i think wearing tight clothing on the whole is considered inappropriate. It is considered immodest because it reveals the awrah. And thats an important part of islam.
Amnas statement Hiba ka jo dil chahay woh keray😂 But that freedom is not available for others including Zakir Naik. Selective freedom of choice Thanks for selecting both these topics together IHypocrisy cannot be shown any better than this!!
this is definitely not classified as selective freedom, it saddens me that people have not yet understood the concept of freedom vs hate speech and demeaning other humans.
Abu Salih reported: Abu Huraira, may Allah be pleased with him, said, “Some women are clothed but naked, inclining to evil and seducing with it. They will not enter Paradise, nor smell its fragrance, even though it can be found from a distance of five hundred years of travel.” Source: al-Muwaṭṭa’ 1694 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Ibn Abdul Barr
If you guys don't practice religion completely that's fine we won't judge you. Similarly if ZK wants to practice his religion properly and wants to avoid free mixing you guys shouldn't judge him negatively either. You people are liberal Muslims he's orthodox muslim. He is a student of comparative religion. You guys I'm sure won't even have 1% of knowledge that he possesses in terms of religion. He knows better than you people. So leave religious matters to religious people.
Why shall we not judge Zakir Naik when he is well known for supporting terrorist, spreads hate and divisions among masses? What his mother a 'man' that he refuses to meet young girls or is his 'iman' so weak that he cannot help himself when among young girls? Common guys what type of Islam this Zakir Naik spreading which only divides people and spreads hate? Wasn't Islam a religion of 'peace and friendship?'
Don't think Dr zakir Naik knows everything about religion plzzzzzz We don't need mulla to understand Quran it's very simple Based on Faith in Allah Honesty Humanity
@@mrsecret4567 and far away from TAQWA 🙏 Amna has a problem with maria b's opinion but she herself is so rude when it comes religion. Our religion is Qua'an and Sunnah 🥰🥰
With all due respect Amana you saying it’s Hiba ‘s choice either she want to show her baby bump or not and that is 100 percent right and I agree with you but Dr zakir has no choice if he is uncomfortable to be very close to girls I like you Amna but You are giving to different statements as we know Dr zakir Naik from Long time and agree with Hassan there must be any strong reason behind that either he was unaware or he is not comfortable with that so please give him respect too
Aamna I think u should not mix your liberal thoughts with islamic facts ...In islam when there is a command or law for something then someones opinion doesnt matter. If you want to counter someone, Then counter with facts not with opinions. ..PLEASE
I'm glad that at least there is someone who understands this matter all But sadly, even in these comments, people are still blaming Dr. Zakir Naik like who are these people!!!!?
@@ZahaibbinEhsan Islam is an ideology, not a fact. Just because something is an 'islamic fact' that doesn't make it an actual fact. Sorry to burst your bubble.
When Hassan and Amna were discussing Hiba Bukhari's dress, I received a call from Angelina (you know how sometimes Amna and Hassan get calls from celebrities, and sometimes we, the audience, too). 🙂 Angelina asked, "Are Hassan and Amna too naive to understand the dress code for a pregnant woman in Pakistan? In Pakistani culture, pregnant women even cover their bump with a dupatta in front of the elders of the family or any male member of the society." Angelina also said, "I am not debating right or wrong here; it's the culture of your country." I just thought I would share my conversation with Angelina Jolie with you all. 🙂
You should tell Angelina that Hiba definitely will cover her bump in front of elders of the family in Pakistan. But here she was in London and not in the presence of elders of the family.
Don't know why Amna take such topics to discuss in which her knowledge is just zero or wrong, The Do's Of Modest Clothing In Islam "Muslim women should wear loose-fitting clothing that does not cling to the body"...its Compulsory in ISLAM, not optional
Does ISLAM tell you to police other women? Hiba will answer Allah on her behalf and so will you. People are not evil because they are not as religious as you
Its haram to watch movies, videos, dramas and songs too. You displaying your pic aka idoi for namahrams. You can't do cherry picking Why does your culture and religion start and end with women and their clothes. Also why should pregnant women cover their tummy? Is this something to be ashamed of? Actually, women's body is a matter of shame for you people.
I just learned today that Dr zakir naik didn't refuse to give awards to girls due to this mehram namehram reason ,but because his commitment of time to that event had ended, he had to go elsewhere.
You are wrong. You should see his yesterday's lecture where he himself said that he went off because they were Na Mahram for him. Please watch that lecture which he gave in Karachi
I have attended zakir naiks lectures... we asked him questions and he replied very nicely we didnt have any other opinion other then that he is a great Gem for islam and we must respect him
Amna, your religious views which will ''offend'' people are not religious views in the first place. Religion comes from religious sources which are more or less agreed upon by everyone (in bigger matters). So girls, however young they may be, when hit puberty, begin to fall under the mehram na-mehram category. Free mixing isn't allowed. Times and culture have normalized it. However, Religiously, it will always stay haram even if nobody observes it in practice. Please present these ideas as your "personal opinions" that do not concern religion. Or present authentic sources of your veiws everytime you talk about them. I am not a fan of Dr Zakir Naik but he surely presents references everytime. You want to critisize someone on Religious orientation, counter them with religious sources or just don't name your sayings as "my religious" veiws. Just own them as Liberal veiws instead.
well said. I respect her but her negative view of religious scholars is sometimes very off and offensive (i also get it sometime maybe she hasnt had good experiences with religious ppl but she does exactly what she tells us not to: pass judgement)
If Amna shares her opinion in a way that hurts other’s feelings in a judgemental way, it will be wrong. I don’t see her doing that. People did troll Hiba in that way though
Hiba wants to show her baby bump....by all means do so but you got to choose the dress and fabric that compliments the body. The dress didn't do nothing to Hiba. Instead a flowy dress wud hv worked wonders. Maternity dresses are styled differently. The fabric was ...uuuhhh. unfortunately she didn't look great in the dress. Sorry Hiba...
pick on Dr. Naik for practicing his beliefs that are harmless but chill mahaul for open behaya practices otherwise. wow Amna, you sound so reasonable. Zakir Naik - no personal choice. Hiba Bukhari - personal choice 🙄
And why do you think just because she wasn’t dressed modest enough, she deserves criticism instead of mubarakbaad? Just because Urwa was wearing an eastern outfit when she announced, doesn’t mean her baby bump wasn’t showing
@@Like.every.other.mother That's what I said, urwa showed her baby bump. 'Baby bump' isn't a taboo, it's a miracle and there's nothing wrong in showing your bump.. And i didn't say anything about eastern/western dresses. Western doesn't necessarily mean immodest. Her dress was immodest. She herself wasn't comfortable in that. Also, I'd like to quote another statement here as well... Aamna said 'it's her personal choice' which I respectfully agree but why is it that actor/actresses have a personal choice and people don't?? People have a personal choice as well, they can choose to praise, criticize, troll, abuse or whatever they want to say about anyone. Ignore krnaa seekhen na..!
On one hand, Pakistanis claim they don't believe in forcing religion, but over the past 15-20 years, artists have been relentlessly trolled, showing a complete lack of respect for personal beliefs and choices. This is happening in a country that doesn't even have laws against clothing, dancing, music, or clubs. People argue that the youth are easily influenced, but I disagree. Are we really assuming that, as a nation, we’re so weak that every artist or TV show can sway us? Are we animals who can’t control ourselves? We ban dramas because we can’t simply switch the channel, or ban artists and movies because we can't just boycott or block them? I wonder what these religious zealots will do when Dajjal arrives or when their kids go abroad. There’s no logical thinking in our nation; we're blinded by culture and religion without even understanding the facts. Are we even thinking rationally? Banning porn and people still having an access to that is the prime example. You can't ban the world, you can't ban opinions, verbal or visual. All you can do is create boundaries and choose what is right for yourself rather than shamelessly trolling celebrities in the name of religion
@ahmadrehan5059 15,20 saalon ki koshish sy jo nudity aam howi hai wo bhi muslim artists ki tarf sy wo bhi pehly itna openly nhi hoti thee, kya mtlb religion force nhi kiya ja skta ISLAMI Jamhoriya Pakistan mai ? ye sirf Aazadi non muslims k liye hai, muslmaan by_lgaam nhi chhorra jata k gumrah ho k obscenity sy gumrah krta phiry, sb choices islam k basics k under tayy hain tau unhain maan'na hoga, ap jaisy khud ko mahaan smjhty jinhain shetaan nhi bhatka skta, nabiyon sahabiyon jaisi naozobillah pakeezgi ly k otary tau islam k qanon librals k liye change nahi hojaingy, human is a social animal jo ik dosry sy adopt krty hain acha bura sb, islam sy ziyada logical aur rational koi mzhab nhi jb os ny keh diya, behayai mai aib hai tau hai ap logon ny porn daikhna tau 24 daikho, khud ka imaan sucha pakka sabit kro, agr apko Allah ki guidance blindness lagti, ap apny liye kafi ho,apka personal belief Allah ki obedience sy barra hai tau in shameless boundaries ko khud tk limited rakho, vulgurity k advocate na bano
Aghr kuch b dykhny sy koi effect nhi hota or kisi ko kuch b pyhanay or bolny ki azadi hy to phr jo log objection krty un ko b azadi hy jysy ap kisi ko zbrdsti nfrt nhi krwa skty to mohabbat b nhi krwa skty aik trf khud ko liberal kyhny waly kyhty sub ko apni bat kyhny ki azadi hy phr jb dooari trf un sy koi ikhtlaf krta to us ka ikhtlaf b brdasht nhi hota
@ahmadrehan5059 15,20 saalon ki koshish sy jo nudity aam howi hai wo bhi muslim artists ki tarf sy wo bhi pehly itna openly nhi hoti thee, kya mtlb religion force nhi kr skta agr ISLAMI Jamhoriya Pakistan tau ye Aazadi non muslims k liye, muslmaan by_lgaam nhi chhorra jata k gumrah ho k obscenity krta phiry, sb choices islam k basics k under tayy hain tau unhain maan'na hoga, ap jaisy khud ko mahaan smjhty jinhain shetaan nhi bhatka skta, nabiyon sahabiyon jaisi naozobillah pakeezgi ly k otary tau islam k qanon librals k liye change nahi hojaingy, human is a social animal jo ik dosry sy adopt krty hain acha bura sb, islam sy ziyada logical aur rational koi mzhab nhi jb os ny keh diya, behayai mai aib hai tau hai ap logon ny porn daikhna tau 24 daikho, khud ka imaan sucha pakka sabit kro, agr apko Allah ki guidance blindness lagti, ap apny liye kafi ho,apka personal belief Allah ki obedience sy barra hai tau in shameless boundaries ko khud tk limited rakho, vulgurity k advocate na bano
@ahmadrehan5059 15,20 saalon ki koshish sy jo nudity aam howi hai wo bhi muslim artists ki tarf sy wo bhi pehly itna openly nhi hoti thee, kya mtlb religion force nhi kr skta agr ISLAMI Jamhoriya Pakistan tau ye Aazadi non muslims k liye, muslmaan by_lgaam nhi chhorra jata k gumrah ho k obscenity krta phiry, sb choices islam k basics k under tayy hain tau unhain maan'na hoga, ap jaisy khud ko mahaan smjhty jinhain shetaan nhi bhatka skta, nabiyon sahabiyon jaisi naozobillah pakeezgi ly k otary tau islam k qanon librals k liye change nahi hojaingy, human is a social animal jo ik dosry sy adopt krty hain acha bura sb, islam sy ziyada logical aur rational koi mzhab nhi jb os ny keh diya, behayai mai aib hai tau hai ap logon ny porn daikhna tau 24 daikho, khud ka imaan sucha pakka sabit kro, agr apko Allah ki guidance blindness lagti, ap apny liye kafi ho,apka personal belief Allah ki obedience sy barra hai tau in shameless boundaries ko khud tk limited rakho, vulgurity k advocate na bano
Amna is so secular, defending Hiba for wearing what she wants to wear but criticising zakir naik for his choice. Shame on her. These kimd of ppl love to degrade Islamic ppl
I totally agree! Amna thinks she’s incredibly smart and aware as a journalist, assuming she can also comment on Islamic issues. Hiba was clearly not dressed modestly, yet Amna is defending her with the "her body, her choice" argument. Amna doesn’t agree with the Islamic principles of modesty and reduces everything to a matter of personal choice. Really? One day, Amna might even defend sex in public. I live in the Netherlands, where most people aren’t Muslim, but even here, showing off a baby bump isn’t considered appropriate. Amna’s perspective is strange-definitely unsubscribing! P.S. I’m an educated person, doing PhD and living in Europe, so I understand where people like Amna are coming from. It’s bizarre how some disagree with everything and label immodesty as a "matter of choice." Amna, you really need to unlearn and relearn some things!
