Should Seattle Seahawks stick with Drew Lock over Geno Smith? | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ธ.ค. 2023
- Drew Lock praised Geno Smith for helping him in the lead-up to the Seahawks’ win over the Eagles, but is Seattle ripe for quarterback controversy now? #NBCSports #ProFootballTalk #DrewLock
» Subscribe to NFL on NBC: th-cam.com/users/NFLonNBC?sub_...
» Watch Pro Football Talk live on Peacock weekdays 7a-9a: peacocktv.smart.link/v82e9dl56
» Get the latest from Pro Football Talk: profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/
NBC Sports Group serves sports fans 24/7 with premier live events, insightful studio shows, and compelling original programming. NBC Sports is an established leader in the sports media landscape with an unparalleled collection of sports properties that include the Olympics, NFL, Premier League, NASCAR, PGA TOUR, the Kentucky Derby, Tour de France, French Open, IndyCar and many more. Subscribe to our channel for the latest sporting news and highlights!
Mike Florio, creator of the industry-leading Profootballtalk.com, offers his NFL insight alongside regular guests, including former NFL athletes such as Chris Simms. Pro Football Talk informs and entertains with the most up-to-date news and analysis surrounding the topical NFL stories of the day.
Watch more from NFL on NBC TH-cam: / nflonnbc
Visit NBC Sports: www.nbcsports.com
Find NBC Sports on Facebook: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Twitter: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Instagram: / nbcsports
www.nbcsports.com/nfl/sunday-...
nbcsports.com/motors/nascar
nbcsports.com/soccer/premier-...
Should Seattle Seahawks stick with Drew Lock over Geno Smith? | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC
/ nflonnbc - กีฬา
Finally a show that includes a discussion about the Seahawks instead of just whining about the Eagles. Kudos.
I'm actually enjoying the whining by Philly Phans.
😆😆😆😆😆😆
I agree with your statement, I knew last night when the seahawks went up that if they pulled the win out, the media would be talking about the eagles no matter what.
Oh how I hate that.... Never givin credit to the Victor💪🏽💚💙. Main reason why I stopped watching mainstream news... always Negative & maybe the reason for so many copycat "Crime"..... "Monkey see Monkey do" SIDK😆🤷🏾♂️
Yea totally get it. Seahawks lifer since 1984. Have long accepted the fact we are a small market team and the major media outlets will not 'waste' any minutes on our team. If the Seahawks win against any major market team / Dallas / SF/ Philly etc - its going to be all about how that other team lost the game because most of the viewership is not in the PNW. Even during those magical SB years in the last decade with Wilson / LOB et all - -EVEN then the disrespect was immense when you think back. Doug Baldwin and Richard Sherman could do a 4 hour talk on that issue alone. So whenever they do win - and get some attention on MSM - I love every minute of it.
I do love that they brought up how Gino acted. It’s because he knows that feeling he was a back up for so many years thrown in the trash, and forgotten but Seattle gave him a chance so he knows how that feeling was for lock
Drew has the hot hand!.......
I'd imagine Seattle would want to keep both QBs if they can. A great backup QB is a valuable thing to have in the NFL, and there really aren't many better jobs out there than being a backup QB. This could extend both of their "playing" careers for many years.
nope need a new qb or new oline
No sense of having 2 back up QB cause that's what they are!
@@ScottyJones67 Not really
Good and bad. Tuff for the starter to be looking over his shoulder every bad game too. I say draft QB's next year and ship Geno. Geno is who he is and someone could use him at Qb 1. See what Drew can do. Don't think he had a full season at Denver due to minor injuries etc. If he bombs you get a high draft pick and can close the book on lock...or re-write it. 2 cents
This one game doesn’t mean that Loch is a good QB. Seattle needs to draft a QB this year.
Drew did his job and did it well. But if Geno can start of course he's going to.
Geno Smith 15 TDS 9 INTS on the season and you still want him to start over the guy coming off the bench who kept it close with the 9ers and just beat one of the best teams in the NFC in a 4th quarter comeback from behind under 2 minutes under pressure. Seattle fans are so dumb.
