Train Automation at Chadwick Model Railway | 108.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ส.ค. 2020
- Train Automation might be easier than you think at Chadwick Model Railway.
Patreon Link. www.patreon.com/bePatron?u=15...
Donation Link. paypal.me/ChadwickModelRailway
www.amazon.co.uk/shop/chadwic...
www.dcctrainautomation.co.uk
Callum's Channel / sdjr7f88
Affiliate Links.
Heat-Shrink Tubing Printer amzn.to/2B87Sfu
Printer Heat-Shrink Tubing amzn.to/3duEuwX
Bosch Hot Glue Gun amzn.to/2VWtK6X
Ferrule Crimping Tool amzn.to/2TpJ4FU
12 way Terminal Block amzn.to/39IZNd5
8 way Terminal Block amzn.to/2Q7NxeJ
Plug-in Terminal Blocks amzn.to/2zjyA3L
WERA Screwdriver set amzn.to/2ZX0VJu
Magnetic Clamps amzn.to/2Nczc0y
Makita Drill amzn.to/2ZSJaLr
New Battery Dremel amzn.to/32CC8r4
Sculptamold amzn.to/2Wh5RGr
Polystyrene Cutter goo.gl/GpWgWp
Iwata Airbrush goo.gl/P1ABXd
Compressor amzn.to/2MKItc1
Com Art Paints amzn.to/2KFuDKn
Laser level amzn.to/2KRA5Y9
Soldering Iron amzn.to/2XPkKhM
Helping Hand amzn.to/2qOt0Oy
Miniature Camera goo.gl/UzYWp6
Optical Visor goo.gl/ljSzBi
Magnifier Table Lamp goo.gl/seg8Dj
Fire Extinguisher amzn.to/34FEBCN
First Aid Kit amzn.to/2AhaWSk
Video Gear
Video Camera (4K) goo.gl/Q36cAY
Microphone goo.gl/RqY6MR
Old Sony Camera goo.gl/r8ao7k - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Swiss Stage DAY 3 // FPX vs GEN | G2 vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9lFnPhYhBIg/mqdefault.jpg)
I’ll just sit over here in the corner with my dunce hat on...As soon as I seen all the flashy lights and wiring I had brain strain but it looks really cool it’s truly amazing how far this hobby has gone
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Steamhead101. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Automation is something I struggled with at first as I could not understand it at first , there were very few videos on you tube 10 years ago..
Now its all running great and I work trains manual and auto..with complex routes working on three trains its great to see all the points fire in a few seconds and the trains stop and go etc....
Auromation is another hobby on its own I think...
great vid Charlie.......
Jim
I totally agree but ..................... it's very adictive!
@@ChadwickModelRailway I am getting my friday evening fix now....lol
I look forward to watching it early saturday morning with my first cup of coffee.
It’s a date Andrew
Hi Charlie - as a recent returner to model railways and DCC in particular, you have become my go-to person for advice/instruction from your brilliant videos. Your style really chimes with me and as a consequence I've learned a great deal very quickly. Keep up the great work!!
What a heartwarming, comment, Chris, and very much appreciated. Regards Charlie
Hi Charlie. Just bought a simple shuttle from Block Signalling and they have now updated it so now they have done away with the need for external diodes! Much easier!
Regards Alan
Thanks Alan I’ll have to check it out
I'm not a model railway owner or maker but this is a beautiful hobby. Very absorbing, peaceful and fun.
Thanks RB, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it mate. Regards Charlie
Tremendously helpful. The layout I'm planning will be five staging tracks (American for fiddle tracks) through a double ladder to four station tracks, all on a lower level to represent a below-grade station in a fictional town west-north-west of Amsterdam. Above the station will be a city scene with streetcars, and both the lower level and city scene will be fully automatic if I can just get my act together and start figuring out the tremendous amount of planning, wiring and programming that I need to do. (There's be a freight line to the left of the city scene on the upper level that will be DCC but not automated.) And all of this in N-scale (gauge), Dutch trains running on Kato Unitrack on a shelf 15" deep in a room that is also my office, our exercise and yoga room and a guest bedroom that sleeps 3 but is no more than 10 by 12 feet in our 1920s craftsman cape in Upstate New York. Your videos are so very helpful! Thank you!
