Anything that is created or has a beginning must be under the influence of time. According to science time is a phenomena that exists only in the universe. Anything outside this universe does not fall under the influence of time. Since the Creator is outside of his creation(universe), time cannot affect him. Therefore He is eternal and uncreated. He is Allah/God.
no brother, space and time are logical concepts, how they affect a being is what changes (related to physic laws), when scientists say that time has a beginning they're talking about the local time of our universe, because we cannot know what was before it because our universe didn't exist, but in general time and space are absolute, like laws of logic (non-contradiction, causality...), they're what defines existence, abscence of space and time is basically non-existence, a being requires space to exist and an event require time to happen, God tell us clearly in the quran that the 7 heavens are one on top of the other and above them the throne as their ceiling (probably like the layers of an onion), and God is above them, we don't say God is spaceless and timeless, that's an innovation, rather we say God is infinite in space and in time (eternal), just think about the creation of the world, at some point it didn't exist, then it became existent, moving from the state of non-existence to existence is an event and it requires time, and that event is initiated by God, he's the creator, the doer of this event..
@@IslamicAwareness27 All I am saying is that God is eternal and since he created time and space, this doesn't affect Him the way it affects us. He knows what happens in the past, present and future. So He basically controls time and also created the laws of physics. If He was under the influence of time then He would also have a beginning and a creation. And I think time in God's realm is totally different than the time in our world if it exists
Real answer is... Our human brain doesn't have enough capacity to understand about god.. that's why Quran gives so many evidences to believe the Creator... Here our job is... Following only commands of God.. it's impossible to imagine heaven & hell as well as God.. For example: we can't teach University degree programs to grade one school students... Like wise we can't imagine the God by our brain.. but we can prove existence of God...
@@AimanAlnnfan imagination means.. we can't discover or explore or research on Allah... we can explore his creations only... in this way, we accept him as our creator..
Mohamed created Allah in his mind to cheat humanity. When he wanted to do paedophilic deeds he used god's concept to defend himself by telling that was done as per god's order to make that valid.. if he hadn't done so people had thought him different way..
@@mrathiest9522 and your saints created fake 330 million gods to cheat everyone. Now thats too much, isnt it? Gosh.. it will take 2 centuries to learn those names, how do you guys do it? Obviously, by watching the stupid ramayan and mahabharat. Hahahahaha
@@mrathiest9522 i have encountered many fools like you, who just did 1 percent research and think that they are the new scholars lolol. Now im being serious, before blaming others religion, do some research. Dont listen to media as they are full of lies. May Allah show you the right path.
@@haroonkapoor8233 the question surely needs more clarifying and i have the full answer to why god doesnt need a creator. if youre interested in it brother reply to me and say so so i can explain it to you
If you go to discover the creation of Almighty Allah, you will become more knowledgeable. But if you go to discover Allah you will become Atheist. Cause Almighty Allah didn't give us the capacity to think of him.
When a Muslim is asked this question, and their only answer is *"Allah has no creator just because.... (nothing)"* A response like that would falsely prove the Atheist's point, resulting in a False positive, thus making the Muslim lose the argument in the Atheist's mind. I know how to respond to this question, and it involves analysing the underlying nature of the question itself. But let's Analyse the question that comes before it: When the Atheist asks *"Who created the universe?"* They're only thinking of the materialistic portion; Planets, Stars, Galaxies, etc. The Atheist's mind is programmed to not include Time or Physical Laws, since they have no material form. Their brain is programmed to believe that Time & Physical laws are eternal & uncreated, which is where the seperation comes from. This is a Conceptual trap the Atheist subconsciously lures the Muslim into. And it usually works if the Muslim isn't a person who contemplates the nature of the Universe. Onto the Actual Question; When the Atheist asks *"Who created God/Allah?"* The Atheist subconsciously believes that Time & Physical laws are uncreated things. What the Atheist DOESN'T know is that the very nature of Time itself and the Laws of Physics are creations of Allah. If the Muslim doesn't know this, they've already lost the argument. To properly respond to this question, one must inform the Atheist of what they're doing wrong as they ask it; Here's what I would say: _"No, see; What YOU'RE doing is you're subconsiously thinking of time as an eternal entity that is independant of the universe, as well as the Laws of Physics. What you don't realise is that Allah/God is the creator of Time itself and the Laws of Physics. And Allah/God cannot by bound by anything he creates, otherwise he wouldn't be Allah/God. So when you asked me _*_"Who created God/Allah?"_*_ , You are subconsciously implying that time existed before Allah/God. Which doesn't make sense because only Allah/God is eternal, whereas Time is not. What you need to realise is that since Time and the Laws of Physics are created by Allah/God, then it is Allah/God that controls them, not the other way around._ _So let's go back your Question; _*_"Who created Allah/God?"_*_ Nobody, because Nothing can come "before" the one who created the very nature of Time itself. He is Eternal and fully self-sufficient and independant of anything that we can understand."_
That is the big bang argument. At least with the big bang there are some consequences you can observe: the universe. Unfortunately, it's not the case of god who does not show up and whose existence cannot be proved, same for the prayers or actions of god. So you cannot live disregarding god, and if god wants something from the humans, he sould be communicating clearly to everybody.
I had this question in my since I was a child. Never bothered to look this up, but all the time I used to have confusions, curiosity. Now from this video and from the respectable comments I am satisfied with the answer.
@@mashable8759 Question is illogical again. The universe doesnt create anything according to science, its a whole concotion of things according in a single point which explodes, leading to formation of galaxies, stars. Science wholeheartedly believes this is just a formation not creation. Point is how can all of those things just happen out of nowhere? But an uncreated God who can create a universe with life and a certain time frame for it to end makes more sense. We cant throw a bunch of wood into the water and expect a boat to form.
