It was checked. The vernier used was calibrated at Ibrox though. It's a clear conspiracy. The fact that Celtic have only conceded one penalty this season is mere proof that they're trying to hide the conspiracy. Celtic thus should just be handed the 3 points
@@surfnturf7832 Yes thats why VAR is in the game as fans don't often see clash points. I drops down and hits the celtic players with his arm out. The ball hits his outstretched arm which away from the body and he wasn't forced to jump like this. What part of that is not a penalty? Stupid yes but those are the rules as written as what part of out in front of you is in sillouhete or a natural position?
@surfnturf7832 first of all you can hear some fans appealing. Secondly, that's what VAR is for, to spot things that almost everybody has missed - and it was a pen
Celtic fan here. Hearts unlucky not to win 3 nil. Well played Jambos. Rogers is a massive surprise and disappointment. Seems we were spoiled with Ange.
That pen they got was never a penalty. Was a foul to hearts. Unbelievable decision as usual. The refs are jumping at the chance to give them penalties and not to give them against if they’re playing the famous.
Lol so someone you don't know left a generic comment that got u so worked up you're answering said unknown person back 24hrs later?? 😂😂 what point do u lot realise you're no different to crazy people that approach and talk to strangers at the bus stop 😂😂 you're jus arguing with your imagination 😂
i saw the motherwell boss calling it soft too which is weird as his player tackled and made no contact with the ball the textbook definition of a penalty
Brenda crying about the refs lol didnt hear him bring up septic dodgy pen 🤣 😂 as for the red according to brenda when it happned at stmirren " its a stud to the eye , straight red all day " his words 😂😂😂
Hearts 2nd isn't even offside. The lines are angled. You can see that the 18 yeard box line is straight across the screen and the lines are tilted left to right. The distance between line and box at the far end is less than the closer end. Thre penalty wasn't a penalty and should have been a hearts Free kick, and the referee should have been smart enough to know that kicking someone in the face with your studs is a straight red without the VAR check.
@@MrFirefoxCeltic fans are some of the most detestable and pathetic fans on the planet. No wonder they and Liverpool fans love each other so much. I’m a Dortmund fan, and even I hate Celtic and Liverpool fans more than Schalke and Bayern fans
To be fair I wish fans like yourself wouldn't say it. I remember Helicopter Sunday and we are gonna be playing on the Sunday due to our Europa League, they will play on Saturday and will probably go ahead until we play. Long way to go mate, this is going down to the last game
Let’s not get complacent cos we were awful yesterday. If we don’t show every team in the league respect then we will throw away the league to a poor Celtic team.
Rangers fucked up Saturday big time but the hearts did us big favour the day and to be fair they were the better side good game to watch Mon gers for leauge
Anybody saying Hearts shouldn't have got a pen... Are you not noticing it comes off 2 players arms? Iwata might not have known much about his, even then shouldn't have arms flailing about in the box when the balls in the air. But Johnston defo knew about his, he watched the ball come in, took his eye off it, went for the header & completely missed then the ball came off his elbow, on to Iwata's elbow. Can't surely be claiming neither of them were a handball? And anybody saying the red shouldn't be because he was flicking the ball over his head? Nope, that's what he tried to do but made no connection with the ball, the ball comes off the top of Cochranes head, Yang boots his head instead of the ball. If he had got the ball & missed Cochrane, might have been yellow for the high boot, hence why that's what was first given. But once the ref sees no contact was made on the ball & Cochrane got a boot to the face, he has no other choice but red. The same way making contact with the ball matters in most challenges... But Celtic getting a pen for their player barging in & falling over as a result, with no contact made? Absolute shambles of a decision.
Spot on about the handball it clearly hits both of the arms and they are both in unnatural positions not in silhouette so no matter who handled first its a handball as the rules state. The handball rules might be nonsense but they arer applied properly here and not sure why the press seem so adamant it wasn't
Iwata's arm is not in an unnatural position because his own player barges into him in mid-air, so his arm comes out to balance himself. Go over the park with your mates ,jump in the air, and get your mate to push you from behind, and i bet your arms come out. It's a natural human reflex reaction.
@@jaycfc6955 Sooo you decided to totally ignore the point about it coming of 2 players arms? Hit of Johnston's arm before it hit off Iwata's, even if you think Iwata's isn't a pen, Johnston's defo is a pen. And no ref has said it was awarded against Iwata, he wasn't yellow carded for it & everybody has just assumed that it's him because it's the more obvious one... I also notice you've not cried about how your penalty award was much worse? If you're just going to ignore any points made & keep your green tinted specs on, don't bother arguing.
@AD270479 hello mate The cfc in my name is Chelsea Fc , i was born and bred in Chelsea long before the Russian arrived. I didn't say it never hit both players on the arm. My point was that all this unnatural arm position was wrong regarding Iwata due to his own player barging into him in mid-air. And celtics penalty was a disgraceful decision, a blatant barge into the hearts player, then he dives to the ground. How Var never overturned that astounds me. Today's football is not the game I grew up with in the 70's,80's & 90"s.
