How do mainland Chinese citizens living in Hong Kong feel about the protests?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ส.ค. 2019
- Subscribe to our TH-cam channel for free here: sc.mp/subscribe-youtube
Hong Kong is in the grip of its biggest political crisis since the city’s 1997 handover from British rule to Chinese sovereignty. Continuing protests, which at times turned violent, have slammed the government since it proposed an amendment to the city's extradition laws that would open the door to transfers of suspects to mainland China.
Hong Kong people say they are slowly losing freedoms they enjoy - freedoms not offered to citizens on the Chinese mainland. But how do mainlanders who live and study or work in Hong Kong view the crisis?
Follow us on:
Website: scmp.com
Facebook: / scmp
Twitter: / scmpnews
Instagram: / scmpnews
Linkedin: / south-china-morning-post
That UK flag in the background though. We forget that Hong Kong was probably the only British colony that was not happy about the British departure
When the alternative is an authoritarian communist regime, colonial rule from the British doesn't sound all that bad.
@卟咖卟咕工作室 lol not a Hong Konger, but I know how horrible Communism is and that China ranks towards the bottom of the human freedom index while the UK ranks towards the top.
@卟咖卟咕工作室 those questions can be answered in those evil websites your government believes you shouldn't look at.
卟咖卟咕工作室 出来看看一下世界吧，有时候东西不是像你们媒体所说的一样
@@ghostf6321 not having access to TH-cam and Facebook became standard of human rights violation for westerners. They think Chinese people aren't aware of outer world but fact is in every trade there is involvement of a chainese.
Props to the PhD student trying to understand the HK perspective.
This post is not getting enough likes.
Give it twenty years, these open-minded and highly educated individuals are going to become the main driving force of mainland China's political system and economy.
@@germsspices No it won't. The current ruling class is the legacy of Mao, extremely ignorant and arrogant, and they are pumping this mentality into the young generation. The new generation of red guard is already here. The future of China is doomed.
Smou Louch the ruling class of the present day China is a legacy of Deng who was deemed a traitor by Mao.
Qimeng zhang not Xi. Xi is a diehard follower of Mao. So it’s bad news for China
9:15 "I agree that we need stability, but it must stand on justice. If society doesn't have justice, then prosperity is just an illusion."
Well said 👍
Golden Eagle the only idiots are the delusional youth that are destroying their own city in the false hope of ‘freedom’
Golden Eagle lol if you talk bad about the Chinese government or anything pro Hong Kong democracy movement than I guess she did broke laws in China.
well said
@Golden Eagle SB
There will be a change in tone when that presumably false prosperity is gone.
‘’We will be even more heartbroken if they end up beating you’’ 😭😭
This video is such a nice propaganda piece. But what about the many mainland tourist that were beaten by the protesters or the many mainland chinese living their lives in fear?
@@dlee8995 how can you talk about propaganda and Hong Kong. The CCP are propaganda masters
@@martijnkeulen5937 I'm sure China like any other country have their own propaganda but I can't read Chinese so I will not argue with you on this point. However, I have some HK friends and relatives that send me videos of the crazy things rioters are doing that Western and HK media never show. Western media call these peaceful protest and claim completely unarmed protesters were met with police brutality, but in the videos that were never published in mainstream media, the police were outnumbered and the mobs were viciously attacking police, which led to the police actions that I see in the news. Two days ago a rioter was shot by police; Western media only show the part where the cop open fire and cut out the part prior to the shooting, which would show why the cop had no choice but to fire as he was fearing for his life and his fellow cop that was on the ground being beaten by a mob with lethal steel pipes and hammer. To be fair, news outlet should show the full video so viewers can judge for themselves instead of hiding evidence and twisting facts to mislead the public. Comparing what I see on the news the past months and watching uncut video footages and hearing from actual friends and families living in HK, I find the dishonesty and deception in Western and HK media quite disgusting.
@@dlee8995 I ofcourse don't agree with violence against these mainland Chinese people. It's horrible. It's just that I follow a lot about China (the part that China doesn't want you to see a specially) and I really understand the hatred to the chinese communist party. There is just so much wrong in that country that I don't even know where to start talking about. If you would like to learn more about China I would really recommend the TH-cam channels adv china and China uncensored. Cheers
@@martijnkeulen5937 So is America LOL
Humanity shows when they warn her to wear protective gears🙂
Yea, I think that's a face of the protesters that I don't think any media before has ever showcased before.
Yeah just like the protest in America the media shows thr bad one like Vox said
They want her to wear protective gear because it's a symbol that you stand with the protestors. She refuses to wear because if she does, she will be part of the protest and any negotiation with police or whoever on the other side becomes impossible. That's why she's complaining that they never let her go to the front. She wants to go to the front to help ease tensions.
1:57 we will be more heartbroken if they end up hitting you
so heartwarming
10:39 Also when she bought the food for a protester.
Look at how they care about each other...heartbreaking..
thư nguyễn ya they care so much about the country, to the extent where they try taking the guns of police.
We must try to understand each other why must the other point fingers.
Why is it heartbreaking that people care about each other
@@calm-men6957 it's not heartbreaking there's a divide communist or not
They care for each other? Some even beat up an unarmed elderly man just because he uttered some words which aren't music to their ears. He was seriously injured.
