We Compete to Make the Most SATISFYING CGi #4
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 เม.ย. 2023
- Our videos are made possible by our amazing website subscribers. Consider joining us! ► corridordigital.com/
The crew competes to make the most SATISFYING render in the 3D Program of their choice. Hopefully they can impress their friend Wes...
Jordan's VFX TUTORIAL ► www.corridordigital.com/
More Satisfying Render Challenges ► • We Compete to Make the...
Follow us on Instagram ►
/ corridordigital
OUR GEAR, SOFTWARE & PARTNERS ►
Puget Systems Computers: bit.ly/PC_Puget_Workstations
Lighting by Aputure: bit.ly/CORRIDOR_LIGHTS
Our Go-To Gear: bhpho.to/3r0wEnt
ActionVFX: bit.ly/TheBest_ActionVFX
Cinema4D: bit.ly/Try_Cinema4D
Nuke by The Foundry: bit.ly/Nuke_Compositing
Simulations in Houdini: bit.ly/HoudiniSims
Octane Render by OTOY: bit.ly/Octane_Wrender
MUSIC ►
Epidemic: bit.ly/Corridor_Music click this link for a free month! - บันเทิง
Honestly, I feel like Peter’s can totally loop with the hedgehog peacefully closing its eyes and dreaming about the night the farmer found him in the rain.
I thought the same, and I've seen others say that as well. Hopefully Peter sees the comments and adds a loop transition lol
Damn thats insane
Yeah!
I was totally expecting that!
Yeah, but it would be hella unsatisfying. The satisfying part was the warmth of the story. Take that away and it becomes a story about a hedgehog suffering the wild on loop.
Another 4 years for finishing this animation. It'll be 2027 and TH-cam will no longer exists.
I think one thing wren missed is that people kept watching not only because they didn't realise it was a loop, but because they wanted to see the flat surface after all the puzzle pieces have fallen in. Watching that puzzle piece render gives you an 'edging' kind of feeling, it perpetually feels so close to being complete and satisfying.
yeah, its the satisfying events while approaching expected perfection which really made the puzzle loop blow up.
Gross
Yes exactly. It almost has to be slightly unsatisfying so people will keep looping it in the hope it at some point becomes fully satisfying.
"an edging kind of feeling" never have I heard that term perfectly sum up a situation.
High-tolerance fitments are incredibly satisfying to most people. Perfect fits are like crack to the brain.
After seeing Peter's I think they should see who can make the most emotional renders. Really tug at the heartstrings.
Nothing will beat Fry's dog waiting for him outside de pizza shop for the rest of his life.
Amazing suggestion!
In my opinion, the thing that makes Wren's viral satisfying render work is specifically the sound design combined with the physics of the puzzle pieces sliding into the holes that are perfectly machined to slide in with just the right amount of resistance that alerts your subconscious that the two pieces are perfect fits. I don't intend to be negative, but i kinda feel like a lot of these renders are missing that element and instead are going for the loop and complexity and fantastical-ness. I think Fenner's pool render actually is the one that gets closest to the nuts and bolts of what makes Wren's puzzle render successful, but it doesn't reach it because pool balls going into giant holes doesn't scratch that same itch of machined objects with perfect fit. Jordan's render is more akin to Wren's viral render in terms of it depicting machinery, but i think it misses because it went for complexity of the machinery, which distracts from the precision of the pieces moving together partly due to having to be zoomed out to a wide shot to see all the machinery. Which causes you to lose the details of the perfect fit machinery happening that you need to see in a closer shot. And Peter's render, while visually fantastic and as well as being emotive... It literally has nothing to do with this specific challenge outside of the farmer character sliding the house roof on. I get you can say it's emotionally satisfying and give a pass on that technicality, but come on, we know what this challenge is actually supposed to be about lol.
just want to add that in Peter's render the nail hit and the paint strokes were also intended to be perfect and thus satiesfying.
Bro wrote a whole essay on it
@@Mr.Nuggy. It be like that sometimes.
@@Mr.Nuggy. Just the past few lines were.
Bruh the 300 page essay ending with lol
Peter:
he wins because its more satisfying to finally finish the video than to do the challenge
Its so amazing tho
well, I guess WES actually had a killer argument to keep Peter in the chalenge... so they did!
Peter should just have the hedgehog DREAM of the rain for the looping moment... just some comic like thought-bubbles around the little head with the shut eyes, growing until they cover the whole frame and lead you to the first image!