My wee Irish pal sent me a screenshot of the Rangers result yesterday, i could have sent him two back today if i was that petty. Both his teams got stuffed today.....Celtic & Utd but he wouldn't see the phone screen from all that greetin 🤣😂🤣
i am at a loss he goes in front then falls over because he dove in front its incredible VAR didn't say to the ref have a look. Remember it was adam VAR who hit the penalty off the keepers legs because all that tavernier does is score penalties they are so easy
Whatever happened to extended highlights? Between this and the SPFL official highlights you're lucky to see five minutes of your team a week if you cant go to the games or pay for exorbitant subscriptions for the product you actually get. Football is no longer a game for the people.
I’m not a Celtic fan - but please can we all agree these VAR/officials inconsistencies are ruining the game. It feels after every match we’re all bitter one way or another about decisions that in one game are acceptable and others aren’t.
Aye. In these highlights alone we had a Non-sense Red Card, Non-sense Penalty given to Hearts, a Non-sense Offside against Hearts, and a Non-sense Penalty given to Celtic. Football is deep down the drain.
Completely agree. I wouldn’t have awarded either penalty but there was a case for the Celtic player getting his leg in front and it being taken from under him. The Hearts one was ridiculous though. Especially as it’s gone to VAR. The Celtic player didn’t move unnaturally to the ball as his motion was a result of being pushed, and furthermore the ball wasn’t moving toward goal so he wasn’t blocking a shot. The red card was obscenely bad officiating. Yellow was appropriate for high foot and unintentional contact. It’s encouraging to see underdogs get results against the giants, and then you see how they got them. The Celtic manager has every right to complain. When the VAR official is incapable of officiating without deep seated bias, the whole league becomes a mere theatrical formality. That said, Hearts still had a job to do and executed well but I’ve rarely seen such biased refereeing.
@@lightningtree5432 ok lets dissect this celtic penalty yang puts his leg in front then falls over he initiated the contact no var intervention penalty given 2. yang high boot intention or force are irrelevant to endangering opponents. Kemar roofe was red carded in europe exactly the same foot high going to insitinctively win the ball as soon as it goes head height red card 100% correct decision won't find a referee who says its not 3. hearts penalty drop and hits johnston then iwata. johnston has his hand in front of him, misses his header and hits his outsretched arm remove everyone else stonewall penalty. Drops to hit iwata now if the ref thinks it hasn't hit johnston then its hit iwata in exactly the same position. Handball rules are stupid as written but if not in sillhouette or natural position and it hits your hand its a penalty. It wasn't s short range shot it fell out of the sky from a corner so i can't see the argument here other than that handball rules are dumb as written but VAR enforce the rules not write them I don't like VAR as i think it slows everything down but lose gracefully. We lsot to a good motherwell side it happens where var i thought could have done more but it was on the players. You make excuses blaming others
Brendan blaming everyone else instead of looking on the mirror 😅😅, he through a tantrum at Leicester because they wouldn't just hand him a blank cheque to spend and he'll be leaving Celtic soon because he's an absolute bottler
The spl is a laughing stock. It's pathetic hard 2 watch..with the added religious bigotry..watching highlights is like watching protestants & catholics shouting at each other with police in the middle
yep jonshtons hand hits it first and if he doesn't touch it for the ref then iwata's arms are in an unnatural position unless you stand with your arms out in front of you. The ball is a cross so no excuses of distance and cruicially no refs (you met get dermot trying his best) agree with the pundits assessment. Lundstram got one against him with his hands at his side i didn't hear brendan calling that out at the weeekend
@@paulgal Have you seen a referee stating it was incorrect or just pundits? a cross comes in the box and johnston misses his header and hits his arm now this happens anywhere else its a free kick. Intention is irrelevant and your hand ahead of you is not in silhouette the conditions for it not to be handball so can you explain why it isn't a penalty?
@@Chop2016 tbh other teams have actually started to preform better against the old firm, maybe Hearts v Celtic isn’t the biggest shock because hearts have good form but for Motherwell to beat rangers is the biggest shock probably this season
McGregor admitted it when Celtic were put out of Europe. Celtic are refereed to a different standard, in Europe the rules apply because the ref's are not intimidated by your support in Scotland ref's are terrified for themselves and their families. It's all been done before and your support and indeed your manager do not have the sportsmanship to accept a decision against your team. When Roofe committed the same tackle I would find it impossible to find a Celtic fan to say it was a yellow, it was a red and so was yesterday's foot to the head. The Morelos goal and the Roofe goal chopped off in the OF were goals and Celtic benefitted from those decision's. Your team has been helped for year's by the SPFL, SFA and officials but even when a legitimate penalty or red card is awarded against you it's meltdown time because of your inflated entitlement.
The red card Brendon says yellow but if the shoe was on the other foot he would be shouting red along with the fans losers always blame everything and everyone else hearts deserved the win give them credit instead of this and that they were the better team the result showed that well done hearts 👍
Sending off is correct. No malice agreed but if you apply the rules the way everyone else has got then definitely a red card. Celtics penalty is a disgraceful decision. Celtic player runs into and across the Hearts defender and throws himself down. Kyogo got an even worse one previously against Hearts too. Hearts penalty for handball wasn’t a penalty imo. So much conflicting and contradictory decision making around penalties at the moment. This week alone St Mirren and Rangers denied blatant handballs yet the referee awarded this one? Doesn’t make sense and not consistent. This was however the first Celtic have had awarded against them this season is it not?