Being modest and having Haya are one of those attributes which differentiate muslims from non muslims. I find nothing wrong with Sir Dr Zakir approach, by the fundamentals teaching of Quran muslim men and women are encouraged refrain from na mehram. I disagree here with Aamna here. As muslims we cannot be liberal about everything. We are the people blessed with the best religion Islam and there are clear do's and don't and we should not cross those lines. Same for Hiba, I wish her well on the her new journey to parenthood. Her dress was not modest and it seemed like she wanted attention for her pregnancy. Again as I said Haya is the gift of Allah, unfortunately our Pakistani people are very keen on losing it.
Zalir naik is no doubt religious personality... I know i am not that very religoius, bt still what ever he says is right we have to refrain from non mehram... Hum woh apny aap pe apply nahi karty doesn't mean it is not in our religion .... So one should know Doe's and don'ts of our religion ( whether we apply it on our self or not) From India
I don’t know Dr. Zakir Nayk personally but based on my experience with attending religious gatherings I can say that he was probably misinformed about the setting of the event. Free mixing isn’t allowed in Islam but in Pakistan these Obligations orders are seen as being offensive. If we favor woman wearing revealing clothes in public, then we should also agree with men choice of not interacting with the non-mehrams. There is nothing degrading about it; is it actually a gesture of giving respect.
Please guys don’t talk about religion , keeping your personal opinion to yourself is better if you have no knowledge about Islam. We all do different sins but claiming that its not even a sin in public is worse than doing the actual sin
Every one has choice…same goes for #Dr zakir Naik…. But according to Amna choice srif actors n vulgure logon ki hoti hai ….religious people should first consult Amna😅😅😅😅…
Dr. Zakir Naiq has had sessions attended by thousands of women. He has been questioned by as many women as men. He never showed any resistance answering them. He has interacted with many women of different religions, wearing all sorts of dresses. Please do not drag him in any controversy. He is an extremely learned person. We should be thankful to him for visiting Pakistan. I have immerse respect for him.
Well said mahnoor I mean what that man has done in the past is work of brilliance I mean converting people to the religion of Islam is not easy. In the stream of scholars he might be one of the few one’s who actually give references about every statement. Least we can show is respect to the person . This topic is not a means of entertainment or trivia to be discussed I feel. Felt weird. Especially when aamna is saying she doesn’t know him then how can you judge the person. It’s simple if he didn’t want to interact or shake hands in close proximity it’s fine. Otherwise in all the videos it’s pretty normal for him to talk to both the genders very casually .
But he has also said alot of controversial things. He doesn’t respect minorities either. As Muslims we’re taught to treat everyone with respect & not to create fitna. Don’t just follow anyone blindly & giving him award for best scholar though he’s not that learned & claims to have read every religion. When he doesn’t even interpret islam properly.
Also zakir naik has been proven many times to provide false references. And it’s not a one of mistake, his demeanor of knowing everything and quoting history and books are mostly fake and made up
People are not criticising hiba because of pregnancy, but she chose a very bad dress and doesn't look nice. I think she could look beautiful in Eastern attire. I think people should know which kind of dresses they should wear on different occasions and hiba clearly have bad taste same like yumna.
Majority of comments I have seen are criticising her for accentuating her baby bump. Reffering to her as “shameless”. Why does it matter if her dress is Eastern / Western
There is something called 'apni marzi'.... And it is her choice how she wanted to dress. Ager kissi ko modest nahin laga tu woh khud aise kapre na pehne when they get pregnant. Behayai tu tub hoti ager Hebah and Arez were not married and having a baby and then flaunting their pregnancy. Aik Halal kaam jis kee Allah swt ne ijaazat dee hai tu woh ghalat kaise ho sakta hai. Ager haya kee baat karni hai tu phir tu har woh aurat aur mard Jo Allah swt ke bataaye huay dress code ko follow nahin karte woh Behaya hain.... Iss liye Jo best cheez log kar sakte hain woh yeh hai ke koshish karein ke woh khud aisa kuch na karein Jo against the principles of Islamic values ho. Apne aap ko improve karte nahin log aur dosron ko criticise karna shuru kar daite hain.
I have no issue with wht hibba is wearing its her choice but being pragnant myself I was surprised to see her wearing so tight n uncontrollable clothes…I dont know how women manage wearing so tight clothes in pragnancy???for me its in bearable n my belly hurts if i wear little tight trouser…😅all my clothes during pregnancy are xxl
Exactly forget about the bump ,it looked so fitted even from the back.She could have done something classy instead of this. Btw immodest isn’t only when skin is showing.Plus the way she had her hands on the stomach come on stop getting influenced with west in all the wrong things 🤦🏻♀️
I think with hiba bukhari it was that she’s always shown herself to be a very modest actress until like last year where she changed her dressing. Whenever someone perceived modest dressed open for the first time they always unfortunately get trolled 😭. And I’m pretty sure it wasn’t because of the baby bump but very tight clothing
After listening this discussion and reading most of the comments i came to an answer That we as nation r going away from Practising deen. We call ourselves Muslims but we are unaware of its teachings. We pick & choose from deen what suits us. Here lies the answer. Once we start practising deen, there will be no such discussion as reality will be clear to us.
Actually those girls could be baligh. Some girls become baaligh at 8 or 9. They were not Little girls of 4,5,6 years of age. So most religious scholars like to maintain a safe distance. You will not find any religious scholar from Saudi or Madinah Islamic University, addressing girls such close proximity.
This is the most pathetic reasoning I've ever read. Which girl become baligh at 8 or 9? This sentence will get one jailtime in the USA. Only a pervert thurkhee budha will get turn on by kids of his grand daughter age. Didn't he eat food and drink water in the plane? Who served him that? Edhi Sahib was a 10 times b better person than this thurkee budha. He took care of 1000's of girls.
My thoughts exactly. I like the show, but not the audience and comments. Aamna and Hassan have raw chats, the audience it seems, are still living under rocks.
Comments padne ke baad to lagta hai kya hi kar liya hum insaano ne plane banakar? ,kya hi karna tha matlab kyu educate ho rahe hai rahne dete hai kyuki farak hi nhi padta hai kyuki education sirf deegree ke paper me hi hai number ke roop me dimag me to sirf😅 rahne dete h Haa ab kuch log aa kar reply karege please stay away from this topic it's about our relegion and yeah that's true I am not muslim but yaar maar daloge kya samne wale ko matlab pura comment section bhara pada hai hiba bukhari ne kaise kyu kiya , tum logo ko koi kaam dhandha nhi jab dekho dusro ke kapdo aur vo jo kar rahe hai us par comment pass karte rahte ho 😅😅😅😅 chodo sorry kisko samjha rahi hu mai bhi 😅
Nope. She is definitely being trolled for being out and about whole being pregnant. Her green dress was probably one of the modest dress on the red carpet. She was covered head to toe.
@@rubina9031head to toe but like a tight ghilaf. there are many ways to decently dress while pregnant and still show the bump. Her hips were showing too. It was not a good fit.
Amna, Islam is very differently practiced worldwide in different muslims countries. Having grown up in Saudi Arabia, Zakir Naik is not wrong. I went to a school that was completely segregated, during parent-teacher conferences my or any other students father couldn’t come inside. We had to cover our faces when leaving, that was a choice. But yes, he is correct. Girls are na mehram. But, he could’ve informed beforehand what he is and isn’t willing to do.
Anyways, something haute platform should not discuss this topic coz Dr Zakir Naik is a MOTBER personality of this era. Please don't do You discuss hiba bukhari dress mamiya dress etc Please 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Stopped watching the video when Amna associated people having a problem with Hiba's dress with them actually having a problem with sex. 😂 Like seriously you both are looking like noobs giving cultural commentary on a country you were born and brought up in. Hiba should NOT have been trolled. But dont act naee-vay (naive). You guys know that the problem was not her pregnancy or her body shape. It was the 'choice' of her dress. Yes Aamna. The word is CHOICE. Jus how Dr. Zakir Nail CHOSE to not interact with the young girls.
First of all nobody is saying that a pregnant lady needs to stay home. Secondly, in Islam it is compulsory ( not optional)to dress modestly for all women, then you think it will be fine for a pregnant woman to dress in such a figure hugging outfit. And since you guys are so keen on comparing with Hollywood, i think she tried to replicate Angelina Jolie's iconic green dress in her first preg. Well go and see the pics online, she is far more modestly covered, the silhouette was flowy, the fabric everything was right. And did you see Hiba's back side( sorry to be soo crude) but it was not a good look. And as far as Hiba and Arez's reactions are considered, i mean are you guys unique or the first ones to be parents! It is special to you and your fans but not to the rest of the world. Grow up!! Arez definitely mentioned it to Nadia Khan, so why the outrage. I hope the best for both of them but they need to mature. Hiba was walking around London and not expecting anyone to find out while being so heavily pregnant 🤔
Amna and Hassan acting like they don’t know what cultural nuance on “modesty” is … yes, our culture expects women to wear more flowy clothes, no one is blind and can’t notice a pregnancy but the way she was dressed was meant to really over emphasize it …
Totally agreed! Being pregnant is a natural process but you are not supposed to showcase yourself purposefully. One should not leave the modesty in anyway.
Aamna aap se ek request hai aap apne subject ke alawa religion aur islamic books ki study bhi start karen please....pregnant lady kya kare hasan se na poochen. 😂
Hiba looked very pretty on the red carpet; her skin was glowing. She just seemed a bit conscious and uncomfortable; she could have carried the dress more confidently.
Although the topic was not religious at all, it was about a scholar, getting off the stage, by any reason known to him, still I am shocked by the comments on #Amna and her take which is really non existent. She tries to stay away from such topics, although I found her a genuinely open minded and morally correct person in last 5 years
First of all, in pakistan, the management of most of such events is very off. They don't inform the guests beforehand about the whole programme, its requirement and right timings. So it's a big possibility that he wasn't informed about the time and he may have to go somewhere else or he wasn't informed that he would have to present shields to young girls. 2ndly, even if he knew, he might not know that it'd be young girls who are na-mehram for him, it's his right to decline. He is entitled to act according to his beliefs. Giving answers to religious questions in a mehfil is allowed in islam, but handing over shields means there will be physical interaction which is not allowed. 3rdly, dr. Zakir naik is a religious scholar who knows Quran and all the books of hadith. He definitley knows more than you and me. We are no one to criticise him. Lastly, the number of people he has converted to islam (may Allah accept and reward his deeds) he deserves immense respect and should not be criticised over such trivial issues. Lets discourage the propaganda of indian media and specific sect in pakistan.
your second point is so valid.. it is completely his right.. waise tou subko sare hi rights yad rehte hain mgr koi scholar apne liye koi right use kre tou sub ko masla ho jata hai
Absolutely I am shocked that an Islamic scholar is being criticized for not mingling with girls. Yes they are little girls but they fall in the category of na mahram as the age of puberty varies from age of 8 - 13.
An absolutely despicable thing . Very disappointed so you are not interested in a scholars visit to Pakistan unless a controversy came up . This is your sincerity with deen and then you think you bringing a change by your 2 cents. You guys have hours to discuss people's clothes and fashion sense but didn't have 2 sentences to welcome him to Pakistan unless it has become controversial. Good TRP scheming.
I agree with Hassan Dr. Zakir replies very logically quoting ayats from Quran and is very convincing. Many people have accepted Islam being convinced by his logical debate.
@@ayshcandy7155 Actually his answers to non muslims are really good. He probably comes prepared in India and Dubai to debate with non muslims. Maybe he didn’t take questions of muslims in Pakistan too seriously or the questions were not challenging. Also he is more used to and is fluent in english than in urdu. Sometimes people ask stupid questions, jin ka jawab kia de. I saw a video of a young girl who couldn’t even formulate the question properly, but probably wanted to know why we have zina and pedophile in a muslim society. He preaches Islam, if muslims are not true muslims and commit sins , it is not the fault of islam. Zakir Naiq is an expert in comparing Bible geeta with Quran. For example when an Indian hindu talks to me about the status of women in islam, i tell them that islam is the only religion that has given rights to women , even right in inheritance, no other religion has . That is why other religion states had to make their own laws later on. So it is Islam vs other religions , not what muslims do and what non vs non muslims do in today’s world.
