ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 เม.ย. 2024
- Pro-Palestinian encampments have effectively paralyzed dozens of college campuses across the U.S., with some schools' finals and graduation ceremonies being impacted. NBC News' Antonia Hylton spoke to Joseph Slaughter, a Columbia University professor, on law enforcement being called to campus.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#columbiauniversity #NYPD #columbia
In my era Vietnam Stop The War they used tear gas on us.
And those students were right, they were protesting for a cause worth supporting; these students are just plain ignorant, manipulated by Hamas propaganda and disinformation. They should all be forced to take a class on the history of the Middle East.
not even close to the same cause
True we were protesting something that effected our lives and futures. These people are shouting "Death to America"@@grepbeer
@@grepbeer Not true, they're still using that same tear gas
@@allanaaa no they are not. They even release these criminals same day
The president needs to go. She completely mishandled these protests.
She should’ve called NYPD
@@dragonflarefrog1424 Well, she should not have, and the entire world disagrees with you.
@@Rades1055 Wrong, she should’ve called them much earlier, this is why a bipartisan group of Congresman called for her resignation.
Finally, she called the cops, and everyone except anarchists and pro-hamas supporters agree that it was right, but way too late. You’re not the whole word, polling shows most Americans don’t support criminal trespass.
@@dragonflarefrog1424 whatever! The pro-Hamas bla bla bla propaganda is utterly disgusting!
@@Rades1055 next time she will call the military. Time to be tough.
Still nothing on last night’s “counter protest” at UCLA.
They are Isreal propaganda, they reguse to report it.
Doesn't fit the propaganda narrative being pushed.
“Crying in despair.” Most of those kids have most likely never experienced anything that would cause despair. If this is the worst they ever experience then they will absolutely be alright.
bot
@@stakstik2884 😂 Really? Is that your default answer to anything you don't agree with? Or, are you just letting us all know that you are a bot?
blame game has begun...no one willing to take responsibility... when in reality everyone involved is responsible for the results of there actions or inaction......
As a professor, and as a graduate of Columbia University, I am embarrassed to be a professor listening to this and other Columbia faculty.
Why? Be specific
Doing everything you want without any consequences?! What do these students think? Colleges are out of control
That’s literally what Israel is doing.
They know the consequences. Someone needs to speak for the women and children of Gaza.
@@Zarastro54 That's literally what Hamas is also doing, and what all Arab countries want to do, they all want to get rid of each other.
It's called free speech.
@@lochlannach7 No, Hamas launched its war expecting a response and no help. Israel routinely engages in war crimes and expects everyone to excuse them simply on the basis that “Hamas struck first.” Heck, THEY literally struck against Iran by illegally hitting a consulate building and killing one of their generals, then acted indignant when they shot back in response. If you are looking for entitled people who want to act with impunity, look no further than the Israeli government.
Apparently, these students have no concept of actions have consequences.
Haven't heard one of these virtue signalers speak about the genocides going on in China, Burma, Ethiopia or, Sudan...That makes me think this isn't really to do with Gaza/Palestinians , it's just a way for entitled kids to have something to scream about. and a way to express their true antisemitic feelings. It's a shame they don't do their homework to know the full history like who the true indigenous people of Judea(the true name of what they refer to as Palestine)are, or that Judaism is a millennium older than Islam, or that many very poor Jewish people in Europe pooled their money to buy back some of the land in Judea(that was stolen from them), or that the name Palestinian is barely over a hundred years old and describes an amalgamation of various Arabs that wanted a title for political purposes. That most other Arab countries don't allow Palestinians into their countries That Egypt also shares a walled border with Gaza.. And that Palestinian "refugees" have been on the dole from UNRWA for 80 years non-stop, even though many have Jordanian citizenship. They spew phrases without knowing the historical meaning, or geography they refer to. I just can't figure out how they got into university, really......
That's 100% true.
Crying like a 5 year old being put in time out.
Nobody has told them "no" enough times in their lives for them to grow up, so yeah, they have pretty much stayed as spoiled children who throw a tantrum and always get their way.