Gers should sign shankland hes just got it Union bears need a banner set up get the message out us fans want him next season that smile to naismith at end of game is just what i needed the day 😂 shankland your the man so much like mccoist and look what he done watp
Jesus that red card was diabolical. No malice. No intent. Eyes on the ball and going for the ball. A red card 😅😂😂😂WTF is going on up there? Referees need banning
intent/malice are the same thing and irrelevant shawcross didn't mean to snap ramseys leg in half but he did.. keeping your eye on the ball doesn't matter when your opponents head is in between and he lifts his foot head heightso if his studs say catch his eye he might not be able to see hence why your foot shouldn't be up there. in football your feet never need to be that high off the ground he could have just literally used his head and stayed ont he field. He knows immediately he is going and is surpsied only to be booked at first look at the players as the ref comes over
How on earth was Heart's second goal offside 😮. They were definitely going to win this game anyways. 😂. That'll be Celtic back being no longer a massive club anymore like they were against diabolical Dundeeeee 😂
Mind yous said ange would be gone by Christmas and gerrard would batter him hahaha, mind when yous said beale would win 56 and he was the ‘brains behind 55’ hahaha, I’d be careful what you say next
@@crs2385 we’re too use to winning mate, 11 out of the last 12 we all thought it was over yes, but we’ve been in this situation before and we’ve already bet you twice this season👍
@surfnturf7832 And overall Rangers still have more titles. You won 10 of the last 12. Your title in 2020 was an asterisk, and 4 of those titles was with Rangers out the league, two were before Rangers could compete properly. Hardly an achievement. How's Brenda looking now he's actually got competition? Still wanting him gone? 😂😂😂 But it's okay, because "we've been here before", what? Blowing a 7 point lead? 😂 Can't mind that happening in recent times 😊🔴⚪️🔵
Commentator Chris Sutton felt the decision was harsh, but Rodgers felt a 'stud to the eye' clearly merited the sending-off. He said after the game: "The guy's not meaning to do it, but of course if you're taking a stud in the eye, it's dangerous play. It was clearly a red card. 2 Jan 2024. Was against a St Mirren Player v Celtic.
celtic penalty was a joke and that shankland called off goal never offside in million years as for red put boot up like that risking red does not matter if it hits him or not its dangerous play same way var never sent johnstone off for second yellow for fighting at the end guess they must forgot that hmmmmm
@rorymethven3182 Right, YOU are a Catholic Hearts fan, and sometimes there are Catholic Rangers fans here and there. Doesn't mean Rangers aren't a protestant club. Hearts were founded as a protestant club. So no, it's not a mental statement at all.
@@followfollowatw "officially"..what you on? There was full contact on Harts head but there was no intentional violent conduct .Boot was as high as Harts head was low..Your heads full of mince.
contact is irrelevant for a red card its endangering an opponent with high feet and given he just about took his face off clearly that criteria was met. yangs boot does not to be shoulder height for any reason even if instinctual he knows it and barely complains leaving the field. Not the worst challenge but just because he didn't take the players face off didn't mean he couldn't do so
Brendan blaming the var decisions when he brought on a teenager to win a game. The board must be scratching their heads at the money they've spent to sit on the bench.
Celtics penalty was absolutely laughable. Not an honest person who has played football on the planet would think that was a foul by the Hearts player. The offside was offside. Hearts penalty decision was just as bad as the one against Lundstram although I persoinally think that neither were pens. Red Card was nailed on. First time I have seen it and thought it was going to be touch and go after hearing Brendan Rogers going on about it. That was a red card all day long and to deny it and slag off Beaton is really desperate stuff and uncalled for. I think the guy is under enormous pressure and cracking.
1 of the most corrupt displays of cheating ever done by a Scottish football referee. Up there with Mike McCurry. This will surely end referees refereeing the game of the team they grew up supporting.
@@JT1873-ly8hrJust let Rangers (the worst ever team in the history of the Champions League) win for once - they can't win without the officials cheating
I cannot believe that Rodgers gave the penalty to Idah to take , looking at the size of him and his lack of goals for Ireland it was a monmumental blunder. His goals for Celtic have been a welcome surprise but he is not a penalty taker IMO .
To all celtic fans complaining about red card. Why don't you all go read the rule book it says endangering an opponent should be punishable with sending off. Are you all saying that's only a red if he takes his eye out with the studs. Why not put shoe on other foot coz you all be screaming for red if it was a gear's player.
@@richardsteven3935if that’s two rangers players there you’re not saying that’s a penalty you wee fud, if rangers were given that against them I would say it’s incredible soft. Least I can admit the first one is not a penalty
@@BloodSweatAndMeth It matters when there is no contact..because nothing actually happened ..clutching your face and falling down like you've been hurt is LYING..he should be suitably embarrassed and carded for diving..Initial yellow was the decision and should have stood....try to comprehend. no contact and nothing happened.. ref initially called it for what it was.
Brendan blamed the referee but completely ignored the fact that they got the softest penalty you'll see literally sums Celtic up.
Always cheated never defeated theyre a total shambles and embarrassment.
