This Nirvana Song Is Criminally Underrated
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 เม.ย. 2023
- In today's livestream I discuss a Nirvana song that deserves a lot more attention.
📚The Beato Ultimate Bundle - $99 FOR ALL OF Rick's Courses. Get it here: ⇢ rickbeato.com
📘- The Beato Book Interactive - $99.00 value
🎸 - Beato Beginner Guitar - $159.00 value
👂- The Beato Ear Training Program - $99.00 value
🎸- The Quick Lessons Pro Guitar Course - $79.00 value
… all for just $99.00
Get it here: rickbeato.com
My Beato Club supporters:
Justin Scott
Terence Mark
Farren Mahjoor
Jason Murray
Lucienne Kilpatrick
Alexander Young
Jason Wagner
Todd Ladner
Rob Kline
Nicholas Long
Tim Benson
Leonardo Martins da Costa Rodrigues
Eddie Perez
David Solomon
MICHAEL JOYCE
Stephen Stubbs
colin stead
Jonathan Wentworth-Linton
Patrick Payne
MATTHEW KARIS
Matthew Barouch
Shaun Samuels
Danny Kurywchak
Gregory Reedy
Sean Coleman
Alexander Verbitskiy
CL Turner
Jason Pappafotis
John Fulford
Margaret Carno
Robert C
David M Combs
Eric Flatt
Reto Spoerli
Herr Moritz Adam
Monte St. Johns
Jon Beezley
Peter DeVault
Eric Nabstedt
Eric Beggs
Rich Germano
Brian Bloom
Peter Pillitteri - เพลง
One of my favorite Nirvava songs is Lounge Act. I love the bass intro, I love how the song progresses into harder and faster.
This song still amazes me 30+ years after hearing it. I started doing karaoke on an app a few years ago and I never really sang before. It turns out that I do best on Nirvana songs and i didn’t expect that even though they are my favorite. BUT…I can never get Lounge Act right! The vocals on that are in some bizarre pitch that I just can’t reach. Most Nirvana songs are my comfort zone but I just can’t figure out how he sings this one. With other bands, I can kind of get close with practice, but not this one. I have done most of their songs and I don’t know what it is about the vocals on this one.
Good call
This, yes. I was recently talking with a friend and I mused that you could reasonably have taken Lounge Act and Drain You off of Nevermind, replaced them with literally anything else, and then built another record off of them as lead singles, and it would have worked.
My favorite nirvana song since I first heard it
One of the first basslines I taught myself to play
People often overlook how essential Krist Novoselic's basslines were to Nirvana's sound. Him and Kurt had this symbionic relationship musically. Alot of Krist's playing is unorthodox, but it always mirrors Kurt's own eccentricities in his playing.
Totally agree!
Fantastic bass lines. Listen to Krist on Lithium and how much his bass crafts that songs melody.
Lounge act
Yes. Krist's sound and tone are an integral part of Nirvana's sound for sure
You betcha man
Aneurysm and Francis Farmer are two of my favorite Nirvana gems, that never really got mainstream notoriety.
I love D-7. It sounds like a fun song to play on drums and it has that soft>loud thing that Teen Spirit has. There are lots of good stuff that doesn't get radio play or that people really listen to that is incredible. I loved the Incesticide record and the Outcesticide records are really good too.
@@matthew6427love D-7 too but it is a cover... Nirvana owned every cover they ever did tbf, so the song has become theirs at this point 😝
Yeah Francis Farmer is legit
Serve The Servants.
Matter of fact In Utero is their best record in my opinion.
Hell yeah 🤘 those are two of my favorite as well. Aneurysm being a B-side shows just how much talent they had bursting out of them.
@@omegahorizon82absolutely his, their, masterpiece. Been listening since 92 and love all their music, but In Utero is just raw and pure. And honestly, you know your right is one of my least favorite songs, right there with polly. Wouldn't sound right on the last album.
When I was in a music school, I mentioned to a jazz head what a great songwriter Kurt was and he went 'When has anyone ever praised Kurt Cobain as a SONGWRITER?' I sometimes feel like people confuse Kurt's slacker image with his musical ability. He actually had incredibly intricate melodies and bizarre chord changes and managed to fool generations of both fans and musicians that he was playing really basic 3 chord music. In Bloom has 10 (mostly) chromatic chords, for example.
Ask that jazz head to write you a song that would be a massive commercial success but still has an edge and an alternative or interestingly progressive feel. Or even a retro feel but still 'of the moment'. If he can't hear Cobain's songwriting ability and communication skills to a mass audience then he's clearly got some kind of problem with his ears.
In my time , before i knew anything about music cobain was like the most despised musician on earth..however cobain is gone but his music remains among us
He is an under rated guitar player too.
People look at me weird when I tell them that Nirvana is my 2nd favorite band of all time (right after Led Zeppelin). 😎
Jazz is garbage, too abstract, not circular enough in my opinion.
