This shows that he is more of an actor than a singer. Rather than striving for the perfect note he instead fills the song with emotion, he becomes the Phantom.
She was a 17-year-old high school student when the film was made; 18 when it was released. How does a 17-year-old learn facial expressions of wonder and terror as she does in this film. And sing like angel. Amazing.
A little trivia: It might interest you to know that the mannequin actually was her. They couldn't get the wax copy to look good enough, so they just had the actress pose completely still for that shot.
As far as I'm concerned, Erik is the most tragic character in all of literature. He loves Christine, but has no idea how to convey it. He desperately wants to be a part of the world that rejected him, and hopes that Christine will be his link to that world. He never developed any social skills, and so has no outlet for his genius. When Christine chooses Raul, He tries to hate her, but can't. In the end he can't reconcile his love for Christine with his own ambitions, and he lets her go. Tragic.
Gerard Butler as the Phantom is absolutely beautiful.. It melts my heart. His voice. His face. His hair. Is it just me, or is it simply wonderful in every detail? Enchanting, by all means.
Am I the only one who can watch this over and over without getting tired of it? C'mon, it can't just be me. When he hits that high note, it's like... O.O
Something is just so haunting and beautiful about Gerard's version. It's not technically good like Ramin's but Gerard's voice is like velvet. This version has something magical that none of us(the one's who love this version) can explain...the curse of music.( and i know I'm just going to get ripped for just saying that but I don't care)
I don't know why people say they dislike his voice. I think it's beautiful. Just because he isn't first and foremost and opera singer doesn't mean he can't sing at all.
seeing how Gerard Butler young was in this movie , I still can't believe he voices Hiccup's dad in How to train your dragon and I almost didn't recognize his voice almost
I knew he was talented, but I never knew he could sing like this, until I saw this movie. His voice, his acting makes your heart ache for this Phantom that he plays so well...
I believe that this is the best song in the whole movie. Every time I listen to this specific song my eyes tear up, his voice is beautiful and smooth...
I love the rawness and emotion and even vulnerability in the way Gerard Butler sings and depicts the Phantom. So moving (albeit in a slightly creepy way, which I think is the intended effect!)
I think Gerry did a wonderfu job. I spent the first thirty years of my life with music.I am a retired concert violinist and I've heard many people sing this song and I can say that without a doubt, Gerry Butler did a better job than a lot of the other singers did in the same role.
I listen to all types of music, from dubstep to pop to classical, but nothing moves me more than broadway music. the amount of emotion that they add to a beautiful story is truly stunning. I saw this live in New York as a young child, and I have never, and will never, forget it.
He got so much criticism but had we (the people) had our chance to vote.. WE LOVE HIS VOICE and his interpretation of Erik... Gerry please keep on singing to us.. we love you,, and your voice.
Out of everyone who's ever sang this song I've always felt that this guy did the best interpretation of it. Unlike all the other people who just sing it loudly and think they can get away with it.
This song has an inexplicable effect on me. It makes my heart swell and my blood slow in anticipation of each note, each word. It's beautiful in every sense of the word, and it possesses my very soul every time I listen to it.
In my opinion, I think Gerard is veri underrated in this role, I personally think he did a fantastic job at it!! I can never understand why there are so many people judged him wiv so many -ve comments...I like his voice in this song as well as the Phantom!! Even if his look is not taken into account and just listen to his voice, he has one of the most passionate, sexy and beautiful voice!! How can others ALWAYS bashing about his voice and ignore all the strength he has!?:(
I just love Gerard's Phantom. So raw yet beautiful. Ramin has a very good voice (an angel's voice) but as you can see, in the book/movie, Phantom had no formal lessons/trainings on opera, so I think Gerard's voice is more suited for Phantom! Loved Ramin and JoJ, too, btw! :)
i watched this movie in choir last year, and every time the Phantom sang, especially this song, i was like in a trace much like Christine appeared to be. I just stared at the screen in complete awe. I'm still in awe when ever i hear or see this movie. Gerard Butler portrayed the Phantom very well.
he's not a sociopath. He's just irrevocably in love with Christine and he'll do anything to be with her. That's an admirable fact. And he's not creepy. He's just intense.
Yes. there is something to be said to be with a man who needs you as much as he wants you. There's just something undeniably romantic about a man who thinks a woman is his everything.
