Was Gandhi Really A Mahatma? | Favouring British Over India | Abhijit Chavda
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มิ.ย. 2024
- Checkout my Introductory course Bharata: A Biography of the Oldest Civilization
Enroll here - abhijitchavda7460.ongraphy.co...
For business/collaboration, email at business.chavda@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
📸To stay in touch closely, let's connect online:
INSTAGRAM: abhijitchavda.page.link/Insta...
TWITTER: / abhijitchavda
TELEGRAM: t.me/TheAbhijitChavda
DISCORD: / discord
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/1WmKYRI...
My gear for shooting this video:
🎙Shure MV7 USB Podcast Microphone: amzn.to/3n1rcme
🎥Logitech C922 Pro Stream Webcam: amzn.to/3ZYyg1G
🎤RØDE Rodecaster Pro II: amzn.to/3Jwo3Cj
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Support The Channel:
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/AbhijitChavda
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
✅ Subscribe To Our Other TH-cam Channels:-
Abhijit Chavda Clips: @AbhijitChavdaClips
Abhijit Chavda हिंदी (Hindi Channel): @AbhijitChavdaHindi
Abhijit Chavda Vlog: @AbhijitChavda2
Indian Interest (Podcast): @IndianInterest
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Mahatma Gandhi is regarded as one of the most influential figures in the entire world. He was one of the key figures in getting India it’s independence. But the question is was Mahatma Gandhi really a Mahatma? In this video we compare Mahatma Gandhi to Abraham Lincoln and his legacy of pulling out America from a civil war and making it a superpower. We compare the steps taken by Mahatma Gandhi and Abraham Lincoln and analyse which was the better path for the country during times of distress. We talk about facts and figures of those times and try to come to a conclusion about who was a better leader. We also talk about Jinnah and Jawaharlal Nehru and their role in the partition and the governance of India respectively.
Let me know what you think about the same in the comments below!
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
About:
The Abhijit Chavda channel is an expansive library of content that uncovers the ‘HIDDEN TRUTH’ and offers a fascinating insight into ancient history, astrophysics, geopolitics, and science.
With over 40+ years of experience, Abhijit Chavda is a Geopolitics & History Expert and an Indian physicist.
He is the host of the AskAbhijit show and IndianInterest podcast which is the home for super-insightful discussions with subject matter experts from around the world on topics that covers national & international geopolitics, world and Indian history, astrophysics, philosophy, and many more every week.
There is something for EVERYONE on this channel. Abhijit Chavda's research-backed views on top Indian podcasts and case studies have made him one of the strongest voices in the Indian Digital Intellectual Space, and he has represented India at international forums, including the G20 summit.
#gandhi #abrahamlincoln #indianpolitics
“Freedom is not given - it is taken." -Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose.
houdhu
"Gandhi is our father of the nation". - Subhash chandra bose
Freedom through violence never ends well
USA Lincoln himself is an European orgin
Fight between separatist
West thought India would success even for year but we have 75+ history
@@Themenbuilt because netaji is true karmayyogi he read Shrimad Bhagwat Gita and swami vivekananda principles very well .He did his karma
I was slapped by my teacher for questioning Gandhi when I was just 10 as I was of opinion that he is no Mahatma. Today it feels so good to see that almost everyone is learning the same and I would like to meet my teacher again 😬😬
Pretty good knowledge for a 10 year old I would say.
Send this video to that teacher. 🙂
Now.. if your teacher is still alive then goto your teacher and slap him with your shoes and shout that Gandhi was a british ass licker..
You must have been brain washed and tutored by your parent, to denigrade Mahatma Gandhi, which is why your teacher slapped you.
A stupid teacher considering that Gandhi adopted non violence.
Savarkar is great ? One who apologized?
As a Sri Lankan I find it fascinating learning about the history of India which you don't find in textbooks. I love how the Indian population view such issues and are not blinded by the globalist narratives.
As Sri Lankan I believe our strongest geopolitical ally should be India and follow on their footsteps on foreign policy, which is the non alignment concept which would be key in preserving peace in our region during the coming conflict. 🇱🇰 🤝🏾 🇮🇳
👍
Excellent 👍
...during the coming conflict. fully agree. There's a big one coming and it's going to establish a new world order.
Post 2014 India see Sri Lanka, Nepal and Bhutan as part of the same civilisation. We're only divided by modern political nationhood borders but we're one. Sticks put together is harder to break for outsiders!