How great would an hour of rick chatting with jerry cantrell of AIC about how he came up with melodies be!?
Yes, please & thank you!
Jerry’s current tour is fixing to wrap up…………….
I'll second that emotion!!!
That would be great, grand, and swell!!!
How about chatting with Kurt Cobain?
“You Know You’re Right” is my absolute favorite Nirvana song. I remember hearing it for the first time as a preteen and feeling such a swell of emotion that I normally only got from bands like Pink Floyd. It hits exactly the same twenty years later.
But if I was going to pick an “underrated” Nirvana song, I’d personally go with “Sappy.” Such a simple yet beautiful heavy dirge. That guitar solo is emotionally charged punk bliss.
I actually thought Sappy was going to be the song Rick was referring to. It's always been one of my favorites. Plus, You Know You're Right isn't even underrated. It's properly rated for being released 10 years after Nirvana's & Grunge's (if you want to call Nirvana grunge, I personally don't) heyday. Only old Nirvana heads were into it in 2002.
It's funny you mention Floyd because they were the band I got WAAAY into after Nirvana. in the 90s. Probably no coincidence that's also when I got way into dropping acid every weekend. But anyway Nirvana is one of those bands like Floyd, the Beatles, and Led Zeppelin that don't have many throw away songs. There are a few songs on Bleach that I skip over, and I was never a fan of "Come as You Are." But otherwise, even counting unreleased tracks like Sappy I love em all and it's hard to pick a favorite.
@@thebigjimmyd Yeah, You Know You're Right is hardly an underrated song. Big fanfare when it was released, people tend to know it and like it.
Awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
Yep was gonna say Sappy... my fav song by anyone of all time
YKYR has always been my favorite Nirvana song!
I think Dumb is one of the best songs Kurt wrote. A lot of people are snobs when it come to Kurt’s abilities as a songwriter. For me he was the Lennon of his generation.
With you on Dumb. Amazing melody , amazing lyrics, and that middle 8 is perfect!
Disagree. Noel Gallagher exists.
Agree completely
@@agustinsimone3277 are you kidding me ?!
@@agustinsimone3277 lmao, nirvana destroys oasis. Noel Gallagher has been bland as hell since what’s the story morning glory
Cobain was indisputably one of the best melody writers of his generation. People say he was a bad guitarist and overrated as a musician but nobody can deny that the guy could write infectious hooks that stand the test of time. That's not easy to do.
And to think he would do so with the most depressing goddamn thoughts is pretty fucking amazing. It's like AIC; nutshell is the most heartbreaking earworm songs ever written. Miss ya Kurt and Layne.
And he had technical proficiency guilt that later spread to metallica...meanwhile metalica is better as heavily technical band and Cobain just wanted to be musically accessible like college rock bands so who knows how good he was technically.
Indeed it's the hardest of things to do as a musician...
@@billium99 He probably saw himself as artist. A musician can be very clinical thing if minimal interest in art.
he has, what?5 or 6 songs in his Lp´s with melody, it´s easy to be sucessfull after being suicided
If you look at the way Kurt actually played certain chords you'll find some of these traits in other places. It helped him discover the melodies because he had a 'wrong' note to fight against or clash with or create something different with. The way he bars with his third finger on power chords is quite unusual. It could be considered 'incorrect' but it leads to these different combinations and different territories to explore. It wasn't born out of music theory knowledge, it was simply born out of playing chords in a bastardised way because he didn't know any better.. Having a natural gift for melody was very helpful to his success though, of course.. but he wouldn't be able to explain it to you from a theoretical point of view. He didn't really consider himself a proper musician.. It was never about technical expertise for that band. That's why the punk ethos was important to him as an influence because he realised you didn't need to be a great player or educated in music theory to express yourself and communicate with a mass audience on an emotional and artistic level. I'm happy he made that connection and gave us those songs.
Right on. 🤘
Excellent summary. It’s both tragic, yet beautiful, because more than not, Kurt belongs among the creative minds who’s “bastardized” way of playing/thinking/etc is what makes them a pioneer in their fields. It’s exactly that kind of doing things outside the box that challenges the status quo.
thank you for this.
@@swirleynoise2424 My pleasure.
@@constructionbootgazer That's right.. it's a combination of an idiosyncratic guitar style, the natural gift for melody and a voice and attitude that connected with people on an emotional level.. and being the right guy in the right time and place for whatever reason. It's a perfect storm of chance and fate. It's comparable culturally to the Beatles or Star Wars what happened with Nirvana. Not as big maybe but the more you look at it it's almost a miracle it ever happened at all considering where he came from.
There’s a home demo called do re mi which I think had real promise as well. What a gift he shared with us.
I think I like that song better to be honest. Simple, but the chord changes/melody are great. I play that song much more often than "You Know You're Right" even if there was never a fully produced version.