I was mesmerized by Eric and his voice to begin with. Then when I found out it was Gerard Butler...BOOM! When a good looking man can sing with such beauty.
Thank you for this beautiful post. It really inspired me to sing this and also some more show songs. Gerard Butler was awesome as the phantom in this clip. My very best regards.
I have been singing this since I was a very little girl. I saw the show live when I was about six, and was in love with it ever since. Only shows, the darkness is not something to fear, but to embrace and let it betroth you. What I thought was beautiful in the light, turned to be foolish and cross. The dark reveals the true beauty you cannot see with your eyes. 3
He was about 32 at the time and she was 16 when filming began. When they went out in public together, they had a chaperone. Emmy turned 17 during filming and was old enough to consent to the "Grope" scene, we see here...in all it's beautiful romance...and commented about having to wear those tight corsets that the real original Christine, from the 1800's had to wear. She commented that she could hardly breathe at times, after 14 hrs a day in them. Great production by Joel for 90 million pounds.
I have never seen this movie, but I am going to read the book. This song really makes me shiver. Plus the phantom's high note was really great! Love Opera!
This just gives me shivers everytime I watch it; the play version is okay, and I know that's where it came from, but since this was the first version I ever saw, it really touches me differently. :) :,)
Gerard carried the mask better than any of the other actors that played Erik. They are good in their own way but crawford freaked me out and ramin's voice wasn't dark enough. Gerard knows how to be dark and dangerous. Plus....he's so cute!
This song is the perfect combination of beauty, sadness, love and melancholy. Whenever I hear it, I just need to stop for a a moment....and just BE! I was happily surprised to see what an incredible job Gerard Butler did with all of the songs in this movie. BRAVO! I've always believed I would be quite content to just sit and listen to this man read from the phone book (I love his accent) but now I'd be happy if he sang to me, too ;)
She had such a beautiful & soulful connection to him. I would have been more interested in what this relationship turned out to be, more than Christine & Raoul's.
i sang this one year back when I was in Vocal, we didn't have Orchestra, just vocal. i fell in love with this song when i saw the movie, can't believe i didn't realize it until i saw it on a list of movies he was in that this Gerard as the Phantom, and that he did his own singing, Great voice and great performance Gerry!
I like erik (phantom) soooo much better. Raoul is simply the lovesick puppydog of a childhood sweetheart. Erik is the tortured genius shunned and driven to madness by the cruel world for something he had no control over, the man who fell in love with a woman's voice before her, and trusted her with his heart, his music, a man willing to kill for her. Slightly twisted? yes. Slightly creepy? yes. but evil? hell no!
Yes he did. He used to play in a band with some of his mates when he was a lawyer, or before that. He had 24 extra singing lessons to get it right for this movie. ALWebber wanted his voice, a slightly rock n' roll ballad type voice and Emmy sang her part too. She was ballet and singing trained since she was 4 or 6yrs old and is the most perfect Christine ever.
its so nice to hear someone your age say so ! Not that im some old geezer (im 41), but your comment gives me hope that younger generations can both recognize and appreciate the beauty in classical, opera, and other types of music that arent necessarily "main stream" these days. There's so many talented people out there who can make beautiful music, and its so under-appreciated by lots of young people. I saw Phantom as a teenager (on stage in NYC) many years ago, and it blew me away !
for not being a trained singer, Gerard does admirably. I love how his voice is soft and flows over the words. But Ramin has more power and i love his look more then Gerard's. Nothing about his appearance is frightening or off putting. He looks like a gorgeous man in a mask.
SPOILERS IF U HAVE NOT SEEN LOVE NEVER DIES:..Christine didn't choose Raoul, she chose the Phantom. Watch Love Never Dies. Christine is amazing. Her and the Phantom end up having a child. The Phantom is in love with her, wants to give her everything she needs, while Raoul doesn't care. He wants it his way. It's so obvious Christine and the Phantom were meant to be. Even the Little Lotte scene, Raoul doesn't give her freedom. Then the Phantom helps her. (Love you, Gerard and Ben!)
This shows that he is more of an actor than a singer. Rather than striving for the perfect note he instead fills the song with emotion, he becomes the Phantom.
