Ash would never tell combee “you’re not cut out for battling. Guess you can go back to the lab,” seems out of character for him to give up on a Pokémon.
Once again I’m glad to see this type of different approach with Ash’s team, not limiting him to just Gen 4 Pokemon. Swampert was a real surprise and so was the choice to not evolve Turtwig. I vote that Piplup evolve, only since he seems more open to it in this timeline, and I personally really enjoy what ifs where they make a lot of big changes from canon, but that’s just me.
@@rodrigoandorinha9259 Personally I think it would have been nice to see a different take on Torterra where he didn't get totally shafted the moment Infernape came along, but choosing for him to remain unevolved is interesting too.
I like this new format with showing what Pokémon are at Oak's Lab, and what are with Ash on his journey. Whoa Swampert that's so serious water power that Ash caught, but of course it doesn't listen him that's a trademark for Ash. 😆 I got to say Combee did good in his gym fights an idea you could do is he helps Ivysaur in keeping the peace at Professor Oak's Lab. Hm? 🤔 Ice Stone huh I wonder what Pokémon Ash & Dawn will use their Ice Stone on? Finally I say evolve Piplup, but later when Piplup feel like he's ready. Anyways another really good part, and looking forward to the next part soon.
No, Piplup should not evolve, the reason he didn't evolve originally was because he believed it might ruin his performance and appearance for contests, I see no reason for that to change here, regardless of the circumstances Edit: I also don't think Turtwing should evolve either, since he sees the importance of his battling style (And let's be honest, he was better as a Turtwig anyways)
This was definitely an interesting entry it was great to see Totodile put confidence in minum and help it learn thunderbolt and discharge But one thing that surprised me Was the choice to not evolve Turtwig one thing I feel like the anime should of done for Ash's Torterra was teach him rock polish that way he could regain some of the speed he lost as he evolved maybe then he might of won some battles after evolving from Grotle into Torterra
As much as I don’t like Paul, he was right saying relying on luck makes for a bad strategy. Hopefully, Ash will teach Minun some non-Electric attacks soon. Gible joining earlier and Chimchar evolving early are greatly appreciated. Swampert’s capture was mind blowing to me though I guess it wasn’t too surprising it would be disobedient (wouldn’t want things to be too easy). I appreciated seeing Ash bring back some of his veterans to help out the team or with other events. It’s something the anime never capitalized on enough. But that talk between Piplup and Charizard about evolution was excellent. Since Ash’s starter wasn’t Pikachu, Charizard would definitely have a different perspective on evolving. However, she gave both sides of the debate fair representation and made sure Piplup would be the one to make the final call. I’d love to see how Piplup would handle evolution. It would give him more moves to work with and handle different challenges. Glad to have you back, Dex. This what if series is pretty cool.
it would also be nice if you could involve some of his old and new Pokémon and used to The battles improperly try to joy the new battle frontier from Sinnoh would be great
It's definitely been a while that I began to think you might have given up on this series glad to see I was wrong. I like how the team is so far although I wasn't so sure about Ash having 2 fire types but you seem to make it work. Ash having another disobedient pokemon always makes things interesting. As for Pimplup evolving I think it should stay the same and evolve in the seasons where Dawn returns.
