This proves that the golden globes matter. Green book won screenplay, best picture, and supporting actor at the globes and the same happen at the oscars.
Its always hard to gauge when something wins comedy though, cause it doesn’t compete with the drama films. It also didn’t compete with Roma. But screenplay yeah, they called that.
@@TheOscarExpert It was the PGA that mattered. It doesn't always as was the case for Spotlight and Moonlight. But they use the same preferential ballot system as the Academy. And I guess an absence of a film editing nomination (Roma) is a bigger killer than an absence of a directing nomination (Green Book). And also, yea, academy members like Spielberg hate Netflix.
@@TheOscarExpert i love olivia , absolutely ... but even after winning globe + sag + critics choice -- how did glenn lose? i was so shocked sad for her... very torn actually bcs no one can hate olivia..
I don't understand how a generic White Saviour film can still win so many Oscars in 2019, that trope is tired and boring. The Oscars are happy to show support for POC storylines and minority representation as long as it's own their terms.
@Xcuze What on earth are you talking about. It's clear that you read the word 'white' in my comment and just went off on your own tangent. I'm POC and even I'm saying Green Book was not deserving of the Best Picture oscar *because* it was a lame attempt by the Academy at honouring what they deem a socially acceptable movie. My pick was The Favourite or Roma, both insanely good films. Green Book was average and Black Panther... that wasn't even the best Marvel film to come out of 2018 let alone Best Picture worthy. Blackkklansman was great as well but I would have been happy if any of 3 I mentioned would have won. Not everything is an SJW triggered post, you sound more pissed than I do
@Xcuze You're clearly a fucking idiot, i have given you now 2 chances to understand what I am saying very fucking clearly... I'M LITERALLY SAYING THE WHITE FILM SHOULD HAVE ONE; The Favourite. Green Book was not the best film in the bunch, The Favourite and Roma were MUCH better films. Both The favourite and roma were interesting, innovative films and should have won, oh and guess what... they weren't Black films and I wanted them to win. What I will say for a third time now is that white saviour movies are not good, they are the common denominator of basic, dated film ideas, and Green Book was one of them. Period. I would rather see a shit film like Transformers win over something like Green Room. The Oscars pick White Saviour films for the sake of being diverse, I would rather they picked the best film in the category each year, irrespective of race. You're clearly incapable of logic and reasoning. Why don't you comment the same thing for the Third time saying I'm complaining about race cos that's all you can say.
I knew "Roma" was in trouble in the weeks leading up to the Oscars when I heard too many people say they tried to watch "Roma" but they couldn't finish it because they were bored with the movie. And there are a lot of influential industry people who don't like what Netflix is trying to do to the movie industry. What people like Steven Spielberg and Christopher Nolan have to say about movies from streaming services is a reflection of what a lot of Academy voters are thinking.
wizardgry ? Lmao did you just compare Roma to Citizen Kane? That piece of overrated garbage won’t ever have the legacy that CK has, and it’s nowhere near as well made
I was really, really scared that Bohemian Rhapsody will win Best Picture after all these awards for this, sooooo it's not that bad as it could be... Roma was the best, Green Book is another safe choice :(
I honestly thought The Favorite should have won. Also Isle of Dogs losing to Black Panther in Best Score makes me SO mad. And A Quiet Place should've 100% won Best Sound Editing!
_"Roma_ all the way", yet... _Green Book_ won TIFF People's Choice (1st match since _12 Years a Slave),_ the National Board of Review, the Comedy/Musical Golden Globe, and P-G-freaking-A. Can't deny that _Green Book_ was right there as well.
Lol Blackkklansman was boring. The premise is a black man infiltrating the KKK yet it turns out Adam Driver is doing the hard infiltrating. Spike Lee is so up his own ass, I'm glad he didn't win.
This was a crazy year for Oscars. A lot of shocking winners. I was happy Spike Lee won and Olivia Coleman was incredible and one of my "favourite" Oscar moments ever. I knew Rami sweeped, but it was so upsetting that Bradley Cooper did not win best Actor, he deserved so much more. Green Book is just OK.
tbh glenn had sag and olivia had bafta, critics choice didn’t mean anything this year a tie is bullshit (also colman did get a critics choice at least). they’re more likely to give sag to a veteran because the voters of sag are all very pally with them ! also yes a racist and perve won screenplay and picture, well done academy
Many people hated Bohemian Rhapsody but they have to respect what it is. Many people say that they skimmed over Freddie's homosexuality, which I personally did not agree with, but even so, that wasn't what the movie was supposed to be about! The film was meant to honor Freddie and Queen's legacy, which it did. The editing was amazing, especially during the concert scenes. Casting for this movie was truly remarkable and Rami Malek deserved his Oscar with every inch of his body. He did so much to prepare for the role: learned piano, learned guitar, learned his accent, studied every piece of Freddie possible, got a singing coach, worked with a movement coach, and much more. Although it is almost like a war between the critics and the viewers, I believe that this movie is so deserving and it will remain a favorite of mine forever.