@@strawhatmucci7086 anything with a non zero probability will occur in infinite amount of time. If you threw wood into water and gave it infinite amount of time, then yes it will form a boat.
I saw this answer some time ago and it was really logical: This is an example you can give them as an answer: " The wall is blue, who painted the wall? The Painter. So who painted The Painter? " This example can be used as an easy, understandable answer to that question.
Arshia Ghanbarian that doesn’t really make sense tho you should of said something like look at the sun and you would say ouch I can’t that would hurt my eyes then say and the sun is a creation so how could you see the creator then
A *painter* paints the *painting* 🖼, but if you ask who *painted* the *painter?+, no one because *painter* is not a *painting*. **_similarly Allah is a *creator_*_ not _*_creation_*
The answer to the atheist is Allah did tell us in surah Al Ikhlas; in verse no 3 and 4. Lam yalid walamyulad, walam yakullahu kufuan ahad. Means.... He begetteth not, nor is He begotten. And there is none like unto him.
I asked myself same question if God wasnt created by anyone, then it could be that particles came together and so God came out of nowhere... Well I was going a bit crazy at that time when I made this theorom, and later heard wispering saying God killed his mother I understanded, well it could mean God stopped anything that could make a new him out of nowhere.... those days were crazy I even saw 2 birds come through my frontdoors window when you cant even open it... also I saw these holograms drawing things, and even I was asked by wispering to negotiate with sahitan... I kept on writing on a paper I lay it down go away come back and everything was gone that I have written on the paper, till I wrote something like who is your master then that was not removed anymore.... probably because I knew there is only one supreme God and that is allah the most beloved... In those days i hid my laptop and f couldnt find it for a while because I saw this orange color coming on outer of my display and thought they would hack it completely as I was losing files etc... so I hid and for a few days without laptop but got alot of things for me, till I found it again.. well those things dont happen anymore so all is good lol.. my family were away on those days though, so i was alone... and also couldnt record it because my mobile phones battery couldnt fit in my mobile phone anymore.... crazy but a voice told me pray the fard salat on laylatal qadr so God accepts you as one who perfilled his prayer duties, as I was not praying those days... I did but still pray the fard though these days, wasnt doing that those days.....
There is also an alternate to this Answer work hard and do good deeds follow GOD's command and once you pass the test and reach Jannah than ask ALLAH this Question yourself.
@@bhaswanthgudimella344 Surah Ikhlas: Allah is one and has no partners with him, he is alone, he is the Eternal refuge, he was not created and not born, there is no one like him and equivalent to him. Allah is only one.
No one created him He is one n only Allah... He is the first He is the last He is the most high... Ni one can see him He is the Allah one n only Eternal refuge Neither begotten nor is born N none is comparable to him. the definition of God is who is uncreated No one created him That is Allah
Esselamu aleykum, here is the answer ---) Science has proven that everything came with the Big Bang (space, TIME, matter). This is proven and even mentioned in a Quran Ayah. If someone asks for example -) Before you was your father and before that your grandfather and before that your great-grandfather etc. up to Adam (as). Before that, Allah created the Jinn. Before that, ALLAH created the angels, etc. up to ALLAH (swt). If someone then asks ---) What was "before" ALLAH, makes no logical sense, because "before" is a "time indication" and "time" is a creation of ALLAH (swt) SubhanAllah, so clear. (Repeat: "Time" came with the Big Bang (ALLAH caused the Big Bang), so there was "no time" before the Big Bang. Even though "maybe" there was a time, it is not a problem because we Muslims believe also that ALLAH is independent from everything, so ALLAH is also independent from the time, which is the creation of ALLAH anyway (ALLAH is the absolute, the eternally independent on whom everything depends). So the question is ---) "What was before ALLAH?" completely impossible and illogical). We can see that it is so, but not how, because our mind has a limit, like everything else about us ---) Your eyesight has a limit (you can't see everything), your hearing has a limit (you can not hear everything, fo example ants, bacteria etc.), you can lift 30 kg, but it is impossible to lift 30 000 kg (your muscle strength has a limit), you can calculate 80 × 80 in your mind = 6400, but can you 62662636626266363726376373828 × 63762637273727 + 62672 ÷ 82772-62625266 =? No, you can't, because you have a limit there. We see that there is a limit to everything in us, so why don't some people accept that our mind also has a limit? If you do not accept that, you will deify your mind. SubhanAllah how clear ALLAH makes everything to us, if we only think logically. ------------------------------------------------------ Big Bang: Before the expansion of the universe began, the entire universe was in a single tiny point. This is called the "singularity", means ---) So everything in the universe and thus also the earth was a unit, which was then separated by the beginning of the expansion of the universe (Big Bang). --------------------------------------------------------- Quran (21 : 30) ---) ,,Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"(Big Bang) Quran (51 : 47) ---) ,,And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are still expanding (it)."(Expansion of the universe) Salam
Tunahan cantruk, " Science has proven that everything came with the Big Bang "- But Science's "Big Bang" theory has nothing to do with God. So I guess as per what you wrote Quran affirms Science?
