In Pakistan, millions of Baloch freedom, liberation, freedom fighters are fighting Pakistan Army colonial occupation with Reign Of Terror. Pakistan Army colonial occupation is a direct continuation of British colonial occupation from London. All Pakistan Army generals, politicians, business owners have dual nationality and live and retire in UK, USA, Canada, Australia. Pakistan Army Chief is the viceroy of British colonial occupation.
Sir, in his ( Dr. Mirza)voice it's clear full frustration of getting a lions share of power sharing in GB. I am following him since when he was active in the movement when he started radio Himalayas. In the beginning he used to tell to obey Indian constitution & hold Indian flag but when he smelled some movement he was telling of autonomous structure of GB. Who is he to tell what type of our leaders should be. It's we who elect ourleaders. Please don't give him space in your respected channel.
@chanchaldas6850 exactly who the hell is he to advice our EAM,he slowly opening his opinion of his radical mindset,why India bather about Bangladesh,POK?In the case of Bangladesh we supplied cotton electricity day to day perishable goods,those people embrace religion before everything why we need to care,in POK we need only the land which is ours we dont want liabilities ie the radical people of POK.Why this channel produce this kind of video with this kind of guest,useless,its better to not see this channel
@@indiastoplistwe dont want GB,we got enough from Bangladesh for liberating it,so we dont want radical minds ,better put all muslims from India to a seperate land ,let them and let us live peacefully.Let see who will have good standard of living.Even Saudi Arabia UAE want to have secularism but these beggars Pakistan Bangladesh want radicalism
@@shakeelqureshi505 Khane ke liye nahi aata, aur chale Kashmir lene 😂😂😂 Go and check history of Kashmir from your own people --Do you know Raja Hai Singh?
@taneemtaha4230 @simransidhu617 exactly ,what a nonsense he spoked and see the host of this channel giving love symbol for all those nonsense and anti India comment.Better guys dont watch this nonsense channel
As long as India's borders do not change we as Indians succeed in not giving the world a reason to destroy peace in the subcontinent. Let's hope we can delay any changes till the dust settles down on the planet and people seeing a clearer vision of the future.
Before reaching 33, I had changed my opinion about Dr Amjad Ayub Mirza in a positive manner and was going to thank You for showing that side of him. But then, just before 33 when he said Democracy is not meant for India (or something like that), made me to put my hand on the forehead and wornder do these people even have any inkling, leave alone understanding, about what democracy is, how does it operate.... Not that I have anything against him. It is just that over the period of time I have been hearing that he has been giving date/month about POJK merger with India that I did not take him seriously. But, today, when I heard him about the possibility of disintegration of Pakistan I had started changing my opinion to the positive.. But then, he, just before 33... .....Just felt like saying. You handled pretty well, and I do understand that he was being bit emotional and said that in the flow of things. But that is not an excuse about what was said about democracy itself, General Saheb.. By the way, I do not know how true it is but my understanding is that democracy was being practised in certain parts (Sangha?) of ancient India, and that bring mixed feelings of pleasure, delight, wonder, awe, pride and more, in me...
Party-based democracy with a feature of ruling and opposition parties is certainly not good for India. We need a council-based system, a democracy practiced in ancient India.
@@amitabhkumar8379 I wonder whether there ever was or is any political system which was satisfactory to All the people who lived through it? My memory could be bit hazy, but as I recall, many years ago in one of the episodes of Discovery of India, it was shown that how lazy, slow and vulnerable council based system is, that was being practised in ancient India. And how a strong Raja/kingdom could gobble it up.
Excellent podcast Lt Gen Shankar Sir. I wish Dr Mirza had elaborated what kind of political system he thought was better for India if not democracy or "western style" as he put it. The problem with unification of the Pak occupied territories that belong to India is the population which is extremely radicalised, with a very low level of education or training. These factors and more would make integration very difficult. On our side of Kashmir, despite having lived with Hindus, there was a genocide of Hindus and they were driven out. At present the simmering situation in Gilgit Baltistan is because of the Shia factor but how the situation would change if that land was taken back also remains to be seen. Dr Mirza voiced his disappointment with the Indian government but while he has his point, the Indian government too has many aspects that it has to consider apart from that. If one looks at old videos of that region, the anti India sentiment is very clear. It's only when the food prices shot up and other problems became more that they started saying that they want to join with India. Once their bellies are full, what guarantee is there that they will be peaceful and not start something? Let's not jump in to buy timber that we know is termite riddled. I particularly liked your response on the democracy point, Sir. Salute and thank you.
@bhoomalahashetti2617,really?what struggle? What he elaborated here?its his mindset of radicals,why what caused Bangladesh for their problem,is it India?Its time for Hindus to take arms thats the way,if hindus have that then we will stop all this nonsense.Hindus need to look Israel way of bombardment
An Volcanic interview full of fire & wit. Two erudite minds at logger heads ia always a treat to watch. ❤ Dr. Mirza is forthright & doesnt mince words. His understanding of our politics & failures of our Politician is commendable. Especially the slap on the EAM, about his arrogance & blockages, needs to b elobrated, may b a session in TJD. 😊 Thank U Dr & General
Dr saheb your Right and your Dream will be reality soon India is beyond Religion it's way of life and governance Respect for all and progress for all peace for all
*Dr Mirza you are a great human being doing service to liberate your motherland. Indian government should nominate you in the state assembly or Parliament as the representative of the POK which India claims is a part of the Indian union*
Yes,why shy about including him and many others. We must . Its legally our land. We have to include pok in our soceity. Assimilate it. Pok people should feel indian
@@induchopra3014 If I am not wrong, there are 29 seats reserved in the Kashmir assembly for the representative of the POK area. Thanks for your support. There are few more POK origin Kashmiris who are very vocal supporters of the Indian cause.
@@Kanishka-d6w we really want kashmiris to be recognised as peaceful hospitable culture. There is no hate in Central asian islamic countries for any hindu . How Pakistan islam become so poisonous ? Lot of money was invested in developing this mindset . By west..dollars were poured. Kashmir was most peaceful preparation, even 50s,60s. Secularism is answer to all evils. Give, what you want. Pakistan has been preaching hate too long. It cant preach and practice two different things..Pakistan ideologically is dead. It died with jinnah. Noone thinks muslim is a nation. Noone
At the same moment dictatorship may be dangerous in India, like in Pakistan our dictators may be coaxed and purchased by Western power to act as per their wish.
India has messed up very badly. The distraction of the elections has cost us so much time and space, it's really sad. Modi's self aggrandizement has ruined whatever gains had been made in a decade.... really sad
There are almost 14 million Hindus i.e. 8% or above in Bangladesh. We should not talk about getting them out but rather there should be a strong effort to empower them Overtly and/or covertly) and make them a strong community, especially in terns of training them so they can defend themselves so any one trying to hurt them and take them for granted, should think twice. I am for Subash Chandra Bose philosophy.
