ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ส.ค. 2017
- Subscribe and 🔔 to the BBC 👉 bit.ly/BBCTH-camSub
Watch the BBC first on iPlayer 👉 bbc.in/iPlayer-Home Programme website: bbc.in/2fRV7uy Gurinder Chadha visits her aunts and mother and talks to them about their memories of Partition.
#bbc
All our TV channels and S4C are available to watch live through BBC iPlayer, although some programmes may not be available to stream online due to rights. If you would like to read more on what types of programmes are available to watch live, check the 'Are all programmes that are broadcast available on BBC iPlayer?' FAQ 👉 bbc.in/2m8ks6v. - บันเทิง
![[ไฮไลต์] แบดมินตันชาย วิว กุลวุฒิ(ไทย) vs Kenta Nishimoto(ญี่ปุ่น) รอบ 16 คน | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kaQRLljJkSI/mqdefault.jpg)
When her voice cracked when she said she hasn’t been to Rawalpindi since, my heart dropped :’( I wish I could take being here and show her what it’s like now
It is sad and terrible what partion did to us.. We are two nations now when we were supposed to be one, not to forget the bloodshed at the time.. just red blood.. No Indian, no Pakistani... Sad... :-(
@@dikshaojha142 Would you mind enlightening me why there was bloodshed if before the partition, everyone lived in peace and harmony?
@@xtsflame747 Well... The video and the comment i replied to talk about partion and emotions attatched to partion. Now when i talk about the sorrows brought out by partition, i genuinely feel and take into consideration thousands and thousands of people who had to separate themselves from their very root. There had been bloodshed before the partion. I never said peace prevailed all the time before partion but imagine someone coming and throwing you or me out of our abode... That will break us... nothing to fight for. This is what i wanted to express in the previous comment.
As far as bloodshed is concerned, Humanity is our rescue. Blood and gore since times immemorial have happened due to lack of basic human natute. Humanity has great power. Peace ! ✌
Rabia F Please do a favour of not slaughtering her then and there.
yea its sad
only elders who were born in pakistan would understand the pain of partition and vice versa who were born in india and now in pakistan....my grandfather still talks of his roots cries he still writes in urdu ...i wish he could visit his native place
Do you live in India?
In which city your grand father belong to in Pakistan?
Nobody cares about your side. We are talking about the Indians
My grand mom's family still lives in India but she migrated with her in laws to Pakistan. Her last wish was to met her brother in India but could not realize it. She is no more now( May her soul rest in peace!). Imagine a girl whose parents had died in her childhood and she had the only brother in whole universe and partition had stanched him as well.
Very sad
Really painful for the rest of life
Stop playing the victim card.
You only have your political leaders to blame for this, they wanted the partition.
I wish I could take dadi Maa to her hometown Rawalpindi.
I have had to live away from Rawalpindi for years- not for reasons as painful as hers- but I do understand the yearning one has for one's native town.
Hugs for dadi Maa.
Same
The story of India 's partition and the killings should be studied by students all over the world. It's an important lesson to keep in mind. How many innocent people were killed and for what ?
to avoid what is happening now to muslims
Thousands of women were kidnapped and raped..
nighat asar many Hindus are suffering as well. Nothing will change unless education system gets better and better
Innocent people were killed for the mad fanaticism of the Muslim League.
Exactly
I am also from Rawalpindi ..... If they came to Rawalpindi we welcome them ❤❤
It would never happen sorry ...
@@drpankajgoswami8322 if u don't have positive words then at least don't talk negatively. He is just welcoming, at least he s nice human being unlike u. Next person will read ur comment will prepare image about entire country, N i m proud hindu Indian(mentioned just to cut off more comments).