@@UseedNapkinThat's what I see. I say let Drew cook until he F's it up bad. But he hasn't yet.
@@UseedNapkingeno torched the cowboys just a few games ago when they were the number 1 team in everyone’s eyes it’s geno’s job I love lock tho 100% still
@@UseedNapkin lock almost through like 2-3 picks on that last drive he played great but i still think geno should be the starter next week if geno messes up put drew in
Walker III and Metcalf stepped up huge and that had nothing to do with Lock.
I wouldn’t necessarily go that far, yet, but I will say one thing: Lock makes the opposing D hang back for an extra fraction of a second, throws to a greater variety of targets and allows the OC a bit more creativity. Make of that what you will.
The O-line is playing better as well. Make of that what you will as well.
Play calling was better last night. Make that of what you will
Drew saw who was open and threw it to them.
Locke has a better command over this Waldron offense . saw it in the pre season. nice to see them take the training wheels of at the end of this one . Locke is still capable of bonehead plays . I made a pizza with it!!!!
Helps when your QB actually gets rid of the ball quickly and does not start to crumble before the pressure is even there@@randyrenner7643
Good report. The NFL has changed and in the current NFL you need three quarterbacks. Battery starter in a back up. And I believe it’s getting to the point where on any given day against any Defense any one of the three could play. It’s gonna take like major league baseball certain quarterbacks have certain strikes to get certain defenses supplier or in the entries are adding up soda have. It takes three quarterbacks to win the trophy.
I'm a niner span. And I actually think that he did very well. This season, his game against the niners was actually very, very good, so now he threw two picks. Both were late in the game and they were down by double digits. Other than his 2 pick he played very well. His throws were exceptional.
As a Broncos fan I’m stunned that Lock did this. We never saw this. Same goes for Geno. I’ll give Pete Carrol credit he can win with any ordinary QB
.... he had multiple game-winning drives for the Broncos
All I know is, if Pete puts Geno back in, Geno better perform well cause it will be a really bad look if Geno falls on his face
Hey man throwing a football in the rain is really hard.
The problem is that Lock is on a one year deal, there is no guarantee that we can even keep him. I fully expect that one of Lock or Geno will move on and we will also try to draft a guy if the right one is available. Just happy to see Drew have some success, he was not in a good situation in Denver and then got sick during the QB competition here is Seattle. The guy can make all the throws, it's the processing he lacks and that only comes with experience.
Speaking of Denver , rumors are ...
friendly reminder that lock had 126 yards going into that last drive.....where dk made two of the craziest catches this year on the same drive. its a once in a lifetime type shit thing
It's Russell Wilson type stuff.
@@TheFrenchPugfor sure, keep turnovers minimal and make big plays when needed
@ahaaha84 That's all Russ did. And he threw tons of heart attack passes that could have been intercepted. He even threw continuous pick 6's in our Red Zone. Yet, his heroics and our receiver's always seemed to save the game.
Metcalf made Lock look better than he is actually by making uncatchable passes.
No. And these QBs know their roles. True teamsmen!!
Drew has a rifle for an arm, he's mobile and look at him blocking on the first TD. He's committed and all in. Go with Drew
Exactly! He has all the tools. Just a little more risky but maybe that's what we need with this team.
Metcalf made Lock look better than he actually is by catching uncatchable passes.
@@kalijasin that's called letting your playmaker make plays. That's literally the 49ers whole offense.
Great report. Thanks for giving Seahawks some love!!
Drew Lock's a top talent there's a bias against 2nd round picks , his misfortune was being drafted by a horrible team as a 2nd round pick despite this he played well as a rookie and also during a covid year and with bad coaches . When he got to Seattle he couldn't compete for job in camp cause he had covid himself otherwise he wins the job cause he's better than Geno , this past camp it wasn't an open competition , Lock looked fantastic in Pre Season . If Drew Lock was a 1st round draft pick he's starting his 4th year as a starter that's the way this league works if you're a 1st rounder you stay on the field even if you suck . If you're a 2nd rounder who's now a backup the media and public buries you . I give Lock all the credit for hanging in there he deserves to play .
