Racial Matters With Malay Singaporeans | On The Red Dot | Who We Are, What We Eat - Part 2
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มิ.ย. 2024
- Host Haresh Tilani explores Malay cuisine and culture, when he goes to lunch with a celebrity, a chef, and a politician.
First on the menu is Nasi Rawon, the favourite dish of actress and host, Munah Bagharib. Over a meal that brings back childhood memories for her, Munah shares what it is like to be a minority in media.
Then, it is on to a feast of Nasi Padang with Haikal Johari, Executive Chef of the Michelin-starred restaurant, Alma. Haikal recounts his culinary journey and return to his roots, while also sharing stories about his mixed marriage.
The final lunch is shared with Minister Maliki Osman, who regales Haresh with tales of his childhood. Over a meal of Tahu Telur and Ikan Bakar, the two diners discuss the relevance of the CMIO model, and whether racial quotas in the Group Representation Constituency (GRC) system gives minority politicians an advantage.
===========
About On The Red Dot: CNA's weekly programme documents the stories of ordinary Singaporeans and celebrates their resilience, identity and sense of belonging.
===========
On The Red Dot playlist: • On The Red Dot | Full ...
#CNAInsider #OnTheRedDot #Singapore #Minority #Malay
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider
I don't feel Munah being close to typical Malay. She already shown quite reluctant to be called Malay. Just my opinion...
Because rawon is Javanese food, East Javanese to be exact. Even some Javanese of other areas like Central Javanese wont claim it.
*That's why I always say that Singapore is just a physically developed country. Mentally, psychologically, and emotionally, they still live in the 18th century where race, nationality, and ethnicity play a big role in a day-to-day life.*
Perhaps America would be the shining example :p
Just look north of Singapore will do
Tribalism is part of human nature. Being rich does not mean you stop being human and stop having primitive instincts, no matter how repressed they are.
Singapore is still far better than many countries out there.
@@wanghui562 what do u mean by that?
The food in this series is making me hungry! But I would have liked to see more "ordinary" Malays because the personalities here are very successful/well-known and thus have different experiences that most Malays.
what do u mean by "ordinary malays"?
@@shanekiat2177 At the very least people who aren't MPs who are somewhat shielded from everyday acts of racism and microaggressions that minorities without class privilege experience!
@@shanekiat2177 regular malays who work as waitress or at hawker centers
Kinda sounds like the point she was talking about, does Race matter?
Agree. Once the minister came in, I turned off. Such a person, regardless of race, is not representative of a cross-section of society. It hints of atypical self-promotion in the image, at the least.
Chef Haikal you have my utmost respect for being so open and understanding there in SG even in your adversity 🙏💙 . Terima kasih
Encik Malik Osman good luck to you and East Coast has changed so so much ...I missed the East Coast of the yester years 70's 80's where citizens were so much more respectful of the 'other' races
This is so weird, quality and style of production surpass that regular mediacorp... please keep it up!
Good series!! I’m so glad you made it. Wholesome content!
it is funny that they want to push everything under a malay umbrella when they are obviously not.
I kinda like this minister.. can feel he's a super nice guy.
Munah does not represent Malay
REALLY healthy culture in Singapore. I really proud to see Singapore . Giving full freedom and NATURALLY are growing peace with own faith .
cool video :) and wow, i’m craving for all the food that was showcased in this video now haha
The chef has it down. Respect.
I love it that each person he interviewed he get the person to share a food.
i love the anecdote from minister osman, how he shares his front porch with his neighbour & vice versa!
👋 Haresh! From a YahLahBut podcast fan!
We can never banish racism. especially in a job place where majority is the u know who. Most majority i know when they make a mistake they were given 2nd chance eventho they make a big mistake. but when came to minority no chance at all.
@Zhong Anthony Felix Xina lol
Yes, finally found this 💯
You mean in the place up north where the government practices institutional racism. Yeah, man. When the political leaders steal money and make racist statements they keep getting voted in again and again because they are the right skin. If you are honest and capable, you are still out cuz you are wrong skin.
ohhh minority with no chances ... like Malaysia
I agree with you..even tho Malaysia is for Malays..no.. when I interviewed for a job which Sino Singapore ... actually for the job for accountant..at the last question can I speak Mandarin.. what can I say economically Chinese control the economy in Malaysia
Most of my Malay peers are some sort of mix..Except proto Malays, other Malays are not a homogeneous ethnic group.. there are Eurasian Malay, Eastern Asian Malay, Middle Eastern Malay, South Asian Malay, African Malay etc. and they can look totally different from each other... Singapore and Malaysia have been melting pots for diverse cultures for so long until today, you can not expect the Malays to not fall in love and intermarry anyone who is coming to this part of the world 😂...