All the british cononies have leftover problems. Can anyone notice this? India vs Pakistan；Malaysia vs Brunei；China Hongkong vs China mainland etc... No exception.
Hate to say this but the end result is " british won"😢😢
Malaysia VS Indonesia
When did Malaysia vs Brunei actually existed?
I totally agreed with your comment.
@@twiceforever6887 The british will not win in HK (China). The Chinese people will solve this problem since they can refer to over 5000 years history and experience to figure out the answer. On the other hand, the UK is decending, no one can deny this trend.
The young people ask the elders to have gears and concern about her safety is really2 heart warming
Then it comes out the news where they killed an unarmed senior citizen who holds different opinion with them
@@wongziao9432 where is that news
@@mauropereira187 here is it
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Luo_Changqing#:~:text=Luo%20Changqing%2C%20a%2070%2Dyear,Kong%20on%2013%20November%202019.
Ngl if I lived in HK I would be terrified to even step out of the house
Why? My camera is always watching.
that's because you have no spine. if I lived in china id be scared, Chinese abroad are pro Hong Kong unless they are tied to the communist party.
@@jarastafaria3088 Do you support the Communist party? If you say no, then your comment would be censored and banned, but if you say yes, i give you a free cookie
Mao Zedong : with a name like that you must be a ghost!
I live in Hong Kong but I ain't scared
"Without justice prosperity is just an illusion"
It's the trust factor.if HK trusted China,they would've signed it long back
hakuna matata do they have a choice back then no kidding bro that assumption didnt hold
China is a hard to trust country
hakuna matata I would rather trust a venomous king cobra the size of a whale that haven’t eaten in 3 months.
Lol if you know about history you wouldn’t be saying so
A Pei China was doing some fishy things, like writing a long article on why regions or colonies shouldn’t be in the UN and UK should return the colonies back! Hong Kong never wanted and Uk never wanted to return it, but China’s bad morals and visions made them!
Reposted in order to blur code on the guy's laptop at 4:29. He was identifiable through that.
joop123 I have the original.
already located him and sent agent 47 to get the job done
The Only Wae he just speak his mind, and he should be killed by that?
@@filcoco Probably won't
It was the editor's fault for not censoring enough details so obviously the speaker there is not in trouble
"People willing to trade their freedom for security deserve neither and will lose both." -- Benjamin Franklin. Fight to stay free, Hong Kong.
@Kes Mangkuk China is straight up voiding the agreement and trying to incorporate HK 20 years early
@@sd-fz3wn
I think it's step-by-step process. Year after year, the PRC gradually introduces new measures which align with the CCP line until by the time 2047 comes, no one notices the difference in transition.
@S CsasvC S
If the CCP breaks the deal then it is null and void, and Hong Kong has a right to self determination.
I support your country fighting for freedom Van Thai. If you have police in your country you aren’t free. Don’t let your country have police and abolish it in your country
True freedom is anarchy.
That's not protest, that's struggle for freedom.
That’s rioting in the most free region on earth
Yes, old men are beaten to death, opponents have their legs broken, policemen have their throats slit, how free they want to be.
That’s not protest, that’s riot
Thats not struggle for freedom, thats just riots and exerting violence on innocent people
@@0291FS you and the previous clowns are commenters, of course freedom involves rioting because true freedom would bring the death of the people who withhold that freedom, or has history taught you nothing about people who stand against oppression? Dont answer that because by your ignnraot comments you probably have never been outside of a white neighborhood.
Only the people who have tasted the fruit of freedom will understand what they have lost and become fearless to fight for it back. There is a difference between people who fight for freedom and people who fight for lost freedom.
Singapore is not fighting how strict it is and we are still one of the best country??
I think it is going to a bitter fruit. No one can change the fact that Hong Kong is China's Hong Kong. Chinese government will take over when have to. Hope Hong Kong government can solve the problem peacefully, but the economy will be impacted for sure.
Singapore is literally ruled by a dictator with heavy internet censorship yet one of the freest city on the planet. Libya had a dictator, but he was toppled, now the country is one of the least free on the planet. Do your MATH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is not about freedom nor democracy, take a look at the mobs rule at 1.30
th-cam.com/video/nB7wTkSt07U/w-d-xo.html
The protesters are yelling for freedom. But what kind of freedom do they mean freedom of violence, freedom of vandalism, freedom of destroying.
They could atleast telling what kind of freedom. That make it easily to understand
It's incredible to see the amount of care that the protesters have for each other.
Is obviously to be pretended.
They must fight for what freedom they can hold on too freedom isn't free
Especially the younger generation watching out for the seniors. "They'll beat anyone. We just want you to be safe. We'll be more heartbroken if they end up beating you"
They know that the reporter was there...
@@KT-ln8em They have the most lawless freedoms in the world, including beating innocent passengers, elderly man women. What shameful HK freedoms !
My whole family is Catonese, only my mother is Chinese. Because of the protest, I had to skip my lessons just to protect her while she was going to work. What is wrong with them, what is wrong with us?
