Mega Man X VS Classic Mega Man - Which is better? Classic Mega Man and Mega Man X Series Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- Don't forget to Make a Whatnot account for a free $15!!
www.whatnot.co...
Mega Man X VS Classic Mega Man - Which is better? Classic Mega Man and Mega Man X Series Comparison
In this video we go over both the Classic Mega Man Franchise as well as the Mega Man X franchise and decide which of these legendary game franchisees is objectively the best one!!! Since, obviously this is not subjective...
Links:
Whatnot: www.whatnot.co...
Patreon: / tooterppp
Discord: / discord
Reddit: / tooterp
Merch: www.zazzle.com...
Twitter: / tooterpyt
![Mega Man: Maverick Hunter X: THE DAY of Σ OVA [HQ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7-lgTS_BZPs/mqdefault.jpg)
I prefer Mega Man X, but the classic series games as a whole are better. X has higher highs but also lower lows.
Agreed
Yeah the classic series was very balanced in quality
Higher Highs? Nope, not at all
But that difference is so negligible. I think they both have higher highs depending on your criteria.
X all day
Tooterp: 3D Mega Man X? That would be bad.
Megaman X7: *Laughs evilly*
"You can play as Zero for real now, but he's not OP" speedruns would disagree XD That dash cancel is insane
Literally thought that myself as I kill a boss in seconds lol
And then you have CROUCH cancel, and then you have Crouch Cancel with Laser Shield
Plus Zero is much cooler than Protoman and Bass combined
I think Classic series is more consistently good compare to the X series, but when the X series is good, it’s really good
Both are two of my favorite series in all of gaming. I don't think I could choose one over the other.
Classic games had consistency. X had some pretty great highs (X4 being the best), but its lows are very, very low (looking at you X7).
On paper, Mega Man X is a step up from the classic series in every regard. The X series has got a very solid and fun foundation.
The actual games built on that foundation however... Vary in quality a lot, to say the least.
Despite having a really strong core, most of the X series games fall short for me in level design department. Even though the games are very fun mechanically, I dont't really have fun actually getting through most of them.
So the classic series is definitely better in my eyes.
The best thing about the X series - it paved the way and passed on that strong core to the very best Mega Man series, the Zero series.
I just told my mother that you suggested I try to beat MegaMan X without the dash boots. She just looked at me and said nothing…
She's already done it
MM: Rock N' Roll
MMX: Heavy Metal
No, I agree. My favorite game of all time is X2. It's my go-to game that I keep playing when I'm happy, when I'm sad, or when I just need to enjoy myself. And I love X6 because how broke that game is.
However, subjectively, Classic is better.
Ps: I did played X without boots upgrade. I had to. RetroAchievements made me do it.
BASED.
If I could change just *ONE FECKING THING* about X6 though...
Zero's "up slash" in the air is the DUMBEST SHIT EVER, especially for a game that revolves around high enemy density over bottomless pits with a billion climbing ropes, and nowhere to Giga Attack.
@@TonyTheTGRThat's what you'd choose to change about x6? Not any of the other problems it has?
I'd say it's the most absolutely detrimental one if I had to choose just one, because it's so blatantly unintuitive. I guess Shadow Armor X having a valid route through Gate #1 would be a second?
@@TonyTheTGR Yes you are right, that's just the most detrimental thing ever. Not the shitty nightmare system. Not the poor and sometimes bland level design. Not portals to the Zero and High Max boss fights appearing out of nowhere before the player is properly prepared to take them on. Not the half-dozen box of donuts in Blaze Heatnix stage. The whole reason the game is bad, is the bloody upslash.
I'm the kinda guy who holds Megaman 8 and X6 as his favorites
why?
MM8 is a game about balls and gay jokes and so is MegaMan X6.
I say this as a fan of both of them myself.
