"Modi hates the media, even those that love him" | Vir Sanghvi Memoirs | Barkha Dutt
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2021
- One of India's best-known journalists Vir Sanghvi speaks to Barkha Dutt on his memoirs- 'A Rude Life' spanning decades of contemporary politics and the people he met and knew along the way.
#VirSanghvi #NarendraModi #BarkhaDutt - บันเทิง
"Modi is a selling point for everyone" - including modi haters, they write books on him just to fill their pockets.
Both of them
utterly biased
have pre committed views
belong to fraud secular gang
If I had a penny for every time I heard 'Modi hater'.. The man is doing disaster after disaster and bhakts have only one narrative - all are 'Modi haters'..
Buddy, some of us don't give a damn about him. Our world's don't revolve around him like yours does.
Our only concern is that he is destroying the country - in every way possible.. That's the only reason he is even mentioned anywhere.
@@mrgyani tell that to the two people in this video discussing about many things and somehow out of everything "like you mention -world doesnt revolve around modi" decided to the title the video on modi
Sorry I don't endorse Modiji... However compared to all politicians he has done more good to India than his predecessors... lies is spread by media to confuse and spread fear in common man... The fact is there are forces controlling all of us thru various means and media belongs to those forces..... Believe it or not left up to each individual
Just like hitler 😏
Both vir and Barkha were stars in Radia tapes😇
They made millions but still preach to others 🤫
They are bold,appreciate that they brought it up bravo barkhaji and Sanghviji
@@cinnow Millions 😀😀😀😀😀😀😀 😀😀😀😀😀😀😀
Such proud moment.
It is not only Modi, but we even ordinarily folks hate the media who always takes sides. Professional journalism has been thrown out of the window. The media has really lost it credibility. I stopped watching TV news channels and also stopped buying newspapers. It is waste of time!!
That tells you have become old and may be matured ..media is the same..
@@kavisiddu someone's views about media is distastefully used to determine his/her age. The junket of 60-70 ace journalists flying to foreign destinations, their lodging and sumptuous dinners/lunches used to be sponsored by Govt ( we tax payers) so that they can cover foreign trips of Prime Minister. Where will be their objectivity in reporting issues ?? when they have already sold their souls for foreign trips and bottle of liquors
i thought am the only one did the same thing :)
@@bharatsrivastava3964 You are expecting journalists to live in a idealistic world which even you can not live..
I realized that we need to take newspapers with a pinch of salt by age 18.
Barkha and Sanghavi both were players in Radia Tape. When discussing ' rude life' and memoir , no discussion about it, only Modi, Modi, Modi.
Have you seen the whole program? Don't show your ignorance to all by commenting for the sake of commenting.
@@rahuk9369 Boss. There is no need to see the whole program. The very existence of Barkha Dutt as a journalist is to harm my country. We have so many proofs. She deserves condemnation.
These people Belongs To Anti-Modi Gang. 👎
This Channel is Anti-BJP. 👎
They have Modi for BF, LUNCH N DINNER
Indian media has made journalism an untrustworthy, disregarded almost vile profession
Though sadly true, could not have pulled it up without active cooperation from the readership at large
@@monojdas-gupta5918
.
Yes i agree ravish kumar quint and wire they all been sold out .......
Absolutely...Media peddlers of lies and confusion
@@kamalchauhan5470 republic tv is not sold out….and its viewers like you are the most intellingent people on world
There is such a nice flow between the two... its like two friends chatting about their common career! 🧡
Lovely, flowing, conversation, full of candour and humor when needed!
Vir's eloquence & grace is simply a mark of legends among journalists.
Among the greats 👍👍👍
Loved the conversation. Vir sangvhi should be on prime TV more. Very eloquent
The country pivoted Vajpayee to centre, Modi has pivoted country to the right.
Another astute line by Barkha after,
The media in India right now is either chamcha or morcha.
Absolutely love these effortless insights by Barkha.
Sir how about khasmiri Hindus who excludes from their homes
BAKWAS !
@@altlogodesigns1834 Modi supposed to resettle Kashmiri Hindu's in Kashmir.. what happened to that project..?
@@altlogodesigns1834 what about them ?
Whose chamcha/ Morcha is she we all know from Radial tapes
So today vajpayee has become a liberal 😂😂😂
Librus love dead right wingers.
