So Surf and Turf wars part 2 came out And damn it was pretty good, like VERY good. It honestly might be one of my favorite Eddsworld episodes of all time. Might make a video on the new episode if yall want me too!
as someone who found eddsworld around a month before edd died i gotta say i genuily like the modern one as i am the audience meant to cater to aka teens only problem i have with the modern one is how long the jokes drag on and tom's voice actor just does not completely feel right other than that i am glad matt is keeping it alive
The Beyond style CAN be good, and the perfect example is Casting Call. The pacing is way faster, and the jokes are actually funny. I laughed a couple of times, meanwhile in the other eddisodes it's hard for me to laugh. The eddisode feels like it's full of inside jokes and they land really well. I've rewatched it countless times because it's just a fun watch, and it deserves way more love
I have been a eddsworld fan for awhile, But when i found out about it, it was when i was sad and upset and crying, i was scrolling through TH-cam videos and found a eddsworld animation, i watched acouple of them and realized i stopped crying and it made me happy, that's one of the reasons i love eddsworld, It made me happy and gave me joy, it is a reason for my motivation to even keep on animating in the first place, i looked up to edd and matt dearly (still do), and when i found out edd died due to cancer, that broke my heart and i started to cry again but decided to watch some eddsworld episodes again, it made me happy, it always makes me happy, but the new eddsworld and team are really good but i don't know, some of the new episodes are a bit boring, strange, less interesting? Don't get me wrong i respect the new team and the episodes but it's just not really the same as it used to be, Matt is is great for continuing eddsworld though:), i love his dedication, he was edd's best friend, yk? He cared alot for edd, Im not saying tom or tord didn't care for edd, I'm just saying matt was edd's *best* friend The episodes are still good! Im very happy george started voicing edd's character, that makes me really happy and im sure it made other's very happy aswell! he's trying and i love that!:D Surf and turf wars part 2 was very good and i loved it! Matt looked like a cutie patootie The little jokes they added like the Titanic reference, In the background is a red and blue ship labelled "TMTD", referencing TomTord which is the one the cannons destroyed, and when the guy said "It's no good sir! the cannons are only damaging the ships! D:" and then the girl said "The *head cannon* ?" And then he said "No sir! *ALL* the cannon!" and then they both stared at the camera like "😐" i seriously enjoyed that It sucks how tord kept getting harassed and stalked so he had to leave eddsworld:( and then afterwards he had to literally change his name and hide, let's not forget he kept getting called very bad words and kept getting death threats because he didn't show up to edd's funeral, tord didn't even know edd died at all or what had happened:( that wasn't his fault. I genuinely think tom doesn't get enough credit, All people do is think about the stuff he didn't do, Tom done so much honestly and he deserves more credit for that :( But most importantly to end this comment, *r.i.p edd gould :(
@@todsworldd I agree. Tom and Tord are my comfort characters. I relate to them to much, and he was one of the most harassed out of the fandom besides Paul and Patryck.
TBH I miss the Tom era, because it actually tried to branch out and do its own thing. What Matt is doing is basically just trying to emulate what Edd used without taking the time to consider if it had aged well (which it kinda didn’t).
it DID age well unfortunately matt doesnt seem to have that vision the perfect example of what i mean: spooky month, and others by its creator they are chaotic and its so fun i LOVE chaotic episodes (i mean look at TERMINAL MONTAGE, and METY333) chaotic, still absolutely slaps, unfortunately people nowadays arent that level of chaos anymore
I think the problem with the jokes is because of younger audiences. They elongate and over saturate the jokes with complete nonsense. They are plain and dragged on so younger audiences can laugh. Edd's puns in the newer episodes (for the most part) fail a little too much to where they don't even make you laugh. (for example, "Egg to meet you.") Unlike how the older episodes are. The older episodes have Edd's crappy puns that fail enough but also make sense enough to where they can crack a laugh. The new episodes just make the jokes so dry and nonsensical.
I laughed At Majority of the Jokes in the Beyond error I don’t see the problem with the humor in the Beyond error it’s like Edds humor. Eddsworld was never bad to me it may have had problems with the legacy error. The Beyond error so far is way better imo because it has that classic feeling while being modern.
This video was a relief, i barely see people who dislike the new eddsworld episodes, i find them pretty boring and don't really feel like regular eddsworld episodes aside from the main cast, i hope the new episodes use less cutaway gags and have better pacing. Edit: I think i was a bit too harsh in my previous comment, i think matt might not be too used to make eddsworld episodes, though i still think they need more working in the comedy aspect, anyways i hope all goes well to the team
I still don’t get why people dislike the beyond error so much. The pacing is completely fine to me and the humor is funny as always and feels like Edds humor. Also they do feel like eddsworld episodes.
Great video! I remember Eddsworld growing up as it was quite popular back in the day. While I didn't watch the original show regularly I did know of Edd Gould's passing and was saddened by the news. I am glad the series is still around and you had a lot of good criticisms about why the new series isn't as good as the original.
As an extreme Eddsworld fan, (not a fangirl, anti-fan, toxic fandom member, etc. … I just like it a lot), this is my favorite show ever. I became a fan one year after The End, and boy did I love it. When I found out Eddsworld came back, I was so excited. But, as I watched all of Eddsworld Beyond that they have so far, I only found myself liking Fan Service 2, The Birds and Bees, The Casting short, Randumb, and Zombeh Picnic. I didn’t care for Beaster Bunny, Slippery Slope, or Surf & Turf. I don’t like Ed Templer, the new voice of Tom, or how the Eddsworld humor was lost. I also can’t get used to their new animation style. Nonetheless, I will always love and appreciate Eddsworld, and I do hope they try more on Beyond.
I TOTALLY agree with you on this video, Matt is still not used to having the writing role, and i think we should give him time to improve. Hes honestly doing really great so far, and i cant wait to see what the future of eddsworld has to offer! :))
Maybe the reason why Eddsworld feels off is probably due to Matt being the only remaining member of the original Eddsworld team/voice cast and It probably must be hard for him to keep up with the making of the new eddisodes or maybe even come up with an idea for an Eddsworld eddisode plot and the reason why they take so long to upload a video, even though all 3 of his real life friends: Tom, Tord, and Edd are now gone, but at least Matt chose to stay on the show and is trying his best to keep it going for the fans with a little help from the new Eddsworld team/voice cast and also by adding his own spin to the show as well
Great effort put into these videos, keep it up! I've been a fan of Eddsworld since 2011 and was pretty excited to see it come back. I watched the first of the new episodes, and while I enjoyed it, I never came back to check for new episodes. I felt that the show's humor was geared towards teenagers, and I'd simply grown out of that style of comedy. In 2011 I was 16, I'm 27 now and have very different tastes. I'd bet if I watched the old episodes for the first time at age 27 without nostalgia factoring in, it wouldn't hit the same to me today. I'm glad they are continuing on the legacy of the show for a whole new generation of people to enjoy and learn about the great guy that was Edd Gould.