Haha he actually blamed the VAR official who doesn’t even make the decision 🤣
The one wrong decision today was Celtic's penalty. But you know, you lose you blame the ref, it's a tradition.
celtic failing to to capitalise in a league they bought
Plus the 'off-side' Hearts goal that was never off-side.
Did anyone check the length of the grass? It might have been too long again! 😂😂😂😂😂
It was checked. The vernier used was calibrated at Ibrox though. It's a clear conspiracy. The fact that Celtic have only conceded one penalty this season is mere proof that they're trying to hide the conspiracy. Celtic thus should just be handed the 3 points
🤌🏻
Tbh hearts did actually intentionally do that before
Zander Clark played a blinder today. Thanks from Govan.
that first penalty is the worst decision i have seen in my life
take it you never seen hearts pen against hibs
Agreed, the Celtic pen was never a pen. Typical scum refs giving them everything.
I take it you’ve not watched the full video and seen the second penalty, no hearts fan even appeals for it
@@surfnturf7832 Yes thats why VAR is in the game as fans don't often see clash points. I drops down and hits the celtic players with his arm out. The ball hits his outstretched arm which away from the body and he wasn't forced to jump like this. What part of that is not a penalty? Stupid yes but those are the rules as written as what part of out in front of you is in sillouhete or a natural position?
@surfnturf7832 first of all you can hear some fans appealing. Secondly, that's what VAR is for, to spot things that almost everybody has missed - and it was a pen
Celtic fan here. Hearts unlucky not to win 3 nil.
Well played Jambos.
Rogers is a massive surprise and disappointment.
Seems we were spoiled with Ange.
You are the only non delusional Celtic fan
You sure now?
That offside decision is absolutely disgraceful
100%
Watch Liverpools var..especially against spurs & Chelsea elcf
THe lines drawn in the image arent even right, CarterVickers shoulder is further than where the red line is drawn! its onside
Agreed so glad I saw this comment now I know I’m not the only one 😉✌🏼👍🏼🏴
@@WeeRabyexactly what I said in another reply 👍🏼🏴
That pen they got was never a penalty. Was a foul to hearts. Unbelievable decision as usual. The refs are jumping at the chance to give them penalties and not to give them against if they’re playing the famous.
The title is lava.
Someone left a comment yesterday, about how Rangest lost despite getting their usual soft penalty LOL What was this then? Despicable!
Lol so someone you don't know left a generic comment that got u so worked up you're answering said unknown person back 24hrs later?? 😂😂 what point do u lot realise you're no different to crazy people that approach and talk to strangers at the bus stop 😂😂 you're jus arguing with your imagination 😂
i saw the motherwell boss calling it soft too which is weird as his player tackled and made no contact with the ball the textbook definition of a penalty
@lloydymk2013 in your case it was 8 hours lol
God save the king Tav.
Chris Sutton has gone missing!
Haaaaasssss anyone seen Chrrrrris Hutton? In the style of Jason Cundy.
Chris Sutton is in hiding dry ur eyes Sutton
@@grahamjones9888Not for long how did the league go
Brenda crying about the refs lol didnt hear him bring up septic dodgy pen 🤣 😂 as for the red according to brenda when it happned at stmirren " its a stud to the eye , straight red all day " his words 😂😂😂
A know yer oriental but there will be no karate kicks round here😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
An appallingly guid joke!!!!
@@mikeharper3459 drunk at the time of writing 🤣
Hearts 2nd isn't even offside. The lines are angled. You can see that the 18 yeard box line is straight across the screen and the lines are tilted left to right. The distance between line and box at the far end is less than the closer end. Thre penalty wasn't a penalty and should have been a hearts Free kick, and the referee should have been smart enough to know that kicking someone in the face with your studs is a straight red without the VAR check.
It was clearly offside
@@Lubo-qd2zs It was clearly ONSIDE, squint-eyes 🔴⚪️🔵
Hahaha nae bother mate
@@Lubo-qd2zs 😂👍
See physics Isnae yer strong point
Celtic fans all talk yesterday all to end up STILL beneath Rangers Hahahaha
I dont even follow this league but you can tell they are the most hateable
@@MrFirefoxCeltic fans are some of the most detestable and pathetic fans on the planet. No wonder they and Liverpool fans love each other so much. I’m a Dortmund fan, and even I hate Celtic and Liverpool fans more than Schalke and Bayern fans
You’ve won one league title in the last 12 years which was played behind doors 🤡 you’ve been beneath Celtic this whole century you 🍊
@@MrFirefox clearly says a lot about you !! And your sectarian head on ye.
What about now?
Rodger’s is a bit of a sore loser when he’s not walking it
He is walking it though?
@@Chris-fs7gy How lmao
Brendan doesn't even know how VAR works. 🤣🤣🤣 Its the ref, the Celtc fan Don Robertson, who made the decisions today.
Good girl
Congrats Hearts! ❤🎉
We shall not be moved 🇬🇧
Butchers apron
@@1Jameskelly 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
To be fair I wish fans like yourself wouldn't say it. I remember Helicopter Sunday and we are gonna be playing on the Sunday due to our Europa League, they will play on Saturday and will probably go ahead until we play. Long way to go mate, this is going down to the last game
Let’s not get complacent cos we were awful yesterday. If we don’t show every team in the league respect then we will throw away the league to a poor Celtic team.
