Fun fact: Morrissey once filled out a questionnaire prior to an interview: "Where and when were you happiest?" He answered: May 21, 1959. .......... That's the day before he was born.
I've never found this song depressing. It reminds me of that time in life when you feel like nobody understands you. You just want to leave and drive until you find a place where you can start over and be someone else.
In my modest opinion, Andy is among the best bass players of all time and I explain why: he proved the bass can be leading melodic line in a terrific great song creating his mark on it, till a point the song doesn’t sound the same without it. Also, he used different tunings on his bass and played a lot of lines with slaps and palm hand mutings all the time with both the pick and also the fingers. Morrissey and Johnny were really lucky to have him on the band.
I totally agree. And I would add that he was lucky to have Marr and his genius guitar playing, giving him room for that bass, the 2 working and playing of each other. Think of This Night Has Openned My Eyes. Astonishing dance of guitar and bass. And awesome song.
He is in a tunnel with his partner, and he is thinking to grab the steering wheel to crash head-on with an oncoming vehicle, but at the last moment, he looses his nerve. The 'light' is at the end of the tunnel, and represents hope and resolve in the midst of depression. Love your videos!!!
His voice is so unique I love it. Great tune *can't wait for your reaction to I Know It's Over, you'll get your bass and depression outta that one It's such a great song
I've just been watching a few of your Smiths reaction videos and am re-living the wonderment of the first time I heard them back in the early 80s, through you. Especially touched by the way certain lyrics (as well as the bass line) resonate for you and you don't have to go into why that is so. Best wishes from a new Music, Cats and Coffee fan here in England.
Most People don't get that Morrissey has penned some subtle morbid lyrics, that can be amusing and funny at the same time. If you laugh, or just smile at some of those lyrics, then you are among the few that get it. I feel Morrissey became even more skilled at using the best word choices to convey a message after the Smiths ended, and he went on to his next Band bearing his name. His sound changed post Smiths, but it's still lovely with relatable lyrics. .... Someone asked in a Smiths Fanzine 4-5 years after the Smiths breakup, if anyone could suggest a band with a Smiths sound/style, with some relationship difficulty/failure lyrics, and the suggestion was: The Sundays Album: "Reading, Writing, And Arithmetic." They sound like the Smiths but with a Female vocalist.
As a withdrawn teen who had autism but didn't know it at tne time i spent a fair amount of time listning to the smiths when tney were at their peak and the lyrics actually spoke to me
Yep… ‘Asleep’ about tops the depressing chart , as far as The Smith’s goes! There’s a lot of humour with morrisey aswell - try ‘pretty girls make graves’ or ‘girlfriend in a coma’ …. And yes, you’ve guessed it , quite dark humour!
I'm probably twice Lauren's age, but these Smiths songs have awakened the angsty 80's teen in me. It's a cool, amazing and depressing trip down Memory Lane! 😎
I love what u said about the bass being more prominent the instruments come through beautifully in the smiths music especially Johnny mars he’s a legend
Yes, most underrated band of the 1980s, maybe the most underrated band of all time. It’s hilarious how she focuses on the bass, when the Smiths have Johnny Marr, the best rhythm guitar songwriter in the history of music! Haha .. I laff
Just found your channel and I'm really enjoying it so far, so thanks for that. What people forget is that How soon is now was originally a b side! That's pretty mad in reality for a tune that is a 10/10 for me. Here's some other suggestions for you: As others have said, "I know it's over" is a masterpiece. Suedehead is a gem Everyday is like Sunday again is just great I have forgiven Jesus - Morriseys VERY dry sense of humour comes out here. Just a few for you to delve into 👍
There's a quote from Stone Roses frontman Ian Brown about why they didn't crack America where he says: "America doesn't deserve us yet." Maybe this was true of The Smiths too? I'm a British-post-Smiths-break-up stereotype; came across them in your teens and having that moment of clarity of having a band that speaks to me. To this day, they're still this 38-year-olds favourite band. You're gonna get hit with so many recommendations; especially when it comes to the better-known singles, etc. and rightfully so! They are the most popular/liked for a reason. But if you want a couple of "different" or 'uncommon" recommendations, generally speaking, 'Cemetry Gates' is a vastly underappreciated song. You might also appreciate 'Ask' or if you like the bass, then maybe 'Barbarism Doesn't Begin at Home' But you're going to get so many recommendations and you're sucked in now; so it's just a case of when rather than if you get to them all.
