Honestly, this is too epic for this scene. The one they got from the original episode suits the morbid, macabre of the scene, and for what's awaiting humanity next....
Yeah but for the last part of the song i think the epic tone fits eren transforming. I would delete Ymir's part music and put it on the part where the lighting begins
Tbh i feel like its supposed to be epic and morbid. We are seeing the erens biggest and terrying form with basically colossal titans around him. i think there could be a better ost tho. but the original kinda didnt get the mark either. so this edit and the ost dont have the full effect on whats happening here. And that sucks.
@@juicy5251 I mean, Eren HAS made an epic power up. One that fits him for specifically the Rumbling, and what shall unfold upon humanity. Be it grace, chaos, loyalty, or destruction.
The original still suits this scene more...but this..this is masterpiece lol the other channel who did this didnt fit the timing of song with what happened but this one does. Good job love this!
@@ASkeleton-fy2ir Governments get their power from the people, silent complacentcy isnt the same as being innocent. also basically every citizen of the other countries also wants to genocide eldians
fun fact it would take like 20 years to cover the earth with the rumbling, and you could easily just move out of the way to the side ahead of time of the relatively short line of titans mowing the lawn back and forth, and come back in behind them. You'd lose buildings but not that many people.
I love YouSeeBigGirl, but Footsteps of Doom was the perfect track for this scene I would never replace it To me, I associate it too much with the Reiner & Berthold scene in Warrior But I think we can all agree that the Attack on Titan OST is goated
Of course u cant just simply put you see big girl over every epic scene in AoT but to be fair it of course also works here and enhances this scene a lot. I think u gave the rumbling a lot more punch through your editing, it's the first time I got some chills from it and it put a smile on my face. So nice work. Thank you. :)
A lot of people are saying the original music fits the tone better, and while I agree that it worked VERY well, I do feel like this one is more appropriate than it seems. To me, this song is about regret. Hard choices, betrayal, wishing things could have gone differently. It plays when Ymir transforms for the first time, throwing away the life she had built for a chance to save the girl she loves. It plays when Reiner and Bertholdt are revealed, returning to Marley - despite everything it’s done to them - because they can’t conceive of anything else. This one also shares some parts of ‘Vogel im Käfig’ from the first season, which has its own aura of loss and regret: It plays over Carla’s death, giving up her own life so her children will have a chance. Eren’s first transformation, becoming the thing he hates more than anything. The deaths of Levi’s squad, which Eren sees as happening because he decided not to fight. What I’m saying is despite the tone, this doesn’t feel like a song of triumph. It feels like Eren’s final decision, coming back to the idea mentioned so often throughout Season 1, the idea Eren’s been fighting against the entire show: that to fight monsters, you have to become one yourself. In his conversation with Reiner under Liberio (at least in the dubs), he describes the Warriors as ‘trying to save the world’ and declares that he’s doing the same thing, that he’ll just keep moving forward until he’s killed all his enemies. In a way, the revelation at the end of Season 3 was the ultimate betrayal: this whole time, Eren’s been fighting to save humanity, and now he discovers that not only is humanity thriving, most see THEM as the threat. He’s done being idealistic, he’s done being betrayed, and he’s going to keep HIS humanity safe no matter what it takes, no matter how many he has to kill, no matter what he has to become.
100 years later. The day when the walls fell and humanity could indeed be destroyed by the Titans, but this is shown by the other side. Isayama is a genius!
If this was the live version of this event with this music I would have had a heart attack. I already had an overload just watching it, but the music to boot would have been overwhelming.
Always gonna agree that the original is best suited for this scene, but I’ve seen quite a few edits with this song and this one is by far the best made. Well done
I've seen a lot of these fan edits and the thing that most of them have in common is that they think just because the scene fits the timing of events of their favorite song, it's only natural that it should have been edited that way. But it doesn't work that way. The lyrics and tone of this song are about overcoming adversity and triumph. You could make the argument that this is exactly what is happening in the scene, and I would whole heartedly agree IF we hadn't spent the ENTIRE first part of the season watching Erin turn into a monster. All of the episodes leading up to this moment are meant to make you question Erin's motives, methods, and your idea of who he is. The entire show, Erin has wanted to be the typical Shonen hero that believes in the power of friendship and believing in yourself and every time he tried to do this, he was met with betrayal and bitter disappointment in reality. As a result, he's no longer the hero, he's the omen and the creator of the series wants the audience to know that Erin's actions are objectively wrong. Using songs of triumph in a moments like this would cause a disconnect. But the foreboding horns of the actual song they used fits because it signals the beginning of the end. It heralds in the final act and cements in the audience's mind that Erin has started down a dark path that he can't return from and that no one should ever follow.