Same goes to our Malayo-Polynesian friends in Indonesia, the Philippines, Papua and Oceanian islands as well...
Majority of Malaysia are Malays, they know it, some are Javanese, Buginese, Makassarese, Acehese, Mandailings, Sundanese, Ambonese, Minahasan, Bawaean, many intermarried with local Malays(Melayu), and some assimilated. Riau, Johor, Singapore, Melaka and Riau archipelago are melting pot. Riau in Sumatra are Malaya twin, they have chinese and tamil too, but most tamil in North Sumatra and Aceh. brought by Dutch and some come from Malaya. they are other malay who have middle eastern ancesry mostly Yemeni Arab, Gulf Arab from Iraq, intermarried with local Malay, almost non pure arab in Malaysia, indonesia, Timor and singapore, the Mari Alkitiri also Yemeni arab but intermixed with local Timorese. the name Timor it from Malay word for East, mean East East. Indian muslim mostly Tamil muslim, Gurjerati muslim, and Kerela muslim[mahathir grandfather], they still many in Penang, without mixed, but many of them mixed become Malay. the west and south coast of Peninsular place with many people, but in Kelantan, Terengganu, Kedah, Perlis, Pahang, also Malay of Southern Thailand in Santun, Yala, Narathiwat, Songkhla and Pattani very2 low in mixed with others race like Arab, persian, india, chinese or others Nusantaran group like Javanese, Sundanese, Acehnese, Buginese, Makassarese, Ambonese and others. Kelantan-Patani-Terengganu Malay very strong in their ethnics, they only like to stick with 'kelantanese malay, patani malay and terengganu malay" the archiecture of east coast like Kelantan-terengganu and patani are different, they used 'bumbung pemeleh", while rest of Malay used 'balai adat melayu" bumbung lipat kajang. the others malay sub-group like Minangkabau, from West sumtra, form a state in Negeri Sembilan, Minangkabau with Proto-Malay/orang asli Temuan and semelai intermarried and become 'Bidunanda' ethnic. and Minangkabau mixed with local Malay become negeri sembilan malay, the langauge of negeri smbilan malay more close to Jambi Malay and Bengkulu Malay, because of element of Malay, Minangkabau langauge are difficult to understand. others Malay group from Kalimantan/borneo is Banjar and Kutai, and other Brunei. in Singapore, Malay and Orang Laut(orang seletar, orang kanaq, orang kanaq) are outnumber by javanese, bugis, bawaen, arab-malay mixed and malay from johor and riau. Orang laut in singapore almost extict, same orang laut and orang asli in Riau, Jambi sumtra, Sakai in Riau number just 5000+
@@safuwanfauzi5014
Its British Doctrine 😂
@@timeaftertime-om7os give me a fact and list, that its was british doctrine? mean myammar, brunei, india to is british doctrine? included singapore? included Bengkulu?
@@safuwanfauzi5014
Malay archipelago
Malay world
Adalah British Doctrine
Karena hanya orang melayu yang cooperative dengan british
Portuguese sebut sonda isle atau the isle of sonda.
Karena dahulu Sunda cooperative dengan portuguese.
Arab dan Persia sebut jazair al jawi
Karena orang Jawa yang lebih dahulu berdagang dengan orang Arab Persia.
Tapi orang Jawa mau nya disebut orang NUSANTARA 😎
@@timeaftertime-om7os termasuk Sundaland, Lesser Sunda ISLAND, Greater Sunda island, ini orang tak faham, Isitlah bukannya bermaksud suku MELAYU, TERMSUK sundaland bukan bererti suku sunda. bodoh, belajar x reti.
keep up the good job YLB! (:
Excellent!
Great content , it would be great to include some Malays who live in Kampongs as well at pulau berani etc etc , other than personalities
and ask them about thier mundane Life? no thanks
@@praba991ify please dont be judgemental. Try to mix with others and be humble.
