love the scene (music) in season 2 with the elegant ladies walking into B-Altman and then in comes Suzie stomping out a cigarette on the floor searching for Midge
The entire Catskills episode is a work of art, how the different families arrive, it's end to end genius. The cinematography on the show is next level.
Yeah and Suzy Meyerson walking around with her plunger, and she even ended up naming the plunger..... that was a funny episode, but they are all funny.
My GOSH Tony Shalhoub is gracious. For his favorite scene to shoot, after complimenting the show as a whole, he chose the one where Brosnahan was shining and he was barely present. For the Emmy he was awarded, he credited the costume designer. Be like Tony Shalhoub.
My favorite line will always be Abe’s when he’s chastising Joel in the bedroom for being unfaithful to Midge. “Nothing. You call me nothing. You don’t talk to me or look at me. If you see me on the street, you will cross the street whether or not there is a crosswalk present. Your pedestrian safety is of no importance to me anymore.” I have used this line so many times. 😂😂😂😂
The "secret sauce" is the compassion for all the characters on the show. They are all lovingly written and acted. No one is a trope of some political agenda. You almost instantly want to consider them family. That is rare.
One of the things I love about this show is how artful the scenes are made and enacted. Some of the scenes feel like a musical or a play. Truly magnificent!
This show is truly earnest, and that's not very common. Also, not a single character exists solely as a device to forward the story. They each have room to breathe, to grow, to exist, to evolve. One thing that struck me immediately was how the show dealt with the Joel/Midge situation. So many other writers and creators would have used it merely as inspiration for Midge to get her comedy start, then simply cast Joel aside. But life is more complicated than that. Love is more complex than that. Joel is flawed, but he isn't evil. He loves her, and she loves him. Like life, there are no easy answers.
@@Tina-qp7py And you're at liberty to hate his character all you want, of course. But the creators didn't play it safe or easy by turning their back on him or the complex feelings that exist between him and Midge. Like him or not, that's one example of what sets this show apart.
After reflecting on your response, I realized I don't like the script. Joel, Abe and Rose are indefensible in their irresponsible behaviors. Abe quits his job with no plan, losing their home, and Rose refuses to stand up for herself with her relatives to secure her financial future and their income from the trust. None of these plot points have anything to do with Midge's journey as a comedian. The parents and the ex- husband are weak, and I don't care about their characters. Their acting is great but doesn't make their story any more palatable. Also, the whole sub plot about Joel's club in Chinatown is unnecessary. I want to see more about the world of comedians in that era which excluded women and how Midge handled it. Also, I hate it when the script doesn't let Midge finish her comedy set and I miss the jokes.
@@Tina-qp7py To be sure, a few of the plot points this season were less compelling than others. (While I'm still curious to see Joel's character progress, the nightclub story never really got off the ground.) But your notion that the side plots-especially those of her parents-have nothing to do with Midge or her comedy career, I'm going to respectfully disagree with. I think they have everything to do with it. Midge beginning a career in comedy is a lightning rod in the world of the show. It's THE event that sets other events in motion and keeps them moving. Midge is learning she is both like and unlike her parents. Her parents are learning they are like and unlike their daughter. Her father, while practical and manic, sees through the insufferable phonies in his field and aspires to precision, perfection, and meaning. Much like his daughter, he suffers no fools and refuses to settle. And Midge opens his eyes to how he's lost touch with the sociopolitical climate he claims to care so much about. And her mother? While she also likes the stability and reliability (to a degree) of an ordered life, she will not be pinned down, and bucks against her restraints when pushed too far-also like Midge. Nearly all of Midge's comedy career and joke writing is her working out her life experience onstage. Unpacking, contemplating, reflecting. It's quite literally art imitating life. We see where Midge's head is when she's behind the mic. (Obviously, we the viewers can more easily tell it's a team of polished show writers at work when Midge riffs so perfectly off of something that has JUST happened to her moments before she takes the stage. But we're willing to suspend disbelief, because the show story lines are much better suited for TV episodes when framed neatly in this way.) I think you sell this show sort if you describe it simply as a woman who becomes a comic...and also her family is in the show, too. No, no. The show is about how one tiny little world is upended-and will never be the same-because one woman did the absolutely unexpected. Like ripples in the water, that inconceivable decision changes all those around her. And the spreading waves create new ones, some of which head back toward Midge herself. Everything is connected. It's all one story.
