Except us(Indians) everyone is studying Sanskrit. Good point is that the language will survive and become popular like Yoga. At the end people from India will travel abroad to master what once originated from their own country. I appreciate people like Mr Dean Brown to understand and promote the language.
I am a Tamil too but I feel Sanskrit belongs to all Indians since time immemorial. This notion of white aryans chasing down the dark skinned people down south is a myth perpetually used by the British and the intelligentsia to rule India. That this a myth has been proven again and again. So, why this exasperation of drawidians getting bullied by Brahmins and the northerners. The people who want to perpetuate this myth today are mostly the politicians in the south and even the media who think they know best. It is these politicians who are holding the people ack, not he religion or the Brahmins. It is high time that Indians of all stripes acknowledge that we all share a common history
Very true. I am very happy to listen this from a Tamil brother/sister. This Aryan-Dravidian is a greatest nonsense myth composed by idiot William Jones and Max Muller to create infighting amongst ourselves. Tamil and Sanksrit are both languages of same soil. There is nothing called Noth or South people here. All have same DNA class. Actually original name of the country was Aryavratha (city of noble people). Then changed to Bharatvarsha(by ruler Bharata), then Hindustan(my mughals) and finally India(by Britishers). Who have rules this nation, have changed its name. Time to reinvent Sanksrit and rename the country to Aryavratha. Our Dharma name is not Hindu, its Arya Dharma, and we all are Arya Putra. Vande Mataram.
Partha Sarathi Regarding the word Arya, I want to say it is confusing and debatable. Many South Indians believe it is a different invading race, many brahmins believe they r descendants of Aryas, and the Allied powers of WWII shiver in the name of Arya. Again there is the believe that Arya means "noble". In pure Sanskrit Arya means "arrived" as an adjective. Some claim "Aryavarta" is India, and others, "North India". On the other hand I want to make the point that it was Hindus only in the whole world who never named their religion. Whenever they mentioned Dharma (not Religion but loosely translated as Duty), they used the phrase "Sanatan Dharma" (Eternal Ways). We now translate Religion as Dharma. So actually we are Sanatandharmis or Sanatanis and our land Sanatanbhumi (The Eternal Land). Please consider this. Please also take into consideration that Bhaarat is derived from the name of a mythical king Bharat. So the name of our religion should be changed from the wrongly pronounced Hindu (Sindhu>Hindu) to Sanatandharma or Sanatan (Noun used as adjective). Then we become Sanatanis (The one with the eternal faith or plainly the eternals) and our land Sanatanbhumi (or the land of the Eternals). One day the whole world will be rightfully Sanatanbhumi, unified in heart, in the belief in One where all believes will have place, including atheism. The conquest will be by winning the hearts of people, not through conquest of land (as done by Mughals), or seas (as done by British) or space (as done by Americans).
Guys, learn about Tamil language. What is it? people say that language is aimed by lord Siva, designed by Agathiyar, and published in the presence of of Lord Muruga. How is it possible?
@@Grilledburger99Marathi and “Hindu” as you’ve so eloquently mentioned stem from the Devanagari script which came from the Nagari script that originates from the Gupta Script, the Rigveda (3,500 years old) was written in Sharada and Devanagari scripts. The problem is that Malayalam and Tamil stem from Proto-Dravidian, an ethnolinguistic language with no script since they practiced oral traditions (Kannada and Telugu are slightly more influenced by Sanskrit).
I am learning sanskrit....some times when speak it i feel like am talking the language of gods. Each word has specificity, each word is designed very scientifically. when i utter the slokas sometimes i feel like some metaphysical dimension is opening around me. Sanskrit is really powerful and peaceful too. Sarvejanaha sukhinobhavanthu....
@@BhaveshSinghBhanucsgo I'm telling you the words in English you can check the Sanskrit and Russian words for them Chai, ours, one's own, thou, brother in law, to speak, loot, neck,
@@BhaveshSinghBhanucsgo I've had the opportunity to meet the Russian Ambassador to India. She was the on who told us about it. Dever ( brother in law) Chai Dvar/Dever ( door)
@@Bombay_wali_clips o man, these things have nothing to do with caste, but there were people to discriminate and those type of people are still there in all over world and are discriminating on several basis.
+ajaykumar sandula There is a small problem. We get here truth in a language which is grey and to my humble opinion still full of emotions with stupid feelings of superiority. In my language (German) we have a much closer connection to Sanscrit. First all substantives have a gender (die, der,das = female, male, neutre) and what gender have the words in German: world, sun, earth, majesty, arts, music, science, power, strength, force, discipline ? all female ! Second the German language is able to put substantives together. The English language cannot do it likewise. We put Welt (world) and Schmerz (pain) together and get "Weltschmerz" and arrive at a completely new meaning = feeling universal depressing moods. The German language is by far more flexible as we pick up with no problem words from other languages, especially from French. Still, coming back to cosmology, English was chosen by Sri Aurobindo to reveal or open the door to a new chapter or episode of the universal evolution. The episode of the homo sapiens, it was a long episode, is coming to an end and the new being with a new supramental consciousness will take over. So, India is and has been in the spiritual domain always no. 1. The real spiritual and material evolution you can find in "Savitri" by Sri Aurobindo, written in a mode of English which has a supreme level (never have been achieved ever before)
I am born in Tübingen,where a specific dialect is spoken. I moved to Jena, Koblenz, Wuerzburg, Bonn, München and Berlin. The German language is taught in all places in the same way. So the older dialects never had any influence on the unified German language, especially on German literature, which was build up and unified first by Luther ( a bit earlier than 18th century) and brought to the highest level by v. Goethe and later by the romanic poets Kleist, Hölderlin - even by Nietzsche, Thomas Mann - manifested best in their poems. Why should todays German be artificial? Grammar has not changed. Spelling has been simplified yes. But what are the artificial elements ? As I remarked two characteristics are outstanding. The gender specification and the use to put substantives( in which language is there something similar)? Last not least the German language is far more open to new impulses coming from modern Russian, French and English. We invented the word "handy" for mobile and the word "showmaster", both words never used in English.
Dievas (Lithuanian) meaning ‘gods’ is similar to Devas (Sanskrit). Ugnis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘fire’ is similar to Agnis (Sanskrit). Dantis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘teeth’ is similar to Dantas (Sanskrit). For ‘smoke’, the Sanskrit dhumas is similar to the Lithuanian dumas. Lithuanians wish profit and wealth to others and say ‘labhas’, similar to the Sanskrit ‘labh’. Sapnas in Lithuanian means dream, similar to swapn in Sanskrit.
@@simonthodas8409 Sanskrit is said to Mother of all languages There was trade relationship Between India and rest of world from ancient times And if you talking about Aryan Invasion theory then I will say I don't believe in that
संस्कृतम् সংস্কৃতম্ ਸੰਸ੍ਕ੍ਰਿਤਮ੍ સંસ્કૃતમ્ ସଂସ୍କୃତମ୍ సంసకృతమ్ ಸಂಸೃತಮ್ சமசுகிருதம் സംസ്കൃതം සිංස්කෘතම් སཾསྐྲྀཏམ྄ should again become the national language of Bharat.
Simardeep Singh Sodhi Save India? Learn your scripts! There is more evil emerging from people like you who have not even an atoms worth of knowledge of their scriptures!
hinduism is based on knowledge and scientific , which is made in the form of belief, tradition. foreigners are keen and interested in decoding sanskrit into their scientific form and trying to destroy its origins. but knowedge and scientific nature is there in indian dna which cannot be destroyed
No one can destroy Sanskrit. Because it is most scientific language. When human being evolve better and better, they naturally start learning Sanskrit. Most intelligent nation will grasp Sanskrit fast. But Tantra will always remain secret as it requires a Guru to transfer power. Else it will cause damage.
Sanskrit has died in north india over the years by converting to prakrits and then modern indo aryan languages(with heavy persian and arabic influence). The islamic rule totally wiped the language off. Only in south indian languages (eg. malayalam) it is still preserved a lot. Tamil is an exception
Sankrit was there before Tamil as Shruti. Veda was described with language that is vedic sanskrit. Only taught thru sound. Tamil no doubt was oldest scripted language. Sanskrit Grammar was defined by Panini. Panini is the father of sanskrit grammar.
arakkal abu again another with corrupted by fake and propoganda studies of aryan and dravidians theory. Sanskrit never mentions aryan it does arya meaning the brave or pure or else as Sanskrit have different meaning while dravida meaning from the land where two water or ocean or sea meet. Like penisula. So stop propogating aryan or dravidian theory which was more populaized by german or european. We are not related to them and about people migrating from iran or else. They are there even today persian etc and never called aryan ot what so ever. Our common language in indian subcontinents or even far was Sanskrit and like english today and also have many regional languages.
I have heard that Latvian and Lithuanian languages have something common with Sanskrit, so that means Latvian and Lithuanian are one of the oldest languages in Europe, as Latvian, I really want to hear Sanskrit.
Dievas (Lithuanian) meaning ‘gods’ is similar to Devas (Sanskrit). Ugnis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘fire’ is similar to Agnis (Sanskrit). Dantis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘teeth’ is similar to Dantas (Sanskrit). For ‘smoke’, the Sanskrit dhumas is similar to the Lithuanian dumas. Lithuanians wish profit and wealth to others and say ‘labhas’, similar to the Sanskrit ‘labh’. Sapnas in Lithuanian means dream, similar to swapn in Sanskrit.
Sanskrit is the mother of all European Languages… which shows civilisation is an “OUT OF INDIA” phenomenon. The Aryan Invasion theory and the synthetic PIE (Proto-Indo-European Language) was fabricated during the colonial era so European’s could claim ownership of the Sanskrit language. In over 200 years nobody has been able to prove the existence of PIE and the Aryan Invasion Theory or migration Theory has been completely discredited with multiple sources of scientific evidence
Linguistics comes from Sanskrit. The first literature on grammar in the world were made in Sanskrit over 2500 years ago and it is still relevant today as Backus-Naur Form. That is why sanskrit is often termed as "mother of all languages" because it was the first to discuss and posit nouns, adverbs, verbs, adjectives, phonemes, morphemes, phonetics, etymology, morphology. All the things a language needs now and what we learn in school now. Thus proper credit should be given and not ignored.
panini would be the one who established the study of language in sanskrit, using sanskrit as the meta language itself, and we can find that in the ashtadhyayi
pri22v11 That it be descended from "Sanskrit" as we know it now is disputed. That our languages all come, in evolutionary terms, from a common ancestor, to which Sanskrit (a very old language) is closer... this is not so much disputed - a Proto-Indo-European language has incredible amounts of corroborating evidence. I would still be interested in reading about counter-theories, if you can suggest anything pri22v11, I would be much obliged.
Chris Rob People who closely follow and do sadhana based on the Vedas see the proto-European language theory as a theory originating from Eurocentric thinking during the Colonial days. The Vedas see Sanskrit as an eternal language. Basically Europeans and Americans (I'm one myself!) see our culture as being the pinnacle of 'evolution', but Veda sees us as a little blip in time - some ruffians that killed billions of cows, and more. "Searching for Vedic India" book by Devamrita Swami has some good info in this regard.
Thank you Dr. Brown for writing a book on the Upanishads. Thank you Jeffrey Mishlove for recording it, your own knowledge seem to be very commendable indeed. There is a mention of Upanishads and its relevance to science here. The ancient hindu sages have thought a lot about the cosmos or manifest universe and came to the conclusion that it has to be INFINITE. No other explanation of finite and closed system can provide any conclusion to the debate to the contentious question of the srishti or creation. At first look it may appear some what an escapist excuse to pronounce the srishti as infinite and be done with it. But then the alternative explanations are all highly inadequate and hence they settled for this dimension of ANANTH or infinite. If someone say the universe is finite then pat comes the question, what is there outside of the uni or multiverse? Simialrly if some one says TIME began some 13.5 billion years ago, pat comes the question, what was there before 13.5 billion years ago. Now, having determined that the srishti or manifest creation is infinite they could not make creator any smaller. Beacuase if the creator god is smaller, then he can not control this infinite srishti and paradoxically and ruefully he will be controlled by the srishti in turn. So what to do. They said the creator god , BRAHMAN is also infinite and this manifest creation is only a small fraction of his creation. Now, everything falls in place and everyone is content. Vedas, from whom Upanishads were derived are treasure troves of wisdom. Please read the Upanishads, get them from libraries or on amazon. Thanks.