Agree, our culture is very similar, we should protect our identity by helping each other to Grow
Since childhood we have been brought up idolizing Gandhi, and to hear this parallel version, though convincing and truthful is a journey. To see History as it is, keeping our prejudices aside is a learning. 🙏
@@yamlajatt7481looks like you are living in delusion. Anyways people like you will never agree even if facts are presented
As Indians, it is important to recognize that Lincoln-like figures should be idolized in our country, rather than Gandhi. Our heroes should include figures such as Shivaji Maharaj, Sardar Patel, Subhash Chandra Bose, Chandra Gupta, and the Cholas, who served Bharat and upheld its cultural identity while pursuing national interests.
On a side note, I found the video to be very impressive, and I look forward to seeing more videos like it in the future. Perhaps...Sir, you could consider creating a video that explores the history, present, and future of the Anglo-Saxon Empire.
You missed it. Sardar Patel betrayed the Navy fighters, befooled them by false promises, and prosecution followed to oblivion.
@@satyabratachoudhury3503 probably under Gandhi’s pressure just as in case of choosing first prime minister of India.
Which Anglo-Saxon empire you are talking about? The Anglo-Saxon era of England has long gone.
*Netaji himself said Gandhiji was a symbol of Indian nationalism and called him “The Father of Nation" (Mahatama)... so was even Netaji wrong?*
Nelson Mandela walked on Gandhiji's principles in Africa and propagated Satyagraha etc. Martin Luther King Jr. of America too was heavily influenced by Gandhiji and mentioned it on numerous occasions.
Had Gandhiji joined the Military uprising against the UK and joined hands with Germany, USA would've Nuclear bombed India just after Japan.
Like any other leader, Gandhiji made several mistakes but he was the only one that showed a humanitarian way without fighting a war. *Why are we propagating war mongers like Mao and Stalin etc over Gandhiji, lol?*
If he was so much of the agent of the West, he wouldn't have done satyagrahas in South Africa and India against the British Crown.
Who do you think gave *"Do or die"* and *"Quit India movement"* if Gandhiji was such a softie?
Why did Veer Bhagat Singh say in his autobiography that youth should follow the noble principles of Gandhiji and You must support your general (Gandhi). Only then will you be able to win independence for the country”.
Gandhiji, Netaji, Patelji, Phuleji, Ambedkarji, Bahagat ji, Rajguruji, Savarkarji etc were all equally tall leaders in their own right.
And let's not even start the surname wars, Mahatma Gandhiji & PM Modiji are both Gujarati's.
Cheers 🎉
why the hell Lincoln-like i mean why even compare we don't relate to Linclon yaha pe bhi GORA he chaiye tell you what how about Patel-like bhagat singh-like. have a brain of your own.
I am South-African born Indian and I always wondered why people in South Africa including my family members were not trusting of Ghandi. This makes a lot of sense. Thank you for helping us understand our past. We appreciate you 🙏
he was pedo and fake saint
Yeah. I was wrong about Gandhi almost 28 of my life😢
Gandhi was a molle planted by british raj groomed from south africa.. India should apologise South African collered aboriginal people... For racisst gandhi's behaviour.
The commitment to non violance... When True patriotic son of India Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and INA entered India.. congress, neheru and gandhi vowed to use weapons against INA , citing so called Japanese occupation... Weapon against Netaji but non violance against British... gandhi vetoed partition in CWC(where he was not a member)
True power of gandhi: excuse of congress granting immens power and leadership"", british raj listined to him"" Vise Versa, excuse of british ,""congress the so called all people of India listined to him ""
Gandhi use to sleep naked with his grand daughters,can search in google.
@@FalseProphetMuhammad but why he acted for British
My Dad and his family were a victim of the Bengal partition. He was the eldest son in the family and he had to run away from erstwhile East Pakistani all by himself at the age of 14 and struggle in Bharat to reestablish himself while sleeping at the railway station until he found a job and a place to live and bring all his family members to Bharat. My entire family always loathed the Nehrus and Gandis. I wonder why God never punished them ever.
That's quite saddening! Yeah, as you expressed, I also feel that India was cursed by God by sending these 'Great Souls'! :(
Agree bro, but without any sins no one can touch us.
Unknowing taking side of wrong also have some time huge penalty.
Being a bad is far better then being have good label.
