A Christmas Carol (1984) * FIRST TIME WATCHING * reaction & commentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- 🎥 UNCUT watch alongs, Bloopers, & VOTE FOR MOVIES! bit.ly/3o1ftVw
👕 Merch & More: bit.ly/42Eugon
OPEN ME FOR MORE.
Full list of Movies received/watched:
docs.google.co...
(THANK YOU SO MUCH TYLER FOR MAKING THIS!!!!)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🤩let's be friends!🤩
Twitch: bit.ly/3o5TD3l
Facebook: bit.ly/42UmXbK
Instagram: bit.ly/44ZzaOi
Twitter: bit.ly/454sHBs
4636 Lebanon Pike #362 Hermitage, TN 37076
This has been my hands-down favorite version of A Christmas Carol since I was a kid. Best Scrooge, best Marley, best score, best sets. I never get tired of watching this one.
Mine too it’s free to see year round on TH-cam
Don't forget the 1999 Patrick Stewart version. Paramount+ has it up for streaming right now, and there's a DVD out there for it.
YES!!!❤❤❤
It is one of my favorite versions, because it explains many things.
This is the the standard version of a Christmas Carol for me. Nobody plays a mean old man like George C. Scott.
1951 is superior. All of the Christmas Carol Scrooges do a great job playing the mean old man, but the 1951 version has the best post transformation scrooge by a long shot
"That's the most action his bed has ever seen". 🤣
I'm glad people are discovering this version -- this was magnificent. George C. Scott really did this character justice, and all the other actors were stellar as well. The whole thing is perfect.
And what a treat seeing David Warner playing the ultimate Good Guy of English literature!
I love the way George C. Scott’s take on the character goes into a different direction than previous ones. Where others raged with the line “Buried with a stake of holly” Scott has his Scrooge laugh sadistically. He was original. This might be my favorite version of “A Christmas Carol.”
This is definitely my favorite. Scott plays Scrooge with much more depth and not just anger but you see his regret over past events even early on and his change at the end was a complete 180 in character and was very joyous.
Somehow his laugh makes him worse than other Scrooges. He seems to _enjoy_ being awful in a way other Scrooges don't.
@@Serai3 That's true, he probably enjoyed the spreading of misery and stepping on people in any way he could :(
The scene where he scowls at his father for denying his younger self more time with his sister gets me every time. So much of Scrooge’s later decisions stem from his grief over his sister and you can really see that here.
This is the best version. I was 10 when it came out.
"You still think it was something you ate? What'd you eat, shrooms?" 😂 You had me rotfl!
"You don't know us."
"Nor do I wish to."
That never fails to make my mother and I laugh when we watch this.
17:36 That is a Christmas pudding, also known as a plum pudding or a figgy pudding, and it’s a traditional Christmas dessert dish eaten in the UK. It’s often covered in brandy and lit on fire when served, for a dramatic flourish. To an American palate, Christmas pudding may taste like a yummy, gooey, extra-rich fruitcake (in a good way) that's slathered with hard sauce (which ensures that you will like it even if you don’t care for fruitcake) and eaten with a spoon.
Pudding, in general, is dessert of any kind.
Also worth pointing out. Plum pudding has no plums in it, but raisins.
I LOVE this version. Don't know quite why... Perhaps Scott's performance hits all the right notes? Very happy to see it being shared with a new generation.
@@miguelvelez7221 for me, it’s George C. Scott. He gives such a tremendous, lived-in performance. The script for this adaptation is fantastic. And, Mr. Scott’s co-stars in this movie are impeccable. It’s a virtual all-star cast.
@@miguelvelez7221 also, I think the music of this adaptation stands out. In particular, I LOVE that they made (Tiny) Tim Cratchit’s famous line “God Bless Us, Every One “ into a full blown song.
George C Scott played George S. Patton, in the film Patton (1970) he declined the Oscar nomination but won anyway. First actor in history to do so. An amazing proformace for an amazing movie. A must see.
Also, memorable as General Buck Turgidson in "Dr. Strangelove". "He'll see the big board!"
yeah, he did his best to sabotage the movie, actually. Trying to portray Patton as insane.
@@gnericgnome4214 From Patton's wiki... 'Although the 35th Division (of which Patton's tank troop was a component) eventually captured Varennes, it did so with heavy losses. Trying to move his reserve tanks forward, Patton relates that he might have killed one of his own men, stating: "Some of my reserve tanks were stuck by some trenches. So I went back and made some Americans hiding in the trenches dig a passage. I think I killed one man here. He would not work so I hit him over the head with a shovel." Patton was a successful leader. He was also quite a piece of work. I thought Scott did a great job.
@@creech54"But I do say no more than 10 to 20 million killed, tops. Uh, depending on the breaks."
I watch a different version of “A Christmas Carol” with my kids every holiday season, this is one of the best of the straight readings of the original source material.
Did you ever see the version from the 1930's? It's a little bit of a rough watch because the film quality is pretty bad but it has a different ending than the Simms one. Same idea but they showed more emphasize on different parts at the end.
