Unfortunately, I can't change the transcription from the video but if you choose to grab the pdf file all these mistakes (and others that I found after checking again) are fixed. m.12 - last chord symbol should spell A7(b9) and not Gdim. Thank you @htctatoo100 for pointing that out! m.15 - second half of the measure: interpreting Ab7#5 as actually Aminmaj7 keeps the same function as the previous chord (Am7) and makes more sense, as @fredericlinden pointed out. I also kept Ab7#5 in the pdf as an alternative chord symbol because most (if not all) publications I found use that chord symbol instead of the minmaj7 one, for reasons I don't completely understand. m.20 - chord symbols should be Dbmaj7 and Gb7 (beat 3). @billgrahammusic spotted a variation on the Tadd Dameron turnaround (which begins with the last chord from m.19) m.38 - as @EliaGaitau pointed out, on beats 3 and 4 the leading melody is doubled in the left hand one octave lower (removing Ab from the chord). After a closer look, I noticed an Ab on beat 4 in the left hand in the lower octave. m.42 - last chord symbol should read Eb7(#11b9) instead of E7(#11b9). Thank you @JakeChapman! m.52 - first chord should be a Dbmaj7 and not an Eb7sus - Thanks @hdb28091! m.71 - what looks like the 2nd half of beat 3, LH: the grace note should be one octave lower (thanks @silver1788 for spotting it!) m.73, first 3 beats: LH plays the bottom note one octave lower (and in octaves), and the top note is incorporated into the RH. The 5th chord is also part of the 6th dim. scale and the C7 chord is voiced as follows: a low C note (C2) in the bass, an E a 10th higher, and then Bb, Db, F#, and A in the right hand. Thank you @Ambidextroid for flagging this!
m.38 over the Ab diminished, is a typical block chord technique- I can hear the voice leading note being doubled an octave below. You have it as only the top note playing over a static chord. Fantastic transcription btw! Just throwing in my 2 cents 😅
@@EliaGaitau Thank you so much! I remember enjoying your videos on Jam of the Week. I took a closer look and you're absolutely right! It was hard to hear that inner movement but it's there nonetheless. I can also hear an Ab in the lower octave on beat 4. Thank you again!
Can't begin to imagine how much study and practise the pianist must have put in. His playing left one of the greatest jazz pianists virtually speechless at points. Don't think praise and recognition really gets much higher than that. Superb.
I rmemeber coming across this video of Barry years ago when I first started getting into jazz and this pianist’s accompaniment was just so beautiful to me. I think many pianists do not recognize how important melodic comping is and it usually takes a back seat to soloing when realistically, you will be comping most of the time you’re playing. It makes me happy to see modern pianist like in this video, and others such as Emmet Cohen, truly embrace the interactive melodic and harmonic nature of comping. It makes me even happier to see this transcription! Wonderful job
Very well said and put, another wondeful player who demonstrates such sensibility is Rossano Sportiello who in Barry Harris' own words is "the best stride piano player" he's ever heard.
@@PianoDigitalScoresVery well said and put, another wondeful player who demonstrates such sensibility is Rossano Sportiello who in Barry Harris' own words is "the best stride piano player" he's ever heard.
@@tomatocroissant378 I actually know of the guy but didn't remember his name. I remember looking at his stride videos but forgot to follow through. Thanks again!
Bro how does a person even become this good? How do you learn to come up with this accompaniment on the spot? How does one attain this power? If I could play the piano like this I would never stop
I don't know how it was for him but for me most likely it will take a lot of work. I also think that he knows the tune inside out and has played many variants of what was recorded here. After that you just naturally put pieces together. Nevertheless, he is truly remarkable.
You're welcome! Fortunately, there are a lot of recordings of his workshops on youtube. He also has one recorded by Howard Rees when he was younger which you can buy here (comes with a book and CDs): jazzworkshops.com/the-barry-harris-workshop-video/
How does a person at this age still manage to sing with such control?!!! Absolutely beautiful the way he speaks in between the singing, smooth and not a moment of disconnection in the transition.