General Saheb, glad to see you have captioned this topic with a question, and not a definite statement as has been the case with most of youtubers, and media in general in India... Am at 12.00 and still watching.. It so happens that just couple of days I have written the following somewhere.. Countries do not break just like that! No matter how much Indian TH-camrs or media in India may keep on shouting and desire (read misleading). Pakistan will not break. There has to be an outside power to instigate and push it through. Until and unless India actively gets involved and work towards it, Pakistan will remain intact. Is there any real desire on the part of Indian state that wants to see break up of Pakistan? Has anyone ever made a case showing that how breakup of Pakistan is beneficial for India? Bangladesh is a prime example. What is the result? With the migration of hundreds of thousands of Bangladeshis into India, if not millions, there already is a demographic change among other things. A factor to be kept in mind. This is not to say that break up of Pakistan should or should not happen. This is merely to say that other than emotional outburst there has to be rational thinking behind it. Anyone who knows India of 50s/60s/70s/80s would know that it was predicted by many that India will break into several countries. There were so many insurgencies, movements for sepration were going on be it in North, East, South of India. India of that time was very weak in every respect. Be it politically, militarily, economically and otherwise. State, is very a strong and powerful entity, and of all the people Sanjay knows this as he has been part of it. But I guess caption like this attract more views so......
Yes Indian govt did not even issue a courtesy statement---shame, shame.....India keeps crying kashmir belongs to India--but in reality does absolutely nothing, shame shame.
More like china will try to ensure now. Since USA's withdrawal in Afghanistan now china is more closer to Pakistan considering all the port development, highways , oil pipeline from Pakistan to China,etc.
In the case of Indian sub-continents' Independence struggle, the British did not have their own soldiers to suppress the movements whereas in the case of Pakistan, so long as the Army is powerful independence will not be possible. Only time the independence movement can win is when the Army does not have the economic where Withall to sustain their action against independence. So it is going to be economic downfall of Pakistan followed by victory for independence struggle. Meanwhile people will suffer all kinds of indignities by the army and also their hired goons.
Dr. Mirza indian government is sleeping, they are so weak with their policy. By not handling , they create more problems for themselfs and same is with Bangladesh region.
@varindererkumar7092,do you really understand whats going on,you really understand english.Dont be childish,before commenting get some knowledge or please dont let public with wrong perception
No one can disintegrate Pakistan at all as Tribal Chiefs,Landlords and Punjabi COMISSION Agents and so called Chaudhery of Pakistan controlled Kashmir can never ever AFORD this tertorial or geographical disintegration of PAKISTAN.
Gandhiji were lucky that he had to fight Britishers. His non-violent approach worked with Britishers. His approach could not have worked with any other hypothetical colonizer/occupier. In case of Balochistan, occupier is Pakistan Army. Non-Violent movement will never be successful against Pakistan Army.
1. Dr Sahab is fine as he talks about Pakistan and POJK but not about India. He is emotional about what India should do but that is not how it will be. 2. India will not go into POJK on its own but people there first must rise against Pak Administration and ask for India to take over. This has not happened at a mass level and hence, India is waiting. 3. Perhaps disintegration of Pakistan will hasten this process.
Yes he last time says says this Balochistan 🇩🇯 and PoJK way back in 2016 independence day 8 years back. BJP is only talk and no action. Paxtan disintegration will start only from integration of PoJK and Gilgit baltistan with India. After May June protests in PoJK, the once in a lifetime opportunity is lost.
General, the only involvement by Bharat should be to stir up problems for Pakistan. Help weaken Pakistan and help disintegration. Cannot trust the local's loyalty towards Bharat.
We should recognise and establish GOVERNMENTS OF BALOCHISTHAN, SINDHUDESH, PASHTUNISTAN & AFGHANISTAN in one single piece of land adjacent to each other.
Gen. Shankar, you have the right to delude into Paskaitn's disintegration. You know the capability of the core you commanded and Pakistan's response, I do not have to educate you on that.
Agree with Dr. Mirza 100% that the Indian Govt, BJP, Home Ministry & foreign affairs have all failed Balochistan, POJK & failed in Indian Neighborhood over last 4-5 months
@@essm4179 hey what the hell you are talking about,you mean India need to take all those radical mindset,who's problem is Bangladesh?its their radical mindset .POK the land is ours but not that radical mindset liabilities.For those radical mindset religion is above all not seculiarism.First those radicals create problem if the other party push back those radicals play victim card.
Mark this, if Pakistan disintegrates, it will set precedent in India as well, Kashmir, Khalistan, South India, Northeastern Sister States and even West Bengal trying to join Bangladesh…. So India must refrain from this.
There is not even the chance of a snowflake in hell of Pakistan's integration. Any speculation to this effect can only be based on ignorance. First and foremost, her constituent units are only administrative units and not based on separate ethnic groups. To quote just one example, ethnic Balochis in Baluchistan form only 40 % of the population of the province. These are distributed among 82 large and small tribes that are not united by any means and remain mostly at odds with each other. There are more ethnic Baluchis who call Sind and Punjab their home than they do in Baluchistan. Pakistan's population has the same Aryan origins, overwhelmingly the same religion and is economically unified by the mighty Indus. Her people readily intermarry which is the universally accepted hallmark of a nation. This is a lot more than can be said about her neighbour to the east.
Sir can you have a discussion on the Indian army again purchasing assault rifles from the USA when there are Indian pvt companies which can build one and it's totally Indian.. that pvt company is manufacturing on its own it's not only assembling here in India...
Gunners Shot,,, Can it be ,,,how Pak can be well integrated as a Nation ? If U discuss Paks disintegration There will be India 's. Tomorrow Why add fuel to fire Can we be more positive more about another Country ? Particularly with our Neighbour ? Let there be a debate,,, discussion how to strengthen Indias integrity if you are really concerned & Patriot.
This part of Pakistan will remain united; the one that was separated by Indian conspiracy will come back. This part will remain a pain in the ass for India, and China will take her land back. South will depart, and impoverished poor millions and millions will scramble for food.
Not sure what you mean by modern time.. regime change, creating a new country out of an existing country is not a big deal. I think, latest established country is South Sudan.. am sure there could be a one or two more but I do not recall as of now...All it needs is assistance of another strong country to create another country.
Dr. Mirza thinking is akin to Pakistan's Generals. Enter without an exit plan or a definition of a win or a calculation of reactions. Fortunately, we in Bharat have the well understood example of Abhimanyu who knew only how to enter the Chakravyuh. The Doctor himself has spelt out the challenge. Three generations of people who have no clue of Sanatana Dharma or rather have been ingrained to have a negative view of Hindus. There are definitive benefits for the people of POJK. What's in it for an average resident of UP or Bihar? Existing resources being diverted from them?
What will be iran's reaction sir coz western balochistan is under iranian(persian) colonial rule just like eastern balochistan under punjabi(pakistan) colonial rule as it was designed by the british imperialist planning and maping?
