My first season was survivor China. I still remember watching those reward challenges that are basically "wrestle each other", and thought "........how is this even fun? how are those skinny men supposed to take on James and Aaron?"
The wrestle challenges that go on for like hours with the people utterly exhausted just stuck in a stalemate lol I think China and another season had one
@@ExitSiign you mean the one where they had to push massive balls? It was in Philippines where it resulted in stalemate. In China James just bulldozed everyone lmao
Cagayan is a fair honorable mention. The Brawn tribe clearly dominated the challenges behind Cliff, Tony, Woo, and Sarah. The Beauty tribe was hilariously bad at working together, but at least they had LJ and Jeremiah. The Brain tribe is the Brain tribe. Garett is huge, but didn’t work well with the others. Kass couldn’t do much outside of puzzles, which they almost never let her do. They had Spencer soloing challenges half the time.
A really strange part is that in practice, The Beauty tribe was pretty much on par with the brawn tribe. There were five pre-swap challenges, and beauty got first in three of the five, and brawn in two of the five. With beauty having one loss, I'd call that about equal. And it wasn't just LJ and Jeremiah hard carrying the tribe. Alexis was crucial in puzzles and as the caller in the blindfold challenge, honestly doing at least as much as Jeremiah in challenges. And Morgan, Jefra, and Bryce were pretty good, especially Morgan, much to my delight on a recent rewatch (she did quite well in all the post merge challenges!) They were bad at working together strategically. There's a reason brains and brawns effectively picked them off, but if there wasn't a swap, I think beauty has equal numbers to brawn going into the merge, or is like one down.
@@YoshiDryBones She did pretty well in Cooks Island but usually took 3rd place to Ozzy and Yul. In Micronesia she did win an individual immunity, but she was more of a mastermind because she lost a challenge on purpose at the final 3. She also passed up on an immunity idol, so Parvati played a much more cautious game in Micronesia. While in Heros vs Villains Parvati wanted to not only win but be seen as the best because she was on a different level as far as challenges and she played two idols.
David vs Goliath was wildly outmatched too. John, Alec and Dan all on one tribe seemed like they had Dodgers-level payroll. Plus Jonathan on this season automatically makes the tribes imbalanced in favor of Taku.
@@Rodanguirus Yeah, Malcolm and Denise are strong competitors. And on paper Russell and Roxie should be strong too. The only all around weak link was Zane, and he was voted out first.
Production literally could have done a tribe swap and interfered and helped Matsing if they wanted to. I’m fine with the fact that they didn’t - the tragic story was beautiful to watch. But I wish they would just never do it. It always screams production interference to me. Literally the producers saying “we don’t like the current storyline, let’s deliberately kill it.” I never understood why people are OK with tribe swaps but hate the idols they hid for Ben. It’s all production controlling the outcome way too much. The school yard picks hit a little different because there’s agency for the players instead of production literally forcing the outcome they want.
Fun Idea: 5 Survivor Players who lost their minds on the island. Not including players like Coach and Debbie of course who already lost their minds coming into their season, but people who started the season as fairly standard normal people and by the time they get voted out they're just not even a human being anymore they're so insane. Obvious examples that come to my head are Shane Powers, Brandon Hantz, J’Tia, and arguably Phillip Shephard.
I definitely want to see an assessment of tribes created via school yard pick, and not just tribes created at the beginning of the game but also ones formed at tribe switches as well, such as in Panama, Micronesia, and even Gabon had a tribe shuffle based on yet another school yard pick decision.
It reminds me when I was in school. I'm terribly unathletic and clumsy. However, I was never the last picked. Why, because people liked me. I was never picked high but towards the end where all the "losers" were, I'd be picked. It's like Survivor does the same but based on appearances. Who looks like they'd be a nice person?
This happens in Roblox Survivor, having the kids to pick the teams often results in me being the last pick and the easy vote out despite being the person carrying them for most of the challenges, thank goodness that many of these kids don't know how to find idols which helps me to get them out when they target me, leading to their friends to ragequit after one of them get blindsided
@@bartallen8121 and then when u immunity run to the end (so many people left that you immediately transported to the merge) the one juror votes their friend to win
I would like to bring attention to 15:49, where on the tribe swap letter that Zhan Hu receives, Jean-Robert's name is spelled as John Robert. I dont know what to do with this information but its funny regardless.