Facts!!!
Lock is below average, Geno is much better. As a Seattle fan I don't want to see him start another game, unless Geno is hurt.
@@glow4417 So, Drew Lock scored more points against the Niners and is below average. What does that make Geno?
No buddy average QB's with limited playing time don't do 92 yard winning drives in a pressure game in the pouring rain that means the season. . They also don't have the ability to make those type of throws either .
@@Mysticrich485 100% Agree. Kid us used to winning just like JSN was at The Ohio State.
Lock!
Lock in🔒 putting down for my City 😊
I think Geno's O-line was so decimated, he deserves another shot. Somewhere else. Because it wasn't all his line's fault. We knew when we resigned him that he had a drinking problem, and that's why the Shawks got a very team-friendly deal. He should have been suspended last year by the league for his 100mph drunken car chase where he repeatedly threatened to beat up the cops if they took off his cuffs. Everyone looked the other way so he could get a new and better contract and maybe retire in some comfort, but still. These things happened, and many predicted his drinking would creep in and hurt his play the next season.
This is why the S-hawks are moving on from Smith. If they plan on doing it next year, they MUST do it NOW. And instead of bringing in someone else to be QB1, why not give Lock a chance to show what he has? What he has is a rocket for an arm that can hit all of the tight windows, but can he put it all together? It's time to find out!
As a Seahawks fan, I say we stick with Geno if he can play. Yes, Lock delivered big in the comeback in last night's game, but even on that last drive he had missed throws that were a mile from the receiver. The first throw of the drive was almost an interception. He did what everyone hopes a backup can do: keep the season alive while the starter is out. But I wasn't seeing enough consistency to suggest he should be the starter. Unless he was missing targets simply because he hasn't had enough reps with his receivers in practice and that improves with time.
and Geno has done better? have you even been watching the games this year? Geno has thrown for 15 touchdowns and 9 interceptions and you're over here talking about how Lock almost threw a pick coming off the bench as a starter...🤣🤡
@@UseedNapkinExactly!!! Drew has done better every time he played.
@@UseedNapkingeno just a few games ago almost single handily carried us vs the cowboys I love lock I do but it’s geno if he is ready
I agree with starting with geno but that almost int was on Fant
@seahawksfan3118 Yes it was. And 3 passes Lock threw hit the receivers in the hands, and they dropped them, including Fant another time.
Drew did do great, it was a performance that rode that gray blurry line between excellence and luck. But if you want to give the man a crown after a couple games, he almost threw 2 picks on the same drive, missed a bunch of throws to Lockett whether that was drew or Lockett or a bad decision. DK’s miracle catch was an iffy throw and it was only a stunning set of 3rd and longs that he converted on deep passes that won the day. You simply can’t take it away from him. He did it and won that game. You look at some of the how he won that game and you say, dude did great but I wouldn’t put money on that being highly repeatable. I say this as a diehard Seahawks fan and happy the kid got his moment to show what he can do. And I’d love to see him and Geno have more of that luck. Take notice but understand the context.
I know the players really love Gino, so I’m not surprised.
Lock still needs to develop. Geno’s already has a bit more polish. Lock got lucky on a lot of things and even some of his good/big plays, he made mistakes with placement or missing a better read. Lock it’s a competent guy that makes for a great backup when he’s needed right now, but he still has a ways to go before he’s ready to take anyones job lol
He's done better than Geno in every appearance he's made.
@@TheFrenchPugnot really and I used to be a big geno hater, but it does seem Pete / Waldron have lock on a leash
@jdcobb9267 Oh yes, he has. Who has scored more points against the Niners between Dak, Geno, and Jalen without Walker playing? Correct! Drew Lock (and it was in Santa Clara!). Who beat a top 3 team on Monday night football with only 1 game under his belt in the rain? Correct! Drew Lock. Who came in for 3 sets of downs against the NY Giants and scored as many points as Geno scored the entire game? That's right! Drew Lock. Gotta open the eyes.
