Wall-E is the first movie that fully enraptured me, maybe because it was the first one I fully understood. Being so simple in its presentation and having no dialogue made it so easily relatable. While not the best movie ever made it is my personal favorite and the only one I will never tire of watching
this movie was one of the first actual movies ive ever watched ive watched it time and time again, (Will after this too) and i dont thing any other movie has ever made me feel the same since this one, i mean sure they all give me emotions, but this one made me realize what true love through hardship is. it was such an impactful movie for me and shaped a large part of my mind and the way i think
Great essay ! Wall-E is definitely one of my top 3 pixar movies, and top 15 favorite movies of all time. Incredibly well written and directed film about love, capitalism, ecology, and how to rediscover the lost and long forgotten humanism we all need to live, not to survive.
title is kinda confusing. dialouge-less animation has been around since the beginning of the artform. referring to a "rule of animation" when it really means "trend in modern children's movies" is misinformed, because there are very well defined set of rules for animation. they are usually referred to as the 12 Principles of Animation, but also informally as rules or guidelines. i was like, which rule does it break? when i was in school for animation, wall-e was held up as an great example of animation principles in action because of its lack of dialogue, not in spite of it. the sound design stuff and camera stuff is interesting, but there is no rule of animation against having no dialogue to tell a story and many of the rules of animation reinforce the opposite, to use animation to convey a story purely visually and through character body language. it is an interesting thing bc i get it's a title to grab attention, and that many ppl not into animation don't realize talking about animation rules or principles actually refers to a specific thing animators follow, not just a popular trend or to as a figure of speech. but i feel like a title can be eye catching without being confusing/misleading.
The title is misleading because it talks more about sound design than animation itself. I thought you were going to talk about animation principles, but I got a topic on how sound design is more elaborate in animated films. I don’t see how this has to do with breaking any animation rules. The title is clickbait and that’s not necessarily bad, but it’s pretty annoying.
Yeah; I find the bombastic tone of clickbait titles annoying by itself, but at least I expect to have the answer to the title by the end of the video, even if it was blown out of proportion or if it was just an excuse to introduce the real subject of the video just afterwards. I have watched this video in its entirety and I still don't know what's animation's biggest rule, let alone how Pixar apparently broke it
Since the Disney Renaissance, animated films were heavily reliant on sound, and probably singing, but in particular, by dialogue. It helps keep children, the primary audience, engaged. By removing that for the majority of the film, WALL-E breaks that "rule." It does successfully it through it's intensive sound design and the way it's shot. Like Andrew Stanton states "When you remove something as crucial as dialogue, the other elements have to fill in that hole."
@olutukko2681 Where I Grew up and all the videos I see, we sometimes refer to animated movies in general as "Animation", at least when talking about what makes them
amazing video but the title doesn’t quite describe the main topic of the video but it is a really good title algorithmically. Really good work tho made me remember how amazing Wall-E is
Thanks! and yeah, It's a tough balance. I don't want the video to be a "claim" as much as a celebration of what made it so unique. So what made the film great is that it went against convention "the rules" and had little dialogue, then the celebration is all the other elements that had to step up to make it work.
When I was a kid, I was always obsessed with figuring out how cel animation achieved those smooth textures. All I knew to exist at the time were crayons. That obsession got me chasing the medium of animation before I knew what it was called. I think lately, so many films of the genre have been so good and experimental that I can’t help but feel reinvigorated every time I go to the movies. Spiderverse has done a lot to influence the genre for the better. Your video has absolutely reminded me how beautiful Wall•E was.
this movie is actually amazing, i genuinely love it so much
How do are you so small?? your videos are incredibly fun and well made! keep it up I am sure you will grow in no time!
Wall-E is the first movie that fully enraptured me, maybe because it was the first one I fully understood. Being so simple in its presentation and having no dialogue made it so easily relatable. While not the best movie ever made it is my personal favorite and the only one I will never tire of watching
I love that description! When they took out the dialogue it really forced you to immerse yourself in the film.
this movie was one of the first actual movies ive ever watched ive watched it time and time again, (Will after this too) and i dont thing any other movie has ever made me feel the same since this one, i mean sure they all give me emotions, but this one made me realize what true love through hardship is. it was such an impactful movie for me and shaped a large part of my mind and the way i think
hit the algorithm good job bro
Fantastic video essay 👏🏼
Thank you so much!
hey man! your content is great and entertaining, really underrated! cant wait to see what you do in the future
Thank you so much! It's been a blast so far!