I don't know why the people here in comment section start accusing nd cursing each other( India &Pak) ....the real idea was to make us understand the how horrible the situation was then....how hatred raised in place of friendship..how HUMANITY was killed by partition..
rafay kashmiri but Indians will say the same about you
Quite frankly if someone kills your family member - you hunt them down and hurt them back fair enough - you don’t torture people of the same group! Both parties had no sense - they couldn’t control their anger and took it out on anyone and everyone- how is it they are managing to exist now in each other’s countries ? Because they’re not being ‘provoked’ that’s why, not because they enjoy ruining people for the fun of it (both are guilty of this)
👏🏽
i really hope we can live in peace again
@@aryan_kumar because you believe when UN says other things about other countries.
i see these videos and cry... Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs all lost their life :'(
This partition should ever have happened. I think a lot of people have been brainwashed by hatred. I've come across young people... youth of Indian and Pakistani origins that hate each other. So sad.
Emmanuel Ray I continue to hate peckistan till reunification of india
Quite funny we Pakistanis hate India intensively
+Quite funny..... indeed, on our dead body...... India must be further divided
for the sake of innocent minorities & Dalit's safeguard.....
rafay kashmiri in sha Allah v soon India will divide into many pieces just wait
amit krishnani just shut up u cheap worshipper of hanoman get lost okkk
I am from Rawalpindi !! Much love to you auntie g !!
i feel a tear tickling down my cheek this is too much
Such a powerful video...nostalgic...My Nana and Dada's stories in front of my eyes right now as I type this...May all live in peace, prosperity and harmony...!
Seeds of Indian partition started in the mind of an ambitious lawyer called Jinnah and supported by the British Raj to use this idea to divide India before their exit. It was half heatedly accepted by Mahatama Gandhi & Jawaharlal Nehru to keep peace and not have riots before independence, but they were wrong. Rest is in the history pages. My family was not directly linked to the partition so I don't have horror stories linked to my family's past, but I grew up listening and learning about this massive horror event, greatest massacre in human history. It played a huge role in my own understanding of the sub-continent, its psyche, trusts and mistrusts. The narrative of the partition turned out to be a genocide that no one ever expected. It's still unclear what caused the genocide, who instigated it and why after 70 years of independence the roots of hatred are still getting stronger each and every day. Peace is a day dream between the two communities. It is far and surreal and will remain such as long as hatred and violence based on 2 nation theory, 2 communities that cannot and will not live together continues to be the narrative on both sides of the Radcliffe line.
The British were against partition. The last viceroy of India tried to persuade Jinnah for a united India and he himself said that if he had know that Jinnah had TB, then he would most probably tried to sabotage the creation of Pakistan.
Nothing was half-hearted. Gandhi willingly pledged Congress support to Khilafat, which sowed the seeds of Partition. Ironically, Jinnah was initially opposed to the Khilafat.
Jinnah was dying of lung cancer, which he kept a secret. He had nothing personal to gain from it. He secured the constitutional rights of the largest minority of India forever. We didn't want to live under only a mere change of Masters.
India even kept lord mountbatten as their governor general and kept Lockhart as commander-in-chief of Indian army British after "independence"!! Maskebaaz Hindu nation! That is how you got favoured in partition, they gave you Muslim majority Gurdaspur to give you at least one land route to Kashmir. That is how disconnected kashmir had always been from Hindu majority areas!
Jinnah was a man of dignity and he saw what Hindu leaders' long term strategy was. Where a Muslim Indian will have to spend his entire life proving loyalty and nothing would be enough.
Look at India today. UN has called it the most dangerous place for minorities in the world!
We never take our freedom for granted and can never forget those who sacrificed their everything for our independence, from British and the Hindus.
@@saanea2000 I agree (except he was dying from tuberculosis not lung cancer).
The scenario they witnessed was surely unbearable 😭
Love u dadi ji❤️😘
your Rawalpindi is still their. you may come to have e a warm welcome out their.
Asjid Raza People like you should fill the world to make it a better place
Love to my brother from a brother!
Yes we will come back with our army very soon
Watch this documentary, she was denied visa by Pakistan as they didn't want her to film there
@@abhishekraj5632 yes we will welcome you with 150 nukes😘😘😘😘
@@abhishekraj5632 bro it's conversation between chaddha family with pakistanis why do you have to incite hate here.