I'm surprised he didn't flip out (but he might have and it didn't make it into the show). People have the right to have their name pronounced properly. But he was such a douche, I almost don't care.
there's also naseer last season singlehandedly cancelling out his tribe members' attempt at a challenge throw (as well as cliff who did the same in cagayan, rest in peace)
On paper the EoE tribes didn't look that bad. If Wardog was as competent as he looked the season's now pretty balanced. It also doesn't help when they vote out their only viable challenge competitor Chris premerge. Heroes vs Villains on the other hand, the heroes had a definite edge on the physical portion. They were winning just about every physical challenge but in challenges with puzzles, generally the puzzles are the part that matters more. You can gain or lose more time there than you can on the physical parts, and the villains had Rob who was single handedly carrying his tribe to wins on that portion.
That's what I like most about B-Rob, even if you don't care for his strategic game, he alone is really good in challenges and he's even better at getting a tribe to work together and lead them in the right direction.
I just shake my head because the stupidity of this vote is glaringly obvious. This was not the first season, but some people don't watch the show before appearing on it. This is another glaringly stupid idea as well.
I absolutely love your videos. I do think this would be best with a title card at the beginning or end recognizing the untimely and recent passing away of Ashley Massaro, who is featured heavily in this video in kind of a negative light. She didn’t have a great survivor run, but I don’t think that should take away from remembering her tremendous accomplishments in wrestling and the great sacrifices she made for her daughter while she was with us. She also quite possibly had one of the worst and least functional starting outfits in survivor history, and didn’t get a fair shake compared to most survivors who have sneakers or any type of clothes they can move in. I would have absolutely loved to see her get another chance on any other more traditional season. Gone way way too soon. Rest in power Ashley 💪🏻🙏🏻
That’s so sad to hear she passed away. I was really rooting for her in Survivor and was sad when she got voted off so soon. She had so much potential for challenges and for entertainment, but getting sick kind of doomed her. Her wrestling is very impressive and her personality seemed fun from her brief time on the show. And she was only 39 when she died, definitely too soon 😔
@@drewbyrd1093 That's why I love him too. Big Brother is actually my favorite show. But it's because I like to watch the psychology of these shows. Big Brother has more of that into play. I only like TAR because I like to see the destinations.
They both put so much thought and effort into their videos. They don't just slap something together hoping to get people to watch because they like the TV show. Seriously these videos are almost academic because of the quality of content.
Starting tribes from China because yeah, and Drake vs Morgan in PI because Drake had Sandra the only Spanish in the whole cast and they had to that first day get your supplies from this local village thing.
That wasn’t even the problem with Morgan. The problem with Morgan is they couldn’t get their egos out of their way and communicate. Ryano saved money for the boat and didn’t tell anyone, Skinny Ryan got booted too early cause he couldn’t dive and was physically weaker, then Lill hit the same treatment. Then there’s Osten almost drowning and being on the verge of quitting for a few tribals in a row but their egos didn’t let them mercy kill. Meanwhile outside of the Shawn/Burton vs Rupert/Fairplay fiasco, Drake was a functional tribe
@@jolteon345 I wasn't saying it was the only reason but the village thing didn't help them and Morgan was a mess no matter what. But Drake was given an advantage if having Sandra that first episode and it help them dominate the first half of the season. And honestly it shows that them not having stuff hurt them.
@@Lsaldana92 That’s more of an issue with over committing to the pirate theme than Sandra speaking Spanish. It was almost haves vs have nots, and had Fairlay not thrown a challenge and handed Rupert over with the unexpected twist then Morgan would’ve been left with just a pot and machete by the merge. Rupert literally gave the Morgan tribe life and saved them from another Uulong situation
If the China rumor is true, it's such faulty logic on Survivor's part. The saying of "a team is only as strong as it's weakest player" is true but a team is also only as strong as it's strongest player. Add on to that the overwhelming carry potential for basically all of Survivor's team challenges as well as the ability to choose who sits out if you're a person over and you can quickly see the problems with the 4 strongest/4 weakest vs the 8 in the middle division.
With no James it would probably be OK, but if half of the challenges are physical and one tribe has a guy who could literally take on the whole of the other tribe and win, then you have a problem.
I'd argue Taki was weaker. Daniel and Lydia aren't what I'd call a physical force. Mike is probably their strongest member and even then he is not close to Jonathan or Rocksroy.
It seems bizarre to me to put a tribe with Rob and Tyson on the wrong side of a tribe mismatch. Both of them were driving forces behind dominant tribes in their most recent appearance (going into HvV) and put on great displays in the individual challenges as well. I'd give the edge to the heroes overall but not nearly so much as to be on this list.