@@konyaku3072
please don't overthink
and stop playing pc games and lose weight and be successful in life
@@praba991ify praba prabu have the most overweight because of curry and only 7%. Up north also 7%.
Kampongs? There is less the 100 people in Singapore who live in one.
Interesting. I wanna go try the nasi rawon soon
me too;)
As an Asian American, this perspective is so new to me. Anytime an Asian or person of color is successful in the US, it’s a victory for every person of color, not just that specific ethnic group.
In Singapore, the races are all POC, with Chinese being the majority. In a way similar to what you said when a minority race(s) is successful, it's a victory for them.
But then again, I don't think we see it has a competition to win but more towards "fairness".
e.g. getting a job because you meet the relevant skills not because you can speak mandarin.
One can aurge that speaking mandarin is a relevant skill.
And there lies the advantage the Chinese has over the minority, right from the beginning.
But when there are too many Asians doing well in elite high schools and colleges, the Asians get lumped in with whites and it's no longer a victory for POC. Often when they say POC, they don't include Asians. They only mean Hispanics and blacks.
For me if an unvaxed person is successful it makes me proud
@@laughter95 yeah like there was a time in football coaching ppl critised Eugene Chung, an Asian for having the offensive line coach instead of a black coach and often times white passing Hispanics get excluded too due to "white privilege" the Hispanics they refer to are tanned / dark skinned Hispanics. makes me rethink the term "POC" constantly.
@@shanekiat2177 Is why we should not focus on skin color and instead look at merit and socioeconomic disparities, needs of communities that are not necessarily defined by melanation.
i like that chef (the 2nd guy), he seems quite intelligent 👍
Rawon is recorded in Javanese Taji Inscription from back in 901 CE. How is it a Malay food? Smh, not in SG or MY, all Malays are narrow-minded on ethnicity & culture.
I think the way singapore generalize malay is just from whatever came from malay archipelago and they just don't don't mention it too specific. Just because u r too obsess on generalizing foods and cultures it doesnt make anyone else narrow-minded when they don't do the same.
@@cocoafea9880 malays is just a political term. most if not all are indonesians. i cant even tell the difference between indos and malays physical wise unless they're mixed
Singapore Malays and Indonesians share similar tradition and values, which is understandable that we share similar foods too. Take east asia as an example, ramen is commonly found in both Korea and China despite originating in Japan. So don't have to argue la, relax. We know where it came from too and that is all that matters.
@@maybona these are propaganda preying on people ignorance like Russia claiming there are no Ukraine.
Indonesian is a term created by George Windsor Earl that even he wasn't happy with. He preferred to call the area Malayunesia instead which makes more sense. Indonesia means Indian Archipelago while Malayunesia means Malay Archipelago. Read up on your history Indonesians.
Like a certain politician used to say "racial hormony doesnt exist.. if u can have racial tolerance its good enough already"
Where is the hawker location , that sell nasi rawon?
great content look forward to more of your videos Haresh~
What I like about singapore is how they respect indonesian heritages by mentioning original place like javanese nasi rawon that comes from indonesia
yeah, i really appreciate it.
yes agree
The IC put Javanese, can’t escape
You have no idea how painful it is to be a Malay in Singapore. Hopefully the java does not become the second China.
sorry to hear that, anyway, java is fine, even chinese here speak javanese and assimilate with fellow citizen of Indonesia@@klewank2615
Does anyone know where the hawker centre with the nasi rawon is from?
Looks like Tampines Hub hawker.
The video mentioned Tampines so should be somewhere in that area
Me could be wrong, but me think she is the wrong kind of "malay" for u to elaborate this kind of topic.
Haha as a malay person myself, I can understand what you are trying to convey.💐
are you trying to say "not malay enough" ?
yes you are wrong
@@subrotoxing8214 Yes
Haiyyah...we are all human. A little more arab a little less malay, that make us more human. No profiling.
for me as a chinese, this is a really good documentary to learn the malay food and culture. Sometimes when i pass malay hawker i really wanna try the food but just dunno how to order....
