Beastinvader I’d recommend Avengers Earth Mightiest Heroes show if you wanna see more of how Tony is the futurist and how his good intentions are sometimes can be turned to his worst. Both cap and Tony talks about that quality and an entire 1 or 2 episodes are dedicated to that. Also Ultron is handled almost perfectly even with Tony’s small but important contributions.
The hope vs fear thing is something I pointed out in a different video a couple of years ago ( was more focused on the hope v fear thing than the past v future). Glad to see I'm not the only one that noticed.
"the man out of time" vs "the futurist" it was right there lol Steve was always seeking something from his past to cling to (Peggy and/or Bucky) whereas Tony consistently thought about and planned harder than anyone to prepare for the future.
It’s surprising looking back and seeing how many villains there actually were in this trilogy. Red skull, Armim Zola, Batroc the Leaper, Winter Solider, Alexander Pierce, Jasper Sitwell, Crossbones, Baron Zemo and technically even iron man, black Panther, Spider-Man, black widow, war machine and vision. Oh and don’t forget the entire legion of hydra
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
what i love the most about steve is that he IS stubborn, but he stays faithful to his values, despite everything he saw in the war and went through in his private life, he never lost hope in humanity or gave up on himself, it's kind of a unrealistic inspiration for me, because irl there's a belief that no one can physically and mentally endure the nightmare of carrying that weight of responsability and honor, but every time things get too hard and impossible for me, the whole capitan america story and its beautiful ending, of him finally getting to live the life he sacrificed, it makes me happy and hopeful that i can get out of a dark place
This is such a beautiful and well made video of one of my favourite Marvel superheroes. It's actually funny because I was never the biggest fan of Captain America before the MCU. I always found him to be annoying. I hated his boyscout personality. I never found him interesting. He was basically just Marvel's Superman and nothing more. That all changed when I saw Captain America The First Avenger. This film was such a perfect origin story for Cap. We saw how everything that he stood for started in this film. His friendship with Bucky. His relationship with Peggy. His devotion to his country and just his good will as a human being. The part where Steve jumps on a dummy grenade in the camp full of army buddies that pick on him for being too small and the scene of Dr Abraham Erskine's observation of him really says it all. Cap was fine in the first Avengers film but it was really The Winter Soldier that solidified him as not only my favorite Avenger and my favorite main hero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe but as one of my favorite superheros of all time in general. I love how everything that he stood for in this film and in Civil War was tested. His friendship and loyalty to Bucky. His friendship and loyalty to Tony Stark/Iron Man. His loyalty to SHIELD and the Avengers. Peggy dying of old age and leaving him and then losing half of his friends to Thanos in Infinity War before bringing them all back in Endgame and finally getting the happy ending that he deserved after he had been through so much shit for so long. That is the story of Steve Rogers/Captain America folks. And to think. I used to hate the guy and I used to find him to be annoying.
I love video essays, I’m new to you’re channel but I’ve suscribed now. Could you do a video on depression and anxiety someday if that’s possible however you seem like you could tbh
Another thing about Steve's vs Tony's genesis is that Steve volunteered while Stark is kidnapped. Steve chose to be what he became, while Tony has no option but to escape from there. Action vs Reaction. God, Civil War is so good.
And it's so cool how that was flipped in Civil War. Tony decided to take the initiative and willingly entered a fight for the future whereas Steve is trying to figure out how to adapt or whether to double down on his previous circumstances. But that decision was forced upon him.
@@wafflingmean4477 Fight for the future? He was so mired down in guilt, fear, misery and selfishness I wonder that he could find his way to the parking lot, let alone Germany.
One thing I didn't see you mention was the endings of all the movies. At the end of TFA, Steve sacrifices himself to save the world. At the end of TWS, Steve sacrifices himself to save a friend. And at the end of CW, Steve sacrifices his friendship with Tony to save Bucky. What's so interesting about the CA trilogy is Steve never really wins. He always does what's right, but by doing that he lost his past, almost lost his life, and lost the family that was The Avengers. As you said, his character is all about perseverance, and I think all of his movies ending with him losing something extremely important to him, or to anyone, is what makes his character so compelling and inspiring.
@@Spartain14 personally I think it's a good end to his arc. After a lifetime of selflessness and sacrifice he ended up taking something from the person he least expected: Tony Stark. He chided Tony for being a selfish man when they first met only to indulge in a selfish act at the end of his journey and enjoy his own life rather than return to duty. He even says he got the idea from Tony. But I don't think selfishness in this case is a bad thing because Steve truly earned it
@@Spartain14 I saw it opening night with friends, and the ending was the only time I've ever full on cried in front of people. I relate to Cap a lot, and I know how it feels to sacrifice a lot for others. Cap lost his past, his family, his friends, everything, and even after the snap he still continued to dedicate his life to helping others in any way he can, such as group therapy sessions. The way I see it, his ending was essentially his reward for sacrificing everything he ever had, and I was very happy that he got the happy ending he deserved. People say it's out of character, which I can kind of see why, but if you put yourself in his shoes it makes sense. After years of sacrificing his happiness, he finally decided to let himself be happy for once
Out of all of the Avengers, Captain America was always my favorite, even with how “square” he always seemed. What the Russo’s and Chris Evans as a whole did to this character made me love Cap even more. If the avengers had a backbone, cap would be that backbone
@Oddwolf 799 Captain America was their heart and their backbone, Hulk was the muscle, Tony the brain, and Thor was clearly the abs of the Avengers. Their sexy, sexy abs.
MCUs Captain America is what Henry Cavills Superman should have been, surrounded by a negative world but still retains his hope and positive outlook on life
Wow Mos was a way better story then the first avenger. You get nostalgic About it now but that movie was really boring. Why didn’t he jump out of the plane? I mean he doesn’t need a parachute to survive? But wow you looking to a character who didn’t have to change through his trilogy and Superman who was redeemed at death. Cap never says “no one stays good in this world” And in civil war he is wrong!!!! He dies saying so. Holding on too nostalgia tony was compromising bc that’s what a true hero does. But no since the Bucky thing hijacks the story cap never apologizes for being a non sensical asshole. His arguments don’t make sense. What if they send us somewhere we don’t want to go???? Then don’t go!!!! But at least throw people who are afraid of your power a bone!!!