I am glad that I am not the only one that feel this way Edd's eddsworld and Tom's eddsworld are perfect. There's always something missing with Matt's eddsworld.
my biggest problem with modern eddsworld is that lately they are focusing way too much on the merchandise and less on the episodes. It's...just starting to feel like a cashgrab to me, i'm sorry. I still like EW, but this is just a feeling i have
I was researching Eddsworld stuff regarding the Beyond era and I feel relieved that someone else is having these thoughts about it. The first two Beyonds really worked for me showing who were the people in charge now mocking the weird demands by fans. But everything that came after that has been really disappointing. Not for being bad, but how unnecessarily it is shoehorned into Eddsworld instead of being Matt & Bing's own spin-off like Tom's Crash Zoom is. It's really sad how much Tom was harassed and criticized for leading Eddsworld for a while even if he gained nothing from it while Matt & Bing are clearly making profit from Beyond. Not that they deserve bad publicity, but at least they should really try harder and get better writers.
Wait, where di you get that information? I was actually wondering why tord was back even though the creator wasnt comfortable with tord being in the series.
I think this shows that, it’s just hard to redo what others did. Trying to get what made eddsword so great is kinda difficult It’s like asking people to wrestle a lion like hercules did
I agree with you about the situation with Eddsworld Beyond sometimes. Here my own opinions of this show. Positives of Eddsworld Beyond: - The animations are a little more fluid than classic Eddsworld - The main characters of Eddsworld are still likeable, and funny - The Eddsworld Episodes are still not running out of ideas - There are some good episodes (Casting Call, Fan Service 2, Zombeh Picnic, and Surf and Turf Wars Part 1) - Ed Templer is a very good actor for Tom that almost sounds like the original voice actor, TomSka, same with George Gould for voice Edd. - There are still many clever jokes that makes me laugh (mainly Fan Service 2 and Casting Call) - Matt is still currently voiced over by Matt Hargreaves Negatives of Eddsworld Beyond: - Some of the jokes feels slow and kinda meh to me - Some of the episodes are kinda alright (Slippery Slope, The Birds and the Bees, and RANDUMB) - The background characters can get a little overused to the stories, but many of them are likeable and decent You did a great job making this video on what Eddsworld Beyond needs to improve on. I respect the Eddsworld Crew for making this show alive and I'm proud of them for doing their best.
@@spider-manunknown9193 Good pun, bro. I agree with your opinion that Slippery Slope was a good episode. Though in my opinion, the episode should've been a little longer. 🙂
@@spider-manunknown9193 Hope Eddsworld make some Ellisodes too in the future too. Ell, Tamara, and Matilda are such great characters just like the main characters as well.
I think one of the reasons why this Edda world is lacking in the writing department is because of the loss of tomska in the show. He was a very funny writer and now I feel like it’s very boring. Not saying it’s bad just saying it need more oomph. :)
The show hasn’t become boring,it never has become boring. Tomska left because of the people who complained about the legacy error if they didn’t complain about it he probably still be on eddsworld but he’s doing his own stuff now. The new voice actor is also very good for Tom. Also for writing we only really have 2 or 3 big episodes in the beyond era the rest are shorts.
@@spider-manunknown9193 1. Tom didnt leave the show because of the complaints about the legacy era. He left because it was mentally taxing. 2. what im trying to say is TO ME this show does have the same pacing as per say saloonatics. an episode Tom wrote and thats ok. 3. What does the voice actor for Tom have anything to do with what i said??
@@elmopizza I thought you were saying that the show went downhill after Tom left and how his new voice actor sucks. Idk why I read it like that. That’s my fault.
I thought this show ended. Bringing it back is kinda risky and this shows. It already had an official ending. But I guess the fandom was still very active & they wanted to take advantage of that. I’m still conflicted on the matter, yet I’m still all for eddsworld having some relevancy. Its Goofy lil web show about dudes doin their thing. Man if only that’s what it was like for them IRL.
Your editing is spot on man, great video! Honestly I'm surprised I haven't seen more Eddsworld video essays out in the wild, and you've done a fantastic job chronicling this important part of so many of our childhoods/teenage years on the Internet! Subscribed 👑
OH FINALLY! i am relatively new to the eddsworld fandom, like 2 years maybe? and i am also still like a kid, but i LOVE the older eddsworld. I found new eddworld incredibly boring, especially surf n turf wats two. Thanks for making this, you really adressed all the issues. Like, i loved hammer and fail, and zanta claus 3 still is the best.
I do think your reasons are pretty valid, but I really like it, I think Matt is trying his best and all the other directors, it can be hard to remake a show from scratch, plus having all the funding taken away due to back taxes, but I think the show will get better in time. But what you're saying is valid though.
Not many people will like what I have to say today, but I see a serious drop in quality in my eddsworld beyond episodes. Don't get me wrong, I know how hard Matt works, he works hard to keep the show afloat, but I don't like Matt's sense of humor. In the eddsworld classic, eddin's sense of humor was like loneytoons, in legacy, tom's humor and parts were more sci-fi, like rick and morty. but mattin's sense of humor is like screaming burp. I wish Matt would focus on sections instead of dealing with things like Instagram posts and lgbt. maybe tomska doesn't need eddsworld but eddsworld needs tom. be honest when we say eddsworld we all think of zombie attack the end tom was the pinnacle of the show. don't get me wrong I love every single person who contributed to this show not only the show is not where it deserves. If Tom had continued, maybe eddsworld would have been released on a platform like netfilix (Sorry for bad english)
I think what happened with the writing is that in the original show, I'm pretty sure it was mainly Edd and Tom writing, and you could even tell when a joke was written by Tom just based on watching things like ASDF movie. I think Tom and Edd's writing styles sort of balanced themselves well with each other. When Legacy happened, Tom didn't have that balance anymore and was probably trying to make it feel like Edd's writing, but his own interpretation mixed with other writers on the show might have muddled it a bit. Tom was also dealing with a lot of grief at that time as well. All that being said I actually enjoy Legacy quite a bit but I usually omit it from when i rewatch the series, apart from Space Face. With Eddsworld Beyond, it's mainly Matt and Mr.Bingham now I believe. I don't know how much Matt wrote for the original series or his history with writing in general. The one thing i do like about Beyond is that Matt doesn't feel like a background character anymore, even in the original series I felt that.., but I think Edd and Tom's characters are suffering a bit because of it. I think Matt understands Edd's humor, but just not the aspect of pacing and writing. Like the jokes do remind me of Edd's jokes, and even Tom's somewhat, but the way they are presented as OP said is less than funny. Again, this is just from what I know of the original cast, but I've probably misinterpreted things and I haven't really researched much about the modern show since it simply doesn't interest me. If anybody wants to share more info in the replies or correct me that is absolutely welcomed.
Also, I think the reason why Beyond feels off nowadays is because of the new voice actors for both Tom and Edd and the new writing/directing approach by Matt
Also alot of scenes usually don't have background music in the background which makes it feel empty. Or it could just be me loving the background music in legacy.
I'll say this I think I like Beyond a lot more than Legacy quality wise it feels at least a bit more like classic eddsworld but those old episodes are still classics It feels like legacy and beyond are trying to cater to a specific audience while og eddsworld wasnt (given that it was made in the wild west era of the internet) it felt like Edd just made the cartoon he wanted to without restrictions Beyond saddly doesn't have that luxury
tbh they couldve just maybe discontinued the series rather than spilling out a bunch of junk, yea surf and turf wars was good but for me i liked their old versions and personailties better :/ what would be a better idea was they would make mini eddisodes or smth rather than putting a lot of filler and unfunny jokes note: this is my opinion i dont hate matt or the team for tryna bring back the old era!!