I should advise that instead abusing each other in comments,learn a lesson from this
I m from Pakistan, my grandma used to say there were rivers of blood at the time of partition!!!!!!! 😢
Folks, it's true zealots can't feel pain of these elders. Past cannot be changed. But we can bring a good future as youngsters by showing love and respecting each other's culture as well as positive thoughts. If we make our present correct then future will be corrected automatically.
If we still keep fighting through negative comments then how can we get peace which is being seeked by everyone.?
Its not a forgotten story we will never forget it
My family is from Rawalpindi. This auntie is welcome home anytime.
heart breaking
Good to know that the comments section shows why partition was necessary even in 2020 if something like this was required I'd leave for the place where I'd be secure without any hesitation. Nothing belongs to you and don't take freedom for granted when others have given their lives for it.
Spot on! It was necessary! Just a change of masters is not freedom and thank God we have this homeland to live freely in with dignity.
Where to find full episodes? Website says its no longer available on iPlayer.
She’s right. My parents say that there was an ocean of 🩸 blood when the partition took place. They’re so affected they refuse to talk about it.
This is just sad and people still spewing hate in the comments are even sadder...😭
I hope this division would have never happened
This happened to both communities on both sides of boarder
One demonization has caused such panic..can't imagine how bad it would have been to relocate, losing family, friends.
The Decision of Partition of India and Pakistan on the basis of Religion caused great set back for the Common People of both side,even today, some people are happy that it was a good decision.I think, only those people who suffered, survived and started from the very beginning ,can realise the degree of Unforgettable pain even today, with regards from Hoshiarpur, Punjab, India.
Irony is BBC posting these interviews😑
im a chadha as well and my grandad's from rawalpindi too
Such a good imperial story for BBC
Dear Gurinder...i got a chance to see the entire documentry... you ended up in southall to sooth everything out...not a good place to end a story of "my" agony...i still am in india...and i suffer each day for i dont know what went wrong with my culture....while the same is being celebrated in southalll..
Your are more than welcome to visit, in Rawalpindi where exactly your mom 's home was at that time?
It was so sad, painful
I have been looking for the full video but unfortunately I can't find plz share the full video
Thank you very much
long live family .
Can we get the full episode?
Jhelum is my hometown
THANKS GOD IT NVER EVER HAPENED WITH NEPAL WE LIVE WITH DIFFERENT CULTURE AND RELIGION BUT MUTUAL RESPECT EACHOTHER ! ITS SCARY .
It may be historical for someone but if you talk to the people who went through this horrific separation you would automatically go through their pain and cry with them . This cannot be helped so . Please pakistan and India replaced people get together with love and affection once more and pour out all the pain for once and all . Can it be done??????
hi miss smithson and miss warren. if you are seeing this comment it is because year 9 at baca is learning about migration and partition 😸✌️
The seeds of partition were planted when the British first took control of india. Its written in history that they were shocked how all faiths and cultures got along and for the British to succeed they need to plant division. Divide and rule
Peace is biggest achievement
Can someone please tell me Where I get the full video ?
IM from Rawalpindi Now a days I rarely find any sikh
I saw some in Moti bazaar. They have a shop there.
Where, I can watch whole documentary in hindi???
Where can I watch the whole documentery 🙄🙄🙄
Gurinder Chaddha hai yeh toh!
Indians and Pakistanis are united in cricket. India and Pakistan are united in children's education thru Nobel Peace Laureates Kailash and Malala. God is great.
They show wrong Indian flag.. double standard BBC
map ?
@@aryan_kumar sry as Indians we consider pok as India.
Don't post half a video, especially if the second half is going to be taken down off your site so soon after you posted this one. I won't be watching any more BBC videos like this one if there's a chance of them leading to dead ends.
😢😮
&
❤❤
Prayers for everlasting peace between India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh !!!