I Bet after 2 decades these guys will make modi ji a liberal 😂
Both these interviewer and interviewee were minister-fixers in UPA era, as per Radia tap leak. Both were notorious characters in that tap. And now their privacy is under threat - Privacy for Power Broking ? See their audacity.
Shameless
I find Vir always with great clarity of mind and articulation
Alma maters of Radia School of Journalism for a change discussing 'ethical journalism'
Even after knowing that Supreme Court had ruled tapes were doctored..
Those that believe the sun revolves around the earth etc... 😊
@@kavisiddu Vir Sanghavi & Barkha Dutt can pontificate that 'Caesar's wife must be above suspicion' for everyone except themselves. Since when journalistic ethics are guided by courtroom decisions? This is on record confession from Barkha Dutt - she appeared in NDTV show and called it ' error of judgement' for the same so called doctored audios, though everyone knows that she went beyond her brief as journalist & acted as a conduit between DMK camp and Congress, when everything was 'on sale' including ministerial berth. Same is the case of Vir Sanghvi, he apologized for pre recording of his interview with Mukesh Ambani. All these confessions had happened after the so called doctored audios came to public domain. None of ace journalists have ever denied that these conversations had never happened. The Govt agencies had merged the audio recordings of several days in few CDs & in a very technical sense it is said 'doctored'.
@@bharatsrivastava3964 Most of the times journalists are used as conduits by politicians and businessmen..it is not new in India and it is true even today.
Yeah, a lot of mess happened earlier, but what is happening now in the modi era is superlative. And of course, everything is excused by his loyalists as this regime has given legitimacy to Muslim bashing, which thrills a lot of people.
This is an amazingly fascinating talk.
specious arguments, prevarication, frugal in truth and utter lies fascinates few
@@bharatsrivastava3964 🤣😂 only jokers get fascinated with these sellouts
Barkha Dutt, whose journalism is endorsed by none other than Hafiz Saeed ( Mumbai attack master mind & among the top of world terrorist ) and admired her, must have amazingly fascinating talk
Brilliant questions, brilliant answers
Quite interesting and beautiful conversation 👍
no mention of the radia tapes??
Absolutely super discussion in the most civilised manner possible. Hope this kind of journalism stay alive and thrive.
Civilised yes.. truthful..?
@@navazmody8671 compared to current media standards and the fake news spin from the likes of Godi media then relatively speaking they appear more truthful. About the absolute truth who knows?
Leave agendas and pasts aside, leave personal feelings aside, these are two journalists in an amazing jugalbandi
Lol. Ya. Radia Tapes proved that.
@@shankarr8234 still stuck in the past?
@@joymascarenhas3491 if you dont learn from the past, your future is also screwed. So yes , Radias poodle cant wipe her shady past away and claim to be holy now. She is completely defrocked. LOL.
@@joymascarenhas3491 history as a subject needs to be scrapped, which only discusses past
Very good talk 👍🏻
PM Singh was the best. If you want charismatic then you are paying price for it now. Dr. Singh was the silent hard-worker. If corruption allegations were true, how come no one is behind bars. People were fooled big time and are now paying over 100 for petrol diesel and Home-oil at 220.
Really no one behind bars ?? Find out who all r
Dr Singh was definitely silenced by Sonia . Put up in front as P.M whereas sonia would rule with no sense of what india is...
This is a very good watch. Quite refreshing candor for a change.
Vir, I'm glad I'm following you so much. At the risk of embarrassing you, I find you endearing. Obviously you are a wonderful journalist and all that!!
It's a delight listening to Barkha Dutt and her interviews.
Love Vir Sanghvis writing always . Food writer amongst many hats he wears .
Haven’t seen him in London of late …
Amazingly gripping conversation..This is what real journalism should be like.
Really!!
Heard of RADIA tapes ?
Thoroughly enjoyed the conversation between two of my favourite journalists. Keep it up!