Fr lol
When i was studying Animation, 1 project we had which was fun. Everyone in the Class was given the Same 10 second Audio Clip of noises/sound fx, and everyone had to make a scene that fit the audio. Everyones was different and unique, it was quite interesting to see what people did to weird sounds. Think you guys should do the same. Same Audio clip, you all have to Create a scene/animation that fits to it
That's such a great idea!
I really like this idea.
yes :)
This sounds like a really fun idea!
Terrific idea! Corridor needs to read this comment!
I found the three elements of building the house was very satisfying…the one hammer hit completely sinking the nail, that is extremely difficult to do in real life, then one stroke of the brush perfectly covering one board with paint was satisfying, and finally the roof sliding on perfectly. As a amateur carpenter who has made a dog house and many other home projects, this was amazingly satisfying…to create something that helps someone you love, that’s amazing! Standing ovation. ❤
I even loved how the paint covered it like paint. For example, the third and fourth boards showed imperfection in the grains, and appropriately they did not get a perfectly "even" covering when he swiped the brush, but they got just enough to show the grain... amazing. The imperfections add to the realism and feel
Yes, the roof getting put on was satisfying. But also couldn't it side off if pushed towards the back enough?
Also, finally getting to see the final product after 2 years was the most satisfying thing.
@@idkmyname12 Yes, I have a chicken coop thats pretty similar, but the roof is pretty fuckin heavy, not much is gonna push the roof off that wouldnt take the entire chicken coop with it.
Corridor once again proving that they are amazing VFX artists who struggle to understand what a satisfying render is lol
Man, Peters animation would have been perfection if only as the Hedgehog closed his eyes at the end, thunder strikes and he wakes up back outside, creating the loop to begin the animation once again.
Release the Keelan Jon agitation cut!
Exactly what I was thinking.
Yeah I can't tell if it's just one of those obvious things that slipped his mind or if he ended up running out of time again haha
I was expecting it to keep zooming in as it closes it's eyes then the lightning strikes and it's in the rain again.
But yeah that would have been perfect!!
@@steamer2k319 It's a good thing I know my way around blender 🤣
As realistic as possible cryptid / UFO render challenge, let's go! The goal is for the other crew members not to be able to debunk it.
hehe yes
Create the most convincing UFO footage.
I LOVE this idea they should totally do this!
With CD as the judge
bloody good idea
It would be cool if you guys did a “most realistic render” challenge where you make something as photo-real as possible. Another cool idea would be to do a practical effects challenge. I feel like in react you talk about practical stuff frequently and it would be a sweet exercise to try and make something yourself. Maybe in teams of 3 or something similar
If you were to somehow combine Jordan’s and Wren’s… it would be perfect. Wren’s concept with Jordan’s immaculate colour design and textures. Also, here’s a theme I’ve been wanting you guys to do for a while: satisfying Rube Goldberg machines!
They realy should make rube goldberg machines
I think Peter should remake this every year so we can see his progress.
Remake and add scenes to it every year, til it becomes a short movie.
@@zamora3D yes, or like they have competitions to make the best short film.
It would be sweet to see a “Remastered” Challenge, where you guys take super old projects of yours and make them better with all your new knowledge since then
Especially with Clint's zen garden! :)
I'll second that; I'd love to see a full episode on it!
what makes a good satisfying video is the anticipation and suspense, Peter completing an old project meant it had months of anticipation built up behind it, and the fact that it's finally complete makes it the most satisfying of all.
Simplicity is key to satisfaction. Find something simple and perfect it, instead of spreading your time between different parts of a render.
This is why the puzzle piece was so magnificent. So simple, so satisfying. Jordan's render was too complicated.
Jordan was such a good hire for the crew. Man has great banter!
That reminds me that I haven't seen Jordan for a while. Did something happen to her?
@@theevilteacher we see her in almost every video, often on the sponsored content side of things. i think shes more behind the scene now.
He's a sunshine filled bundle of joy. But he won't hesitate to cut a fool if they step outta line.
Jordan my fav.
@@progactif is jordan a guy or a girl? i see he and her
The satisfaction of seeing Peter finally finish his animation after two years makes up for the fact that he broke the rules of the challenge.
All his animation needed to be looped was a swirling transition to a hedgehog dream of being rescued.