Free Americans from AIPAC
Spoken like someone who hates Jews. Sad to be filled with hate.
Free Palestine from Hamas
Free America from Hamas. We fly American flag, not Hamas flag.
They need to fire the president of Columbia University.
Never been told no before. When the one who occupied the building demanded food I thought "The revolution will be catered?"
Listening to this makes me realize why students are going to be homeless unemployed adults thanks to these teachers. Save your money, parents.
From the videos I've seen, I have to say the NYPD had every right to be there. The "protest" had descended into chaos, vandalism and lawlessness. Stop making excuses.
They were invited by the president of the University. It's private property and they need their permission to enter.
@@howardj602 What are you talking about? They took over private property, and barricaded themselves in. They broke windows and smashed doors. Even worse they have descended into a disgusting hateful mob that screamed about burning Columbia to the ground until their "demands" are met. This may have started as a legitimate cry for peace, but they aren't yelling for a return of the hostages, or a two state solution. They are calling for the final solution, as in, Hitlers final solution. They are calling for Israel to become Palestine from the river to the sea, as in goodbye Israel. Jewish students, who were identified by nothing more than a Star of David around their necks, (not carrying an Israeli flag), and they have been called k*(kes, spit on, harassed, blocked from movement by human chains, beaten with sticks and had their property stolen. It's nauseating and reminiscent of 1930's Germany. Stop gaslighting and acting like this is A okay with the administrators. It is not and that is why they called the cops.
I hope you understand what the cops have done for fueling the protesters.
They're peaceful protesters being harassed and arrested by NYPD for practicing freedom of speech. Those who stand up for these police are the lawless thrash.
@@al-bot1094 You should thank the outsiders, provocateur-types for that
Is this guy serious ? This tells you who is fuelling this or playing a role in it.
Kent State....May 4th, 1970....
No one was shot you pleeb.
@@danielberry698 Not yet...
This is not the only campus protesting...
BTW....no need for insults.
@@alfredgeorge3186 eh I think there is need for it. You disgust me.
The Kent State protest was because there had been thousands of Americans killed in Vietnam and the war was expanding into Cambodia. A stretch on your part.
That was the national guard, not the police, and nobody was shot here, other than that, it's a great analogy.
This is why “all protests MUST be off campus!” . .far away & televised!
Omg!!! Police establishing order!!! Definitely a reason to cry in despair!!! 😂😂😂😂😂
I lasted 1 minute 24 seconds
Play stupid games and win stupid prizes...FJB the Manchurian president
Strange to hear that an academic is suddenly concerned about repression at universities.
Especially so soon after the pandemic.
The professors are crazy. The school is a school and not a political setting. They should fire the professors.
Oh I'm sorry they broke in and were violent and broke into Hamilton Hall this guy is insane!
They had to find and enabler to interview 🙄
Is this man kiding me these kids were fighting the police.
"Crying in despair?" Welcome to the Generation S (Snowflake) in college. The kind of pseudo-adults who get a windburned cheek in a strong breeze then cry "trauma" and "PTSD"...
Says the keyboard warrior
@@cloudyshades8983 Gosh, that stung. I find myself crying in despair...
@@cloudyshades8983 Students crying in despair? Where is the ir bravery? These students are weak little snowflakes!
@@nursejoed you probably got bullied in school 😂. Nobody thinks you’re smart
The Universities are now full of brainless snowflakes. Their professors are tools as well.
This man is a whimp!!!
Good that you've let everyone know that you support genocide.
He’s on national tv risking his reputation. He’s got more b alls than you ever will.
@@afridgetoofar1818 Just cuz he goes on TV does NOT make him brave! Grow up!!!!
@@iluvmoney6767 THE POINT is what the man is saying. Is there any logic to be found in your insulting "adulthood"? Oh, you should know that multiple replies have been deleted from this page. What's your best guess as to why that is?
@@sharonmassey2923 Snowflakes are snowflakes.
Not protesters insurrectionists.
why no mention of that wife of a known terrorist?
Disgraceful reporting. Is this guy for real?
The disgraceful reporting has been MSNBC and CNN all along. If you only get your news from mainstream and not from non-corporatized independent journalists, you don't have the real story.