@@TonyTheTGRmmm balls
I think that the limitation of mega man's abilities in the classic series allows for tighter design with more emphasis on tight platforming and enemy placement, which is why I prefer it over the x seriies
Hmm.. were you in one of Nico's videos?
No. But I do watch him
I'm a big Megaman X fan and Is my favourite,the First one especially.However i like coming back to the classic series too and i like it's lighter tone. Megaman Zero Is awesome too but i find myself playing It less.
What makes Megaman Zero so boring to me is the fact you got to collect Elves which all look the same. I don't like that mechanic and i wish it got a progression more like the original and even X.
@@damsen978
You don't even need elves. You just need to get Rank A - S to get new moves from Zero 2 onward.
I only play it less than X because
1. It's longer than the X games
2. It's sweaty, you gotta give 100% attention to play these games
3. It's not casual play. It's definitely requires a higher skill level in terms of precision and movement.
The OG Megaman really has no bad main line entry (yes even 8 is good despite some flaws). The X series on the otherhand started getting bad after X4 or 5.
It was bad from X3.
Well, I could argue megaman 5 and 2 were pretty bad. Idk the X games and how bad some entries were so I don’t know what megaman 5 and 2 are being compared to
@@mohdadeeb1829 L take
@@megaedge2762it's not that 5 was bad, its just the the buster was overpowered. But i will say the weapons could be better (looking at you charge kick, wouldn't mind you so much if you actually worked well enough).
Level design wise, i actually think 5 is one of the best in the series.
@@megaedge2762 if megaman 2 was bad then there wouldn't have been megaman after 2 buddy
While classic megaman might be more consistent; those first 5 megaman X games are amazing in my opinion, I love the exploration in them and trying to beat them with the least amount of backtracking
Mega Man X games are more thematically and artistically creative, but the Mega Man Classic games are more consistently good games.
If you don't think zero is overpowered in megaman X4 I feel like I should show you some tricks to change your mind
Well, Zero is only broken if you exploit SDC. Without that, X's 4th Armor with the Plasma Shot is completely overpowered and intended to be so by the programmers. He clears the screen (and off screen) enemies and generally shreds mid-bosses. And his charged weapons have safer kill options for all bosses, including Sigma.
Megaman X It is better for me, but I do like the classic series
I like Classic but prefer X and Z. There's a lot of yoku blocks, enemies leaping from bottomless pits, spike falls and mandatory usage of sub weapon/items (in the first 3 games) that dampens my opinion of the Classic games.
I'm thinking of getting the first X legacy collection very soon, this video helped my expectations lol
Can't decide. They are just 2 of the best Mega Man series.
4:05 not me, because I personally go this order: guts, cut, elec, ice, fire, bomb, dr w
I love both and I wouldn't be able to decide. They are both awesome.
I Prefer Mega Man Xtreme 1 And 2 Over The Classic Mega Man Game Boy Games,Due To The Wall Jump!The Air Dash In Xtreme 2,Specifically With Zero's Hyper Dash "RepliCust" Part,Is An ABSOLUTE BLAST!Here Is The GameShark Code To Equip 4 Parts On Armored X And Zero:010497CA!Best Parts For Zero:Hyper Dash,Energy Saver,Saber Plus 1 And 2!And For X:Hyper Charge,Speed Shot,Buster Plus 1 And 2!Save With The Parts Equipped,And You Can Switch Ultimate Buster For Hyper Charge On X As Long As You Don't Remove Speed Shot Or The Buster Plus Parts!You Can Then Go On A KILLING SPREE With Your Rapid Fire REAL ULTIMATE BUSTER!HAVE FUN,UNIT!
Good stuff, hey from 2024! I'm totally bias towards the MMX series. I -still- listen to the music when I want 16 bit synthy-rock melodies while i'm drawing.
I am not looking at franchise consistency. I am looking at individual games. From where I stand, nothing touches Megaman X4. It's action platform perfection.
