CHOOSING YOUR FIRST TIN WHISTLE
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ย. 2019
- If you're ready to start your tin whistle journey and want to learn with me, or by yourself using the information you can find on TH-cam and online, then here's some simple tips and suggestions for choosing your first tin whistle :) I hope you enjoy!
If you did enjoy this video don't forget to like, subscribe and share.
Some useful links:
clarketinwhistle.com/
www.feadog.ie/
www.waltons.ie/home/products/...
For rewards, including mp3 files of my music, exclusive videos and more check out my Patreon page:
/ cutiepiepiper
You can also buy me a coffee at:
www.ko-fi.com/cutiepiepiper
Follow me on
Facebook: / whistletnt
Instagram: / cutiepie.piper
CutiePie Official Merchandise here:
teespring.com/stores/official...
www.zazzle.co.uk/cutiepie_piper
I don’t understand why tin whistles aren’t more popular... they produce such a beautiful sound and they’re easy to pick up literally and figuratively
We need a tin whistle renaissance methinks
Well, in my mom's case she is definitely not fond of the chirpy chiff that is common in tin whistles. It's also why she does not like the classical flute and piccolo. Granted, it also depends on the skill of the player, but unless it's a low whistle, you really cannot avoid the chirps. She encouraged me to learn the clarinet precisely because she loved its more mellow sound.
In the multicultural folk ensemble that I play in, our recorder player can also play the tin whistle, but he chooses instead to play the soprano/tenor recorder all the time, as he says that the tin whistle does not provide him with all the notes he needs (i.e., the recorder is fully chromatic). In a trad. Irish piece, the soprano recorder sounds almost indistinguishable from the tin whistle to most audience members. Still, the tin whistle has a beautiful sound in its own right, & should be considered by more players (especially considering its very low entry-level price). George, Canada
I don't know if this is gonna help anyone out there choose a flute or not, but the original Clarke was the only whistle my cat allowed me to practice on without leaving the room.
This does indeed help! I have now bought one in green, thank you!
@@Ebenholz :) happy fluting
Does that mean i've got to buy a cat or can i just hire one for the day - or borrow yours !
I have a bamboo tin whistle fixed with tapes and glue. It still impressively sounds good.
bought mine in a charity shop thinking it was a metal recorder. never been happier
Serendipity!
Would love to see an updated video of all the whistles you own :)
Just ordered my first tin whistle. Can't wait to start.
Thank you!!! I wanted to start learning because I love everything Irish and similar, and was unsure which tin whistle to get here in Argentina, but your video really breaks it down easily than rather just comparing the two tunes and then choosing which one I like most. Thank you! Will certainly check the rest of your channel :)
Thank you Stephanie for all of your videos. Really very helpful.
I am a church pipe organist, (5,000 whistles) but the single tin whistle is so pure, simple, sweet, and personally expressive, and it makes our hearts sing.
I use inexpensive Feadog whistles in D, but I am liking some of the ABS plastic whistles, with a subtle gentle rich warm sound, almost like a wooden "recorder". - Matt
Music recomendation: Ballad of the Wind Fish from The Legend of Zelda Link's Awakening 💚
Just ordered the Clarke Sweetone D today. Thank you for all the video's!
Picking my first tin whistle has been a long journey for me. I really was completely lost until viewing your video! I first discovered I wanted to learn the instrument after watching Riverdance in Philadelphia along with listening to lots of Irish folk music. I really appreciate this video and I’ve decided to start with the Clarke Celtic Whistle (In D).
After a few days of research I found your videos and was able to find the right fit for me. Thank you so so much! I look forward to more videos from you and learning the tin whistle! :)
This was awesome! Thank you lots
This is Fantastic! Thank you So Much 💞
Thanks for your videos, they're very informative! I just got my first whistle, a red Clarke Sweetone in D :)
Hace poco conozco este instrumento y sinceramente me enamore, tus videos son muy buenos y sin dudas el mejor canal sobre Tin Whistle
Very nice Stephanie, will help loads of people :)
Many thanks Stephanie.
