WHICH DEHYDRATOR IS BEST? Excalibur VS Cosori VS Nesco Food Dehydrators
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 มี.ค. 2021
- Have you ever wondered which dehydrator is best? I put three of the most popular dehydrators to the test - which one is the champion? (CLICK MORE FOR INFO)
At Cosori:
GET 15% off sl.vesync.com/Bq7trp USE CODE TPP15
Get 15% off the Cosori Premium Stainless Steel Dehydrator, any accessories, and all other kitchen appliances they carry.
At Excalibur:
excaliburdehydrator.com?aff=19
At Amazon:
Cosori Dehydrator: amzn.to/3fkWgr6
Excalibur Dehydrator: amzn.to/39mLD3j
Nesco Dehydrator: amzn.to/2Pv3CNY
Cutting Glove: amzn.to/3crG3OV
Which dehydrator is best for you? www.thepurposefulpantry.com/t...
5 Day Mini Dehydrating Course: fantastic-maker-9968.ck.page/...
MORE VIDEOS ON DEHYDRATING: bit.ly/2Sat9tU
📖 My Books
*NEW* DEHYDRATING BASICS & JOURNAL
All the info you need to learn to dehydrate - plus keep an ongoing record of all of your projects!
shop.thepurposefulpantry.com
BEGINNER'S DEHYDRATING TOOLBOX: shop.thepurposefulpantry.com/...
30-DAY PANTRY CHALLENGE
shop.thepurposefulpantry.com/...
SUBSCRIBE: / thepurposefulpantry
📑 N E W S L E T T E R 📑
Free printables library and weekly tutorials and tips
www.thepurposefulpantry.com/l...
🧰Tools I Use & Recommend🧰
🛒 Shop for everything here: www.amazon.com/shop/thepurpos...
Cosori Dehydrator with coupon codes! thepurposefulpantry.com/cosori
Excalibur Dehydrator: amzn.to/2X4q8N5
Sahara Folding Dehydrator: brodandtaylor.com/darcy-baldwin
Nutri-Ninja to grind powders: amzn.to/325OYOo
Vacuum Sealer: amzn.to/3Lhmbzs
Wide Mouth & Regular Mouth jar attachments: amzn.to/2Ie2zOu
Handheld Vacuum Sealer amzn.to/3cJ1WYK
For Jar Lids: forjars.co?sca_ref=1912723.5vNLp0drZl Use Code PANTRY10 for an extra 10% off any purchase
Harvest Right Freeze Dryer: affiliates.harvestright.com/4...
GreenStalk Garden Tower: lddy.no/1fw97 Use code PANTRY10 to get $10 off $75 purchase
👀 To see more of the tools I love, check out my Amazon Store!
www.amazon.com/shop/thepurpos...
👕 MY T-SHIRTS & MORE ☕
Canning Shirts @ Amazon: amzn.to/2JyY0gl
Canning Shirts, mugs, and more @ TeePublic: www.teepublic.com/user/thepur...
Dehydrating Shirts: amzn.to/34gg1t0
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
◄ L E T S C H A T ►
Dehydrating Tips & Tricks
/ dehydratingtipsandtricks
🖥️ C O N N E C T W I T H M E 🖥️
WEBSITE: thepurposefulpantry.com
INSTAGRAM: / thepurposefulpantry
FACEBOOK: / thepurposefulpantry
PINTEREST: https:://pinterest.com/thepurposefulpantry
EMAIL thepurposefulpantry at gmail dot com
📫 MAILING ADDRESS: I love letters and will always write back!
The Purposeful Pantry • P.O. Box 125 • Allen, TX 75013
I am an Amazon Associate member which means that I may receive a small commission on a purchase made through these links, at no cost to you.
#bestdehydrator #thepurposefulpantry #fooddehydratorreview
![แฉ [2/4] 17 ก.ค. 67 “ลิลลี่ เหงียน” เปิดใจหลัง “เอิร์ก เลเดอเรอร์” ตอกกลับเรื่องโกงเงิน 50 ล้าน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/s8KapfEO5NI/mqdefault.jpg)
I started out with an inexpensive round dehydrator. Simple on/off, no adjustment for temperature. It dried everything as if I were making beef jerky. Result was poor, at best. Gave up on dehydrating until a neighbor loaned me her Excalibur. Fell in love with it. This was an older model with the controls on the front. Sadly I had to return hers. Shortly thereafter I received my 9 tray w/timer. That was in 2001. Yes, 20 years ago! It still works. Couple of years ago, I bought a new fan kit for it, for just in case. Havent' needed it.
Also had a 4 tray that I liked to use to make yogurt. Gave that one to my sister. While I'm glad I could help her out, sometimes I wish I still had it for small batches and yogurt.
Even though it's fairly large, mine has a permanent place on a kitchen counter. It is a multipurpose machine. Yes, I dehydrate fruits and vegetables. Buy things like green peppers, celery and onions when on sale. Using a Chop Wizard style cutter, it doesn't take long to have a batch ready for a full load in the dehydrator. Same thing for in season fruits. Take advantage of sales and local farmers markets.
Appreciate the amount of food I can get on the square trays. That was another complaint I had with my round dehydrator.