@@TheFrenchPug bro did not just use total points scored as the only indicator of performance LMAOOOO
@hadokenexe OK. Drew had 269 yards vs Niners and Geno 180 and also outscored him. And now I just heard Lock is starting this weekend per KJ Wright.
Geno is a choke artist proof is in the record!
Florio wants his precious Vikes to make the playoffs but they face Detroit twice in 3 wks lol
Im a hawks fan. Weird stuff happens at Lumen in primetime games. I saw the seahawks actually get explosives from the running game, a terrible Eagles secondary and a serviceable back up QB doing his job but certainly not taking anyones job. Flip a coin and he throws a pick 2-3 times on the last drive and never gets to find JSN for the winner.
Geno defenders explain without your bias how he beats someone who can give the same production but younger and more willing to put his body in harm's way just for the win?
Lock wouldn't have put up 35 against the Cowboys, with how the defense played and the mistakes made by the Eagles, Seattle should've won by more.....Lock overthrew numerous receivers.....no bias
GENO SMITH IN THE LAST GAME HE PLAYED ACCOUNTED FOR 35 POINTS ,3 PASSING TDS, 1 RUSHING TD. DREW LOCK HAS ACCOUNTED FOR 36 POINTS AND 3 PASSING TDS OVER 2 GAMES. STOP WITH THE BULLSHIT.
@@BLACKMAATAnd Drew had to play against two of the top 3 teams and scored more points vs. the Niners than the Geno, Dak, or Jalen has!
@@jeremyestrill1764 we seen them play the same team and drew lock played better not by a little a lot remember 49ers? He also did it with 1 day with the starters and over there. If we are going to back n forth than that proves my point SAME PRODUCTION but younger and willing to leave it all on the field.
I hope they stick with Locke.
This is five minutes of speculative filler to spice up a narrative. And it isn't there. I will tell you what will happen because I've sensed this from the minute the Seahawks made that jackpot trade with Denver: Once Geno was established as the starter during preseason last year, he was and _is_ going to be the starter for the duration of his contract, regardless of whether the team blows it up next year or takes it all the way out to 2025; and at that point Drew Lock will take the reins. Pete Carroll did it with Geno as Russ's backup, and after 4 years as the backup he was _ready_ to start after waiting patiently for his opening.
I think Pete's approaching it exactly the same way with Drew Lock; keep him in that backup role for the duration of Geno's contract, and once Geno hits 36 y/o and assuming the Seahawks have stayed competitive, they'll let Geno retire or move on with all the proper tributes to what he did for the team, and Drew Lock will become the heir apparent. That's the way Pete is -- he loves developing talent that other teams were unwilling to take the time to do because they made no attempt to understand what. makes. these. players. _tick._
To Pete it's self-evident the talent Geno and Drew both possess, he's just very adept at getting Geno and Drew to be the best Geno and Drew possible in order to get the most out of that talent. It's Pete's secret to being the great HC that he is. He is 100% player-oriented and _most_ of the players respond to that -- at least those who don't have egos or have been jaded by other teams. I'm convinced that's how this story is gonna play out, as long as Seattle stays in playoff contention each season and Geno's not the reason they're not competitive.
No BUT you run those same offensive personals with Geno like you did with Lock.. simple
exactly. Geno is way more accurate, just needs those plays called and quick release
@@sctim123It really felt like the plays there were giving lock were way better then what they have been with geno.
da fuq, Geno doesn't have the arm Lock has to make those throws.
you blind?@@UseedNapkin
Drew missed bad on several throws. He amassed a whopping 208 yards. He didn't throw any picks and that counts! He did make the throws he absolutely had to in the moment. Drew Lock proved he has the ability to lead and to make plays. But is he actually better than Geno? Hard to say...
Metcalf made Lock look better than he actually is by catching uncatchable passes.
Well, Fant and Lockett also dropped a few passes
@@kalijasinall qbs throw uncatchable passes every week. Even Mahomes and Josh Allen do. I don’t get the double standard.
You guys must not have been watching the same throws, not a little off and they couldn't get them, way off the mark. And yes, everyone has those. You also must not have read the whole comment I made. Re read it. I'm giving him praise as well. I'm nit against Lock doing well.
