Vocal Coach & Songwriter First Time Reaction to Proof Live - BTS (방탄소년단) | 2 Year Anniversary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- ☕ Buy Us A Coffee: buymeacoffee.c...
🎙 The Vocal Gym (Online Course): throga.com
🐱 Shirley Jones Mug: throga.printif...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
DESCRIPTION
Join us for a live first-time reaction and analysis of Proof Live by BTS on the 2 year anniversary of it’s original release with Guinness World Record-breaking vocal coach, Richard Fink IV, and Billboard #1 songwriter, Johnny Cummings.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
ORIGINAL VIDEO
▶ Proof Live - www.youtube.co...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
JOHNNY CUMMINGS (INTRO/OUTRO)
iTunes - / johnny-cummings
Spotify - open.spotify.c...
#BTS #BTS_proof #reaction #vocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts #thronly
I would like to mention that it was Jin who wanted to give the hugs. And the company wanted it to be just 50, but Jin "fought" for it to be more.
yes Jin originally wanted to hold the event outside and give a hug for anyone who showed up😭 he insisted on it for a month despite the company refusing for obvious safety concerns until they compromised with an indoor event with selected number of fans. They suggested 50 winners only for Jin to ask for 3,000. Then they said 300 to his 2000, and finally 500 to his 1000 which they ended up settling on 1000. The whole thing was his idea and he even asked that we don't hold it as a standard to the other members when they return lol
E foi o Jin que disse que poderia haver telemóveis no recinto. Ele queria que todas as armys vissem estes momentos. Obviamente, que ele sabia que não seriam apenas fotos que seriam tiradas.
@@foreverinsfiredJin always gets his own way. He may seem mild mannered but he sticks to his guns.
Jin was a bit disappointed the hug session ended so fast he said he could have hugged a thousand more or he he could have spent a few more seconds with each person
I absolutely love Jin. I feel lighter of heart now he is back 💜
Your eyes tell, film out, Christal Snow, blue and gray 💜💜💜💜💜💜
Up pleasee
Yes please react to this songs ❤ and i always love ur reactions btw 😊
Yes!!!!! Plissss....
All great songs!
The song yet to come was their final group video song before their military enlistment. The video is so memorable they've basically recreated all of their iconic scenes from other song.
I think the final group song before their enlistment is TAKE TWO
@@mimirasidi1144 I said final group MV. As in official music video.
@@mimirasidi1144I was going to say that too. Abby, don’t get defensive
Yes final Mv is Yet to Come. Others are digital singles like The Planet, Run BTS n Take Two.
I get what you mean about Jimin's tone. Each vocal line member is a fantastic singer, and between the 4, no two sounds the same. That being said, Jimin's voice really cuts through the mix when they sing collectively. It is usually very easy to hear and identify his vocals. I liked the way you described them as shimmery (JM), warm (JK), crooney (V), and intense (?; Jin). I think Jin has a very pop rock feel to his voice.
Thanks for the super fun hangout earlier, Richard and Johnny! For Wednesday, I think you'll love their vocals in their MTV Unplugged performances. They covered Coldplay's "Fix You", and also did 4 of their songs -- Telepathy, Blue & Gray, Life Goes On, and Dynamite (all in the BE album). The vocals are SUPERB!! In addition, you don't want to miss Jimin's "Letter" (a hidden track in his album Face; dedicated to ARMYs; live performance available in BangtanTV); as well as Jungkook's cover of Oasis' "Let There Be Love" (live at the Live Lounge BBC Radio 1). See you Throga fam!!
Super recommendations! I know that BTS caught some ridiculous flack for covering "Fix You" but their rendition (I think) is stunning. The day it dropped I had it on a loop for about four hours 😊
"Wing"album is the masterpiece
‘Dad’s here!’ Took me out 🤣🤣🤣
Jin commpleted his service yesterday and the other members took leave to be there to congratulate him. RM even played Dynamite on his sax.
RM’s new album. I recommend listening to the whole album including all the music videos. The album is again a masterpiece.