i disagree with this part "overcoming adversity and triumph", what i see when i hear this song is someone betraying people they got to known as friends up to this point, This song got played when Reiner and Bertholdt betrayed the scouts/island, That is the reason to why this music fits this scene
@@alar_xSeems like you only interpret it that way because of the scene in question you think about when listening to the song. Overall, general interpretations of the lyrics and the message revolves around overcoming challenges and adversities; and facing them head on without giving up - no matter how difficult it may be. Again, this is General interpretation. Perhaps, the director and producers shine a different light on it. However; it definitely isn't just about betrayal. I mean, the song played when Eren's mom got eaten. I highly doubt you thought about betrayal when watching it. So, while I love this song and I wouldn't mind them just shoving it in for the sake of fan service. It doesn't necessarily fit with what the narrative has been leading up too. It's no longer about a black and white world where you're fighting the bad guys. It's about a world desperate for security, peace, and freedom. Where people are just people. The world has become grey. The scene portrays a form of judgement day, Armageddon, the end times, Ragnarok. A prophesied telling of the end of the world. The song really doesn't fit into that narrative.
The fact that they’re were thousands of colossal titans in the walls for all those centuries is absolutely just crazy. I trip on how they’re just in there all that time, and hidden.
Great work on this! Although I prefer the original OST, you did a really damn good job of fitting the right scenes with the OST to give it the proper sense of emotional weight.
Don't get me wrong or something, but this song was made for the *"Colossal and Armored titan reveal"* . So using it for every epic scene ruins it. Even though this scene is insane and epic.. I think that *"Footsteps of Doom"* fits it in a good way..
yeah of course its sounds dope and looks nice together, but as everyone knows. if this song were used for all the scenes over and over than it would just get old
0:03 (Ore wa ōke no chiwohiku-shada)=(I'm of royal blood) Zeke 1:03 (Gabiiiii) Reiner 1:13 (Song part) Singer All of them are insane, when everything is moving to end that's sounds of last moment
This played during Reiner's review, showing their "betrayal". It kinda hints that the titans that Eren hated and swore to kill... He had now become the monster that is going to "betray" humanity.
![Attack on Titan Season 4 Part 2 BLU-RAY x ORIGINAL CUT | RUMBLING ARRIVES AT MARLEY [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bPpFPOmE4fc/mqdefault.jpg)
Honestly, this is too epic for this scene. The one they got from the original episode suits the morbid, macabre of the scene, and for what's awaiting humanity next....
Yeah but for the last part of the song i think the epic tone fits eren transforming. I would delete Ymir's part music and put it on the part where the lighting begins
Tbh i feel like its supposed to be epic and morbid. We are seeing the erens biggest and terrying form with basically colossal titans around him. i think there could be a better ost tho. but the original kinda didnt get the mark either. so this edit and the ost dont have the full effect on whats happening here. And that sucks.
@@misa8286 I agree with you
Get rumbled stay humble
@@misa8286 I think into the night by yamamoto could’ve fit really well in this scene or Vogel
0:57 CHILLS running down my spine
Plot twist: The wormy thing is running down your spine
*Virgil proceeds to commit mass genocide*
@@HOUnse xd
@@HOUnse lololol,..
Become mindless titan with weird face and funny walking
@HOUnse it's a hallucigenia
why is this the BEST OST we have at our disposal for every major scene?!
Something to do with the average IQ of a normal AoT fan being colder than ice.
What is the name of this song ?
@@ThePaganj43 youseebiggirl.... it's in the title....
@@aceoffours9354How can IQ be cold ☠️
@@mffthefrog1307 You're a perfect example of it.
They shouldve put youseebiggirl on a constant loop for the entire series
Like when reiner is buying food for falco and gabi at the festival 💀
Sasha eating while a FUCKING ORCHESTRA IS SINGING IN THE BACK
"You see big girl" has another meaning now.