Fabulous! Doctor Barry Harris, Ph.D. (Northeastern University) His voice is a Vintage, Mature Portwine. Classy, Highly Musical, the Soul of a Grest Artist. The Interaction with the Participant Audience is Fantastic, leading all of them to a grandious Finale.
Even the very first chord at the beginning of the video, before the intro, it sounds so beautiful and it's just an F6. There's something about his touch that probably can't be transcribed, but just with the sheet music alone, there's years worth of content to study, thank you for this!
i totally agree! his arpeggiated chords/runs are just so even, well-paced and clear and so tastefully sprinkled throughout...the colors they create are just too cool
It’s really just the way he voices the chord. More top note and bass note with subtle emphasis on inner notes to shape the entire chord. Classically trained maybe? Either way he plays it beautifully.
I keep coming back to this improv absolutely FLOORED by the transition from the Ab9 to Fm11 at 1:13. Absolutely brilliant rendition of a gorgeous piece ❤
I played piano in my Dad's band. First dance job I was 14 years old in 1956. We had 5-7 pieces. I would go to sleep at night listening to 33 1/3 records. Joe Bushkin, Art Tatum, George Shearing, Erroll Garner, Ahmad Jamal. I agree, this is a wonderful piano accompaniment, smooth as silk. I love one like this where you wait in anticipation for the next creative sound.. When it sounds this easy you know he has put endless hours finding that beautiful flow and sound. Thank you for this.
Totally AWESOME! I've always loved BH, but this made me love him more. What a loss to the music world and mankind as a whole when he went home. Thanks for the transcriptions. Now I can possibly learn some of those jazzy "sugar-chords" and embellishments.
I used to go back to this video at least once a week, and loved every single second of it. I am so incredibly thankful that you chose to transcribe this! Rip Dr. Harris
One of the most beautiful six minutes I've ever experienced. Barry Harris is love in this video! The combination of his improvised lyrics and his running commentary on the piano accompaniment is just exquisite! Thank you so much for this delicious interval!
This video is truly a gift. I cant imagine how long this took, i tried my hand and it took hours to even get the introduction!! This video is a gift, and your hard work will allow many more people (at least me) to be able to finally try understand whats being played
Thank you for the awesome feedback! I'm not gifted when it comes to transcribing by ear so it took me a lot of hours to complete it. I'm glad you found it valuable!
A seen this and had to agree. If this pops up in your feed, your definitely a musician of some form and also realize how important and impactful it is to be aware of the generations that came before and how cold they were for real. I really think TH-cam is one of the greatest tools/media for any artist, visual or musical. It’s like having a pbs channel for the things you love. For those that find value in it, being able to see and hear this great teacher for free from anywhere and anytime is really priceless.
The accompaniment from m.42 (2:40) to m.53 sounds especially beautiful to me. This chromatic triplet progression at m.43, how he subtly recalls the melody at m.45 and m.47-48, very elegant arpeggios and chords. I don't understand the harmony a lot because I'm dumb, but that sounds brilliant, I'd like to learn to play like this. Also, I didn't know Barry Harris could sing that well.
@@testtest-lc4xzYes, but not just that. Starting at the end of m.19 you have a tritone substitution for a vi-ii-V that leads to F, but with a twist (check out the Tadd Dameron turnaround).
Thank you for transcribing this! This is the video I always share to my friends in the band when they asked what jazz ballad are. I think some of the measures and chords can clean up a little bit. For example, the second chord of measure 1 (Fmaj#5) can be omitted as this is an embellishing chord to resolve from Fmaj7/9 to F6, this is also the application of the 6dim. scale. Gdim7 chord on measure 12 should be an A7(b9) instead. Also, can choose either m7b5 or half dim chord.
My pleasure! I'll leave the Fmaj#5 just to show how one could embellish the space between those two chords. As for measure 12, you are right. I'll make the correction to the PDF in a few days as I'm traveling at the moment. Thank you for pointing that out!