Same, I miss the old personalities, old jokes and old voices especially Tom who's old voice and personality I prefer and yeah the newer jokes in beyond are not as funny as the classic or legacy era's which is why I prefer the old ones better
@@michaelb.2662 glad someone agrees, i may be a new fan but i feel like eddsworld is like one of those unfunny adult swim n kid shows mushed up together with soulless shit. the end part 2 would be better off alone along with a few mini eddisodes
Everything u said is true and if you look at their social media they keep releasing new merch here and there i think they are just making profits off the show's popularity
holy shit THANK YOU for making this, Eddsworld Beyond really bothers me and hasn't been my favourite, even after the new release of the episode a few days ago... in my opinion it just, isn't good, and this is coming from someone that really enjoyed legacy, so its nothing to do with how the casting is different or whatever, it just is 'objectively' bad pacing, focus & writing wise, it's painful... it feels like i'm watching a rehashed Eddsworld that was pitched to CBBC (look it up).
the animatiom in legacy are interesting heres why: each episode was animated by a different person (except the ones that looked similar) people actually went up and out of their way to animate the eddsword episodes so they incorperated their unique styles to their episode
i laughed at the clips in eddsworld you showed so it just shows that the shows humour isn't bland, your sense of humour is bland!-a person about to die
I have a theory: what if Matt is trying to transform Eddsworld from a merely comical serie to a big adventure, trying to tell an actual story instead of little separate gags? I tought that he, after years of stop, is trying to make the show more appealing for a lager public, or not?
I've been an Eddsworld fan for almost 2 years now, (Yes, I did find it through Friday night Funkin', but I did do research on the show before watching the episodes) and I feel like what made the Classic Episodes so great is because they felt like a real conversation between 3 people. Even though I do really like modern Eddsworld and I have a lot of respect for the team, it does have its flaws. Great video btw, and I agreed with most of the things you said. Also yeah, "The birds and the bees!" was a pretty sucky "Edd"isode.
I could agree that Legacy Eddsworld is not as great as orginal i think that beyond Eddsworld is actually pretty good so far surf n turf has so many references to the old episodes it feels alot like an older episode and has alot of funny jokes to it. It may not be the same but its aleast pretty close
Oh god I hope this show does not end up like the next family guy, the simpsons or spongebob to where its been running for so long that it ends up losing all its charm that made it good in the first place and becomes a rotting corpse thats souless and devoid of life pls dont let that end up being the case...
@@Faunadude Mine too I mean look at how long the show is been running and now this video pops up showing how modern edd's world is not very good? Its starting to feel all too familiar...
I used to be a big Eddsworld fan watching between the Legacy and the Classic era. When I heard that it was coming back and not gotta lie I was very excited for it's return. When I saw a couple of episodes of Beyond, I felt really underwhelmed in terms of its jokes and humor. The only episode I felt that sorta stands out for me was Casting Call. Everything I felt lacked passion and soul compared to the previous eras. Everything felt like a downgrade compared to legacy in terms of music, writing, the jokes or gags, overall voice direction. I know Legacy has its issues too at least that was made for a charitable purpose. This feels like they are all doing it for the money then actually trying to add in any passion or love. If you love Beyond more power to you, I am glad you love this era of Eddsworld. I am just not a big fan of this current era at all.
@spider-manunknown9193 Honestly, they are doing for the money to pay there staff. Which i don't think it's a bad thing of course. Like the sponsorships at the beginning in some shorts or eddisodes proves it. Personality it feels corporate in my eyes, there some attempt of passion yes but it fails due to the animation feeling rush in some cases. While it cool they are paying the animators and I think they deserve it for there hard work. Like a lot of there animators have been crunched to worked on Beaster Bunny it really proves it. I think crunching is a terrible practice. Power to you, if you like the era. I personality don't like it too much, due to me not enjoying the overall quality.
I feel incredibly sad when i watch the beyond epsiodes as it has a lot of unfunny jokes mainly due to the fact the crew is forcing it to be something that edd would create but they just can't do it cuz they are not edd. Tomska kept the ew vibes alongside putting in his own humor and his own creative ideas side by side with different artstyles and that's what i think made the eddsworld legacy funny, exciting and memorable even if some episodes weren't the funniest, matt and his team tend to replicate Edd's artsyle and his humor alongside making the show watchable for 7 and 8 yotoo which is why beyond feels like just a ripoff of the original eddsworld with few new characters here and there.
@@michaelb.2662 i never said anything about tom's voice. It's okay the va can change it's not a big deal, the deal is eddsworld is not what it was anymore and i don't even think the old fans are watching the new episodes there's no way any old fan can like the modern ew, i refuse to believe that
i love Eddsworld, it gave me so much motivation for becoming an artist, but looking into Legacy Eddsworld and original Eddsworld, im noticing a lack of emotion between the Voice actors, no hate towards George or Templar, but Fan service 1 had alot more emotion as a short then the actual episodes
As one that got on TH-cam around 2017-2019 I can say that around this year I've found this channel called "Eddsworld" and I started following them. Me, bc I didn't know very well english, I started looking for Italian eddisodes. But, now, when I actually look the original voices of the original Eddsworld, modern Eddsworld and the transleted Eddsworld there's a HUGE different. Because: 1- The voices: "All the voices are different (between modern EW and original EW Matt's voice is still the same as usual) ; 2- The animation. Oh g0d the animations between modern EW and original EW.. sometimes they're different sometimes they're similiar;" 3- The jokes: " sometimes I hear the same joke told in a different way, but the jokes between the modern EW, the original EW and the transleted EW are so different. I mean, they are all different. Though ppl try to translete in other language the eddisodes, but sometimes Google Translete bugs and it gaves the wrong translete. That happen a lot, and I hope it would never happen again. Bout original and modern EW, and their jokes in netrual, they have so different jokes that I can't even understand if the modern EW is still EW or even "Mattsworld"! Ik that Edd Gould created it and named it "Eddsworld". Ik for ppl who doesn't know or heard him must think he's crazy. But why don't create new and funnier jokes? I mean, they're already fun like this, but not as funny as the original ones. I still watch the original eddisodes, and when I'm bored I go watch (if I want though) the moderns ones." That's what I see between those 3 types of EW. Btw, have a good day! ( and here some 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪 if you readed 'til here lol )
Is it weird that the episodes I like in Beyond were made by Matt and Jamie spicer Lewis but then after Jamie left for reason that are just terrible. It was just getting boring
Dude, you should keep uploading, I see you in like 3 years having like 200,000 subs, I hope you remember me, I was a mod at SWEGTALK, and I believe we did speak to each other here and there, good luck dude!
I didn't think much about Eddsworld Beyond before watching this video. Now that I watched this, I can never look at eddsworld Beyond the same way again
I mean its not THAT bad, i personally enjoy i mean its been about 6 years since the EW legacy ends since then.. i never really know what to watch since eddsworld been one of my favorite shows when i first discovered internet i think the new eddsworld is just some love letter for the remaining fans including me. so as i was saying its not really bad but some of you may find it boring or think "this is not what edd would want" but cmon, didn't they say it themself, even if edd dies his world will keep on spinning enjoy it for a while who know what would happen in the future.