I feel sorry for your mother. Politics is should not threaten the safety of the innocent. If the protestors want to cause problems with the police or government, it’s not my right to tell them to stop. But leave others out of it
R u dum, Cantonese is Chinese too wdym?
@@user-fi2vc7ei8v she/he probably means their family is from Hong Kong, or at least Guangdong
Yeah hk people are pretty racist it you are outside of hk
@@Willxdiana any person can see that it is China trying to oppress them. I don’t understand why China can’t stop being so sensitive and let them be.
Even admist all the protests I’m glad they still care about the elderly :)
not rlly tho, some of them beat up the elderly because they have a different view and opinion about the protest.
Issanagay 499 have you not seen video of protester beat up elderly
Not really
They set fire to an old guy
Heartbroken when seeing all these.
the mainlanders who oppose the protests don't understand that Hong Kongers enjoy rights and liberties they never even had. Living under an authoritarian regime is their normal. Sad.
KUDOS to Aunti Liu.
I just don’t understand what kind of democracy theses youngsters want. Before 1997, all the land of HK belonged to the Queen, there were no election system until 1991 when British found that they had to give HK back to China in 1997. it is suspicious why the British government only introduced democracy to HK at then. Even when the so called democracy was introduced, HK people still had no right to vote on British matters. They were not even considered as British.
They want universal sufferiage according to the basic law. And to be honest, many of them weren't born when the British ruled, the lack of progress is squarely on the generations before them.
They want what they have after 1997 up until 2015 ...the youngsters weren't "living"/voting before 1997
HK don't want to vote on british or chinese matters. They want to be left alone. Do you mainlanders not have enough land to rule? You are allowed to express pro China opinions in our country. We are not allowed to express pro Hong Kong opinions in your country. That is the difference between us. Why does China want to restrict our basic freedoms? Think about it.
L M Have you seen those people who expressed pro China opinions were beaten in HK?
@@inofstyle Mainland people never felt hk is that much a part of China, at least for advanced educated people. Im from mainland but I have lived half of my life abroad. The freedom you are demanding right now felt like an excuse to me. The main driving force right now is the hatred toward mainland, admit it. Most of the people protesting right now seems dont have a clue on what exactly are they protesting for especially for these few weeks. Your organization is really bad. I support your protesting in any peaceful manner, even if its for independence. But your protest this time felt like a mental breakdown for people cant fit in in this era of change.
Dictatorship sees human lives as necessary sacrifices for its selfish delusions.
HXX LORD CIA is manipulating this young people to participate in riots. u should blame democracy for whts happening.
@@taiwanno.1islandinchina123 lol yeah keep doing for a century.
ARE YOU HUMAN OR ANIMAL//
You mean the herd immunity and the 'loss of our loved ones' quoted from Boris Johnson?
@@winstonwei9694 everything needs sacrifices. But the sacrifices must come from yourself, a cause built upon the sacrifices of innocent civilians has no meaning. As a Vietnamese, i have negative sympathy for the CCP who are trying to steal our islands. But i do have sympathy for the people in HK who lives are being ruined for nothing by these rioters.
Color me shocked that mainlanders don’t understand why Hong Kongers are fighting for their democracy.
"I agree that we need stability, but stability must stand on justice. If there is no justice, then prosperity is an illusion". THIS! In just 2 sentences, this old lady, originally from the mainland, said the truth that most in mainland choose to ignore for short term illusory prosperity, and the key difference in thinking b/w hk people, most of the world, vs. current mainstream mainland china thought. WELL DONE!
DJ SIGGY I love this lady. She knows!!!
She's navive , if she lived in western country for a decade, she will change her mind ~
金泰宇 where did you get that? She said she moved to HK from China. So she knows full well what freedom means. She’s out there helping the youngsters fighting for their freedom. You need to take a seat. Unlearning is hard especially after generations of being brainwashed by CCP
There is not justice and freedom at all. All these fancy sugar-coating words are just the lies that keep people having beliefs for the future. A government can define what freedom and justice mean in any way whenever it is needed. So just wake up from your comfortable dreams. There is no single government that was born to be at your service or build the world you want them to build. All the pathetic truth will be revealed and it is just a matter of time.
@@nicknguyen3019 Wow you are more brainwashed than I expected, first of all ,may I ask what is freedom means to you? you see ,in personal level, the main difference between mainland and HK is that HK has so call "freedom of speech"(even though it's fake),that's all, is that the true freedom to you? that's pathetic,let me tell you what is independent thinking, your so call freedom was define by the goverment, not by yourself,but you believed it anyway,that's what I call brainwashed, to me, criticising goverment and having vote are not freedom, cause I'm the one who has the right to define my own freedom, not you nor the goverment, no one has the right to tell me what is freedom what is not except for myself,get it? and my freedom is having free time for life,and no gov in this world can provide me that, so to me there are no freedom
The aunty is so sweet, I want to be her neighbor :')
Teach u falungong haba
They had peace protests already. The goverment didn't budge. Sooooooo
They are not peaceful at all. The camera only points to Police. They are violence from the beginning because those people are trained by CIA. The HK citizen found this out.
Y Y no like before the violent protests
@@YY-wz7mm nice conspiracy meme buddy
@@YY-wz7mm 50 cent everyone report him
@@YY-wz7mm And you are trained by CCP.