Also watch for sales of plain frozen vegetables. Especially, mixed vegetables and green peas. All the prep work has been done! Break up the clumps before opening the bag. Spread the frozen food on the trays and load the dehydrator. To catch any drips, I keep a sheet of parchment paper on the floor of my Excalibur. Held down with a few river stones, found at one of the discount stores that are used in vases for flower arrangements. Been using 6 stones, 3 across the front and 3 across the back.
I use my dehydrator to dry 2 liter soda bottles used to store rice, popcorn, blackeye peas, sugar and such. Take out the trays and lay the bottles on their side with the mouth facing the back of the dehydrator. Takes about 20 minutes rather than hours to dry them.
Since last year, I've been using my dehydrator to heat jars for pressure canning. Remove the trays and set the jars on the floor of the dehydrator. It will hold 7 quarts, 16 wide mouth pints or 18 regular mouth jars. I start these when I start heating the water in the canner. The jars are hot when I need them. I've canned around 500-600 jars, mainly pints, since I started this and haven't had a problem.
A good dehydrator is well worth the investment. If mine fails and I can't repair it, I wouldn't hesitate to order another one.
Hope this helps, someone.
Great ideas here!!😊
Why would you dry out plastic bottles?
@@SkelNeldory When plastic bottles, such as soda and juice bottles are used for dry food storage, they need to first be thoroughly washed, rinsed, sanitized and dried. Once clean, it takes a fairly long time for them to air dry on the inside. They must be completely dry before adding food to be stored.
Using a suitable dehydrator reduces the time from a couple of days to approx 20 minutes, depending on several variables.
Note: 2 or 3 liter soda bottles are strong because they must endure the pressure of a carbonated beverage. Thus, they are an option for long term food storage of appropriate items. (Rice, sugar, salt, small dried beans & peas, popcorn and such.
Disposable water bottles do not make good candidates for long term dry food storage. They are biodegradable, thus will break down fairly quickly.
Can you please tell us the brand cus we are all looking for the best dehydrator to buy
@@richardazianyo3443 My dehydrator is an Excalibur 9 tray with timer.
Cosori... is quiet... I'm sold!
When I made the decision to buy a dehydrator, I compared the Excalibur to the Cosori and I finally bought the Cosori due to the cost for one, but had every quality as the Excalibur. And I can say, the Cosori has not let me down.
Mine let me down 1 year after purchase
@@canonli Well I haven't had mine that long but I have been using it a LOT, so we'll see how it does. Most people who I've seen who recommend it also too love theirs and have heard no complaints about them. Maybe try and get in touch with them.
How are you liking your cosori now
@@kawaiisenshi2401 I am still loving my Cosori. I use it a lot, even during the winter months and non canning season.
I bought a Cosori because it was cheaper than Excalibur, rated at lower decibels, and had a hinged door. I love it and am really happy with my decision. I cut old white sheet into squares to fit trays. When finished dehydrating I wash squares in vinegar and air dry. That eliminates heated plastic mesh.
Thanks for sharing!
What a great tidbit of info!!!! Sheets 🤦♀️ I would not have thought of that on my own!! Awesome share, thank you 👍
@@donnagarcia4541 thanks for the compliment, but it was not an original idea. Somewhere in my deh
@@donnagarcia4541 didn’t finish my comment🤪. Somewhere in my dehydrating journey another utuber posted it.
Awesome idea.
I have a 5-tray Excaliber that I found at an estate sale for $20! It's an older one, but it works great. If I'd had to spend $300 for it, I probably would have chosen another brand, but I got VERY lucky!!
I got one for $50 at ya
I ended up getting a chinese knockoff of the excalibur. It was actually bigger which was a huge plus, and worked about as well, but the trays were incredibly cheap.
Sweet !!!!!
Just wanted to add my two cents and express my joy at finding a barely used 4 tray Excalibur for 15 bucks. Can't wait to start this dehydration journey.
When I got my Nesco, 10+ years ago, I didn’t even know there were others. I got an amazing deal, 12 trays, 12 fruit trays, and 12 mesh trays for less than the 4-tray units. I’ve used it happily, until I watched your video. Now I feel like I want the latest and bestest. But then I look at my old faithful slow poke and guess I’m pretty happy. It’s worked this long. I’ll keep it.
Thank you for a very interesting video. It was fun to learn.
I have an Excalibur that I've owned for a few years. I just found out that I can buy stainless steel racks for it. They turned out to be great. I can put them in the dishwasher to not only clean, but to sanitize. Also, I just purchased a package of four silicon rubber trays with 1/2" lips that allow me to put liquids or runny products into it and they dry just fine. Just thought I'd let you know about them
Since the 1960s when I mainly did fruit leather in the round. Somewhere along the way I bought a Ron Popiel round tall dehydrator which needed to be changed out often. The layers had a number assigned in their booklet. Eventually it got crooked or must have overheated and no longer worked. There were a few more along the way until I saw ads, probably in Mother Earth News, for my eventual dream machine....The Excalibur 9 drawer.
☆☆♡♡♡☆☆
About 30 years.
Although I am currently in a travel trailer and have been using my toaster oven for frozen vegetables....just returning from food bank I will need my Excalibur for preserving all my precious foods, mixed frozen veggies, blueberries fresh zukes, potatoes, onions, angel food cake, and more.
Thought of buying a small freezer.....but at this juncture I will love making room for Excalibur 9 drawer.