Just a few point 1) Sanskrit is called as the "Deva Bhasha" (Language of the GOD). Even for a trained Indian tongue it takes at-least 10 years to learn the exact pronunciation patterns and rules. Coz, you have to regulate and modulate the frequency by your vocal cord. 2) Not just the world but the entire Universe and also beyond Universe (this is a bit tough to visualize for the westerner mind) is just a combination of numerous vibrations of differing frequency. These Sanskrit verses are a frequency transformer. The chanter, upon regular chanting with devotion (Devotion = increased concentration) gradually changes his body vibration from gross materialistic to spirituality. With regular practice it metamorphose you into a higher spiritual plain (body, mind and all your presence).
dont try to me smart. dont think westerns are fools in spriituality. be humble. the findings of rishis's are not your finding. so dont take it as your achievement.
Tons and tons of thanks to Dr. Dean and Jeff for bringing this vdo to us! Even at my age of 60+, i came to know few things, which i was not aware of, inspite of being well read and well informed, and coming from a spiritual Hindu family! We are very proud of you, esp. because you have made us feel proud of our rich Indian heritage and culture! Only with God's grace one can be so knowledgeable, blessed and at the same time be so humble and soft like our ancient Rishis! You are true rishis and true Hindus! May Bhagawan Krishna bless you both! Hari Aum!
@@netaji-thebritishslayer it doesn't really translate to "sound". But the word OM has significant value itself. If you are really watching videos on linguistics you should have already known that you can't justify Sanskrit words (a vast and rich language) by using English (an Over simplified language with lot of errors)
@@AnkitRawat-ry3gmthere are no errors in english… or any language for that matter, there are words which are untranslatable in a philosophical context in every language, om in sanskrit, logos in greek, geist in german, etc
What lovely and healthy discussion. Thanks a lot making this type of documentory. Bringing whole human being in one platform to love each other and peace. Om shanti.
There are many schools and Sanskrit universities in India and also in other countries.I am learning it from an on line school. It is an easy language to learn and has many benefits due to his everything is pronounced.
I'm glad to choose Sanskrit as second language in my 9th & 10th class. I was able to learn hindi myself so I chose to learn new language. And now I know total 5 language correctly.
@@jethiya7990 even I am proud of studying Sanskrit language in class 6th 7th and 8th and that makes my total language count to 4 (Hindi, English, Sanskrit, Maithili)
Sanskrit is such a great language....we can simply apperciate the magnanimous persona of this language...Enchanting the mantras in sanskrit is truely blissful..... Mother of all languages...take a bow!! Om bhurbhuvahaswaha tatsviturvareniyam bhargodevasya dheemahi dhiyoh yo naha prachodayat.....
And do remember that this man was a scientist...since everybody is so SCIENCE-OBSESSED. Prof. Dean Brown was a physicist, mathematician and computer scientist. His interest in philosophy led him to study the Upanishads and the Yoga Sutras and naturally ofcourse Sanskrit.
Sanskrit is actually a sophisticated form meant for writing of scriptures and mantras. The coloquial counterparts are Prakrit. Saanskritik(Traditional)> Sanskrit, Praakritik(Natural)> Prakrit. We see such cases in many other languages. Especially in Literature studies.
***** no Malay as in native language of Malaysian people. Aiman Travista I taught Malay was a Austro Asiatic Language with high influence of Tamil and Sanskrit Loan words in it due to the presence of southern indian (tamil) rulers in that region. Correct me if I'm wrong
+Manjunath S Yes it is a Polynesina Language with high influence of Sanskrit and Tamil, which is the case of almost every South East Asian languages. but they have no presence in Indian Subcontinent. Malayalam is a totally different language present in South Indian state of Kerala.
Manjunath S, Because Malayalam came from Sanga Thamizh. 50% Sanga Thamizh and 40% Sanskrit using in Malayalam. Balance 10% Was own words. Malayalam is mixer of Samskrutha and Damiskrutha.
Sanskrit, the language is a treasure trove in itself. An ancient language that holds immense amount of wisdom, scientific and metaphysical realities intertwined with each other, so much intuition - what else remains after this ? A pure consciousness is the creator, whether it is god or anything else is a matter of debate, but this theology is very human, this perception of the cosmos is sheer wisdom. Brahman and Atman alignment works in sync creating and recreating the universe again and again ! 🙏
The beauty of Sanskrit language: Vocabulary is infinite. There are meaning associated with every alphabet or we can also call it vibration and you can split a word in to its basic vibrations and derive the meaning. These alphabets are designed in tune with vibration of the cosmos and hence Sankrit mantras have tremendous power. You repeat a mantra (destined for a purpose) focusing to improve a situation or illness and you can see the result yourself. We can measure the vibration of one's aura ( or the bioplasmic body) when we call a person a name and determine which name would be more appropriate in expanding his/her consciousness. For every word there is vachyarth ( verbal or logical meaning) and bhavarth (emotional or creative meaning). The language is powerful to express meanings in very precise way. In English we say love but in Sanskit there are hundreds of words to express love- love of an elder towards an young, love of a mother, love between partners, love or devotion to God, extreme feeling of love as bliss etc. A two line sloka from a vedic text when translated in other languages becomes as essay that span across many pages. Sanskit is based on communication using feelings so one should comprehend both vacharth and bhavarh to comprehend the meaning. The ability to comprehend the bhavarth is up to the stage you have evolved your consciousness. Each time you read a sloka, you come to know more dimensions of its bhavarth. It is essential to be in the level of consciousness of an author to truly appreciate and understand his writings. Hence it is important to learn this language to truly understand the old texts in its original form, vedas and the science of physics, quantum physics, mathematics, astrology, astronomy, Ayurveda ( medicine) the philosophy, culture, tradition and millions of scriptures since time before time. We talk in Sanskrit with a slang which is in accordance with the vibration of the words. We should learn it to reap its benefits. In ancient India there was no religion and all was based on Dharma which is a way of thinking of what is most appropriate for one to do provided a situation and this is based on basic understanding that you do not do some thing to others which you do not do to yourself, an act done with pure intention in mind for the upliftment of the other is Dharma. One always raises questions to his own self on whether each thought, word or action he/she does is Dharma. Sanskrit is purely secular and expresses the ideology of a civilized society as this itself is one of the word meaning of Sanskit ( "Civilized"). We forgot our civilization and culture and it is time to remind ourselves who we were, what we are n how we want to be.
Lovely, Sanskrit learning will enhance one's brains development. The reason why it has died out in India was due to the fact that the teaching of the vedas was not taught to every Indian, only the brahmins and few others kept it to themselves. If Sanskrit along with the vedas were taught like the bible , koran and dharmapada to all , it would be the strongest and most pratical method of living...
Luckily almost all western languages derive from the same proto-IndoEuropean language as sanskrit. I'm a south Slav (Croatian) and I'm always fascinated how simmilar and familliar some sanskrit words sound to me. There is a strong connection between the West and India, we influence eachother over and over again throughout millenias.
I am from Poland and our Langauge including other Eastern,Western and southern Slavic languages have roots in Sanskrit.I started to Study Indology in my city's university but i came to know that was less Indology but more German-Brits colonial mindset Indology.Infact i can chant "Svasti Vachan".I came once India in Rishikesh.😊 Mum Namah Karina Asti
The Upanishad s hymn he talks about has a stirring memory for me - it was the favorite of my language teacher and she had a beautiful voice. It also defines infinity to mathematically inclined. He did not translate it well, Ishopanishad is what I would search if I were you.
Thanks for Sharing such a constructive and vast teachings of Hindu Religion and Correlating the teachings of other religions as same... Since its the Worst Yug going On " The Kalyuga", many of us may not agree to the fact that is stated in the video... but Its really true and we should just inculcate each and every good aspects of the teachings stated in each and every religion.... Being a part of the oldest Way Of Living (religion HINDU) fills me with proud....
I grew up in TamilNadu in the 80's, Hindi was very very rare and completely ignored as it did not mean anything. Sanskrit was non existent or limited to fee temples around where a Tamil brahmin priest (with or without understanding) chants sanskrit mantras. I still see it that way... Tamil for regular communication, Hindi (to watch some movies) and Sanskrit in the temples.
Bro people hated Sanskrit because of Brahmans , who gave birth to Caste system in Hinduism and tried to establish their superiority. In Rigveda there is no caste system but Later it was developed by them. Sanskrit was developed much before Brahman's caste system
Why these f^¢king tamil d|¢Kh£@ds so much obsessed with Sanskrit language, no one gives s#it about there language Tamil 🤡 on which they have illogical claims
Sanskrit is not the eldest or the brother it like all other languages is the off spring of the mother Greek language. Every word in Greek has a meaning, example you can not call a "cloud" a "car" in English, Sanskrit and all other languages the word "mother" only has the meaning that was attached to it, if "bar" was attached instead of "mother" then we would be calling our moms "bar" but in Greek you cant do that because every word has meaning, "mother" "miter" comes from Eve the first mother and just like Eve was made without earth the word miter means mi=without ter=earth. What does mi ter mean in Sanskrit or English? jack chit.
"Language" another Greek word thank you very much. It comes from lingua which comes from glossa, I wonder without Greek how would you be able to speak? and say your bs like "Indo-European" you wouldn't you would speak like the barbarian that you are with grunts and noises.
You dumb ass even your user name is Greek, kriminos logia en ekaton en, ekatonthrough the formation of dialects became ekathron, ekhathron, ekhadron, ehandron, handron and the rest is history, gee what do ya know another Greek word, istoria.
By the way, appreciating a language like Sanskrit, does not mean any other language is inferior. Every language has its beauty and there is always a comfort and nostalgia in speaking, listening in your mother tongue. In India we teach Hindi, English and the official language of that specific state as primary languages. We should add Sanskrit also to this list to truly appreciate our culture and philosophy and expand the vocabulary which is used in common across Indian languages. May Sanskit be a unifying factor to appreciate our common culture and inheritance as a civilization. We should uphold the commonality to remind us of our oneness. India always remain secular and appreciate the beauty in every everything and it is the choice of a person to decide what is good for them
I'm a Psychology student and like hindu culture. While reading the Bhagavad-Gita and learning about Advaita Vedanta and other ideas, it really seemed to me like an "ancient Psychology", because of its understanding of our spiritual and psychological natures. Now that he mentioned how Sanskrit is so precise in describing consciousness and mind etc., it really makes sense to me.
A lot of text has been lost but still reading something from 5-7 thousand years back and still having such incredible information is just other wordly , people misrepresent them as Religious texts but for me they feel like encyclopaedia , a way of life
Sanskrit language is the softest language and every word of it is polite if even a bad word becomes soft in Sanskrit language so that no one gets hurt by it.....🙏
Guys, learn about Tamil language. What is it? people say that language is aimed by lord Siva, designed by Agathiyar, and published in the presence of Lord Muruga. How is it possible?
