SubhA this is not only mind blowing but totally a game changer. I have ways felt the 'traditional' translations to be problematic. I've been on a very long journey and InshA feel closer to the true message of the Quran than ever before. Please keep up the fantastic work ,this is vitally important for the believers. Thank you and Allah bless you with continuous enlightenment.
Subxanallah this is so beautiful and mesmerizingly mind blowing, I have noticed that actually it is not even correct grammatically to refer to الملائكة because this sounds like جمع مونث or حمع التكسير and so many other verses use ت with all the verbs that refer to the angels: تتوفاهم، تري الملايكة، تعرج الملايكة، تنزل الملائكة تاتيهم الملايكة So the verb would have been قلن or قالت Thanks and Jazakallah for this unraveling this deep meaning.
Aameen! Thank you for your duas at the beginning and the end of this presentation. There is no accountability for any being who is not given the ability to choose between "fujuur" and "taqwaa". Without this ability, it would be impossible for this being to raise any questions. MasyaAllaah! What a great lecture, Dr. Hany! Alhamdulillaah...
While agreeing with you that angels can never question Allah's actions my humble opinion is that you have taken the interpretation of verse 2:30 to a different metaphorical level which is controversial. However, that is your interpretation and we may ponder over it. Like I mentioned in my previous comments Quran has layers of meaning and you have dealt with a layer that was not attempted by previous interpretations of Quran. Therefore, please don't ridicule them as ignorant or arrogant. Some of them were pious predecessors of Islam. I have learned something from your noble efforts and may Allah bless you for that.
Part of understanding the Quran ACCORDING TO THE ORGANIC QURANIC METHODOLOGY (not according to my opinion) is to understand what the Quran says about those who belied and who ignored the ayats of Allahh. THIS IS NOT ME RIDICULING EARLIER INTERPRETERS ! THIS IS THE QURAN EXPLAINING WHY THEY DID NOT SEE THE AYATS, AND WHY THEY MISINTERPRETED AND MISGUIDED SO MANY GENERATIONS. (Capital letters used only to highlight the importance of what I am saying, not to scream!) Regards
@@MarvelousQuran jazakallah alkhair for your explanation. But isn't it outrageous to claim that until you apply the organic methodology all predecessors haven't interpreted Quran correctly and the Muslim umma has been ignorant during the past 1,400 years?
@ Nakeeb Issadeen If using the "ummah" argument was valid, then the Christians, and the Jews before them, would have a much stronger claim to truth... So don't use the word "ummah" in your argument, because Allahh deals with each individual separately, not as a group... rigt? And therefore, Here's the same question you asked, but articulated using the Quranic terminology: "Is it outrageous to claim that an individual who belied the ayats of the Quran is misled for a long period of time?" What is 10 such individuals belied the ayats? What if 1 million individuals belied the ayats? What if 100 generations belied the ayats? I hope you see the point! I know this is Yucky and painful! But Truth is often bitter! And detoxification takes a lot of courage!
It was pretty obvious that the traditional interpretation did not make sense as to how angels could have known that God was creating a new creation that would cause bloodshed etc. as if they had the ability to access God’s knowledge as to what human beings would turn out to be like and further more when the angels consult God supposedly about Jinn on how they were corrupt and why God is creating another creation “humans” that would do the same? How did they know what God’s new creation would do? Just assumed because Jinn were corrupt beings etc.? They had access to God’s knowledge? Whenever I read it, it never made sense to me and so now your explanation Dr Hany clears it all up, thank you.
@@kgdangar2 previous scholars and pretty much every one in modern times have been so obviously wrong on so many things I think its fair to say we need a fresh approach. I'm done with all the traditionalists full stop.
@kgdnagar2 You say "Allah clearly mention in Sura Ali Imran in verse 8 "And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allah"" It's Aya 3:7, not 8. And your translation is erroneous. We have detailed it and shown the clear interpretation for this aya See the video here th-cam.com/video/mMqfaeiIIDw/w-d-xo.html
Alhamdulillah, Dr. , i hv been listening to this almost since 6 months, so many times, wow, every time i get excited, so much of info u hv loaded, great, losers are those who dont concentrate on learning this knowledge. Thnx dr. HA.. may Allah gives strength, energy, more and more to u.
Even though your understanding and explanations of the Quran are so different from what scholars are teaching, the way you are glorifying Allah Almighty by giving Him all the points He owns and the way you describe the holiness of the Quran makes me fall in love with Islam again and again. This is the reason why I come here every time to hear your explanations and to reflect on true Islam. Alhamdulillah for these lectures. Thank you, Dr. Hany!
Salaamun alaykum. Isn’t the same situation that every community goes through? They feel their understanding has been perfected and they are practicing the most purified way, so any new understanding of the scripture is blasphemous. By Allah’s will, may He open up our hearts so we can encounter His knowledge with its pure understanding.
Salamun Alaykum. This was a paradigm shifting segment for me! Your interpretation of Aya 2:30 makes perfect sense! I cannot believe that I had glibly swallowed a flawed and fanciful interpretation for so long even though I reflected about it many times. You had promised that the new BAYYINAH in this segment will blow our minds and it did just that for me; wow! The clear evidence provided by the Ayat you expounded exposed the locution of the people of Fir3aoun without a shadow of a doubt. (I also noted the little teaser about these people being BANI ISRAEL). Indeed Allah SWT has hidden gems of knowledge in plain sight if only one has the eyes to see them. Thank you and may Allah bless you for teaching us this wonderful new tool to decipher more of what the Quran is really trying to teach us. I am keenly looking forward to the next segment on the story of adam.
alhamdulillah and thanks very much Dr Hany. new paradigm for me. please archive your work in digital format, just incase as you mentioned before. i think many of us here in this channel willing to pay for views of your extensive research works.
I missed the point ‘why Allah has to inform malaikah’ on selecting adam as khalifah. So looking for this video again. Really totally a different perspective now from what I understood before. Jazakallah DH
Wallahi I was wondering about this Al-Baqara Ayat 30 and no one in my closest could answer me this question. Well they did to their best, but it just didn't feel right to me... YOU Dr. Hany by the Help of Allah swt have opend my core (Qalb) ;) and help me to understand it correctly. Tabarak Allah!
Shockingly exposed! tears keep flowing towards the end of your presentation ... a new unraveled piece of information - huurun'ain - to fill my cup, my 'arash. thank you dr hany, alhamdulillah, subhaanallah.
JazakumAllahu khair Dr Hany. This ayah never made sense to me. My 10 year old was shocked and confused when in the past I had tried to erroneously explain it the traditional way. SubhaanAllah even a child knows angels don’t question their Lord.
alhamdullilah, previously when i read the interpretation of tafseel, the angels asking why Allah want to create human/chaliph on earth (and the angel somehow have the knowledge of previous event that had happened on earth) -said they (this human)will create trouble and bloodshed.....my assumption was may be there are human on earth before adam, and may be the angel meant the djin who has stayed on earth created all the bloodshed. alhamdullilah i found your translation is logical. i really dua to Allah that this is the true tafsir,and i will be in selected true believer.