During my childhood i wondered how Ghandhi lived as a Mahatma. But when i entered inside my heart i have questions on Gandhi and Nehru
1. For Gandhi who gave rights to give partition on India
2. For Nehru why he ruled like a British agent
Now my wish atleast nxt generation true history should be educated. Stop celebrating this British agent
Future documentary ideas :-
•Mahabharata
•Ramayana
•How British (& Mughals) ruined India
•The future of India (Indian economy in 2030 and beyond)
Feel free to add more in the reply section (if someone's interested)
Sardar patel
Vedas ,purana
Islamic mythology
For Rāmāyaṇa especially the itihasic Rāmāyaṇa itself i.e Vālmiki Rāmāyaṇa watch 21 notes TH-cam channel which is also completely devoid of ad sense monitisation
Add Maratha empire full history and governance
Why Netaji should be called the "Father of the Nation" instead of Gandhi
My blood still boils whenever I think , watch or listen anything about partition and what the Britishers did to our country hands in hands with Gandhi and Nehru ! You hv done a brilliant task ! I pray to Lord Shiva that India shld rise to its former glory in my lifetime 🙏🏻
Partition, though many may not accept, was or is not a problem please rethink about it. Improper partition is the problem. Translocation of the population should have been done, not very immediately but on a planned basis over a suitable period of time. Why it was not considered is very well known to us.
Don't forget the 'm'ain reason responsible for that! 🙄
@@jigneshparmar3526Wrong!
Jinnah was good ? Or was it just gandhi and nehru
Out of topic... But I request you all to choose our upcoming leader wisely in lok sabha elections 2024.... We need a strong candidate for this country..🧡
When I was a kid , i used to wonder why Mohandas and jawaharlal never felt the pain of laathi in India, and i remember our sincere teacher told us these two , though arrested , they enjoyed all daily routines of life, but when asked why the normal citizens never even recieved normal medical treatment 💅 an old video was seen as Mohandas was protected by Britishers, but the others were bleeding , 🙏👍👌💪, what was the truth,. .
Mahatma is a title given by the illuminati's to Mohandas. So is *Rabindranath* "Thakur" (Tagore) His poems are copied from some where. The history of "Thakurs" is that there ancestors belonged to the infamous Chandanpur ( not sure of the town but the town starts with a C) And these *notorious bandits* nabbed peoples land and gold - acquired wealth and called themselves *Thakur*s, which translated in Bengali is also called " god ". With their power of their wealth they have appreciated themselves in the media. The caste divisions were very strong in India and hence they could not unite as they should and it was leveraged by Nehru ( the guys father had all the stolen wealth of the shah) ….. and the rest is
Exactly. They both never have a single Bruce on any part of the body 😂😂😂😂. Don’t know how leader of the pack never got hit if he was really working on our side
Congress Party was creared by British Bureaucrat
Nothing like a Nehru or Gandhi roast by Abhijit on a Sunday evening 😂
*Shri Nehru, one of the greatest Prime Ministers of India ! Abhijit ji's sarcasm is unparalleled :D
😂😂😂 made my sunday
This is not roasting MF its hard truthful fact which we dont know and you want entertainment roasting watch carryminati dont post this kind of nonsense comments😠
That's quite Tru....
I am actually watching it on Sunday evening right now 😂
I am a foreigner, from a very far place from India. My father was a very well educated man, who used to read a lot about world history and many other topics. I know just a few things about the political history of Bharat, just the barely essentials.
Then, at 19 years old, I started practicing Yoga and later on went to a trip to Bharat. Once, my father told me this: "People think Gandhi was a great man and a reformer of India. If only people knew his true story, his indecent ways of living, people would think very differently about him". I was shocked to hear that from my father. But, later on, learning a little more about Bharat's history, and with this type of critical thinking videos, now I come to understand my father's words. Thanks for this video!
If you really love Gandhi then read the book "Why I killed Gandhi" by Nathu Ram Godse and you will know the real truth about Gandhi. What happened with Gandhi is the same thing that happened with Mother Teresa. People in India when they saw western journalists getting amazed by Mother Teresa themselves started thinking that Mother Teresa might be a great figure and hence all the popularity came at India's expense.
Yeea right lol
जय श्री राम 💐💐🙏
You don’t have to know from father Gandhiji himself has written in his autobiography also there are some spiritual aspects which a common man would not understand. To understand Gandhiji read his books. Also read book Autobiography of Yogi by paramhansa Yogananda and his chapter on Gandhiji
Thank you for sharing your father wise thoughts
Wow, simple, yet straightforward & powerful questions. Thank you sir, for your perspective !
Finally, someone talking sense and is actually interesting to listen to. Many thanks and regards Mr AC :)
OMG what a coincidence today! This morning I saw a short video where you explained about Eichman (and I watched the movie yesterday about him) and now the explanation whether Gandhi was a mahatma (I was just discussing this with my friend from India).