Sorry Dr.Mirza, we have our Home Ministry and Defence Ministry in the hands of totally ineffective, old, out of touch, dynasts, who's busy making sure their next generation is well placed as the heads of multi billion dollar organisations like BCCI. Modi and Yogi are different because they are Sanyasis and true Brahmacharis(not celebacy), and that gives mental clarity and physical energy to work 24 hours. But unfortunately for Bharat, the rest of the team are not competent enough
Hard hitting view points from Dr Mirza, all hitting bulseye. BJP led govt sleeping and weak, now even more. And we have a PM who is running around doing Intl diplomacy when the country and its neighborhood needs attention! Modi is going to Brunei and Singapore next week. Another trip? Arre bhai look at domestic problems and solve them. You are leaving everything to Mota Bhai Amit Shah, he cannot handle it. Focus on jobs creation and not try to solve Russia-Ukraine war. He is delusional, wants Nobel Peace Prize. Just building hospitals, universities, and highways not enough. Create jobs.
Even though one does not have to be big supporter of Modi but most of what he is doing especially on the foreign front, should be understood and appreciated. It is imperative that he/India is fully engaged in Russia-Ukraine affair. The economic growth that India is enjoying today, and Jaishankar is able to raise his voice can be attributed to Russia in a major way. Russia-Ukraine war has opened doors for multi polarism. Had Russia not stood up to the USA/West, countries like China, India and others would not have had the guts to say things openly which they are doing today. Just look at India's reaction before the start of SMO, and the sea change after seeing success on the ground by Russia. Sometimes, things do not appear to have impact directly. Getting cheap oil from Russia, and that too in non USD currency has, and continue to help India. Jobs may not be being created as fast as desired but that does not mean that work is not being done towards it. There are other reasons also for agonising gradual increase in job opportunities.. for example, education system itself, which does not produce engineers, mathematicians, physicists who truly contribute to the growth of economy... As to his wanting Nobel, you cannot blame him. Many leaders are afflicted with this bimari/illness.. Him being a delusional, was clear when he claimed to be non biological entity. However, all these negatives are not enough to overlook, outweigh and negate his postiive contribution, to India, so far. Like anyone else, he has his limitations.
Mirza saab what you say is right but remember that what you are expecting is difficult because the current government has no support of the opposition in india on action in pokk and baluchistan.
STOP CALLING THIS SO CALLED ACTIVIST .. ONLY TALK NO SUBSTANCE.. WHAT DOES HE KNOW ABOUT INDIA AND HOW THE ARMED FORCES HAVE SACRIFICED THEIR LIVES FOR THIS COUNTRY.. GENERAL SAAB WE LOVE AND RESPECT YOU BUT CAN'T TOLERATE THIS BEHAVIOUR BY SO CALLED ACTIVIST!!
@@gunnersshot *Gen. Sahab , Dr. Mirza's views are not considering Chinese, US influence on PoK. Our government, did a wrong thing when Skardu, Shias were yelling "Kargil Chalo" there was no statement from the Indian government, which shows they don't want PoK and PoK is jut kept for elections and politics. Now all those leaders are booked under schedule 4.*
Pakistan is a lucky bastard if Uncle Sam (USA) beats it will go to Chacha (China), in addition to this it gets help from relatives (Islamic and European countries). On top of this Papa (India) has taken a soft approach.
@Amjad Ayub Mirza - Planets and Prarabdh has decided 2027-2031 as the time, if you want the hint from mother nature or as you call qayanat. Whether Indian government likes it or not they will be forced to deal with developments. We agree with hizada enunchness of Maulana Modi, Jhumlatantra, and inaction cladded Indian army folks. मित्रो - पल पल पाई पाई का हिसाब १. गुजरात मॉडल दिल्ली में नहीं चला। १०% विकास एक भी साल नहीं हो पाया, जब की १० साल १०% विकास बच्चो का खेल था २०१४ में ! २. मुजरिम गाँधी वाड्रा आज भी खुल्ले आम घूम रहे है देश में और विदेशो में - मास्टरस्ट्रोक ३. १५ लाख प्रति नागरिक की लूट वापास नहीं आयी, गाँधी वाड्रा ने ४-२- का १ कर दिया!! ४. इटली और ब्रिटिश नागरिकता का साबुत गृह मंत्रालय के पास गाँधी वाड्रा के विर्रुध पता नहीं क्यों नहीं काम करता!! ५. सबका साथ, विकास, विश्वास याने जिहादियों का साथ, क़ुरानियो का प्रयास और इस्लामियों का विकास - अल्लाह मालिक ६. बुलेट गाडी समय अनुसार २०२२ से पहले चल नहीं पायी ७. जम्मू कश्मीर आज भी पाकिस्तान और चीन द्वारा अधिकृत है ८. स्वर्णिम चतुर्भुज रेल मार्ग और राष्ट्रीय मार्ग आज भी अधूरा पड़ा है!! ९. १० करोड़ नौकरी का हिसाब नहीं है १०.आतंकवाद के बावजूद पाकिस्तान में पानी बह रहा है ११. UCC, CAA, NRC , पीसीसी आदि आदि हवा हवाई बाते है २०२3 में, राम राज्य का वायदा किया था!! १२. हिंदुस्तान में हिन्दू का सर तन से जुदा हुवा है, क्यों की भाजपा ने सबका साथ, विकास, विश्वास की बकवास की है १३. भाजपा को संसद चलाना भी नहीं आता है। चुल्लू भर गुंडे चिल्लाते रहते है!! देश का तमाशा बना दिया है १४. कानून, पुलिस, और लोकतंत्र पूरी तरह से देश में थप है। जिहादियों का राज है एक भी आतंकी को आज तक सजा नहीं हो पायी है! १५ २०१४ से २०२४ तक १ डॉलर का मूल्य ६९ रुपये से ८४ रुपये तक पहुंच गया! १४ चुनाव से पहले:न खाउंगा न खाने दूंगा--चुनाव के बाद: थोड़ा खिलाओ थोड़ा भाजपा पार्टी ऑफिस बनावो १५ राम राज्य में अधर्म जिहादी को सजा नहीं होगी, सर तन से जुदा होगा, सनातनियो को अधर्म के सामने झुकना होगा! सुभान अल्ला। १६ बांग्लादेशी पाकिस्तानी, अफगानी लोग घुसे हुवे है देश में और उनको सब मुफ्त में चाहिए, लेकिन CAA नहीं चाहिये , वाह मोदी है तो मुमकिन है १७ कल्पसर प्रोजेक्ट के बारे में मोदीजी क्यों नहीं फेंकते है आज कल, क्या हुवा? १८ AMCA भी समय अनुसार उड़ नहीं पाया १९ चुनाव के लिए राम मंदिर का उद्घाटन करना पड़ा!! मास्टरस्ट्रोक!! २० चलता है, मोदी है तो मुमकिन है। धन्यवाद !
BTW sanatan ka gyaan lene se ek insaan thoda shaant avashy ho jata hai, sanatani ban-na bahut dooor ki baat hia isliye darein nahi, bus padhe, jeewana badle apne radicals ka bhi aur non-radicals ka bhi
Balochistan has to start looking at its old history and religious roots and call for integration with India, with some special provisions as enjoyed by many NE Indian states.