Salaamoon Alaykum, Tafseel, like it was depicted through the caravan of the siblings breaking apart from the main caravan, is a great usage and a means to epistemology itself. Beautifully delivered in this segment.
"Salamun Alikumm". Alhamdullillah. Thank U Dr Hany for the light full lecture videos. It's a very realistic video on mining the truth of the Holy Quran which was missing for the last 1400 yrs. I have been looking for such a platform for a long time. My eyes filled with tears on viewing the video's published so far. It is a blessing for the human, Specially we Muslims will be able to raise our heads again with the great truth ignoring the past. Now I am so lonely on this journey with you all to find out the proper way of making supplications. I hope days are waiting for all to return under the same umbrella. Thanks to your team members for their efforts to help you on the way to extensive research.
MashaAllah..thanks for the good work sheikh..i would like to suggest this lecture should be peer reviewed by other scholar to improve validity of the content.
Salamun Alaikum Dr. Hany Thank you. Just wondering about two words Earth and samaawaat, ? does these words are used to mean space/layer of space (7 skies) or space and objective world( visible universe/ dimensions) in any places of Holy Quran? There are some sura/Ayah's explaining creation of universe and objects where saamawaat wal earth used? Your insight regarding this and help will be highly appreciated. Fi amanillah
Downloaded it a few minutes after you uploaded it, Alhamdulillah. MashaAllah……no words to express and no questions to ask as no gaps in this little mind. With regards to river flows underneath jannaat, ayat 14:32 explains it……is it Dr Hany? Thank you so much. Forever indebted. Wasalam
Timestamps: 0:00 Intro 0:34 The Concept of Unlearning and Re-learning 2:34 A Special DuƐāꜤ 3:32 In This Segment 4:57 We Assume That You Understand 6:04 Reminder About بَعُوضَةٌ “Ba3ūḍatun” 7:00 Aya 2:28-29 from Sūrah Al-Baqarah 15:03 Aya 2:30 - Prelude to ādam’s Story 22:06 The Problem With Claiming the Angels Questioned Allahh? 26:18 Bayyinah: When a Question is NOT a Question! 41:34 Aya 2:30 (Cont.) 47:25 The Oath Taken By Allahh SWT of All the Prophets 49:43 What Happens to People Who Belie the Ayat of the QurꜤān? 53:59 Outro
I hope I'm making comment on right video. Making a statement in an interrogative way is really bizarre way of communicating. Well explained dr. Hany. I really get it.
I also got stuck here how angels asked allah subhan wa ta ala and how they know that mankind will make corruption in the world even the sunnah of sahaba is that they never answer what they dont know they always used to say allah and his rasul saw knows better.
Salaam from Kashmir. Sir, Please share the Print out in the Description via Google Drive so that it becomes Easy to Memorise the Verses after your Explanation & please make the Arabic font better
Assamulaikum Dr Hani, May Allah give your strength and good health always to pursue your great efforts. I have followed and comprehended almost all your past segments and looking forward for more. It hurts each time to watch local TV network going on ‘story telling’ unchecked to millions, the tafseer of the Holy Quran based on writing of earlier mufassiruns and interpreters. May Allah guide and show them the right direction to learn, unlearn and relearn.
It actually makes sense, cause how can an angel question God's action? It just doesn't work like that, again I ask my question over and over; what other lies have I been told?
Wonderful lecture. 100% agree with your translation Dr Hany . Allah is authoritative. The supposed conversation with the angels questioning him doesn't give to Allah SWT his true reverence .
Salaamun Alaykum. What a splendid segment and discovery from within the Qur'an. This has cleared up so much confusion in our tradition. Sad that we did not give Allahh SWT his due reverence in regards to the understanding of this story. Alhumdulillah we can now see clearly the truth.
@@MarvelousQuran Waw....thanks for this reply. This very reply is exactly what I'm expecting :). It pooves 100% indication that you're just another modern world's 'fitnah' or 'syubha' for ummah. Such an arrogant reply, far from humble and understanding that everything that happen is because of Allah's permissions, including your 'so called' great mind :). Alhamdulillah Allah quickly showed me who you really are.
@Udin Salam Do you see the smiley face at the end of my reply? In case you are not familiar with this icon, it means that it's a joke! Regardless, thank you for your words!
This is mind blowing! if i understood correctly this group of people are rejecting any scripture or prophet sent by Allah mostly because they believe any new revelation or knowledge should pass through them only and on that basis CHOOSE not to believe. This is Arrogance and Super Ego on an unbelievable scale. God Bless you for this information and you are right it does form the basis of the Holy Quran
Absolutely Loving your work. Perhaps part of the Locution of the Bani Israeel is to ask Rhetorical Questions. It’s at least a lot easier to understand it that way.
Assalamualaikum, respected sir why is Allah telling malaika what he is going to do...and then why are baudah replying while they were not addressed about khalifa in previous ayat
@ Imran Bangash This segment is part of a series. Unless you watch the series, there are many concepts that you missed... The Ba3udah is mentioned 4 ayats earlier... You think it is irrelevant? Or maybe you think Ba3udah means mosquito?????
This puts the the narration in Surah Sa'ad regarding Allah Subhanahu giving respite to Iblees in a completely different light. I really would like your explanation. Shukran.
I appreciate Dr. Hany efforts, and well presented videos, but after viewing more than a handful of his videos, it appears to me that all his efforts are directed towards explaining the Quran metaphorically.. and reveal well hidden meanings, and hidden "bayinat", as if the Quran was only revealed for highly deep thinking, highly philosophical persons and this is not the case. In my opinion, we should take a break, zoom out a bit, and find simplicity in the Quran.
@ Sharif TABBARA Obviously you need a break. In the meantime, we are loosing the educated Muslims and the youths by the millions...You go ahead and stay at the superficial layer... The rest of us are enjoying diving into the beautiful nuggets of wisdom deposited below the superficial layer.
Salamun Alaykom, I always wondered why would Angel's be questioning Allah (SWT) I thought they have no free will and supposed to be obedient. There was another bogus story about Harut and Marut questioning Allah that they are better than human and sent to earth etc.
@Marvelous Quran: Can you elaborate more on last sentence of this Ayat. قَالَ اِنِّىۡٓ اَعۡلَمُ مَا لَا تَعۡلَمُوۡنَ. Your translation do not specify anything about word used on this sentence.
Assalamualaikum Dr Hany, Thank you for your presentation and tafseel. Really appreciated it, Btw, I would like to ask regarding why you put the "A" in "Adam" as lower case letter "a". Been through the whole lecture in this video then only realized it was not addressed. Hope you can help and guide us more about it ya. 🙏. Thank you!
Slamun Alikum dear Brother. I am a regular flower of you channel. I really appreciate your efforts. May Allah swt gives you hayat and energy to serve the Muslim ummah, enlighten them with the correct interpretation of Holly Quran. Brother I have query regards to the word Samawat and Samaawaat. According to your previous lecture you said samawat means heaven or sky while samaawaat is a Abrahamic locution means understanding. But in this segment 2:28 you said Samawat as understanding, or seven layers of understanding. Pl clarify my doubts. May Allah bless you. Thank.