I am surprised by some of the angry reactions here as although there are mistakes here and there the essence seems to be well understood and the central point that Sanskrit has its roots in a culture that also influenced 'Western language and culture'. One criticism seems to be that he thinks European languages come from India but he does say right at the beginning that Sanskrit comes from 'proto-Indo-european language' as do many ''English, Russian , French ,Greek'' (the first three indirectly). There are a couple of mistakes not long after that for instance "many, many words in the English languages have Sanskrit origins or origins that are traceable to the Sanskrit tradition and the earlier proto-european language" (it's a mistake but it is clear that they understand that there is an earlier language from which both European language and Sanskrit derive. It is made clearer still by the fact they talks just before about Buddhism going from Western culture to the East). There where many different tribes as some of you say with a probable epi-centre around the Baltic (the earliest evidence of homo-sapiens is not far away in Romania about 40,000 years ago). So he is not saying that European languages derived from Sanskrit but that they both have their roots in a mother tongue (not known). Sanskrit is probably the closest language to that mother tongue (that is known about) apart from the Hittite language. The term Aryan relating to the modern name Iran originally was a term that simply referred to the people of that area (and later came to mean noble) by the time these peoples arrived in Iran their language had changed into what is now termed Indo-Iraninan, it then entered into India in several forms as it was un-codified so there where regional dialects. The Rg Veda was written in Vedic sanskrit which was then supplanted by the formalised classical sanskrit organised by Panini who apart from other changes assorted some pre-extant Indian words (elephant for example). There is also a criticism of his pronunciation of Sanskrit which is forgivable but I am unclear which of his translations are completely wrong? nmg70nmg it would be great to chat those through if you're up for it? Someone else comments that Buddha was born in Nepal not India which is correct although again the area was probably not called Nepal but was again more of a region of principalities first occupied by the Tibeto-Burmese about 2,500 years ago. The area is first referred to in the Atharaveda Parisista which was composed considerably later than the veda(1200-1000 BCE) on which it expounds (disliked by Buddhist and Jains in some of the scriptures). At the time Lumbini was what in what which really was a conglomeration of kingdoms and principalities. It was not until the time of the third Mauryan Emperor Ashoka's reign that we can see a unified 'India' which at the time would have included Lumbini (prior to which Kalinga remained separate - it was said to be the bloody war on the plains of Kalinga that converted Ashoka to non violence and Buddhism). Anyway although yes it is more accurate to say Nepal it is not as straight forwards and a forgivable convenience to use the term India which again was not the name of the region even at the time of Ashoka. I liked Omondi Akura comments ''when we talk about ancient India what we are referring to is not the current geographical boundaries but the ancient geographical and cultural boundaries together.'' One of the comments was very unpleasant about the Indian culture I suppose this is a 'Troll'? Luckily the gaping holes in the arguments (and the careless way in which it was written) mean that it undermines itself. I understand that looking at some of the degeneration of Indian culture such as the caste system, bad hygiene and abject poverty may give a bad impression but anatomy, astronomy and mathematics (what would we do without the zero?) such as we use in the West originated in India. In India written language is traceable at least 4,500 years and it is likely that India was the first place to invent the plough. A look at the incredible architectural achievements and advanced metal work of the country out surpasses most of what was being created in Europe at the time. Part of the difficulty India has has been created by aggressive raids on the country not east by the Brits (I am a Brit and love this land and our culture but this is an undeniable fact of our past). Not only that in many areas again India is on the rise if you look at large parts of Indian history it has been down only to get up and become again a major inspiration in science, craft and culture. Love to All Quotes that I like from the video ( I also like his smiling eyes as he says some of these) 'Through all your senses you comprehend God' 'To comprehend te divine one comprehends oneself' 'The route through everything you sense is through your centre' 'Our sensuality and spiritualty really coming together' 'God is approached through nature'
Thank you for sharing your wisdom. I'm Indian and although I have learnt Sanskrit from school, I don't know as much as you do about Ancient India. So, thank you once again for inspiring me to educate myself.
Jim its a human nature of exchange-in words.., an santosh, its the global rat-race which lead the schoolin to briefin the history or the root, an many more global matters/ scenes..
Jim Tarran I appreciate you very very much to be an open minded person to accept the truth as it is! After my many years of experiences with many kind of nationalities, British people have nevertheless the courage and audacity to accept new things and acknowledging and nurture it. It makes this small British island the biggest nation in the world! As it proved earlier times, it was not the vastness of a country, it is the people who makes it big and civilized. In Big India, it'll take a long time to come to where this small British Island had achieved in few years, why? Because there lack the most important part of Human beings; To respect each other in any level of social status. All these wonderful knowledge of Vedic Sciences are useless if it is not used for eradication of poverty, discrimination ( Woman ! ), corruptions and most ugliest ofthem all: CAST SYSTEM! It is going to be a long, long way to com there!
Dear Jim Tarran, vedanta is open to all sir. Its as much yours as is mine. Just because I was born as an indian doesn't give me exclusive right on it but of course gives me advantage. Coming from a completely different tradition the man here is more knowledgable of vedanta and devouted to it than many many indians today. This is commendable and at the same time credit also goes to him and likes of similar intellectuals whose effort will help preserve this precious wealth of mankind...
Hi guys here is for your information Buddha he was born in India it's true because when he was born there's no borderline bit mean India and Nepal so that is why we call he was born in India and also that time we call to India (Bharat) not India ...... So thank you so much and God bless you
Md, nothing can be done. There are some languages and religions they have self effect power. It is matter of time. Any religion become old slowly looses its strength. At the beginning to spread force is used , people kill people to spread and later when it is spread fully. it starts its own effect. It is like a living being. Every living being is strong at childhood, become weaker when old and older finally it becomes historic. It takes 12000 years as per Vedic knowledge. So now after Christianity, Islam has become new. But people in these countries never live in peaceful. Because God is one. we are one. There is incarnation. Today I am hindu and in my next life i may take birth as a muslim or christian. And same for others. This is truth. So better keep every religion safe and peaceful. Let no one fight. all live peacefully. Om Santi Santi Santi. That is the idea of Hindus...
Outstanding interviewer, J. Mislove, deserves credit for conducting an informative interview of Dr. Dean Brown. This was a tight 23 minutes that could easily have become garbled. It held my attention and walked me steadily forward. I cannot say I agree with notions of 'everything being everything' and 'everything being nothing' but such an idea is as good as any when all thinking is seen as an hypothetical tool. Any thesis creates order in the pause required to consider it and a philosophy is a collection of thoughts seeking to hold the pause in one's the thinking ad infinitum. Well done lads. Carry on.
Learning Sanskrit while staying in the Western world is very appreciated. To understand Sanskrit you have to be an Indian and stay in India. Anyway, a great beginning. Just one point - Sanskrit is the language through which one may learn our scriptures and the pronunciation is very important. That's why I have emphasized about being an Indian or staying in India. Using the Shalokas with Western dialect will lead to 'nowhere'🙏🙏
Kireeti Bharadwaj Every word in all languages has its own meaning. Learning Sanskrit really gives happiness to children because that is the only paper you can score 100, just copying the question paper in answer sheets. Sanskrit is not a mother tongue for any Indians. Then how come, it becomes a mother of all languages?
+Sundar vedanth Regarding the "mother to all languages" point, Sanskrit is the only existing, intact descendant of the Proto Indo-European language. Other Indo-European languages are descendants of another Proto Indo-European language which is now effectively "extinct". Hence, Sanskrit can be considered as a mother to modern Indo-European languages.
+Dave75Mendis: Glad to hear that. just show some evidence of writings on rocks or palm scripts in India. I am afraid you haven't considered certain things like logic, truth..
The interviewer mentioned about Brahman around 12:33, and then at 12:54, called it the Supreme deity...Just to clarify here, Brahman is not known as a deity. We don't worship Brahman simply because normal human beings cannot communicate with Brahman like the other deities. Now as for the Supreme DEITY, there is Lord Brahma who is the God of creation, meaning the creator of all that is living. There is a very big difference between Brahma and Brahman...Where Brahman is indeed the very essence of the universe, the omnipotent "entity" that is present within every human soul, the "Atman", thereby making us humans being tied with Brahman via our souls. This is how the Buddha came to be known as the enlightened, awakened one, because he realized his self as one with the Supreme One, the Brahman. According to the Upanishads, the Brahman is known as the ultimate reality of all existence. An entity that shares no human feelings, but is something that is responsible for every event that went on from the beginning of the universe to its end as well.
Brahmin is the supreme deity, we all have to become one with the atman . When we attain moksha, we dont cease to exist, rather we become brahmin - a physical form of the atman. Atman is the soul, at its paramount. Hence he said that brahmin is the supreme deity. Its unfortunate that cruel kings and some wicked brahmin community members have spread the wrong notion among the common people . You must read vedas and upanishads from the age you began to speak, dont memorise it, but try to understand the basic essence of those texts.
I am a native Tamil speaker and well versed in English. Recently I got surprised by the amount of hidden knowledge that Sanskrit can offer. Many of the western scientists were Sanskrit scholars ex: Schrödinger, Bohr, Heisenberg, Oppenheimer, Fibonacci etc took knowledge and inspiration from Sanskrit.
You will soon realise that Tamils are living in illusion that their language is the oldest surviving language ,also the knowledge present in Sanskrit in diverse fields like Mathematics, Astronomy, Medicine, Surgery, Economics, Philosophy etc is way more richer than Tamil language
@@-hindihinduhindusthan7111 I would disagree to it. If you have read the Tamil scriptures you can get so much amount of knowledge comparable with Sanskrit. But Sanskrit explores science and mathematics unlike any other language.
sanskrit is a very affactionate language as well as unique sound in the universe believe your breathing in and out both ways feels happiness in their soul.
Guys, learn about Tamil language. What is it? people say that language is aimed by lord Siva, designed by Agathiyar, and published in the presence of Lord Muruga. How is it possible?
Hi Dave, perhaps, you might be interested in knowing that other than "jal", "Pani" and "neer", there're other terms for water in sankskirt: "Ambu, Amrit, Udak, Som and Wari (water?), Toy". You would probably be also interested to know that other terms in Latin for terms (or waterlike) are: "Unda (Udak?), Imber (amrit?). Also the Greek words for water is Hudor(Toy?). I'm not implying that they're definitely related. I've never studied this. I just learned these synonyms for water in school.
OM is "Mine of Infinite virtues (gunas) / potentialities" with each virtue co-existing with its exact opposites in it.....thus balancing the Mine to exactly zero, shunya. From integrated perspective OM is Nothing and from differentiated perspective OM is everything. Nothing contains everything. You take out infinite from it, even then infinite remains. OM shantih shantih shantih Deepak Nagar
Actually I seldom see the divide between the West and East what the professor mentioned. Because although we find a large gap in the linguistics between the East-Asian languages and Indian languages, day-by-day we see more and more proofs of Hinduism and Hindu temples, sculpture and tradition in most of the East-Asian countries like Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam and such countries. ... Like it is even said that Taj-Mahal which was originally a SHIVA's temple seems like a miniature replica of the famous Angkor-Vat temples.
Aryans originated around Punjab in North West India, Rama is often referred to Arya in the Ramayan, and existed well before 12000 BC, The Arayan influence then moved to Middle East, Western Europe and also East Asia. Aryans did not come from Central Europe to India as Westerners like to believe. Sanskrit is the mother tounge from which other languages like Latin or Greek could have developed
Sanskrit was ruined for me because of a terrible teacher I had back in school. Here in India, we CBSE students have to choose between Sanskrit and French after fourth standard as a third language. I found it odd that students of French could introduce themselves in French after only a month of studying it, while none of us ever understood even a little of the Sanskrit syntax. Although our teacher was capable of teaching well, she was simply unwilling to explain topics to us and was always very grumpy. Easily, the worst teacher I have ever had.
He pronounced 0:32 _"योग सुत्र/Yoga Sutra"_ & 2:38 _"वेद/Veda"_ perfectly. Sadly even Indians don't appear to pronounce it proper as many Indians will either pronounce it as "योग् सुत्र" or "योगा सुत्रा" & "वेद्" or "वेदा".
I'm from Keralam. In Southern India, in my opinion, we generally use the original Sanskrit pronunciation. Like Sa'm'skrtam (संस्कृतम्) instead Sa'n'skrit, Pra'jna' (प्रज्ञ) instead of Pra'gya', Jnana/Jnanam (ज्ञान) instead of Gyaan, etc. 🙏
@@slomojohnjoshi5990 Thanks for the info. In Maharashtra we too don't pronounce words like प्रज्ञा or ज्ञान with "G/ग" but we use "D/द" instead which is probably unique to us. Then for संस्कृत we pronounce ऋ in कृ as "ru" instead of "ri", also in pronunciation of सं we don't pronounce it as सन् or सम् but simply add nasalisation to it like "Sã" which I think is the original use of the "ं" (anusvāra) symbol.
अहं गर्वम् अनुभवामि यत् अहं संस्कृतभाषी अस्मि। (मैं गर्व का अनुभव करता हुं कि मैं संस्कृतभाषी हूं।) (Feel proud to be a Sanskrit speaker.) #जयतु_संस्कृतम्#जयतु_भारतम्
I don't understand why most of the western scholar try to connect Sanskrit and Indian Vedas with the West. There are no Strings attached. Sanskrit and Vedas go back to time when there was no concept of Jesus and other tradition existed.
Vivek Kumar Singh Well because Jesus is actually not even western. However there there are real european gods. who are vedic i.e. Mithras(Mitra),Wotan(Varuna), Ogon(Agni)
Wow! Great video! AUM~ Amen. Sanskrit seems to be the Mother of all Languages... Knowledge is more powerful when it is being used for the welfare of all living beings!!! Krishna / Christna / Christ / Christos
If you look carefully, you will find that the letter Sri in Sinhalese is the same as Swastika which has been rounded at edges by monks who wrote works of art (probably the same thing Shakespeare did with English). We find Swastika in rock inscriptions of 5k years old.