🤲🤲🤲
Aameen, Elaahi Aameen
I want to know this presenter name because, i want watch full documentary, this given doc is a short part. Anybody have full documentary? please share LINK
Syar you ever
Why is bbc so interested in the partition ,the british did it in the first place
@@aryan_kumar Thats a complete lie. Jinnah was the one who was against partition. He comprised with the congress many many times just so this doesnt happen. The congress repeatedly rejected his demands for the minorities (yes Jinnah advocated for all minorities, but muslims were the largest). Nehru saw partition as the lesser evil compared to accepting Jinnah's demands. He was forced to take the only option left.
Were the subtitles necessary?!?
Painful thing happened in the past kindly learn from the past and take lesson from this vedio
Oy, I know I'm probably not gonna get a response, but would rebooting Walking With Dinosaurs be too much to ask? Because at this point, dinosaurs and their contemporaries are portrayed as mere monsters and not animals, with excessively violent imagery. The state of Paleo-documentaries is pretty sad to say the least. Plus, it's been almost two decades since WWD's release. Information has changed and the public should get to know. With recent video games such as _Saurian_ and _Prehistoric Kingdom_ featuring accurate, well designed dinosaurs, I think it's time television did the same. Plus, one of the most beloved dinosaur medias of all time getting a reboot? That would definitely catch the attention of viewers and could even boost ratings. I'm telling ya, that wouldn't be such a bad idea. Just. give it good shots, realistic puppets and CG, a compelling narrative, and accurate information, and this could be a really amazing series.
m sadqqqe aaap aaaaen rawalpindi
So sad I am Pakistan rawalpindi
Myam you have to visit your birth land rawalpindi once
It's all North Indian(Hindus+Muslim) Responsible for what happened during 1947 in Undivided India. Politicians widen the rift between the community which resulted into intolerance of staying peacefully together. Now the politician sowing the same seed of animosity between the two major community. Please try to spread love and brotherhood within your society irrespective of religion n beliefs.
I'm not denying the women's lived experience but this is their point of view. Ask any Muslim family living in these neighbourhoods and you'll hear completely different. Especially in Punjab and Sindh.
PLease put correct map of India
One thing I don't understand is why the Sikhs didn't get Punjab and make Khalistan ? Because the Nankana Sahib and Kartarpur Sahib are in Pakistan while Harmandir Sahib is in India. How come Muslims got two countries but the Sikhs didn't?
Why did it happen😢😢😢
muslims(muslim leader religious and political) dont wanted to live with Hindu Majority , So they demanded Another country . After creation of pakistan , it was a anti hindu, sikh force came which ....
we all know till this day .
Because of the Muslim league, Jinnah and because of how Mountbatten wanted India to have independence as soon as possible (he thought that a civil war would break out if he didn't execute the independence soon enough). Mountbatten wanted a united India but for that, he would have had to wait until Jinnah's death or just not give India independence until Jinnah would finally change his for which he had no time according to him.
@SAMURAI 武士 No. The Congress was chiefly responsible for this. Do not forget Khilafat - it was only a conference at first. Gandhi and the Congress turned it into a movement. It had nothing to do with Indian nationalism. In the Khilafat, the Muslims were mobilized on religious grounds and their allegiance was pledged not to India but to an extraterritorial entity, namely, the caliph. Ever since, it was nigh-impossible to pledge Muslim allegiance to India until Partition.
I don't understand this host's Gurinder Chadda family's mindset. They are Sikh, British caused so much of atrocities like Jalianwala bagh massacre, and just after independence .. they go and settle themselves in UK. How can someone do that ? don't they have any self esteem ? , and then they come back and act like tourists in India !!
India,Pakistan problem will never be solved by political leaders .
Well,Mr Atal Bihari Vajpayee took all initiatives.Started a bus to Lahore went to Lahore on that bus.We got Kargil.Evrn After that He invited musharraf to Agra.We got Parliament attack and 26/11
I hate to sound so cynical but I think that peace, that "brotherhood" came from all being equally kept under the thumb the security of knowing that the others have about as much chance of getting out from under the boot as you do..