So it is similar to a numerical series like 1,2,3 next is 1,2,3, ? And like that sometimes mat be 1,? 3, 4, 5,? Is this pattern of understanding is closer to you? I mean, always not the very words, but the momentum of the construction of the sentences will carry the metaphor to catch the intrinsic meaning?
Asalāmu’alaikim Sir, Absolutely Commendable, keep up the great work no words to show our gratitude for the amazing translations and revealing of the truth from the Quran. 👍👍🙏🏻
Alikom Salam a nice lecture about the troubles with text and words in the Quran.... Can you please explain [2-33] قَالَ يَٰٓـَٔادَمُ أَنۢبِئۡهُم بِأَسۡمَآئِهِمۡۖ فَلَمَّآ أَنۢبَأَهُم بِأَسۡمَآئِهِمۡ قَالَ أَلَمۡ أَقُل لَّكُمۡ إِنِّيٓ أَعۡلَمُ غَيۡبَ ٱلسَّمَٰوَٰتِ وَٱلۡأَرۡضِ وَأَعۡلَمُ مَا تُبۡدُونَ وَمَا كُنتُمۡ تَكۡتُمُونَ In this verse is really confusing me because first Adam is telling them the "names" and than I think that Allah s.w.t. is telling “ "Have I not told you that I know the invisible in the heavens and in the earth, and that I know what you reveal and what you keep hidden?" what does this verse really mean ??
@ Jamal Larossi As we said, the same one who told them about their labels also told then, in their locution: Did I not tell you, etc..." meaning "I have not told you, etc..." which means that Allahh is the one who told me so.
Alhamdulillah: JazakAllah Kairn! May Allah forgive us......how we failed to apprehend and question, especially given that the Ayah is in distinct contradiction to what we [most muslims ] have been taught as one of the major attributes of Angels: that they only execute as Commanded by Allah....no questions.
Do you recall the amazing transformation in meaning for the last 3 words in Aya 2:71, in the Video about "How to Circumcise a she-cow?" --- starting at min. 44:40 Simply by making a small "Tafseel" change to the particle "ma", changing it from a negation particle to a relative pronoun, we had a huge, sudden change in meaning --- as if it appeared from nowhere!!! Recall that? That is just like magic, isn't it? There are many other aspects of the Quran that makes it behave like "slight-of-hand magic" Hopefully, in the future we may get to discuss such aspects Regards
Everything makes sense except that the Aya says "When your lord said to the angels". I don't understand why Allah would say it to the angels and then the Banu Israil are responding arrogantly. How did they receive the message that Allah will sent successors in the scripture? I am just asking for learning. I am very happy for every segment that Allah allows me watch and to comprehend.
Jazakallahu khair. Good point Dr., but one question.. At 45:40 as you said that the ayah suggests Allah wasn't replying to anyone, but through the scripture to all human-kind. However, there's a word "qola" prior the sentences which supposed to (as i concerned) indicates that the subject was talking/saying to 'specific' person at specific time. Or did i miss something, Dr?
"Qaala" simply means "He said". No indication of when or how, and no indication that it's in reply to anyone in a specific conversation, etc. As a matter of fact, in accordance with the acceptable "Tafseel", there is no clear indication of the subject of the verb "Qaala". It may refer to the "Khalifah". And in that regard, this last sentence of Aya 2:30 may be indicate that the "Khalifah" is retorting to the "Ba3oodah": I know things that you don't know! If you take it that way, then that sentence is a summary of the next 3 ayats.
One of the reasons I find many of your videos so long winded and difficult to actually place back into context in the Qur'an around the things you are referring to into as an overview to gain a more rounded perspective is there is too much and you seems to jump around all over the place, I personally can't even keep up with you or what you say next. If you were to take a copy of the current best english version of a translation, then fix those errors you make reference to. So that we could read the surahs with these passages fixed, that would be of far more benefit than these utube videos for me. Which I find at time obscure like ones named "why no pineapples in the Qur'an", which I personally find distracting and obscure and hard to take seriously. Also the catch frazes you now tend to use when setting up your framework, I find distracting and off putting. Especially when repeated over and over again before actually saying things of value. Things like saying you are giving us all 7 gifts this time or that. As if your video is offering extra steak knives along with the truth. I would actually really like to hear and benefit from what you are attempting to say and make reference to, and actually want to know about these translation differences you are brinfing to light in here, but I just find it painful watching these long winded videos to get there. At the end of each video have no way of using them to improve the english translation understanding. Maybe by setting up in advance so english speakers can have their Qur'an open to each surah and change the actual word out there to fix it. Then limiting each of these contents to a 5 or 10 minutes. Then start the next one. Doing Videos in some order that the wrong interpretations could actually be crossed out And replaced with what you are saying and referring to. Then we could read the better meanings in their right context and their place in the Qur'an to actually gain a better understanding of what you are referring to. Or better still, just fix a whole English translation of the Qur'an with these things you claim are wrong so we can read it understand it in this new context then accept your views or reject them. Thanks
@@MarvelousQuran We are interested in learning. Afraid that even if your explanation is correct, it will not reach the people. Lack of clarity because of mixing too many things at a time, Repetition, jumping from one to other. In the process the message is lost. Two lines should have only 2 lines as translation. Let the explanation follow. I spent 54 minutes. But the message is not clear.
@ Anon Amos Subhanallahh... The best reply to your comment is what's in the video "Why are only five fruit types mentioned in the Quran? What is Zikr and what do fruits represent?" found here th-cam.com/video/MEvSVYodS8A/w-d-xo.html. It's the one with the thumbnail that says "Why No Mango or Pineapple in the Quran?" :) Unfortunately, this is the exact video that you found, as you said, "distracting and obscure and hard to take seriously". A primary concept discussed in that video "about pineapple" is the need for patience. With all due respect, and with full love and sincerity towards you and everyone who is suffering impatience, I would recommend, my brother, to revisit your intention from watching this channel. On this channel, we are teaching the key concepts that allow you to learn two things: 1. How to avoid the problems that all available books of tafseer suffer from, including the rushed interpretation 2. How to apply the concepts of the organic Quranic methodology, coupled with some of the Abrahamic locution terms that we offer as kindling, in order to have the self discipline to have a relationship with Allahh This channel is NOT to offer you a better understanding or translation of the Quran. As we said in several videos, only Allahh can do that! This channel is ONLY to encourage you to have a direct relationship with Allahh, using the correct methodology. Take the time, and watch the above video with patience, and insha Allahh you will benefit a lot. I promise! If it does not work, take Wuduu, and watch it again! Regards
@ Anon Amos To quote your first paragraph from your original comment: "One of the reasons I find many of your videos so long winded and difficult to actually place back into context in the Qur'an around the things you are referring to into as an overview to gain a more rounded perspective is there is too much and you seems to jump around all over the place, I personally can't even keep up with you or what you say next."
There was a video of you talking about how the prophet overlooked the spelling of the Quran that was interesting but I can’t remember which video it was can you direct me ?