Blimey MM, you have a huge amount of work ahead of you. A friend of mine once said, make sure that you are young enough to see it through!
@@ChadwickModelRailway It’s only 4 meters long, and the lower level is essentially unscenicked. Because of the many challenges I was considering starting a YT channel and recording it all but I share your friend’s concerns and don’t want to divest myself too much. - Maarten
I'm sorry but when Charlie sat down with a book and glasses, I def considered it was going to be Jackanory. "the wicked witch who stole the trains"?
Now that comment certainly made me chuckle Leslie. Regards Charlie
Oh My! The whiteboard is out so I know I need to concentrate :-)
Be brave Bill.
now pay attention class
Charlie, where were you 30+years ago? ....lol man you make this a lot more simpler than try to figure it out your self. Like it was back in the day. Thank you so much for doing this.
I’m so pleased that you found it interesting mate.
Hi Charlie,
The most lucid explanation on computer control I've ever come come across. I've experimented for years with DIY computer programs with limited
success but this program opens up new hope that one day I may achieve what I'm after. Anything you have to offer in the future on the subject would
be very welcome. Well done Charlie. Regards.
Thanks Indigo, I’m so pleased that you found it interesting, regards Charlie
@@ChadwickModelRailway Hi Charlie... What happens if you shut down your railway and shift the trains, or locos to different
locations on your layout and then switch the layout back on. Does the computer system find the trains new locations on your
computer program track plan? or does it bring up the old locations? I've never seemed to have been able to find any solid answer
to this. Regards indigoDVW NZ
Good video, thanks. This confirms my thinking that it was so much easier and cheaper to do simple automation, like shuttleing, in old DC systems. Today, If I want to do the same in DCC, I need to invest hundreds in a computerized system in addition to the central DCC system. Or to make an isolated DC trackage beside the DCC trackage. Or, to feed the current to isolated trackage via a DC/DCC switch.
I’m so pleased that you found the video useful, regards Charlie
Amazing...the many facets of this hobby people still think of as a circle of track around the Christmas tree.
There is a niche for everyone. I am fortunate to have a member of my work crew who is a retired signal man on the railroad. Loves to wire mine and other railroads 😁.
So I see signals on my layout in the future but the trains are operated by the crews so I don’t see computer control ahead. Fascinating video.
Thank you Charlie.
Ps I’ve put the signalman onto your channel and I’m sure we will be hearing all about loco net at tonight’s session 🚂
Thanks Joe, I’m so pleased that you have found the channel interesting.
Inspiring to say the least. Wiring is fun. It never scared me. The more complicated it get, the more I dive into it. Who know? Maybe one day I will be into block detection .. got a laptop for it too hahaha
Beware, computer control can be addictive SPL.
@@ChadwickModelRailway hahaha so what else is new? Been around them most of m,y life, even at work :) Long time ago now :)
Very good demonstration. Thanks. Easier than programming an arduino.
Thanks Mark, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it, regards Charlie
Great treatise Charlie, thanks for posting.
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Dean. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Than you Sir, from Spain, outstanding channel.
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Jose Rico. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Every time I think of a subject matter I need to learn and move into you seem to release a video that corresponds... Great video, helped my simple little mind understand it!
Alan I'm so pleased that you found the video useful.
Regards Charlie
Wiring and programming sounds fun
It taxes my little grey cells!
Another good article, Charlie.
Thanks Nigel I’m so pleased you enjoyed it
Um. I think I need to run that again. Well done Charlie
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Clive. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Absolutely brilliant Charlie. Great info
Thanks Alan, you’re too kind
See, now this is exactly the kind of thing that fascinates me these days Charlie, because back in the days when I did have a railway none of this stuff was even heard of.I used to have a layout that spanned something like twenty seven feet by sixteen, I'm possibly going back to something like 1976 (ish) here, even back then my clever cloggs brother had worked out a very crude system where he could make trains stop and start by regulating the current to the track. To cut a long story very short, his system did actually work, no control over speed of approach or anything like that, but he did come up with a way of making trains stop at red signals and they wouldn't move again until that signal went to (off) green. This is one of the main reasons I love following stuff like you and other people of course, post. The stuff you guys do these days is just a natural progression of that bizarre idea my brother had all those years ago. This channel is easily my favourite from all the model railway vlogs I follow and if it wasn't for the cost I could quiet easily start setting up another layout after watching your posts and try to catch up on all things I used to wish I had back in those days. Great work Charlie.... Keep it coming and thank you.