Not to mention that Parvati and Danielle were both solid challenge competitors on their previous seasons, so it's not like it was only Rob and Tyson that carried the Villains tribe
I saw somewhere that Candice from Raro tribe and Parvati we’re supposed to switch tribes meaning: Candice from Raro tribe: Villain -> Hero Parvati: Hero -> Villain Had they did the switch, we could’ve gotten Black Widow Brigade 2.0
After premier of 45, I feel like the Lulu tribe will be in a new version of this video. I thought they were physically weaker in pre season analysis, but damn they’re WAY weaker. Kaleb has to do ALOT of carrying
I'm surprised you didn't mention the season that had one tribe living in luxury and comfort and the other tribe is given a flint and not much else and how the "rich" tribe was trouncing the other one.
he did mention it (fiji), at the very beginning of the video. as one of the seasons he would not be counting because that was (coincidentally) a tribe where the cast split themselves up.
Paused at 2 to predict the top spot: Pearl Islands. Not only does Drake have the stronger team no matter how you measure it they also had the ONLY Spanish speaker on a season where tribes had to barter for starting supplies with people who ONLY spoke Spanish. Morgan had no chance,
I love Survivor because of the psychology of it. Let's vote out our strongest player because he'll beat us when it become individual challenges. Weak minded people never win. I'd want to create a strong alliance with him/her so that when the tribe is merged, I might have a strong alliance so that I wouldn't be voted out until the very last part. Also, we'd probably win the reward challenges too. This would make us stronger physically at the time, while the other team is starving and unmotivated. Getting rid of Jimmy J was so stupid too. I think they were jealous of his success in life. So it's like we have one of the strongest leaders in the history of all things non-military, but let's vote him off early and be petty.
That's probably because puzzles featured heavily on DvG, and the David tribe had Christian, who took about 5 seconds to do the slide puzzle on the opening challenge
Out of everyone on Gabon, Randy, Corinne and Sugar were the most iconic. And it was very clear that Randy and Corinne's personalities were farther from heroes than Sugar so that's why she ended up on the Heroes.
12:12 - As a daughter of a retired P.E. Teacher, mom and I absolutely had the double standard put onto P.E. Teachers regarding physical ability. If she's good at a sport, oh of course she is, she's a P.E. Teacher. If she's bad at a sport, she should be better, she's a P.E. Teacher. 🙄 So to hear Survivor Casting expected physical gold from the P.E. Teacher, disappoints me but doesn't surprise me.
I kinda wonder what a season would look like if they used the exact same cast as the previous season. Obviously it would never happen as it wouldn’t make for that interesting of tv, but it would be interesting to see alliances formed by everyone who got fucked over by the eventual winner, and the person who came in last the first time around might go farther this time
I mean if look at the Coyopa tribe than Rocker and Nadeya should carry the tribe but than they lose all but two challenges and one of those wins was the immunity challenge Drew single-handedly threw to get rid of Kelly Wentworth.
@@cdawg4021 Not necessarily, because when Hunahphu had Jeremy/Jon/Reed/Drew/Natalie/Wentworth all on one tribe, while Wes and Rocker were pretty much it when it came to challenge strength for Coyopa, then it's easy to figure out what tribe would be winning most of the challenges
The Villains were lucky when JT gave Russell the Idol, because that's all they needed to get back in the game after losing Tyson and Boston Rob. It seems like such a dumb move by JT now, but remember that Survivor: Samoa didn't even air until Heroes vs Villains was close to finish filming, and with Parv, it was easy to assume that she was leading an all women alliance on the Villains tribe when you take Micronesia into account (poor Erik)
So we got lopsided tribe swaps and lopsided starting tribes. I'm just counting down the days until we get the top 5 blowouts in challenges, whether for tribe or individual challenges.
@@IdoledOut I'm surprised, because 29 was way more lopsided than 20 was...when Keith Nale and Missy are the only weak links on Hunaphu, it's a safe bet that that tribe wasn't going to be visiting Jeff that often
The wardog challenge montage is what keeps me going I literally spat out my food as soon as it started. This is the new candice from the raro tribe
I will accept any theme for a Survivor video that allows for the inclusion of the Wardog challenge montage!
In what sense? The Bobby quote about her? Her existence?
i will never get sick of the wardog challenge montage
came here for this comment
So embarrassing to call yourself "War dog" and can't come close to living up to that moniker. I laughed loud and long everytime someone said it.
@@garycarter6773 Reminds me of the dog named Alpha in Up with the chipmunk voice
@@vaporterra lol. :)
Wardog is the gift that keeps on giving
My first season was survivor China. I still remember watching those reward challenges that are basically "wrestle each other", and thought "........how is this even fun? how are those skinny men supposed to take on James and Aaron?"