Our beloved SAWS oversaw the spelling of the Quran. See this video th-cam.com/video/a7aW57nf25M/w-d-xo.html and this video th-cam.com/video/lVm1g6PZVu4/w-d-xo.html and this video th-cam.com/video/_38cs71cR9g/w-d-xo.html. They all provide clear examples... When we talked about Tafseel, we also discussed the fact that the separation of sentences across multiple ayats is also evidence of divine instructions re. the script of the Quran. Regards
Surah Mariam, ayah 8: He said, "My Lord, how will I have a boy when my wife has been barren and I have reached extreme old age?" Isn't Prophet Zakariya asking for clarification or additional information from Allah?
First of all: Thank you for a great question! Do you really believe that Zakariya was speaking directly to Allahh, as you speak to your friend? Even if Zakariya was making a duaa (note the beginning of the Aya), for additional knowledge, for Allahh to show him how he would end up with a son, does that prove that the angels questioned Allahh? Or even that he was questioning Allahh? And finally, see the Aya 3:39: The angels are the ones who gave him the news of a son. Therefore, he was unsure that he received the information correctly FROM THE ANGELS! Remember, Zakariya is NOT an angel. So... Zakariya was making a duaa to receive more knowledge. Also, Ibrahim asked in a similar way (Duaa) in Aya 2:260, when Ibrahim was asking for more knowledge. This is NOT QUESTIONING, NOR CHALLENGING! One last side point: The translation you used suffers a serious error for the word "barren", whoch we will deal with later insha Allahh! Regards
@@MarvelousQuran , Angels were asking for more knowledge, can't it be so? May be they thought that they are going to be replaced by someone else since their worship was lacking something?
Im learning alot of the right understanding of our truth Quran.May Allah give more guidance to u and us sir..Love u very much..! SIRATIKALMUSTAQIM..Insyallah
Aslm, shukran for interpreting these ayats..I have a question: Ayat (2:29) implies there seven layers of understanding? But we need to convert the scripture into abstract 1st?...So in essence the Tafseer we possessed cannot give us the abstract understanding due to its flaw in methodology/interpretation, hence we have missed out completely with the seven layers of understanding?
Thank you Dr. Atchan. Question, is it at all possible for you to attach each transcript/pdf, to each video? I have a journal notebook specifically for your lectures but its too much to write down. I do take time out but with my situation its difficult to keep up. Thanks again for your hard work. May Allah (SWT) continue to inspire and guide you.🦋🌼❤
hi Dr Hany, your lecture videos and the justifications that you based on, for your findings are really compelling. Will you publish a full english translation of the Holy Quran with corrected english translation? or maybe publish a wholly English Version book of the Holy Quran? (without the arabic jawi). I would be interested to buy the e-book of such publication.
The reason I am enthusiastic about getting a copy of your English Translation version of the Holy Quran, is that your questions in this video is exactly what I have been asking myself since last year. ie. if we were always told that the angels have no free will unlike mankind, then why (in Surah Al-Baqarah) did the angels question Allah SWT when Allah SWT said that mankind shall be the khalifah on the earth. I have so far accumulated 6 Arabic-English Translation Versions of the holy Quran (for eg. Sahih International, Pickhall, Hilal Itani, Yusuf Ali, etc) and 2-3 wholly english version of the Holy Quram. But so far all are just different choices of english words of the same meaning. However, your translation (based on “locution”) changes the whole “generally accepted meaning” itself. And why I 100% agree with your findings is because your “correction” translation now makes verses in the holy Quran to make more sense to me. It is no wonder that Allah SWT has guided me to coincidentally come across your video in TH-cam and be fortunate to view these videos of yours. May Allah SWT continue to support and guide you in your efforts and more muslims (especially those whom have the same questions) are made aware of your channel and be put on the “Straight Path” by your findings. Amiin.
Qāla Rabbi Ashraĥ Lī Şadrī Wa Yassir Lī 'Amrī Wa Aĥlul `Uqdatan Min Lisānī Yafqahū Qawlī This du'a is for Fir'awn or for all people ? We're not Fir'awn, Wa salam
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA Finals D1 | Fall | ยิงต้องโหด ให้เหมือนโกรธกันมาก่อน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OnTdfGySmds/mqdefault.jpg)
SubhA this is not only mind blowing but totally a game changer. I have ways felt the 'traditional' translations to be problematic. I've been on a very long journey and InshA feel closer to the true message of the Quran than ever before. Please keep up the fantastic work ,this is vitally important for the believers. Thank you and Allah bless you with continuous enlightenment.
Alhamdulillah. Thank you too for your kind words
This has been something that has had troubled me and now clarified. Jazakallahu khairan
Subxanallah this is so beautiful and mesmerizingly mind blowing, I have noticed that actually it is not even correct grammatically to refer to الملائكة because this sounds like جمع مونث or حمع التكسير and so many other verses use ت with all the verbs that refer to the angels:
تتوفاهم، تري الملايكة، تعرج الملايكة، تنزل الملائكة تاتيهم الملايكة
So the verb would have been قلن or قالت
Thanks and Jazakallah for this unraveling this deep meaning.
Masha Allahh. So perceptive
How come others did not catch that?
Aameen! Thank you for your duas at the beginning and the end of this presentation.
There is no accountability for any being who is not given the ability to choose between "fujuur" and "taqwaa". Without this ability, it would be impossible for this being to raise any questions.
MasyaAllaah! What a great lecture, Dr. Hany! Alhamdulillaah...
Alhamdulillah
While agreeing with you that angels can never question Allah's actions my humble opinion is that you have taken the interpretation of verse 2:30 to a different metaphorical level which is controversial. However, that is your interpretation and we may ponder over it. Like I mentioned in my previous comments Quran has layers of meaning and you have dealt with a layer that was not attempted by previous interpretations of Quran. Therefore, please don't ridicule them as ignorant or arrogant. Some of them were pious predecessors of Islam.
I have learned something from your noble efforts and may Allah bless you for that.
Part of understanding the Quran ACCORDING TO THE ORGANIC QURANIC METHODOLOGY (not according to my opinion) is to understand what the Quran says about those who belied and who ignored the ayats of Allahh.
THIS IS NOT ME RIDICULING EARLIER INTERPRETERS ! THIS IS THE QURAN EXPLAINING WHY THEY DID NOT SEE THE AYATS, AND WHY THEY MISINTERPRETED AND MISGUIDED SO MANY GENERATIONS. (Capital letters used only to highlight the importance of what I am saying, not to scream!)
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran jazakallah alkhair for your explanation.
But isn't it outrageous to claim that until you apply the organic methodology all predecessors haven't interpreted Quran correctly and the Muslim umma has been ignorant during the past 1,400 years?
@ Nakeeb Issadeen
If using the "ummah" argument was valid, then the Christians, and the Jews before them, would have a much stronger claim to truth... So don't use the word "ummah" in your argument, because Allahh deals with each individual separately, not as a group... rigt?
And therefore, Here's the same question you asked, but articulated using the Quranic terminology:
"Is it outrageous to claim that an individual who belied the ayats of the Quran is misled for a long period of time?"
What is 10 such individuals belied the ayats?
What if 1 million individuals belied the ayats?
What if 100 generations belied the ayats?
