Engineering in movies be like
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ม.ค. 2022
- Visit brilliant.org/ZachStar/ to get started learning STEM for free, and the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual premium subscription.
STEMerch Store: stemerch.com/
Trivial shirt: stemerch.com/collections/trivial
Support the Channel: / zachstar
PayPal(one time donation): www.paypal.me/ZachStarYT
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @zachstar
►Follow me
Instagram: / zachstar
Twitter: / imzachstar
2D Graphing Software: www.desmos.com/calculator
Animations: Arkam Khan (For contact info go to www.arqum333.com/)
Check out my Spanish channel here: / zach star en español
►My Setup:
Space Pictures: amzn.to/2CC4Kqj
Magnetic Floating Globe: amzn.to/2VgPdn0
Camera: amzn.to/2RivYu5
Mic: amzn.to/35bKiri
Tripod: amzn.to/2RgMTNL
Equilibrium Tube: amzn.to/2SowDrh
►Check out my Amazon Store: www.amazon.com/shop/zachstar
![ความรักของยักษ์เขียว (ทศกัณฐ์) - เดี่ยว ไออุ่น [OFFICIAL MUSICVIDEO 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yCCy-QVHqK8/mqdefault.jpg)
The real genius here is the guy who thought of a way to save his golden fish using a _fucking_ Dyson's sphere
It’s simple really, why else would it take him 5 seconds to do it
Or the person who wants it for some other reason, the goldfish is a lie.
Join us next week when we create a alien s gravity drive spacecraft to walk the dog.
I mean with that much energy at your disposal, it might end up being a trivial matter.
@@RaynDBU Don't say "It's simple really" u have to say "It's elementary really"
Alternative title: 7 seasons of the Flash summed up ... xD
Kind of tough to tell, but the background of this video that I photoshopped myself into is Star labs. Thought of this video idea while watching the flash.
Yea I noticed the back ground is STAR labs
Lol
@@icandothisallday986 I'mma be honest: I didn't notice the background. It's just the first thing that came to my mind, which is just sad for a show that could have been amazing, lol.
The Flash is just a show of a couple of guys saying random yet complicated words based on random yet sometimes wrong math, inventing some stuff in a minimal amount of time by no more than a handful of people with no testing needed as it always works perfectly on the first attempt.
@@zachstar oh my god yes it is ahha, genius!
Wait, you forgot the hundreds of millions of lines of code that executes perfectly on first run without a single missing semicolon! Not that it ever stopped Tony Stark though.
And he slapped the project together in 5mins.
@@resphantom From a box of scraps!
@@CLove511 after three days of starvation
That's coz it was a scripting language, silly
@@RamkrishanYT Tony codes with HTML confirmed
Physics in movies:
The exact same thing, but instead of the hammering sounds and tool, its a pencil (either in hand or behind the ear or both or both ears or all of them) and the physisist character starring intensly at a CGI moebius strip floating over the table and it glows blue (the glow is of course CGI too). Also the character makes minecraft villager noises for 20 secounds and has then solved the problem.
Sidenote: You know its a movie with high budget, if the moebius strip is also slowly rotating during the scene.
I can’t pinpoint exactly which movie it is but I know that scene involves Tony Stark with his daughter sitting on the steps close to him and then he accidentally cursed in front of her
@@coleabrahams9331 endgame
oh plus the constant usage of the word "quantum" and "particle"
@@ehsaanyousef2273 I see you're a man of culture. ':D
Aka iron man
I'm crying every time I see he rotates the wrench around the axis of his hand instead of it's tip. That's never been done before. He's a real engineer there
Oh god I can't unsee it now
@@SoumilSahu me neither. My eyes are blessed and cursed by this legendary engineer
I don’t think you’ve ever tried to mime using a wrench on nothing. You’d do it like that too.