They didn’t tho? They had some cons in the Legacy Error and the beyond error is the revival of the series. Also Edd mom said he wanted the show to continue after he was gone.
man that modern tom clip threw me off lol, kinda forgot to check the channel after the beaster bunny so i legit forgot that i disliked the new tom voice. will definitely say i didn't mind the animation quality jumping about in legacy, each episode had its own lead animator which let their own style flourish, so while episodes like saloontics does run at a slower framerate and stands out like a sore thumb it at least had its own unique style, that and have you seen edds own animations, the style would shift every couple episodes, sure it was always for the better but yaknow kinda used to taking off the nerd glasses to enjoy the passion behind the work. though with the whole audible advert episode and a lot of the jokes being obligated to be there does seem like a lot of that passion has been drained, secondary revivals tend to have that issue as a whole, i do hope it picks up steam again because it is an amazing series and its continuation is directly the wishes of the family but i dunno it seems like the show already had a somewhat satisfying ending, albiet focusing on other characters like matt in space face then tom and tord in the end. though i will admit i'm somewhat affected by tomskas public meltdowns about how continually working on a tribute never allows for closure, having years of animations post ed, kinda makes the series less ed focused. dilutes his ameature charm compared to entire teams of proffessionals. i dunno at least with legacy tomska had written entire eddsworld episodes and was a substantial cowriter in the golden age so it still felt like eddsworld while not stepping on the originals toes with all the varied artstyles. i dunno conflicted, matt makes sense as a show runner but it's obvious he worked more as a voice actor than a director, as painful as that is to say and i'd rather not have eddsworld flanderise itself in the way the simpsons did lol
0:58 AM I THE ONLY ONE THAT REMEMBERS DICK FIGURES??? like you can tell a lot of people left that show in the past, but it's nice seeing it be mentioned once a while. Thanks for bringing me more nostalgia out of nowhere bro.
My main complaints with beyond are focusing on matt too much and just being forgettable and kinda bland (like surf n turf ive seen it twice and it left like zero impression) love the animation tho
The reason I don’t like Eddsworld beyond is cuz of Tom’s new actor, Tom’s meant to be or at least considered in a youtuber Tomee Bear’s eyes:Cynical, Violent, Confrontational, and anger issued. Tom is NONE of those things in the Eddsworld beyond videos he’s just another character for jokes and I understand Tomska left the show but they could’ve at least found someone similar to voice him and keep his original personality.
I agree with you. Tom doesn't act the same anymore in the new episodes, which is why I prefer the old episodes better. Along with his original personality, attitude, and his old, previous voice actor, Thomas Ridgewell/TomSka from the Classic and Legacy Era, better
While I don't think this video really hit the nail on the head for what's wrong with nu-eddsworld, I do agree with the general sentiment. Although the one part that I disagree with from the video is the animation. I think the difference in quality is pretty big still. I think the animation lacks charm, personality, and style plus a lot of the shots are just 3/4 talking shots. Edd drew very expressive and loose whereas even the more "wacky" faces look more constrained. Also I think a lot of the staff (minus a few standout artists) just doesn't know how to draw, nor take criticism very well, and from what I can tell those artists don't really get control or direction of how it looks. Also hear that the production is a mess, even before all the outings. Anyway I would go on a bit about writing, but I think i've said enough. Overall: Not a good reboot so far.
0:23 nah the big reason why it is popular it is because of luck of how the pilot got big on views bruh and people just want to capitalize off of poplar thing to get money
well damn, the Beyond Era has had some of my favorite episodes so far, pretty on par with the best OG episodes in my personal opinion. But I respect that you and the comment section do have a right to your own thoughts and feelings about the newer episodes. Glad you liked Surf & Turf pt 2, that was peak comedy for me personally lol
So Surf and Turf wars part 2 came out
And damn it was pretty good, like VERY good. It honestly might be one of my favorite Eddsworld episodes of all time. Might make a video on the new episode if yall want me too!
Yeah i would like of you to make it lol
Yh might as well do it
Really? I stopped watching it halfway through
Yes
Surf and turf wars part 1 and 2 are dumpster fire
5:40 visual style does NOT mean "dip in quality." Because those episodes looked appealing in their own right.
It was intentional
as someone who found eddsworld around a month before edd died i gotta say i genuily like the modern one as i am the audience meant to cater to aka teens only problem i have with the modern one is how long the jokes drag on and tom's voice actor just does not completely feel right other than that i am glad matt is keeping it alive
Toms new Voice is lowkey kinda hot 💀
@@skittles9480 can't dissagree with that tho
😅
The Beyond style CAN be good, and the perfect example is Casting Call. The pacing is way faster, and the jokes are actually funny. I laughed a couple of times, meanwhile in the other eddisodes it's hard for me to laugh. The eddisode feels like it's full of inside jokes and they land really well. I've rewatched it countless times because it's just a fun watch, and it deserves way more love
PLEASE STOP HATING ON SALONATICS IT'S NOT A BAD EPISODE.
LITERALLY
Its one of the weakest, alongside Superedd.
@@LeeSixTwentyI mean they aren’t that bad, honestly other than the end those are my two favourites from legacy
same about the end both parts
erm actually it’s “Eddisode” ☝️🤓
Birds and the bees isn’t an “eddsworld episode” it’s just a random short of some character like edd did with dental appointment and starring contest
I have been a eddsworld fan for awhile, But when i found out about it, it was when i was sad and upset and crying, i was scrolling through TH-cam videos and found a eddsworld animation, i watched acouple of them and realized i stopped crying and it made me happy, that's one of the reasons i love eddsworld, It made me happy and gave me joy, it is a reason for my motivation to even keep on animating in the first place, i looked up to edd and matt dearly (still do), and when i found out edd died due to cancer, that broke my heart and i started to cry again but decided to watch some eddsworld episodes again, it made me happy, it always makes me happy, but the new eddsworld and team are really good but i don't know, some of the new episodes are a bit boring, strange, less interesting?
Don't get me wrong i respect the new team and the episodes but it's just not really the same as it used to be, Matt is is great for continuing eddsworld though:), i love his dedication, he was edd's best friend, yk? He cared alot for edd, Im not saying tom or tord didn't care for edd, I'm just saying matt was edd's *best* friend
The episodes are still good!
Im very happy george started voicing edd's character, that makes me really happy and im sure it made other's very happy aswell! he's trying and i love that!:D
Surf and turf wars part 2 was very good and i loved it! Matt looked like a cutie patootie
The little jokes they added like the Titanic reference, In the background is a red and blue ship labelled "TMTD", referencing TomTord which is the one the cannons destroyed, and when the guy said "It's no good sir! the cannons are only damaging the ships! D:" and then the girl said "The *head cannon* ?"
And then he said "No sir! *ALL* the cannon!" and then they both stared at the camera like "😐" i seriously enjoyed that
It sucks how tord kept getting harassed and stalked so he had to leave eddsworld:( and then afterwards he had to literally change his name and hide, let's not forget he kept getting called very bad words and kept getting death threats because he didn't show up to edd's funeral, tord didn't even know edd died at all or what had happened:( that wasn't his fault.
I genuinely think tom doesn't get enough credit, All people do is think about the stuff he didn't do, Tom done so much honestly and he deserves more credit for that :(
But most importantly to end this comment, *r.i.p edd gould :(
@@todsworldd I agree. Tom and Tord are my comfort characters. I relate to them to much, and he was one of the most harassed out of the fandom besides Paul and Patryck.
Tbh the whole scene of Rose drowning Jack in Surf & Turf Wars Part 2 felt a lot like something that would be in a classic Eddisode
saloonatics was stylized not a dip.