I hope you see the point! I know this is Yucky and painful! But Truth is often bitter! And detoxification takes a lot of courage!
@@MarvelousQuran I will rest my case and may Allah guide all of us on the straight path.
This information is a great eye opener and make so much sense. May Allah forgive me for my ignorance.
May Allahh forgive us all, and keep us guided towards the truth
It was pretty obvious that the traditional interpretation did not make sense as to how angels could have known that God was creating a new creation that would cause bloodshed etc. as if they had the ability to access God’s knowledge as to what human beings would turn out to be like and further more when the angels consult God supposedly about Jinn on how they were corrupt and why God is creating another creation “humans” that would do the same? How did they know what God’s new creation would do? Just assumed because Jinn were corrupt beings etc.? They had access to God’s knowledge? Whenever I read it, it never made sense to me and so now your explanation Dr Hany clears it all up, thank you.
@kgdangar2 Plz watch the video before you respond to people, lest they think you are trolling
@@kgdangar2 previous scholars and pretty much every one in modern times have been so obviously wrong on so many things I think its fair to say we need a fresh approach. I'm done with all the traditionalists full stop.
@kgdnagar2
You say "Allah clearly mention in Sura Ali Imran in verse 8 "And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allah""
It's Aya 3:7, not 8. And your translation is erroneous.
We have detailed it and shown the clear interpretation for this aya
See the video here th-cam.com/video/mMqfaeiIIDw/w-d-xo.html
There is a saying in Russian:
Don't reply on my question by a question like a jew.
Amazing
Alhamdulillah, Dr. , i hv been listening to this almost since 6 months, so many times, wow, every time i get excited, so much of info u hv loaded, great, losers are those who dont concentrate on learning this knowledge. Thnx dr. HA.. may Allah gives strength, energy, more and more to u.
Even though your understanding and explanations of the Quran are so different from what scholars are teaching, the way you are glorifying Allah Almighty by giving Him all the points He owns and the way you describe the holiness of the Quran makes me fall in love with Islam again and again. This is the reason why I come here every time to hear your explanations and to reflect on true Islam. Alhamdulillah for these lectures. Thank you, Dr. Hany!
Salaamun alaykum.
Isn’t the same situation that every community goes through? They feel their understanding has been perfected and they are practicing the most purified way, so any new understanding of the scripture is blasphemous.
By Allah’s will, may He open up our hearts so we can encounter His knowledge with its pure understanding.
Excellent Masha Allahh
Salamun Alaykum. This was a paradigm shifting segment for me! Your interpretation of Aya 2:30 makes perfect sense! I cannot believe that I had glibly swallowed a flawed and fanciful interpretation for so long even though I reflected about it many times. You had promised that the new BAYYINAH in this segment will blow our minds and it did just that for me; wow! The clear evidence provided by the Ayat you expounded exposed the locution of the people of Fir3aoun without a shadow of a doubt. (I also noted the little teaser about these people being BANI ISRAEL). Indeed Allah SWT has hidden gems of knowledge in plain sight if only one has the eyes to see them. Thank you and may Allah bless you for teaching us this wonderful new tool to decipher more of what the Quran is really trying to teach us. I am keenly looking forward to the next segment on the story of adam.
Alhamdulillah brother.
alhamdulillah and thanks very much Dr Hany. new paradigm for me. please archive your work in digital format, just incase as you mentioned before. i think many of us here in this channel willing to pay for views of your extensive research works.
Insha Allah brother
Thanks a lot dr. Hany for this video. Mashallah. Alhumdulillah. ❤❤❤❤
I missed the point ‘why Allah has to inform malaikah’ on selecting adam as khalifah. So looking for this video again. Really totally a different perspective now from what I understood before. Jazakallah DH
Alhamdullilah.. Masha Allah. Beautiful!
Wallahi I was wondering about this Al-Baqara Ayat 30 and no one in my closest could answer me this question. Well they did to their best, but it just didn't feel right to me...
YOU Dr. Hany by the Help of Allah swt have opend my core (Qalb) ;) and help me to understand it correctly.
Tabarak Allah!
Shockingly exposed! tears keep flowing towards the end of your presentation ... a new unraveled piece of
information - huurun'ain - to fill my cup, my 'arash. thank you dr hany, alhamdulillah, subhaanallah.
JazakumAllahu khair Dr Hany. This ayah never made sense to me. My 10 year old was shocked and confused when in the past I had tried to erroneously explain it the traditional way. SubhaanAllah even a child knows angels don’t question their Lord.
Thank you Dr Hany. Alhamdulillalh. Waiting patiently for your next segment.
Alhamdulillah. Thank you, Beautiful interpretation
Thank you. AlhamduliLlahi
alhamdullilah, previously when i read the interpretation of tafseel, the angels asking why Allah want to create human/chaliph on earth (and the angel somehow have the knowledge of previous event that had happened on earth) -said they (this human)will create trouble and bloodshed.....my assumption was may be there are human on earth before adam, and may be the angel meant the djin who has stayed on earth created all the bloodshed.
alhamdullilah i found your translation is logical. i really dua to Allah that this is the true tafsir,and i will be in selected true believer.
May Allah bless you in every way for all of your work clarifying many things in the Nobel Quran.
Salaamoon Alaykum,
Tafseel, like it was depicted through the caravan of the siblings breaking apart from the main caravan, is a great usage and a means to epistemology itself. Beautifully delivered in this segment.
"Salamun Alikumm". Alhamdullillah. Thank U Dr Hany for the light full lecture videos. It's a very realistic video on mining
the truth of the Holy Quran which was missing for the last 1400 yrs. I have been looking for such a platform for a long time. My eyes filled with tears on viewing the video's published so far. It is a blessing for the human,
Specially we Muslims will be able to raise our heads again with the great truth ignoring the past.
Now I am so lonely on this journey with you all to find out the proper way of making supplications. I hope days are
waiting for all to return under the same umbrella.
Thanks to your team members for their efforts to help you on the way to extensive research.
MashaAllah..thanks for the good work sheikh..i would like to suggest this lecture should be peer reviewed by other scholar to improve validity of the content.
The Quranic evidence we presented is NOT enough???
Subhanallah
Thanks for the lecture dr. Hany.
Learn, unlearn, relearn
Salamun Alaikum Dr. Hany Thank you. Just wondering about two words Earth and samaawaat, ? does these words are used to mean space/layer of space (7 skies) or space and objective world( visible universe/ dimensions) in any places of Holy Quran? There are some sura/Ayah's explaining creation of universe and objects where saamawaat wal earth used? Your insight regarding this and help will be highly appreciated. Fi amanillah
Downloaded it a few minutes after you uploaded it, Alhamdulillah.
MashaAllah……no words to express and no questions to ask as no gaps in this little mind.
With regards to river flows underneath jannaat, ayat 14:32 explains it……is it Dr Hany? Thank you so much. Forever indebted. Wasalam
Faithful. Grateful. Beautiful
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
0:34 The Concept of Unlearning and Re-learning
2:34 A Special DuƐāꜤ
3:32 In This Segment
4:57 We Assume That You Understand
6:04 Reminder About بَعُوضَةٌ “Ba3ūḍatun”
7:00 Aya 2:28-29 from Sūrah Al-Baqarah
15:03 Aya 2:30 - Prelude to ādam’s Story
22:06 The Problem With Claiming the Angels Questioned Allahh?
