Notes: While I show Russia annexing parts of Ukraine on the map to indicate the change, I am not in any way supporting the illegal annexation or the invasion. The war is a terrible thing. Keep the comments civil.
@@Supernimo735Ukraine is in its 10th year at war with one of the world's biggest superpowers and Ukraine still exists, so I think they're doing alright.
6:23 20 November 2022 9:36 20 February 2024 Just look how little has changed in 1 Year and 3 Months. Yet people are gonna die by hundreds and thousands every day.
Pretty much anyone who's we even vaguely familiar with the modern military operations knew this would be never an option, unfortunately , since the prolonged war is significantly worse for all sides involved.
it would have ended if russia was competent enough to have enough gas and supplies for their troops. NATO wasn't even sending weapons and Russia still lost in Kiev for their own fault (and Ukrainian determination to fight), and they still had to retreat from north and northeast of Ukraine lmao
I thought it would last a few months. I just didn't think Ukraine had the armament to last much longer. I expected the western Ukraine to survive around Lviv.
Reading your comment made me think of how young people must view my past. I grew up with Veterans of both world wars Korean war and Vietnam, as friends and neighbours and relatives. My profile picture is me as a Hippy back in 1970! Such is life. Peace and Love and all Best Wishes
You'd think a supposed super power like Russia, with all it's military might would be able to defeat a much smaller neighbor. Maybe Russia isn't so powerful after all. And the Ukrainians are far tougher than anyone thought. Slava Ukraini!
keep telling yourself that, Russia with 120k soldiers doing pretty good, if you have in mind that ukraine had around 300k, it usually takes a 3:1 advantage to successfully invade a territory and control it, so Russia did the job with only 10% of the 900k soldiers needed. Pretty impressive if you ask me. Plus Ukraine was a top 5 European army at the time of the ivnasion. Did it go as smoothly as Russia planned? Of course not, but it never does, that's war@@Pnaraasi94
Russian invasion started long before, you can see in 2014 (august 26-28) when Russia crossed the border. You can look up on wikipedia what came after... Ukraine would have won in 2014 otherwise.
Sorry I forgot to include the battle's name. It's called the battle of Ilovaisk. Fought almost entirely by regular Russian army troops. And that was in 2014!
The Wagner revolt happened around the time when Skibidi Toilet was at its peak popularity. Skibidi Toilet is also very popular in Russia and the maker of it was born in Russia and went to Georgia after the war started. What could this mean?
@--------123 me and my parents always knew it would happen, I'm from the West Coast US and was on a plane to check out colleges with my mom. When we took off there was talk of the russians potentially backing down. When we landed six hours later and were back in cell service, the Russians had crossed the border and were 40 miles from Kyiv. At the rate this war is going I'll be done with college before all is said and done.
This is interesting. I was wondering yesterday if you had an up to date video about this, looked it up and didn't find it. Only to see today that you uploaded it 9 minutes ago!
Probably not. The win in Avdiivka has increased Russian morale and I think Russia will try to take Kherson again this year. Russia took Kherson in 2022 but then Ukraine took it back. If Russia can regain control of Kherson, it would be a blow to Ukraine's morale considering all Ukraine did to make Kherson Ukrainian again. I think Odesa and Kharkiv are off limits for this year. But in 2025, Russia will try to take at least one of these two cities. Ukraine will of course fiercely resist. My guess is this war is only going to end in 2026-2027.
They are not stagnant. Little changes there and there, with casualties every day. It's now about who's gonna run out of forces first, not about "encirclements" and "breakthroughs" that HOI players are used to
Slavs can't live in peace unless they're ruled by foreigners. That's why the most prosperous slavic states were Austria-Hungary, Ottoman Empire, Holy Roman Empire(Had Czechs and Slovenes) and Grand Duchy of Lithuania. Compared to Polish-Litthuanian Commonwealth(half Baltic, constantly fighting itself, partitioned), Yugoslavia(Collapsed with bloody ethnic wars), USSR(Same as Yugoslavia but the wars got delayed) and russian empire(Run by tsars who spoke French and had German blood, kept it's people as slaves, became a filthy backwater and lost WW1 despite being on the winning team).
True they literally don’t do anything else but kill each other and still they are very clear about the “brother thing” or atleast the Russians are. Ukrainians not so much anymore
We don't hear much about them for two reasons: first, Russia doesn't want us to know about them, and second because they need to keep their own operations secret to have any chance at success. That said, I've been following the war somewhat closely for the past two years, and from daily reports from multiple sources, I've heard of: - Partisans providing key intelligence for Ukrainian cruise missile strikes (even in Crimea) - Partisans sabotaging Russian supply lines (on rare occasion, this even happens deep within Russia proper, and that's the only time the mainstream media ever talks about it) - Partisans assassinating mid-level officers and notorious collaborators. In short, they're doing the sorts of things the Free French forces did, but if you watch a day-by-day battle map of WWII in Europe, you wouldn't really be able to notice their contributions. (On another note, though many videos of Russian military equipment is posted on the internet by random by-standers, some of it is intentionally sought out and posted by partisan groups such as Atesh and Yellow Ribbon. This is useful for more than just propaganda, it also provides critical battle-damage assessment for Ukrainian long-distance strike forces, so they can gauge how successful their strikes are against military targets). EDIT: For those curious about operations deep within Russia, I can think of a few legendary exploits off the top of my head. There was one instance where some guy walked hundreds of miles on foot in the dead of Russian winter to sabotage an Su-35S fighter and was never caught (more likely a group of people). More importantly, sometime after N. Korea agreed to ships artillery shells to Russia, someone detonated a bomb in a tunnel that all shipments from Korea must pass through to reach the rest of the trans-Siberian railroad - Russian military logistics are heavily dependent on rails (that last one was probably special forces, not resistance, though).
In 2014 the protests were not only in Donetsk and Luhansk regions. For instance,Odessa,Kharkiv,Mykolaiv. In these regions and cities were a huge number of protests against new authority of Ukraine which had been staying after events that know as "Maidan". But the most dreadful and chaos battles were in Donbass region. Definitely,before 24.02.2022.
@@Vicktoor-b1b В 100% случаях такое пишут те, кто на этих территориях никогда не был. Съезди, поинтересуйся у местных. Кастрюля с головы спадёт сама собой
Exactly 2 years ago, we all thought that Ukraine would fall in weeks and that the war would be swift. Now it has been 2 years since the full-scale invasion began, and there is no end in sight, and of top of that, thousands of human lives have been lost on both sides.
If Russia wanted it to be over in that time they could have made it so, but likely for political/humanitarian reasons (many Russians would see Ukrainians as national cousins and would not want to impose more pain on them than is necessary for the greater good) Russia withdrew from many theatres of operation. Only the battle of Kharkov and 2nd battle of Lyman can be considered full fighting victories for Ukraine. The rest were voluntary retreats/withdrawals by the Russians but still count as victories for Ukraine in the general sense.
@@andrewmckenzie292 That's bullshit and you know it. "humanitarian reasons" have never been a consideration. A Russia that cared about "humanitarian reasons" would not have invaded another country. They would not have massacred the civilians living in Bucha, they would not have blown the Nova Kakhovka dam and flooded the lowlands. Russia withdrew from many theateres because the resistance of the Ukrainians (who wanted no part in Russias "humanitarianism") forced their hand.
@@andrewmckenzie292 You guys suck. Cope harder. If the Russian military was competent, Ukraine would be conquered without many casualties on both sides.
I remember when my father woke me up today 2 years ago and was shocked to hear the news that Russia started its invasion of Ukraine. 2 years later and this war is still ongoing. I'm quite worried for Ukraine's future, since it already had one of the lowest birthrates worldwide before 2022 and it has now lost several million people with the mass emigration and soldiers/civilians dying every day.
@@IsseKonja US openly supported the overthrow of the elected government in Ukraine/2014. As Putin eluded to in his interview with Tucker Carlson if the pro-western areas want to be separate from Russia so be it but the imposed 2014 Kiev regime also applied to those areas that did not support the coup, in effect US was taking the side that happened to align more with US hegemonic interests (ensuring Russia does not become a rival to US in Europe) rather than moral considerations. Ukraine will likely split roughly in half (in line with election results). Northern and north western Ukraine will likely become a strictly neutral state while southern and eastern Ukraine will become part of Russia to one degree or another. US has supported many questionable regimes before, but this attempt was unusually brazen...underestimating Russia's willingness to retaliate.
Сомневаюсь, что кто-то не знал про существование одной из самых больших стран Европы. А то что они поддерживают Украину - это нормально. Во-первых, любой адекватный человек не поддержит развязывание войны в любой стране. Во-вторых, они понимают: если Украина падёт, следующими будут они. Если русские массово убивают своих родственников и разрушают их города на этой войне, то что бы они сделали в Польше или Финляндии?
@@Александр-о2о8п о да, начнется хаос, злые рюсские всех хотят уничтожить. Ты переоцениваешь умственные способности этих людей. Им сказали с телевизора или в ленте твиттера кого ненавидеть и кого любить, они слушаются Даже в некотором роде жаль, что это не так. Европе не помешал бы лёгкий демонтаж
@@Александр-о2о8п Что за бред ты несешь? Они просто не вникали в суть происходящего, вот и поддерживают Украину. Война началась с того, что страны запада поддержали незаконный захват власти неонацистами на Украине, а часть страны была с этим не согласна. И это была гражданская война, где страны НАТО и их союзники поддерживали неонацистов-русофобов. Русские и так долго закрывали на это глаза. Польша и Финляндия нас вообще не интересуют. Там нет философии "маскаляку на гиляку" на государственном уровне и нет притеснений русских по национальному признаку. Да и общая история с этими странами у нас на совершенно ином уровне. К чему эти глупые пугалки? Россия даже с больной на голову Украиной пыталась столько лет договориться.
@@ЕвгенийКарабанов-р6й напомни, кто из государственных лиц Украины философствовал "москаляку на гиляку"? Львивянин Мыкола из комментов твиттера не считается. Кто из "неонацистов" захватил власть? Даже после 2014 года, когда Россия оттяпала Крым и поддерживала сепаратизм на Донбассе, русофобия в Украине была очень небольшой. Правые радикальные партии набирали меньше голосов на выборах, чем яблоко в России. Никто не запрещал деятельность откровенно пророссийского ОПЗЖ вплоть до начала полномасштабной войны. Какая тебе разница, каким путём украинцы выбирают себе власть? Пусть хоть каждый месяц революции проводят, если им нравится. Это не моё и не твоё дело. Майдан 2013-2014 не первый в истории Украины. До этого майданы тоже были, но отношения с Россией не портились, потому что Москва не совала свой нос на Украину
@@ЕвгенийКарабанов-р6йда русские ещё с 2013 года готовили украину к захвату по этому чудили в донецких и луганских областях смуту готовили сепаратистов из числа этнических русских
What's actually crazier isn't even that, but how much Ukraine's armed forces have changed. Back then, they were in an extremely precarious state. They were completely disorganised and badly equipped. Quite literally, they couldn't put up a fight in Crimea against Russian forces and in the Donbas region they struggled against well equipped russian militias. Nowadays instead they are holding off a nuclear superpower, they are well equipped, well trained and well organised. Their command structure is indeed efficient and responsive and most importantly they have a lot of western equipment and training which did pay off. Simply put: if Russia tried to pull off the hostomel airport raid in 2014, Ukraine would not have been able to respond the way it did in 2022
@@Orion8729 There could've been the possibility the West although not in the same extent as now would support them to a decent level where they could fend off Russia.