Florio just sayin anything. Just say you only watched the last drive
You don't bench Geno unless his time with the Seahawks is over.
Lock earned himself a chance to compete for the position in the offseason again IMO.
I'll bench who I FEEL like benching, son.
You don’t bench a guy that kept your season alive and beat a top 3 team in The NFL for a guy who’s proven all year he’s mediocre
U talk like you dont want to hurt players feeling ..Gino's time is over !! Change then release to save cash
@@SavageShane32 Geno would have beaten the Cowboys if his defense could have done anything to stop them in that game. Kind of how Lock was lucky that his defense kept him in the game because he did jack shit until that final drive barely having over 100 yards passing before that drive.
@@SavageShane32 yeah just if you play Lock, it's kinda of a death spell for Geno. Not sure Pete is ready for that.
I'd rather see Lock next week, just don't think it's gonna happen.
It is no coincidence that the offensive line looks better with a QB is quick and decisive with the ball. Geno holds the ball too waiting to see receivers come open and takes sacks. Lock let's his guys go make plays.
YES!!! Drew should play,
Drew Made some great throws last night, and too many poor ones. This would improve, probably, with him actually playing more and having his receivers become more used to his ball, instead of a left-handers. But, I don't think after last night, that Geno is out for the rest of this year. He may be at the end of the year, though. And Drew should get serious consideration for starting somewhere, like the former Husky is on his team. If Geno moves on, Drew might be a good choice to tutor whatever QB that the team drafts for at least a couple of years. It seems to me that a lot of promising QBs coming into the league have been far too rushed to be thrown in to the lions. So, I would like any future QB coming in to this team to get some transition time., and Drew might be a good choice for the transition. After all, most incoming QBs will be right-handers.
They're both right-handed
Geno Smith isn’t a lefty…
Sorry, i was misinformed.@@CD-gk9ix
He played 2 games you think he’s going to hit ever target? SMFH!
Lock is below average at best, as a Seahawk fan I never want to see him in the game again unless Geno is hurt.
He scored more points against SF than Dak, Jalen or Geno. Geno has had multiple opportunities this year to win in the 4th quarter and it didn’t happen. The guys are clearly rallying around Drew. He had many multiple drops by receivers and he had a couple of bad balls as well.
Geno had the best qbr in week 13 against the Dallas Cowboys. 300+ yards 3TDs. All against a top 3 defense in the league. Drew lock did great for a backup but he was playing against a bottom 5 defense in the league. Geno hasn’t looked great all year because of injuries and o line troubles. I love big cock lock but if we had him all year we would probably have 3 wins. Best backup in the league but geno is qb1 for a reason
GENO SMITH HAS 3 GAME WINNING DRIVES AND HE WOULD HAVE HAD 4 IF JASON MEYERS COULD HAVE MADE A FIELD GOAL
BUT I GET IT YOU WANT THE WHITE QUARTERBACK .
I WANT GENO TO LEAVE SEATTLE TOO.
@@BLACKMAAT L racism
finally, a voice of reason.
As a hawks fan I love lock he is an amazing person and he is getting better but if geno is healthy it’s geno 100%
If you win stay in simple
I think we should run with lock for rest of season - only fair
How is that fair?
Why? He is 1-1. Genes is 6-6. And lock didn’t even play well until the final drive.
Can’t bench your starter bc of injury
@@trentwise3762 that was clutch. Look who lock has been thrown in against - give him a break
@@colonelquickshifter6534 I mean I could say the same about geno. Give him a break too.
I think we keep Lock, let geno start for one of these other teams using backup QBs, and draft our QB of the future.
can you name one team that would show any interest in Geno ? Maybe as a backup? some team may pick him up ! as a starter ? Hell NO !!!
@@integrity-ut8ff Steelers would benefit from him more than pickett...
Want to lose the room? Bench G. Adjust the wig.
Just the title of this video got me here. Dumb question. Last drive was awesome for Drew but there was 3 times he almost gave the game away throwing into coverage.