I love dried sliced apples and ground some 10 year old apricot fruit leather that is simply Devine.
I am 76 years young.
Isn't life great?
This was a very good practical test and review. You've helped me validate what I had already decided on. I loved your approach to consumer testing. The Excalibur is my selection because I need that additional space for drying honey samples :) Non-Digital and no timer is fine with me. Size is everything, along with drying efficiency. You did a fantastic job reviewing the value of the many features. Very much appreciated!
You're drying honey? How does that turn out?
@frederick dunn. how do you dry honey?
Excalibur wins
I bought the Cosori last year and use it all the time. I also wish the mesh extended to the sides, so I bought larger BPA-free mesh sheets and cut them to size. The added benefit is that I can fold them up to dump contents straight into jars. I don't have any kind of problem with food sticking. Also, tip for those cursing that hole in the middle while loading and unloading trays. I put a 4oz ball jar upside down over that hole while filling so nothing falls through the middle while loading. And I have put tray on top of ball jar and scoop contents through the middle hole straight into the jars. Happy dehydrating!
I ended up using that same mesh on my nesco to make one large round mesh without cutting hte hole - it works wonders!
I have a Cosori also and did the same. Bought it last summer and bought mesh sheets, cut them to size. They are working out very well - and the Cosori is SO quiet. Wonderful! =^..^=
Which brand larger BPA-free mesh sheets, please.
Thank you
My question is addressed to those that purchased the larger sheets. Like 14x14 or little larger. Thank you
After doing a ton of research, I decided on a Cosori last year and absolutely LOVE it. There is more than adequate space between trays, is unbelievably quiet and dehydrates very well. Yes, I do wish the mesh trays extended to the sides for more coverage but that is not a show-stopper. I highly recommend the Cosori to anyone thinking of getting a dehydrator.
Thanks for sharing your experience!
Thank you. I was about to get the Excalibur but opted for the cosori. It was half the price of the Excalibur I was looking at. I think the area for dehydrating is less, but I think its a good trade off for lower price and quieter machine. I think a loud machine would drive me nuts.
You can buy mesh mat and cut it to the required size you want... There are for dehydrators and BBQs
I love my Cosori. My old Excalibur completely failed at dehydrating delicate herbs and teas. Actually, the Excalibur failed at everything. It wanted to cook everything I tried to dehydrate. So I just finished another season of dehydrating mint, echinacia, chamomile, white pine needles, basil, cilantro, oregano, parsley, garlic, onion, lemongrass, celery, tomatoes, peppers, spinach, kale, mushrooms, squash, and other vegetables. I even bought a second Cosori because it saves so much money over canning.
Now I'm going to try dehydrating stock and vegetable stock veggies, as well as fully prepared foods for backpacking trips. Like spaghetti, chili, curries, and stews. No more Mountain House!
I have one too and love it!!
One thing I would also consider is the energy cost to dry. Energy prices have been going up a lot and even if the Cosori is more expensive, in the long run I think you save money if you dehydrate a lot.
Living in a cold climate like Canada, I’ve learnt that our times will always take longer. My utility bill has gone up a bit but nothing I can’t financially handle. However, some things take days to dry 😭😂
I think your test was very fair and equal. I have owned my Excalibur for over 20 years. I go through spurts of use. The thing that I like about the Excalibur is that they offer replacement parts for almost everything in the dehydrator. I could not find that with Cosori but I could be wrong. You are correct that the Excalibur is noisey but I still would choose it over the Cosori. Thanks for your review.
Thank you for mentioning the air circulation differences between the circular/stackable model and the square tray/rear fan model.
Years ago I bought my used Nesco at a garage sale and it looked almost new. Worked great but again limited surface area. As the years have gone on I have picked up additional trays where ever I can fund them..I think I am up to 13...which is too many to dry at once. I have hung on to them because over time the plastic does become some what brittle and that way I have spares. Last year I found an almost new set with 4 trays and bought it. Now I have 2 setups with extra trays.
I have heard good things about Excaliber and thought I had to have one, but just had not spent the money.
I had begun thinking maybe I didn't want to spend the exta money for it and here are my reasons I have decided to stick with what I have:
1. I don't feel that inconvenienced about having to remove dried product and rotate the trays.
2. My son has become a vegetarian so I don't need to make as big batches of jerky ( I used to give him between 2-4 lbs, dried, for holidays and birthdays, plus gift it to my daughters and their husband and boyfriend. Now I only need to make enough for my 2 girls and us.
3. Yes it is noisy..and they do put out heat and moisture into the room. If any of these issues bother me, I just put it out in the attached garage.
4. Length of time to dry- now that I am retired, I have more time to work with it and it is easier to plan dry time.
5. I do purchase produce to dry as well as using vegetables and herbs from my small garden and so far it works fine for that.
5. I already own the 2 Nescos and i can live with #1-4. If I were to have to replace these, I would likely go with a Cosiri due to price, size, and noise level. Also, since we don't hunt, drying massive amounts of any thing (such as game), the Excalibur seems unnecessary for me at this point in time.
6. Space- storage of the Excalibur would be a problem as well as having a place to use it when drying. I would have to carry it up and down the stairs to store. I store the 2 Nescos with the trays in 13 gallon trash bags with the pull closure. Easy to store and keep clean, store, and carry up and down the stairs.
Hope these reasons help you with your decision.