@@cuberrt а вы хотели , чтобы она шла так же быстро как в Газе, и погибло много гражданских? Для России не проблема устроить быструю войну, таким образом она может сохранить жизни своих военных, но при этом погибнет много мирного населения на Украине
Если бы Америка не вмешивалась, то всё бы закончилось за 2 недели. А так, мы отвели войска от Киева, т.к это было одним из условий мирных переговоров. Затем прилетел Борис Джонсон и скомандовал " воюйте с Россией ". И то, вы видите, что даже с поддержкой более 50 стран, Украина не в состоянии одолеть Россию, а ведь Россия даже 50% своей мощи не использует
Скажи это 500тысячам мёртвых солдат. Забыл чтоли как наша рос гвардия от пригоженских войск бежала? Он спокойно дошоо бы до Москвы , если бы не Лукашенко. А ты верь , что с нато воюете
От Киева узкие отвели войска потому что там им навесили хорошенько, какой мощи? видели мы эту мощь в Киеве и Херсоне,Харькове, уже была «частичная могилизация» на расие и потери у эрэфии страшные, и война еще не кончилась что бы приписывать победу срашке, типичный соссиянин
There should have been more notes on particular events of 2014 - like, about MH17, about direct russian involvement causing a major turn in the war and about their involvement overall
US OPENLY supported the VIOLENT overthrow of the elected government in Ukraine/2014. This new regime was IMPOSED on Crimea/Donbass and other areas nearby that voted for the original elected President. In the US/western view they were expected to recognize the new regime that was imposed on them and involved the violent overthrow of their preferred President (Yanukovych). This would be like more than half of Americans being expected to follow a President that was imposed on them by illegitimate and probably illegal methods...oh wait. Seems a bit co-incidental that Biden who was the main beneficary of this action was also a senior member of the administration that oversaw the events in Ukraine/2014.
Это путин развязал самую большую войну в Европе с 1945 года. В этой войне уже погибли сотни тысяч, и погибнут еще сотни тысяч, а может даже миллионы. Путин сумасшедший и может использовать ядерное оружие.
@@ДенисД-ф5в An elected official. Look who is in power in Russia? A thug that murders his opponents. He's been in power almost as long as I have been alive. We've had 5 different presidents here in the US in the same time, while Russia is still ruled by the same autocrat.
Would it be at all possible to summarize changes in the front line at a smaller scale? You couldn't show the entire front but would have to chose segments with important changes. Also zoom in time-wise. I very much appreciate channels like yours or weeb union.
Devastating how quickly people are already bored of supporting Ukraine, not realising that this will backfire on them long term. 'The Great Northern War' lasted for 21 years! This is what becomes of people not knowing any history.
The big question is how this war will be conducted on the Russian side after Putin is gone and someone else, probably more hawkish than even Putin, takes power.
@Nationalistsocialistbecause Putin/Russia would exploit any "deal" that is done on their terms, not with terms of Ukraine. Ofc if Ukraine doesn't get enough aid from the west then sooner or later Ukraine is forced to do a deal that is unfavorable for them anyway
@@Balnazzardiа у Украины есть выбор? Она на протяжении этих двух лет находилась в невыгодном положении. Также скажи спасибо Борису Джонсону за то, что приказал Зеленскому воевать дальше, а не идти на переговоры
@@messier8379 1. 4 years, in 2018 ATO was cancelled and ukrainian goverment starts Joint Forces Operation (2018-2022) 2. there is no information about "48 hours", bruh
1:41 I wonder what would've happened if that pocket near Horlivka wasn't liberated. It looks like it constituted for a major stabilization of the Uranian lines in Dontesk and if crushed would've been a major Russian advantage for further offensives. I mean part of that force is destroyed later, but that's after the momentum stopped.
Then the war wouldve looked a lot more different. It was a complete disaster and it allowed the ""ukrainian"" separatists to get massive backing and supplies from russia which let them solidify their claims. Had that not happened, perhaps donetsk wouldve been cut off and fully recaptured while luhansk would be under constant attack
Он и не был освобождён! Был договор о том, что украинские военные выйдут спокойно в обмен на сдачу Горловки без боя. Русские не сдержали слово, больше половины украинцев были убиты при выходе!(
Great work. Could you add percentages of territory held by Ukraine. I believe the current break down is roughly 83% of Ukraine is under Ukraine's control and Russia occupies approximately 17%. I know it will take some doing but I'd be very interested in the exact percentages as of now.
Tell me, which volunteers are you talking about? Those roosters who took over one chicken coop in the village, and then disappeared somewhere and there is still no news from them, they are called ordinary collaborators, traitors.
Russia will probably invade Europe, and get beyond humbled immediately. They can barely hold somewhat of a victory against a 3rd world country using Nato hand-me-downs
When ukraine got invaded two years ago, everyone expected Kyiv to fall in a week. But, the ZSU fought back and went on to win back Kherson city at the end of 2022. However, Russia's defenses are too strong in the south and east. Don't think that the Ukrainian Armed Forces can overcome them.
Aside from the Battle of Kharkov and 2nd battle of Lyman all other Ukrainian victories have been the result of Russian withdrawals/retreats to varying degrees.
@@prohibitedarea8590 From what I recall there was no specific directive from Russian command to withdraw from those areas but the Russians were pushed back while fighting was still going on so I consider those two to be actual military victories while the remaining Ukrainian victories were "political" ones as they were a result of command from above rather than on-the-ground military reality.
@@andrewmckenzie292 So Bakhmut and Avdiivka were Russian "political" victories and not military on the ground ones since senior command told Ukrainian forces to pull out?
@@prohibitedarea8590 Well not sure about Bakhmut, that was pretty grinding but with Andiivka yes. I am not saying they don't count as victories in the general sense, just if you say have a purely military standpoint they wouldn't hold the same prestige in my view.
Странно видеть переживания иностранцев об Украине, хотя они не знали о ее существовании до 2024 и до сих пор не могут показать ее на белом глобусе. Странно видеть 2014 - 2021 годы Российско-Украинской войны, хотя в это внемя на Украине была гражданская война и ОБСЕ, ООН не зафиксировали наличие российских войск. Странно видеть, когда иностранцы говорят, что Украина сражается за демократию, хотя там закрыты границы, отменены выборы, запрещены независимые СМИ и попираются гражданские права. При этом все это разрешено в России.
Какая гражданская война??😂😂 Гиркин и моторола украинцы? Хотя бы гражданство имеют? Украина 11 раз призывала ООН ввести миротворцев на Донбасс, вето накладывала как раз таки раша. Совпадение??😂😂 Закрытые границы никак на демократию не влияют, это буквально никак не связаные вещи. Какие независимые СМИ непонятно, но раз так сказали по росс тв значит правда. Чё по Эху Москвы клоун??😂 Выборы отменены из-за войны, хоть я считаю что их провести нужно. Гражданские права вообще смех, на расии такого слова вообще нет. Проявление разрешёности всего этого наверное в убийстве всей вменяемой оппозиции, в отраве независимых журналистов и т.д. Про взрывы домов гексогеном, норд-ост и прочую борьбу с террористами которых раша и делает я вообще молчу. А так фсё идёт по плану, попэта зизи
Some of those blue dots in Russian held areas of Ukraine, are those supposed to be lakes, or are they Ukrainian hold outs? Maybe cities under siege? Either don't show lakes at all, or else use a different color for Ukrainian territory, it is very confusing what is going on there.
@@rexblade504 I realized that later on, but it really isn't obvious at all. I mean, yes, the rivers are done in a much lighter cyan, but since you aren't ever really focused on the rivers that isn't as obvious a tell as you might hope. They just need to be a completely different color, not any shade of blue.
@@jamozmynamoz Do you know in some languages, they do not have separate words for blue and green, there is one word to describe both colors? For this purpose here on this map, in the way the color is used, the color used is too similar to blue to be advisable. I'm rather surprised that an experienced cartographer would make this mistake. I actually majored in cartography in college myself and made my share of maps. This is a rookie mistake.
I was born and raised in Kuban (southern part of Russia). I have relatives in Crimea. And I am irritated by the words about the annexation of Crimea. I asked in 2014, after the referendum, and the population of Crimea wanted to return to Russia. Just read the history of Russia. It is very hypocritical to talk about annexation when the EU and US allowed the collapse of Yugoslavia and supported Kosovo.
@MajinBuu-oo3vn "Yugoslavia collapsed on its own" - yeah, tell that to the people of Belgrade. "Also maybe Mongolia should invade Russia since they used to rule you going by that logic." - yeah, and the Americans should return the land to the Indians, and Ireland should become free from Britain. I understood you correctly? And the main reason for the war is not the desire to seize Ukraine, but to prevent NATO from getting closer to the borders of the Russian Federation. Just read their laws before the war and stop speaking the words of your propaganda. I'm saying that your "rules" or world order are just double standards and nothing more.
@MuslimsAreEvil626 If Russia wants to capture Ukraine, then only its eastern part. You are also talking propaganda, not ours, but your own. No one except the governments of the Countries knows the truth.
I understand that you will pretend that the Russians have not pursued a policy of Russification of ethnic minorities for hundreds of years, have not committed dozens if not hundreds of genocides, and have not occupied Eastern Europe for decades.
@@owoc8260 You have a sick imagination. What is genocide? - it is an action committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, any national, ethnic, racial, religious or other historically formed cultural-ethnic group. Was this in Russia? - no. Around the 1600s there was an expansion of territories, but there is not a single example of genocide (some skirmishes with natives - yes). You can compare this with the British colonies - the British destroyed up to 90-95% of the Australian Aborigines when they colonized the continent / in the 1870s "the British carried out the genocide of the Zulus in the Cape Colony, and in 1954-1961 - the genocide of the Kikuyu people in Kenya." "In response to the murder of 32 white colonists, the English authorities killed 300,000 representatives of the Kikuyu people and drove another 1.5 million people into camps. These are the first examples from Google. About Russification. In Kuban we speak Russian and a little Ukrainian. Moreover, we have Adyghe, Circassian, Turkish languages and about 100 nationalities. In Moscow, for more than a year, there was an exhibition where there were stands of all regions and nationalities of our country. Genocide, right?))) Perhaps you want to cite the Baltic countries as an example, but they have a special product for the West - hatred of everything Russian. (They have already lost or sold the Soviet heritage and industry).
I am ukrainian and I can say that it`s not 10 years war. In that period were different wars with different goals, strategy, politics, opinions and so on. We need to understand this to be honest to ourselves. This can help us to understand this conflict better and build strategy for the future that will work. Strategies and goals that were good earlier are not working right now
All the people making a major fuss about the loss of Avdiivka, just look at the map and zoom out and you'll see how relatively insignificant that capture is.
Fortress town are indeed not very visible on the map, cunning observation, but it is not insignificant. With every town liberated the morale of Ukrainians and Westerners falls, making the end of this war ever closer
@@kipkipper-lg9vl Time will tell, as the only reason it fell was due to a shortage of ammunition because of a lack of western aid. But if that situation changes and Ukraine is properly supplied and equipped then they could recapture Avdiivka and the other lost territory. It’s only a matter of time and there’s many variables that are involved here.
This really puts into context how small Russian gains in the past year or so have been. Everyone freaks out about Severodonetsk, Bakhmut and now Avdiivka, but it's clear from the map that these are nowhere close to making up for the Ukrainian counter-offensives in Kharkiv and Kherson oblasts back in 2022. There have been no large gains for either side in over a year.
True whenever a Ukrainian town falls the vatniks celebrate as if its a decisive victory like in bakhmut and lysychansk saying it still has strategic value but in the end it still is rubble
@@Silvergalaxy7383it’s still a victory, and given the fact that a lot of effort is spend by the Ukrainian side to defend, it raises the morale of the Russians, add the fact that the Russians are advancing in the donbass constantly
Не было никаких партизан, были деверсионно-разведовательные группы, которые пытались оттянуть на себя внимание во время "контрнаступления" по большей части занимались террором мирняка, и ничего не добились.
It's surprising to me how this war is mostly a stalemate really. Like Russia is literally Russia and has a huge border with Ukraine and yet Ukraine somehow stands
It's de facto Russian. If Russia takes Odesa and continues westward in Southern Ukraine, then it'll link up with Transistria to create the complete land bridge.
Odd that the didn’t mention China, India, North Korea, Iran, Cuba, Syria, Somalia etc because they’re sending our country soldiers, wespons money, and ammo.
Crazy how there have not been any major changes since ukraine retook kherson. You gotta remember, cities like avdiivka and bakhmut are actually minor cities population wise, yet all we hear about in the news are these 2 cities, although nowadays no one really talks about bakhmut anymore. That all just goes to show that we've reached the point of a stalemate. With every passing day it gets harder to believe that either side is gonna win this. I feel like this war is gonna drag on for a loooong time, until one side just calls it quits.
with stalemate comes attrition, and ukraine cannot win a war of attrition against a neighbor with 7 times the population and 10 times the military spending.
@johnhudson2210 nato can provide equipment, but not people. And even then the equipment they give to ukraine is in low numbers, and the support for such aid is decreasing.