@ I have seen the early ‘50s one, not sure on that one
I have a whole collection of different versions on dvd. Even the really bad A Carol Christmas and A Diva's Christmas Carol. 😂
It's my tradition that starting Christmas Eve and and finishing Christmas Day I watch as many versions as I can. They all have their charm. Scott is masterful here.
The Patrick Stewart version (1999) is pretty good too.
Yay! This is my favorite Christmas Carol. I love George C. Scott's Scrooge. The greatest thing about him, for me, is his laugh. He's the only Scrooge I've seen who laughs, and somehow it just makes him MORE awful and cruel.
Here is a listing of all of the Christmas Carol interpretations on film or video:
Scrooge (1935) black & white, with Seymour Hicks as Scrooge
A Christmas Carol (1938) a black & white, weakened version of the ghost story
Scrooge (1951) the black & white version most prefer with Alistair Sim
Mr Magoo's Christmas Carol (1962) the first animated interpretation
Scrooge (1970) a musical with Albert Finney
A Christmas Carol (1971) animated and shortened, but still a good version and Alistair Sim voices Scrooge
An American Christmas Carol (1979) with Henry Winkler (the Fonz) as a 1930's version of Scrooge
Mickey's Christmas Carol (1983)
A Christmas Carol (1984) the version above with George C Scott
Scrooged (1988) with Bill Murray
A Muppet Christmas Carol (1992) the original version with Belle's song
A Christmas Carol (1997) another animated version
A Christmas Carol (1999) with Patrick Stewart
A Christmas Carol: The Musical (2004)
Disney's A Christmas Carol (2009) with Jim Carrey
A Christmas Carol (2012) lackluster effort
A Christmas Carol (2019)
Scrooge: A Christmas Carol (2022) CGI animated and another one to skip
his dry raspy laugh and voice is amazing
This is my mom's favorite and one of mine with Mickey's as my other favorite both classics and perfect
Agreed. George C Scott was born to play Scrooge. He is so well suited to the role.
Yes, my favorite too. Scott is perfect.
That's not soup, it's gruel. A
watery oatmeal.
And bed curtains are a means of keeping warmer
Keeps out the draft.
Thus shows a lot about Victorian architecture. Instead of having a hallway with all the rooms off of it there were lots of rooms with lots of tightly closing doors with windows for circulation in summer and fireplaces in every room for heat in winter. The crachits house was basically one room surrounding the hearth and a scullery in the back.
14:49 The Ghost of Christmas Present was played by Edward Woodward, who is most famously known in the USA (particularly to Gen Xers) as the original Robert McCall on The Equalizer, the 1985-1989 American television series.
That was such a great show. I was thinking the other day I need to go back and watch it.
His best role was in Breaker Morant (1980).
He was great in everything.
And as the tightly-wound Sergeant Howie in the original Wicker Man.
For me Edward Woodward's Christmas Present ties with my other favorite, Kenneth More in the musical Scrooge with Albert Finney. They are opposites with Woodward properly scolding Scott for his attitude opposite More's more gently humorous approach with Finney.
I do want to point out that you've also seen Scrooged, which is technically also A Christmas Carol.
Technically, it's A Christmas Carol (with America's favorite old fart narrating, and the Solid Gold Dancers) inside A Christmas Carol
And mice with antlers. Stapled or taped, whichever one you can do easiest
There is even a Muppet Christmas Carol with Michael Caine, which is pretty funny.
Out of all the versions of this story is this is easily my favorite. The scene where Scrooge makes amends to his Nephew is just so wonderful, Fred is just so damn happy his uncle finally came around, I love it
This is my favorite as well and when he says at his nephew's house, "God forgive me for the time I've wasted" can bring me near to bawling as it can hit hard to just about everyone. All the time we waste in our lives and opportunities passed and or ignored and he says it with the utmost sincerity.
I wish they had been able to squeeze in the part where his sister dies giving birth to his nephew.
I also like that Scrooge went to visit Fred before the party. It makes it more touching when he apologizes to Fred about his earlier attitude and confesses to Janet that he once was in love.
Fun Fact: The actress playing Bob Cratchit's wife played Superman's birth mother in the Christopher Reeve 1978 film. 😊
One of the Charity collectors was Alfred in The Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer and George Clooney (terrible movie) batman movies!
@Edd25164605 Yes, I am aware of that 😊
I knew I recognized her from somewhere! Thanks for this post! -- The person I recognized was the former Doctor Who companion, Mark Strickson (young Scrooge).
And the actor playing Bob Cratchit played Jack the Ripper in an obscure SF movie called Time After Time.
@@i.marchand4655 Seeing her watch a movie with David Warner in it reminds me that she needs to see Tron.
It took me many a christmases before I realized that Tiny Tim runs out to Scrooge with out his crutch and walked unaided by his side at the end.