Been using Nesco dehydrators for decades. Always in my price range. Very pleased with their performance.
My dehydrator, that I bought for $20 about 30+ years ago, was just too slow and inefficient. Considering a new dehydrator, it was between Excaliber and the collapsible Brod & Taylor Sahara. A few years ago, the Sahara was outrageously expensive. In the meantime, the Excaliber prices kept climbing. But I have NO place to put a dehydrator in my tiny, overstuffed kitchen. *sigh* Finally, I checked the Sahara again and found the price to be around the same as the Excaliber..EUREKA! So I bought it and I LOVE IT. It's quiet, fast, and dries evenly. It's stupid-simple (for those of use that are mechanically-challenged) and is a really slick design. And, it folds down to 1/3 of its expanded size and stores neatly in a case you can purchase separately (which I did, so I could fit the shelves and mats in it as well). Now I can pull it out for my 1-2 week a month dehydrating runs and then store it away neatly until the next time (so I can use my top-load washer). Brod & Taylor customer service is terrific too. When I bought my Sahara, it went on sale for $20 less the next day. I wrote to them, didn't ask for a refund, but they gave me $20 back anyway! They also had a deal of 3 free silicon mats if you purchased the carrying case but I didn't realize you had to add them to the cart; they sent me the mats right away. They have a very happy new customer now!
Thanks for sharing!
I love this video I was just thinking that I need to get a dehydrator! I loved your input and fair assessment of the machines! Thank you!
Thank you for this video. I ended up with the Cosori. Although I almost did not get it because it was made in China, I am new to this and the thought of the expense in buying the Excalibur to just let it sit was not sitting well with me. Aside from where manufactured, I do love the Cosori. I love to powder stuff. Amazing to see the end result from what it started. You had mentioned the loss in tray real estate when using the screen trays, so I followed your advise (I think it was you) and made myself liners for the trays using cheese cloth and that works great. Thank you.
I have a 9-tray Excalibur with the twist dial on the top. It is in almost constant use from about mid-July until November, usually. I wish it weren't so loud, but it works well and does a great job of drying whatever I put in it.
I absolutely adore your videos! I recently got into dehydrating, after wanting to for many years - I finally live in a home with counter space and some fruit trees outside!! I have a stressful job (but I love it!), and at the end of the long day, while eating dinner, I watch your videos, and it just calms me right down. I learn some great tips to try that next weekend, and I get a good laugh from your cool sense of humor. Your videos bring me a lot of joy - thank you! 🌻
Glad to see this video as I have been thinking about a dehydrator and was having problems deciding so now, I will be checking these out. Great video and you have demonstrated these machines very well.
Both Lowes and Home Depot carry the Nesco at their regular price of $66 (usually with free shipping, mine is due Monday), which makes it a solid deal if you're looking to get into (or back into) food dehydrating. You can always buy up if you think you'll stick with it.
I run 2 dehydrators during the summer. I finally wore my American Harvester out after 22 years. I loved that machine so much my daughter gave me hers! She benefits from my drying crazy summers.
VERY, very helpful review! Thank you for taking the time to test and share the info. We are looking to purchase our first dehydrator (1st year homesteaders with the blessing of a bountiful garden harvest this year so far...) and this video has helped us narrow it down. Many thanks!!
Glad it was helpful! There are lots of brands on the the market that are great, but I only have so much room and money :) Magic Mill would be a good larger mid-range machine to invest in, too.
I love my Nesco. Just made jerky in it two days ago. The fan on the top is a big plus for jerky makers. You don’t have to be concerned with fluid going into any electrical areas.plus the stackable trays is amazing. I have 8 total trays.
Excellent review, thank you! I'm a beginner at dehydrating, so this was very helpful.
Thanks for the comparison! I have an Excalibur and hate the fact I have to remove trays! Also, when I dry light items like herbs, they get blown out of place by the blower. I also have a nesco which I love. I use it for most of my herbs and other things. If I had to repurchase, I think I would still buy the nesco first. Love your videos!
I love my nesco it might take a bit more attention but I usually just run mine over night or in the garage I’ve even had on back patio doing onions. It’s light weight and gets the job done. Perfect for people without a dedicated space. I store mine on my appliance shelf in the garage
I am a newbie to dehydrating. I bought an excecaIibur 5 tray. I found it around October of 2020 at Ollie's for $75. I had seen a couple of videos on dehydrating so I knew a lot of people had the Excalibur. I have used it a lot this week. It is loud and puts off some heat but I love it. I am pulling veggies out of my freezer to dehydrate Lol. Im having a blast dehydrating. So glad i found your channel tonight. Stay Safe and God Bless.
I really enjoyed this review! Right now, I have three of the round, stackable dehydrators, and the stainless steel Cosori. My first was a Mekey. It's okay - It has a thermostat and it does a good job, but like the Nesco, the trays have to be rotated and it takes a long time. I was given a Victorio - it has bigger trays that have to be rotated, and it only has 1 heat setting. Hot. Having those two worked pretty well, because I could make jerky with one and dehydrate veggies with the other. And then I was given another dehydrator - It's the size of the Victoria, but has a thermostat. When I started dehydrating potatoes, I bought my Cosori. I bought the Cosori because I couldn't afford an Excalibur, and honestly, I got lucky! I love this thing! Quiet and efficient! Everything dries so much faster (HOURS faster) than the round, stackables, and consequently, I use it a lot. The only time I use any of the other is if I've got more than will fit on those six Cosori trays.
