1999 Caroline Benson 46-Jason Walks Out On Robin

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
  • Jason tries to call Carly but she doesnt answer. Jason is furious with Robin and tells Sonny to take her home and dismisses her. He leaves and heads to the brownstone.

ความคิดเห็น • 64

  • @luckyjasonfan
    @luckyjasonfan 10 ปีที่แล้ว +58

    Yes, Robin thinks that Jason is stupid and that she has to "save" him from Carly. Well, Jason knows EXACTLY what he was doing and Exactly what Carly was capable of doing to him... but he LOVED Michael (and Carly) anyway.... which Robin couldn't stand!

    • @terrolynjones0179
      @terrolynjones0179 9 ปีที่แล้ว +11

      yeah I just couldn't stand to look at this because it was sad really her jealousy and anger ruined a family. I just couldn't understand this like for real Robin.

    • @chadfan45
      @chadfan45 6 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      @@terrolynjones0179 No Carly ruined her "family" with Jason when she spread her legs for Sonny all because she was jealous of Liz!!

    • @sandrajohnson4778
      @sandrajohnson4778 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Terrolyn Jones is right.....robin broke up that family.

    • @luckyjasonfan
      @luckyjasonfan 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@chadfan45 Jealous of Liz.. nope. Carly was vulnerable and had a Lot of mental/emotional Issues!! Sonny lied to her face, said Jason was sleeping with that girl and then, took Advantage of Carly! He was/is a Pig!!

    • @gummybeer119
      @gummybeer119 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Yep. And he never wanted to be saved from Carly. Never. He TOLD Robin he could not imagine a future without Carly is in his life. She just couldn't believe it, couldn't understand it.

  • @yaniramartinez3857
    @yaniramartinez3857 5 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    The problem with Robin's argument is that it was without merit because Jason never did anything he didn't want to do. So, Carly could have not been manipulating nor controlling Jason because he knew exactly who she was and what she was always up to. What is interesting is the fact that Robin was accusing Carly of trying to control and to manipulate Jason when at times Robin has done the same thing to him. Nevermind, that goes to show the little faith that Robin had in Jason because if Robin truly knew him she would have known that Jason could always tell when Carly was lying to him or was trying to play him. So, there was no way that she could manipulate him because no one can make Jason do something he doesn't want to do. Also, the fact that Robin said that Carly was using, manipulating and emotionally having a hold on Jason was ridiculous because he never care about material stuff. Jason only cared about Carly's and Michael's safety and well-being. He just wanted to make good on his promise to Michael to love him and to keep him safe. Unfortunately for Robin, part of making Michael happy and to keep him safe meant to keep his mother the same way. Furthermore, when Robin went back to Jason she knew about his commitment to Michael and that Carly was his mother. But most importantly, Robin knew the whole truth about how Jason became Michael's father. So, to ask him to choose was unfair. And to later on, break the promise she made to Jason to never reveal the truth about Michael's paternity just to be vindictive towards Carly was an act of betrayal of the worse kind.
    Blessed be!

    • @irishmoore8674
      @irishmoore8674 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Carly manipulated Jason with Michael

  • @natalieps2387
    @natalieps2387 6 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    What Jason said when robin said she loved him and he responded that it's something he didnt know how she really meant it. Damn. He was saying she didnt really love him.just controlled him.which she did she used emotional blackmail. And save it robin about helping jason she wanted to raise michael with Jason but when carly got out of ferncliff robin was waiting for Jason to choose her when he didnt to her shock she dropped the bomb to hurt carly snd jason and she never loved Michael years later she told carly Michael was her bastard .

  • @jarlymorgan
    @jarlymorgan 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Robin taught Jason how not to be under no control like she tried controlling him. Making his decisions for him. That's what robin taught him.

  • @bubblezzxxd15
    @bubblezzxxd15 9 ปีที่แล้ว +32

    All Robin does is tell other people's business. She did not do the right thing, as it was not her place. If AJ wanted to know for sure that he was Michael's father he should have established paternity, but he didn't. That was his responsibility, if Carly was so in the wrong. Yet, the situation had less than nothing to do with Robin, Jason signed up to be Michael's father, & she couldn't stand it, which is why she knew for so long before saying anything. She was being self righteous and spiteful

    • @Pinkranger87
      @Pinkranger87 7 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Misty Waters i agree. She told A.J because Jason chose Michael over her. H

    • @chadfan45
      @chadfan45 6 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Robin did the right thing. Jason and Carly had no right keeping the truth from AJ. He deserved to know the truth. Carly and Jason NEVER would have told the truth. Someone had to do it and i am glad it was Robin. People think Jason is so great but he is nothing but a lying and cheating weasel. Robin was right to tell AJ despite what Jason said. He is nothing but a hypocrite. He hates when people lie to him but he has no problem lying when it fits his needs. Him and Carly deserved what they got. Robin was 100 percent correct!!

    • @beegee1960
      @beegee1960 6 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Cindy Davidson you realize you also just described Robin. And no, someone did not have to tell AJ. He could have been perfectly happy without knowing. In fact he and everyone would have been happier if he had never known. You don’t miss what you never had.

    • @chadfan45
      @chadfan45 6 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Alice Soefje um yes someone did need to tell AJ. He had every right to know. Michael is AJ's and that skanky, lying ass Carly had no right keeping Michael from him. I bet you are one that hates Liz and thinks she is wrong for lying. But guess what Carly did the same thing and you think it is right. Hypocrite much?

    • @natalieps2387
      @natalieps2387 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      In a way ajs life would have been better off if he did not know Michael was his. He was dealing with a bunch if admoral psychos that played very dirty. If sean k was in the role I believe carly would have been at his doorstep. The whole reason they made the baby ajs was to hook them up later. The triangle was gonna be tony carly aj. Sean k was a match for Jason in the looks & body dept & played aj as a very sweet good man who was an alcoholic. He was sick not mean. He & sarah had great chemistry. Guza took over was in love with jason & recasted aj with the exact opposite of what aj looked like. Also inferior to jason. He was really short much older had black hair & brown eyes & had a weasly weak quality to him & aj that sean did not have. Sean quit the show for personal reasons. It's a shame bc he quit as the story was heating up. Carly just found out she was pregnant. It just would have been interesting to see how this was handled if he stayed. Plus carly & ajs sex scene was pretty hot. I cant ever see sarah & Billy having a hot love scene. Plus alan was so tall why Hire a very short man to play his son. Steve burton said he had to wear lifts in his shoes to get the part bc the aj before sean was tall bc alan was very tall. So I'm convinced guza wanted the physical opposite of steve hired. Nothing against billy but he was not really a hunk as Jason & aj were def hunks lol

  • @luckyjasonfan
    @luckyjasonfan 10 ปีที่แล้ว +30

    "Jason, you know I love you" "I know you mean something by that I didn't think it meant" BURN! Robin had no clue what Jason was about at this point... He was so in love with Michael and she took that away from him!

    • @terrolynjones0179
      @terrolynjones0179 9 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      yeah

    • @hotchocolate8320
      @hotchocolate8320 5 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      luckyjasonfan.... Jason was obsessed with Micheal like a creep. Yes it’s okay to love your child but it’s another thing to keep him from his rightful parent. AJ even tells Jason he can have visitation rights to Micheal but no Jason was hellbent on getting AJ out completely. Micheals upbringing was up to Carly and AJ not Jason or Sonny. Man looking back I really dislike Jason’s character.

    • @crayzeetony4367
      @crayzeetony4367 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@hotchocolate8320 agree

  • @dookie4life04
    @dookie4life04 12 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    I agree with that. I think Robin wanted to say something for awhile, but she did it at that point to put a wedge between Carly and Jason which was selfish of her. Robin should have said something in the beginning if she really felt that strong about it, and it was dumb to expect Jason to understand. She was destroying his family and she thought he should be grateful lol. Everyone screwed up back then, I hope AJ does get a chance with Michael now though.

    • @cscarly
      @cscarly 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Only time she wanted she wasnt jason girlfriend and michael mother .
      Bobbie warn jason you have carly or robin no way have both

  • @jaquen1977
    @jaquen1977 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    To this day I agree with what Robin did. I wish she’s done it earlier. What Carly and Jason did to AJ was just vile. Carly and Jason were total trash during this period. Robin shouldn’t have had an ounce of remorse.

  • @TheOnly1tonid
    @TheOnly1tonid 14 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    This is the second time she sided w/ someone against Jason & Michael, then tried to blame it on Evil, heartless, horrible Carly. First, there was Tony Jones. She blamed Carly for Tony kidnapping Michael & defended him in open court. Now, she does it again w/ AJ. She breaks Jason's heart & his trust over & over again, but it's never her fault. She is a self-righteous, self-serving emotional bully just like Carly said. Love me or I'll... That is how I know their's was not a true love match.