I'm very happy to be able to see the continuation of What if Ash woke up on time but it was not what I expected I was less exciting and too fast than the others because this season in the region of Sinnoh It's one of the more emotional adventures and I thought it was going to be more amazing than the original I wish I could see the Ash catching his Staraptor and Buizel because they were outstanding Pokémon of this adventure, it would have been cool, I think I had seen the rivalries of these new Pokémon from the Ash for example Staraptor Buizel Minum against Skarmory Swampert Pichu it would be amazing and it would be cool if you had caught new Pokémon in this adventure for example Geodude Shiinx Shieldon Buneary Spiritomb Snover this six will be really good for ash team
I love this what-if, it goes in a more unique direction with not only teams, but with the way trainers are handled as well. I love it, hope to see more in the future ^w^ Also, will Ash get Froslass? 030
As much as I love Piplup, I'm choosing to vote for him to Evolve and I'll be explaining why so those who are voting to keep him the way he is listen up as well. So one of the Main Reasons why I want the Little Penguin Pokemon to Evolve is because we've already seen multiple Pokemon What Ifs of the Same Copy Paste Scenario before of Piplup choosing to not to Evolve, getting a Everstone and Dawn going on lose again to Zoey in the Sinnoh Grand Festival Finals and goes on to see Ash lose in the Top 4 or lose to Paul before going on Johto. Do you see what I mean here? At this point it's gotten very repetitive because the Same Scenario for Sinnoh in a lot of What Ifs gets blurred together and even though there was one where Ash was able to win the Sinnoh League, it's still shows the Same Scenario for Dawn like in Canon as usual in that one too however this What If here by DexComics is aiming to be different from the rest of them especially the previous Ash Woke Up On Time What Ifs before it and I love it how it's giving everyone the chance to change things here in Sinnoh rather than just going to do the same thing. The 3 other Main Reasons are that I really want to see Dawn actually beat Zoey this around in the Sinnoh Grand Festival Finals this time around (rather than it being a early Alain Situation again before Alain) but barely so she knows she still needs work and I really want to see Ash Challenge the Sinnoh Battle Frontier and Win the Sinnoh League other than the What Ifs on Ash Waking Up On Time and finally I want to add something else too: I want the Sinnoh Group to be able to compete in the Qualifiers for the Pokeathlon in Johto and actually go to Johto to compete in it instead of a Plot Hole, maybe Stop the remnants of Team Galactic from attempting to use Arceus to maybe bring back Cyrus and create their own World with him as well as create their own Creation Trio at Sinjoh Ruins (mix In The Stuff from The Arceus Chronicles)and then they go their separate ways in Johto( with Dawn staying in Johto) using the Magnet Train and Ash and Brock can go theirs as Canon. I'm also hoping that you'll be including Stuff from Pokemon Legends Arceus like I have a feeling that you're going to do like Ash's Scyther becoming a Cleavor, Moves from The Game and maybe a certain Quilava becoming a Hisuian Typloshion.😉😉😉 Additionally if you ever get to Unova, do you think you can incorporate Contests being in Unova from The Pokemon Journeys Series, have Ash win some Competitions/Tournaments in Unova unlike in Canon where he only won outside of the Region and maybe have Ash's Battle in the Unova League Finals end in a Draw? Considering that we've seen previous What Ifs having Ash losing in The Vertress Conference beforehand, a Draw is definitely a very interesting outcome and helps you stand out from the rest.
Swampert's evolution line never got to shine in Hoenn because Brock never got it here. Plus the Piplup will always belong to Dawn, Kenny and Barry I couldn't in good conscious give it to Ash
@@DexComics I can’t say you aren’t wrong, The mudkip Line were robbed in Advanced. Ash should have gotten swampert instead of corpish even tho I like ash’s Corpish. The Piplup line never really suited ash. I never said he should have gotten piplup. I never said he should Get piplup tho,btw Good choice on evovling turtwig.
I am so glad you made your on little changes this is so interesting and I really do hope Ash gets to challenge the sinnoh battle frontier maybe this could help ash get stronger make some pokemon evolve heck maybe he could beat tobias with the stronger mons but I am kinda weirded out that Ash caught a male combee i think he matches dawn more while Ash catches the female one and I really do hope Gible evolves and for piplup well sure evolution will change but it has its perks so say evolve but right now maybe when ash sees him at unova
Yes Piplup should evolve because to me personally Dawn getting the Everstone from Zoey or Nurse Joy was a copout and copycat of how Ash doesn't give Pikachu the Thunderstone
I love the layout of all the Pokémon he had, but I was gonna say you added an extra Beedrill, but then I remember he caught one in the bug catching contest but why is there a weedle
I have a bit of a peeve about this episode because offensively a male conbee would be Way more better for dawn in her contest and the female one would have been way more better for ash But other than that this story was awesome I can't wait for the next sport and hopefully we don't to wait a year for the next episode to come out And also other new episodes of what if's to come out because you sir has been gone for a while
I doubt ivysaur, rhydon would be cool if it evolved but unlikely, catarpie would work, Paras is very unlikely, weedle I doubt because now he would have 3 beedrills, scyther deserves to evolve he just teased us abt it, totodile would be likely, pichu is a guaranteed he said it himself, vibrava deserves to evolve, and snowrunt is most likely to evolve
Whats up with writers giving Ash especially an experienced Ash, disobediant Pokémon? Like this is Ash's 4th region and gave him a disobediant Swampert which is so dumb, and giving these inexperienced trainers giving Ash lessons is so dumb. Those disobediant days should of been over by now. 😐🤦🏽♂️ Basically it is just a copy and paste at this point with minor tweaks and different Pokémon and you giving him weaker Pokémon instead of stronger ones too. Like whats up with that? Also what is up with writers giving Ash's traveling companion better development too? It just never makes sense to me.