@@ayshcandy7155 Actually he is an expert in debating with non muslims. If a non Muslim challenges something from the Quran, then watch his replies. He is expert in comparing Bible geeta with Quran.
The propaganda about Dr. Zakir Naik seems completely false. He answered questions from anchor and actress Farah Sadia in a program, and he appeared to be completely okay with it.
Whats so wrong if Dr Zakir Naik.did not wanted to come so near and present shields to non mehram girls? It is his choice and if this is his point of view we should respect it. Interacting with opposite gender when needed and when not needed is different. He answers the questions to ladies but when presenting something you have to smile and there is a chance of touch and every practicing muslim will want to avoid that. That should be respected. Most of the girls are becoming adult at age of 9-10 nowadays and one have ti follow rules of sharia for that.
I agree we need to spread love . My grandparents and parents were born and raised in Pakistan. Partition was sad and they had to move to Punjab India. My love for Pakistan is strong and I wish to visit my family's villages one day. ❤❤❤❤❤
17:50 Hassan, Tarak Fateh was never given a red carpet and was never state guest in India. Also, Tarak Fateh was never provided presidential security in India. He was mostly invited by News Channel and not by Prime Minister of India. He wasn't banned in western countries. Infact, he used to live in Canada and was Canadian citizen. He was never given Indian citizenship. Get your facts right. Zakir Naik is banned in many western countries and has serious money laundering charges against him. Don't compare apple and oranges
But the question is, was any of those allegations proven against him? Because this could also mean, that they banned him for the sake of banning not for an actual crime?
@@afaqahmadkhan2956 He wasn't banned in India. He ran away due to fear of arrest which is cowardly because many opposition leaders, activists have been to jail, fought and won their case against government. Even if he didn't want to return, he could have hired a lawyer to fight his case. It's not that he is poor and can't afford lawyer.He belongs to affluent family.
Everybody can talk on Religion Its not ristricted to Mulla,s only I enjoyed Hassan and Amna,s conversation Coz Allah said in Quran 756 times to research on Me (Allah) and then follow So plz dont b emotional on religion conversation so much Allah believes in peace
Sultan Salahuddin Ayyubi: The set of Sultan Salahuddin Ayyubi was originally built for Emre Konuk's previous series "The Great Seljuks" so, Pakistan almost has no contribution to it and Hassan keeps mentioning that it's a collaboration with the creator of Ertugrul Ghazi but no this series is produced by Akli Films, whereas Ertugrul Ghazi was produced by Tekden Films & Akli Films previous successful project was The Great Seljuks franchise btw Aamna thanks a lot for visiting the set and I'm looking forward for your reviews in the episode, where Noor ul Hassan would make a cameo. thanks for reading.
You don't need these stupid shield issues to highlight the hypocritical nature of Zakir Naik. Just listen to his answers on KPK girl question on religious bigotry in the name of Islam in her region. Just listen how angrily he didn't even listen instead humiliated that innocent young girl. Even one pak actress was also got negative response by this same guy.
Y Not invite Dr Zakir Naik? He’s the Real celebrity, a genius, human computer and an asset for us Muslims who put to shame so many Debaters who picked on Quran and Islam. What a shame that we stir controversies about a personality like him without even looking at his brilliant background. Should give him some benefit of doubt rather than yapping about something that we don’t have the full knowledge of
Please talk about it too. Zakir naik insulted a pathan girl when she asked we have islamic rules but still people are pedophiles why it is like that ? He misbehaved so badly. Plus he said if a woman can’t find a single man, any modest woman will choose the married man to get marry and those who choose not to get marry are public property or bazari aurat.
Hi guys, just wanted to let you know, I am an ardent cricket fan and Vikrant Gupta is known in the cricketing circuit for inflammatory statements and spewing hate against cricketers. He does not have any credibility as a ‘journalist’ and will say about anything that will create a controversy and/or is click bait. Unfortunately his negative comments garner a lot of views and he has become popular in that way. Please don’t think his statements portray the view of the cricketing circuit or Indians as such! Love you guys, and respect for Pakistan!
Excuse ne Hassan Choudhary !!! How could you define Zakir is good man coz he address women as sister. Don't forget in Islam you marry sister. So, calling someone sister doesn't mean he respects women.
Why do we as a nation ALWAYS feel the need to comment on ANYTHING and EVERYTHING especially when it comes to women?! Our sense of religion begins and ends with women! Who cares if she didn’t carry her dress well? Who cares if her dress was not the right cut, material, bla bla bla! It is so difficult to dress comfortably when you are heavily pregnant! Instead of congratulating Hibba on her pregnancy, the entire focus was on what and why she was wearing! Seriously people grow up and learn to be a little less opinionated! People don’t even consider the impact their words will have on the person in question ESPECIALLY when that person is pregnant which is a beautiful but difficult period of one’s life as is!
@@Meemomina but why do u CARE how she dresses up? I don’t understand how her wearing that green dress impacts you? Ur comment further proves my point that we feel the need to have an opinion on EVERYTHING!
@@gulrukhsarzeb7965 as a society impact tau hota hai tbhi Allah ny surah noor ayat no. 19 mai mana kiya hai ahadees mai bhi mana kiya gya aisy dress sy jisy pehn k bhi kuch cover na ho, as a muslim concern tau hota hai ya Allah ki had tot'ty howy khamoshi sy khudgharzi sy daikhty rahain? Burai ko achaai bna k sabit krain?
@@gulrukhsarzeb7965 as a society impact tau hota hai tbhi Allah ny sorah noor ayat no. 19 mai mana kiya hai ahadees mai bhi mana kiya gya aisy dress sy josy pehn k bhi kuch cover na ho, as a muslim concern tau hota hai ya Allah ki had got'ty howy daikhty rahain? Burai ko achaai bna k sabit krain?
@@gulrukhsarzeb7965as a society impact tau hota hai tbhi Allah ny surah noor ayat no. 19 mai mana kiya hai ahadees mai bhi mana kiya gya aisy dress sy jisy pehn k bhi kuch cover na ho, as a muslim concern tau hota hai ya Allah ki had tot'ty howy daikhty rahain? Burai ko achaai bna k sabit krain?
They have right to discuss ZK as he him self carries 1000 Kg Social media equipment and 8 social media workers with him. From social media perspective. Plus ZK was so rude to so many locals asking questions. Then he dodged questions. Both parties need to be polite
KGF and RRR are Kannada and Telegu films, from the states of Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh and Telengana, not Tamil films, which is from Tamilnadu. The three languages and their origins are totally, completely differet.
Muslim countries are honoured to have Omar sulaiman, sheikh Assim al Hakeem, Zakir Naik as guests to their country, and here our esteemed SH hosts say they shouldn’t come because of they follow Islam to the core. Bhai wah!
Miss amna agr ap ko mazhab ka nh pata to plzzz seekhain.....ap khud kiya mazhab k mutabiq dressing krti hain...hust look at your self and think about it... Me blkul batamizi nh kr re...Allah nai aurat ko haya ka paikar banaya hai....yh kis traf jaa rahy hain ap sb ya mein ya hm sb....plzzzzzzzz abhi bhi wqt hai hm sb sambhal jai. Plzzzzz🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
Mind your language! Her dresiing is always decent and modest. Islam mn dusron per tohmat lagana or ghalat bayani kerna bhi bohat barra gunah he which you are committing atm.
@@AthenaRamz Sorry if i hurt you but plzzz read thiss Quranic verse translation and do read tafseer... And say to the believing women to lower their gaze and to guard their private parts and not to show their beauty spots except that of it which is normally shown. They shall also cover their cleavage with their 'khimars'. They shall not show their beauty spots except in the presence of their husbands, their fathers, the fathers of their husbands, their sons, the sons of their husbands, their brothers, the sons of their brothers, the sons of their sisters, other women, what their right hands possess, the male attendants who have no sexual desire and the children who are yet to attain awareness of women's nakedness. They shall not strike their feet so as to reveal details of their hidden beauty spots. You shall repent to God, all of you, O believers, so that you may succeed. 24:31
M currently living in melbourne n i guess zakir naik, refusing to present shields, needs to be appreciated, thats how religion is practiced. Over here abu taymyah, abu hammuda also came for australia tour, in their lectures they allowed women but questions and lunch session with the scholars was restricted for men only. Free mixing is normal these days, we are all guilty of it, but it doesnt bring any good at many levels.
Those girls must be literally half age of his grand daughters, na mehramon ko sheilds deni thi un k ilm par, na k un k nachne ganay par, I am speechless for those who are favoring this nonsense act, is waqt jab we need more people to present Islam in a positive light Zakir Naik is refusing to present and encourage those little girls.
22:26 Don't pass comments about such personalities. His stature is too high to be discussed like that. We have watched his numerous shows and we have witnessed his behaviour with women.
HibaB: no comments on religious views on her looks. I believe in women celebrating their bodies and pregnancy the way they want or not. Having said that, while her dress was gorgeous, she couldn’t carry it well and seemed uncomfortable for the most part. For me, it’s not even about the fact that the dress was form fitting, I think that’s cute, but she should’ve chosen a dress she felt comfortable in. Either it should have been set better, or she should’ve chosen a different dress.
Some pregnant women find body hugging dresses comfortable. It provides them with support and eases the pressure on their back. I don't get why everything specific to women's bodies from periods to pregnancy is treated as a taboo. Pregnancy is difficult and we make it even harder for our women.
Islam mai allow nhi figure revealing dreses pehnna, agr itni he support mili rahi the body hugging dress sy tau apna awrah he chadar orrh body k around cover lyti, grace mai kami na aati izaafa he hota
Islam mai allow nhi figure revealing dreses pehnna, agr itni he support mili rahi the body hugging dress sy tau apna awrah he chadar orrh body k around cover lyti, grace mai kami na aati izaafa he hota
Islam mai allow nhi figure revealing dreses pehnna, agr itni he support mili rahi the body hugging dress sy tau apna awrah he chadar orrh body k around cover lyti, grace mai kami na aati izaafa he hota
How I love Aamna & Hassan! Your clarity in thoughts & unprejudiced outlook in a society jahan everyone is judged left & right requires strong willpower. Exactly how well read people usually are, their conscience works best for guiding them towards what’s right and how one should conclude any conversation. Keep up the good work.
Aoa Amna and Hassan. While I respect that you have tried your best to give a neutral take on Dr Zakir Naik, there are some points I would like to get across. Dr Zakir is a very renowned and respected personality with Muslims all around the world and that includes Pakistan. He is absolutely deserving of the protocol and entourage he has been provided with and it doesn't just seem like he's a 'bari shakhsiyat', he actually is one for a huge fraction of Muslim society. The evidence for this is the huge crowd currently gathered to watch him deliver his talk at the governor house, at the screening in a ground and the online live. So I think its disrespectful of you to suggest that he shouldn't have been called to Pakistan if he chose not to interact with those girls on religious grounds. Islam does not allow free mixing, even if nobody follows this command. And no, a lot of the times, event planners in Pakistan do NOT give you a proper schedule with all the expected activities. Its likely that Dr Zakir's team was not told that he would have to present shields. Also, to clarify on the matter of Dr Zakir Naik taking questions from women in his talks, the arrangement of the audience in those talks is such that the women are seated very far from him. The males are right in front of him. He has clearly stated that the reason for this is so he cannot see the faces of the women asking the questions. He can hear them, sure, thanks to the sound system. He can tell which direction in the audience the question is coming from so he can direct his gaze there, but when he looks, he cannot make out the facial features of those women. He can just see a crowd. Its his choice, his beliefs and he is revered for them greatly in Pakistan as well. If you don't agree, thats your choice, of course. But Dr Zakir is as free to have his own opinion and beliefs as you are. And the public is well within their right to follow him if they choose so. Lastly, the Soha and SRK show was just a platform he was invited to to talk about Islam and he had no control over the setting there. The host was very derogatory towards him and it ignited a huge outrage at that time btw. He has never been to such a platform since. Wishing you both well. Cheers.