@@MichalKaczorowski that's genius!
meta satisfaction
@@MichalKaczorowski yep I thought for sure after the hedgehog closed its eyes that the camera would zoom in and fade into a dream sequence to restart it
@@flenoble i was hoping for the hedgehog to open its eyes, camera zooms in on one of the eyes, and the eye is reflecting the start of the animation
thanks for having me guys!!! this was dope!
😂
Need you in more fam. Loved your vines.
Satisfying simplicity: soft/pastel colors, symmetry, simple sounds, simple environment and simple looping (as I have come to observe) are keys for satisfaction.
What I found superb about Wren's puzzle blocks render was the material. The reflections, the texture of the surface that affected the reflections, the way the different bits of the pieces emitted light that subsurfaced or something as the pieces sank. It also had a goal, in pieces sliding into the position that allows them to sink. When it looks and sounds right, the perfect motion that serves the goal gets amplified and transcends from artificial to satisfying.
This new render just looked CGI, in the sense that it looked unreal. It didn't FEEL like materials. The cloth just forms out of nothing, its texture swirls spastically, and when the tube comes in, it kinda tenses in 8 directions suddenly before it gets "sucked" in. It lacks tangibility. It lacks a goal.
Totally agreed. I feel like the golden orb one sorta hit on the same notes. Would be easy to watch a bunch of loops of it if the material changed a few times.
You really hit the nail on the head with the element of reality to these renders being a vital aspect. The abstract "rendered" looking stuff is always phenomenal, but that puzzle render looks like real pieces of machined metal with some abstract touches sliding into place perfectly. We've all see those zero tolerance machining videos. That shit is SATISFYING as fuck to watch. Wren tapped into that with the puzzle render. Something that looks and feels tanigble while doing something novel or "impossible" feeling is what makes it for me.
100% agree. I kinda think a lot of these satisfying renders have jumped the shark as to what Wren's puzzle block render actually achieved. It's the materials, the simplicity, the physics, the sound, and the fact that (with Dude Perfect levels of precision and repeated attempts) you could actually do it in real life. Like Technical Gaming said, Wren's puzzle render tapped into the essence of what makes zero tolerance machining videos so good. And i think it's interesting that in the video when Wren was analyzing his own puzzle render, even he didn't seem to isolate that element of why his puzzle render worked so well. The fact that it looped helped, but the zero tolerance machining aspect is what really makes the puzzle render shine.
Yeah I actually agree with your feedback. I had some ideas that would've taken my cloth renders a little further but ultimately I didn't have the time to take it that far. It's ok though! I'm still happy with mine despite not getting it to a better point. As pointed out in this video, I think I'll always be trying to measure up to the puzzle render haha.
@@SirWrender Good luck in your future endeavors.
Peter may be onto an interesting series idea, or at least a one-off, revisiting past renders and taking your skills you''ve learned over the years and "updating" them.
imo he kinda made it worse though. The original was nicely stylized and the hair/fur almost looked like brush strokes
@@Bolt6265 New version entered an uncanny walley. Such realistic rendering requires a motion capture and full hair physics, or it breaks. The old one was s stylized CG so people do not expect realistic movement from it.
I’ve always wanted Pixar to revisit the first Toy Story and make a remastered version that better matches the rest of the movies. At the same time I don’t know if that would be a slap in the face to the people that worked on the original because I think nobody would ever choose to watch it over a remastered version.
@@heyjustj Right, like how everyone universally loved George Lucas's updated versions of the original Star Wars trilogy. 😂
@@mr.maikawa I get that, but he also changed things about the actual movie. Even if they updated textures, ray tracing, fur simulations, etc. The first Toy Story has some uncanny valley stuff and weird things going on that IMO could use a face lift.
That gold ball one was literally perfect, everything the visuals the sound
I haven’t seen any mechanical satisfaction, like a perfect reload of an M1 Garand, followed by the ping.
Hard disagree: the laser cutting was off center and the ball didn’t fall straight which completely ruined it for me.
@@supC_ I agree with you supC I think if it was a thin laser that let the ball fall as one piece. Then hit the top and split into two sides that slid down the ramp would have made it near perfect.
@@supC_ yeah I wish that the lazer made the ball melt evenly into both sides, not split into two. actually I really just wish there was no lazer, but like an endless series of golden spheres being produced, polished and wisked away to somewhere.
What made Peter's so satisfying is actually finally being able to see his amazing short video!
one of the best series on youtube, change my mind
No i don't think a will...