This show really fires on all cylinders its such a well oiled machine. I love the characters, the cinematography, music, fashion, dialougue, everything.
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is an excellent show!! There is not one cast member who is expendable...they all add their flavor to the show!! The interaction between the Weismans is priceless! My wife and I are breathlessly waiting for the 4th season.
Tony Shalhoub is so humble, polite and attentive even though he is such a big celebrity. In film and on stage. He could really be a lot more arrogant. That's why he has so many fans. I am one of them. 😇
Also the secret of the mass success is the message that failure is a normal part of life. If you grow up thinking failure is not an option and suddenly you see the characters going through various crises and still coping in certain ways, adjusting and moving on, it's so liberating! It's like forgiveness to yourself - ok I failed but I'm moving on. And also encouragement- if those characters got through soo much, my problems are not really that big. It's amazing in the way that series can change people's lives, it's like a TV version of counselling ♡♡♡
The woman used to get out of bed like 90 minutes before her husband woke up to put on makeup and do her hair: I'm gonna pass on that level of "fussing," thanks.
It reminded me so much of my late father. He didn’t wear a romper but he was strict about exercising daily; so many of those exercises looked like what my dad would have done! I think it was ingrained from his military background. So cool! Romper Aerobics by Tony/Abe… it would sell!!
Some of it to me, is educational! I really didn't realize how great comics like Lenny Bruce, Mama Mabley were really like! Watching them on TH-cam. Catskills scene for the families!
Absolutely love the entire family. Midge is a brave, funny, badass. Rose and Abe have a dynamic that is completely priceless. Midge and Susie need each other to grow. Joel’s gone from a nervous kid to a solid, loveable man. Benjamin is freakishly, weirdly, imperfectly perfect. I worry about Astrid having a nervous breakdown. Moishe and Shirley drive me mad, but their hearts are always in the right place. And OmG Lenny Bruce. I love his irreverence and the banter with Midge is pure chemistry resulting in GOLD. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Why is this show so beloved? Because Amy-Sherman-Palladino writes storytelling without the dark cloud following you throughout. Do viewers searching for something new to watch think , “Oh boy, death, violence, drugs, betrayal, murder, evil plots. Let’s watch!” Mrs. Maisel is multi-faceted. Sure, it has death, violence, drugs, betrayal, murder, and even evil plots (Sophie). But look up “entertainment” in the dictionary. They’re soon to add Ms. Palladino’s name!
We love this show. It’s got it all. The humour, sharp wit and repartee and those cringy moments that makes you feel uncomfortable and want to cover your eyes and ears. “ please God don’t let her say ……..” Brilliant Brilliant Brilliant clever writing. There are no weak characters. Abe and Rose slay me. I’m in love with Rose. ❤️
Not to give anything away so I'll be vague here but as the plane flew away in Season 3...I didn't realize that there were no more Seasons. I can't wait for Season 4. This cast is fantastic and Brosnahan is just unbelievably good.
My mother was from the Pocono Mountains and though I’d never been to the Catskills they seemed to be somewhat similar during the time period of the 50’s and 60’s .
Does tony knows how famous he is ?? But tbh the writer is the reason for the show’s success in my opinion from gg she knows how to write characters that you would get invested in , she knows how to build up relationships , her realistic lines , THE HUMOR put on top of all of that the fact that each actor in that show is GREAT !! no cringey acting *expect for u know who* , perfect line delivery great chemistry, perfect!! every thing is just perfect thats why its so successful
I absolutely love the principal characters and just want to hug them. You want so badly for things to work out for Midge that it is more than a bit taxing emotionally. If I ever have a nervous breakdown, it'll be watching this program.
I think the characters in the show really are relatable to so many people. Life generally DOESN'T turn out like you thought it would. I didn't think I'd be a divorcee, then a widow, with 4 sons. But that's what happened. And something about watching Midge makes me feel brave and I'm NOT brave. I have to work really hard but I kind of think of her in that first episode especially and I won't compromise doing work that makes me happy. I'm an artist and a spell candle maker and I have a really really cool work life like she does but it's not without it's trial and error and failure. "Starving artist" is a real thing and like her I have to just work and work and work and when you finally start to see the fruits of all that labor and failure and then success the feeling is unmatched by anything.