The wrestle challenges that go on for like hours with the people utterly exhausted just stuck in a stalemate lol I think China and another season had one
@@ExitSiign you mean the one where they had to push massive balls? It was in Philippines where it resulted in stalemate. In China James just bulldozed everyone lmao
My first season was China too, I was immediately hooked and watched all the other seasons :)
@@cringeproof100 such a great season to start with, literally every character is entertaining and likeable in their own way 😂
Cagayan is a fair honorable mention. The Brawn tribe clearly dominated the challenges behind Cliff, Tony, Woo, and Sarah. The Beauty tribe was hilariously bad at working together, but at least they had LJ and Jeremiah. The Brain tribe is the Brain tribe. Garett is huge, but didn’t work well with the others. Kass couldn’t do much outside of puzzles, which they almost never let her do. They had Spencer soloing challenges half the time.
That might be partly because they had rice, genuinely
Trish made a smart move I think!
A really strange part is that in practice, The Beauty tribe was pretty much on par with the brawn tribe. There were five pre-swap challenges, and beauty got first in three of the five, and brawn in two of the five. With beauty having one loss, I'd call that about equal. And it wasn't just LJ and Jeremiah hard carrying the tribe. Alexis was crucial in puzzles and as the caller in the blindfold challenge, honestly doing at least as much as Jeremiah in challenges. And Morgan, Jefra, and Bryce were pretty good, especially Morgan, much to my delight on a recent rewatch (she did quite well in all the post merge challenges!)
They were bad at working together strategically. There's a reason brains and brawns effectively picked them off, but if there wasn't a swap, I think beauty has equal numbers to brawn going into the merge, or is like one down.
The brain tribe would probably ok if Jtia werent in it.
@@aronpuma5962 honestly, I hadn’t realized they had more pre-swap wins, thank you
are you telling us J'tia was not the challenge beast
That guy Manu voted out third had a lot of potential. Wish he’d get a second chance.
He did, but he only played 13 days unfortunately.........
His name was like… Chip Thunderwood or something
@@ADJ7046 No 🙄
His name was Dick Bigwood
@@evildeathcuddles886 🤣
@@evildeathcuddles886 pretty sure it was Clint Eastwood
Parvati being an unexpected challenge beast in Heros vs Villains did help the villains too.
Didn't she do well in Micronesia too though? I think that's when she really came out as a physical female threat.
I feel like she was always good in individual immunity challenges but I don’t have the data lol
@@YoshiDryBones She did pretty well in Cooks Island but usually took 3rd place to Ozzy and Yul. In Micronesia she did win an individual immunity, but she was more of a mastermind because she lost a challenge on purpose at the final 3. She also passed up on an immunity idol, so Parvati played a much more cautious game in Micronesia. While in Heros vs Villains Parvati wanted to not only win but be seen as the best because she was on a different level as far as challenges and she played two idols.
@@cringeproof100 She was always solid at challenges but she looked much stronger in Heros vs Villains.
@@zeaferjones1404 very smart since now she is the best lmfao
The Fans vs. Favorites in Caramoan probably had no shot.
As for season starting with 3 tribes, Matsing was destined to lose everything.
David vs Goliath was wildly outmatched too. John, Alec and Dan all on one tribe seemed like they had Dodgers-level payroll. Plus Jonathan on this season automatically makes the tribes imbalanced in favor of Taku.
I mean, on paper, there was nothing horribly wrong with Matsing.
@@Rodanguirus Yeah, Malcolm and Denise are strong competitors. And on paper Russell and Roxie should be strong too. The only all around weak link was Zane, and he was voted out first.
Production literally could have done a tribe swap and interfered and helped Matsing if they wanted to.
I’m fine with the fact that they didn’t - the tragic story was beautiful to watch. But I wish they would just never do it. It always screams production interference to me. Literally the producers saying “we don’t like the current storyline, let’s deliberately kill it.” I never understood why people are OK with tribe swaps but hate the idols they hid for Ben. It’s all production controlling the outcome way too much.
The school yard picks hit a little different because there’s agency for the players instead of production literally forcing the outcome they want.
@@lerdog The Angie erasure in that comment is something I'm not here for...no cookies for you
Considering the final 4 of HvV were all villains, it seems to have worked out well for them when they voted out Tyson and Rob.
They have JT to thank for that
@@vaporterra And Candice for flipping lol😂😂.
Fun Idea: 5 Survivor Players who lost their minds on the island.