India should have been independent but it could not have been handled worse. I guess the empire didn't see much point is wasting time, recources and money doing it properly.
So this archive film is of constricted realities of india somehow curtailed and shortened into a time frame of events recurring in of history. So india its students are taught this and that that india got freedom in 1947 and before that the history was black and white. And later discoveries were made and science technology progressed. But since 1600 a.d. some scenes are missing, as if indira gandhi and her aggressor sikh regiment of kamptee school nagpur were already involved in some mass killings of 1730s of bombay india atrocities done to change manipulate some things to get indian government acquisition and to fall of royalty states and families. So that time too coca cola tv fridge was there....bollywood was also there. And these are infact teesra janam of indira gandhi of her life cycle....in 1730s. And there were many people at that time with her they in 1975 were wearing school dress in nagpur schools. So these were the real terrorists minds of india of their teesra janam, in their dusra janam they were already married and had children. And in fourth janam they reversed aged and acted dumb like innocent ignorant people celebrating independence republic days. So these people saw 80 years lifetime one janam in 1600, then in 1700, then in 1800, then in 1900 and again they want to enjoy illegal life without shame.....in 2020 to 2099....and again in 2120 they would wear school dress and group in kamptee school with body cover n name changed....reversed aged with their childrens or others children taken as adopted......
So only muslims of south bombay and infinx midc INC office they were only doing satyagraha morcha? and no hindus?
so how many years this constriction program of bombay would see people from all walks of life of years pertaining 1650s on one week, then next weeks 1750s people came, then next weeks 1850s people came and next weeks 1950s people came...this is insanity, as there is no continuity in people seen again and again......??? so when would freedom be attained from all this?
so are there tunnels somewhere above in pakistan iran above provinces there these people of india hide themselves when the above times stops and next janam also stops. So if ptolemi above planets as written in bhagvad gita shlokas, the above penance spaceships are used programmed to sort out all the weird people unlike mindedness and taken them to settle in near some lands near syria provinces above, and given banks, houses, cars everything, and they make their governments and their society and their leaders. And do not return to india. So half of the population of india would had gone there.
And Kashmir was independent. That map is wrong.
Jinnah, see what you've done!
The irony for those which cause the reason for partition, the family is now supporting and working for that same country, Instead of serving Pakistan or India
where they can't been able to feed themselves which led to her sister's death, interestingly they somehow settled in UK WoW
Jinnah and Muslim League were the main reasons for partition. Most British leader at the time wanted a united independent India, not an independent Pakistan and a smaller independent India.
@@aryan_kumar You have been brainwashed my dude.
@@NativeVsColonial no
British did this to us., they used muslims against hindu and vice versa.
Ra JeSh never mind the fact that Sectarian Violence always occured
*Sorry but BBC is covering only one side of the coin which was very mild. The othe rside of story is REALLY heart wrenching when 50,000 **_YES THAT'S FIFTY THOUSAND_** Muslim females/girls were kidnapped/abducted and raped or killed or forcefully married with Sikhs. Hajra Bibi in Canada is one such example. There are may such other Muslim female that are now surfacing on TH-cam.*
The British divided us. We were one, they planted the seed of hatred which still exists and is growing more and more every day
BBC is uploading it . wow hypocrisy
yr le aaaao
Partition was Engineered by Brits & executed by Contractors M/S Jinnah Nehru & Co Private Ltd for their personal benefit. Today their heirs are all Billionaires
It was because of the Muslim league, not the British.
Here come RSS chadiwalas with their version of "WhatsApp forward" based history!
Hey,,, don't share the wrong map of My 🇮🇳India
..to divide and conquer.
nelson 100 no our ancestors were so stupid, believing giving extreme Islamic clerics millions of people to rule over a solution to the violent religion, without any thought of what the Quran said do to disbelievers
Most British leader were against partition. It was Jinnah who wanted partition, not Great Britain.