I am so happy to hear your reviews. I just purchased the Cosori and just went by the reviews on Amazon. It is really hard to go on Amazon reviews because you are never quite sure if they got a bad one or if they just don't know what they are doing when they leave a bad review. Most of the reviews were good and there were thousands of them so on a wing and a prayer I just got it the other day. It has been wiped down and a dry run. I just need to figure out the temp and timer thing. It definately runs quiet. I was doing the dry run and forgot I put it on. Several hours later I went to the kitchen and realized it was still going. I grabbed some apples and oranges and such for my first run.I hope to start it tonight if I can get off my bum.
Thank you sooo very much for your reviews. I have a very old Harvest Made stackable and am in the market for a new machine. This review and the prior reveal of the Cosori have pretty much sold me on the machine. It seems to be the the best mix of features, performance, and price. I am a fairly recent subscriber to your site and am really enjoying your input and content. Well back to pinching pennies so I can get the new machine!!!
Glad to help
This is the most useful dehydrator review on the Tube. It's what people who were looking need to see; simple and to the point. It would be great if you could do this same video with some beef and deer jerky (maybe even one video on slice and one on ground), it would be a huge asset and it would get a ton of hits. Also, I might suggest getting a hold of a new Gardenmaster from Nesco for the tests. Don't change anything else. Great work!
This video is a blessing
Thank you
Newbie here but CREATING the life I choose is priority
You're officially my dehydrating Mentor
I greatly appreciate your clear, concise, succinct, delivery of detailed and pertinent information. Thank you!
You're very welcome!
I will be looking for a dehydrator when we get back from vacation in the middle of May. Thank you so much for all that you do!!
Love your thorough review. Appreciate how you broke down all the pro/cons. Perfect! I bought the Casori. Thanks for the link. Convenient. I’m an absolute beginner. Will watch a few more of your vids before turning it on! Probably a bag of frozen mixed veggies. Thanks again. Love your Channel!!
Glad it was helpful! Happy dehydrating!
Thank you for the review. We have been dehydrating for years and have several dehydrators; 2 Excalibur and 3 Nesco. We have found advantages and disadvantages to either one, depending on what you are processing. I can tell you that all of the machines are running 24/7 during canning season! Lol!
One of the things that we do with the Nesco is rotate the trays bottom to top and cycle through the stacks every 2-3 hours initially. It seems to help speed up and even out the drying time.
I really appreciate your evaluation of the machines. I was checking into adding another dehydrator myself. I had to give one away because it was too loud for me. New sub!
Absolutely love this video Darcy, extremely informative and I’m seriously thinking of purchasing the Cosori dehydrator..
Glad it was helpful!
Thanks for the comparision ! I'm getting ready to order my first one this week.
What machine did you end up settling on?
@@ThePurposefulPantry Cosori. 600 watt, 6 tray, 110 v service. It is square much like the one you had on the video.
Great info; really appreciate your info! Considering doing this!
I have the Nesco. I like it because it is lightweight and trays fit in dishwasher with a little adjusting. When I stack 12 trays I do have to rotate but I got a 600 watt for 60 dollars new online. I don't care about stainless steel, timers, digital readouts.
Usually does what it needs to overnight. Maybe before but I prefer to run it then. If you just have to time it buy a 4 buck timer from Wal-Mart and plug it in.
It holds more than I normally do at once so the less trays the faster its is done.
I just got a new one several weeks ago because the one I bought 7 years ago at a thrift store quit heating. I was wanting to expand the number of trays but they were so expensive I didn't. The new machine cost me less than the trays and the old trays fit the new one. I made sure by checking tray part numbers for both machines.
I have been well satisfied with it's construction, longevity and cost. I am going to add an inline switch for on and off. To me that is it's only downfall.
I've had a Cosori about 2 months now and love it. Yes it is very quiet and I like the automatic timer. I also ordered dehydrator sheets from Amazon that can be cut to exact size of the tray.
What is on the bottom floor of the cosori? I watched an add and it showed them putting thick sliced bacon in it. How hard would it be to clean up all that grease?
I had a really old Ronco circular, no panel or controls which worked almost good. This spring I got a presto with a control panel to monitor time and temp which is kind of loud but works great. I found your channel recently and was like "I want a cosori!" So I found a new one from a couple who just didn't want to use it (their loss) and $30 cheaper then brand new. I love it. So quiet.
Very cool!
Thank you I really appreciate the review on the dehydrators I wasn't sure which one to buy, but now I know which one I'll buy.
Yay!! Thank you so much for making this video. Taking notes 📝 😊
You're so welcome!
We bought a Cosori 18 months ago. Love it. I use parchment paper on the stainless steel trays plus just bought the silicone trays and cut to fit flexible silicone mesh mats. Being able to set the timer and temp is a real advantage. It is quiet and doesn't put out much heat. Huge pluses since it's currently set up in a one room studio while we build a house.
Would you mind sharing where you got the sheets? 🌻
I do have the Nesco you reviewed. I had no idea it would take soooo long to dehydrate an onion sliced almost paper thin. So I checked out what you had to say in what I would say was a very just and fair test. I will be checking out the Cosori for sure. What a relief to hear someone I consider to be an honest person just tell the truth about the test results and the observations made. Jesus bless.