Just a little bit of correction! Amna said that he should not be invited to mix gatherings then. His instructions should be followed. She never said that he shouldn't be coming to Pakistan. Rather, they both are defending him from that infamous FB journalist
@@AthenaRamzI agree with the part about them defending him against the journalist. And I respect them for it. :) However, I am referring to a comment in the last minute of the segment on Dr Naik in this video, where it has been insinuated that if he didn't want to interact with the girls, he shouldn't have been invited on a 'national level'. That is a big statement which I think, is disrespectful not just towards Dr Naik but also towards the hundreds of thousands (probably millions) of people who are elated about his visit. Hope you have a good day. 🙂
Now half of pk ppl after amna!!!! That’s the only thing you guys do. Only criticism!!!! No tolerance no acceptance!!!! Now keep on ranting!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mujhe to nhi lagta ki koi pyaar hai dono nations me aur kabhi hoga haa similarities hai aur ek dusre ke country ke stars aur artist ko pasand bhi karte lekin iska matlab ye nhi hai ki pure country se pyaar ho gya hai haa appreciate karte hai hum us individual ko uski art ke liye . aur agar pyaar tha to fir separate hi nhi hote . separate huye because our thinking is not aline .
The fact of the matter is Dr. Zakir Naik was not asked to hold hands and hop around with those girls. A decent human being IS allowed to award a shield WITHOUT having to touch the girl. This is an absurd ideology. Secondly, I watched the live session by Hiba and Ariz. They pointed out Nadia's shortcomings multiple times without taking her name. Hiba clarified that the swelling on her face during the shoot of Radd was not due to pregnancy. She also said that this is a very personal thing and only she and her husband have the right to reveal her news. Then she said "but it's okay". And to that Ariz said, "no it's not okay but she's too nice, I'm not. I will not let this go and will surely roast the person responsible in a seperate video that the public will see on my own channel"
OK lets get this straight - no issues showing ur baby bump but showing it in a way that Hiba did was uncalled for. Amna it was not only the belly but the entire body that was flaunted. Hasan seems more sensible - what are designer maternity dresses for??? She can wear whatever but it did not look decent to most of us . BTW a figure hugging burqa is also not modest for ur point that she was fully clothed .Dont think ur opinion is always correct .
I want to share my view on Mr zakir naik reaction that if it was becz of this that girls are namahram I guess he was not informed earlier otherwise a person like him will never refuse and of he had refused he did absolutely good he is ma sha ALLAH a religious person he can talk with female gender in order to invite them or teach them islam but he doesn't want to go beyond this ..to present Shields to anyone is not an act which will grant you jannah but yes to respect female gender will make you eligible for jannah so I want to show my support to Mr zakir naik
Amna say dont force religion or your religious opinion on others, while defending Barzakh she said that this drama cannot harm or influence anyone then why she feels so threatened by Dr Zakir naik views. Hassan and Amna both said parenting matters and nothing can influence our children then why you feel like Dr zakir should not be invited or he should not follow his value system. dont judge Hiba bukhari but judge Dr Zakir Naik, like what is this behaviour, and your platform is entertainment why you need to discuss religious matters
May be she didn’t LOOK good, modest, comfortable etc to others, but maybe she FELT good, modest and comfortable which is all that matters. Let the pregnant woman be y’all!
We generalize a lot. A PhD does reserach in one particular topic in one subject. A doctorate in specific area of macro economics doesnt make anyone master in all area of economics. Similarly, while Dr. Zakir Naik has used logic to convince Hindu to revert to Islam. He is not a master of all of Islam. He has his flaws like all humans have.
whenever critics talk about plus size fashion or a fashion for a broader body they criticise if they do not have a right silhouette..even they explain the dress should be layered flowy/pleated/ wrap and breathable, that is simply the case..leave the pregnancy its not a shame anymore..the size has increased, body shape has changed, need to dress accordingly. I think the criticism is on a dress actually which was not a great choice to show a baby bump all aside I felt bad for her that she has to go through this
I don’t think ZN has a problem with sitting next to females or answering questions, he gives interviews as well, I think it had some touching involved for him to leave the stage.
Hiba apna baby bump bina itna tight dress ke bhi dekha sakte the... Logo ne hamesa Hiba ko ek modest girl ki tarah hi dekha ha, that's why now people are so disappointed from her.
I didn’t even mind the tight dress, but she herself was not comfortable in that dress( her comfort should be first priority when she is this pregnant )
Ya it was a bad dress she was not comfortable and it looked bad. She should have found a maternity dress that is supposed to hug the baby bump and flatter the other pregnancy related bumps
I don't believe in Dr sahib Coz he considers Hadees so much We Only Follow QURAN In Quran We🎉don't anybody between Quran and Insaan Agreed with u HASSAN AND AMMNA 🎉 IN MY OPINION WOMEN IS NOT BORN TO LIVE IN HIJAB ABBAYA ETCCCC MAN HAS LOTS OF RISTRICTIONS DO THEY FOLLOW 🎉????
Amna you don’t have to withhold your religious views , please we need women like you speaking out , u seemed reserved today , while Hassan was quiet expressive about everything , please don’t let the negativity of people in comment section get to you. Your views wether religious or not absolutely make sense and you speak what’s in our minds and in our hearts. Unfortunately the society is not ready for us ;) But that should not stop us from speaking up . Anyways I think Hassan should speak less though , just a thought 😊 as not everything he say makes sense at times like today , supporting dr zakir stance Incase he’s avoiding na mehram girls on stage but on the contrary he’s sharing the stage with soha Ali khan in India ? Also what’s wrong with celebs doing photoshoots and celebrating their pregnancies or other important events however they choose to do it , by showing themselves or covering themselves, that’s their choice ! Their lives . That’s all I had to say , i watch your show regularly , this is my first time commenting on any channel FYI . Amna , u go girl !
@@sabahatmazhar6056 and who are we to decide about that ?? Are we some religious scholars ourselves? No right , so yeah everyone has the right to say what they want , some would disagree and some would agree , this is how it is .
@@Sh87-cv9ds who are we to decide that? You already decided that Aamna should speak out no matter what…and I’m asking a simple, logical question that she should speak out even without knowledge, something that she’s admitted herself many times?
Hamza Ali Abbasi from Maula jatt is a terror sympathizer and has defended Hafiz Saeed (Master mind of Mumbai terror attack) multiple times! I think this reason is enough for you guys to know about the protest against the release of Maula Jatt!
The Case of Maula Jatt should be taken as a lesson. Zee TV bought the rights to it two years ago and got it banned in India. Now , the makers of Maula Jatt can't sell it to China and OTT until it is released in India. Maula Jatt is only opposed by Shiv Sena, but there were plenty of Indian movies that were protested against by Hindudtva and 17 states, but still, the movies were released. Indian SC lifted the ban on Pakistani movies and actors in 2023. The truth is India doesn't want to release it. Meanwhile, at least 3 indian movies ( north and South) came out with copied scenes and background scores of Maulla jatt. This is how India destroys Pakistani entertainment industry. The cinemas that initially boycotted Maulla jatt in Pakistan are also owned by Indian investors. All thanks to our Muhajir population in Karachi. Indian policy is to get a market in Pakistan for Indian movies and destroy the local Pakistani industry. These so-called Punjabi movies made in England are also produced by Bollywood.
@@gerryburntwood9617 What freedom a person born in punjab pakistan will get by sending ter*or*st to Mumbai India and by killing hundreds of people including foreigners? Are you seriously saying that the attacks that took place on 26/11 were okay? You need to get your Brain checked
Speaking of behayi.. young married Pakistani women are constantly asked are they pregnant/when are they getting pregnant/ when are they having their second/third child, etc? That literally translates into are you having sex without contraception.
Dr. Z Naik ;In a world where diddy exists ( n who know how many more hollywood celebs) , i don’t mind if an adult doesn’t want to interact with young girls.
You have any idea how many girls are raped and molested by their mehrams? And im not talking about their husbands here. So the less said about today's world, the better.
I doubt Maula Jutt will get a release in India because of the current political climate. The best thing is for Maula Jutt to be released on an OTT Platform.
I was introduced to this channel when a controversy regarding tere bin MR sequence had just unfolded. And that was out of the blue, i didn't even know about this show (tere bin) but i got haute's video recommended on my feed and i watched it. I was quite happy reading all the progressive comments there regarding women's respect and dignity. But the kind of comments i read on this video are so different even disturbing to a degree. Zakir Naik is the same person who had said that women who remain unmarried are 'public property'. This video from 8 years ago still exists on TH-cam. So many people are defending him here, even worse, pointing out what a great religious scholar he is. I don't know how their audience has changed completely in such a short time. Sad.
i think wearing tight clothing on the whole is considered inappropriate. It is considered immodest because it reveals the awrah. And thats an important part of islam.
Amnas statement
Hiba ka jo dil chahay woh keray😂
But that freedom is not available for others including Zakir Naik.
Selective freedom of choice
Thanks for selecting both these topics together
IHypocrisy cannot be shown any better than this!!
True💯
Sooooo true
this is definitely not classified as selective freedom, it saddens me that people have not yet understood the concept of freedom vs hate speech and demeaning other humans.
Ur comment deserves a pin!!
Nailed it!!
Abu Salih reported: Abu Huraira, may Allah be pleased with him, said, “Some women are clothed but naked, inclining to evil and seducing with it. They will not enter Paradise, nor smell its fragrance, even though it can be found from a distance of five hundred years of travel.”
Source: al-Muwaṭṭa’ 1694
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Ibn Abdul Barr
THANKYOU
It's nothing to do about hiding pregnancy. It's about dressing.
If you guys don't practice religion completely that's fine we won't judge you. Similarly if ZK wants to practice his religion properly and wants to avoid free mixing you guys shouldn't judge him negatively either. You people are liberal Muslims he's orthodox muslim. He is a student of comparative religion. You guys I'm sure won't even have 1% of knowledge that he possesses in terms of religion. He knows better than you people. So leave religious matters to religious people.
Why shall we not judge Zakir Naik when he is well known for supporting terrorist, spreads hate and divisions among masses? What his mother a 'man' that he refuses to meet young girls or is his 'iman' so weak that he cannot help himself when among young girls? Common guys what type of Islam this Zakir Naik spreading which only divides people and spreads hate? Wasn't Islam a religion of 'peace and friendship?'
@@LovethisLife785what division and hate has he spread?
Exactlyyy
@@introvertkinda2649 true
Don't think Dr zakir Naik knows everything about religion plzzzzzz
We don't need mulla to understand Quran it's very simple
Based on Faith in Allah
Honesty
Humanity
Please stick to drama reviews and haute talk just about celebrities
Don’t talk about religion because you guys are not experts in that domain
@@mrsecret4567 and far away from TAQWA
🙏
Amna has a problem with maria b's opinion but she herself is so rude when it comes religion.
Our religion is Qua'an and Sunnah
🥰🥰
Amna becahri ko talaq tak ka pata nahi n her baat py religion py comment kerny lgti hein with zero knowledge
Hey Guys please review Nadaan drama it looks really promising 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Everybody has right to express their point of view.Period
@@mrsecret4567 exactly they are noob and talking about the most most influential Islamic personality.
With all due respect Amana you saying it’s Hiba ‘s choice either she want to show her baby bump or not and that is 100 percent right and I agree with you but Dr zakir has no choice if he is uncomfortable to be very close to girls I like you Amna but You are giving to different statements as we know Dr zakir Naik from
Long time and agree with Hassan there must be any strong reason behind that either he was unaware or he is not comfortable with that so please give him respect too
True choice srif actors n vulgure logon ki hoti hai …religious people should first consult Amna😅😅😅😅
Mujy pta tha amma zakir naik k bry me negative bilain gi is ly wo topic suna he ni 😂😂...Amna ka religious knowledge zero hy
@@kafeelakouser5503
😂😂
Amna has zero knowledge of Islam then why she discuss these topics if she doesn't know anything??
she has all the right to give her opinion and she actually talks sense !!
Aamna I think u should not mix your liberal thoughts with islamic facts ...In islam when there is a command or law for something then someones opinion doesnt matter. If you want to counter someone, Then counter with facts not with opinions. ..PLEASE
I'm glad that at least there is someone who understands this matter all
But sadly, even in these comments, people are still blaming Dr. Zakir Naik like who are these people!!!!?
@@ZahaibbinEhsan Islam is an ideology, not a fact. Just because something is an 'islamic fact' that doesn't make it an actual fact. Sorry to burst your bubble.
@@PancakeRights we would rather refer an 'Islamic fact' than an 'actual fact' if the two come in contrast.