@@SilentValley2023 Wa alaykoum salam, I'm kinda late sorry. I think what he meant was that the BBT we've all heard about is true, since it does make sense with what the Quran said, But the BBT in itself is an atheist theory however I think he wanted to make a point that the Quran and Islam are the truth by stating that the BBT is mentioned in the Quran (And I'll add to that the constant expense of the universe). There is much more about it but I'm not qualified to explain any of it haha. Allah knows best.
aRa Creotic 📌Sorry but perhaps your true understanding of the the Bing Bang Theory is not great❗️ 💢 brother who told you that BBT is true ⁉️ it’s just another theory like the Evolution Theory ‼️ ⭕️ it is important to understand that Big Bang theory 💥 is just that-a theory❗️ The exact nature or cause of that “beginning” has not been explicitly proved by empirical science, nor can it be‼️ 📌It is also important to note that, prior to the development of the Big Bang theory, disbelief in God was tied closely to the idea of an eternal, un-caused, and un-created universe. 👉Afterwards, however, non-believers began to claim that these advances in science actually disproved God👈 ☄️ What had always been interpreted as clear support for a Creator-and resisted for that very reason-almost overnight turned into the claim that atheists had been right all along.❗️ 👉 if you accept BBT, then you should be accepting the Evolution Theory as Well...Do You❓
aRa Creotic 🧲 The “big bang” is a story about how the universe came into existence. It proposes that billions of years ago the universe began in a tiny, infinitely hot and dense point called a singularity. This singularity supposedly contained not only all the mass and energy that would become everything we see today, but also “space” itself. According to the story, the singularity rapidly expanded, spreading out the energy and space. 🧲 It is supposed that over vast periods of time, the energy from the big bang cooled down as the universe expanded. Some of it turned into matter-hydrogen and helium gas. These gases collapsed to form stars and galaxies of stars. Some of the stars created the heavier elements in their core and then exploded, distributing these elements into space. Some of the heavier elements allegedly began to stick together and formed the earth and other planets. 👉This story of origins is entirely fiction. But sadly, many people claim to believe the big-bang model. It is particularly distressing that Islam has totally embraced the big bang, perhaps without realizing its atheistic underpinnings. They have chosen to reinterpret the teachings of Quran in an attempt to make it mesh with secular beliefs about origins.📌
What inside atom? = Electron Proton neutron What inside Proton and neutron? = Quarks. What inside quarks? = Vibration strings What inside vibration strings? = ? Just like the absolute Creator, there is no creators above Him, He is the first and the last. He Who create Vibration Strings = Quarks = Proton/Neutron/Electron = atom = BIGBANG
@bo jackson Very poor choice of verses. "As if" NOT "Exactly". It's like people calling the moon as if it made out of cheese but it didn't right? It's like calling the Sun looks like it's orbiting the Earth but it actually didn't right? Human eyes sometimes can get very confused...are you even reading this? Human eyes can get very confused they mistranslated some verses AND as a matter of fact, look to something a bit different as if it was something else. For example, "a group of sheep" looks like a huge cloud from far away. These are what people call "Optical Illusions". So saying the Sun "as if" it falls to a pile of dark mud, is just an illusion.
السلام عليكم دكتور ذاكر نايك، بارك الله فيكم استاذي الفاضل وارجو من الله عز وجل الاطاله في عمرك واستمرارك في تعليمنا امين اللهم امين، ارجوك يادكتور ذاكر نايك ان تدعو من الله ان يكتب لي كل خير وحسن الخاتمه، نسألكم الدعاء يا شيخ الاسلام ونحن طمعانون في دعائك من الله لنا بالخير والثبات على صراطه المستقيم.
We cannot watch d air ... because our eye has not capable... this is an best example ... alot of things v cannot watch but still present in the world ..... InshaAllah v will watch the Allah SWT after the death ... AlhamdulilAllah v r muslim... I testify that there is God but Allah and Muhammad SAW is the messanger of Allah...
For a cause to exist...it isn't necessary that there must be a command to cause that cause...like what is the cause of earthquake? When tectonic plates bump into each other(cause) (proven) assuming that there is an entity who is commanding that cause to take place is not the proof of god but a blind assumption...so if there is no command to that cause it means it is causing on itself...due to nature not a designer who is tellin good it to happen and does whatever he wants...🤦🏻♂️
If Allah 1 created by Allah 2, then who has created Allah 2. It is Allah 3. Then who created Allah 3. It is Allah 4. Then who created Allah 4. It is Allah 5. If go in this way we will find infinitive and unenble list of Allah and system is error because the final Allah has not found yet. But if we say like that Allah is one and equal powerful of infinitive Allah subhanaho tala then the answer is correct.💯🍔🎾🌈🛸🌴🥕🚲🪔🧃🌳🍕🚀💐🌴💥
Time sirf hmary liye h naa k Allah k liye ALLAH time sy Azad h to hm ye sawal kr e ni skty ALLAH kb sy h blky Time to ALLAH Ny bnaya h or Science bh proof kr chuki h hmari universe mn e time lago hota h us k bd nahii to ALLAH kb sy ha ye sawal illogical ha or Allah ko Kis ny bnaya agr Allah ko kisi ny bnaya ya peda kiya to usko kis ny peda kiya aiesy ye kbi khtm na hony wala question ha so kahi to hmy ruknaa pry gaa k koi aik ha jo hmesha sy ha or Wahi to khuda ha ALLAH ha
Who painted the wall?! The painter... Who painted the painter?! Nobody, because the painter is not the painting! Like wise God is the creator, not the creation!!! God is absolute, he doesn't need to be created. He has no beginning or end... The question who created the creator?! Is a ilogecal question as God cannot be created as he is eternal
If 5 is created by 4 and 4 is created by 3...then who created 1...it can't be created by 0 becoz it is nothing..And nothing can't create something.. It proves that, the first thing is uncreated.And that is Allah
for this I can say as what I heard from my ISMAILI SECT in Islam is the best answer IF an athiest asked you about who created ALLAH or ALLAH doesn't exist than reply him/her that if on death he comes than ... We do Salah on our Faith and ALMIGHTY HIS CREATION LIKE SUN MOON AIR SAND MOUNTAINS ETC ETC created by ALMIGHTY ALLAH and us also and we do belief that after this life the original life Eternity is going to start by the blessings of ALLAH SWT, and we all Muslims do all fear of ALLAH truth... Tell Ethiest if HE will be exisisted than you will be in totally Loss forever HE THE ALMIGHTY ALLAH will not reward you anything afterlife.. for your soul and spirit..