I think the better series is where people go to impoverished countries to help them out financially
@@martialmurdock6866 incorrect opinion
The Bob Ross challenge is up there
No can do.
There's a very simple way to make Peter's animation loop nicely. Cut after the final hedgehog close-up in the sun to the exact same shot but at night, in the rain, like it was all a dream, and loop back to the beginning
I was thinking the same thing.
THATS what I thought was going to happen, missed opportunity for a perfect satisfying loop
I was thinking a nice loop might be to pan to other houses, or "Hedgehog Rescue" on his back, then it'd loop to him saving another hedgehog with the same level of care
That's more of a nightmare, getting reduced then scared again because you dreamed it.
Yeah the easy way to loop it would be to just start with a camera pull out that's so close to the hedgehog's nose that the first frame is all black, end with the push in to a full frame of black hedgehog nose. Might've had to darken the nose texture a bit, but it'd work.
I really loved the pool shot one, I think if it was rendered with more vibrant colors it would go TikTok viral
It was OK but missed a lot of potential. One of the most satisfying parts of pool is the ricochet shots and I wish he relied on those more. It would help with suspense especially having the 8 ball bounce off the walls multiple times before slowing down and barely making it into the hole with a satisfying clunck. (Also longer shots would help disperse the manual correction that looked liked wind?? and make. it less obvious)
That flip fluids transition to talking about it for an hour is comedy gold 😂
Huge props to Peter for actually finishing that little movie of his! That hedgehog needed a home and he delivered.
Always nice to see Peter wander out of his room to drop some content every once in a while.
16:00 that could have looped by adding a lightning strike and rain and the hedgehog waking up as if the entire thing was a dream!
It would be horribly sad tho D:
I´ve not seen anyone say it so I will: You all did an AMAZING job, I had to pause the video to choose which one I liked the most for like 30 seconds. Seeing you all compete to make CGI feels like watching very skilled martial arts expert fight. It´s needless to say that I loved every and each one of the renders. Congratulations to you all, your careers and skills are to be very proud of.
Peter finishing the animation after 2 years is where the real satisfaction is
i just imagine a looped version of peters render with a lightning strike waking up the little creature
I saw the critter waking up, and realizing that the last however long was a dream. The close up on the face/eyes looping into the start of the critter in the rain.
@@tobrinajolly3714 Nah that would be such a sad end to the video 🤣🤣🤣You realise the critter never actually got rescued, he was just dreaming about it 😂😂😂
This is also exactly what I imagined lol
Striking the house so it breaks and hedgehog runs away.
@@bulletproof1581 Yeah but then it is rescued again
What’s ironic is that you all set out to make incredibly satisfying videos, but in the process you have officially made the word “satisfy” into the new “moist”.
Peters not only had visual and auditory satisfaction, but it had nostalgic, anticipatory, and emotional satisfaction.
Main thing on Wren's jigsaw render for me was, that its constantly building up to something and you keep wondering what the finished product will look like. None of the following renderings have that.
2:15 "I like machines that make things and break things"
I love the way you enthusiastically proceed to describe it, spectacular series
it does feel VERY satisfying to finally see the complete video we've been waiting for from Peter for two years now! I was so surprised lol
We need more of these challenges. They are the best!!!
I'm glad we got the Peter cut, but I don't think it should have overshadowed the other entries, especially since the other entries have again raised the bar. Then again, I am immensely satisfied so I shouldn't complain. Another satisfying render challenge please! Maybe some new rules like a shared common theme
I think what made Wren's first render so good was the sounds, and I really enjoyed watching him make them himself in that first video! I think a challenge where you make the team go back to previous renders they've done and make the sounds from scratch would be really interesting.
I have binge watched all 4 of these and I have an idea that I am going to try to attempt to make. As a slightly OCD person, I really like everything on my desk to be exactly perpendicular or parallel to everything else on the desk and the desk itself. I am going to attempt to make a loop that has an arm and hand moving everything on a messy desk, perfectly in place. You guys inspire the HELL out of me to learn VFX. Thank you for helping me find a true passion of mine.
They are all so good at storytelling! Amazing to already imagine the end result while hearing the initial idea.
There is nothing more satisfying than another satisfying render challenge video from the Corridor Crew!
