BigBrainCo Debunked - Reincarnation | Pseudoscience Police
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ธ.ค. 2022
- This is a video examining Bigbrainco’s claims on the Reincarnation of Shanti Devi.
One-time donation:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Community:
TH-cam Membership: / @scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
Discord: / discord
#Reincarnation
#Rebirth
#ShantiDevi
Sources:
[1]: The BigBrainCo Video I’m examining - • SHANTI DEVI -Indian Re...
[2]: Carol Bowman’s Website - www.carolbowman.com/dr-ian-st...
[3]: International Aryan League Report on Shanti Devi - indianculture.gov.in/archives...
[4]: The podcast that critically analysed Shanti Devi’s case -
open.spotify.com/episode/2gP9...
Patrons that support me at the highest tiers:
Wesley Potts
Nithin V Nath
Animesh Chaudhary
AV
rahul raman
Abhilash
Nate Hand
Prabhakar Bhat
Jeevan
Sumana Gopinath
Vivek Balasubramanian
Arun Kumar
Rags H
Anshul Kashyap
Yudhister Satija
Abhilash Narendra
Sushanth
Kiran CJ
sashipraveen kalli
Suds Mekathotti
tariq sharif
Dev Agrawal
Thinking Humanist
Dheeraj
Wrichik Basu
Music Credits:
Warzone - Anno Domini
Bodega - Underbelly
Hop Hip - Kwon
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
TH-cam: / scienceisdope
Reddit: / scienceisdope
And Ranveer's reply to this video will always be "But bro science doesn't know everything, what if science proves reincarnation in the future"?
@@motherisape haha
I just read the "" part in ranveers voice 😆
Y not? Science has already proven reincarnation... Once you die and become ash or soil...you go back to the soil and be there as some chemical elements and plants will absorb you and you eventually can be reincarnated as a flower or a fruit. 🤣
🤣🤣
@@abj1203 😂😂😂
With big views comes big pseudoscience
With big pseudoscience comes big views
with less views comes big science
With big views come big money.
Majority is very unsophisticated audience!
False analogy 😂😂😂
I realised that compared to older videos, in your recent ones you have become more polite and composed and you try to put out your point without attacking someone for the beliefs they hold. This is really good and shows your knowledge/maturity because earlier these guys had an excuse of "you hurting their sentiments" to dismiss your rational points, but now they can't even do that. I too need to learn this from you , to put forth my point in a much better way to people I am talking to.
@@AamAadmiSamajwadiParty brother read actual science not mumbo jumbo
@@AamAadmiSamajwadiParty 😂😂he's a hypocrite
@@AamAadmiSamajwadiParty why?
@@wolframsigma6 actual science is based on trying and testing. Even you can verify it. Reincarnation for example, cannot be verified no matter how much you argue.
"Xx
I'm still not convinced bro, it's like you don't wanna accept just because they come from a box as you just explained in the earlier minutes of the video 😅 Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai bhai
Apart from Shanti devi there are multiple other evidences/ stories of reincarnation. It's a faith based on evidence - why assume that any scientific theory concluded didn't have any bias of the scientist. Even if he didn't have an objective to prove if you think you can read through data and not deduce something different from the other person is stupid
I respect him for exposing pseudoscience but it's fair to say he's bias too. Calling reincarnation, karma as a unicorn in the room - karma is the only thing that can explain how we are different from birth. Or would they just say this is pure luck - in a world which has been proven by science to be so proportionate and mathematical, this is just by chance?
Listen to what he said. He didn't say that these stories are fake. Nor did he say reincarnation is wrong. He too said he isn't convinced, need more proof for him to believe
He opinionated this basis of few google searches and his beliefs that arya samaj people can't be unbiased. He didn't give any evidence to support his statement that they were unbiased while studying the reincarnation. You might see this in his other videos as well where he asks for evidence but when provided he uses reasoning to discard it, without providing any evidence supporting his reason.
@@user-qm1dc6lz7u didn't he said that those people already believed in reincarnation? So yes it can be biased, but can be true too?
@@awesomeboi1772 meaning what? If I show you some result of an experiment, you can't claim it's authenticity because of biasness. In order to study and correlate phenomenons like reincarnation, that bias is required and justified. It's like saying dark energy is there because one is biased towards science. It's really funnily stupid argument to make when one presents evidence of it. 😅
The main hypothesis at the center of re-incarnation is that physical bodies can die, but the consciousness does not : it just changes its location to another body. the fundamental problem is that currently science does not have a way of defining or measuring consciousness, or to track its movement. but scientists accept that we are conscious, that is why we are able to think & reason. It's a strange paradox that scientists cannot deny the existence of consciousness(as they could not think or have awareness without it), yet they cannot define it , thus they cannot disprove its claimed ability of re-incarnation. Without this ever being clearly defined, this subject can never be proven or disproven. I am interested if anyone has a method to actually approach this subject in a new way, rather than just calling it a hoax.