I personally didn't like it, but not because it skimmed over his sexuality, or that it basically ignored his illness, but because despite being based on Freddie mwrcury, it somehow managed to be boring. It was by the numbers, the dialogue was cringey af...the only good thing to be enjoyed was the music. But that's me
Georgia Milne NO. That film is full of massive lies and is almost complete fiction. It is trash and the editing is actually some of the worst I have seen in a mainstream film, it’s so clunky and badly written
Nigel Gillett LOL... Box Office doesn't equal to quality, duh! Also, Black Panther earned more than Bohemian Rhapsody, so by your logic Black Panther is a better movie than Bohemian Rhapsody... Again, Green Book has the highest audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, that means people actually liked it more, so again by your logic, Green Book is a better movie than Bohemian Rhapsody... And Bohemian Rhapsody has the lowest critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes, it got nominated because they campaigned hard... Otherwise, it didn't deserve the nominations as well as the wins...
My family always makes a ballot bet as well. Last night I did the worst I had done at all the past Oscars, I only got 17 out of 24. I really fell behind with Original Screenplay, Score, Best Picture, and Best Actress (that came out of nowhere)! Can't wait till next year!
@@TheOscarExpert Thats good to hear at least. Some years the Oscars are so predictable its almost like a 24/24. Not sure if I like this unpredictable direction its going in, but I guess we will have to see...
@@Sithuhein100 Yeah my sister won with 18 or 19 right. She didn't vote for King as well, but she put a lot of money on Green Book! I guess I should have done the same... (though I am still bitter)
At least your predictions weren’t way off. I think we done similar. I got 17/24. (top 5% on GoldDerby) The ones I got wrong: • Picture (I had Roma) • Actress (I had Close) • Supporting Actor (I had Grant) • Original Screenplay (I had The Favourite) • Production Design (I had The Favourite) • Visual Effects (I had Avengers) • Live Action Short (I had Marguerite) SO disappointed that Green Book won Best Picture. It wasn’t even top 5 in the films nominated. Actress was such a pleasant surprise. I’m happy they went with the best performance, and not just the one who was “overdue”. Green Book winning Original Screenplay was a joke. Avengers was robbed, and I just followed GoldDerby on Live Action Short. I’m so annoyed about Supp. Actor & Production Design as I originally had them correct but literally changed last second. BP winning Production Design was a joke, seeing as half that film was CGI. Side note: The Oscars should just remain host-less forever. Time was actually spent on the awards and not cringey jokes.
we had similar predictions! and i got 17/24 too (plus the top 5% haha) i matched 6 of your choices but i went with weisz for s. actress and panther for production design. completely agree with everything you said!
I had 14/24 My mistakes at the Oscars this year: Best Costume Design: The Favorite Best Production Design: The Favorite Best Live Action Short: Marguerite Best Original Score: If Beale Street Could Talk Best Original Screenplay: The Favorite Best Adapted Screenplay: Can You Ever Forgive me? It won the WGA Best Lead Actress: Glenn Close, damn it, but Olivia did a excelent work in The Favorite Best Film Editing: Vice Best Visual Effects: The Avengers: Infinity War Best Sound Editing: First Man
Best Editing went to a film that performed almost 60 horrible jump cuts in one scene. I feel bad for A Star is Born, that was a better made movie than Bohemian. Olivia Colman's speech was just incredible!
"Bohemian Rhapsody's" film editing win was for the Live Aid scene and for the editor having to salvage the movie after the Bryan Singer mess. The Oscar win might not have been deserved, but it wasn't a total surprise, since the movie won the Drama Feature prize at the ACE Eddie Awards.
I guess the logic is there, it was second favourite after all (Vice was the favourite). However, when I look back at A Star is Born's editing which to me in contrast is so much smoother and consistent (including their concerts).
I think this prove why people take more seriously film festivals over the Oscars... At the end Roma and Netflix won big over the big film companies and the cinema chains. Even the Brits were smart enough to recognize the value and importance of the international films and make history already. It was obvious that the producers which means the traditional companies couldn't tolerate the idea of Netflix changing the film industry but by been nominated in 10 categories and win 3 of the most important they just did it.
Netflix and other streaming services are a threat to a lot of Oscar voters whose business depends on theatrical releases and box-office results. Netflix is the only streaming service that doesn't report box-office numbers for its movies released in theaters, and a lot of movie industry people HATE that. That's why it might be a while before Netflix wins Best Picture at the Oscars. Then there's the issue of how Netflix will campaign the same movie for an Oscar and an Emmy (Netflix does that with a lot of their documentaries), and a lot of Oscar voters hate that too.
"I think this prove why people take more seriously film festivals over the Oscars" You...are aware that _Green Book_ *won* TIFF People's Choice, right? A festival award that results in a Best Picture nomination 9/10 of the time?
You are wise my friends. You should consider study filmmaking. It was definetely a bad choice for the Academy to make. They didnt realize that Roma had all the critics, the press, the latino community, the art community in the whole world and the liberals in the pocket. So the backlash is going to be HUGEEEE. That is the problem when they cannot see beyond and they vote for the movie they like. It Is not wise. It damage the Academy Prestige (the most important thing they have).They have to make decisions with the brain. Also I think the Academy should teach its members how to vote because if they dont they will vote for what they like and it Is harmful for the Academy itself. Great video guys!!!!
"Roma" is from Netflix, and that's what hurt its chances the most. The business model of the movie industry would be radically upended if a streaming service that doesn't report box-office numbers and doesn't work with the majority of movie theaters won an Oscar for Best Picture. It's possible that a streaming service will eventually win the Best Picture Oscar, but the movie industry still relies heavily on major movie theaters for revenue, and Netflix doesn't work with major movie theaters.