I bought a brand new nesco at a liquidation store for $36. I couldn't pass it up as my first dehydrator. Plus, I needed one that took up very little space. I like that it can expand to 12 trays if needed. And, if in 6 months I decide it's not for me, I'm not out of a bunch of money.
@@knothead35 Thanks for the input and hope we both have a long lasting machine!! Jesus bless.
Have a nesco usually made jerky with fair results. I just tried it for rosemary drying 13 hours later still not dry. I’m ready to put the nesco in the garbage because except for jerky it sure seems like what it is…. Garbage
@@2fargonedaytona128 Thanks for your input. I've still so far to go in canning, dehydrating, etc. My next goal is drying herbs. I am seeing here and there that some have enough oils in them it really takes a little while to dry them sufficiently. Of course, I have learned to take things with a grain of salt....you can get a 100% surefire answer from both ends of the spectrum...lolol. I feel Darcy is pretty solid and I trust her methods and knowledge.
Hope your experiences constantly improve. I hope mine do. Take care and Jesus bless.
@@sandrarichardson2713 thanks Sandra! I need all the blessings I can scrape up. I didn’t mean to come off so brutish but you certainly could sense my aggravation. I’ve had as I mentioned fair luck w/meats & jerky and this Nesco has to be 12 years old. Yes, the rosemary was oily and almost resin or tar like stickiness just in the touch and the sprigs were pretty bushy. I guess would set me off is I’ve read 3-4 hours at 120 degrees and I set this as the machine said 95 or so. It took about 16-18 degrees with me shutting machine off and resuming later on the next morning. This device wasn’t expensive and in betting it with like most all other things you get what you pay for. Cheers and I like you will continue learning, researching, practicing and in my case experimenting!
Thank you for making this presentation on these dehydrators. It definitely helped me, because I am in the market to buy one. When I came across this presentation it really caught my attention. I'm so glad that I stopped and listened to it all the way through.
Thank you for sharing. I have been trying to figure out, and you helped a lot.
Thank you! I like how quiet my Cosori is. So far it is doing what I hoped it would do.
I have a non digital Excalibur-I've had it for about 10yrs but haven't used it the past couple years.
Pulled it out this morning, washed the trays, watching all your dehydrating videos, & gonna get back into it. 😃
Yay!!!
Thank you thank you I couldn’t decide and had no idea where to start. Thank you
I have two of the Excalibur like you showed. I purchased stainless steel racks for them. I bought mine about 10 years ago and they still run just like the day I bought them. But I did buy the heavy duty motor on both of them and that may be why I haven't had any issues.
I ran up on this at the perfect time! I was torn between exactly these 3 dehydrators! Seriously, I have all 3 in my cart on Amazon! I've been scouring the internet and TH-cam about them. Thank you for this video!
By the way, I subscribed! GOD bless
This is exactly what I have been pondering, which to get on limited income. I have some old, as in 30yrs. that are failing and need to freshen up, as I do lots of herbs along with veggies and berries. Thank you so very much for your time in sharing your experiences and knowledge.
I only just discovered you today and and can't stop watching. I used to live in Bellville Tx 30yrs. ago and moved to n.w. arkansas. It's a paradise in these mountains. Thanks again.
Best of luck! I think the Nesco FD75A is a good machine in the under $75 that works well - or the Cosori round machine. Good quality machines that will last. The Presto Dehydro is also good also. I just really recommend the temperature adjustment instead of going with a one-temp when possible. Also, be sure to check those thrift stores when you can!
Hi Candace. I live in Dallas and purchased a cabin in the foothills of the Ozarks in northwest Arkansas. I would have to agree with you stating it’s paradise living in the mountains! I spend as much time as possible at my cabin and love it! It’s on 5 1/4 acres. I am a retired nurse and love being surrounded by nature.
I wore out one NESCO, but it lasted a good 12-15 years of almost year-round use. I regularly used 8-10 trays at a time, too. I bought another one and am using it now. (This one and the one I wore outhad an adjustable temperature setting). I also have a NESCO that has a "fixed" temperature at 165°. I think it was sold as a "jerky maker". I bought it used and have used it for at least 10 years now. I use it mostly for "heavier" foods and meats. I've never had another brand, but have loved these.
Thanks for sharing your experience!
I use 3 old Ronco dehydrators, which I bought used from Ebay. They work just great, and I found extra trays for them. I think any dehydrator is fine, they all get the job done, you just have to figure out how to use it best. Last night I dried a nice big batch of carrots.
I bought a 9 tray Samson dehydrator off of Amazon, looks a lot like the Cosori. Very quiet and very affordable. I love it.
I started with the Hamilton Beach rectangular dehydrator but passed it along to a good friend when I found an exceptional deal on a barely used 9 tray Excalibur that came with the paraflexx sheets for $100 CAD. It is the same model you used in this video. I do sometimes wish that there was a bit more space between the trays without having to take out every other one.
Use a mesh piece on top to push things down as you slide it in - works like a charm!