Hi Sir, I am a student of Shri Shankaraacharya's Advaita Vedanta Darshana. Having studied other Indian Philosophical schools such as Nyaya and Purva Mimamsa Darshana, let me give my perspective of Re-Incarnation. Please bear with long answer.
Also I have highlighted few words using double inverted commas and has put my views in points for easy understanding.
1) Theory of Incarnation is the byproduct/"corollary" of "Law of Karma".
Law of Karma is just a "Model" trying to explain the differences we experience in all of our Life similar to Atomic "Model" trying to explain different observed phenomenons such as Photoelectric effect or Heat transfer between different bodies or Chemical Reactions etc.
Model word used here in my perspective is a theoritical framework which is a closer "approximation" to Reality based on Available Data and Inference.
2) Let me clarify what I am trying to say with a hypothetical example.
Let's say person A and B has a son C born in place P1 at time T1, person D and E has a daughter F born in place P2 at time T2.
Now if anyone asks a question which may look absurd or weird to us which is "Why" was C born to A and B only but not to D and E? "Why" was C born at place P1 only but not at place P2 or some other place?
3) "Why" was F female but not male to which initially we can say because the way chromosomes arranged in Zygote to which again it can be asked that "Why" were chromosomes happened to be arranged in that way and this discussion goes on with further "Why".
4) Let's say F had good education and not C. Now one person can again ask "Why" F got good education but not C?
Even if we give answer with reasons such as A and B were poor and could not afford good education to C etc to which the questioner can further ask "Why" A and B were only poor but not D and E.
5) Here Law of Karma tries to explain these differences with the concept/"Hypothesis" Merits(Punya) and Demerits(Paapa) of C and F which were generated out of there past action.
6) Now the questioner may ask When/Where/Why did C and F do an action that generated Punya or Paapa that made them to be born in respective families in first place to which Law of Karma through "Anumana(Inference)" says that they "probably" must have done this action in "their past life".
Again not based on Pratyaksha("Direct Perception") but just Inference.
7) This "Model" also serves another purpose. Since it says that past actions result in merits and demerits at present, similarly present actions decide our future and "may" help in our next life "if exists" to go good if we do good deeds and not do bad deeds. This may be true or not but motivates people to do good deeds and keeps them in check to not do bad deeds at present.
8) The gist of above 7 points is Law of Karma is just a "Model" to explain the differences in each of our life experiences and Theory of Incarnation is just a "corollary" of that Model accepted in almost all Bharathiya Darshana or Indian Philosophical Schools.
Of course this Model has greater potential to be misused to fool people as well.
9) It cannot be proved as an objective fact like 2 + 3 = 5 because it is just a "Model".
It becomes a problem to those Belief Systems(Religion)/Philosophical schools which considers the Law of Karma as an objective fact whereas there is one Philosophical School which has no problem which is Advaita Vedanta Darshana of ShriShankaraacharya because Advaita Vedanta though accepts it in the beginning finally refutes and rejects this Law of Karma as well.
10) In future if a new Atomic Level Phenomenon is observed and current Atomic Model falls to explain it and a person P comes up with another Atomic Model which explains all past observed phenomenons and in addition explains this new phenomenon, then current Atomic Model will be rejected and that new Model of person P will be accepted. Till then current Atomic Model will be considered the best "approximation" of the Atom. Similar is the case with "Law of Karma Model" which is the current best possible explanation to different kinds of "Why" questions whereas other Models such as "Chance" or "God's will" etc may not explain all these satisfactorily.
@@subramanya1780 thank you so much for such a detailed and wonderful explanation. I would love to discuss all this with you! Is there any way we can?
Science can't totally deny the existence of ghosts either. Cause there's currently no way to prove it wrong 100%. Does that make it real? Many religions and cultures believe in ghosts. Does that make it real??... These things can neither be proved real, nor be proved wrong. Also the people claiming these things should prove their claims. Why should science have the burden of proof?
Good news for you. Every individual soul is going to break free from the cruel cycle of re-birth when all the glaciers on earth melt down. Don't save glaciers, save souls.
@@subramanya1780 this is very comprehensive advaitic understanding. But it's somewhat theoritical Or bookish. We actually came up with certain proofs of experiences or fallacies that itself points out that reincarnation is the only possible answer. These are more from actual experience pov and not from the books.