I think “Burn the rain” from montage of heck is one of the most mystifying songs I’ve ever heard and then the phone call cuts it off
If I may
And if I might
Lie me down weeping
And if I say
What it's like
I might be dreaming
I was surprised this song didn't make a bigger splash when it was released. Definitely up there with their best.
Brittney had already destroyed music by then
I completely agree. Actually my favorite song on the album.
@@mewjr1 Brittany the internet, Auto-Tune, in-ear monitors, plugins, and most of all Tik-Tok and it's 15 second chipmunk vocal songs that for some reason gen z just stinks is the coolest thing when in reality it is pathetic and disgusting.
yes ,maybe ,it was a nice song that was slow and not sounding like nirvana but it was made great in bootlegs
It was a pretty popular radio single in its day. I remember it was the most requested song on my local rock station at one point when I was a kid.
"talk to me", "sappy", "verse chorus verse", "i hate myself and want to die", "here she comes now" some awesome lesser known gems.
sappy is my favorite
Here she comes now = velvet underground
Old age
Love Sappy so much
When I was at high school in the 90's, 'Sappy' had a cult following even back then.
If only Kurt knew that decades later, people would be seriously analyzing his songwriting and making parallels to Lennon.
I don't think Kurt was comparable to Lennon (who was minus McCartney), but he certainly was a great song writer.
@FooFan-vt4bnthat a joke?
@@piteusx8440 I can’t think of anything Lennon wrote that stands up to Kurt’s best. But I’m not the biggest Beatles fan so I could be wrong. But if so, it must be a non hit.
@@SharpEdgeStandardOfficial It posts this spam 1000x, then goes back and gives each one a like. I'm reporting 'em as spam.
Wasn’t one of his mental health issues due to his feeling his stardom was undeserved or intrusive? I’d imagine this comparison would make that even worse
I remember this was released. It made me so sad because this song is so interesting and it made me think about how Kurt could have continued to grow and change as an artist.
Well said!
Totally. 🤘
Exactly what I thought... It still pisses me off
he would be forgoten like other bands that their lead singer didn´t get suicided
@@RUfromthe40s forgotten like the Foo Figthers? Or forgotten like Rage Against the Machine perhaps? Forgotten like Metallica or Megadeth? What kinda of forgotten bands youd have in mind here?
Kurt didn’t even know theory or the notes on a guitar. He was just a pure beam of light that channeled music instinctively. Incredible
not a theory "Let's line up three semitones" “It’s cool when you enter from the fifth degree.”
This is territorial pissing, and in bloom
Same chords and melody
He knew basic theory. Only people with 0 theory could think he has 0 theory.
@@bigfatburn6229 knowing a few chord shapes is not theory dude, everything else Kurt was unaware...fooling around with tunnings isnt theory, is fooling around...I mean: even some of the notes that Rick is so fascinated about were handslips never corrected in a punk spirit....basically: if it sounds okey, probably theres a whole bunch of theory behind only to explain why it sounds so good.
@@YOSOYLADISCO 1- I am not a dude
2- I am 44 and grew up with Nirvana
3- I studied in music at univ
4- Kurt was always fooling around pretending he was different and « natural ». He was like anybody else. But had tremendous creativity. He knew basic theory. You can find interviews of him pretending he does not know theory and others where he speaks of music like someone knowing basic theory (few years of learning). Problem is the cult after his death trying to make of him some kind of genius. He was just an ordinary guy.
Intuitive musical genius indeed....🤘🤘, Kurt was oh so talented
kurt is a legend, he would write songs with 3 notes that will make your favourite genius guitar hero cry to sleep wishing they could write as good
that's why they always gotta say he was a mediocre musician 🤣
Awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
I can’t believe how many seasoned musicians I know understate Kurt’s musical abilities. He was a genius, no doubt about it. Great video, Rick!
They're just hating
It always offends some when someone without any actual musical schooling or pedigree has a greater ability to create unique and interesting things. That and also the fact that he had the "wrong" crowd so to speak. Sort of "If those slobs and freaky kids get it, it has to be too simple for me to like!"...
Do they really understate his musical abilities or his guitar abilities? I find more of the latter.
To them I say try to play All Apologies and sing it simultaneously lol
@@GuitGuyPL If you can't change an entire generation with all the fiddly skills and music theory under your belt and do it with 4 power chords, then maybe skill on guitar isn't what you need?
Lots of emotions when this came out. It's a great track, a hint of what could have been. Kurt had really mastered his voice when they recorded this.
maybe overrated
@@RUfromthe40s I disagree 😢
@@RUfromthe40s hey everyone, Rui wants you to know he’s different and unique...... 🙄
Awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
@@RUfromthe40s everyone is literally overrated dude....Metallica is big but guess what, I think they're overrated. Blasphemy I know 🤐
Beautiful. Cobain had it all as a song writer. The delivery of this song is intense, how the melody flows, the tension and release, the lyric (OMG), the pain and emotion are all pouring out, it's a tough listen. The final offering of a genius. Excellent analysis.