The forgotten story ????, you f**in kidding me BBC ???. That's another story why people CHOOSE to forget it, cause you can't live with the sorrow your WHOLE LIFE!!
Both my paternal & maternal families were of
Kashmiri origin from Anantnag & Srinagar, they were
deported from Kashmir by Dogra/Sikh Raj, went to live
in Amritsar, situated very close to Kashmir, they lived in
Punjab for 90 years in Amritsar, but ugly humanity's
real face was demasked, our own neighbors of 90 years
killed our children & kids, even my auntie & my cousin were burnt alive inside the mosque where they took refuge.
13th august the whole Amritsar was emptied of muslims......Pakistan welcomed us, gave us refuge,
saved us, nourished us & million of others, thank
heavens we are not in India....Its life time achievement
of ur life when you are born in a free country.
Longlive Pakistan.
You see if you plant a neem tree don't expect mangoes on it....it was pakistan which started all this "direct action day" and it was pakistan which did it again during the partition. A train loaded with deadbodies of Hindus and Sikhs landed in punjab from lahor and this was the trigger point.
Beware all, "Jancy Varghese" is a black Indian hindu nationalist hiding behind a western sounding feminine name.
@Jancy Varghese I know making mummies
out of hindus doesn't demand lot of work, but to
make mummies of sikhs....the whole afternoon's
job, take off his 6 yard pagg, shave his ever-growing
hair in every corner, put some deodorant, sell his
kirpan, Jancy ki Raani ....
@Storm .... How many? If they were driven
out, but not killed. You are not only an ignorant but also a Liar ignorant.
In Pakistan there are dozens of associations who still have records of victims, their family references, place date of birth, they disappeared on their way to Pakistan.
@Storm hahahaha..... in fact, u are living in obedience of Brit Raj
slave bondage epoch, a colonial nostalgic paranoia.
Violence was ignited, incited, spread & monitored by every Hindu
extremist Nazi politician whether INC, RSS, SS, Jane Sangh's
anti-Muslim riots in W. Bengal, then, Bihar, UP & punjab.Jan-sangh.
Hahahahah, one nation theory was pure fabrication of Indo-Brit
secular leftist ninkumpoops, negociating alone with Brit colonial
swines on the subject of 'Quit India', Round Table conference existed
way after, by the grace of MAJ & ML. The useful boot lickers Pundit
was busy licking vice-reign's intimacy, as for those " zamindar & aristocrates, non of them had anything to do with The Mighty ML,
they still existed aay from ML, on the subconti they still exist, busy
proving that they were harami faithfull Ghulams, tatpoonjiyas of
Brit-Raj's left testicule.... they call themselves secular NS.
Particularly, in Pakistan they are the right-hand dallals of all Feudals, singing eternal dadrah of Roti Kaprah, Makkan Progressivism,
Roshankhayyalism, Marxism Stalinism. Maoism, all that usual crap.
The Great MAJ realized the most historical unity called All India Muslim League....& revived 2 nation theory... fixing u guys a shameful gigantic
GPL.....Democracy is :
by the crooks
of the swindlers
for the dumbos...
jinnah is responsible...
British are responsible. They deliberately gave undue importance to Jinnah who could have been easily sidelined.
Divya Chowdhary they both were
@@croppedhair_31 That's true but the British also tried to persuade Jinnah for a united India. If not giving importance to Jinnah was so easy, then the British would've done that instead of trying to persuade Jinnah for united India. So there's a reason to why the British gave so much importance to jInnah.
There are some more facts I like you to be aware of about India perhaps you are not aware of them ,
Sanatan dharma has been looking after interest of good muslims from the beginning of your religion, we have been always compassionate to muslims but the same is not happening in Pakistan and Bangladesh where even minority muslims right are being suppressed. Dont forget that Prophet Mohammed kins were not killed by hindus or jews they were killed by muslims and a Hindu king had promised shelter and refuge to them when Hassan and Hussain were being persecuted in Arabia.