General Sir , i am a great fan of urs . I always listen to u r vlogs first of any other video. But of late , u r some comments are very pathetic and heart breaking , example 1. when will Pakistan disintegrate? Pakistan s disintegrated alreay . 2. Indian army s got nothing to do in Bangladesh crisis etc , Sir if tiniest countries like Nepal , Maldives Bangladesh, manamar, srilanka etc are not afraid of Indian army, it s pathetic, i m nt telling India to attack anyone but Indian army can give tough messages and display some rough postures to save Hindhus of these countries and West Bengal etc , u r statement that * indian forces had very tough times in Srilanka etc* s increased our blood pressure immensely. If our position in a country like শ্রীলঙ্কা was so , god only can save us😮is our army so weak under u r leadership, don't want to believe that, and finally even if it is so , please don't give such statements openly as u r heard worldwise including our enemies like Pakistan etc , u r not a political leader and u a general of great Indian army , please talk like a army general , goph kete felun Sir😅 regards
@@gunnersshotwe r not emotional Sir but u r approach and statements v made us nervous, Sir ki politics join korchen ? U r statements are more like a political leader than a army general, Bankurar tanter sari ar Purulia r ki ancher churi ,, Mamta Banerjee is waiting for you Sir , u can join TMC
@45th minute, he says people of PoJK don't have any operations hindu temple or a copy of Bhagwat Geets..Excuse me - what about internet, youtube, importing/smuggling copies of Geeta? There are millions of GB n POJK asylum seekers in the western countries...many have become citizens of western nations - study there, preach or at least flood reading material into GB/ PoJK. Ban to Ayub Mirza sahab bhi honge PK mein, bol rahe hain na PK, uski army, leaders sabke khilaaf...to aise hi Sanatan ka gyaan bhi lo... COmmunal issues pe tumne pakistan banaya, goro pe hindustaniyon se adhik bharosa kiya...ab mummy mummy karte Bharat maa ko rote hain aap...hosh ki dawa kijiye sahab
What is stopping India to to take back ancient Sharada Peeth temple, when it's just 3-Kms away from the LoC, Keran sector.. Forget this, our past govts. don't even have guts to open a Kartarpur sahib-like corridor for Hindus in Jammu and Kashmir to visit our thousands years old university. The Sharda peeth committee, in Kashmir requesting this demand since 2006. But both congress and BJP are clueless untill 2023 when committee members made a proposal again to the LG and centre. It's only In 2023, when a Hindu couple from Hong Kong given visa by pak, visited the famous temple premises and performed Aarti and rituals as per the tradition for the first time in 77-years. What was India doing when paxtan made Mangla dam reservoir in 1964 and it just swept away almost all surrounding rural villages in Mirpur and killed many people and lands lost, one famous Shivala temple (abandoned after PoJK revolt)🛕 also found itself levelled below the flood and now a part of dome temple can be found in remote sandy rubble. The images Ganga Choti and Shiva temple kotli among a half dozen are available in Google.
Dr.Amjad Ayub Mirza is a nice man. But he is looking at things in a very selfish way. He wants to become POJK PM and to get there he needs Bharat's help. That's why he is talking the way he is. Calling Dr.Jaishankar an arrogant person shows his selfish intentions. Bharat doesn't want a radicalized populace from POJK and it should make very calculated moves.
Aap ko Balochistan wali saziah aaj se 30 sall pehly krni chahye thi ab Kya faida 😂😂😂. Ab to gawadar port clear ho Gai hai aur airport bhi bn gya hai aur inauguration bhi complete ho Gai hai sary project ki, aur phir baat krty hain PAK army 🪖 ki aur an aisa kabhi bhi mumkin nahi Hoga 😂😂😂😂
In Pakistan, millions of Baloch freedom, liberation, freedom fighters are fighting Pakistan Army colonial occupation with Reign Of Terror. Pakistan Army colonial occupation is a direct continuation of British colonial occupation from London. All Pakistan Army generals, politicians, business owners have dual nationality and live and retire in UK, USA, Canada, Australia. Pakistan Army Chief is the viceroy of British colonial occupation.
do u have any idea what is colonial occupation mr. indian ?
@@shahzadaslam384 STFU! Zubair just stated the facts. Why do paki generals have dual-citizenship?
@@shahzadaslam384 Your entire country is under colonial occupation of US and Chyna, facilitated by your army mr. paxtani
Sir, in his ( Dr. Mirza)voice it's clear full frustration of getting a lions share of power sharing in GB. I am following him since when he was active in the movement when he started radio Himalayas. In the beginning he used to tell to obey Indian constitution & hold Indian flag but when he smelled some movement he was telling of autonomous structure of GB. Who is he to tell what type of our leaders should be. It's we who elect ourleaders. Please don't give him space in your respected channel.
Exactly...people of GB want independence NOT joining India.
@chanchaldas6850 exactly who the hell is he to advice our EAM,he slowly opening his opinion of his radical mindset,why India bather about Bangladesh,POK?In the case of Bangladesh we supplied cotton electricity day to day perishable goods,those people embrace religion before everything why we need to care,in POK we need only the land which is ours we dont want liabilities ie the radical people of POK.Why this channel produce this kind of video with this kind of guest,useless,its better to not see this channel
@@indiastoplistwe dont want GB,we got enough from Bangladesh for liberating it,so we dont want radical minds ,better put all muslims from India to a seperate land ,let them and let us live peacefully.Let see who will have good standard of living.Even Saudi Arabia UAE want to have secularism but these beggars Pakistan Bangladesh want radicalism
🎉
Karima Baloch = we will never forget you . Balochistan Zindabad 🎉
🎉❤🎉
@@shakeelqureshi505 Khane ke liye nahi aata, aur chale Kashmir lene 😂😂😂 Go and check history of Kashmir from your own people --Do you know Raja Hai Singh?
@@shakeelqureshi505 Liberation for Pakistan from hunger and begging
KAHLISTAN, MANIPUR, NAGLAND, , FREEDOM FROM INDIA 🇵🇰💪
@@miskeenshah-z6v then say - I want India---phati hai kya.
Compliments to Dr Mirza from Scotland.
For what..what he has done so magical ar of importance that he should be complemented??
@@taneemtaha4230 He came drunk on the show, by the looks of it 🤣🤣
@taneemtaha4230 @simransidhu617 exactly ,what a nonsense he spoked and see the host of this channel giving love symbol for all those nonsense and anti India comment.Better guys dont watch this nonsense channel
@@shanmugasundaramrajeswaran8737 but you have watched it.
@@simransidhu617 did you smell alcohol on his breath on this TH-cam channel??
Ajmad ayub mirza sir always support and love Bharat and also have very good knowledge of all pakistan people
@@kkentertainment1990 thank you
But very disappointed with the Bharat government.
How?? Can U highlight
If Dr. Mahrang Baloch joins the other side, it may endanger the women even more perhaps. It's not so easy like Dr Mirza says.