@@derekeastman7771 Tried it. There is definitely some drift of the tip that isn't supposed to be there, but it is nowhere near as pronounced. It'll also become less and less noticeable as you increase the size of the wrench
its*
Yeah it's kind of stupid when you actually know what they're doing. I rewatched Iron Man now knowing mechanical/electrical engineering and oh boy, I didn't remember it being this funny.
Kinda funny how iron man isn't even close to being the worst offender
Well, they got the "build, fail, fix repeat" part right.
And the fact engineers use soldering irons, sometimes.
Just like when u work in the medical and u watch a serie with doctors and nurses prescribing medication that would kill the patient in real life lol
And then there's being a physics man and seeing a movie/book/whatever throw out absolute nonsense stuff
Engineers are paid more as compensation for never enjoying a science fiction or action movie again
That engineer should be a billionare for solving the world's problems.
He can't for plot related reasons, he will need to be saved from evil AI by the protagonist.
Only to the untrained eye
i think he should be given 3 nobel peace prizes for saving goldie
Should be, but soon progressive politicians will state that time travel machines are a human right.
You mean elon?
You forgot the part where the main character has to go through a dangerous mission so he can get 1 certain material that is crucial to building the time machine
and it's on top of a volcano, in a cave, right above the lose ledge that's in front of a cliff. also the main character always starts the journey form the wrong end to make sure he has to face all the natural obstructions instead of taking the easy route.
@@RKBock and don't forget the main character needs to be accompanied by at least one, preferably two sidekicks. One that is strong but simple who will be useful at first but fie somewhere around the middle in a noble yet easily avoidable sacrifice so that everyone realizes how dangerous the trip really is. And the second one will reveal to be a traitor, saying stuff like "our friend died for this and all you're gonna do with it is saying a damn goldfish". Then, they will die after some form of redemption and the main character will come out of the experience more mature. Until the next movie / episode where they'll start right back to square one and those who died will probably never be mentionned again
@@docomega7862 Don't they usually come back to life tho?
@@akiraigarashi2874 Nah they all get their shitty spin-offs nowadays since they miraculously survive their noble sacrifice somehow
Engineer: "We only have two minutes"
Guy: "I'll just use the time machine, to ask for the Dyson sphere a few minutes earlier, is 5 minutes enough?"
Engineer: "Make it 6 just to be safe"
Not any longer though.
I wouldn't risk any more than six minutes.
@@invenblocker Clank?!
Genius
Oh, sorry, i build a one-use-only time-machine....... you didn't ask for one that can be used multiple times.
The scissors making drill noise killed me lol
They're only scissors to the untrained eye.
@@danielhobbyist but wrap your hand around the bottom and they become...
A drill
So on-point for many movies' sound designs which tend to go for what sounds cool or is expected, rather than realistic....
"Physics of the every day"
*proceeds to talk about dyson spheres
@misyah s begone
It would be a every day item
Virgin dyson sphere vs Chad Dyson Swarm
You don't use dyson sphere on daily basis?
@@sadsader100yearsago9 lol imagine using dyson sphere
creates a transformational technology that shifts the paradigm of engineering development and pushes human civilization into a new age
forgets about it after stopping bad guy
Right. In the flash they literally create a way to go into a different universe and forget about it
They made a time machine in avengers endgame. No one use it anymore!
@@billytanadi8303 that could atleast be explained in that Stark wanted nobody to exploit this power after returning the stones. In the Flash, they literally don't mention useful stuff later.
@@rudrodeepchatterjee I prefer to think that fighting someone who could time travel (Kang), everyone agreed that using time travel against time travel is dangerous. But they never mentioned anything soooo we're left with no explanation
@@billytanadi8303 in the real world "it's too dangerous !" rarely seems to prevent people from using dangerous technologies to gain more [power, wealth, insert your villain's motivation, etc.]
Actually the engineer has long ago realized that his friend only needs the power of belief to warp reality. All he has to do is make the feather.