@johnhudson2210 Китай дал согласие КНДР послать России больше артиллерийских боеприпасов, чем смогла поставить или хотя бы произвести все НАТО. Мир изменился, Юг и Восток ещё спросят с вас всех за опиумные войны, вывоз рабов из Африки, за колониальной рабство. Против вас большая часть человечества, и заодно богатейшие территории с основными ресурсами мира и заодно основные мировые промышленные регионы, вы же решили по своей тупости что у вас якобы постиндустриальное общество, когда вы всем НАТО проигрываете в военном оснащении маленькой КНДР.
@johnhudson2210 uhm ukraine is kinda close to doing so, most of their young male population left the country 2 years ago. Their population is only 23 million currently.
@@gifer6438 ну покажи, только эти видео, вероятно, будут из Ростова, Воронеж вагнеровцы объехали мимо, по окраине, потому что трасса из Ростова до Москвы проходит рядом с Воронежем. Как человек из Воронежа говорю
That still doesn't change the fact that there are 49 million kangaroos in Australia and 3.5 million people in Uruguay, which means if the kangaroos were to invade Uruguay each person will have to fight 14 kangaroos
Strangely, the author talks about the Russian-Ukrainian war, for example, in 2015 or 2017. There was a civil war in Ukraine at that time, and the Russian army was in Russia. The OSCE monitoring mission did not see the Russian army.
Girkin, Motorola, russian so called "donbass heroes", guys who started all this, they were from Moscow and Rostov. They might be not official army ofc, but these "green" people how they called themselves were russian citizens living in russia before the invasion in 2014. hundreds of these "green" men were sent to start the war which was not civil
As someone who is married to someone from Luhansk: you are incorrect. My partner's entire family and their neighbors lived in fear for many months in 2014 when Russian soldiers began to appear in their city. The city was flooded with armed Russians more and more each day, and slowly all pro-Ukrainian families began to leave the city fearing for their lives, including my partner's family, due to the hostility of these armed people and the wildly aggressive rallies led by these strangers who had never grown up in Luhansk, who had never been to Luhansk before 2014. They were strangers. Locals didn't view this as a "civil war." It was an invasion.
Как же ж так то!?.. Выж за это право - говорить свободно открыто и правдиво - вы угробили официально уже признав это пол миллиона жизней украинцев - за право говорить открыто и свободно, за свободу умираете - за право всем говорить!.. Умираете даже и за нас за русских - вроде как и за нашу свободу тоже свободно умираете!.. И что ж вы делаете, вы мне все ответы со всех аккаунтов скрыли тут!.. Как же братцы так-то!.. На чьей вы оказывается тут стороне - если все те украинцы погибли за свободу и не рабство - которым вы обмазывались тридцать лет и давали понюхать это русским, и тридцать лет трясли перед носом русских!.. Ради свободы которой вы развалили себе пятую экономику и промышленность доставшегося вам от СССР!.. Свобода, ради которой вы открыли западу рынки сбыта и обанкротили отечественного производителя... И теперь у вас свобода - которой все вам завидуют: - коррупционное, капиталы, рабочие руки, мозги и женщины - свободно утекают на запад... И за свою и нашу такую свободу вы и боретесь - с нами же!.. И что ж выходит, все эти жертвы и миллион свободно погибших и разрушенные свободные города были напрасны, и были нужны только вот за то-чтоб свободно мне скрыть тут мои комментарии ответа дискуссия!?.. Выходит, тот миллион тех миллионов погибших - которые ещё погибнут за свободу и правду украинцев - они все сейчас на моей стороне - на стороне правды которую вы так тщательно тут скрыли со всех моих аккаунтов это скрыв - и никому не показав!.. Неужель вы думаете что скрытое тут так и останется тут скрытым!?. Нет конечно, это преднамеренно будет размножено десятками и сотни раз в других местах - повторяемо и цитируемо - о том какие вы оказывается свободные и свободолюбивые - и какая у вас свобода слова - и не желание читать элементарную правду об окружающей вас действительности за периметром информационного пузыря - так тщательно и бессознательное создаваемого себе - и тем кто лайкает вас из корпоративных соображений - поддержав этим свои и ваши убеждения - того озвученного желаемого - таким это то желаемое видеть и отовсюду об этом именно таким себе слышать!
There is no annexation. In 2014, there was a coup in Ukraine and as a result, new states were formed. And Crimea has become Russian. Referendums in 3 regions were legal. To not recognize them is to ignore the legal facts. And Russia did not come to Crimea. Russia has ALREADY been in Crimea, because the Black Sea fleet and thousands of Russian soldiers are in Crimea even BEFORE 2014.
The occupation of crimea was the thing that really got me strongly interested in world affairs (i remember the Arab spring aswell, but i was still too young). I have been following the conflict ever since, but until 3 years ago it only looked like a frozen conflict similar to other russian breakaway states like Abkhazia. Then came the big russian "drills" and a lot of people panicked. Many however (including now adult me) thought nothing of it. Russia could not possibly be stupid enough to invade. But then on february 24th the invasion came. We then saw how bad of an idea it was to invade, but they continued fighting. Now the conflict again looks like it´s not moving, but there are way more people dying (or affected in general) by it then from 2014-2022. I hope Ukraine (and their supporters) out last the Russian regimes ability to wage this war.
Sadly the russians have been on the offensive since October '23 and now they've been breaking Ukrainian defenses like in the Avdiivka direction, Kupiansk direction(maybe theyve halted I dunno) and in the Zaporizhia direction towards Orikhiv. The deaths on both sides seems to be about the same (44,000 confirmed for russia and 42,000 confirmed for Ukraine) but Russia can afford and don't care about losing thousands upon thousands of men but Ukraine can't do the same. Sadly it's not going well for Ukraine but it sure as hell wouldn't of gone well if they gave up at the start of the full invasion when the Russians were marching towards Kyiv
-First Zelenski gets installed, highly likely with the help from foreign covert agencies. The pro-Russian leader is chased out of his country and replaced by this actor who is full on pro west. -ethnic Russians are targetted to be 2nd class citizens OR shelled even. -provinces with majority ethnic Russians try to break away from this madness. -Zelenski tries to get into EU/NATO, which is yet another breach of the Minsk accords -Western powers are and have been training soldiers in Ukraine -etc. -Russia invades to protect and secure the ethnic Russian parts and secure a peace deal that ensures the Minsk accords are upheld. Turkey assisted in this peace talk, but Boris Jonson intervened and promised Zelenski the world after which the peace deal was wiped from the table. -Israel tried again, but the same thing happened: Western powers intervened. They now for sure have blood on their hands for prolonging this war. my point? Just countering the many people who think Russia is doing it just to expand or did it for no good reason. There are many reasons, some i consider good/valid, some i don't. another point: this war could've been prevented if western meddling wasn't a thing.
@@AwoudeXWhat a moron, you don’t even know that Zelensky wasn’t the first post-Maidan president, the first guy that chased out the pro-Russian Yanukovich was Poroshenko lmao
2008 year: Ukraine soliders on tanks joined Georgia's attack to Russia. Of course, "thanks for 10 but not 2 years". 19st Feb 2022, Ukraine shoot Rostov oblast by Grad. In the 21st of February of 2022, Ukraine soliders invaded Rostov oblast - 2 Infantry fighting vehicles and 5 Ukraine troops was killed. Facts that you too stupid to see.
6:02 "The world does not recognize this annexation" I don't see why? When the USA illegally invaded Iraq, did the world raise a finger? When Russia invades Ukraine, everybody cries themselves stupid. Like what? I don't support war, but such bias should not exist.
DID USA annex or try to annex Iraq? No! Yes their invasion of Iraw was based lies/false information, no one is denying that. But US didnt annex Iraq and even if its regime was changed, let me remind you that Saddam Hussein himself was a dictator who started wars against Iran and Quwait and was hated by many Iraq citizens. There are few who miss him or his regime. Meanwhile Russia is waging a war in full purpose to destroy Ukraine as independent nation and annex it as part or Russia. So extremely poor comparison , you cant compare the two wars with eachother
@@monofnk6581 Some have a harder life than others, but the error many make when looking at a "hard life" in eastern Europe is they look at who is still standing while blanking out literally everyone who isn't around anymore or of whom there is little left.
The generally accepted symbol of Russia is a bear, and the symbol of Ukraine is usually portrayed as a nightingale. Probably similar scales based on economy, Military size, population, and the like. But the fact Ukraine managed to hold off an opponent that out did them on nearly every metric except morale, is really impressive. Also an amusing mental image of a bird beating up a bear.
At the start of the invasion, Ukraine had a bigger army in the field than Russia, let that sink in for a moment. That simple fact gives credit to the claim of it being a 'special military operation (at least at the start before conscripting and consolidating). They never built up enough army to conquer or occupy entire Ukraine. It's too big for the force they mustered. That also again gives credit to that claim. The initial peace deal would have Russia withdraw fully again and Ukraine not becoming part of NATO or EU. end of war, Minsk accords were upheld.
@@AwoudeXWhat bullshit are you yapping here? The Russian army was not nearly as prepared for the invasion as it should habe been beacause Putin naively thought Ukraine would crumble under his military might. The insane overestimation of his army and likely his ignorance towards corruption led to this embarasing military failure that is the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Kiev in 3 days huh?
@@alexeistrife56 learn to read, in the almost finished peace deal, that was on the table, Russia would've, as in it didn't happen because they didn't arrive at peace.
4:30 Okay, but why is it not mentioned Daily Full Report No. 40/2022, published by the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine (SMM) on February 21, 2022, according to which 2,158 ceasefire violations were recorded, including 1,100 explosions during the period(! !!)February 18 to February 20? And guess from whose controlled territory the muzzle flashes were recorded and from whose side the explosions were recorded.
@@Frikin_idiotaна Украину с 2014г стали завозить западное оружие и кредиты. И сейчас завозят оружие, деньги, наёмников и разведданны из 67 стран. Назовите сколько спутников есть у Украины или что из оружия сейчас производят там?
I suggest changing the wording of the 30 September 2022 note. NATO countries and their allies are not "The World". Also, the referendums were no more "shady" than any other referendums anywhere else, and when a democratic referendum decides something, the result of it can't be "illegal". I realize you have a bias, but a little less biased language could be useful.
Not entirely stalemate, Russia did conquer Avdiivka just recently. But for sure it just shows that neither Russia nor Ukraine has had the required force to make big breakthroughs, though at the moment Russians are pushing and Ukranians are having hard time with lack of ammunition, which is why its absolutely critical for west to send significantly more aid there if west ever wants Ukraine to hold their lines, let alone dream of winning this war. At the moment its war of attrition which Russia is slowly winning because they have ramped up their war production while aid from US has stopped for the moment because of Republicans in the House and meanwhile Europe still hasnt managed to get their own weapon production up to speed. More European countries should take example of Denmark who gave up pretty much their entire artillery shells to Ukraine as well as all their old F16s If USA would give Ukraine all the tanks, IFVS and their soon to be retired fleets of old fighters, this war could turn around back to Ukrainians favor but unfortunately west seems weak and not bold enough to make the decisions necessary. And I dont think many yet realize the danger of the situation what would follow if Putin is allowed to win and annex Ukraine or even given partial victory.
This war began much earlier, in 2014 only the hot phase began. In 1993, I read a document in English, the authors of which were very interested in Ukrainians who were fighting (at that time) against Russians in Chechnya under red-black flags. The document contained a map of Ukraine, divided into six or seven parts, contained photos of Bandera, etc. I still interesting - at that time who created this document and, most importantly, why?
because it's Russian propaganda, genius. OH NO!!!!! YOUU MEAN A NON-KREMLIN TAKE ON THE WAR?!!??!?! WOW!!!!! LET'S ONLY WATCH RUSSIAN MEDIA AND BELIEVE WHAT THEY SAY ABOUT DONBAS!!!!!! 🤣🤣🤣
wikipedia gives Odessa and Donbass as alternate spellings, and they're also more accurate in terms of representing the pronunciations, as single 'S's in both would be pronounced like a 'Z' (see words like has, laser, and applause). using 'S's is clearer about the pronunciation and still pretty accepted, so i don't think they're really misspellings
@@jatgreen2995 check out Wiki once more and you'll see that "alternate variants" are actually "Russian spellings", meaning they're officially wrong to use to Ukrainian toponyms
@@jatgreen2995 "Odessa" kinda makes sense because it's a greek-inspired name derived from the ancient city of Οδησσός (Odessos). But "Donbass" doesn't, it's literally "Donets coal basin". You wouldn't say 'bassin'.