Never fails to make me feel at-ease with your CGI animations!
yo we have similar pfp
@@kmimkl close
Alright. Hear me out. I have an idea and I think one of you is going to really like it. These satisfying renders usually loop in a 1:1 ratio, meaning that everything that needs to be reset gets reset fully at the same time before the short loop begins again. Try creating an extra long loop where different elements reset at different rates. For example, in a 2:3 ratio loop, one of the objects resets at the 1/2 mark and at the end, and another object resets at the 1/3, 2/3 marks at and the end. For a 12-second loop that would be Object A resets at :06 and :12 and Object B resets at :04 and :08 and :12.
This probably has in overall the most satisfying renders in a challenge so far, all were amazing
It is incredible to see each of these artists' evolution throughout this series. Learning from past mistakes, wins, ideas, combinations etc, and then bring all of that to the current challenge to showcase the best of what their talents can create.
I feel like the renders so far have been really colourful and machine based. If there was a theme for next time, I'd wanna see what you can do with only black and white. Bonus points if you can do it without it having a mechanical base.
I love the mechanical renders, but I am very much in favour of a black and white/greyscale/monochrome theme!
What do you mean by mechanical base?
@@MasterReady12 The ones that simulate machinery, like the gold one.
im always so excited for when another one of these finally comes out
They just keep getting better wow!! I think the gold ball was my favorite. Something about the colors and the liquid sim together was just perfection!
The answers to your question "shall we do an NFT?" are always going to be "no" and "unsuscribed".
5k views in 5 minutes, man, this channel's content never ceases to amaze. Been watching since 2011 when you were just coming out from making stuff in the garage with just Sam and Niko, to seeing the scale it has grown to. Props, props indeed!
Also Wren made his render from butthole looking to phallus lookin
W comment I agree
NOW ITS 32K IN 30 MINUTES!
Now its 60 min and 62k views
95k in 2 hours
I love what Fenner did! So cinematic and satisfying. But Sir Wrender is still an MVP at delivering satisfaction. 👌🏼
The most satisfying thing is seeing another episode of this series on my reccomended
The most satisfying part of these videos is watching the artists of Corridor Digital push past their previous limits. Wren is a god and will always be regarded as an “Iron VFX Chef”.
I’m consistently impressed by Peter. I’m so glad Corridor took a chance and brought him onboard.
A render challenge I'd recommend is similar to what jazza is doing where you get a random prompt of description of a certain render (usually very vague) and all the competitors have to visualize the prompt in their own manner and art style. This will bring out a lot of waky ideas and humour while making them especially if it's one of those time limit ones. That's my recommendation hope you consider it and love your channel and vids🔥👌🏾
I think the biggest satisfaction was to see the improvement in Peter's work.
When Corridor drops its like Christmas morning came early
I'd like to see them compete against real ASMR vs animated ASMR. Would be fun
There is nothing more satisfying than another satisfying render challenge video from the Corridor Crew
Legit a copied comment
I genuinely love listening to Jordan talk about something he's interested and invested in. The first few minutes of this video and his critique of the VFX production process in The Flash video are fantastic. As much as I love these Satisfying CGI videos and the Bowling Animation competitions, I think I'm going to subscribe just for more Jordan.
Peter wins, hands down. I've been waiting SO LONG to be satisfied with this!
Peter is just insane. He's making a movie in a week while his main projekt is his own game. Crazy stuff
always glad to see people like Peter and Wes. not that the normal crew is boring, just makes it seem like a special occasion
Everyone was simply incredible. Satisfied beyond belief.
You guys have satisfied me more times than I can count! Please continue the LOOPING satisfactory videos!
I feel like a satisfying horror challenge would be a good one tough one too. So not only does it need to make you scared it needs to satisfy
This is brilliant, and would make for an excellent Halloween video. “How perfectly can the machete cleave someone in half? Click here to find out!”
...those are kind of opposite vibes. The point of horror is the adrenaline rush that comes from being afraid, triggering that fight/flight response. The point of a satisfying video is the relaxed endorphin rush it gives.
Completely different vibes and different chemicals activated in the body.
If horror satisfies you the same a perfectly fitting object does or like petting a fluffy cute animal...You've got some pretty crossed wires going on
@@PacMonster0 Ever seen Midsommar?
A vote for Jordan's render! Thanks for another cool challenge!
All were fabulous. The gold ball satisfied me the most. Bravo!
The breaking apart of the gold orb is perfect. Clear winner!
Being able to satisfy a whole group of men like that is no small feat. Firm handshakes all-around. 👏
Only skillful people can satisfy a whole group of men like that. 👏
I want to see them do something like what peter did. Take an old satisfying loop, improve it, and extend the loop to take an old satisfying loop to new levels of satisfying.