@@ZahaibbinEhsanuh no! learn to take criticism of religion 😭
When Hassan and Amna were discussing Hiba Bukhari's dress, I received a call from Angelina (you know how sometimes Amna and Hassan get calls from celebrities, and sometimes we, the audience, too). 🙂
Angelina asked, "Are Hassan and Amna too naive to understand the dress code for a pregnant woman in Pakistan? In Pakistani culture, pregnant women even cover their bump with a dupatta in front of the elders of the family or any male member of the society." Angelina also said, "I am not debating right or wrong here; it's the culture of your country."
I just thought I would share my conversation with Angelina Jolie with you all. 🙂
@@shehlamalik6038 good one
O my my my!!!!too good
@@shehlamalik6038 good one! This is me commenting second time. Idk where the first comment went.
You should tell Angelina that Hiba definitely will cover her bump in front of elders of the family in Pakistan. But here she was in London and not in the presence of elders of the family.
Goooooooooodddd
Don't know why Amna take such topics to discuss in which her knowledge is just zero or wrong,
The Do's Of Modest Clothing In Islam
"Muslim women should wear loose-fitting clothing that does not cling to the body"...its Compulsory in ISLAM, not optional
Does ISLAM tell you to police other women? Hiba will answer Allah on her behalf and so will you. People are not evil because they are not as religious as you
Its haram to watch movies, videos, dramas and songs too. You displaying your pic aka idoi for namahrams. You can't do cherry picking Why does your culture and religion start and end with women and their clothes. Also why should pregnant women cover their tummy? Is this something to be ashamed of? Actually, women's body is a matter of shame for you people.
@@starsrox7427 amar bil maroof and nahi anil munkir, yes Islam gives you right
@@starsrox7427 yes
Ghalat ko ghalat bolo
Atleast
🥰
Wow how literate of you knowing this fact. Then why are you just criticising Hiba and not the other attendees?
Shame on the person who started the controversy about Zakir naik to get views or earn some money.
Exactly…like what the hell?
Hasan take on religious issues is always on point. On the other hand amna's opinions are always worrisome
There you go! another judgement on someone’s religious views 😁
Thts not a judgement ..its a reality.. Islam say door log door he bolqey jaety hain.. bus kerdo@@zoq8384
Why are they worrisome for you?
@@zoq8384 exactly! Anyone who thinks exactly like them is right otherwise everyone going to hell.
💯
haya(sharam) is the beautiful thing for both male and female. It's a beauty of our religion.
I just learned today that Dr zakir naik didn't refuse to give awards to girls due to this mehram namehram reason ,but because his commitment of time to that event had ended, he had to go elsewhere.
Either way, it’s a complete nonissue…
You are wrong. You should see his yesterday's lecture where he himself said that he went off because they were Na Mahram for him. Please watch that lecture which he gave in Karachi
Plane mai photo kerwa li namehram ke sath. Award dene mai maut aah rahi hai.
I have attended zakir naiks lectures... we asked him questions and he replied very nicely we didnt have any other opinion other then that he is a great Gem for islam and we must respect him
Amna, your religious views which will ''offend'' people are not religious views in the first place. Religion comes from religious sources which are more or less agreed upon by everyone (in bigger matters). So girls, however young they may be, when hit puberty, begin to fall under the mehram na-mehram category. Free mixing isn't allowed. Times and culture have normalized it. However, Religiously, it will always stay haram even if nobody observes it in practice.
Please present these ideas as your "personal opinions" that do not concern religion. Or present authentic sources of your veiws everytime you talk about them.
I am not a fan of Dr Zakir Naik but he surely presents references everytime. You want to critisize someone on Religious orientation, counter them with religious sources or just don't name your sayings as "my religious" veiws. Just own them as Liberal veiws instead.
On point 🤍👍
Nailed it 👍🏻
well said. I respect her but her negative view of religious scholars is sometimes very off and offensive (i also get it sometime maybe she hasnt had good experiences with religious ppl but she does exactly what she tells us not to: pass judgement)
well said!
bht sahi kaha. Exactly
Zakir Naik is a religious scholar! He can be invited by any Muslim country without India bullying them.
Why is OK for Amna to give her opinion on things but not OK for others to give theirs on the same matter??!!
If Amna shares her opinion in a way that hurts other’s feelings in a judgemental way, it will be wrong. I don’t see her doing that. People did troll Hiba in that way though
Opinion dene mei aur trolling mei zameen aasman ka farq hai
Because shes giving her opinion while you are giving judgements
Hiba wants to show her baby bump....by all means do so but you got to choose the dress and fabric that compliments the body. The dress didn't do nothing to Hiba. Instead a flowy dress wud hv worked wonders. Maternity dresses are styled differently. The fabric was ...uuuhhh. unfortunately she didn't look great in the dress. Sorry Hiba...
Finally someone said it. Her dress was so tight. Why couldn’t she wear something flowy. Whose asking her to hide because she is pregnant
pick on Dr. Naik for practicing his beliefs that are harmless but chill mahaul for open behaya practices otherwise. wow Amna, you sound so reasonable.
Zakir Naik - no personal choice.
Hiba Bukhari - personal choice
🙄
AMNA IS EVER BIASED. AND TAKES PRIDE IN HER LACK OF KNOWLEDGE
Hiba's dress was immodest. Period!
Urwa Hocane also showed her baby bump in an award show, no one trolled her. Everyone congratulated her and Farhan.
Exactly
ill mentality.
Modest and immodest are very relative. What you are wearing could be immodest for someone who doesn't prefer to show any skin.
And why do you think just because she wasn’t dressed modest enough, she deserves criticism instead of mubarakbaad? Just because Urwa was wearing an eastern outfit when she announced, doesn’t mean her baby bump wasn’t showing
@@Like.every.other.mother That's what I said, urwa showed her baby bump. 'Baby bump' isn't a taboo, it's a miracle and there's nothing wrong in showing your bump..
And i didn't say anything about eastern/western dresses. Western doesn't necessarily mean immodest. Her dress was immodest. She herself wasn't comfortable in that.
Also, I'd like to quote another statement here as well...
Aamna said 'it's her personal choice' which I respectfully agree but why is it that actor/actresses have a personal choice and people don't?? People have a personal choice as well, they can choose to praise, criticize, troll, abuse or whatever they want to say about anyone. Ignore krnaa seekhen na..!
very goog je. Hiba jo b pehne us ki choice Dr Zakir kis ko shield dain aur kis ko nahi wo b unki choice
On one hand, Pakistanis claim they don't believe in forcing religion, but over the past 15-20 years, artists have been relentlessly trolled, showing a complete lack of respect for personal beliefs and choices. This is happening in a country that doesn't even have laws against clothing, dancing, music, or clubs. People argue that the youth are easily influenced, but I disagree. Are we really assuming that, as a nation, we’re so weak that every artist or TV show can sway us? Are we animals who can’t control ourselves? We ban dramas because we can’t simply switch the channel, or ban artists and movies because we can't just boycott or block them? I wonder what these religious zealots will do when Dajjal arrives or when their kids go abroad. There’s no logical thinking in our nation; we're blinded by culture and religion without even understanding the facts. Are we even thinking rationally? Banning porn and people still having an access to that is the prime example. You can't ban the world, you can't ban opinions, verbal or visual. All you can do is create boundaries and choose what is right for yourself rather than shamelessly trolling celebrities in the name of religion
Agreed
@ahmadrehan5059 15,20 saalon ki koshish sy jo nudity aam howi hai wo bhi muslim artists ki tarf sy wo bhi pehly itna openly nhi hoti thee, kya mtlb religion force nhi kiya ja skta ISLAMI Jamhoriya Pakistan mai ? ye sirf Aazadi non muslims k liye hai, muslmaan by_lgaam nhi chhorra jata k gumrah ho k obscenity sy gumrah krta phiry, sb choices islam k basics k under tayy hain tau unhain maan'na hoga,
ap jaisy khud ko mahaan smjhty jinhain shetaan nhi bhatka skta, nabiyon sahabiyon jaisi naozobillah pakeezgi ly k otary tau islam k qanon librals k liye change nahi hojaingy, human is a social animal jo ik dosry sy adopt krty hain acha bura sb, islam sy ziyada logical aur rational koi mzhab nhi jb os ny keh diya, behayai mai aib hai tau hai ap logon ny porn daikhna tau 24 daikho, khud ka imaan sucha pakka sabit kro, agr apko Allah ki guidance blindness lagti, ap apny liye kafi ho,apka personal belief Allah ki obedience sy barra hai tau in shameless boundaries ko khud tk limited rakho, vulgurity k advocate na bano
Aghr kuch b dykhny sy koi effect nhi hota or kisi ko kuch b pyhanay or bolny ki azadi hy to phr jo log objection krty un ko b azadi hy jysy ap kisi ko zbrdsti nfrt nhi krwa skty to mohabbat b nhi krwa skty aik trf khud ko liberal kyhny waly kyhty sub ko apni bat kyhny ki azadi hy phr jb dooari trf un sy koi ikhtlaf krta to us ka ikhtlaf b brdasht nhi hota
@ahmadrehan5059 15,20 saalon ki koshish sy jo nudity aam howi hai wo bhi muslim artists ki tarf sy wo bhi pehly itna openly nhi hoti thee, kya mtlb religion force nhi kr skta agr ISLAMI Jamhoriya Pakistan tau ye Aazadi non muslims k liye, muslmaan by_lgaam nhi chhorra jata k gumrah ho k obscenity krta phiry, sb choices islam k basics k under tayy hain tau unhain maan'na hoga,
ap jaisy khud ko mahaan smjhty jinhain shetaan nhi bhatka skta, nabiyon sahabiyon jaisi naozobillah pakeezgi ly k otary tau islam k qanon librals k liye change nahi hojaingy, human is a social animal jo ik dosry sy adopt krty hain acha bura sb, islam sy ziyada logical aur rational koi mzhab nhi jb os ny keh diya, behayai mai aib hai tau hai ap logon ny porn daikhna tau 24 daikho, khud ka imaan sucha pakka sabit kro, agr apko Allah ki guidance blindness lagti, ap apny liye kafi ho,apka personal belief Allah ki obedience sy barra hai tau in shameless boundaries ko khud tk limited rakho, vulgurity k advocate na bano
@ahmadrehan5059 15,20 saalon ki koshish sy jo nudity aam howi hai wo bhi muslim artists ki tarf sy wo bhi pehly itna openly nhi hoti thee, kya mtlb religion force nhi kr skta agr ISLAMI Jamhoriya Pakistan tau ye Aazadi non muslims k liye, muslmaan by_lgaam nhi chhorra jata k gumrah ho k obscenity krta phiry, sb choices islam k basics k under tayy hain tau unhain maan'na hoga,
ap jaisy khud ko mahaan smjhty jinhain shetaan nhi bhatka skta, nabiyon sahabiyon jaisi naozobillah pakeezgi ly k otary tau islam k qanon librals k liye change nahi hojaingy, human is a social animal jo ik dosry sy adopt krty hain acha bura sb, islam sy ziyada logical aur rational koi mzhab nhi jb os ny keh diya, behayai mai aib hai tau hai ap logon ny porn daikhna tau 24 daikho, khud ka imaan sucha pakka sabit kro, agr apko Allah ki guidance blindness lagti, ap apny liye kafi ho,apka personal belief Allah ki obedience sy barra hai tau in shameless boundaries ko khud tk limited rakho, vulgurity k advocate na bano
Amna is so secular, defending Hiba for wearing what she wants to wear but criticising zakir naik for his choice. Shame on her. These kimd of ppl love to degrade Islamic ppl
@@twinkletwinkle-toddlers5717 this is not being secular, this is being hypocritical.
Shame on Amnna
I totally agree! Amna thinks she’s incredibly smart and aware as a journalist, assuming she can also comment on Islamic issues. Hiba was clearly not dressed modestly, yet Amna is defending her with the "her body, her choice" argument. Amna doesn’t agree with the Islamic principles of modesty and reduces everything to a matter of personal choice. Really? One day, Amna might even defend sex in public. I live in the Netherlands, where most people aren’t Muslim, but even here, showing off a baby bump isn’t considered appropriate. Amna’s perspective is strange-definitely unsubscribing!
P.S. I’m an educated person, doing PhD and living in Europe, so I understand where people like Amna are coming from. It’s bizarre how some disagree with everything and label immodesty as a "matter of choice." Amna, you really need to unlearn and relearn some things!
Zakir naik is a man of religion and he follows it to the core. If he didn’t want to present shields to the girls it’s his right.