I’ve always been more of a fan of Megaman x then the original series the darker themes zero plus x 4 was my first Megaman game so I’m pretty biased
I enjoy both, and most of the different series have some stinkers. But in terms of overall quality, classic has better consistency.
Only REAL Megaman fans, aka, SUBSCRIBERS, WANT a video on Megaman and Megaman X pause screens!
For the FIRST Time on this platform, I actually enjoyed watching the Sponsored Add... XD
The correct answer is neither. It's ZX. Can't really beat a Megavania running of the X formula. All they need to do was expand the overworld and make it feel less linear.
Not even a question. Classic series annihilates X series like how Storm Tornado annihilates Mega Man X.
Mega Man X games all have different set of problems but if we dig deeper we might see a pattern. Except X7 that game has an entire book of problems. Mega Man X games have forgettable enemies. I get how everything looks soulless but that soul less nature makes me forget enemies in this game, If you send me a picture of enemy and ask me which game is it from, I would struggle.
Mega Man X games also have a problem with difficulty balancing. Games like X4 and X5 and maybe even X2 feel way too easy while games like X3, X6 and X8 feel way too difficult. X4 and especially in X5 you can tank through enemies and would not need to worry about it.
Balancing is another issue about stage lenghts. All games have stages that are either too long or too short for what they are. Weapon balance is also off. Only X1 and X2 and maybe X3 have good weapons. The stages are so stale in these games that you don't want to use special weapons and save them for bosses.
Repetition is another problem with X series. We see a challenge and it is repeated five to six times without any change.
Classic series on the other hand is memorable, consistently difficult, balances about stage lengths and weapons and just plane round creative.
Mega man was cute. But Megaman X and X4 got me into the series. Megaman Zero then solidified me as a fan.
I'm a be real with you. I love both series for their own reasons, but objectively, I think Rock has the better games, because the quality is more consistent across the majority of his games, which is more than I can say for his younger brother, X. Out of all 8!l games, I only like 4 of them: 1, 4, 5 and 8.
Agree wholeheartedly, but Zero series has the best quality across the board.
Can you imagine how crazy a 3D Mega Man game would be? That would be terrible. It would probably be called something odd, like Mega Man Legends or Mega Man 64 lmao. I have a deep respect for both Mega Man and X, it's hard to choose.
The Japanese games are:
Sakatsuku 2010 World challenge サカつく (saka being short for "soccer" and tsuku no doubt being short for "tsukuru", or "to make"),
Eiken DS 英検 (or "English Proficiency Test DS")
Otona no Jishikiryoku 大人の常識力 (or "The Power of Common Sense (for adults))
DS Rakubikijiten DS楽引辞典 (Or the "DS Rakubiki Dictionary")
and
Chuugaku Jitsugi Yonshuuka DS中学実技4数科 (or "DS Junior High School Practical 4 Mathematics").
So really you've got a bunch of dictionaries.
100% agree
classic is better, but it’s individual… I have not much time, I play short rounds … and believe it or not I still play Mega Man 2 and 6, Bomberman 2 and 4 … Mario Bros. 1 regularly from time to time.
I really love the X series too… it looks much better, Upgrades are on point … but it cost more time and… personally, Mega Man is to big 😁 the the ladders too. I think Mario World is better or Mario 3 but it’s not the same I start Mario bros and play a round, quit and all in 5-10min. It’s perfect for me.
My biggest love is ghost n goblins arcade… I would always choose it over Mega Man… but Mega has the free choice… and this makes it so great repayable.
And by the way I would love a resurrection version of Mega Man classic
If you love the idea of playing MegaMan/X with friends in multiplayer... you should REALLY look into 20XX and 30XX.
But I *am* gonna make this simple. Play Guts Man's level. Play Armored Armadillo's level.
Mega Man X is clearly, by a country mile, FAR superior to Mega Man 1. The end.
As someone who only play a game once, i think X series has better new player experience than classic.