Contrast!
Great job everyone! Next render challenge should focus on contrasting elements. I think that is what Wren's first masterpiece really captured. There was significant contrast between the rough texture of concrete, followed by a smooth slide and pop that morphed into a seemless piece. I believe that is what made the render truly satisfying and I would love to see everyone's render focus on Contrast.
To me, satisfaction in these videos is all about the perfect fit. I think that is what made that first video go viral. Seamless fits make brain go whooo
I love how many non sponsored shout outs y'all give companies because you actually use them, like them, and want their name out there as well as giving your audience knowledge
I feel like a tight depth of field and high texture detail plays a big role in satisfaction and is an overlooked part of what made Wren's puzzle slider so successful, so here's my suggestion for a theme: using macro shots, make a loop that takes us back to our childhoods and explore classic boardgames, Legos, or other toys we might've grown up with. Reignite those feelings of euphoria we felt with those pieces of plastic, wood, and cardboard between our fingertips!
A render challenge where it is both trickshot and satisfying AND it has to loop. Now that would be something I would watch over and over again.
Great vid always fun to watch your challenges
Accidental Wins. Its an older viral category but its great. People passing a football back and forth and a bus drives by with the windows down and the football goes perfectly through the bus windows, and perfectly on accident. Stuff like that, slipping on a banana peel and doing a perfect back flip, etc.
I like the idea of doing a render that appears to be a satisfying loop but then transitions into an unsatisfying render and make that process the loop
I think they did that in their unsatisfying render challenge; cause all of of them went for the 'make it seem kinda satisfying' strat and then 'ruined it' on purpose
I loved that Peter finished his old one, but if I'm being honest, I believe once again Wren had the most satisfying render. Not as good as his first one, but, it just hit all the checkmarks of a satisfying render for me.
Also one of the rules were looping, and Peter didnt really loop
Personally, Wren takes my point again. A huge part of the puzzledrop was knowing how little there actually was to it, and putting a heavy focus on the sound. And now, I love the sounds he used while scrambling his fabrics
There’s a type of kinetic sculpture called a gravitram that’s kind of like a contained Rube Goldberg machine. Or mechanically raises balls and drops them onto tracks that weave around each other, and balls on one track can flip switches that affect other tracks. Making a render of one would be a huge amount of work but it would also make for an immensely satisfying video.
One of my favourite series on TH-cam! These Render Challenge videos are so freaking good, and it's even better when Peter is competing!! I absolutely love Jordan and Fenner too!
Literally laughed out loud at the "I could talk about this for an hour... And I did...over on corridor digital" 😂
Definitely one of my favorite series from you guys.
Nothing will ever be as satisfying as a fine, slow mo, theatralic reload. :)
Thank you Peter for completing your masterpiece!!!
My life is now complete!
It’s better than I thought it would be
I think like a cyberpunk-ish theme might be fun, with lots of machines that perfectly fit inside of/assemble each other!
To make it loop, you could have a machine that disassembles itself at one end, transports the pieces to the other, and reassembles itself continuously.
Peter's would loop perfectly with just the addition of the sound of a thunderstorm rumble and a lightning strike right at the end to loop as a nightmare that becomes a dream.
The new crew members have such charisma and really work well together. Great crew overall!
Man, even without knowing almost nothing about animation, Peter seems like a freaking beast.
He was just there casually saying everything he did.
In this crazy time. we all need a little Satisfaction. Thank you Corridor Crew.
Okay honestly what satisfied me the most was seeing the side-by-side of Peter's before and after.
Peter’s was definitely the best. And, the whole thing got so much better, even the beginning scenes, compared to the first one. So cool.
dude.. you guys have no idea how much i wished to see Peter's final complete render last time. thank you for giving me my wish ❤️
I love that Wren's uses some TF2 sounds. Also, Fenner's was very well rounded, good animation, good storytelling, good sound design, and an overall very satisfying video.
Jordan was the clear winner for me, just his description of the render had me literally swinging with satisfaction, and he delivered, best render of all challenges in my opinion.
I still think "most unexpected twist" could make for a good hook; as with the satisfying videos it doesn't offer too much direction and there's a lot of scope for how something can be unexpected, though I'd probably add the qualifier that it should play with expectations (so not just be a jump scare or a cut to Jordan's "slightly offensive" video), could also limit it to a g-rating.