EXACTLY THANK YOU
TBH I miss the Tom era, because it actually tried to branch out and do its own thing. What Matt is doing is basically just trying to emulate what Edd used without taking the time to consider if it had aged well (which it kinda didn’t).
Same here
it DID age well
unfortunately matt doesnt seem to have that vision
the perfect example of what i mean:
spooky month, and others by its creator
they are chaotic and its so fun
i LOVE chaotic episodes (i mean look at TERMINAL MONTAGE, and METY333)
chaotic, still absolutely slaps,
unfortunately people nowadays arent that level of chaos anymore
@@DavidledonkayyI mean tbh some of it didn't age well
@@neolbioldey okay some of it DIDNT
but some of it did!
@@Davidledonkayy I mean, I guess it's just kind of inevitable with how much the internet changed
I think the problem with the jokes is because of younger audiences. They elongate and over saturate the jokes with complete nonsense. They are plain and dragged on so younger audiences can laugh. Edd's puns in the newer episodes (for the most part) fail a little too much to where they don't even make you laugh. (for example, "Egg to meet you.") Unlike how the older episodes are. The older episodes have Edd's crappy puns that fail enough but also make sense enough to where they can crack a laugh. The new episodes just make the jokes so dry and nonsensical.
Yeah that’s true
I laughed At Majority of the Jokes in the Beyond error I don’t see the problem with the humor in the Beyond error it’s like Edds humor. Eddsworld was never bad to me it may have had problems with the legacy error. The Beyond error so far is way better imo because it has that classic feeling while being modern.
@@spider-manunknown9193not to be hateful,
being *classic-looking* doesn't automatically mean *good writing*
This video was a relief, i barely see people who dislike the new eddsworld episodes, i find them pretty boring and don't really feel like regular eddsworld episodes aside from the main cast, i hope the new episodes use less cutaway gags and have better pacing.
Edit: I think i was a bit too harsh in my previous comment, i think matt might not be too used to make eddsworld episodes, though i still think they need more working in the comedy aspect, anyways i hope all goes well to the team
I still don’t get why people dislike the beyond error so much. The pacing is completely fine to me and the humor is funny as always and feels like Edds humor. Also they do feel like eddsworld episodes.
Same
You are a monster my friend
Great video! I remember Eddsworld growing up as it was quite popular back in the day. While I didn't watch the original show regularly I did know of Edd Gould's passing and was saddened by the news. I am glad the series is still around and you had a lot of good criticisms about why the new series isn't as good as the original.
As an extreme Eddsworld fan, (not a fangirl, anti-fan, toxic fandom member, etc. … I just like it a lot), this is my favorite show ever. I became a fan one year after The End, and boy did I love it. When I found out Eddsworld came back, I was so excited. But, as I watched all of Eddsworld Beyond that they have so far, I only found myself liking Fan Service 2, The Birds and Bees, The Casting short, Randumb, and Zombeh Picnic. I didn’t care for Beaster Bunny, Slippery Slope, or Surf & Turf. I don’t like Ed Templer, the new voice of Tom, or how the Eddsworld humor was lost. I also can’t get used to their new animation style. Nonetheless, I will always love and appreciate Eddsworld, and I do hope they try more on Beyond.
...
OH I FORGOT I WAS SUPPOSED TO MAKE MY OWN WEBSERIES
its gonna be CHAOTIC
New Eddsworld… it’s better then the show ending. But nothing beats old Eddsworld.
I TOTALLY agree with you on this video, Matt is still not used to having the writing role, and i think we should give him time to improve. Hes honestly doing really great so far, and i cant wait to see what the future of eddsworld has to offer! :))
Old Eddsworld is goated!
Gives off a tone no other piece of media does.
Maybe the reason why Eddsworld feels off is probably due to Matt being the only remaining member of the original Eddsworld team/voice cast and It probably must be hard for him to keep up with the making of the new eddisodes or maybe even come up with an idea for an Eddsworld eddisode plot and the reason why they take so long to upload a video, even though all 3 of his real life friends: Tom, Tord, and Edd are now gone, but at least Matt chose to stay on the show and is trying his best to keep it going for the fans with a little help from the new Eddsworld team/voice cast and also by adding his own spin to the show as well
"How am i even conscious right now" 💀
Man im dying
Great effort put into these videos, keep it up!
I've been a fan of Eddsworld since 2011 and was pretty excited to see it come back. I watched the first of the new episodes, and while I enjoyed it, I never came back to check for new episodes. I felt that the show's humor was geared towards teenagers, and I'd simply grown out of that style of comedy. In 2011 I was 16, I'm 27 now and have very different tastes. I'd bet if I watched the old episodes for the first time at age 27 without nostalgia factoring in, it wouldn't hit the same to me today. I'm glad they are continuing on the legacy of the show for a whole new generation of people to enjoy and learn about the great guy that was Edd Gould.
Would a better title be: “Why Modern Eddsworld Is Flawed”?
I am glad that I am not the only one that feel this way
Edd's eddsworld and Tom's eddsworld are perfect. There's always something missing with Matt's eddsworld.
I know, right? I prefer Tom and Edd's versions of Eddsworld, too, instead of Matt's version
Honestly I was surprised when there was cursing and violence in space face because modern eddsworld is much less edgy and bloody
my biggest problem with modern eddsworld is that lately they are focusing way too much on the merchandise and less on the episodes. It's...just starting to feel like a cashgrab to me, i'm sorry. I still like EW, but this is just a feeling i have
I also noticed that, too.They rarely post eddisodes and focus more on the merch instead
I was researching Eddsworld stuff regarding the Beyond era and I feel relieved that someone else is having these thoughts about it. The first two Beyonds really worked for me showing who were the people in charge now mocking the weird demands by fans. But everything that came after that has been really disappointing. Not for being bad, but how unnecessarily it is shoehorned into Eddsworld instead of being Matt & Bing's own spin-off like Tom's Crash Zoom is. It's really sad how much Tom was harassed and criticized for leading Eddsworld for a while even if he gained nothing from it while Matt & Bing are clearly making profit from Beyond. Not that they deserve bad publicity, but at least they should really try harder and get better writers.
0:13 Where my BFDI at?
You’re right
IKR IT DOESN'T FEEL THE SAME AS THE OLD EPISODES- even if I'm a newbie compared to you (joined to the fandom almost 5 years ago)
14:33 Yeah it would be, except for the fact that Tord does not want to be in Eddsworld at all. Also Tord was in "The End" without his permission
Wait, where di you get that information? I was actually wondering why tord was back even though the creator wasnt comfortable with tord being in the series.
I think this shows that, it’s just hard to redo what others did. Trying to get what made eddsword so great is kinda difficult
It’s like asking people to wrestle a lion like hercules did
I understand but Matt tries his best to having eddsworld to come back as Edds vision
I don’t hate the new videos but like it’s just so soured by Matt and bing and their crew
I agree with you about the situation with Eddsworld Beyond sometimes.
Here my own opinions of this show.
Positives of Eddsworld Beyond:
- The animations are a little more fluid than classic Eddsworld
- The main characters of Eddsworld are still likeable, and funny
- The Eddsworld Episodes are still not running out of ideas
- There are some good episodes (Casting Call, Fan Service 2, Zombeh Picnic, and Surf and Turf Wars Part 1)
- Ed Templer is a very good actor for Tom that almost sounds like the original voice actor, TomSka, same with George Gould for voice Edd.