    • @jkn3712
      @jkn3712 7 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      If you can't see that AJ had the right to know he fathered a child or that Tony acted out of hurt as Robin attested to, then you're not understanding of human nature. People do things that are hurtful in the name of Truth, but also when they've been hurt very-badly. Jason hurt Robin by choosing Michael, and Carly hurt Tony (and EVERYONE else in PC) by lying to . . . everyone, and re: Michael to Tony + taking him away from Bobby out of revenge.
      J & R and the truest love match GH has concocted in 40 years. Period.

    • @teamtony4623
      @teamtony4623 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@jkn3712 Carly did a terrible thing to a good man.

  • @irenegai3168
    @irenegai3168 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Robin is vindictive

  • @lisagarcia9014
    @lisagarcia9014 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Omg Jason why you so scared

  • @vanessa4704
    @vanessa4704 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Rewatching this episode in 2022, I still agree with Robin's decision to tell AJ. Yeah, she was hurt, wouldn't you be if your woman's intuition told you your man was being manipulated by a conniving itch and one day that lie they perpetrated was going to hurt him. Carly used Jason from day 1. She slept with Jason and their bond was made by having sex without sharing names. I believe she (Carly) said it was like having sex with a robot. She knew there was something not fully there with Jason. Then when he(Jason) told Robin and she mentioned it was wrong, Jason stopped sleeping with Carly. So he chose Robin and Carly did not like that Jason chose Robin over her to love and she (Carly) was just Jason's sex buddy. Thus, her dislike for Robin begun. Look at her face when Jason climbed on stage at the nurse's ball and carried Robin off. Carly saw Micheal as a way to control Jason and stay in his life, and until Jason died she was still controlling Jason and Sonny, through the kids she had with them. Jason has said it and so has Sonny, that Carly does this to them. Every woman Jason had as his character evolved as Jason M, Carly through Micheal up in his face, that he needed to be there for Micheal, even after she screwed Jason over when she got with Sonny. Later, in the s/l Jason apologized to Robin. He understood better what she did and why. Also, how can what Jason and Carly did be so right. Again, when Carly got with Sonny, he (Jason)lost Michael to Sonny after all his (Jason) fighting with lawyers to keep Michael to himself and from the Q's. During some of the earlier fighting, Carly was no f'ing where to be seen. Then, come around Carly gets with Sonny and he does the same thing to AJ, that Jason did, helped her keep Michael from the Q's. What good did all Carly's, Jason and Sonny's lying do. Micheal got shot, killed Claudia (I know why, still don't discredit the life that put him in that situation), went to jail, was raped in jail, found out about AJ and now has no relationship with Sonny. So, can it really be said, AJ wouldn't have been a better father to the son HE created with Carly. IJS. Robin deserved better from Jason. She was his lifeline from the day he woke up and decided to become Jason M. Yes, she did have morals, and so did Sonny and Jason, even as wise guys before Carly. After Jason grew to realize what Robin had tried to do for him, they developed a friendship again. So, I said it then and I say it now, Guza sucked with his desire to make Carly the forefront of Jason and Sonny's life. She added no value to their lives, no growth, and relationships throughout GH were ruined from Jason, Sonny, Tony, Bobby in the beginning and AJ's!!!!

    • @renealexander2703
      @renealexander2703 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Carly was better for Jason and Sonny. Robin was too good for Jason and Sonny.

    • @joannreader3260
      @joannreader3260 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Agree 💯

    • @joannreader3260
      @joannreader3260 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@renealexander2703Robin should have never forgotten or forgive Jason or Sonny they treated her like dirt .Glad she found love with Patrick

    • @vanessacooper5993
      @vanessacooper5993 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@renealexander2703Carly was better for them after they lost their morals. In the beginning, Sonny was a mobster with a conscious and Jason wouldn't tell a lie. After Carly, they both went to shit. Sonny had no morals and Jason lied and covered up for Carly and her wrong doings at every turn.

  • @CAM8689
    @CAM8689 13 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    watching this again ironic now considering the Jake/Lucky situation what goes around comes around

  • @kathyadorno5488
    @kathyadorno5488 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Jason doesn't hate you AJ, Carly does. He doesn't even think about you or really know you. You made it more about a competition than about your son... Now maybe later on Jason started to hate you, but he was only thinking about Michael....When you have that first kid it really does change you...

  • @sonyab1974
    @sonyab1974 13 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    Don't worry Robin. Someday Jason will understand why you did it. :)

    • @joannreader3260
      @joannreader3260 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Jason did not deserve her to come save his life 2005 or to be his friend again 😤

  • @CAM8689
    @CAM8689 12 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    with AJ being back this just brings new meaning Jason,Carly and Sonny can lie to themselves and to Michael all they want AJ will always be his father no matter how much others hate it.
    Still can't believe Sonny would go on along with this considering how much being present in his children's lives meant to him Carly and Jason's ethics are pretty much nonexistent.