Geno Smith 15 TDS 9 INTS on the season, and you're talking about Lock almost throwing a pick coming off the bench after he threw a game winning drive in the 4th quarter from behind under 2 minutes, he threw 0 picks against one of the best teams in the NFC. The Seattle fanbase copes so hard it's funny.
@@UseedNapkin not really sure what point you're trying to make. Not really sure what "copes" means in this context. Just pointing out that I don't think Lock is gonna be some kinda savior for Seattle.
Get rid of Geno Smith!!!
Let Drew brew!
Jamal Adams didn't even go to the game.....Pete will play Adams and smith next week and kill what little momentum the hawks have
Umm, hell no! Happy they won, but Lock almost threw 3 picks on that drive. He's just not very good.
"Geno is our starter." - Pete Carroll
"we won't trade Wilson" Pete Carroll
Sometimes Pete won't say true. Drew young, Geno old
With this showing I think GENO gets yanked or benched during a game a lot easier now, which should light a fire
Pete also has to say things as a smoke screen to throw off the scent of what they're doing
Drew Lock over Gino Smith?
No way.
Geno may not be a Pro Bowl player, but Drew Lock will only be a success as a backup.
Ride the hot hand? Had 1.5 good minutes.
Defense won that game IMO.......subtract K9 touchdown and Myers field goal and Seattle loss that game but all off a sudden he should replace Geno lol......and I'm not talking like Geno the best but as of right now, he's better......can they mold Lock into a good QB? I definitely think so
@jeremyestrill1764 exactly. I'd say MAYBE if geno comes back and flops over the next 2 games and basically eliminates the seahawks from tbe playoffs , then j could see letting lock get some play time. But definitely if geno is healthy, he'll be starting next game
GINO WHOO !!!!!!!!!!
100% Lock. Geno needs to get his head back on.
Drew Lock did a great job!
Walker III and Metcalf stepped up huge and that had nothing to do with Lock.
absolutely Not.
Florio makes shit up.
Lock is no where near as good as G.
I'm a sports fan who doesn't know shit.... Is there any possibility of having 2 starting QB's, each playing depending on against which team.
Why wouldn't Geno Smith celebrate winning when he's supposed to return as the starting QB and his team's playoff future is on the line? Geno Smith returning next season very well may rest on him winning a playoff game.
It’s because so many other teams don’t have the kind of culture that Seattle does like are they growing pains obviously look at how DK acts sometimes but the environment in Seattle is one of a kind in the nfl with Pete
Hawks have to win out. Lock has the momentum and likely the locker room after a huge win like that. He’s also a better explosive playmaker than Geno and didn’t turn the ball over. KJ Wright thinks Lock gets the nod next week. I do too.
After this season? Its gonna be interesting. I don’t think you can build a SB team around Geno. We also haven’t seen enough of Lock but he’s younger with potentially a higher ceiling. Really depends on how the season closes out but I say draft a QB either way.
He played one good game. ONE!!! Replacing a 2022 Pro Bowl QB for a guy who played one good game. Be serious…..
Geno has not played like a pro-bowl QB for at least a year. It's clear he's not the guy. Give Drew a real shot.
You can stop with the Geno copium, the guys best record ever is 9-8 with a career losing record.
@@GreenBeanGreenBeanyes. On a team that was predicted to be a bottom 3 team😂
Like I love how you blame geno for the Seahawks historically bad defense last year. Shows you clearly are a casual fan. No research done
@@Parallax982geno also has almost no help. K9 has been hurt a few games. The play calls have been terrible. And the defense has been a let down all year.
But yeah. Bench the dude who drop 30+ on both the lions and cowboys.
@@trentwise3762 Uh yea they thought Geno was a bottom 3 QB lmao.....most predictors literally had the Cardinals ahead of Seattle last year.
When you lose the time of possession battle by 8+ minutes a game it is tough to win....and even if your D is bad, last time I checked the refs give you the ball back to be able to drive back down the field and score..... guess what, Geno went 3 and out or threw a pick. Most games it was the Hawks that didn't score 20 points that was the problem.