mashaallah such a Beautiful logical answer...here one more answer suppose there is a sniper who aims on his enemy and he is about to shoot but he is not shooting coz he diidnt get orders from his senior so he asked his senior.. his senior said。。。 i dont know coz i cant give you the permission i have to ask the army chief...so he ask the army chief...the army chief said i dont know ..i have to take permission from brigadier...so he ask the brigadier...the brigadier said the same i dont know i have to ask the president...now the president says i am the higher authority i dont need to ask or take permission from anyone i order to shoot... so in this way the big bang theory which led to creation of the universe the explosion ordered by someone who dont take orders someone who isnt controlled by any circumstance or any scenerio...who gave the concept of birth and death...who created things and terms like birth and death...who implant things like something is created by something in humans mind....who make these things as trials and ease...for a believer and nonbeliever...and he is alone ....the almighty allah
Dont know in which world you live but here on earth president is not above judiciary. Also he is elected(directly or indirectly) by people, just as god is created by we people
Army Chief, a 4 star general (O-10), has to take permission from a Brigadier(O-7), a one star officer that isn't even considered a general in some armies, bruh what do you smoke.
There is no illogical question.... Whatever happens in this world happens by the will of allah swt..even this question is the will of allah swt ..and allah has answer to everything....i want allah to give answer
Anything that is created or has a beginning must be under the influence of time. According to science time is a phenomena that exists only in the universe. Anything outside this universe does not fall under the influence of time. Since the Creator is outside of his creation(universe), time cannot affect him. Therefore He is eternal and uncreated. He is Allah/God.
ZazakAlallah
Beautiful explanation :) may Allah bless you and all of us
no brother, space and time are logical concepts, how they affect a being is what changes (related to physic laws), when scientists say that time has a beginning they're talking about the local time of our universe, because we cannot know what was before it because our universe didn't exist, but in general time and space are absolute, like laws of logic (non-contradiction, causality...), they're what defines existence, abscence of space and time is basically non-existence, a being requires space to exist and an event require time to happen, God tell us clearly in the quran that the 7 heavens are one on top of the other and above them the throne as their ceiling (probably like the layers of an onion), and God is above them, we don't say God is spaceless and timeless, that's an innovation, rather we say God is infinite in space and in time (eternal), just think about the creation of the world, at some point it didn't exist, then it became existent, moving from the state of non-existence to existence is an event and it requires time, and that event is initiated by God, he's the creator, the doer of this event..
@@IslamicAwareness27 All I am saying is that God is eternal and since he created time and space, this doesn't affect Him the way it affects us. He knows what happens in the past, present and future. So He basically controls time and also created the laws of physics. If He was under the influence of time then He would also have a beginning and a creation. And I think time in God's realm is totally different than the time in our world if it exists
@i am Muslim Beautiful link :) may Allah bless you and all of us human beings
I am a kid and Alhamdulillah I am a muslim and in fact this was the biggest question of my life which got answered by Dr zakir Naik
I am a teen
15 years old
Search why god has no beginning the hidayah
ᴀʟʜᴀᴍᴅᴜʟɪʟʟᴀʜ
@@atiqueahmad5333 iam 16 years and 10 months
@@newsspreader4726 no one cares, stop self promoting
Real answer is... Our human brain doesn't have enough capacity to understand about god.. that's why Quran gives so many evidences to believe the Creator... Here our job is... Following only commands of God.. it's impossible to imagine heaven & hell as well as God..
For example: we can't teach University degree programs to grade one school students... Like wise we can't imagine the God by our brain.. but we can prove existence of God...
Allah is above imagination :)
@@AimanAlnnfan imagination means.. we can't discover or explore or research on Allah... we can explore his creations only... in this way, we accept him as our creator..
You have to read theory of evolution by Charles Darwin
@@hakim_804 theory of evolution is just a theory, it isn't a fact.
If Allaha cont prove himself how we believe him.... he cannot make us understand then he is not allaha
Answer: surah al ikhlass
May Allah bless all of us amiin
Amiin
Ameen
Ameen Ya Rab
Ameen
Bro use capital letter A in Allah word.
this is the same question i had when i was little
Nd i was same stupid when i was small as u all are now
And I was the same stupid during my childhood as you are right now at the moment.
Mohamed created Allah in his mind to cheat humanity. When he wanted to do paedophilic deeds he used god's concept to defend himself by telling that was done as per god's order to make that valid.. if he hadn't done so people had thought him different way..
@@mrathiest9522 and your saints created fake 330 million gods to cheat everyone. Now thats too much, isnt it? Gosh.. it will take 2 centuries to learn those names, how do you guys do it? Obviously, by watching the stupid ramayan and mahabharat. Hahahahaha
@@mrathiest9522 i have encountered many fools like you, who just did 1 percent research and think that they are the new scholars lolol. Now im being serious, before blaming others religion, do some research. Dont listen to media as they are full of lies. May Allah show you the right path.
Allah has no beginning and has no end, He is the first and the last, the everliving.
Allah says in baqarah chapter 1 verse this a book in which there is no doubt a guidance from Allah
God is the Creator, he can’t be created
Ewa drerrie
I see yur name is called geert mocro wilders so yu are from holland 🤣🤣🤣
Afg.elpatron yess
Hahahahahahahhaha mooie naam
I think god is created god 😑
May Allah increase us all in knowledge.