@@RS__7 3 butchers aprons
Can someone explain to me how / why Celtic got awarded that first penalty?
Rangers fucked up Saturday big time but the hearts did us big favour the day and to be fair they were the better side good game to watch Mon gers for leauge
League 😅
So arrogant and so shite.....rodgers has ruined everything that ange done@1Jameskelly
Done you a favour two weeks running.
Correction - John Beaton did you a big favour, not Hearts.
@@celticm1888 John Beaton wasn't even on the monitor 😂
Thanks you heats
You to keep Rangers on the top of the table ❤
Who else but Shankland ❤ HHGH 😁
Anybody saying Hearts shouldn't have got a pen... Are you not noticing it comes off 2 players arms? Iwata might not have known much about his, even then shouldn't have arms flailing about in the box when the balls in the air. But Johnston defo knew about his, he watched the ball come in, took his eye off it, went for the header & completely missed then the ball came off his elbow, on to Iwata's elbow. Can't surely be claiming neither of them were a handball? And anybody saying the red shouldn't be because he was flicking the ball over his head? Nope, that's what he tried to do but made no connection with the ball, the ball comes off the top of Cochranes head, Yang boots his head instead of the ball. If he had got the ball & missed Cochrane, might have been yellow for the high boot, hence why that's what was first given. But once the ref sees no contact was made on the ball & Cochrane got a boot to the face, he has no other choice but red. The same way making contact with the ball matters in most challenges... But Celtic getting a pen for their player barging in & falling over as a result, with no contact made? Absolute shambles of a decision.
Spot on about the handball it clearly hits both of the arms and they are both in unnatural positions not in silhouette so no matter who handled first its a handball as the rules state. The handball rules might be nonsense but they arer applied properly here and not sure why the press seem so adamant it wasn't
Iwata's arm is not in an unnatural position because his own player barges into him in mid-air, so his arm comes out to balance himself.
Go over the park with your mates ,jump in the air, and get your mate to push you from behind, and i bet your arms come out. It's a natural human reflex reaction.
@@jaycfc6955 Sooo you decided to totally ignore the point about it coming of 2 players arms? Hit of Johnston's arm before it hit off Iwata's, even if you think Iwata's isn't a pen, Johnston's defo is a pen. And no ref has said it was awarded against Iwata, he wasn't yellow carded for it & everybody has just assumed that it's him because it's the more obvious one... I also notice you've not cried about how your penalty award was much worse? If you're just going to ignore any points made & keep your green tinted specs on, don't bother arguing.
@AD270479 hello mate
The cfc in my name is Chelsea Fc , i was born and bred in Chelsea long before the Russian arrived.
I didn't say it never hit both players on the arm. My point was that all this unnatural arm position was wrong regarding Iwata due to his own player barging into him in mid-air.
And celtics penalty was a disgraceful decision, a blatant barge into the hearts player, then he dives to the ground. How Var never overturned that astounds me.
Today's football is not the game I grew up with in the 70's,80's & 90"s.
Bien x los hearts👏👏.saludos desde Argentina. De un simpatizante del hibernian. Siempre es Bueno ver al celtic y su soberbia llorar cuándo pierden 😂
My wee Irish pal sent me a screenshot of the Rangers result yesterday, i could have sent him two back today if i was that petty. Both his teams got stuffed today.....Celtic & Utd but he wouldn't see the phone screen from all that greetin 🤣😂🤣
Your we irish pal supports 2 teams. Obviously he isn't passionate about football
@@Chop2016 So he's not passionate because he follows two teams? I hope that was sarcasm 😂
Who’s greetin now 😂 yous lot have for the last decade now 😂🤣🤣
Genuine question, how was that a penalty to celtic? Celtic player runs into the hearts player on purpose then throws himself down.
i am at a loss he goes in front then falls over because he dove in front its incredible VAR didn't say to the ref have a look. Remember it was adam VAR who hit the penalty off the keepers legs because all that tavernier does is score penalties they are so easy
Whatever happened to extended highlights? Between this and the SPFL official highlights you're lucky to see five minutes of your team a week if you cant go to the games or pay for exorbitant subscriptions for the product you actually get. Football is no longer a game for the people.
C'mon now who outside bigoted Scotland would want 2 watch any spl side let alone any spfl side..Sunday league in England is more competitive
I’m not a Celtic fan - but please can we all agree these VAR/officials inconsistencies are ruining the game. It feels after every match we’re all bitter one way or another about decisions that in one game are acceptable and others aren’t.
Aye. In these highlights alone we had a Non-sense Red Card, Non-sense Penalty given to Hearts, a Non-sense Offside against Hearts, and a Non-sense Penalty given to Celtic. Football is deep down the drain.
