay anymore but maybe offering a fringe player such as Targett might sweeten the deal for Palace
Lets hope this doesn't come back and bite us on the backside not getting a quality Centre back in for the early stages of the PL. Our defence was awful last season.
Thanks for updates keith.. why is longstaff. Fraser. Hendrick .Haydon. dubvraka . Lewis. Targett still here. Get rid of dead wood ..we need to step up .if we want to win things we need to be big fees for big players.
What a joke there is no negotiation from CP. Money talks as Neil Diamond says so KP is going to lose a decent offer and does not look good. I'd let the paint dry and wait for 24 months and get him on a free. With KP wallet minus 60 million😂
I reckon Guehi will be a Newcastle player by end of this window but it might run closer to deadline day than expected. I think Palace know the player wants to go and just a case of holding off till Newcastle pay what they want unless there's any real alternatives being looked at then Palace might take the offer that's on the table because Newcastle haven't got any rival bidders. Palace could end up with an unhappy player and no money if they don't accept. I personally am not really arsed if Guehi gets signed or not. I think the offer currently is good enough and if they dont get Guehi im sure they'll get someone else pretty decent at that kind of money.
Would be happier seeing other players coming in we need more then one player and it would be good to see it happening after seeing United signing ✍️ players
Your right, we are absolutely fed up now. To be honest I'd like to see that he's more interested in coming. If he wants to come and us welcome him to the family he needs to push for the move to prove to us he wants it. That interview said to us he's happy where he is? Old news now let's find someone else
If the player wanted to he could force a move for the 60 Newcastle have offered. The fact he hasn't shows he isn't that bothered. Palace are doing whats right by them and fair play to them, the player should do the same if he wants the move.
Pull the plug on this 1 they just want to pull our pants down over this deal go for the 2 lads at Chelsea Chalobah and Madueke we could get both for the same price and it would solve our problems in both positions nice work Keith
love the office Keith! :) sometimes fans are their own worst enemy looking for conspiracies. it does feel like this is dragging on a fair bit. wonder why palace took 3 days to reject. any idea on that aside from time wasting?
There is no way of dressing it up- it has been an enormously underwhelming transfer window for NUFC. We moaned a bit about last summers window but that was pretty dam good in retrospect. I can only hope that we keep the nucleus of the squad fit but the glass man is already injured of course.
Any ideas on 'plan B's' or maybe another young defender from a slightly more competitive league who could possibly be in and around the 1st team as back-up?
I'd really like Guehi, largely for the sake of having another England international in the squad and obviously he's done well in recent times, but I do wonder if he's actually any better than Malick Thiaw who was supposedly available for around £35m. The question would be is Guehi £30m better than Thiaw, a player with Champions League experience, and would Newcastle not perhaps be better off banking that £30m difference and pushing the boat out on a right winger. I fully expect Newcastle to do business on one or two deals before the transfer window ends but I do have a concern about the lack of noise around some very obvious outgoings that should really be happening (Fraser, Lewis, Hayden and perhaps the likes of Almiron and Dubravka)
Hi Keith, I can't say I agree with a lot of this on crystal Palace point of view I think its pretty low and I know everyone has a price but I think they are using everyone involved in the wrong way buddy and everyone knows it but can't say it and yes I am sick of hearing about it haha. Thanks for updates
We have to leave it to Mitchell, but it would be interesting to know Eddie’s priority. My guess is is that his priority is a right winger, but there seems to be no progress there. I think Keith is right. The danger is that Mitchell has vested so much in this that he doesn’t want to lose face by walking away - especially as he has no obvious alternative lined up. As things stand, we have done rather better on transfers when we haven’t had a DOF than when we have ! I’m convinced that Amanda did more behind the scenes than most of us realise !
Completely agree that these sporting directors don't seem to be the essential role everyone thinks they are. We're certainly no better off (from the outside looking in obv)
@@phil5357 We’ve still got two weeks to go. My worry is that we spend big on someone that Eddie doesn’t really want just so Mitchell can show he’s capable of big deals. In my view, it’s the coach’s head on the block if we don’t perform so the DOF has to buy according to what he wants. That worked well with Amanda. We never made a bad move in the market, but this is a new era and, as yet, it’s been underwhelming.
To the Board :
Walk away from the deal
Hi I am from the board and we won't.