It's hard to believe he had no professional singing experience before this. He's amazing.
She was a 17-year-old high school student when the film was made; 18 when it was released. How does a 17-year-old learn facial expressions of wonder and terror as she does in this film. And sing like angel. Amazing.
A little trivia: It might interest you to know that the mannequin actually was her. They couldn't get the wax copy to look good enough, so they just had the actress pose completely still for that shot.
This is my favorite scene in the whole movie because I enjoy seeing the Phantom pour his soul out for Christine to see. Beautiful.
I had NO IDEA Gerard Butler could sing, until this. It's surprising. He has a BEAUTIFUL voice.
As far as I'm concerned, Erik is the most tragic character in all of literature. He loves Christine, but has no idea how to convey it. He desperately wants to be a part of the world that rejected him, and hopes that Christine will be his link to that world. He never developed any social skills, and so has no outlet for his genius. When Christine chooses Raul, He tries to hate her, but can't. In the end he can't reconcile his love for Christine with his own ambitions, and he lets her go. Tragic.
Gerard Butler as the Phantom is absolutely beautiful.. It melts my heart. His voice. His face. His hair. Is it just me, or is it simply wonderful in every detail? Enchanting, by all means.
Am I the only one who can watch this over and over without getting tired of it? C'mon, it can't just be me. When he hits that high note, it's like... O.O
4:21 "Oh, she just fainted. No worries, happens all the time. No reason to interrupt my singing."
Something is just so haunting and beautiful about Gerard's version. It's not technically good like Ramin's but Gerard's voice is like velvet. This version has something magical that none of us(the one's who love this version) can explain...the curse of music.( and i know I'm just going to get ripped for just saying that but I don't care)
Gerard should just sit in my room and sing me to sleep. So beautiful.
I love the phantom's intensity. If you watch his eyes you can see the emotions he feels and you can feel his pain and love.
He is one of the best actors they could have chosen to play the phantom un my opinion he is amazing! 3
I don't know why people say they dislike his voice. I think it's beautiful. Just because he isn't first and foremost and opera singer doesn't mean he can't sing at all.
seeing how Gerard Butler young was in this movie , I still can't believe he voices Hiccup's dad in How to train your dragon and I almost didn't recognize his voice almost
This cracks me up...she goes from a freshly washed face in her dressing room to this black eyeshadow look during this song... Magic!
"Turn your face away from the garish light of day," Gerard is THE perfect Phantom. Get chills everytime.
I knew he was talented, but I never knew he could sing like this, until I saw this movie. His voice, his acting makes your heart ache for this Phantom that he plays so well...
Gerard Butler will always be the best Phantom in my eyes. Such feeling, such singing *.*
I believe that this is the best song in the whole movie. Every time I listen to this specific song my eyes tear up, his voice is beautiful and smooth...
That was the most beautiful part of the movie. In my opinion I believe this was the most romantic, sensous, passionate and sweet scene I've ever seen.
I love the rawness and emotion and even vulnerability in the way Gerard Butler sings and depicts the Phantom. So moving (albeit in a slightly creepy way, which I think is the intended effect!)
Everytime im bored studying, playing or.drawing, i always accompany it with this music. Cause it makes u feel sad yet happy mood.
I think Gerry did a wonderfu job. I spent the first thirty years of my life with music.I am a retired concert violinist and I've heard many people sing this song and I can say that without a doubt, Gerry Butler did a better job than a lot of the other singers did in the same role.
I listen to all types of music, from dubstep to pop to classical, but nothing moves me more than broadway music. the amount of emotion that they add to a beautiful story is truly stunning. I saw this live in New York as a young child, and I have never, and will never, forget it.
Gerard Butler really does put so much feeling into his singing its incredible.
I don't know why Christine didn't fall in love with him right then and there
sexiest phantom EVER!!!!! I choose him over raoul any day
He got so much criticism but had we (the people) had our chance to vote.. WE LOVE HIS VOICE and his interpretation of Erik... Gerry please keep on singing to us.. we love you,, and your voice.
how can you possibly not love someone as that ?
I fell in love with the phantom. :)
Out of everyone who's ever sang this song I've always felt that this guy did the best interpretation of it. Unlike all the other people who just sing it loudly and think they can get away with it.