Completely agree. I wouldn’t have awarded either penalty but there was a case for the Celtic player getting his leg in front and it being taken from under him. The Hearts one was ridiculous though. Especially as it’s gone to VAR. The Celtic player didn’t move unnaturally to the ball as his motion was a result of being pushed, and furthermore the ball wasn’t moving toward goal so he wasn’t blocking a shot. The red card was obscenely bad officiating. Yellow was appropriate for high foot and unintentional contact. It’s encouraging to see underdogs get results against the giants, and then you see how they got them. The Celtic manager has every right to complain. When the VAR official is incapable of officiating without deep seated bias, the whole league becomes a mere theatrical formality. That said, Hearts still had a job to do and executed well but I’ve rarely seen such biased refereeing.
I hope all the clubs, and I mean all, can put aside the rivalries and unite for some changes to how VAR is being handled
@@lightningtree5432 ok lets dissect this celtic penalty yang puts his leg in front then falls over he initiated the contact no var intervention penalty given
2. yang high boot intention or force are irrelevant to endangering opponents. Kemar roofe was red carded in europe exactly the same foot high going to insitinctively win the ball as soon as it goes head height red card 100% correct decision won't find a referee who says its not
3. hearts penalty drop and hits johnston then iwata. johnston has his hand in front of him, misses his header and hits his outsretched arm remove everyone else stonewall penalty. Drops to hit iwata now if the ref thinks it hasn't hit johnston then its hit iwata in exactly the same position. Handball rules are stupid as written but if not in sillhouette or natural position and it hits your hand its a penalty. It wasn't s short range shot it fell out of the sky from a corner so i can't see the argument here other than that handball rules are dumb as written but VAR enforce the rules not write them
I don't like VAR as i think it slows everything down but lose gracefully. We lsot to a good motherwell side it happens where var i thought could have done more but it was on the players. You make excuses blaming others
Brendan blaming everyone else instead of looking on the mirror 😅😅, he through a tantrum at Leicester because they wouldn't just hand him a blank cheque to spend and he'll be leaving Celtic soon because he's an absolute bottler
Two really bad decisions by the ref. The penalty for Celtic should have been a free kick to Hearts and the offside was a howler as well.
Rogers blaming everyone now hahaha he’s turned a treble winning team into a laughing stock
The spl is a laughing stock. It's pathetic hard 2 watch..with the added religious bigotry..watching highlights is like watching protestants & catholics shouting at each other with police in the middle
Aged well
Big Brenda greeting about the sending off , I never knew karate was allowed in football , dry yer eyes Timothy 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Tears of joy now ha ha ha
Was comedy gold watching these lot crumble under the pressure. Brenda must stay!!😂
John Lundstrum is the best on earth 😂🤣🍀
Love it Jambos ❤
Yaaaaaasss! Skelped them home and away this season 😂😂😂 mon the Jambos!!
'Skelped' - you mean gifted by the cheat John Beaton - literally down the Rangers supporters club now celebrating
lol "gifted", the worst decision went in celtics favor @@celticm1888
Beaton doesn’t make any decisions he only suggests the ref to look at the incident again. The referee made the calls for both pens and the red.
@@Demondoink1it is a 95%+ overturn rate. the var ref de facto makes the decision subject to occasional exception
@@celticm1888waaaaaa 😭🇬🇧
Come On Rangers💙
the ball hits two celtic players arms for Hearts penalty in the slow-motion you can see it
yep jonshtons hand hits it first and if he doesn't touch it for the ref then iwata's arms are in an unnatural position unless you stand with your arms out in front of you. The ball is a cross so no excuses of distance and cruicially no refs (you met get dermot trying his best) agree with the pundits assessment. Lundstram got one against him with his hands at his side i didn't hear brendan calling that out at the weeekend
Thankyou HEARTS , ❤️ I am a Ranger fan from Bangladesh
In Scotland & around Europe they known as "rangers"
Referee's got every decision correct today except for Celtic's penalty. Unbiased view here.
You’re the only person including huns who think hearts was a pen.
@@paulgaleven hearts fans admitting they were lucky😂 only ones is the huns, 1 league in 12 years
@@paulgal Have you seen a referee stating it was incorrect or just pundits? a cross comes in the box and johnston misses his header and hits his arm now this happens anywhere else its a free kick. Intention is irrelevant and your hand ahead of you is not in silhouette the conditions for it not to be handball so can you explain why it isn't a penalty?
A rare sight, Celtic and Rangers loosing over the same weekend
Been near 20 years since the last time I believe....
@@navnig I actually think it was in 2018, I heard some commentator on bcc say that
@@CappyXS yep feb 2018
Have you seen the state of the teams they play. Every week
@@Chop2016 tbh other teams have actually started to preform better against the old firm, maybe Hearts v Celtic isn’t the biggest shock because hearts have good form but for Motherwell to beat rangers is the biggest shock probably this season
McGregor admitted it when Celtic were put out of Europe.
Celtic are refereed to a different standard, in Europe the rules apply because the ref's are not intimidated by your support in Scotland ref's are terrified for themselves and their families.
It's all been done before and your support and indeed your manager do not have the sportsmanship to accept a decision against your team.
When Roofe committed the same tackle I would find it impossible to find a Celtic fan to say it was a yellow, it was a red and so was yesterday's foot to the head.
The Morelos goal and the Roofe goal chopped off in the OF were goals and Celtic benefitted from those decision's.
Your team has been helped for year's by the SPFL, SFA and officials but even when a legitimate penalty or red card is awarded against you it's meltdown time because of your inflated entitlement.