Not only non-muslims are there in Middle East, but also Muslims are there in secular countries of the world and they are given much more freedom then the non-muslims getting freedom in Saudi and UAE. In USA, Europe, India all secular countries give freedom to muslims which the muslims enjoy but do not reciprocate to non-muslims in Saudi Arabia. UAE and Bahrain and Oman are exceptions but still even in these countries a non muslims cannot do what liberty enjoyed by muslim in non-muslims secular countries. If you like I can give you stats and numbers with facts.
Meanwhile there are some more facts I like you to be aware of about India perhaps you are not aware of them ,
1. India and Pakistan were divided based on religion, yet it was hindu majority they had option to create a hindu country (dont forget Pakistan became Islamic state, but today there is nothing islamic about pakistan ) but they created a secular constitution that allowed all Indian including minorities to practice their religion with full freedom, unlike pakistan were minorities were exterminated the same did not happen in India.
2. It was hindustan where a hindu king build the earliest mosque in 7th century so that the arab traders could rest and pray.
3. It was hindustan where distressed zorastrians and rohingya muslims got refuge while most muslim countries did not take them.
4.It was maulana azad who said he will not contest election from muslim majority constituency because he wanted to represent Indians not muslims. We love muslims like Maulana Azad, we feel he is part of hindustan culture as much as we are.
5. it is hindu majority parliament that approved haj subsidy to continue for muslims minority of India post independence, even hindus in India dont get pilgrimage subidy. Do you even know how much 1000 crores are spent on muslim haj subsidy in India, even muslim countries including Pakistan does give haj subsidy.
6. it was abdul ghaffar khan who was jailed in Pakistan soon after partition. We love muslims like bachaa khan or frontier gandhi, we feel he is part of hindustan culture as much as we are.
7.Are you forgetting that Indian muslims who went to pakistan became muhajirs and continue to fight for their rights in pakistan.
8. Have forgotten that it was pakistan who killed 4 million Bangladeshis including muslims in 1971.
9. it was hindu majority who allows muslims to build mosque freely in India even after partition, there are 3 lakh new mosques in India after 1947.
10. it is a hindu majority India where muslim actors and musicians are getting famous because hindus film/ music fans dont think same way you think. In a hindu majority country the 3 khans are top of the charts and AR Rahman the most prefered musician.
11. it was a hindu Vikram Sarabai who was mentor to Abdul Kalam who made India proud. We love muslims like Abdul Kalam, we feel he is part of hindustan culture as much as we are. The whole nation wept when he died.
12. Dont ever forget that it was a hindu king Raja dahir who had given shelter to the family of Imam Hussain. did you know pakistani considers mohammed bin qasim as their hero who was sent to kill Imam hussain's family who was in shelter under raja dahir. check out muhammad bin qasim uncle who was governor of iraq was enemy of prophet family, you might want to research on the history of hijaj bin yusuf. Yet on national television we have Imams in India who support Mohammed bin Qassim and Taimur.
13, it pakistanis who are killing muslims in balochistan, and in 1971 they killed bangladesh muslims and hindus, it is pakistan who sent taliban in afghanistan to kill muslims there.
14. Dont ever forget that when RSS went to help Kashmiris during the earthquake it did not ask anyone their religion before helping them yet pakistan when it sent aid to Nepal a hindu country it sent them beef packets which was only intended to help muslim victims knowing very well that hindu Nepalis dont eat beef. Its very clear you have a lot to learn about india. Pakistan curriculum teaches hatred and in such conditioned environment you could not have access to facts and history to understand right from wrong.
It was rubbish,It should never go in that way,it should never had happen ,u make wel 10 countries but why people leave? and so many dead ,jinnah and neheru both were responsible ,idiot things happened
Yu showed wrong map of India...some of my state yu showed in Pakistan....
Its disputed... no india nor pakistan can claim that part.
Then I am not a citizen of India?Maybe you read wrong History.Brush it up,before you shame yourself again.