The preferential ballot needs to be dumped. Too many times now the 2nd or 3rd or even 4th film is winning to top honour. Either go back to first past the post(most number one's) or they need to weight the preferential ballot to give the number one choice more credence/points than just one more point than 2nd. We're just getting the likeable but meh winning. I might also have just the branches all vote for their category rather than everyone voting in every category i.e the sound mixing/editing fiasco. Expanding the membership does not always ensure the quality of choices gets better.
at this point i’m just watching this video again to feel something (something being anger and sadness and frustration that green book beat one of the greatest artsy movies of the decade)
Still thinking Roma was inexplicably overhyped that year. Not even the best movie in the International category imho. The Favourite should've been the film to beat that night.
guys please upload more movie reviews and lists not only about award shows I love watching your videos and I agree with a lot of your opinions about movies
If "Roma" was from a traditional studio, not a streaming service, it would've had a better chance of winning. A lot of Oscar voters have a problem with how Netflix handles theatrical releases, and they still think of Netflix as a content studio that caters to the small-screen experience, so don't under-estimate Oscar voters' mistrust of Netflix. Also don't under-estimate that "Roma" is a foreign-language film. Almost all Best Picture winners are about Americans or British people.
I was going for Roma for Best Picture too. But I did a quick minute change and went with Green Book. Why? The Academy does this thing called preferential balloting. Changes the whole ball game.
Haha love the reactions... Had some nice $$$ wins too: Green Book 15-1 (November) Colman 5-1 First Man - Visual Effects 4-1 Black Panther - Original Score 3-1 Bohemian - Sound Editing 4-1 Ali 1-1 (November)
I love your reaction to Olivia Coleman winning Best Actress 🤣🤣 I felt the same way when i did not hear Glen Close either!! But, when you listen to Colemans' speech she makes you feel happy that someone so genuine, & was as shocked as, im sure the rest of the world was, won. Now with that said CLOSE WAS ROBBED 😫😫😫
Dudes you should have known when Roma won best foreign language film it wasn't going to win. That's usually the consolation prize for foreign films nominated in the Best Picture category.
Seeing the of the video, I am with you. I have predictions for every category that can be predicted at this point for next year. I have a couple wildcards in my Best Picture predictions, but I made a list of all the possibilities and just picked several of the most likely candidates and a few wildcards that have a chance just based on a gut feeling. When do you think that video of 2020 predictions will be up out of curiosity?
Ranking the best picture nominees 08. Vice B+ 8/10 07. Bohemian Rhapsody B+ 8/10 06. Green book -A 9/10 05. The Favorite A 9/10 04. Black Panther A+ 9/10 03. Roma A+ 9/10 02. A Star is born A+ 9/10 01. Blackkklansman S 10/10
Your reactions to the Best Actress Award is everything!! I’ve watched it multiple times. By the way, please don’t ever compare Green Book to Crash again. Crash was a wreck. Haha
This season I tried to see the foreign films before the English speaking, I can say that the 5 could have been nominated for best film, I think the final decision is that the academy would be forced to next year maybe remove the category of foreign film and nominate 3 or 4 to Best Picture, big change and would almost become something like Cannes, for me would have been great, plus it would probably be the only thing that Netflix would expect to invest in their own theaters.
5:57 Whooa!!! You guys thought infinity war might win, but no (well yeah to this day, I still think infinity war should’ve won the Oscar) first Mann won the Oscar.
2011 was kind of a weak year (in terms of what was actually nominated Best Picture) so no one would remember whatever would have won if The Artist hadn't.
I was also pissed off with the sound editing winner. But I went beyond pissed off with Olivia and Green Book winning. It’s just so unfair.However I enjoyed this year’s show better than last year’s
I think people have green book all wrong.. it is a feel good movie that everybody likes, the controversy is so silly its not even worth mentioning. The people who have problems with Green Book would have problems with every movie. I think you have to try to dislike Green Book. it is a movie with zero political leaning and is about a friendship, nothing else. I think it will age well
Green Book won screenplay at the GGs, won NBR, won at the PGA's and we all stuck with Roma... looking back it was all there we just refused to believe it..
"Roma" was winning more Best Picture awards this year than any other film, and "Green Book" didn't get a Best Director nomination, so it's understandable that a lot of people would think that "Roma" was going to win Best Picture at the Oscars. "Roma's" loss is mostly about it being a Netflix film, because Netflix is a threat to the U.S movie industry's traditional business model. Most Oscar voters still want the Best Picture Oscar to go to movies that aren't going to be eligible for Emmy Awards. A lot of Oscar voters don't want to blur the line between the Oscars and the Emmys.
Bohemian Rhapsody won big and rightfully so if you ask me. Although it didnt deserve sound editing or editing (lol), it did deserve at least a few awards. I know the movie gets a lot of hate from critics and ''movie nerds'' because of things like the story not being 100% true, because we didnt learn new ''spicy'' details about freddie mercury's life or because the movie didn't have much of a character arc for any of the characters. But people have to remember that its first and foremost a hollywood movie, not a documentary. The story isn't 100% accurate, but it makes the movie more exciting. We don't learn any new details about freddie mercury, but that's a good thing. This movie is more about honoring the memory of freddie and showing the rise of Queen. Freddie was a very private man and we have to respect that. Brian and Roger certainly did. The movie is a biopic about Queen which, while taking a few liberties when it comes to the story, still stays true to Queen and what Queen were. The movie is extremely entertaining and very rewatchable aswell which is definitely a plus. I haven't even mentioned the extraordinary casting for the movie (they even got young Brian May to play Brian May) and Rami Malek's AMAZING performance as Freddie Mercury. He nailed it and definitely deserved best actor. I wasn't a Queen fan going into the movie, but I am now.