I’m so happy I clicked on this video. This is so thorough and good. It hits just right. Thank you!
Thank you! There's a huge serotonin hit that comes with celebrating films we love!
Great essay ! Wall-E is definitely one of my top 3 pixar movies, and top 15 favorite movies of all time. Incredibly well written and directed film about love, capitalism, ecology, and how to rediscover the lost and long forgotten humanism we all need to live, not to survive.
Beautifully said!
wow great video, thought you were a big channel since the production value was so good!!
Thank you! Comments like this give me so much motivation!
title is kinda confusing. dialouge-less animation has been around since the beginning of the artform. referring to a "rule of animation" when it really means "trend in modern children's movies" is misinformed, because there are very well defined set of rules for animation. they are usually referred to as the 12 Principles of Animation, but also informally as rules or guidelines. i was like, which rule does it break? when i was in school for animation, wall-e was held up as an great example of animation principles in action because of its lack of dialogue, not in spite of it.
the sound design stuff and camera stuff is interesting, but there is no rule of animation against having no dialogue to tell a story and many of the rules of animation reinforce the opposite, to use animation to convey a story purely visually and through character body language. it is an interesting thing bc i get it's a title to grab attention, and that many ppl not into animation don't realize talking about animation rules or principles actually refers to a specific thing animators follow, not just a popular trend or to as a figure of speech. but i feel like a title can be eye catching without being confusing/misleading.
wow nice yeah one of my favs lot of work behind it and the result was perfect
Every time I dig into the making of a film, I'm reminded of the immense talent it takes.
The title is misleading because it talks more about sound design than animation itself. I thought you were going to talk about animation principles, but I got a topic on how sound design is more elaborate in animated films. I don’t see how this has to do with breaking any animation rules. The title is clickbait and that’s not necessarily bad, but it’s pretty annoying.
Yeah; I find the bombastic tone of clickbait titles annoying by itself, but at least I expect to have the answer to the title by the end of the video, even if it was blown out of proportion or if it was just an excuse to introduce the real subject of the video just afterwards. I have watched this video in its entirety and I still don't know what's animation's biggest rule, let alone how Pixar apparently broke it
Since the Disney Renaissance, animated films were heavily reliant on sound, and probably singing, but in particular, by dialogue. It helps keep children, the primary audience, engaged. By removing that for the majority of the film, WALL-E breaks that "rule." It does successfully it through it's intensive sound design and the way it's shot. Like Andrew Stanton states "When you remove something as crucial as dialogue, the other elements have to fill in that hole."
@olutukko2681 sorry I was under the impression Wall-E was an animated movie.
@olutukko2681 Where I Grew up and all the videos I see, we sometimes refer to animated movies in general as "Animation", at least when talking about what makes them
@@cargentiusg5289 it is
amazing video but the title doesn’t quite describe the main topic of the video but it is a really good title algorithmically. Really good work tho made me remember how amazing Wall-E is
Thanks! and yeah, It's a tough balance. I don't want the video to be a "claim" as much as a celebration of what made it so unique. So what made the film great is that it went against convention "the rules" and had little dialogue, then the celebration is all the other elements that had to step up to make it work.
I've always loved all the real world object and devices in sound design - probably because it's so disjointed from the images on screen.
The laser noise Burtt got from simply stretching a slinky and hitting it is wild!
Wall-E pixars finest
Is there an animated film responsible for renewing your love of the medium?
a movie I always loved was Robots
When I was a kid, I was always obsessed with figuring out how cel animation achieved those smooth textures. All I knew to exist at the time were crayons. That obsession got me chasing the medium of animation before I knew what it was called.
I think lately, so many films of the genre have been so good and experimental that I can’t help but feel reinvigorated every time I go to the movies. Spiderverse has done a lot to influence the genre for the better.
Your video has absolutely reminded me how beautiful Wall•E was.
There’s two: Puss in Boots The Last Wish, Across the Spider Verse.
Definitely wall-e
animation isn't a genre
8:15 wdym they shot it with those lenses? isn’t everything computer generated? what were they pointing their lenses at? lol
They used calculations and software to create those lenses in the computer. They had to use the real lenses to get calculations and references!
Whos going to watch wallie after this?
it was ok