Agree mate
100%
I would walk away from this deal. Our third offer was a good offer. Parish going on TV was not a good look.
Hopefully the lad stays at Palace and runs his contract down over the next two years and Mr Parish has cause to regret not accepting a very fair bid from the toon and his unfortunate spoutings in public.....hope the kid leaves Palace in the next couple of years on a free or a vastly reduced transfer fee than our offer....
@@rabcnesbitt5736Oh dear. You thought Saudi money was going to get you everything lol. If he runs down his contract then Palace have the England starting centre back for two years for nothing. You'd have to pay £65m for that 😂😂
@@MarcoSpeaksNadsat Palace will miss out on decent funds. Their call ...
Walk away don't be held to ransom they won't get anywhere near that amount with only two years on his contract left his price will only go down year after year till it runs out and palace will be left with nothing good for them greed is not a good look parish
@@terrychandler4036 Gosh. Someone tell Parish, quick. 🤡
Someone will get him for free in two summers probably. It'll be a generational bargain.
Superstar bargain.
Aye - Keith should interview Parish when Marc leaves on a free in a couple of seasons.
You can guarantee it won't be Newcastle lol
@MarcoSpeaksNadsat Newcastle will be interested in elite players only ...
@@MarcoSpeaksNadsat You never know but that's not the point mate.
When Parish came out with that if anyone wants him they should be prepared to pay superstar money, it would have been nice for the reporters to have challenged that and asked whether that equally means increasing Guehi's wages to superstar levels to keep him at the club...
I would wager that Palace wouldn't.
It would be a bit rich of Parish to almost insinuate that Newcastle don't value the player high enough to reflect his quality, while Palace are happy to pay him below "superstar" wages
Good point
👏👏👏
I’m sure his agents saying that now if he stays
Sky and Keith are anti Newcastle.
Reporters don't challenge owners because they are scared if they offend the owners will have them banned from press conferences etc. It's fking stupid, it just causes reporters to ask simple boring questions like they're up their assets.
Must admit would rather spend 30 mil on a defender and 30 mill on a right winger
But will have to be lower league players or fringe PL players for that money. Inflation has hit regular first team PL players in recent years
How the hell we getton a better rw for 30 ffs might aswell keep miggy and test others on the right
@@smanvir94 unless our scouts find an emerging talent
Yeah I don't know but most players that are worth daft money weren't that originally so you hope you get them before they are worth that like we did with minteh
@@slduk88Or European players.
Thanks for admitting that we are a step up Keith, Palace fans are delusional calling the this a sideways step
If we do the deal, every club we try and do business with is going to think we’ll come back 2,3,4 times with a better offer.
why would they? We've not come close to the price we were quoted - if someone offered to buy your house for 75% of your asking price, would you sell?
@@andrewharrison7767 I’m not talking about being a seller. I’m talking about being a buyer. You’re comparing apples with rocks.
@@andrewharrison7767 If your house depreciated in value to 50% in the next year, you'd be daft not to take 75%.
If you knew you lost your house for £0 in 2 years, you should be chomping at the bit to cash in.
@@hydrohobbyist so why should a club accept less than their market value, just because we ask? They don't have psr pressures because Olise's sale cleared their losses from 21/2 & 22/3 so we don't have leverage.
A good concise vlog Keith is always a pleasure to listen to you
Ask yourself this, if Arsenal came in for Bruno with 75 mill and got him we'd be kicking right off! So we can't twist when another club want top dollar for their player can we. If that's the price they have set then either pay it or walk away. We can't have it both ways.
True, he is worth 75m though, Guehi at 65m is a bit of a stretch
@@micky1858 Newcastle wouldn't sell Isak for that amount, so it's not a realistic situation.
Parish labels Guehi as a superstar - in all but salary.
@@BillyfromConsett So why should a Palace sell him for less if we won’t sell our players for less?
@@turn1210 Our opinions mean jack shit mate.... The only ones that matter are the selling club.
Great insight Keith appreciate the honesty and walking us through how these things work. Push the deal through and move on!
Well spoken Keith very professional
65m for a centre half ,jog on Palace, he'll be going for 10m next summer.
He's worth £10m now. Average British player
this is nonsense maddison depsite being relegated with leicester costed 40m-45m with only one year left on his contract
Howay, 10 mil for a proven prem english cb? It's not 2009 anymore mate. 65mil is pricey I
agree but you are just being daft.