Not including players like Coach and Debbie of course who already lost their minds coming into their season, but people who started the season as fairly standard normal people and by the time they get voted out they're just not even a human being anymore they're so insane.
Obvious examples that come to my head are Shane Powers, Brandon Hantz, J’Tia, and arguably Phillip Shephard.
First player that jumps to mind is Kathy from Micronesia. I remember reading somewhere that she was basically having a breakdown out there.
This comment made me choke 😂
If I never see a Hantz on tv again it’ll be too soon.
@@robbie7753 but didn't she already have some mental problems?
J’Tai - nothing says “lost their mind” like burning your tribe’s rice.
I definitely want to see an assessment of tribes created via school yard pick, and not just tribes created at the beginning of the game but also ones formed at tribe switches as well, such as in Panama, Micronesia, and even Gabon had a tribe shuffle based on yet another school yard pick decision.
he did that already lol
It reminds me when I was in school. I'm terribly unathletic and clumsy. However, I was never the last picked. Why, because people liked me. I was never picked high but towards the end where all the "losers" were, I'd be picked. It's like Survivor does the same but based on appearances. Who looks like they'd be a nice person?
This happens in Roblox Survivor, having the kids to pick the teams often results in me being the last pick and the easy vote out despite being the person carrying them for most of the challenges, thank goodness that many of these kids don't know how to find idols which helps me to get them out when they target me, leading to their friends to ragequit after one of them get blindsided
@@bartallen8121 and then when u immunity run to the end (so many people left that you immediately transported to the merge) the one juror votes their friend to win
@@noavink1 At least now the case is that there are bonus votes from Jeff so it isn't an auto win for the kid with a friend on the jury
Always knew I needed a Wardog challenge compilation. Thank you 🙏
I would like to bring attention to 15:49, where on the tribe swap letter that Zhan Hu receives, Jean-Robert's name is spelled as John Robert. I dont know what to do with this information but its funny regardless.
I'm surprised he didn't flip out (but he might have and it didn't make it into the show). People have the right to have their name pronounced properly. But he was such a douche, I almost don't care.
wardog is a legend dude. The montage was the kind of thing you see in a hof introduction vid!!
I know I suggested this before but last week sparked it up for me. Top 5 times one castaway single-handedly won a challenge for the whole tribe?
Jonathan just won single handedly for his tribe this past week
Yeah add guys with beard XD
@@desirae827 probably where the inspiration came from
there's also naseer last season singlehandedly cancelling out his tribe members' attempt at a challenge throw (as well as cliff who did the same in cagayan, rest in peace)
I literally choked on my food when the eagle screetched during the heroic Candace montage 😭
On paper the EoE tribes didn't look that bad. If Wardog was as competent as he looked the season's now pretty balanced. It also doesn't help when they vote out their only viable challenge competitor Chris premerge. Heroes vs Villains on the other hand, the heroes had a definite edge on the physical portion. They were winning just about every physical challenge but in challenges with puzzles, generally the puzzles are the part that matters more. You can gain or lose more time there than you can on the physical parts, and the villains had Rob who was single handedly carrying his tribe to wins on that portion.
That's what I like most about B-Rob, even if you don't care for his strategic game, he alone is really good in challenges and he's even better at getting a tribe to work together and lead them in the right direction.
I went DAMN when the strongest guy in Survivor China got the first boot
I just shake my head because the stupidity of this vote is glaringly obvious. This was not the first season, but some people don't watch the show before appearing on it. This is another glaringly stupid idea as well.
I absolutely love your videos. I do think this would be best with a title card at the beginning or end recognizing the untimely and recent passing away of Ashley Massaro, who is featured heavily in this video in kind of a negative light. She didn’t have a great survivor run, but I don’t think that should take away from remembering her tremendous accomplishments in wrestling and the great sacrifices she made for her daughter while she was with us. She also quite possibly had one of the worst and least functional starting outfits in survivor history, and didn’t get a fair shake compared to most survivors who have sneakers or any type of clothes they can move in. I would have absolutely loved to see her get another chance on any other more traditional season. Gone way way too soon. Rest in power Ashley 💪🏻🙏🏻
That’s so sad to hear she passed away. I was really rooting for her in Survivor and was sad when she got voted off so soon. She had so much potential for challenges and for entertainment, but getting sick kind of doomed her. Her wrestling is very impressive and her personality seemed fun from her brief time on the show. And she was only 39 when she died, definitely too soon 😔
That wardog compilation is Oscar worthy
I will submit it for the fan favorite award next year. If Zach Snyder can win, so can I
The Wardog kazoo montage always will make me laugh.