I have a level 3 in violin from Romania, the tin whistle is the next step, I love the sound it is full of magic, there is something really deep about it.. Also it is easy to learn if u did violin..
Amazing, thanks 🙏🏼🌈
Nice video. Finally picked up and started playing my £5 Walton's D tin whistle that I bought about 15 years ago! Loving it, just struggling with the upper octave!
Just be sure you're playing in the lower octave to start with 😊 otherwise, just keep practicing and you'll get there. I have a beginner's course in my playlists with some good places to start. x
I immediately ordered a tin whistle while watching this video! I will learn from you! Thanks.
I hope you have a great time learning to play 😊 it's a lot of fun! x
@@CutiepieTinWhistle Thank you so much.
I would also add don't overlook some of the great craft whistles. Those that are produced by hand by individuals.
If you're in the states one I really like is from Becker Whistles. IMO the low price does does not match the high quality for the type of whistle it is.
I say "if you're in the States", maybe Canada, because otherwise any postage or import duties might negate the lower price. But you could always check.
Another good one is a CHRIS WALL, which Stephanie reviews. (only disregard the observation that one of the whistles is kind of sticky to the touch, that was a fluke having to do with some bad paint and was corrected long ago) Although it's slightly more pricey, I would say worth it. The only downside is that because of the quality and workmanship that goes into them he's a bit backlogged, so you could have a 90 day wait. But if you have other whistles to practice with until his arrives I think it's worth it.
SUSATO whistles are also very good, although not craft whistles and I have had only a very limited experience with them, I I hear many good things about their line.
You may notice that the whistles I mentioned are "plastic" whistles.
For me MY better playing experience has been on a variety of those types, anything from PVC conversations to those that are purposely made from the ground up as a whistle. Although I'm not the uber player Stephanie is.
One inexpensive craft whistle that I really like that is metal comes from Timothy J Potter. So that's something to at least look at.
Besides her very great channel a variety of different whistles are showcased on "FlutesOfTheWorld&Kantele" (I'll put the link below to that one because it's kind of hard to find amongst all the other flute review sites of its type and she does flutes and recorders and whistles so you have to scroll down a little bit)
and "David Cartmell".
th-cam.com/video/2JQ4sCs0Auw/w-d-xo.html
Anyway, Stephanie and those two other sites are the ones I pretty much reied on last year for whistle information when I was just starting out...again 😄
Mine is a Feadóg brass traditional Irish tin whistle in the key of D. It also plays in the key of G. 😉 ♫
I need a cheap whistle... like a moose needs a hat rack! Burn the candle at both ends buying high and low. Well done Steph!
She is beautiful
I agree that if your not sure if you are serious about learning the tin whistle or if you are just curious and don't want to put in the money for a better one those cheap whistles are pretty decent,. However if you are serious about learning the whistle I would invest in something a bit more expensive than the $10 especially for your first whistle because if you are squeaking you want to make sure that its you and not the whistle as an expert this wouldn't be a problem because you could easily tell the difference but as a beginner it could be quite hard to tell what the problem is. If your serious about learning the tin whistle start with something in the $25 range at least.
Love all your videos! I've just started learning the tin whistle and your tips are a great help.
I purchased 2 "D" whistles -- one is a Woodi; and the other is a Clarke Sweetone.
I love the feel and handling of the Woodie and I notice that it plays really well, with nice sounding tones, in the lowest octave; but it doesn't play at all well above the high "A"; and I can't make the Woodi produce anything above the high "A". Additionally, you have to uncover the top hole to produce the high "D"; and half-cover the top hole to produce the high "E - A" notes, which makes it hard to play as a beginner.
The Clarke Sweetone, plays really well in the high octave, but not as well in the low octave; the tones in the low octave are a bit fractured the volume is low. Overall, the Clarke is easier to play in both the low and high octaves, but I'm not really enthused about the seam down the back of the Clarke.
Can you recommend a beginner whistle that plays like the Clarke Sweetone (i.e. easy to play in both octaves), but doesn't have the seam down the back?
I'd also be interested to hear if you have any suggestions for how to get the Woodi to play the higher notes well.