I just didn’t think about if for years. 😂
One time in high school before I graduated, I got to attend a live theater play performance with one of my classes downtown of "A Christmas Carol", and it was a wonderful experience. The young actor who played the boy who Scrooge payed off for the turkey in the play I saw, Scrooge was to toss coins to him, and the actor bless his heart couldn't quite catch one of the coins, and it rolled off the stage into the audience; we all had a nice little laugh about it. It was cool for me to see the story in play form; and I shall never forget it.
😊🎅🎄
My absolute favorite version, I make sure I watch this every Christmas season.
A Christmas Carol (1951) with Alastair Sim is my definitive adaptation. I think it captures the bleak and atmospherically creepier vibe of the novel better than any other adaptation since.
Me too...
Without a doubt! That is the quintessential SCROOGE!
I see your Alister SIM and raise you Michael Caine
@@maggedo-x1s Who said they didn't like it? Just there is a version they prefer and given the number of adaptations there are of this work that isn't surprising.
@@maggedo-x1s I don't see where anyone said they don't like this version. They said they liked a different version better. I too agree with them that A Christmas Carol (1951) with Alastair Sim is my favorite version. That being said, this is probably my second favorite version.
This makes me so happy that you watched this version. It's my favorite rendition of the story. It's the version that I grew up with, and will always love sooo much.
Ghost of Christmas Present: "They are your children! They are the children of all who walk the earth unseen! Their names are Ignorance and Want! Beware of them, for upon their brow is written the word "doom"! They spell the downfall of you and all who deny their existence!"
My favorite quote from this movie, though the original quote from the book is better:
"This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want. Beware them both, and all of their degree, but most of all beware this boy, for on his brow I see that written which is Doom, unless the writing be erased. Deny it!"
Ghost of Christmas portrayed spectacularly here by Edward Woodward, another great English actor. He was also fantastic in Breaker Morant (1980).
@@thomast8539_The Wicker Man,_ man! No bees there 🙉
I know Edward Woodward from the Equalizer.
David Warner, who plays Bob Cratchet, you saw him as the photographer who was decapitated in "The Omen". You saw George C. Scott as one of the generals in "Dr. Strangelove" and would have an Oscar worthy performance in "Patton" (1970), which he refused to accept the award for Best Actor.
The actress who plays the Ghost of Christmas Past is the daughter of Donald Pleasence, who played Dr. Loomis in "Halloween".
Warner also plays Jack the Ripper in Time After Time.
Warner was also in the show Twin Peaks in which his character was shot at the local hotel.
@@richardb6260 I sent her that DVD (she opened it during a live stream a few of months ago), so hopefully she'll get around to watching it at some point.
She really is her father's daughter. The films they did together weren't the best but they obviously worked great together.
i grew up with this one, we had it recorded on VHS with old vintage commercials, in my opinion the best one out there
Same!!!!
Same! I found it as an adult on DVD at a Barnes and Noble and surprised my mom with it as an early gift. She was so excited.
I originally had this version recorded on VHS too. IBM was sponsoring the showing and so all of the commercials were about them.
my dad worked at IBM so that was part of why we rcorded it
Same! I did eventually get it on DVD. I fell in love when it when it was first on TV in '84. Thank goodness I thought to ask that it be recorded!
I've seen all the major versions of Christmas Carol & George C. Scott plays Scrooge different than anybody else I've ever seen. Most Scrooge's are caricatures of blustery, over-the-top, bitter old men but Scott plays him as a man with restrained, jaded cynicism--detached and laughing at a world that deserves the misery it has heaped upon itself.
I completely agree with him 😊
Yes Scott brings great depth to the character and it makes his change of heart all the more believable to me.
@@robmaddison8645 One of our greatest actors, IMO
The Ghost of Christmas Present is played by Edward Woodward - who played the original “Equalizer” in the 1980’s
I hate that he's nearly forgotten for that role.
Yes it is, but unfortunately all too common a case. The title music still gives me chills
I LITERALLY screamed with JOY when I saw the Thumbnail! This is absolute FAVORITE version of A Christmas Carol EVER!!!!! AHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!
The poor houses were worse than death for many people. Work all day every day. You are separated from your family. This is on purpose so no one has even emotional support while in a poor house.
I was shocked to my bones to hear her ask "why would they rather die?"
Is the modern age so out-of-touch with traditional values?
A man works for a living or he's not a man. He supports his family, or he's not a man. That's been the ethic of western civilization for centuries, and it built the modern world.
To have to crawl to the gov't and admit you're unable to feed your family or yourself was the worst kind of shame to a man... in that age where dishonored men often shot themselves.
Dickens knew about the poor houses of London because his father was "sentenced" to one and he had to take his whole family with him into the poor house. It's a theme that runs through most of Dickens works.
Shame is one thing, but death eliminates all possibilities. If one is still alive, there exists a chance that you can improve your situation. Death removes that chance.
@@davidroel3047 One can say the same thing about pain.