Hk’s new definition of democracy : freedom of violence,freedom of consequences.
How does it feel to use an VPN to hate on hong kong hm?
@@nelliee6736 dude, using VPN is Just like using an app...
@@nelliee6736 It's not hate if it's true.
You are allowed to express pro China opinions in our country. We are not allowed to express pro Hong Kong opinions in your country. That is the difference between us. Why does China want to restrict our basic freedoms? Think about it.
Nellie E lol I m not using a VPN,I m not even living in China .how shallow of you to think that only people living in China can comment on this situation
this is getting so out of hand
ZOMBIES
This affects Hong Kong people too especially future generations this fight is for future generations and from personal experience I am living I fear for my future my safety and Hong Kong and the government is not listening to voices of the citizens and people are risking their lives and this is effecting everyone that is unfortunately in this situation it's so sad that we are either living with fear ,anger and depression
Lol did they repost it? I saw this yesterday and it came right up from my notificstion
Yes they re-uploaded it.
yes
Too many people saw through their lies. SCMP is inches away from supporting either violent separatism or US-backed Libya-style terrorism.
Slightly different. 😉
The only terrorist comments I see are from Chinese bots. Who claim HK is China but hate them. HK doesn’t hate mainland China it wants to keep its autonomy. But Chinese people keep calling them terrorists because they won’t agree with a CCP system. If all the protesters stopped after the bill, what about the next? Does stopping protesting stop CCP policies? No.
I am from Poland and I strongly support the Hong Kong protest. In the 1989 my country's people also protested the one-party system and authoritarianism. I can absolutely understand why did people of Hong Kong wants to have a free and just system and not be part of the one-party system we're only the interest of the party matters and not the interest of the citizen.
I look at this and feel privileged that I in my country can go and do protests the way I want. Speak on any topic - criticize my prime minister and I feel no fear. We all should be thankful if we live in that system. It is almost like breathing air. Govt are not gods.
Too funny, on Sunday there was a person wearing a Hong Kong Phooey
outfit and sign autographs for the kids - he was with the protesters but he took time
to lighten the tension.
Yeah, title changed also.. from
Mainland Chinese citizens living in Hong Kong discuss extradition bill protests
it is merely one party disagree with another, but one of them has army... so the result would be so apparent... pray hard... peace...
Nah, it’s more like the conflict between eastern western morals and values plus the political power struggle between the west and China.
China can't send army to Hong Kong, if they do it China economy go down along when Hong Kong died. All of their China investor are in HK and they now has start to move to invest in Vietnam.
@@sweeleongng333 lol, how important is Hongkong now? It's a wreck
@@Ummmmmmmm841 communism isn't "eastern morals"
Mao killed and burned all Chinese morals with his cultural revolution
@@sweeleongng333 China actually does care about it's public image ,it doesn't want to be seen as aggressive and that's why most of the times Police doesn't attack protestors.
On the other hand Hong Kong doesn't hold any economic value to China anymore so China wldnt think twice before using force to suppress protests
CCP doesn't deserve to control this beautiful city.
China and ccp never hear from the western society country.Oh,just remembered this,MODI DOESN'T DESERVE TO CONTROL KASHMIR BEAUTIFUL COUNTRY.PERIOD.Sorry my friend,western country a lot of worst,evil than china remembered in middle east
@Random Potato india is part of china gee, just wait and see
Regardless of anything, if a person commit a crime, he ought to be arrested on the spot. Drawing griffati, preventing train doors from closing, blocking walkway, blocking road, spraying paint on camera, cutting down lamp post, etc, the culprit/s ought to be arrested on the spot. Why? Because these people are criminals. They have broken the law regardless.
If these criminals are captured and jailed, the protests will be more peaceful. No more violent people in the protestors and the jailing will serve as a deterent.
In some strict countries like Singapore, all these rioters will be jailed for a few years and be caned.
why do you think they cannot do that. They are being accused of "rioting", which already has a jail sentence. But they know that, that's why they're hiding their faces. And besides, you can't imprison 1/4 of the country. At that point, it's not a crime, it's a revolution. So you want these people to be arrested for fighting for what they believe in? You're out of your mind. You probably don't know much history as change has never happened unless an opposing force existed. They're not committing a crime, they're changing the country.
@@Tapiboba They are literally attacking the country on their own premise. Only one quarter of the country and you are talking about majority. What a joke. From one demand to four more demands. More will come if acceded.
Talk? The protesters refuse to talk to the government. Wow.
The police should take a leaf from US. Shoot a few terrorists on the pretext of self defence. Then taser the rest that are violent. Simple and effective. Would have qurlled the protestors turned terrorists in the first two weeks.
Tapiboba not all 1/4 of the populations are rioting. Plus is not a country, it’s a city. And rioting is still rioting. Where are the 3/4 of the populations?