Agree!
One of my favorites is Negative Creep. One of their more punk inspired songs. A definite headbanger
Oh mate I Loved that recording even though it's mentioned,The Chorus Chords are just such a beautiful psychosis within the history of electric guitar amplified which in context has not been that long 80 years very basically.
Would love Beato to do a breakdown of "Aneurysm" (live version of course) at some point, it has to be one of the most 'complex' Nirvana songs. The long multi part intro before singing begins, the bass lines alternating during certain parts to help build intensity / slow down the pace, the insane drumming, and that melody...
I'm 73, and ever sinceTeen Spirit stopped me dead in my tracks when I first heard it, Nirvana has remained my favorite band, and I go way back to Surfin' by the Beach Boys in 1962, and I graduated from high school during the Summer of Love, 1967, which was an absolute tsunami of revolutionary music. But Nirvana is my absolute obsession. Aneurysm still gives me goose bumps, especially the live version at Del Mar, with it's frantic pace and absence of the chirpy, grating "beat it, beat it", which may be Kurt's only false step. The subtle modulations in tempo, and the thematic complexity -- there are 4 separate themes running theough the song. This was what I played in the car as I drove my 8 year old son to his soccer games on Saturdays. It amped him up, to say nothing of me.
That song is easy tbh. I wouldn't say it's complex at all.
@@danejurus69 Maybe not difficult for you to copy now that it exists but can you write a song of the same calibre? I'd love to hear it.
Aneurysm is one of the most awesome songs ever. So incredibly heavy, and super interesting progression. It’s just one hell of a song!
studio version, you can barely hear the instruments in the live version
I love how Curt completed chords with his voice. His guitar and voice were a single instrument.
Rick helped me see this. As did listening to some live stuff I found by them.
I’ve tried to explain this to my fiancée for years now lol we’re both musicians but he’s not a singer. Just a guitarist. He doesn’t fully appreciate lyricism and using vocal tones as a whole different instrument in itself. Glad I’m not the only one who recognizes this about Kurt
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
Google the McKenzie tapes to find the live show I was talking about. Many early 90s live shows. In the Nirvana one I dug, a woman yelled "taper scum!" into the guy's mic.
So awesome!
The song encapsulates Nirvana’s sound so well. Beautiful melody, apparent simplicity and an aggression that flows between catchy to freaky.
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
I was at the concert where they played this for the only time live, in Chicago at the Aragon Ballroom. Such an amazing time!
I'm so jealous!!!
I always thought "Dive" was one of their best songs. The fact this was on a B sides record is insane.
Their two "pre-fame" albums contain some of the best music they ever did. There's not a POS anywhere on either record.
@@OslerWannabe two? Bleach was the only album to come out pre-Nevermind. Incesticide came out in 92.
@@reverb508 I suppose the point is that the material on Incesticide was cobbled together from mostly pre-Nevermind recordings.
@@BudSchnelker ok, I buy that reasoning lol. Looking back at the liner notes, I forgot how many of those tracks had Chad Channing or Dale Crover on drums!
"Dive," "Aneurysm," "Frances Farmer," and "You Know You're Right" must top the list of overlooked gems.
Would love to see you do a deep dive into The Pixies, Dino Jr., Husker Du, and especially The Replacements and how Nirvana is interrelated to all of them and the collective is all tied to The Beatles.
The Beatles suck.
@@Thinkforwardnow Big shout out to The Replacements! Listening to tracks like " Tommy gets his tonsils Out", that ragged raw melodic alt rock with Punk Undertones is a huge influence on Nirvana. I remember 20 years ago a good friend burned "Let it Be" for me. He'd just gotten into the Replacements and knowing I was a lifelong Nirvana fan, he enthused on Westerberg's impact on their sound. Hearing the album, I knew he was right, and I heard the connection.
Very true
@@Thinkforwardnow 2🎉💗😂🤔🐂
Pixies pixies!
Lounge Act. That's the one I'd pick.
The acoustic version of "old age" is my absolute favorite. Such a haunting song with it's raw/home demo tinge. Beautiful. Shed many a tear to that song while going through a rough period of my life. That song really helped me pull through it all. Thank you Kurt. We love you. Burn bright. Never fade, people.
I KNEW you're going to be talking about "You Know You're Right." I love this song so much, and that it was officially released 8 years after Kurt's death, giving us one more piece of proof of his genius, has always made it one of my favorites!
I thought he was talking about something off of Bleach because he named all of the albums it isn't on and he didn't say Bleach.
The cool thing is also that he doesn’t always play the 3rds. So the difference between minor and major is mostly on the melody. Which makes the it so effective
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
I love the fact that Rick loves Kurt Cobain and appreciates his music. I second what other people said, Jerry Cantrell would be great to have on. Such a fantastic guitar player and songwriter.