If your D is on the field excessively because the O goes 3 and out quickly.......that ain't on the D.....they actually get tired eventually, unlike the O.
Nope. Look at the film minus the emotion. Lock through three nearly picked balls and had two INT in the previous game. The first part of his game was meh at best. Did you look at what Geno did in his last game? 300 yards and 3 TD. He’s led multiple game winning drives. He’s our starter and there is a reason he won the job over Lock. That’s what Pete said.
Seattle should STICK both Drew Lock and Geno Smith.
☝️😆👍
Let's go drew let's go hawks .....
Yes stick with drew he has finally grew up
Bro just be saying anything tf! Know damn well drew lock was not close to geno for the starting qb for Seattle last year!! Where he get that bs from
I am not a Seattle fanat all but as soon as Gino is healthy put him back in there. He has been there Guy since Wilson left.
How come everyone looks so depressed when they have to say positive things about the seahawks or talk about a hawks win. even the MNF commentators seemed bothered when the Hawks made a good play.The hawks are coming and would be further ahead if that one flag happy ref. crew didnt ref so many of the hawks games .Yeah these guys are trying to start controversy in Seattle .. good luck with that ..
I would use both of the QBS down the final stretch I dont understand why teams dont shuffle them about a bit , give the opposition a few problems to solve when it gets a bit stale....and take it from me Geno has been rotten at times this year
Geno is far better
Bench Chino...
Lock proved himself. Geno is injury prone
Ha! 😀
It's not just Drew. it's how the team plays with Drew. Something special happened last night. At least start him another game and see where it goes.
Geno is a decent backup at best. Lock is the man.
Cut Geno
Yes. Smith needs to be gone after this season. Had a great 1st half of last season. Has mostly reverted back to the norm since. Too expensive next two seasons. Need to see what Lock can do over the next 3 games to Ser if he can be kept around when the Seahawks draft a QB this upcoming draft.
🤣🤣🤣 wishful thinking....Geno stays
No
The Seahawks also dropped several passes in the game, including the one that bounced off Fant at the beginning of the final drive that could have been picked. The weather obviously played a part in those drops, so Lock's numbers could have been better.
Still, I think Lock and Smith are virtually the same player. They're both slightly above average and can look good for stretches, but neither are consistent enough to get you to the Super Bowl.
I could see the Seahawks figuring out which one they like better in the off season and going with him for another year or two, but letting him act as a mentor for the quarterback of the future they get in the upcoming draft.
Drew lock has alot more upside than geno he's alot more talented than geno. Geno has veteranship over drew which is about it. Lock has everything else. If lock gets another chance to play next week I hope they do more play action to intermediate throws and push the ball down field to his playmakers, because that's what drew does best.
@@milville2329
RRRRACIST!
Lock should just rule out trying to throw to Fant at this point.
Save money with Lock. Why are we paying Geno Wilson money when Lock is about the same skill level. Lock also has more potential and room to grow.
Facts
They have to reward DL with a second start !! I used to be annoyed with Lock when he played for Denver as a Boltz fan , but he impressed me last night big time !!!!
This was his 2nd start
His start last week included 2 picks and a loss
Before that final drive what did he do that was impressive and made you think yea should be the starter over Geno. He had like 120 yards passing and a bunch of inaccurate throws.
GENO's still better.
@@wisewolftonyyes dude idk why everyone just ignores that. Like yes is was a great drive. Incredible drive for lock. But it took 59:32 seconds for him to have a touchdown.
And honestly his passes weren’t as good as people say. I think Both DK and jsn made INCREDIBLE catches more than lock made good throws to them
Like the double coverage throw seemed like just “I hope this works” play. And the jsn throw was to far but jsn made a freaking awesome grab.
@@trentwise3762 I mean I will give him credit for the 2nd throw as seen guys overthrow it or underthrow those types of passes all the time so any throw that gives them a chance is good in my eyes. But as a unbiased Dolphins fan I would 100% rather have Geno as my QB than Lock at least for this season. Now next year if they would rather release him save money and think Lock or someone else can be a better option than sure maybe do that. But right now Geno gives them the best chance to win.