Being modest and having Haya are one of those attributes which differentiate muslims from non muslims. I find nothing wrong with Sir Dr Zakir approach, by the fundamentals teaching of Quran muslim men and women are encouraged refrain from na mehram. I disagree here with Aamna here. As muslims we cannot be liberal about everything. We are the people blessed with the best religion Islam and there are clear do's and don't and we should not cross those lines. Same for Hiba, I wish her well on the her new journey to parenthood. Her dress was not modest and it seemed like she wanted attention for her pregnancy. Again as I said Haya is the gift of Allah, unfortunately our Pakistani people are very keen on losing it.
Zalir naik is no doubt religious personality... I know i am not that very religoius, bt still what ever he says is right we have to refrain from non mehram... Hum woh apny aap pe apply nahi karty doesn't mean it is not in our religion .... So one should know Doe's and don'ts of our religion ( whether we apply it on our self or not)
From India
I don’t know Dr. Zakir Nayk personally but based on my experience with attending religious gatherings I can say that he was probably misinformed about the setting of the event. Free mixing isn’t allowed in Islam but in Pakistan these Obligations orders are seen as being offensive.
If we favor woman wearing revealing clothes in public, then we should also agree with men choice of not interacting with the non-mehrams. There is nothing degrading about it; is it actually a gesture of giving respect.
on point
Pakistan ko zaik naik jaise hateful joker ki zaroorat nahi hai.
Please guys don’t talk about religion , keeping your personal opinion to yourself is better if you have no knowledge about Islam. We all do different sins but claiming that its not even a sin in public is worse than doing the actual sin
Every one has choice…same goes for #Dr zakir Naik…. But according to Amna choice srif actors n vulgure logon ki hoti hai ….religious people should first consult Amna😅😅😅😅…
100%
Dr. Zakir Naiq has had sessions attended by thousands of women. He has been questioned by as many women as men. He never showed any resistance answering them. He has interacted with many women of different religions, wearing all sorts of dresses. Please do not drag him in any controversy. He is an extremely learned person. We should be thankful to him for visiting Pakistan. I have immerse respect for him.
💯 Amna Isani with her own version of Islam drags people into unnecessary controversies.May Allah give hidayat to us all,Ameen.
Well said mahnoor I mean what that man has done in the past is work of brilliance I mean converting people to the religion of Islam is not easy. In the stream of scholars he might be one of the few one’s who actually give references about every statement. Least we can show is respect to the person . This topic is not a means of entertainment or trivia to be discussed I feel. Felt weird. Especially when aamna is saying she doesn’t know him then how can you judge the person. It’s simple if he didn’t want to interact or shake hands in close proximity it’s fine. Otherwise in all the videos it’s pretty normal for him to talk to both the genders very casually .
But he has also said alot of controversial things. He doesn’t respect minorities either. As Muslims we’re taught to treat everyone with respect & not to create fitna. Don’t just follow anyone blindly & giving him award for best scholar though he’s not that learned & claims to have read every religion. When he doesn’t even interpret islam properly.
Please amna you are a wonderful person but please refrain from commenting on religious issues
Also zakir naik has been proven many times to provide false references. And it’s not a one of mistake, his demeanor of knowing everything and quoting history and books are mostly fake and made up
People are not criticising hiba because of pregnancy, but she chose a very bad dress and doesn't look nice. I think she could look beautiful in Eastern attire. I think people should know which kind of dresses they should wear on different occasions and hiba clearly have bad taste same like yumna.
Yesss exactly
Majority of comments I have seen are criticising her for accentuating her baby bump. Reffering to her as “shameless”. Why does it matter if her dress is Eastern / Western
There is something called 'apni marzi'.... And it is her choice how she wanted to dress. Ager kissi ko modest nahin laga tu woh khud aise kapre na pehne when they get pregnant. Behayai tu tub hoti ager Hebah and Arez were not married and having a baby and then flaunting their pregnancy. Aik Halal kaam jis kee Allah swt ne ijaazat dee hai tu woh ghalat kaise ho sakta hai. Ager haya kee baat karni hai tu phir tu har woh aurat aur mard Jo Allah swt ke bataaye huay dress code ko follow nahin karte woh Behaya hain.... Iss liye Jo best cheez log kar sakte hain woh yeh hai ke koshish karein ke woh khud aisa kuch na karein Jo against the principles of Islamic values ho. Apne aap ko improve karte nahin log aur dosron ko criticise karna shuru kar daite hain.
I have no issue with wht hibba is wearing its her choice but being pragnant myself I was surprised to see her wearing so tight n uncontrollable clothes…I dont know how women manage wearing so tight clothes in pragnancy???for me its in bearable n my belly hurts if i wear little tight trouser…😅all my clothes during pregnancy are xxl
I think if she wore same dress but maybe bigger size or lose design dresses for pregnant women but she looked pretty MashALLAH
Aamna seems to have her own definition of modesty. She wouldn’t be asking “Kiun” again and again, if she would just look up details on modesty.
Hiba looked stuck in that dress, she didn't look good from the aesthetics point of view as well apart from the behayai and religious debate
She herself wasn't comfortable
Exactly forget about the bump ,it looked so fitted even from the back.She could have done something classy instead of this.
Btw immodest isn’t only when skin is showing.Plus the way she had her hands on the stomach come on stop getting influenced with west in all the wrong things 🤦🏻♀️
I think with hiba bukhari it was that she’s always shown herself to be a very modest actress until like last year where she changed her dressing. Whenever someone perceived modest dressed open for the first time they always unfortunately get trolled 😭. And I’m pretty sure it wasn’t because of the baby bump but very tight clothing
After listening this discussion and reading most of the comments i came to an answer That we as nation r going away from Practising deen. We call ourselves Muslims but we are unaware of its teachings. We pick & choose from deen what suits us. Here lies the answer. Once we start practising deen, there will be no such discussion as reality will be clear to us.
Actually those girls could be baligh. Some girls become baaligh at 8 or 9.
They were not Little girls of 4,5,6 years of age. So most religious scholars like to maintain a safe distance. You will not find any religious scholar from Saudi or Madinah Islamic University, addressing girls such close proximity.
This is the most pathetic reasoning I've ever read. Which girl become baligh at 8 or 9? This sentence will get one jailtime in the USA. Only a pervert thurkhee budha will get turn on by kids of his grand daughter age. Didn't he eat food and drink water in the plane? Who served him that? Edhi Sahib was a 10 times b better person than this thurkee budha. He took care of 1000's of girls.
Reading the comments made me realize why we havent developed as a soceity ✌️
My thoughts exactly. I like the show, but not the audience and comments. Aamna and Hassan have raw chats, the audience it seems, are still living under rocks.
Comments padne ke baad to lagta hai kya hi kar liya hum insaano ne plane banakar? ,kya hi karna tha matlab kyu educate ho rahe hai rahne dete hai kyuki farak hi nhi padta hai kyuki education sirf deegree ke paper me hi hai number ke roop me dimag me to sirf😅 rahne dete h
Haa ab kuch log aa kar reply karege please stay away from this topic it's about our relegion and yeah that's true I am not muslim but yaar maar daloge kya samne wale ko matlab pura comment section bhara pada hai hiba bukhari ne kaise kyu kiya , tum logo ko koi kaam dhandha nhi jab dekho dusro ke kapdo aur vo jo kar rahe hai us par comment pass karte rahte ho 😅😅😅😅 chodo sorry kisko samjha rahi hu mai bhi 😅
Hasan
People are not trolling hiba because she is pregnant but because of the green dress she wore
Fabric was not suitable
Nope. She is definitely being trolled for being out and about whole being pregnant. Her green dress was probably one of the modest dress on the red carpet. She was covered head to toe.
@@rubina9031head to toe but like a tight ghilaf. there are many ways to decently dress while pregnant and still show the bump. Her hips were showing too.
It was not a good fit.
People clearly said pait phula kar agayi!!! What the hell! There was no issue regarding fabric or dress
@@rubina9031aisa dress Allah ny allow nhi kiya k pehn k bhi nangy ho ap hr part of body alag dikh raha ho
Amna, Islam is very differently practiced worldwide in different muslims countries.
Having grown up in Saudi Arabia, Zakir Naik is not wrong.
I went to a school that was completely segregated, during parent-teacher conferences my or any other students father couldn’t come inside. We had to cover our faces when leaving, that was a choice.
But yes, he is correct.
Girls are na mehram.
But, he could’ve informed beforehand what he is and isn’t willing to do.
Anyways, something haute platform should not discuss this topic coz Dr Zakir Naik is a MOTBER personality of this era. Please don't do
You discuss hiba bukhari dress mamiya dress etc
Please 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Ab Saudia modern horaha hai.
Stopped watching the video when Amna associated people having a problem with Hiba's dress with them actually having a problem with sex. 😂 Like seriously you both are looking like noobs giving cultural commentary on a country you were born and brought up in. Hiba should NOT have been trolled. But dont act naee-vay (naive). You guys know that the problem was not her pregnancy or her body shape. It was the 'choice' of her dress. Yes Aamna. The word is CHOICE. Jus how Dr. Zakir Nail CHOSE to not interact with the young girls.
First of all nobody is saying that a pregnant lady needs to stay home. Secondly, in Islam it is compulsory ( not optional)to dress modestly for all women, then you think it will be fine for a pregnant woman to dress in such a figure hugging outfit. And since you guys are so keen on comparing with Hollywood, i think she tried to replicate Angelina Jolie's iconic green dress in her first preg. Well go and see the pics online, she is far more modestly covered, the silhouette was flowy, the fabric everything was right. And did you see Hiba's back side( sorry to be soo crude) but it was not a good look.
And as far as Hiba and Arez's reactions are considered, i mean are you guys unique or the first ones to be parents! It is special to you and your fans but not to the rest of the world. Grow up!! Arez definitely mentioned it to Nadia Khan, so why the outrage. I hope the best for both of them but they need to mature. Hiba was walking around London and not expecting anyone to find out while being so heavily pregnant 🤔
Amna and Hassan acting like they don’t know what cultural nuance on “modesty” is … yes, our culture expects women to wear more flowy clothes, no one is blind and can’t notice a pregnancy but the way she was dressed was meant to really over emphasize it …
Also Amna’s definition of modesty is … just don’t do a Demi Moore 😂😂😂
Totally agreed! Being pregnant is a natural process but you are not supposed to showcase yourself purposefully. One should not leave the modesty in anyway.
Agree 💯 on how bad her dress was. The fit, fabric, style, all of it. She should have chosen a maternity or custom dress.
Agree@@ShiQ-gc5tx
Aamna aap se ek request hai aap apne subject ke alawa religion aur islamic books ki study bhi start karen please....pregnant lady kya kare hasan se na poochen. 😂
Hiba looked very pretty on the red carpet; her skin was glowing. She just seemed a bit conscious and uncomfortable; she could have carried the dress more confidently.
Please stay away from religious topics
Agreed…
Although the topic was not religious at all, it was about a scholar, getting off the stage, by any reason known to him, still I am shocked by the comments on #Amna and her take which is really non existent. She tries to stay away from such topics, although I found her a genuinely open minded and morally correct person in last 5 years
First of all, in pakistan, the management of most of such events is very off. They don't inform the guests beforehand about the whole programme, its requirement and right timings.
So it's a big possibility that he wasn't informed about the time and he may have to go somewhere else or he wasn't informed that he would have to present shields to young girls.
2ndly, even if he knew, he might not know that it'd be young girls who are na-mehram for him, it's his right to decline. He is entitled to act according to his beliefs.
Giving answers to religious questions in a mehfil is allowed in islam, but handing over shields means there will be physical interaction which is not allowed.
3rdly, dr. Zakir naik is a religious scholar who knows Quran and all the books of hadith. He definitley knows more than you and me. We are no one to criticise him.
Lastly, the number of people he has converted to islam (may Allah accept and reward his deeds) he deserves immense respect and should not be criticised over such trivial issues.
Lets discourage the propaganda of indian media and specific sect in pakistan.
your second point is so valid.. it is completely his right.. waise tou subko sare hi rights yad rehte hain mgr koi scholar apne liye koi right use kre tou sub ko masla ho jata hai
Absolutely I am shocked that an Islamic scholar is being criticized for not mingling with girls. Yes they are little girls but they fall in the category of na mahram as the age of puberty varies from age of 8 - 13.
An absolutely despicable thing . Very disappointed so you are not interested in a scholars visit to Pakistan unless a controversy came up .
This is your sincerity with deen and then you think you bringing a change by your 2 cents.