@@Chessheromusic "You get nostalgic About it now but that movie was really boring. " Sorry, you're attempting to defend Man of Steel, and you're using the description "boring" as a pejorative? Are you trying to shoot yourself in the foot? "Why didn’t he jump out of the plane?" The planes are on autopilot to major cities. Steve is not Tony, he's not a mechanical genius. Taking the plane back into manual and steering the entire way is the only option which he has available to him. "you looking to a character who didn’t have to change through his trilogy" Yes he did. A lot. He never changed his moral compass, but he changed his political ideologies substantially. He does a complete 180 from being the governments boy scout to fighting for complete individual freedom against corrupt government agencies. "and Superman who was redeemed at death." No. He's still responsible for the hundreds of millions of deaths in Man of Steel. Being suicidal and deciding to sacrifice himself instead of just giving the spear instead of Wonder Woman doesn't redeem his actions. Superman is never given redemption or forgiveness in Justice League, the film just pretends Superman was always good and ignores every single mistake he ever made in his previous 2 films. Which is one of the only redeeming aspects of that film for me, that it's more interested in presenting a faithful adaptation of the character then worrying about irrelevant continuity details, but that just makes his previous 2 films even worse because they were entirely pointless. "Cap never says “no one stays good in this world”" He doesn't need to. The audience can figure that out as they're shocked that Steve lied to Tony. They don't need the central theme forced down their throat, because they're not that stupid. And the entire point of the comment you're replying to is that Superman should not be like this. Superman should not be corrupted for no thematic reason whatsoever. Snyder never uses his cultural vandalism of this pop culture icon to say anything, it's just angst for the sake of angst. And he cannot even fail to "stay good in this world", because he was never good to begin with. He became a hero for selfish reasons thanks to some dodgy philosophical ideas from his parents, and cares so little for human life that he kills hundreds of millions of people. Superman is a threat, not a hero. "in civil war he is wrong" No. He is very clearly the protagonist of the film, and Tony is very clearly the antagonist. Just because he does some immoral things, and Tony is presented as sympathetic, does not mean the film ever calls his position wrong in any capacity, because it always explicitly endorses his actions as correct up until his lie is revealed. "He dies saying so." Who are we talking about? "tony was compromising bc that’s what a true hero does." That's depressing. Is that what you really think a super hero is supposed to stand for? Super heroes are idealistic, power fantasies, givers of agency to an audience which lacks it. They are as far away from compromises as you can get. And notice how Tony's legacy comes from placing the interests of the greater good over his family? Aka, not choosing to compromise and 100% dedicating himself to being a hero and sacrificing himself. Tony in Civil War is a broken Tony, it's the lowest his character ever gets besides at the start of Endgame. It is in no way remotely close to a "true hero". "since the Bucky thing hijacks the story cap never apologizes for being a non sensical asshole." He never needs to. He apologised for the only thing he did wrong, lying to Tony. That's the only mistake cap makes in the story. You've failed to identify any of his mistakes whatsoever. "His arguments don’t make sense. What if they send us somewhere we don’t want to go???? Then don’t go!!!!" And then he's fired from the Avengers, and can't save people without breaking the law. What a great decision. The conflict of Civil War is freedom v oversight, the same one from Winter Soldier. Under the accords Cap does not have the freedom to decline orders from this UN panel, that's the entire point. "But at least throw people who are afraid of your power a bone!!!" That last time he did that, he ended up working for Hydra. And General Ross is gonna turn out to be Red Hulk eventually. So I'm pretty sure Steve made the right move.
Buckey is a symbol of post-modernity and subjectivism. From Roger's perspective, he's a law abiding citizen, a fellow soldier, and a good friend. But from the world's perspective, he's a terrorist, a mercenary, and a danger to society.
@@Zapdos97 Thanks for your comment, friend. Could you do me a favor? Edit out the swear language. The guy above you edited his after i asked him. I would like to keep this comment thread free from foul language. I'm only asking. Thanks
Ive argued with many people that Captain America is not a blind patriot. You summed everything up nicely. As a multi deployed veteran, I really connected with these three movies because they summarized a lot of my personal conflicts as well. This is a great trilogy because as you said, it is all about a person who has invested deeply in a belief system coming to terms with his place in an ever changing world but also staying true to the essence of his beliefs, or himself as a person. At last as far as I see it ;). Well done video man!
Cpt America is a classic story of stoicism. Tradition, principles, beliefs... Those were his strengths. "We don't need a perfect soldier, we need a good man." His sense of skeptism is not against what he sees in the new society, it's what he experienced in the old. He knows how much society has changed in the new, he realises how much the old social values were still valid. That's why it was so fundamentally different from Ironman's sense of revolution.
I think we need to stop calling it the Avengers Quadrilogy, it just sounds funny. I think the Avengers Anthology sounds better, and it means the same thing
I’m so glad that other people can see how deep cap actually is as a character. He’s my favorite super hero for these reasons and he’s like a person I think everyone should want to be like. Not a perfect soldier or perfect anything but a good person
ikr Since he doesn’t always show much emotion, doesn’t always talk about himself, hides his problems and personal issue to the world unlike some other characters (like Chris said, “Cap doesn’t ‘bleed’ on other people), people underestimate the depth because sometimes they can’t see past the subtlety
Is there any way to let Chris Evans know about this video? Your content is fantastic in every regard and this one in particular is a tour de force. Everyone connected with the MCU deserves to know you and your work.
A parallel that I've noticed between Tony and Cap, that defines them, is that as one commenter pointed out Tony never got a say in anything to do with his life until his early to mid thirties whereas Cap was always stepping forward. As well, Tony never looks to his past because aside from it being too painful, it's also too vague. Steve, opposingly, derives much if not all of who he is from his past while he cautiously navigates the present and future (vs Tony thrusting light years into the future). You could almost say that Tony, someone who spent his life running from his past resented that part of Steve that felt he had a past that he loved enough to cling to. Steve, loving his past and wanting nothing more than to go back saw Tony and his need to rush into things and the "future" as foolhardy. Caution vs Reckless. As well, Cap sees Tony as who he might have turned into (personality wise)had he not been raised when and how he was and Tony sees Cap as the man he thinks his father wanted him to be. Tony was always afraid he'd never live up to expectations set by his dad so he never stepped up and just let someone else do the work while he got to play with his toys Vs Steve who was all too ready to accept the responsibility of what he considered doing the right thing. So many parallels!!
That's why I had problems with Tony (and the people who said he was a flawed paragon and saint) and why I was Team Cap all the way. Almost everything Tony did in the ensemble movies revolved around fear, guilt, loneliness and shame. Almost everything Cap did revolved around integrity, loyalty, respect, realism, caring for other people and doing things for other people even though they might have passed, or be in trouble that would spill over onto him and bravery.