Not if he signs a year extension to his deal . Guehi & Parrish have a great relationship away from the club . Palace also have to pay Chelsea .
@@RobBuglass-k6d Fine - the simple fact is that Guehi isn't worth the money Parish wants so he can stay.
Parish can then have the worry of Marc not signing an extension to the 18 months left on his contract & then leaves on a free - simples!
If Newcastle don't get him I think he should be banging on the palace board room door asking for his superstar pay rise then see how long they want to keep him on the books. Take care people 👍
I hope that we pull out of this hugely overpriced negotiation and put the money towards two different players.
Newcastle is a side step
Evanilson is signing for Bournemouth for £40m. Brazilian international striker
@@dansmoviecavemaybe a downward step. You beat us 4-0 last season
🎣@@dansmoviecave
@@dansmoviecaveit’s not man stop talking bollocks
Time to walk away. Go back in for Thiaw for £35 million and spend the rest of the budget on a RW upgrade.
Why would he want to move ? As things stand he’ll be playing CL football next season.
Thiaw's a Championship player. Should re-sign Chancel Mbemba
@@johnenglish929not a regular starter for Milan.
@@DanielCordone9nice bait
He didn't want to come to the toon
We’re not fed up about updates on the story. We’re just fed up with the lack of apparent progress on this or alternate deals.
I liked Guéhi’s comment on the superstar label, though. Seems like a humble and good personality that would fit well in at SJP if he were to join.
🙇♀️just pay the 65 mill ffs...jesus!!!
The moment Palace made the deal public they shot themselves in the foot. This isn’t dragons den. Move on to other targets and we can manage.
The insight you provide on the why, how and what of the interview - brilliant. Really appreciate it as a fan of NUFC and as a fan of football in general. Honestly, it was quite aggravating seeing both of those interviews, but the pinch of salt and the understanding provided here have really helped to understand and alleviate the frustration of it. Top notch as always Keith, much appreciated from all of us i'm sure.
Walk away from greedy Palace!!!! Parish can shove the deal where the sun don't shine as far as I'm concerned!
Greedy palace... let's not speak about the players you've sold for well over the odds..
He's their player and can ask what they want - just as we have with our star players.
What a w@nker 😂😂😂
Like who? @@chrismills5913
Thanks Keith. Nice piece to clarify the situation. Hopefully a 'solution' can be found.
Thanks for the coverage and detail Keith 👍🏼
Replaced.. Malick Thiaw.. Great Signing..
Walk away, they are taking the piss now we cant be a club that bends over and pays whatever!
Then walk away 😂
Back in the day, we broke the [then] transfer record to buy Alan Shearer from Blackburn Rovers. We weren’t bending over then. We were showing intent. If we want you to improve, as a club, then we need top players (better than what we have). 14 clubs in the prem wheel and deal just to hang in there. History has shown us that top clubs make marquee signings.
Class as always keith,it is getting tedious now but i feel we would be making a statement of intent if we can finalise this🤞👍
Great content as always. Little bit of a constructive comment - the wind noise was awful on this visited though
Thanks again for the sensible and measured coverage Keith
im with you that we are so close and hes clearly the outstanding number 1 choice from the manager and if we didn't get it over the line it would be disappointing with all the work that has gone into it
Thanks
Thank you so much Tony, that’s very kind of you! Hope you have a great weekend 😊
Have to appreciate this guy, he's only reporter that gives honest news and doesnt make stuff up 👏
The people making stuff up aren’t reporters
Thank you Keith. I think you've spoken for most Newcastle fans in that summary.
My view is that we MUST walk away from this.
Steve Parish can keep his superstar - though I doubt he's getting paid the going rate for superstars at Palace.
Thanks Keith for keeping us updated, I think it will just come out soon that we have agreed a fee, if we don't in the next week or so we need to move on and find an alternative.
It couldn’t be more obvious, the premiership is totally corrupt.
When the takeover happened the top six clubs were stunned that Newcastle were going to be a major force in football.
Panic stations….So meetings were held behind closed doors, with Newcastle representatives not welcome to discuss how they could stop Newcastle from challenging them.
New rules were made up, along with don’t buy any players from Newcastle & don’t sell any of their best players to them unless they are prepared to pay monumental sums of money.
