Julia Hartley-Brewer CLASHES With Caller On Jewish Man Stopped At Pro-Palestine Protest
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 เม.ย. 2024
- Britain’s biggest police force needs to rebuild the trust of the Jewish community after an antisemitism campaigner was threatened with arrest at a pro-Palestine demonstration, the Prime Minister has said.
Rishi Sunak told journalists that he shared public shock and anger over exchanges between Gideon Falter, chief executive of the Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA), and officers policing the protest in central London on April 13.
But he said he has confidence in the head of the Metropolitan Police, Sir Mark Rowley, if the commissioner works to rebuild the confidence and trust of the Jewish community and the wider public.
Sir Mark has faced calls to resign from Mr Falter and former home secretary Suella Braverman, who has made no secret of her critical views of how the Metropolitan Police has dealt with protests.
He is due to meet with Mayor of London Sadiq Khan on Monday to discuss “community relations”, and is also expected to meet Home Secretary James Cleverly.
Julia Hartley-Brewer clashes with caller Hussein after police described a man as “openly Jewish” near a pro-Palestine protest.
Hussein: “He wanted to provoke a reaction!”
Julia: “You can only provoke a reaction if the people on the other side are provoked by you!”
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
Julia, stop pretending. You know exactly what he was doing. You are a hypocrite.
Gideon Falter (who is not just an average London Jewish person but Chief Executive of Campaign Against Antisemitism) went with a team of people including security guards & a cameraman to a pro Palestinian March where he proceeded to walk into the march, against the flow of protesters in several different locations (not trying to just cross the road as he claimed)
In the full 15 minute video the Police are being courteous & helpful & even guide him to safe crossing places & offer to escort him across the road - all of which he refuses.
The only idiotic thing the Police said was refer to him as “openly Jewish” which is part of the very short & select clip used.
The Policeman says he is concerned about his safety because of his provocative actions, not just because he’s Jewish, but because he is evidently Jewish (wearing a yamaka) deliberately trying to push into the Center of a pro Palestine march & walk against the flow. When Falter asks for proof the Policeman says “this man saw you” Falter replies “but I don’t know this man” whereupon the Policeman informs him that the man is an undercover officer & then Falter looks visibly mortified.
The Police were concerned for his safety, not because he was Jewish but because he was being a provocative troublemaker.
As usual at these events there were a large number of “openly Jewish” pro Palestine protesters who were all fine which defies the logic of the news reports.
The full video should be viewed
That same man apparently requested the police remove Tommy Robinson from a pro Israel march while he was having breakfast.
Touch of irony and karma maybe?
When you’ve been kicked out of so many countries over the millenniums maybe it’s about time you ask yourself what it is you do wrong.
Many Jews lived among us in Morocco. The strange thing is that all the things forbidden in their religion, such as theft, cheating, and lying... are only respected among them, but with non-Jews there is no objection to them
Many Jews lived among us in Morocco. The strange thing is that all the things forbidden in their religion, such as theft, cheating, and lying... are only respected among them, but with non-Jews there is no objection to them
Is this the guy who got Tommy Robison arrested because he didn’t like his views ??!! A little ironic .
ثثبب
Gideon is a hypocrite! He was happy to get an innocent man arrested, assaulted by police and in court because Gideon didn't want him in London. You reap what you sow and Gideon got a taste of his own actions! Moreover the caller is a clown that clearly does not like our freedoms!
What an odd caller.. it's intention is obvious.. but was poorly prepared
Hussain:- "Let's be honest", Oh the irony.
It’s OK as long as that mob agrees.
I don’t remember Julia taking the stance, she is taking here, when Tommy Robinson was arrested for simply turning up on the march arranged by Gideon Falter that she herself attended.
He did the nasty to Tommy Robinson and here he is complaining when a little bit happens to him. Shame on GF
He did didn't he and him and Tommy surport the same cause 😅served tommy right 😊
Exactly mate his organisation did not want Tommy Robinson there he's a hypocrite .
That's not really relevant to this debate
@@watcherwriter1689 He shoould be able to do it and not have the same thing done to him. Only fair.Right?
@@watcherwriter1689
Kind of is.
It shows his character.
a pity this jewish man didn't have the same consideration for Tommy Robinson.
Well said
Your Bang on
correct 😮
That was bit of an own goal for him. He obviously didn’t think that one day he would need English/Christian support.
If Gideon Falter wanted Tommy Robinson banned from a march then he was wrong and the police should have told him that. But it does not alter the fact that GF had a perfect right to walk in London without being harassed or attacked by anyone and that includes police.
How can you provoke a reaction by walking down a public street unless you're a target by a certain group of people.
He’s a professional activist and knew exactly what he was doing.
@@abigfatcuppachai He was walking down the street and wanted to cross the road.
If the protestors were not anti semitic they would have just ignored him.
It’s called crowd control and exists at all large events - you even have it on the tube.
Julia Take a gander at some of the YT vids about the Kings Guards, where tourists of all creeds and cults disrespect them, then see if you change your mind about these idiotic claims are worthy of airtime, or is just filling up a otherwise blank space, if it's space filler then give your research team a kick up the backside and tell them to earn their bread with newsworthy items, sorry but your show is going downhill.
@@ruthbashford3176 How can Jews on the march be antisemitic? Bit antisemitic of you to assume the make up of the protesters.
Gideon deserves what he got, he was behind Tommy Robinson arrest now he knows what it feels like to
Really?
Oh well… why do we care about someone who tacitly supports the mass R of English girls?
Met Police Chief being sacked what a crap country this has become.
He is an agitator he went there with 5 people trying to disrupt it he got stopped he pushed stewards who told him not to walk there.
It’s absolutely irrelevant who he was. Every person in the UK can walk on public ground. End of discussion.
True words but some just hate the Jews 😢
So when there was talks of Palestinian’s protesters marching past the veterans memorial and talks tv was saying they shouldn’t be allow to march past it were you okay with that?
@@kevonslims7269 Yes, they were climbing on it.
@@kevonslims7269 where those propalestinians protesters respectful and just walking around without flags and without shouting slogans like this jew was?
@@kevonslims7269 you seem upset
this caller 'see's, hear's and read's what he want's to.
This guy made no sense 😂
Sadly they'll claim to be British and all what not while happy to deny the other British person free movement and claim the police were doing a good job. Thing is same people will later be against the police when their side does not have the numbers. Crazy
What do you think “Hussein “ is going to say😂
Well said Julia. We are a free country
Except for protests you disagree with. Got it👍
@@abigfatcuppachai Beat me to it...
The Nazi killed the Ashkenazi Jewish Coverts.. Ab Ben Ruach Hakodesh SaLa Zara Zaraitzu Real Jewish
Wear a Celtic shirt and try walking into Rangers rally.
@@abigfatcuppachai I agree with a right to protest. We do live in a free country. I also agree with been able to walk about safely.
So the Muslims are not provocative far as the caller is concerned. This caller saw on the video what he wanted see.
What a surprise the caller that was against the Jewish person was called Mohammed 😂😂😂
ok if he respects the law, like his peace loving fellow protestors...why would the jewish man be in danger?
If an ‘openly’ Muslim had wanted to cross the street during an Israeli protest the police would t have done a thing. Or even escorted them across whatever road he or she wanted to cross!
Gideon is subject to the same laws as Tommy Robinson.
Lots of us oppose the marches but most of us are at home luckily. They have not been peaceful at all.
You’re totally right Julia.
People who have a different opinion to these protesters have no rights when these marches are on. Which is totally unacceptable, if a Jewish man wants to cross the road where they are protesting he as the right to do so.
If these are peaceful marches, why would they be bothered if he crossed the road.
It’s because they want to rule them streets and not let anyone with a different opinion on them streets.
I’m not Jewish , I don’t support these marchers opinions. But if I want to walk where these protesters are, I’m quite within my rights. But that as been taken away from me, where are my rights. Gideon as proved a point these protests are not peaceful.
If they where peaceful why are the police so worried about is safety.
So to me they need banning ASP
Sadly the police think only the pro marches have the rights and others just don't.
Absolute nonsense. There was a pro-Israel group demonstrating yards away, in part of the road that was closed, where Gideon Falter could have crossed.
they didnt stop him the police did the protesters didnt touch him
Agree, the problem is not whether the Jewish man was there innocently, I also don't think he was, but he proved his point. That the police have assessed these protests as being unsafe for openly Jewish people and people who disagree with them. On top of that it's the polices duty to protect law abiding people, even if that Jewish man was there to stir the pot, he has the right to do so and the police should have an obligation to protect him not threaten to arrest him. It has rings of school to me, I remember there was tonnes of bullies in my middle school that relentlessly bullied this girl. Rather then deal with the bullies they took the girl out of class where she had to work alone and lost out on education and social interaction. Its the same thing. It may be harder to deal with 1000s of protestors but that shouldn't stop you doing your job even if it's for one person and if it does something needs to be done about violent elements of the protest.
This is 1930 Germany !
Yes it is, Falter supports the invasion and illegal annexation of Palestinian land. Well spotted.
unless the jewish guy did anything to assault a protestor which he did not, the cops have no business interfering with his movement.
Religion of Peace.
More like the mind virus
Thank you
Which religion?
The caller held his line of argument.The police believed there would be a breach of the peace. (Opposing groups being allowed to mix.)The CAA guy was opposed to the March it was purely provocative
If a British citizen is not allowed to go ahead with their normal day of life activities without the threat of intimidation or aggravation from what is described as a peaceful demonstration, then I would suggest they are not peaceful demonstrations and the police should not allow them to go ahead.
Hussain! Wake Up! You can't Defend the ' INDEFENSIBLE '! END Of, ✊🤘👍
hussain..bit of a clue who he supports
If this is a peaceful protest, then it should have been okay to cross the road, however the police told Gideon that it was not safe, if that is the case then ban these protests, were fed up with them going on for months.
Caller is a fool.. guy didn't push anyone, the police blocked his pathway, his freedome to walk where he wishes....
This caller has rose tinted glasses on where the pro Palestinian marchers are concerned. He needs to open his eyes and llook at things truthfully. Not his own interpretation of the footage.
The caller clearly should think about moving elsewhere to a country were you can arrest someone for literally walking the streets.
Oh yes, a free country but not firvthe likes of Gideon Falter. Free to wave whatever flags you want, but not to walk where you want
😅
Hussein is openly ...... (fill in the blank space)
Racist
…against genocide and apartheid.
A hamas supporter!
Hummus supporters living in London, using right to buy houses at a discounted price? and travelling on British passports?😅
for humanity
Who do these people think they are? This was an individual who happens to be Jewish. He can walk where he likes. If someone doesnt like that then THEY are at fault. THEY can piss off. How is this complicated
what a bs argument
The usual taqqiya
The caller gives himself away when he says "the Right narrative is to respect the law". By implication he belongs to those who don't respect the law.
Was it Abdul who was phoning?😅
It was your dad
@@adamdar5121 Thought it was your Dad
Even if he wanted to provoke a reaction , a reaction shouldn't be so easy to provoke and more to the point YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO BE FREE TO HOLD YOUR OWN OPINION WITHOUT THREAT OF VIOLENCE !!!!!
I will defend his rights because i will be defending my own rights by doing so.
As for sympathy,
I HAVE NONE !
Tell the hypocrite to compensate tommy the £60,000 "HE" has cost him in legal fees !
why dont you educate your self on Tommy Robinson he is a thug
TR is another in a VERY long line of victims of Falters bogus charity.
man was there to just agitate, thats the truth of it. just because somethings legal doesnt mean you should do it, he was just stirring bad feelings, copper was right. when this is all over maybe all the protestors can go and live in palestine and help to rebuild it instead of coming to this country and trying to make it like the one they all ran away from.
You have a choice to accept police assistance but this was forced upon a member of the public because of what he looked like…….. simples and wrong
I think he refused it and committed no offence.
Gideon is a state shill for Israel. He likes to get the freedoms removed from others illegally as he did with Tommy Robinson.
Hossen...
Wonder what his opinion will be...
Never saw a Muslim protect a Jew.
During the Middle Ages, Jewish people under Muslim rule experienced tolerance and integration. Some historians refer to this time period as the "Golden Age" for the Jews, as more opportunities became available to them.
Wikipedia. Check it out yourself. Bye.
Yeah…
They were well integrated then, respected we are told.
I wonder if they did something to make themselves unpopular like everywhere else including Galilee 700 yrs before Christ.
Does anyone know why the mood of that period 180 degreed thereafter?
I mean _something_ must have happened.
@@richardpreece5384Jews were treated *better* by the Arabs and Ottomans, but not well.
Sahih al-Bukhari 2925- 'You will fight against the Jews and you will gain victory over them. And even the stones will be saying: 'Oh slave of Allah! there is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him'
[5.33] The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His apostle and strive to make mischief in the land is only this, that they should be murdered or crucified or their hands and their feet should be cut off on opposite sides or they should be imprisoned; this shall be as a disgrace for them in this world, and in the hereafter they shall have a grievous chastisement,
[5.51] O you who believe!(muslims) do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends. they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.
[5.63] Why do not the learned men [rabbis] and the doctors of law prohibit them from their speaking of what is sinful and their eating of what is unlawfully acquired? Certainly evil is that which they work!
9:34] Oh you who believe! most surely many of the doctors of law [rabbis] and the monks eat away the property of men falsely, and turn them from Allah's way, and (as for) those who hoard up gold and silver and do not spend it in Allah's way, announce to them a painful chastisement.
Perhaps you should read up the wiki page on Jizya too. Not sure how you can call a society tolerant that imposes extra taxes and rules against those who do not partake in the state religion. I don't say this to criticize Islam, because back then there were no truly tolerant societies as we would view them today.
What would happen if someone walked through Tel Aviv waving a Palestinian flag?
It was still legal last year, but the law may have changed.
2 million arabs live peaceably in israel
@@philipskalla4312 Might be legal, but hardly recommended.
@@Titus9508 A visitor to Jerusalem from Saudi Arabia, who was openly Arabian, wearing flowing Arabian clothing, was assaulted by Arabs after leaving the al-Aqsa mosque, but never bothered by anyone who was Jewish.
No one, including the police, barred his way or told him he would be causing a provocation anywhere.
@@paulrichards6894 there's a marked difference between being an Arab Israeli and a Palestinian - as I'm sure you know. What I don't know is why people keep saying that Arab Israelis are doing OK. Does this excuse the genocide, the illegal occupation, the illegal settlements, the apartheid? No, it does not.
London has been fallen into chaos 😟😟😟😟😟😟😟😟😟😟😟
It’s occupied.
That’s not England any more.
C A N C E R ☪️
Yes Zionism is.
@@abigfatcuppachai while hamas are choir boys
By the way most Jews (like me) are not Semites. We are Ashkenazis (Europeans). The Palestinians are the original Semites. So if you are "Anti-Semitic" you are "Anti-Palestinian".
Respect the law. Creeping Shariah law.
Exactly
its coming
Who is this caller! Talking complete rubbish.
I bet the caller is pro Palestine
as soon as I heard the callers name I knew the opinions he would have
And the purpose of the protesters isn't to antagonise the locals? Would a man in a skullcap be a threat to the protesters' safety?
This guy sounds the sort who would say wearing a short skirt is provocative and thus x y z
Absolutely right
His names Hussein i think that tells you where his allegiances lie
Does that surprise you? Allegiances to their faith is paramount.😊
He did not push anyone. Officers stopped him and threatened him with arrest if he did not leave the area. The officers accused him of being provocative despite the fact that he was just standing at the side of the road because he was 'openly Jewish'. If the Police are so frightened of the possibility of violence from the minority of thugs in the protest march then why did they allow it to proceed. The Police have the right to ban a march on the grounds of public order and safety. This is beyond ludicrous.
I enter my 8th decade in London next month. I can't believe some of these comments.
I have to preface my view by saying that Jewish people, worldwide, are the most successful, prosperous people as they are incredibly talented, intelligent, disciplined, and have a strong family and Business structure. However, there is such a thing as COMMON SENSEand PRAGMATISM so, as a Millwall fan,I should be able to walk and stand with thousands of our bitter rivals, West Ham's fans , should they meet??? IF NOT, WHY NOT?
Without lies Islam dies.
Look, maybe the Jewish man did deliberately go there to counter protest or prove a point. I do agree that I somewhat feel for the police, they are having to assess risk and if its detaining one jewish man vs 1000s of angry protestors thats what they do. Howeved It doesn't matter and does not look good. The problem is that if someone was to counter protest and merely being openly Jewish is enough to worry the police enough to ask him to leave or threaten to arrest him that's a huge issue. It suggests that these protests are assessed by the police to be ticking time bombs of violence. Plus the police irregardless of how hard it is its their duty to protect people not punish them. Jewish people or anyone who disagrees with the protestors should be able to go abojt their lives in peace and the police have an obligation a duty to ensure that. Its a shame we are mistreating the most well integrated group in the country.
Gideon Falter, CEO of hardline pro Israel lobby group CAA and director of JNF which raises money to acquire land for colonial settlements in Palestine - just happened to have “stumbled” across a pro-Palestinian protest in London - with his body guards and film crew in tow.
The cops are an embarrassing from top to bottom
At first I would agree but this guy was obviously trying to provoke a reaction and the cop rather clumsily was trying to stop him getting beaten up.
@@paulyoung5514he had just left the synagogue & was train* to cross the road. This isn5 against the law (yet).
He was there to be filmed trying to provoke an incident. Full marks to the police o this one
@@murielscott9958 That's what I initially thought but it isn't the case. He had a film crew and is one of the leaders of anti semitism, all of which is fair enough and you're totally right crossing the road isn't against the law. It just isn't as it was initially made out, that's all.
Gideon falter was looking to cause trouble .
It’s good to get calls like this. Shows how even the apparently moderate supporters of these marchers want to change how British laws have been enforced for 100 yeas or more.
The man on the call was pathetic and a liar
The Nazi killed the Ashkenazi Jewish Coverts.. Ab Ben Ruach Hakodesh SaLa Zara Zaraitzu Real Jewish
We fought 2 world Wars so we can walk where we want,without getting abuse
He could have walked across the road anywhere but chose to do it there just to antagonise the police and spark a reaction ....which he succeded in doing.
The officer wasn’t polite he threatened him with arrest ,he has the right to go anywhere he wants and wasn’t breaking the law,those that threatened him are the people the police should arrest rather than a innocent person,two tier policing in clear view
really why have you got hussein on did we expect anything else from him peaceful march my arse sick of these protests this guy is a joke
Peaceful march my fat arse
Well done Julia, calling out the hypocrisy.
The guy was there to cause trouble that’s it and to attract sympathy for his agenda, how are you falling for that?
Many people on this 'peaceful' march were continually breaking the laws of this country by shouting out hateful chants and calling this 'openly Jewish' man insulting names. Yet, the police ignored them as they have done every time these marches have taken place.
I was there on Saturday, although I never saw this incident. I saw many branches of the law in these so-called' peaceful' marchers.
Great work g-d blesses those who support Israel !
2 sides who think they have an imaginary friend on their side
No one is above the law - refuse to listen to officer is an offence - he should have been handcuffed and fined
Police knew protesters would react harmful but let it go on for 7 months.
Why let that man lie like that, we've seen the footage, he didn't push the officers & if he did I have no doubt they would have put him in cuffs.
True words 😢
He tried to push past them.
Yes he tried to push past.He was exercising his right to walk where he wanted. Not allowed to do so.
@@user-cl1qk9om7l No one, at any large event where crowd control is in operation, has the right to go where they want to go. Were you to come across a road traffic accident on your way somewhere and a policeman asked you to take a detour would you insist on your right to go where you wanted? The police were asking for his cooperation and he refused. The British Jewish community should reject this troublemaker.
The police are not the law
The jewish guy staged it
He wanted to walk across the road!
He was a bit sensitive 😢
Caller is correct
Hussain, quit while you are ahead, like stfu!
They think they are superior to everyone,but they are not.
The whole IQ higher thing was a tiny group of elites.
As usual.
Caked with an F
Who moved in to whose space, it seemed to me it was the police person coraling him with his larger body. That is an intimidating move. I am not on this guys side for what his complaint caused Tommy Robinson, but if he set out to prove a point he succeeded very well.These marches are not peaceful and either the police should ban them or control the amount of protesters to the level they can control them, that they have the right to do under the law, and not use the excuse they don,t have enough serving personnel. Would white and light skinned people including Muslims be told to stay off the street if it was a BLM march??? Or Tomorrow on St Georges day only the White English could stand around??? Tomorrow is a celebration of all the good England stands for like free speech, the right to worship freely, free choice and many more privileges that many countries don,t have.
Come on Julia, you are very forceful with your view normally, but do the same with this man, who just keeps repeating himself and is talking rubbish.
he loves phoning in
Julie Hartley Brewer does not back down, good for her.
This caller is blaming honest Jews for disobeying the law, but what about the pro-Palestinian demonstrations? Did they follow the rules? For more than six months they have not observed the law and have been saying insulting words against the Jews. The police never forced them to stop this practice.
Should policeman be sacked if he ordered him to eat pork sandwich,not all police orders are legal and it is reasonable to disobey a police order if you have not broken the law to cross the street,if police stand in your way to cross the road it's false detention
It’s called crowd control and happens at all events. You even have it on the tube.
Nobody takes mad Julia seriously anymore!
How rude! The interviewer was argumentative & wouldn’t let the man speak without constant interruption!
As an "openly celtic" supporter, I was stopped from marching thru a rangers crowd. The police were anti-celetic
How thick is this guy
I'm sure "Hussein" is being totally impartial and not being guided by Islamic sectarianism at all
Well spoken Julia Hartley-Brewer. You stick to your guns. I am openly white, male, middle aged and middle class. I know some or all of these attributes will offend many people, and I will do my best to avoid marches where people are non-white, non-male, non-middle-aged and non-middle class, but in case I find myself caught up in such a march I wish it to be known that it was not done as an act of deliberate provocation.
Utter bollocks. The Police Sergeant was exemplary in being polite, offering a solution etc. The campaigner was wrong and was offered an alternative way. Nothing to do with antisemitism, just professional advice. The protester wanted confrontation and didn't accept the 'let-out clause' , was offered a way to avoid the confrontation he so obviously craved. His problem, not the Police. His status was bleeding obvious so, quite rightly he was advised to accept advice and he chose to ignore it and then had the cheek to complain about his treatment. Police; damned if they do and damned if they don't. I'm on his side but his actions probably haven't helped the cause.
He expects an angry crowd to part for him…😂😂😂
We shall now and henceforth call this a Moses Complex.
Many people in London use escalators and stick to the right side. They are called tourists. hardly a crime.
He was there to provoke, come on! Police tolerant in fear!
Julia is a super nutcase 😂 😂
Just for one man, so much air time..Falter faltered. No one's above the law...leave it to the law enforcement officer to handle the situation.policeman did his job respectfully and responsibiility....Hats off. There should not a wrong precedent, next time someone else influencial would defy the rule of law .