You guys have hours to discuss people's clothes and fashion sense but didn't have 2 sentences to welcome him to Pakistan unless it has become controversial. Good TRP scheming.
She nitpicks on nothings, goes into specifics of "non-issues", but is completely dumb, in fact intentionally anti-Islamic when it comes to Islam
Exactly. So disappointed.
Agree 💯%
Zakir Naik ki zaroirst Pakistan ko nahi hai.
I agree with Hassan Dr. Zakir replies very logically quoting ayats from Quran and is very convincing. Many people have accepted Islam being convinced by his logical debate.
this wasn't about speaking to women it was about presenting them shields in closer proximity than women usually interact with him
but I did not like his QnA session held in Karachi. his answers were not satisfactory.
@@ayshcandy7155 Did you attend?
@@ayshcandy7155 Actually his answers to non muslims are really good. He probably comes prepared in India and Dubai to debate with non muslims. Maybe he didn’t take questions of muslims in Pakistan too seriously or the questions were not challenging. Also he is more used to and is fluent in english than in urdu. Sometimes people ask stupid questions, jin ka jawab kia de. I saw a video of a young girl who couldn’t even formulate the question properly, but probably wanted to know why we have zina and pedophile in a muslim society. He preaches Islam, if muslims are not true muslims and commit sins , it is not the fault of islam. Zakir Naiq is an expert in comparing Bible geeta with Quran. For example when an Indian hindu talks to me about the status of women in islam, i tell them that islam is the only religion that has given rights to women , even right in inheritance, no other religion has . That is why other religion states had to make their own laws later on. So it is Islam vs other religions , not what muslims do and what non vs non muslims do in today’s world.
@@ayshcandy7155 Actually he is an expert in debating with non muslims. If a non Muslim challenges something from the Quran, then watch his replies. He is expert in comparing Bible geeta with Quran.
Hassan needs to bring his elegance back. He should have a neat hair cut and wear elegant shirts.
The propaganda about Dr. Zakir Naik seems completely false. He answered questions from anchor and actress Farah Sadia in a program, and he appeared to be completely okay with it.
Whats so wrong if Dr Zakir Naik.did not wanted to come so near and present shields to non mehram girls? It is his choice and if this is his point of view we should respect it. Interacting with opposite gender when needed and when not needed is different. He answers the questions to ladies but when presenting something you have to smile and there is a chance of touch and every practicing muslim will want to avoid that. That should be respected. Most of the girls are becoming adult at age of 9-10 nowadays and one have ti follow rules of sharia for that.
I agree we need to spread love . My grandparents and parents were born and raised in Pakistan. Partition was sad and they had to move to Punjab India. My love for Pakistan is strong and I wish to visit my family's villages one day. ❤❤❤❤❤
17:50 Hassan, Tarak Fateh was never given a red carpet and was never state guest in India. Also, Tarak Fateh was never provided presidential security in India. He was mostly invited by News Channel and not by Prime Minister of India. He wasn't banned in western countries. Infact, he used to live in Canada and was Canadian citizen. He was never given Indian citizenship. Get your facts right. Zakir Naik is banned in many western countries and has serious money laundering charges against him. Don't compare apple and oranges
But the question is, was any of those allegations proven against him? Because this could also mean, that they banned him for the sake of banning not for an actual crime?
Money laundry 😅
No point giving them logic. Hassan compared India-Pak relations with India-Qatar. Talk about sensibilities
@@afaqahmadkhan2956 He wasn't banned in India. He ran away due to fear of arrest which is cowardly because many opposition leaders, activists have been to jail, fought and won their case against government. Even if he didn't want to return, he could have hired a lawyer to fight his case. It's not that he is poor and can't afford lawyer.He belongs to affluent family.
That shows Hassan's biasness towards fascist..i don't even know who that tariq is..but zakir naik is a terrorist...
And they r felicitating him...wow
Everybody can talk on Religion
Its not ristricted to Mulla,s only
I enjoyed Hassan and Amna,s conversation
Coz Allah said in Quran 756 times to research on Me (Allah) and then follow
So plz dont b emotional on religion conversation so much
Allah believes in peace
Sultan Salahuddin Ayyubi: The set of Sultan Salahuddin Ayyubi was originally built for Emre Konuk's previous series "The Great Seljuks" so, Pakistan almost has no contribution to it and Hassan keeps mentioning that it's a collaboration with the creator of Ertugrul Ghazi but no this series is produced by Akli Films, whereas Ertugrul Ghazi was produced by Tekden Films & Akli Films previous successful project was The Great Seljuks franchise btw Aamna thanks a lot for visiting the set and I'm looking forward for your reviews in the episode, where Noor ul Hassan would make a cameo. thanks for reading.
You don't need these stupid shield issues to highlight the hypocritical nature of Zakir Naik. Just listen to his answers on KPK girl question on religious bigotry in the name of Islam in her region. Just listen how angrily he didn't even listen instead humiliated that innocent young girl. Even one pak actress was also got negative response by this same guy.
Y Not invite Dr Zakir Naik? He’s the Real celebrity, a genius, human computer and an asset for us Muslims who put to shame so many Debaters who picked on Quran and Islam. What a shame that we stir controversies about a personality like him without even looking at his brilliant background. Should give him some benefit of doubt rather than yapping about something that we don’t have the full knowledge of
I though zakir naik has passed
@@belazia4572😂😂
Please talk about it too. Zakir naik insulted a pathan girl when she asked we have islamic rules but still people are pedophiles why it is like that ? He misbehaved so badly. Plus he said if a woman can’t find a single man, any modest woman will choose the married man to get marry and those who choose not to get marry are public property or bazari aurat.
Hi guys, just wanted to let you know, I am an ardent cricket fan and Vikrant Gupta is known in the cricketing circuit for inflammatory statements and spewing hate against cricketers. He does not have any credibility as a ‘journalist’ and will say about anything that will create a controversy and/or is click bait. Unfortunately his negative comments garner a lot of views and he has become popular in that way. Please don’t think his statements portray the view of the cricketing circuit or Indians as such! Love you guys, and respect for Pakistan!
Excuse ne Hassan Choudhary !!! How could you define Zakir is good man coz he address women as sister. Don't forget in Islam you marry sister. So, calling someone sister doesn't mean he respects women.
Why do we as a nation ALWAYS feel the need to comment on ANYTHING and EVERYTHING especially when it comes to women?! Our sense of religion begins and ends with women! Who cares if she didn’t carry her dress well? Who cares if her dress was not the right cut, material, bla bla bla! It is so difficult to dress comfortably when you are heavily pregnant! Instead of congratulating Hibba on her pregnancy, the entire focus was on what and why she was wearing! Seriously people grow up and learn to be a little less opinionated! People don’t even consider the impact their words will have on the person in question ESPECIALLY when that person is pregnant which is a beautiful but difficult period of one’s life as is!
Tau khud ko showpiece na bnaye na urwa bhi last year pregnant thee jb award show attend kiya
@@Meemomina but why do u CARE how she dresses up? I don’t understand how her wearing that green dress impacts you? Ur comment further proves my point that we feel the need to have an opinion on EVERYTHING!
@@gulrukhsarzeb7965 as a society impact tau hota hai tbhi Allah ny surah noor ayat no. 19 mai mana kiya hai ahadees mai bhi mana kiya gya aisy dress sy jisy pehn k bhi kuch cover na ho, as a muslim concern tau hota hai ya Allah ki had tot'ty howy khamoshi sy khudgharzi sy daikhty rahain? Burai ko achaai bna k sabit krain?
@@gulrukhsarzeb7965 as a society impact tau hota hai tbhi Allah ny sorah noor ayat no. 19 mai mana kiya hai ahadees mai bhi mana kiya gya aisy dress sy josy pehn k bhi kuch cover na ho, as a muslim concern tau hota hai ya Allah ki had got'ty howy daikhty rahain? Burai ko achaai bna k sabit krain?
@@gulrukhsarzeb7965as a society impact tau hota hai tbhi Allah ny surah noor ayat no. 19 mai mana kiya hai ahadees mai bhi mana kiya gya aisy dress sy jisy pehn k bhi kuch cover na ho, as a muslim concern tau hota hai ya Allah ki had tot'ty howy daikhty rahain? Burai ko achaai bna k sabit krain?
They have right to discuss ZK as he him self carries 1000 Kg Social media equipment and 8 social media workers with him.
From social media perspective.
Plus ZK was so rude to so many locals asking questions.
Then he dodged questions.
Both parties need to be polite
You guys should have addressed Adii claiming that Neelam Muneer should remove her mole in order to “attract him” in a podcast with Faisal Qureshi
KGF and RRR are Kannada and Telegu films, from the states of Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh and Telengana, not Tamil films, which is from Tamilnadu. The three languages and their origins are totally, completely differet.
Bhai kgf is a kannada film and its from Karnataka 😂
@@mujtabashadab8346 yes actually. My bad.
Its Te-lu-gu.
Muslim countries are honoured to have Omar sulaiman, sheikh Assim al Hakeem, Zakir Naik as guests to their country, and here our esteemed SH hosts say they shouldn’t come because of they follow Islam to the core. Bhai wah!
Totally agreed with Hassan on Dr. Zakir Naik.... Everybody has a right to have his views and a freedom of speech..
Miss amna agr ap ko mazhab ka nh pata to plzzz seekhain.....ap khud kiya mazhab k mutabiq dressing krti hain...hust look at your self and think about it...
Me blkul batamizi nh kr re...Allah nai aurat ko haya ka paikar banaya hai....yh kis traf jaa rahy hain ap sb ya mein ya hm sb....plzzzzzzzz abhi bhi wqt hai hm sb sambhal jai. Plzzzzz🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
Mind your language! Her dresiing is always decent and modest. Islam mn dusron per tohmat lagana or ghalat bayani kerna bhi bohat barra gunah he which you are committing atm.
@@AthenaRamz Sorry if i hurt you but plzzz read thiss Quranic verse translation and do read tafseer...
And say to the believing women to lower their gaze and to guard their private parts and not to show their beauty spots except that of it which is normally shown. They shall also cover their cleavage with their 'khimars'. They shall not show their beauty spots except in the presence of their husbands, their fathers, the fathers of their husbands, their sons, the sons of their husbands, their brothers, the sons of their brothers, the sons of their sisters, other women, what their right hands possess, the male attendants who have no sexual desire and the children who are yet to attain awareness of women's nakedness. They shall not strike their feet so as to reveal details of their hidden beauty spots. You shall repent to God, all of you, O believers, so that you may succeed. 24:31
Oh please guys don’t discuss Dr.Zakir Nayak on your show especially when this show is all about movies and drama.
M currently living in melbourne n i guess zakir naik, refusing to present shields, needs to be appreciated, thats how religion is practiced. Over here abu taymyah, abu hammuda also came for australia tour, in their lectures they allowed women but questions and lunch session with the scholars was restricted for men only. Free mixing is normal these days, we are all guilty of it, but it doesnt bring any good at many levels.
Those girls must be literally half age of his grand daughters, na mehramon ko sheilds deni thi un k ilm par, na k un k nachne ganay par, I am speechless for those who are favoring this nonsense act, is waqt jab we need more people to present Islam in a positive light Zakir Naik is refusing to present and encourage those little girls.
Maybe he should have stared the girls up and down and try and discern their age before proceeding…
Why the heck is religion looked down upon?
22:26 Don't pass comments about such personalities. His stature is too high to be discussed like that. We have watched his numerous shows and we have witnessed his behaviour with women.
agreed
Agreed great man
HibaB: no comments on religious views on her looks. I believe in women celebrating their bodies and pregnancy the way they want or not. Having said that, while her dress was gorgeous, she couldn’t carry it well and seemed uncomfortable for the most part. For me, it’s not even about the fact that the dress was form fitting, I think that’s cute, but she should’ve chosen a dress she felt comfortable in. Either it should have been set better, or she should’ve chosen a different dress.
Some pregnant women find body hugging dresses comfortable. It provides them with support and eases the pressure on their back. I don't get why everything specific to women's bodies from periods to pregnancy is treated as a taboo. Pregnancy is difficult and we make it even harder for our women.