“Truth Untold” one of my faves. Please hear vocal lines “For Youth” and “House of Cards” just Amazing, they kill it! 🤷🏻♀️ You guys will love these, they are similar to “Truth Untold” these I mention you can really hear the individual vocals of each member. “Zero O’Clock” is another from the vocal line. House of Cards live, the best, Thanks guys 💜
I've mentioned it before with another account, but here are my recommendations.
1) I think the songs from the album "Wings" are absolutely phenomenal. The vibe is also different from the stuff you've seen so far, so it'll be a fun change of pace.
My favs are "First love", "Stigma", "Lie", "Boy meets Evil" "MAMA" and "Blood Sweat and Tears" (so like... nearly the whole album lol) Each song has a short teaser video, where the members can show off their acting skills! The wings album was also one of their most influential albums and it really helped them skyrocket in 2016.
2) I heard y'all like Sugas vocal tone, so I also recommend seeing some of his live performances from his D-Day tour. They are incredibly emotionally powerful. especially his performances of Snooze, The Last, and Dear my Friend. I heard you guys like more grunge or rock-vibe, which he delivered amazingly.
I heard some people in the chat recommend hobipalooza which is also great! Hobis got a great funky style, and the energy was amazing.
Ps. If you do pick "dear my friend" I recommend getting someone to help with a little research/backstory. The song is extremely personal to him, it's about yoongis relationship with his old friend.
Great recommendation! Wings album is the first one with solo songs/stories from members. Here is why it makes sense to listen to it around their anniversary
J-Hope in Lollapalooza slayed. Suga jn D-Day tour slayed. 💜💜💜
Actually...the day Jin was disharged from military was our country's independence day😅 so it was very fitting for Filo-ARMYs🇵🇭🇵🇭💜💜
Yahoo, Mabuhay! 🇵🇭💜
WWH has come home!! I think this 2 concerts have been the best in decades: D Day from Suga and Hobipalooza from J Hope. Then, last BTS concerts from LA and Las Vegas are spectacular. And PROOF live is the coolest ever. Listening singing live in an environment without Armys screams, hahaha and without them dancing like crazy really let us hear their amazing vocals to the fullest. They look slick as hell.
Yep! 💜🫰
Your Eyes Tell - one of their Japanese songs. A soundtrack for Japanese movie. It is particularly challenging to sing and one of their best live performances.
It has to be in my top 5 BTS songs I think.
my fAV!
I always cry at the end of For youth, and Jimin's voice... I have no words....I just love it💜
Angelic 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Talking about their relationship Jin just got out of the military and all the members took a day off to see him exit and they were able to get a photo of all 7 together …they were hugging each other they were so happy to be together
It's so beautiful to see all the hugs 💜
Crystal Snow (Jin's triple high note on this song) and other BTS Japanese songs 💜🥳🎶
Saying Yet To Come is a happy song when I couldn't listen to it for 2 months without crying and it still pinches my heart a little even 2 years later 🥲🥲🥲
I guess it's just a super nolstagic song for many ARMY !
Sim, também não considero Yet To Come uma canção alegre, por causa disso.😅
they still baby army. They don't get it. It's ok. Hugs.
Thank you for showing appreciation for V’s vocals. I feel like sometimes people just see him as a pretty face and not the true vocalist he is 💜 He has a great tone that can change depending on what’s needed for the song and even with fewer lines sometimes, he leaves an impact on the song with the parts he is given 😊
Every member really adds a certain character to the songs and it would not be the same if one was missing. I also agree on Jimin’s voice that we can only describe as a shimmer. It stands out so well and it gives trademark to their songs. No one sounds like him 😂
And I believe John’s bias is Jin.
I think Johnny has several (maybe seven) biases lol. I remember him listening to "Filter" for the songwriting, but instead has Richard stop the video so he can say "I think Jimin is also Worldwide Handsome" Haha!
At 51:05, Johnny asked if V is Johnny’s bias, I thought he meant John Reaves 😄
Since he a songwriter, I can totally see him liking Jimin and his voice. I also love how they acknowledge how good and point out the strengths of each member.
John Reeves bias is Jin. I think Johnny bias is all 4 vocalists since he appreciates the special qualities of each one. My guess would be Jin or V.