What a cracking comment Jon. Yes things have travelled a long way since the 1970s but the complexity has led to wonderful functionality. Clearly something that I now enjoy, regards Charlie
Charlie, I really don't know how you do it!
This is fascinating to me as when I was modelling, the most technical item was the old Hornby black colour light signal with the big yellow on/on switch (come on, who remembers that one?!) Just watching your amazing inspirational video about how to setup an automated sequence and develop it truly blew me sideways. Train Controller looks looks more like a modern signal box than a model railway. The capability available to modellers today could not even be dreamed about when I had my layout and as usual, you make it informative, interesting and a joy to watch.
That probably applies to a lot of us peeps of a certain age on here Simon 😆
Hi Simon, time managment is always a struggle but with complexity comes confusion! Regards Charlie
Thanks for a great info. Combinning equipment you have and showing really good practical exsamples of train control and movment.
Thanks Dave, regards Charlie.
one of the best videos ever. lots of new information i learned today. would like to see series on start to end for the dcc setup.
I shall add it to the list.
Hello Charlie, Bruce from St. Paul, Minnesota in the USA. I wanted to congratulate You on the time, no matter how frustrating it can get, I have been literally fascinated by You're videos and I am also a fan and a subscriber. I am an N Scale modeler and stuck on stupid when it comes to the UK currency. I have tried to purchase a few things in the UK from a few Vendors and it never happens.
You and another UK guy Tim use to be FMR is now, I am 61 years old and having a brain fart, something else. He and You have taken the time to show some of Us , no matter what scale We are into,
some do's and don'ts in this all inspiring Hobby. We all need to learn something new or different, even if it's to admire someone else's work or even their mistakes to help each other. I enjoy You're work and the kindness in respect You display while helping Us modelers. I wanted to say from my heart with respect to You, thank you. Keep up the wonderful job, when you enjoy something its no longer a job, now is it? Haha 😄. Stay Safe, You and You're family . Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours. Bruce
What a heartwarming comment Bruce. I’m so pleased that you enjoy the channel and it’s comments such as yours that make it worthwhile.
Ooooh my friend pleasure is all mine. If You get a chance to Check Out Tim's channel Island Scenics n scale TH-cam channel.
I am greatly appreciative of You guys in the UK. And love You're since of humor. I understand You and Tim are into photography . I have a great time watching your videos and his.
Stay safe and blessings to You and your family.
Here in Minnesota the Virus is up 82%, according to our Governor. Hopefully it doesn't affect You're family or You.
Keep up the wonderful work and the smiles You put on a lot of faces in this Wonderful Hobby. Bruce
Another great video Charlie. Very interesting, thank you
Thanks Andy I’m so pleased you found it interesting.
My layout is automated with ITrain and the associated Digikeijs hardware. I have lots of videos on this and it's ace to have!
Sounds terrific buddy.
Finally got to watch latest video. Enjoyed the content and hoping to install a automated system. Thankyou
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it Stephen
Thank goodness! I thought you were either sick or hailed up on a Bahamian beach taking a well earned (TH-cam paid for) break haha...excellent to watch this evening and get on with the learning...notebook out.....cheers
Thanks Simon, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it, regards Charlie
In one of your older videos, someone suggested to use automobile audio-damping material underneath the layout board to reduce the train rattle. I added the suggestion to use those 4x8 feet foam insulation boards.... thinking that they would be easy and quick to install.... at least they would be easy before the tracks, etc are laid.
- Hope this helps.. God Bless.
A good suggestion and I will try once the rtracks are ballasted as that's when they tend to become noisier.
Well, that made a lot of sense! Being a single operator on my layout I can see how helpful it would be to allow a passenger train to loop the layout on automation while I am running the mine train up and down the mountain line. You did a very good job explaining that concept.