Unsettle Newcastle’s players & club with constant rumourmongering of our best players moving on.
Games fixed through VAR etc.
Watching Guehi play in the Euro’s, I thought ‘wouldn’t he be a great player to sign’ but to be honest didn’t think we would try. I would love him at Newcastle, but we are being held to ransom, the figures involved now are repulsive 🤮
Walk away from the deal, as this is going to have real repercussions in the future with ffp.
Palace are living in dreamland.
Thanks for the frank update Keith. There is a reason you are my fav reporter. Regarding the fee, personally I dont want our club record signing to be a defender. We are famous for our #9s, Attacking entertaining football. Am I a bit weird for that stance? probably.
Make the leap of faith and pay that extra 5 million! This guy is worth it!
There is zero chance a mid-table defender is worth more than Alex Isak.
@@steveoram1there squad is not mid table no more . They took 3 English players to the euros . Best palace team I can remember . Fancy them top 8 if they keep Guehi & getting top dollar for Olise & buying Sarr for 1m was top notch business, plus we got isak at a bargain , his price has doubled
They came 10th. That is 100% mid-table. It's just counting.
You've lost Olise, potentially losing Guehi and Eze. You've brought in Sarr for £15m, an under 21 for the same amount and got half a dozen loans back. Think 14th/15th is probably respectable for Palace this season.
Really appreciate your take on the situation and how you explain things cheers. TONY
Thanks Tony! And thank you for the beer 🙏🏻
While I agree 65 is a lot of money I think it’s important to remember how many goals we shipped last year. Even when Botman was in the team he looked a different player than the previous year. I would prefer spending more on Guehi as he’s less of a risk than getting in a centre back with zero prem league experience. He is also the type of character Eddie Howe loves. If he’s their number one target they should just cough up the extra 5 mil.
that was more down to consistently playing dan burn at left back
Spot on as per Keith, thanks for the update!
The club should give you that parking space for life Keith
😂😂 great idea that actually
i hope we pull out. We went in too low, Mitchell is not looking great right now, but in all honesty it's too much. I would rather we look for a more reasonable deal and get the RW in, get some bodies out. Cheers Keith, great update but enough is enough. We need to walk.
Walk away. He’s a good player but £65 million is too much and “Generational Talent” is just a mockery.
Newcastle United should not break their transfer record on a CB, walk away and get a superstar RW & another CB at a reasonable price
Why not im sure were gonna break a lot of our transfer records over the next few years if we want to win the prem we gotta get used to spending our owners money people complaining like theyve gotta put their hand in their own pockets get real winning nothing on budget buys as we saw during cashleys tenure
My first reaction was that we should walk away, but it does sound like all the stuff played out in the media was Palace's attempt to bring other clubs into a bidding war. Now that hasn't happened I feel like we could still get this over the line
I was thinking the same thing.
Really reminding me of the Maddison transfer saga!
It’s nothing like the Maddison saga I don’t even think it was a saga 😂
Nope, Maddison would've been a decent signing. Guehi is a waste. Way worse than Schar
Did we even bid on Maders?
Maddison didn’t want to come that’s the difference
Great video as always Keith
Thanks 👍
It’s a clear ‘statement’ signing opportunity. We’re now mixing it with the ‘so called’ top six. If we walk away, it’s either because we’ve lined up someone just as good (but from abroad maybe) or, we walk away and look like berks.
Love Steve Parish calling him a 'Superstar'............ A pound to a pinch of shit Parish isn't paying him 'Superstar' wages 🤔
My worry is if we give in and pay the £65 then every club we negotiate with in the future is just gunna stay strong and expect the same treatment
Please invest in a mic Keith, can barley hear because of the wind
I know one thing for sure if we ever wanted one of their players again they’d think twice or give them a year notice
Only now our fans are realising that the Guehi deal is overpriced! Hes not worth half of what we offered! Mitchell needs to give his head a wobble big time if he’s thinking about going BACK for him! Move on and get a RW and a young CB that will be good cover till Botman gets fit and be willing to learn from who we have now
Keith, I’m fed up of these NUFC fan channels telling us what we already know as if they’re in the know. They should leave it to the legit pro’s like you guys.
Thanks for the video.
I get your point totally. They just spout the bleedin’ obvious very confidently and it’s nothing but old fish wives blether. I’m sure they mean well but it creates too much noise and you can’t see the facts sometimes.