You get what you vote for, so why they crying. 😆
They are fighting for human rights not to be murdered by the helping hand of the country they live in ❤❤
Have you noticed, mostly women that couldn't even be picked up by the drunkest person in a bar so they have no life and this is it! And the guys are just as bad they probably haven't been laid their whole entire life! This is the only thing these people have to look forward to to make their life seem worth living.
Nom, they are fighting to vilify Israel and ignore actual genocides everywhere else. Ask yourself why.
Quit getting your news from Tik Tok and Facebook.
@@2stoves1 Israel provoked Hamas. Palestine has nothing to do with it, yet Israel is now ethnically cleansing them.
Keep in mind this administrator thinks of himself as a mature adult how crazy is that
Well at least he has a spine
An honorable man might add
I know that might sound like complicated lingo to you
@@MedoKen-xs6fv
You sound like an angry kid grow up son
This is a more balanced report than one earlier in the day. A teacher saying "Students were crying in despair" is not relevant to the issue at hand. These people (students and teachers) can afford to pay tuition at the school and/pr receive a fairly generous salary to be at in this instance Columbia. Despair is not a word to describe people who chose the actions they are taking. The people in actual despair are people in Gaza who are under threat of attack or the people in Israel who were targeted when the initial rockets entered Israel. If they really want to help, raise funds or get in kind donations which could be sent to people in Gaza. If they say that wouldn't work, have they really tried to improve the lives of others. Get on a bus to DC to protest in front of the Capitol or White House to have elected officials negotiate sending in aid. Or maybe contact some countries' missions at the UN to work on the issue to use their relations to accomplish their goals. Whether students are sad or teachers are in despair is irrelevant to the people of Gaza, Israel and Palestine who have had their personal safety effected by the actions of the leaders of their governments.
Occupying a library for students and not allowing other students to study in the library is completely unacceptable. These students should know the consequences lol
The protestors are at fault for the escalation. All protests should be off campus, at least 3 miles away!
No, the protesters are not at fault, but you wouldn't know that unless you get at least some of your news from non-corporatized independent journalists. Why should the protests be off campus? Is there a choice spot to protest genocide that's 3 miles away? Have you protested the genocide in any way, shape or form?
@@sharonmassey2923 the students are on a private campus and pay lots of money to have a safe place to study and attend classes. All protests should be off campus! Protestors have no right to disrupt this. They should protest off campus, at a public space.
@@AnnaMishel I posted this up top, and hopefully it's still there. Your thoughts on the reason? "It should also be noted that multiple replies have disappeared from this page. As only one example, the post below of jccarriere3719 had several replies, including one from me, and now there are none, although it says there's one reply."
college campuses are exactly where this type of protest should take place
A bunch off crybabies complaining
Gen z in a nutshell
@@ryblack5032yup
There would be more comments if some weren't censored.
I just posted this up top. Let's see if it sticks. "It should also be noted that several replies have disappeared from this page. As only one example, the post below of jccarriere3719 had several replies, including one from me, and now there are none, although it says there's one reply."
@@sharonmassey2923they’ve been using bots to spread false support and have been deleting comments that they don’t like for some time now. Social media platforms have just become another tool to shape the narrative.
Where were they when Israel got attacked?
EXACTLY!! FREE THE HOSTAGES!!
I heard that a lot of Germans cried when they surrendered at the end of WW2.
Crying in despair? Omg get over yourselves! Most US citizens are WAY over you.
Amen 🙏
Not really, the establishment was obviously really worried.
@@ayonibrahim9985 I shouldn’t have to say this but most US citizens are not a part of the establishment.
That professor is a joke. What they have achieved from all of this? The majority of Americans are against them!
"You're making us do this" - Columbia University and Hamas
Entitled brats…
Have you objected to genocide anywhere?
@@sharonmassey2923 There is no genocide, just propaganda from Hamas, and misinformation. Israel is doing everything by the book and correctly, keeping civilian deaths to an absolute minimum. And the only way the Palestinian people will ever be free from Hamas is if Israel destroys Hamas. Then there can be elections and an actual government that represents the people can lead a free Palestinian nation state. Too bad the Palestinians didn't do that back in 1947 when they were given land for a Palestinian nation state along side the state of Israel.