The problem with the low notes on the Clarke is likely because you're blowing a little too hard. Try blowing REALLY softly. The notes will be quiet, but shouldn't break 😊 All whistles are quieter on the lower notes than the higher notes, due to the way they're made and the nature of how you hit the high notes - more air = more volume.
You'd could try a generation. Some people love them, they're just not for me. Otherwise, if you'd like a step up, go for a Killarney in a few months time. Stick with what you have while you learn the basics 😊
I started with the standard Feadog D, I must say- I like the whistle but it’s a bit pitchy in the upper register, and also loud. That being said I recommend spending the extra +7 usd to get a Clarke Original- it’s much softer, takes more air- but very beautiful. Idk if the sweet tones the same way as the original, but it’ll bet it’s probably good.
I've found key A whistles are best for having roommates, since it's lower pitch is nicer on the ears especially for beginners. The finger spacing is bigger but you get used to it. (I've been playing since I was a kid, entirely self-taught, my poor family... yes, they like the A whistle best!) For learning D songs, you just slide the fingering up or down three fingers and you're there. (No fingers D =three fingers A, only difference is that you'll need to half cover the top hole whenever you'd normally have no fingers).
Janes Addiction...Nirvana....Elton John....Charlotte Church....Carmen....Electra
Didn’t even think to see what kind of whistle to get. Just found this video because I picked one up on impulse and got a Feadóg in D luckily
Thanks for the videos, I wonder what changed your mind about the Clarke Sweetone. I just ordered one based on this video where you say its your favorite, then i watched the review of the 3 clarke whistles from 2018 and you said you dont like playing it all ...
I play the flute. , And I really love the flute. A friend who plays the whistles said I should give it a go playing the whistle . I love it I really do . I would love to play the low d . But my hands are so small . I can't reach the keys . And I really have tried. IE also the Irish flute . So the whistle is my fun time and we'll I wish I had started years ago. Keep whistling
I love you cutie pie.
acorn is Painted Brass, and the D whistle comes in Yellow, Green, Blue, Red, and Black.
i got the red one from amazon. made in England not china which surprised me.. i was so excited when it was delivered. the end was smashed. got a refund. took a small crochet hook and opened it. went up size after size of crochet hook opening it then gently with a pliers with felt for cushion to round it out some more. still a little odd but it works. my cats are not fans. they run for cover when i pick it up.
Tenia una razon para suscribirme... saber sobre estas flautas, pero ahora es otro motivo tambien😍🌹
I just purchased a Walton's Guinness black whistle and it sounds quite good in comparison to the others mentioned in this video. It has the cream coloured whistle head (like a pint) and it plays in tune. I don't even drink beer but it's a very nice whistle :)
Yes, I had one of them Black Guinness Whistles too, it played great. I think I got it free with something. It played so nice I gave it to a young lad, that seemed keen, after hearing me play, to get him started.
@@FiddlingwithmyWhistle That's one of the greatest gifts you can give a person ;)
Check out David Cartmell's channel for additional perspectives on various whistles.
@@michaelrs8010 His reviews are very honest and informative, I second that.
Please do a tutorial for "Speak for the dead" ceremony song from The Dark Crystal: age of resistance
Why am I watching this right after buying a whistle? 😂 I went for a Generation Bb since I like it better than the D. Hope it sounds good 🙏
At us too two fleytyclarke Sweet tone-at the daughter,different flowers.Good very much.
Hi there , i have found your channel recently , and i find it educative , recreational , and i like your reviews as well , i’m trumpet player ( play mainly in church) and i would like to try play whistle too , what would you recommend i should start with for this type of music i’m into.. many thanks
acorn is a good affordable Brand, and has been around since at least 1981.
My first Whistle was a Clarke D
Cheap D whistle. I did something right! Hooray for me! I love your channel. You are my first step in my journey to the bagpipes.
I love the Bagpipes... but you will pick up some really bad habbits starting on the Whistle :0
@@FiddlingwithmyWhistle It's cool. Bad habits are kinda my thing. I have quite the collection. I have bad habits in piano, guitar, ukulele, drums & life. Yet I persist. Have a great day/week/month/year/existence.