+Adrian Bury Agree, Here are few similarity Surya=Sun Dwar=Door Matru= Mother Bandhu=Brother=Bruther(german) Pitru=Pater (latin)=Father Ek= Aucho(spanish)= One= Ein(german) Dwo=Dos(spanish) = Two= Tri=-Tres(spanish)=Three Spanish Number match exactly with sanskrit. Rita=Right Deva=Devine=Deus(greek) Prakriti= Practical Aum=Amen=Alohim(jews) List goes on I am not good Laguaist, So forgive Me If I responded do n to make any sense. Mahendra
2:49 Sanskrit is an artificial/synthetic language (like latin of the medicine and law) • doesn't tell much about the conversation among the people in say a bazaar. 4:08 Sanskrit words are so precise about what they are talking about that they can't be replaced by any ENG equivalents. 4:23 - Sanskrit can not only describe the Emotions one is feeling but so there are words to exactly specify the Thought and states of consciousness [Sanskrit can provide specificity to the abstract] 4:45 Some Sanskrit hyms like the Upanishads are not Written just because they loose the melody once they are written, yes, these hymns are not only pin point specific but melodious too.
There is no proto european language but there is only Sanskrit!!! Its called proto european because the West didn't want to think that their language derived from a country of brown people
Very interesting talk! Agreed the ancient Indian thoughts were original, scientific and very rich. Someone mentioned 11th century of the start of decline, if I understand thats when the Islamic invasion of India started when we saw the destruction and decline of the great Hindus, Buddhists and Sanskrit languages and cultures. Interestingly around that time, many of the Buddhists texts and great scholars from the great universities such as Nalanda found refuge in Tibet under the patronage of the Tibetan kings that many of the ancient texts were carefully translated into Tibetans and given top proirity (i.e. akin to Tibetan project of the US sending first human to moon -:)) that would otherwise been lost in India. The Tibetan spiritual traditions and philosophy which is spreading around the world now by great teachers like the Dalai Lama, has direct source to the Nalanda Indian thoughts. If you listen to Dalai Lama who always gives great credit to ancient Indian thoughts and admirer of that tradition. He starts most of his Buddhist teachings by recitation of Heart Sutra from many traditions and will start off with Sanskrit renditioin.
this is the definition of Yoga by Tantra of Lord Sadashiva who lived as a spiritual/social Guru about 7000 years ago. He was the father of civilization and of Tantra. The authority on this is Shrii Shrii Anandamurit aka Shrii Prabhat Rainjan Sarkar. Please do not miss to research his writings
All I-E languages born from Sanskrit, language of Vedics/Aryas. Sanskrit is PIE. 👉All European, Mediterranean, C.Asian, G.steppe nations are founded by race of Bharath (Vedic/Arya). Kings, warriors of West, C.Asia, G.steppe are R1a1a/R1a1Y {Vedic warrior caste (Shatriyas)}, this marker didn't exist in steppe to Europe before 1k BCs. They've descended from CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas who've conquered G.steppe then Europe, China in the 1k BCs from India-Iran region when Vedics from India already conquered upto Anatolia (Mittani-Hatti-Hari) in 2k BCs. Greco-Roman descended from M-H-H Aryas, only Aryas can bring IE language, chariot, Mitra, thunder/sky God, astronomy, astrology, funerary cremation in Greece-Italy. Aryas in west have turned blonde/white breeding with white women (Celts R1bY Yamnyan, Veneds R1aY Sintashtan) like brown Jews have turned blonde. Aryas are brown skinned, dark haired/eyed (Check G-R, Irani, Saka, TochaArya, Kushan frescoes). Europe's Monarchies came 1300 years after Sakas monarchy of 700 BC., literature after 7th c CE. Greece-Italy Monarchies came 1000 years after M-H-H. Proven conquest of west by Aryas.👉In 2k BCs Mittani-Hatti-Hari conquered upto Anatolia. 👉In 800 BCs CimmeArya, Saka conquered Balkan, Ukraine, Russia. 👉In 500 BCs Parsha conquered Greece, Balkan. 👉In 400 BCs. Sauromata, Alani conquered upto Ukraine, then to British Irish Isles, remember RgVedic Goddess Danu. 👉 In 400 CEs one Alani branch conquered Spain raiding Greece, Italy. 👉In 4th c. Hun conquered half of Europe descending from Tocha-Arya, Wushun." ++++++++ 👉Since 800 BCs white (Celts, Veneds) & C.Asian trib@ls are en$laved by Aryas (CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan). 👉Whites are next en$laved by Roman descending from Mittani-Hatti-Hari Aryas. 👉Next en$laved by Hun descending from Tocha-Arya, Wushun Aryas. 👉Next en$laved by moors for 700 years, moor leaders are Irani Aryas. 👉Again en$laved by Turk, Mongol. L0rds of Turk, Mongol tribals are Tocha-Arya, Xiangno, Wushun Aryas. 👉Lords of Turk, Mongol, Avar, Khazar, Tatar trb@ls are Tocha-Arya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas. Xiangno, Wushun, Kushan conquered China, Tibet. Shatriyas of eastern India conquered SE Asia, possibly China bringing chariot & great flood mythology (ref. GE Gerini). R1a1a/R1a1Y are in Chinese, Tibetan, Turk, Mongol, SE Asian, Jews, Arab. Nations' kings don't share common race with $laves, commoners. Trib@ls don't give birth to conquerors. Shatriya Arya, Ezyptian, Mesopotamian are only martial races. ++++++++ Whites trib@ls (Celt, Vened or old Slavic) aren't IE/Aryas or warrior race, no evidence of native language. Let alone riding chariot, didnt even ride horse. Roman labelled them subhum@n. IBN Fadlan described yellow haired are f!lthiest of God's creation. Till 10th c. r@ping, hum@n s@crifice were their custom. Stark contrast of people in a continent confirms different races. Whites aren't martial race but they @nnihilate weakers, they've @nnihilated native Euros. Roman, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Hun Aryas could do the same with whites but didn't. In last 1k years Aryas in west assimilating with whites commited gen0cides of American, African, Asian, Australian. Hiroshima nuking, WW1/2. British rulers who are Arya R1a1a/R1a1Y l00ted $45 tril. alone from India & feeding white p@rasites leaving over 10 mil. starved to death. Vedic civilization is destroyed by her own long lost children. ++++++++ West isn't one race. Stark difference in civiliation confirms different races. There are Aryas, Celts, Veneds, Phonecian-Etruscan from Middle East, Negroids from sub Sahara, some C.Asian, some native Euros, Gypsies, Mongoloids. ++++++++ Shatriyas are founder of Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism. Shatriya Buddha, Mahavira, Ashoka TG, Kurus TG are the greats no race on earth could give birth. Abrahamic religions are existing because Kurus TG saved Judaism from extinction, he's the only non-Jews regarded "messiah" in Judaism. Literature of all civiliations combined can't reach half of Vedic. RgVeda is the oldest IE literature. 40% Earth's population speak Arya languages. Aryas who surpass even great Mesopotamian, Ezyptian can't originate from civilizationless Steppe. Oldest chariot found in "Sinauli" India. None ever rode Chariot in Steppe. Vedics=Aryas=IE. +++++++ Will Durant, American historian. "India was the motherland of our race, and Sanskrit the mother of Europe's languages: she was the mother of our philosophy; mother, through the Arabs, of much of our mathematics; mother, through the Buddha, of the ideals embodied in Christianity; mother, through the village community, of self-government and democracy. Mother India is in many ways the mother of us all." William James, American Author "From the Vedas, we learn a practical art of surgery, medicine, music, house building under which mechanized art is included. They are encyclopedia of every aspect of life, culture, religion, science, ethics, law, cosmology and meteorology."
There's a huge lobby of Celts across the globe, they're destroying Aryas using Aryas. They circulate Arya deities/heroes in blonde blue eyed all over. It's a question of survival of Bharath, nukes are stationed at our door step. Anti Bharath forces are being created within Bharath & nearby. I can't believe how Aryas in west be st00ge of subhum@ns!!!! I request you to give some contemplation on my study. It's h0rror experience when I found Europe's Aryas has more access to science yet so manipulative, despite learning their R1a1aY R1a1Y aligned with Celts in destroying Bharath. Entire net world is full of Aryan invasion theory.
Except us(Indians) everyone is studying Sanskrit. Good point is that the language will survive and become popular like Yoga. At the end people from India will travel abroad to master what once originated from their own country. I appreciate people like Mr Dean Brown to understand and promote the language.
+Nitin Yoga is from Crete
bart hill Crete ? Whats that
+Nitin an island in the Mediterranean
+bart hill sure ur also one from there
+MR 1 I had already mentioned that in my comment.
I am a Tamil too but I feel Sanskrit belongs to all Indians since time immemorial. This notion of white aryans chasing down the dark skinned people down south is a myth perpetually used by the British and the intelligentsia to rule India. That this a myth has been proven again and again. So, why this exasperation of drawidians getting bullied by Brahmins and the northerners. The people who want to perpetuate this myth today are mostly the politicians in the south and even the media who think they know best. It is these politicians who are holding the people ack, not he religion or the Brahmins. It is high time that Indians of all stripes acknowledge that we all share a common history
Very true. I am very happy to listen this from a Tamil brother/sister. This Aryan-Dravidian is a greatest nonsense myth composed by idiot William Jones and Max Muller to create infighting amongst ourselves. Tamil and Sanksrit are both languages of same soil. There is nothing called Noth or South people here. All have same DNA class. Actually original name of the country was Aryavratha (city of noble people). Then changed to Bharatvarsha(by ruler Bharata), then Hindustan(my mughals) and finally India(by Britishers). Who have rules this nation, have changed its name. Time to reinvent Sanksrit and rename the country to Aryavratha.
Our Dharma name is not Hindu, its Arya Dharma, and we all are Arya Putra.
Vande Mataram.
Very well said, there is no better way to it!
cheers
Partha Sarathi Didn't William Jones say that the European languages derived from Sanskrit? Does that not do India honour?
I agree
Partha Sarathi Regarding the word Arya, I want to say it is confusing and debatable. Many South Indians believe it is a different invading race, many brahmins believe they r descendants of Aryas, and the Allied powers of WWII shiver in the name of Arya. Again there is the believe that Arya means "noble". In pure Sanskrit Arya means "arrived" as an adjective. Some claim "Aryavarta" is India, and others, "North India". On the other hand I want to make the point that it was Hindus only in the whole world who never named their religion. Whenever they mentioned Dharma (not Religion but loosely translated as Duty), they used the phrase "Sanatan Dharma" (Eternal Ways). We now translate Religion as Dharma. So actually we are Sanatandharmis or Sanatanis and our land Sanatanbhumi (The Eternal Land). Please consider this. Please also take into consideration that Bhaarat is derived from the name of a mythical king Bharat. So the name of our religion should be changed from the wrongly pronounced Hindu (Sindhu>Hindu) to Sanatandharma or Sanatan (Noun used as adjective). Then we become Sanatanis (The one with the eternal faith or plainly the eternals) and our land Sanatanbhumi (or the land of the Eternals). One day the whole world will be rightfully Sanatanbhumi, unified in heart, in the belief in One where all believes will have place, including atheism. The conquest will be by winning the hearts of people, not through conquest of land (as done by Mughals), or seas (as done by British) or space (as done by Americans).
As a Malayali, I can testify that many of the words used in everyday Malayalam conversation are Sanskrit in origin.
Guys, learn about Tamil language. What is it?
people say that language is aimed by lord Siva, designed by Agathiyar, and published in the presence of of Lord Muruga.
How is it possible?
Obviously it's the mother language - Marathi, Hindu, etc
@@Grilledburger99Marathi and “Hindu” as you’ve so eloquently mentioned stem from the Devanagari script which came from the Nagari script that originates from the Gupta Script, the Rigveda (3,500 years old) was written in Sharada and Devanagari scripts. The problem is that Malayalam and Tamil stem from Proto-Dravidian, an ethnolinguistic language with no script since they practiced oral traditions (Kannada and Telugu are slightly more influenced by Sanskrit).
This is why sanskrit called origin of all languages
@@sportss360Degree
No guys! some people claim Tamil language is given by God
I am learning sanskrit....some times when speak it i feel like am talking the language of gods. Each word has specificity, each word is designed very scientifically. when i utter the slokas sometimes i feel like some metaphysical dimension is opening around me. Sanskrit is really powerful and peaceful too. Sarvejanaha sukhinobhavanthu....
Sanskrit is also called deowani means language of gods .(deo+wani)
Yes it is a divine language
Where can I learn Sanskrit ?
Where are you learning? Can you suggest some good books or online available source?