- There are still many clever jokes that makes me laugh (mainly Fan Service 2 and Casting Call)
- Matt is still currently voiced over by Matt Hargreaves
Negatives of Eddsworld Beyond:
- Some of the jokes feels slow and kinda meh to me
- Some of the episodes are kinda alright (Slippery Slope, The Birds and the Bees, and RANDUMB)
- The background characters can get a little overused to the stories, but many of them are likeable and decent
You did a great job making this video on what Eddsworld Beyond needs to improve on.
I respect the Eddsworld Crew for making this show alive and I'm proud of them for doing their best.
Slippery Slope was a good short episode or should I say Ellisode.
@@spider-manunknown9193 Good pun, bro. I agree with your opinion that Slippery Slope was a good episode. Though in my opinion, the episode should've been a little longer. 🙂
@@whitney7up425 I will agree it should have been longer and hopefully they will make more ellisodes in the future.
@@spider-manunknown9193 Hope Eddsworld make some Ellisodes too in the future too. Ell, Tamara, and Matilda are such great characters just like the main characters as well.
@@whitney7up425 facts 💯
believe me guys its will be better with more space
I haven't heard of Eddsworld, but this made me super interested! This video is really thorough and detailed! Great work!
Yoooooo thank you so much for the comment. I really love your channel so it’s awesome seeing you here :)
I think one of the reasons why this Edda world is lacking in the writing department is because of the loss of tomska in the show. He was a very funny writer and now I feel like it’s very boring. Not saying it’s bad just saying it need more oomph. :)
The show hasn’t become boring,it never has become boring. Tomska left because of the people who complained about the legacy error if they didn’t complain about it he probably still be on eddsworld but he’s doing his own stuff now. The new voice actor is also very good for Tom. Also for writing we only really have 2 or 3 big episodes in the beyond era the rest are shorts.
@@spider-manunknown9193
1. Tom didnt leave the show because of the complaints about the legacy era. He left because it was mentally taxing.
2. what im trying to say is TO ME this show does have the same pacing as per say saloonatics. an episode Tom wrote and thats ok.
3. What does the voice actor for Tom have anything to do with what i said??
@@elmopizza I thought you were saying that the show went downhill after Tom left and how his new voice actor sucks. Idk why I read it like that. That’s my fault.
@@spider-manunknown9193 ok man its fine mistake happen. also i meant to say the newer episodes do not have the same writing as saloonatics.
Yeah, i think some of the best episodes were when edd and tom worked together
I thought this show ended. Bringing it back is kinda risky and this shows. It already had an official ending. But I guess the fandom was still very active & they wanted to take advantage of that.
I’m still conflicted on the matter, yet I’m still all for eddsworld having some relevancy.
Its Goofy lil web show about dudes doin their thing. Man if only that’s what it was like for them IRL.
Your editing is spot on man, great video! Honestly I'm surprised I haven't seen more Eddsworld video essays out in the wild, and you've done a fantastic job chronicling this important part of so many of our childhoods/teenage years on the Internet! Subscribed 👑
Thank you so much, I really appreciate it :)
OH FINALLY!
i am relatively new to the eddsworld fandom, like 2 years maybe? and i am also still like a kid, but i LOVE the older eddsworld. I found new eddworld incredibly boring, especially surf n turf wats two. Thanks for making this, you really adressed all the issues.
Like, i loved hammer and fail, and zanta claus 3 still is the best.
Agreed, the old ones were better, and Zanta Claws 3 is a good episode. It's one of my favorites
Zanta Claws 3 is by far my favorite Eddisode from the whole Eddsworld show!
I'd rather not include Tord as a main character....idk I mean he DID leave the show!
I do think your reasons are pretty valid, but I really like it, I think Matt is trying his best and all the other directors, it can be hard to remake a show from scratch, plus having all the funding taken away due to back taxes, but I think the show will get better in time. But what you're saying is valid though.
Not many people will like what I have to say today, but I see a serious drop in quality in my eddsworld beyond episodes. Don't get me wrong, I know how hard Matt works, he works hard to keep the show afloat, but I don't like Matt's sense of humor. In the eddsworld classic, eddin's sense of humor was like loneytoons, in legacy, tom's humor and parts were more sci-fi, like rick and morty. but mattin's sense of humor is like screaming burp. I wish Matt would focus on sections instead of dealing with things like Instagram posts and lgbt. maybe tomska doesn't need eddsworld but eddsworld needs tom. be honest when we say eddsworld we all think of zombie attack the end tom was the pinnacle of the show. don't get me wrong I love every single person who contributed to this show not only the show is not where it deserves. If Tom had continued, maybe eddsworld would have been released on a platform like netfilix
(Sorry for bad english)
I agree
@@michaelb.2662 thanks man
Your welcome 👍
I found eddsworld in May 2021 and was obsessed until like July where I saw everything and was like. What now?
I didn't notices why the Modern version of Eddsworld wasn't that good like the original.
I think what happened with the writing is that in the original show, I'm pretty sure it was mainly Edd and Tom writing, and you could even tell when a joke was written by Tom just based on watching things like ASDF movie. I think Tom and Edd's writing styles sort of balanced themselves well with each other. When Legacy happened, Tom didn't have that balance anymore and was probably trying to make it feel like Edd's writing, but his own interpretation mixed with other writers on the show might have muddled it a bit. Tom was also dealing with a lot of grief at that time as well. All that being said I actually enjoy Legacy quite a bit but I usually omit it from when i rewatch the series, apart from Space Face. With Eddsworld Beyond, it's mainly Matt and Mr.Bingham now I believe. I don't know how much Matt wrote for the original series or his history with writing in general. The one thing i do like about Beyond is that Matt doesn't feel like a background character anymore, even in the original series I felt that.., but I think Edd and Tom's characters are suffering a bit because of it. I think Matt understands Edd's humor, but just not the aspect of pacing and writing. Like the jokes do remind me of Edd's jokes, and even Tom's somewhat, but the way they are presented as OP said is less than funny.
Again, this is just from what I know of the original cast, but I've probably misinterpreted things and I haven't really researched much about the modern show since it simply doesn't interest me. If anybody wants to share more info in the replies or correct me that is absolutely welcomed.
For me, the things that I don’t rly like abt eddsworld Beyond, is the S O U N D E F F E C T S
and the fandom being h e l l. Itself.
Not gonna lie, I kinda find the Beyond episodes forgettable because of the blandness.
I can't remember a single scene!
Same
7:18 to be fair, this type of gag is also in ruined, a classic episode. I'm not saying that this gag doesn't get tiring, but it isn't only in beyond
the super guy joke was a reference to wtfuture when the same character "died" with a lazer beam
Sadly you were right, now the fandom is deader than ever
I’m here tho
Something about Beyond just feels...off. Classic and Legacy are a hundred times better
Ikr and I agree legacy and classic were better
Also, I think the reason why Beyond feels off nowadays is because of the new voice actors for both Tom and Edd and the new writing/directing approach by Matt
Also alot of scenes usually don't have background music in the background which makes it feel empty. Or it could just be me loving the background music in legacy.