Reminds me of Norse mythological weapons, Gleipnir which was an enchanted rope that is tied around Fenrir. Apparently the dwarfs that made the rope required 6 impossible ingredients to make it. The ingredients was:
- The sound of a cat's footfall
- The beard of a woman
- The roots of a mountain
- The sinews of a bear
- The breath of a fish
- The spittle of a bird
@@resphantom
Those aren't impossible though, atleast not with modern technology. The only thing we could synthesize material to make the rope from though would be the mountain roots and bear sinews. Fish's breath though is more a maybe but cat's foot fall is useless as I don't see any need for any subsonic vibration adding anything to the mix, and a woman's beard is pretty much a given it would work as the bonding agent for the structure.
@@guytheincognito4186 xD If only
Ork in Warhammer be like
@@guytheincognito4186 mountains don't have roots my dude
Love how he's wearing a shirt that's says trivial while making a time machine
I could totally invent all this stuff, but I like to avoid the trouble by not having friends to ask for them.
pathetic.
@@AlexandrBorschchev
Indeed. I invented all these things twice over then solved the grandfather paradox by boning someone else because grandma wasn't hot enough, killing myself twice to stop my inventions from happening, due to ruling the world is overrated and way boring. All I got stuck with going back to my present was to extra families apart from my own with claimed blood relation to me. I solved that problem in the present by murdering all of them and burning all documentation of their existence up to my grandma.
hey could you build me a dyson sphere?.... *AS A FRIEND?*
Hey can you build me a comically large spoon
But it must be sentient AI
Can you build me a a throwing knifes that always hits its target and then teleports into my pocket?
Me: I need a laptop that can run 120 frames per second and 4k graphics and won’t overheat
Engineer: It’s never been done before
Me: Please, it’s the only way I can play Cyberpunk 2077 without major issues
Engineer: How about a time machine instead?
I want to like this comment, but it has 69 like, so I'll just comment instead.
@@luiscuellar685 how else is it getting 77 likes?
don't forget that the fans have to run completely silent
@@PikachuComments someone has sacrificed itself to go further beyond
Listen, as a computer engineering student, either play in 4k or at 120 fps
the fact that there was a time limit to build the dyson sphere as if he didn't literally just build a time machine lol
This is SO accurate. It's always as if the problem was the literal BUILDING of it and not the entire concept _of the collective brain of all science did not yet figure out how to do this, how is saving your brother's life changing this at all?_
hey man using the wrench the way he did required some serious level of skill idk, that seems like the hard part to me
The funny thing is, both planes and helicopters were built before the means of how they work were discovered. In fact, I think we still don't know why helicopters work (I mean we do, it beats the air into submission, which shouldn't work, but it does)
@@hiomanthis sounds like some ‘bumblebees should not be able to fly’ bullshit.
@@ryonalionthunder it is
@@hioman
So it’s not true then. K.
Needed the sound effect of an air wrench removing lug nuts from a car. Maybe a little smoke from the soldering iron (used to put the smoke into an electrical device to make it work).
Yes because smoke is the one thing that is necessary for any electrical device to work.
@@PhilippeCarphin are you telling me my electronics aren’t supposed to be smoking?
@@sirshotty7689 Think about it, when the smoke leaves the device it stops working.
@@PhilippeCarphin what does that have to do with my laptop having a rampant tobacco addiction?
@@sirshotty7689 One of the components might have lost its smoke and the laptop is trying to get it back.
That seemed like flash
@misyah s Shut
Just a reminder, just do not reply to the bot. It's better to report the bot. Just press the Report Button and tap the "Child Abuse" option.
@@NathanRio79 lmfaooo child abuse
he used it with that spoon thing
@@NathanRio79 Yeah good point. I reported, but I like to reply anyway. TH-cam doesn’t do shit.
People joke about the trope of:
Boss: "We need X"
Engineer: "I need Y time"
Boss: "You have Z time"
But like when has management ever set reasonable goals for production? Scale back expectations and move the goalposts go brrrrrr.