@@meenishjaiswal1790
डडड
ड
ड
ड
डडड
डड
डडड
I recently started learning Russian and amazed at the influence of Sanskrit in Russian. I need to go back to my school text books :)
There are 800 Sanskrit words in Russian
@@firsthope9254 for example plz
@@BhaveshSinghBhanucsgo I'm telling you the words in English you can check the Sanskrit and Russian words for them
Chai, ours, one's own, thou, brother in law, to speak, loot, neck,
@@BhaveshSinghBhanucsgo I've had the opportunity to meet the Russian Ambassador to India. She was the on who told us about it.
Dever ( brother in law)
Chai
Dvar/Dever ( door)
@@BhaveshSinghBhanucsgo There are many more words
Many of them even I'm not aware of
Ancient india rocks..... Sanskrit, Ayurveda, Yoga, Moksha, Vedas, Upanishads, Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism, Sikhism, Bhugol, Vedic Mathematics, Astronomy..... wow
Cosmology
Surgery, Electricity
Metallurgy
Caste discrimination existed back then too
@@Bombay_wali_clips o man, these things have nothing to do with caste, but there were people to discriminate and those type of people are still there in all over world and are discriminating on several basis.
Truth has been spoken :)
+ajaykumar sandula There is a small problem. We get here truth in a language which is grey and to my humble opinion still full of emotions with stupid feelings of superiority. In my language (German) we have a much closer connection to Sanscrit. First all substantives have a gender (die, der,das = female, male, neutre) and what gender have the words in German:
world, sun, earth, majesty, arts, music, science, power, strength, force, discipline ? all female !
Second the German language is able to put substantives together. The English language cannot do it likewise. We put Welt (world) and Schmerz (pain) together and get "Weltschmerz" and arrive at a completely new meaning = feeling universal depressing moods. The German language is by far more flexible as we pick up with no problem words from other languages, especially from French.
Still, coming back to cosmology, English was chosen by Sri Aurobindo to reveal or open the door to a new chapter or episode of the universal evolution. The episode of the homo sapiens, it was a long episode, is coming to an end and the new being with a new supramental consciousness will take over. So, India is and has been in the spiritual domain always no. 1.
The real spiritual and material evolution you can find in "Savitri" by Sri Aurobindo, written in a mode of English which has a supreme level (never have been achieved ever before)
I am born in Tübingen,where a specific dialect is spoken. I moved to Jena, Koblenz, Wuerzburg, Bonn, München and Berlin. The German language is taught in all places in the same way. So the older dialects never had any influence on the unified German language, especially on German literature, which was build up and unified first by Luther ( a bit earlier than 18th century) and brought to the highest level by v. Goethe and later by the romanic poets Kleist, Hölderlin - even by Nietzsche, Thomas Mann - manifested best in their poems.
Why should todays German be artificial? Grammar has not changed. Spelling has been simplified yes. But what are the artificial elements ?
As I remarked two characteristics are outstanding. The gender specification and the use to put substantives( in which language is there something similar)?
Last not least the German language is far more open to new impulses coming from modern Russian, French and English. We invented the word "handy" for mobile and the word "showmaster", both words never used in English.
language is entirely a natural process, labeling it as artificial is itself an artificial viewpoint.
Orly ? So esperanto is purely natural, lol
ajaykumar sandula indeed
I'm the lucky one to know basic Sanskrit !!!
Sanskrit is truly an amazing language.
Dievas (Lithuanian) meaning ‘gods’ is similar to Devas (Sanskrit). Ugnis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘fire’ is similar to Agnis (Sanskrit). Dantis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘teeth’ is similar to Dantas (Sanskrit). For ‘smoke’, the Sanskrit dhumas is similar to the Lithuanian dumas. Lithuanians wish profit and wealth to others and say ‘labhas’, similar to the Sanskrit ‘labh’. Sapnas in Lithuanian means dream, similar to swapn in Sanskrit.
@@simonthodas8409 Sanskrit is said to Mother of all languages
There was trade relationship Between India and rest of world from ancient times
And if you talking about Aryan Invasion theory then I will say I don't believe in that
संस्कृतम् সংস্কৃতম্ ਸੰਸ੍ਕ੍ਰਿਤਮ੍ સંસ્કૃતમ્ ସଂସ୍କୃତମ୍ సంసకృతమ్ ಸಂಸೃತಮ್ சமசுகிருதம் സംസ്കൃതം සිංස්කෘතම් སཾསྐྲྀཏམ྄
should again become the national language of Bharat.
Bro do you know all these scripts or just use the Google Keyboard to write them?
But you forgot the script of Burma , Thailand and Indonesia.
I agree
Please God save India's spirituality from evil islam
Simardeep Singh Sodhi Save India? Learn your scripts! There is more evil emerging from people like you who have not even an atoms worth of knowledge of their scriptures!
Whatever the language is, knowledge and truth always prevails, dont fall into language ego trap, it will close the possibilities to see rationally.
hinduism is based on knowledge and scientific , which is made in the form of belief, tradition.
foreigners are keen and interested in decoding sanskrit into their scientific form and trying to destroy its origins.
but knowedge and scientific nature is there in indian dna which cannot be destroyed
No one can destroy Sanskrit. Because it is most scientific language. When human being evolve better and better, they naturally start learning Sanskrit. Most intelligent nation will grasp Sanskrit fast. But Tantra will always remain secret as it requires a Guru to transfer power. Else it will cause damage.
Hello Arun, Would it be ok with you yo share your email id? I have some questions I needed to ask.
Thank you!
You can ask here. What is your question?
What you want to ask?
It's true
Sanskrit has died in north india over the years by converting to prakrits and then modern indo aryan languages(with heavy persian and arabic influence). The islamic rule totally wiped the language off. Only in south indian languages (eg. malayalam) it is still preserved a lot. Tamil is an exception
Telugu has more Sanskrit influence than Malayalam.
Marathi is totally based on Sanskrit.
arakkal abu Yeah, but Sanskrit is still spoken in a few villages in Karnataka and Telangana.
Sankrit was there before Tamil as Shruti. Veda was described with language that is vedic sanskrit. Only taught thru sound. Tamil no doubt was oldest scripted language. Sanskrit Grammar was defined by Panini. Panini is the father of sanskrit grammar.
arakkal abu again another with corrupted by fake and propoganda studies of aryan and dravidians theory. Sanskrit never mentions aryan it does arya meaning the brave or pure or else as Sanskrit have different meaning while dravida meaning from the land where two water or ocean or sea meet. Like penisula. So stop propogating aryan or dravidian theory which was more populaized by german or european. We are not related to them and about people migrating from iran or else. They are there even today persian etc and never called aryan ot what so ever. Our common language in indian subcontinents or even far was Sanskrit and like english today and also have many regional languages.
I have heard that Latvian and Lithuanian languages have something common with Sanskrit, so that means Latvian and Lithuanian are one of the oldest languages in Europe, as Latvian, I really want to hear Sanskrit.
Dievas (Lithuanian) meaning ‘gods’ is similar to Devas (Sanskrit). Ugnis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘fire’ is similar to Agnis (Sanskrit). Dantis (Lithuanian) meaning ‘teeth’ is similar to Dantas (Sanskrit). For ‘smoke’, the Sanskrit dhumas is similar to the Lithuanian dumas. Lithuanians wish profit and wealth to others and say ‘labhas’, similar to the Sanskrit ‘labh’. Sapnas in Lithuanian means dream, similar to swapn in Sanskrit.
Sanskrit is the mother of all European Languages… which shows civilisation is an “OUT OF INDIA” phenomenon. The Aryan Invasion theory and the synthetic PIE (Proto-Indo-European Language) was fabricated during the colonial era so European’s could claim ownership of the Sanskrit language. In over 200 years nobody has been able to prove the existence of PIE and the Aryan Invasion Theory or migration Theory has been completely discredited with multiple sources of scientific evidence
Linguistics comes from Sanskrit. The first literature on grammar in the world were made in Sanskrit over 2500 years ago and it is still relevant today as Backus-Naur Form.
That is why sanskrit is often termed as "mother of all languages" because it was the first to discuss and posit nouns, adverbs, verbs, adjectives, phonemes, morphemes, phonetics, etymology, morphology. All the things a language needs now and what we learn in school now. Thus proper credit should be given and not ignored.
Sanskrit more ancient than that because mahabharat happened 5000 years ago
panini would be the one who established the study of language in sanskrit, using sanskrit as the meta language itself, and we can find that in the ashtadhyayi
That European language is derived from Sanskrit is entirely new to me. Very interesting.
The notion that western languages are descended from Sanskrit as a mother language is disputed.
Yes, still an entirely new idea to me. Extraordinary.
pri22v11
That it be descended from "Sanskrit" as we know it now is disputed. That our languages all come, in evolutionary terms, from a common ancestor, to which Sanskrit (a very old language) is closer... this is not so much disputed - a Proto-Indo-European language has incredible amounts of corroborating evidence. I would still be interested in reading about counter-theories, if you can suggest anything pri22v11, I would be much obliged.
It's why the Nazis were interested in Southwest Asia and the Indo-European region which is where their idea of the Aryan race originates.
Chris Rob People who closely follow and do sadhana based on the Vedas see the proto-European language theory as a theory originating from Eurocentric thinking during the Colonial days. The Vedas see Sanskrit as an eternal language. Basically Europeans and Americans (I'm one myself!) see our culture as being the pinnacle of 'evolution', but Veda sees us as a little blip in time - some ruffians that killed billions of cows, and more. "Searching for Vedic India" book by Devamrita Swami has some good info in this regard.
Thank you Dr. Brown for writing a book on the Upanishads. Thank you Jeffrey Mishlove for recording it, your own knowledge seem to be very commendable indeed.
There is a mention of Upanishads and its relevance to science here. The ancient hindu sages have thought a lot about the cosmos or manifest universe and came to the conclusion that it has to be INFINITE. No other explanation of finite and closed system can provide any conclusion to the debate to the contentious question of the srishti or creation. At first look it may appear some what an escapist excuse to pronounce the srishti as infinite and be done with it. But then the alternative explanations are all highly inadequate and hence they settled for this dimension of ANANTH or infinite. If someone say the universe is finite then pat comes the question, what is there outside of the uni or multiverse? Simialrly if some one says TIME began some 13.5 billion years ago, pat comes the question, what was there before 13.5 billion years ago.
Now, having determined that the srishti or manifest creation is infinite they could not make creator any smaller. Beacuase if the creator god is smaller, then he can not control this infinite srishti and paradoxically and ruefully he will be controlled by the srishti in turn. So what to do. They said the creator god , BRAHMAN is also infinite and this manifest creation is only a small fraction of his creation. Now, everything falls in place and everyone is content.
Vedas, from whom Upanishads were derived are treasure troves of wisdom. Please read the Upanishads, get them from libraries or on amazon. Thanks.
Just a few point
1) Sanskrit is called as the "Deva Bhasha" (Language of the GOD). Even for a trained Indian tongue it takes at-least 10 years to learn the exact pronunciation patterns and rules. Coz, you have to regulate and modulate the frequency by your vocal cord.
2) Not just the world but the entire Universe and also beyond Universe (this is a bit tough to visualize for the westerner mind) is just a combination of numerous vibrations of differing frequency. These Sanskrit verses are a frequency transformer. The chanter, upon regular chanting with devotion (Devotion = increased concentration) gradually changes his body vibration from gross materialistic to spirituality. With regular practice it metamorphose you into a higher spiritual plain (body, mind and all your presence).
Excellently put
I doubt Deva(s) have any languages. They communicate beyond languages. Listen in silence
dont try to me smart. dont think westerns are fools in spriituality. be humble. the findings of rishis's are not your finding. so dont take it as your achievement.
this is the kind of thing one says when he hasn't even studied sanskrit once
Tons and tons of thanks to Dr. Dean and Jeff for bringing this vdo to us! Even at my age of 60+, i came to know few things, which i was not aware of, inspite of being well read and well informed, and coming from a spiritual Hindu family! We are very proud of you, esp. because you have made us feel proud of our rich Indian heritage and culture! Only with God's grace one can be so knowledgeable, blessed and at the same time be so humble and soft like our ancient Rishis! You are true rishis and true Hindus! May Bhagawan Krishna bless you both! Hari Aum!
At 6:02, they said "OM" is the sound of universe !!
Really u think universe has sound 😂😂
@@netaji-thebritishslayer it doesn't really translate to "sound". But the word OM has significant value itself. If you are really watching videos on linguistics you should have already known that you can't justify Sanskrit words (a vast and rich language) by using English (an Over simplified language with lot of errors)
@@AnkitRawat-ry3gmthere are no errors in english… or any language for that matter, there are words which are untranslatable in a philosophical context in every language, om in sanskrit, logos in greek, geist in german, etc
Bhagavad gita is also religion off all birth of other religion , Google has use Sanskrit for search engine.
jaman amlani
Joke
Ved
What lovely and healthy discussion. Thanks a lot making this type of documentory.