How Steve goes from the perfect soldier to fugitive to war criminal to nomad in infinity war I think is the best example of "the difference between a rebel and a patriot depends upon who is in power at the moment"
@monokhem Bullshit he had no idea he could fly dipshit not to mention the world hated him and Thor's development was completely thrown out the window guess he is the God of hammers
When did America try to uphold that level of honor and care for everyone? I can go thru history and honestly say America was a great idea that never lived up to its potential... not even close
When the MCU was in its infancy and Captain America was announced, I remember saying to my wife “How on earth are they going to make this stars and stripes symbol of American WW2 propaganda relevant to modern audiences?” They did it by casting the perfect actor, giving him a meaningful and well written character arc, and allowing plenty of time for his journey to unfold. They didn’t rush things, the MCU gives characters and plot lines time to exist and breathe before moving the story along. Pretty much the exact opposite of, and explains why the DCEU has disappointed me so badly. I knew of but hardly cared about Cap, Iron Man and Thor. My childhood heroes were Superman and Batman and Wonder Woman (and Spiderman and the Hulk). But DC screwed the DCEU versions of Supes and Batman by rushing, rather than giving characters time to grow. Such a shame :-( At least I’ve got the Nolan Batman movies, and Wonder Woman.
You could definitely took Winter Soldier and from MCU and it can slot right in into James Bond or Mission Impossible. One of the best Solo Movie in MCU is the one that isn't actually a superhero movie
MysterySteve: The Pathetic Gamer I always see people chose Cap trilogy as the best trilogy in MCU, including being announced as Rotten Tomato’s Top 3 in the trilogy category But I agree The First Avenger is so underrated even though it’s good
@@MissLaraAshcroft I seriously wish I could meet the fans people keep talking about who love the Cap trilogy. All the people I know call it bland/dull bug it's my favourite trilogy.
MysterySteve: The Pathetic Gamer It’s obviously not dull when it contains The Winter Soldier, which always regarded as one of best movies (not necessarily in MCU)..and whoever said Civil War is bland need serious check-up ahead I seriously wonder what type of people that said those and the type of movies that they like
Great essay actually. ...And then Cap returned the soul stone to Red Skull who was guarding it for some reason, and who knows what happened when they met up. 🤷🏻♂️
I have a theory that may have given each other a hug and a high five, or a dramatic stare with sad piano music playing in the background as they reflect how much they and the world has changed. One of the two
@@ImplicitlyPretentious Yeah. "Bro Hug" is my theory, too. The only two people who could possibly understand the other one. A glance, a nod, a hug. That's all they'd need.
I hope you aren’t as hard on yourself as you put on. You should be proud that the video you made at 19, with the mic backwards, a more pronounced lisp, and a lot less experience. You made a video many people connected with - your ideas and your presentation of them. That’s like artistic creation and stuff. I hope you keep it up. I look forward to hearing what you have to say.
Thank you! That's incredibly flattering! And yeah I'm not as hard on myself about it now since I can joke about it, but I absolutely appreciate the words :)
Nicely done. I would like to add that because of his strong traditionalism, Cap is the steady fulcrum, the moral gold standard perhaps, from which every other Marvel character is measured. He demonstrates that a principled perseverence can prevent tyranny where submission for the sake of social convenience could not. He was such an important character for the MCU that I'm slightly concerned that they will lose their way without him at the center. Time will tell.
Wonderful breakdown of the evolution of Captain America. Love your videos! What I appreciate in Endgame in regards to Captain America is that we get to fully realize and appreciate his evolution when he's pitted against himself from earlier in his journey. There's an exasperation with his younger self beautifully executed from the line "I can do this all day." He acknowledges how frustrating his rigid idealism meant he was often solving problems "harder" instead of "smarter." Though also a nod to the controversial recent Captain America comics, the fact that older Cap chooses to say "Hail Hydra" to get the tesseract versus taking on the entire elevator of armed guards shows yet more growth. He's well aware these are the "bad guys" but he has more important shit to do, and the deception is just faster and more efficient.
The Captain America Trilogy is THE best superhero trilogy. It's the most complete, it's the most consistent, it has a compelling overarching story, and most importantly, it doesn't fail in the end (looking at you Dark Knight trilogy).
Oh my god, you have the words to my reasons why Cap is my favorite avenger. I never knew, what fascinated me about him that much. But as I was listening to you, I realised, it's exactly this. Thank you.
Considering most countries in the world are thousands of years old, the US is extremely young. Speaking as a Greek Egyptian, but I’m sure the Chinese would back me here.
Rudra Singh while the US as a country is technically not that young, as a cultural location it’s incredibly young. Greece as a country is technically a hundred years younger than the US but as a cultural identity it’s centuries older
i dont care,i think the Captain America trilogy is one of the best. i love all three in their own special ways and viewed together just enhances each separate movie. ill always be #teamcaptainamerica, he portrays what America at its best could be and what we all want America to be. We are a country of rebels and i think we've forgotten that, Capt. reminds us to always buck the system if we think it's wrong. Thats what we were founded on. thank you for this video, def. enjoyed it. xoxo
Funny how one of the less popular og avengers had the best trilogy out of all of them and it’s not even close. I mean Iron Man’a trilogy had only one good film. He’s the clear favorite but didn’t have the greatest solo films save iron man 1. Thor also is kinda mid except for ragnarok which I thought was pretty good bht of course they went too far with love and thunder. Captain America’s trilogy is the one i keep coming back to aside from avengers. They just get better and better. I just love the setup of the first one being a period piece and then almost completely changing genres and becoming gritty spy thrillers with superheroes in winter soldier and civil war.
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Tradere is pronounced Trad-eh-rey. Awesome video essay but just in case you're curious, latin letters are always pronounced the same way. Vowels are: a = ah e = eh as in bed i = ee as in seen o = oh u = oo as in cook
Thank you for this video. Truthfully, it's very touching. Cap's attitude and values are ones that make me relate to him, which is why he is my favorite superhero. It's been rough lately, to understand some things. This made me feel okay about it all. By the way, the last song, "I'll Remember You", can you provide the artist? Thanks!
What makes Cap trilogy great is it isn’t only impact on audience, the story impact on Cap and really let us understand why he make these decisions cuz of his perspectives throughout this trilogy 👌
this is why i don’t understand why people hate Cap’s endgame ending, because it makes SO MUCH SENSE and it’s satisfying to see Steve finally compromising and being selfish FOR ONCE and finding his peace.
I just realized. Cap always represented the right way to move forward. To be the product of future science and past ideas. Just as red skull degraded from the serum and cap became better, the role of science was to make them stronger and to magnify the values they hold.
I really enjoy your breakdown of Steve's journey through modernity vs nostalgia/tradition. I like how you tied his compromise in EG with his lack of personal compromise in CW. I am a little disappointed that you didn't dig more into his choices in IW and EG though I understand that this is a CA analysis not an analysis of those two movies. I tend to feel like the things people have the most divergent interpretations on are the extent to which he's in a bad place in IW (which pulls into the larger question of how much he's in the "wrong"/has compromised his personal beliefs for personal reasons at the end of CW), whether his counselling work is a positive (re: his personal progression) or negative sign and of course his ending. You talked a bit about your views re: his ending/time travel and I think "compromise" is a good way of putting it and you discussed the counselling a bit in your EG analysis where I think you went on the positive sign. I really like the idea that where the Cap films are all about Steve struggling with the contemporary and the tradition/nostalgia v modernity, the Avengers films are a resolution to the particular struggle expressed in the preceding Cap movie. Thanks for the great video!