I honestly just thought the movie was ok. I just thought it was so cliche, like when he coughed blood into the napkin I laughed. Now Rocketman, THAT I am excited for!
I think Green Book won for some reasons: 1. It's a good safe choice 2. It shows racism is in the past and make some white people feel like they're not racist. 3. Black Panther and BlacKkKlansman had no chance of winning. 4. Roma already won Best Foreign Film and (of course) Academy wasn't going to give Best Picrude to a Netflix movie 5. A Star Is Born is great but had some flaws 6. Bohemian Rhapsody is good but has some really ridiculous moments. 7. Vice and the Favourite was interesting but they aren't politically and socially-favored so they weren't going to win. (I think some people hate it that it won because they didn't see the movie)
Predicting "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood" to win best pic and finally give Tarantino that award for best pic and best director. You heard it here first folks.
Hey guys. I knew The Favourite wasn't going to do good at the Oscars. Olivia Colman's win was a surprise but I'm happy she won and I was happy for Green Book. A lot of people have underestimate Green Book, Bohemian Rhapsody and Black Panther. You guys sure SWEAR a lot
"Roma is still a movie we will remember and ultimately the Oscars don't have a final say over that" - best sentence of the night.
Till the end of the year no one will remember Roma anymore.
@@OCriticoAle we had to watch it for a cinematic auteurs class and everyone loved it
Very true
Laura Guerra I forgot about Roma lmfaooo
Roma's great and has a Criterion release. How many people still talk about generic Oscar Bait like Green Book, except to disparage it for winning BP?
You two are like a knee-slapping hyperactive version of the Winklevoss Twins
Rowan Crump you mean the Winklevii?
Only way uglier.
@@TheTerryE they are not ugly
Anne V But compared to Armie Hammer...
@@bucklakelukie I don't think Hammer Is handsome.
“Describe this video in 1 word”
me: MoNeY
Money
WoWsers
CHILDISH.
"Wait, what if this time... it's the white person to drive the car?"
And I thought I was the only one freaking out
You’re never alone
This proves that the golden globes matter. Green book won screenplay, best picture, and supporting actor at the globes and the same happen at the oscars.
Its always hard to gauge when something wins comedy though, cause it doesn’t compete with the drama films. It also didn’t compete with Roma. But screenplay yeah, they called that.
Not really... Just happen this year.
@@TheOscarExpert It was the PGA that mattered. It doesn't always as was the case for Spotlight and Moonlight. But they use the same preferential ballot system as the Academy. And I guess an absence of a film editing nomination (Roma) is a bigger killer than an absence of a directing nomination (Green Book). And also, yea, academy members like Spielberg hate Netflix.
@@TheOscarExpert i love olivia , absolutely ... but even after winning globe + sag + critics choice -- how did glenn lose? i was so shocked sad for her... very torn actually bcs no one can hate olivia..
I don't understand how a generic White Saviour film can still win so many Oscars in 2019, that trope is tired and boring. The Oscars are happy to show support for POC storylines and minority representation as long as it's own their terms.
@Xcuze What on earth are you talking about. It's clear that you read the word 'white' in my comment and just went off on your own tangent. I'm POC and even I'm saying Green Book was not deserving of the Best Picture oscar *because* it was a lame attempt by the Academy at honouring what they deem a socially acceptable movie. My pick was The Favourite or Roma, both insanely good films. Green Book was average and Black Panther... that wasn't even the best Marvel film to come out of 2018 let alone Best Picture worthy. Blackkklansman was great as well but I would have been happy if any of 3 I mentioned would have won. Not everything is an SJW triggered post, you sound more pissed than I do
@Xcuze You're clearly a fucking idiot, i have given you now 2 chances to understand what I am saying very fucking clearly... I'M LITERALLY SAYING THE WHITE FILM SHOULD HAVE ONE; The Favourite.
Green Book was not the best film in the bunch, The Favourite and Roma were MUCH better films. Both The favourite and roma were interesting, innovative films and should have won, oh and guess what... they weren't Black films and I wanted them to win. What I will say for a third time now is that white saviour movies are not good, they are the common denominator of basic, dated film ideas, and Green Book was one of them. Period. I would rather see a shit film like Transformers win over something like Green Room. The Oscars pick White Saviour films for the sake of being diverse, I would rather they picked the best film in the category each year, irrespective of race.
You're clearly incapable of logic and reasoning. Why don't you comment the same thing for the Third time saying I'm complaining about race cos that's all you can say.
Cause the Academy is 60% old white men.and this was the Boomer choice
@@yepitsthatguy5278 Black Panther is not nearly best picture nomination quality but it’s much better than 3 hours of constant fighting and fan service
Bohemian rhapsody's editing was tragic. Amateurish at best.
"Glenn Close is Oscarless!" - what the whole world thought.
I knew "Roma" was in trouble in the weeks leading up to the Oscars when I heard too many people say they tried to watch "Roma" but they couldn't finish it because they were bored with the movie. And there are a lot of influential industry people who don't like what Netflix is trying to do to the movie industry. What people like Steven Spielberg and Christopher Nolan have to say about movies from streaming services is a reflection of what a lot of Academy voters are thinking.
a pity then. The change will come.