26:18 Bayyinah: When a Question is NOT a Question!
41:34 Aya 2:30 (Cont.)
47:25 The Oath Taken By Allahh SWT of All the Prophets
49:43 What Happens to People Who Belie the Ayat of the QurꜤān?
53:59 Outro
Thank you very much... Uploaded
Al7amdoelillahh Al7amdoelillahh Al7amdoelillahh!
Masha’Allahh JazakaAllahu Khairan Dr. Hany
I hope I'm making comment on right video. Making a statement in an interrogative way is really bizarre way of communicating.
Well explained dr. Hany. I really get it.
Yes you are correct
This segment answered "1000 questions I had it in mind" . Allahu Akbar
Rewatched this segment, what apowerful presentation of the interpretation of that aya."2:30".
I also got stuck here how angels asked allah subhan wa ta ala and how they know that mankind will make corruption in the world even the sunnah of sahaba is that they never answer what they dont know they always used to say allah and his rasul saw knows better.
Salaam from Kashmir.
Sir, Please share the Print out in the Description via Google Drive so that it becomes Easy to Memorise the Verses after your Explanation & please make the Arabic font better
Salaamun Alaykum to all, Alhamdulillah
It’s so true
Befor this video I think God Almighty Engage in discusses With his creation, to give more of understanding
Alhamdulillah !
Alhamdulillah.. thank you.
Asa Rabbi ayyahdhiyani sawa as sabil
I pray for my Lord to guide me to the balanced way.
Assamulaikum Dr Hani,
May Allah give your strength and good health always to pursue your great efforts. I have followed and comprehended almost all your past segments and looking forward for more. It hurts each time to watch local TV network going on ‘story telling’ unchecked to millions, the tafseer of the Holy Quran based on writing of earlier mufassiruns and interpreters. May Allah guide and show them the right direction to learn, unlearn and relearn.
Aameen. We have a lot of work to do
salamun aleykum Dr. Please when you do the story of Adam, please address all the ayat pertain to him. We really need to learn
Subhanallah! May Allah bless you, Ameen!
It actually makes sense, cause how can an angel question God's action? It just doesn't work like that, again I ask my question over and over; what other lies have I been told?
Keep asking my brother
Glory to Allah who granted me the opportunity to understand the scripture as it should be understood.
Wonderful lecture. 100% agree with your translation Dr Hany .
Allah is authoritative. The supposed conversation with the angels questioning him doesn't give to Allah SWT his true reverence .
Thanks Dr. Hany
Salamun alaykum
Alhamdullilah keep going it short and perfect
Salaamun Alaykum Alhamdulillah
Salaamun Alaykum. What a splendid segment and discovery from within the Qur'an. This has cleared up so much confusion in our tradition. Sad that we did not give Allahh SWT his due reverence in regards to the understanding of this story. Alhumdulillah we can now see clearly the truth.
Takeaway .... ALLAHH IS NEVER QUESTIONED REGARDING WHAT HE UNDERTAKES TO DO....PEOPLE OF SHEIKHS USTAZ PLEASE GET THIS IN YOUR DAILY REMINDERS
Alhamdulillah
Thank you Dr Hany… ❤️
14:41 that's exactly one of my vague understanding in understanding Quran, but I cannot express it in a good sentences. And you did that. Remarkable!!
Alhamdulillah. Great minds think alike :)
@@MarvelousQuran salamun aleykum Dr. Please when you do the story of Adam, please address all the ayat pertain to him. We really need to learn
@@MarvelousQuran Waw....thanks for this reply. This very reply is exactly what I'm expecting :). It pooves 100% indication that you're just another modern world's 'fitnah' or 'syubha' for ummah. Such an arrogant reply, far from humble and understanding that everything that happen is because of Allah's permissions, including your 'so called' great mind :). Alhamdulillah Allah quickly showed me who you really are.
@@udinsalam4751 whats with you ?
@Udin Salam
Do you see the smiley face at the end of my reply?
In case you are not familiar with this icon, it means that it's a joke!
Regardless, thank you for your words!
This is mind blowing! if i understood correctly this group of people are rejecting any scripture or prophet sent by Allah mostly because they believe any new revelation or knowledge should pass through them only and on that basis CHOOSE not to believe. This is Arrogance and Super Ego on an unbelievable scale. God Bless you for this information and you are right it does form the basis of the Holy Quran
Thank you, and Allah bless you with continued enlightenment
This tafseer makes more sense than any other tafseer I've ever heard
Absolutely Loving your work. Perhaps part of the Locution of the Bani Israeel is to ask Rhetorical Questions. It’s at least a lot easier to understand it that way.
Assalamualaikum, respected sir why is Allah telling malaika what he is going to do...and then why are baudah replying while they were not addressed about khalifa in previous ayat
@ Imran Bangash
This segment is part of a series. Unless you watch the series, there are many concepts that you missed...
The Ba3udah is mentioned 4 ayats earlier... You think it is irrelevant?
Or maybe you think Ba3udah means mosquito?????
This puts the the narration in Surah Sa'ad regarding Allah Subhanahu giving respite to Iblees in a completely different light. I really would like your explanation. Shukran.
We will discuss the issue of Ibliss in a future segment insha Allahh
💞
Salamon alaykom brother im very amaze on what you geven to us ldo you have a group that i can learn about
Thank you
You're welcome
Subhanallah. Amazing
Thank you
I've always wonder why would the angels questioned Allah SWT? Thank you for sharing Dr. Hanny.
I appreciate Dr. Hany efforts, and well presented videos, but after viewing more than a handful of his videos, it appears to me that all his efforts are directed towards explaining the Quran metaphorically.. and reveal well hidden meanings, and hidden "bayinat", as if the Quran was only revealed for highly deep thinking, highly philosophical persons and this is not the case. In my opinion, we should take a break, zoom out a bit, and find simplicity in the Quran.
@ Sharif TABBARA
Obviously you need a break.
In the meantime, we are loosing the educated Muslims and the youths by the millions...You go ahead and stay at the superficial layer...
The rest of us are enjoying diving into the beautiful nuggets of wisdom deposited below the superficial layer.
Salamun Alaykom, I always wondered why would Angel's be questioning Allah (SWT) I thought they have no free will and supposed to be obedient. There was another bogus story about Harut and Marut questioning Allah that they are better than human and sent to earth etc.
@@takisaki1503 I don't know, I just read books and heard from people
Me too.
Salamun Alaykum wr wb do you have english translation of the quran based on this new amazing findings ?
Salaamun Alaykum... Working on it insha Allahh
@Marvelous Quran: Can you elaborate more on last sentence of this Ayat.
قَالَ اِنِّىۡٓ اَعۡلَمُ مَا لَا تَعۡلَمُوۡنَ. Your translation do not specify anything about word used on this sentence.
Coming in a future segment insha Allahh, soon.