Absolutely dying at the Older Women bit
1 minute ago
the wardog comp is a classic🤣
Peridiam is great and everything, and I'ma let you finish, but Idoled Out is one of the greatest Survivor TH-cam channels of ALL TIME!
@@drewbyrd1093 They are both great at what they do
@@drewbyrd1093 I'm glad Idoled Out doesn't talk about Big Brother. I don't like that show.
@@drewbyrd1093 That's why I love him too. Big Brother is actually my favorite show. But it's because I like to watch the psychology of these shows. Big Brother has more of that into play. I only like TAR because I like to see the destinations.
They both put so much thought and effort into their videos. They don't just slap something together hoping to get people to watch because they like the TV show. Seriously these videos are almost academic because of the quality of content.
Starting tribes from China because yeah, and Drake vs Morgan in PI because Drake had Sandra the only Spanish in the whole cast and they had to that first day get your supplies from this local village thing.
That wasn’t even the problem with Morgan. The problem with Morgan is they couldn’t get their egos out of their way and communicate. Ryano saved money for the boat and didn’t tell anyone, Skinny Ryan got booted too early cause he couldn’t dive and was physically weaker, then Lill hit the same treatment. Then there’s Osten almost drowning and being on the verge of quitting for a few tribals in a row but their egos didn’t let them mercy kill. Meanwhile outside of the Shawn/Burton vs Rupert/Fairplay fiasco, Drake was a functional tribe
@@jolteon345 I wasn't saying it was the only reason but the village thing didn't help them and Morgan was a mess no matter what. But Drake was given an advantage if having Sandra that first episode and it help them dominate the first half of the season. And honestly it shows that them not having stuff hurt them.
@@Lsaldana92 That’s more of an issue with over committing to the pirate theme than Sandra speaking Spanish. It was almost haves vs have nots, and had Fairlay not thrown a challenge and handed Rupert over with the unexpected twist then Morgan would’ve been left with just a pot and machete by the merge. Rupert literally gave the Morgan tribe life and saved them from another Uulong situation
Welcome to Idoled Out, where we separate the Alpha Gamer Gods from the Weenie Hut, Jr.'s.
Lmao 😂
You owe me a new beer. The Candice Eagle made me spit take
Jane calling Marty Farty always cracks me up lol
Not Farty, it's Mister Farty. That boomer humor energy, never gets old. ;)
If the China rumor is true, it's such faulty logic on Survivor's part. The saying of "a team is only as strong as it's weakest player" is true but a team is also only as strong as it's strongest player. Add on to that the overwhelming carry potential for basically all of Survivor's team challenges as well as the ability to choose who sits out if you're a person over and you can quickly see the problems with the 4 strongest/4 weakest vs the 8 in the middle division.
With no James it would probably be OK, but if half of the challenges are physical and one tribe has a guy who could literally take on the whole of the other tribe and win, then you have a problem.
On paper Ika looked VERY weak compared to the other tribes, but it seems to be working out for them.
must be the extra strength they get from having tori's angelina-esque cheerleader skills
@@uglyaniimals 🤣🤣
I'd argue Taki was weaker. Daniel and Lydia aren't what I'd call a physical force. Mike is probably their strongest member and even then he is not close to Jonathan or Rocksroy.
It seems bizarre to me to put a tribe with Rob and Tyson on the wrong side of a tribe mismatch. Both of them were driving forces behind dominant tribes in their most recent appearance (going into HvV) and put on great displays in the individual challenges as well. I'd give the edge to the heroes overall but not nearly so much as to be on this list.
Not to mention that Parvati and Danielle were both solid challenge competitors on their previous seasons, so it's not like it was only Rob and Tyson that carried the Villains tribe
Now you can change “so and so carrying their tribe to a challenge win” to “Jonathan (S42) carrying his tribe to a win. Literally carrying them! 😂
Is it strange that I remember where I was when I watched the swapped tribes video? Guess it left an impact.
But where were you?
@@IdoledOut study hall, not doing my calculus!
No, I remember I was when certain events happened too. But only if I wasn't home watching by myself.
I have never in my life watched an episode of Survivor, yet I've watched many many hours of your videos lol.
The most lopsided tribe in the history of the world is the tribe that loves stew and the weaklings who don't.