Thank you! And that's a really great perspective! And yeah I'm planning to do a whole essay on the Avengers quadrilogy, so I can devote more on infinity war so that's why it's only in the periphery of this one! :)
Title notwithstanding, I don't think "Captain America: Civil War" should be considered part of the Captain America series. It's much more an Avengers movie and every bit a Tony Stark movie as Cap movie. If they didn't want to classify as part of the Avengers series, they should have called it "Marvel's Civil War".
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
I think I remember watching your first video and thinking it was great. Don't see the need for remaking it with this one, but alright. I'm a Captain America fan, so I'm all for putting his stories out into the universe a second time.
Great vid, I've watched it twice. You're welcome to do more stuff about traditionalism vs modernity (and I don't think we've left modernity behind, in spite of postmodernity, I'd rather say we live in a world that is a mix of modernity and postmodernity). You can certainly draw parallels between currrent social media censorship and Hydra/Shield.
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
I liked the Captain America films, Iron Man 1, Incredible Hulk, the first Thor, Avengers 1 and Infinity War, the Daredevil and Jessica Jones shows and Season 1 of Punisher. I liked Black Panther too. But the MCU now, rather than a superhero series with some comedy that's actually clever and funny is now bad comedies about people in superhero cosplay.
I just found this video and I want to see more from you. You’re intelligent and your essay about Captain America and Steve Rogers is spot on. I love your analysis of the dynamic between Steve and Tony. I want to add one thing about them. I have always felt that Steve is a highly evolved person with lots of emotional intelligence, Tony is not. He’s an emotional mess with narcissistic tendencies. Eventually he evolves but it’s mostly after Thanos’ snap and everything slows down. It’s then that he’s forced to look at himself. Keep up the great work!
he didn't 'compromise' in endgame...he found peace...he stayed back in time because he knew he would be there when the world really needed him...he defeated thanos...the world would be fine without him...he got to enjoy a well earned RETIREMENT with a family and the woman he loved
This is making me think that another logical conclusion to Steve's story is if we didn't get Infinity War, to have a fourth Captain America movie where S.H.I.E.L.D. returns, Cap tried to stop them and does a brutal death, symbolizing that what he's fighting for is dead and the new era of modernity will live on, despite the previous generation refusing to give way to it.
Cap holding on to the past and Stark holding on to the future is a duality that I never noticed before.
Beastinvader They call Tony “the futurist” at one point in Civil War.
Beastinvader I’d recommend Avengers Earth Mightiest Heroes show if you wanna see more of how Tony is the futurist and how his good intentions are sometimes can be turned to his worst. Both cap and Tony talks about that quality and an entire 1 or 2 episodes are dedicated to that.
Also Ultron is handled almost perfectly even with Tony’s small but important contributions.
The hope vs fear thing is something I pointed out in a different video a couple of years ago ( was more focused on the hope v fear thing than the past v future). Glad to see I'm not the only one that noticed.
Definitely the parallel with their "hearts" was something cool that I had not noticed before.
"the man out of time" vs "the futurist" it was right there lol Steve was always seeking something from his past to cling to (Peggy and/or Bucky) whereas Tony consistently thought about and planned harder than anyone to prepare for the future.
The Captain America trilogy of movies were all great film's, that's a claim that even Iron Man doesn't have.
Chris Evans’s Captain America is one of the greatest, most iconic movie characters of all time. Change my mind.
It’s surprising looking back and seeing how many villains there actually were in this trilogy. Red skull, Armim Zola, Batroc the Leaper, Winter Solider, Alexander Pierce, Jasper Sitwell, Crossbones, Baron Zemo and technically even iron man, black Panther, Spider-Man, black widow, war machine and vision. Oh and don’t forget the entire legion of hydra
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
what i love the most about steve is that he IS stubborn, but he stays faithful to his values, despite everything he saw in the war and went through in his private life, he never lost hope in humanity or gave up on himself, it's kind of a unrealistic inspiration for me, because irl there's a belief that no one can physically and mentally endure the nightmare of carrying that weight of responsability and honor, but every time things get too hard and impossible for me, the whole capitan america story and its beautiful ending, of him finally getting to live the life he sacrificed, it makes me happy and hopeful that i can get out of a dark place
Your video are seemingly beautiful...Background music, editing and your narration..everything is top notch...
This is surprisingly a very good video that rings true in more than one way.
This is such a beautiful and well made video of one of my favourite Marvel superheroes. It's actually funny because I was never the biggest fan of Captain America before the MCU. I always found him to be annoying. I hated his boyscout personality. I never found him interesting. He was basically just Marvel's Superman and nothing more.
That all changed when I saw Captain America The First Avenger. This film was such a perfect origin story for Cap. We saw how everything that he stood for started in this film. His friendship with Bucky. His relationship with Peggy. His devotion to his country and just his good will as a human being. The part where Steve jumps on a dummy grenade in the camp full of army buddies that pick on him for being too small and the scene of Dr Abraham Erskine's observation of him really says it all.
Cap was fine in the first Avengers film but it was really The Winter Soldier that solidified him as not only my favorite Avenger and my favorite main hero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe but as one of my favorite superheros of all time in general. I love how everything that he stood for in this film and in Civil War was tested. His friendship and loyalty to Bucky. His friendship and loyalty to Tony Stark/Iron Man. His loyalty to SHIELD and the Avengers. Peggy dying of old age and leaving him and then losing half of his friends to Thanos in Infinity War before bringing them all back in Endgame and finally getting the happy ending that he deserved after he had been through so much shit for so long. That is the story of Steve Rogers/Captain America folks. And to think. I used to hate the guy and I used to find him to be annoying.
I never would've matched the voice with the face. Nope! Totally unexpected.
nice to see you. fantastic thinking.
I want to see him break down both iron man and captain America whole arc throughout the mcu
Yeah! I really want to do that, either in a comparison essay or in the Avengers quadrilogy video :)
Implicitly Pretentious cool sounds good👍🏻
Beautiful piece.
I love video essays, I’m new to you’re channel but I’ve suscribed now. Could you do a video on depression and anxiety someday if that’s possible however you seem like you could tbh
Yeah sure Mr Wick, I'll put it on the list :)
Loved the captain America winter soldier reference thanks brother!!
Nice essay
Another thing about Steve's vs Tony's genesis is that Steve volunteered while Stark is kidnapped. Steve chose to be what he became, while Tony has no option but to escape from there. Action vs Reaction. God, Civil War is so good.
And it's so cool how that was flipped in Civil War. Tony decided to take the initiative and willingly entered a fight for the future whereas Steve is trying to figure out how to adapt or whether to double down on his previous circumstances. But that decision was forced upon him.