Hello TPP! What a GREAT review! Listen, you were prescient in one thing you said a year ago. You said most people weren't doing the big dry for long term. As you know that has changed. Now many are. I really perked up my ears when you said that. I'm in it for the big one, but I'm in the 'can't afford it' group, thus your recommend of the Corsi, after your no-nonsense experiment just sold me. I was looking at that along with the Nesco when I paused and went looking for reviews. Yours popped up and angel that you are it was perfect for my purposes. Times being normal I'd just stick with the one lunger, but times aren't normal. (Grrr!) The garden waits on no dehydrator.
Many and umble thankees,
Norm
I love my Excalibur when I'm doing really big batches but I bought a smaller 600w one from amazon to do all the small batches of stuff that I don't have a full load for my Excalibur. The warranty on the Excalibur when I bought it was a big selling point. I have no complaints with either one. I had a nesco and it didnt last. I was very disappointed with it.
I have the Corsori. I purchased silicone sheets for it and cut them to fit. I am not a fan of heated plastic. I love it.
That is something to think about... Good to know.
Thanks for all your information, I am learning so much from your videos and website.
After much research, I just purchased a Consori. I also bought the magnet you are selling that shows the drying times/ temps.
Wonderful! I hope you love using it!
This was extremely helpful, I am trying to decide what to get. I have also been looking at the Magic mill.
Hi! I bought the Cosori quite a few months before I knew about your videos... I just started dehydrating a few days ago and I like it a lot, but after watching your review/comparison I am even more pleased with my decision ☺
I like that it is not plastic and it is nice and quiet, but I had no comparison before. I thought they were all this quiet. 😁
Glad you like them!
Thank you so much for your honest evaluation. I personally love my Nesco with a blower. I have used it for several years and am happy with the finished product. The main disadvantage is that the trays need to be switched around for even drying. I don't like that I have to unplug machine to do this. I still am happy with results.
Which model Nesco do you have?
I got my Cosori in June 2020. Debated between the Excalibur and the Cosori. Cosori had a lot of good reviews and I liked that people commented how quiet it is. I'm still learning but don't regret my decision in the least. Like others mentioned, I purchased mesh and cut to fit the shelves. I haven't made leathers yet but that's next on the agenda.
I'm working my way through your videos. Wish I'd found them earlier. Lot's of good detail. Thanks
Thanks for watching!
This was just what I needed! I just placed an order through your link...I chose the Cosori. Looking forward to prepping with this. Thanks!!
Hope you enjoy it!
I spent $15 on a dehydrator at Christmas. I am loving dehydrating but I've already outgrown my machine (it's the round style). Thanks for the review of the Excalibur vs. Corsori. I have both in my Amazon shopping cart just waiting for me to save up enough money.
Sounds great!
I have a Food Pantry stackable dehydrator that was gifted to me. I never opened it or started using it until I found your channel. You give so much GREAT information. I caught the dehydrating fever. Got a Cosori 6 tray on Amazon Prime Days. Now I can run both at different temps. Thanks Darcy for all your amazing instructional videos.❤
That is awesome!
That was a great comparison. I had considered an Excalibur or Cosori but due to expandibility and 1000 watts,and price, I chose a Nesco Gardenmaster. I am not saying it is better than any of the others. It is just a better fit for me. I now have 2 units and 24 trays.
I just bought one and it ran for about 10 minutes and something electrical burned up inside. I can smell it and it no longer runs 😂
I have a Nesco 1000 watt Gardenmaster and love it. My Gardenmaster has the fan on the bottom and can hold up to 30 trays in which I rotate at the halfway tier halfway through their drying cycle. This can be bought on Amazon for about $135.00 and comes with 8 trays, 8 screens and 8 fruit roll up sheets. The trays are 15.5", so you can dehydrate a lot at one time and I've used up to 26 trays with no issues. It has adjustable temperatures of 95°F - 160°F. I've done all kinds of veggies and fruits, raw eggs for powder, and vegetable sauces into "fruit rollups" to be reconstituted when needed. I vacuum pack everything and then seal inside of mylar bags to keep the light from it and then store in barrels and tubs.
I purchased mesh sheets for my Cosori and cut them to the exact size of the trays. The sheets wash easily & have served me well.
I just found your site randomly and this information was very timely very thorough and fantastic! Thank you for taking the time to do such a thorough comparison. I have had an Xcaliber for I don’t know close to 15 years and I absolutely love it and I do participate in long term food storage with it but I have needed another dehydrator for a while and I am going to purchase aCorsori now. The price point can’t be beat for what I need right now. Thank you
Hi, when you get the cosori would you mind commenting which of the both is better? thanks
@@fabianagramos8135 After much thought I decided to buy a second Excalibur because I’ve had mine for so long with no problems running it constantly that I trust that machine
Love your channel new subscriber also the comments have been filled with user knowledge and helpful hints that a very worth reading. I’m going to have to figure out what I’m going to get. Thanks everyone and have a fantastic day
I have the cosori and I love it. It also looks nicer than the others
My Nurtichef has metal racks but a very cheap metal used for the racks. After use for a year, the racks have bowed. Still works wonderful and quiet and small enough to fit under my kitchen cabinets. Replaced my round Ronco which worked but took so much more time and effort to dry foods completely. Also had no heat settings like my Nutrichef.
Thank you so much for this comparison! I was really wanting the Cosori now I’m getting it.
Glad it was helpful!
I have an American Harvest Snackmaster Dehydrator which became Nesco at some point. I’ve had mine some 30+ years. I like it so well I bought a second one off eBay. Mine has the motor and fan in the base with a temperature dial for heat settings. I’m one of those people without room or money for an Excalibur.