The humor is just awesome. Especially in a time that it’s so needed. With covid, loves ones passing away. My mother passed in June, if she had seen this show I think it would have made her end much easier. I just happened upon it a week ago by accident, it certainly has brightened my disposition. Watched the first Catskills episode last night look forward for more tonight. Great show. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻.
Susie's plunger was a wonderful cast member and we shall never forget it!
Laughed out loud at your comment 😁😁😁
Pamela!
Pam!!
love the scene (music) in season 2 with the elegant ladies walking into B-Altman and then in comes Suzie stomping out a cigarette on the floor searching for Midge
The entire Catskills episode is a work of art, how the different families arrive, it's end to end genius. The cinematography on the show is next level.
I agree! It's mesmerizing!
Yeah and Suzy Meyerson walking around with her plunger, and she even ended up naming the plunger..... that was a funny episode, but they are all funny.
@@mudwiser1391 Ah yes, the birth of the plumber joke. Definitely my favorite.
I agree. It's a favorite of mine.
@@mudwiser1391 I think she is the best character in the show.
Tony shalhoub might be the most underrated actor of all time.
Yes, but if he were "bigger" he might not get the same kinds of "craft" roles he gets. Monk. The alien shopkeeper in MIB. Stuff like that.
No, the most underrated actor is some person you and I have never heard of.
I honestly only knew him from Spy Kids...
Im sure he’s won a tony no?
@@ChannelBecauseIHave2 dont forget paulie❤😩
My GOSH Tony Shalhoub is gracious. For his favorite scene to shoot, after complimenting the show as a whole, he chose the one where Brosnahan was shining and he was barely present. For the Emmy he was awarded, he credited the costume designer. Be like Tony Shalhoub.
My favorite line will always be Abe’s when he’s chastising Joel in the bedroom for being unfaithful to Midge.
“Nothing. You call me nothing. You don’t talk to me or look at me. If you see me on the street, you will cross the street whether or not there is a crosswalk present. Your pedestrian safety is of no importance to me anymore.”
I have used this line so many times. 😂😂😂😂
The "secret sauce" is the compassion for all the characters on the show. They are all lovingly written and acted. No one is a trope of some political agenda. You almost instantly want to consider them family. That is rare.
Very well said, David, I couldn't agree more!
Yeah, I couldn't hate a single character for more than a few episodes at a time! Lovely characters!🥰
What a show!! Her wardrobe is off the charts!
HAAHHAHAAH is that actually your name
Ikr?
One of the things I love about this show is how artful the scenes are made and enacted. Some of the scenes feel like a musical or a play. Truly magnificent!
I think the biggest proof, that Tony Shaloub is a fantastic actor is that during Mrs Maisel I never think awwww look Monk seems much healthier now
great comment, and i know what you mean.
YES!!
when he was at the beach with that one guy, i kept trying to see him as monk and i couldn’t!
@@lucybarrera6980 imagine Monk in the romper 😂.
Well said!
This show is truly earnest, and that's not very common. Also, not a single character exists solely as a device to forward the story. They each have room to breathe, to grow, to exist, to evolve. One thing that struck me immediately was how the show dealt with the Joel/Midge situation. So many other writers and creators would have used it merely as inspiration for Midge to get her comedy start, then simply cast Joel aside. But life is more complicated than that. Love is more complex than that. Joel is flawed, but he isn't evil. He loves her, and she loves him. Like life, there are no easy answers.
Joel is a jerk not just flawed. He had a wonderful marriage with Midge which wasn't important to him. No sympathy.
@@Tina-qp7py And you're at liberty to hate his character all you want, of course. But the creators didn't play it safe or easy by turning their back on him or the complex feelings that exist between him and Midge. Like him or not, that's one example of what sets this show apart.