@@wafflingmean4477 Fight for the future? He was so mired down in guilt, fear, misery and selfishness I wonder that he could find his way to the parking lot, let alone Germany.
One thing I didn't see you mention was the endings of all the movies.
At the end of TFA, Steve sacrifices himself to save the world. At the end of TWS, Steve sacrifices himself to save a friend. And at the end of CW, Steve sacrifices his friendship with Tony to save Bucky.
What's so interesting about the CA trilogy is Steve never really wins. He always does what's right, but by doing that he lost his past, almost lost his life, and lost the family that was The Avengers. As you said, his character is all about perseverance, and I think all of his movies ending with him losing something extremely important to him, or to anyone, is what makes his character so compelling and inspiring.
So how did you feel about Captain America's ending in Endgame? About his choice?
@@Spartain14 personally I think it's a good end to his arc. After a lifetime of selflessness and sacrifice he ended up taking something from the person he least expected: Tony Stark. He chided Tony for being a selfish man when they first met only to indulge in a selfish act at the end of his journey and enjoy his own life rather than return to duty. He even says he got the idea from Tony. But I don't think selfishness in this case is a bad thing because Steve truly earned it
@@Spartain14 I saw it opening night with friends, and the ending was the only time I've ever full on cried in front of people. I relate to Cap a lot, and I know how it feels to sacrifice a lot for others. Cap lost his past, his family, his friends, everything, and even after the snap he still continued to dedicate his life to helping others in any way he can, such as group therapy sessions. The way I see it, his ending was essentially his reward for sacrificing everything he ever had, and I was very happy that he got the happy ending he deserved.
People say it's out of character, which I can kind of see why, but if you put yourself in his shoes it makes sense. After years of sacrificing his happiness, he finally decided to let himself be happy for once
This is what made his ending in Endgame so emotional and perfect. Beautiful arc.
How do you think his self-sacrifice squares with his choice in the ending of Avengers Endgame?
Out of all of the Avengers, Captain America was always my favorite, even with how “square” he always seemed. What the Russo’s and Chris Evans as a whole did to this character made me love Cap even more. If the avengers had a backbone, cap would be that backbone
@Oddwolf 799 Captain America was their heart and their backbone, Hulk was the muscle, Tony the brain, and Thor was clearly the abs of the Avengers. Their sexy, sexy abs.
I echo these sentiments.
MCUs Captain America is what Henry Cavills Superman should have been, surrounded by a negative world but still retains his hope and positive outlook on life
They wasted Henry Cavill.
Hope they get it right in the future and make the character right
Excaly i used to say DC should look at The First Avenger to get Superman back on track.
Wow Mos was a way better story then the first avenger.
You get nostalgic About it now but that movie was really boring.
Why didn’t he jump out of the plane? I mean he doesn’t need a parachute to survive?
But wow you looking to a character who didn’t have to change through his trilogy and Superman who was redeemed at death.
Cap never says “no one stays good in this world”
And in civil war he is wrong!!!!
He dies saying so. Holding on too nostalgia tony was compromising bc that’s what a true hero does.
But no since the Bucky thing hijacks the story cap never apologizes for being a non sensical asshole.
His arguments don’t make sense. What if they send us somewhere we don’t want to go????
Then don’t go!!!!
But at least throw people who are afraid of your power a bone!!!
@@Chessheromusic "You get nostalgic About it now but that movie was really boring. "
Sorry, you're attempting to defend Man of Steel, and you're using the description "boring" as a pejorative? Are you trying to shoot yourself in the foot?
"Why didn’t he jump out of the plane?"
The planes are on autopilot to major cities. Steve is not Tony, he's not a mechanical genius. Taking the plane back into manual and steering the entire way is the only option which he has available to him.
"you looking to a character who didn’t have to change through his trilogy"
Yes he did. A lot. He never changed his moral compass, but he changed his political ideologies substantially. He does a complete 180 from being the governments boy scout to fighting for complete individual freedom against corrupt government agencies.
"and Superman who was redeemed at death."
No. He's still responsible for the hundreds of millions of deaths in Man of Steel. Being suicidal and deciding to sacrifice himself instead of just giving the spear instead of Wonder Woman doesn't redeem his actions. Superman is never given redemption or forgiveness in Justice League, the film just pretends Superman was always good and ignores every single mistake he ever made in his previous 2 films. Which is one of the only redeeming aspects of that film for me, that it's more interested in presenting a faithful adaptation of the character then worrying about irrelevant continuity details, but that just makes his previous 2 films even worse because they were entirely pointless.
"Cap never says “no one stays good in this world”"
He doesn't need to. The audience can figure that out as they're shocked that Steve lied to Tony. They don't need the central theme forced down their throat, because they're not that stupid. And the entire point of the comment you're replying to is that Superman should not be like this. Superman should not be corrupted for no thematic reason whatsoever. Snyder never uses his cultural vandalism of this pop culture icon to say anything, it's just angst for the sake of angst. And he cannot even fail to "stay good in this world", because he was never good to begin with. He became a hero for selfish reasons thanks to some dodgy philosophical ideas from his parents, and cares so little for human life that he kills hundreds of millions of people. Superman is a threat, not a hero.
"in civil war he is wrong"
No. He is very clearly the protagonist of the film, and Tony is very clearly the antagonist. Just because he does some immoral things, and Tony is presented as sympathetic, does not mean the film ever calls his position wrong in any capacity, because it always explicitly endorses his actions as correct up until his lie is revealed.
"He dies saying so."
Who are we talking about?
"tony was compromising bc that’s what a true hero does."
That's depressing. Is that what you really think a super hero is supposed to stand for? Super heroes are idealistic, power fantasies, givers of agency to an audience which lacks it. They are as far away from compromises as you can get. And notice how Tony's legacy comes from placing the interests of the greater good over his family? Aka, not choosing to compromise and 100% dedicating himself to being a hero and sacrificing himself. Tony in Civil War is a broken Tony, it's the lowest his character ever gets besides at the start of Endgame. It is in no way remotely close to a "true hero".
"since the Bucky thing hijacks the story cap never apologizes for being a non sensical asshole."
He never needs to. He apologised for the only thing he did wrong, lying to Tony. That's the only mistake cap makes in the story. You've failed to identify any of his mistakes whatsoever.
"His arguments don’t make sense. What if they send us somewhere we don’t want to go????
Then don’t go!!!!"
And then he's fired from the Avengers, and can't save people without breaking the law. What a great decision. The conflict of Civil War is freedom v oversight, the same one from Winter Soldier. Under the accords Cap does not have the freedom to decline orders from this UN panel, that's the entire point.
"But at least throw people who are afraid of your power a bone!!!"
That last time he did that, he ended up working for Hydra. And General Ross is gonna turn out to be Red Hulk eventually. So I'm pretty sure Steve made the right move.