Assalamualaikum Dr Hany, Thank you for your presentation and tafseel. Really appreciated it,
Btw, I would like to ask regarding why you put the "A" in "Adam" as lower case letter "a". Been through the whole lecture in this video then only realized it was not addressed.
Hope you can help and guide us more about it ya. 🙏. Thank you!
Soon insha Allahh
@@MarvelousQuran Aaaminnn
Slamun Alikum dear Brother.
I am a regular flower of you channel. I really appreciate your efforts. May Allah swt gives you hayat and energy to serve the Muslim ummah, enlighten them with the correct interpretation of Holly Quran. Brother I have query regards to the word Samawat and Samaawaat. According to your previous lecture you said samawat means heaven or sky while samaawaat is a Abrahamic locution means understanding. But in this segment 2:28 you said Samawat as understanding, or seven layers of understanding. Pl clarify my doubts. May Allah bless you. Thank.
There is no samawaat in the Quran. Only samaawaat, meaning layers of understanding
Salaam alaikum. Please make a video about nafs and ruh. Are these two are same or different?
Insha Allahh
So it is similar to a numerical series like 1,2,3 next is 1,2,3, ? And like that sometimes mat be 1,? 3, 4, 5,? Is this pattern of understanding is closer to you? I mean, always not the very words, but the momentum of the construction of the sentences will carry the metaphor to catch the intrinsic meaning?
Please i need subtitle to clearly understand your incredibly work and learn more about my religion may allah reward you
Noted. But TH-cam is delaying the subtitles for reasons beyond our control. Sorry my brother
Barakallahofik but im a sister !
Asalāmu’alaikim Sir,
Absolutely Commendable, keep up the great work no words to show our gratitude for the amazing translations and revealing of the truth from the Quran. 👍👍🙏🏻
Happy to have you aboard this journey
Wa'alaikum salaam wrwb...masya Allaah. Jzklh brother Dr Hany...may Allaah open our hearts to unlearn for a relearn. Insyaa Allaah
Alikom Salam a nice lecture about the troubles with text and words in the Quran.... Can you please explain [2-33] قَالَ يَٰٓـَٔادَمُ أَنۢبِئۡهُم بِأَسۡمَآئِهِمۡۖ فَلَمَّآ أَنۢبَأَهُم بِأَسۡمَآئِهِمۡ قَالَ أَلَمۡ أَقُل لَّكُمۡ إِنِّيٓ أَعۡلَمُ غَيۡبَ ٱلسَّمَٰوَٰتِ وَٱلۡأَرۡضِ وَأَعۡلَمُ مَا تُبۡدُونَ وَمَا كُنتُمۡ تَكۡتُمُونَ In this verse is really confusing me because first Adam is telling them the "names" and than I think that Allah s.w.t. is telling “ "Have I not told you that I know the invisible in the heavens and in the earth, and that I know what you reveal and what you keep hidden?" what does this verse really mean ??
@ Jamal Larossi
As we said, the same one who told them about their labels also told then, in their locution: Did I not tell you, etc..." meaning "I have not told you, etc..." which means that Allahh is the one who told me so.
Alhamdulillah: JazakAllah Kairn! May Allah forgive us......how we failed to apprehend and question, especially given that the Ayah is in distinct contradiction to what we [most muslims ] have been taught as one of the major attributes of Angels: that they only execute as Commanded by Allah....no questions.
Alhamdulillah
Dr. Hany please tell us, what is the magic that has been talked by Baudah in these verses. What is the magic that has been often used in the Quran.
Do you recall the amazing transformation in meaning for the last 3 words in Aya 2:71, in the Video about "How to Circumcise a she-cow?" --- starting at min. 44:40
Simply by making a small "Tafseel" change to the particle "ma", changing it from a negation particle to a relative pronoun, we had a huge, sudden change in meaning --- as if it appeared from nowhere!!!
Recall that? That is just like magic, isn't it?
There are many other aspects of the Quran that makes it behave like "slight-of-hand magic"
Hopefully, in the future we may get to discuss such aspects
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran alhumdulillah.. Wonderful Dr. Hany, thanks for answering
Regards 😊
Assalam aleikum. Please upload the video again
Please upload the video again. It is still not streaming after many hours.
Try again
It says “no stream”.. is anyone else having issues viewing this video.
give it time. I am able to see it fine. Others are telling me that they can't open it yet
and me
SubhahanAllah....just finished watching
A'udhubillahi An Akuna Minal Jahilin....
Watched at last! Alhamdulillah
Everything makes sense except that the Aya says "When your lord said to the angels". I don't understand why Allah would say it to the angels and then the Banu Israil are responding arrogantly. How did they receive the message that Allah will sent successors in the scripture? I am just asking for learning. I am very happy for every segment that Allah allows me watch and to comprehend.
As we explained, when "Allahh said to the angels" it means that Allahh provided scripture
Jazakallahu khair. Good point Dr., but one question.. At 45:40 as you said that the ayah suggests Allah wasn't replying to anyone, but through the scripture to all human-kind. However, there's a word "qola" prior the sentences which supposed to (as i concerned) indicates that the subject was talking/saying to 'specific' person at specific time. Or did i miss something, Dr?
"Qaala" simply means "He said". No indication of when or how, and no indication that it's in reply to anyone in a specific conversation, etc. As a matter of fact, in accordance with the acceptable "Tafseel", there is no clear indication of the subject of the verb "Qaala". It may refer to the "Khalifah". And in that regard, this last sentence of Aya 2:30 may be indicate that the "Khalifah" is retorting to the "Ba3oodah": I know things that you don't know!
If you take it that way, then that sentence is a summary of the next 3 ayats.
One of the reasons I find many of your videos so long winded and difficult to actually place back into context in the Qur'an around the things you are referring to into as an overview to gain a more rounded perspective is there is too much and you seems to jump around all over the place, I personally can't even keep up with you or what you say next.
If you were to take a copy of the current best english version of a translation, then fix those errors you make reference to.
So that we could read the surahs with these passages fixed, that would be of far more benefit than these utube videos for me.
Which I find at time obscure like ones named "why no pineapples in the Qur'an", which I personally find distracting and obscure and hard to take seriously.
Also the catch frazes you now tend to use when setting up your framework, I find distracting and off putting. Especially when repeated over and over again before actually saying things of value.
Things like saying you are giving us all 7 gifts this time or that.
As if your video is offering extra steak knives along with the truth.
I would actually really like to hear and benefit from what you are attempting to say and make reference to, and actually want to know about these translation differences you are brinfing to light in here,
but I just find it painful watching these long winded videos to get there.
At the end of each video have no way of using them to improve the english translation understanding.
Maybe by setting up in advance so english speakers can have their Qur'an open to each surah and change the actual word out there to fix it.
Then limiting each of these contents to a 5 or 10 minutes.
Then start the next one. Doing
Videos in some order that the wrong interpretations could actually be crossed out And replaced with what you are saying and
referring to.
Then we could read the better meanings in their right context and their place in the Qur'an to actually gain a better understanding of what you are referring to.
Or better still, just fix a whole English translation of the Qur'an with these things you claim are wrong so we can read it understand it in this new context then accept your views or reject them.