@Mrinal Sood haha well said
Manmohan was so democratic that even people like Barkha decided who will be minister😂
Both of them had their careers finished post the exposure Radia tape. They apologised that time. Public memory is short fortunately for them 😊
Comon man just think that's is a democracy time they both go thru that time but another arnab goswami did you see his whatsapp massages which prove most off indians suspesis about pulwama attack this is dictatorship time no media talk about that I can tell you millions things which came up more bad then radiya tapes after notebandhi but media not talk about them we indians from old time to till today making same mistakes there is time in 1970 when indira became most powerful political leader in country she centralized all the power that is main time when big cruptions start in india poltics then in indians system thsts the time when ambani rise start because like modi she finished all local means states powerful leaders so no one can challenge her in party ever plus new cm and ministers she put back in states they all know they only wining in indira gandhi name they all stop doing any good things for there states just always try to make indera happy to secure there seats and we as a country till today paying for that and now our new powerful leader doing samething like indera finishing all bjp powerful states and center leaders if you are young then wait and watch you and me going to pay for these rest off our life country already start paying it even in indera gandhi time media is free they still writing lots off things against indera to let country mens wakesup and now even media is under control they can't ask even singel questions they all got oders from government what debate tonight is on air then all channels have same topic debate because media not let people's off our beloved country know what is happening thats why people's dont know what they are going pay for atleast next 30 years for this kind off government
Comon man just think that's is a democracy time they both go thru that time but another arnab goswami did you see his whatsapp massages which prove most off indians suspesis about pulwama attack this is dictatorship time no media talk about that I can tell you millions things which came up more bad then radiya tapes after notebandhi but media not talk about them
Brilliant interview...love both of them...amazing gutsy journalists!!
That's how it looks when someone is stronger,wait time is powerful than alll of us .
vow bharkha and vir u brought the radia tape! and gave us a little insight of your side of the story .it was a delight to hear u speak Vir with such candor and not over the top criticism of anybody
However they were extremely economical with the truth…
BUT THEY STILL BETTER THAN ARNAB
Very interesting interview, and very informative, especially for those who lived through the 70s, 80s till now. I'm sure Vir Sanghvi's book will be eminently readable.
Why fail to talk about sale of free vaccine by punjab govt
Really loved the discussion between the two seasoned journalists. Enjoyed the entire show. Loved the conversation about Amitabh Bhachan @11:06 and Manmohan Singh's relationship with media @29:51 .. @31:19 .. @31:55
Havent seen Mr.Sanghvi for a long time. could not recognize him in the display pic.
Very good discussion
Very interesting conversation between Vir and Barkha. If I remember Vir used to be the editor of Sunday magazine.
Really loved the video and discussion in an extremely tough times that we live in... looking forward to reading the book...!!!Great work Mojo Story and Barkha Ma'am...!!!
Modi doesn't hate media.... He simply doesn't trust them
Congratulations to you both stalwarts. for such a meaningful discussion.. Good luck to ‘A rude life’. Hope to read it sometime. and a lot more luck and prayers to you both to keep up the fight to bring the fourth estate back on its feet to sustain democracy.
The kind of luck & prayer is poured on them, as if he is not a journalist but some player going to participate in Tokyo 2020 Olympics
What a brilliant conversation between two great journalists..as one who has followed Vir Sanghvi from his days as Editor of the Sunday magazine, I was looking forward to his thoughts on the current issues in India and I must say I was delighted by the quality of the conversation.. very good insights into Manmohan Singh and the faltering UPA days..I like Vir Sanghvi for his dispassionate style of dissecting the past without letting it being clouded much by his own opinions or judgement.. ditto for Barkha Dutt..his analysis of Mr Modi and the reasons for the current disarray in the Congress is also spot on..as for the attacks on both the media stalwarts by the trolls, that is to be expected nowadays considering the current state of affairs in India.
Nice interview
Amazing talk to hear after a long time thank you Barkha, I am not missing NDTV
just remembering , I ve first seen him in 1994 - Vir hosted a weekly round-up in DD.
Excellent interview. Vir is a very intelligent man.
Loved the interview. So much ease, both of you
Great interview
Nice to listen to both my favourite evergreen JOURNALIST, rare to find niw a days. 👍👍
Very well structured interview/ talk show 👏
It's always interesting and enriching to hear you Barkha .
Your provocative no holds barred approach is the adrenaline that the mainstream media desperately needs
One question I thought you needed to ask Vir Sanghvi is why he's so fascinated by the word RUDE
Rude Food and Rude Life
It will be Interesting to know
thanks for sharing MOJO STORY
is this sanghvi that sanghvi of radia tapes?
I can't believe India produced journalists like these two and also Arnab 😂😂😂. Oops that was an Oxford production.