Bringing whole human being in one platform to love each other and peace. Om shanti.
There are many schools and Sanskrit universities in India and also in other countries.I am learning it from an on line school. It is an easy language to learn and has many benefits due to his everything is pronounced.
I'm overwhelmed by this conversation. I never knew before what I learnt today.👌👍
Excellent conversation between Dean and Jeffery. Quite educative and motivating for learning Sanskrit.
Excellent piece of work by Jeffrey. It shows Vedas and Upanishads in new light. Thanks
I'm glad to choose Sanskrit as second language in my 9th & 10th class. I was able to learn hindi myself so I chose to learn new language. And now I know total 5 language correctly.
Hindi, Khortha, Sanskrit and English now I'm learning Gujarati and Telugu.
@@jethiya7990 even I am proud of studying Sanskrit language in class 6th 7th and 8th
and that makes my total language count to 4 (Hindi, English, Sanskrit, Maithili)
@@pkpk9513 that's good but it was compulsory. 😉 It was basic sanskrit and was part of syllabus not like 9th 10th.
Sanskrit is such a great language....we can simply apperciate the magnanimous persona of this language...Enchanting the mantras in sanskrit is truely blissful..... Mother of all languages...take a bow!! Om bhurbhuvahaswaha tatsviturvareniyam bhargodevasya dheemahi dhiyoh yo naha prachodayat.....
Gaurav Joshi
Well,there is no evidence that Sanskrit is the mother of ALL languages.
But of Aryan languages,yes.
@@adityanawani8134 you don't always need an evidence sometimes it's good to live in delusion
This is such an overlooked and underrated interview
And do remember that this man was a scientist...since everybody is so SCIENCE-OBSESSED. Prof. Dean Brown was a physicist, mathematician and computer scientist. His interest in philosophy led him to study the Upanishads and the Yoga Sutras and naturally ofcourse Sanskrit.
Sanskrit is actually a sophisticated form meant for writing of scriptures and mantras. The coloquial counterparts are Prakrit. Saanskritik(Traditional)> Sanskrit, Praakritik(Natural)> Prakrit. We see such cases in many other languages. Especially in Literature studies.
Who's interviewing whom here ?
Really liked how aware and informed the host was !!
I'm Malay. And Malay language is from sanskrit
***** no Malay as in native language of Malaysian people.
Aiman Travista I taught Malay was a Austro Asiatic Language with high influence of Tamil and Sanskrit Loan words in it due to the presence of southern indian (tamil) rulers in that region. Correct me if I'm wrong
+Manjunath S Yes it is a Polynesina Language with high influence of Sanskrit and Tamil, which is the case of almost every South East Asian languages. but they have no presence in Indian Subcontinent. Malayalam is a totally different language present in South Indian state of Kerala.
Manjunath S, Because Malayalam came from Sanga Thamizh. 50% Sanga Thamizh and 40% Sanskrit using in Malayalam. Balance 10%
Was own words. Malayalam is mixer of Samskrutha and Damiskrutha.
Sanskrit, the language is a treasure trove in itself. An ancient language that holds immense amount of wisdom, scientific and metaphysical realities intertwined with each other, so much intuition - what else remains after this ? A pure consciousness is the creator, whether it is god or anything else is a matter of debate, but this theology is very human, this perception of the cosmos is sheer wisdom. Brahman and Atman alignment works in sync creating and recreating the universe again and again ! 🙏
The beauty of Sanskrit language: Vocabulary is infinite. There are meaning associated with every alphabet or we can also call it vibration and you can split a word in to its basic vibrations and derive the meaning. These alphabets are designed in tune with vibration of the cosmos and hence Sankrit mantras have tremendous power. You repeat a mantra (destined for a purpose) focusing to improve a situation or illness and you can see the result yourself. We can measure the vibration of one's aura ( or the bioplasmic body) when we call a person a name and determine which name would be more appropriate in expanding his/her consciousness. For every word there is vachyarth ( verbal or logical meaning) and bhavarth (emotional or creative meaning). The language is powerful to express meanings in very precise way. In English we say love but in Sanskit there are hundreds of words to express love- love of an elder towards an young, love of a mother, love between partners, love or devotion to God, extreme feeling of love as bliss etc. A two line sloka from a vedic text when translated in other languages becomes as essay that span across many pages. Sanskit is based on communication using feelings so one should comprehend both vacharth and bhavarh to comprehend the meaning. The ability to comprehend the bhavarth is up to the stage you have evolved your consciousness. Each time you read a sloka, you come to know more dimensions of its bhavarth. It is essential to be in the level of consciousness of an author to truly appreciate and understand his writings. Hence it is important to learn this language to truly understand the old texts in its original form, vedas and the science of physics, quantum physics, mathematics, astrology, astronomy, Ayurveda ( medicine) the philosophy, culture, tradition and millions of scriptures since time before time. We talk in Sanskrit with a slang which is in accordance with the vibration of the words. We should learn it to reap its benefits. In ancient India there was no religion and all was based on Dharma which is a way of thinking of what is most appropriate for one to do provided a situation and this is based on basic understanding that you do not do some thing to others which you do not do to yourself, an act done with pure intention in mind for the upliftment of the other is Dharma. One always raises questions to his own self on whether each thought, word or action he/she does is Dharma. Sanskrit is purely secular and expresses the ideology of a civilized society as this itself is one of the word meaning of Sanskit ( "Civilized"). We forgot our civilization and culture and it is time to remind ourselves who we were, what we are n how we want to be.
Thank you very much Professor Dean Brown for expressing so beautifully about Vedas and Sanskrit. 🙏
Sanskrit is binary languge. Other languages are c++ java unix etc etc
FIX IT BOY ???
+KAMEHAMEHA unix is not a language
Hello World, Unix is also a language as per him. Because he must be speaking Unix. In that sense....
LOL! This is the first time I've heard Unix being called a language.
UNIX is an OS, for your kind information.
Lovely, Sanskrit learning will enhance one's brains development. The reason why it has died out in India was due to the fact that the teaching of the vedas was not taught to every Indian, only the brahmins and few others kept it to themselves. If Sanskrit along with the vedas were taught like the bible , koran and dharmapada to all , it would be the strongest and most pratical method of living...
Both guys possess great respect for our great nation India🇮🇳 and its cultural heritage ❤️❤️❤️
Luckily almost all western languages derive from the same proto-IndoEuropean language as sanskrit.
I'm a south Slav (Croatian) and I'm always fascinated how simmilar and familliar some sanskrit words sound to me. There is a strong connection between the West and India, we influence eachother over and over again throughout millenias.
I am from Poland and our Langauge including other Eastern,Western and southern Slavic languages have roots in Sanskrit.I started to Study Indology in my city's university but i came to know that was less Indology but more German-Brits colonial mindset Indology.Infact i can chant "Svasti Vachan".I came once India in Rishikesh.😊
Mum Namah Karina Asti
Sanskrit is mother of all languages.
Amrendra Singh Who is the father?
Sundar vedanth Dravidian Language..:)
Sundar vedanth who is you father ..can you tell without DNA test
You are not for healthy argument. Who knows, we both may have same DNA.
You are not for healthy argument. Who knows, we both may have same DNA.
The Upanishad s hymn he talks about has a stirring memory for me - it was the favorite of my language teacher and she had a beautiful voice. It also defines infinity to mathematically inclined. He did not translate it well, Ishopanishad is what I would search if I were you.
Thanks for uploading! well done! just wish this is shown to kids at school
PROUD TO BE A HINDU
@Sagar Chandra yes it is a way of living. It tells us how to live.
Proud to be Sanatani.
@Chandra Sagar ok Santan dharm now ok ??
@Chandra Sagar , Hinduism is Sanatan Dharma. Not religion. And the word Hindu and Hindu Rashtra is mentioned in the Vedas too.
@@jyotinoname2577 Bitch. What's your problem if she's proud? It's her right to freedom of speech
@@jyotinoname2577 I dont want to reply u. But everybody can easily understand why u r so irritated.
Thanks for Sharing such a constructive and vast teachings of Hindu Religion and Correlating the teachings of other religions as same... Since its the Worst Yug going On " The Kalyuga", many of us may not agree to the fact that is stated in the video... but Its really true and we should just inculcate each and every good aspects of the teachings stated in each and every religion....
Being a part of the oldest Way Of Living (religion HINDU) fills me with proud....
I grew up in TamilNadu in the 80's, Hindi was very very rare and completely ignored as it did not mean anything. Sanskrit was non existent or limited to fee temples around where a Tamil brahmin priest (with or without understanding) chants sanskrit mantras. I still see it that way... Tamil for regular communication, Hindi (to watch some movies) and Sanskrit in the temples.
Bro people hated Sanskrit because of Brahmans , who gave birth to Caste system in Hinduism and tried to establish their superiority. In Rigveda there is no caste system but Later it was developed by them. Sanskrit was developed much before Brahman's caste system
Why these f^¢king tamil d|¢Kh£@ds so much obsessed with Sanskrit language, no one gives s#it about there language Tamil 🤡 on which they have illogical claims
Sanskrit is Mother of almost all language
Yes it is
Sanskrit is not the eldest or the brother it like all other languages is the off spring of the mother Greek language. Every word in Greek has a meaning, example you can not call a "cloud" a "car" in English, Sanskrit and all other languages the word "mother" only has the meaning that was attached to it, if "bar" was attached instead of "mother" then we would be calling our moms "bar" but in Greek you cant do that because every word has meaning, "mother" "miter" comes from Eve the first mother and just like Eve was made without earth the word miter means mi=without ter=earth. What does mi ter mean in Sanskrit or English? jack chit.
well most of the languages, not all of the languages brother. No offence!!!
"Language" another Greek word thank you very much. It comes from lingua which comes from glossa, I wonder without Greek how would you be able to speak? and say your bs like "Indo-European" you wouldn't you would speak like the barbarian that you are with grunts and noises.
You dumb ass even your user name is Greek, kriminos logia en ekaton en, ekatonthrough the formation of dialects became ekathron, ekhathron, ekhadron, ehandron, handron and the rest is history, gee what do ya know another Greek word, istoria.
Interesting to hear that it is the Tantras (the shamanic practices of the proto-vedic people) that evolved into the Vedic metaphysics!
Incredible discussion. Thank you for posting!
By the way, appreciating a language like Sanskrit, does not mean any other language is inferior. Every language has its beauty and there is always a comfort and nostalgia in speaking, listening in your mother tongue. In India we teach Hindi, English and the official language of that specific state as primary languages. We should add Sanskrit also to this list to truly appreciate our culture and philosophy and expand the vocabulary which is used in common across Indian languages. May Sanskit be a unifying factor to appreciate our common culture and inheritance as a civilization. We should uphold the commonality to remind us of our oneness. India always remain secular and appreciate the beauty in every everything and it is the choice of a person to decide what is good for them
I'm a Psychology student and like hindu culture. While reading the Bhagavad-Gita and learning about Advaita Vedanta and other ideas, it really seemed to me like an "ancient Psychology", because of its understanding of our spiritual and psychological natures. Now that he mentioned how Sanskrit is so precise in describing consciousness and mind etc., it really makes sense to me.
A lot of text has been lost but still reading something from 5-7 thousand years back and still having such incredible information is just other wordly , people misrepresent them as Religious texts but for me they feel like encyclopaedia , a way of life
The world knows Sanskrit is heavenly along with being the mother of all languages and the oldest language on earth
Sanskrit language is the softest language and every word of it is polite if even a bad word becomes soft in Sanskrit language so that no one gets hurt by it.....🙏
I am Indian.... proud to be indian...for ever...
love listening to wisdom keepers who share their knowledge, great conversation.
Thank you very much Mr Dean Brown for the video. God bless you.
Sanskrit is developed by the rishis in deep meditative state thats why it has great and deep significance!
Guys, learn about Tamil language. What is it?
people say that language is aimed by lord Siva, designed by Agathiyar, and published in the presence of Lord Muruga.
How is it possible?