Shankland controls the shot for the second goal so well. He's become a very good all round player.
Well done Hearts super performance what did Celtic get a penalty for Hearts one definitely one and red card any day of the week boot far too high.
Aye, John Beaton announced over the Hearts tannoy as man of the match
@@celticm1888 Ok Brenda.
The red card Brendon says yellow but if the shoe was on the other foot he would be shouting red along with the fans losers always blame everything and everyone else hearts deserved the win give them credit instead of this and that they were the better team the result showed that well done hearts 👍
Sending off is correct. No malice agreed but if you apply the rules the way everyone else has got then definitely a red card. Celtics penalty is a disgraceful decision. Celtic player runs into and across the Hearts defender and throws himself down. Kyogo got an even worse one previously against Hearts too. Hearts penalty for handball wasn’t a penalty imo. So much conflicting and contradictory decision making around penalties at the moment. This week alone St Mirren and Rangers denied blatant handballs yet the referee awarded this one? Doesn’t make sense and not consistent. This was however the first Celtic have had awarded against them this season is it not?
Gers should sign shankland hes just got it
Union bears need a banner set up get the message out us fans want him next season that smile to naismith at end of game is just what i needed the day 😂 shankland your the man so much like mccoist and look what he done watp
Refereeing errors 😢
Crazy week😂😂😂
Surprise 🤨 loss Celtic I am from Iraq 🇮🇶 ❤️ 🇯🇵
Jesus that red card was diabolical. No malice. No intent. Eyes on the ball and going for the ball. A red card 😅😂😂😂WTF is going on up there? Referees need banning
intent/malice are the same thing and irrelevant shawcross didn't mean to snap ramseys leg in half but he did.. keeping your eye on the ball doesn't matter when your opponents head is in between and he lifts his foot head heightso if his studs say catch his eye he might not be able to see hence why your foot shouldn't be up there. in football your feet never need to be that high off the ground he could have just literally used his head and stayed ont he field. He knows immediately he is going and is surpsied only to be booked at first look at the players as the ref comes over
How’s that a penalty to Celtic 💀
Right up ye🇬🇧🔴⚪️🔵
Don't bear 🐻 a grudge ....RFC
How was the Celtic penalty first awarded ? I’m very confused 😅
Indeed a beautiful Sunday 👍🏼
Dujon Sterling got Red carded for less against Aberdeen, no way Celtic are trying to protest this one🤣
they can't even fill their stadium
How on earth was Heart's second goal offside 😮. They were definitely going to win this game anyways. 😂. That'll be Celtic back being no longer a massive club anymore like they were against diabolical Dundeeeee 😂
Even with help they still lost 🤣
LS is class
Even when Rangers give Celtic a massive chance to go top they still lose🤣. May as well give us the title now🇬🇧🏆
Mind yous said ange would be gone by Christmas and gerrard would batter him hahaha, mind when yous said beale would win 56 and he was the ‘brains behind 55’ hahaha, I’d be careful what you say next
@@surfnturf7832 Mind yous said you won the league when yous were 7 points clear? 😂😂😂
@@crs2385 we’re too use to winning mate, 11 out of the last 12 we all thought it was over yes, but we’ve been in this situation before and we’ve already bet you twice this season👍
@surfnturf7832 And overall Rangers still have more titles. You won 10 of the last 12. Your title in 2020 was an asterisk, and 4 of those titles was with Rangers out the league, two were before Rangers could compete properly. Hardly an achievement. How's Brenda looking now he's actually got competition? Still wanting him gone? 😂😂😂 But it's okay, because "we've been here before", what? Blowing a 7 point lead? 😂 Can't mind that happening in recent times 😊🔴⚪️🔵
@@1306r worked out well for yous eh
Commentator Chris Sutton felt the
decision was harsh, but Rodgers felt a 'stud to the eye' clearly merited the
sending-off. He said after the game: "The guy's not meaning to do it, but of course if you're taking a stud in the eye, it's dangerous play. It was clearly
a red card. 2 Jan 2024. Was against a St Mirren Player v Celtic.
Brenda is cracking
celtic penalty was a joke and that shankland called off goal never offside in million years as for red put boot up like that risking red does not matter if it hits him or not its dangerous play same way var never sent johnstone off for second yellow for fighting at the end guess they must forgot that hmmmmm
Clearly offside ya cabbage.
How can VAR give Hearts goal as offside.? The Celtic players`arm is at the least level with Hearts man, bloody disgrace.!!
Staunch 🇬🇧🇱🇻
Thank you our Protestant brothers in Edinburgh, yessssssssss we are the people 🇬🇧
Butchers apron
What a mental statement. I’m a hearts fans, a Catholic and I hate rangers. Your teams no brother of mine!
@rorymethven3182 Right, YOU are a Catholic Hearts fan, and sometimes there are Catholic Rangers fans here and there. Doesn't mean Rangers aren't a protestant club. Hearts were founded as a protestant club. So no, it's not a mental statement at all.
@@1Jameskelly🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
@@crs2385 it is when no other club cares about religion except Celtic and rangers. Keep religion out of football. Simple
Well. I never expected those two results. It's mad.