Honestly speaking, many people in Chinese aren't so tought against the HK people as HK people are. Actually, the protests that have taken place in HK over the past one and half year was all due to the vast cultural difference between Chinese nationals and HongKongese. Both are totally lack of understanding towards the government consitutional system and make more inflammatory remarks to the others. I have checked the comments among many social medias and most of them are not atrocious. Education is one of the most essential aspects of what sustains a healthy, high~quality and dynamic soceity. The education in HK needs to be curbed and makes a fundamental improvement. Many students are seditious told to be tough against China by listening many thing negative about China. My suggestion is organzing a tour to China, letting students understand the Chinese cultures and exchange ideas from different Chinese students. Such controversities are avoidable if there are more and more rational talks and multi~sided conversations between Chinese students and HK students.
Before you do your field trip to China, warn the students about what they speak while in China.
This is exactly what needs to be done. I believe the punishment of the rioters should be done through some social services in China with duo purpose. Let them experience the real China and pay their debts to destruction of property in HK.
The princess of Dubai knows all to well that wealth is an illusion without freedom.
Yes
and freedom is an illusion without forces.
And jail just a place
@@ruichengli7337 And freedom is an illusion if I am hungry, poor, uneducated and sick.
@@ruichengli7337 And freedom is an illusion if I am made homeless and denied health care
That auntie was lucky. In another video, another 60 or 70+ yo auntie was taunted at, shouted at by a crowd by masked protestors, had green light shone into her eyes while she was being pulling traffic cones that was blocking the road..... filmed....she was not anti or pro china...just a frustrated elderly woman who is tired of the senseless vandalisms during such protests....
The life that makes up of Hong Kong is the community of its people, not China nor its government. Governments are to be elected to serve society, not the other way.
Love and support from India ❣️ Hong Kong people we are with you!
Nobody asked and nobody care.
@@syedmuhammadmusab9573 folks do see the support.. I know you don't.. that's ok buddy. I wish you well.
Hong Kong is turning into....
your moms basement..
@@thephantomzoneboxing wowwwwwww hahaha love your answer bro
Worldwide Entertainment
A better Singapore, free from China.
...Chaina
The truth of the matter is well over 5 million Hong Kong people are originally descended from Mainland China.
What of it? That's not the issue behind the protest. Hong Kong's freedoms are being eroded. No sane population will willingly give up its freedoms without a fight. Mainlanders dont know what democracy feels nor looks like, that's why I always say, Hong Kongers and mainlanders are not the same! Mainlanders dont have a clue because they dont know freedom.
So?
And HK are the people who trully embraced the vision of Dr Sun Yat Sen.
Who died and made China mainland the only ones who can call themselves "China"?
@@KillerChair1 true that
Protestors are getting frustrated. You do so many peaceful protest and the government does!t listen. You push people to a level of distraction....this is the government y’s fault. And really does show they don’t care about Hong Kong citizens
CPP only cares about power and controling as many people as they can
Just because you protest doesn't mean the government has to accept it. How entitled do you have to be to think that just because you ask for something, that the other side has to acquiesce to your demands?
You need to give the government an actual, logical reason. When the lawyers and businessmen first marched against the bill, they gave actual concerns and constructive criticisms. The HK government accepted it and came out with the 2nd draft, which the lawyers and businessmen stated they were happy with.
But these hooligans? Can they point to a single word, nay, a single *character* that was the problem with the 2nd draft? They couldn't come up with jack. So no, you don't get to throw an irrational tantrum and expect to get what you want.
@@lilchad-ig1oj )
这个视频挺好的，它展示了两方的观点。
I love how everyone is trying to protect her
Who are they afraid of enough to have to blur their faces just for speaking on camera? Yeah, I thought so. Stay strong Hong Kongers in your fight for your freedom.
Lol they are afraid of the violence mobs
@@jacklee-oc3tv They aren't afraid of Hong Kong, they are afraid of what they say can be misconstrued by Mainland China as anti CCP absolute rule.... they know any difference in opinion, for being a mainlander, can land you in an internment camp.
引渡条例
1.犯罪行为必须是违反了大陆的法律，同时该违法行为也违反了香港的法律。（双重犯罪，只违反大陆的法律的犯罪不可引渡）
2.它必须是法案允许的犯罪之一。（犯有37种国际公认、且刑期都在7年或以上的罪犯。还规定了“八不移交”，明确说明被移送的罪犯不涉及与言论相关的行为，即不涉及新闻、言论、学术、出版等方面的行为。）
3.大陆必须在香港法院提供犯罪证据。然后法院将对此案作出裁决。必须要由特区法院和特首双批准，才能实施移交。
大陆不能逮捕任何他们想要的人并送往大陆。
六四屠殺
6月3日早上，一輛軍隊越野車及後來運載軍械的旅遊巴士被民眾發現，裝備被沒收。下午，為奪回旅遊巴士上的槍械，北京武警和戒嚴部隊在六部口新華門和人民大會堂西側首次使用武力對付學生、工人和市民，有近百名市民受傷。
晚上大約10時，當局發布緊急通告，宣布戒嚴部隊將強行清場。軍隊出動坦克和裝甲車，衝向天安門廣場，沿途不斷遭到民眾阻攔。
凌晨三點左右，天安門廣場的學生和戒嚴的軍隊達成協議，從廣場東部撤離了天安門廣場。
從深夜11時起至6月4日凌晨，荷槍實彈的軍隊在各地段與沒有武裝的學生與市民激烈衝突。北京城徹夜槍聲不斷，血流遍地。這就是震驚世界的「六·四」事件。
暴民不会看的，他们只看自己想看的只听自己想听的
瓦努阿圖的國家隊教練 恶魔化中国政府可以上到焚书坑儒，可你却看不到你的祖国正在进步
瓦努阿圖的國家隊教練 现在从来没有哪一个机关也好政府也好证明六四到底是血流成河还是没死多少人，直接说共产党是流氓得了，你应该很庆幸我没当上国家主席，我如果是主席台湾可能十年前就回归了，香港现在死的人比六四还多
@@user-ex1jq2gu2w 你是不是煞笔？稍微年长一辈的都知道六四死人又不是只死了学生，军人被民众打死了多少你怎么不说。两边加起来的死亡数都算不上是个屠杀，何况屠杀是指针对没有抵抗能力的人的大量杀戮，抢了军车武装起来的暴乱分子那叫屠杀？何况清场前喊了那么久让人走，你不走，赶你走，期间死了点人就是屠杀了，你怕不是脑子被西方媒体忽悠瘸了。
Why asking people don’t have no voice.