After reflecting on your response, I realized I don't like the script. Joel, Abe and Rose are indefensible in their irresponsible behaviors. Abe quits his job with no plan, losing their home, and Rose refuses to stand up for herself with her relatives to secure her financial future and their income from the trust. None of these plot points have anything to do with Midge's journey as a comedian. The parents and the ex- husband are weak, and I don't care about their characters. Their acting is great but doesn't make their story any more palatable. Also, the whole sub plot about Joel's club in Chinatown is unnecessary. I want to see more about the world of comedians in that era which excluded women and how Midge handled it. Also, I hate it when the script doesn't let Midge finish her comedy set and I miss the jokes.
Absolutely. I completely resonate with your thoughts.
@@Tina-qp7py To be sure, a few of the plot points this season were less compelling than others. (While I'm still curious to see Joel's character progress, the nightclub story never really got off the ground.) But your notion that the side plots-especially those of her parents-have nothing to do with Midge or her comedy career, I'm going to respectfully disagree with. I think they have everything to do with it. Midge beginning a career in comedy is a lightning rod in the world of the show. It's THE event that sets other events in motion and keeps them moving. Midge is learning she is both like and unlike her parents. Her parents are learning they are like and unlike their daughter. Her father, while practical and manic, sees through the insufferable phonies in his field and aspires to precision, perfection, and meaning. Much like his daughter, he suffers no fools and refuses to settle. And Midge opens his eyes to how he's lost touch with the sociopolitical climate he claims to care so much about. And her mother? While she also likes the stability and reliability (to a degree) of an ordered life, she will not be pinned down, and bucks against her restraints when pushed too far-also like Midge. Nearly all of Midge's comedy career and joke writing is her working out her life experience onstage. Unpacking, contemplating, reflecting. It's quite literally art imitating life. We see where Midge's head is when she's behind the mic. (Obviously, we the viewers can more easily tell it's a team of polished show writers at work when Midge riffs so perfectly off of something that has JUST happened to her moments before she takes the stage. But we're willing to suspend disbelief, because the show story lines are much better suited for TV episodes when framed neatly in this way.) I think you sell this show sort if you describe it simply as a woman who becomes a comic...and also her family is in the show, too. No, no. The show is about how one tiny little world is upended-and will never be the same-because one woman did the absolutely unexpected. Like ripples in the water, that inconceivable decision changes all those around her. And the spreading waves create new ones, some of which head back toward Midge herself. Everything is connected. It's all one story.
Just watched this again. Great! Thank you!
This show really fires on all cylinders its such a well oiled machine. I love the characters, the cinematography, music, fashion, dialougue, everything.
They forgot to mention the music, that's what helps to take everyone back to those times.... Love the show!!!!
“It’s comedy or cabbage “ its such a beautiful episode! Loved everything about it
My favourite too
That last scene of lenny ughhhh kind of break my heart 🥺🥺🥺
Tony Shalhoubs voice - so soft and pleasant, I could drown in 🌈
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is an excellent show!! There is not one cast member who is expendable...they all add their flavor to the show!! The interaction between the Weismans is priceless! My wife and I are breathlessly waiting for the 4th season.
if you tell me they're father & daughter in real life, I would believe it. That's how great the casting and acting are in this show.
My husband and me love this show, and my husband is a huge fan of Tony. I love his character
I've loved Tony Shaloub since Wings. Everything he does is fantastic.
The writing and acting in this show is brilliant.
I wish there were bloopers available from the show.
there are now
@@ed93435 Are you talking about the one in this video, or are there others somewhere else?
@@MewWolf5 the show in general
@@ed93435 I haven't seen the bloopers. Are they on Prime or have they been posted on social media or something?
@@MewWolf5 TH-cam
Watching these two incredible actors discussing the show and the characters they play is completely mesmerizing. I love this show so much.
He's always in the character of Abe 😂😁
Alex Borstein is also rather "Susie" every time she's being interviewed.
Great series wonderful acting and personifies the era.
The depth of this show is brilliant! Funny, timeless,just a great show can't wait till season 4!!
Tony Shalhoub is so humble, polite and attentive even though he is such a big celebrity. In film and on stage. He could really be a lot more arrogant. That's why he has so many fans. I am one of them. 😇
Amy Sherman-Palladino gets the BEST people on her shows, the cast of Gilmore girls has the same respect for each other, it’s amazing to see
The best show. Not a ringer in the bunch; great cast, smart writing, delirious score. And so insightful. Love it, love it, love it!
mad men walked so midge could RUN
Hahahahahaha
midge is fantastic...