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
Cantrell’s such a talented melody maker, riff writer, lyricist and guitar player that I’ve only recently discovered. I’m 61, and can’t believe how I missed it back then.
The evolution from each Nirvana album to the next was astonishing. I like all of them, but I like each one more than the one before it (I’m not including Incesticide, which is great in its own right). This track will forever be only idea we get about what would’ve come next. It’s a haunting song anyway, but that sentiment makes it that much more haunting to me.
My two favourite Nirvana songs are Blew and You Know Your Right. Both of those songs are criminally underrated.
And on both of those songs the vocal melody is parsing notes of the guitar chord.
Kurt was a master. When they hit, it was like Rock & Roll went back up to the highest level.
Let's not get carried away.
@@Dave-nm3xc he's right
@@Dave-nm3xc I’m going to assume your last name is Grohl and you’re being modest. 11! Nirvana went immediately to 11!
@@dr.buzzvonjellar8862 underrated comment. 😆
@@soulfuzz368 she had him killed sure as you have a bad sense of humor.
In my opinion, "You Know You're Right" is THE perfect example of what Nirvana is.
This. It totally captures the essence of each member...I was blown away when I first heard it (and melancholic for obvious reasons) and said right away that it was the quintessential Nirvana sound. I only wish we could have had more and would love to have heard their sound evolve over time.
Awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
The song moves me so deeply, even still. It’s unreal.
Great breakdown, Rick. I loved how you were singing out those notes so high and called Kurt's guttural tone beautiful. Well, it certainly is amazing that he could sing that way. Also, your Beatles reference is on point. Love your channel bud.
I was just covering a bunch of Nirvana songs this morning. Been going back down the Nirvana rabbit hole for the first time in almost a decade. Good timing Rick
This has always been one of my favorite of not favorite songs by them. So happy to see it getting love
I know your right is a great song I did not know it was underrated
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
Scentless Apprentice and Serve the Servants... great great sound, Albini and Nirvana are a great combo
Kurt was (is) real. I still remember hearing this song when it was released driving in blizzard in Alberta, it Was absolutely haunting. All I can say is I still want more. My kids now listen to Nirvana and love it.
Nirvana is my second favorite band of all time (after The Beatles). I’ll NEVER forget that day in April 1994, when I was 16, when I came home from school and heard the news. Anyway, Rick is spot on that this song is underrated and I respect Rick even more for picking this tune. I always thought Frances Farmer was criminally underrated as well.
Me 2! T’was on my 17th Bday…was already a depressed teen, already hated Bdays, that announcement was the perfect icing on a big ol’ Gen-X cake of 90s bummer crumbs. That summer, ate some mushrooms & imagined I was in communication w/ Kurdt🖤
I often wonder how many rock stars were taken out because they became too big of a cult of personality.
@@DesignRhythm None. Zero. No one is murdering musicians just for being popular. That is a weird thing to wonder.
@@noneofyourbusiness747 Sure. Yep.. and Oswald killed JFK 😆
@@DesignRhythm Yes, compare JFK to a musician. That is a totally rational thing to do. 👍
Such a haunting song. One of their best in my opinion.
...and last song :(
Good Choice Mister Rick 🤩
Probably my favorite of theirs yet it doesn’t get much play! Travesty to be fair
Just listened to TPS learned about here been seeyyour clups forever just got yoyr bundle thank you
THE best, for me anyway. It's actually the only song I really like of Nirvana.
Brutally beautiful song. Kurt is missed.
he wasn´t a good musician , this said by him and if you listen to the records they are not musically speaking, work of art. Some forget that before he died he´s last record which is a very good album wasn´t much sold, i myself was in the last concert he gave in Portugal this before flying to Italy and the space was 1/5 of the room filled but the ones who went to see him were a good audience , he even said " you´re not much but a great audience" and he played the entire concert having a public that did like nirvana ,you didn´t once heard"PLAY, SMELLS LIKE TEEN SPIRIT!!!" if he hadn´t died today was one more band that no one buy´s his records or with the level of improvement they would be a band that always sells a few albums world wide and concerts would always have public, the unpluged was a very sad concert this because he was very high on heroin and if you saw the entire show, you would remenber he going to the public to light a gigar ,this one after the other , Lee Renaldo was laughing because of the whole situation and some people think he was sober, AHAHAH!!! but they put out a great show
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
need more nirvana breakdowns like this
yesss, trueee
This video made me listen to "Frances Farmer Will Have Her Revenge on Seattle" again after not listening to it for 16 or 17 years.
Thank you. How could I forget this beauty?