Learn the malay language la. It's singapore national language
No need shy. Just ask them. If they are really interested in doing a good food business they should be more than willing to introduce their dishes to new customer. That's how I discovered cow lung
@@hailyrizzo5428 tks man will do
like me la want order chinese food only in grab bcs i shy
i'm a chinese too, but when i go to the nasi padang stall i just tell the aunty - "aunty, i want this one, that one, this one, that one" LOL =) all the nasi padang aunties are very nice and accommodating :)
munah is so pretty.
Not people here passing a label and saying that someone is not "Malay" enough. Then, what makes one a true Malay? 🤔
Well, in Malaysia, the official definition of Malay as a person who professes the religion of Islam, habitually speaks the Malay language, and conforms to Malay custom.
@@RambutanLaw does this look like malaysia to u
They have a point though. Was it really so tough to find pure blood Malays in SG?. Why most of the people here is like some sort of mixed. I understand why there are people who feel misrepresented even though your idea of "true Malay" is agreeably debatable.
.
Being a 'true' Malay comes from own cultural perspective. It is non-canonical experience could not be described based on text alone. Sir Frank Sweetenham has noted his observation of Malays race in Pulau Jawa, Peninsular Malaya and other parts of Nusantara back in end of 19th century. You could start reading from there (it is available online) and you could take some figure from the similarities drawn against current generation.
This is purely for you to seek if you really asking for answer.
Chef haikal ur my idol.
Wish the interview had approached those more closer to the ground and gotten their experiences.
Agreed. I wonder if he felt pressured to portray "successful" minorities instead of everyday Malays.
Yeah when they do, they would know they are not even malay.
True
ya lah but! on CNA nice one. My goodness I am missing Indonesian/Malay food. One day I love to see a doco feature of Tengku /Prince, Shawal of Sg.
@Portofolio Film Yusuf Kurniawan My malay is well sketchy to understand this but ... check out this interview with bumi Putra Rockers. That AK47 guitar is amazing th-cam.com/video/CSXGb8p3_5U/w-d-xo.html
who segments your video? the typos are unreal. "Moona", "Hija Mahuna"?
this munah gaharib power siol JAMBUUUU
God make us different races not just to love our own race but to respect other races too.. Its a test, if it's not god just already made us all same type as our forefather Adam..
Not feeling it with the personality interviewed and the platform, CNA. Def not getting the whole true story.
On my Tiktok channel recently I spoke about how Malays in Singapore didn't care about special rights unlike Malaysian Malays who can get highly sensitive about defending this preferential treatment despite the reality that shows that only a handful really enjoy the "special rights"... The post went viral, and caught the attention of many Singaporean Malays, who started chiming in to defend their point-of-view as Malaysian Malays by and large think that Malay Singaporeans are too liberal, too permissive to LGBT and alcohol consumption.. I wish you could do a video on how Malay Singaporeans perceive Malay Malaysians and vice-versa
Firstly, bumiputeea rights earn by malay and DAYAK (3.9 million). Go ask dayak people too.
The Malay country was colonized by foreigners. Singapore originated from Malay people.
(singa:lion,pore:pura:tample)
Nasi Rawon, Nasi Padang they are all Indonesian food, not Malays.
That aside, I love visiting Singapore for the Hawker Centres.
They still live in the british colonial era 😀
There are Mexican japan persian Philippines vietnam thai korean indian nepal chinese foods
But no Indonesian foods
Nasi rawon / skul rawon has been written in 10 th century javanese inscription
So stupid and ridiculous
Nasi Rawon is Javanese dish, Nasi Padang is Malay dish. It's just happened those foods were originated from a land which is now called Indonesia. Javanese, Malay = Ethnic, Indonesians = Nationality.
@@BlackScale86
are you still living in the british colonial era?😀
I'm gonna ask you
Tom yum is malays food or thai food ?
Nasi lemak is malays food or malaysian food ?
Nasi ayam hainan is chinese food or singaporean food ?
Well basically majority of Malays are from the descendants of malay archipelago, Indonesia. That’s why some Malays on their IC race is boyanese, javanese etc But all group as one under malay.
@@Irkkan The term 'Malay Archipelago' itself created by British. The Sriwijayan call their place as 'Bhumi Melayu' not 'Kepulauan Melayu'.
LOL... Of coz they are showing all the nice, friendly and peaceful stuffs... but in reality it is NOT always rainbows and unicorns...🙄😏😒
this haresh show her old videos, lol she never seen his videos , more crazy , lol
Beow Tan Is Shocked
Nasi Padang!!!