@@sharonmassey2923 have you objected to the genocide that Hamas is committing against Israel & Gaza?
Or Hamas theft of humanitarian aid that Israel sent to Gaza?
Or Hamas use of human shields?
@@debbyrabold6069 What ON EARTH are you talking about? That's the kind of non-sense I'd expect from a man. From Wikipedia: "As of 24 April 2024, over 35,000 people (34,262 Palestinian and 1,410 Israeli) have been reported as killed in the Israel-Hamas war, including 97 journalists (92 Palestinian, 2 Israeli and 3 Lebanese) and over 224 humanitarian aid workers, including 179 employees of UNRWA."
"The vast majority of casualties have been in the Gaza Strip: over 34,262 have been killed, 70% of them are women and minors." And "...with thousands remaining unaccounted for, including those trapped under rubble."
In addition to your bizarre arithmetic, there are horrendous atrocities and horrendous hardships that you apparently know nothing about because MSNBC et al haven't reported on it, or you just don't care, such as little kids having to endure limb amputations without anesthetic. If there are any more of the horrific events that genocidal Netanyahu is responsible for that you'd like to know about, let me know, or you could search for non-corporatized, independent journalists, such as Mehdi Hasan, who was fired by MSNBC for telling too much truth.
Here's a question for you to ponder that many people have pondered and come to a plausible conclusion about: Why did it take Netanyahu several hours before he took any action on October 7th, leaving "his people" to flounder in terror for hours, apparently receiving news of the attack from a slow-flying carrier pigeon? If you'd like to know what that conclusion is, again, let me know and I'd be happy to share it with you.
They broke in and destroyed private property? Their encampments are on private property.
The UAW was there??? Really??
If they don’t like the administration’s stand, then attend a different school - same with professors, go try and be employed at a new university.
Exactly.
Very one-sided view, with a vague reference to scared Jewish kids at the very end.
Their parents paying their tuition are also crying in despair! 90K went to waste if they get expelled.
They better not be wasting Federal financial aid dollars.
Well college certainly didn't help your critical thinking skills.
Weird response, he might be in some alternate reality
What is happening in Gaza is NOT genocide...Israel is attempting to eliminate Hamas, not the Palestinian people...This is a professor that does not understand what genocide is...
Get realistic. Annihilation of entire population , killing of children in an occupied territory is not targeting Hamas. By the way who funded Hamas in 2019- stop the propogonda. The students stand with human rights.
Can you explained about the killing in West bank that not where Hamas is.
@@carlleggett1379 Right after you explain why several Muslim states occupy Palestine, but you only have a problem with Jews living there?
Probabyly the only intelligent comment in here...
I wonder if this professor has ever heard about the Israeli Hostages held by the Savage Hamas Terrorists.
I bet you never heard of illegal occupation, illegal settlements, brutality that Izrahell guilty of for so many decades. Izrahell is apartheid state playing the victim card
Obviously not. If you swing at a boxer you have to expect to be KO'd in return!
@@myopinion8761
What? Translation, Please.
He has and does not care
@@tbird2006
So, great shame on him.
And on everyone who thinks like him.
My parents paid for a meal plan for me.
Faculty bored with their life?
Take over a building an expect no consequences? Really
I'm sick of these student protests.
We are sick of you
@@MedoKen-xs6fv Now, now. He has as much right to express his opinion as the students do.
my question is.. what this university, in particular, can do to stop the war in Gaza??
Send the student protesters to Gaza for a cultural exchange program so they can fight?
😂😂😂
@@NPK476I mean that to agree and laugh with you...not mocking what you said! 👍
Billions of dollars are invested in Israel from the hedge funds of the colleges.
Financially removing yourself from these investments make more pressure to curve ones actions.
Why do you think America sanctions and applies tariffs to its advertisers.
@@jtact5487Why do students think they get to dictate the financial investments of their university?