Ameen
Rubi zidni ilma
Oh Allah increased me in knowledge ameen
Mashallah there is no question in the world which dr zakir naik can't answer
so what he say? he say a man can not give birth to a child but the question is who created god???
@@haroonkapoor8233 the question surely needs more clarifying and i have the full answer to why god doesnt need a creator. if youre interested in it brother reply to me and say so so i can explain it to you
If you go to discover the creation of Almighty Allah, you will become more knowledgeable. But if you go to discover Allah you will become Atheist. Cause Almighty Allah didn't give us the capacity to think of him.
Y not?
That’s crazy subhan allah. This made me tear up, because jinn was saying how was Allah created. Then I hear this and relieved any doubts I had.
May Allah give my all life to you...♥️Love you sir from the core of my heart...
Love u sir
I am from Bangladesh
The Prophet (ﷺ) said,
1."Convey from me even an Ayah of the Qur'an;
2."Acquire knowledge and impart it to the people."
Al-Tirmidhi, Hadith 107
جزاک اللہ خیر۔
بےشک
When a Muslim is asked this question, and their only answer is *"Allah has no creator just because.... (nothing)"* A response like that would falsely prove the Atheist's point, resulting in a False positive, thus making the Muslim lose the argument in the Atheist's mind.
I know how to respond to this question, and it involves analysing the underlying nature of the question itself. But let's Analyse the question that comes before it:
When the Atheist asks *"Who created the universe?"* They're only thinking of the materialistic portion; Planets, Stars, Galaxies, etc.
The Atheist's mind is programmed to not include Time or Physical Laws, since they have no material form. Their brain is programmed to believe that Time & Physical laws are eternal & uncreated, which is where the seperation comes from.
This is a Conceptual trap the Atheist subconsciously lures the Muslim into. And it usually works if the Muslim isn't a person who contemplates the nature of the Universe.
Onto the Actual Question;
When the Atheist asks *"Who created God/Allah?"* The Atheist subconsciously believes that Time & Physical laws are uncreated things. What the Atheist DOESN'T know is that the very nature of Time itself and the Laws of Physics are creations of Allah. If the Muslim doesn't know this, they've already lost the argument.
To properly respond to this question, one must inform the Atheist of what they're doing wrong as they ask it;
Here's what I would say:
_"No, see; What YOU'RE doing is you're subconsiously thinking of time as an eternal entity that is independant of the universe, as well as the Laws of Physics. What you don't realise is that Allah/God is the creator of Time itself and the Laws of Physics. And Allah/God cannot by bound by anything he creates, otherwise he wouldn't be Allah/God. So when you asked me _*_"Who created God/Allah?"_*_ , You are subconsciously implying that time existed before Allah/God. Which doesn't make sense because only Allah/God is eternal, whereas Time is not. What you need to realise is that since Time and the Laws of Physics are created by Allah/God, then it is Allah/God that controls them, not the other way around._
_So let's go back your Question; _*_"Who created Allah/God?"_*_ Nobody, because Nothing can come "before" the one who created the very nature of Time itself. He is Eternal and fully self-sufficient and independant of anything that we can understand."_
That is the big bang argument. At least with the big bang there are some consequences you can observe: the universe. Unfortunately, it's not the case of god who does not show up and whose existence cannot be proved, same for the prayers or actions of god. So you cannot live disregarding god, and if god wants something from the humans, he sould be communicating clearly to everybody.
MASHALLAH DR. SAHAB.. Bohot Logical Answer diya Aap ne...Allah aap ki madad farmaye aamin..
He has huge knowldge what a man seriously
@@leonidbrezhnev9917 LOL!
nageen nadeem, may be knowledge but lacks wisdom!
I had this question in my since I was a child. Never bothered to look this up, but all the time I used to have confusions, curiosity. Now from this video and from the respectable comments I am satisfied with the answer.
if allah is uncreated then why can't the universe be? have you ever thought about that
@@mashable8759 Question is illogical again. The universe doesnt create anything according to science, its a whole concotion of things according in a single point which explodes, leading to formation of galaxies, stars. Science wholeheartedly believes this is just a formation not creation. Point is how can all of those things just happen out of nowhere? But an uncreated God who can create a universe with life and a certain time frame for it to end makes more sense. We cant throw a bunch of wood into the water and expect a boat to form.
@@strawhatmucci7086 anything with a non zero probability will occur in infinite amount of time. If you threw wood into water and gave it infinite amount of time, then yes it will form a boat.
@@DrAdityaReddy there is absolutely no way a structured boat is gonna form if you throw a bunch of wood into water with even infinite time.
@@strawhatmucci7086 I can't argue with you :-)
May Allah elevate our Rank in jannah #ameen
ameen
I saw this answer some time ago and it was really logical:
This is an example you can give them as an answer: " The wall is blue, who painted the wall? The Painter. So who painted The Painter? " This example can be used as an easy, understandable answer to that question.
Arshia Ghanbarian that doesn’t really make sense tho you should of said something like look at the sun and you would say ouch I can’t that would hurt my eyes then say and the sun is a creation so how could you see the creator then
@@ismailjundi1766 Your example is the answer to the question " Why can't we see Allah? "
What i said was the answer to " Who created Allah? "
Arshia Ghanbarian I know but saying who painted the painter just doesn’t make sense I know what you mean but it just doesn’t
@@ismailjundi1766 Exactly. It doesn't make sense.
Same goes with Allah. Cause Allah being created doesn't make any sense!
Ok I understand now the question should have been who created the painter?
Hanya izin dari Allah yg kuharapkan untukku besar lagi melakukan kebenaran alhamdulillah.