Vipul Khajuria it is before partition map
vipul khajuria i knew right after watching the map that some idioit would comment and here i found you..chutiah the part you see is called by u is pok and the reality is that it is in paksitan. and the same a pakistani would say that jamu and kashmir is theirs...so do not be stupid...ye teri baap ki jageer ni hai...haqeqat ye hai ke woh kashmir tum logo ke pas ye hamare pas....and the irony is after watching such a sad story still you are fighting over things which would not be solved by a map in a video or by you and me...
Actually that one is correct. India doesn't any control in POK and Siachin.
BBC SHOULD APOLOGISE FOR THE WRONG MAP SHOWN POK IS NOT A PART OF PAKISTAN AS SHOWN
shubham rakesh yes it is. India doesn't control it, Pakistan does. You can't claim something as yours which you don't even control.
POK belongs to Pakistan and IOK belongs to India
Sorry Gurinder Chaddha, search for the stories from true Indian point of view. There is only a western color to this inquiry.
Correction....India wasn't divided in two. The British Empire was divided in two. Coterminous Pakistan was a separate entity going back to the Indus Valley civilization.
Jancy Varese another hindu nationalist myth. Your marathas couldn't even get past the Muslim mughals north of them; my a$$ they united any country. All your marathas knew how to do was burn themselves & commit suicide everything they were subjugated by conquerors.
And "india" is an English word invented by the British.
You are wrong here. Parts of india were also there in Indus Valley civilization
It also included whole pinjab , gujrat and bit of up
Britain should repent for its horrendous crimes.
Divya Chowdhary so do the Muslim aggressors
chutiye bbc please correct map of india
Brits will pay for this. One Day they will face this same fate. Jay Hind ( India + artificially created states pakistan , Bangladesh )
For the past 5000 years , people of this subcontinent were living together, following different faiths. Then came the looters (The Royal Crown) and massacred this great civilization. States were made based on religion. Britain you will have to face KARMA.
Bhagwan ke ghar der hai andher nahi.
The muslim league is responsible for the partition as well as the British but mostly the Muslim league.
very wrong
i am very angry to see the INDIAN MAP
shows kshmir as part of pak
Sumit Kumar the Indian portion of kashmir is shown as part of India, whereas Pakistan part is shown as part of Pak. How can you claim something that you don't even control? Makes no sense if you ask me
Sumit Kumar I am an Indian and I see nothing special in that Pakistani side of Kashmir. They all think themselves as Pakistani and can do anything for Islam. They will never join India,we already have trouble with Kashmir Valley,don't want more.
How dare the BBC partition the map of Kashmir on a video about ...... partition.
Narmi the same way your types are hijacking BBC to show india-centric, one sided story lines.
And Kashmiris aren't ethnically indian, they're a dardic ppl.
### Whoosh ###
Hypocrsy is still there!!! Everything was fine . Wahhh
your shooing wrong map of bharat
Wrong map of india please correct it BBC
Kashmir is an integral part of Pakistan , you should have to show it on Pakistan map instead of India.
Sajid Bashir Take the people and go. Land is ours simple.
Haider Akhlaq lol! You need to decide. Because pakistan is land of india. 😂😂
Haider Akhlaq lol! There were muslims before invasion. Why are you claiming hindu lands then? Jokes can be made on begging muslims as well. 😂😂😂
Kashmir itself is named after a Hindu sage Kashyap...
Jews state of Israel and Islamic state of Pakistan are no different....
No...Not the secular republic of India with second largest muslim and largest Sikh population in the world.....
I think the partition was very good. Allah wanted the partition. And the way the British ruled Hindustan nobody has. Everything was in place.
Where exactly did your God say that they wanted the partition?
so wat bout d Muslim who didn't cross over......if at all Allah wished partition......waz dat he wanted dem 2 remain az Indians......only u can answer dat brother.....
Amar Suleman only for you its good step ask those people who suffered a lot bcz of this political step
Allah wanted Partition...God wanted Crusaders to take Jerusalem....Bhagwan wanted untouchables...wow when god entered politics???
Amar Suleman jinha ki maki chut