Thanks for the info!
I have one I purchased in 82-83 and my son uses it now as I bought a new one so he could have mine.
I have this same machine that was gifted to me by an elderly friend. I don't know how old it is but I have to wonder if it's older than me haha (45). I don't know any different but I'm glad to have it and it seems to work well. I could technically afford a new one but I'm not sure if it would make that much difference. Any thoughts on that? I want to use my resources wisely.
@@crazyaboutcards use it until it dies. That’s the best use of resources.
Thank you! I'm looking into getting one. Great video
I have had an old one-speed round, stacking dehydrator for years. I would get it out in the summer to attempt dehydrating my garden's overabundance. Alas, that one speed - high - did not yield a successful product most of the time unless I was willing to endlessly rearrange and rotate contents. I started researching newer dehydrators and narrowed it down to the three you just compared in your great video. I ended up choosing the Excalibur, not because I have a big budget, but because I felt its capacity would help me cope with abundant produce from the garden. Though I have used it exactly once, it beautifully dehydrated a full load of mixed brassica greens that had to be harvested during the recent Arctic cold snap. I am so pleased!
Glad you're enjoying it!
I didn't even know that Cosori existed, I truly want to cry right now because I'm truly trying to change my lifestyle around, and the excalibur would be around $300 for me with discounts included and I literally gasped and almost cried when I saw how cheap the Cosori is in comparison to excalibur.
Thank you, thank you, thank you.
Truly, thank you.
Edit: And the Cosori is 1 tray more than the 5 tray Excalibur model. Wooooooow.
Thank you for your review! I’m shopping for one and there are so many choices. Very helpful 🥰
You’re welcome 😊
Just started my research on a dehydrator and found your videos with tons of useful information. Subscribed!
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you so much for your review, I actually have the Excalibur and was considering replacing it for a less noise one.
Glad I could help!
I LOVE my Nesco..but have never had the Excaliber
This was a great review- thank you! No extra talk/fluff- just right down to business and you are an excellent reviewer! Stuck betwween the Cosiri and the Excaliber.
I appreciate that! Excalibur wins for volume. Cosori wins for price and quiet. There's another machine in the Cosori price range that is also VERY quiet, Elechomes, with 8 trays with a bit larger tray space. I haven't been able to test it, but Leisa @Suttonsdaze is testing it right now and let me see and hear it this morning - it's VERY quiet, and so far she's really happy with it. You'll probably see a video on it (and making bread) next Tuesday>
If it helps, Cosori is doing a Black Friday promotion with the purchase of a Cosori through this link: sl.vesync.com/uyxzuo (and use code TPP15 to get 15% off) this week. They are giving away a free gift with any Cosori purchase this week. Not trying to sell you on them - just a promo they are doing if if plays into the equation.
The results did surprise me. I really thought they were all about the same drying time except maybe the Nesco might take a bit longer with rotating the trays. I've got a old Bee Beyers square machine from the 70's and 2 Nescos from the 80's that are still going strong! I picked them all up from church rummage sales, spent a total of $30 for all 3! I use the mesh trays on all of them. It's just easier to get the product off of them. I use them year round as I look for really good sales and clearance items! My favorite thing to do in them is onions and it's what I do the most of. Really a money saver!
I was surprised, too - not that the Nesco didn't win, but by how much longer it took. I knew stackables were slower, just surprised by how much slower this one was.
The Cosori is priced very reasonable at Amazon so are extra screens. We have an older Rosewill and newer Nesco but may consider an upgrade to the Rosewill as it has been used to no end. All three are more in our budget than the excalibur.
Thank you for this video it is amazing. I will probably get the Cosori because I do not need to dry a massive amount with just the two of us. I am so happy I found your channel!!!!😍
Glad it was helpful!
one thing not mentioned about the excalibur is the material used. from my research, prior to purchasing the cosori. i found that not all the plastic used in the excalibur is PBA free! i was shocked to have read this! therefore was my reasoning to purchase the cosori stainless steel.
Thank you for the reviews.
I have the Excalibur w timer. I disagree about the timer. I think it is a must have. You don’t have to babysit it, you can go off and leave it running. I have also purchased the stainless steel racks to make jerky and the silicone sheets to do fruit leathers. At first I bought very cheap silicone mats. Don’t bother they just don’t work.
After watching these comparison between the machines.
I wish that the door was different on the Excalibur and it was a little quieter.
Thanks for the reviews.
Truly not trying to be argumentative, but I can leave my machine running forever and never babysit it :) I just think it's not something you have to pay more for. But we all have our preferences!
Phenomenal thank you for being so thorough and concise.
Thanks so much for sharing. I am looking at getting an excalibur. Currently have a Circle one and it just takes forever and can't do much at a time. I have a large garden and trying to preserve more for winter. This helped answer questions I didn't know I needed answers to.
Glad it was helpful!
To me the Zucchini dried in the Excalibur looked slightly more shriveled and dry than did that dried in the Cosori - but it was very close. Great video Darcy :-)
I have a Cosori because I had a Cosori air fryer that was eligible for the recall replacement and it was a spare after being set aside for the Cosori Dual Blaze. Otherwise I probably would never have gotten a dehydrator at all. I’m enjoying it though 👍🏼