Classic has annoying enemies & annoying stages that probably will make some players rage quit the game. Which is usually no longer an issue when replaying the game since you already know what to expect.
As a subscriber I'm allowed to respectfully disagree... but I enjoyed the video... I hope you can read this lol
So, the dawn of time was in 1993? Wouza.
The game with the guy yelling looks awesome! The intensity!
I'm the one and only person here to say that I use bombs in cut man's stage. At the end of the stage, if you don't have ice slasher yet, you can spam hyper bomb from the ladder to kill the annoying big eye without taking damage.
I like both, but my favorite is the Megaman X series. But I have to acknowledge that Megaman X has less consistency in quality. Even though I prefer the X series. And my favorite thing that megaman has that other games don't have is MEGAMAN. Mario doesn't have megaman, Socnic doesn't have megaman, Bomber man doesn't have megaman, and so on. You cannot play with megaman in those games. Hahahaha. In addition to that, megaman looks like Master Mind, both are blue. Here in Brazil, the title version of Master Mind is MEGA MENTE, which sounds like Mega Man in the Brazilian accent.
Mega Man 7 and Mega Man X.
That's it. The best ones.
To be fair, i played Mega Man X first. X , X2, and X3 are the best out of the X series but if were talking Mega Man, ive only played Mega Man 11 for Switch. I need to actually play the other Mega Man classic games myself to give a fair critique
Every one I've spoken to say X4 is the best one.
@@Neethan3247 I would disagree I think X, X3, X2 in that order are the best. I find the graphics and artstyle worked way better in 16bit, also the soundtracks in X-X3 are so much more appealing and memorable than X4 and so is the leveldesign.
I generally prefer the classic games for several reasons. Firstly the classic characters are extremely charming and memorable. Rock, Roll, Blues, Auto, etc. are likeable. It's also more colorful and lively. The level design is mostly the same, but the levels actually have challenge. The problem with the X games are that the wall climb ruins the challenging level design. By being able to climb walls and dash around like Sonic makes the levels way too easy. Most levels in MMX games are just a joke. The main challenge is the boss fights. They are very fast and challenging. But the classic robot masters were also challenging. Another thing I don't like about the X series is the special weapons you acquire don't feel that meaningful. The X games give you so much armor and a powerful charge shot so it makes the weakness order sort of redundant, especially the later X games. Lastly I don't like the characters much in the X series. They're always angry and humorless. X is really not a likeable hero, compared to classic Rockman. Zero is cool, but he feels somewhat out of place. And I especially hate the animal headed robot masters. They just look stupid and goofy. A pink, ninja, man, robot, centipede? WTF am I looking at? I like the collectable gameplay of Sub Tanks and Heart Tanks in the X games and getting upgrades is cool. The classic games can feel too minimal at times though. So it's a sort of mix up between the two series.
Let's go!
Hey PooterT pls do a video on the Mega Man pause screens
I think I should go with each X game's individual faults.
X1: X1, for a Mega Man game is almost perfect from start to finish. There are flaws. I am not a fan of starting with Half Life especially with exploration elements. Would have preferred if we gained 2hp by defeating a Maverick. Also the fact that The Dash is in Chill Penguin's stage makes it more linear that it should.
X2: There's nothing inherently wrong with X2 on a macro level. Except it is bit easy for my taste, some secrets are very cryptic and stages are too short for what they are. X2 has a lot of small game design mistakes that makes it less enjoyable than 1.
X3: X3 is mediocre. The game lacks apparent enemy diversity, enemies do way too damage and absurd amount of backtracking. And besides the stages are just uninteresting corridors with same enemies repeating over and over again with no set pieces or gimmicks.
X4: X4 have 3 major sins that make the game much worse. Enemies do too little damage, Health energy drop like candy and gameovers aren't harsh eneough. If these three faults were fixed, would have made the game much better. Maybe even better than X1. But as it stands, X4 is too easy.