Buckey is a symbol of post-modernity and subjectivism. From Roger's perspective, he's a law abiding citizen, a fellow soldier, and a good friend. But from the world's perspective, he's a terrorist, a mercenary, and a danger to society.
Ooh Yeah that's a great interpretation!
bob polo woah lol that’s deep
Technically he *was* a danger to society. It only took words to unleash the beast.
@@Zapdos97 Thanks for your comment, friend. Could you do me a favor? Edit out the swear language. The guy above you edited his after i asked him. I would like to keep this comment thread free from foul language. I'm only asking. Thanks
bob polo as you wish. Btw, that was only a reference to Buckys words in Civil War, nothing malicious
The Captain America trilogy is so far the best trilogy in the MCU. It's the only trilogy that got progressively better as it went on!
Iron Man trilogy is better. Iron Man 2 & 3 are ten thousand times better movies than anything from Captain America's trilogy.
@@MachineFuckingHate ewww wth man
EgocentricHead have you ever watched winter soldier?!?!
@EgocentricHead No lol, Iron Man can suck Captain America's dick. Iron man is a shitty trilogy. Nowhere near Captain America.
EgocentricHead You must love Iron Man 3000 times over.
Shiet, you're the first person who ever pointed my attention towards the "Heart" difference between Cap and Iron Man.
This video is refreshing!
Ive argued with many people that Captain America is not a blind patriot. You summed everything up nicely. As a multi deployed veteran, I really connected with these three movies because they summarized a lot of my personal conflicts as well. This is a great trilogy because as you said, it is all about a person who has invested deeply in a belief system coming to terms with his place in an ever changing world but also staying true to the essence of his beliefs, or himself as a person. At last as far as I see it ;). Well done video man!
Cap is internationally venerated IRL because he is what America bills itself as being, and he opposes America when they don't line up with that ideal
Stark: HYDRA isn't going to attack you with a pocket knife
HYDRA Goon: pulls out pocket knife
Cpt America is a classic story of stoicism. Tradition, principles, beliefs... Those were his strengths. "We don't need a perfect soldier, we need a good man."
His sense of skeptism is not against what he sees in the new society, it's what he experienced in the old. He knows how much society has changed in the new, he realises how much the old social values were still valid. That's why it was so fundamentally different from Ironman's sense of revolution.
I can't wait for The Avengers Quadrilogy is Deceivingly Beautiful
Thanks! It's probably going to be done after a video on guardians of the galaxy! :)
Implicitly Pretentious it isn’t tho. No deception involved. Just beautiful
@@ImplicitlyPretentious you should wait Gardians of the galaxy for this one.
But not everyone was fond of Age of Ultron.
I think we need to stop calling it the Avengers Quadrilogy, it just sounds funny. I think the Avengers Anthology sounds better, and it means the same thing
I’m so glad that other people can see how deep cap actually is as a character. He’s my favorite super hero for these reasons and he’s like a person I think everyone should want to be like. Not a perfect soldier or perfect anything but a good person
ikr
Since he doesn’t always show much emotion, doesn’t always talk about himself, hides his problems and personal issue to the world unlike some other characters (like Chris said, “Cap doesn’t ‘bleed’ on other people), people underestimate the depth because sometimes they can’t see past the subtlety
@@MissLaraAshcroft well said
Captain America turned from my least favorite avenger to my favorite over the course of the MCU movies. Good video as usual fam!
Thank you!
Same here. I actually believed he was going to fight Thanos' army by himself, in endgame.
He was always been my Favorite avengers. Even before the MCU.
Mine too
@@menecross if no one had showed up, he would have fought till he had breath in his lungs. Cap is really underrated
That little supercut of Bucky getting his ass kicked and ending with cap's "he's my friend" line is the perfect trailer for civil war lol
Is there any way to let Chris Evans know about this video?
Your content is fantastic in every regard and this one in particular is a tour de force.
Everyone connected with the MCU deserves to know you and your work.
I think he's active on that Twitter thing?
A parallel that I've noticed between Tony and Cap, that defines them, is that as one commenter pointed out Tony never got a say in anything to do with his life until his early to mid thirties whereas Cap was always stepping forward. As well, Tony never looks to his past because aside from it being too painful, it's also too vague. Steve, opposingly, derives much if not all of who he is from his past while he cautiously navigates the present and future (vs Tony thrusting light years into the future). You could almost say that Tony, someone who spent his life running from his past resented that part of Steve that felt he had a past that he loved enough to cling to. Steve, loving his past and wanting nothing more than to go back saw Tony and his need to rush into things and the "future" as foolhardy. Caution vs Reckless. As well, Cap sees Tony as who he might have turned into (personality wise)had he not been raised when and how he was and Tony sees Cap as the man he thinks his father wanted him to be. Tony was always afraid he'd never live up to expectations set by his dad so he never stepped up and just let someone else do the work while he got to play with his toys Vs Steve who was all too ready to accept the responsibility of what he considered doing the right thing. So many parallels!!
That's why I had problems with Tony (and the people who said he was a flawed paragon and saint) and why I was Team Cap all the way. Almost everything Tony did in the ensemble movies revolved around fear, guilt, loneliness and shame. Almost everything Cap did revolved around integrity, loyalty, respect, realism, caring for other people and doing things for other people even though they might have passed, or be in trouble that would spill over onto him and bravery.
How Steve goes from the perfect soldier to fugitive to war criminal to nomad in infinity war
I think is the best example of "the difference between a rebel and a patriot depends upon who is in power at the moment"
legal does not always mean moral
When Marvel writes a better Superman than WB.
When development isn't something comic book fans understand
@monokhem That DCEU Clark Kent was developing into Superman that's the whole point why he looked miserable he was still trying to find himself
Trevor Philips DCEU Clark Kent’s was trash
@monokhem Bullshit he had no idea he could fly dipshit not to mention the world hated him and Thor's development was completely thrown out the window guess he is the God of hammers
@@roz067 no he had actual development unlike the boring one from the comics
Captain America is the personification of an America that never really existed... but at least it did strived to do so.
MCP/ChronicBuzz for some reason this comment almost made me cry
Faxxxxx
Superman is similar in that fashion.
Yet oddly enough his arch-rival, Lex Luthor, was the true personification of an American.
mbogucki1 damnnnn man had to come back I thought the first comment blew my mind but what you had to say was even crazier like
When did America try to uphold that level of honor and care for everyone? I can go thru history and honestly say America was a great idea that never lived up to its potential... not even close
When the MCU was in its infancy and Captain America was announced, I remember saying to my wife “How on earth are they going to make this stars and stripes symbol of American WW2 propaganda relevant to modern audiences?”
They did it by casting the perfect actor, giving him a meaningful and well written character arc, and allowing plenty of time for his journey to unfold. They didn’t rush things, the MCU gives characters and plot lines time to exist and breathe before moving the story along.