@@ayararesara6253 oh very interesting, i didn't actually know that. i think i'd still be somewhat inclined to spell it Donbass though. the ukrainian etymology doesn't really work in english (it'd have to be pronounced to rhyme with "base" to match "basin"). instead it seems more sensible to translate the full ukrainian word into english, with english spelling rules, instead of reforming the word from english ones
It's weird to think how this war has gotten so small but yet there's more casualties than ever- at the beginning people were expecting huge swathes of territory and major Ukrainian cities (perhaps even Kyiv) to quickly fall to Russia. Now, it seems like every small village of only a few hundred people ends up being bitterly contested for months before being hailed as a major victory. Neither side has advanced more than 10 miles or so in almost a year and a half.
@@TopMusic-rf3mt It's been a year since Bakhmut, and they're still trying to take Chasiv Yar which is only a few miles away. Avdiivka took several months as well. It will take them several years to reach the Dnipro, let alone Kyiv.
When you see the war from 2014, realizing that Donetsk and Luhansk were de facto occupied to a great extent, you see how mediocre are the gains of Russia since the invasion of Feb 22.
Почему? Это война на истощение, вспомни первую мировую. Тут надо не территории забрать, а уничтожить армию. Вот Наполеон взял Москву, но армию потерял и в итоге проиграл.
А если включите мозг, то поймёте что это было народное восстание русского населения Донбасса, а если изучите вопрос то узнаете что весной 2014 года перед референдумом о независимости Донбасса Путин просил отложить референдум, что Путин подписывал пахабные Минские соглашения предающие Донбасс, вам все и всему западному миру спасибо за срыв Минских и Стамбульских соглашений, спасибо что заставили Путина сделать хоть что-то в защиту русского народа.
@@дмитрийчеканов-б1х Среди русского населения Донбасса, которое по последней переписи 2001 года составляло меньшинство, где-то появились новые российские танки, рсзо, артиллерия, снаряды. Купили в магазине хз
if you start at the age of 14, then it would be fair to write that in half of the country there were pro-Russian separatists (such as: Odessa, Mykolaiv, Kherson, Zaporizhia, Dnipropetrovsk, Luhansk, Donetsk, Kharkiv regions, Crimea - there were overwhelming pro-Russian riots. In Odessa, they were generally afraid to go out with the Ukrainian flag, there were so many pro-Russians there. after May 2, everyone went silent. and the central regions are 50/50. +- see Odessa : th-cam.com/video/aniF-dBF8Zs/w-d-xo.html
This war will only end with Russia keeping its gains. Either Ukraine comes to the negotiating table for a settled offer, or the West stops funding the Ukrainian war effort. Russia has made it clear it has the domestic production and desire to keep this war going for as long as necessary, whereas Ukraine is reliant on the whims of foreign leaders.
This seems to be reality, Russia wanted what her neighbors had and is taking it by force, such has been the norm throughout history. Only the collapse of Putins regime will save Ukraine, which could happen if Ukraine achieved major victories on the battle field buuuut…..
![Russian invasion of Ukraine 2022-2024 - 1000 DAYS [Russo-Ukrainian War. Part II]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/F8peAwRga3Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Notes: While I show Russia annexing parts of Ukraine on the map to indicate the change, I am not in any way supporting the illegal annexation or the invasion. The war is a terrible thing. Keep the comments civil.
Thank you, both for doing mapping for more than a decade by now and for your human position against this terror, you're still my beloved mapper
🇺🇦 is losing..
illegal according to who?
@@Supernimo735Ukraine is in its 10th year at war with one of the world's biggest superpowers and Ukraine still exists, so I think they're doing alright.
@@FAMEROBinternational law
Everyone complaining about how the war is taking too long and the frontlines barely move
Iran and Iraq: first time?
Nafoids and Westoids doesnt care about the brown people
Western front of world war 1- "hold my beer"
Medieval sieges literally staying static for 10 years:
afghanistan, who had to deal with this shit 3 goddamn times: amateurs
@@jakerupp3840 Chinese warring states: 10 years??? How about 400 years of endless wars
6:23 20 November 2022
9:36 20 February 2024
Just look how little has changed in 1 Year and 3 Months. Yet people are gonna die by hundreds and thousands every day.
Not by day, but by year? Maybe.
Dude Bakhmut fell.
It's like WW1. The best thing to do is not to go on the offensive and try to minimise damage by controlling the skies.
@@nobodyherepal3292 No hundreds die every day at least. The death toll of this war is most likely easily 300,000+
@@stephmod7434Russia captured two cities… and they are basically rubble with nothing to celebrate
Go figure
Can't believe how long this mess has been going on.
Ye
Russia must stop its imperialist project for this suffering to end
Almost two years of this
@@Trolligi Agreed
@@PleasantPark-StarrySuburbs actually 10 years
Bruh who else remembers the first 2 days and everyone thought the war would last like a week with the spetsnaz landing in Kiev
Pretty much anyone who's we even vaguely familiar with the modern military operations knew this would be never an option, unfortunately , since the prolonged war is significantly worse for all sides involved.
it would have ended if russia was competent enough to have enough gas and supplies for their troops. NATO wasn't even sending weapons and Russia still lost in Kiev for their own fault (and Ukrainian determination to fight), and they still had to retreat from north and northeast of Ukraine lmao
We all thought it'd be more of a guerrilla war, not static warfare.
It would have prevented so many deaths, now it will only get worse for Ukraine.
I thought it would last a few months. I just didn't think Ukraine had the armament to last much longer. I expected the western Ukraine to survive around Lviv.
It's haunting how wars are going on at the moment in our lifetime, imagine how our ancestors felt throughout ww1 and ww2
Reading your comment made me think of how young people must view my past. I grew up with Veterans of both world wars Korean war and Vietnam, as friends and neighbours and relatives. My profile picture is me as a Hippy back in 1970! Such is life. Peace and Love and all Best Wishes
They probably thought moscow would fall any minute now
Чувствовали тоже самое, как и в этой войне.
@@pontiuspilot9301Are you a 'hippie' or an impotent pacifist?
О, наши предки чувствовали такой же азарт и ужас как и сейчас мы. Это у нас в крови. У всех людей, не будьте ханжой признайте это.
7:01 February 20th 2023
9:50 February 20th 2024
One full year and negligible changes and yet hundreds of thousands have died and millions are refugees
Thank Boris for ending negotiations
You'd think a supposed super power like Russia, with all it's military might would be able to defeat a much smaller neighbor. Maybe Russia isn't so powerful after all. And the Ukrainians are far tougher than anyone thought. Slava Ukraini!
@@Pnaraasi94 the war doesn't work like that, remember the US army was defeated by extremist terrorists
keep telling yourself that, Russia with 120k soldiers doing pretty good, if you have in mind that ukraine had around 300k, it usually takes a 3:1 advantage to successfully invade a territory and control it, so Russia did the job with only 10% of the 900k soldiers needed. Pretty impressive if you ask me. Plus Ukraine was a top 5 European army at the time of the ivnasion. Did it go as smoothly as Russia planned? Of course not, but it never does, that's war@@Pnaraasi94
The war is attrition, not territory. This requires big battles such as in Bakhmut and Avdeevka.
I can't believe it's been two years since Russia started the invasion. My heart and thoughts go out to those directly affected by that war.
Russian invasion started long before, you can see in 2014 (august 26-28) when Russia crossed the border. You can look up on wikipedia what came after... Ukraine would have won in 2014 otherwise.
Sorry I forgot to include the battle's name. It's called the battle of Ilovaisk. Fought almost entirely by regular Russian army troops. And that was in 2014!
since "Ukraine" started the invasion.
It's a war of attrition that Russ will win
@@tobby12347yea and I'm emperor of China
The Wagner revolt happened around the time when Skibidi Toilet was at its peak popularity. Skibidi Toilet is also very popular in Russia and the maker of it was born in Russia and went to Georgia after the war started. What could this mean?
It means Prigozhin was a turd.
@@timesnewlogan2032 His plane got shot down by Titan Speakerman.
It means the Skibidinvasion has began
😂😂😂
People after drugs be like:
4:20 the calm before the storm
420 nice number
@--------123 me and my parents always knew it would happen, I'm from the West Coast US and was on a plane to check out colleges with my mom. When we took off there was talk of the russians potentially backing down. When we landed six hours later and were back in cell service, the Russians had crossed the border and were 40 miles from Kyiv. At the rate this war is going I'll be done with college before all is said and done.
This is interesting. I was wondering yesterday if you had an up to date video about this, looked it up and didn't find it. Only to see today that you uploaded it 9 minutes ago!
yeah me too
10 years of war.. jesus christ.
What about him?
@@stanleypines1026 who?
@@tvnsoq you blaspheme
The Middle East and the War on Terror: First time?
@@tvnsoq You used somebody’s name without thinking, didn’t you??
Do you think the frontlines will be as stagnant this year as last year?
Yes. This war has evolved into a trench war, after all.
It depends on how NATO is going to be involved. If NATO states keep the current level of involvement then ukrainian resistance will be over in 2024.
Probably not. The win in Avdiivka has increased Russian morale and I think Russia will try to take Kherson again this year. Russia took Kherson in 2022 but then Ukraine took it back. If Russia can regain control of Kherson, it would be a blow to Ukraine's morale considering all Ukraine did to make Kherson Ukrainian again.
I think Odesa and Kharkiv are off limits for this year. But in 2025, Russia will try to take at least one of these two cities. Ukraine will of course fiercely resist. My guess is this war is only going to end in 2026-2027.
They are not stagnant. Little changes there and there, with casualties every day. It's now about who's gonna run out of forces first, not about "encirclements" and "breakthroughs" that HOI players are used to
@@VR36030 Kherson is over the big river. It surely will be taken after Kharkov.
My condolences to the families of those who have suffered throughout the decade since this all started.
И всё и за ЦРУ и гос переворота в Украине 2014 году.
Спасибо
@@SeverKurdне слушай пуйла, за умного проканаешь 😂
@@SeverKurd согласен. хотя другая сторона тоже не ангел и тоже действует исходя из геополитических интересов. 2 стороны одной медали
Thank you brother, now Russia will help us to end this war.
Donbass people never giving up
Eastern Slavs trying to live in peace (impossible challenge)
more like russia electing another demagogue who believes in irredentism and then attacks neighbours
Slavs can't live in peace unless they're ruled by foreigners. That's why the most prosperous slavic states were Austria-Hungary, Ottoman Empire, Holy Roman Empire(Had Czechs and Slovenes) and Grand Duchy of Lithuania.
Compared to Polish-Litthuanian Commonwealth(half Baltic, constantly fighting itself, partitioned), Yugoslavia(Collapsed with bloody ethnic wars), USSR(Same as Yugoslavia but the wars got delayed) and russian empire(Run by tsars who spoke French and had German blood, kept it's people as slaves, became a filthy backwater and lost WW1 despite being on the winning team).
@henrykkeszenowicz4664 I don't get your point when the Ottoman empire, HRE and austro-hungarian empire had bloody endings as well
True they literally don’t do anything else but kill each other and still they are very clear about the “brother thing” or atleast the Russians are. Ukrainians not so much anymore
@@henrykkeszenowicz4664bruh Ottomans were catastrophe for slavs.
I keep seeing Ukrainian partisans om maps like these but I never hear anything about them, could you give me some context on them?
west media propaganda
, @@СлавикСапронов-м3друсский по-твоему чистую правду говорят да
Это Партизаны воюющие на оккупированных территория
@@СлавикСапронов-м3д You're not even trying to justify your claims are you
We don't hear much about them for two reasons: first, Russia doesn't want us to know about them, and second because they need to keep their own operations secret to have any chance at success. That said, I've been following the war somewhat closely for the past two years, and from daily reports from multiple sources, I've heard of:
- Partisans providing key intelligence for Ukrainian cruise missile strikes (even in Crimea)
- Partisans sabotaging Russian supply lines (on rare occasion, this even happens deep within Russia proper, and that's the only time the mainstream media ever talks about it)
- Partisans assassinating mid-level officers and notorious collaborators.
In short, they're doing the sorts of things the Free French forces did, but if you watch a day-by-day battle map of WWII in Europe, you wouldn't really be able to notice their contributions.