Thanks
Noted. Thank you
@@MarvelousQuran
We are interested in learning. Afraid that even if your explanation is correct, it will not reach the people. Lack of clarity because of mixing too many things at a time, Repetition, jumping from one to other. In the process the message is lost.
Two lines should have only 2 lines as translation. Let the explanation follow. I spent 54 minutes. But the message is not clear.
@ Anon Amos
Subhanallahh... The best reply to your comment is what's in the video "Why are only five fruit types mentioned in the Quran? What is Zikr and what do fruits represent?" found here th-cam.com/video/MEvSVYodS8A/w-d-xo.html. It's the one with the thumbnail that says "Why No Mango or Pineapple in the Quran?" :)
Unfortunately, this is the exact video that you found, as you said, "distracting and obscure and hard to take seriously".
A primary concept discussed in that video "about pineapple" is the need for patience.
With all due respect, and with full love and sincerity towards you and everyone who is suffering impatience, I would recommend, my brother, to revisit your intention from watching this channel. On this channel, we are teaching the key concepts that allow you to learn two things:
1. How to avoid the problems that all available books of tafseer suffer from, including the rushed interpretation
2. How to apply the concepts of the organic Quranic methodology, coupled with some of the Abrahamic locution terms that we offer as kindling, in order to have the self discipline to have a relationship with Allahh
This channel is NOT to offer you a better understanding or translation of the Quran. As we said in several videos, only Allahh can do that!
This channel is ONLY to encourage you to have a direct relationship with Allahh, using the correct methodology.
Take the time, and watch the above video with patience, and insha Allahh you will benefit a lot. I promise!
If it does not work, take Wuduu, and watch it again!
Regards
@ Anon Amos
To quote your first paragraph from your original comment:
"One of the reasons I find many of your videos so long winded and difficult to actually place back into context in the Qur'an around the things you are referring to into as an overview to gain a more rounded perspective is there is too much and you seems to jump around all over the place, I personally can't even keep up with you or what you say next."
There was a video of you talking about how the prophet overlooked the spelling of the Quran that was interesting but I can’t remember which video it was can you direct me ?
Our beloved SAWS oversaw the spelling of the Quran. See this video th-cam.com/video/a7aW57nf25M/w-d-xo.html and this video th-cam.com/video/lVm1g6PZVu4/w-d-xo.html and this video th-cam.com/video/_38cs71cR9g/w-d-xo.html. They all provide clear examples...
When we talked about Tafseel, we also discussed the fact that the separation of sentences across multiple ayats is also evidence of divine instructions re. the script of the Quran.
Regards
Hope you can give me cop❤y of marvolous quran wed complet translation
Surah Mariam, ayah 8:
He said, "My Lord, how will I have a boy when my wife has been barren and I have reached extreme old age?"
Isn't Prophet Zakariya asking for clarification or additional information from Allah?
First of all: Thank you for a great question!
Do you really believe that Zakariya was speaking directly to Allahh, as you speak to your friend?
Even if Zakariya was making a duaa (note the beginning of the Aya), for additional knowledge, for Allahh to show him how he would end up with a son, does that prove that the angels questioned Allahh? Or even that he was questioning Allahh?
And finally, see the Aya 3:39: The angels are the ones who gave him the news of a son. Therefore, he was unsure that he received the information correctly FROM THE ANGELS! Remember, Zakariya is NOT an angel.
So... Zakariya was making a duaa to receive more knowledge. Also, Ibrahim asked in a similar way (Duaa) in Aya 2:260, when Ibrahim was asking for more knowledge. This is NOT QUESTIONING, NOR CHALLENGING!
One last side point: The translation you used suffers a serious error for the word "barren", whoch we will deal with later insha Allahh!
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran , Angels were asking for more knowledge, can't it be so? May be they thought that they are going to be replaced by someone else since their worship was lacking something?
On my iPhone, I see the message no Stream while on the three different computers, I can watch the video without any issue. even if I am not logged in
Im learning alot of the right understanding of our truth Quran.May Allah give more guidance to u and us sir..Love u very much..! SIRATIKALMUSTAQIM..Insyallah
Aslm, shukran for interpreting these ayats..I have a question: Ayat (2:29) implies there seven layers of understanding? But we need to convert the scripture into abstract 1st?...So in essence the Tafseer we possessed cannot give us the abstract understanding due to its flaw in methodology/interpretation, hence we have missed out completely with the seven layers of understanding?
Seven layers above the scriipture
Shukran...May Allah reward you for allowing me and soo many others this glimpse of Inspiration 😁
Alhamdulillah 🥰🌹❤❤❤
Thank you Dr. Atchan. Question, is it at all possible for you to attach each transcript/pdf, to each video? I have a journal notebook specifically for your lectures but its too much to write down. I do take time out but with my situation its difficult to keep up. Thanks again for your hard work. May Allah (SWT) continue to inspire and guide you.🦋🌼❤
or Dr Hany archive his work and we pay for view. that also will help him financially for his works.
hi Dr Hany, your lecture videos and the justifications that you based on, for your findings are really compelling. Will you publish a full english translation of the Holy Quran with corrected english translation? or maybe publish a wholly English Version book of the Holy Quran? (without the arabic jawi). I would be interested to buy the e-book of such publication.
Working on the translation insha Allahh
Syukur Alhamdulillah, I shall await patiently for it. Thank you for your reply. May Allah SWT is pleased with your efforts and grant you paradise.
The reason I am enthusiastic about getting a copy of your English Translation version of the Holy Quran, is that your questions in this video is exactly what I have been asking myself since last year. ie. if we were always told that the angels have no free will unlike mankind, then why (in Surah Al-Baqarah) did the angels question Allah SWT when Allah SWT said that mankind shall be the khalifah on the earth. I have so far accumulated 6 Arabic-English Translation Versions of the holy Quran (for eg. Sahih International, Pickhall, Hilal Itani, Yusuf Ali, etc) and 2-3 wholly english version of the Holy Quram. But so far all are just different choices of english words of the same meaning. However, your translation (based on “locution”) changes the whole “generally accepted meaning” itself. And why I 100% agree with your findings is because your “correction” translation now makes verses in the holy Quran to make more sense to me. It is no wonder that Allah SWT has guided me to coincidentally come across your video in TH-cam and be fortunate to view these videos of yours. May Allah SWT continue to support and guide you in your efforts and more muslims (especially those whom have the same questions) are made aware of your channel and be put on the “Straight Path” by your findings. Amiin.
Aameen. And thank you brother. I am so lucky to have brothers and sisters like you, joining us on this beautiful journey
Subhanallah. “Your way Allah “
Angels don't question God, we humans do.
Qāla Rabbi Ashraĥ Lī Şadrī
Wa Yassir Lī 'Amrī
Wa Aĥlul `Uqdatan Min Lisānī
Yafqahū Qawlī This du'a is for Fir'awn or for all people ? We're not Fir'awn, Wa salam
Assalamu alaikum,,,n what about the names that angles learned from Allah,,,Adam recalled it n angles did not ,, please tell
Sir,Can u explain Sura 5:18.... jews, Don't think God as a father.