In a word. No.
G Smith!!
LOL F the Seahawks
such a stupid topic given pete already announced geno was starting last night, also when he was healthy this offense just exploded against the dallas defense
Ppl gotta stop with this drew > geno.
Free threw for 120 yards until the final drive. It took him 59:32 minutes to score a TD.
Geno hasn’t been as good as he was last year. But is is 100% better than drew
Drew scored more points against the Niners than anybody else. He has more upside potential and is a gamer.
@@TheFrenchPug yes, with k9 and a healthy o-line.
yeah more potential, but every young player has potential, but lock has shown he probably won't live up to that potential.
@trentwise3762 Drew has shown that he is growing into his potential in only two starts. He scored more points against the Niners than Geno, Dak, and Jalen in their games against them. Geno has had all preseason, last year, and this season when he doesn't have a band-aid on his owie, to practice and play. Drew got two shots and beat a top 3 team in his 2nd start. AND...you can tell the players rally around him. Maybe because he throws the ball to everyone and not just DK and Tyler?
@@TheFrenchPug yes. And he did it with k9 and a healthy o-line. Something geno didn’t have.
And it was also 3 more points. Let’s not act like he put up 25+ on them. Seattle scored 3 more points than with geno
Nobody is saying he isn’t good. But he is nowhere near as consistent as geno. And many seattle fans will tell you that the play calling with drew has been way better than with geno.
Again I’m not saying lock is bad. I think he is better than a few team’s starters. But geno’s ceiling is higher than locks
Stop.....😂😂😂😂
🥹🥹🥹🥹😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I like both QBs, they've done well. Geno had his magic season last year but the magic is gone. This season he seems to make numerous horrible decisions each game and hasn't been seeing his receivers or the field as well as last year, despite all his new weapons. Drew is good, and can flourish in this type of system. But he also makes some bad throws and to me, doesn't have enough arm strength for the deep, deep balls, or enough arm finesse for the touch passes. The Seahawks can't make a deep playoff run with either QB, they need someone more dynamic. I'd love for them to draft a young QB (hopefully Bo Nix...I'm a UW Huskies fan and love Penix but prefer Nix in this kind of system more). Pete is never, ever, ever, ever, ever going to change his ways so the Hawks will be relegated to winning late in the 4th quarter because Pete likes the game close, keeps running even though they have less than 20 total yards rushing midway through the 4th quarter, and is okay if his defense gives up 400 yards and 30 points per game...as long as they win at the end. But the new Hawks aren't built for those kinds of comebacks each game, especially with Wilson gone. Geno and Drew cannot, and will not be able to do that every single game. It may be a blessing if they lose out and get a higher draft pick. Better that than barely not making it in the playoffs or getting beat during the wildcard....again.
Qb change asap Gino's time is over
CUT GENO NOW SO THE BROWNS OE VIKINGS CAN PICK HIM UP
@BLACKMAAT they really don't know what they got.......this his second year as a starter and he's 30+ years old and playing at this level....and they want him to go elsewhere lol riding narratives of him being bust, when he was thrown to the wolves by Rex Ryan and a trash Jets team who never developed a QB......Geno would've been a terror to this league had he been drafted to Seattle from the beginning
@@jeremyestrill1764 THEY MAY NOT KNOW WHAT THEY GOT. BUT THEY DAMN SURE KNOW WHAT THEY WANT. AND WHAT THEY WANT IS " DREW LOCK"WHICH IS WHY I CALL THEM "LOCK'S LUNATICS "
@jeremyestrill1764 the blame somebody else game is full effect
Hell yes they should! GO HAWKS!
NO! He almost threw 3 picks!!
Stick with Lock " Geno had way to many chances , he holds the ball to long / takes to many sacks ! Lock has the hot hand give him a chance . against the Eagles Lock took a couple of sacks, Eagles would have sacked Geno at least 7 or 8 times and we would have got blown out as we did with previous games Geno played in ! Lock has a quicker release than Geno , video`s don`t lie...
Geno
No
No