I sure would have chosen to sing the music of the night with this gorgeous man..for life ;)
This song has an inexplicable effect on me. It makes my heart swell and my blood slow in anticipation of each note, each word. It's beautiful in every sense of the word, and it possesses my very soul every time I listen to it.
If my stalker could sing like him, I'd be down.
And that is how you bring a woman to the dark side.
I showed this to a friend of mine who'd never seen Phantom and he said he'd never look at Gerard Butler the same way again...
In my opinion, I think Gerard is veri underrated in this role, I personally think he did a fantastic job at it!! I can never understand why there are so many people judged him wiv so many -ve comments...I like his voice in this song as well as the Phantom!! Even if his look is not taken into account and just listen to his voice, he has one of the most passionate, sexy and beautiful voice!! How can others ALWAYS bashing about his voice and ignore all the strength he has!?:(
I just love Gerard's Phantom. So raw yet beautiful. Ramin has a very good voice (an angel's voice) but as you can see, in the book/movie, Phantom had no formal lessons/trainings on opera, so I think Gerard's voice is more suited for Phantom! Loved Ramin and JoJ, too, btw! :)
This is why I'm in love with Gerard Butler.
Re-correction. Respect for a man who sang that song flawlessly in his audition for Andrew Lloyd Webber himself.
i watched this movie in choir last year, and every time the Phantom sang, especially this song, i was like in a trace much like Christine appeared to be. I just stared at the screen in complete awe. I'm still in awe when ever i hear or see this movie. Gerard Butler portrayed the Phantom very well.
He's hypnotizing her :)
Sometimes I fall asleep to it because it's so beautiful!!! And Gerard Butler is an amazing phantom!!
he's not a sociopath. He's just irrevocably in love with Christine and he'll do anything to be with her. That's an admirable fact. And he's not creepy. He's just intense.
No one can play 'PHANTOM ' the way gerard can...seriously.
Yes. there is something to be said to be with a man who needs you as much as he wants you. There's just something undeniably romantic about a man who thinks a woman is his everything.
I believe being creepy was the point. But you have to love him anyway.
Words cant express how relaxing this song is.
I was mesmerized by Eric and his voice to begin with. Then when I found out it was Gerard Butler...BOOM! When a good looking man can sing with such beauty.
I bet the phantom was the only person in the world who got to see THOSE bedroom eyes. I bet even Raoul couldn't get that look out of her. ;)
Thank you for this beautiful post. It really inspired me to sing this and also some more show songs. Gerard Butler was awesome as the phantom in this clip. My very best regards.
I've decided the part when she closes her eyes is foreshadowing for how she regrets choosing Raul... lol
to me this powerful song tells about the beauty and greatness of darkness
I have been singing this since I was a very little girl. I saw the show live when I was about six, and was in love with it ever since. Only shows, the darkness is not something to fear, but to embrace and let it betroth you. What I thought was beautiful in the light, turned to be foolish and cross. The dark reveals the true beauty you cannot see with your eyes. 3
*sigh...never gets old ♥
his voice, it freaking touches my heart each time
Me: I shall be productive today and make all of my homework!
Phantom of the opera videos: Lol, nope. *CAPE SWOOSH*
Respect the man who can hit that high note
He was about 32 at the time and she was 16 when filming began. When they went out in public together, they had a chaperone. Emmy turned 17 during filming and was old enough to consent to the "Grope" scene, we see here...in all it's beautiful romance...and commented about having to wear those tight corsets that the real original Christine, from the 1800's had to wear. She commented that she could hardly breathe at times, after 14 hrs a day in them. Great production by Joel for 90 million pounds.
I've always pitied the Phantom and favored him. I dont know why but he attracts me:)
I have never seen this movie, but I am going to read the book. This song really makes me shiver. Plus the phantom's high note was really great! Love Opera!
This just gives me shivers everytime I watch it; the play version is okay, and I know that's where it came from, but since this was the first version I ever saw, it really touches me differently. :) :,)
Gerard carried the mask better than any of the other actors that played Erik. They are good in their own way but crawford freaked me out and ramin's voice wasn't dark enough. Gerard knows how to be dark and dangerous. Plus....he's so cute!
This song and scene gives me chills! I love Gerard Butler even more that I know he can sing!