...but mad men is still the best sry
cptunicorn thats what zoe is saying too
Rachel Brosnahan is stunningly beautiful. Her personality adds to her beauty!
I loved the telling Abe she’s working scene. He was satisfied and relieved. Lol
Also the secret of the mass success is the message that failure is a normal part of life. If you grow up thinking failure is not an option and suddenly you see the characters going through various crises and still coping in certain ways, adjusting and moving on, it's so liberating! It's like forgiveness to yourself - ok I failed but I'm moving on. And also encouragement- if those characters got through soo much, my problems are not really that big. It's amazing in the way that series can change people's lives, it's like a TV version of counselling ♡♡♡
Loved Abe’s arch!! Tony 😍
Thats one of my favourite too. The scene where Midge goes in for her first day of work and Abe makes sure she has everything.
I LOVE this show so much! Both of you are fantastic!!!
She's absolutely gorgeous! I am so enamored by classic fashion. Im a total retro girl and think women should fuss over themselves :)
same
The woman used to get out of bed like 90 minutes before her husband woke up to put on makeup and do her hair: I'm gonna pass on that level of "fussing," thanks.
I just started watching this show a few weeks ago and wow I LOVE IT! Thank you Amazon. I adore Rachel, she is AMAZING!.
The Romper scene is channeling his inner Jack Lalanne! He did a regular studio calisthenics exercise show every day on B&W TV!
It reminded me so much of my late father. He didn’t wear a romper but he was strict about exercising daily; so many of those exercises looked like what my dad would have done! I think it was ingrained from his military background. So cool! Romper Aerobics by Tony/Abe… it would sell!!
One of my favorite moments was when Midge got in trouble for coming home late - am happy they also loved that scene 🤣❤
Loved to see their father daughter relationship ❤️❤️
I loved Tony Shalhoub in Wings and now in this!!
Monk was also outstanding.
Some of it to me, is educational! I really didn't realize how great comics like Lenny Bruce, Mama Mabley were really like! Watching them on TH-cam. Catskills scene for the families!
Absolutely love the entire family. Midge is a brave, funny, badass. Rose and Abe have a dynamic that is completely priceless. Midge and Susie need each other to grow. Joel’s gone from a nervous kid to a solid, loveable man. Benjamin is freakishly, weirdly, imperfectly perfect. I worry about Astrid having a nervous breakdown. Moishe and Shirley drive me mad, but their hearts are always in the right place. And OmG Lenny Bruce. I love his irreverence and the banter with Midge is pure chemistry resulting in GOLD. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Why is this show so beloved? Because Amy-Sherman-Palladino writes storytelling without the dark cloud following you throughout. Do viewers searching for something new to watch think , “Oh boy, death, violence, drugs, betrayal, murder, evil plots. Let’s watch!” Mrs. Maisel is multi-faceted. Sure, it has death, violence, drugs, betrayal, murder, and even evil plots (Sophie). But look up “entertainment” in the dictionary. They’re soon to add Ms. Palladino’s name!
tony is so elegant and charming!
I hate soaps, BUT if Mrs' Maisel was on every day I'd be there !!! Most fun I had in yrs. Thanks.
Rachael and Tony THANK YOU! For emodying a daughter/father crisis so well.
We love this show. It’s got it all. The humour, sharp wit and repartee and those cringy moments that makes you feel uncomfortable and want to cover your eyes and ears. “ please God don’t let her say ……..” Brilliant Brilliant Brilliant clever writing. There are no weak characters. Abe and Rose slay me. I’m in love with Rose. ❤️
That was better than 90% of these celebrity things.
Hats off to the work by tony... He's effortless.. 🌸🌸
I really love that they include so much of the people surrounding Midge.
This show is literally a gift. 👌🏼
LOVE THE FABULOUS DRESSES
Fantastic show, love the whole cast
Bravo 2 d cast & crew! Kudos esp. to Rachel ... 👏
Love the show, love them!!!! ❤️
I'm so excited for season 4 for everyone involved... the writers, the director, the actors, and everyone
Not to give anything away so I'll be vague here but as the plane flew away in Season 3...I didn't realize that there were no more Seasons. I can't wait for Season 4. This cast is fantastic and Brosnahan is just unbelievably good.