11:16 Chef Haikal said " i fall sick SIAL" ......eh cannot la ...on tv how can say siall ? hahaha i chinese i also know
I love Malay cuisine
Kalio and Rendang.. is not the same .. my dear....
This is very interesting from the perspective of a minority ethnic person in Malaysia, where our voice and life chances are shaped more by our racial group rather than my individual merit. It is great to see that in Singapore, where the ratio of the two main racial groups is the reverse opposite, minority ethnic people seem to be treated more as an individual regardless of skin colour.
But in Malaysia even tho there is a so call bumiputra benefits or something like that you should see from this perspective. how many minority in malaysia given a chance to do business n succeed? there Malay/Chi/Ind in politic. but when u go to India how many malay or chi politic? same goes for china. are the minority been given the same right?
Alisha et al, I think the majority should ask this question. If parents adopt stepchildren on top of having own children, they have 2 approach choices on their stepchildren. One is give some, hold back some and at times act one way in public and act differently in private. The other is unconditional love, giving and consistent in actions and fair treatment between own and stepchildren. Let's be really transparent, the reality is the former rather than the latter actions. Try staying in a non Malay community and witness for yourself the positive and negative effects of the govt policy. What you see may imply success among non Malays but in reality there are a also lot of non Malays who barely get by and are struggling in their business and personal life. This is not made known publicly and because race minority numbers are small, it may not get the due highlight needed. I understand from a Malay perspective given my upbringing but not many Malays will understand and fathom a non Malay perspective. As long as race is still being harped on through direct or indirect political policies, the thread that holds the unity of the citizens will always be stressed and at times break. Singapore's model is not ideal too and I know of racial biases happening by and large within it's own communities just like Msia. Msia can do better than Sgp in every aspect but race based politics will hold back the nation from moving forward at a faster pace.
@@alishaaishahandayah4054 You are comparing an apple to an orange. Chinese and Indians in Malaysia have been with the Malays even before our Merdeka. Unlike Malay and Chinese in India, or Malay and Indian in China.
@@alishaaishahandayah4054 Stop being stupid and using China and India to compare. Before you ask how many Malays in politic there, why don't you ask how many Malays living there? Chinese and Indians have been living in Malaysia and Singapore for generations. Are you willing to migrate to other countries and work hard for generations over there? Don't forget the Chinese and Indians actually contributed to building Malaysia and Singapore. All the towns, cities, roads, infrastructure etc built with their blood sweat and tears. In fact, they were here before the country Malaysia was even in existence. Malaysia is formed from separate little kingdoms and Sabah and Sarawak.
@@hailyrizzo5428 to call other's opinions stupid shows how you u are. but i am sure u r too clever.
Why do Indonesian dishes get referred to as Malay in Singapore? They say it is a Malay dish but Indonesian origins? I am so confused.
What we know as Malays today were immigrants who moved from the Indonesian archipelago to the Malay Peninsula/Singapore in the 16th century. Honestly almost everything Malay has Indonesian origins (correct me if I'm wrong)
Indonesia only exists in 1945 but Malays have existed for thousands of years.
@@hueyenooi5174 not all malay peninsula people come from Indonesia im one of them my ancestors come from north peninsula of Malaysia and we don't have any relation with Indonesia
@UChtpeIZZYJtHPz4hdbdtbiA Asam pedas come from melaka and sumatera basically malaysia and Indonesia dish but yes one of malay dishes
@@hueyenooi5174 you are totally wrong... Indonesia just exist after 1945.. it is a nationality just like Malaysian, Filipino.. this whole region is called Malay Archipelago, the modern day Malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore, Brunei and Southern Thailand... Indonesia is basically established due to dutch colonist... while Malaysia is because of British colonist
im hungry now..
I almost confuse the host with Mak Cik Rosmah
Human beings are equal, no one can live over 150 years. Why should we care about races. Just live happily together during your stay.
religions divide them and not race. The gays with no religion are attracted to Chinese boys and hot Indians. No war. All they see is beauty.