Well, the NYPD weren't even their for them. They were there for everybody
This is making Jan 6 look like NOTHING!!!!!
Once again msnbc with a far left radical reporting
The impact on Gazans really does break my heart. I don't know how it could NOT break the heart of any sentient being. But that doesn't seem to be what either the protests, OR the Hamas strategy is about. Has Hamas made a point of keeping their activities confined to areas where the populace would not simply become collateral damage? Does Hamas want any sort of peace that does not involve wiping Israel off the map? They haven't really given any signs of that. So exactly what is the point of these protests and disruptions? Is it merely to engage in symbolic punishment of Israel? Is it all performative?
I was in Israel in the 70s when Hamas locked Palestinian women and children in apartment buildings to make the body count higher. True story.
@@Lisa-pl6gv I won't deny the abominable behavior of some settlers, and the almost "manifest destiny" attitudes of some in the cabinet and the whole gush kattif nonsense. But Palestinians have been pawns in so many geopolitical games, including those played by their own supposed leadership, that they have been abused for several generations. Too many at the top want some sort of vindication MORE than they want peace and prosperity for the people they represent.
Funny how I don't see any of the protestors including Hamas in their protests.
Funny how it's only private videos which show this. The press is super careful to hide all this.
The admin needs to step down. Saying “we are calling the police to make sure that we have a normal graduation” is birdlike, trivial, and pathetic. I’m sure the student protestors also wanted to have a normal graduation. She should have done her job and listened to both sides to maintain peace.
Hey genius, if u want to have a normal graduation at ur school its probably not a good idea to trespass on its grounds, occupy it and vandalize it.
The students are crying in despair?
These are some of the most privileged people in all of human history. Get over it.
The professors should just quit.
It should also be noted that multiple replies have disappeared from this page. As only one example, the post below of jccarriere3719 had several replies, including one from me, and now there are none, although it says there's one reply.
Taking over a campus building. without permission Is trespassing! It is against the law! That is not a peaceful protest! Everybody needs to sit down and like adults and listen to what the other side has to say. This so-called peaceful protest is not helping in any way. it certainly not helping in Gaza or Israel. It is just making unnecessary trouble. Sitting down in a room and all sides laying out their concerns is a better way to find solutions to your problems.
No it's not. You're spreading false information.
@@MaddenFifaterrorist
@@Boyofwar how am I a terrorist
@@MaddenFifa😂 how is it false information you sound like a trump supporter
@@Boyofwar who you support are terrorists. Like the US and who they're funding. And they're attacking free speech bcs of their interests.
College executives don't care. The school year's over. Go home.
Free America and American government from AIPAC. Remove politicians who accept money from foreign nations . American for Americans
Actions have consequences.
So they were crying for cerelac in a war zone?
It's not a genocide Hamas killed many people this guy is insane
Why are they protesting at the University? What is the goal here?
To get the university to stop funds to Israel. Same with the US government. They're funding genocide.
They want the university to divest from any Israeli financial investments.
They don't know. It's just an excuse to be terrible people and not go to school or work.
Exactly, the students need to get on a plane to the mid-East and support the Palestinian cause THERE. Otherwise, their actions are just "hormonal nosies." Disrupting universities, maybe those who disagree with the protest uncomfortable or threatened Is not the most intelligent response. I was told by a university student that a poli-sci prof promised extra credit for the class he taught if students in his classes help organize or attend the protests. Here's the real shocker: 40% OF ALL FEDERALLY FUNDED SCHOLARSHIPS ARE AWARDED TO FOREIGN STUDENTS.. That needs to stop; they may be university students, but they are also, still, easily manipulated. Scholarships for foreign students come from the pocket books of hard-working Americans that trudge off to some pretty exhausting and demeaning work environments 5 days or more a week just to put a roof over their heads and food on the table. These students are insulting everyday working Americans. Students blocking traffic on major U.S. bridges was a step too far...I have No respect for them anymore.
@@rosemarieroth1984 International students are not eligible for federally funded scholarships. Who told you that?