As a guitar player, I desperately wish I could comp like this. 😭 I missed my calling as a keyboard player. But I will apply as much as I can of this to guitar. Thanks for the incredible post.
So sad that camera man moved away from Barry... I can see he was moved. The great playing, him teaching and doing what he loves till the last momemt. "Come board my ship, for a trip, to paradise".... RIP mister Harris.
Hello beautiful people I am back for another ?? lol ok Now Barry I should say Mr Harris sings Embraceable you by George Gershwin first then he continues into another beautiful song which made my ears very happy Is the song called Come board my ship ? Who wrote this song anyone know Please , pretty please thanks
@@PianoDigitalScores Thankyou Piano digital for taking the time to elaborate on this masterpiece. Now I am going to cry lol cause the chords look so complicated . I Its doesn't look like easy read lead sheet . Still I can always come back to this video for a listen and let my ears enjoy.
You're welcome! I am studying his approach but not as much as I'd wish. I don't know if Jakub was his student. In the original video, at the end, Barry asks for the name of the pianist.
I guess the best resources are records (or even this video). I don't think there is a step by step lesson out there that teaches you to comp at such an advanced level. You just need to listen to a lot of music and try stuff out. Transcribe, incorporate, develop.
Great work. But an even better intro and great solo on this tune was played by Barry himself on the dynamite two piano recording with Kenny Barron called Confirmation. I recommend listening to it! IMHO it’s the best two piano jazz recording ever made even better than the two albums Tommy Flanagan and Hank Jones did together.
bar 52, should that be a Dbmaj7 and not an Eb7sus? EDIT: also bar 20, instead of Fm it should be a Dbmaj7. FYI, GREAT job transcribing, I purchased a copy - thank you for making it available! I LOVE Barry's improvised chorus on this...are the lyrics improvised or are they taken from something somewhere?
Hey man! Thank you for your feedback and corrections! The one in m.20 was already fixed. I wanted to reply to you sooner but I had to finish going through the whole transcription again to check for other mistakes, which I had already started doing (took a while, I know). I've found other mistakes and fixed them and will soon be sending out a pdf update to everyone that purchased it.
Hi, this is really great stuff, how would anyone learn to transcribe chords and ear different voices so precisely, this seems so hard to me, how did you achieve this level?
A lot of doing (transcribing), software to slow down the audio and a lot of plays and replays (where it wasn't clear to me) to have time to hear everything. But this is me without perfect pitch or a good ear. Others might take less time and with less effort. I'm still practicing and learning. It also helps to have a keyboard near to try to replicate the harmonies you hear and see if they match. Also, even so, I did slip some errors into the video version. I've since made edits to the PDF to be more accurate.
@@PianoDigitalScores Thanks a lot, are there some easier compings to transcribe that you started with and can recommend me to try? I don't think there are many people that could do much better than you here, there is always room for improvement but your level is a goal for me right now. Relative pitch is a slow process and a long journey but I don't think that having perfect pitch would be way better, surely you wouldn't have to ear train this much, but I have friends who have perfect pitch and are not that good at hearing inner voices (because they never train) or just don't have the patience to transcribe long solos or compings.
@@ferdinandodamico5796 I would start transcribing melodies first (regardless of the instrument playing it) and then move to harmonies. If you already got the first step under your belt you can start with some Errol Garner compings.
I could transcribe a melody and identify most chords... but how do you know the voicing? Or when there are blocks of 3-4 notes at once as eight notes? Is it like a next level? How to practice?