1. What we assume as birth and death is simply presence and absence of experience. No one has witnessed his own birth or death in any sense. All one has is third party pov, conveying him in the experience itself that he is born or gonna die. Lack of actual experience of this(Prtaykasha) is the key thing to note.
2. Let's focus on one's memories as well. Let's say if one actually borns as new soul, then there has to be some starting point of experience. But in our case, no one remembers when exactly his experiences have started. The nature of experience remains same throughout, though contents in that change as per individual. So the only possible conclusion of this is this is beginingless, which is the actual observation we all can agree upon.
Same way one can speak of death as well. There is always tomorrow. No one remembers dying.
3. Now you could say that memory is associated with body. So it might not be valid measure. True. But there is none measure that would show us cognise the birth and death. It always feels like infinite loop, where there's tomorrow everyday. This is what caused them declaring Moksha is the highest goal because without it, this never actually ends.
With these understandings, our vedas, irrespective of darshana, univocally stated that reincarnation exists. So when a sweet talking youtuber says reincarnation is not real, either he relies too much on bookish knowledge and has none intelligence to learn from experience to form his valid opinion (Jnana), and all of that for money which is worst that a hindu can do to his own religion.
Sad times we live in. Where people don't ask evidence for BS claims but need to be shown evidence to debunk those claims.
Where is the evidence which debunks this? Did you dig deeper? Sad times we live in. When people believe in random people making baseless videos refuting reality in the name of science instead of searching for true knowledge in content created by people who devoted their entire lives studying and researching on the matter.
People like you think that by repeating "science science" you will look cool, irl y'all seem to have zero scientific temperament. The video guy had no rebuttal at all. He just blabbered relentlessly for 10 min with no substance. And then there are experts like you looking down on people haha.
@@sai62789 you think by littering all day about your Vedas and scripture will make you superior to others. The guy in the video is asking for proofs which you couldn't provide. Hence all your claims are denied and that is what hurting you.
This is the earliest I've ever been, but I just want to tell you to keep continuing the good work. India and the entire world need to think more critically..
I have doctorate in ninjutsu, why does no one takes me seriously : (
We need the evidence 🫡
I know about this guy who committed suicide, and in his note he said that he wants a better life in his reincarnation. Poor guy. Remember people, there's no way to make sure that you get an other life after death! Please embrace the one you've currently, and live the fullest.
Reminds me of Sadhguru lol. "If you believe in heaven then it means you believe that somewhere there's a place filled with joy and happiness. If this is your belief then what are you doing here? Why don't you go there? Now obviously there's only one way to go to heaven. And that is to die. But you don't want to die, you just want to "believe" in some imaginary place. Instead of improving your life here, on this planet, instead of making your surroundings heaven-like, you just wanna excuse your misery by saying you believe in some imaginary place called heaven. A place you can't even access in this life you're living right now. That's really stupid if you ask me"
@@lolong5976 not everyone can improve the situation they are in, this only applies to able bodied first world npcs born with a silver spoon. Classical victim blaming, same with the concept of "karma". What drivel.
Imaging being punished for something you don't even remember. Honestly it's just rationalization so indians could enforce their amoral caste system and justify povery and suffering as brought upon by that person so they could look away and not do anything.
Really disgusting.
Yea Hebrews 9:27 “And as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment.” true life comes from accepting Jesus Christ alone. There is no “2nd life”. ❤
Suicide actually decreases your soul's points for better life and u will end up in serving more harsh conditions
@smilingladka yeah that's true but that last message is for people who can actually enjoy their lives, remember not everyone has the same view on life, some people just can't keep living without hope and others is difficult for the surroundings conditions.
U know what i fear , it's not these big psudeoscience youtubers , it's their influence they have on community...
It's quite scary
thankyou for a great debunk video, today i learned not to only look for who has written/proven a thing but also to cross check their qualifications if they are biased towards that or not"
@@AamAadmiSamajwadiParty ps bs
This wasn't really a debunk video
@@rishinair595 Yeah, you don't really need to debunk these things because common sense and education is enough to do that. He is just stating the obvious facts people don't tend to accept.
Even Einstein's opinion on quantum entanglement was not accepted in scientific community and now almost after a century it's proven that Einstein was wrong. It's absolutely the basic tenet of rationality that persons are immaterial, ideas and evidences are supreme. It's a misleading narrative being run for long that science doesn't know everything, whereas science never ever claimed to know everything. The right narrative about science would be "science questions everything, and please don't get offended instead cooperate".