As long as India's borders do not change we as Indians succeed in not giving the world a reason to destroy peace in the subcontinent. Let's hope we can delay any changes till the dust settles down on the planet and people seeing a clearer vision of the future.
Outright views of Amjajdji are looks practical and must be
Huonored.
Before reaching 33, I had changed my opinion about Dr Amjad Ayub Mirza in a positive manner and was going to thank You for showing that side of him. But then, just before 33 when he said Democracy is not meant for India (or something like that), made me to put my hand on the forehead and wornder do these people even have any inkling, leave alone understanding, about what democracy is, how does it operate.... Not that I have anything against him. It is just that over the period of time I have been hearing that he has been giving date/month about POJK merger with India that I did not take him seriously. But, today, when I heard him about the possibility of disintegration of Pakistan I had started changing my opinion to the positive.. But then, he, just before 33... .....Just felt like saying. You handled pretty well, and I do understand that he was being bit emotional and said that in the flow of things. But that is not an excuse about what was said about democracy itself, General Saheb.. By the way, I do not know how true it is but my understanding is that democracy was being practised in certain parts (Sangha?) of ancient India, and that bring mixed feelings of pleasure, delight, wonder, awe, pride and more, in me...
Party-based democracy with a feature of ruling and opposition parties is certainly not good for India. We need a council-based system, a democracy practiced in ancient India.
@@amitabhkumar8379 I wonder whether there ever was or is any political system which was satisfactory to All the people who lived through it?
My memory could be bit hazy, but as I recall, many years ago in one of the episodes of Discovery of India, it was shown that how lazy, slow and vulnerable council based system is, that was being practised in ancient India. And how a strong Raja/kingdom could gobble it up.
Excellent podcast Lt Gen Shankar Sir. I wish Dr Mirza had elaborated what kind of political system he thought was better for India if not democracy or "western style" as he put it. The problem with unification of the Pak occupied territories that belong to India is the population which is extremely radicalised, with a very low level of education or training. These factors and more would make integration very difficult. On our side of Kashmir, despite having lived with Hindus, there was a genocide of Hindus and they were driven out. At present the simmering situation in Gilgit Baltistan is because of the Shia factor but how the situation would change if that land was taken back also remains to be seen. Dr Mirza voiced his disappointment with the Indian government but while he has his point, the Indian government too has many aspects that it has to consider apart from that. If one looks at old videos of that region, the anti India sentiment is very clear. It's only when the food prices shot up and other problems became more that they started saying that they want to join with India. Once their bellies are full, what guarantee is there that they will be peaceful and not start something? Let's not jump in to buy timber that we know is termite riddled. I particularly liked your response on the democracy point, Sir. Salute and thank you.
Very interesting... Thanks sir
Welcome
General and Miriam Saab I liked your conversation.great.
Amjad is right. He understands various struggles.
Really... What are the proof of his struggles
@@bhoomaiahalishetti2617 What struggles ???
@bhoomalahashetti2617,really?what struggle? What he elaborated here?its his mindset of radicals,why what caused Bangladesh for their problem,is it India?Its time for Hindus to take arms thats the way,if hindus have that then we will stop all this nonsense.Hindus need to look Israel way of bombardment
An Volcanic interview full of fire & wit. Two erudite minds at logger heads ia always a treat to watch. ❤ Dr. Mirza is forthright & doesnt mince words. His understanding of our politics & failures of our Politician is commendable. Especially the slap on the EAM, about his arrogance & blockages, needs to b elobrated, may b a session in TJD. 😊 Thank U Dr & General
Great insights by Dr Amjad
@@sanjeevsingh4590 what is so great about ...can u explain
Perhaps it is better to go with an arrogant minister than with the aggressive activists so tnat the country is safe🤔
@@naliniraghu7698 He is frustrated that India has not attacked Pakistan.
Mirza is desperate as it seems
He is the embodiment of a mountain of patience and commonsense. @@taneemtaha4230
Dr saheb your Right and your Dream will be reality soon India is beyond Religion it's way of life and governance Respect for all and progress for all peace for all
The West always plays its games. Using religion, caste, race for geopolitical goals is a persistent game of the West. The West will help Pakistan.
Amjad is right on Indian leadership.
Really??how
Hope so.
Mirza saab. Wait till November.
*Dr Mirza you are a great human being doing service to liberate your motherland. Indian government should nominate you in the state assembly or Parliament as the representative of the POK which India claims is a part of the Indian union*
Yes,why shy about including him and many others. We must . Its legally our land. We have to include pok in our soceity. Assimilate it. Pok people should feel indian
@@induchopra3014 If I am not wrong, there are 29 seats reserved in the Kashmir assembly for the representative of the POK area. Thanks for your support. There are few more POK origin Kashmiris who are very vocal supporters of the Indian cause.
@@Kanishka-d6w we really want kashmiris to be recognised as peaceful hospitable culture. There is no hate in Central asian islamic countries for any hindu . How Pakistan islam become so poisonous ? Lot of money was invested in developing this mindset . By west..dollars were poured. Kashmir was most peaceful preparation, even 50s,60s. Secularism is answer to all evils. Give, what you want. Pakistan has been preaching hate too long. It cant preach and practice two different things..Pakistan ideologically is dead. It died with jinnah. Noone thinks muslim is a nation. Noone
At the same moment dictatorship may be dangerous in India, like in Pakistan our dictators may be coaxed and purchased by Western power to act as per their wish.
India has messed up very badly. The distraction of the elections has cost us so much time and space, it's really sad. Modi's self aggrandizement has ruined whatever gains had been made in a decade.... really sad
There are almost 14 million Hindus i.e. 8% or above in Bangladesh. We should not talk about getting them out but rather there should be a strong effort to empower them Overtly and/or covertly) and make them a strong community, especially in terns of training them so they can defend themselves so any one trying to hurt them and take them for granted, should think twice. I am for Subash Chandra Bose philosophy.
Hmm
👍
General Saheb, glad to see you have captioned this topic with a question, and not a definite statement as has been the case with most of youtubers, and media in general in India... Am at 12.00 and still watching.. It so happens that just couple of days I have written the following somewhere..
Countries do not break just like that! No matter how much Indian TH-camrs or media in India may keep on shouting and desire (read misleading). Pakistan will not break. There has to be an outside power to instigate and push it through. Until and unless India actively gets involved and work towards it, Pakistan will remain intact. Is there any real desire on the part of Indian state that wants to see break up of Pakistan? Has anyone ever made a case showing that how breakup of Pakistan is beneficial for India? Bangladesh is a prime example. What is the result? With the migration of hundreds of thousands of Bangladeshis into India, if not millions, there already is a demographic change among other things. A factor to be kept in mind. This is not to say that break up of Pakistan should or should not happen. This is merely to say that other than emotional outburst there has to be rational thinking behind it. Anyone who knows India of 50s/60s/70s/80s would know that it was predicted by many that India will break into several countries. There were so many insurgencies, movements for sepration were going on be it in North, East, South of India. India of that time was very weak in every respect. Be it politically, militarily, economically and otherwise. State, is very a strong and powerful entity, and of all the people Sanjay knows this as he has been part of it. But I guess caption like this attract more views so......