I do think He should evolve because he didn't evolve in the original series and I would really like to see what kind of damage and also other Combo moves dawn will come up with with a plainpump I'm sorry if I put your name or even spelled it wrong it's just been a while
Its Minun not Minum its giving me vibes your reading from a script getting some names wrong ,also if your going to have a mon use Metronome make sure you know what moves were available at the time in Gen 4.
Dex whyyyyyyyy I wish you were going to give ash snover not brock dang it I really wanted ash to have an Albomansnow and now he won't get hippotas either damn it whyyyyyyy 😭😢
![โฮ่ง! (SUGOI) - LYKN [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nFp4zjAARFs/mqdefault.jpg)
Ash would never tell combee “you’re not cut out for battling. Guess you can go back to the lab,” seems out of character for him to give up on a Pokémon.
Once again I’m glad to see this type of different approach with Ash’s team, not limiting him to just Gen 4 Pokemon. Swampert was a real surprise and so was the choice to not evolve Turtwig. I vote that Piplup evolve, only since he seems more open to it in this timeline, and I personally really enjoy what ifs where they make a lot of big changes from canon, but that’s just me.
After the become a torterra turtwig din't see victory , so i think it was a good choice
@@rodrigoandorinha9259 Personally I think it would have been nice to see a different take on Torterra where he didn't get totally shafted the moment Infernape came along, but choosing for him to remain unevolved is interesting too.
@@oragewoods5606 👍
I like this new format with showing what Pokémon are at Oak's Lab, and what are with Ash on his journey. Whoa Swampert that's so serious water power that Ash caught, but of course it doesn't listen him that's a trademark for Ash. 😆 I got to say Combee did good in his gym fights an idea you could do is he helps Ivysaur in keeping the peace at Professor Oak's Lab. Hm? 🤔 Ice Stone huh I wonder what Pokémon Ash & Dawn will use their Ice Stone on? Finally I say evolve Piplup, but later when Piplup feel like he's ready. Anyways another really good part, and looking forward to the next part soon.
Agrre
So glad you finally have a layout showing all the mons ash caught
Yup
@DexComics when you doing the next one I really Ike how u do this and want see how u end his story u already had him won a pokemon league
It is time it been a whole year but now it is back part 8 and now the what if king is back
Woah, the fact that it’s been a year is mind boggling
@@altrxceyt2949indeed that is mind blowing
This episode was great, although swampert is a bit weird. Keep Piplup as it is btw
True
Paul starter would have been fully evolved as he traveled to all of the same regions as Ash (although in a different order)
Hey don't listen to the scam it is not even dex
@@yaboisanti8932 no worries
No, Piplup should not evolve, the reason he didn't evolve originally was because he believed it might ruin his performance and appearance for contests, I see no reason for that to change here, regardless of the circumstances
Edit: I also don't think Turtwing should evolve either, since he sees the importance of his battling style (And let's be honest, he was better as a Turtwig anyways)
Love how you made costume victory poses for Ash and Dawn's different teams hope to see when ever it comes out
This was definitely an interesting entry it was great to see Totodile put confidence in minum and help it learn thunderbolt and discharge
But one thing that surprised me Was the choice to not evolve Turtwig one thing I feel like the anime should of done for Ash's Torterra was teach him rock polish that way he could regain some of the speed he lost as he evolved maybe then he might of won some battles after evolving from Grotle into Torterra
I'm happy you gave Swampert, as Swampert is one of my favourite pokemon.