Imagine a fat sasha.
te la has sacado nene
Shut upsito @@xxllight
Aot fans when youseebiggirl isn’t in every single scene
Me
Aot fans when they don't see a big girl
They didnt use it at all in s4
@@lukegzero98good
@@Cooprthjok
This is a great example that you see big girl goes with everything, even with the rumbling.
It just doesn't fit with this though it's too epic. It's meant for you to understand that doom is on its way not the hero has made an epic power up
@@juicy5251 I mean, Eren HAS made an epic power up. One that fits him for specifically the Rumbling, and what shall unfold upon humanity. Be it grace, chaos, loyalty, or destruction.
People are pairing the song with Sasha eating a potato like "omg they go so well together!"
ESPECIALLY the rumbling
@@juicy5251I like this better than the music that actually played during the scene :p
This is PERFECT, exactly what I was looking for. The best I've watched!
Check my channel ;)
The way you made the music fit with the movements, makes the start of the Rumbling even more Dramatic, Badass and Scary
The original still suits this scene more...but this..this is masterpiece lol the other channel who did this didnt fit the timing of song with what happened but this one does. Good job love this!
@@musicvideoedits3394 You deserve more views for this! The transition of song with each scene was perfect 👏🏻
stop forcing it dude this is wayy better
@@swat4751 this is not better than the original
@@swat4751 it’s not
@@swat4751 yeah, is not.
i love how u made it such a way that the music fitted perfectly for each scene
nothing will ever top this show man
This scene is perfect with this track. It's Eren's most heroic moment for me.
HEROIC?? BRO IS LEGIT GONNA KILL 80% OF THE POPULATION CUH
How is this heroic, he’s about to slaughter billions of innocents 💀
@@ASkeleton-fy2ir Governments get their power from the people, silent complacentcy isnt the same as being innocent. also basically every citizen of the other countries also wants to genocide eldians
Who cares? @@ASkeleton-fy2ir
@@NoU-pf8fc This is a youtube comment section, sir. I don’t need someone to “care.”
This is EXACTLY how I imagined this. Great job, honestly
The editing is so perfect!!
0:57 this scene and song make me goosebumps. #erenforever
I smile, Cry and Angry at the same time while watching this
Armoured titan running in like they the mc 💀
0:57 literally felt that in my bones
0:57 YOU CAN FEEL THE HYPE OF THE TRANSFORMATION AND THE VOICE 🔥💀🔥💀
someone once said "think big, do big" Eren took it to whole another level
Eren's transformation is a great example of me waking up from sleep 🥶👌
fun fact it would take like 20 years to cover the earth with the rumbling, and you could easily just move out of the way to the side ahead of time of the relatively short line of titans mowing the lawn back and forth, and come back in behind them. You'd lose buildings but not that many people.
I love YouSeeBigGirl, but Footsteps of Doom was the perfect track for this scene
I would never replace it
To me, I associate it too much with the Reiner & Berthold scene in Warrior
But I think we can all agree that the Attack on Titan OST is goated
Wait it actually fits. 💫🔥
Of course u cant just simply put you see big girl over every epic scene in AoT but to be fair it of course also works here and enhances this scene a lot. I think u gave the rumbling a lot more punch through your editing, it's the first time I got some chills from it and it put a smile on my face. So nice work. Thank you. :)
@Rando Viewer aot fans complaining about ashes of fire being overused then proceeding to put youseebiggirl over literally every scene
A lot of people are saying the original music fits the tone better, and while I agree that it worked VERY well, I do feel like this one is more appropriate than it seems. To me, this song is about regret. Hard choices, betrayal, wishing things could have gone differently. It plays when Ymir transforms for the first time, throwing away the life she had built for a chance to save the girl she loves. It plays when Reiner and Bertholdt are revealed, returning to Marley - despite everything it’s done to them - because they can’t conceive of anything else.
This one also shares some parts of ‘Vogel im Käfig’ from the first season, which has its own aura of loss and regret: It plays over Carla’s death, giving up her own life so her children will have a chance. Eren’s first transformation, becoming the thing he hates more than anything. The deaths of Levi’s squad, which Eren sees as happening because he decided not to fight.