Right? I'm working on a project right now where we told management it would probably take two years. They said they wanted it done in six months.
Anyway, a year and a half later, we're getting close to finishing.
That's management for you. "I can get that done by next week."
"If I wanted it next week I would have asked you next week."
that’s usually the most realistic part of the plot !
That's why we always *grossly* exaggerate Y. That way, when it gets cut in half or whatever, it's still hopefully enough. Occasionally that strategy actually works...
(Note: I'm assuming that Z < Y.)
Geordi: Yeah, well, I told the Captain I'd have this analysis done in an hour.
Scotty: How long would it really take?
Geordi: An hour.
Scotty: Oh, you didn't tell him how long it would really take, did you?
Geordi: Well of course I did.
Scotty: Oh, laddie, you have a lot to learn if you want people to think of you as a miracle worker!
- Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Relics"
The biggest joke in this sketch is Brilliant's physics of the everyday containing a lesson on Dyson spheres.
they have everything
When your electric goldfish with a power requirement of 38 Yottawatts is running out of battery and the only way to charge it is by building a dyson sphere by shooting your bed with a shotgun to summon some scotch tape
🤣 I am now experiencing cardiac arrest from laughing
The way they use time travel in the movies, its like an ancient Greek story of someone who could move stars around, and used it to communicate to people halfway across the mediteranian.
Congratulations on million subscribers! You deserved it
He deserved it? So he doesn't deserve it anymore?
@@Martin-jp8pw no. Now he deserves 2 millions.
The sponsor shift is always so damn smooth.. Superconductivity !
man's is truly outstanding
Antagonist: This trap is inescapable. There is no physcal way to find your way out.
Protagonist: You fool! Remember that paperclip you dropped 3 seasons ago? I put that in my pocket for no reason, but it seems that it was actually a very good decision. How convenient that there also happens to be a sticky note on the floor! With these materials, I have engineered a lockpicking device!
lockpickinglawyer
@@byte7645 Every lock that can't be opened in a movie.
LPL ruined them all.
One more time to show it wasn't a fluke.
LPL ruined them all.
@@byte7645 beat me to it.
Sounds more like one of the original MvGyver episodes... LPL would introduce and describe the lock before making the manufacturer cry.
Imagine if this trope was deconstructed. Like the engineer just said: “I can’t help you with that. You need to move on, live life for your sake. Don’t be caught up in the past.” Would honestly be a pretty interesting take on all this.
0:27 He was cutting the fabric of time with those scissors.
I'm going to need a funny, overplayed, exaggerated sketch about engineering in movies.
It's never been done before.
I'll need 4 minutes and 44 seconds
Blow torch noises intensifies
1:52 The most impressive part of this video has to be that he already patented it.
He built the time machine remember. So he had the patent by the time he finished building it.
2:30 wait that actually was way more creative than most movies.
It’s true I did this in a movie once
are you an engineer ?
It’s true, I was the movie
@@johnsoapmactavish9921 lmao
@@johnsoapmactavish9921 It is true, I was I.
Is this weird that this is one of the reason I am doing engineering??😂
Yes, they said to aim for the stars but this is too high
If you mean that your fish is about to die then kind of .
That you want to do these things or that you hate seeing this in movies?
@@BrooklyFire well building dyson spheres is literally aiming for the stars
No, inspiration is key.
Literally every sci Fi movie and episode of McGuyver and Scorpion🤣
Hey now, half the stuff in McGyver actually works irl. And he's not exactly doing things that have never been done before. He's doing things that have been done many times and are well understood, but without the proper tools or materials.
Old McGuyver is very plausible, just convenient and absurd that he knows all that right stuff for what he does. If your talking about the new version of McGuyver, then yes that is almost entirely bull crap, but somehow the other characters are even more absurdly in their abilities.