Now it's funny how Netflix and other streaming plataforms will save the movie industry and the awards season this year.
For someone who likes arthouse films, I also can't get through Roma. I tried watching it 3 TIMES.
Well, it's like CRASH over BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN all over again.
Nope. It's like Moonlight winning over the far superior LA LA LAND.
Not even close, Roma is no Brokeback Mountian!!!!
or like shakespeare in love winning over saving private ryan
wizardgry ? Lmao did you just compare Roma to Citizen Kane? That piece of overrated garbage won’t ever have the legacy that CK has, and it’s nowhere near as well made
Caleb Smith woah there partner I just meant it as like an example of an upset an Oscar history ya know?
Jesus you two are so entertaining. Absolutely brilliant
, the two disadvantages that has Roma are : is a netflix movie in spanish language, two things that the academy doesnt like
My exact reaction to Olivia Colman
Me too.
tommykevans3 same my parents and i screamed
I was really, really scared that Bohemian Rhapsody will win Best Picture after all these awards for this, sooooo it's not that bad as it could be... Roma was the best, Green Book is another safe choice :(
I honestly thought The Favorite should have won. Also Isle of Dogs losing to Black Panther in Best Score makes me SO mad. And A Quiet Place should've 100% won Best Sound Editing!
@@jayisgreg1787 Yes, The Favourite is great too. Oscar for Olivia is the best thing that happened.
That’s exactly how I felt. People need to stop complaining about Green Book because it could’ve been SO much worse
It was Roma all the way....if favorite or blackkklansman won I wouldn't have been so sad...
_"Roma_ all the way", yet... _Green Book_ won TIFF People's Choice (1st match since _12 Years a Slave),_ the National Board of Review, the Comedy/Musical Golden Globe, and P-G-freaking-A. Can't deny that _Green Book_ was right there as well.
Lol Blackkklansman was boring. The premise is a black man infiltrating the KKK yet it turns out Adam Driver is doing the hard infiltrating. Spike Lee is so up his own ass, I'm glad he didn't win.
12:14 I think you can see them both go through all 5 stages of grief
“We’re gonna top off the night with Green Ass Book?”
This was a crazy year for Oscars. A lot of shocking winners. I was happy Spike Lee won and Olivia Coleman was incredible and one of my "favourite" Oscar moments ever. I knew Rami sweeped, but it was so upsetting that Bradley Cooper did not win best Actor, he deserved so much more. Green Book is just OK.
Honestly, I kind of wanted Bohemian Rhapsody to win just to see the internet turn into chaos.
The Olivia Coleman reaction is perfect 😂
tbh glenn had sag and olivia had bafta, critics choice didn’t mean anything this year a tie is bullshit (also colman did get a critics choice at least). they’re more likely to give sag to a veteran because the voters of sag are all very pally with them ! also yes a racist and perve won screenplay and picture, well done academy
I lost it at 12:28 lmaoo looking forward to next year's video!
That “next year” video did not disappoint after all, haha. 👌
This is the best reaction video I’ve seen in years!
Bohemian Rhapsody has more Oscars than The Godfather
Many people hated Bohemian Rhapsody but they have to respect what it is. Many people say that they skimmed over Freddie's homosexuality, which I personally did not agree with, but even so, that wasn't what the movie was supposed to be about! The film was meant to honor Freddie and Queen's legacy, which it did. The editing was amazing, especially during the concert scenes. Casting for this movie was truly remarkable and Rami Malek deserved his Oscar with every inch of his body. He did so much to prepare for the role: learned piano, learned guitar, learned his accent, studied every piece of Freddie possible, got a singing coach, worked with a movement coach, and much more. Although it is almost like a war between the critics and the viewers, I believe that this movie is so deserving and it will remain a favorite of mine forever.
I personally didn't like it, but not because it skimmed over his sexuality, or that it basically ignored his illness, but because despite being based on Freddie mwrcury, it somehow managed to be boring.
It was by the numbers, the dialogue was cringey af...the only good thing to be enjoyed was the music.
But that's me
Rami's portrayal was caricaturish and inconsistent... The actual best actor last year (Ethan Hawke) wasn't even nominated...
Georgia Milne NO. That film is full of massive lies and is almost complete fiction. It is trash and the editing is actually some of the worst I have seen in a mainstream film, it’s so clunky and badly written
Black panther definitely deserved original score no question about that
first man was better ,wasnt even nominated
it was First Man's year, shame oscars
First Man is the best score. Black Panther is good score but not so memorable
The best visual effects are the practical effects.
Roma was robbed. It was (way) better than Green Book. Blackkklansman, Black Panther and The Favourite were all better than Green Book. #OscarsSoDated
Black Panther better than Green Book??? C'mon, Black Panther and Bohemian Rhapsody didn't even deserve to be nominated in the Best Picture category.
Gaurav W Bohemian Rhapsody was amazing
@Nigel Gillett Every other film nominated for Oscar was better than Bohemian Rhapsody.
@Nigel Gillett And you keep hallucinating that Bohemian Rhapsody was better than the other nominated movies.