I love that song. When I listen to it, it's really hard to not play it a few more times in a row to really feel it
Contrary to the liner notes of the album that this track was released on, as well as the music video for the song, Kurt isn’t actually singing “Pain” in the song’s chorus. The isolated vocal track has been available for some time, and upon listening it becomes clear that Kurt is simply belting out the word “Hey” over and over again. And, it makes sense, in the greater context of Kurt’s song writing, because he often liked to sing the word “hey!” when it came time to exclaim something in a song. Lithium, Heart-Shaped Box, Dive, Smells Like Teen Spirit, and Tourette’s all spring to mind as other examples of Kurt summoning an emphatic “Hey!” from his chest and throat to express an emotion he didn’t feel like putting into words. I suspect that, phonetically, it was a very easy and comfortable syllable for him to sing. He could really _lean_ into it.
i always thought it was obviously 'Hey' ever since it came out, i dont know who perpetuated the 'Pain' myth but its really hard to hear it as 'pain' and ive tried hearing as that many times. annoyed me seeing that in every review when it came out. The lyrics are a bit on the nose for me, hes usually a bit more subtle with his subjects, metaphors and contradictions and humour, he must have been in a bad place to be this direct with communicating his misery.but i think singing 'pain' would have been a bit much for even him
Interesting analysis, though I disagree. I've never read the notes for the song, but I've always heard it as "pain" since the day it came out. It sounds different to me than the "hey" you mentioned, but I agree it does have a similar sound that he likely sang very naturally.
@@ElectricIguana - Have you listened to the isolated vocal tracks? They’re on TH-cam. Do that, and then get back to me. He is very obviously saying “Hey”.
@@TestMeatDollSteak That isolated track is incredible to listen to. And yeah, it actually sounds like "Hey" rather than "Pain" when isolated!
@@ElectricIguana - I hate to say I told you so! ;) A couple of the lyrics in the song are mumbled/garbled enough to make them debatable, even with the isolated vocals, but “Hey!” comes across crystal clear. The lyrics building into the chorus are: “No thought was put into this / I always knew it’d come to this / Things have never been so swell / I have never failed to fail”, and the chorus is then “Hey, you know you’re right” (and he modifies that to “You know your rights” at the end).
Hey Rick, awesome video. They confirmed using the isolated vocal track that Kurt is actually singing “Hey!” not “Pain!” In the chorus. I always thought it was pain too.
The song was so ahead of it's time tat when it came out 10 years later or so, on the radio, it rolled right into the current mix of the day. Sounded like a band toud been listening to for years that just grew and progressed. Killer song.
I will never forget the first time I heard this song. I was a Nirvana fan already and about to buy the Best Of the day of its release just for that song but having never heard it before and uncapable of waiting until I get home I just listen to it at the CD shop with their earphones. I was blown away by the simple yet evocative melody. I felt I knew that song before, like it was part of me. An indescribable feeling.
I had a bootleg version, so I was familiar. The bootleg version, I think, is better. More powerful sounding. You should be able to find it on YT.
I could listen to Rick talk Nirvana all day. Love the passion, love Nirvana, rock on 🤘🏻
I always liked, " I'm on a plain"...the lyrics and the subtle back round vocals are pretty sweet. It's off the Smells like teen spirt album. 😊
Straight banger.
Nevermind
My personal favorite
the smells like teen spirit album 💀
I do agree! I think "I'm On a Plain" may be the best song they ever made. "Love myself better than you, know it's wrong, but what can I do???" And that bridge so fuckin slams!!!
Love that first blast of distortion - comes blasting out 👌🏻
this song analysis is much appreciated, it is great to hear about music this way, usually the popular part of it is not taken into account
@@FooFan-vt4bn you a bot, dude, not cool
I remember nirvanna, but I'd stepped away from music to have babies,and work. I lost my first son in 93 and was way to busy after that. Imb60 now and I'm hearing and learning these songs for the very first time. This song I just heard yesterday for the first time. It's kinda neat. I dig the direction he was going in. It's sad he was killed
Another Beatles song that comes to mind with this one, is 'Love You Too', the 2nd Harrison song off Revolver...Kurt's chorus melody brings to mind the Indian inspired line "you don't get time to hang a sign on me-ee-ee-ee-E"
Me and my bandmates in high school geeked out when this song came out and we were blown away and sad he was already gone when it came out.
Its so cool when melodies are sophisticated and imply chord extensions with bare bone instruments providing groove. Love your work Rick 🎶💀🎶
I think you actually just summed up my childhood that I never understood….. I signed to an indie in the early summer of 93 and they sent myopic this little old lady near Detroit that made me lay an the hard wood floor and put weights on my stomach and make me vocally march the note’s she played on the piano, that happened for months before they put us in the studio…. Even though we never sold out, we toured the country for years, and you just made me understand what they were teaching me….. I give you the utmost respect for explaining my youth 😁😁😁😁😁😁
I'm glad you mentioned Frances Farmer. It's cool that you appreciate Nirvana. My guitar teacher when I was young could never appreciate Cobain and I couldn't understand that. He was a jazz guy btw.