Scorpion at least gets the principles right even though the scale is often completely wrong, they never have enough time for what they are doing, and they use hand tools for something that should take an assembly line.
2:53 Dude(s), you have a time machine.
still, better plot consistency than A LOT of scy fi movies
Love the fact that the background is Star labs :D too accurate.
The unchanged backing track despite the continuous change in tools makes this 10x more accurate
Even with my untrained eye, this is a Masterpiece🔥.
This video came in perfect timing.
Because last night I had a dream where I used a time machine and I traveled back to 2014 telling my earlier self to stop gaming and apply myself
Imagine being worried about the time limit when you just made a time machine lmao
Nailed it! Even includes product placement like a real movie!
I loved it damn top humor!
Hug from Portugal 🇵🇹
Looks like my dude is also an engineer from the movies. Can I use your time machine please.
"We only have 2 minutes
until goldy is dead"
Lets just forget about our
LITERAL TIME MACHINE
imagine traveling to another wold **and** eating cereal at the same time
humanity is not ready for this kind of innovation...
Can we talk about how good that advertisement Segway was? I'm genuinely willing to listen to the advertisement just because of how smooth that was.
"ZACH STAR BUILT HIS TH-cam CHANNEL IN A CAVE WITH A BOX OF SCRAPS!"
The best part of building a time machine is that it doesn't matter how long it takes you to build it.
This was so interesting to watch - would love a part 2 and 3
I need you to build me a death star capable of wiping out the core worlds in one salvo
But also give it the ability to reload, encase we forget to target the dessert planet with the only character that is allowed to beat us.
Have any of you seen “The Vault”? Because there is no movie that so blatantly ignore physics like that movie to try and make the plot interesting. You’d think if the movie was based around a genius engineer breaching a safe, and his innovative ways, they could at least consult with someone with a high school physics credit.
No, but i thought you were talking about a different movie where a safecracker puts his ear to the door, makes some distorted faces and fantasizes how the lock works (que animation) (and then just uses the numbers provided to him by the script). Don't recall the name of the movie but the safecracker was nerdier than "the good doctor".
Now I think the building of the devices needed a montage with more jump cuts with you in different positions every time. Thes would include one with you pointing to the upper left corner of the shot, one of you frowning while standing with your hands on your hips, the thoughtful pose, the eureka moment, etc. Of course, if you wanted to be fancy you could have translucent mathematical symbols floating in various directions. This video is entertaining and gets that creative spark really flowing.
And not once did he dive under the table to work at something in a very awkward position......
they really do just be beatin rocks together and attributing EVERYTHING to quantum mechanics or positron things
I really like watching the ones where the person makes something very complicated out of random things that just happen to be around and it works perfectly the first time (all during a time crunch). Also brilliant has a lot more fascinating courses than I thought, might have to go check them out
Reminds me of Tony Stark building an Iron Man suit AND solving the worlds energy problem with a device smaller than a dish, in some ill equipped terrorist lair
I like how a mainframe computer breaking was shown as a card sorter spitting cards onto the floor.
lmao I love how you need 3min for a dyson sphere, but you have no idea how much time you need to build a spoon :D also your transitions into adds are Michael Jackson levels of smooth
1:00 That'd create a grandfather paradox. If the brother is alive, the main character would never tell the engineer to build the time machine, meaning that the brother would die.
Bold of you to assume that logic exists there
There is no grandfather paradox. If you go back in time on may,17, 2023 to May, 16, 2023, you have experienced two different days that had the same name. The first May, 17 (or 16), 2023 is different from the second May, 17 (or 16), 2023 (as every day is different from the other ones).
Plot armor fixes that paradox
Congrats on 1 million subs! Deserved beyond belief.
This channel has some of the best transitions into adverts that I’ve ever seen! They don’t even piss me off.
Looks like the chicken "debate tactic" from "TH-cam debates be like" is actually a genius engineering strategy
The fact that you are wearing a shirt that says "Trivial" just adds so much lmao.