I’m so pleased that you found it useful, regards Charlie
Thanks Charlie. Interesting oversight. My dad (who was the electrics genius on our big DC layout) did a lot this with relays, but essentially the same as you describe, but analogue, not digital. You'd have hated it: all that noise of the relays firing! But we didn't have sound locos 30+ years ago, so it didn't matter. When we extended the layout in the 80s, we built in a 12 track shadow station (as the Germans would call it) - not a fiddle yard as there was no fiddling hands involved, and not a marshalling yard as it was all below the sceniced baseboards. That shadow station was controlled by a diode matrix: something I happened to come across in an old Railway Modeller, and my dad made work for the layout. When one train arrived, it would stop, and the next train would then depart, setting the entry points to the free line. I couldn't tell you how on earth it worked (apart from breaks in the track, sprung points and a shed load of diodes), but it was great: you could set a train off on a circuit including the shadow station, and it would be about 25-30 minutes before you saw it again.
It’s guys like your father, who have a brain is the size of a planet. A great insight into your past Andrew, thank you regards Charlie
I can not go done the DCC route as the more videos I watch the more I learn what it can do and as you said the costs go into the hundreds and that is beyond my pocket. If my son Jason does show more interest in Model Railways and less in his phone, then maybe at some stage he may go DCC and by then it will be another much larger kettle of fish, but maybe easier to install as more and more electronic come into it and less wiring. Have a good two weeks and thanks for another interesting video. Martin. (Thailand)
Hi Martin, yes this one is getting far too complicated for most of us! Stay safe regards Charlie
Another cracking video. This hobby is amazing, it just keeps giving, thanks to contributors such as you Charlie!
What a heart warming comment Fircombe Hall Railway OO Gauge. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Excellent video. Thanks Charlie
Thanks Dave.
Brilliant stuff, Charlie. Thank you. Been thinking of dabbling in shuttles. This has given me a taster.
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it RM
Whilst I am waiting to have our dream home to truely break out into a dedicated space for a layout, the idea of going DCC is quiet interesting to me and a great deal of time and research for a design that suits me, in the meantime vids like this give me an understanding of the concepts and principles behind a layout and hopefully I'll be able to incorporate this into my layout, thanks Charlie!
It seems you have a great adventure in front of you, as long of course, that it’s DCC. Regards Charlie
Smashing mate, very instructive. And didn't have to dodge "she who must be obeyed" once.
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Robin. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Most interesting video 👍🏽 As a user of DCC I have been experimenting with automation without a PC through the use of various methods including the Lenz ABC braking modules which require the fitting of Lenz decoders . Another way is to setup the command station to perform shuttling operations again without a PC in sight . The Marklin CS3 as well as the ESU ECoS are more than capable of achieving that and even the old technology Uhlenbrock Intellibox ( Loconet ) will do nicely
I am aware of ABC Braking and perhaps I ought to do a video on it.
The beauty of the Digikeijs stuff to me is you can use practically anything you like with it. Your digitrax handsets will all work - they just need plugging into the appropriate port in the DR5000 with the usual curly cable or the appropriate digitrax reciever needs plugging in to the DR5000 and then you can use the radio or infrared feature of the digitrax handset as normal.
I have a roco wlanmaus handset running my DR5000. The large round control knob suits my oafish way of controlling things perfectly! The dr5000 has a built in router and I've connected the roco handset to it that way. The range is great. I've had my wife stand in the railway room in the front of the house and I've walked half way down the garden with the handset and pressed various buttons and the layout has behaved exactly as it has been commanded to do.
What I really like about your digitrax handset is the dual control knobs - seems to add an element of labour saving when you have a handset with only one control knob.
You say you've "got too much invested" in digitrax to consider swapping, well who says you have to sell up and swap?
If you are interested in having a play with digikeijs then you don't HAVE to get rid of what you have. That's what makes it unique. All of your stuff can be used with a DR5000 if you like. You can even mix and match with other brands. You aren't trapped into having to keep spending with digitrax if you want to add more modules.