This performance of For Youth is my favorite, Jimin voice is really shimmer 😊
They are so interesting because of all 7 have different talents and styles yet blend so perfectly luv everything abut bts. Plus the love for us old and young. Not a mean bone in their beautiful bodies❤💜💜💜💜💜💜luv to hear you appreciate them thanks😮❤
Would love to see a focus on their Japanese songs. Crystal Snow, Your EyesTell, Film Out, Don't Leave Me, Let Go, Stay Gold, Lights, maybe the Japanese MV for Airplane Pt.2.
Yeah, their high notes here are crazy 💜
Airplane pt. 2 is so good
YES!!!!!!!!!
The live versions of these songs are some of my favorites ❤
Their Japanese songs are always so good. Even the older ones
Pied Piper, House of Cards, Film out, Stay gold, Magic Shop.
Yes, if you want to see the whole vocal lines full falsetto’s (even “V”) for most of the song, watch “Pied Piper) one of Army’s favorite, it’s usually played with “Dimple” right before it at same concert. Most reviewers do them together, Dimple first, followed by Pied Piper 💜
THIS!!!
Yet to Come was mostly written by Max. BTS worked on the Korean lyrics and probably handled the production. This was Max’s first #1 song on Billboard. 💜
Who is max?
@@frofro7134 Max is an American pop singer/songwriter. He featured on AgustD’s song Burn It.
Unfortunately, I was working. I was so happy to see this. Yay! our Jin is back!
true with what you said about jimin´s voice. i have always decribed it as a female tone with a base sound ontop of it. when he was younger the base tone was less so it sounded more like a teenage boy when the voice shift between boy and man.
someone also decreibs his voice as robotic in a beautiful way and baby like. idk there is no right way to decribe it. he has the most interesting and beautiful tones i have heard. it´s not always about how well you sing if your tone is horrible.
방탄 라이브, 보는 사람도 편안하게 해주죠 ㅎㅎ 먼저 본인들이 편안하고 즐기고있으니까요
they want to grow old together.Hello Throga and Vocal Gym, they are not just friends they call themselves family and even brothers. I guess when you live together for over 7 years you get to respect and love one another.Even now they all brought homes and live in the same building or 5 to 10 minutes from each other. They are brothers for life.
Remember Jin saying in an interview that he doesn't have any friends and immediately all the members start scolding him, and Jin saying "no I'm sorry, you're FAMILY I'm sorry! " lol so sweet. But they are. All brothers. ❤
The first song was Born Sinner and the made it to Born Singer and put in there own lyrics
When this was shown I wondered why they didn’t do, Run BTS, which I was loving so much and then the Busan concert happened in the October and we found out that they were saving it to knock our socks off on stage. Born Singer, is a reworking of J. Cole’s, Born Sinner. They sang it very early in their career and the performances are always emotionally charged. I don’t know if they couldn’t get permission from J. Cole to release it but eventually it came out officially on Proof. J.Cole is J-Hope’s hero. The words have changed a bit over the years. Anderson Paak is of Korean heritage and his ex-wife was Korean so he speaks a little Korean. They recorded this while they were performing in Vegas.
33:58 Some things I think have made them be able to get along so well is the fact that they always, from the start, been free to do solo work is a big win for BTS.
They have been able to compromise and make music together but then release their own stuff to where they have full creative freedom and can speak just for themselves and not for the whole group and I think that is really good.
Another thing I think helps to keep their friendship is that they always seen each other as a team and utilized and admired each others strengths and individuality.
They have also evolved with time, they have changed, the music have changed, they never put themselves in a box. I think that is important, we change with time and express ourselves different in different stages of our lives so the way we are and express ourselves through music or other ways change too.
They also since the beginning have through their music and as a group read and explored about the human psyche, what is important, mental health, self love etc etc so they have been self aware and been able to talk among themselves and written very personal lyrics so they have formed a real bond.
They also lived together in dorms for a long time.
Bang PD also since the beginning made it a rule that if they fought even if it was just between 2 they would come together all 7 and resolve it.
And they also just are very good people that instead of competing they admire and lift each other up like you do with family.
one of my favourite performances of all time, thanks for the great reaction ❤🎉
I really love your reactions. You are a good mix of chilled fun and really interesting vocal and composition information, and make me laugh too. As Jimin said "You nice keep going".