In The Far East And South East Asia if you are Olive (Mediterannean), Brown(Desi, Australian Aboriginal, Tasmanian Aboriginal, Polynesian, Micronesian, Mestizo, Or Pardo), Black(Sub Saharan African, Melanesian, Or Papuan), Red(Amerindian), Eskimo/Aleut then you will be treated with disdain and distaste collectively while if you are Yellow(East Asian) or Golden Brownish(South East Asian) you will be treated with less hostileness and if you are Western White(North Western European) then you will be treated like royalty generally yeah.
they make trouble everywhere, be patient okay,
The thing is the people who mentions there's racial matters here are the people who have the racial sentiment issues in themselves. An American friends told me that immigrants in America are not truly American becos they still speaks their own mother tongue instead of English. No one can ever change the ethnicity in our blood. Just live with it.
Rawon with seperate soup? yay
never seen that
i mean i never order rawon in sg
I love Malay calture
Why is Geylang Serai so popular? I'm Malaysian by the way 😅
It is the cultural and commercial gathering of Malay communities in Singapore.
@@khairiaris I see 🙂
"I consider myself quite woke?" lmao
Non-Malays only get 3% of special Budget in ... you know where
Eh where..
where? What?
BUMIPUTRA
Sometimes not about race. Should also question the MP if he feels that 16k allowance just for the MP allowance portion is already overpriced. The ministerial salary is also skyrocketed etc. He's born from humble background, but right now on the skyrocketed salary path, should try to equilabarise a bit. There are quite many SG politicians now every month earning 100k SGD on wards, but at the same time able to tell their history of 10+ people sharing rental flats etc. Clearly there is inequality in SG, where our country's founding principle is justice, liberty and equality, but now there is inequality. Meritocracy is fine, but not to the current extend of high inequality
Food has no race but only culture. Who cares as long as it's yummy.
Being A Malay sometumes also difficult. Because if you are A Malay sit in The Bus Or MRT,some people prefer not to sit beside you. Maybe smelly or what?? But mostly are okay. You can sense it.
Mostly Malays smell good, maybe they are just not confident enough to sit with Malays...
As far as I know, the Chinese don't take a bath in the morning for lucky thingy reason.
lmao!!
:(
@BlackBannerz
Dude are you for real?
How do you know that? Is that true?
@blackbannerz9830 even in this vid you are here. go back to malaysia PAS supporter.
Non muslim people always mistook Malay just don't eat pork but actually we are too don't eat any beef or chicken meat that cucuk only.
Race?
Human race.
Hi. Thanksgiving.
Last time shiok can camp at corridor… now.. hmmm so many people complain and take video, becoming an unwanted culture
this can not be happening in Malaysia as it is going into serious situation
17:37 Belacan is paste shrimp originally from malacca, Malaysia. Please find your own identity food Singapore 🙄
its funny how they talking about Singaporean race yet they were ate Indonesian-originated foods. So basically, cmon man, we are equal. let's stop this colonization concept.
most dont wanna admit the fact that they are migrants
Singapore Malays and Indonesians share similar tradition and values, which is understandable that we share similar foods too. Take east asia as an example, ramen is commonly found in both Korea and China despite originating in Japan. So don't have to argue la, relax. We know where it came from too and that is all that matters.
I can speak Malay and tamil in addition to English and Chinese……..
Follow indonesia lah, walaupun poor they have big dignity. Everyone speak bahasa there. Siapapun yang nak datang, nak tinggal, nak beranak pinak, cakap! tak de tu ni Hao ni Hao.
No bahasa you out!
should interview those typical ones, not Munah. fair-skinned 'malay' gets treated way differently i bet
perkedel - bergedil😁
In Malay dictionary the accepted spelling is Bergedel and Pergedel. I searched Indonesian Dictionary, Perkedel, Bergedel and Pergedel are all accepted.
@@solehsolehsoleh Perkedel is authentic Indonesian cuisine . Javanese , Sundanese , Batavianese etc said PERKEDEL , *never said* begedil or bergedil.
Perkedel = persatuan kentang dan telur
Why Malaysian & Singaporean change it to begedil / bergedil ???
Iissskkkk
@@AZA020406 fyi, singaporeans and malaysians pronunciation differs from bahasa indonesia. as long as we know what it is and where it originated from, all's good. lek la
@@derpybin Its origin is in northern europe look at the name its originally frikadelle brought by the Dutch to East Indies, java specifically which change the meat (usually pork) with potato.