    • @jkn3712
      @jkn3712 7 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      And had AJ had the chance to be Michael's father from the beginning, it might have saved the character from total destruction; he may have straightened up to be a good dad to Michael. But NO, Jason KNEW better, didn't he, and it was alright for HIM to lie, but nobody else should/could lie according to Mr. Don't-Lie-to-Me Morgan!

  • @victoriaindigo
    @victoriaindigo 8 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Oh please, Jason kept Michael to spite AJ! If Robin indeed told AJ to spite Carly then Jason needs to be called out on the same thing

    • @jasoncarly
      @jasoncarly  8 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      +victoria grant exactly!

  • @hotchocolate8320
    @hotchocolate8320 5 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Looking back on these scenes Damn Jason was a damn Creep. It’s one thing to love a child but to go to the unnecessary lengths he did is creepy. Jason highkey is a physcopathic loser. It’s not his kid to be making these decisions. Lying is the most horrible thing to do unless it’s him(Sonny,Carly or Liz) doing it in his book.

    • @hughjanus8960
      @hughjanus8960 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I don’t agree with what Jason did but how the fuck is it creepy, he just loves Michael that much, not saying what he did was right.

    • @crayzeetony4367
      @crayzeetony4367 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      agree

  • @victoriaindigo
    @victoriaindigo 13 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Accusing Robin of thinking she can make your decisions better than you can Jason? Didn't you think you could make AJ's decisions better than he could regarding his own biological son? What incredible arrogance.

    • @jkn3712
      @jkn3712 7 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      Spot on, good observation!

    • @duckipersons3918
      @duckipersons3918 7 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      victoria grant lmao Jason wasn't in a fucking relationship with aj. Robin was. Him doing what he did has NOTHING to do with her being a self righteous little bitch.

    • @Gabbs_0.x
      @Gabbs_0.x 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      To be fair, AJ is an Alcoholic. He did ever step up or take responsibility for anything and played the victim. He had valid issues but refused to get proper help.

    • @crayzeetony4367
      @crayzeetony4367 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@Gabbs_0.x Wrong

  • @victoriaindigo
    @victoriaindigo 13 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Robin was so much better off without Jason, she wasn't meant to be a mob doctor lol
    Michael will always be AJ's son. I think Starr will bring him back into being a Q, which he truly is!

  • @kathyadorno5488
    @kathyadorno5488 7 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Here's the thing, 1st let me say I don't like Robin, I never did. But, she was right for telling the truth...The problem is, she did it for the wrong reasons, she did it because she thought it would release Carly's place or hold on him...Later in 05, she lied when she barged into his apartment with Sam to "speak her peace", that AJ deserved to know the truth. Maybe, but that's not why you initially told the truth....BIT$%, if you're so big on honesty, be honest with yourself...

    • @jasoncarly
      @jasoncarly  7 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Kathy Adorno understood but just so you know I have been a fan of Robin since she debuted in 1985 as a little girl and I literally grew up with her as we are around the same age me just years older than km so although I disagree with some choices she makes I will always love Robin. just thought I would say that but I respect your opinion.

  • @dookie4life04
    @dookie4life04 12 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    To be fair, Carly set this whole thing in motion the night she showed up and begged Jason to lie about being Michael's father. The truth coming out was always something that was a possibility. If Carly/Jason and later Sonny had given AJ a shot to be a real father to his child, he wouldn't have spiraled so out of control and did the things he did. Not whitewashing AJ, but Carly holds a lot of the responsibility squarely on her shoulders.

    • @jkn3712
      @jkn3712 7 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Agree!

    • @aprilmoses8303
      @aprilmoses8303 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I hate that all of you people think that Robin Scorpio, deserves to have Jason mr don't lie to me Morgan and Sonny turn their backs on Robin Scorpio for doing the right thing.

  • @CAM8689
    @CAM8689 13 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Jason you ain't nobody special you don't get to dictate other people's lives or there children.

  • @MGPMGP18
    @MGPMGP18 14 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    god i hate robin during this

  • @sandrajohnson2741
    @sandrajohnson2741 ปีที่แล้ว

    Robin supposedly knew PJ right and she knew the Qs.....so she felt she did the right thing because jason was to stupid to know when he was being used right....but it seemed that she did not even think about the repercussions.....or maybe she did not care.....did she not study what PJ and his psycho family would do....did she not consider that....she was a prude with a halo, and she was good and right and carly was a demon and bad.....i wonder how she felt when both Sonny and Jason turned their backs on her.....she deserved that.