You should definitely do "Well, I wonder", one of the most beautiful songs ever written and with a very prominent and wonderful bass, by the way, like all Smiths songs, that is.
I was lucky enough to see the Smiths live in the 80s, lots of great suggestions here in the comments, for more great bass Melodie’s try Joy Division, Love Will Tear Us Apart, Dead Souls, Transmission or Ceremony
Unrequired love? Girl Afraid, Back to the Old House, Well I Wonder. Deep pool of those with the Smiths. Elsewhere most of Tame Impala's Lonerism album is about unrequited love (Mind Mischief, Music to Walk Home By...) if you've not heard those.
I think that the depressing lyrics and bright music combo is part of the intended effect, but I also personally like the more consistently dark songs. But this was an obvious poll winner since its so well loved. I still think you're gonna like 'I know its over' better, it has more of that relatable longing for death thing Morrisey is so good at. Also if youre into this kind of vibe but want slightly heavier music, i'd check out The Cure, especially the early stuff. Surprisingly heavy for the time, and the Bass is very much at the top of the mix
Hi, just caught your videos tonight. Really enjoyed watching all of The Smiths analogies. I was an original fan in the UK, they got their TV break on a show called Riverside, which I saw. Their debut album was ground breaking at the time as all we had on Top of the pops was New Romantic bands with videos on bloody yaughts and palm trees which meant bugger all to me in a northern English town. Thank god for The Smiths. Please check out Girlfriend in a coma. That is if you haven't already. Anyway thanks for reminding me of a great era and a band that actually spoke to me and no bloody palm trees 😂
I love seeing people discover The Smiths. I have been a huge fan since the 80's. These songs have been old friends for decades. You really need to listen to Unhappy Birthday. And if you want really depressing listen to Asleep. And if you want amazing bass listen to Rush Home Ruffians. And for a laugh listen to Vicar In A Tutu. (Where I got my name from) Great reaction vid. New subscriber here :)
In my point of view, this song is about a ghost. They died side by side crashed by some large and heavy vehicle. He couldn't even understood if it was a double decker bus or a ten tonne truck! He wants to see people "young and alive". He's "welcome no more" because he's dead, he's a ghost. The light that never goes out, is the love between the two souls. I could be wrong, but that's my interpretation.
That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore is the archetypal Smiths song and you would probably love that . Shimmering guitar , killer bass line , sombre yet playful lyrics . Songs like The Queen Is Dead are very different ... I have no idea what you would make of that ! So many great songs to choose from.
Loving lyrics like you do, try Half-man Half Biscuits' God Gave us Life, or National Shite Day. Loads of good British acerbic wit, and just as entertaining. Some of the name drops are obscure, but you'll love Restless Legs and Eno Collaboration. Go for it.
A great song from a very clever band. There is a lot of dry humour in the lyrics. If you like bass driven tunes check out some more bands also from Manchester: Joy Division/New Order and The Fall. JD is angst ridden, totally brilliant both musically and lyrically, but not always an easy listen given their singer (Ian Curtis) killed himself aged 23. Morrissey tells a story of how he and Ian used to get the bus home together after punk gigs. JD later became New Order. The Fall are well unique. Enjoy.
Maybe Melancholy is the word you are looking for? The Smiths music will be enjoyed by many for a very long time. It was original, unique and distinctive. They coined a sound, a whole genre really.
If you're looking for in-your-face bass while still being chill as fuck... Morphine. They were a trio, a drummer, a sax player, and a bassist who only had 2 strings on his bass. Try Morphine - Empty Box.
Fun fact: Morrissey once filled out a questionnaire prior to an interview: "Where and when were you happiest?" He answered: May 21, 1959. .......... That's the day before he was born.
RIP Andy Rourke. Glad you appreciated him
*She's got impeccable taste*
If you think this is depressing then you have a treat in instore when you do “I know it’s over”
That's an all time favorite of mine
Or "Last night I dreamt that somebody loved me"
This is my next one. Bring it on. 😎
@@WesWsly yes, rather bombastic for them and an intriguing intro, too.
@@WesWsly what about "asleep". That is probably the peak depression on this band lol
I've never found this song depressing. It reminds me of that time in life when you feel like nobody understands you. You just want to leave and drive until you find a place where you can start over and be someone else.