Nigel Gillett LOL... Box Office doesn't equal to quality, duh! Also, Black Panther earned more than Bohemian Rhapsody, so by your logic Black Panther is a better movie than Bohemian Rhapsody... Again, Green Book has the highest audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, that means people actually liked it more, so again by your logic, Green Book is a better movie than Bohemian Rhapsody... And Bohemian Rhapsody has the lowest critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes, it got nominated because they campaigned hard... Otherwise, it didn't deserve the nominations as well as the wins...
My family always makes a ballot bet as well. Last night I did the worst I had done at all the past Oscars, I only got 17 out of 24. I really fell behind with Original Screenplay, Score, Best Picture, and Best Actress (that came out of nowhere)! Can't wait till next year!
This year was pretty unpredictable. We got 17/24 too, but according to gold derby that’s actually the top 10% at least so not bad
@@Retrogirlgamer Yeah I stupidly predicted that Vice would win editing (deservedly so) and A Quiet Place would win Sound editing
@@TheOscarExpert Thats good to hear at least. Some years the Oscars are so predictable its almost like a 24/24. Not sure if I like this unpredictable direction its going in, but I guess we will have to see...
I got 18 out of 24 even i didn’t vote for King and Ali... lol
@@Sithuhein100 Yeah my sister won with 18 or 19 right. She didn't vote for King as well, but she put a lot of money on Green Book! I guess I should have done the same... (though I am still bitter)
At least your predictions weren’t way off. I think we done similar. I got 17/24. (top 5% on GoldDerby)
The ones I got wrong:
• Picture (I had Roma)
• Actress (I had Close)
• Supporting Actor (I had Grant)
• Original Screenplay (I had The Favourite)
• Production Design (I had The Favourite)
• Visual Effects (I had Avengers)
• Live Action Short (I had Marguerite)
SO disappointed that Green Book won Best Picture. It wasn’t even top 5 in the films nominated.
Actress was such a pleasant surprise. I’m happy they went with the best performance, and not just the one who was “overdue”.
Green Book winning Original Screenplay was a joke.
Avengers was robbed, and I just followed GoldDerby on Live Action Short.
I’m so annoyed about Supp. Actor & Production Design as I originally had them correct but literally changed last second. BP winning Production Design was a joke, seeing as half that film was CGI.
Side note: The Oscars should just remain host-less forever. Time was actually spent on the awards and not cringey jokes.
we had similar predictions! and i got 17/24 too (plus the top 5% haha)
i matched 6 of your choices but i went with weisz for s. actress and panther for production design. completely agree with everything you said!
I had 14/24
My mistakes at the Oscars this year:
Best Costume Design: The Favorite
Best Production Design: The Favorite
Best Live Action Short: Marguerite
Best Original Score: If Beale Street Could Talk
Best Original Screenplay: The Favorite
Best Adapted Screenplay: Can You Ever Forgive me? It won the WGA
Best Lead Actress: Glenn Close, damn it, but Olivia did a excelent work in The Favorite
Best Film Editing: Vice
Best Visual Effects: The Avengers: Infinity War
Best Sound Editing: First Man
Best Editing went to a film that performed almost 60 horrible jump cuts in one scene. I feel bad for A Star is Born, that was a better made movie than Bohemian.
Olivia Colman's speech was just incredible!
"Bohemian Rhapsody's" film editing win was for the Live Aid scene and for the editor having to salvage the movie after the Bryan Singer mess. The Oscar win might not have been deserved, but it wasn't a total surprise, since the movie won the Drama Feature prize at the ACE Eddie Awards.
I guess the logic is there, it was second favourite after all (Vice was the favourite).
However, when I look back at A Star is Born's editing which to me in contrast is so much smoother and consistent (including their concerts).
I think this prove why people take more seriously film festivals over the Oscars... At the end Roma and Netflix won big over the big film companies and the cinema chains. Even the Brits were smart enough to recognize the value and importance of the international films and make history already. It was obvious that the producers which means the traditional companies couldn't tolerate the idea of Netflix changing the film industry but by been nominated in 10 categories and win 3 of the most important they just did it.
Netflix and other streaming services are a threat to a lot of Oscar voters whose business depends on theatrical releases and box-office results. Netflix is the only streaming service that doesn't report box-office numbers for its movies released in theaters, and a lot of movie industry people HATE that. That's why it might be a while before Netflix wins Best Picture at the Oscars. Then there's the issue of how Netflix will campaign the same movie for an Oscar and an Emmy (Netflix does that with a lot of their documentaries), and a lot of Oscar voters hate that too.
"I think this prove why people take more seriously film festivals over the Oscars"
You...are aware that _Green Book_ *won* TIFF People's Choice, right? A festival award that results in a Best Picture nomination 9/10 of the time?
i think i went back and replayed your reactions to olivia colman winning like a thousand times lmao
You are wise my friends. You should consider study filmmaking. It was definetely a bad choice for the Academy to make. They didnt realize that Roma had all the critics, the press, the latino community, the art community in the whole world and the liberals in the pocket. So the backlash is going to be HUGEEEE. That is the problem when they cannot see beyond and they vote for the movie they like. It Is not wise. It damage the Academy Prestige (the most important thing they have).They have to make decisions with the brain. Also I think the Academy should teach its members how to vote because if they dont they will vote for what they like and it Is harmful for the Academy itself. Great video guys!!!!