Even your digitrax command station could be re-used if you want with a dr5000, I believe there's a couple of pins you change on the front to convert the command station into a booster module and it then acts as a slave to the DR5000? - The digikeijs unit even comes with dedicated ports for loconet.
I picked up my DR5000 from James at the start of the year - I think it was around £180 so not expensive at all to get in to at all if you want to have a play with one.
£ for £ the digikeijs modules are definately the cheaper system block for block as you rightly pointed out.
All the best,
Jon.
What an excellent comment Jon, Yes I was aware that the Digitrax Trademarked loconet,Is an industry standard.
A whole new world indeed, is right Charlie. I watched this Clip once and watched it again. First time, I was all confused (WTFudge..!??)
Second viewing was a little more enlightening. I am still Scratching my 'Bonce' but it was becoming clearer.
Thx for opening up this wonderful field of possibilities, but think I will be watching and Scribbling Details down for weeks.
Thx for your Efforts in enlightening this Luddite, it is appreciated, muchly..!
My Old Lap top a 10yr. old Toshiba is at least a Start.
Cheers from Kim in Oz. 😎
P.s. I just Subscribed.
Yahoo..!!
Thanks Kim, I'm so pleased that you found the video useful.
Regards Charlie
Thank you very much for this overview of options. Very well explained and some good advice indeed. Seeing your rains run makes it easier to understand how the system works and what is possible. Keep it up, always a pleasure watching your videos!
Thanks TM, I’m so pleased that you found it interesting, regards Charlie
The Vista Start Up Sound gives me a twitch to this very day :)
Another great video.
Yes it makes me twitch too.
Brilliant. Very well explained.
Thanks Alex, I’m so pleased you enjoyed it
Interesting, as you said useful I imagine for exhibition purposes if you have shunting to be done. Well done Charles!
I’m so pleased that you found it interesting mate, regards
Thanks Charlie, another very thoughtful Video, makes my old HO Triang Trainset my dear Mum and Dad bought me in the Fifties like something from the from the Stone Age. Keep Safe.
I’m so pleased that you found it interesting Peter.
It's wonderful to see another video Charlie, I do appreciate and really enjoy watching them. I've also found a number of useful tips/advice since watching which have helped me.
Simon, I'm so pleased that you found the video useful.
Regards Charlie
Thanks again Charlie for firing the imagination!
We have to, it keeps us sane, regards Charlie
Thanks Charlie, another fascinating video. One thing worth a mention are the Lenz ABC modules for DCC. I have these working my branch line in shuttle mode and for £20 a pair they work fine. This assumes you are using compatible decoders but all my ESU sound decoders work well with this system. My Class 121 bubble car goes to and fro all day... well, it keeps me amused anyway!
Is that using asymmetric breaking?
Is that using asymmetric braking?
Is that using asymmetric braking?
@@ChadwickModelRailway There is an echo in here ;-) Yes, but a lot of decoders can do the "shuttle" thing with programable stopping time. The Loksound decoder in my Class 121 can be programmed to stop for up to 4 minutes before reversing back down the branch line. Braking/stop distances can be set very precisely.
Thanks Charlie. Train automation is one of the interesting aspects that has drawn me to DCC. As all of this is still new to me I found this video very helpful. Cheers!
Thanks Warren, I’m so pleased that you found it interesting. Regards Charlie
AUTOMATION helps operating complex activities on larger areas quick and correct in lesser time.
Interchange, halts, speed variations, signalling, etc......
I couldn’t agree, more KW. Regards, Charlie
My eventual plan is to use merg cbus with jmri and the merg cbus dcc system. If you can solder through hole components then it can be a big money saver! Being disabled and on a limited budget, that saving will make a big difference.
Great, do keep me posted on your progress.
@@ChadwickModelRailway i will when time and health allows me to get back to model railways. I've had to be taxi driver for my other half after he suffered a detached retina in August, meaning he can't drive until he has cataract surgery, hopefully next month. I hope to try and get some progress on building track though soon as that is what is holding up making progress, the fun of deciding on p4 😄 not that I regret it!
Fascinating, and clearly enunciated too. Thanks Charlie
Thanks David, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it.
Morning Charlie 👍
Good morning, I do hope that you enjoy it.