Mine too
As much as I don’t like Paul, he was right saying relying on luck makes for a bad strategy. Hopefully, Ash will teach Minun some non-Electric attacks soon.
Gible joining earlier and Chimchar evolving early are greatly appreciated. Swampert’s capture was mind blowing to me though I guess it wasn’t too surprising it would be disobedient (wouldn’t want things to be too easy).
I appreciated seeing Ash bring back some of his veterans to help out the team or with other events. It’s something the anime never capitalized on enough.
But that talk between Piplup and Charizard about evolution was excellent. Since Ash’s starter wasn’t Pikachu, Charizard would definitely have a different perspective on evolving. However, she gave both sides of the debate fair representation and made sure Piplup would be the one to make the final call.
I’d love to see how Piplup would handle evolution. It would give him more moves to work with and handle different challenges.
Glad to have you back, Dex. This what if series is pretty cool.
Imagine Sawyer meeting Ash's Swampert! I believe that his jaw would fall into the pits of the earth!
From all the what if's ash....... In the whole TH-cam this is the best
When is part 9 ?
Agreed but unfortunately that question is unknown
A thought crossed my mind now. Since Ash has Charizard as his starter, wouldn’t he have had a better chance fighting Hunter J?
I don't think so
We need mooooore
I pretty sure Paul would have Toreterra by the time he first met Ash since he is just as experienced as Ash and is very kin to evolving his Pokemons
Nope because he don't in the show
it would also be nice if you could involve some of his old and new Pokémon and used to The battles improperly try to joy the new battle frontier from Sinnoh would be great
At 8:43, did you mean Soak? That's the move that turns Pokemon into water types, meaning Thundershock would hurt Geodude.
Also I think charizard should be the one to who has blaze instead of infernape. And you should make gible evolve all the way into a Garchomp
It's definitely been a while that I began to think you might have given up on this series glad to see I was wrong. I like how the team is so far although I wasn't so sure about Ash having 2 fire types but you seem to make it work. Ash having another disobedient pokemon always makes things interesting.
As for Pimplup evolving I think it should stay the same and evolve in the seasons where Dawn returns.
LET ME DO A QUICK RECAP ON ASHS TEAM
1 charizard
2 ivysaur
3 rhydon
4 beedrill
5 fearow that was released
6 kingler
7 muk
8 primape
9 snorlax
10 taoros
11 another taoros
12 scyther
13 lapras that he released
14 kabutops
15 weedle
16 paras
17 catarpie
18 heracross
19 bayleaf
20 another beedrill
21 quilava
22 totodile
23 pichu
24 shiny noctowl
25 sceptile
26 mightyena
27 skarmory
28 grumpig
29 another snorlax
30 vibrava
31 snorunt
32 minum
Wow looking back Ash has a lot for his reserves
Have Piplup evolve I'm curious how that would turn out. Also, thanks for listing all the pokemon at Oak's Lab.
Ash sure is getting a lot of evolutionary items
I'm very happy to be able to see the continuation of What if Ash woke up on time but it was not what I expected I was less exciting and too fast than the others because this season in the region of Sinnoh It's one of the more emotional adventures and I thought it was going to be more amazing than the original I wish I could see the Ash catching his Staraptor and Buizel because they were outstanding Pokémon of this adventure, it would have been cool, I think I had seen the rivalries of these new Pokémon from the Ash for example Staraptor Buizel Minum against Skarmory Swampert Pichu it would be amazing and it would be cool if you had caught new Pokémon in this adventure for example Geodude Shiinx Shieldon Buneary Spiritomb Snover this six will be really good for ash team
Can't wait for the next one
Dude, please continue this series... I love it. Hope in future you can create your own series too, instead of following Ash
I love this what-if, it goes in a more unique direction with not only teams, but with the way trainers are handled as well. I love it, hope to see more in the future ^w^
Also, will Ash get Froslass? 030
As much as I love Piplup, I'm choosing to vote for him to Evolve and I'll be explaining why so those who are voting to keep him the way he is listen up as well.
So one of the Main Reasons why I want the Little Penguin Pokemon to Evolve is because we've already seen multiple Pokemon What Ifs of the Same Copy Paste Scenario before of Piplup choosing to not to Evolve, getting a Everstone and Dawn going on lose again to Zoey in the Sinnoh Grand Festival Finals and goes on to see Ash lose in the Top 4 or lose to Paul before going on Johto.
