Thankyou so much dito sir.Ang hirap maghanap ng source para mapaliwanag yung Cavite Mutiny Fil and Spanish perspective. Report namin to buti nalang nahanap kita.Thankyou po!🫶
Thank you po sa information dahil magagamit ko siya sa posisyong papel na activities namin sa kasaysayan ng Pilipinas. Mas malawak ko po naunawaan ang tungkol sa Cavite Mutiny.
Ang nakakalunngkot lang, sa ngayon, mga kapwa filipino na nasa kapangyarihan ang nag aabuso sa kanilang pamamahala. Gaya rin ng mga mananakop na dayuhan noon.
Baka po my makakatulog ano po kayang similarities ng cavite mutiny and yung sa spanish po Pa help naman po currently making a compare and contrast sa history subject
Ser magandang Gabi PO meron po akung gustong malamat about Philippine history,,,Ano po Ang 10 towns in the province of kabite that were recovered by the sangguniang magdiwang from the Spanish rule....pls po pahelp
As much as we hate to see violence, but I think the mutineers saw that their action is their only way to reach their objective as the Spanish colonial government has been almost deaf in hearing the grievances of the Filipinos for 3 centuries
Goodafternoon Prof. I want to ask lang po, we will have this debate po about Cavite Mutiny and naassign kami sa negative team. Pag sinabi po bang negative e kokontrahin namin ang naging mabuting kinalabasan ng pagaalsa nila? Or magbbase po kami sa accounts ni Pardo and Edmund?
I think it was with Pardo De Tavera's account. Dun pa lang sa part ng Izquierdo report na sinasabi na guato maging hari ng mga Gomburza sounds like a ridiculous claim
Thanks for this prof. Can you do a discussion po sa history ng taxation because isa din yan sa important highlights ng history din po. 😁😁i am looking forward for your discussion about taxation😊
Good morning po I have a question, Were they all eye witnesses to the event? Either they were or not, how do you think it could influenced on the credibility of their written accounts? about the cavite mutiny
thank you so much for this idea sir it really helps for my study hope you will never get tired continuing making videos about history of the philippines. -grace
Lolo sya ng lolo ko (amo ng nanay ko noon). Meron din kaming portrait nya rito. Sayang nga lang eh kinuha ng pamangkin ng lolo ko yung rebulto nya. Sa las piñas sya nakalibing ang pagkatanda ko
Sir, ma-ididiscuss niyo po ba yung Cavite Mutiny by Edmund Plauchut? May pagkakaiba po ba ito sa dalawang perspective na nadiscuss niyo about sa Cavite Mutiny?
@@MilesJenner366 The details po about this is already on the video. The Filipino perspective stems around the removal of the reforms made by Carlos Ma. Dela torre as Gov. General
Good day po, ask ko lang po hindi po ba umangal o nanlaban ang Gomburza nung pinagbintangan silang Mastermind gayo'ng hindi naman talaga sila ang mastermind? Tinanggap nalang ba nila basta ang hinatol sa kanilang kamatayan? Thank you. Report ko po kase to sa Tuesday hehe.
Hello, inilaban po nila ang kanilang pagkainosente sa isang court martial pero mabilis masyado ang desisyon nito na sila ay patawan ng kamatayan. Sa 3 pari, si Burgos lamang ang nagpakita ng desperasyon bago ito patayin ngunit natanggap naman nya ito sa huli.
Good evening, sir! I have a question. I hope you will notice this 🙏 Why was it impossible for Fr. Burgos to have been implicated with the Cavite Mutiny? Thank you po.
Actually idinawit lng nmn si Jose Burgos dahil sa kanyang aktibismo para sa sekularisasyon. Walang malinaw na ebidensya na sya ang nagutos daw kay Zaldua na magrecruit ng mga sundalo para sa pag aalsa. Idinawit lng talaga sya para mabawasan ang kalaban ng mga prayle
Sir is there a record po ba kung anong accounts po yung unang napublished?Yung version po ni Tavera parang sumasagot po kasi sa points nila Inquierdo at Vidal po. In addition po, kung nauna yung Filipino perspective, nakakapanghinala paanong hindi nagdefend yung authors ng kabilang side para sa mga detailed reports ni Tavera including the prohibition of founding school arts po. That just corroborate lang po they are really against of these liberal thinkers and not those mutineers po. Because the mutineers yearned for their taken privileges before. Pero spaniards tried to connect invisible dots like turning their crisis into opportunities as they target their political hindrances Ang hirap po kasi magjudge and conclude between two contradicting versions po kaya kahit yung exact day or time po ng publication may help. Unsure if they are an eyewitnesses of the event. At least po sana yung history na tinitreasure ng kasalukuyan ay hindi fiction :((
Sa palagay ko po ay hindi. Gaya ng sinabi ko sa video, idinamay lang sila ng simbahan dahil natatakot sila sa paglakas ng sekularisasyon sa Pilipinas at pagkawala ng kapangyarihan nila
thank you po prof. 2yrs ago na pero nakatulong pa din sakin ngayong 2024 😊
Salamat po sa panunuod. Sana ay makatulong sa mga darating pa 😊
Thankyou so much dito sir.Ang hirap maghanap ng source para mapaliwanag yung Cavite Mutiny Fil and Spanish perspective. Report namin to buti nalang nahanap kita.Thankyou po!🫶
Welcome! I wish you all the best sa inyong report. Please subscribe!
Maraming salamat Sir! To share the story about the Phil.history
Thank you Sir, I won my debate earlier this morning because of your video.
@@PreciousSocayre Wow congrats! That was good to know ☺
sino po yong nanalo ang spanish version or pilipino version??
@@profnextdoor21 sino po yong nanalo ang spanish version or pilipino version??
@@JhiemwillIgnacio Spanish version po, kami po yung opposition☺
@@PreciousSocayre any tips po? same side po kasi kami
Thank you Sir! Report namin to next week! Ill use your insights po. Salamat
I wish you all the best! Thank you for watching!
Ang galing nyopong magturo Sir grabe naintindihan ko agad kesa don sa nilalaman nung material na binigay samin. Thank you po
@@willhmernavarro6965 thank you very much for the appreciation!
Super thankful for this sir! Sobrang napadali maintindihan. Ipagpatuloy niyo po
Thank you for the appreciation. Enjoy learning and please share and subscribe!
Thank you Sir! Laking tulong nito sakin!🙂
Thank you din! Enjoy learning!
Thank you, sir! ❤️
Thank you po sir! napakagaling po ng explanation.
Thank you so much! Please subscribe and share!
Thank you sir, meron na akong natutunan dito
Salamat. Please watch also part 1 the spanish perspective
Thank you po sir! Ang laking ng help po ng mga contents nyo 🙏
Thank you! Happy learning!
Salamat po ng marami natapos ko na po activity ko
Prof, super thankyou, you really give the facts about cavite mutiny in a clear way...
Thank you very much for the appreciation. Please subscribe and sare to others!
thank you Prof ❤❤❤
Thanks po sir again for filipino history!
Thank once again for watching
Thank you po sa information dahil magagamit ko siya sa posisyong papel na activities namin sa kasaysayan ng Pilipinas. Mas malawak ko po naunawaan ang tungkol sa Cavite Mutiny.
that is good to know. Happy learning!!
THANK YOU PROF!
Welcome! Please share and subscribe!
I really appreciate this sir!
Thanks so much po, Sir. God bless you!
Thank You!!❤
Ty laking tulong para sa report ko
Welcome! Please subscribe and share!
Sir, you've been very helpful! salamat sa mga topics mo...keep it up! :) sana po taxation naman next
Thank you! We will do our best to have more topics. God bless!
sir maraming salamat po sana ipatuloy nyo lg po yan
Thank you so much for making this! super big help siya sa debate namin. :>
Thank you po Sir for this, very helpful po siya for my lecture
Welcome po! Enjoy learning
Hello po Sir, meron po ba kayo nong sa taxation fiscal policy 1946 to present??
Thank you so much for this, Sir! It really helps a lot in my study
Can i ask po, ano po mas prefer niyo na perspective yung filipino or spanish? Mas exaggerated para sa akin yung perspective ng spanish
Ang nakakalunngkot lang, sa ngayon, mga kapwa filipino na nasa kapangyarihan ang nag aabuso sa kanilang pamamahala. Gaya rin ng mga mananakop na dayuhan noon.
Thank you sir
Thank you po sir
Pumasa aq sa exam dahil sainyow
Especially sir joseph is there any happen na nagkaron po ng argument ang mga authors thaaankyou sir!
Thank you so much for this! Sir! ❤️
sino po yong nanalo ang spanish version or pilipino version??
Baka po my makakatulog ano po kayang similarities ng cavite mutiny and yung sa spanish po Pa help naman po currently making a compare and contrast sa history subject
sir can we see your sources po para makapag read further pa po kami
omg that ❤Slipknot❤ poster behind really make me pay more attention
ME TOO
Diva sir apat po na account Yun? Kasama Si dr.trininidad at Yung french na writer.. kalimutan ko Yung name Pero kumpari ko Yun E.
Yes it was from edmund plauchut. It shares the same point of view with Dr. Trinidad
Hello po sir! Can I ask po kng saang repositories po makita ang cavity mutiny book po?
may i ask po the sources of this topic including the spanish perspective. pls suggest a book or article about this that I can read?
Hi! I hope this can help
nhcp.gov.ph/the-two-faces-of-the-1872-cavite-mutiny/
Ser magandang Gabi PO meron po akung gustong malamat about Philippine history,,,Ano po Ang 10 towns in the province of kabite that were recovered by the sangguniang magdiwang from the Spanish rule....pls po pahelp
Sir pwede pong paexplain. were the mutineers justified in their action to stage a mutiny against the policy of the new governor general
As much as we hate to see violence, but I think the mutineers saw that their action is their only way to reach their objective as the Spanish colonial government has been almost deaf in hearing the grievances of the Filipinos for 3 centuries
Thank you so much sir godbless po❤️❤️
Hello sir goodday its is true po ba na ang statement ni dr tavera are the dame also thr statement ni edmund
Goodafternoon Prof. I want to ask lang po, we will have this debate po about Cavite Mutiny and naassign kami sa negative team. Pag sinabi po bang negative e kokontrahin namin ang naging mabuting kinalabasan ng pagaalsa nila? Or magbbase po kami sa accounts ni Pardo and Edmund?
kuya pa update haha
big help for my report
Sir ano po yung commonalities ng Spanish at filipino account po? Nalilito kasi me
Bat po tinawag na cavite mutiny kung sa maynila naman po inattack nina lamadrid yung spanish government?
Dahil po sila Sgt. La Madrid po ay sumugod sa Cavite Arsenal at hindi po sa Maynila 😊
permission to use this video for debate purposes, thank you!
Go ahead po. Thank you for watching!
Which is more reliable between the two versions po?
I think it was with Pardo De Tavera's account. Dun pa lang sa part ng Izquierdo report na sinasabi na guato maging hari ng mga Gomburza sounds like a ridiculous claim
kinakabahan tuloy ako spanish perspective pa naman din po kami huhu pano po namin yun madedefend kung mas reliable pala yung statement ni pardo tavera
Hello sir, thank you for sharing your video, new friend visiting your house sir looking for friendship, stay safe and healthy 🤝👍🛎❤
Thanks for this prof. Can you do a discussion po sa history ng taxation because isa din yan sa important highlights ng history din po. 😁😁i am looking forward for your discussion about taxation😊
sure! we can do that. Thank you and happy learning!
😢@@profnextdoor21
Good morning po
I have a question, Were they all eye witnesses to the event? Either they were or not, how do you think it could influenced on the credibility of
their written accounts? about the cavite mutiny
hello po, ask ko lang po kung anong reason kung bakit sinulat ang cavite mutiny?
To show the truth about what actually happened during the event. Two perspectives were written: Pardo de Tavera vs. Gen. Izquierdo
thank you so much for this idea sir it really helps for my study hope you will never get tired continuing making videos about history of the philippines.
-grace
Thank you so much! Please subscribe and follow my YT and FB pages 😊
Pro ask ko lang ano po pangalan ng leader ng Mutiny?
Hi! He is Sgt. Fernando La Madrid
Lolo sya ng lolo ko (amo ng nanay ko noon). Meron din kaming portrait nya rito. Sayang nga lang eh kinuha ng pamangkin ng lolo ko yung rebulto nya. Sa las piñas sya nakalibing ang pagkatanda ko
Sana po ay mapreserve ninyo dahil very historical po ang naging part nya sa Filipino liberalism noong 19th century.
Sir, ma-ididiscuss niyo po ba yung Cavite Mutiny by Edmund Plauchut? May pagkakaiba po ba ito sa dalawang perspective na nadiscuss niyo about sa Cavite Mutiny?
Edward Plauchut's version is the same as with the version of Pardo de Tavera's
Nice one slipknot
hi sir ano po yung positive side ng Filipino??
Hi! What do we mean with Positive side ng Filipino?
@@profnextdoor21 yung issuport po yung Filipino side
@@MilesJenner366 The details po about this is already on the video. The Filipino perspective stems around the removal of the reforms made by Carlos Ma. Dela torre as Gov. General
Good day po, ask ko lang po hindi po ba umangal o nanlaban ang Gomburza nung pinagbintangan silang Mastermind gayo'ng hindi naman talaga sila ang mastermind? Tinanggap nalang ba nila basta ang hinatol sa kanilang kamatayan? Thank you. Report ko po kase to sa Tuesday hehe.
Hello, inilaban po nila ang kanilang pagkainosente sa isang court martial pero mabilis masyado ang desisyon nito na sila ay patawan ng kamatayan. Sa 3 pari, si Burgos lamang ang nagpakita ng desperasyon bago ito patayin ngunit natanggap naman nya ito sa huli.
Sir yong source nyo po sana, please for references lang po thank you
You can check NHCP's article about this topic or if you have access to Zaide's book, Documentary source of Philippine History.
Hello sir. Ano pwede gawing proof para maging guilty ang GomBurZa
Hi! You can watch the part 1 of this video the Spanish Perspective to get the details you need. Thanks for watching!
wala po nong kay Edmund😭
I decided not to include it since his version was similar with pardo de tavera. They both blamed the colonial govt for the mutiny
Sir may tanong po ako,
which account of cavite mutiny shows "victory"?
which account of cavite mutiny shows "failure?"
Good evening, sir! I have a question. I hope you will notice this 🙏
Why was it impossible for Fr. Burgos to have been implicated with the Cavite Mutiny?
Thank you po.
Actually idinawit lng nmn si Jose Burgos dahil sa kanyang aktibismo para sa sekularisasyon. Walang malinaw na ebidensya na sya ang nagutos daw kay Zaldua na magrecruit ng mga sundalo para sa pag aalsa. Idinawit lng talaga sya para mabawasan ang kalaban ng mga prayle
❤️❤️❤️❤️
Sir is there a record po ba kung anong accounts po yung unang napublished?Yung version po ni Tavera parang sumasagot po kasi sa points nila Inquierdo at Vidal po.
In addition po, kung nauna yung Filipino perspective, nakakapanghinala paanong hindi nagdefend yung authors ng kabilang side para sa mga detailed reports ni Tavera including the prohibition of founding school arts po. That just corroborate lang po they are really against of these liberal thinkers and not those mutineers po. Because the mutineers yearned for their taken privileges before. Pero spaniards tried to connect invisible dots like turning their crisis into opportunities as they target their political hindrances
Ang hirap po kasi magjudge and conclude between two contradicting versions po kaya kahit yung exact day or time po ng publication may help. Unsure if they are an eyewitnesses of the event. At least po sana yung history na tinitreasure ng kasalukuyan ay hindi fiction :((
THANKYOU Po🖤
Sir what are the similarities in terms with other versions po? Sana masagot thank sir!!
Sir guilty po ba yung gomburza?
Sa palagay ko po ay hindi. Gaya ng sinabi ko sa video, idinamay lang sila ng simbahan dahil natatakot sila sa paglakas ng sekularisasyon sa Pilipinas at pagkawala ng kapangyarihan nila
hi sir can i get na ppt po
Hi I dont have a ppt for the topic but I can share a link for a detailed article about it.
More subscribe to comepo
Sir what are the similarities in terms with other versions po? Sana masagot thank sir!!
The biggest similarity for both versions is that a mutiny took place inside the arsenal and there are Spanish officials that were killed.
❤❤