I don't expect modernized people to understand. "My ass is the most precious thing" is pretty much the standard today; pride and self respect are obsolete.
@@richardgazinia5482 that experience is probably what turned Dickens into a socialist slaver.
The 1999 version with Patrrick Stewart is womderful as well
Absolutely!!
Highly underrated. Some of the costume choices (such as the Ghost of Christmas yet to come) are a bit bizarre looking, but the acting is terrific and I *love* Patrick Stewart's version of Scrooge because his transformation is so huge. He doesn't just go from being mean to being nice. He literally transforms and has to re-learn to do human things such as when he doesn't remember how to laugh or when he sings again. I've always loved that about that version of Scrooge.
Definitely my favorite as well
The 1999 TNT/Hallmark production seems much authentic in locations, costumes and how Ebeneezer is more human than a caricature of Angry Man turned Happy Man via master actor Sir Patrick Stewart. The actor who portrays Bob Cratchet is perfectly cast as well. do yourself a favor and watch this Made for TV Movie.
Its the best, also there is a TNG episode where data is playing scrooge.
This is the only "Christmas Carol" where the actor (George C. Scott) doesn't play Scrooge as a grump. He's still greedy and grasping but he actually loves being a mean guy. He relishes dumping on people! It was such a change.
So then when the ghost takes him back to the past, you can see why he so relishes being mean; it's a form of "revenge", taking his pain out on the world.
And when the ghosts get through to him, he doesn't come across as manic or overcompensating- his cynicism has shattered, allowing his youthful optimism and happiness to re-emerge. He is delighted to find he can still feel them.
Exactly!! He plays Scrooge with realism in his performance that I have rarely seen in another actor playing the part.
@@gnericgnome4214 Yes! I said something similar above. He's become embittered, by life's events and by the choices he's made. He's jaded and cynical. But he has turned blame outward, rather than looking inward. I love the way the past scenes are done. You CAN see that, despite his father's coldness, there were moments when he might have turned towards a life of happiness. (I think one thing this version doesn't quite do is get across clearly enough that he starts on the path of making money because he wants to provide for Belle and himself; but then it turns into an end in itself.)
@@gryphonvert I think I like this version best, because Scott's version of Scrooge seems more capable of reformation than the other versions I've seen. In his facial expressions and body language, as he squirms under the assaults by the spirits, you can see him realizing there's something wrong with _him_ , not the world.
Maybe I'm projecting. As I type this, it's 10 minutes to Christmas CST. I sit in my apartment, alone; no wife, no family, no friends... no money. It would be even easier for me to become embittered and cynical than Scrooge... and yet I feel content. Grateful for the gift of life.
I'm a self-made man; I know that where I am in life isn't God's fault, or my father's fault, or my neighbor's fault. _I_ built this life, as surely as Marley built his chains. And it's up to me to fix it, no one else. IMO, I think that's a problem with a lot of modern people; there are excuses all around them, and if you can blame the world... why fix yourself? "I'm not a failure; I'm not a bad person... I'm a _victim_ ! the world did this to me!"... feels so much better than looking in the mirror and seeing the real architect of your misery. Which probably isn't all that miserable.
There's an old song called "Burning Bridges". The lyrics are about a man looking back on his life, at all the people who tried to help him, whom he turned his back on. Like Scrooge turned his back on Fan, his sister. Mr Fezziwig. Belle, his fiance, even his nephew Fred. And so he's left, sitting alone in his bedchamber on Christmas even, eating a bowl of stew. Alone.
"For all sad words of tongue and pen, the saddest are these, 'It might have been'."
- John Greenleaf Whittier
But the spirits gave him the greatest Christmas present of all: hope.
Now I'm going to go nuke myself some pizza. Merry Christmas to you, and God bless you, every one.
Yay I'm so glad you're watching this! This was the version of the Christmas Carol my family watched all the time when I was a kid but I haven't seen it in forever! The 80s had such great weird scary kids movies.
My favorite version of this story. My family watches it every year after Thanksgiving dinner to usher in the Christmas season. Great reaction Ashley!
7:08 That's a bell usually rung by a resident of the house to call a servant to come do something.
I love the fact that it's covered in cobwebs, showing that Scrooge is too cheap to hire a servant.
@@ShawnRavenfire Well, but also: the owner of the house would ring the bell to call a servant. The bell wouldn't ring in the master of the house's rooms, right? It would ring down where the servants would be found. Scrooge is living in this huge, grand house, of which he only uses one room on a lower floor, and it must be part of the servants' area.
This is my favorite of all the movie adaptations of this fine old story! We watch it every year. Besides the way its production values seem to perfectly capture the period, the acting is top notch. One of my favorite moments is where Sir Edward Woodward as the Ghost of Christmas Present leans in toward Scrooge in a close-up and growls out "MILLIONS!" Just perfect!
I've seen several versions - including one starring Mister Magoo, which was surprisingly good.
Good old Magoo.