Hmm
No ban on Daylight Dreams 😂
Yes Indian govt did not even issue a courtesy statement---shame, shame.....India keeps crying kashmir belongs to India--but in reality does absolutely nothing, shame shame.
It's a dream which would never come true
Impossible. It is the mischiefmaker for india,s enemies.
America will ensure Pakistan stays
More like china will try to ensure now. Since USA's withdrawal in Afghanistan now china is more closer to Pakistan considering all the port development, highways , oil pipeline from Pakistan to China,etc.
Till when
🙏
Democracy is not for subcontinent like nepal pakistan india bangladesh 100% with ayub mirza
Hmm
For delusional 'activist' democracy don't have any logic
In the case of Indian sub-continents' Independence struggle, the British did not have their own soldiers to suppress the movements whereas in the case of Pakistan, so long as the Army is powerful independence will not be possible. Only time the independence movement can win is when the Army does not have the economic where Withall to sustain their action against independence. So it is going to be economic downfall of Pakistan followed by victory for independence struggle. Meanwhile people will suffer all kinds of indignities by the army and also their hired goons.
Dr. Mirza indian government is sleeping, they are so weak with their policy. By not handling , they create more problems for themselfs and same is with Bangladesh region.
Hmm
How??
@varindererkumar7092,do you really understand whats going on,you really understand english.Dont be childish,before commenting get some knowledge or please dont let public with wrong perception
MOST DEFINITELY
The short answer is yes inshallah. Question is when. Hopefully soon. Jai Bharat.
No one can disintegrate Pakistan at all as Tribal Chiefs,Landlords and Punjabi COMISSION Agents and so called Chaudhery of Pakistan controlled Kashmir can never ever AFORD this tertorial or geographical disintegration of PAKISTAN.
Gandhiji were lucky that he had to fight Britishers. His non-violent approach worked with Britishers. His approach could not have worked with any other hypothetical colonizer/occupier. In case of Balochistan, occupier is Pakistan Army. Non-Violent movement will never be successful against Pakistan Army.
10,000 + views within 13 hours and only 500 likes 😢.... REQUEST everyone to Please LIKE & SHARE the video
1. Dr Sahab is fine as he talks about Pakistan and POJK but not about India. He is emotional about what India should do but that is not how it will be. 2. India will not go into POJK on its own but people there first must rise against Pak Administration and ask for India to take over. This has not happened at a mass level and hence, India is waiting. 3. Perhaps disintegration of Pakistan will hasten this process.
Fact in what is said by the guest,Mrs Gandhi made Bangladesh and Modi failed in freeing Po J&K.
And Modi is going to fail in Baluchistan.
What about India where sikh, naga land and others state are asking for independence
I agree with Dr. Mirza- Modi only mentions Baluchistan and POJK in political rallies. All talk no action. The Peter Principle has been proved by Modi.
Yes he last time says says this Balochistan 🇩🇯 and PoJK way back in 2016 independence day 8 years back.
BJP is only talk and no action.
Paxtan disintegration will start only from integration of PoJK and Gilgit baltistan with India.
After May June protests in PoJK, the once in a lifetime opportunity is lost.
Hmm
Hmm
100%agree with mr ayub mirza
Hmm
Why??give logical arguments
General, the only involvement by Bharat should be to stir up problems for Pakistan. Help weaken Pakistan and help disintegration. Cannot trust the local's loyalty towards Bharat.
We should recognise and establish GOVERNMENTS OF BALOCHISTHAN, SINDHUDESH, PASHTUNISTAN & AFGHANISTAN in one single piece of land adjacent to each other.
Hmm
We also should recognise and establish government of, KAHLISTAN, nagland, manipur, West Bengal, and many more, don't worry 🇵🇰💪
There is no such thing as non-violence with Pakistan. Gandhi type movement will get you nothing but 100 years of misery....
Freedom for pushtunistan balochistan sindh gilgit baltistan jai hind 🇦🇫 🇮🇳
Gen. Shankar, you have the right to delude into Paskaitn's disintegration. You know the capability of the core you commanded and Pakistan's response, I do not have to educate you on that.
Hmm
Agree with Dr. Mirza 100% that the Indian Govt, BJP, Home Ministry & foreign affairs have all failed Balochistan, POJK & failed in Indian Neighborhood over last 4-5 months
Hmm
Really??how.. give arguments
@@essm4179 What Nonsense !!!
@@essm4179 hey what the hell you are talking about,you mean India need to take all those radical mindset,who's problem is Bangladesh?its their radical mindset .POK the land is ours but not that radical mindset liabilities.For those radical mindset religion is above all not seculiarism.First those radicals create problem if the other party push back those radicals play victim card.
@@shanmugasundaramrajeswaran8737 You seem to be living inside bollywood. How come the land belongs to you and not the people
Mark this, if Pakistan disintegrates, it will set precedent in India as well, Kashmir, Khalistan, South India, Northeastern Sister States and even West Bengal trying to join Bangladesh…. So India must refrain from this.
Hmm
There is not even the chance of a snowflake in hell of Pakistan's integration. Any speculation to this effect can only be based on ignorance. First and foremost, her constituent units are only administrative units and not based on separate ethnic groups. To quote just one example, ethnic Balochis in Baluchistan form only 40 % of the population of the province. These are distributed among 82 large and small tribes that are not united by any means and remain mostly at odds with each other. There are more ethnic Baluchis who call Sind and Punjab their home than they do in Baluchistan.
Pakistan's population has the same Aryan origins, overwhelmingly the same religion and is economically unified by the mighty Indus. Her people readily intermarry which is the universally accepted hallmark of a nation. This is a lot more than can be said about her neighbour to the east.
Hmm
Sir can you have a discussion on the Indian army again purchasing assault rifles from the USA when there are Indian pvt companies which can build one and it's totally Indian.. that pvt company is manufacturing on its own it's not only assembling here in India...
मिर्ज़ा साहब, भारत पहले अपने दुश्मनों से तो निपट ले.
Hmm
I have heard that Pak is going to disintegrate for the past several years! Nothing has happened inspite of all these predictions.
hmm..
Gunners Shot,,,
Can it be ,,,how Pak can be
well integrated as a Nation ?
If U discuss Paks disintegration
There will be India 's. Tomorrow
Why add fuel to fire
Can we be more positive more
about another Country ?
Particularly with our Neighbour ?
Let there be a debate,,, discussion
how to strengthen Indias integrity
if you are really concerned
& Patriot.
Hmm
Dr Mehrang Baloch has declared Independence from Pakistan today . What is the impact on Pakistan ?
Interesting
Total lie😂😂😂
@@Sport_corn her speech was in English and shown on TV
@@sanjaydoshi7968 🤣🤣 send me link ghodi media affected😀😀
It will not happen automatically. Neighbour ing contries must help them for millitarily action.