@@whykoks well said
Bro, When you said, "Biased does not mean wrong, it can be right", my respect for your scintific temperment touched sky. Your reasoning is so open and awear about every possibilites and thier respective probability #respect
Well if you see everything just through one lens without having the possibility of know multiple lenses then you're not rational
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 I agree with you 100% but that doesn't imply that the lense which you are using is wrong, I mean that possibility is wrong
@@laxyasharma7535 well how do you say that lense is not wrong what possibility is wrong judging our religion by western lens is wrong judging our civilisation by western lens is not wrong
Well how do you say the probability is wrong
@@laxyasharma7535 well the lens which you're using is not rational nor does it see different perspectives
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 Agree 🙏
Thanks for choosing this topic. India should be saved from pseudoscience.
@@AamAadmiSamajwadiParty pseudoscience bs
@@softgrowl well psychology is also pseudoscience would you deny that
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 source please. Back your claim if you are serious
@@softgrowl well psychology is pseudoscience do you know what pseudoscience is or you're just ranting psyche of a person is observed through just seeing the individual not a physical and science is observing the physical not non physical psychology isn't a physical quantity like you can measure it's a abstract idea just like reincarnation
Psychology is considered pseudoscience by scientists themselves you you would not tell people not to go to a psychologists and say psyche is real which it is just like reincarnation can be real based of the memories which is exactly the same as described by the individual
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 that's not the topic discussed here. Reincarnation is bs. No time for your empty rants whataboutism. Whataboutism itself is acceptance of ps.
I always wonder - Why does people with such unique doctorates never get Noble Price for their contribution.🤔
When I was a kid I used to tell lies in such deatail and confidence people almost used to beleive them, maybe she was doing the same
Hello Modiji 😂
I used to tell them that I came as an alien from Mars 😂😂😂
@@aakarshmaurya2265 in 1900s they would've believed you
@@ambikasankarguru8537 maybe, lol 🤣
I think her parents were con artists they must had forced her to say nonsense to get famous
My 2 cents for the Creator: As a student of science, I would love to humbly ask you to incorporate phrases like "These views are based on my understanding of reasons, and might carry some self induced bias here and there, or possible shortcomings." Since, in one of your previous videos, you just debunked few points (forget the title) without proper backing [as backings to claims are integral part of scientific debates/discussions]. So just passing on my thoughts. 😇
Congrats on 100k.
If there any channel who deserves it and so much more it’s you
Great job Pranav! Keep up the good work!
Years ago I read this book - Many Masters, Many Lives, by Brian Weiss and it touches on the same subject. Frankly, reincarnation is a fascinating topic in itself. But forcing it down on people as truth just takes the curiosity away. Good video, as always.
Dr. K.S. Rawat - Doctorate in 'Reincarnation'
Dr. Pranav (a.k.a. Science Is Dope) - Doctorate in 'Grabbing psuedoscience peddlers by the balls'
Gayyy
Well we have gender ideology studies so why not reincarnation studies.
Great video bro looking for more videos in the series, keep doing
About time you covered “Reincarnation” Pranav 💯👏.......the lack of evidence on reincarnation is a big reason why I left Buddhism. But the number of so-called real life reincarnation stories are in the thousands - and all of them lack reasonable, nevermind extraordinary, sources.
One thing I learned that religion all comes alike oneday, buddha had a whole different view from the religion teachings - buddhism. But its is comes alike with religion . Its better to learn by ourself rather than a groupe 😅
Here is something to see as well
th-cam.com/video/zWWa612Eq-4/w-d-xo.html
So are u an Atheist now?
What type of evidence your intellect will require to conclude otherwise ?
@@causeseffects5604 evidence must be empirical, replicable, falsifiable, systematic and objective....
Brilliant as Usual.
I've been watching your for a while, lately I've noticed that the Presentation has improved.
Keep it up.
Can't wait for the rest of this series, super excited!
Great video, had fun watching it. Keep making them.
Nice going bro.
Your subscribers are increasing.That is a good sign.
We need more people like you to debunk these type of videos.
Also why is it one person in billions? These stories are always very selective. If reincarnation is real shouldn’t it be for everyone in the world? What about animals ?
You don’t understand the duality of our world. Things will never be 100 percent. Your going to have people in both sides of the spectrum.
@@yeahsowhat643 so only few people get reincarnated? how do you know this?
@@bossgandy and how do you know they don’t. My point is you don’t know and the story could be much bigger then our minds can fathom. You don’t understand that energy never does and our mind and souls are constant energy on this plane. Please explain where the energy goes if it’s not reincarnated. Also, maybe others remember for particular reason but to say it’s completely false is a narrow minded human thought.