Whether it's the Civil Rights Movement, the Vietnam War, South African Apartheid, the Iraq War or the current genocide of the Palestinians, it's fascinating how often students are at the forefront of all these historical events, what is later referred to as "the right side of history", while the media and political elites are on the wrong side of history, and yet here we are.
This channel is like fox news when it comes to our youth. Ppl who know better parroting their talking points like they are the moral highground. Amazing they published this at all.
University students after graduations will have hard times finding new jobs. One very important question to be asked in any interviews: "Did you participate in any protests?" Any protests made you look stupid not smart.
The Violence was horrific to watch my view the College Faculty & Police are to blame for the Violence.
1) College has failed in their duty to protect theirstudents. 2) The faculty that called Riot Police to hurt their students should BE FIRED! !!
College should be ashamed of their staff THEIR FAILURES
These spoiled entitled brats need to disperse immediately.
Who gave out UAW signs?
Exactly. I was beginning to think MSNBC was showing incorrect news footage.
Oh man this makes me laugh. Ohhhhhh noooooo i have to face repercussion for my actions!!! 😅😅😅
Of course they were crying. They are children. Infants really.
A professor that supports terrorism must be charged.
The business of universities is research and treaching, not hosting a bunch of chanting teenagers with an over inflated view of their importance.
Building occupation is criminal action. Hate speech is criminal action. Listening to their professors, helps you realize who failed these students.
Where is the hate speech?
@@afridgetoofar1818inform yourself. There are plenty of sources on the internet
@@juelasejdo1706 ok, pease share
Rats v. Roaches
Donors Over Freedom of Speech and Assembly
their voices have been heard for over 5 months now. not sure what they expect. free speech doesn't mean other people have to listen to you.
Exactly!!! Crying in despair because they aren't getting enough attention. 🤦
Amen 🙏
And most normal people do NOT want to see or hear it!!!!
Would the professor said it's garbage. Yes they've been having talks but unless the students get everything that they're demanding then they became violent. The university does not owe these students anything nor do they need to shift their fiscal and or financial responsibility or investments because a whole bunch of college students are protesting it. If they don't like it they can leave. They have the right to protest absolutely! But they must do it peacefully and recognized if the college decides not to give in to their demands then that is their answer. It's not against the law for a university not to meet their demands! What is illegal is occupying a space breaking Windows being violent and chanting anti-semitic and hate speech
EXACTLY
@@Lisa-pl6gv YEs !
This guy is the reason why this is going on....
As a journalist, I find your skewed coverage of this event incredibly disconcerting.
You must be new to the US media
It's MSNBC. The bottom of the barrel.
The professor made good points except you must condemn the destruction of private property. And let us not forget antisemitism.
Don't cry, poor babies. Your helicopter parents will save you from yourself once more.
This professor is acting like a giant baby crying for attention😅
That's what you're doing here.
rex84 that is the situation understand policy
This is what you get from go sit in time out instead of you go out there and cut me a switch and it had better be the right size .
Thankfully, the nannies were always on hand to deliver humanitarian aid to the naughty chair.
SLAUTER YOU ARE FULL OF IT !!!!
Reality bites.
end the occupation , stop the genocide
Why is there such a surge and flippant disregard for anti-semitism in the West these days?
Can anyone explain?
What is antisemitism for you? Criticizing Israel? What they are doing in Gaza? Have you read articles? Seen the images?
Because people like Frances get their news from Tik Tok and Facebook videos, and have absolutely no clue about the history and what is actually happening in Gaza.
@@francescomercanti7500
Apparently I can't reply to you with specific details. My comments keep getting deleted. I'll try again:
Specific slogans they chant regarding a river and a sea.
Many (if not all) pro-Pally protestors see nothing wrong with the events of October seventh.
@@francescomercanti7500
I'd love to tell you, but my replies keep getting deleted no matter how vanilla and objectively true they are.
Gotta love leftist censorship.
@@francescomercanti7500
MSNBC is really going nuts on censorship.
I literally can't reply to you.
Expel these students if they don't disperse.
Glad the police came to get the students out. Negotiations ? Please leave the US. This news channel is not Main Street America. They way off course.
It's a religious war.