😅
Hmm
POJK can first Abandon Radical Islam first
Now what will happen to these terrorists, you have not thought about it, they are not good now
Hmm
Punjab k sikhon ko nahi sambhaal sako ge aap , ye baat likh lo
This part of Pakistan will remain united; the one that was separated by Indian conspiracy will come back.
This part will remain a pain in the ass for India, and China will take her land back.
South will depart, and impoverished poor millions and millions will scramble for food.
IT is difficult in modern time to break a state.
Not sure what you mean by modern time.. regime change, creating a new country out of an existing country is not a big deal. I think, latest established country is South Sudan.. am sure there could be a one or two more but I do not recall as of now...All it needs is assistance of another strong country to create another country.
Hmm
Both pakistan and baloch people will be happy if it dissociate. Mirjaji a nice gentleman.
Dr. Mirza thinking is akin to Pakistan's Generals. Enter without an exit plan or a definition of a win or a calculation of reactions.
Fortunately, we in Bharat have the well understood example of Abhimanyu who knew only how to enter the Chakravyuh.
The Doctor himself has spelt out the challenge. Three generations of people who have no clue of Sanatana Dharma or rather have been ingrained to have a negative view of Hindus.
There are definitive benefits for the people of POJK. What's in it for an average resident of UP or Bihar? Existing resources being diverted from them?
Good to continue= Freedom struggle must continue in all directions 🙏🏻 , ultimate goal - Freedom 💓
Ajit doval se Kaho jitna zor wo lga sakta hai lga Le 😂😂😂
ask general sir , IF possible can you make a special video on LAC and LAC using google earth or google sattelite map
I will
What will be iran's reaction sir coz western balochistan is under iranian(persian) colonial rule just like eastern balochistan under punjabi(pakistan) colonial rule as it was designed by the british imperialist planning and maping?
Sorry Dr.Mirza, we have our Home Ministry and Defence Ministry in the hands of totally ineffective, old, out of touch, dynasts, who's busy making sure their next generation is well placed as the heads of multi billion dollar organisations like BCCI. Modi and Yogi are different because they are Sanyasis and true Brahmacharis(not celebacy), and that gives mental clarity and physical energy to work 24 hours. But unfortunately for Bharat, the rest of the team are not competent enough
Hard hitting view points from Dr Mirza, all hitting bulseye. BJP led govt sleeping and weak, now even more. And we have a PM who is running around doing Intl diplomacy when the country and its neighborhood needs attention! Modi is going to Brunei and Singapore next week. Another trip? Arre bhai look at domestic problems and solve them. You are leaving everything to Mota Bhai Amit Shah, he cannot handle it. Focus on jobs creation and not try to solve Russia-Ukraine war. He is delusional, wants Nobel Peace Prize. Just building hospitals, universities, and highways not enough. Create jobs.
Even though one does not have to be big supporter of Modi but most of what he is doing especially on the foreign front, should be understood and appreciated. It is imperative that he/India is fully engaged in Russia-Ukraine affair. The economic growth that India is enjoying today, and Jaishankar is able to raise his voice can be attributed to Russia in a major way. Russia-Ukraine war has opened doors for multi polarism. Had Russia not stood up to the USA/West, countries like China, India and others would not have had the guts to say things openly which they are doing today. Just look at India's reaction before the start of SMO, and the sea change after seeing success on the ground by Russia. Sometimes, things do not appear to have impact directly. Getting cheap oil from Russia, and that too in non USD currency has, and continue to help India. Jobs may not be being created as fast as desired but that does not mean that work is not being done towards it. There are other reasons also for agonising gradual increase in job opportunities.. for example, education system itself, which does not produce engineers, mathematicians, physicists who truly contribute to the growth of economy...
As to his wanting Nobel, you cannot blame him. Many leaders are afflicted with this bimari/illness.. Him being a delusional, was clear when he claimed to be non biological entity. However, all these negatives are not enough to overlook, outweigh and negate his postiive contribution, to India, so far. Like anyone else, he has his limitations.
pakistan haters again from india
Mirza saab what you say is right but remember that what you are expecting is difficult because the current government has no support of the opposition in india on action in pokk and baluchistan.
STOP CALLING THIS SO CALLED ACTIVIST .. ONLY TALK NO SUBSTANCE.. WHAT DOES HE KNOW ABOUT INDIA AND HOW THE ARMED FORCES HAVE SACRIFICED THEIR LIVES FOR THIS COUNTRY.. GENERAL SAAB WE LOVE AND RESPECT YOU BUT CAN'T TOLERATE THIS BEHAVIOUR BY SO CALLED ACTIVIST!!
Relax...must hear all views.
@@gunnersshot *Gen. Sahab , Dr. Mirza's views are not considering Chinese, US influence on PoK. Our government, did a wrong thing when Skardu, Shias were yelling "Kargil Chalo" there was no statement from the Indian government, which shows they don't want PoK and PoK is jut kept for elections and politics. Now all those leaders are booked under schedule 4.*
Balochistan ko hm sambhaal Len gen Lekin 1 baat yaad rakhna k Punjab aur khalistan movement aap se nahi sambhali JAE gi 😂😂
It's true that India has maintained a blinding silence over human rights violation in PoK, it's really very surprising.
Hazaroon khawashian ayesi k her khwaish py dum nikalae
Pakistan is a lucky bastard if Uncle Sam (USA) beats it will go to Chacha (China), in addition to this it gets help from relatives (Islamic and European countries). On top of this Papa (India) has taken a soft approach.
Hmm
@Amjad Ayub Mirza - Planets and Prarabdh has decided 2027-2031 as the time, if you want the hint from mother nature or as you call qayanat. Whether Indian government likes it or not they will be forced to deal with developments. We agree with hizada enunchness of Maulana Modi, Jhumlatantra, and inaction cladded Indian army folks.
मित्रो - पल पल पाई पाई का हिसाब
१. गुजरात मॉडल दिल्ली में नहीं चला। १०% विकास एक भी साल नहीं हो पाया, जब की १० साल १०% विकास बच्चो का खेल था २०१४ में !
२. मुजरिम गाँधी वाड्रा आज भी खुल्ले आम घूम रहे है देश में और विदेशो में - मास्टरस्ट्रोक
३. १५ लाख प्रति नागरिक की लूट वापास नहीं आयी, गाँधी वाड्रा ने ४-२- का १ कर दिया!!
४. इटली और ब्रिटिश नागरिकता का साबुत गृह मंत्रालय के पास गाँधी वाड्रा के विर्रुध पता नहीं क्यों नहीं काम करता!!
५. सबका साथ, विकास, विश्वास याने जिहादियों का साथ, क़ुरानियो का प्रयास और इस्लामियों का विकास - अल्लाह मालिक
६. बुलेट गाडी समय अनुसार २०२२ से पहले चल नहीं पायी
७. जम्मू कश्मीर आज भी पाकिस्तान और चीन द्वारा अधिकृत है
८. स्वर्णिम चतुर्भुज रेल मार्ग और राष्ट्रीय मार्ग आज भी अधूरा पड़ा है!!