Безукоризненно все!Чудесный сериал,спасибо!
Such a wonderful cast, with everyone bringing something worthwhile to the table...well done all of you ..
My mother was from the Pocono Mountains and though I’d never been to the Catskills they seemed to be somewhat similar during the time period of the 50’s and 60’s .
actually they were very similar Im only 17 but ive been to the Catskills several times and it looked similar
Does tony knows how famous he is ?? But tbh the writer is the reason for the show’s success in my opinion from gg she knows how to write characters that you would get invested in , she knows how to build up relationships , her realistic lines , THE HUMOR put on top of all of that the fact that each actor in that show is GREAT !! no cringey acting *expect for u know who* , perfect line delivery great chemistry, perfect!! every thing is just perfect thats why its so successful
I'm missing something, what do you mean 'for you know who'?
Manon Duvic joel , that guy cant act 🤷🏻♀️
Love MMM - it's a breathe of fresh air at this turbulant time.
Beautiful colours, clothes.
Quirky. 👍
I just love these 2 so much
i just love the whole 50's vibes
Rachel is an amazing actress she is really amazing in this series
She has the most beautiful eyes. She needs to be cast in a huge movie. I love her.
I love this series 🥰 fantastic casts, characters, costume, setting, HUMOR!!!... fantastic everything!
The best show ever! Love love love everyone and everything about it
My wife and I both love the show, and we NEVER like the same things.
We love all of your characters so so much!
It’s hysterical, it’s smart, it’s perfect
This show is sooo good
The romper is like the ones Jack LeLane used to wear on his exercise show...years ago. Except he wore black, I think.
Abe looks like Jack Lalanne in that jumper... yes, I'm dating myself! 😊
Yeah! you're right I remember him too
Love Suzie. There's too many scenes to mention where her character cracked me up.
Brilliant actors/comedians!
The clothes are beautiful.
Also the show has a great music.
The romper scene is the best!
Love the interview, love the show!!!! Rachael and Tony are great 👍😁
Great actors. Nostalgia
Love all the B Altman shots. Grand department store.
I absolutely love the principal characters and just want to hug them. You want so badly for things to work out for Midge that it is more than a bit taxing emotionally. If I ever have a nervous breakdown, it'll be watching this program.
Unrecognizable!
I think the characters in the show really are relatable to so many people. Life generally DOESN'T turn out like you thought it would. I didn't think I'd be a divorcee, then a widow, with 4 sons. But that's what happened. And something about watching Midge makes me feel brave and I'm NOT brave. I have to work really hard but I kind of think of her in that first episode especially and I won't compromise doing work that makes me happy. I'm an artist and a spell candle maker and I have a really really cool work life like she does but it's not without it's trial and error and failure. "Starving artist" is a real thing and like her I have to just work and work and work and when you finally start to see the fruits of all that labor and failure and then success the feeling is unmatched by anything.
I got in for the cars and costumes, I stayed for Abe and Rose
She looks totally different!
This is my favorite active show.
Love ❤️ this series.
The humor is just awesome. Especially in a time that it’s so needed. With covid, loves ones passing away. My mother passed in June, if she had seen this show I think it would have made her end much easier. I just happened upon it a week ago by accident, it certainly has brightened my disposition. Watched the first Catskills episode last night look forward for more tonight. Great show.
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻.
Hola, estoy esperando las siguientes temporadas,muy buena.desde Arica- Chile
That romper gave me galaxy quest vibes ❤️
the shock the day I realized she's also Rachel the shy exploited call girl in House of Cards.
The fact that so much talent was reduced to a side character call girl makes me ill. She should have been a star a long time ago!
Oh wow I didn’t know that till u brought it up.
I loved it when Abe tried to be serious about Midge's comedy then puts on the straw hat.
We love this show but after we watch, we crave deli.
I love this show
I'm in love with Joel.
Love the show cause it's about FAMILY.
One day I'm going to see you guys and I'm going to be so happy!
Regarding the exercise romper, anyone remember Jack LaLanne?
YES. I thought of him immediately :)