"Roma" is from Netflix, and that's what hurt its chances the most. The business model of the movie industry would be radically upended if a streaming service that doesn't report box-office numbers and doesn't work with the majority of movie theaters won an Oscar for Best Picture. It's possible that a streaming service will eventually win the Best Picture Oscar, but the movie industry still relies heavily on major movie theaters for revenue, and Netflix doesn't work with major movie theaters.
@@popcultureexpert2790 3 years later and CODA is the first streamed film to win
9:22 everyone's reaction when they said Olivias name! she is awesome though
*Who's the unseen third guy in the room?*
« We’re gonna top off the night with green ass book » is one of the best thing i heard in a long time 😂😂
I loved the "WHAT are YOU DOING?" lmao
I was shocked with Oliva, I feel so bad for Glenn.
“green ass book” i’m yelling
The preferential ballot needs to be dumped. Too many times now the 2nd or 3rd or even 4th film is winning to top honour.
Either go back to first past the post(most number one's) or they need to weight the preferential ballot to give the number one choice more credence/points than just one more point than 2nd.
We're just getting the likeable but meh winning.
I might also have just the branches all vote for their category rather than everyone voting in every category i.e the sound mixing/editing fiasco.
Expanding the membership does not always ensure the quality of choices gets better.
I was freaking out when I heard Olivias Name😍😍😂
at this point i’m just watching this video again to feel something (something being anger and sadness and frustration that green book beat one of the greatest artsy movies of the decade)
Still thinking Roma was inexplicably overhyped that year. Not even the best movie in the International category imho. The Favourite should've been the film to beat that night.
Spike lee Trying to walk out of the oscars.
The ref mad a bad call
guys please upload more movie reviews and lists not only about award shows I love watching your videos and I agree with a lot of your opinions about movies
If "Roma" was from a traditional studio, not a streaming service, it would've had a better chance of winning. A lot of Oscar voters have a problem with how Netflix handles theatrical releases, and they still think of Netflix as a content studio that caters to the small-screen experience, so don't under-estimate Oscar voters' mistrust of Netflix. Also don't under-estimate that "Roma" is a foreign-language film. Almost all Best Picture winners are about Americans or British people.
I was going for Roma for Best Picture too. But I did a quick minute change and went with Green Book. Why? The Academy does this thing called preferential balloting. Changes the whole ball game.
Very true, if a film seems as likely to be a person's 1 or 2 as it is their 9 or 10, then you have to question if it'll survive
Haha love the reactions... Had some nice $$$ wins too:
Green Book 15-1 (November)
Colman 5-1
First Man - Visual Effects 4-1
Black Panther - Original Score 3-1
Bohemian - Sound Editing 4-1
Ali 1-1 (November)
Also called Green Book winning if it got Original Screenplay... I was very happy with the result though... Much preferred the film haha
I was shocked too when Green book won!
I love your reaction to Olivia Coleman winning Best Actress 🤣🤣 I felt the same way when i did not hear Glen Close either!! But, when you listen to Colemans' speech she makes you feel happy that someone so genuine, & was as shocked as, im sure the rest of the world was, won. Now with that said CLOSE WAS ROBBED 😫😫😫
Dudes you should have known when Roma won best foreign language film it wasn't going to win. That's usually the consolation prize for foreign films nominated in the Best Picture category.
Green Book - Roma is identical to Coda - The Power of the Dog last year
12:26 LMAO. That was my reaction.
Their reaction when Olivia Coleman won was my reaction lol
I love you guys so much
9:23 This part XD OH MAII GOOOD
i had the SAME reaction for best actress
Absolutely no one is still watching Green Book.
I wish i had someone in my real life to share my love of movies as this two!📽🎞📺
We had the same reaction with Olivia winning lol
Driving Miss Daisy part 2. My reactions exactly!!!
Cole: *Raging over Bohemian Rhapsody winning Sound Editing and going on a rant*
Brother Bro: COLE COLE…. I GET CASH 😃
Green Book WILL last in my DVD shelf.
Well this was entertaining. Your reactions were brilliant.
Seeing the of the video, I am with you. I have predictions for every category that can be predicted at this point for next year. I have a couple wildcards in my Best Picture predictions, but I made a list of all the possibilities and just picked several of the most likely candidates and a few wildcards that have a chance just based on a gut feeling. When do you think that video of 2020 predictions will be up out of curiosity?
I really thought Rachel weisz should have won the oscar for supporting actress tbh :/ she was brilliant
Ranking the best picture nominees
08. Vice B+ 8/10
07. Bohemian Rhapsody B+ 8/10
06. Green book -A 9/10
05. The Favorite A 9/10
04. Black Panther A+ 9/10
03. Roma A+ 9/10
02. A Star is born A+ 9/10
01. Blackkklansman S 10/10
I loved this seasson with you!! Of course i will keep watching
Your reactions to the Best Actress Award is everything!!
I’ve watched it multiple times.
By the way, please don’t ever compare Green Book to Crash again.
Crash was a wreck. Haha
Nice to see Anakin Skywalker reacting to Oscars instead of slaughtering the children.
Olivia is so deserved
Glenn is gonna win for sunset blvd
hopefully
This season I tried to see the foreign films before the English speaking, I can say that the 5 could have been nominated for best film, I think the final decision is that the academy would be forced to next year maybe remove the category of foreign film and nominate 3 or 4 to Best Picture, big change and would almost become something like Cannes, for me would have been great, plus it would probably be the only thing that Netflix would expect to invest in their own theaters.