(On another note, though many videos of Russian military equipment is posted on the internet by random by-standers, some of it is intentionally sought out and posted by partisan groups such as Atesh and Yellow Ribbon. This is useful for more than just propaganda, it also provides critical battle-damage assessment for Ukrainian long-distance strike forces, so they can gauge how successful their strikes are against military targets).
EDIT: For those curious about operations deep within Russia, I can think of a few legendary exploits off the top of my head. There was one instance where some guy walked hundreds of miles on foot in the dead of Russian winter to sabotage an Su-35S fighter and was never caught (more likely a group of people). More importantly, sometime after N. Korea agreed to ships artillery shells to Russia, someone detonated a bomb in a tunnel that all shipments from Korea must pass through to reach the rest of the trans-Siberian railroad - Russian military logistics are heavily dependent on rails (that last one was probably special forces, not resistance, though).
In 2014 the protests were not only in Donetsk and Luhansk regions. For instance,Odessa,Kharkiv,Mykolaiv. In these regions and cities were a huge number of protests against new authority of Ukraine which had been staying after events that know as "Maidan". But the most dreadful and chaos battles were in Donbass region. Definitely,before 24.02.2022.
Протесты? Протесты приехавших из России людей изображавших протесты за деньги
@@Vicktoor-b1b Ты их паспорта на границе проверял?!
You are too old to be living in denial@@Vicktoor-b1b
@@Vicktoor-b1b В 100% случаях такое пишут те, кто на этих территориях никогда не был. Съезди, поинтересуйся у местных. Кастрюля с головы спадёт сама собой
@@jenpsaki7103дык что с ними споришь? Они же имбицилы.
Exactly 2 years ago, we all thought that Ukraine would fall in weeks and that the war would be swift. Now it has been 2 years since the full-scale invasion began, and there is no end in sight, and of top of that, thousands of human lives have been lost on both sides.
If Russia wanted it to be over in that time they could have made it so, but likely for political/humanitarian reasons (many Russians would see Ukrainians as national cousins and would not want to impose more pain on them than is necessary for the greater good) Russia withdrew from many theatres of operation. Only the battle of Kharkov and 2nd battle of Lyman can be considered full fighting victories for Ukraine. The rest were voluntary retreats/withdrawals by the Russians but still count as victories for Ukraine in the general sense.
@@andrewmckenzie292 That's bullshit and you know it. "humanitarian reasons" have never been a consideration. A Russia that cared about "humanitarian reasons" would not have invaded another country. They would not have massacred the civilians living in Bucha, they would not have blown the Nova Kakhovka dam and flooded the lowlands.
Russia withdrew from many theateres because the resistance of the Ukrainians (who wanted no part in Russias "humanitarianism") forced their hand.
@@andrewmckenzie292Russian lie.They wanted to take Kyiv,but their troops didn't got supplies,and retreated.
@@andrewmckenzie292
You guys suck. Cope harder. If the Russian military was competent, Ukraine would be conquered without many casualties on both sides.
@@andrewmckenzie292 чел, мы видим что у тебя глаз уZкий, не прикидывался американцем
I remember when my father woke me up today 2 years ago and was shocked to hear the news that Russia started its invasion of Ukraine. 2 years later and this war is still ongoing. I'm quite worried for Ukraine's future, since it already had one of the lowest birthrates worldwide before 2022 and it has now lost several million people with the mass emigration and soldiers/civilians dying every day.
blame the CIA, They started all this
@@kipkipper-lg9vl
Boooo evil CIA against super kind Russia
Дякую за підтримку 🇺🇦
@@IsseKonja US openly supported the overthrow of the elected government in Ukraine/2014. As Putin eluded to in his interview with Tucker Carlson if the pro-western areas want to be separate from Russia so be it but the imposed 2014 Kiev regime also applied to those areas that did not support the coup, in effect US was taking the side that happened to align more with US hegemonic interests (ensuring Russia does not become a rival to US in Europe) rather than moral considerations. Ukraine will likely split roughly in half (in line with election results). Northern and north western Ukraine will likely become a strictly neutral state while southern and eastern Ukraine will become part of Russia to one degree or another. US has supported many questionable regimes before, but this attempt was unusually brazen...underestimating Russia's willingness to retaliate.
Hi bro long time no see :)
A decade of this conflict is just insane…
From 2014 to Feb 2022 it was very limited & more like civil war than full invasion
" civil war " :D :D @@777mustdie
ахахах та нормально)
За 20 век было столько войн, что вы axyeeте, даже не знаю, что будет с вами если вы это осознаете
Все имеет свой смысл
Small mistake: you didn't show Belgorod Oblast clashes
Not a mistake, those are skirmishes, not territorial changes on a map.
@@ThaatEpicKittenstill should be mentioned at least as a blurb on the side
Я подумала что это просто шутка,а оказывается что про него даже вики-страница есть
@@ThaatEpicKittenPro-Ukrainian forces controlled parts of Russian territory for at least a day.
@@ThaatEpicKitten they were minimal, around 2-4 km from border for few days, but they were
Thank you. This is much better than going through numerous different maps.
Так забавляют комментарии иностранцев, поддерживающих Украину, но не знавших о ее существовании еще два года назад
Сомневаюсь, что кто-то не знал про существование одной из самых больших стран Европы.
А то что они поддерживают Украину - это нормально. Во-первых, любой адекватный человек не поддержит развязывание войны в любой стране. Во-вторых, они понимают: если Украина падёт, следующими будут они. Если русские массово убивают своих родственников и разрушают их города на этой войне, то что бы они сделали в Польше или Финляндии?
@@Александр-о2о8п о да, начнется хаос, злые рюсские всех хотят уничтожить. Ты переоцениваешь умственные способности этих людей. Им сказали с телевизора или в ленте твиттера кого ненавидеть и кого любить, они слушаются
Даже в некотором роде жаль, что это не так. Европе не помешал бы лёгкий демонтаж
@@Александр-о2о8п Что за бред ты несешь? Они просто не вникали в суть происходящего, вот и поддерживают Украину. Война началась с того, что страны запада поддержали незаконный захват власти неонацистами на Украине, а часть страны была с этим не согласна. И это была гражданская война, где страны НАТО и их союзники поддерживали неонацистов-русофобов. Русские и так долго закрывали на это глаза. Польша и Финляндия нас вообще не интересуют. Там нет философии "маскаляку на гиляку" на государственном уровне и нет притеснений русских по национальному признаку. Да и общая история с этими странами у нас на совершенно ином уровне. К чему эти глупые пугалки? Россия даже с больной на голову Украиной пыталась столько лет договориться.
@@ЕвгенийКарабанов-р6й напомни, кто из государственных лиц Украины философствовал "москаляку на гиляку"? Львивянин Мыкола из комментов твиттера не считается.
Кто из "неонацистов" захватил власть? Даже после 2014 года, когда Россия оттяпала Крым и поддерживала сепаратизм на Донбассе, русофобия в Украине была очень небольшой. Правые радикальные партии набирали меньше голосов на выборах, чем яблоко в России. Никто не запрещал деятельность откровенно пророссийского ОПЗЖ вплоть до начала полномасштабной войны.
Какая тебе разница, каким путём украинцы выбирают себе власть? Пусть хоть каждый месяц революции проводят, если им нравится. Это не моё и не твоё дело. Майдан 2013-2014 не первый в истории Украины. До этого майданы тоже были, но отношения с Россией не портились, потому что Москва не совала свой нос на Украину
@@ЕвгенийКарабанов-р6йда русские ещё с 2013 года готовили украину к захвату по этому чудили в донецких и луганских областях смуту готовили сепаратистов из числа этнических русских
Its crazy how its been 10 years already and ukraine is still holding
first 8 years were mostly just the rebels in Donbas
What's actually crazier isn't even that, but how much Ukraine's armed forces have changed. Back then, they were in an extremely precarious state. They were completely disorganised and badly equipped. Quite literally, they couldn't put up a fight in Crimea against Russian forces and in the Donbas region they struggled against well equipped russian militias. Nowadays instead they are holding off a nuclear superpower, they are well equipped, well trained and well organised. Their command structure is indeed efficient and responsive and most importantly they have a lot of western equipment and training which did pay off. Simply put: if Russia tried to pull off the hostomel airport raid in 2014, Ukraine would not have been able to respond the way it did in 2022
nothing happened after 2014 until 2022 years nothing happened
@@Orion8729nato support
@@Orion8729 There could've been the possibility the West although not in the same extent as now would support them to a decent level where they could fend off Russia.
That flash of the invasion was really scary. It takes guts to stand and push back at that.
Also Mariupol breaks my heart.
Cry more
The people of Mariupol live normal lives now. They are fine.
@@levoGAMES The ones that are left after the battle + forever psycologial trauma and barely rebuilt infrastructure, definitely not "fine"
@@MrIkaGeo They are fine in the context of having survived a war. Come on now.
@@levoGAMES Most did flee this city.
9:32, Fall of Avdivika
*andiivka
You can hardly see it
@@colegilbert673Avdeevka.
@@natenae8635 And yet it is still the most noticeable advance on the map in months. It's crazy how slow this war is going.
@@cuberrt а вы хотели , чтобы она шла так же быстро как в Газе, и погибло много гражданских? Для России не проблема устроить быструю войну, таким образом она может сохранить жизни своих военных, но при этом погибнет много мирного населения на Украине
Если бы Америка не вмешивалась, то всё бы закончилось за 2 недели. А так, мы отвели войска от Киева, т.к это было одним из условий мирных переговоров. Затем прилетел Борис Джонсон и скомандовал " воюйте с Россией ". И то, вы видите, что даже с поддержкой более 50 стран, Украина не в состоянии одолеть Россию, а ведь Россия даже 50% своей мощи не использует
Скажи это 500тысячам мёртвых солдат. Забыл чтоли как наша рос гвардия от пригоженских войск бежала? Он спокойно дошоо бы до Москвы , если бы не Лукашенко. А ты верь , что с нато воюете
От Киева узкие отвели войска потому что там им навесили хорошенько, какой мощи? видели мы эту мощь в Киеве и Херсоне,Харькове, уже была «частичная могилизация» на расие и потери у эрэфии страшные, и война еще не кончилась что бы приписывать победу срашке, типичный соссиянин
Мы дагестанцы поняли
Что русские очень хитрые 😊❤
И ты тоже 😊
Если бы Америка по настоящему вмешалась то все бы закончилось через 2 недели для соссии а не Украины 😂
@@ins-pectorчё то не вмешивается)
There should have been more notes on particular events of 2014 - like, about MH17, about direct russian involvement causing a major turn in the war and about their involvement overall
I see, the video in general omits many events by purpose.
Still, I think there should’ve been a note about the Minsk agreement taking place
US OPENLY supported the VIOLENT overthrow of the elected government in Ukraine/2014. This new regime was IMPOSED on Crimea/Donbass and other areas nearby that voted for the original elected President. In the US/western view they were expected to recognize the new regime that was imposed on them and involved the violent overthrow of their preferred President (Yanukovych). This would be like more than half of Americans being expected to follow a President that was imposed on them by illegitimate and probably illegal methods...oh wait. Seems a bit co-incidental that Biden who was the main beneficary of this action was also a senior member of the administration that oversaw the events in Ukraine/2014.
Also the attacks on Mariupol in 2015 and the Donetsk airport clashes
Yeah, like failed proclamaition of Kharkiv people's republic
The Shyrokine operation is straight up skipped too
10 years of conflict, fighting, war, death and suffering... Humanity never learns...
Only the bigger part of humanity..For the smaller part war meant always business and more money. Those ppl never change.
При чем здесь человечество? Ты посмотри кто у власти на украине
Это путин развязал самую большую войну в Европе с 1945 года. В этой войне уже погибли сотни тысяч, и погибнут еще сотни тысяч, а может даже миллионы. Путин сумасшедший и может использовать ядерное оружие.
@@ДенисД-ф5весли судить по власти в росиси, пора развертывать стратегическое яо
@@ДенисД-ф5в An elected official. Look who is in power in Russia? A thug that murders his opponents. He's been in power almost as long as I have been alive. We've had 5 different presidents here in the US in the same time, while Russia is still ruled by the same autocrat.
Would it be at all possible to summarize changes in the front line at a smaller scale? You couldn't show the entire front but would have to chose segments with important changes. Also zoom in time-wise. I very much appreciate channels like yours or weeb union.