Pretty much the exact opposite of, and explains why the DCEU has disappointed me so badly.
I knew of but hardly cared about Cap, Iron Man and Thor. My childhood heroes were Superman and Batman and Wonder Woman (and Spiderman and the Hulk). But DC screwed the DCEU versions of Supes and Batman by rushing, rather than giving characters time to grow. Such a shame :-(
At least I’ve got the Nolan Batman movies, and Wonder Woman.
lmao i lost it when you said "damn kids and their F*** Tik Tok" outta nowhere
You could definitely took Winter Soldier and from MCU and it can slot right in into James Bond or Mission Impossible.
One of the best Solo Movie in MCU is the one that isn't actually a superhero movie
Always what I wanted him to be; what Steve Rogers is.
The heart of the Marvel Universe.
It's such a beautiful trilogy, I don't see why it gets such a bad rep. The First Avenger is still one of my favourite MCU films.
MysterySteve: The Pathetic Gamer
I always see people chose Cap trilogy as the best trilogy in MCU, including being announced as Rotten Tomato’s Top 3 in the trilogy category
But I agree The First Avenger is so underrated even though it’s good
@monokhem Well most of the people I talk to call it dull. I hope to meet your friends some day.
@@MissLaraAshcroft I seriously wish I could meet the fans people keep talking about who love the Cap trilogy. All the people I know call it bland/dull bug it's my favourite trilogy.
@monokhem Well I'm just glad to know someone somewhere out there has some goddamn taste.
MysterySteve: The Pathetic Gamer
It’s obviously not dull when it contains The Winter Soldier, which always regarded as one of best movies (not necessarily in MCU)..and whoever said Civil War is bland need serious check-up ahead
I seriously wonder what type of people that said those and the type of movies that they like
Great essay actually.
...And then Cap returned the soul stone to Red Skull who was guarding it for some reason, and who knows what happened when they met up. 🤷🏻♂️
I have a theory that may have given each other a hug and a high five, or a dramatic stare with sad piano music playing in the background as they reflect how much they and the world has changed. One of the two
@@ImplicitlyPretentious Yeah. "Bro Hug" is my theory, too. The only two people who could possibly understand the other one. A glance, a nod, a hug. That's all they'd need.
They probably never met. It is never said in Endgame that the stones to to be returned to where they were taken only when.
@@christianochoa3779 no, they need put in exactly where it was last time to avoid branch timeline
Implicitly Pretentious
I like your optimism. I shall adopt the theory of the bro fist.
I hope you aren’t as hard on yourself as you put on. You should be proud that the video you made at 19, with the mic backwards, a more pronounced lisp, and a lot less experience. You made a video many people connected with - your ideas and your presentation of them. That’s like artistic creation and stuff. I hope you keep it up. I look forward to hearing what you have to say.
Thank you! That's incredibly flattering! And yeah I'm not as hard on myself about it now since I can joke about it, but I absolutely appreciate the words :)
This is the most wholesome comment I've ever seen, and you seem like an amazing person. I hope you have a great day.
Greaek Stronghammer Thank you. I hope you have a great one!
Brown leather jacket with ww2 style helmet is my fav cap outfit from the mcu. Hes my fav hero along with Thor
One of the best videos on Captain America
Holy cow, thank you so much for the high praise!
You’re just so great at making videos man
Oh wow, Thank you!
Nicely done. I would like to add that because of his strong traditionalism, Cap is the steady fulcrum, the moral gold standard perhaps, from which every other Marvel character is measured. He demonstrates that a principled perseverence can prevent tyranny where submission for the sake of social convenience could not. He was such an important character for the MCU that I'm slightly concerned that they will lose their way without him at the center. Time will tell.
Slightly concerned? Undeniably it's downhill from here.
Wonderful breakdown of the evolution of Captain America. Love your videos!
What I appreciate in Endgame in regards to Captain America is that we get to fully realize and appreciate his evolution when he's pitted against himself from earlier in his journey. There's an exasperation with his younger self beautifully executed from the line "I can do this all day." He acknowledges how frustrating his rigid idealism meant he was often solving problems "harder" instead of "smarter." Though also a nod to the controversial recent Captain America comics, the fact that older Cap chooses to say "Hail Hydra" to get the tesseract versus taking on the entire elevator of armed guards shows yet more growth. He's well aware these are the "bad guys" but he has more important shit to do, and the deception is just faster and more efficient.
Well Said!
The Captain America Trilogy is THE best superhero trilogy.
It's the most complete, it's the most consistent, it has a compelling overarching story, and most importantly, it doesn't fail in the end (looking at you Dark Knight trilogy).
Captain America is my favorite trilogy of all time, and Spider-Man has been my favorite for so long
Same here
Someone needs to show this to Scorsese, since he doesn't think there is anything to be learned from these films.
Oh my god, you have the words to my reasons why Cap is my favorite avenger. I never knew, what fascinated me about him that much. But as I was listening to you, I realised, it's exactly this. Thank you.
13:00 "America is a young country"
India is 70+years old
Canada is 40+ years old
U.S.A. is 300+ years old
*Laughs in young*
I mainly meant in terms of its developing cultural memory, but yeah you got me there lol
Considering most countries in the world are thousands of years old, the US is extremely young. Speaking as a Greek Egyptian, but I’m sure the Chinese would back me here.
Rudra Singh while the US as a country is technically not that young, as a cultural location it’s incredibly young.
Greece as a country is technically a hundred years younger than the US but as a cultural identity it’s centuries older
i dont care,i think the Captain America trilogy is one of the best. i love all three in their own special ways and viewed together just enhances each separate movie. ill always be #teamcaptainamerica, he portrays what America at its best could be and what we all want America to be. We are a country of rebels and i think we've forgotten that, Capt. reminds us to always buck the system if we think it's wrong. Thats what we were founded on. thank you for this video, def. enjoyed it. xoxo
Thank you so much!
Lord this was beautifully edited and analysed. Well-done essay. Well-done. Keep it up!
Thank you so much!
Dude I loved this video! Very interesting way of looking at it. You really explained the deeper notions behind it all extremely well. So awesome man
Thank you! And I'm so flattered that you still watch my channel! :)
@@ImplicitlyPretentious Of course man I'm always hyped when you post a new video!
1:55 man you cant just drop a headbanger like that then cut it off before the chorus
Funny how one of the less popular og avengers had the best trilogy out of all of them and it’s not even close. I mean Iron Man’a trilogy had only one good film. He’s the clear favorite but didn’t have the greatest solo films save iron man 1. Thor also is kinda mid except for ragnarok which I thought was pretty good bht of course they went too far with love and thunder. Captain America’s trilogy is the one i keep coming back to aside from avengers. They just get better and better. I just love the setup of the first one being a period piece and then almost completely changing genres and becoming gritty spy thrillers with superheroes in winter soldier and civil war.