I saw somewhere that Candice from Raro tribe and Parvati we’re supposed to switch tribes meaning:
Candice from Raro tribe: Villain -> Hero
Parvati: Hero -> Villain
Had they did the switch, we could’ve gotten Black Widow Brigade 2.0
Jonathan should not have any tribemates in 42. He's already to strong on his own
Seriously, everyone else should be on a tribe against him. And he'd still probably win.
@@IdoledOut He probably would win against Joe Anglim.
@@IdoledOut aged like milk
Wow, when you went through Naviti and Malolo I was shocked how unfair the tribe casting was, I never realized that til now
That montage never gets old lol
In Cagayan, beauty had massive LJ and Jeremiah. Brawn had huge Cliff and Tony and Woo. Poor Spencer was up against all of them.
After premier of 45, I feel like the Lulu tribe will be in a new version of this video. I thought they were physically weaker in pre season analysis, but damn they’re WAY weaker. Kaleb has to do ALOT of carrying
You never miss your shot to straight up dog on Candice 😂
4:15 - sure you can keep Rob forever but that means only 2 things: 1) Rob wins 2) Jeff’s happy.
OMG I LOVE IT - The war-dog bit LMFAO
I'm surprised you didn't mention the season that had one tribe living in luxury and comfort and the other tribe is given a flint and not much else and how the "rich" tribe was trouncing the other one.
he did mention it (fiji), at the very beginning of the video. as one of the seasons he would not be counting because that was (coincidentally) a tribe where the cast split themselves up.
Paused at 2 to predict the top spot: Pearl Islands. Not only does Drake have the stronger team no matter how you measure it they also had the ONLY Spanish speaker on a season where tribes had to barter for starting supplies with people who ONLY spoke Spanish. Morgan had no chance,
OK so clearly we were thinking on different wavelengths but IMO Pearl Islands has a MASSIVELY lopsided starting tribe dynamic.
Oh boy Wardog. He looks like Tony's cousin but his challange performance is at same level like Dan Lembo from S21 Nicaragua
That Wardog montage is legendary
War dog the Challenge god!
We are not the same. I would take any excuse to talk about Gabon.
Naviti Strong! You picked great lopsided tribes. How in Gabon, Fang was picked that way, still mind boggles me.
Five minutes in and I could no longer stand that drone.
i didnt even realize how fucking strong the heroes tribe was
You probably didn't notice because of how badly they did at puzzles.
I love Survivor because of the psychology of it. Let's vote out our strongest player because he'll beat us when it become individual challenges. Weak minded people never win. I'd want to create a strong alliance with him/her so that when the tribe is merged, I might have a strong alliance so that I wouldn't be voted out until the very last part. Also, we'd probably win the reward challenges too. This would make us stronger physically at the time, while the other team is starving and unmotivated. Getting rid of Jimmy J was so stupid too. I think they were jealous of his success in life. So it's like we have one of the strongest leaders in the history of all things non-military, but let's vote him off early and be petty.
OMG THE WARDOG COMPILATION IM DEAD 🤣
I hope Taku is on here haha
Considering the fact that every tribe has lost immunity exactly one time so far, I think it's too early to call.
We need a video dedicated to the queen of meme herself, Candice
Best tribes in new era of survivor according to me :
41. Luvu tribe (danny, DeShawn, naseer, erika, Heather, Sydney)
42. Taku tribe (Jonathan, Omar, jackson, Lindsay, Maryanne, maria)
43. Coco tribe (ryan, Geo, James, Cassidy, Lindsay, karla)
44. Ratu tribe (brandon, kane, Matthew, maddy, lauren, jaime)
45. Belo tribe ( bruce, jake, brando, Kendra, Katurah, kellie,
46. Nami tribe (hunter, randen, tevin, venus, soda, liz)
Casting hit an all-time Malolo low, with these tribe divisions.
Editing a eagle cry over a clip of a bat for Candace... hilarious.
I find it funny that the 2 seasons surrounding DvG (ghost island and EoE) are both on this list but the literal DAVID VS GOLIATH tribes aren’t 🤣
That's probably because puzzles featured heavily on DvG, and the David tribe had Christian, who took about 5 seconds to do the slide puzzle on the opening challenge
Five fewer working knees. I’m dying.
“It’s a fun conspiracy like Bigfoot existing or the moon being real.”
Biggest What If in Survivor; what the HvV cast had been able to watch Samoa and see Russell's playbook before going out?
In Hero’s vs villains James should’ve been on the villains squad and that significantly makes it more balanced
Wardog was the male version of Crystal
How come Candace is always called out as being misplaced on the Heroes tribe but I never hear anything about Sugar? How tf is Sugar a hero???
Both Candice and Sugar belonged on that season way more than Amanda.