@@yeahsowhat643 If you have evidence, we can discuss, till then it doesn't concern any of us. We have this life to lead, so let's make the best of it
Ranveer is really stupid but... "People are not stupid. They believe things for reasons. The last way for skeptics to get the attention of bright, curious, intelligent people is to belittle or condescend or to show arrogance toward their beliefs." - Carl S
Nope I think Ranveer is Smart enough to know the stuff he puts on his platform is Bulls**t. He very well knows where can he get views from
That makes people who consume his media stupid
Ranveer is smart enough to know what content sells.
ranveer is a fuckin genius man, he himself does not believe in this stuff that's why he puts a disclaimer to play safe but he knows where the capital is in fact he might be watching your video with a smile thinking i know man chill, he is nothing less than a politician man kudos to him and you both
Your name is I don't know..but You know the truth👌😊
His audience are mostly Bhaktas
He is a perfect buisnessman
What do u mean by he's great then if he knows n still creates such misleading videos
I like the patterns in your videos
like hammering Carl sagan's evidence quote exactly when it's needed
And that burden of proof at 7:05
Perfect style of video presentation hope it effects the people who atleast try to think before believing everything
Really loved your take on this issue. Thanks for the video once again and again you ended up in my liked videos. Now I guess I have to make a separate playlist for your videos, lol. 😅😅😅
I'm curious. You didn't debunk Shanti Devi's reincarnation story.
Don't you believe it has some truth to it if a girl can vividly describe her past life and things actually turn out to be accurate. Also she isn't the only person in the world who remember events from their oast life, there have been multiple stories of children accurately describing their past life all across the world
I don't believe it but i'm open to it. All I need is convincing evidence
@@scienceisdope you can research it on your own, many cases of reincarnation is present.
If it’s true then we’ll find out after the post credits scene.
Arpit explains debunked it
Oh never underestimate children's memory and their ability to imagine. What if she overheard someone from Mathura who were discussing this story ? Anything could've happened.
Pranav I would love that beside Pseudoscience Police series, you would make more educational videos on topics on popular superstitious in the country (there are tons). Trying to disprove BeerBiceps and his content too much might lower your credibility as one who is desperate.
Imagine every viewers of bigbrainco watched this and become rational 😌
it will be for the better but one video does not make someone rational it is a transition, they will be denial initially and it will take many more experiences for a particular person to get to know the truth , for example I was a huge elon musk fan but then I slowly bit by bit I got to know his reality he is not the founder of tesla , he is from a rich family from south Africa who used to use child labor for their mines , has no knowledge about urban planning and lobbied against the California high speed railway in order to make his hyper loop also he lied on stage that he came up with the idea of hyperloop but it's from 1904 failed idea what he failed to do because he is basically trying to reinvent train.
Braincos' audience are indian... You expect indians to grow a brain and become rationalists overnight?
Woah, your explanation quality leveled up along with the content quality. (Atleast , that's how I felt. It was easier to understand)
You brought in the counter argument against the sceptical perspective at the perfect time! Bravo! And this is something I’ve been interested in too. Excellent work!
Hi Pranav, since the sources of information were involved in past life theories and the team that went to investigate Shanti Devi was from a religious group, they are biased sources but then isn't your own opinion on this topic a biased opinion. You don't really seem like a skeptic, but an outright non-believer in the possibility of extra ordinary happenings instead. So your opinion itself is a very biased opinion to look at things.
You are doing a great job brother👍
Hi Pranav, I have been your subscriber for a long time now. I was thinking how an outro would be at the end of your videos? Just a suggestion; amazing Content though. Cheers!
Hey Pranav , really appreciate your content , and what are you doing for the awareness of the society , as there is a thin line between science and pseudoscience . Which is the obvious reason of people getting trapped in the logical looking holes .
Can you please tell how to find the solid and true facts without being distracted by the logical looking sources .
Thanks a lot, Pranav for debunking all these myths, the damage that pseudoscience has caused seriously needs to be undone. I hope your channel grows really fast.
There is a video that has both Beerbiceps and PraveenMohan, must be pseudoscience on steroids 😂 Don't know what else they will do to ruin the scientific mindset of young people.
Sadly you get called a jihadi,anti national,anti hindu, deshdrohi,or whatever when you call out pseudo science in india.
@@sammybosak10 but how
he did not debunked it, tf? he just said it might be true but there is not enough evidence from unbiased point of view.
@@TH-camHandle00018 the 'others' are earning by doing m**- b** of science. So in this case, if you think Pranav is earning on these 'others' videos, I would any day support Pranav and Science Is Dope.