My mum and dad were born and raised in the mainland and they seem to think that HK protestors are being paid to partake in these ongoing protests. When I have a debate with my mum with regards to HK, she thinks that only younger people are taking part in the protests and that they're being misinformed about the truth, whereas the reality is that HK freedom and autonomy are being eroded by the dictatorship led by Xi Jin Ping. The fact that some mainlanders who have gone to HK have come to understand the reasons behind the protests and support them clearly says something about the CCP and its currently way of ruling...
You are false
Your mum is right. Go read the actual document of the extradition treaty. I also thought that before I actually did research myself avoiding news media as they're always bias
@CheungyNSX
Stay STRONG, SAFE + RESOLUTE.
@CheungyNSX
If not done already, you should ask your mom, why she + your dad moved to HK; I'm serious, NOT AT ALL SARCASTIC.
@@HeyitsJin
Her mom is wrong; lawyers, bankers, government workers, journalists + public hospital's nurses + doctors ALSO ARE PROTESTING.
Because Lam has been stonewalling, the situation has GONE BEYOND THE EXTRADITION BILL.
For Hong Kong to move forward + progress, SHE MUST HAVE MONITORED, FREE UNIVERSAL SUFERAGE.
Fascinating to hear the opinions of mainland Chinese living in Hong Kong. Almost all were sympathetic to the aims of the protest. But only one endorsed violent methods of protest. Thank you, SCMP. Great reporting.
i agree it's fascinating cos there hasn't been that much reporting on the perspective of people in the mainland, and mainlanders in HK
@@linm770 Interviewees were able to keep their anonymity. Results aren't presented as a representative sample.
@Jam Lee Easy to make spurious accusations, too.
You trust this report? Lol.
@Jam Lee yeah that's typical. interview people most like your viewpoint
2047 will be a crazy year it seems...
a kid running on the street and shouting he has no freedom at home.
Man is born free and everywhere he is in chains.
at least he can run.
I hope these protests in HK can give CPC some useful warning to not push people too far.
Obviously it is not CCP who are abusing violence and pushing too far right now.
你需要去医院治疗一下！
Kid, wake up! Time for taking your medicine.
@@zhaohuideng8836 problem is the sar government is seen as the party's proxy in HK society. If the cpg intervene too much, the locals may decry erosion of autonomy. But if the sar made mistake and the cpg did not do anything, it makes the party look bad.
20 years ago moved to HongKong? that auntie liu must be a FALUN GONG. I remember when I went to Hongkong, there were signs of "FALUN GONG is great" everywhere.
How do you know that? Falungong are mainly based in the West, not in HK
Sick ccp propanda.
yay re-upload, im interested to hear what they have to say about this
Don''t bother. They will take down all these videos after the protesters bomb Tiananmen square or fly an airplane into HSBC building for freedom and democracy.
@@tapasgaspocho61 i don't think blockading an airport is usually on the same level as that but to each his own 😂
You have to give them time to work up to it.
What is revolting and craved by the Chinese?
Hong Kong
Beijing: "why? Why HK does not love me?"
HK: Because you're too pushy!
Why would China crave Hong Kong? Hong Kong already belongs to China and it isn't a jewel. Hong Kong has lost much of its importance to China since China opened up in the 1990s. Neighbouring Shezhen is more successful and more important to China than Hong Kong.
@@freenational - Hong Kong has lost much of its importance to China since China opened up in the 1990s. Oh really? if that is the case how come Beijing wants more rather than less oversight and control over Hong Kong than a decade ago?
@@joycekoch5746 , even if Hong Kong has become less important to China, it will not allow separatists to take Hong Kong out of China. That would be suicide as the Americans will surely install missiles there aiming at China.
@@freenational America would not want missiles in Hong Kong and the citizens of Hong Kong don't want American missiles in Hong Kong. The citizens of Hong Kong want both America and China to keep their hands off Hong Kong. The only place America plans to deploy updated missiles is Taiwan but only if things turn sour with China concerning The Sprately Islands, Hong Kong or Taiwan.