Sugar is one of my least favorite people to ever be on that show
Out of everyone on Gabon, Randy, Corinne and Sugar were the most iconic. And it was very clear that Randy and Corinne's personalities were farther from heroes than Sugar so that's why she ended up on the Heroes.
11:52 His job is beach. Just beach.
12:12 - As a daughter of a retired P.E. Teacher, mom and I absolutely had the double standard put onto P.E. Teachers regarding physical ability. If she's good at a sport, oh of course she is, she's a P.E. Teacher. If she's bad at a sport, she should be better, she's a P.E. Teacher. 🙄
So to hear Survivor Casting expected physical gold from the P.E. Teacher, disappoints me but doesn't surprise me.
No idea what he acted like, since I haven't seen the season, but Wardog seems like a sweetheart 😂
Also calling the 30s old..
Ravu vs Moto pre-merge Fiji was pretty crazy. They should have named the season "Haves vs Have-Nots"
I kinda wonder what a season would look like if they used the exact same cast as the previous season. Obviously it would never happen as it wouldn’t make for that interesting of tv, but it would be interesting to see alliances formed by everyone who got fucked over by the eventual winner, and the person who came in last the first time around might go farther this time
Damn bro i would cry if i was on one of those tribes and i watched this video ur ruthless lmao
Omg not Taps for Candace!
You should do a video about worst challenge competitors/challenge performances in survivor history
Crystal Cox from Gabon or Wardog from Edge of Extinction.
I think we need a video just for a WarDog montage 😂
Thems are some fighting words about the exile island “older women” tribe. 😂
🤣🤣
"and I got downhearteeeeed... Every time that I -"
"-PUMBA! Not in front of the kids!"
Haha "Farty"
San Juan Del Sur is also extremely lop sided
I mean if look at the Coyopa tribe than Rocker and Nadeya should carry the tribe but than they lose all but two challenges and one of those wins was the immunity challenge Drew single-handedly threw to get rid of Kelly Wentworth.
@@cdawg4021 Not necessarily, because when Hunahphu had Jeremy/Jon/Reed/Drew/Natalie/Wentworth all on one tribe, while Wes and Rocker were pretty much it when it came to challenge strength for Coyopa, then it's easy to figure out what tribe would be winning most of the challenges
fun fact! the "pe teacher" on malolo was actually my PE teacher!
Yeah I can never understand the tribe matchups in edge of extinction. Genuinely what were they thinking
🤣 I'm literally rewatching China while watching this as well.
1:10 Excuse me? Survivor Gabon is a good season.
7:03 can this be Wardog's official theme song?
the fact that i preferred almost everyone on the villains team than almost everyone on the heroes team on heroes vs villains
Best tribes in new era or survivor according to me :
41. Luvu tribe
42. Taku tribe
43. Coco tribe
44.
45. Reba tribe
46. Nami tribe
i hope laurens crush isnt joe anymore
I agree with the top 1 pick.
I'm surprised David vs Goliath wasn't mentioned although that was kinda the theme of the season
Flashback to Harry Styles.....
H: this is a family show .......or is it?
🤭🤭
For what the heroes won in challenges, the villains made up for in game play
When your second strongest guy on your tribe is Wardog, you're in trouble in the challenges.
did bro just say Chris Lauren and WARDOG to carry a team (did yall not see Wardog try to throw)
What if the physical challenges were every tribe member at the same time, besides challenges like Schmergen Brawl
The Villains were lucky when JT gave Russell the Idol, because that's all they needed to get back in the game after losing Tyson and Boston Rob. It seems like such a dumb move by JT now, but remember that Survivor: Samoa didn't even air until Heroes vs Villains was close to finish filming, and with Parv, it was easy to assume that she was leading an all women alliance on the Villains tribe when you take Micronesia into account (poor Erik)
If there was one thing Naviti proved it was that purple tribes can be dominant and produce winners without being made of returning players.
Can we please have a top ten Coach moments video?
Heroes were stronger physically the Villains were better in terms of puzzles.
So we got lopsided tribe swaps and lopsided starting tribes. I'm just counting down the days until we get the top 5 blowouts in challenges, whether for tribe or individual challenges.
lemme guess
season 15
season 29
Season 36
Season 37
Season 38
37 and 29 just missed the cut for me, as did 11!
@@IdoledOut ah!
@@IdoledOut I'm surprised, because 29 was way more lopsided than 20 was...when Keith Nale and Missy are the only weak links on Hunaphu, it's a safe bet that that tribe wasn't going to be visiting Jeff that often