Mash'Allah 💗💗
SUBHANALLAHAA SUBHANALLAHAA SUBHANALLAHAA. ALLHUMDULLILLAHA
A *painter* paints the *painting* 🖼, but if you ask who *painted* the *painter?+, no one because *painter* is not a *painting*. **_similarly Allah is a *creator_*_ not _*_creation_*
Exactly! nice
Harshul Jain Roll 31 Lol. I was just explaining about the creator isn’t made by anyone.So no one created Allah
Yeah you are 100% right
The answer to the atheist is Allah did tell us in surah Al Ikhlas; in verse no 3 and 4. Lam yalid walamyulad, walam yakullahu kufuan ahad. Means.... He begetteth not, nor is He begotten. And there is none like unto him.
I love you Dr sahabb ... Allah bless you
Thank you dr Zakir Naik ow I know only Allah knows about his past so hopefully inshallah I will make it to
Jannah so I can ask that question.
Insallah ❤
I asked myself same question if God wasnt created by anyone, then it could be that particles came together and so God came out of nowhere... Well I was going a bit crazy at that time when I made this theorom, and later heard wispering saying God killed his mother I understanded, well it could mean God stopped anything that could make a new him out of nowhere.... those days were crazy I even saw 2 birds come through my frontdoors window when you cant even open it... also I saw these holograms drawing things, and even I was asked by wispering to negotiate with sahitan... I kept on writing on a paper I lay it down go away come back and everything was gone that I have written on the paper, till I wrote something like who is your master then that was not removed anymore.... probably because I knew there is only one supreme God and that is allah the most beloved...
In those days i hid my laptop and f couldnt find it for a while because I saw this orange color coming on outer of my display and thought they would hack it completely as I was losing files etc... so I hid and for a few days without laptop but got alot of things for me, till I found it again.. well those things dont happen anymore so all is good lol.. my family were away on those days though, so i was alone... and also couldnt record it because my mobile phones battery couldnt fit in my mobile phone anymore.... crazy but a voice told me pray the fard salat on laylatal qadr so God accepts you as one who perfilled his prayer duties, as I was not praying those days... I did but still pray the fard though these days, wasnt doing that those days.....
Who created Allah? Well that is perfectly obvious, It was Muhammad.
Nope, Allah is infinitely above Muhammad SAW
There is also an alternate to this Answer work hard and do good deeds follow GOD's command and once you pass the test and reach Jannah than ask ALLAH this Question yourself.
Thats only if they become muslims which they gonna consider until they have full proof but till then its endless loop ..Subhanallah
Allah is the Almighty. No one can create Allah.
How did the uncreated pop up
What was that uncreated doing before humans have been created
@@bhaswanthgudimella344 Shut up. read Surah Iklahs the translation
@@HyBp-np9bf sorry no time if you post it here I will read
@@bhaswanthgudimella344 Surah Ikhlas: Allah is one and has no partners with him, he is alone, he is the Eternal refuge, he was not created and not born, there is no one like him and equivalent to him. Allah is only one.
True
MashaAllah good answer zakeer sir
Beautiful example which make my Iman strong❤
No one created him
He is one n only
Allah...
He is the first
He is the last
He is the most high...
Ni one can see him
He is the Allah one n only
Eternal refuge
Neither begotten nor is born
N none is comparable to him.
the definition of God is who is uncreated
No one created him
That is Allah
Esselamu aleykum,
here is the answer ---) Science has proven that everything came with the Big Bang (space, TIME, matter). This is proven and even mentioned in a Quran Ayah. If someone asks for example -) Before you was your father and before that your grandfather and before that your great-grandfather etc. up to Adam (as). Before that, Allah created the Jinn. Before that, ALLAH created the angels, etc. up to ALLAH (swt). If someone then asks ---) What was "before" ALLAH, makes no logical sense, because "before" is a "time indication" and "time" is a creation of ALLAH (swt) SubhanAllah, so clear. (Repeat: "Time" came with the Big Bang (ALLAH caused the Big Bang), so there was "no time" before the Big Bang. Even though "maybe" there was a time, it is not a problem because we Muslims believe also that ALLAH is independent from everything, so ALLAH is also independent from the time, which is the creation of ALLAH anyway (ALLAH is the absolute, the eternally independent on whom everything depends). So the question is ---) "What was before ALLAH?" completely impossible and illogical).
We can see that it is so, but not how, because our mind has a limit, like everything else about us ---) Your eyesight has a limit (you can't see everything), your hearing has a limit (you can not hear everything, fo example ants, bacteria etc.), you can lift 30 kg, but it is impossible to lift 30 000 kg (your muscle strength has a limit), you can calculate 80 × 80 in your mind = 6400, but can you 62662636626266363726376373828 × 63762637273727 + 62672 ÷ 82772-62625266 =? No, you can't, because you have a limit there. We see that there is a limit to everything in us, so why don't some people accept that our mind also has a limit? If you do not accept that, you will deify your mind. SubhanAllah how clear ALLAH makes everything to us, if we only think logically.
------------------------------------------------------
Big Bang: Before the expansion of the universe began, the entire universe was in a single tiny point. This is called the "singularity", means ---) So everything in the universe and thus also the earth was a unit, which was then separated by the beginning of the expansion of the universe (Big Bang).
---------------------------------------------------------
Quran (21 : 30) ---) ,,Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens and the earth were a joined entity, and We separated them and made from water every living thing? Then will they not believe?"(Big Bang)
Quran (51 : 47) ---) ,,And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are still expanding (it)."(Expansion of the universe)
Salam
Tunahan cantruk, " Science has proven that everything came with the Big Bang "- But Science's "Big Bang" theory has nothing to do with God. So I guess as per what you wrote Quran affirms Science?