In my modest opinion, Andy is among the best bass players of all time and I explain why: he proved the bass can be leading melodic line in a terrific great song creating his mark on it, till a point the song doesn’t sound the same without it. Also, he used different tunings on his bass and played a lot of lines with slaps and palm hand mutings all the time with both the pick and also the fingers. Morrissey and Johnny were really lucky to have him on the band.
I totally agree. And I would add that he was lucky to have Marr and his genius guitar playing, giving him room for that bass, the 2 working and playing of each other. Think of This Night Has Openned My Eyes. Astonishing dance of guitar and bass. And awesome song.
I love that you appreciate the brilliance of Andy Rourke. The entire Smiths catalog is worth a listen.
i do not believe they did a bad song.
the smiths were the soundtrack to my teenage years. this band was for the outcast, the introvert, the weirdo, the loner
He is in a tunnel with his partner, and he is thinking to grab the steering wheel to crash head-on with an oncoming vehicle, but at the last moment, he looses his nerve. The 'light' is at the end of the tunnel, and represents hope and resolve in the midst of depression. Love your videos!!!
Almost did this at Griffith Park 1995. My partner saved us. Thank you Iris.
When he sings "There is a light that never goes out" at the end I always thought of it as our Souls and people we all know that passed
Am I going to say “Heaven Knows I’m Miserable Now” again? Yes... is not a “love” song, but is so relatable haha, also the bass in that track is 👌
His voice is so unique I love it. Great tune
*can't wait for your reaction to I Know It's Over, you'll get your bass and depression outta that one It's such a great song
I've just been watching a few of your Smiths reaction videos and am re-living the wonderment of the first time I heard them back in the early 80s, through you. Especially touched by the way certain lyrics (as well as the bass line) resonate for you and you don't have to go into why that is so. Best wishes from a new Music, Cats and Coffee fan here in England.
This is my favorite Smith's song. The melody is amazing. It feels so happy and so tragic at the same time.
And I can not stress how much I enjoy hearing you go on about Andy and his bass work on these Smith's songs. I love it.
😎
Depressing sounding, but paradoxically, somehow uplifting.
"Everyday is like Sunday" is comically depressing.
Or the most depressing side: I was the bus driver.
Or the truck driver
I think it's a romantic song. 😄
Yes!!!!
I didn't know this one! It looks like I'll be a n00b on the rest of this journey with you. Great video and great song!
The line: "Because it's my home it's there home and I am welcome no more" is pretty powerful. I always think of all the kids kicked out of their house
Great reaction. Loved this. Your reactions are the perfect fit for this group.
Most People don't get that Morrissey has penned some subtle morbid lyrics, that can be amusing and funny at the same time. If you laugh, or just smile at some of those lyrics, then you are among the few that get it. I feel Morrissey became even more skilled at using the best word choices to convey a message after the Smiths ended, and he went on to his next Band bearing his name. His sound changed post Smiths, but it's still lovely with relatable lyrics. .... Someone asked in a Smiths Fanzine 4-5 years after the Smiths breakup, if anyone could suggest a band with a Smiths sound/style, with some relationship difficulty/failure lyrics, and the suggestion was: The Sundays Album: "Reading, Writing, And Arithmetic." They sound like the Smiths but with a Female vocalist.
I think Johnny Marr even played on that album, or produced it?
I hope there's more of The Smiths to come because that's why I subscribed!
As a withdrawn teen who had autism but didn't know it at tne time i spent a fair amount of time listning to the smiths when tney were at their peak and the lyrics actually spoke to me
Yep… ‘Asleep’ about tops the depressing chart , as far as The Smith’s goes!
There’s a lot of humour with morrisey aswell - try ‘pretty girls make graves’ or ‘girlfriend in a coma’ …. And yes, you’ve guessed it , quite dark humour!
Andy kills it in “The Queen is Dead”. Bass perfection
If you love the bass, then ‘Barbarism begins at home’ will be right up your street
I'm probably twice Lauren's age, but these Smiths songs have awakened the angsty 80's teen in me. It's a cool, amazing and depressing trip down Memory Lane! 😎
You really must listen to "I Know It's Over".