Dude I love your channel! The facts and evidences you come up with raises the bar high with every new video.
What evidence did he showed in this video proving reincarnation is false claim.
Kindly share with me as well , will be helpful for me.
I was not able grasp , accurate pinpointed evidence , proving reincarnation to be false claim.
🙏😀
Hi pranav what's your take on Channel called String? Have you seen them?
I've made a video on him
@Success and Worth hahaha
Hi Pranav, can you do a video on Eugenics, Racial Purity(DNA), is there any science actually ? Or just cultural racism?
Reincarnation if FALSE, nothing like that , 1 birth and 1 death thats all.
He recently wrote a Tweet on some meditation backed by science 🤣
I replied plz do attach those research paper in your description..
Let's see what he'll do
Meditation is definitelly backed by science. They can measure how to parts of the brain that contains stress get smaller over time when having a meditation habit.
@@frisianwarrior2295 I asked for those research paper links ..
Please share 🙏🏻
What happened to Sudhanshu trivedi's video? Can't find it.
These ppl are gonna sell anything nonsense in the name of religion..
can you cover the other famous reincarnation story of this kid who claimed to had been a WW2 fighter pilot and several neurologists from different universities, especially the University of Virginia researched on that case? I'd really love to hear your take on it since that case was probably the beginner of belief in reincarnation in the West.
Well they won't because they think it's just pseudoscience
No he won’t. Because it doesn’t suit his propaganda. Let him debunk Hyper Quest arguments
@@sandeerao86 lmao
You can hear voices whilst still in the womb, it's not as clear but you do pick up on vocal patterns. This hypothesis wouldn't work well.
Another hypothesis I have is that maybe some degree of the parents memory gets passed down through the formation process, perhaps the wife hearing stories coming from their husband, but I can't prove this so I'm only speculating. I don't have the tools to test my hypothesis.
@@Im-BAD-at-satire yea that might have something to do with it. Or maybe stories from grandparents and all. Idk lol. I would love to have an expert in this matter.
I would love to get behind the psychological reasons why the girl could recall those accounts in detail, was it something that got engrained in her through conversation or was it an elaborate con all together?
U can watch arpit explains video on this he has explained whole story
the latter
@@abk192 any link?
@@booksanimeenthusiast3802 Arpit explains punarjanam aisa search karo mil jayega
@@abk192 ty
Plzz make something about Abhijit chavda
That guy seems knowledgeable but sometimes he just propose conspiracy theories
Lol he is pseudoscience spreader and conspiracy theorist
Like what?
Edit:-this is a science centered channel, it doesn't cover any other genre.
He is a propaganda guy fr
Your work is amazing
Your channel is a gem,sir
Can you please do a livestream with ranveer? I think it will be a very fruitful conversation with interesting perspectives from you both
Congratulations for 1 lakh subscribers.
Introduction rocks! Good going 🤟🎉
You didn't touch the kernel of the story again, Pranav. You simply discredited the people associated with it. That is not the scientific method, for such discredition can be applied to practitioners of any profession. (Ex: One can say scientists are biased against non material things only because they have the label scientists.)
Kindly research more, Ian Stevension has written a book on it which I will begin in a few days. I recommend you to read it as well. If you truly are open minded that is.
Here's the thing. The story can't be trusted to be true. There's one central source, this is different from science where several independent studies are conducted.
@@vaishanthjv2519 Not necessarily bro. I mean when the evidence is rare, not everyone can study it.
But my point was that it has been studied, in detail too. Just not by too many people. You can read the book as I suggested, or watch ucla video as a primer.
@@anshumanpanda1227 and when something hasn't been studied by a lot of people you can't know its credibility. Your excuse can't be "Not many people study it" thats the reason you can't trust it yet.
@@vaishanthjv2519 Why don't you take up its study then? Certainly, rejecting something without study is unscientific.
@@anshumanpanda1227Did I ever say I reject reincarnation?I just said I am not convinced that it is true. The burden of proof lies on the one making the claim, if you claim reincarnation is true, it is up to you to prove it.
Science is dope is my favorite science channel on youtube
this is of the few genuine science channels and I love it
Today Vimoh talked about Acharya Parshant can you also make a video about him I would like to hear you thoughts on him, as I kind of disagree with vomih.
Wow nice work..Can you do research on this topic and make a video on how rationalist think about reincarnation claims and their conclusion on those cases. Really eager to learn
Thanks . Your channel is awesome. Would love to hear your take on Vandana Shiva.
Thank you!