Radia school of journalism ,alumni base is strong 😂😂
Excellent Video.
I liked the video. Very well done
Nice discussion
This guy speaks as if he has rehearsed his lines several times. No hesitation; no rephrasing; no stuttering. One complete sentence after another.
Barkha, you generally do great stories. Would like you to cover the farmers protest more with the same courage and honesty as you have recently covered COVID deaths and the government coverups in India. Wish you continued success.
You are asking too much my friend.. She is a vulture journo.. She didn't say a word about Danish Siddique's cold blooded killing by Taliban. Taliban pulled him out and shot him. To confirm the death Talibanis mowed his head by their vehicles.. But Burkha has no comments..
Thanks Vir for everything.
I have learnt to love indian politics reading your articles.
I can listen you two whole day.
As always, good
True Journalism at it's Outstanding Best ! What an interview ....Wowww !!!
only if these crooks have the courage to call 1st family of Congress as dictators. they don't even have the courage to interview them.....
Very good chat...
great talk. Thanks Barkha for covering migrants and the recent Case of floating bodies in Ganges . My respect for you as journalist has increased
If she had the same lens during the UPA govt. picking their flaws she wouldn't have been jobless today.
Great talk. Enjoyed it
I am buying the book now for sure.. I think it will make very interesting reading
What makes you both talking like exiled intellectuals
the journalists who already crossed their expiry
@@bharatsrivastava3964 ...and youtube channel is their only hope and source of income...How sad!!
Why are YOU watching them if they are outdated 🙁
@@zeenatahmed990 A humble attempt to bring truth about their criminal act of bringing disrepute to pious profession of Journalism
Vir should speak on TV CHANNELS . He is really erudite and convincing and has seen many politicians at close quarters
Vir Sanghvi in his book as memoir shares his private conversation with Murali Deora on tragic untimely death of Sanjay Gandhi ( as per him, Murali Deora used crass words ). The motherload of hypocrisy is; Vir Sanghvi is sharing a private conversation in public domain to sell his book but in same breath he accuses Radia tapes as invasion of privacy.
There is no hypocrisy. The Radia tapes were not leaked for the purpose of writing a book and all the main characters in the tapes were alive at the time of the leakage of the tapes. Of course the leakage of Radia tapes did a great service to the people of the country. Life most of the times is shades of grey rather than white or black.
@@Achintyanath There is an obvious commercial intent in writing the book therefore please don't attach any morality to it. Vir Sanghvi hadn't taken any consent from Murali Deora to reproduce the statement after his demise. Therefore conversation between Murali and Vir remains privileged private conversation which later shared in public domain & it hardly matters whether the information shared is in CD or book. That criticism of Radia tape was also that consent is missing
@@bharatsrivastava3964 Writing a book for commercial intent with details about dead people is very different from creating a scandal by tapping private phone conversations and leaking them. You don't need to believe in the concept of morality to understand that.
@@Achintyanath what is the morality in referring privileged private conversation when the person concerned is unfortunately not alive to defend himself. Can VS provide any substantive evidence to prove his point, what if such conversation had never happened & commercial intent is the only motive to sensationalize the fictitious incident. Had VS made the disclaimer (at the time of Mr S Gandhi's demise) to Mr Deora that any private conversation would be reproduced in future, perhaps Murali Deora wouldn't had used such crass words, which metaphorically it is treachery and back stabbing. At the risk of repeating myself, the Radia tainted journalists of inferior morality had complaint that their consent wasn't taken & the same very question Mr Murali Deora is asking from his grave.
@@bharatsrivastava3964 You obviously hate Vir Sanghvi so there is no point in talking to you any further.
Persons who publicizes others privacy in the name of profession and earns livelihood wants there privacy intact!
Very insightful discussion..The point is that there is a problem with Modi, but what's the option?? Gandhi?..oh no.
"....passionate people alone keep values alive..." Realism.
Barkha do one episode about all corrupt journalist who spoil India.
Pleasure listening to Vir
"The king can do no wrong."
You mean the proconsul turned Rex Namo Maximus ? Actually you could also include the court jesters.
Very correct.
@@sikhasengupta5590 Only when he has no clothes on and praetorian guards are off duty.
And Nero played the fiddle.........
@@SAFFRONINFERNO You corgi are you still at it, desperate to be heard? Didn't I told you to go yelp at somebody else's ankle?