I went the other way. From GHB to the whistle.
@@soslothful Me too. Kept trying to use my thumb for the longest time on the the whistle when going for the high notes 😄
@@michaelrs8010 Curious you mention this. I recently bought a D whistle from Gary Humphrey with a C natural thumb hole in the back. It has taken some getting used to.
Aware of the fact about D whistles being the most common, I got one in F because I love it and idgaf. My first pennywhistle was 75c from party city, and if I could make that crap sound sorta like a real instrument, I deserve to chose the key I want lol.
And the Most Common Key is D like My Yellow acorn pennywhistle.
I have used your advice to buy my first tin whistle, a Clarke sweetone in the key of D (in green because...I dunno...celtic vibes? Haha) Thank you!
Thank you so much for your support! It really means a lot
I just purchased a Clarke in D and a Clarke Sweetone in D; under 20 € for both. :-)
Would you review the Lequin ABS tin whistle? I saw one video from Ray Lequin, it's a polka, I didn't get much out of it, and since it is ABS, I'd love your opinion as a first tin whistle and your opinion of ABS material.
Would you like to know how I came out playing the whistle ? I found a Walton Little Black Whistlre in a garbage can. I still have it.
Hi, it's a very cool and informative video! Thank you for that "Tin Whistle coosing video"! Is it possible for you to make a video for the Tin-Whistle-choosing for runaway tin whistle playere? Where are you from and do you make live concerts, where you play the Whistle? Greetings from Germany.
Hi, I'm glad you enjoyed the video. I'm from Wales, but no, I don't play live concerts 😆 I don't know anyone who would come!
@@CutiepieTinWhistle 🤣okay but just do it! If no one comes you can say, you are just practicing..... but if you do a live concert, I would really try to join! I hope, my English is understandable 😉anyway...... It's just awesome to see, how you play whistle. I play the Whistles too an my second wind instrument is an German/Belgian back pipe. Please continue making interesting, informative and funny videos!
Does it matter if it's High D or Low D?
and played the streets in Chicago
You should play senorita
The video mentions other reviews but I don't see any links to them in the video or the description. Where they removed?
Maybe you could set up Amazon links with their affiliate program or something. The links are overseas.
Me who has asthma: hehe tin whistle go woooooo
When I first heard the tin whistle was the the Arabian penny whistle from Eric online. I couldn't afford a 165 dollar carbon fiber whistle. I want to learn and Master the Irish whistle and than move on to the Arabian whistle.
i chose a waltons whistle
Pretty lady 😊
Hello, amazing video as usual. Your receive lots of comments so I don't think you are gonna read this hahaha. But just in case I have a question maybe you can help me with. I bought my first whistle 2 weeks ago. A clarke celtic in D, I never played before and I found it was very easy for me to get a good sound in this whistle en the 1rst octave, but when I go to the second it sounds really awfull. I cannot find reviews on this particularly whistle, so I just wanna know If the problem is my technique (i hope is this cause I just have to improve) or is a problem of the whistle. I never have seen you play de celtic. Hope you can give me some orientation.
Sorry, not CutiePie, but I do have experience with the Clarke Celtic. I bought one last March when the whole covid thing started because I wanted to learn tin whistle. I now have 7 whistles in my collection, but the Celtic is still my favorite. The upper register should come for you in time. I think Clarke's quality control in general is excellent, and experience in breath control/velocity really makes a huge difference.
c'est super mais je dois acheter une tin aisle en RE
Can you make a video about, your second whistle?
Sure 😊
High G is the highest?
FYI, at 2:48 you are pointing up to the top right corner of the screen, obviously expecting one of those TH-cam boxes that viewers can click, but it is not there. I'm not a TH-camr myself so I have no idea how to fix that, but I just thought you should know.
Thank God I got a D key lol
I'm a advanced player and I still use only Generation and Clarke sweetone Whistles. From my point of view the difference is the following: Clarke sweetone Whistles will work fine. They are "good". But never very good. Generation Flageolets, especially newer ones will in most cases not be good enough to play concerts or record them, most of them are unplayable. BUT one in 10 or 20 of them is excellent.