What I’m saying is despite the tone, this doesn’t feel like a song of triumph. It feels like Eren’s final decision, coming back to the idea mentioned so often throughout Season 1, the idea Eren’s been fighting against the entire show: that to fight monsters, you have to become one yourself. In his conversation with Reiner under Liberio (at least in the dubs), he describes the Warriors as ‘trying to save the world’ and declares that he’s doing the same thing, that he’ll just keep moving forward until he’s killed all his enemies. In a way, the revelation at the end of Season 3 was the ultimate betrayal: this whole time, Eren’s been fighting to save humanity, and now he discovers that not only is humanity thriving, most see THEM as the threat. He’s done being idealistic, he’s done being betrayed, and he’s going to keep HIS humanity safe no matter what it takes, no matter how many he has to kill, no matter what he has to become.
What a great point
Yup, the people who are saying the original is better are the same idiots who are emotionally stunted enough to like the ending.
Dayum
Ehhh the original fits the theme of "the world is fucked" vibes which was the entire point of the rumbling.
honestly this theme is waayyy to epic and heroic for the rumbling. the rumbling isnt something meant to be praised
Damn you did it perfectly man! Props to you! I got goosebumps 🥺 make one again with the rumbling at marley someday 😎
Thanks buddy🧡........yeah sure i will when its out
@@musicvideoedits3394pls
DAMN MAN THIS IS EPIC, the real sound of this scene is depressing, this one is hyping
MAN, THANKU FOR THIS
The og song is already incredible, this made the scene 10x better
Are you stupid
i came here from your comment. i'm not mad tho, it was really well done
DIO tryna stop his bro from getting the founding titan, lol.
0:57 Why does it look like the founding titan is singing this part
100 years later. The day when the walls fell and humanity could indeed be destroyed by the Titans, but this is shown by the other side. Isayama is a genius!
0:18 this edit made me perfect 😢😢❤❤
This time the betrayal was real! Totally love how the walls fall down, one of the most spectacular moments in anime history!
If this was the live version of this event with this music I would have had a heart attack. I already had an overload just watching it, but the music to boot would have been overwhelming.
Dude, this anime is just INSANE. I ve watched many animes in my life, but AOT is very different.
I love how the song drop is exactly on queue with when eren shifts into the founding titan
Attack on Titan would've killed too many people with coolness if this song was used for all of the moments that we wanted it over.
Always gonna agree that the original is best suited for this scene, but I’ve seen quite a few edits with this song and this one is by far the best made. Well done
Bro actually good job, u deserve more views and subs
if only they added this music in those moment... i would actually have a heart attack
Thats why they dont
Are you stupid or is this song the only music you’ve ever heard
This is really well made
Zeke: I command you!
Eren: may I have one rumbling pls? I feel your pain.
Ymir: ok.
I’m sorry no matter how good this is I keep imagining the music playing when Eren is in his transformation and saitama just punches him dead 👀
Really I got goosebumps when I saw it and it chills everytime❤ aot is one of my favourite animes
0:33 perfect
I've seen a lot of these fan edits and the thing that most of them have in common is that they think just because the scene fits the timing of events of their favorite song, it's only natural that it should have been edited that way. But it doesn't work that way.
The lyrics and tone of this song are about overcoming adversity and triumph. You could make the argument that this is exactly what is happening in the scene, and I would whole heartedly agree IF we hadn't spent the ENTIRE first part of the season watching Erin turn into a monster. All of the episodes leading up to this moment are meant to make you question Erin's motives, methods, and your idea of who he is. The entire show, Erin has wanted to be the typical Shonen hero that believes in the power of friendship and believing in yourself and every time he tried to do this, he was met with betrayal and bitter disappointment in reality. As a result, he's no longer the hero, he's the omen and the creator of the series wants the audience to know that Erin's actions are objectively wrong. Using songs of triumph in a moments like this would cause a disconnect. But the foreboding horns of the actual song they used fits because it signals the beginning of the end. It heralds in the final act and cements in the audience's mind that Erin has started down a dark path that he can't return from and that no one should ever follow.
i disagree with this part "overcoming adversity and triumph", what i see when i hear this song is someone betraying people they got to known as friends up to this point, This song got played when Reiner and Bertholdt betrayed the scouts/island, That is the reason to why this music fits this scene
@@alar_xSeems like you only interpret it that way because of the scene in question you think about when listening to the song.
Overall, general interpretations of the lyrics and the message revolves around overcoming challenges and adversities; and facing them head on without giving up - no matter how difficult it may be. Again, this is General interpretation. Perhaps, the director and producers shine a different light on it.
