Personally I think you should go in release order and first listen to the singles then the respective album. So going by that the order will be: What makes you beautiful One thing Gotta be You Up all night (album) Edit: I stand corrected.. I think doing them in a random order with compilation in between would be the best option
I think it’d be more fun if you did it randomly!! Like one song from the last album then one from their second and so on. And in between you do like live performances and friendship videos and compilations. It’d definitely be more fun than going in order. I feel like people who do it in chronological order get bored. And you honestly barely see progress going this slowly. That, in addition to the fact that Niall and Louis are barely featured on the first two albums, so it’d be boring waiting for them to have their solos. You know I’m going to watch your reactions either way! Whichever method you choose to go with, I’ll watch and I’ll love it because you’re such an amazing person! I’m just suggesting you go about it randomly, but you choose whichever suits you.
@@sophiagreenhills3239 yes my thought process was the same but I wanted to just get those first two albums over with.. but I agree that randomly doing them would be the best
@@nehanaik2040 the first two albums have some good songs here and there, it gets better with the second album but not quite there yet. It’d be more enjoyable if she mixed them up a bit with the other albums and other random reactions, you know? Getting the first two albums “over with” makes it sound like a chore, but they’re honestly good (sure they’re not GREAT, but they’re not like bad bad) so I think mixing things up would be best, and it’d honestly be very interesting going back and forth to see their progress and how much things changed, instead of doing it slowly chronologically. Just my thoughts!
Have to feel bad for Niall though, because he didn't get to experience being greeted in his home town. I think they would have made a really big thing out of welcoming him home
I do believe they had some gimmicks done to their iems. I happen to know a few of ex X factor contestants in my country and they all said if they wanted to show some act in a bad light, there's always this option with monitors( I bet it was a franchise thing.. Although there's a chance they didn't have much time for 2 new songs and 1 old song with all that travelling and press conferences and additional shooting and rehearsing that week. I bet it was very exhausting by this time. Still I loved their Torn here, and believe it or not with all imperfections of the duet song of all 4 contestants they sounded better then the rest. I liked Matt's duet with Rihanna but the rest were quite miserable)) But 1D came third fair and square imo, they weren't the best act out of 3 people in the final. Their brilliance came through a little later when the tv show ended :)
I think you should do the first album with the music videos in order. I can't wait for you to come on ever week and do the one Direction videos. You are the best. Keep up the good work.
I think nerves played a big part in them being a bit ”messy”. It happens later too. I think you have to remember they’ve only sung together for 10 weeks and with new songs every week plus all the other things they do each week. They were simply not good enough to just smash it every time as they didn’t have as much time as they probably needed to rehearse. They were still ”beginners”. Like, I love them and love them as singers but they aren’t the best in the world and they weren’t the best on x factor. They are still great though. Not sure I’m making sense. To me they grew a lot on X Factor. I loved to see how they came together and I thought you could see their improvement in this short amount of time. It was a journey! But like I’ve said before, I was already a fan when I watched this so I just thought they were the cutest. Coming 3rd is really good! Matt and Rebecka deserved their place though.
30:04 I still wish Liam wasn’t harmonizing with Louis on this one. Louis by himself would’ve been perfect. Liam has such a rough and deep voice, in contrast to Louis’ sweet and high one. I just don’t think Liam works in this. Later on in their career the two learn to harmonize together despite their different… ranges? Is that what it’s called? (most notably the “Hey Angel” bridge) but for right here when they’re so young… I think they should’ve given the whole part to Louis and just Louis. Or maybe let one of the other boys harmonize. Thank God Louis’ voice isn’t overshadowed by Liam’s in this one (probably cause Liam’s mic volume is low) but in other performances Liam’s harmony would be louder than Louis’ part.
If you watched all the way to the end....comment here on what your preference is going forward!!
Album up all night first
Personally I think you should go in release order and first listen to the singles then the respective album.