Thank you Sir 🙏🏻 I love India and I have been watching you from Switzerland for quite some time now.
hey i remember you from morning
Abhijit is a Super star in India Now
@@Highly910 yeah...I am surprised too that the answeres I have been looking for in the past two days I got them today by Sir Chavda
Lakshay@ true.
What Swiss people watch Indian content?
Thank you sir. I live In America and I watch you regularly. And I am the better informed because of it. You have enlarged my understanding of history and geo politics. Spiritually , India has given the world more wealth than what the British have stolen.
Thanks 😢
Well said
But india itself lacking in all of these due to these governments
_420 % TRUE_ 🤣🤣🤣
*LAFOOOOT MAHATMA GANDHI & NEHRU Both Are BRITISH PARTNERS* 😠😠😠
*Gandhi 1947 Year INDIA County Divides Two Parts ONE Muslims Country Pakistan* ( _Muslims 90 % Population_ ) *And SECOND FAKE SECULAR Country INDIA* ( _90 % Hindus_
_Why FAKE SECULARS GANDHI & NEHRU Always Hate For HINDU Religion & HINDUSTAN Country Division_ 😂😂😂
*INDIA FAKE SECULAR Country & FAKE Division in 1947 year* 😱😱😱
*PAKISTAN CONGRESS Gandhi ,,, xyz PARTY introducing FAKE INDIAN SECULAR History Books introduced in INDIAN Education system & School History Books* 😂
Absolutely amazing podcast Abhijit, mind blowing and v enlightening. Not to mention the excellent analysis (running out of adjectives!)
Indians were so good as to tolerate Gandhi- Nehru group
If I was taught history civics in school by Abhijit chavda ji.... Durga Mata would know where I'd be today in life
Brilliant explanation sir!! So nicely you brought out the point that the real issue was not non-violence... The issue was whose interest was being served.. very nicely explained how even using non voilance he could have achieved it... Never thought in this angle
I barely remember the history that I have studied during my school because those stories were never compelling to me but I remember almost every point you mention Mr. Abhijit. Thank you for the enlightenment.
WHAT A TOPIC!!!! I was thinking the same from long time. Thank You Abhijit. For 75 Years we have been given Gandhi Churaan by Indian National Congress and Biased Historians.
Mohandas “Mūḍhātmā” Gandhi was arguably the GREATEST sinner in the history of the nation known as “India” (correctly called “Bhārata”), because he helped usher-in (so-called) democracy.
Any form of governance other than a legitimate MONARCHY is intrinsically evil.
Ask me to explain the REASON for my seemingly-audacious assertion.
😇 सत्यमेव जयते! 😇
@@TheWorldTeacher yes right
!!!...Greatest Sinner!
I got one.
Why exactly Europeans were able to colonise other countries, why they developed earlier and why not Asian and African countries were able to do it?
True
@@TheWorldTeacher you think monarchy isn't evil? one person having absolute control over everyone isn't hindering anyone's rights?
This is what youth wants...
As grown up in middle class Hindu family our parents always tolled us that Gandhi was Mahatma and God like.... For what? Even they didn't had the satisfying answer...
History should be clear and factual!
Thanks for bringing such topics on such a big platform 🤗
Most today's youth don't want to know our country's history they say it's a waste of time and it doesn't get them jobs unfortunate
In fact our old generation were unaware of the truth that Gandhi, Nehru and Congress were British creation...? To liberate the oppressed the oppressors formed an organisation called Indian National Congress, controlled by the Britishers for years,
and years, ... then two leaders of Indian origin working abroad under British Raj were brought to India to lead the freedom struggle... difficult to digest for any sensible Indian..??
@@ramanakanchibhatta4316 Lmao. Not like their Btech degree is getting them jobs anyways.
मगर मेरे पिताजी हम लोगो को बताया करते थे की गांधी और नेहरू चरित्रहीन थे जबकि सकूल में गांधी और नेहरू का महिमामंडन किया जाता था। आज पिताजी दुनिया में नहीं है लेकिन अब सारे लोग जब ये बात कहते हैं तो लगता है कि वो सही कहते थे।
If you are dare enough write an authoritative book and put for discussion. In social media you can speak whatever you want without any proof! What authority you have to retell the whole Indian freedom struggle? The people whom you support never participated in it but surrounded to the British!