In most cases I slow down the audio. I would first start with listening to the top and bottom notes and then fill in the rest. Some chords I already have in my ears and recognize them by now. The rest of them I just try them out at my piano and if a particular chord color is hard to figure out I try to listen to each note/frequency. If I am unsure I then test by playing the chord against the recording and see if they sound alike or if a note is dissonant. I also use the software Transcribe which identifies and represents frequencies on a visual keyboard (can also slow down the audio). Depending on the audio quality, this can speed things a lot. You can also get good results if you extract the piano from the recording (if voice or other instruments distract you). I use lalal.ai but in some cases it doesn't include everything. This is why I use both audios to transcribe, to make sure I include everything. Happy transcribing! :D
Unfortunately, I can't change the transcription from the video but if you choose to grab the pdf file all these mistakes (and others that I found after checking again) are fixed.
m.12 - last chord symbol should spell A7(b9) and not Gdim. Thank you @htctatoo100 for pointing that out!
m.15 - second half of the measure: interpreting Ab7#5 as actually Aminmaj7 keeps the same function as the previous chord (Am7) and makes more sense, as @fredericlinden pointed out. I also kept Ab7#5 in the pdf as an alternative chord symbol because most (if not all) publications I found use that chord symbol instead of the minmaj7 one, for reasons I don't completely understand.
m.20 - chord symbols should be Dbmaj7 and Gb7 (beat 3). @billgrahammusic spotted a variation on the Tadd Dameron turnaround (which begins with the last chord from m.19)
m.38 - as @EliaGaitau pointed out, on beats 3 and 4 the leading melody is doubled in the left hand one octave lower (removing Ab from the chord). After a closer look, I noticed an Ab on beat 4 in the left hand in the lower octave.
m.42 - last chord symbol should read Eb7(#11b9) instead of E7(#11b9). Thank you @JakeChapman!
m.52 - first chord should be a Dbmaj7 and not an Eb7sus - Thanks @hdb28091!
m.71 - what looks like the 2nd half of beat 3, LH: the grace note should be one octave lower (thanks @silver1788 for spotting it!)
m.73, first 3 beats: LH plays the bottom note one octave lower (and in octaves), and the top note is incorporated into the RH. The 5th chord is also part of the 6th dim. scale and the C7 chord is voiced as follows: a low C note (C2) in the bass, an E a 10th higher, and then Bb, Db, F#, and A in the right hand. Thank you @Ambidextroid for flagging this!
yep. i heard the Csus // Ab13 // Dbmaj // Gb13 too
Exact
m.38 over the Ab diminished,
is a typical block chord technique- I can hear the voice leading note being doubled an octave below.
You have it as only the top note playing over a static chord.
Fantastic transcription btw!
Just throwing in my 2 cents 😅
@@EliaGaitau Thank you so much! I remember enjoying your videos on Jam of the Week. I took a closer look and you're absolutely right! It was hard to hear that inner movement but it's there nonetheless. I can also hear an Ab in the lower octave on beat 4. Thank you again!
Thank you for sharing this. It’s a beautiful arrangement. How can I get the pdf of the performance?
Can't begin to imagine how much study and practise the pianist must have put in. His playing left one of the greatest jazz pianists virtually speechless at points. Don't think praise and recognition really gets much higher than that. Superb.
I rmemeber coming across this video of Barry years ago when I first started getting into jazz and this pianist’s accompaniment was just so beautiful to me. I think many pianists do not recognize how important melodic comping is and it usually takes a back seat to soloing when realistically, you will be comping most of the time you’re playing. It makes me happy to see modern pianist like in this video, and others such as Emmet Cohen, truly embrace the interactive melodic and harmonic nature of comping. It makes me even happier to see this transcription! Wonderful job
Thank you! I wholeheartedly agree with what you said about comping.
I'm a big fan of Emmet too.
Very well said and put, another wondeful player who demonstrates such sensibility is Rossano Sportiello who in Barry Harris' own words is "the best stride piano player" he's ever heard.
@@PianoDigitalScoresVery well said and put, another wondeful player who demonstrates such sensibility is Rossano Sportiello who in Barry Harris' own words is "the best stride piano player" he's ever heard.
@@tomatocroissant378 I'll have to check him too. Thank you for sharing this!
@@tomatocroissant378 I actually know of the guy but didn't remember his name. I remember looking at his stride videos but forgot to follow through. Thanks again!
Bro how does a person even become this good? How do you learn to come up with this accompaniment on the spot? How does one attain this power? If I could play the piano like this I would never stop
I don't know how it was for him but for me most likely it will take a lot of work. I also think that he knows the tune inside out and has played many variants of what was recorded here. After that you just naturally put pieces together. Nevertheless, he is truly remarkable.