Thank you so much for your reaction💜💜💜
"Hey Mom!" was so wholesome ❤😂
With June being FESTA MONTH this is most appropriate to react to!!!
Jin’s comeback live show pls.
Welcome back Johnny. You both are my favorite reaction channel, i think mainly because you enjoy each other's company, sincere and good human. Plus you are funny cause you dont take yourselves too seriously, similar to Bangtan ❤
Agree with all this. They're great together & to watch. Love their reaction style & content.🙂👍🏻
omg sooo many things i'd love to see you react to! maybe magic shop, or some of the japanese songs? or more songs from BE
BTS Blue & Grey. Your Eyes Tell (it's a japanese song)
Jimin can use a bit of vibrato, in his mix or chest. it's a cool vibrato . Kind of like Shakira's vibrato but more subtle.
Yet to come was written by the Rap line and Pdog was the producer.
Also, I think of Best to Come as a bittersweet song, not just a bop…which may explain why Richard liked it even though he doesn’t typically like happy songs.
You are right.. V is a chameleon !
Both vocally and visually ! 💜😅
He blends so well with everyone and anyone it's fascinating, he balances their energy out too ....no wonder he became my bias very fast even when he never caught my eye until my 28290th intro vid as a baby Army. You have to get to know him first n then BAM you're in love 😂✨
When you did MMA 2019, Richard asked about one of the tracks that played during each member’s feature. Would love to see you guys watch the live of that song: “Fire”. Maybe do Full Live Performance MAMA 2016. That performance also includes another iconic song of theirs “Blood Sweat & Tears”. It also has a mashup of "Lie" & "Boy Meets Evil" as intro. They have so many songs I personally love. I’ll try not to be greedy so I’ll request just that one… for now😆
regarding the kissing: no, she DID kiss him on the neck and it baffles me that people downplay it. it's technically assault.
she was among the chosen to get a hug, not to take advantage of it and just do whatever she wants... he's a human being.
just cause he chose to hug armys doesn't mean he automatically gave his consent to whatever else they are up to.
consent doesn't only matter if it's women.
I still can't listen to "Yet to Come" without tearing up, so your commentary on it made me laugh 😂
I really enjoy your reaction to BTS's song.. So I think you should check BTS japanesse songs :
- Your Eyes Tell
- Crystal Snow
- Film Out
- Let Go
- Stay Gold
- Don't Leave Me
It should be the LIVE version, Jin's high note in Crystal Snow just.. WOW!
The fantastic thing with BTS is 10-11 years in, and they are still making rich, catchy and hook-filled music. 💜💜💜 I'm sure you agree
First time seeing this intro - LOVE IT!! I probably watched Proof live for like 10x because been mising them, Soulful Tae is such a vibe. Have you reacted on Fri(ends) ? V did some really cool adlibs that we haven't heard before! If not - please check it out!
i'd like to recommend rm's new album!! it's so so soooooo good
I love that you commented on this Proof Live video! When this video came out I was still a baby ARMY. I am a 2 year old ARMY! I love all your BTS reactions.
Also it's okay that you weren't there from the beginning. Yoongi said that the day you met us is the day we debuted for you. 💜
I love going on you with this journey inside the Magic Shop, or what they call the TH-cam rabbit hole. Borahae! 💜
I'm still surprised that no one besides me has asked for a reaction for IU's "LOVE WINS ALL" with a special appearance by V... I think I've suggested it since January, now that she's going to do shows in the US I might be able to do it. It could be together with "FRI(END)S" and "WHEREVER U R" which were also not made, I think, just on this channel. What a shame!!! And the better, the mv's no block!!!😉😉😉
Suggestions:
Agust D - First Love
Agust D - Set me free
V - Stigma
Jimin - Letter (Dear Army)
BTS - Louder than bombs
BTS - Airplain Pt. 2 (Japanese MV)
BTS - Young Forever
BTS - Blue and Gray
Thank you 💜
Love JK's voice for me he's a chameleon and he can sing all kind of music genre .