Don't think you are scoring to high, its just The Smith have aload of 10 out of 10s
I liked the 500 days of summer reference
I love what u said about the bass being more prominent the instruments come through beautifully in the smiths music especially Johnny mars he’s a legend
The Smiths are ART
Yes, most underrated band of the 1980s, maybe the most underrated band of all time.
It’s hilarious how she focuses on the bass, when the Smiths have Johnny Marr, the best rhythm guitar songwriter in the history of music!
Haha .. I laff
Just found your channel and I'm really enjoying it so far, so thanks for that. What people forget is that How soon is now was originally a b side! That's pretty mad in reality for a tune that is a 10/10 for me.
Here's some other suggestions for you:
As others have said, "I know it's over" is a masterpiece.
Suedehead is a gem
Everyday is like Sunday again is just great
I have forgiven Jesus - Morriseys VERY dry sense of humour comes out here.
Just a few for you to delve into 👍
The check engine light on my car 🤣
The live versions with Johnny olaying the strings part as a guitar solo are incredible.
There's a quote from Stone Roses frontman Ian Brown about why they didn't crack America where he says: "America doesn't deserve us yet."
Maybe this was true of The Smiths too?
I'm a British-post-Smiths-break-up stereotype; came across them in your teens and having that moment of clarity of having a band that speaks to me. To this day, they're still this 38-year-olds favourite band.
You're gonna get hit with so many recommendations; especially when it comes to the better-known singles, etc. and rightfully so! They are the most popular/liked for a reason.
But if you want a couple of "different" or 'uncommon" recommendations, generally speaking, 'Cemetry Gates' is a vastly underappreciated song. You might also appreciate 'Ask' or if you like the bass, then maybe 'Barbarism Doesn't Begin at Home'
But you're going to get so many recommendations and you're sucked in now; so it's just a case of when rather than if you get to them all.
5:36 someone claiming they can one up The Smiths has to be the funniest thing I’ve heard
You should definitely do "Well, I wonder", one of the most beautiful songs ever written and with a very prominent and wonderful bass, by the way, like all Smiths songs, that is.
The build up of the music and the fade out are the best part. I love the flute.
The best part of the track is 'In the darkened underpass..........and I just couldn't ask'
They have a song along the lines of "your version"
Unhappy Birthday
As a fellow Andy fan... "That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore". You won't regret it.
Love this song. It’s a bit depressing but uplifting too if that makes sense. This charming man or bigmouth strikes again are must songs to check out!
pls do “i know it’s over” the smiths
oh wow! you now have my heart!
I was lucky enough to see the Smiths live in the 80s, lots of great suggestions here in the comments, for more great bass Melodie’s try Joy Division, Love Will Tear Us Apart, Dead Souls, Transmission or Ceremony
Unrequired love? Girl Afraid, Back to the Old House, Well I Wonder. Deep pool of those with the Smiths. Elsewhere most of Tame Impala's Lonerism album is about unrequited love (Mind Mischief, Music to Walk Home By...) if you've not heard those.
The good ol' proverbial "light" ("that never goes out") great reaction. Thank you
They’re so fantastic
I think that the depressing lyrics and bright music combo is part of the intended effect, but I also personally like the more consistently dark songs. But this was an obvious poll winner since its so well loved. I still think you're gonna like 'I know its over' better, it has more of that relatable longing for death thing Morrisey is so good at. Also if youre into this kind of vibe but want slightly heavier music, i'd check out The Cure, especially the early stuff. Surprisingly heavy for the time, and the Bass is very much at the top of the mix
My favorite song of all times - you can't get any better!!!!
BTW, the unrequited version of this song is "Please, please please, let me get what I want."
Hi, just caught your videos tonight. Really enjoyed watching all of The Smiths analogies. I was an original fan in the UK, they got their TV break on a show called Riverside, which I saw. Their debut album was ground breaking at the time as all we had on Top of the pops was New Romantic bands with videos on bloody yaughts and palm trees which meant bugger all to me in a northern English town. Thank god for The Smiths. Please check out Girlfriend in a coma. That is if you haven't already. Anyway thanks for reminding me of a great era and a band that actually spoke to me and no bloody palm trees 😂
...'In this one we're getting hit by a bus and it's a great thing' ....is soooo The Smiths. Brilliant. :)
I know its over ...& Sing me to sleep should be your next two songs from the Smiths
Nice reaction - i would suggest "i know its over" next or "what difference does it make"
❤
Great song and reaction again!!😎
But I still prefer Disintegration by The Cure for depressing music😁
You'll also get your bass fix too!!😎
That song is so hypnotic and melancholic it's amazing. A perfect album as well from start to finish
@@cloudbloom and the head on the door! one depressing song sinking but the rest is so good!!