Thanks Charlie, interesting stuff. Like you say, research, research, research ! I did lots of it in planning for Pevenbourne. I’ve settled on iTrain 5 Plus to run alongside my Z21 Black. With lots of advice, I decided to go with Digikeijs block detection. I had planned to use the Z21 block detection, but it’s so expensive. The Digikeijs 4088s give me twice as much detection for my money. So far I’ve installed two 4088s and getting on fine with them. The only issue I find though is the fact that the detection current is quite sensitive so you have to be careful how you run your wires. They can’t be more than a metre long either otherwise false detection occurs. James Hudson at DCC Train Automation is very knowledgeable as you say, and also very willing to help. I had a problem with detection on my ADM Turntable and James suggested that I replaced its inbuilt autoreverser with one from LS (I already had one of these to control a reverse loop on the layout at James’s suggestion), this solved the problem. So James can help suggest solutions that interact with his knowledge of the many products on the market. Anyway, until next time, take care Charlie.
Thanks Brian, I’m pleased that you found it interesting.
Exactly the video I was hoping you'd do eventually. Super informative. Thanks :)
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it AMG
Thanks Charlie for a very informative video, I also just watched your first video following this one, triggering horn and flange wheel sounds added a lot to the immersion, fascinating stuff and I can see how addictive it would become building ever elaborate sequences. Keep safe - looking forward to more on how this progresses on Chadwick! 👍
Thanks ZT, i’m so pleased that you found it interesting
Smart Charlie to do all that computer stuff, keeps your shirts clean.
It does tax those little grey cells I must confess
Thanks Charlie you have re energised my enthusiasm will have a look at Train controller as I have been struggling with jmri for a couple of years and it seems more of a programmers thing than model railway control if you know what I mean :-)
I know exactly what you mean. But do you have a look at iTrain, it’s cheaper and probably easier.
Chadwick Model Railway yes I am Charlie, but I’m told it doesn’t work too well with NCE??
Another great video Charlie. I'm new to all this and I definitely look forward to the next one. i hope to set everything DCC and computerized.
You can do it Phil, planning is the key.
Yet another fantastic masterclass! Thanks Charlie...
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it Mike.
brilliant video as usual Charlie. i may be revisiting this video in the future.
Thanks MSR, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it, regards Charlie
Fascinating stuff Charlie , most of it way above my pay scale , but definitely something that I enjoy watching and learning about . Thanks for the heads up on DC automation , I wasn't aware it existed .
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it Graham.
Excellent video Charlie. Been considering Block Detection on my new layout and this video is really helpful. Very well put together as usual. had to smile at the Autofocus trying to deal with that Whiteboard when you were out of shot. Great stuff and many thanks.
I’m so pleased that you found it useful Dave. It’s an expensive option.
Thanks Charlie for another great and instructive video.
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it Allan.
Very educational video Charlie!! Thank you for sharing. Cheers Onno.
Thanks Onno, I’m pleased that you enjoyed it.
Hi Charlie, superb video and must admit it was chadwick that led me to looking into automation.. Must thank you for your pmd advice and can confirm that James at dccautomation is a wealth of knowledge and I am currently on my way to doing my block detection on my layout.. Superb and keep up the good work.. Must stop watching your videos its bad for my bank balance 😂
What a heartwarming comment Lou.
An interesting and informative presentation Charlie ...always look forward to your uploads .
Thanks David, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed the video
Hi Charlie. Another good video. I’ll send you the equivalent from ESU and iTrain which I am building up at present so you can compare to Digitrax for interest.
I’ll await your video with interest Alec
Fantastic video Charlie. I've not done any modelling since my old (pre-DCC!) N-Gauge layout 30+ years ago. Nice to see how the electronics and automation has progressed.
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it Simon.
Another great video. Thanks Charlie
Thanks John, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it. Regards Charlie.
Very informative and far from the days of dead sections with a basic switch.
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Simon. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Interesting , just plain Interesting, Thank you so much for sharing.
I’m pleased that you enjoyed it Dave, all the same.
Thanks Charlie for another interesting video on a technical subject. The world is your oyster I guess.
regards
Gareth
But it can be a very confusing oyster!