You say "If I could play piano like this I would never stop"... The answer is that "he can play piano like this, because he never stop (playing)"
@@alessandroferrarachitarra👏👏👏 Perfectly said, you sir nailed it with this comment.
Practice
Practice and study, practice and study. And don't stop.
This is precisely what I so want my piano playing to be. Incredibly wistful, nostalgic, colorful and melancholy. Thank you for transcribing!
You're welcome! Happy practicing!
Brought me to tears. Seeing the joy on Barry’s face and that beautiful playing… I miss the workshops. Thank you for the transcription!
You're welcome! Fortunately, there are a lot of recordings of his workshops on youtube. He also has one recorded by Howard Rees when he was younger which you can buy here (comes with a book and CDs): jazzworkshops.com/the-barry-harris-workshop-video/
How does a person at this age still manage to sing with such control?!!! Absolutely beautiful the way he speaks in between the singing, smooth and not a moment of disconnection in the transition.
I mean... he literally lived through the era.
How? He s Barry!
Fabulous! Doctor Barry Harris, Ph.D. (Northeastern University)
His voice is a Vintage, Mature Portwine.
Classy, Highly Musical, the Soul of a Grest Artist.
The Interaction with the Participant Audience is Fantastic, leading all of them to a grandious Finale.
Even the very first chord at the beginning of the video, before the intro, it sounds so beautiful and it's just an F6. There's something about his touch that probably can't be transcribed, but just with the sheet music alone, there's years worth of content to study, thank you for this!
I'm glad you find it valuable! Happy practicing!
i totally agree! his arpeggiated chords/runs are just so even, well-paced and clear and so tastefully sprinkled throughout...the colors they create are just too cool
It’s really just the way he voices the chord. More top note and bass note with subtle emphasis on inner notes to shape the entire chord. Classically trained maybe? Either way he plays it beautifully.
That tritone-sub turnaround was just what Barry needed. He absolutely loved playing that stuff.
I keep coming back to this improv absolutely FLOORED by the transition from the Ab9 to Fm11 at 1:13. Absolutely brilliant rendition of a gorgeous piece ❤
You and me both! I'm still studying what Jakub played.
Yess that was amazing
I played piano in my Dad's band. First dance job I was 14 years old in 1956. We had 5-7 pieces.
I would go to sleep at night listening to 33 1/3 records. Joe Bushkin, Art Tatum, George Shearing, Erroll Garner, Ahmad Jamal. I agree, this is a wonderful piano accompaniment, smooth as silk. I love one like this where you wait in anticipation for the next creative sound.. When it sounds this easy you know he has put endless hours
finding that beautiful flow and sound.
Thank you for this.
You're welcome!
3:09 Harris' singing is also very beautiful here!
And what a pleasant surprise!
Yes. This little line pops into my head every once in a while, and then I have to get back to this video.
Totally AWESOME! I've always loved BH, but this made me love him more. What a loss to the music world and mankind as a whole when he went home. Thanks for the transcriptions. Now I can possibly learn some of those jazzy "sugar-chords" and embellishments.
But what a blessing it was to experience his teachings. Happy practicing!
I used to go back to this video at least once a week, and loved every single second of it. I am so incredibly thankful that you chose to transcribe this! Rip Dr. Harris
One of the most beautiful six minutes I've ever experienced. Barry Harris is love in this video! The combination of his improvised lyrics and his running commentary on the piano accompaniment is just exquisite! Thank you so much for this delicious interval!
so effortless, what an incredible talent barry was and i never knew he could sing just as well as he played ty for posting
As for me the best jazz teacher I have ever heard. Barry Harris, the legend!!!
This video is truly a gift. I cant imagine how long this took, i tried my hand and it took hours to even get the introduction!! This video is a gift, and your hard work will allow many more people (at least me) to be able to finally try understand whats being played
Thank you for the awesome feedback! I'm not gifted when it comes to transcribing by ear so it took me a lot of hours to complete it. I'm glad you found it valuable!