Best interview
Always remember him for his comments on food.
Looking forward to reading the book.
Excellent interview 👍👍
This book should have been a video of Vir narrating the stories. Just like in this interview..
Ok going to get that book. It’s interesting and very on point!
It seems like get together 🙏🙏
Back scratching for old times sake by fellow travellers in the ruts of great Indian journalism.
This was a brilliant interview..
This interview seems to show that even critical policy decisions even at the top most level are usually made by certain individuals relying on their shear subjective judgements and mediocre personal world view... The wish to anyhow gain power employing petty cunningness has overcome everything else in every walk of life, especially of politicians, journalists and, as I now realize, even the beurocrates. This lack of objectivity and, thus, ignoring the meritorious in the society has led to unwanted complications and impeded progress in all spheres today...
You can hate Modi but can't ignore him
It was Karan Thapar who provoked Narendra Modi in a personal interview about Gujarat riots and from there on he stopped giving interviews, because he knows, some journalists would be ready to pester him on that episode at the drop of a hat. There are so many journalists who would never try to understand his side of the story. And now it is too late, he has already made up his mind.
Yes made up his mind to reach his goal
Vir Sanghvi, s business interviews titled " Men of Steel " ( 2009..I think) was a Gem of a Sweet Book.. I am sure this one also will be a sweet companion of thoughts, anecdotes, wisdom from his journalistic endevours... It defnitely wont be..RUDE.. at all..
FASCInating. Barkha Veer keep up yr passion and standards when everyone else except sm like you hv disgraced themselves. You are our hope. Def reading the book.
Beautiful Bharkha
Looks like they are falling in line, slowly and painfully.
Two perfectly detested and detestable creatures.
Media blaming Modi for media's failure
Enriched
Vir sanghvi is like Vijay Mallya of Journalism, he thinks he has some royal class and flamboyance to him ..typical Lutyens(Thali) ka Baingan!!
That is how he lived..you are simply jealous of him..
And a full of lies like Malaya
@@Mysm80 You are also jealous..?
@@kavisiddu "he lived"?? Oh, has he died? And Jealous of Vir Sanghvi...Lol...you sound like his pet.
@@witwiki9008 Are you alive..?
Campaigning for 'A RUDE LIFE'.
If Modi hates media also who loves him. Then, who is godi media of which people talk usually
Vir Sanghvi has been my all-time favorite. Longing rudely to A Rude Life. Good Interview too.
a
Absolutely brilliant conversation between two of my favorite journalists . And will read Vir's rude life. Is there a way to get it signed by him
Particularly despicable to show the buried dead in pictures at the end, desecrating the privacy of the Hindu deaths. Slanting the covid response responsibility to the central government when the state governments did a pathetic job. As always Burka Dutt never disappoints in her Hinduphobia.
Is criticism of modi, criticism of all Hinduism? Is that what makes barkha dutt (and im no fan of hers) a "hinduPHOBE"?
@@KarandeepSinghK obviously not since my comments did not refer to Modi. The photo collage shows a tiny subset of Hindu “graves” in saffron with incense. This sect follows this practice as usually Hindus cremate the dead. Like pictures all over the media of Hindu crematoriums and no graveyards of other faiths disrespecting their dead, the selective disrespecting of Hindus is what I am referring to. Barkha a a track record of Hinduphobia and a soft spot for Islamists and Terrorists. Her justification of the Kashmiri Pundit Genocide by blaming the Pundits would be akin to blaming the Sikhs for the horrendous targeting of our Sikh brothers and sisters during the 1984 “riots” by Congress Goons. For the record Hindu congress workers refused to be involved in that revenge criminality for the assassination of PM Indira Gandhi.
Greater prosperity by Manmohan 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 15 lakh crore scams many not even reported guess whose prosperity
15 lakh crores😆
even burqa dutt got his cut from scams...
Can you name one scam which is proved even after 7 years of Modi govt..? This govt came to power promising to punish those scammers..now it looks like we citizens are scammed again..
@@kavisiddu yeah can u prove 1 hour this corrupt family has worked in their life to support their lifestyle u joker
@@mrfacts6860 All the politicians need money to do politics including Modi..that is why he bought corrupt system called Electrol bonds.. There is nothing new and nothing to prove..
I remember there was an issue of Vir writng an article sponsed by a big company and not revealing it.