Yes😊
J hope first part of Lollapooluza concert was in my opinion amazing - Like you guys I was never a fan of Rap, but this guys change that, from Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple, Pink Floyd to/and BTS!😉
Guys, thank you so much for this reaction. I knew you'd enjoy Proof Live. Other suggested songs.....Blue & Grey, Your Eyes Tell, Film Out ( CDTV live), The Truth Untold, Heartbeat, So What, ( concert version for the energy!), Stay Alive & Dionysus (live.)
Please watch Stigma by V. If you wanna hear his super high notes! Johnny will love it!
48:59 Yes yes yes! It genuinely feels like I am being personally serenaded. It’s a very unique feeling.
Love this BTS is great
Film out by bts is a Japanese song
I really love this Proof live session. They sound amazing! Glad you are watching it. Just FYI Anderson Paak’s tiny desk is pretty cool example of a multi-talented drummer doing a live set.
Thanks for mentioning this. I'll check it out.👍🏻 A growing Annderson Paak fan here. Have you heard the song he has out currently with Fred Again? It's called Places to be. I can recommend the mv recorded in Eagle Rock in April this year of the two of them jamming this song. It's really good!
Jimin’s shimmer, love that description! His tone is so beautiful and unique! 💕
I would like to recommend:
Film Out (live at Music Blood)
Your Eyes Tell
Stay Gold
Letter by Jimin (Festa 2023 live performance)
Neuron by JHope
Any of the new tracks from RMs new album Right Place, Wrong Person
Thank you for the reaction, guys! My recommendations for next Wednesday:
💜 RM's Change Pt. 2, Still Life, Closer (Indigo album)
💜 Your Eyes Tell live
💜 Truth Untold live (vocal line) stage mix video is the best
💜 RM's Come Back To Me, Domodachi (Right Place Wrong Person album)
💜 solo songs from Wings album, especially Lie, Stigma, First Love, Reflection
💜 JK's performance on NY Times Square
💜 V's Sweet Night
If you think Namjoon, you should really listen to "Groin" from the new album "Right Place, Wrong Person". 🤓 Or "Nuts"... 👀
Nuts! 🎉
I love your intro theme song. Your reactions are priceless. Keep giving us you. Thanks again❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉
Johnny's dog is adorable
Jhope returns in October.!Only 4 months left! And the rest next June!💜🫶🏼
Já devia estar cá!
JHOPE en LOLLAPALOZA fue muy intenso, espectacular ...STIGMA de V una cancion tan espectacular de principio a fin, STILL LIFE de RM exquisita,... NEVERMIND de SUGA,...MOON de JIN,... HATE YOU de JUNGKOOK,...LIE de JIMMIN. LOUDER THAN BOMBS,.. BLUE AND GREY, SECOND GRADE CYPHER 1, 2, 3, 4... DDAENG...
Wings album is great and musically versatile. Also, the first album with solo songs/stories from members. Here is why it makes sense to listen to it around their anniversary. Dark, rich, and interesting.
here are some songs that I could think of from different eras and with different genres:
come back to me by RM
house of cards
your eyes tell
look here
pied piper
home
maybe solo stuff or live shows? 😁 its so hard to choose, but I'll be waiting for Reaction Wednesday and Filipino Fridays🥂
This was so much fine! Loved it. Suggestions for future reactions: Jimin's hidden track "Letter", Jin's song "Yours," "Film Out," "Your Eyes Tell," "Blue and Gray," their cover songs, etc.
New songs of Rm, Jhope, V and Jungkook. Thank you ❤
Gracias por la reacción. Otra recomendación sería The Truth Untold en vivo. Es una canción que solo participa la línea vocal.
I was going to recommend this too. I've come to love it a lot over my 4 years of being an army.🙂💜
Ohh, I've also been part of the fandom for 4 years now...
Yes, it really is a great song and it would be great if you could react to it.
Love hearing you discuss and describe their voices. Also cracked up when you said "She-who-must-not-be-named" and Johnny immediately started playing (beautifully) Harry Potter theme!