This is making me nostalgic for sociology class.
See what I did there?
I didn’t sign up for the JAB either! “I could do this all day!” “I don’t like bullies.” 🇺🇸
As always , a great video , i am from Israel
Zrubavella Portermacher Nice
Oh wow! Thank you! I never imagined anyone beyond my friends would watch my videos let alone, Israel! :)
this is such an interesting way of looking at the trilogy & helps me to hold civil war in a higher esteem, great job man!
Thanks! That's really flattering!
1:55 song PLEASE
Non face reveal videos are like manga, you think you can picture a dude by his voice and the next thing you know the British sounding guy is Asian
Y'all notice that the avengers didn't break up after civil war? It was just tony alone with spider-man. Steve was with everyone else
The Avengers after Civil War were Rhodes, Vision and Iron Man.
Amigo Rigo yep
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Tradere is pronounced Trad-eh-rey. Awesome video essay but just in case you're curious, latin letters are always pronounced the same way. Vowels are:
a = ah
e = eh as in bed
i = ee as in seen
o = oh
u = oo as in cook
Ironman has the best first movie out of his trilogies
Thor has the best third movie out of his trilogies
Captain America has the best trilogy
Thank you for this video. Truthfully, it's very touching. Cap's attitude and values are ones that make me relate to him, which is why he is my favorite superhero. It's been rough lately, to understand some things. This made me feel okay about it all.
By the way, the last song, "I'll Remember You", can you provide the artist? Thanks!
What makes Cap trilogy great is it isn’t only impact on audience, the story impact on Cap and really let us understand why he make these decisions cuz of his perspectives throughout this trilogy 👌
futurist folk... don't consider that the people of an era have been educated by that era and insist they change into them... this is the problem.
I think Big Boss and Cap could share a pint and really relate.
Definitely
IP: I'm Pretentious.
Full Fat Videos: I don't care
Bro you blew my fucking mind at the 10 min mark.
Oh wow thank you!
I keep hearing Madonna-ty every time you say modernity
this is why i don’t understand why people hate Cap’s endgame ending, because it makes SO MUCH SENSE and it’s satisfying to see Steve finally compromising and being selfish FOR ONCE and finding his peace.
I just realized. Cap always represented the right way to move forward. To be the product of future science and past ideas. Just as red skull degraded from the serum and cap became better, the role of science was to make them stronger and to magnify the values they hold.
Bruh I’m early but I am Aya amazing video
Thank you!
I really enjoy your breakdown of Steve's journey through modernity vs nostalgia/tradition. I like how you tied his compromise in EG with his lack of personal compromise in CW.
I am a little disappointed that you didn't dig more into his choices in IW and EG though I understand that this is a CA analysis not an analysis of those two movies. I tend to feel like the things people have the most divergent interpretations on are the extent to which he's in a bad place in IW (which pulls into the larger question of how much he's in the "wrong"/has compromised his personal beliefs for personal reasons at the end of CW), whether his counselling work is a positive (re: his personal progression) or negative sign and of course his ending.
You talked a bit about your views re: his ending/time travel and I think "compromise" is a good way of putting it and you discussed the counselling a bit in your EG analysis where I think you went on the positive sign.
I really like the idea that where the Cap films are all about Steve struggling with the contemporary and the tradition/nostalgia v modernity, the Avengers films are a resolution to the particular struggle expressed in the preceding Cap movie.
Thanks for the great video!
Thank you! And that's a really great perspective! And yeah I'm planning to do a whole essay on the Avengers quadrilogy, so I can devote more on infinity war so that's why it's only in the periphery of this one! :)
Title notwithstanding, I don't think "Captain America: Civil War" should be considered part of the Captain America series. It's much more an Avengers movie and every bit a Tony Stark movie as Cap movie. If they didn't want to classify as part of the Avengers series, they should have called it "Marvel's Civil War".
I liked your video very much. I thought you made some excellent points, especially in describing the tension between Steve and Tony. Good job!
This was the first video of yours I watched and I subbed right away. Cap is my favorite superhero and I love this video. You nailed it.
The background music during the Winter Soldier portion of this video is 👌🏽
*chef's kiss*
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
Leo, your work is so insightful. I love it. And I'm delighted to finally see you face. Thanks, man.
I think I remember watching your first video and thinking it was great. Don't see the need for remaking it with this one, but alright. I'm a Captain America fan, so I'm all for putting his stories out into the universe a second time.
Great vid, I've watched it twice. You're welcome to do more stuff about traditionalism vs modernity (and I don't think we've left modernity behind, in spite of postmodernity, I'd rather say we live in a world that is a mix of modernity and postmodernity). You can certainly draw parallels between currrent social media censorship and Hydra/Shield.
Captain American: I dont wanna kill anyone. Buuuuut.... if they are in my way, they are dead. (kills soldier, fucks up many hydra men)
Amazing video, thanks for sharing! Really liked the Captain America trilogy, he was my favourite avenger in the MCU, not for his abilities, but for his character. Your video really did an amazing job of explaining who he is. :-)
This is an excellent essay and I thank you for it, brother.
For your next video - do is nick fury completely incompetent as a spy?
Just saying hydra was right under his nose like always and then Fuckin mysterio which that was not the real fury but he still didn’t know
No one researched a fucking former stark employee
The creator of barf 🤮
My god fury do you do any more investigative work
I liked the Captain America films, Iron Man 1, Incredible Hulk, the first Thor, Avengers 1 and Infinity War, the Daredevil and Jessica Jones shows and Season 1 of Punisher. I liked Black Panther too. But the MCU now, rather than a superhero series with some comedy that's actually clever and funny is now bad comedies about people in superhero cosplay.
I just found this video and I want to see more from you. You’re intelligent and your essay about Captain America and Steve Rogers is spot on. I love your analysis of the dynamic between Steve and Tony. I want to add one thing about them. I have always felt that Steve is a highly evolved person with lots of emotional intelligence, Tony is not. He’s an emotional mess with narcissistic tendencies. Eventually he evolves but it’s mostly after Thanos’ snap and everything slows down. It’s then that he’s forced to look at himself. Keep up the great work!
he didn't 'compromise' in endgame...he found peace...he stayed back in time because he knew he would be there when the world really needed him...he defeated thanos...the world would be fine without him...he got to enjoy a well earned RETIREMENT with a family and the woman he loved
This is making me think that another logical conclusion to Steve's story is if we didn't get Infinity War, to have a fourth Captain America movie where S.H.I.E.L.D. returns, Cap tried to stop them and does a brutal death, symbolizing that what he's fighting for is dead and the new era of modernity will live on, despite the previous generation refusing to give way to it.
Damnit , thats too deep , you just severed my wrists
I agree