This is like Chinese cultivation novels where youngsters are reincarnated. 🤣🤣
Hey Pranav... Can we get a detailed analysis on the planchette thing and how it is fooling us ?... Looking forward to learn more from you ... Respect and Love bro ❤️
You are very articulate... Intro was on point
It's actually a vicious cycle. These people make pseudoscientific videos and more people watch it; Since more people are watching such contents they make more such videos🤦♂🤦♂
these videos end up spreading through whatsapp
Yep, a vicious positive feedback loop for making tons of money.
@@Amin-js4en I've been using whatsapp for 7 years and I've barely come across these stupid posts on pseudoscience lol.
I guess I'm living under a rock.
@@Crabbyfeet You'll see such contents in family WhatsApp groups..
u rock bro keep doing it...
Thank you so so much .. I was about to request you to do the same but I thought it might be weird.. But anyways it's happening.. Thanks bro 💓🙌
Good work bro. 👏
When will you reveal you silver play button for 100k subscribers ???
I think there is zero possibility of previous incarnation
After lugdi Devi's death her past life husband used to visit shops in front of her house - this was said by many of her neighbours and lan whatever guy.
Also don't trust anything gandi says 😂
I don't normally Like or comment on videos. But I am doing it now, I gotta support u, on what u ar doing.👍
This video should also have included
1) what could be the simple parsimonious explanations for how the girl explained the alleged past life events
2) why reincarnation claims are untestable, without the possibility of inducing false memories or blatantly lying ?
Yes let's go pranav we want series
Greatly appreciate your videos! Ranveer doesn't only spread willful lies about science but also about history. As a historian, it makes my blood boil at the sheer nonsense that this channel and his podcasts spread as objective and well-researched truths. On top of that he brings conspiracy theorist abhijeet chavda as an expert instead of actual historians on his platform. I am shocked why a so-called well educated, liberal minded person would willfully indulge in such false narratives. Sadly unlike your channel there is none out there debunking stupid history lies on these channels. :/
Bringing physicist to discuss history is like bringing Tendulkar to play football.
Ranveer is not a liberal, he has been a RW propagandist for a long time now
@@ayanchoudhury6697 I see that now, but the circles he moves in, the people he interacts with in his personal life (other english speaking influencers and comedians) had me under a different impression. I guess its also easier to get views catering to RW propoganda (even if he wont agree with it personally) which makes him an even bigger a**hole. Just like Pranav has shown elsewhere that he doesn't practice NoFap himself but continues to push that bullshit down young impressionable teens.
@@ayanchoudhury6697 Ranveer Alhabadiya is a fast friend of Dhruv Rathee. At one time Ranveer fought with FMF and defended Dhruv too.
@@kostubsarma4873 well he is rw then he is pretty moderate because he doesn't say anything to leftists
Keep going. You are amazing yet simple guy
If there is a doctorate for 'reincarnation', then there should be a Nobel prize for that
Hi Pranav, Really appreciate you man, as an atheist i can wholeheartedly say that you made my arguments against existence of God much better and clear. But i have one question, like you said that "reincarnation is definitely possible", but can you explain it how? Maybe some another video on this or some scientific evidence or theory behind it?
I think he misspoke right there. But it should be like 'Reincarnation has a possibility to be true or false'
@@ezer8528 but still i wonder how can reincarnation be true. I mean this isn't even Imaginative to me
@@kashishaggarwal2217 You should consider all the outcomes even the ones that seem to be absurd. All you need is crediable evidence to believe
@@ezer8528 yeah yeah I am considering it. It's just that my mind is f*cked when I think of reincarnation being true😂
@@kashishaggarwal2217 Well, I can't imagine how f*cked up the people's life are when they needed the reincarnation to be true
A person's brain which is a storehouse of life's memories disintegrates and decomposes so even if we consider reincarnation to be true, how can the same person claim he was someone else with exact details in his past life?
How can a electron be present in two different place at the same time its not possible but its true in quantum world. Same applies on other things nor everything is understood by science. For science we need tools to observe things and every tool has limitation that's a fact so how can you say something like reincarnation could be understood by science. It's like your trying to understand projectile motion with cell theory.
@@indreshprajapati9095
You're validating ridiculous superstitions using your half baked understanding of quantum mechanics.
In standard quantum mechanics, there is no principle that claims a particle is present at two different places simultaneously. Quantum mechanics does involve some unique and non-intuitive phenomena like superposition, where a quantum particle can exist in multiple states at once, but this doesn't mean it's physically located in two places simultaneously. It's a probabilistic description of where the particle might be found upon measurement.
The phenomenon you might be referring to is the wave-particle duality, where particles like electrons exhibit both wave-like and particle-like characteristics, but this is about the nature of particles and doesn't mean they exist in two places at the same time.