Islam mai allow nhi figure revealing dreses pehnna, agr itni he support mili rahi the body hugging dress sy tau apna awrah he chadar orrh body k around cover lyti, grace mai kami na aati izaafa he hota
Islam mai allow nhi figure revealing dreses pehnna, agr itni he support mili rahi the body hugging dress sy tau apna awrah he chadar orrh body k around cover lyti, grace mai kami na aati izaafa he hota
Islam mai allow nhi figure revealing dreses pehnna, agr itni he support mili rahi the body hugging dress sy tau apna awrah he chadar orrh body k around cover lyti, grace mai kami na aati izaafa he hota
How I love Aamna & Hassan! Your clarity in thoughts & unprejudiced outlook in a society jahan everyone is judged left & right requires strong willpower. Exactly how well read people usually are, their conscience works best for guiding them towards what’s right and how one should conclude any conversation. Keep up the good work.
lol, But they themselves judged Dr Zakir Naik
Aoa Amna and Hassan. While I respect that you have tried your best to give a neutral take on Dr Zakir Naik, there are some points I would like to get across. Dr Zakir is a very renowned and respected personality with Muslims all around the world and that includes Pakistan. He is absolutely deserving of the protocol and entourage he has been provided with and it doesn't just seem like he's a 'bari shakhsiyat', he actually is one for a huge fraction of Muslim society. The evidence for this is the huge crowd currently gathered to watch him deliver his talk at the governor house, at the screening in a ground and the online live. So I think its disrespectful of you to suggest that he shouldn't have been called to Pakistan if he chose not to interact with those girls on religious grounds. Islam does not allow free mixing, even if nobody follows this command. And no, a lot of the times, event planners in Pakistan do NOT give you a proper schedule with all the expected activities. Its likely that Dr Zakir's team was not told that he would have to present shields. Also, to clarify on the matter of Dr Zakir Naik taking questions from women in his talks, the arrangement of the audience in those talks is such that the women are seated very far from him. The males are right in front of him. He has clearly stated that the reason for this is so he cannot see the faces of the women asking the questions. He can hear them, sure, thanks to the sound system. He can tell which direction in the audience the question is coming from so he can direct his gaze there, but when he looks, he cannot make out the facial features of those women. He can just see a crowd. Its his choice, his beliefs and he is revered for them greatly in Pakistan as well. If you don't agree, thats your choice, of course. But Dr Zakir is as free to have his own opinion and beliefs as you are. And the public is well within their right to follow him if they choose so. Lastly, the Soha and SRK show was just a platform he was invited to to talk about Islam and he had no control over the setting there. The host was very derogatory towards him and it ignited a huge outrage at that time btw. He has never been to such a platform since.
Wishing you both well. Cheers.
Just a little bit of correction! Amna said that he should not be invited to mix gatherings then. His instructions should be followed. She never said that he shouldn't be coming to Pakistan. Rather, they both are defending him from that infamous FB journalist
@@AthenaRamzI agree with the part about them defending him against the journalist. And I respect them for it. :) However, I am referring to a comment in the last minute of the segment on Dr Naik in this video, where it has been insinuated that if he didn't want to interact with the girls, he shouldn't have been invited on a 'national level'. That is a big statement which I think, is disrespectful not just towards Dr Naik but also towards the hundreds of thousands (probably millions) of people who are elated about his visit. Hope you have a good day. 🙂
Now half of pk ppl after amna!!!! That’s the only thing you guys do. Only criticism!!!! No tolerance no acceptance!!!! Now keep on ranting!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mujhe to nhi lagta ki koi pyaar hai dono nations me aur kabhi hoga haa similarities hai aur ek dusre ke country ke stars aur artist ko pasand bhi karte lekin iska matlab ye nhi hai ki pure country se pyaar ho gya hai haa appreciate karte hai hum us individual ko uski art ke liye .
aur agar pyaar tha to fir separate hi nhi hote . separate huye because our thinking is not aline .
The fact of the matter is Dr. Zakir Naik was not asked to hold hands and hop around with those girls. A decent human being IS allowed to award a shield WITHOUT having to touch the girl. This is an absurd ideology.
Secondly, I watched the live session by Hiba and Ariz. They pointed out Nadia's shortcomings multiple times without taking her name.
Hiba clarified that the swelling on her face during the shoot of Radd was not due to pregnancy. She also said that this is a very personal thing and only she and her husband have the right to reveal her news. Then she said "but it's okay". And to that Ariz said, "no it's not okay but she's too nice, I'm not. I will not let this go and will surely roast the person responsible in a seperate video that the public will see on my own channel"
پاکستانی قوم تو یہ بھی ثابت کردے گی کہ ذاکر نائیک مسلمان ھی نہیں ھیں ھم تو اتنی چیتی قوم ھیں
@@fakhrasaadat7456 sad reality
OK lets get this straight - no issues showing ur baby bump but showing it in a way that Hiba did was uncalled for. Amna it was not only the belly but the entire body that was flaunted. Hasan seems more sensible - what are designer maternity dresses for??? She can wear whatever but it did not look decent to most of us . BTW a figure hugging burqa is also not modest for ur point that she was fully clothed .Dont think ur opinion is always correct .
I want to share my view on Mr zakir naik reaction that if it was becz of this that girls are namahram I guess he was not informed earlier otherwise a person like him will never refuse and of he had refused he did absolutely good he is ma sha ALLAH a religious person he can talk with female gender in order to invite them or teach them islam but he doesn't want to go beyond this ..to present Shields to anyone is not an act which will grant you jannah but yes to respect female gender will make you eligible for jannah so I want to show my support to Mr zakir naik
Amna say dont force religion or your religious opinion on others, while defending Barzakh she said that this drama cannot harm or influence anyone then why she feels so threatened by Dr Zakir naik views. Hassan and Amna both said parenting matters and nothing can influence our children then why you feel like Dr zakir should not be invited or he should not follow his value system. dont judge Hiba bukhari but judge Dr Zakir Naik, like what is this behaviour, and your platform is entertainment why you need to discuss religious matters
May be she didn’t LOOK good, modest, comfortable etc to others, but maybe she FELT good, modest and comfortable which is all that matters. Let the pregnant woman be y’all!
We generalize a lot. A PhD does reserach in one particular topic in one subject. A doctorate in specific area of macro economics doesnt make anyone master in all area of economics. Similarly, while Dr. Zakir Naik has used logic to convince Hindu to revert to Islam. He is not a master of all of Islam. He has his flaws like all humans have.
whenever critics talk about plus size fashion or a fashion for a broader body they criticise if they do not have a right silhouette..even they explain the dress should be layered flowy/pleated/ wrap and breathable, that is simply the case..leave the pregnancy its not a shame anymore..the size has increased, body shape has changed, need to dress accordingly. I think the criticism is on a dress actually which was not a great choice to show a baby bump
all aside I felt bad for her that she has to go through this
A person as STATURE of dr zakir naik shoudnt had been asked to distribute shields regarless of gender..he is here for dawah
Yeah pehle kyon nahi decide kiya?
I don’t think ZN has a problem with sitting next to females or answering questions, he gives interviews as well, I think it had some touching involved for him to leave the stage.
Why don't you both wear your something haute merch....???
Hiba apna baby bump bina itna tight dress ke bhi dekha sakte the... Logo ne hamesa Hiba ko ek modest girl ki tarah hi dekha ha, that's why now people are so disappointed from her.
Agreed
I didn’t even mind the tight dress, but she herself was not comfortable in that dress( her comfort should be first priority when she is this pregnant )
Ya it was a bad dress she was not comfortable and it looked bad. She should have found a maternity dress that is supposed to hug the baby bump and flatter the other pregnancy related bumps
One of reason to hide baby bump was to keep you safe from evil eye .
I don't believe in Dr sahib
Coz he considers Hadees so much
We Only Follow QURAN In Quran
We🎉don't anybody between Quran and Insaan
Agreed with u HASSAN AND AMMNA 🎉 IN MY OPINION
WOMEN IS NOT BORN TO LIVE IN HIJAB ABBAYA ETCCCC
MAN HAS LOTS OF RISTRICTIONS
DO THEY FOLLOW 🎉????
We don't need anybody between Quran and human
Discussing Zakir Naik.. really ?? 🤮
They are rather defending him.Please watch the whole discussion and then come up with some proof.
@@AthenaRamz that 🤮 was for Zakir Naik.. I really dont care if they defend him or oppose him..
No offence but I don't think Tamil movies should be released in Pakistan as I don't think censor board will allow it
Amna you don’t have to withhold your religious views , please we need women like you speaking out , u seemed reserved today , while Hassan was quiet expressive about everything , please don’t let the negativity of people in comment section get to you. Your views wether religious or not absolutely make sense and you speak what’s in our minds and in our hearts.
Unfortunately the society is not ready for us ;) But that should not stop us from speaking up . Anyways I think Hassan should speak less though , just a thought 😊 as not everything he say makes sense at times like today , supporting dr zakir stance Incase he’s avoiding na mehram girls on stage but on the contrary he’s sharing the stage with soha Ali khan in India ? Also what’s wrong with celebs doing photoshoots and celebrating their pregnancies or other important events however they choose to do it , by showing themselves or covering themselves, that’s their choice ! Their lives .
That’s all I had to say , i watch your show regularly , this is my first time commenting on any channel FYI .
Amna , u go girl !
Aamna should speak out about religion despite not knowing much about it?
@@sabahatmazhar6056 and who are we to decide about that ?? Are we some religious scholars ourselves? No right , so yeah everyone has the right to say what they want , some would disagree and some would agree , this is how it is .
@@Sh87-cv9ds who are we to decide that? You already decided that Aamna should speak out no matter what…and I’m asking a simple, logical question that she should speak out even without knowledge, something that she’s admitted herself many times?
Why are you shocked....the Pakistani producers need to accept and sell it to streaming service!
Hamza Ali Abbasi from Maula jatt is a terror sympathizer and has defended Hafiz Saeed (Master mind of Mumbai terror attack) multiple times!
I think this reason is enough for you guys to know about the protest against the release of Maula Jatt!
Evidence? You do know one persons terrorist is another persons freedom fighter!
The Case of Maula Jatt should be taken as a lesson. Zee TV bought the rights to it two years ago and got it banned in India. Now , the makers of Maula Jatt can't sell it to China and OTT until it is released in India. Maula Jatt is only opposed by Shiv Sena, but there were plenty of Indian movies that were protested against by Hindudtva and 17 states, but still, the movies were released. Indian SC lifted the ban on Pakistani movies and actors in 2023. The truth is India doesn't want to release it. Meanwhile, at least 3 indian movies ( north and South) came out with copied scenes and background scores of Maulla jatt. This is how India destroys Pakistani entertainment industry. The cinemas that initially boycotted Maulla jatt in Pakistan are also owned by Indian investors. All thanks to our Muhajir population in Karachi. Indian policy is to get a market in Pakistan for Indian movies and destroy the local Pakistani industry. These so-called Punjabi movies made in England are also produced by Bollywood.
@@gerryburntwood9617 What freedom a person born in punjab pakistan will get by sending ter*or*st to Mumbai India and by killing hundreds of people including foreigners? Are you seriously saying that the attacks that took place on 26/11 were okay? You need to get your Brain checked
Really wah!!!
Speaking of behayi.. young married Pakistani women are constantly asked are they pregnant/when are they getting pregnant/ when are they having their second/third child, etc? That literally translates into are you having sex without contraception.
Dr. Z Naik ;In a world where diddy exists ( n who know how many more hollywood celebs) , i don’t mind if an adult doesn’t want to interact with young girls.
You have any idea how many girls are raped and molested by their mehrams? And im not talking about their husbands here. So the less said about today's world, the better.
I doubt Maula Jutt will get a release in India because of the current political climate. The best thing is for Maula Jutt to be released on an OTT Platform.
No one is against Hiba celebrating the new step in her life. It's the dressing that should've been modest.
U r right. Amna ko adat hy bhayai ki cheezy promote krny ki. Bila fazol hiba ko cover kr rahi hy. Han ji amna ji
What was immodest about the dress? Was Hiba going to a religious event?
She certainly wasn’t immodest! I don’t like obese men showing their paunch, but no one cares when this protrusion happens even in a shirvani🤣🤣🤣
I was introduced to this channel when a controversy regarding tere bin MR sequence had just unfolded. And that was out of the blue, i didn't even know about this show (tere bin) but i got haute's video recommended on my feed and i watched it. I was quite happy reading all the progressive comments there regarding women's respect and dignity. But the kind of comments i read on this video are so different even disturbing to a degree. Zakir Naik is the same person who had said that women who remain unmarried are 'public property'. This video from 8 years ago still exists on TH-cam. So many people are defending him here, even worse, pointing out what a great religious scholar he is. I don't know how their audience has changed completely in such a short time. Sad.