Good source material can work wonders
it was probably this movie, that solidified why the 2nd ghost is my favourite. he is described and portrayed as a generous, hearty, almost innocent or naive figure. There is alot of Santa in his design and action, caring, compassionate, and positive. But there is steel beneath him, and there are several times he uses Scrooge's own words against them, showing what he so casually mention or throws out. He shows the real people, the real consequences, the issues mentioned so casually. i love the line involving "millions of children"
it was this movie where that occurred to me, this one or The Flintstones Christmas Carol, 1994. It is also very good, and worth watching.
This version of Christmas Present is my favorite, exactly for the way Woodward's performance shows that steel underneath. He's clearly generous, and hearty, but you can tell throughout that you should also be a little wary of him (something Scrooge only really learns at the end). Plus -- Scott is such a great actor, and gives so much depth and dimension to his Scrooge; but Woodward is such a big presence that he can go toe to toe with Scrooge and even out-intimidate (and out-sarcasm) him. Truly, no bad performances in this, I love all of them; but Woodward is amazing.
The curtains around the bed were for warmth. If the power goes off, you can create a warm bed by sleeping under a table or other covered with quilts and blankets.
Love this version, and the 1970 musical with Albert Finney, and the 1951 with Alastair Sim
I LOVE the Albert Finney version! It’s one of my “it’s not fully Christmastime until I watch it” movies.
Yes! "Thank you very much!"
@@ISoWin4evaAnd the song is back in my head. It's infectious
That's the nicest thing that anyone's ever done for me!
My top 3 as well!
This is my absolute FAVORITE version of A Christmas Carol!!
This has remained my favorite interpretation of "A Christmas Carol" on film. George C. Scott acted incredibly as Scrooge.
My all-time favorite interpretation was Patrick Stewart's one-man show on Broadway in the early 1990's where he performed on stage with only a table, a chair, and the book by Charles Dickens and you would SWEAR there were 20 other actors up on stage performing with him!
Along with other posters, I love Scott's multidimensional portrayal of Scrooge (his first "Bah, Humbug" is a deliberate joke) but I also love the against-typecasting of the compact Edward Woodward as the giant Ghost of Christmas Present and the usually-villainous David Warner as the saintly Bob Cratchit.
Scrooge wit Albert Finney is my favorite version. He was 34 when he played Scrooge and played him like he was 70. And the song Thank You Very Much was great. So good. Gonna go watch it for the 4th time this month.
There’s so much sarcasm in the Albert Finney version and I am HERE for it!
“Uncle Ebeneezer! I cannot tell you what a joy it is to see your happy smiling face!”
“humbug”
It's one of my favorites; that's probably my favorite song of any of the musical versions. There was a church in my hometown that rented out the Civic Center auditorium to put on the musical every year. It was awesome! The pastor played Scrooge and did so well. The best part is, they did it for free every year. I went back home to see it, even after I moved away. It was a bummer when he had to retire it, but I'm thankful the movie is still there.
Yes. Albert Finney is the only Ebenezer Scrooge screen actor I know of to play the older and younger versions of the character.
17:37 Ah yes, that would be the old fashioned traditional Christmas pudding.. a delicacy in those days. 😌🎅🎄
It's kind of like a fruitcake, topped with brandy.
This is my favorite version, and I've seen 29 different versions. I won't even be mad if you don't like it, I'm just glad to have you watch it. 😊
My other favorite movie with George C Scott is The Changeling (1980). Oh, and if you've seen Robin Hood: Men in Tights, you've seen Roger Reese, who played Scrooge's nephew Fred. He was Sherriff of Rottingham.
The pudding that they all blew on and she took the Holly out of is a traditional British Christmas pudding. It’s not like our American pudding where it’s smooth. It’s almost like a really dense cake with piece of dried or candied fruit on the inside and it’s usually doused in brandy. It takes a long time to cook and it has a lot of traditions on how to prepare and serve it.
As stated above it is a dense fruit cake that is cooked by steaming. My wife encases the balled ingredients in foil wrapping and then steams them in a large pot. When served, the pudding is covered with brandy or rum and then lit. In dim light, it appears that the pudding is illuminated with a blue flame.
I've always wanted to try that since I saw it on an episode of Are You Being Served.
You should watch the movie titled "The Man Who Invented Christmas." It tells about how Charles Dickens came up with the story and how he managed to write it and have it published in only six weeks! It stars Dan Stevens as Charles Dickens. I highly recommend it! 😁
Excellent film indeed!
My parents owned an old Reader's Digest or Time Life Christmas book when I was a kid in the 1970s. It had an illustrated version of this story, and the picture of the ghost of Marley talking to Scrooge gave me such heebie jeebies that I absolutely DE.tested this story until the Muppet version came out!
From now on every year we watch one version of the Christmas carol. We have Scrooged and a muppet Christmas carol and now this one. Even doctor who has a version of the Christmas carol.
Spirited with ryan Reynolds and will Ferrell is really good
What did you think of the Jim Carey animated version? There are things I like and dislike about that one. I think the animated faces are little too creepy.