Hi Charlie have watched all your videos from the start as I’ve just got back into model railways and planning a layout in my loft I’ve found all your videos informative and entertaining please don’t delete your past videos as I will be going back to them as and when I start my build as for weathering track before ballasting you’ve got it spot on I’m a train driver and ballast can be different shades of grime and can be black in station areas and at some signals. Keep it up looking forward to more videos.
What a heart warming comment Mark. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Charlie thank you for your informative info because as with lots of other old farts on your blog we grew up with just a circle of track n a train 😆 So watching this stuff is like rocket science to us and just amazing at what can be done now a days with model railway layouts! JohnE
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it John, it is a great leap forward from where we started all those years ago.
They’re great everyday videos Charlie which ur viewing public seem to like a lot👍
Automation is definitely something that I will be implementing on my next project. A very informative video which I hope will lead me down the right path. As you say, you need to do loads of research to pick the best way forward , more videos on this topic please Charlie.
Geoff, I'm so pleased that you found the video useful.
Regards Charlie
Excellent video, Charlie, even more so than usual. You don't need to keep kneeling to the altar of Digitrax; the Digikeijs DR4088LN seems to be a drop-in replacement (at least it is if you don't add any DR4088CS to it to really save money, I think you'd need the DR5000 controller to make use of that combo). But on it's own (or with lots of them), the DR4088LN option seems to be the one to go for.
My only problem is that I've acquired a bunch of BDL168s over the years, so it will be a long while before I venture to a digikeijs unit - even though I'm now using a DR5000 controller to replace my DCS200 - or rather to make that box a powerful booster.
I have a similar history John. I bought several BDL168s from a deceased estate. It would now be suicidal to replace those.
I will admit automation is something I would like to implement in my layout but assume that it is too complicated. Watching this has certainly given me some great ideas to think about. A little bit of setting up and to get started but once your used to it and comfortable using such software, it will become easier. Will definitely look into this a bit more. Looks quite good. Thanks for sharing this Charlie! All the best, Clint
I’m so pleased that you found it interesting Clint.
Hi Charlie, I think this lock down has given us all a bit more time to consider what were doing on our layouts, i love the idea of I Train i think it would work well for me. However one bit at a time as they say. I am a member of Rainhill MRC and we have not been idol, One of our guys is working on buildings and the station while others are building signals useing MERG electronics hopefully a lot of this will be ready to fit when we return to our club. Your doing so well with your layout I look forward to your next edition Regards Alan Massie
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed the video Alan. The West camel model railway society of which I’m a member, meets for its first Saturday today. So hopefully we will have a reasonable turnout and can plan a way ahead for the remainder of this year. Regards Charlie
Another great video. Well explained.
Thanks Frank
This was well timed. I'm just starting on my first layout and thinking about a shuttle system. Thanks Charlie.
I’m so pleased that you found it useful
Brilliant video as always, although not my style of operation it was very interesting to learn about. I may look into it in the future when space, time & money allows.
All the best,
Owen 😊
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Owen. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
That was a really helpful video Charlie. Thank you. By reference to your earlier video where you "lashed up" all the red wires to demonstrate the switches, and this one, I have now worked out how to do all the wiring for block detection (time consuming but inexpensive), but not install the BD168 until the budget allows. Thank you again for a really useful video.
Thanks John, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it.
Fantastic. Thanks it has clarified alot for me. I am just building my first layout and after talking to dcc train automation have gone the digikeijs route. Their help and your videos are invaluable as I think I am the only railway modeller in Seychelles so there is no local advise.
But me a ticket, I’ll help 😜
Wow! Great video and really clearly explained Charlie. I am considering how to digitise my new layout once it is built and, this is a great starting point. Guess I will be doing a lot of reading and research before I even begin!! Also considering getting another couple of jobs to pay for it all!!! Thanks again, great video.
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Clive. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Terrific explanations! Many thanks. It's a whole new world, and well done for explaining it so well.
Thanks mate, I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it. Regards Charlie
Hi Charlie hope your blocks on r&r co are all able to take your longest trains
My Cyclebycle , it’s all in the planning!