I loved Gerard in this part!!!! He truley sold it with acting! An actor that sings rather then a singer who acts.
Always gives me chills..
So wonderful
Gerard Butler, your voice is very surprisingly magnificent. Lovely.
When I first saw this I was waiting for the moment he takes off his clothes and has the spartan armor on and scream ''THIS IS OPERA!!!''
Love this song and Gerard's singing
Gerard Butler can be my phantom any day.
OH my God. How beautiful. What a voice!
i love this version mainly because Gerard Butler can sing like a champ
His voice is amazing...I LOVE HIM SOOOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!
This song is the perfect combination of beauty, sadness, love and melancholy. Whenever I hear it, I just need to stop for a a moment....and just BE! I was happily surprised to see what an incredible job Gerard Butler did with all of the songs in this movie. BRAVO! I've always believed I would be quite content to just sit and listen to this man read from the phone book (I love his accent) but now I'd be happy if he sang to me, too ;)
Ramin is my favorite Phantom, but I will always love Gerard Butler in this movie. He was my first Phantom and I think he did a great job.
this is way too brilliant. just pulls you into their world. art and poetry at their best
im learning to sing this song and surprising my fiancé with it at our wedding reception
I can't ever see this enough looking at HIS face and listening to that VOICE... love love love. That is all :-)
She had such a beautiful & soulful connection to him. I would have been more interested in what this relationship turned out to be, more than Christine & Raoul's.
Ok. wow. he can definitely cure the random insomnia I get at times
i sang this one year back when I was in Vocal, we didn't have Orchestra, just vocal. i fell in love with this song when i saw the movie, can't believe i didn't realize it until i saw it on a list of movies he was in that this Gerard as the Phantom, and that he did his own singing, Great voice and great performance Gerry!
I like erik (phantom) soooo much better. Raoul is simply the lovesick puppydog of a childhood sweetheart. Erik is the tortured genius shunned and driven to madness by the cruel world for something he had no control over, the man who fell in love with a woman's voice before her, and trusted her with his heart, his music, a man willing to kill for her. Slightly twisted? yes. Slightly creepy? yes. but evil? hell no!
Gerard will always be remembered for this movie and song.
Yes he did. He used to play in a band with some of his mates when he was a lawyer, or before that. He had 24 extra singing lessons to get it right for this movie. ALWebber wanted his voice, a slightly rock n' roll ballad type voice and Emmy sang her part too. She was ballet and singing trained since she was 4 or 6yrs old and is the most perfect Christine ever.
Currently doing my thesis and this song motivates me to do my best! I love Phantom of the Opera!
damn he held that last note like a pro!
Gerald Butler was an amazing Phantom. thats all i have to say
I love this song! I "accidently" keep hitting the replay button! 3
God he makes an amazing Phantom. His voice is beautiful 3
Around 3:30 - did he cop a feel? Phantom/Gerard Butler... My heart always bleeds for him, the character...one of my all-time favorite love stories!
its so nice to hear someone your age say so ! Not that im some old geezer (im 41), but your comment gives me hope that younger generations can both recognize and appreciate the beauty in classical, opera, and other types of music that arent necessarily "main stream" these days. There's so many talented people out there who can make beautiful music, and its so under-appreciated by lots of young people. I saw Phantom as a teenager (on stage in NYC) many years ago, and it blew me away !
for not being a trained singer, Gerard does admirably. I love how his voice is soft and flows over the words. But Ramin has more power and i love his look more then Gerard's. Nothing about his appearance is frightening or off putting. He looks like a gorgeous man in a mask.
I love this song so much! when he sings its like magic!
I was holding my breath watching this for some reason :P
This is my favorite song in the movie
Gerard Butler did an amazing job
he's by far the most attractive phantom :)
SPOILERS IF U HAVE NOT SEEN LOVE NEVER DIES:..Christine didn't choose Raoul, she chose the Phantom. Watch Love Never Dies. Christine is amazing. Her and the Phantom end up having a child. The Phantom is in love with her, wants to give her everything she needs, while Raoul doesn't care. He wants it his way. It's so obvious Christine and the Phantom were meant to be. Even the Little Lotte scene, Raoul doesn't give her freedom. Then the Phantom helps her. (Love you, Gerard and Ben!)
Same here!! They picked the right people to be in this movie!! :)