९. १० करोड़ नौकरी का हिसाब नहीं है
१०.आतंकवाद के बावजूद पाकिस्तान में पानी बह रहा है
११. UCC, CAA, NRC , पीसीसी आदि आदि हवा हवाई बाते है २०२3 में, राम राज्य का वायदा किया था!!
१२. हिंदुस्तान में हिन्दू का सर तन से जुदा हुवा है, क्यों की भाजपा ने सबका साथ, विकास, विश्वास की बकवास की है
१३. भाजपा को संसद चलाना भी नहीं आता है। चुल्लू भर गुंडे चिल्लाते रहते है!! देश का तमाशा बना दिया है
१४. कानून, पुलिस, और लोकतंत्र पूरी तरह से देश में थप है। जिहादियों का राज है एक भी आतंकी को आज तक सजा नहीं हो पायी है!
१५ २०१४ से २०२४ तक १ डॉलर का मूल्य ६९ रुपये से ८४ रुपये तक पहुंच गया!
१४ चुनाव से पहले:न खाउंगा न खाने दूंगा--चुनाव के बाद: थोड़ा खिलाओ थोड़ा भाजपा पार्टी ऑफिस बनावो
१५ राम राज्य में अधर्म जिहादी को सजा नहीं होगी, सर तन से जुदा होगा, सनातनियो को अधर्म के सामने झुकना होगा! सुभान अल्ला।
१६ बांग्लादेशी पाकिस्तानी, अफगानी लोग घुसे हुवे है देश में और उनको सब मुफ्त में चाहिए, लेकिन CAA नहीं चाहिये , वाह मोदी है तो मुमकिन है
१७ कल्पसर प्रोजेक्ट के बारे में मोदीजी क्यों नहीं फेंकते है आज कल, क्या हुवा?
१८ AMCA भी समय अनुसार उड़ नहीं पाया
१९ चुनाव के लिए राम मंदिर का उद्घाटन करना पड़ा!! मास्टरस्ट्रोक!!
२० चलता है, मोदी है तो मुमकिन है। धन्यवाद !
Interesting
Why don't you join politics since you have such a good understanding.
BTW sanatan ka gyaan lene se ek insaan thoda shaant avashy ho jata hai, sanatani ban-na bahut dooor ki baat hia isliye darein nahi, bus padhe, jeewana badle apne radicals ka bhi aur non-radicals ka bhi
Hmm
Respectively, I think you mean WHEN as opposed to WILL Pakistan disintegrate !!!
BAAY GAANEE SHADEE MAAY ABDULAAY DEWAANAAY 😅🤣🤣
Balochistan has to start looking at its old history and religious roots and call for integration with India, with some special provisions as enjoyed by many NE Indian states.
Please worry about your Red States & Christian States.
Will Manipur sir ?
No
General Sir , i am a great fan of urs . I always listen to u r vlogs first of any other video. But of late , u r some comments are very pathetic and heart breaking , example 1. when will Pakistan disintegrate? Pakistan s disintegrated alreay . 2. Indian army s got nothing to do in Bangladesh crisis etc , Sir if tiniest countries like Nepal , Maldives Bangladesh, manamar, srilanka etc are not afraid of Indian army, it s pathetic, i m nt telling India to attack anyone but Indian army can give tough messages and display some rough postures to save Hindhus of these countries and West Bengal etc , u r statement that * indian forces had very tough times in Srilanka etc* s increased our blood pressure immensely. If our position in a country like শ্রীলঙ্কা was so , god only can save us😮is our army so weak under u r leadership, don't want to believe that, and finally even if it is so , please don't give such statements openly as u r heard worldwise including our enemies like Pakistan etc , u r not a political leader and u a general of great Indian army , please talk like a army general , goph kete felun Sir😅 regards
Don’t get emotional….
@@gunnersshotwe r not emotional Sir but u r approach and statements v made us nervous, Sir ki politics join korchen ? U r statements are more like a political leader than a army general, Bankurar tanter sari ar Purulia r ki ancher churi ,, Mamta Banerjee is waiting for you Sir , u can join TMC
Did Pakistan mordabad
@45th minute, he says people of PoJK don't have any operations hindu temple or a copy of Bhagwat Geets..Excuse me - what about internet, youtube, importing/smuggling copies of Geeta? There are millions of GB n POJK asylum seekers in the western countries...many have become citizens of western nations - study there, preach or at least flood reading material into GB/ PoJK. Ban to Ayub Mirza sahab bhi honge PK mein, bol rahe hain na PK, uski army, leaders sabke khilaaf...to aise hi Sanatan ka gyaan bhi lo...
COmmunal issues pe tumne pakistan banaya, goro pe hindustaniyon se adhik bharosa kiya...ab mummy mummy karte Bharat maa ko rote hain aap...hosh ki dawa kijiye sahab
Hmm
What is stopping India to to take back ancient Sharada Peeth temple, when it's just 3-Kms away from the LoC, Keran sector..
Forget this, our past govts. don't even have guts to open a Kartarpur sahib-like corridor for Hindus in Jammu and Kashmir to visit our thousands years old university.
The Sharda peeth committee, in Kashmir requesting this demand since 2006. But both congress and BJP are clueless untill 2023 when committee members made a proposal again to the LG and centre.
It's only In 2023, when a Hindu couple from Hong Kong given visa by pak, visited the famous temple premises and performed Aarti and rituals as per the tradition for the first time in 77-years.
What was India doing when paxtan made Mangla dam reservoir in 1964 and it just swept away almost all surrounding rural villages in Mirpur and killed many people and lands lost, one famous Shivala temple (abandoned after PoJK revolt)🛕 also found itself levelled below the flood and now a part of dome temple can be found in remote sandy rubble. The images Ganga Choti and Shiva temple kotli among a half dozen are available in Google.
Dr.Amjad Ayub Mirza is a nice man. But he is looking at things in a very selfish way. He wants to become POJK PM and to get there he needs Bharat's help. That's why he is talking the way he is. Calling Dr.Jaishankar an arrogant person shows his selfish intentions.
Bharat doesn't want a radicalized populace from POJK and it should make very calculated moves.
Modi is past the shelf life . He talks about Gandhi and Buddha now. Flopped miserably 😊
Is he drunk..sounds like a mad fool
Hmm
You. Wished 😂😂😂😂😊
Gandhian movement will never get independence ……even India got independence because of Subhash CHandra BOse
Crap all the way from Amjad. I feel like being accidently placed in Arts class whilst being a Maths enthusiast.
Nothing new.
Hmm
Wrong time to discuss this issue..
Hmm
this guy is general ?
This so called Dr has no idea about India.
Hmm
Aap ko Balochistan wali saziah aaj se 30 sall pehly krni chahye thi ab Kya faida 😂😂😂. Ab to gawadar port clear ho Gai hai aur airport bhi bn gya hai aur inauguration bhi complete ho Gai hai sary project ki, aur phir baat krty hain PAK army 🪖 ki aur an aisa kabhi bhi mumkin nahi Hoga 😂😂😂😂