HOLY CRAP SOMEONE FINALLY SAID IT.
one thing that i hate modern eddsworld, is that modern eddsworld is more popular than older eddsworld
I'll say this
I think I like Beyond a lot more than Legacy quality wise it feels at least a bit more like classic eddsworld but those old episodes are still classics
It feels like legacy and beyond are trying to cater to a specific audience while og eddsworld wasnt (given that it was made in the wild west era of the internet) it felt like Edd just made the cartoon he wanted to without restrictions
Beyond saddly doesn't have that luxury
tbh they couldve just maybe discontinued the series rather than spilling out a bunch of junk, yea surf and turf wars was good but for me i liked their old versions and personailties better :/
what would be a better idea was they would make mini eddisodes or smth rather than putting a lot of filler and unfunny jokes
note: this is my opinion i dont hate matt or the team for tryna bring back the old era!!
Same, I miss the old personalities, old jokes and old voices especially Tom who's old voice and personality I prefer and yeah the newer jokes in beyond are not as funny as the classic or legacy era's which is why I prefer the old ones better
@@michaelb.2662 glad someone agrees, i may be a new fan but i feel like eddsworld is like one of those unfunny adult swim n kid shows mushed up together with soulless shit. the end part 2 would be better off alone along with a few mini eddisodes
Exactly, and I noticed that they sometimes joke about their own fandom in some of the episodes
Everything u said is true and if you look at their social media they keep releasing new merch here and there i think they are just making profits off the show's popularity
True, maybe that explains why it takes them so long to release a new episode
holy shit THANK YOU for making this, Eddsworld Beyond really bothers me and hasn't been my favourite, even after the new release of the episode a few days ago... in my opinion it just, isn't good, and this is coming from someone that really enjoyed legacy, so its nothing to do with how the casting is different or whatever, it just is 'objectively' bad pacing, focus & writing wise, it's painful... it feels like i'm watching a rehashed Eddsworld that was pitched to CBBC (look it up).
I agree with you
The animation for the legacy era was amazing but i know matt and the animators are doing their best
the animatiom in legacy are interesting
heres why:
each episode was animated by a different person
(except the ones that looked similar)
people actually went up and out of their way to animate the eddsword episodes
so they incorperated their unique styles to their episode
i laughed at the clips in eddsworld you showed so it just shows that the shows humour isn't bland, your sense of humour is bland!-a person about to die
I have a theory: what if Matt is trying to transform Eddsworld from a merely comical serie to a big adventure, trying to tell an actual story instead of little separate gags? I tought that he, after years of stop, is trying to make the show more appealing for a lager public, or not?
I was watching eddsworld when fan service 2 came out I went crazy
I remember when that video was uploaded it was to good to be true.
I've been an Eddsworld fan for almost 2 years now, (Yes, I did find it through Friday night Funkin', but I did do research on the show before watching the episodes) and I feel like what made the Classic Episodes so great is because they felt like a real conversation between 3 people. Even though I do really like modern Eddsworld and I have a lot of respect for the team, it does have its flaws.
Great video btw, and I agreed with most of the things you said. Also yeah, "The birds and the bees!" was a pretty sucky "Edd"isode.
I found that episode more of the eddisode that doesn’t involve any main character and it happens to be a short.
Sounds like maybe they just need to pay closer attention to the animatics to see if the pacing works before they properly animate it
I could agree that Legacy Eddsworld is not as great as orginal i think that beyond Eddsworld is actually pretty good so far surf n turf has so many references to the old episodes it feels alot like an older episode and has alot of funny jokes to it. It may not be the same but its aleast pretty close
Oh god I hope this show does not end up like the next family guy, the simpsons or spongebob to where its been running for so long that it ends up losing all its charm that made it good in the first place and becomes a rotting corpse thats souless and devoid of life pls dont let that end up being the case...
Holy crap that is my new biggest fear
@@Faunadude Mine too I mean look at how long the show is been running and now this video pops up showing how modern edd's world is not very good? Its starting to feel all too familiar...
You could see the state of SMG4.
New grounds is a website where it has all sorts of
other web cartoons which are neither good or bad with
games and activities.
Personally I like the legacy art style more since it looks much better then the beyond art style
Me too
in my opinion the beyond artstyle is perfect because it looks like if Edd's artstyle is continued. But this is only my opinion
@@_a.lel_ That’s the reason why I like the Beyond art style.
I used to be a big Eddsworld fan watching between the Legacy and the Classic era.
When I heard that it was coming back and not gotta lie I was very excited for it's return.
When I saw a couple of episodes of Beyond, I felt really underwhelmed in terms of its jokes and humor.
The only episode I felt that sorta stands out for me was Casting Call.
Everything I felt lacked passion and soul compared to the previous eras.
Everything felt like a downgrade compared to legacy in terms of music, writing, the jokes or gags, overall voice direction.
I know Legacy has its issues too at least that was made for a charitable purpose.
This feels like they are all doing it for the money then actually trying to add in any passion or love.
If you love Beyond more power to you, I am glad you love this era of Eddsworld.
I am just not a big fan of this current era at all.
There’s definitely passion in the Beyond error saying it’s for the money only sounds disrespectful. Imo
@spider-manunknown9193 Honestly, they are doing for the money to pay there staff. Which i don't think it's a bad thing of course.
Like the sponsorships at the beginning in some shorts or eddisodes proves it.
Personality it feels corporate in my eyes, there some attempt of passion yes but it fails due to the animation feeling rush in some cases.
While it cool they are paying the animators and I think they deserve it for there hard work.
Like a lot of there animators have been crunched to worked on Beaster Bunny it really proves it.
I think crunching is a terrible practice.
Power to you, if you like the era.
I personality don't like it too much, due to me not enjoying the overall quality.
@@DalekEnclave123 I feel like saying it’s for the money only and not for the fans at all feels disrespectful imo.
the effort you put in the beginning with the mask 👺👺
fr brotha andrew
I feel incredibly sad when i watch the beyond epsiodes as it has a lot of unfunny jokes mainly due to the fact the crew is forcing it to be something that edd would create but they just can't do it cuz they are not edd. Tomska kept the ew vibes alongside putting in his own humor and his own creative ideas side by side with different artstyles and that's what i think made the eddsworld legacy funny, exciting and memorable even if some episodes weren't the funniest, matt and his team tend to replicate Edd's artsyle and his humor alongside making the show watchable for 7 and 8 yotoo which is why beyond feels like just a ripoff of the original eddsworld with few new characters here and there.