@NWAWskeptic I barely remember it but I wasn't a big fan. I think it was also the same creepy face factor
So glad you watched this one, this has always been my favorite version.
My ABSOLUTE favorite version!
This is my favorite version of A Christmas Carol. My family and I have watched it every year since it debuted. Merry Christmas Y’all!
My favorite A Christmas Carol! Thank you my dear Ashleigh.
Definitely my favorite adaption. I think we'll keep seeing more versions as there's always ways to play the characters, plus things that are often passed over, particularly the ghostly funeral procession in the beginning. Some also like to throw in additions to show what kind of a person Scrooge is.
I remember when this came out, ABC TV, sponsored by IBM, so there were few ads during the whole thing, and they spared no expense while making this.
IMO, this is the best and most definitive version of A Christmas Carol.
I agree
Absolutely agree. The best.
yes
I agree, though the humor and music of The Muppet Christmas Carol melts my heart every year.
This was filmed in my town, Shrewsbury!
When you think about it, the Muppet Christmas Carol had Dickens/Gonzo literally start the story by talking about the Marleys being dead to begin with-- ghost stories on Christmas Eve used to be a tradition, and i can't think of a better way to start a ghost story than with a corpse.
Dickens absolutely detested the Malthusian philosophy of his day, between this, David Copperfield, and Oliver Twist, Dickens really wrote about what he lived.
I taught the play as part of my drama unit, and I always showed this version because it is closest to the play. Ashleigh reacts so perfectly to all of the lines that I love best!
15:35 Bob Cratchit is played by David Warner, who was in dozens of movies over the years, but perhaps is most famously known for playing Mr. Lovejoy, Cal Hockley’s henchmen, in TITANIC (1997).
Mrs. Cratchit is played by Susannah York, who is perhaps best known for playing Superman’s biological mother, Lara, in SUPERMAN (1978).
Warner also was two different characters in 2 back-to-back Star Trek movies (5 & 6)
@@nancyomalley6286 And plays Jack the Ripper in "Time After Time" and gets decapitated by a flying sheet of glass in "The Omen".
He was also originally supposed to play Freddy Krueger.
@@tophers3756 Never heard that one!
My favorite version of "A Christmas Carol" remains "Scrooge" from 1970 and starring Albert Finney. I have a feeling you'd love it too if you haven't already seen it, as it is a musical.
I love that one too
"I release you" was a fancier way of saying "I'm breaking up with you" back in those days.
But also she really did feel that she was releasing him from a contract that he regretted.
@@HuntingViolets She even starts by saying in the original text that "our contract is an old one" and ends by suggesting that he would chalk their relationship up to "an unprofitable dream," so there was no doubt extra meaning behind the choice of words.
@@Osprey850 Exactly.
This ties with Muppet Christmas Carol as my favorite adaptations. George C Scott was such an incredible actor...his capacity to run from terrifying to compassionate is delectable. He was married to another great Colleen Dewhurst whom i adored in Anne of Green Gables...and she was in a movie with their son, Campbell Scott....Dying Young....this is the train of thought that pops whenever i think of certain actors.😂
Omg, I never knew Campbell Scott was George’s son. Learn something new every day, lol.
i have watched many versions of this movie, and read the story. This was one of the versions that stated the reason why Scrooge's father doesn't like or love him. The original story doesn't mention this, but after watching many versions, i came up with the same idea. You also find out why Scrooge doesn't love Fred, for the same reason. It doesn't show that in this version, but i believe the Alastair Sim version (1951) does allude and show that.
This is also one of the few versions that show Scrooge's father. In many ways, Scrooge ends up just like his father (when it comes to his relationship with his family), and for much the same reason. It's interesting to wonder how Scrooge and his father would have been, to each other, without the same tragedy.
i have never thought about it, but you're right. The fact that he sent over a giant turkey that has to be plucked, dressed, and cooked - that's going to take all day.
But it’s not frozen so that will speed things up.
I always think about that! Let's assume it may have been dressed (i.e. the innards taken out), as that would have kept it fresh longer, I think. And thank goodness it was winter. But the plucking! Even with several hands, it would take forever! I also always wondered whether the Cratchits had an oven big enough.
My favorite version is Scrooge, the musical, from the early 1970s. It's a wonderful rendition with some really fun songs. I hope Ashley will do that one next year. Maybe make a Jingle Beans tradition of watching a different version of a Christmas Carol every year would be fun.
I agree. It has my favorite Christmas song: th-cam.com/video/CG7Z1AJNMCM/w-d-xo.htmlsi=NjTvouPgqO1x0Ax4 A Christmas Carol. It is featured in the Disneyland Christmas Parade.
I love that this version quotes directly from the book. I especially love that Ash is reacting strongly to all the poetic language - and existential questions - posed by Dickens' text.
You can't do a faithful Dickens adaption without quoting his dialog.