I love HK. Let HK be itself. WE love you HK
9:14 you said it, auntie 😭😭💕
auntie looks like she could lob a few gas bombs.
Ooh how touching...
Mainlanders can't even criticize the CCP without threat of reprisals. Of course they have to criticize the Hong Kong citizens. However, smashing things up is not right. Be careful the mainlanders moving to HK do not seem to assimilate as they have the CCP mentality.
I think the introduction was deliberately misleading.
moderfucker i am seeing you in every video says this exact same comment i support hk freedom
Facts Check, GDP per capita comparison (you can check yourself)
In 1996/1997, mainland China is about 1/40 (worse for earlier years) of Hong Kong and UK is a little higher than Hong Kong. In 2018, mainland China is 1/4 (or 1/5 depending on PPP or not) and Hong Kong is about 30% higher than UK. Shenzhen (and some other major cities in mainland China), out of nowhere, has exceeded Hong Kong in total GDP since 2017 and has GDP per capita of 2/3 (some say higher with PPP) of Hong Kong.
Did Hong Kong lose its glory from 1997 and before? Completely the opposite with these numbers. As a matter of fact, mainland China has contributed greatly to current prosperity of Hong Kong against UK. What was lost is the relative "supremacy" for Hong Kong vs mainland China. For this, people in Hong Kong should feel happy instead as we are in the same blood line in broader sense. Anyways, per 张爱玲, Hong Kong's prosperity was borrowed （香港的繁荣是借来的) and rooted in China. Think about this deeply before any reckless actions.
Also, per maslow's hierarchy of needs, the development of a society should come in that order also, as witnessed by development of Asian tigers. You have to give credits to the achievements of Chinese government for this regard. The achievements are high/impressive enough to make the only super power to use any excuses to push down or even destroy China/Chinese companies and it will inevitably spill into Chinese people (no matter where you are) as long as you have different views (here goes the freedom and democracy) together with racism.
Think carefully and globally and historically about what you should do. I would rather race to make Hong Kong a high tech hub or something like Singapore.
Sorry pal,all I can see in UK is evil opresive and backward comunist regime envious on the freedoms of HK acting like murderous brute. So it's got to be true. I mean I've seen it on every UK reputable news channels!?! Sky news , BBC ...etc. Had a glimpse on American ones , and I feel like America should send liberating troops in HK!!!!
@@leeroyleeroy6099 Very smart phishing effort. Express yourself straightforwardly.
@@leeroyleeroy6099 Satire.
Hence the protest. Because everything is better now according to your figures....
And out of gratitude they should surrender themselves to a police state?
My sympathies for those trapped by the senseless violence. Stay safe!
你们要的民主就是不让不同意见的人讲话。
12 kman 那中国呢？你们让不同想法的人讲话吗？
@@deadjosh13 他的意思是，世界可以西式民主独裁，不可以其他任何威胁西式民主独裁利益的其他任何政治体制，这不是谁对谁错的事情，是谁活得更好的问题，甚至谁能活下去的问题。
Curious😕 who is laughing behind that situation
Maniacs
Don't beat up people -- *especially old people!*
Yup!Just bet up 3 last weekend.
What????
What's the difference in the final product? How about two cuts to see, a mainland version and a HK version.
I am really stuck in a dilemma, I always hate mainland people because of their behavior, but when I saw this, I think maybe My thoughts were too harsh and they are not as bad as I think. Or maybe I can even start to like them.
But at the same time, there are lots of mainland people coming to Hong Kong to support China, I do not hate them for supporting China, but I do not like them getting paid to support China.
I think my hatred towards China people became a racism instead of political view.
I like mainland people overall but not those who blindly express their political view for money without truly understand what is going on around them
I am just 16 years old Hong Kong citizen so don’t hate me for conveying my thoughts 💭
Really I think most people are ok with each other. It's more the government that Hong Kong doesn't like.
I take my hat off to Hong kong young people for standing up and take action to their belief
The reason your support them is because that you don’t care if the Hong Kong has been breaking into pieces
Me too until they run of money and destroy all their infrastructure.
@@longlilily if you read between the lines, i said supporting to stand up, NOT VANDALISING.. DONT sum up 2 different things into one conclusion
V N What about “take action” part? We all know what kind of action they’ve taken
They care about each other 🥺 and that’s what we need in this world.
I have a Chinese friend working in Hong Kong. He and his Hong Kong colleagues get along just fine and even have discussions regarding the protests. Contrary to what the media and the people in the comments would like you to believe, Mainlanders and Hong Kongers aren't all at each other's throats.
The blood behind these protests is pretty heart wrenching and kind of discouraging.
Once a British salve, always want to be a British salve.
Regardless which side is the right one, in the end the one will win is the one with power. Justice has no role here.
Sal Player:
If Hong Kong people asked for democracy for all the Chinese people, not for Hong Kong alone, I think it is a better movement. In turn the POWER you referred to might be weakened. Chinese people inside China even might start their own movement to demand democracy from the communists.
@@whkwole6842 Are you serious ?
Chinese people's income tripled in the last decade .
Who would come out and protest for democracy ,which essentially requires a regime change ?
@Solid Water I think the west like India more than China. At least CCP has done the best work among all the countries in the last 30 years.