Also many of the Bb Generations are fine to excellent, and all Sweetone C Whistles are crap.
Last, these are all soft instruments which are very good for recording or close miking on larger stages. If you play sessions or extremely small clubs with a loud drummer they are out of place.
Andrea😍😍😍😍😍
You may have alluded to and partly answered, but do ALL Clark whistles have the "line" down the back? (metal fold)
They do yes 😊
Theeeeen going to SantaMonica(tryingto get on Jimmy kimmel....so is he lets me play on his show..I'll give you all a shout out. I been to Devon....Sticklepath.....and...Woolacombe...andInstow...Cardiff
then going to Vegas to see the Stanley Cup
Thanks. How much does an expensive whistle cost? What's the range? Just curious to where this might lead. I bought my Clarke Sweetone in D. Arrives tomorrow.
Most whistles that could be considered 'high-end' whistles are £100+ :)
@@CutiepieTinWhistle Thanks for the response! That was quick Lol. Thanks for your hard work and useful vids. 😊👍🏼
You mentioned not playing the Walton's whislte, but have you heard anything about it's quality? I bought one and was disappointed it didn't have the sweet and light melody I am accustomed to when listening to Irish music. In fact, someone pointed out it sounded more like a recorder (which I don't want at all!) Any advice for this first timer?
I've never played a Walton's whistle, bit most reviews are complimentary. I mean, the cheaper whistles are never going to be wonderful, but at the same time, a lot of it is to do with player experience, technique, breath control and of course, your personal preference to the sound you're looking for 😊 I have a troubleshooting video that is helpful for squeaky whistles, and I cover breath control in some of my tips videos too (the 'Vibrato' video I think) and perhaps the 'ornaments' video. These might help.
Thanks for your reply! I saw the troubleshoot vid several times already, I'll give the other a check. One more question: what daily practices would be helpful? There's no tin whistle instructors by me and I can't trust my own ear to hear how I'm progressing. Any tips for that? Thanks for all your help!
@@benbray4792 Search Tin Whistle Tutorials on YT. Whistletutor, Ryan Duns. There are several printed tutorials: Grey Larsen, Stephen Ducke, L.E. McCullough, Clare McKenna, Mary Bergin, Robin Williamson.
I've noticed in videos people playing with the mouthpiece off to the side..you seem to play mostly straight on..is it a preference or easier one way or other? Thanks
It really doesn't matter where you play, but it's actually easier to put less air through the whistle if you play off centre, as the whistle is slightly out of the 'direct' airflow.
If you play other instruments, like saxophone, bagpipes, trumpet etc that need a LOT of air, sometimes switching to tin whistle (which needs far less air) can be quite challenging. The off-centre playing helps with that. 😊
Please make a seven drunken nights tutorial
William Ossot YES! I was thinking about this song a day or two ago. I’d love that.
Umm, I have a problem. I accidentally ordered a Clarke sweetone in the key of c for my first whistle. Is that going to be a problem? I think it is too late to change my order... #worried
If you can afford it, I'd go ahead and get a D whistle as well. It will make learning so much easier! 💚 And once you get into it, you'll still be able to use your C whistle anyway. You could try another affordable D whistle, like a Walton's, Generation, or Feadog, which will help you determine your preferences further down the line too! ❤️
What's mean 'Warming Up' a Metal Whistle?.. is like Holding in Your Hands?
You need to have the instrument near your body temperature, otherwise you will get condensation from your breath.
Good morning madam let me hope your fine this morning well I wanted to inquire some information from the best book for classical musical notes for beginners because I want to be a classical player thanx a lot
I'm sorry, I'm not really the best person to ask, as I don't read musical score, use books, or really play classical music 🤣 BUT, if you look for sheet music for 'flute', 'clarinet' or even 'oboe' you should be able to play that on tin whistle.