So going by that the order will be:
What makes you beautiful
One thing
Gotta be You
Up all night (album)
Edit: I stand corrected.. I think doing them in a random order with compilation in between would be the best option
I think it’d be more fun if you did it randomly!! Like one song from the last album then one from their second and so on. And in between you do like live performances and friendship videos and compilations. It’d definitely be more fun than going in order.
I feel like people who do it in chronological order get bored. And you honestly barely see progress going this slowly. That, in addition to the fact that Niall and Louis are barely featured on the first two albums, so it’d be boring waiting for them to have their solos.
You know I’m going to watch your reactions either way! Whichever method you choose to go with, I’ll watch and I’ll love it because you’re such an amazing person! I’m just suggesting you go about it randomly, but you choose whichever suits you.
@@sophiagreenhills3239 yes my thought process was the same but I wanted to just get those first two albums over with.. but I agree that randomly doing them would be the best
@@nehanaik2040 the first two albums have some good songs here and there, it gets better with the second album but not quite there yet. It’d be more enjoyable if she mixed them up a bit with the other albums and other random reactions, you know? Getting the first two albums “over with” makes it sound like a chore, but they’re honestly good (sure they’re not GREAT, but they’re not like bad bad) so I think mixing things up would be best, and it’d honestly be very interesting going back and forth to see their progress and how much things changed, instead of doing it slowly chronologically. Just my thoughts!
Have to feel bad for Niall though, because he didn't get to experience being greeted in his home town. I think they would have made a really big thing out of welcoming him home
I do believe they had some gimmicks done to their iems. I happen to know a few of ex X factor contestants in my country and they all said if they wanted to show some act in a bad light, there's always this option with monitors( I bet it was a franchise thing.. Although there's a chance they didn't have much time for 2 new songs and 1 old song with all that travelling and press conferences and additional shooting and rehearsing that week. I bet it was very exhausting by this time. Still I loved their Torn here, and believe it or not with all imperfections of the duet song of all 4 contestants they sounded better then the rest. I liked Matt's duet with Rihanna but the rest were quite miserable)) But 1D came third fair and square imo, they weren't the best act out of 3 people in the final. Their brilliance came through a little later when the tv show ended :)
I think you should do the first album with the music videos in order.
I can't wait for you to come on ever week and do the one Direction videos. You are the best. Keep up the good work.
i can't believe we're getting started on the first album! I'm so happy to be here on this journey with you
Loved the surprise!! Grenade was another song they did on the X Factor live tour and it’s my fav of their pre-album era.
You go gurly 😝😝 keep slaying queen 👑👑
I think nerves played a big part in them being a bit ”messy”. It happens later too. I think you have to remember they’ve only sung together for 10 weeks and with new songs every week plus all the other things they do each week. They were simply not good enough to just smash it every time as they didn’t have as much time as they probably needed to rehearse. They were still ”beginners”. Like, I love them and love them as singers but they aren’t the best in the world and they weren’t the best on x factor. They are still great though. Not sure I’m making sense.
To me they grew a lot on X Factor. I loved to see how they came together and I thought you could see their improvement in this short amount of time. It was a journey! But like I’ve said before, I was already a fan when I watched this so I just thought they were the cutest. Coming 3rd is really good! Matt and Rebecka deserved their place though.
Liam Payne - Strong live on the LP Show, please 🙏
30:04 I still wish Liam wasn’t harmonizing with Louis on this one. Louis by himself would’ve been perfect. Liam has such a rough and deep voice, in contrast to Louis’ sweet and high one. I just don’t think Liam works in this. Later on in their career the two learn to harmonize together despite their different… ranges? Is that what it’s called? (most notably the “Hey Angel” bridge) but for right here when they’re so young… I think they should’ve given the whole part to Louis and just Louis. Or maybe let one of the other boys harmonize. Thank God Louis’ voice isn’t overshadowed by Liam’s in this one (probably cause Liam’s mic volume is low) but in other performances Liam’s harmony would be louder than Louis’ part.
Can you please react to Why Don't We's Music Video for their Song Love back
Too bad you didn't see the results at the end and how they lost and what they said after.