Very nice to hear this .. really sanskrit is a beautifu n valuable language
I am surprised by some of the angry reactions here as although there are mistakes here and there the essence seems to be well understood and the central point that Sanskrit has its roots in a culture that also influenced 'Western language and culture'. One criticism seems to be that he thinks European languages come from India but he does say right at the beginning that Sanskrit comes from 'proto-Indo-european language' as do many ''English, Russian , French ,Greek'' (the first three indirectly). There are a couple of mistakes not long after that for instance "many, many words in the English languages have Sanskrit origins or origins that are traceable to the Sanskrit tradition and the earlier proto-european language" (it's a mistake but it is clear that they understand that there is an earlier language from which both European language and Sanskrit derive. It is made clearer still by the fact they talks just before about Buddhism going from Western culture to the East).
There where many different tribes as some of you say with a probable epi-centre around the Baltic (the earliest evidence of homo-sapiens is not far away in Romania about 40,000 years ago). So he is not saying that European languages derived from Sanskrit but that they both have their roots in a mother tongue (not known). Sanskrit is probably the closest language to that mother tongue (that is known about) apart from the Hittite language. The term Aryan relating to the modern name Iran originally was a term that simply referred to the people of that area (and later came to mean noble) by the time these peoples arrived in Iran their language had changed into what is now termed Indo-Iraninan, it then entered into India in several forms as it was un-codified so there where regional dialects. The Rg Veda was written in Vedic sanskrit which was then supplanted by the formalised classical sanskrit organised by Panini who apart from other changes assorted some pre-extant Indian words (elephant for example).
There is also a criticism of his pronunciation of Sanskrit which is forgivable but I am unclear which of his translations are completely wrong? nmg70nmg it would be great to chat those through if you're up for it?
Someone else comments that Buddha was born in Nepal not India which is correct although again the area was probably not called Nepal but was again more of a region of principalities first occupied by the Tibeto-Burmese about 2,500 years ago. The area is first referred to in the Atharaveda Parisista which was composed considerably later than the veda(1200-1000 BCE) on which it expounds (disliked by Buddhist and Jains in some of the scriptures). At the time Lumbini was what in what which really was a conglomeration of kingdoms and principalities. It was not until the time of the third Mauryan Emperor Ashoka's reign that we can see a unified 'India' which at the time would have included Lumbini (prior to which Kalinga remained separate - it was said to be the bloody war on the plains of Kalinga that converted Ashoka to non violence and Buddhism). Anyway although yes it is more accurate to say Nepal it is not as straight forwards and a forgivable convenience to use the term India which again was not the name of the region even at the time of Ashoka.
I liked Omondi Akura comments ''when we talk about ancient India what we are referring to is not the current geographical boundaries but the ancient geographical and cultural boundaries together.''
One of the comments was very unpleasant about the Indian culture I suppose this is a 'Troll'? Luckily the gaping holes in the arguments (and the careless way in which it was written) mean that it undermines itself. I understand that looking at some of the degeneration of Indian culture such as the caste system, bad hygiene and abject poverty may give a bad impression but anatomy, astronomy and mathematics (what would we do without the zero?) such as we use in the West originated in India. In India written language is traceable at least 4,500 years and it is likely that India was the first place to invent the plough. A look at the incredible architectural achievements and advanced metal work of the country out surpasses most of what was being created in Europe at the time. Part of the difficulty India has has been created by aggressive raids on the country not east by the Brits (I am a Brit and love this land and our culture but this is an undeniable fact of our past). Not only that in many areas again India is on the rise if you look at large parts of Indian history it has been down only to get up and become again a major inspiration in science, craft and culture.
Love to All
Quotes that I like from the video ( I also like his smiling eyes as he says some of these)
'Through all your senses you comprehend God'
'To comprehend te divine one comprehends oneself'
'The route through everything you sense is through your centre'
'Our sensuality and spiritualty really coming together'
'God is approached through nature'
Thank you for sharing your wisdom. I'm Indian and although I have learnt Sanskrit from school, I don't know as much as you do about Ancient India. So, thank you once again for inspiring me to educate myself.
Jim its a human nature of exchange-in words.., an santosh, its the global rat-race which lead the schoolin to briefin the history or the root, an many more global matters/ scenes..
Jim Tarran I appreciate you very very much to be an open minded person to accept the truth as it is! After my many years of experiences with many kind of nationalities, British people have nevertheless the courage and audacity to accept new things and acknowledging and nurture it. It makes this small British island the biggest nation in the world! As it proved earlier times, it was not the vastness of a country, it is the people who makes it big and civilized.
In Big India, it'll take a long time to come to where this small British Island had achieved in few years, why? Because there lack the most important part of Human beings; To respect each other in any level of social status. All these wonderful knowledge of Vedic Sciences are useless if it is not used for eradication of poverty, discrimination ( Woman ! ), corruptions and most ugliest ofthem all: CAST SYSTEM! It is going to be a long, long way to com there!
Dear Jim Tarran, vedanta is open to all sir. Its as much yours as is mine. Just because I was born as an indian doesn't give me exclusive right on it but of course gives me advantage. Coming from a completely different tradition the man here is more knowledgable of vedanta and devouted to it than many many indians today. This is commendable and at the same time credit also goes to him and likes of similar intellectuals whose effort will help preserve this precious wealth of mankind...
http : / / www programotu ru / file /Az jpg Вся истина кроется в этом.
Beautiful ! Thanks for the upload.
Great interview , great scholar ❤
Hi guys here is for your information Buddha he was born in India it's true because when he was born there's no borderline bit mean India and Nepal so that is why we call he was born in India and also that time we call to India (Bharat) not India ...... So thank you so much and God bless you
Best religion ever! Hate my old religion Islam.
Md, nothing can be done. There are some languages and religions they have self effect power. It is matter of time. Any religion become old slowly looses its strength. At the beginning to spread force is used , people kill people to spread and later when it is spread fully. it starts its own effect. It is like a living being. Every living being is strong at childhood, become weaker when old and older finally it becomes historic. It takes 12000 years as per Vedic knowledge. So now after Christianity, Islam has become new. But people in these countries never live in peaceful. Because God is one. we are one. There is incarnation. Today I am hindu and in my next life i may take birth as a muslim or christian. And same for others. This is truth. So better keep every religion safe and peaceful. Let no one fight. all live peacefully. Om Santi Santi Santi. That is the idea of Hindus...
Md Rahman don't hate other religions bro, hindu accept every religion and every way to attain the truth.
Don't underestimate anything.
Islam is a cult
Don’t hate on other religions, it is their belief. But yes I do agree that Hinduism is a very good religion also I’m a hare krsna devotee
Love from Bangladesh.Hare Krishna
Outstanding interviewer, J. Mislove, deserves credit for conducting an informative interview of Dr. Dean Brown. This was a tight 23 minutes that could easily have become garbled. It held my attention and walked me steadily forward. I cannot say I agree with notions of 'everything being everything' and 'everything being nothing' but such an idea is as good as any when all thinking is seen as an hypothetical tool. Any thesis creates order in the pause required to consider it and a philosophy is a collection of thoughts seeking to hold the pause in one's the thinking ad infinitum. Well done lads. Carry on.
Learning Sanskrit while staying in the Western world is very appreciated. To understand Sanskrit you have to be an Indian and stay in India. Anyway, a great beginning. Just one point - Sanskrit is the language through which one may learn our scriptures and the pronunciation is very important. That's why I have emphasized about being an Indian or staying in India. Using the Shalokas with Western dialect will lead to 'nowhere'🙏🙏
Every Sanskrit word has its own meaning .learning Sanskrit gives real happiness .
Kireeti Bharadwaj Every word in all languages has its own meaning. Learning Sanskrit really gives happiness to children because that is the only paper you can score 100, just copying the question paper in answer sheets. Sanskrit is not a mother tongue for any Indians. Then how come, it becomes a mother of all languages?
+Sundar vedanth Regarding the "mother to all languages" point, Sanskrit is the only existing, intact descendant of the Proto Indo-European language. Other Indo-European languages are descendants of another Proto Indo-European language which is now effectively "extinct".
Hence, Sanskrit can be considered as a mother to modern Indo-European languages.
+Dave75Mendis: Glad to hear that. just show some evidence of writings on rocks or palm scripts in India. I am afraid you haven't considered certain things like logic, truth..
learn Sanskrit before commenting . Don't speculate .by the way I'm a Sanskrit lecturer
Learn Tamil before anything. Sanskrit lecturerer is God or what. Full of lies.
Your every thought is a trance...a spell...draped over awareness which is peace Itself...your true eternal nature.
D Graf could you please explain a bit please, you seem to know something :)
The interviewer mentioned about Brahman around 12:33, and then at 12:54, called it the Supreme deity...Just to clarify here, Brahman is not known as a deity. We don't worship Brahman simply because normal human beings cannot communicate with Brahman like the other deities.
Now as for the Supreme DEITY, there is Lord Brahma who is the God of creation, meaning the creator of all that is living. There is a very big difference between Brahma and Brahman...Where Brahman is indeed the very essence of the universe, the omnipotent "entity" that is present within every human soul, the "Atman", thereby making us humans being tied with Brahman via our souls. This is how the Buddha came to be known as the enlightened, awakened one, because he realized his self as one with the Supreme One, the Brahman. According to the Upanishads, the Brahman is known as the ultimate reality of all existence. An entity that shares no human feelings, but is something that is responsible for every event that went on from the beginning of the universe to its end as well.
***** Where does it say in science that we come from nothing? Please do show me proof of this being shown. I would love to see it.
***** I can see that you are completely incapable of saying anything that makes any logical sense in the way you speak.
***** Ouranos (Uranus, not Urine) is a primordial deity that personified the sky symbolizing heaven in the Greek mythology.
Brahmin is the supreme deity, we all have to become one with the atman . When we attain moksha, we dont cease to exist, rather we become brahmin - a physical form of the atman. Atman is the soul, at its paramount. Hence he said that brahmin is the supreme deity. Its unfortunate that cruel kings and some wicked brahmin community members have spread the wrong notion among the common people . You must read vedas and upanishads from the age you began to speak, dont memorise it, but try to understand the basic essence of those texts.
Tanishq Chauhan Brahman* ... Brahmin is a caste.
Thank you for sharing! 🙏🏽 Do you have part 2 as well? Would love to see/listen to the follow-up of this interview.
This documentary aged well 🧡🕉️
THE MAGIC MANTRA
How you did that
I am a native Tamil speaker and well versed in English. Recently I got surprised by the amount of hidden knowledge that Sanskrit can offer. Many of the western scientists were Sanskrit scholars ex: Schrödinger, Bohr, Heisenberg, Oppenheimer, Fibonacci etc took knowledge and inspiration from Sanskrit.
You will soon realise that Tamils are living in illusion that their language is the oldest surviving language ,also the knowledge present in Sanskrit in diverse fields like Mathematics, Astronomy, Medicine, Surgery, Economics, Philosophy etc is way more richer than Tamil language
@@-hindihinduhindusthan7111 I would disagree to it. If you have read the Tamil scriptures you can get so much amount of knowledge comparable with Sanskrit. But Sanskrit explores science and mathematics unlike any other language.
@@-hindihinduhindusthan7111disagree as a maratha. he is right❤
sanskrit is a very affactionate language as well as unique sound in the universe believe your breathing in and out both ways feels happiness in their soul.
Guys, learn about Tamil language. What is it?
people say that language is aimed by lord Siva, designed by Agathiyar, and published in the presence of Lord Muruga.
How is it possible?
Hi Dave, perhaps, you might be interested in knowing that other than "jal", "Pani" and "neer", there're other terms for water in sankskirt: "Ambu, Amrit, Udak, Som and Wari (water?), Toy". You would probably be also interested to know that other terms in Latin for terms (or waterlike) are: "Unda (Udak?), Imber (amrit?). Also the Greek words for water is Hudor(Toy?). I'm not implying that they're definitely related. I've never studied this. I just learned these synonyms for water in school.
OM is "Mine of Infinite virtues (gunas) / potentialities" with each virtue co-existing with its exact opposites in it.....thus balancing the Mine to exactly zero, shunya. From integrated perspective OM is Nothing and from differentiated perspective OM is everything. Nothing contains everything. You take out infinite from it, even then infinite remains.
OM shantih shantih shantih
Deepak Nagar
Dean is a scholar - hats off to him
Westerners are appreciating what we could not. What a shame
Bharat is the mother of all civilised cultures.... 🌹
I'm beginning to agree
Actually I seldom see the divide between the West and East what the professor mentioned. Because although we find a large gap in the linguistics between the East-Asian languages and Indian languages, day-by-day we see more and more proofs of Hinduism and Hindu temples, sculpture and tradition in most of the East-Asian countries like Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam and such countries.