However; it definitely isn't just about betrayal. I mean, the song played when Eren's mom got eaten. I highly doubt you thought about betrayal when watching it.
So, while I love this song and I wouldn't mind them just shoving it in for the sake of fan service. It doesn't necessarily fit with what the narrative has been leading up too. It's no longer about a black and white world where you're fighting the bad guys. It's about a world desperate for security, peace, and freedom. Where people are just people. The world has become grey. The scene portrays a form of judgement day, Armageddon, the end times, Ragnarok. A prophesied telling of the end of the world. The song really doesn't fit into that narrative.
I stopped reading when i read "Erin"
Yes i would say the same..this scene is too epic with masterpiece soundtracks ..truly great anime
Eren gave up the world and himself for his friends and love.
This suits it if you are a Yaegerist.
Which I’m
Youseebiggirl has always been about the feeling of betrayal. While I like footsteps of doom I think it fits well with this moment.
The most epic and horrifying scene I ever saw in my life
This is honestly an extrodinary episode oh my. Eren's transformation gave me chills bro 🥶
1:39 is my favorite shot in the whole anime
dude even the percussion at the end compliments to rumbling
This song is ATTACK ON TITAN and ATTACK ON TITAN is this song!!!!
Ultimate....fantastic.....goosebumps......now words ❤❤❤
comeback😈
Here before this blows up
:)
how does this masterpiece doesn’t have million views already
Most badass moment in entire AOT history😍
YouseeBigGirl is one of the greatest compsitions I've heard.
The fact that they’re were thousands of colossal titans in the walls for all those centuries is absolutely just crazy. I trip on how they’re just in there all that time, and hidden.
This music makes everything perfect
The background music is just🔥
The theme that was gonna be used if Eren just used the wall of Shiganshina:
This is so synced man! Just perfect
By now I already forgot the original scene. If it's not for the title, I won't know that this is edited. Good work
Mesmerized would be an understatement.
This ost put over this scene makes it feel like the older episodes which included this ost, nice
THIS IS PERFECT MAN🔥🔥🔥
Gabi single handedly ended the world.
1:09
Great work on this! Although I prefer the original OST, you did a really damn good job of fitting the right scenes with the OST to give it the proper sense of emotional weight.
1:04 This is the first time I hear Reiner's giant voice.
~Gabiiii
Goosebumps ON TOP of goosebumps!
anime is a feeling which you cannot comprehend
Don't get me wrong or something, but this song was made for the *"Colossal and Armored titan reveal"* . So using it for every epic scene ruins it. Even though this scene is insane and epic.. I think that *"Footsteps of Doom"* fits it in a good way..
This literally have me chills. This is what been missing from Mappa's adaptation
Gat damn is impossible not to get goosebumps with this video
yeah of course its sounds dope and looks nice together, but as everyone knows. if this song were used for all the scenes over and over than it would just get old
This ost seems more heroic to listen whereas ost used for scene seems more villainous befitting eren current character.
omg that's perfect the sound begin and the end of the song all is perfect now I want this xD 😆 gg for ur work
Your editing is perfect but i like original theme because it has terror like theme and it suit well in eren scary face which was shown at end
Aot fans want this ost cover on every important scene...and i agree with all of them
0:03 (Ore wa ōke no chiwohiku-shada)=(I'm of royal blood) Zeke
1:03 (Gabiiiii) Reiner
1:13 (Song part) Singer
All of them are insane, when everything is moving to end that's sounds of last moment
It is my favorite anime 😍 cool
i hope we'll get to hear this soundtrack one last time on screen before the story ends.
u are choosen 1... i newer see this ..... no comment who ever edit this is legend
JUST WHAT I WANTED THANKS
0:57 my favorite
This is so baddass, the shows one also well done but this OST just makes it so much better!🔥💯🙏🏿👏🏿
Holy shit this scene with this music
This played during Reiner's review, showing their "betrayal". It kinda hints that the titans that Eren hated and swore to kill... He had now become the monster that is going to "betray" humanity.
looks very epic with music.
I see perfection in it 👀
The song would have fit very well if the wall titans releasing mean't victory instead of certain death for 1.6 billion people
HOW IS IT LINED UP SO WELL TO THE BEAT
Here after first rewatch...Hisayama...what did you create ?!?!? WHO ARE YOU