Devastating how quickly people are already bored of supporting Ukraine, not realising that this will backfire on them long term. 'The Great Northern War' lasted for 21 years! This is what becomes of people not knowing any history.
The big question is how this war will be conducted on the Russian side after Putin is gone and someone else, probably more hawkish than even Putin, takes power.
@Nationalistsocialist ah yes "peace deal"
If you want to support Ukraine, why don't you support Palestine? @@TheRealPog1
@Nationalistsocialistbecause Putin/Russia would exploit any "deal" that is done on their terms, not with terms of Ukraine. Ofc if Ukraine doesn't get enough aid from the west then sooner or later Ukraine is forced to do a deal that is unfavorable for them anyway
@@Balnazzardiа у Украины есть выбор? Она на протяжении этих двух лет находилась в невыгодном положении. Также скажи спасибо Борису Джонсону за то, что приказал Зеленскому воевать дальше, а не идти на переговоры
Crazy to think we are in year 3 of this 4 day special military operation.
20 years of 48 hour anti Terorist operation
write to the CIA and ask them to stop propping up Ukraine and it may end
If you use quotes from non-politicians, then give the following: They have missiles for 2-3 days. 13 Calibers were flying, 16 were shot down, etc.
@@messier8379 1. 4 years, in 2018 ATO was cancelled and ukrainian goverment starts Joint Forces Operation (2018-2022)
2. there is no information about "48 hours", bruh
Лишь бы не было войны!
Cmon man 10 years…..
Yes its normal from now
А що не так?
USA 9 years iraq war and 10 in vietnam 20 years in afghanistan
7:53 Wagner jumpscare
1:41 I wonder what would've happened if that pocket near Horlivka wasn't liberated. It looks like it constituted for a major stabilization of the Uranian lines in Dontesk and if crushed would've been a major Russian advantage for further offensives. I mean part of that force is destroyed later, but that's after the momentum stopped.
Then the war wouldve looked a lot more different. It was a complete disaster and it allowed the ""ukrainian"" separatists to get massive backing and supplies from russia which let them solidify their claims. Had that not happened, perhaps donetsk wouldve been cut off and fully recaptured while luhansk would be under constant attack
Он и не был освобождён! Был договор о том, что украинские военные выйдут спокойно в обмен на сдачу Горловки без боя. Русские не сдержали слово, больше половины украинцев были убиты при выходе!(
@@ОлександрЧуєвКакую сдачу Горловки?
Great work. Could you add percentages of territory held by Ukraine. I believe the current break down is roughly 83% of Ukraine is under Ukraine's control and Russia occupies approximately 17%. I know it will take some doing but I'd be very interested in the exact percentages as of now.
It's 82-18
The highest was 20-25% if I'm not mistaken. And before 2022 it was 7%
@@ayararesara6253I read in press it was around 26/27% in march 2022.
Смотря, что считать Украиной. Так-то оккупировано процента 2 в Харьковской области. Остальное уже не Украина.
@@gifer6438Сумасшедший фашист путин выдумал что Донецк, Луганск, Харьков, Херсон и Крым не Украина. А еще путин сказал что Гитлер не виноват что началась 2 мировая война🤡 А Такер Карлсон заявил: " То что путин сказал о денацификации- самое тупое что я слышал"© Карлсон😅
absolutely horrible situation
Yes, but now Russia is helping us now
Donbass people will prevail
@@StrongRespectshut up
Nice video, but i think you forgot the Russian Volunteers raid in Bryansk and Belgorod.
Это событие никак не отразить на карте.
Tell me, which volunteers are you talking about? Those roosters who took over one chicken coop in the village, and then disappeared somewhere and there is still no news from them, they are called ordinary collaborators, traitors.
@@dungeonmaster2111ну че? Появились вести)
@@Mihohoi обоснуй
@@Mihohoi опять с0сут)))
The people in the comments who say Russia is weak or a paper tiger are the same people fearmongering that Russia will invade Europe.
Russia will probably invade Europe, and get beyond humbled immediately. They can barely hold somewhat of a victory against a 3rd world country using Nato hand-me-downs
Lol, they can barely hold Ukraine, let alone almost whole Europe
@@hecate7Russia has no desire to invade Europe, what would the point be
It's just that Europe is even weaker
@@ayararesara6253 no, it's not, trust me
This is insane...
Next: The Israel-Palestine conflict: Every day for the past 75 years
2000* years
@@Alexq79-nope it's started in 1948
@@Alexq79-Israeli-Palestinian conflict is in 1948
the same psychos who like israel like ukraine
@@Alexq79- 1948 when ISRAELI invaded into palestine
This is kinda like WW1 but with drone strikes and missiles.
It's not even world wide
When ukraine got invaded two years ago, everyone expected Kyiv to fall in a week. But, the ZSU fought back and went on to win back Kherson city at the end of 2022.
However, Russia's defenses are too strong in the south and east. Don't think that the Ukrainian Armed Forces can overcome them.
Aside from the Battle of Kharkov and 2nd battle of Lyman all other Ukrainian victories have been the result of Russian withdrawals/retreats to varying degrees.
@@andrewmckenzie292Lyman and Kharkov also ended in Russian retreat. Unless you kill every defending soldier every victory is a "retreat" then lol.
@@prohibitedarea8590 From what I recall there was no specific directive from Russian command to withdraw from those areas but the Russians were pushed back while fighting was still going on so I consider those two to be actual military victories while the remaining Ukrainian victories were "political" ones as they were a result of command from above rather than on-the-ground military reality.
@@andrewmckenzie292 So Bakhmut and Avdiivka were Russian "political" victories and not military on the ground ones since senior command told Ukrainian forces to pull out?
@@prohibitedarea8590 Well not sure about Bakhmut, that was pretty grinding but with Andiivka yes. I am not saying they don't count as victories in the general sense, just if you say have a purely military standpoint they wouldn't hold the same prestige in my view.
Странно видеть переживания иностранцев об Украине, хотя они не знали о ее существовании до 2024 и до сих пор не могут показать ее на белом глобусе.
Странно видеть 2014 - 2021 годы Российско-Украинской войны, хотя в это внемя на Украине была гражданская война и ОБСЕ, ООН не зафиксировали наличие российских войск.
Странно видеть, когда иностранцы говорят, что Украина сражается за демократию, хотя там закрыты границы, отменены выборы, запрещены независимые СМИ и попираются гражданские права. При этом все это разрешено в России.
многик рсаауи досих пор понятия не имеют где и что такое Украина, а ти туи про игностранцкв хрюкаешь
Какая гражданская война??😂😂 Гиркин и моторола украинцы? Хотя бы гражданство имеют?
Украина 11 раз призывала ООН ввести миротворцев на Донбасс, вето накладывала как раз таки раша. Совпадение??😂😂
Закрытые границы никак на демократию не влияют, это буквально никак не связаные вещи.
Какие независимые СМИ непонятно, но раз так сказали по росс тв значит правда. Чё по Эху Москвы клоун??😂
Выборы отменены из-за войны, хоть я считаю что их провести нужно.
Гражданские права вообще смех, на расии такого слова вообще нет.
Проявление разрешёности всего этого наверное в убийстве всей вменяемой оппозиции, в отраве независимых журналистов и т.д. Про взрывы домов гексогеном, норд-ост и прочую борьбу с террористами которых раша и делает я вообще молчу.
А так фсё идёт по плану, попэта зизи
@@MarcusLicinius чего трясешься тогда чубатый?) Не бойся, тебя освободят и будешь жить в свободном государстве)
@eddiemurffy467 Украина это часть России, она отделилась от России только 30 лет назад. Ты совсем не понимаешь что пишешь :)
@@ExAudituУкраина ето суверенное независимое государство и к говнороссии отношение не имеет
Some of those blue dots in Russian held areas of Ukraine, are those supposed to be lakes, or are they Ukrainian hold outs? Maybe cities under siege? Either don't show lakes at all, or else use a different color for Ukrainian territory, it is very confusing what is going on there.
They're partisans
@@rexblade504 I realized that later on, but it really isn't obvious at all. I mean, yes, the rivers are done in a much lighter cyan, but since you aren't ever really focused on the rivers that isn't as obvious a tell as you might hope. They just need to be a completely different color, not any shade of blue.
@@sststr But they are. They're green, not blue
@@jamozmynamoz Do you know in some languages, they do not have separate words for blue and green, there is one word to describe both colors? For this purpose here on this map, in the way the color is used, the color used is too similar to blue to be advisable.
I'm rather surprised that an experienced cartographer would make this mistake. I actually majored in cartography in college myself and made my share of maps. This is a rookie mistake.
@@sststr 🤓
people complaining that this war is long
France and England : first time?
I was born and raised in Kuban (southern part of Russia). I have relatives in Crimea. And I am irritated by the words about the annexation of Crimea. I asked in 2014, after the referendum, and the population of Crimea wanted to return to Russia. Just read the history of Russia.
It is very hypocritical to talk about annexation when the EU and US allowed the collapse of Yugoslavia and supported Kosovo.
@MajinBuu-oo3vn "Yugoslavia collapsed on its own" - yeah, tell that to the people of Belgrade.
"Also maybe Mongolia should invade Russia since they used to rule you going by that logic." - yeah, and the Americans should return the land to the Indians, and Ireland should become free from Britain. I understood you correctly? And the main reason for the war is not the desire to seize Ukraine, but to prevent NATO from getting closer to the borders of the Russian Federation. Just read their laws before the war and stop speaking the words of your propaganda.
I'm saying that your "rules" or world order are just double standards and nothing more.
@MuslimsAreEvil626 Russia is one of the three successors of the Mongol Empire, along with Mongolia itself and China.
@MuslimsAreEvil626 If Russia wants to capture Ukraine, then only its eastern part. You are also talking propaganda, not ours, but your own. No one except the governments of the Countries knows the truth.
I understand that you will pretend that the Russians have not pursued a policy of Russification of ethnic minorities for hundreds of years, have not committed dozens if not hundreds of genocides, and have not occupied Eastern Europe for decades.
@@owoc8260 You have a sick imagination. What is genocide? - it is an action committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, any national, ethnic, racial, religious or other historically formed cultural-ethnic group. Was this in Russia? - no. Around the 1600s there was an expansion of territories, but there is not a single example of genocide (some skirmishes with natives - yes). You can compare this with the British colonies - the British destroyed up to 90-95% of the Australian Aborigines when they colonized the continent / in the 1870s "the British carried out the genocide of the Zulus in the Cape Colony, and in 1954-1961 - the genocide of the Kikuyu people in Kenya." "In response to the murder of 32 white colonists, the English authorities killed 300,000 representatives of the Kikuyu people and drove another 1.5 million people into camps. These are the first examples from Google.
About Russification. In Kuban we speak Russian and a little Ukrainian. Moreover, we have Adyghe, Circassian, Turkish languages and about 100 nationalities. In Moscow, for more than a year, there was an exhibition where there were stands of all regions and nationalities of our country. Genocide, right?)))
Perhaps you want to cite the Baltic countries as an example, but they have a special product for the West - hatred of everything Russian. (They have already lost or sold the Soviet heritage and industry).
I am ukrainian and I can say that it`s not 10 years war. In that period were different wars with different goals, strategy, politics, opinions and so on. We need to understand this to be honest to ourselves. This can help us to understand this conflict better and build strategy for the future that will work. Strategies and goals that were good earlier are not working right now
Уже слишком поздно
Agree, the events of 2014-2016 and now just have WAY different scale and intensity, so it's really one war and seperate wars at the same time
All the people making a major fuss about the loss of Avdiivka, just look at the map and zoom out and you'll see how relatively insignificant that capture is.
Fortress town are indeed not very visible on the map, cunning observation, but it is not insignificant. With every town liberated the morale of Ukrainians and Westerners falls, making the end of this war ever closer
it was the most fortified position in the country, if they can't stop Russia in avdiivka they won't stop them anywhere
@@kipkipper-lg9vlthe most fortified positions in New York (if anything in Ukraine)
@@uralcrusader5621and the spirit of Russia did not fall after the loss of several regions?
@@kipkipper-lg9vl Time will tell, as the only reason it fell was due to a shortage of ammunition because of a lack of western aid. But if that situation changes and Ukraine is properly supplied and equipped then they could recapture Avdiivka and the other lost territory. It’s only a matter of time and there’s many variables that are involved here.