I remember the first time I heard this: it was an mp3 of a live version from Nirvana's last tour-the show may have been Milan, Italy? At that time it was titled "On the Mountain." Pretty cool track. Sad that it's the last thing they did.
Chicago October 23 1993
I love this song, I even played it with my band. But for me the one that was criminally underrated is called "SAPPY".
100% man. I like the “verse chorus verse” version better tho.
@@captainautoflower4136 So, I knew "SAPPY" as verse chorus verse, but it seems that there was some mistake and today verse chorus verse is another song that I had never heard. LOL. Another one that I really like and remembered now is called "OPINION"
For sure
That entire No Alternative comp was unbelievable.
'Sappy' was a popular one with my band mates when I was at high school during the '90s. They absolutely loved it even though it wasn't a well known smash hit.
Beautiful content, as always. Thank you so much Rick. It's so heartwarming to see someone so knowledgeable as you braking down one of my favorite songs and loving it as much as I would.
I remember quite well when Nirvana debuted and the world over changed from glam to grunge. I was instantly hooked to the style and sound vs the previous that I preferred in bands like Anthrax, Slayer, Exodus etc. Remembering how much of an impact it had on everything from music to fashion. It just took over like a hurricane. All the sudden, the way I looked and dressed was being hijacked by the more popular kids in highschool. That was a mood killer!
I remember all of this so vividly too. It was absolutely a turning point where the before and after were so different. I already loved Nirvana, but I remember being really shocked the first time I heard them being played on the radio. I never expected it. I was shocked enough that I remember the exact intersection where I was driving in my car, lol
I was sooooooo relieved, I never got into the glam rock & rap drives me crazy.
Grunge was so refreshing…esp nirvana.!
By far my favorite Nirvana song, and you caught me by surprise selecting this for sure, especially this version! Great job Rick!
My go to non-radio tunes have been Sappy, Even in His Youth, Aneurysm & Dive.
School and Blew are up there too
I love "the man who sold the world". That haunting, sorrowful guitar sound at the end just takes me to another place EVERY TIME!
That is David Bowie’s songs.
it's tragic that we never got to hear this amazing song live
Scentless apprentice, radio friendly unit shifter and Frances Farmer will have her revenge on Seattle are so underrated, it's almost criminal like Rick says . All these songs are among their finest in my opinion.
Lounge Act from nevermind as well, that song it's just so good and it hardly gets any recognition, except maybe from such a cool loving Nirvana fan and music master such as Rick .
Lounge Act is the best song on Nevermind by a mile
Milk It is mine. Its the heaviest Nirvana song and goes just as hard as modern metal to me.
I was listening to it very often in my car at full volume. First i thought: "well it's typical Nirvana-music. It's cool!". But the more and more i listened to it, i realized what a masterpiece this is.
Greetings from Bach-City
I subscribed to you since WMTSG video about Nirvana couple of years ago and i'm glad you still talk about them and showing love in these videos. Always keep it coming. There are other Nirvana songs that you do breakdown as well.
It’s amazing the impact that Nirvana and Kurt Cobain are still having. A lot of younger people I know really like them. Just did a song with a very talented young woman from Hong Kong and she loves them. Also a female guitarist I know in Japan named Keisandeath is apparently releasing covers of every song on Nevermind in order, she just put out Breed a few minutes ago. I remember the first time I heard this, being a big Nirvana fan I was (and still am) blown away.
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
I discovered this too using a karaoke app the last few years where you can make or join duets with people all over the world. I have many awesome grunge and punk friends in Indonesia now.
Nirvana is a masterclass in musical and lyrical economy. During the early 90's my musical focus was somewhere else, I had to do a serious look back later in life to get it.
Were u a nu metal Andy
I could always come back to Nirvana! I was still jamming early Metallica. Listening to Soundgarden, Fugazi, Rancid, NOFX, Oh the wild youth!! We were all pretty sad when Kurt passed. What a loss. Their songs are infinitely etched.
@@toomuchsoda8184 No, I was a Jimi and Frank Marino fan, I didn't need metal. :)
I’ve been listening to it on repeat for years! It’s one of my favorites but now I know why!😊
Amazing how much goes into constructing a song like this... it really brings out every little detail when you break down the process on a quantum level Rick great job man!
I've found diving deep into Nirvana's b-sides and rare/unreleased recordings to be infinitely rewarding. Moreso than any other band,even. There's some amazing sh*t down that rabbit hole.
Sappy, and vs chorus vs.
I remember being so heavy into Nirvana around (2003?) when this was originally put out and having no idea it was an unheard-of (for the most part) song. I just remember I had never heard it and I always thought it was just a B side song I had never heard. Blew my mind when I realized it was unreleased. So I got to enjoy hearing a Nirvana song for the first time with everyone else. Old fans and new. Absolutely amazing to have this pop up in the early 2000s! 8+ years after he left us.