@@SilentValley2023 Wa alaykoum salam, I'm kinda late sorry. I think what he meant was that the BBT we've all heard about is true, since it does make sense with what the Quran said, But the BBT in itself is an atheist theory however I think he wanted to make a point that the Quran and Islam are the truth by stating that the BBT is mentioned in the Quran (And I'll add to that the constant expense of the universe). There is much more about it but I'm not qualified to explain any of it haha.
Allah knows best.
aRa Creotic 📌Sorry but perhaps your true understanding of the the Bing Bang Theory is not great❗️
💢 brother who told you that BBT is true ⁉️ it’s just another theory like the Evolution Theory ‼️
⭕️ it is important to understand that Big Bang theory 💥 is just that-a theory❗️ The exact nature or cause of that “beginning” has not been explicitly proved by empirical science, nor can it be‼️
📌It is also important to note that, prior to the development of the Big Bang theory, disbelief in God was tied closely to the idea of an eternal, un-caused, and un-created universe. 👉Afterwards, however, non-believers began to claim that these advances in science actually disproved God👈
☄️ What had always been interpreted as clear support for a Creator-and resisted for that very reason-almost overnight turned into the claim that atheists had been right all along.❗️
👉 if you accept BBT, then you should be accepting the Evolution Theory as Well...Do You❓
aRa Creotic
🧲 The “big bang” is a story about how the universe came into existence. It proposes that billions of years ago the universe began in a tiny, infinitely hot and dense point called a singularity. This singularity supposedly contained not only all the mass and energy that would become everything we see today, but also “space” itself. According to the story, the singularity rapidly expanded, spreading out the energy and space.
🧲 It is supposed that over vast periods of time, the energy from the big bang cooled down as the universe expanded. Some of it turned into matter-hydrogen and helium gas. These gases collapsed to form stars and galaxies of stars. Some of the stars created the heavier elements in their core and then exploded, distributing these elements into space. Some of the heavier elements allegedly began to stick together and formed the earth and other planets.
👉This story of origins is entirely fiction. But sadly, many people claim to believe the big-bang model. It is particularly distressing that Islam has totally embraced the big bang, perhaps without realizing its atheistic underpinnings. They have chosen to reinterpret the teachings of Quran in an attempt to make it mesh with secular beliefs about origins.📌
Wow, nice answer.
For your stupid brain yes
You r great sir.....love u zakir sir
Nice,Alhamdulillah
What inside atom?
= Electron Proton neutron
What inside Proton and neutron?
= Quarks.
What inside quarks?
= Vibration strings
What inside vibration strings?
= ?
Just like the absolute Creator, there is no creators above Him, He is the first and the last. He Who create Vibration Strings = Quarks = Proton/Neutron/Electron = atom = BIGBANG
No one can prove the existence of Allah Allah has no beginning or end
@bo jackson me buying a ticket at an airport to fly and do a research when the heck did Allah said that:
@bo jackson Very poor choice of verses. "As if" NOT "Exactly". It's like people calling the moon as if it made out of cheese but it didn't right? It's like calling the Sun looks like it's orbiting the Earth but it actually didn't right? Human eyes sometimes can get very confused...are you even reading this? Human eyes can get very confused they mistranslated some verses AND as a matter of fact, look to something a bit different as if it was something else. For example, "a group of sheep" looks like a huge cloud from far away. These are what people call "Optical Illusions". So saying the Sun "as if" it falls to a pile of dark mud, is just an illusion.
I love speaking of zakir naik
A human cannot answer that. That is so beyond our understanding.
Mashallah 1st
Search why god has no beginning kumari2london
Alhamdulillah
SubhanAllah
Masha Allah.
Very important question and answer
So nice
Fantastic, I really love this answer what such an inspirational speaker.
But he lied!!
السلام عليكم دكتور ذاكر نايك، بارك الله فيكم استاذي الفاضل وارجو من الله عز وجل الاطاله في عمرك واستمرارك في تعليمنا امين اللهم امين، ارجوك يادكتور ذاكر نايك ان تدعو من الله ان يكتب لي كل خير وحسن الخاتمه، نسألكم الدعاء يا شيخ الاسلام ونحن طمعانون في دعائك من الله لنا بالخير والثبات على صراطه المستقيم.
Agar muje jannat mili...to me sabse pahle Allah se ilm manguga...sb kuch universe k bare me🙂
Search why god has no beginning kumari2london
Asfak khan, Yes...."Agar"!
Masha Allah. .Good Answer Sir..
We cannot watch d air ... because our eye has not capable... this is an best example ... alot of things v cannot watch but still present in the world ..... InshaAllah v will watch the Allah SWT after the death ... AlhamdulilAllah v r muslim... I testify that there is God but Allah and Muhammad SAW is the messanger of Allah...
ماشاء اللہ
تبارک الرحمن ❤❤❤
i want to enter jannah and to understand more about allah at jannah
Subhan Allah
Masha Allaha
Very nice
sir please share your this kind of videos I was completed watching your most of the old videos on youtube please do share.
Whatever you think, imagine is mortal,
What you cannot conceive or imagine is God.'
Jalaluddin Rumi
No one created Allah, Allah was always there.He is the beginning and he is the end.Al Hayy- the ever living
Nobody can convince anybody , that is for sure if it matter of religion.
Salman khna, but Zakir Naik can!
I don't think so .I am practicing Muslim.