X5: X5 does all the things X4 does wrong and adds on to them. At least in X4, dying matters. X5 is ugly from start finish. Lacks enemy diversity. Repetition is real and the worst part. Alia! She interrupts from playing the game saying the most boring stuff ever made.
X6: X6 has the same problems as X4 and X5 but unlike X5, X6's flow is much better.
X7: Needs a full book.
X8: My main problem with X8 is the same as my problem with Mega Man 8. The game style is too deviant from what Mega Man is supposed to be. And Mega Man 8 is a beautiful game but this game ugly from start to finish.
I agree with some criticisms, but I feel some are a bit harsh, lol!
@@sukmykrok3388 Like?
X1 - Near flawless, impressive evolution on the classic formula.
X2 - Mostly a wash. I wish there was a greater consequence for not getting Zero's parts than having him be a brainwashed, semi-final boss, like maybe an extra stage before fighting him. At least the double-charge shot and midair dash were better thought out..
X3 - Tried to cram in too much with too many undercooked ideas. Megaman's basic format might give it some non-linearity, but it's not Metroid. The best new idea was the chance to kill the sub-bosses and get an altered final stage, and even that could've been expanded on. Also starting with this game, every boss rush will be painfully tedious.
X4 - More streamlined and enough variety in the stage gimmicks to stay interesting. Definitely the 2nd best of the series. The only blemish is, of course, the boss rush.
X5 - Mostly the same complaint as MMX3 - the big, new gimmick was needlessly complicated. Otherwise it's an inferior clone of X4.
X7 - Couldn't even get through the whole thing. The camera almost single-handedly tanks it.
X6 and X8 I haven't played
@@duhdeedee You pretty much saw J's reviews's review and came back to it. And you can say the same thing that I saw Nico Evaluate's review and came at it.
@@duhdeedee
Imagine X5, but worse and without a good story. That's X6. 2 Armor Sets that need to be completed to use them. Questionable level design. A big gimmick that causes more problems than anything else. It's not a good game.
X8 is a mediocre return to form. It's not bad. Just could be way better.
I’ve never played X but from this video it seems they’re two different styles of games sort of like comparing NFL Blitz to NFL Madden same sport different rules
Tooterp, did you play Blasphamous?
Which ones better? Depends on WHEN you ask me. Basically from the time of x to x4, x was the best because it was against mm7 and 8. But then mm9 dropped and is the perfect mm game and by then we had the last half of X and it was dead.
Metroid fusion vidoes when?
So Classic is better than X just because it's more casual for adults like you who don't have much time to commit to a game? This isn't objective. You can't make this topic objective. It will always boil down to opinions.
For me personally X series takes the cake for me, i cannot for the life of me imagine playing a Megaman game without wall jumping. It's like not having wall jumps in Metroid games (Like the first two entries).
You have to try the Zero series
I prefer the classic because I like the characters and vibe better. Plus, the X games got so bad at X5 for me that I just stopped following them altogether. You may not want to consider that latter point in your decision, but I will.
Those are good for Halloween
Based upon the fact the classic series didn't have much of a template and that the original didn't have any really bad games I'm inclined to say the classic is better. Sorry X: 5, 6, & 7 brought down the X series a lot and the classic didn't have any games that bad. If it were for the first 4 X games I'd say the X games were better but that's not how things turned out
I personally enjoy both series.
But damn, MegaMan 8, 9, X4, X5, X7 are imo the lowest point in the series.
9 and x4? Genuinely curious as to why you think they're low points.
@@DWN-020 Fact: If you run through enemies in X4, they won't hurt you enough and there would always be a health refill lying around.
Mega Man 9 is.. actually It is good to see people who hate on 9. Yes! It is at the top of my list as well but I don't like it that much personally.
@mohdadeeb1829 true, but that's the best you could come up w/? Color me convinced then.