Everyone has the freedom to speak out. Better protest peacefully in a safe way
wait. this is the south china post. is this not a government news outlet?
Democratic without limitation is just anarchy.. Learn from Indonesia please. We still fighting even the election already finish
Why 'indonesia'?
🇭🇰KEEP IT UP🇭🇰I support peaceful protesters
How to know mainland citizen beside hongkong citizen?
Gotta protest for freedom.
So basically it's like England and America in past.Hong kong is fighting for it's political freedom and survival.coloney has grown tired of it mainland
So basically you broke the Chinese law and used a VPN.
as a Chinese person, I'm just really sad about what happened there, some riots were just protesting peacefully, but some other just went out of the line, they started to think hong kong is a country which is wired. If hong kong actually became a country and everything one their own, imagine the no resource from mainland, no travelers or any kind, the whole economic system will get destroyed.
Thank you, you have shown the true situation, it gives us hope to fight for our right
great video.
All it takes is for Xi Jinping to Extend another 50 years Hongkong self govern policy and promise no more interference.
All Hongkong youths will stop and go back to school in a flash. Ofcourse, locked up violators under18 will be all forgiven and release.
I doubt it they will be unhappy because in 50 years time whats happing now will happen then
@@lilchad-ig1oj no problem. Just extend another 50 years. Let's nature takes its course. Have you heard of THE GREAT CHINESE COMMON WEALTH? It will include all Chinese like Singapore, Indonesia, Taiwan, USA, Canada, ect, Chinese from everywhere. Use your imagination. Cheer up!
why? because these idiots have the guts to break the law and shout the loudest? you know what we think? stop the 1 country 2 system... implement national law immediately
Shame! Hong Kong!
What's an extradition bill tho
If enacted, the bill will allow local authorities to detain and extradite criminal fugitives who are wanted in territories with which Hong Kong does not currently have extradition agreements, including Taiwan and mainland China.[25] People were concerned that the bill would subject Hong Kong residents and visitors to the mainland Chinese jurisdiction, undermining the autonomy of the region and its civil liberties
2:20 that explains this protest is for a genuine cause, not like the anarchist looters.
It's not
Why are Chinese citizens living in Hong Kong other than work purposes? That's probably a better question.
@Heosphoros yes
There are also many Hongkongers living in Mainland China. Many of them are not just there for work either. Apart from a different legal system and different tax system, I'd say HK is not really the best city to live in given how ridiculously expensive housing is and how densely populated it is. People choose to live in places other than their hometowns for different reasons. Political freedom is only one of many and perhaps not even the most important one.
Well we are all Chinese so what's your problem foreigner?
To take over.
They tried it in indonesia in 1950s-1960s. The original indonesian of chinesse decends even readily gives up their human rights and submits to themselves to many registrations rules to differentiate themselves from this "mainland chinesse invander". Their own word not mine.
@@jasontang9192 yes. Mainland china, HK and taiwan are all china. Who died and made mainland china "the only china", anyway?
O.M G....NO SCHOOL TRIP FOR MY KID THAT'S FOR SURE
Can't have school if your school is in a war zone :thonk:
Read the comments I think its best to be clear to all. Mainland Chinese for the most part are willing to put up with the CCP so long as it provides social stability and economic progress, and rightfully so just a generation or two ago the only thing those people knew were poverty, mass famines, and chaos. HK people who have enjoyed the benefits of development much earlier can afford to prioritize other so called rights such as "freedom". HK may be a tough place to live but I don''t think any of those protestors are demonstrating against their lack of food.
The western world instigates conflicts in Iraq, Syria, Libya, Egypt, Afghanistan, Ukraine, Venezuela under the guise of "democracy" and "freedom" thinking that it understands and knows the priorities of the people who reside there. Ask any African, Latin American, Middle Easterner peace and prosperity comes before politics not the other way round. How many years did it take for the US to grant voting rights to all its citizens after its founding?
They are not protesting for new rights, but they are protesting for rights that were guaranteed to them untill 2047.
praying for HK
I am proud of the youngsters protecting the older people 💓
10:38 auntie Liu is so sweet and caring. She bought the protester food, she doesn’t want him to go hungry. She’s a mainlander and she married a Hong Konger. I wish there is peace.
HKers invented the hunger strike relay.
1 1 😂
i see bots
Yeah I am born in the city Amsterdam from the country the Netherlands but don't worry I am an Amsterdamer, I don't think the term hongkonger exist man
Return Hong Kong to Britain or let it be Independent with Commonwealth to Britain.
mrArchduke there's already a deal saying that Hong Kong will be fully returned to china in, I think, 2049. So yeah
@@yifanodili3004 deals can be broken. China has already broken their end of it.
I think Hong Kong police can learn a few tricks from British police, the best one of which is called Kettling. Kettling simply means blocking all the ways that demonstrators have in an area and leading them to a narrow area. This way they are stopped from spreading the disruption. When this stage is achieved, only one tiny passage is opened where the police easily can arrest and film anybody who walks out. I don’t think we in Britain taught you this trick when we were there, but anyway we didn’t let you have democracy and the right to vote during the 100 years we ruled over your shoulders. Kettling was also one of the tricks we kept for ourselves.