4:15
I was expecting him to say "One minute left..."
Loved how you managed to give us an ad with my untrained eye noticing it.
What a lucky Goldfish to have a very kind owner.
Btw congrats for 1 million subscribers!! 🥰🥰🥰
This was so crazy 🤣🤣🤣I enjoyed every minute.
“Only to the untrained eye” Why is this so relatable? 😂
Bruh that transition to the ad, I'm not even mad, it's amazing
2:57 Meme material right there
3:04 too
I'd be very motivated to be an engineer if I could build something that would break the laws of physics. Lmao.
Zach is a master at seamlessly integrating sponsorships into his sketches. Flawless execution!
4:29 " But hey. It's just a sphere. A DYSON SPHERE! Thanks for watching!"
You got me to not skip a sponsored segment. Good job lol.
I like how there is no time paradoxes. So accurate to the shows. There should be a paradox. Think about it. He tells the guy to make a time machine to save his brother. However when he comes back to the present his brother doesn’t die so he never confronts the engineer about making a time machine. But the time machine has to exist for his brother to be saved.
There's no such thing as a time paradox in that sense, as time doesn't loop backward retroactively (The time effects in Looper were pure garbage for that reason). It's always moving forward to the reality caused by the actions of the past.
The machine was created in his past, and he travels forward to a new future, the only issue is that the engineer wouldn't have known him or why he was there, but he's either in a new dimension or a locally-modified version of our dimension.
I prefer to think of it like loading an old save but you keep your character's progress for some reason, and overwrite your later saves where your character actually gained that progress.
The main character: "We don't have time!"
Also the main character: Has a literal time machine
BRILLIANT! As always.
This was truly brilliant!
Speaking of brilliant, did I tell you about today's sponsor?
It's never been done before!
Proceeds to do it in under 1 minute
Makes me wonder how it was never done before.
you forgot the part when the protagonist kid arrives, wires 2 casual pieces, tightens one screw and boom the machine is working now
I like that you still do videos
This is way too accurate lmao
#1 I always love your stuff. Your humor is as dry as a jar of sand.
#2 I feel this critique extends to so many of the platitudes that pass as potential solutions to enormous real-world problems. "All we need to do in order to solve (world hunger / war / climate change / limited energy / etc.) is to do something that humanity has never come close to doing. Why can't we just all work together?"
We have also never worked togheter effectively before. Time travel and human cooperation are about on the same level of realism
Him building is me in the corner of an engineering lab not knowing what's going on
That brilliant part was continuously smooth.
it would be funny to see what's going on inside the person's head matched with the amount of time that went by along with all the classes they did and hours they put in to get to that thought in the first place
As an student in engineering school rn, can confirm, we are on hammers rn
The hammer is the most useful tool in the shop, change my mind.
Screwdriver / drill
I love how he just adds in the sponsorship to the spoof
That was actually the best brilliant plug ive seen in my life
If only this is what it's like in actual school.
I'm totally the engineer in my life - I am the person who creates dyson spheres, wormholes, etc. for all the companies that I invest in - the only difference is I pay them to have all this fun lol.
Very funny and one of the best ad transitions ive ever seen.
I so badly needed you to be behind a green screen when you did 1:32.. this would've been a perfect STEM meme template
Fake, you didn't even calculate the eigenvalues of a mobius strip
the guy: we only hav 2 minutes to solve this oh no
also the guy: invented time travel machine 50seconds earlier
First video I ever see from this channel. Subscribed for that fantastic sponsored segment and segway.
Man your tool work is next level.
the most unrealistic part isn't that a wormhole generator and a time machine got created without a problem, but that it worked the first time
I did not see the sponsorship pitch coming! Well done! And great video btw 😂
The last level of any engineering system in the films are the Nanomachines - from machine design, electronics, power generation, robotics, etc.
Congrats on 1 million subs Zach you earned it