Definitely a bittersweet feeling.
Such a good memory, the buzz around waiting on this song to hit and how it brought the love 😊
Finding I Feel Fine gave me emo-bumps. And then Rush. Dude I love your passion. The learning never ends.
I wish Rick could have interviewed Kurt. Imagine that conversation.
I got the whole Beato course and just used it with my 1st graders. haha. Also, a great way to plan and share new ideas for my YT and Insta. Great stuff Rick. And...I'm going to devour this video now.
Pretty cool that Kurt did not know about music theory, he was a genius in music and art. He could do a lot of great stuffs if he would be with us
I could be wrong but I believe most of the greatest artist never really knew too much about music itself, they just really liked the sounds and we're so in love with it they could seemingly create their own from their ear. Very unique people for sure. I used to play all the time and couldn't even read sheet music for the first few years I did it. Was just good at feeling the songs out I was creating. Learned alot by just listening with my ear
I'm pretty sure most, if not all, of The Beatles couldn't read or write music. You can teach technique and theory, but you can't teach genius.
Im gonna take a stab before he says what it is, and guesssss…. Endless Nameless? Lol
@@buzzbomb67 bruh lmao tbf i guessed about a girl cos of the acoustic guitar
Yes, yeah it’s pretty awesome. Sometimes I wonder if the greats that are still alive look at videos like this thing to them selves well, that wasn’t even what was going through my mind, but hey whatever. Lol
Great stuff as usual !
Thank you so much @Rickbeato for your inspiring flame !
Oh The Guilt was always one of my faves. Sappy too, had it in a bootleg cassette that had it listed as “Everything & Nothing”.
You have completely changed the way I listen to music. It’s truly a treat being able to go back, and gain another level of appreciate for these songs.
Thank you Rick, you have a gift and I’m glad to see you using it for the benefit of the rest of us.
Yes
I’ve always thought Even in his Youth and Sliver were underrated as perfect grunge pop records
Is it just me or does "Even in His Youth" sound _a lot_ like "Pssyche" by Killing Joke?
He does that sus4 power chord all over the place and it always sounded amazing to me. No one notates it when transcribing Nirvana and I'm happy to see you make reference to it!
This is my favourite song from Nirvana. I bought the compilation as a teenager and can't stop listening to this particular song ❤
I was beyond happy and sad when I first heard this song. Happy because it was new Nirvana. Sad because it's the last we can get and you can hear the band was moving into a newer sound. Love Nirvana
O :
“Things have never been so swell, I have never failed to fail / Hey, you know you’re right…”
For me it was "School" being so obvious and so raw and real just underscored the simplicity of awesome.
My fave nirvana tune is drain you, such a perfect grouping of lyrics and music to me. Plus it has special meaning for me
This song sounds a lot like Alice In Chains to me. I’m 51 years old and I love this music and I love Rick Beato’s analysis. Keep doing what you do Rick!🤘🏻
I dont hear that one bit. Jerry Cantrells guitar work is too interesting to be compared to this.😊
@@BigTyronie 🥱
I was literally just listening to this song before clicking on this video. WTF Rick...
Awesome I listened to it a few days ago, and I was thinking of it when I saw the title of this video.
You know you’re right
I know, right, that does happen 😉 synchronicities 🤔
Hey pls recommend me some good songs by nirvana as I want to explore the band . I have heard something in the way and smells like teen spirit
Literally? Reminds me how often this word is used incorrectly…literally reminded.
Rick your way of starting this channel has introduced me to a whole different way of thinking and creating. I am thankful your a great mind. thank you very much
I think Kurt would be in love with your show RIck. We all love your dissections of Nirvana songs/Kurt's musical ability!!!! Legendary stuff mate
I remember back when that song was released someone said “ what a great way for Kurt to finish his music by singing Pain”
"Milk It" is the greatest Nirvana song made.
it was a harrowing visceral showcase into the horror that was the mind of Kurt Cobain.
Radio Friendly Unit Shifter is another one.
I would have loved to hear the Deeper "In Utero" version of Kurts Music more often..
he really hit a psychological and emotional peak with that album
Milk It......respect.
I agree 100%. So violent and paranoid.
Aneurism
by far my favorite song, I first found it when I was 16 before I was really into nirvana, and it became my gateway to them. Very depressing song when you're feeling sad, or struggling with drug addiction.
So awesome! Check out what we're doing!!
Nirvana was the band that first made me "notice" music if you will, that was back in 1993 when i was 12, been hooked ever since and been collecting nirvana memorabilia ever since. To me there's never been a band like nirvana prior or since, the sound, the look all unique
This song shows how brilliant of a song writer he had become. It’s like the pinnacle.
Rick, you might know it, but you should check out Do Re Mi. Another great song, which wasn’t finished, but it’s beautiful.