It's been two years since Russia's "three day" special military operation
А кто говорил ,что она будет 3 дневной,мы ожидали месяц-2
Tbf no actual Russian source said that the invasion would be 3 days
Three days lol😂 2
Three days lol
Three days lol
This really puts into context how small Russian gains in the past year or so have been. Everyone freaks out about Severodonetsk, Bakhmut and now Avdiivka, but it's clear from the map that these are nowhere close to making up for the Ukrainian counter-offensives in Kharkiv and Kherson oblasts back in 2022. There have been no large gains for either side in over a year.
True whenever a Ukrainian town falls the vatniks celebrate as if its a decisive victory like in bakhmut and lysychansk saying it still has strategic value but in the end it still is rubble
@@Silvergalaxy7383it’s still a victory, and given the fact that a lot of effort is spend by the Ukrainian side to defend, it raises the morale of the Russians, add the fact that the Russians are advancing in the donbass constantly
Смысл не в контроле территории, а в том что бы противник потерял больше людей и техники, время покажет кто выбрао правильную тактику
@@discordgmail5307 I guess that's valid
У русских есть пословица "Мы запрягаем медленно, но идём быстро". Сейчас наши наступают по пяти направлениям
Revanchism should never be glorified. Just because land used to be yours does not mean you can take it by force.
Eh Israel 😅
France
Это не реваншизм, это гражданская война
Israel is not revanchist@@hopeundertheblacksun
@@randomnessrules4971 Lmaooo okay sure bro
Exactly 10 years of brutal bloodshet conflict in 10 minutes
"Ukraine + Partisans" is new to me. Never seen any discussions about Ukrainian partisans. Got any TH-cam links?
th-cam.com/video/z5ldFj_8kN0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=U-UF9IQ8HHii-UUq
Do you meen partisans which fight against nazy regim? recently they hit the train by Odessa with western weapons. Look internet
Не было никаких партизан, были деверсионно-разведовательные группы, которые пытались оттянуть на себя внимание во время "контрнаступления" по большей части занимались террором мирняка, и ничего не добились.
даже сейчас дурачки в белгород заходят и дохнут как мухи@@vsevolodsalnikov6332
Mercenaryes
It's surprising to me how this war is mostly a stalemate really. Like Russia is literally Russia and has a huge border with Ukraine and yet Ukraine somehow stands
www.youtube.com/@PatrickLancasterNewsToday
Истественно в тупик, столько окопов и приград, еще натовская техника
This is really cool. I'm glad you made this
Hueta🥰🥰
im just a little bit confused on why transnistria is marked as russian
because it is that
Ikr, do they even acknowledge their "independence"?
It's de facto Russian. If Russia takes Odesa and continues westward in Southern Ukraine, then it'll link up with Transistria to create the complete land bridge.
Russian troops are there since 1992
@donttrustthevoices6885 1944*.
So according to your map Ukraine has no allies?
Odd, must've missed the billions of dollars of military aid, weapons, and volunteers that NATO sent.
Odd that the didn’t mention China, India, North Korea, Iran, Cuba, Syria, Somalia etc because they’re sending our country soldiers, wespons money, and ammo.
Crazy how there have not been any major changes since ukraine retook kherson. You gotta remember, cities like avdiivka and bakhmut are actually minor cities population wise, yet all we hear about in the news are these 2 cities, although nowadays no one really talks about bakhmut anymore. That all just goes to show that we've reached the point of a stalemate. With every passing day it gets harder to believe that either side is gonna win this. I feel like this war is gonna drag on for a loooong time, until one side just calls it quits.
with stalemate comes attrition, and ukraine cannot win a war of attrition against a neighbor with 7 times the population and 10 times the military spending.
@johnhudson2210 nato can provide equipment, but not people. And even then the equipment they give to ukraine is in low numbers, and the support for such aid is decreasing.
@johnhudson2210 Китай дал согласие КНДР послать России больше артиллерийских боеприпасов, чем смогла поставить или хотя бы произвести все НАТО. Мир изменился, Юг и Восток ещё спросят с вас всех за опиумные войны, вывоз рабов из Африки, за колониальной рабство. Против вас большая часть человечества, и заодно богатейшие территории с основными ресурсами мира и заодно основные мировые промышленные регионы, вы же решили по своей тупости что у вас якобы постиндустриальное общество, когда вы всем НАТО проигрываете в военном оснащении маленькой КНДР.
@johnhudson2210 uhm ukraine is kinda close to doing so, most of their young male population left the country 2 years ago. Their population is only 23 million currently.
@johnhudson2210 well they wouldn't have to be basically kidnapping people to be mobilized for the 7th time then
А ведь выросло целое поколение которое не видело мирного неба над головой😢
И это плохо?
@@ДенисД-ф5в А разве хорошо?
@@ДенисД-ф5вКонечно ето плохо. Нет ничего хуже чем войньi. Ето не вина детей. Все детей.
thx NATO
7:52 ЧВК Вагнер не заходили в Воронеж, а обошли его
True
В смысле не заходили? Тебе видео показать с танками на городских улицах?
@@gifer6438 ну покажи, только эти видео, вероятно, будут из Ростова, Воронеж вагнеровцы объехали мимо, по окраине, потому что трасса из Ростова до Москвы проходит рядом с Воронежем. Как человек из Воронежа говорю
Since 12 November 2022 is the war in a stalemate…
The war has not reached a dead end. I just moved into the positional stage.
It's in stalemate but fronts changed little bit
Imagine if they followed the Minsk accords, they would have prevented so much death and suffering
exactly, Ukraine is the aggressor
Tell me where in the Minsk agreements it is said that Ukraine should be neutral?
@@Shirley10.russia started a war...
@@Gidochrome Is neutral better than being reduced to ruble?
@@Just_a_turtle_chad Ukraine have choice
That still doesn't change the fact that there are 49 million kangaroos in Australia and 3.5 million people in Uruguay, which means if the kangaroos were to invade Uruguay each person will have to fight 14 kangaroos
Strangely, the author talks about the Russian-Ukrainian war, for example, in 2015 or 2017. There was a civil war in Ukraine at that time, and the Russian army was in Russia. The OSCE monitoring mission did not see the Russian army.
Girkin, Motorola, russian so called "donbass heroes", guys who started all this, they were from Moscow and Rostov. They might be not official army ofc, but these "green" people how they called themselves were russian citizens living in russia before the invasion in 2014. hundreds of these "green" men were sent to start the war which was not civil
@@technolomics4428
As someone who is married to someone from Luhansk: you are incorrect. My partner's entire family and their neighbors lived in fear for many months in 2014 when Russian soldiers began to appear in their city. The city was flooded with armed Russians more and more each day, and slowly all pro-Ukrainian families began to leave the city fearing for their lives, including my partner's family, due to the hostility of these armed people and the wildly aggressive rallies led by these strangers who had never grown up in Luhansk, who had never been to Luhansk before 2014. They were strangers. Locals didn't view this as a "civil war." It was an invasion.
Как же ж так то!?..
Выж за это право - говорить свободно открыто и правдиво - вы угробили официально уже признав это пол миллиона жизней украинцев - за право говорить открыто и свободно, за свободу умираете - за право всем говорить!..
Умираете даже и за нас за русских - вроде как и за нашу свободу тоже свободно умираете!..
И что ж вы делаете, вы мне все ответы со всех аккаунтов скрыли тут!..
Как же братцы так-то!..
На чьей вы оказывается тут стороне - если все те украинцы погибли за свободу и не рабство - которым вы обмазывались тридцать лет и давали понюхать это русским, и тридцать лет трясли перед носом русских!..
Ради свободы которой вы развалили себе пятую экономику и промышленность доставшегося вам от СССР!..
Свобода, ради которой вы открыли западу рынки сбыта и обанкротили отечественного производителя...
И теперь у вас свобода - которой все вам завидуют: - коррупционное, капиталы, рабочие руки, мозги и женщины - свободно утекают на запад...
И за свою и нашу такую свободу вы и боретесь - с нами же!..
И что ж выходит, все эти жертвы и миллион свободно погибших и разрушенные свободные города были напрасны, и были нужны только вот за то-чтоб свободно мне скрыть тут мои комментарии ответа дискуссия!?..
Выходит, тот миллион тех миллионов погибших - которые ещё погибнут за свободу и правду украинцев - они все сейчас на моей стороне - на стороне правды которую вы так тщательно тут скрыли со всех моих аккаунтов это скрыв - и никому не показав!..
Неужель вы думаете что скрытое тут так и останется тут скрытым!?.
Нет конечно, это преднамеренно будет размножено десятками и сотни раз в других местах - повторяемо и цитируемо - о том какие вы оказывается свободные и свободолюбивые - и какая у вас свобода слова - и не желание читать элементарную правду об окружающей вас действительности за периметром информационного пузыря - так тщательно и бессознательное создаваемого себе - и тем кто лайкает вас из корпоративных соображений - поддержав этим свои и ваши убеждения - того озвученного желаемого - таким это то желаемое видеть и отовсюду об этом именно таким себе слышать!
RIP all fallen warriors. History does not and will not forget you.
Я согласен, мы должны помнить русских освободителей
@@messer722 помнить их будет Сатана
conquerors are not warriors, but cowards. Those who resist and fight back truly have the honour of being called warriors.
@@Game_Hero there goes most of history then.
@@imperatorofman yeah, pretty much, but I don't mind.
"All wars are civil wars, because all men are brothers." -Francois Fenelon
Не дай бог кому нибудь такое пережить. Надеемся что это ужасное событие закончится..
С 2014 года мир устал от войны, но мир молчит. Молчать устали мы.
клутой
@user-os3hy8is5t, да миру, вобщем-то, похуй было. Там больше на ИГИЛ смотрели.
@@PanEban это пока война не пришла в их дом.
There is no annexation. In 2014, there was a coup in Ukraine and as a result, new states were formed. And Crimea has become Russian. Referendums in 3 regions were legal. To not recognize them is to ignore the legal facts. And Russia did not come to Crimea. Russia has ALREADY been in Crimea, because the Black Sea fleet and thousands of Russian soldiers are in Crimea even BEFORE 2014.
great copium
The occupation of crimea was the thing that really got me strongly interested in world affairs (i remember the Arab spring aswell, but i was still too young). I have been following the conflict ever since, but until 3 years ago it only looked like a frozen conflict similar to other russian breakaway states like Abkhazia. Then came the big russian "drills" and a lot of people panicked. Many however (including now adult me) thought nothing of it. Russia could not possibly be stupid enough to invade. But then on february 24th the invasion came. We then saw how bad of an idea it was to invade, but they continued fighting. Now the conflict again looks like it´s not moving, but there are way more people dying (or affected in general) by it then from 2014-2022.
I hope Ukraine (and their supporters) out last the Russian regimes ability to wage this war.
Sadly the russians have been on the offensive since October '23 and now they've been breaking Ukrainian defenses like in the Avdiivka direction, Kupiansk direction(maybe theyve halted I dunno) and in the Zaporizhia direction towards Orikhiv. The deaths on both sides seems to be about the same (44,000 confirmed for russia and 42,000 confirmed for Ukraine) but Russia can afford and don't care about losing thousands upon thousands of men but Ukraine can't do the same. Sadly it's not going well for Ukraine but it sure as hell wouldn't of gone well if they gave up at the start of the full invasion when the Russians were marching towards Kyiv
-First Zelenski gets installed, highly likely with the help from foreign covert agencies. The pro-Russian leader is chased out of his country and replaced by this actor who is full on pro west.
-ethnic Russians are targetted to be 2nd class citizens OR shelled even.
-provinces with majority ethnic Russians try to break away from this madness.
-Zelenski tries to get into EU/NATO, which is yet another breach of the Minsk accords
-Western powers are and have been training soldiers in Ukraine
-etc.
-Russia invades to protect and secure the ethnic Russian parts and secure a peace deal that ensures the Minsk accords are upheld. Turkey assisted in this peace talk, but Boris Jonson intervened and promised Zelenski the world after which the peace deal was wiped from the table.
-Israel tried again, but the same thing happened: Western powers intervened. They now for sure have blood on their hands for prolonging this war.
my point? Just countering the many people who think Russia is doing it just to expand or did it for no good reason. There are many reasons, some i consider good/valid, some i don't.
another point: this war could've been prevented if western meddling wasn't a thing.