My favorite Christmas Carol movie is still A Mickey's Christmas Carol because of the nostalgic factor of when I was a little kid.
"What'd you eat? Shrooms?" OMG! Ashley. That killed me!! Thanks for the laugh. I love you. 😂😘, PJ
Thank you, Ashleigh! ❄ I like this one... but the musical SCROOGE (1970) is great... and my very favorite is SCROOGE/A CHRISTMAS CAROL (1951).
Thank you for reacting to this. It's my favorite version of A Christmas Carol.
My favorite version…a CBS made-for-tv movie with an all-star cast: Oscar winner George C. Scott, David Warner, Angela Pleasence, Suzannah York (“Superman”), Roger Rees, Joanna Whalley (“Willow”) & Edward Woodward who starred in the original “The Equalizer” tv series. It was filmed in England. Quality movies & mini series were a way the 3 networks battled for ratings. NBC filmed “Shogun” starring Richard Chamberlain in Japan so used a Japanese cast…also had John Rhys-Davies who was Sallah in “Raiders of the Lost Ark” & Gimli in “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy. Another favorite was “Backstairs at the White House” which was based on the novel by Lillian Rogers Park about her & her mother’s time working there…from President Taft to President Eisenhower. Again, all-star cast (includes 8 Oscar winners)…Louis Gossett Jr was Houseman Mercer & Leslie Neilsen the head butler Ike Hoover. Olivia Cole & Leslie Uggams played mother/daughter but were only a year apart in age. In “Roots,” Uggams played Cole’s mother-in-law. Then there was “Chiefs” which was a 3-part mini-series about 3 different police chiefs of a fictional town trying to solve serial killings of young runaway boys between the 1920s to the 60s. The 2nd chief, played by the late Brad Davis, said one of my favorite lines: “I squashed him like the manure maggot that he was.” Wayne Rogers played the 1st chief while Billy Dee Williams played the 3rd one. Hard to find but it has been uploaded to TH-cam.
You forgot Michael Gough ("Alfred" in the Tim Burton "Batman" movies) as one of the guys soliciting funds for the poor.
Also not mentioned was Lucy Gutteridge as Scrooge's past fiance Belle. She's probably best known for her role in Val Kilmer's first movie, Top Secret.
At 7:06, that's a bell that was usually used by the masters of the house to call on maids and servants. There were several throughout the house and the maids and servants knew which room to go to based on which bell was ringing. If you've ever seen Disney's Cinderella animated movie, the stepsisters and stepmom ring such bells to tell her to bring them their breakfast at the beginning of the movie. I know they had an elctronic version in the 20th century, too.
My favourite versions are the Muppets Christmas Carol, Scrooge (1970) and Scrooged. This one I do love too, Tiny Tim always looks so frail from the beginning and Scrooge is particularly heartless.
I’m glad to see another share love for the 1970 film. That one is my favorite adaptation, with Sim’s and C. Scott’s versions being close behind.
This is my wife's favourite. It was filmed in her home town of Shrewsbury, Shropshire and she went to see the filming as a young girl. I used to work in Shrewsbury and it's fun to recognise the locations they used.
This is the version I first saw as a kid so it has a special place in my heart.
I was 5 when this came out. My parents taped it off the TV. I saw Marley when I was probably 6 or 7, and I never recovered. I had nightmares for months. Until the early 2000s, he was the scariest thing I'd ever seen on screen. I couldn't be in the same room if I heard the music of the scene...it conjured up images that terrified me
IMO Alastair Sim performed the very best portrayal of Ebenezer in "Scrooge" filmed in 1951.
I was starting to get a little worried when you didn't upload in the morning like you usually do! I have actually never seen this version, so I'm excited to watch it with you. ♥♥
Fun Facts: The man playing Tiny Tim's father was the photographer in the Omen.
One of the men who asked Scrooge for money for the poor was Alfead in the the 80's Batman movies.
He was also the henchman in Titanic that helped to frame Leo and put him in the hold.
Fun fact: he was also "Dillinger" in TRON.
This was a made for TV movie shown at Christmas on CBS for years starting in 1984. It’s my favorite version of a Christmas Carol, as well. George C. Scott really finds the humanity in Scrooge. He plays the sadness and weariness in the character.
Another take on this is "Scrooged" with Bill Murray, 1988.
I really like how there have been so many different versions of this story. I’ve seen three or four and it’s kind of fascinating what each production brings.
No one’s going to get rich making these movies; they’re works of love.
I would love to suggest "Hogfather". It is like no other Christmas movie.
My mom and I watched that without knowing what it was. We were NOT ready for it. I don't recall much, except for being confused and the line "Who the H*** are you". The fact we saw it Ion, a station that normally plays "regular", more friendly things made it even more disarming. It's kinda funny now, but I don't have to see it again.
While every other Christmas special will just have Santa be real, The Hogfather stands out because its “Santa” is both real and fake and said that it’s okay for Santa to not be real.
“Humans need fantasy to be human. To be the place where the falling angel meets the rising ape.” “You need to believe in things that aren’t true. How else can they become?”