Thank you for taking the time to transcribe these beautiful moments. So many lessons in them. Appreciated.
You're welcome! I'm glad you found it useful.
Thank you so much for that. We certainly miss Barry Harris a lot.
I love the TH-cam algorithm; thank you so much for putting this up
You're welcome!
A seen this and had to agree. If this pops up in your feed, your definitely a musician of some form and also realize how important and impactful it is to be aware of the generations that came before and how cold they were for real. I really think TH-cam is one of the greatest tools/media for any artist, visual or musical. It’s like having a pbs channel for the things you love. For those that find value in it, being able to see and hear this great teacher for free from anywhere and anytime is really priceless.
One of my favorite George Gershwin songs.
This was so beautiful. The playing was great. And to be in the presence of one of the greats of jazz. What a thrill.
The accompaniment from m.42 (2:40) to m.53 sounds especially beautiful to me. This chromatic triplet progression at m.43, how he subtly recalls the melody at m.45 and m.47-48, very elegant arpeggios and chords. I don't understand the harmony a lot because I'm dumb, but that sounds brilliant, I'd like to learn to play like this. Also, I didn't know Barry Harris could sing that well.
Grande accompagnamento. Una lezione di riarmonizzazione bella corposa😊
Thank you so much for this transaction and introducing me to this beautiful video, I can’t wait to practice these techniques
You're welcome, Isaac!
m.20 Chord symbols should be Dbmaj7 to Gb7. It's a version of the Tadd Dameron turnaround.
Thanks Bill! It does make a lot of sense if you look one chord behind (Ab9).
@@PianoDigitalScores So Gb7 is functioning as the tritone sub for C7 here?
@@testtest-lc4xzYes, but not just that. Starting at the end of m.19 you have a tritone substitution for a vi-ii-V that leads to F, but with a twist (check out the Tadd Dameron turnaround).
Barry was one of a kind. Wow!
Wow.... This is utterly beautiful - I'm glad you transcribed it!
Thank you so much for this! One of my favorite Barry Harris videos
Mine too, you're very welcome!
I love it. This was truly beautiful👌😍😍🎹🎤🎶😊
Thank you for transcribing this! This is the video I always share to my friends in the band when they asked what jazz ballad are. I think some of the measures and chords can clean up a little bit. For example, the second chord of measure 1 (Fmaj#5) can be omitted as this is an embellishing chord to resolve from Fmaj7/9 to F6, this is also the application of the 6dim. scale.
Gdim7 chord on measure 12 should be an A7(b9) instead. Also, can choose either m7b5 or half dim chord.
My pleasure! I'll leave the Fmaj#5 just to show how one could embellish the space between those two chords. As for measure 12, you are right. I'll make the correction to the PDF in a few days as I'm traveling at the moment. Thank you for pointing that out!
Amazing job on transcription. Well done!
Hey man, thanks a lot!
Brilliant playing
Sensational Barry Harris
As a guitar player, I desperately wish I could comp like this. 😭
I missed my calling as a keyboard player. But I will apply as much as I can of this to guitar. Thanks for the incredible post.
Spectacular, thanks for the upload and transcription! Definitely a lot to learn!!
A lot indeed. You're welcome!
My music hero. Barry born with a gift and worked hard to expand it….then great Barry Harris.
Beautiful !
Thank you SO MUCH you are legend..studying this tonight
It’s sounds like heaven
He's right about Learning the Lyrics. Good accompanying comes from Listening.
Excellent thanks for sharing! If you haven't already fixed this -- last chord symbol of m.42 should be Eb not E
You're welcome and thank you for pointing out that error!
I believe in whoever has written this master piece, is much more capable than the pianist.
If you're referring to me I assure you that's not true.
That is what I call crowd participation. What a beautiful ending to a musical journey…to Paradise.
It's more pretty when you play it with your own inversions :). Thank you for sharing
You're welcome, I'm glad you like it!