@@AwoudeXWhat a moron, you don’t even know that Zelensky wasn’t the first post-Maidan president, the first guy that chased out the pro-Russian Yanukovich was Poroshenko lmao
@@danilapolesciuk4316Лично всех пересчитал?
2008 year: Ukraine soliders on tanks joined Georgia's attack to Russia. Of course, "thanks for 10 but not 2 years".
19st Feb 2022, Ukraine shoot Rostov oblast by Grad.
In the 21st of February of 2022, Ukraine soliders invaded Rostov oblast - 2 Infantry fighting vehicles and 5 Ukraine troops was killed.
Facts that you too stupid to see.
"All war is civil war, because all men are brothers"
It's not civil war
6:02 "The world does not recognize this annexation" I don't see why? When the USA illegally invaded Iraq, did the world raise a finger? When Russia invades Ukraine, everybody cries themselves stupid. Like what? I don't support war, but such bias should not exist.
DID USA annex or try to annex Iraq? No!
Yes their invasion of Iraw was based lies/false information, no one is denying that. But US didnt annex Iraq and even if its regime was changed, let me remind you that Saddam Hussein himself was a dictator who started wars against Iran and Quwait and was hated by many Iraq citizens. There are few who miss him or his regime.
Meanwhile Russia is waging a war in full purpose to destroy Ukraine as independent nation and annex it as part or Russia.
So extremely poor comparison , you cant compare the two wars with eachother
Russia cannot invade own people's burth places (literally 1000 year native Russian cities)
there is a real chance that this specific video will be used as a school material in a history class
People have to undrastend world is changing. This stealmate on front was normal many years ago and now by technological progress is coming back.
I was hoping you'd end up making an update. Awful war
The author forgot about the Kharkov People's Republic. It seemed to mark the beginning of the Russian spring of 2014
Another great work of yours!
This war has been going on for 10 years now😢🇺🇦
@@ප්රබූ Honestly, what is your reason to support what Russia is doing?
@@Science_Atrium Им нравится умерать на чужих землях
@@Русландмитришинситх I don't speak russian.
А жителей Донбасса тебе не жаль? 😂😂😂
@@РусландмитришинситхЭто русская земля. Все города основаны в России, Украины не будет.
Damn eastern europe people really have a hard life...
We all have a hard life...
@@raphsam2967 Some more than others.
It's been going on for hundreds of years
@@raphsam2967 Dropping your bagette while going to home is not comparable to warfare.
@@monofnk6581 Some have a harder life than others, but the error many make when looking at a "hard life" in eastern Europe is they look at who is still standing while blanking out literally everyone who isn't around anymore or of whom there is little left.
I am glad you feature Novorossiya.
Novorossiya is very important to the outcome of this Armed-Conflict.
Это такой же миф как и то что Бельгия появилась благодаря России 😂😂😂
The generally accepted symbol of Russia is a bear, and the symbol of Ukraine is usually portrayed as a nightingale. Probably similar scales based on economy, Military size, population, and the like. But the fact Ukraine managed to hold off an opponent that out did them on nearly every metric except morale, is really impressive. Also an amusing mental image of a bird beating up a bear.
At the start of the invasion, Ukraine had a bigger army in the field than Russia, let that sink in for a moment. That simple fact gives credit to the claim of it being a 'special military operation (at least at the start before conscripting and consolidating). They never built up enough army to conquer or occupy entire Ukraine. It's too big for the force they mustered. That also again gives credit to that claim.
The initial peace deal would have Russia withdraw fully again and Ukraine not becoming part of NATO or EU. end of war, Minsk accords were upheld.
@@AwoudeXWhat bullshit are you yapping here? The Russian army was not nearly as prepared for the invasion as it should habe been beacause Putin naively thought Ukraine would crumble under his military might. The insane overestimation of his army and likely his ignorance towards corruption led to this embarasing military failure that is the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
Kiev in 3 days huh?
@@AwoudeXRussia fully withdraw to their new borders that happen to include all of Ukraine, yeah.
@@alexeistrife56 learn to read, in the almost finished peace deal, that was on the table, Russia would've, as in it didn't happen because they didn't arrive at peace.
@@AwoudeX learn to read, in the peace deal that never would've happened, that never existed, as Russia wanted to annex Ukraine.
4:30 Okay, but why is it not mentioned Daily Full Report No. 40/2022, published by the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine (SMM) on February 21, 2022, according to which 2,158 ceasefire violations were recorded, including 1,100 explosions during the period(! !!)February 18 to February 20? And guess from whose controlled territory the muzzle flashes were recorded and from whose side the explosions were recorded.
It's actually a U S A led NATO v Russia war
Согласен
Lmao what. only 10% of Ukraine weapon is from nato, and also first 3 mounths we didnt get any help
@@Frikin_idiotaна Украину с 2014г стали завозить западное оружие и кредиты. И сейчас завозят оружие, деньги, наёмников и разведданны из 67 стран. Назовите сколько спутников есть у Украины или что из оружия сейчас производят там?
I suggest changing the wording of the 30 September 2022 note. NATO countries and their allies are not "The World". Also, the referendums were no more "shady" than any other referendums anywhere else, and when a democratic referendum decides something, the result of it can't be "illegal". I realize you have a bias, but a little less biased language could be useful.
Great work! Thank you very much.
Damn, so it's just been a boring stalemate for one year now
exactly my thoughts tho it's bad that people still die everyday
Not entirely stalemate, Russia did conquer Avdiivka just recently. But for sure it just shows that neither Russia nor Ukraine has had the required force to make big breakthroughs, though at the moment Russians are pushing and Ukranians are having hard time with lack of ammunition, which is why its absolutely critical for west to send significantly more aid there if west ever wants Ukraine to hold their lines, let alone dream of winning this war. At the moment its war of attrition which Russia is slowly winning because they have ramped up their war production while aid from US has stopped for the moment because of Republicans in the House and meanwhile Europe still hasnt managed to get their own weapon production up to speed.
More European countries should take example of Denmark who gave up pretty much their entire artillery shells to Ukraine as well as all their old F16s
If USA would give Ukraine all the tanks, IFVS and their soon to be retired fleets of old fighters, this war could turn around back to Ukrainians favor but unfortunately west seems weak and not bold enough to make the decisions necessary. And I dont think many yet realize the danger of the situation what would follow if Putin is allowed to win and annex Ukraine or even given partial victory.
А где вы информацию берёте?
из головы. очевидно же. карта давно уже поменялась.
This war began much earlier, in 2014 only the hot phase began.
In 1993, I read a document in English, the authors of which were very interested in Ukrainians who were fighting (at that time) against Russians in Chechnya under red-black flags. The document contained a map of Ukraine, divided into six or seven parts, contained photos of Bandera, etc.
I still interesting - at that time who created this document and, most importantly, why?
4:24 suddenly? Bombing Donetsk and Lugansk by ucrainian military forces throwout that 8 years since 2014 don't count?
because it's Russian propaganda, genius. OH NO!!!!! YOUU MEAN A NON-KREMLIN TAKE ON THE WAR?!!??!?! WOW!!!!! LET'S ONLY WATCH RUSSIAN MEDIA AND BELIEVE WHAT THEY SAY ABOUT DONBAS!!!!!! 🤣🤣🤣
A little nitpick about the names - Dnipro was renamed from "Dnipropetrovsk" only in May 19th 2016 and Odesa and Donbas are spelled with one "s"
wikipedia gives Odessa and Donbass as alternate spellings, and they're also more accurate in terms of representing the pronunciations, as single 'S's in both would be pronounced like a 'Z' (see words like has, laser, and applause). using 'S's is clearer about the pronunciation and still pretty accepted, so i don't think they're really misspellings
@@jatgreen2995 check out Wiki once more and you'll see that "alternate variants" are actually "Russian spellings", meaning they're officially wrong to use to Ukrainian toponyms
@@jatgreen2995 "Odessa" kinda makes sense because it's a greek-inspired name derived from the ancient city of Οδησσός (Odessos). But "Donbass" doesn't, it's literally "Donets coal basin". You wouldn't say 'bassin'.
@@ayararesara6253 oh very interesting, i didn't actually know that.
i think i'd still be somewhat inclined to spell it Donbass though. the ukrainian etymology doesn't really work in english (it'd have to be pronounced to rhyme with "base" to match "basin"). instead it seems more sensible to translate the full ukrainian word into english, with english spelling rules, instead of reforming the word from english ones
Can you make a playlist for these(including last years video and the old War in Donbass video)
It's weird to think how this war has gotten so small but yet there's more casualties than ever- at the beginning people were expecting huge swathes of territory and major Ukrainian cities (perhaps even Kyiv) to quickly fall to Russia. Now, it seems like every small village of only a few hundred people ends up being bitterly contested for months before being hailed as a major victory. Neither side has advanced more than 10 miles or so in almost a year and a half.
www.youtube.com/@PatrickLancasterNewsToday
Напоминает первую мировую.
Nevertheless, there were more civilian casualties in Palestine in just a couple of months
You probably don't follow this conflict at all. In the Avdeevka area alone, Russia has walked almost 25 kilometers over the past 2 weeks.
@@TopMusic-rf3mt It's been a year since Bakhmut, and they're still trying to take Chasiv Yar which is only a few miles away. Avdiivka took several months as well. It will take them several years to reach the Dnipro, let alone Kyiv.
When you see the war from 2014, realizing that Donetsk and Luhansk were de facto occupied to a great extent, you see how mediocre are the gains of Russia since the invasion of Feb 22.
Почему? Это война на истощение, вспомни первую мировую. Тут надо не территории забрать, а уничтожить армию. Вот Наполеон взял Москву, но армию потерял и в итоге проиграл.
А если включите мозг, то поймёте что это было народное восстание русского населения Донбасса, а если изучите вопрос то узнаете что весной 2014 года перед референдумом о независимости Донбасса Путин просил отложить референдум, что Путин подписывал пахабные Минские соглашения предающие Донбасс, вам все и всему западному миру спасибо за срыв Минских и Стамбульских соглашений, спасибо что заставили Путина сделать хоть что-то в защиту русского народа.
@@дмитрийчеканов-б1х Среди русского населения Донбасса, которое по последней переписи 2001 года составляло меньшинство, где-то появились новые российские танки, рсзо, артиллерия, снаряды. Купили в магазине хз
if you start at the age of 14, then it would be fair to write that in half of the country there were pro-Russian separatists (such as: Odessa, Mykolaiv, Kherson, Zaporizhia, Dnipropetrovsk, Luhansk, Donetsk, Kharkiv regions, Crimea - there were overwhelming pro-Russian riots. In Odessa, they were generally afraid to go out with the Ukrainian flag, there were so many pro-Russians there. after May 2, everyone went silent. and the central regions are 50/50. +- see Odessa : th-cam.com/video/aniF-dBF8Zs/w-d-xo.html
There is no way Ukraine will get its territory back.
Are not Ukraine territory. a territory belongs to those who live there. it is called self-determination of peoples.
@@dummag4126 and according to the statistics - everything except Crimea is Ukrainians-majority land
Good to see Transnistria getting recognition
The only international recognition they'll ever get. :P
@@FerdinandPaleologus facts
1:12
July 17, Malaysian Airlines flight 17 is shot down.
Why is Transnistria labelled as Russian-controlled lol
Idk
This war will only end with Russia keeping its gains. Either Ukraine comes to the negotiating table for a settled offer, or the West stops funding the Ukrainian war effort. Russia has made it clear it has the domestic production and desire to keep this war going for as long as necessary, whereas Ukraine is reliant on the whims of foreign leaders.
Don’t listen to Russian trolls, Ukraine will never give up her land.
@@Dmartinez117Your running out of soldiers there Ukey.
This seems to be reality, Russia wanted what her neighbors had and is taking it by force, such has been the norm throughout history.
Only the collapse of Putins regime will save Ukraine, which could happen if Ukraine achieved major victories on the battle field buuuut…..
@@Dmartinez117 Either Ukraine will be Russian, or it will not be at all.
@@Dmartinez117украинцев не бесконечное количество, между прочим)
Partisans? At this time of day, at this time of year, located entirely inside the Donetsk people's republic?
Yes!
@@bod-7268 may i see them?
@@Svevsky ... No
Братья Украинцы я полностью против войны! И хочу чтобы она закончилась! Слава миру , слава нашему братскому народу!
Скажу, как русский, не брат ты мне и твои украинцы....
Героям слава