@@CutiepieTinWhistle thnx a lot madam your videos are more strong and have help many like me who was in the darkness
❤👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
I play....Bond....and....These Boots are Made For Walking
Hi Stephanie, I'm from India. I have gathered a huge inspiration from you in playing a Tin Whistle. But it is not widely available in our country. I've chekced Amazon, and the cheapest one worths Rs 3100 which is equivalent to 42-43 US Dollars, and is clearly out of my budget.
I really want to play a Tin Whistle but can't afford it. I'm helpless.
Hi, amazon India pricing is different and way expensive for such items, which would otherwise are priced under $10. I suggest, you take help of your friends/family in the US and have it ordered and bring it during their visit. I know, that it is a very long and laborious way, but an economical one.:) Good luck!
Could you recommend a quiet one please? I don't want to annoy my wife or neighbours.
The quietest would be a Chris Wall Sweetbrass or a Clarke Original. Or for total silence you could go for the WARBL 😊 I have reviews for all three on my channel.
I want to get one to play ukrainian folk songs because I can’t get a sopilka where I live 🥲
I just bought my first and i got a C :(
I'm watching this video after buying a whistle in C key.... duh!
Is the clarke sweetone in plastic?
no, the mouth piece is plastic though.
Anyone know a whistle that's on the quieter side? ....I live in an apartment complex and don't want to be too annoying to the neighbours.
Clarke original is pretty quiet, as is Chris Wall sweetbrass (hard to get though)
There are some tips here that can help you choose a quieter whistle:
th-cam.com/video/BTFuV1RYgMw/w-d-xo.html
Also, plenty of ways to make any whistle quieter for practise:
th-cam.com/users/shorts1fBQ_dWJEyY?feature=share
You can also look into quieter whistles, like Parks Whistles, though I wouldn't really recommend them, or Shush whistles, but I haven't tried them yet 🤣
@@CutiepieTinWhistle Thanks for the reply. You're quick! I appreciate it. Hope you have good holidays :)
I got bored and bought a Feadóg Brass D whistle, and was under the impression that "cheap = trash" so I didn't expect much, but yeah, it does a decent job on that first register.
Looking into a new whistle to clear up that second register and annoy less people while I play Concerning Hobbits.
As for the key of D recommendation, what if you're a low brass player used to playing in B-flat?
I'm not much of a woodwind player, with the closest thing being that I dabbled in Bass C ocarina recently (which I do still like, btw), but have been looking for a simple bass/tenor range instrument that somewhat correlate with my tuba and trombone. The bass recorder has been popping up lately with it being featured in the Mandalorian soundtrack, but then I was turned onto the low whistle and the fact it comes in many different keys.
Anyway, I still wonder what octave are the B-flat whistles in? I hear low D whistles are D4 (an whole step higher than a tenor recorder), so I imagine the higher B-flat [alto] whistles are Bb4 and therefore a low B-flat [bass] whistle would be Bb3? Or is there the one middle B-flat whistle with different names with possibly an higher soprano version above high D? It just seems weird that ocarinas and recorders specify a fundamental pitch while whistles seem to go by high or low despite different makers offering different ranges of pitches via varying terminology. Oh well, heard good things about the Susato Oriole and was thinking of giving that B-flat a try.
You'll find pretty much every key of whistle, low and high, and details on the available notes on that whistle of you contact the maker 😊. D whistles are recommended if you're following online tutorials or want to play Irish trad music. If you don't, then go for a Bb. I have a Susato Oriole Bb. Nice little whistle 😊 everyone raves over the generation Bb too. Both are reasonably priced, but have very different sounds. All depends on your personal preference.
Not THAT sturdy... I broke my first tin whistle when I accidentally sat on it. I was heart broken. It had a really great sound.
so....I play Denver...in front of Coors Field. I did spotlight for Ian Dury...and opened for the Undertones....had bit of my video on VansWarped website. Staying in Denver for Taylor Swift
Just wanted an excuse to flex on the thumb nail.
LOL... no Bingo Wings there :)
I bought the shitest whistle. (I think so). 0XX000 + - this chord sounds like broken and its made me mad. (sorry my english)
me about a year ago: "go home british soliders", what has the yt algorhythm brought me today?
me now: *watches tin whistle tutorials*
i got a walton irish tin whistle d is this good?