Very interesting video! 👍 I feel this is where the hobby starts to get very confusing 😂 if you can get it perfect though, it can be fantastic! 😀
Also thank you for the help with my trackplan 😊
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed the video. Hopefully your track plan has been finalised too, regards Charlie
Automation sounds good. My layout is DCC so may be out of my price range .It is however intriguing. You can't beat a nice glass of malt and sitting watching the trains go by. Good video and very well explained. Ah, yes the chuckle brothers!
I’m a Laphroaig kind of guy!
@@ChadwickModelRailway Good choice A fine Islay malt, a bit too peaty for my taste.Living on the Moray coast I am more a Speyside malt guy , Look forward to the next video.
Fascinating stuff, Charlie. It’s something I’d love to get in to but out of my depth price wise (for now 😂)
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it, regards
Nothing to stop you planning a layout, costing it and then acquiring what you need a little bit each month until you can start to build.
Perfect! By the time I'm ready to go to TrainController Gold, you'll have worked out all the details and posted 3 dozen videos on how I can make it work. Thanks!! 😄 Seriously, some excellent insights there.
I've recently spent some time looking at TrainController (Gold) vs. iTrain vs. JMRI's script-based auto train control. My initial 10,000 foot view conclusion is that TrainController is the Bentley, iTrain is the Lincoln, and JMRI's automatic train control is the Chevrolet. But when it comes to ease of use, it's iTrain, TrainController and then JMRI. iTrain seems easier mainly because it's has fewer bells and whistles available. While JMRI automation is the most difficult since it's primarily script programming.
Outside of auto train control, JMRI seems to be the best for normal train and turnout control. It's free, regularly updated, has many upscale functions, has smartphone app throttles, isn't as hard as people think, and there's thousands of users to tap for info. On the down side, the owner/designer of TrainController isn't, well, friendly to the community. So, while there's a Freiwald forum on the website that's decent, don't expect a lot of company support.
Of course my dream system would be a generic power supply, 8 or ten buck convertors to power blocks, an Arduino-based command station using DCC++, led by JMRI controlled by TrainController Gold. Sans the $600 for TC Gold, I figure the rest is a few hundred dollars. And no, I'm not an electronics or electrical engineer. ;)
Great comment Frank, it's the way that I would go today starting from scratch.
Well done Charlie, another great video, a bit over my head but still interesting.
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Barry West. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
very clear and interesting thanks
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it James.
Thank you Charlie. I hadn't realised some of the gadgets for DC. As I gather loads of ideas/information, it certainly keeps the dementia in check! Following this video has given me another option to plan in a DC line separately which might suit my older Triang trains of 50+ years ago. That's once I lay a test track - and as I mentioned before, a possible use for my super 4 track and series 3 track of which I have a good few points! The new Peco track I've bought will do the DCC and plumped for Digikeijs maybe using JMRI. Need to learn more yet and look at itrain.
And then I can bring my wealth of knowledge gained from writing Fortran albeit punch card input is no longer necessary😂😂😂
The DC option will be quicker as a way of getting something running for my grandsons!
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed it Iain. However, I would move away from the JMRI idea with more emphasis on iTrain.
Thanks for this one, Charlie. I‘m sitting on the beach at Fuerteventura and looking forward to get back home and working on my layout, n gauge. Looking forward to your next obe!
I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it Nick, lucky you in the sunshine.. Stay safe. Regards Charlie
Great session and no need to change your shirt!
For those who are more into electronics MERG is a much cheaper option BUT you have to build the circuit boards from kits.
Andrew
Yes Andrew an alternative, but another addictive methodology
Hi Charlie, thanks for another nice video; I am always looking forward to the Fridays that you post a new one.
I've been using iTrain since 2012 and I like it very much. Also the (private) forum is very good. In the English section are over 2000 topics and over 15000 posts. It also has sections in other languages: Dutch (that I mostly use because I am Dutch), German, French, Spanish and Italian (the latter three much smaller). In the forum you get good answers to your questions very quickly, often by the developer himself.
By the way, I use Dinamo as interface, which allows mixed running of DC and DCC trains. The interface is made by small Dutch company VPEB.
I’m so pleased you enjoyed the video, and thank you very much indeed for the iTrain info, regards Charlie