@@kitcole4927 any ones you recommend?
Cracking up to date report keith, thankyou. Guehi is obviously a very decent man aswell as being English both of which eddie howe holds in high regard. I think we might get this done as he'll be worth less next year as his contract unwinds.
We need to forget Guéhi i for one am p****d off hearing about him tbh.
Get off social media if it’s affecting you like that ffs
Good to see you in The Stack this morning mate 👍
Thanks for clarifying the Guehi interview Keith. Also you must be as sick as us Newcastle fans about hearing about the Guehi saga. But I think personally he is worth the money by what I've seen of him at Palace. Look forward to the next update, ha.
Top honest video you are one of the best online.......Craig Hope where are ya? 🤣
If Palace think he's a superstar, they sure aren't paying him like it...
Well reported Keith, personally think Newcastle should walk away from this and potentially spend the money to cover two areas.
£65m he's worth it imo.. not just a top defender who can play both LCB & RCB but he's a great guy too by all accounts.
Chelsea's best defender last season, Challobah, is available for under 30 mil. Much better value for money.
Different type of defender unfortunately .
guehi is a ball playing CB with lots of pace and recovery .
Chalobah is a more conventual CB, Still a really good defender but not what Newcastle are after
If our expert professionals are willing to pay over £50 million for this lad then they see something special and therefore I “trust the process” and if we’re that close then let’s get him over the line.
It’s a waiting game: Palace want to get as much as they can. Nufc know this
If we can get Madueke on loan with an option to buy pay the Guehi money. Right wing is the most important transfer. Guehi is class but we have Schar who is class and Kelly and Burn decent with Botman to come back. Otherwise Mbeumo around 40-50mill and a young CB to learn would be perfect 🤞
Some suggestions - Its windy - get in doors. You're bidding for a player - do it privately. Your shopping at Palace - chuck 100 mil on the table and get Eze as well......
Nothing against Palace - they have a player they like and want to keep - but the money on the table is already too much of our permitted budget, so I'd wish them good luck and farewell and walk away. If I was looking to spend that amount on a single player I'd expect them to be bringing regular goals or assists to the team in advance of what we already have. We aren't 60mill desperate for a central defender.
I think 60 million is about what he is worth. I don't think Newcastle should pay anymore but maybe offering a fringe player such as Targett might sweeten the deal for Palace
Lol they wouldn't want Targett. He's a Championship player
@@DanielCordone9 Hello SMB, back again trying to talk to adults?
Get a life and get back on to your mates on RTG.
@@gruffy4967 It's true though isn't it. Matt Targett isn't very good is he.
@@DanielCordone9 I think Target would be the best player in your Championship team. I don’t think your sad trolling impresses anyone though.
@@gruffy4967 Targett isn't even a Championship player. He's a liability.
Time to move on IMO... would be a great signing but not worth £65m IMO, especially when it's not even the area we need to strengthen the most.
We need RCB AND RW so I’d say it’s a position we need if schar gets injured, do u want to rely on krafth?? No thanks
65m+ for a guy who excelled against Slovakia and Serbia is INSANE
Lets hope this doesn't come back and bite us on the backside not getting a quality Centre back in for the early stages of the PL. Our defence was awful last season.
I hope this kid is good
Never heard of him until this
Thanks for updates keith.. why is longstaff. Fraser. Hendrick .Haydon. dubvraka . Lewis. Targett still here. Get rid of dead wood ..we need to step up .if we want to win things we need to be big fees for big players.
What a joke there is no negotiation from CP. Money talks as Neil Diamond says so KP is going to lose a decent offer and does not look good. I'd let the paint dry and wait for 24 months and get him on a free. With KP wallet minus 60 million😂
As long as there is a plan b they should stick with it. Palace will lose a lot of money by not selling now.
Can’t understand why we would spend that sort of money. Our defence isn’t that bad and just needs tightened up and in more need of RW.
It is a lot of money but for me a 24 year old English prem proven player who can play left and right side can't be underestimated
I believe the influence of our owners. Seems to put a market price on players above,what they are worth.
I reckon Guehi will be a Newcastle player by end of this window but it might run closer to deadline day than expected. I think Palace know the player wants to go and just a case of holding off till Newcastle pay what they want unless there's any real alternatives being looked at then Palace might take the offer that's on the table because Newcastle haven't got any rival bidders. Palace could end up with an unhappy player and no money if they don't accept.
I personally am not really arsed if Guehi gets signed or not. I think the offer currently is good enough and if they dont get Guehi im sure they'll get someone else pretty decent at that kind of money.
Would be happier seeing other players coming in we need more then one player and it would be good to see it happening after seeing United signing ✍️ players
Your right, we are absolutely fed up now. To be honest I'd like to see that he's more interested in coming. If he wants to come and us welcome him to the family he needs to push for the move to prove to us he wants it. That interview said to us he's happy where he is? Old news now let's find someone else
If the player wanted to he could force a move for the 60 Newcastle have offered. The fact he hasn't shows he isn't that bothered. Palace are doing whats right by them and fair play to them, the player should do the same if he wants the move.
Pull the plug on this 1 they just want to pull our pants down over this deal go for the 2 lads at Chelsea Chalobah and Madueke we could get both for the same price and it would solve our problems in both positions nice work Keith
love the office Keith! :) sometimes fans are their own worst enemy looking for conspiracies. it does feel like this is dragging on a fair bit. wonder why palace took 3 days to reject. any idea on that aside from time wasting?
There is no way of dressing it up- it has been an enormously underwhelming transfer window for NUFC. We moaned a bit about last summers window but that was pretty dam good in retrospect. I can only hope that we keep the nucleus of the squad fit but the glass man is already injured of course.
Much rather pay that amount for a RW who is going to chip in with goals and assists
Keith, any news on a new RW. I think this is the spot we need the most this season. What do you think?
Any ideas on 'plan B's' or maybe another young defender from a slightly more competitive league who could possibly be in and around the 1st team as back-up?
Bloody hell, did you get the NUFC Audio guy to film this 😂
Watched it back and think my mic was off
Forget this lad there are plenty other options around. Get Madueke in
Hi Keith Sorry to have bothered you after your dinner for a photo with my son, but thanks mate, Top man......
Comon guys get it done he would be unbelievable in our back line
We should pull out , with back and forth this looks dead but we must look at what's available abroad
I really hope we walk away. This price is ridiculous now and would set a dangerous president for us in the transfer market moving forward
I'd really like Guehi, largely for the sake of having another England international in the squad and obviously he's done well in recent times, but I do wonder if he's actually any better than Malick Thiaw who was supposedly available for around £35m.
The question would be is Guehi £30m better than Thiaw, a player with Champions League experience, and would Newcastle not perhaps be better off banking that £30m difference and pushing the boat out on a right winger.
I fully expect Newcastle to do business on one or two deals before the transfer window ends but I do have a concern about the lack of noise around some very obvious outgoings that should really be happening (Fraser, Lewis, Hayden and perhaps the likes of Almiron and Dubravka)
Young talent would be a great addition but it seems the financial doesn’t make sense.
I would rather us pull out and try to see if there's someone we can take a risk on who's younger and let them develop
Hi Keith, I can't say I agree with a lot of this on crystal Palace point of view I think its pretty low and I know everyone has a price but I think they are using everyone involved in the wrong way buddy and everyone knows it but can't say it and yes I am sick of hearing about it haha.
Thanks for updates
Any idea why this is being done so publicly? Is it Palace releasing all this information or is it from the Newcastle side?
This transfer was always a non-starter for me. It's a bargin basement summer for us, i always felt it would be. Cheers keith.
We have to leave it to Mitchell, but it would be interesting to know Eddie’s priority. My guess is is that his priority is a right winger, but there seems to be no progress there. I think Keith is right. The danger is that Mitchell has vested so much in this that he doesn’t want to lose face by walking away - especially as he has no obvious alternative lined up. As things stand, we have done rather better on transfers when we haven’t had a DOF than when we have ! I’m convinced that Amanda did more behind the scenes than most of us realise !
Completely agree that these sporting directors don't seem to be the essential role everyone thinks they are.
We're certainly no better off (from the outside looking in obv)
@@phil5357 We’ve still got two weeks to go. My worry is that we spend big on someone that Eddie doesn’t really want just so Mitchell can show he’s capable of big deals. In my view, it’s the coach’s head on the block if we don’t perform so the DOF has to buy according to what he wants. That worked well with Amanda. We never made a bad move in the market, but this is a new era and, as yet, it’s been underwhelming.