It's hard to stay away from a program that makes you laugh 😅
Thank you for doing this guys!!! Love our lovely boys 💜✌️
I think shimmer is the perfect way to describe Jimin's voice quality. ✨
Johnny you are so sweet and kind. You really are WWH part 2. 😊
ugh this never gets old 🥰
Thank you, i feel better now😅❤
How the hug event came to be was so funny because BigHit did NOT want him to do it, but Jin insisted :D
Jin fought for it until BigHit said "okay, but only 50 armys" and Jin said "No. we will be outside at a park and everyone will get hugs" but BigHit really wanted it to be inside and only 50 people. They went back and forth months until Jin said "Ok we can be inside, but I want to hug 3000 armys", Bighit said he should think of his health and body and insisted on the 50 armys and Jin negotiated that to 1000 armys.
Born Singer is based on J. Cole’s (fantastic American rapper, j-hope’s idol, and collaborator on “on the street (with J. Cole)) Born Sinner. J. Cole’s original is about doing better and BTS’s version is about their hard times after debuting. I love that they did this song so early on; I think they released it on SoundCloud pretty soon after J. Cole had released his album. I also LOVE this live performance. The combination of their live vocals, the band, and the BACKGROUND SINGERS makes me so happy every time I watch this. It never gets old. And, yes, Anderson .Paak paired with Bruno Mars to form Silk Sonic. (Not the Bruno Mars band.) He, like Bruno, also put out some incredible music prior to that as a solo artist.
Hi guys again! Missing you and your bts reactions for so long! Happy to be here! Can’t wait for the next Wednesday bts reaction ! Borahae! 💜💜💜🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽💜💜💜
Hearing about Yet To Come that it's a happy song when I cried all the tears in my body when it got released😂 but I agree there's something uplifting and hopeful, but that was devastating to me😂
The face of Anderson Paak on the drums really enjoying himself.
Collaboration songs and cover songs would be nice. For example, they covered Fix You by Coldplay and they collaborated with Coldplay with the song My Universe. There is also a documentary on their process of doing/recording My Universe with Chris Martin coming to Seoul to record/direct the recording. It would be nice for you to see how they come about and the process of them making My Universe.
They all lived together right up till this year 2022 so lived together for 12/13 years they always say they are family they love each other so much!!
Not really accurate. They kept the group house until then, when the lease ran out. All of them had their own homes for quite a while. At least since 2020, if not before.
@@LisaMT1218 yes. Jin bought a separate apartment from the group dorm at Hannam the Hill in 2018, I believe. He gave that one to his parents in 2020 and bought himself another unit in the same complex. I think V acquired his Apelbaum apartment in 2019, the same year that Yoongi bought into UN Village.
Life Goes on
Anderson pak is 1/2 Korean also married to a Korean
He is currently on a song in the UK charts with Fred Again. It's cslled Places to be.He's great drumming & singing on that. Pretty charismatic. There's a mv of him & Fred again just basically jamming the song with a lot of energy & fun. Recorded in April at Eagle Rock.
Thanks for this, guys ❤
I would love to hear you react to the solo songs on the Wings album. Boy Meets Evil (jhope) Begin (Jungkook) Lie (Jimin) Reflection (RM) First Love (SUGA) Awake (Jin) and Stigma (V).
Would love to see you guys watch their cover of Fix You
Yall are so funny I loved the reaction!!
I think i get what you mean about not liking "happy music" because i'm kind of the same way. It's like most pop songs....i don't really like it. It's just upbeat happy music, but there's no substance in the music or lyrics, so it feels unauthentic. Just fake happiness, like those hosts in kids shows that's always smiley but you know they're miserable. which is what i expected from BTS as well. But then i realized their lyrics had a deeper meaning to it, and it made the music much more enjoyable because it's more relatable and actually had a message. Which makes the "happy" part of it make sense and feel more authentic. All their songs are part of their story and their journey. Even the 3 english songs that i didn't like at first, i like now, because i understand where they came from and the reason for their existence.
Love you guys! 💜🥰
I.m going to need to see a photo of Richard with hair to believe he has not always been hair challenged.🤣🤣🤣🤣
I've seen it!! It exists!
This is hands down one of my favorite live performances! You are right about RM having a tone of conviction. Hadn't thought of it in those terms but makes perfect sense. Looking forward to more live performance reactions 😊
Pied Pipper, Let Go, Rap line: Autro Tear, Cypher 3
Pls react to japaneses songs by BTS, They are the best! I swear