@@mohdadeeb1829you didn't even bother to explain for 9. Once again, color me convinced
I am going to say Mega Man X because I never really liked the original series. The X series just has a better storyline, better characters, and better levels
ain't no way you say "ninja gay then"
So the Doc Robot stages are the reason that mega man 3 is the best NES game so using that as a reason to not talk about greatness of mega man classic vs X is a false statement to begin with. There were a few other "errors" that I'll avoid nitpicking but that one made me sit up and look at my keyboard.
It's as simple as the classic series doesn't have any bad games (7 is the worst and it's still an A), and X6-X8 are not good games, maybe not bad, but they aren't good.
Mega Man X has higher highs but much much much lower lows. X and X2 and X4 are arguably better than the top 3 classic games, but I'd put 9 over X and X4 though, X2 is the peak of video games, so, it's hard, but the classic series is obviously the better series.
Also for whatnot I have no idea how to use a phone or a QR code thing and an app on my phone, I'm 90 years old according to my thumbs and brain content.
Also Rockman CX has a quick man option that allows you to climb the walls, and that hack is stupid so having Quick Man being able to wall jump does make it a better experience, but 9/10 times I'd agree with the assesment that mm would be worse with wall jumping.
NO, MEGA MAN 1 (LIKE ONE 1987) HAS THE BEST MENU OF THEM ALL BY FAR 100% IT'S THE BEST I'LL TYPE IN CAPS THE REST OF THE COMMENTS NOW BECAUSE THAT'S AN ERROR!
SO THERE WAS A RULE THAT I WOULDN'T PLAY MARIO PARTY UNLESS I HAD A SEPARATE TV WHERE I COULD PLAY MEGA MAN ON WHILE EVERYONE TAKES 10 YEARS TO LOOK AT THE BOARD AND FIGURE OUT WHAT THEY WANTED TO DO FOR THEIR TURN, I WAS USUALLY ABLE TO BEAT AT LEAST ONE GAME BY THE TIME THE STUPID MARIO PARTY GAME WAS OVER.
Busque esto literal en google y me saliste vos, i love you
It’s preference
What do you mean play Mega Man X without dash boots? As far as I know, you can't skip them. I suppose you can pick the level they are in last. Is that what you meant?
Mega Man Zero is better than both
OK, so this video answers why the X series gets the snub in many of the listicles that came after. Good to know.
I wasn't aware there were Xes outside of Super Nintendo.
Starting to appreciate other oddities from this YT creator. Cutting himself off at the vid end is something to look forward to -- no disrespect intended.
In the MEG4K video, claimed to have arthritis, and that his script is 20K. In this video, claims to not be able to read. English Class describes such a person as an unreliable narrator.
Do I stink? Sorry, had a bad flu cold and was stuck in bed for a few days. Guess I'll watch that DK video next.
Still answers to be found.
This video is a 10/10 🎉
Heck yeah.
X series were great and my favorites. until they did the bullshit 3d side scrollers. I hate that. Stick to drawing art like x4-x6
It shouldve ended at x6
X series has higher highs but lower lows. Classic series is generally consistent. I think X1-X4 I think are better than the entire Classic series but X6 and X7 are some of the weakest Megaman games in the entire franchise. X5 and X8 are a bit better than those weird middle entries in the Classic series(4--7)
Classic series for me. X series is too hard and completely forgettable stage designs for the most part.
X4 and X5 are EZ.
Coincidentally where I stopped playing them. I rage quit after MX3. Wasn't doing it for me@@mohdadeeb1829
The answer is Mega Man Zero. Sorry, not sorry.
Hey tooter, let us buy your wiis
Unfortunately I don't know how to read
The answer is Megaman Zero
Megaman X >> 🤷♂️
The worst game for classic series is megaman 8, a great game. The worst game for x could go to either 6 or 7, absolute pieces of dogshit. But the X legacy collection 1 games are almost perfect
I prefer mega man X
heres my case: Zero series best
I don't need to watch this video, clearly X is the inferior version.
te amo