Anything on Meat is Murder
Andy Rourke, the bassist, sadly passed a few weeks ago...
I love seeing people discover The Smiths. I have been a huge fan since the 80's. These songs have been old friends for decades. You really need to listen to Unhappy Birthday. And if you want really depressing listen to Asleep. And if you want amazing bass listen to Rush Home Ruffians. And for a laugh listen to Vicar In A Tutu. (Where I got my name from) Great reaction vid. New subscriber here :)
This Night Has Opened My Eyes might actually be the saddest song you've ever heard.
definitely my fav smiths song along with 'last night i dreamt...'
Great reaction! You have got to listen to Big Mouth Strikes Again.
One of my favorite bands ever 👍🏻
The light that never goes out it's from a house's window on the side of the road.
In my point of view, this song is about a ghost. They died side by side crashed by some large and heavy vehicle. He couldn't even understood if it was a double decker bus or a ten tonne truck! He wants to see people "young and alive". He's "welcome no more" because he's dead, he's a ghost. The light that never goes out, is the love between the two souls.
I could be wrong, but that's my interpretation.
That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore is the archetypal Smiths song and you would probably love that . Shimmering guitar , killer bass line , sombre yet playful lyrics . Songs like The Queen Is Dead are very different ... I have no idea what you would make of that ! So many great songs to choose from.
May I suggest, This Night Has Opened My Eyes
Briliant girl, Brilliant
gotta listen too....asleep, lastnight i dreamt that somebody loved me.....truely depressing
have you heard _William, It was really nothing_ ?
You'll do "I know ir's over" next? ... hahaa.... you are not coming back from The Smiths now...
😀😄
Have you ever reacted to joy division from the same city of Manchester my home city?
This Night Has Opened My Eyes is my favorite! Check it out if you haven’t. Very sad
Some great Smiths songs:
Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others
Please Please Please Let Me Get What I Want
Asleep
Loving lyrics like you do, try Half-man Half Biscuits' God Gave us Life, or National Shite Day. Loads of good British acerbic wit, and just as entertaining. Some of the name drops are obscure, but you'll love Restless Legs and Eno Collaboration. Go for it.
They have been my favorite band since high school.
A great song from a very clever band. There is a lot of dry humour in the lyrics. If you like bass driven tunes check out some more bands also from Manchester: Joy Division/New Order and The Fall. JD is angst ridden, totally brilliant both musically and lyrically, but not always an easy listen given their singer (Ian Curtis) killed himself aged 23. Morrissey tells a story of how he and Ian used to get the bus home together after punk gigs. JD later became New Order. The Fall are well unique. Enjoy.
The original line was “ there is a light in your eyes that never goes out”
Nice one, keep it up!
Maybe Melancholy is the word you are looking for? The Smiths music will be enjoyed by many for a very long time. It was original, unique and distinctive. They coined a sound, a whole genre really.
Darling, for your Morrissey-bass love I share with you... From his solo career first album "Alsatian Cousin"
The best track they ever done
So what did you think of the bass then?
Eh, it was ok.
Brilliant
If you want more bass where it is just as or more prevalent than the guitar, then delve into Joy Division/New Order (Peter Hook)
Still Ill is a great song with great bass.
Deliciously depressing.
Did you like the bass, though?
Please If you get chance.. can you react to "that joke isn't funny anymore" by the Smiths.. my absolute fave ✌🏼
spiritual ✨️ 🙏 🎶 ⏲️ 😎
If you're looking for in-your-face bass while still being chill as fuck... Morphine. They were a trio, a drummer, a sax player, and a bassist who only had 2 strings on his bass. Try Morphine - Empty Box.
You want a depressing Smiths song? Listen to “Asleep”.
What she said is a great song
Ok, it’s time for some stone roses.
I recommend made of stone and shoot you down and I wanna be adored - all your kind of vibe
In the 80s, many bands were still playing on real instrments..
B e t t e r t h a n b e i n g a l o n e💛
Isn't the "light that never goes out" hope? :0)
Please react to Morrissey - Hold On To Your Friends