Nice
Mashaallah
Mashallah
Pls add subtitle Indonesia
If Allah enter me in jannah...i will beg all of knwlg abt creation of univers
U can gain knowledge here only just made Dua
Surely allah will give u knowledge of deene as well as duniawi
Say: He is Allah the One, Allah is Eternal and Absolute. Non is born of Him. Nor is he Born. And there is Non like Him. - Surah Al lkhlas -112
Why not just say I DONT KNOW. Very simple
Every good question has a very good answer
Infinite regression, if you go back on and on the chain will never end, there has to be an uncaused cause which started the universe, who is God
Search why god has no beginning kumari2london
For a cause to exist...it isn't necessary that there must be a command to cause that cause...like what is the cause of earthquake? When tectonic plates bump into each other(cause) (proven) assuming that there is an entity who is commanding that cause to take place is not the proof of god but a blind assumption...so if there is no command to that cause it means it is causing on itself...due to nature not a designer who is tellin good it to happen and does whatever he wants...🤦🏻♂️
Please do subtitle English or Arabic
Thank you all muslim.
I think Dr. Zakir should have said God has always existed rather than saying God is uncreated. To me this is clearer and more understandable.
SubhanAllah
MashaAllah
Allahu Akbar
La Ilaha IllaAllah
Astag'furilloh
If Allah can be uncreated then why not the whole world can be uncreated
That is the correct answer to the question, that any rational religious person can give.
How to post the questions to zakir Naik through on-line
മാഷാഅള്ളാഹ്
Sakeena Ashraf, മാഷാdള്ളാഹ്
If Crispy Kreme bake donuts then who baked Crispy Kreme?
Same energy
If Allah 1 created by Allah 2, then who has created Allah 2. It is Allah 3. Then who created Allah 3. It is Allah 4. Then who created Allah 4. It is Allah 5. If go in this way we will find infinitive and unenble list of Allah and system is error because the final Allah has not found yet.
But if we say like that Allah is one and equal powerful of infinitive Allah subhanaho tala then the answer is correct.💯🍔🎾🌈🛸🌴🥕🚲🪔🧃🌳🍕🚀💐🌴💥
Time sirf hmary liye h naa k Allah k liye ALLAH time sy Azad h to hm ye sawal kr e ni skty ALLAH kb sy h blky Time to ALLAH Ny bnaya h or Science bh proof kr chuki h hmari universe mn e time lago hota h us k bd nahii to ALLAH kb sy ha ye sawal illogical ha or Allah ko Kis ny bnaya agr Allah ko kisi ny bnaya ya peda kiya to usko kis ny peda kiya aiesy ye kbi khtm na hony wala question ha so kahi to hmy ruknaa pry gaa k koi aik ha jo hmesha sy ha or Wahi to khuda ha ALLAH ha
Humans can create religions. So, who created God? My answer is the God created by the human minds.
Ridiculous. Yeah I can say I created the Burj Khalifa because I imagined it yesterday.
Who painted the wall?!
The painter...
Who painted the painter?!
Nobody, because the painter is not the painting!
Like wise God is the creator, not the creation!!!
God is absolute, he doesn't need to be created. He has no beginning or end...
The question who created the creator?! Is a ilogecal question as God cannot be created as he is eternal
A curious question wch shall never be answered by hypocrites..
Anyone who loves to listen the holy quran can come hear
@@leonidbrezhnev9917 no..
Wth
Allahu Akbar
He is the only who is one Allah Almighty
Allah created all the things in the world
There's a spelling mistake in the thumbnail, please rectify it
God is first with no beaning and last with no ending
If 5 is created by 4 and 4 is created by 3...then who created 1...it can't be created by 0 becoz it is nothing..And nothing can't create something.. It proves that, the first thing is uncreated.And that is Allah
Alsalam alikom brothers is there any way to ask a question from dr Zaker naik
for this I can say as what I heard from my ISMAILI SECT in Islam is the best answer IF an athiest asked you about who created ALLAH or ALLAH doesn't exist than reply him/her that if on death he comes than ... We do Salah on our Faith and ALMIGHTY HIS CREATION LIKE SUN MOON AIR SAND MOUNTAINS ETC ETC created by ALMIGHTY ALLAH and us also and we do belief that after this life the original life Eternity is going to start by the blessings of ALLAH SWT, and we all Muslims do all fear of ALLAH truth... Tell Ethiest if HE will be exisisted than you will be in totally Loss forever HE THE ALMIGHTY ALLAH will not reward you anything afterlife.. for your soul and spirit..
We are born to serve God. We live to serve God. We die to serve God in Heaven....
Thank God I am an Atheist.
translate please!! i am indonesia i m not understand.
mashaallah such a Beautiful logical answer...here one more answer suppose there is a sniper who aims on his enemy and he is about to shoot but he is not shooting coz he diidnt get orders from his senior so he asked his senior.. his senior said。。。 i dont know coz i cant give you the permission i have to ask the army chief...so he ask the army chief...the army chief said i dont know ..i have to take permission from brigadier...so he ask the brigadier...the brigadier said the
same i dont know i have to ask the president...now the president says i am
the higher authority i dont need to ask or take permission from anyone i order to shoot...
so in this way the big bang theory which led to creation of the universe the explosion ordered by someone who dont take orders someone who isnt controlled by any circumstance or any scenerio...who gave the concept of birth and death...who created things and terms like birth and death...who implant things like something is created by something in humans mind....who make these things as trials and ease...for a believer and nonbeliever...and he is alone ....the almighty allah
Dont know in which world you live but here on earth president is not above judiciary. Also he is elected(directly or indirectly) by people, just as god is created by we people
Army Chief, a 4 star general (O-10), has to take permission from a Brigadier(O-7), a one star officer that isn't even considered a general in some armies, bruh what do you smoke.
There is no illogical question.... Whatever happens in this world happens by the will of allah swt..even this question is the will of allah swt ..and allah has answer to everything....i want allah to give answer
God has no beginning and the end God is the Alpha and the Omega.