Do you see what I mean here? At this point it's gotten very repetitive because the Same Scenario for Sinnoh in a lot of What Ifs gets blurred together and even though there was one where Ash was able to win the Sinnoh League, it's still shows the Same Scenario for Dawn like in Canon as usual in that one too however this What If here by DexComics is aiming to be different from the rest of them especially the previous Ash Woke Up On Time What Ifs before it and I love it how it's giving everyone the chance to change things here in Sinnoh rather than just going to do the same thing.
The 3 other Main Reasons are that I really want to see Dawn actually beat Zoey this around in the Sinnoh Grand Festival Finals this time around (rather than it being a early Alain Situation again before Alain) but barely so she knows she still needs work and I really want to see Ash Challenge the Sinnoh Battle Frontier and Win the Sinnoh League other than the What Ifs on Ash Waking Up On Time and finally I want to add something else too: I want the Sinnoh Group to be able to compete in the Qualifiers for the Pokeathlon in Johto and actually go to Johto to compete in it instead of a Plot Hole, maybe Stop the remnants of Team Galactic from attempting to use Arceus to maybe bring back Cyrus and create their own World with him as well as create their own Creation Trio at Sinjoh Ruins (mix In The Stuff from The Arceus Chronicles)and then they go their separate ways in Johto( with Dawn staying in Johto) using the Magnet Train and Ash and Brock can go theirs as Canon. I'm also hoping that you'll be including Stuff from Pokemon Legends Arceus like I have a feeling that you're going to do like Ash's Scyther becoming a Cleavor, Moves from The Game and maybe a certain Quilava becoming a Hisuian Typloshion.😉😉😉
Additionally if you ever get to Unova, do you think you can incorporate Contests being in Unova from The Pokemon Journeys Series, have Ash win some Competitions/Tournaments in Unova unlike in Canon where he only won outside of the Region and maybe have Ash's Battle in the Unova League Finals end in a Draw? Considering that we've seen previous What Ifs having Ash losing in The Vertress Conference beforehand, a Draw is definitely a very interesting outcome and helps you stand out from the rest.
Bro provide the kalos part it's very important as ash have key stone and mega stone
Finally after a whole year
I like ash’s team so far but It’s quite weird that he got swampert instead of a sinnoh water type.
Swampert's evolution line never got to shine in Hoenn because Brock never got it here. Plus the Piplup will always belong to Dawn, Kenny and Barry I couldn't in good conscious give it to Ash
@@DexComics I can’t say you aren’t wrong, The mudkip Line were robbed in Advanced. Ash should have gotten swampert instead of corpish even tho I like ash’s Corpish. The Piplup line never really suited ash. I never said he should have gotten piplup. I never said he should Get piplup tho,btw Good choice on evovling turtwig.
Yes I believe piplup should evolve and so should turtwig for that mater.
Hell yeah I’ve missed so much
Indeed
I clearly have to go back and watch the previous parts. I don't remember half of Ashes captures lol
I am so glad you made your on little changes this is so interesting and I really do hope Ash gets to challenge the sinnoh battle frontier maybe this could help ash get stronger make some pokemon evolve heck maybe he could beat tobias with the stronger mons but I am kinda weirded out that Ash caught a male combee i think he matches dawn more while Ash catches the female one and I really do hope Gible evolves and for piplup well sure evolution will change but it has its perks so say evolve but right now maybe when ash sees him at unova
Tbh I kinda want to see Ash's Rhydon evolved into a Rhperior, just saying.