Just wanted to credit George Gershwin (music) and Ira Gershwin (lyrics). "Embraceable You" was written in 1928 & published in 1930.
What an absolute GEM, thanks so much for sharing. David Bahar Edinburgh Scotland.
Marvelous job! :D I enjoyed every bar of it
Thank you, I'm glad you did!
Absolutely gorgeous! I would love to see more of these kinds of videos from you!
I'm working on another one. It's not in the same mood as this one but it's of a great pianist that I look up to.
Looking forward to it :)
Good job men.
He got most his stuff out of barry's teaching. He is very deditated and talented.
Thank you!
That was magic!!
But can he play wonderwall?
:))
You’re asking the right questions
I was crazy about the video. Oh my oh my!!!
So sad that camera man moved away from Barry... I can see he was moved. The great playing, him teaching and doing what he loves till the last momemt. "Come board my ship, for a trip, to paradise".... RIP mister Harris.
So soft 😍
beautiful
Pretty sweet playing!
Great job!👍
Thank you!
You're a legend!!
good job thank you
Beautiful, thank you very much for posting.
Thank you very much for grabbing the pdf file!
I'm going to study this! 😉
Have fun!
oh wow, this is real nice
Amazing!
This is one of those videos that make me want to quit lol. So beautiful.
Or study and practice and eventually get better. You got this!
negative mindset. it makes me want to play the piano at 11 pm
Beautiful ❤. To paradise!
So beautiful
My new favorite video
breathtaking
Impresionante.. Bravo!
Amazing work! Thx
You're welcome!
nice job
Thank you!
Barry Harris should have put at least one or two tunes where he sings and they would be so iconic.
Listen to 'the bird of red and gold' if you want to hear him sing one ow his own songs!
@ oh. my. god…. Thank you so much!
@@adamkozielski7358 You're welcome!
Thank you.
You're welcome!
just beautiful! can someone help me why does he want people to think in 6?
He’s referring to 2 Underlying quarter note triplets which define a jazz ballad
Gives it’s a romantic, waltz-y feel
Time to practice, thank you
Beauty.
Love the choice of chords... #9 #11 7th chords (!!)
Agreed
Wowoww. The final arpeggio is bar is so similar to the final bar in Rachmaninoff's Daisies
You have a big brain and some big ears. Pretty remarkable!
Hello beautiful people I am back for another ?? lol ok Now Barry I should say Mr Harris sings Embraceable you by George Gershwin first then he continues into another beautiful song which made my ears very happy Is the song called Come board my ship ? Who wrote this song anyone know Please , pretty please thanks
Apparently it's a Barry Harris original called Em-Barry-Harris-Able You which is basically Embraceable You but with Barry's lyrics.
@@PianoDigitalScores Thankyou Piano digital for taking the time to elaborate on this masterpiece. Now I am going to cry lol cause the chords look so complicated . I Its doesn't look like easy read lead sheet . Still I can always come back to this video for a listen and let my ears enjoy.
@@Sera-ng1zk you're welcome! Take your time and simplify the chords first.
2:44 in bar 43, how do we call this voicing? I know Drop 3, but "Up 3"? Amazing, anyway.
Thank you for this transcription. You should study Barry Harris. The pianist (Jakub Hajdun) was most likely trained by him.
You're welcome! I am studying his approach but not as much as I'd wish. I don't know if Jakub was his student. In the original video, at the end, Barry asks for the name of the pianist.
barry ❤
Do you have any video resources which would be useful lessons in learning to comp this well?
I guess the best resources are records (or even this video). I don't think there is a step by step lesson out there that teaches you to comp at such an advanced level. You just need to listen to a lot of music and try stuff out. Transcribe, incorporate, develop.
Great work. But an even better intro and great solo on this tune was played by Barry himself on the dynamite two piano recording with Kenny Barron called Confirmation. I recommend listening to it! IMHO it’s the best two piano jazz recording ever made even better than the two albums Tommy Flanagan and Hank Jones did together.
Thanks for the suggestion, I'll check it out!
th-cam.com/video/9YcJdLI3s0U/w-d-xo.html
bar 52, should that be a Dbmaj7 and not an Eb7sus? EDIT: also bar 20, instead of Fm it should be a Dbmaj7. FYI, GREAT job transcribing, I purchased a copy - thank you for making it available!
I LOVE Barry's improvised chorus on this...are the lyrics improvised or are they taken from something somewhere?
Hey man! Thank you for your feedback and corrections! The one in m.20 was already fixed. I wanted to reply to you sooner but I had to finish going through the whole transcription again to check for other mistakes, which I had already started doing (took a while, I know). I've found other mistakes and fixed them and will soon be sending out a pdf update to everyone that purchased it.
Can someone explain why is Barry saying “How did you know I wanted that” at 1:19 ? What exactly is “that”?
As @billgrahammusic noticed, it's a variation on the Tadd Dameron turnaround. You can google that, you'll find info on it.
is it isaac raz on the right facing barry?
They weren't ready for his level
Hi, this is really great stuff, how would anyone learn to transcribe chords and ear different voices so precisely, this seems so hard to me, how did you achieve this level?
A lot of doing (transcribing), software to slow down the audio and a lot of plays and replays (where it wasn't clear to me) to have time to hear everything. But this is me without perfect pitch or a good ear. Others might take less time and with less effort. I'm still practicing and learning. It also helps to have a keyboard near to try to replicate the harmonies you hear and see if they match. Also, even so, I did slip some errors into the video version. I've since made edits to the PDF to be more accurate.
@@PianoDigitalScores Thanks a lot, are there some easier compings to transcribe that you started with and can recommend me to try? I don't think there are many people that could do much better than you here, there is always room for improvement but your level is a goal for me right now. Relative pitch is a slow process and a long journey but I don't think that having perfect pitch would be way better, surely you wouldn't have to ear train this much, but I have friends who have perfect pitch and are not that good at hearing inner voices (because they never train) or just don't have the patience to transcribe long solos or compings.
@@ferdinandodamico5796 I would start transcribing melodies first (regardless of the instrument playing it) and then move to harmonies. If you already got the first step under your belt you can start with some Errol Garner compings.
I could transcribe a melody and identify most chords... but how do you know the voicing? Or when there are blocks of 3-4 notes at once as eight notes? Is it like a next level? How to practice?
In most cases I slow down the audio. I would first start with listening to the top and bottom notes and then fill in the rest. Some chords I already have in my ears and recognize them by now. The rest of them I just try them out at my piano and if a particular chord color is hard to figure out I try to listen to each note/frequency. If I am unsure I then test by playing the chord against the recording and see if they sound alike or if a note is dissonant. I also use the software Transcribe which identifies and represents frequencies on a visual keyboard (can also slow down the audio). Depending on the audio quality, this can speed things a lot. You can also get good results if you extract the piano from the recording (if voice or other instruments distract you). I use lalal.ai but in some cases it doesn't include everything. This is why I use both audios to transcribe, to make sure I include everything. Happy transcribing! :D
@PianoDigitalScores Amazing, thank you. And respect for your work.
@@ich-nuta You're welcome and thanks!
Can someone list all the songs he sings? I only know “Embraceable You”!
The other half is Barry's version of Embraceable You that he called Em-Barry-Harris-Able You.
@ Thank you so very much!
i love this accompaniment, do you have like a playlist of these that you can share or something? im not good at finding things
I'm working on a similar transcription and might focus on piano accompaniments for a while. Keep your eyes peeled 👀.
How do one attain this type of perfect pitch to transcribe it
I wish I had perfect pitch. I just spent a lot of hours listening to it in slow-motion and transcribing it.
Wow,awesome, stunning, fantastic, passion etc,etc,etc,etc, 🎹🎶👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🎶🎹🙏🙏🙏
What is the name of this song Barry Harris is singing please? very beautiful.
embraceable you
@@mattykeys thankyou
who is the pianist.. her got Amy more scores available..id love to hear this brother some more
It's Jakub Hajdun