This is my favorite versiob of A Christmas Carol. I saw it on TV on Christmas Eve in 85 or 86, at my grand parents place, and make sure to watch it every time it's on TV.
17:35 Yes, that is a pudding
A Brit said that "pudding" is what they call their dessert. "What's for pudding?" "Chocolate Cake." "Yum!"
Jacob Marley was played by the late great Frank Finlay. One of the best actors to come out of the UK. Pound for pound this has one of the best cast of actors ever put together for a production of A Christmas carol. George C Scott was a truly great Scrooge.
I’ve never seen anyone react to the George C Scott version before! This was always my family’s favorite and was an annual watch in our household.
Ashleigh is the second I've seen to view this version on TH-cam. The only other I can think of is Trixy Blue.
The man who plays Marley in this version of a Christmas Carol is Frank Finlay. He is by far my favorite Marley. I haven’t seen all the adaptations but he’s my favorite Marley. I love that Finlay captures how Marley’s ghost is the epitome of despair.. He also plays the main character’s father in The Pianist.
I love how you didn't know what was happening despite having watched the Muppet version (in a good way) I think you should do a different version each year so hopefully next year we'll et the Alister Sims version.
There's also the TNT original Patrick Stewart version as well 😁
Before I even begin watching the video I've got to say this is my favorite version of A Christmas Carol. George C. Scott is incredible as Scrooge. He even makes me teary-eyed at the end.
This is my favorite version! Yay!
You've seen George C. Scott. He was in Dr. Strangelove.
Edward Woodward, the Ghost of Christmas Present, starred on the mid-80s TV show The Equalizer, which is what the fairly recent movies and TV series reboot were based on.
David Warner is much more heartwarming here as Bob Cratchit than he was as Lovejoy in Titanic. I almost didn't realize they were the same guy for years.
Warner is also known as playing villains and bad guys so having him here as not just playing a good guy but the quintessential good guy in literature is so cool to see.
@@cchavezjr7 He was really creepy in two episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation. He just doesn't look like himself but there's no mistaking the voice.
@@katwithattitude5062 He has played multiple roles in Star Trek, in TNG, Final Frontier and The Undiscovered Country.
As far as the thread for George C Scott, I nominate Rescuers Down Under. True childhood classic for me
This version and the version with Albert Finney (Scrooge, 1970) are both must see films for my family this time of year.
Those are my two favorites
Particularly loved 'Thank you very much!'
@@slytheringingerwitch”I Hate People” makes me laugh too
@medleyoflife I hate people specifically speaks to me. It's like my theme song.
@slytheringingerwitch Those dance numbers are insane. The amount of people in it must have been a nightmare to direct.
Thanks so much for this one, Ashleigh! So far, you're only the second person that I've seen react to my favourite version of this story. I remember watching "A Christmas Carol" with my family when it first premiered on TV. I was 11, and the appearance of both Marley and the third Ghost of Christmas was just the right amount of spooky.
P.S. At 10:05, Scrooge is talking about characters in "Robinson Crusoe", a novel by Daniel Dafoe about a castaway sailor on a desert island.
Please do the sir Patrick Stewart version my favorite
A very good version, but to me Patrick Stewart comes across too much like... Patrick Stewart. He probably plays Scrooge more faithfully to the book, yet in my eyes he doesn't bring the same level of depth to the character as Scott.
You might enjoy the movie "The Man Who Invented Christmas" it's about Charles Dickens writing "A Christmas Carol" - An excellent movie.
This is a very good version of the story. It’s quite truthful to the novel which is traditionally the way it’s done. There are so many good versions of this you could do one of these every year. Every generation puts its own spin on it. The one I like the most is the 1951 British version with Alistair Sim as Scrooge.
Other casting trivia: Frank Finlay (Jacob Marley) played Porthos in The Three Musketeers (1973) (the one with Charlton Heston and Raquel Welch). Angela Pleasance (ghost of Christmas past) is the daughter of actor Donald Pleasance (The Great Escape as Blythe, Halloween as Dr. Loomis). Nigel Davenport (Silas Scrooge) played the Duke of Norfolk in the Oscar-winning A Man for All Seasons (1966). Two of the Cratchit kids were Susannah York (Mrs. Cratchit)'s own children.
Finlay was also in Tobe Hooper's Lifeforce and The Deadly Bees (A great MST3K episode, by the way!). The Three Musketeers and its sequel The Four Musketeers is the best adaptation of Dumas's novel ever and I have it.
@@YolandaAnneBrown95726 Same feeling re. The Three/Four Musketeers. Astounding cast, fantastic movies, definitive adaptation.
You should watch the Bill Murray Scrooge. It’s very funny.
She did that one 3 years ago.
@ oh I did not know that thank you I’m going to watch it
This is the BEST version of A Christmas Carol, IMO! I watch it so many times every year ❤❤❤ I just adore George C. Scott's performance.