Mahatma Gandhi's decision to serve as a medical assistant in the British Army during the Zulu War, despite his opposition to British colonial rule in India, was a complex one and rooted in his evolving beliefs and strategies for achieving change. Here are a few key reasons for his decision:
Patriotism and Loyalty: Gandhi believed in the idea of Indian patriotism and wanted to demonstrate that Indians were willing to serve the British Empire in times of need. He hoped that by showing loyalty to the British during a crisis, it would highlight the inconsistency of denying basic rights to Indians.
Bridge Building: Gandhi saw this as an opportunity to build bridges with the British and create a platform for dialogue. He believed that by working alongside British officials and soldiers, he could better understand their perspectives and convey his message of Indian self-governance.
Nonviolence and Service: Gandhi was a staunch advocate of nonviolence (ahimsa) and believed in the power of service to humanity. His role as a medical assistant allowed him to provide humanitarian aid without directly participating in violent conflict.
Learning Experience: Gandhi viewed this experience as a way to learn valuable skills and gain insights into the workings of the British military, which could potentially be useful in his future efforts for Indian self-determination.
nice comment. I felt that examining Gandhi volunteering to help the British being looked at in a negative light is plainly reductionist and biased.
Great. You hv spoken my mind
Dhruv rathee be like : isne toh sach bol diya
😂
Ye to dhoti khol raha hai
German shepard dog army is coming for you
@@GAMINGBLAZE they can't do anything because they are weak chamcha supporters and non violence
@AbraCAdabra99 iam demoting him
In an interview to BBC, Dr. Ambedkar said “Gandhi was never a Mahatma; I refuse to call him a Mahatma. He was just an episode in the history of India, not an epoch maker”. But this was not just about Ambedkar, even spiritual leaders like Aurobindo held the same view. In the informal talks with his disciples, Aurobindo exclaimed that “The Congress at the present stage-what is it but a fascist organisation? Gandhi is a dictator like Stalin, what Gandhi says they accept and even the Working Committee follows him; then it goes to the All-India Congress Committee which adopts it, and then the Congress.”
Gandhi was a shrewd politician who kept intermingling with his two personalities. When his politics failed, he adapted the role of Mahatma, when his credentials of Mahatma were in danger, (like his “Experiments on Brahmacharya”) he turned back to Politics.
Statement of B.R. Ambedkar- “If there’s any ‘ism’ which has made full use of religion as an opium to lull people into false beliefs and false securities, it is Gandhism. Following Shakespeare, one can well say: Plausibility! Ingenuity! Thy name is Gandhism.
gandhi was an admant old fashioned Hindu , he pressed on hinduism , bhajans and core hindu principles where ever he went ambedkar on the other hand was at the reciveing end of caste biased society he spent his entire life reforming hindu society and class structure thus he always had gandhi ji in envy , it was gandhi who subdued him in favour of having joint electorates
@@jacob9182😑 am I supposed to be a blind follower of Ambedkar that I have to agree with everything he said for anything 😒. Things don't work like that
@@saikiranrao4281 Hahaha nice joke
Rishi Aurobindo * 😊
@@saikiranrao4281 nice joke …. Gandhi was a Hindu
Very to the point video. Hat's off to the courage.
Very intelligent analysis! Simple and true! Worth sharing with the world!
Had this feeling since school that Subhash Chandra Bose should’ve lead the Independence War. This video helps to realise the politics involved of promoting some other leaders.
Personal Interest of political leaders have affected our nation.
Let's share this as much as we can !!! This is gold
Mohandas “Mūḍhātmā” Gandhi was arguably the GREATEST sinner in the history of the nation known as “India” (correctly called “Bhārata”), because he helped usher-in (so-called) democracy.
Any form of governance other than a legitimate MONARCHY is intrinsically evil.
Ask me to explain the REASON for my seemingly-audacious assertion.
😇 सत्यमेव जयते! 😇
Perfect n precise data explanation
Immaculate comparitive analysis by Avijit Sir. Thanks again for sharing the video.
जय भारत ❤️
Avijit is younger than me, but thanks to his channel that I was able to see my mental colonization. Great job buddy, keep this going. And as a Bengali, whose family experienced partition I have much dislike for Mr Gandhi..
Gandhi was a molle planted by british raj groomed from south africa.. India should apologise South African collered aboriginal people... For racisst gandhi's behaviour.
The commitment to non violance... When True patriotic son of India Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and INA entered India.. congress, neheru and gandhi vowed to use weapons against INA , citing so called Japanese occupation... Weapon against Netaji but non violance against British... gandhi vetoed partition in CWC(where he was not a member)
True power of gandhi: excuse of congress granting immens power and leadership"", british raj listined to him"" Vise Versa, excuse of british ,""congress the so called all people of India listined to him ""
@@RM-vx7oxcharkasur is a super word brother
How and why were you mentally colonized? Can you please explain?
Unfortunately the man who actually gave India freedom didn't got his due. Let's appreciate his contribution and give him his due instead of glorifying the dalals of the British. JAI HIND!!!!! 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
M K Gandhi's influence was less than 10% in the independence movement.. Open your eyes. M K Gandhi was a coward.
Superbly explained and convinced with your wonderful explanation
Please continue this format discussing Indian history in comparative manner. Make a lot more sense for viewers in critical thinking.
The threat of Subhas Bose and his INA was responsible for India's independence - Clement Atlee (British PM during 1947, The man who signed Indian independence act)
Thank you for educating us!
Most superb analysis ever heard . Hats of to Chavada
Gandhi was my hero when i was young , but now after now knowing the true history , i consider Mr. Bose , savarkar ,nathu Ram Godse and other who laid their lives for freedom as my heroes
Utmost respect to Godse. He sacrificed his own interests for Bharath. Else, Gandhi would have made Bharath much worse. Who knows, he would have allowed Hyderabad to remain separate nation? And also that West pak to east pak corridor. Just thinking of it makes me relalise how messed up it would have been.
Jai ho Godseji ki.
Gandhi was a molle planted by british raj groomed from south africa.. India should apologise South African collered aboriginal people... For racisst gandhi's behaviour.
The commitment to non violance... When True patriotic son of India Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and INA entered India.. congress, neheru and gandhi vowed to use weapons against INA , citing so called Japanese occupation... Weapon against Netaji but non violance against British... gandhi vetoed partition in CWC(where he was not a member)
True power of gandhi: excuse of congress granting immens power and leadership"", british raj listined to him"" Vise Versa, excuse of british ,""congress the so called all people of India listined to him ""
From childhood i see gandhi a suspicious man 🤨
Because of him we are divided 😐
British Servant 🤷♂
Ab kuch nai chupega 🤐
gandhi allegedly slept with 80 women in his lifetime, now if thats who you want to call ' Father of the Nation' then go on
Abhijit sir saying " was gandhi really a MAHATMA?" says it all 😂 . Sir don't you think Indian government should stop following gandhi's ideology and should follow Netaji's ideology?
Unfortunately the man who freed India never really got his due and the one who partitioned it is still smiling shamelessly on our notes 😪
@@vs_916 that's what i hat-e :5
Gayn-dhi
All of sudden everyones became super geopolitical geniuses, sorry bhai... Ap ko ias Or ajit doval ki sit pad baithna chahiye tha
Netaji himself gave Gandhi the tile Mahatma and father of the nation...
Make a Documentry on "Why India must become Dharmic Rashtra".
A brilliant narration founded onfacts and research ..thank you
Absolutely Truth spoken and imagined by Abhijitji
I could not agree more. Thank you sir for detailed analysis, non-violence was never the answer for freedom, it was just the act of traitor.
Then what was the solution? This youtuber has no creditworthyness just some random youtuber. Even Modi knows the worth of Gandhi. Gandhi saw Indias problems for the next 100 years and made sure India will survive it. He was a visionary, tell me genius? Would a violent revolution would be the solution? Where it happens like in the french revolution? Yes you kick everyone out, but who will decide who gets power? Then internal fights and struggles. Please think next time. This youtuber is western agent. Gandhi wasnt perfect, but truly a genius compared to anyone else during his time.
@@aviaugustin6736
The PEOPLE of India would have "decided who gets the power"! lol
Did the Indian and 'muslim' people LIVE TOGETHER under the beastly british invaders? YES!
You seem to have no faith and trust that Indian people COULD AGAIN rule themselves .... as they have done FOR THOUSANDS OF YEARS prior? lol
The WARS between India & Pakistan ARE "violent revolutions" among the SAME Indian people.
Without the deceptive and devilish division of Indian people, Indian people WOULD NOT TODAY threatening to exterminate themselves with NUCLEAR WEAPONS!
You see, little one, being fearful of "revolution" and being nonsensical 'non-violent' ARE NOT eliminators of violent "revolutions".
Not everyone is equipped to do Politics, regardless of how many people will follow said one.
Gandhi was ill-equipped to do Politics for a nation.
The WARS and Nuclear Threats hanging over the heads of Indian people in BOTH India and 'Pakistan' ARE PROOF POSITIVE that Ghandi's non-violence was misguided or childish at best.
@@aviaugustin6736
Ask Modi what is his view on Islam?
He won't say the truth.
Politicians are bound by political correctness.
You expect them to speak bitter truth??
Stop judging the merit of a statement by the person speaking that statement.
@@aviaugustin6736
Was Gandhi able to stop the Mopla muslims slaughtering Hindus? No.
Was Gandhi able to stop the Direct Action Day? No.
Was he able to stop the Partition? No.
Eventually Partition happened, whatever threats you mentioned, already happened. Gandhi's Peace talks & Lip service couldn't save anything.
It was Sardar Patel who united the 535 princely states. Junagarh, Kashmir, Hyderabad were united by Patel through Non-Violence??
Stupid Gandhian policy is the reason why we lost the 1962 war to China.
Indians were united against the British way before Gandhi came. Before Gandhi it was Lal, Bal, Pal that started the freedom movement on the Pan-National level. Parallel to Gandhi's Non-Violence, there were Armed revolutionaries like Netaji, Bhagat Singh, Alluri Sitaram Raju and so many others. Unity is not a sole monopoly of Gandhi. Gandhi's idea of Hindu-Muslim unity was that Muslims keep attacking Hindus and Hindus must keep getting beaten up. That was Gandhi's idea of Hindu-Muslim brotherhood. You think this kind of "brotherhood" would last long??
@@aviaugustin6736
Solution is what Lincoln did.
Solution is what Sardar Patel did.
Sardar Patel did not unite the 535 princely states on the deluded Gandhian policy of Satyagrah.
He twisted the arms where it was necessary.
The princely states joined the Indian Union for their own safety, security & interests, Not because of some Deluded Pervert oldman's Satyagrah fantasies.
Had there been no Gandhi, the princely states would have still joined the Indian union because the idea of one nation BHARAT MATA had already been cultivated way before Gandhi's arrival.
Point blank shoot, AC I just follow and adore your talks.
Excellent explanation , thanks
This explains Krishna’s call to do Mahabharata so well!
No one can accuse you of being biased against Americans because you are also scrutinizing one of the most important figures of Indian history widely revered around the world
Brilliant. Fully agree
Very articulated and analysed
I loved the editing...made the video very engaging while imparting knowledge🙏
this is not editing why i wacthing this video this is the man of knowlege
Fantastic video i just feel so sad that even today 99 percent Indians consider Gandhi as hero and i don't blame them because even i 2 years ago worshiped him
Things will change for the good.
WOW!!! I'm very surprised of what I just heard!
Great job. 👍🏽
Abhijit, the historical narrative is excellent. But as a ex military man, I must say your strategic assumptions from 15.00 onwards are really well thought out. Completely agree. The 'possibilities' are astounding and we, as a nation are very slowly but surely recovering our poise, power and influence and only in recent times. Thank you for this presentation. Shashi.
If we blur the differences between India and USA and solely judge Gandhi and Lincoln we will find a heart wrenching truth. Gandhi was British slave, he could have done many things to achieve independence but each time when his movement start to achieve success,he took steps back. I think Gandhi was only in favour of getting more rights for Indians and never thought for freedom (actually). Even after quit India(1942) when Brits won the ww2 (1945), they actually thought for another 25years plan to implement.
Gandhi was not even favor of getting more rights for Indians; especially persecuted Hindus here or Jews in Germany!! He asked them to surrender & get killed!!
👍💐But sir,
It should called as freedom or liberation instead of Independance because "who depended on whom?".In my opinion the British depended on India for everything,for centuries,not the other way around.
What rights did Gandhi get for Indians?? Right to get killed and give their lives for M's & British??!!
Very apt comparison,
Duty and a National divide !
I am absolutely in agreement with your statements.
Such a diplomatic takedown of ‘Mahatma’ has never been attempted before, Abhijit has made it into a fine Art !!!
This was so crisply explained with facts. I used to be a hardcore Lutyens specimen because of being educated in a Christian school. It was only during 2005-06 when my interest in reading changed to history from thrillers and espionage etc., that I learned the true history of my country. Since then, I’ve become humbler and developed a strong sense of pride in being an Indian and a Hindu.
Thank you for this fantastic video, Abhijit 🙏🏼
How were you before? And what was taught to you in Christian school? And what made you change your mind?
I received my education from a convent school too but never even once in my life have I had any delusions about who our real heroes were. I have been a BJP/Modi supporter since the very beginning, been a huge fan of the heavy handed lessons given to pissfulls during Godhra, been repulsed by 'Lutyens specimens' always, never once have I ever got interested in the extremely boxed european philosophers, and have never in my life mocked or looked down upon anyone who couldn't speak English.
I know your kind very well. Basically people like you - and there are a lot of such kind - are weak minded people who get easily influenced especially by 'gori chamdi $hit'. If some dolled up razdan spewed douchebaggery words about modi from her delhi studio, lutiyen specimen types went with placards and candles on kartavya path.
I will never understand people who get enchanted just because they received their education in English which is just another Fcuking language. Have you guys got no self-respect? or do you come from families that, sadly, abhor everything related to Bharatiya sanskriti like bowing down to elders, touching their feet etc? As you can see, I am able to manage well communicating in this unscientific, illogical language but I have never had to be guided by someone to know that gandhis were (and are) the rot, that Hindi-speaking people are more intelligent etc.
I appreciate you are changed person now but my rant is against your past because even to this day, kids going to convent schools in Delhi think they are gods just because they speak american garbage phrases and have binge watched american soft porn a.k.a. sitcoms. And we need to stop the assembly line that produces this gender fluid breed. I pi$$ on england, america and all that they have done and continue to do to his day to the world. I didn't need any Abhijit Chavda to tell me that. I wish english-medium schools get banned.
What a comprehensive account 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Very good information well explained
This new style of video is amazing. I love it
We need this type of Videos. Loved it sir. Thanks.
Was waiting for this .. thank u sir
Most sensible analysis
I am so happy to have found this channel . Thank you sir . In today’s context, the questions you pose can’t be any easier to answer . We see clearly !
😊
Very well scripted and presented, we love your generous contribution in educating the people of this great nation. Thank you so much Abhjit Sir....We Love you
Very well summarised comparison.
I completely agree with you.
This was AMAZING...
We definately need more long form videos especially on history like this.
BIG UPS
We need more videos such as this one. Please make this a regular thing!
We are deeply obliged to you, sir, for revealing pristine truths in an unforgettable manner. God bless you. You are one of the immortal heroes of renaissant India. You are an inspiration for learned people for finding out truth and proclaiming it boldly.
Thank u, spread everyday
Impeccable as usual.
Freedom is not gifted.. It is earned ❤
MG as a character itself is very confusing. However, one thing that I derive from the facts is that he put himself (his image) prior to his nation.
Excellent and informative video...
Great page you have here
My Birthday is 02/10, Never have compared it with Bdate of Mr.Gandhi, Always Shshtri ji, As per your conclusion due to some good teachers and critical thinking I was able to derive the role of Mr.Gandhi in our freedom movement in the std.5 and never have looked upon him for leadership while constantly seeking it from Saradar Vallabhbhai Patel, Veer Savarkar and Shahid Bhagat Singh like figures, It fills me with joy that more and more people are realising how brainwashes we were in the past. THANK YOU FOR THIS VIDEO.
#AskAbhijit sir, archaeologists found an ink pen made of gold from mohenjo daro and an ink feast from Chanhudaro(an saraswati-sindhu site) which definitely dated back well before 1000BCE
Unfortunately our historians are busy in claiming that indians don't have a writing system before the greeks came and introduced it
How the hell do you even get this kind of in dept info
@@rakheethakur1814 By doing 20-30mins of serious research! If you're curious about something.. You gonna find things like him
Hey there! LOVE THE FACTS. Can you please tell us how you got this?
@@SpectreKritical watch sanatan samiksha
We all would love to see that golden pen how can we see it?
Brilliant Exposition!!
Sure .no doubt about it . Crystal clear
Absolute eye opener, fully packed with facts
Kudos to you @abhijit sir
Like this video so that it can reach to more people
Salute to you for bold and True analysis the real history should e informed to people Thanks Vilas Deole
Jai hind bhai… very informative video loved it
eye opening for most of the people. Gurudev abhijit chavda🙏
Sir you're great! This kind of documentry should be posted once a month or Bi-monthly! This must be a way to teach history in everyclass! Your work is doing De-colonization! Making Bharat!
Wow. This is a very well presented video.
Great discussion.. the deadpool comic strip at 5.53.. was it intentional 😂😂
Excellent Information 🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏 i was desperately waiting for this type of series!!!!!
Sir u r a gem nd i feel really lucky to come across a podcast of urs with ranveer nd since then a huge fan of urs really love your podcasts
I really like this video.. thankyou
And here comes more than 50 shades of History, Thankyou for the insights Sir ;)