That first shankland goal was not offside 😂😂
Classic bad day at the office for the Hoops
Brenda and the bottle Bhoys
Canny hear a or see a thing today from Celtic fans 😂😂😂😂
No contact with the high boot..yellow card only.
Not an equal game with 11 against 10 for 75 minutes
@@followfollowatw "officially"..what you on? There was full contact on Harts head but there was no intentional violent conduct .Boot was as high as Harts head was low..Your heads full of mince.
@@followfollowatw No one went in two footed on either incident we are discussing.. you are making stuff up now,,..away to your bed...
contact is irrelevant for a red card its endangering an opponent with high feet and given he just about took his face off clearly that criteria was met. yangs boot does not to be shoulder height for any reason even if instinctual he knows it and barely complains leaving the field. Not the worst challenge but just because he didn't take the players face off didn't mean he couldn't do so
Cant believe out of all the teams celtic let me down on my accumaleter
that's why you never back the small teams
Celtic fked me out of 180 quid a few year ago when they lost to killie 1-0 nd I've not put a bet on since then 😂😂
Brendan blaming the var decisions when he brought on a teenager to win a game. The board must be scratching their heads at the money they've spent to sit on the bench.
Thank u hearts ...watp
Anyone notice the hearts fan skelp the celtic player with the baw during the red card kick lol he took his moment well lol
Hearts played well 🇬🇧
Saved By Brother Beaton😏😏😏😏😏
Who doesn't make the decisions 😂
Stuck his neb in when the ref called it a yellow...then the pen🤷♂️🙄😏😏😏😏
@@AP-oh3nf Ref has final say. It's a red card all day long.
Celtic FC - always the victim and always cheated, never defeated. Since 1888 👍🏼
2003 celtic fc was formed before that was Pacific sheif and longer before that was celtic athletic football club
No surrender 🇬🇧🏴🇬🇧
Give it a rest , n get a life.
27 goals for the championship striker that only scores pens😂😁
Celtics penalty was absolutely laughable. Not an honest person who has played football on the planet would think that was a foul by the Hearts player. The offside was offside. Hearts penalty decision was just as bad as the one against Lundstram although I persoinally think that neither were pens. Red Card was nailed on. First time I have seen it and thought it was going to be touch and go after hearing Brendan Rogers going on about it. That was a red card all day long and to deny it and slag off Beaton is really desperate stuff and uncalled for. I think the guy is under enormous pressure and cracking.
Shanks scored two, we all know it. Ref a disgrace as always. WHEN WILL THESE REFS BECOME REFS?
1 of the most corrupt displays of cheating ever done by a Scottish football referee. Up there with Mike McCurry. This will surely end referees refereeing the game of the team they grew up supporting.
Don Robertson is a Celtic fan
@@stephenmackenzie8920 John Beaton
Away and dry yer eyes 😂
@@JT1873-ly8hrJust let Rangers (the worst ever team in the history of the Champions League) win for once - they can't win without the officials cheating
@@celticm1888John Beaton wasn't in charge😂
the level of corruption to try and help Celtic is just mind blowing. Absolutely disgraceful penalty call early on
I cannot believe that Rodgers gave the penalty to Idah to take , looking at the size of him and his lack of goals for Ireland it was a monmumental blunder. His goals for Celtic have been a welcome surprise but he is not a penalty taker IMO .
Mostly pens he’s scored if yous can tarnish tavs record damn sure don’t be a hypocrite.
@@GoogleMeAgainTav doesn't just score from the penalty spot tho.
Justice
The pens ain’t pens but it’s a stone wall red it’s a bloody ninja kick
To all celtic fans complaining about red card. Why don't you all go read the rule book it says endangering an opponent should be punishable with sending off. Are you all saying that's only a red if he takes his eye out with the studs. Why not put shoe on other foot coz you all be screaming for red if it was a gear's player.
Hearts
Those 2 penalties were a joke , especially the first .
Two player handled it mate have a look
@@richardsteven3935if that’s two rangers players there you’re not saying that’s a penalty you wee fud, if rangers were given that against them I would say it’s incredible soft. Least I can admit the first one is not a penalty
That's the worst, and I mean the WORST pen decision I think i've ever seen.
Thr high foot rule is the worst rule ever created. It makes no sense.
@@BloodSweatAndMeth No contact..yellow card only....Oscar nomination for the Hearts player
@@BloodSweatAndMeth It matters when there is no contact..because nothing actually happened ..clutching your face and falling down like you've been hurt is LYING..he should be suitably embarrassed and carded for diving..Initial yellow was the decision and should have stood....try to comprehend. no contact and nothing happened.. ref initially called it for what it was.
There was contact
@@Maestro-ds2hr Nope...yellow was sufficient.
@@strawman80 was yellow sufficient for the st mirren boy on Joe hart?
Commentator got very excited when Idah got anywhere near the ball🙄
So did Idah. That boy couldnae finish a sentence. 😆
Only 3 minute highlights for a game like that 😂 well done Hearts and thanks 🙌 🇬🇧
Always cheated, Never defeated! Delusional if you think that's not a red
Did that slip count as an assist? 🤣
Beyond disgraceful Celtic got a pen for that.
Shanks loving scoring against those ________