I agree with everything you said, and yeah, I do miss TomSka doing the voice of his character
Classic and legacy were better
@@michaelb.2662 i never said anything about tom's voice. It's okay the va can change it's not a big deal, the deal is eddsworld is not what it was anymore and i don't even think the old fans are watching the new episodes there's no way any old fan can like the modern ew, i refuse to believe that
Oh I see
Another masterpiece Mr zac Quinn great job
Thanks king ramen
Eddsworld Was Back In 2004 That Was When Budokai 3 Releases This Is More Like 2 Decades
i love Eddsworld, it gave me so much motivation for becoming an artist, but looking into Legacy Eddsworld and original Eddsworld, im noticing a lack of emotion between the Voice actors, no hate towards George or Templar, but Fan service 1 had alot more emotion as a short then the actual episodes
the world needs more of these videos
Also there was going to be a fan movie about eddsworld but it didn’t go well and it got canceled
As one that got on TH-cam around 2017-2019 I can say that around this year I've found this channel called "Eddsworld" and I started following them. Me, bc I didn't know very well english, I started looking for Italian eddisodes. But, now, when I actually look the original voices of the original Eddsworld, modern Eddsworld and the transleted Eddsworld there's a HUGE different. Because:
1- The voices:
"All the voices are different (between modern EW and original EW Matt's voice is still the same as usual) ;
2- The animation. Oh g0d the animations between modern EW and original EW.. sometimes they're different sometimes they're similiar;"
3- The jokes:
" sometimes I hear the same joke told in a different way, but the jokes between the modern EW, the original EW and the transleted EW are so different. I mean, they are all different. Though ppl try to translete in other language the eddisodes, but sometimes Google Translete bugs and it gaves the wrong translete. That happen a lot, and I hope it would never happen again. Bout original and modern EW, and their jokes in netrual, they have so different jokes that I can't even understand if the modern EW is still EW or even "Mattsworld"! Ik that Edd Gould created it and named it "Eddsworld". Ik for ppl who doesn't know or heard him must think he's crazy. But why don't create new and funnier jokes? I mean, they're already fun like this, but not as funny as the original ones. I still watch the original eddisodes, and when I'm bored I go watch (if I want though) the moderns ones."
That's what I see between those 3 types of EW. Btw, have a good day! ( and here some 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪 if you readed 'til here lol )
Great Job Zac! Man Edd's world ia such a throwback.
Is it weird that the episodes I like in Beyond were made by Matt and Jamie spicer Lewis but then after Jamie left for reason that are just terrible. It was just getting boring
Dude, you should keep uploading, I see you in like 3 years having like 200,000 subs, I hope you remember me, I was a mod at SWEGTALK, and I believe we did speak to each other here and there, good luck dude!
Yo I remember you, thanks sm man, I shall defo keep uploading
@@zacquinn BardiX#9118 hit me up soon dude!
WAIT what did Jamie do??? I'm so curious now.
I didn't think much about Eddsworld Beyond before watching this video. Now that I watched this, I can never look at eddsworld Beyond the same way again
I mean its not THAT bad, i personally enjoy i mean its been about 6 years since the EW legacy ends since then.. i never really know what to watch since eddsworld been one of my favorite shows when i first discovered internet i think the new eddsworld is just some love letter for the remaining fans including me.
so as i was saying its not really bad but some of you may find it boring or think "this is not what edd would want" but cmon, didn't they say it themself, even if edd dies his world will keep on spinning enjoy it for a while who know what would happen in the future.
I miss edds storylines 😔
Thanks you for saying this!! Eddsworld fell off after Edd passed. I think people are just too afraid to say it.
People been said that wym. But it’s never been all that big outside of TH-cam it’s like a lil cute web show that had its own community
They didn’t tho? They had some cons in the Legacy Error and the beyond error is the revival of the series. Also Edd mom said he wanted the show to continue after he was gone.
Everyone says that, but some eddisode were good
man that modern tom clip threw me off lol, kinda forgot to check the channel after the beaster bunny so i legit forgot that i disliked the new tom voice.
will definitely say i didn't mind the animation quality jumping about in legacy, each episode had its own lead animator which let their own style flourish, so while episodes like saloontics does run at a slower framerate and stands out like a sore thumb it at least had its own unique style, that and have you seen edds own animations, the style would shift every couple episodes, sure it was always for the better but yaknow kinda used to taking off the nerd glasses to enjoy the passion behind the work.
though with the whole audible advert episode and a lot of the jokes being obligated to be there does seem like a lot of that passion has been drained, secondary revivals tend to have that issue as a whole, i do hope it picks up steam again because it is an amazing series and its continuation is directly the wishes of the family but i dunno it seems like the show already had a somewhat satisfying ending, albiet focusing on other characters like matt in space face then tom and tord in the end.
though i will admit i'm somewhat affected by tomskas public meltdowns about how continually working on a tribute never allows for closure, having years of animations post ed, kinda makes the series less ed focused. dilutes his ameature charm compared to entire teams of proffessionals. i dunno at least with legacy tomska had written entire eddsworld episodes and was a substantial cowriter in the golden age so it still felt like eddsworld while not stepping on the originals toes with all the varied artstyles.
i dunno conflicted, matt makes sense as a show runner but it's obvious he worked more as a voice actor than a director, as painful as that is to say and i'd rather not have eddsworld flanderise itself in the way the simpsons did lol
dont hate on super guy part in beaster bunny it confirms that super guy is alive and hides in plain sight so he doesnt have to save people
The explosion part at 10:35 is funny af to me ngl. But i get your point.
0:58 AM I THE ONLY ONE THAT REMEMBERS DICK FIGURES???
like you can tell a lot of people left that show in the past, but it's nice seeing it be mentioned once a while. Thanks for bringing me more nostalgia out of nowhere bro.
y'know what they say, yall
old is gold
Yep, indeed
My main complaints with beyond are focusing on matt too much and just being forgettable and kinda bland (like surf n turf ive seen it twice and it left like zero impression) love the animation tho
The reason I don’t like Eddsworld beyond is cuz of Tom’s new actor, Tom’s meant to be or at least considered in a youtuber Tomee Bear’s eyes:Cynical, Violent, Confrontational, and anger issued. Tom is NONE of those things in the Eddsworld beyond videos he’s just another character for jokes and I understand Tomska left the show but they could’ve at least found someone similar to voice him and keep his original personality.
I agree with you. Tom doesn't act the same anymore in the new episodes, which is why I prefer the old episodes better. Along with his original personality, attitude, and his old, previous voice actor, Thomas Ridgewell/TomSka from the Classic and Legacy Era, better
@@michaelb.2662 yeah and unpopular opinion I loved Tim as legacy Edd, he did a great job and I may or may not like him more than George.
Tim did a pretty good job voicing Edd
13:52
Where are they looking?
While I don't think this video really hit the nail on the head for what's wrong with nu-eddsworld, I do agree with the general sentiment. Although the one part that I disagree with from the video is the animation. I think the difference in quality is pretty big still. I think the animation lacks charm, personality, and style plus a lot of the shots are just 3/4 talking shots. Edd drew very expressive and loose whereas even the more "wacky" faces look more constrained. Also I think a lot of the staff (minus a few standout artists) just doesn't know how to draw, nor take criticism very well, and from what I can tell those artists don't really get control or direction of how it looks. Also hear that the production is a mess, even before all the outings. Anyway I would go on a bit about writing, but I think i've said enough.
Overall: Not a good reboot so far.
You are amazing at doing youtube, how are you not at 10,000 subscribers already!
Thanks so much dude
@@zacquinnnp man
0:23 nah the big reason why it is popular it is because of luck of how the pilot got big on views bruh and people just want to capitalize off of poplar thing to get money
well damn, the Beyond Era has had some of my favorite episodes so far, pretty on par with the best OG episodes in my personal opinion. But I respect that you and the comment section do have a right to your own thoughts and feelings about the newer episodes. Glad you liked Surf & Turf pt 2, that was peak comedy for me personally lol
Great video I also love Eddsworld and I mostly agree with your opinions. You should have more subscribers lol
Thank you, I do my best to make banger content
7:20 heh look obscure game refremce in the missing corner
I have to remember that this is a opinion
Yea, I honestly love new eddsworlds
8:08 Matt have been seen by his realistic self..kinda
0:05 yeah... I dont hear much people say red vs blue...
I personally think this error is better than the legacy error since it does feel more like Edds Humor.