Singapore is origin of malay land..others are immigrants..know ur place dear indians and chinese
When why did you separate them from your federation, nationalist?
@@user-kq1fi5nz8d because of british colonisation bringing lots of these guys..conflict happens politically..even these immigrants gonna surpass the number of native..thats why..SG is chinese dominant..u can read more of the history of Malaysia and u will know more
Is she appropriate to represent Malay?
Temasik should return back into being a part of the Malay Nusantara instead of being a foreign ethnic Chinese enclave
Malays were the one who threw Singapore from the federation.
Malay Malaysian.
What's the difference between Palestinian and Malay food????...🤔🇸🇬
Both arabic
@@user-kq1fi5nz8du stupid one for sure
So funny folks in your part of the world view different Asian cultures as diffrent races, when in the West they just call all you folks either Indian or Chinese...🧟♂️🧟♂️🧟♂️
Same this is also state propaganda from Singapore since those food are indonesian specifically east javanese and padang. They are like claiming ukrainian is russian.
More chinese blood than Malay,still Malay?
Just called them mongoloid.
Maimunah, lu nampak macam kacukan olang india. Arab konon 😂😂😂😂. Aleh, saya pun olang Arab la! Moyang saya dari Yemen 😂😂😂
Not rawon! But rames.
The Bumi Malay in Singapore they also get special privileges ?
Yes. Malay Singaporeans pay max 30% of the applicable university/polytechnic fees in Singapore, depending on family income. In addition for primary and secondary education, Malays only pay part of the school fees, which is not means-tested.
@@Ccb88888 how come no one told me i only need to pay max 30% uni fees? i paid full fees!! i feel cheated!
no, Malays still pay the full Singaporean/PR school fees. Malays can apply for assistance or study loans from Mendaki. But we still pay 100% of the school fees.
This is Singapore, not Malaysia. 😂
There are not special privilages in Singapore, all races is same in privilage.
Must wear mask when not eating ...fine them
Singapore is actually MALAY land
none of them here is pure Malay. They're all mixed with Chinese.
Racism... malaysians experience this the most
This is indonesian food
Singapore Malays and Indonesians share similar tradition and values, which is understandable that we share similar foods too. Take east asia as an example, ramen is commonly found in both Korea and China despite originating in Japan. So don't have to argue la, relax. We know where it came from too and that is all that matters.
It was said that Windsor Earl prefer the name Malayunesia (Malay Archipelago) instead of Indunesia (Indian Archipelago), because Malayunesia is an appropriate name for the Malay archipelago, while Indunesia can also refer to Ceylon (Sri Lanka) and Maldives.
to eliminate racism, stop talking about race
No tutop aulat?
lol cute
Being a gay malay how
Melayu hilang di duna? Yes in SINGAPORE!
Melayu paleng corrupt..malaysia...Yeah!
Arab konon
i think identity of a race is important. when you go for both the extremist then you'll have racists and no-identity-folks which is bad. how you balance both side is the tricky part. thats what separates successful and fail civilization. my two cents.
How is it bad to be complete opposite of racist. Seems like a very tribal mentality to have.
There is no such race call indian race! So your view on racism is not right
Their are indonesian not malays lol
Singapore Malays and Indonesians share similar tradition and values, which is understandable that we share similar foods too. Take east asia as an example, ramen is commonly found in both Korea and China despite originating in Japan. So don't have to argue la, relax. We know where it came from too and that is all that matters.
@@derpybin Yeah like Ukraine being claimed Russian, so don't argue lah, relax, because shared values and tradition right?
Malayunesia is another name next to Indunesia that was proposed by George Samuel Windsor Earl to identify the archipelago.[27] It was a Greek translation of the Malay Archipelago also connected to the concept of Malay race, the inhabitant of the archipelago. It was said that Windsor Earl prefer the name Malayunesia (Malay Archipelago) instead of Indunesia (Indian Archipelago), because Malayunesia is an appropriate name for the Malay archipelago, while Indunesia can also refer to Ceylon (Sri Lanka) and Maldives. He also argues that Malay language is spoken throughout the archipelago.
So no difference between Vietnamese and Chinese they share similar culture.
LOL. speakout the truth sure lu kena Singapura ISA.