5:57 Whooa!!! You guys thought infinity war might win, but no (well yeah to this day, I still think infinity war should’ve won the Oscar) first Mann won the Oscar.
Hahaha I like that the short film Live Action presenters were clearly glad it wasn’t Detainment 😂😂
You guys have the best reactions 🤣
2011 was kind of a weak year (in terms of what was actually nominated Best Picture) so no one would remember whatever would have won if The Artist hadn't.
unless Seperation would have won
I'm partial to Moneyball, I think that would've been a memorable winner.
@@tendrugimichal A Separation wasn't nominated. I'm talking about what was actually nominated.
Tree of Life should've swept
I’m literally pissed that infinity war didn’t win for vfx instead of first man
Love this year. I made a LOT money on Visual Effects and Best Picture.
Anyone else rewatching these videos in 2020 because they miss awards season? Or is it just me 😣
Just you
Loved Green Book! Super happy with its win!
Me too
I was also pissed off with the sound editing winner. But I went beyond pissed off with Olivia and Green Book winning. It’s just so unfair.However I enjoyed this year’s show better than last year’s
I think people have green book all wrong.. it is a feel good movie that everybody likes, the controversy is so silly its not even worth mentioning. The people who have problems with Green Book would have problems with every movie. I think you have to try to dislike Green Book. it is a movie with zero political leaning and is about a friendship, nothing else. I think it will age well
Also, _Green Book_ won several of the precursor awards it needed to foretell its Best Picture Oscar win.
i'm dead at the last 2 minutes of rambling you guys would cringe so hard at these videos now🤣
Green Book won screenplay at the GGs, won NBR, won at the PGA's and we all stuck with Roma... looking back it was all there we just refused to believe it..
"Roma" was winning more Best Picture awards this year than any other film, and "Green Book" didn't get a Best Director nomination, so it's understandable that a lot of people would think that "Roma" was going to win Best Picture at the Oscars. "Roma's" loss is mostly about it being a Netflix film, because Netflix is a threat to the U.S movie industry's traditional business model. Most Oscar voters still want the Best Picture Oscar to go to movies that aren't going to be eligible for Emmy Awards. A lot of Oscar voters don't want to blur the line between the Oscars and the Emmys.
I agreed with you. This is conversational.
Bohemian Rhapsody won big and rightfully so if you ask me. Although it didnt deserve sound editing or editing (lol), it did deserve at least a few awards. I know the movie gets a lot of hate from critics and ''movie nerds'' because of things like the story not being 100% true, because we didnt learn new ''spicy'' details about freddie mercury's life or because the movie didn't have much of a character arc for any of the characters. But people have to remember that its first and foremost a hollywood movie, not a documentary. The story isn't 100% accurate, but it makes the movie more exciting. We don't learn any new details about freddie mercury, but that's a good thing. This movie is more about honoring the memory of freddie and showing the rise of Queen. Freddie was a very private man and we have to respect that. Brian and Roger certainly did. The movie is a biopic about Queen which, while taking a few liberties when it comes to the story, still stays true to Queen and what Queen were. The movie is extremely entertaining and very rewatchable aswell which is definitely a plus. I haven't even mentioned the extraordinary casting for the movie (they even got young Brian May to play Brian May) and Rami Malek's AMAZING performance as Freddie Mercury. He nailed it and definitely deserved best actor. I wasn't a Queen fan going into the movie, but I am now.
I honestly just thought the movie was ok. I just thought it was so cliche, like when he coughed blood into the napkin I laughed. Now Rocketman, THAT I am excited for!
Also you kind of sound condescending
exactly.
It deserved nothing.
Jᴀᴄᴋᴇʀᴄᴏ I completely agree. I loved the movie
9:26
Two years later
The meme of the Oscar expert centuries.
#Oscars2019 #OscarExpert
I don't even watch the Oscars and yet here I am!
I NEED A SUPERCUT LOL
I’ll make one don’t worry
I think Green Book won for some reasons:
1. It's a good safe choice
2. It shows racism is in the past and make some white people feel like they're not racist.
3. Black Panther and BlacKkKlansman had no chance of winning.
4. Roma already won Best Foreign Film and (of course) Academy wasn't going to give Best Picrude to a Netflix movie
5. A Star Is Born is great but had some flaws
6. Bohemian Rhapsody is good but has some really ridiculous moments.
7. Vice and the Favourite was interesting but they aren't politically and socially-favored so they weren't going to win.
(I think some people hate it that it won because they didn't see the movie)
Predicting "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood" to win best pic and finally give Tarantino that award for best pic and best director. You heard it here first folks.
You were so so wrong lol 😆
@@lilchaos4792 lol I just really liked OUATIH. But on my ballot I had Roma but still wrong lol
omg I LOVE THIS
2 disagreements.
1. Beale st peaks in the first act, so yeah, a bit forgettable.
2. Cold War > Roma. I consider the cinematography award theft.
Why was Coleman winning such a surprise? I get she only won the BAFTA but she was in a stronger movie than Close.
I'll miss you guys now that awards season is over 😔. Back into hibernation we go.......... Until the End game 😉
Hey guys. I knew The Favourite wasn't going to do good at the Oscars. Olivia Colman's win was a surprise but I'm happy she won and I was happy for Green Book. A lot of people have underestimate Green Book, Bohemian Rhapsody and Black Panther.
You guys sure SWEAR a lot
Lol the Edy’s was the best part of this video