...
Like it is even said that Taj-Mahal which was originally a SHIVA's temple seems like a miniature replica of the famous Angkor-Vat temples.
Aryans originated around Punjab in North West India, Rama is often referred to Arya in the Ramayan, and existed well before 12000 BC, The Arayan influence then moved to Middle East, Western Europe and also East Asia. Aryans did not come from Central Europe to India as Westerners like to believe. Sanskrit is the mother tounge from which other languages like Latin or Greek could have developed
Yes. They can't believe that brown people were civilized before them. Hence, the fake propoganda by the west
agree .... it increasingly the out of India theory which is most plausible
Sanskrit was ruined for me because of a terrible teacher I had back in school. Here in India, we CBSE students have to choose between Sanskrit and French after fourth standard as a third language. I found it odd that students of French could introduce themselves in French after only a month of studying it, while none of us ever understood even a little of the Sanskrit syntax. Although our teacher was capable of teaching well, she was simply unwilling to explain topics to us and was always very grumpy. Easily, the worst teacher I have ever had.
sanskrit should be the national language of india.
easy for you to say....
with all due respect, it's more complex to implement this than you think
He pronounced 0:32 _"योग सुत्र/Yoga Sutra"_ & 2:38 _"वेद/Veda"_ perfectly. Sadly even Indians don't appear to pronounce it proper as many Indians will either pronounce it as "योग् सुत्र" or "योगा सुत्रा" & "वेद्" or "वेदा".
I'm from Keralam. In Southern India, in my opinion, we generally use the original Sanskrit pronunciation. Like Sa'm'skrtam (संस्कृतम्) instead Sa'n'skrit, Pra'jna' (प्रज्ञ) instead of Pra'gya', Jnana/Jnanam (ज्ञान) instead of Gyaan, etc. 🙏
@@slomojohnjoshi5990 Thanks for the info.
In Maharashtra we too don't pronounce words like प्रज्ञा or ज्ञान with "G/ग" but we use "D/द" instead which is probably unique to us. Then for संस्कृत we pronounce ऋ in कृ as "ru" instead of "ri", also in pronunciation of सं we don't pronounce it as सन् or सम् but simply add nasalisation to it like "Sã" which I think is the original use of the "ं" (anusvāra) symbol.
@@NikhileshSurve Thanks for the info, pal. The D/ द thing was new to me. 🙏🙏👍
अहं गर्वम् अनुभवामि यत् अहं संस्कृतभाषी अस्मि।
(मैं गर्व का अनुभव करता हुं कि मैं संस्कृतभाषी हूं।)
(Feel proud to be a Sanskrit speaker.)
#जयतु_संस्कृतम्#जयतु_भारतम्
Too bad there's not much more available on Prof. Brown. Very interesting material here. Invaluable.
Instead of promoting Sanskrit our government is promoting Hindi.
I don't understand why most of the western scholar try to connect Sanskrit and Indian Vedas with the West. There are no Strings attached. Sanskrit and Vedas go back to time when there was no concept of Jesus and other tradition existed.
Vivek Kumar Singh western culture is much developed in the lines of following some of these texts
Vivek Kumar Singh
Well because Jesus is actually not even western.
However there there are real european gods. who are vedic i.e. Mithras(Mitra),Wotan(Varuna),
Ogon(Agni)
Wow! Great video! AUM~ Amen. Sanskrit seems to be the Mother of all Languages... Knowledge is more powerful when it is being used for the welfare of all living beings!!! Krishna / Christna / Christ / Christos
Why did u add christ 😂😂
If you look carefully, you will find that the letter Sri in Sinhalese is the same as Swastika which has been rounded at edges by monks who wrote works of art (probably the same thing Shakespeare did with English). We find Swastika in rock inscriptions of 5k years old.
Glad I found this site today. March 5, 2017
I was hoping actually to hear something about the language itself...
language is spoken by gods (sanskrit) . Mantras are sung and recited in sanskrit..
+Adrian Bury Agree, Here are few similarity
Surya=Sun
Dwar=Door
Matru= Mother
Bandhu=Brother=Bruther(german)
Pitru=Pater (latin)=Father
Ek= Aucho(spanish)= One= Ein(german)
Dwo=Dos(spanish) = Two=
Tri=-Tres(spanish)=Three
Spanish Number match exactly with sanskrit.
Rita=Right
Deva=Devine=Deus(greek)
Prakriti= Practical
Aum=Amen=Alohim(jews)
List goes on
I am not good Laguaist, So forgive Me
If I responded do n to make any sense.
Mahendra
god need a language to speak?
Not really
+TheSeventDoor yes when he came to this earth
I think humans should develop sanskrit over A.I and space it will help computer to think on their own
Why doesn't this video have billion views
Very interesting
Thank you
2:49 Sanskrit is an artificial/synthetic language (like latin of the medicine and law)
• doesn't tell much about the conversation among the people in say a bazaar.
4:08 Sanskrit words are so precise about what they are talking about that they can't be replaced by any ENG equivalents.
4:23 - Sanskrit can not only describe the Emotions one is feeling but so there are words to exactly specify the Thought and
states of consciousness
[Sanskrit can provide specificity to the abstract]
4:45 Some Sanskrit hyms like the Upanishads are not Written just because they loose the melody once they are written, yes, these hymns are not only pin point specific but melodious too.
it is the matter of regret that Germany has.more Sanskrit institution.than India. And. we Indians dealing.with. English. Such ...a......
Tum sabchutiyeho anydoubt you name though..😂😂
There is no proto european language but there is only Sanskrit!!! Its called proto european because the West didn't want to think that their language derived from a country of brown people
Very interesting talk! Agreed the ancient Indian thoughts were original, scientific and very rich. Someone mentioned 11th century of the start of decline, if I understand thats when the Islamic invasion of India started when we saw the destruction and decline of the great Hindus, Buddhists and Sanskrit languages and cultures. Interestingly around that time, many of the Buddhists texts and great scholars from the great universities such as Nalanda found refuge in Tibet under the patronage of the Tibetan kings that many of the ancient texts were carefully translated into Tibetans and given top proirity (i.e. akin to Tibetan project of the US sending first human to moon -:)) that would otherwise been lost in India. The Tibetan spiritual traditions and philosophy which is spreading around the world now by great teachers like the Dalai Lama, has direct source to the Nalanda Indian thoughts. If you listen to Dalai Lama who always gives great credit to ancient Indian thoughts and admirer of that tradition. He starts most of his Buddhist teachings by recitation of Heart Sutra from many traditions and will start off with Sanskrit renditioin.
this is the definition of Yoga by Tantra of Lord Sadashiva who lived as a spiritual/social Guru about 7000 years ago. He was the father of civilization and of Tantra. The authority on this is Shrii Shrii Anandamurit aka Shrii Prabhat Rainjan Sarkar. Please do not miss to research his writings
All I-E languages born from Sanskrit, language of Vedics/Aryas. Sanskrit is PIE.
👉All European, Mediterranean, C.Asian, G.steppe nations are founded by race of Bharath (Vedic/Arya). Kings, warriors of West, C.Asia, G.steppe are R1a1a/R1a1Y {Vedic warrior caste (Shatriyas)}, this marker didn't exist in steppe to Europe before 1k BCs. They've descended from CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas who've conquered G.steppe then Europe, China in the 1k BCs from India-Iran region when Vedics from India already conquered upto Anatolia (Mittani-Hatti-Hari) in 2k BCs. Greco-Roman descended from M-H-H Aryas, only Aryas can bring IE language, chariot, Mitra, thunder/sky God, astronomy, astrology, funerary cremation in Greece-Italy. Aryas in west have turned blonde/white breeding with white women (Celts R1bY Yamnyan, Veneds R1aY Sintashtan) like brown Jews have turned blonde. Aryas are brown skinned, dark haired/eyed (Check G-R, Irani, Saka, TochaArya, Kushan frescoes). Europe's Monarchies came 1300 years after Sakas monarchy of 700 BC., literature after 7th c CE. Greece-Italy Monarchies came 1000 years after M-H-H.
Proven conquest of west by Aryas.👉In 2k BCs Mittani-Hatti-Hari conquered upto Anatolia.
👉In 800 BCs CimmeArya, Saka conquered Balkan, Ukraine, Russia.
👉In 500 BCs Parsha conquered Greece, Balkan.
👉In 400 BCs. Sauromata, Alani conquered upto Ukraine, then to British Irish Isles, remember RgVedic Goddess Danu.
👉 In 400 CEs one Alani branch conquered Spain raiding Greece, Italy.
👉In 4th c. Hun conquered half of Europe descending from Tocha-Arya, Wushun."
++++++++
👉Since 800 BCs white (Celts, Veneds) & C.Asian trib@ls are en$laved by Aryas (CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan).
👉Whites are next en$laved by Roman descending from Mittani-Hatti-Hari Aryas.
👉Next en$laved by Hun descending from Tocha-Arya, Wushun Aryas.
👉Next en$laved by moors for 700 years, moor leaders are Irani Aryas.
👉Again en$laved by Turk, Mongol. L0rds of Turk, Mongol tribals are Tocha-Arya, Xiangno, Wushun Aryas.
👉Lords of Turk, Mongol, Avar, Khazar, Tatar trb@ls are Tocha-Arya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas. Xiangno, Wushun, Kushan conquered China, Tibet. Shatriyas of eastern India conquered SE Asia, possibly China bringing chariot & great flood mythology (ref. GE Gerini). R1a1a/R1a1Y are in Chinese, Tibetan, Turk, Mongol, SE Asian, Jews, Arab. Nations' kings don't share common race with $laves, commoners. Trib@ls don't give birth to conquerors. Shatriya Arya, Ezyptian, Mesopotamian are only martial races.
++++++++
Whites trib@ls (Celt, Vened or old Slavic) aren't IE/Aryas or warrior race, no evidence of native language. Let alone riding chariot, didnt even ride horse. Roman labelled them subhum@n. IBN Fadlan described yellow haired are f!lthiest of God's creation. Till 10th c. r@ping, hum@n s@crifice were their custom. Stark contrast of people in a continent confirms different races. Whites aren't martial race but they @nnihilate weakers, they've @nnihilated native Euros. Roman, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Hun Aryas could do the same with whites but didn't. In last 1k years Aryas in west assimilating with whites commited gen0cides of American, African, Asian, Australian. Hiroshima nuking, WW1/2. British rulers who are Arya R1a1a/R1a1Y l00ted $45 tril. alone from India & feeding white p@rasites leaving over 10 mil. starved to death. Vedic civilization is destroyed by her own long lost children.
++++++++
West isn't one race. Stark difference in civiliation confirms different races. There are Aryas, Celts, Veneds, Phonecian-Etruscan from Middle East, Negroids from sub Sahara, some C.Asian, some native Euros, Gypsies, Mongoloids.
++++++++
Shatriyas are founder of Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism. Shatriya Buddha, Mahavira, Ashoka TG, Kurus TG are the greats no race on earth could give birth. Abrahamic religions are existing because Kurus TG saved Judaism from extinction, he's the only non-Jews regarded "messiah" in Judaism. Literature of all civiliations combined can't reach half of Vedic. RgVeda is the oldest IE literature. 40% Earth's population speak Arya languages. Aryas who surpass even great Mesopotamian, Ezyptian can't originate from civilizationless Steppe. Oldest chariot found in "Sinauli" India. None ever rode Chariot in Steppe. Vedics=Aryas=IE.
+++++++
Will Durant, American historian.
"India was the motherland of our race, and Sanskrit the mother of Europe's languages: she was the mother of our philosophy; mother, through the Arabs, of much of our mathematics; mother, through the Buddha, of the ideals embodied in Christianity; mother, through the village community, of self-government and democracy. Mother India is in many ways the mother of us all."
William James, American Author "From the Vedas, we learn a practical art of surgery, medicine, music, house building under which mechanized art is included. They are encyclopedia of every aspect of life, culture, religion, science, ethics, law,
cosmology and meteorology."
There's a huge lobby of Celts across the globe, they're destroying Aryas using Aryas. They circulate Arya deities/heroes in blonde blue eyed all over. It's a question of survival of Bharath, nukes are stationed at our door step. Anti Bharath forces are being created within Bharath & nearby. I can't believe how Aryas in west be st00ge of subhum@ns!!!! I request you to give some contemplation on my study. It's h0rror experience when I found Europe's Aryas has more access to science yet so manipulative, despite learning their R1a1aY R1a1Y aligned with Celts in destroying Bharath. Entire net world is full of Aryan invasion theory.