If Mahatma Gandhi was involved in this episode, there should be news articles backing this claim!
Yay first comment and like.. Love ur content bro.
Big Brain Co ? Where's the brain tho
😂
Bars
Burn!!
Make your brain bigger...as their banner says ...💀💀
Rationality is the key to a developed nation. 🔥 Great, informative and logical video as always.
Nope this is one of the Most Wahiyaat (asshole) ever Solution from the People like you.
The Key thing for a Developed countries are Good Governance Laws in Prime Minister's Gazette Letter (Raajpatra).
You will observe one thing in Common among Developed country is that.
1.All Developed countries have Right to Recall along with Voting Rights.
2.All developed countries have Jury Rights.
3.All Powerful and Peaceful country have Gun rights.
Carl Sagan refering to 3 major cases for investigating reincarnation debunks your rationalism
100k lets go broooo
Doctorate in reincarnation. That sent me laughing out loud in crowded public place
I have been following your channel from quite a while, happy to see your channel grow 😇
Keep doing what you doing🫡
Thanks for existing Pranav 🙏
bro i am so sorry for judging you at first go, I was in depression back then going through mental breakdowns and probably became one of sad gurus target audience,,, It was with time and actual spirituality introduced to me by Acharya Prashant.. that i could finally fully accept the science rebel inside me.... now your videos are making so much sense.. please if possible and if it falls in your context .. would u like to share your opinion on Prshant's POV. apology again for quick judgment and promise to never fall into the belief trap again.. lots of love
Doctorate in Reincarnation…. You can makeup any shit and become doctor of that field😂
First of all universities giving such degree should be banned 😂😂
it's para-psychology
Pranav , could you pls talk about satvic movement and their diet? Ty. :)
@@namrathainjeti3294 i am talking about their ridiculous diet
@@krantichinchaniwale Don't follow them. They are just a sellout. Recently I saw they are selling enema kit as well which can be dangerous to health. Colonics in US is done under experts and still its risky and these guys are just selling DIY enema kits. Better to follow some other pages.
@@VishwadeepShinde absolutely
Sir , arya samaj is not hindu sect and certainly doesnt believe in reincarnation. Please make this correction.
"Shanti Devi" story is told in Shyam sighh Roy movie climax, and is expedition X show real??today telecasted episode, host talked to ghost lol 🙃
Hey Pranab..
Just discovered your videos few days back..
Loved your bold take on such issues
I request you to do a check on another Dr pseudo science Abhijit chavda
Just because the proofs are put on your face by praveen mohan and Abhijit chavda,and you can't answer them, don't say them pseudoscientist.
beer biceps left the brain😂😂😂😂😂😂
He doesn't have it
congrats on 100k 😇
How about Ravi Verma- Toran Singh (Titu) case? Even BBC had documented. Please give your remarks. Ian Stevenson has documented hundreds of cases....what about them?
there was a 5 year-old boy who came to one of my extended family's house and started saying things in our dead uncle's tone of voice and things that a 5-year old stranger from 150kms away have no chance of knowing. He's 30+ now and don't remember anything but is now part of my extended family and also the reason I believe in reincarnation.
Man I have seen a recent event like this actually a glimpse about it in the local news channel. A boy who died a few years ago reincarnated and told the exact details. Both parents went to the police and the police were shocked and said that both parents could have him as their child. Maybe that will help in understanding it a bit deeper.
There are some things science can't explain it can ever explain, because the human intellect has to reach that level of consciousness to understand certain things. I don't know what it is with you. Just because your intellect is not able to process the information or you are not able to prove with science doesn't mean it is hoax. There are other stories of reincarnation like tutu Suresh case, where the kid remembered about his past life. There are some elements of truth in very religion. Just being an athesit doesn't mean you have to debunk certain philosophies that are written in religious texts. Rather than cooking a story about how this as fabricated, you can try to prove through science this is never possible, which you can't
Here’s the thing man! If him or likes of him are not upto “that” level of consciousness then the people who have “that” level of consciousness should come up with explanations and that too backed with proper evidence or formulas or anything which makes reincarnation believable.
Imagine how easy life would be if reincarnation would be proved.
Literally the world would be a better place. But seems like so called conscious people don’t want to make the world a better place, which is contrary to what they preach for hmmmm?
And if you’d ask me to first believe and then experience, no thanks, cant do that. Cant believe everything anyone tells me as one shouldn’t.
I find The way u handling the topics recently is mature . Previous ur bit rude . But I'm liking ur content because recent videos . Yeah u have point to be considered in previous also now also u have but . There is diff I find . Good work 👍