Yes Piplup should evolve because to me personally Dawn getting the Everstone from Zoey or Nurse Joy was a copout and copycat of how Ash doesn't give Pikachu the Thunderstone
awesome video, cant wait for part nine
I love the layout of all the Pokémon he had, but I was gonna say you added an extra Beedrill, but then I remember he caught one in the bug catching contest but why is there a weedle
He caught the Weedle, Paras and Caterpie in the Orange Islands just before he caught Scyther
I would love to see Ash’s Randomizer continue
Part 9 kab aaya ga
Instead of giving swampert directly let dawn catch buizel and ash catch mudkip while fishing for Pokemon
Don't fall for the scam it is not even dex
@@yaboisanti8932 thanks bro
Your welcome gotta have some fans back
Liking Ash squad so far
Finally you uploaded it
I have a bit of a peeve about this episode because offensively a male conbee would be Way more better for dawn in her contest and the female one would have been way more better for ash But other than that this story was awesome I can't wait for the next sport and hopefully we don't to wait a year for the next episode to come out And also other new episodes of what if's to come out because you sir has been gone for a while
I honestly agree with ya on the Combee thing, Vespiquen works better for Ash's team
@@lunarskygacha9036 Thank you sky
FINALLY ITS BEEN WAY TO LONG!!
I say Piplup shouldn’t evolve. Way to iconic for it to evolve in this timeline
When r u going to post part 9
Dude it's been two months now so where's part 9
I hope Ivysaur, Rhydon, Caterpie, Paras, Weedle, Scyther, Totodile, Pichu, Virbrava and Snorunt evolve
I doubt ivysaur, rhydon would be cool if it evolved but unlikely, catarpie would work, Paras is very unlikely, weedle I doubt because now he would have 3 beedrills, scyther deserves to evolve he just teased us abt it, totodile would be likely, pichu is a guaranteed he said it himself, vibrava deserves to evolve, and snowrunt is most likely to evolve
I hope you do more soon.
I think dawn’s piplup should only evolve once and that’s it
Piplup and turtwig should evolve and turtwig could be listening or gible
Also you should make ash’s swampart listen in the next part and you should also evolve monferno
Don't worry he will evolve along with gligar and gible
I personally think piplup shouldn’t evolve I simply prefer it that way, but it would still be fun to see him evolve in this timeline
once again i hear the probo pass trainers voice sounds like gokus voice
I want to see part 9
Whats up with writers giving Ash especially an experienced Ash, disobediant Pokémon? Like this is Ash's 4th region and gave him a disobediant Swampert which is so dumb, and giving these inexperienced trainers giving Ash lessons is so dumb. Those disobediant days should of been over by now. 😐🤦🏽♂️
Basically it is just a copy and paste at this point with minor tweaks and different Pokémon and you giving him weaker Pokémon instead of stronger ones too. Like whats up with that?
Also what is up with writers giving Ash's traveling companion better development too? It just never makes sense to me.
I think you should let piplup evolve and buneary
I have greatly enjoyed this video.
I believe Piplup should not evolve. Let it remain as is.
I do think He should evolve because he didn't evolve in the original series and I would really like to see what kind of damage and also other Combo moves dawn will come up with with a plainpump I'm sorry if I put your name or even spelled it wrong it's just been a while
I think piplup should evolve
Can someone put a link for next part
Can you do another part of what if ash and red were twins it's my favorite series
What happened to gligar please use it in part 9
Please upload next part
Need Part 2 asap
Let piplup and turwig evolve
Listen don't fall for it
Let's be honest it 100% had to be gible listening to their conversation
Evolve piplup
Facts!!!
Piplup should stay as he is?
Its Minun not Minum its giving me vibes your reading from a script getting some names wrong ,also if your going to have a mon use Metronome make sure you know what moves were available at the time in Gen 4.
it was good i think you gave ash too many Pokémon
It's still not enough
Will Swampert ever obey Ash Ketchum's commands in this timeline?
More importantly will scyther ever will
Don't evolve piplup...he's too iconic
I was late damn it
Dex whyyyyyyyy I wish you were going to give ash snover not brock dang it I really wanted ash to have an Albomansnow and now he won't get hippotas either damn it whyyyyyyy 😭😢
Snover is a really cool pokemon, but I feel like this specific Snover would have fit better with Brock
Well I have hopes for many of ashs pokemon evolving during the league
Yes
When is Part 9?
Yes he should evolve
CHARIZARD DIDN'T DO ANYING
Please release next video
Wait ash's charizard is female
Yeah, he confirmed it in the Johto saga I think.
@@oragewoods5606 yup that is correct
Ashes Charizard being a girl is weird in the anime he’s a boy 😂
@@h0hleek That is Charizard is with Brock
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo