Sotomayor blasts Supreme Court's conservative majority for demolishing foundation of U.S. law
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 มิ.ย. 2024
- Rachel Maddow shares passages from Justice Sonia Sotomayor's dissent from the conservative majority's presidential immunity ruling in which they went above and beyond to concoct an interpretation of the law that would best help Donald Trump evade accountability in his various criminal prosecutions.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#Sotomayor #SupremeCourt #immunity
I am so glad I am on my last leg in this life! As a 20 yr. military veteran, an American citizen for over 70 yr's, I am ashamed for the first time in my life of the so called and NEW rule of law in OUR country! I hope my children and grandchildren have enough foresight to be able to change the wrong that is happening to our democracy and free way of living!
I feel your pain
Thank you for your service 🙏
the majority of military support trump, not biden.and for good reason.
They should and will think for themselves. Nobody should dictate what they think is right and wrong. They are their own people. While I thank you for you service, I hardly agree with your sentiment.
@@talimarks2707 TRUMP 2024! my whole family is military and we live on base, and nobody here is a biden supporter.
Shameful
Corrupt judges
Cope
Corrupt simp.
Ask Garland and your democrat judges.
We are talking the SUPREME court..the highest in the land and right now the most CORRUPT @NotRose-hf7kr
Maga SC justices gave Donald absolute immunity for official acts. All he has to say is “this is an official act” to get immunity on a platter.
Somebody is getting a paid off by his people.
The American people needs to rise up and hold these corrupt judges accountable. This is not acceptable and should be forced to resign!
King Joe Biden needs to now take this opportunity to put a stop to this nonsense.
100%
Don’t we have checks and balances to prevent this? How is it that the the former leader of the executive branch is having an impact on the judicial branch to this extent? Justices are not “president representatives” and should not be given the power to act as such. Despicable. Absolutely disgusting time to be a US citizen
They were it.
WE were always disgusted that you were a citizen, welcome to the club!
Trump purposely destroyed those checks & balances when he appointed 3 corrupt judges to the SCOTUS and the GOP Senate confirmed them, not to mention the 300 Federal judges that Trump appointed. It's hard to believe that one stupid old man with a bad comb-over could do so much damage to America but Trump did it.
ROFLMAO - you had that when America used to be a democracy, but that's now in the past thanks to corrupt justices on SCOTUS.
I agree in principle, but the nation's founders wanted the executive, the court and the congress to be separate in order to protect the constitution - they could not know that 200 years later the evil Trump and the SCOTUS would abuse the spirit of the law. Justice Sotomayor is right to descent. The only one out of nine people with some morality.
Justice Sotomayor is absolutely right. Thank you. 🇺🇸🗳💙
She's wrong. Presidential immunity existed since George Washington, and it's in effect as long as the POTUS upholds the U.S. Constitution, and performs official acts.
@@R0MANS109it’s never been extended to an amoral madman before. SCOTUS are simply Trump’s lapdogs. This will not end well.
@@R0MANS109 Yes, official acts. This SCOTUS has declared telling the DOJ what to do an official act.
@@R0MANS109 👈😂😂😂...proof that MAGAt’s really don’t listen nor process information. 🤦🏼♂️
lol. She’s dumber than a box of rocks.
How can a crime be an “official act”? We don’t elect and pay the President to commit crimes. How much more is the American citizenry going to take this idiocy?
If it's their guy, it's official. If it's the other side's guy, it's unofficial. The Supreme Court has just sliced out a big part of the power constitutionally granted to the legislative branch for itself.
This decision, which grants the executive carte blanche, along with overturning Chevron deference, places the judiciary as the new decider to place constraints on one particular party while allowing the other to do as it pleases.
This is what happens when you allow bad actors to pack the court with partisan hacks.
The courts decide what’s official and unofficial. Guess who controls SCOTUS
@@kylelooper2156 7/3/24: You nailed it! Dark day and many more to follow.
@@kylelooper2156 7/5/24: one of so many reasons why he simply cannot be re-elected.
WE NOW QUESTION THE MENTAL HEALTH, THE BANK ACCOUNTS AND THE LAWS OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGES.....
A CRIMINAL IS A CRIMINAL
They corrupt
@@aliciaharvey4253 ALL Six Of Them!!
My God...I can't believe this is actually happening in America.
If I was a company based in the states I would start moving everything overseas as soon as possible. ( if anyone who runs a company has ever actually read a history book )
You can thank Trump for this..... ✌️🙏
If this was maybe 20 years ago, I’d agree with you. But these days, nothing really surprises me anymore. 🤷♀️
You were sleeping while you should've been protesting. It's all on yourself America!
@cellison9414 I can. I predicted this back in 2015.
I can't control my wife. But I can control yours. -- supreme court justice samuel alito
🎯🎯🎯
At least he has a wife.
lol
how is he controlling your wife and if you say abortion he literally took the control away from the court and put it back in the hands of the voters how can you people be so lost to the fact.
@@Tmanwith3yearsofwork if your wife has that haircut, you're married to a dude.
@@Tmanwith3yearsofworkKudos for keeping the beard, I guess.
This MAGA court is even worse that I thought it would be.
About time you woke up.
It's Exactly What orange jesus Envisioned...
Right Out of The Project 2025 Playbook..
They DO Plan on Overthrowing America by Any Means Possible...
An Armed Democrat !!!!!
Not at all unexpected as this was the plan.
from Europe I'm watching with fear what is happening in US right now. What the heck are you doing to your country/democracy?
watching complete insanity unfold with disbelief
The supreme court has joined the MAGA cult!!!
They have been part of it all along...
Was this not the democracy you were looking for?
Maybe they are the smart ones. It won’t take trump long to form his own brown shirts
Nah. The conservative justices just know how to read and understand what they are reading. That’s a skill no democrat possesses.
Nope. We like free speech.
Well, I guess Biden needs to go to work on holding Trump accountable by going after him. Biden is Immune now.
Biden will do nothing. Too much of a nice guy worried more about his legacy. Pathetic.
He has already been deemed unfit to stand trial. The forgetful old man already had immunity
He has been. Where you been?
That is NOT Biden. As an example Biden could have stopped this by increasing the # of SC justices to 13 early in his administation. And he FAILED to do so. This is in large part -- his own doing. This is sickening to me.
Biden to weak and such a corporate shill he won't do nothing considering he funding a genocide dude has no morals. He like a light version of trump and yt supremacy the both of them
One of the most onerous opinions in this decision is that we can't even look into the Presidents motives for an action, presumption of all actions to be shielded by immunity
Shame on the Supreme Court for this ruling vote for president Biden because if project 2025 comes to this nation gone is everything that we worked hard to win
Shame on Bidens justice department presidents have committed atrocities peeling two pair of white trumped up charges they brought against President Trump, FDR confiscated Japanese Property, businesses and homes and put them in concentration camps throughout the United States also confiscated gold from American citizens, Harry Truman, seizing steel mills Linden, Johnson using the CIA to spy on rivals political campaigns, and the FBI to bug campaign opponents planes Lyndon Bill Clinton bombing a foreign country on the eve of his scheduled impeachment Barack Obama and Joe Biden opening of the borders in violation of direct federal law. These are crimes against the American citizens, by sitting presidents of the United States.
Good point! If encouraging a riot and the interference with the orderly business of congress is not a crime then what is? Why also is it even necessary for a president elect to even take an oath of office which the Supreme Court has now rendered meaningless?
@@davidwalker9989 agree
And the soon to be ex dem congressman who was caught on camera pulling the fire alarm in the Capitol to literally halt proceedings…..
They're setting things up for a 2nd Trump reign
If inciting a riot or interfering with congressional business was illegal ... alot of liberals would be in prison .
Obama should be imprisoned for ordering the execution of a 16 year old son of a terrorist....unless you consider actions as president separate
We better not lose Sonia, Elena or Ketanji anytime soon. They're the ONLY justices with any common sense left in this festering dumpster fire of a SCOTUS.
😆😅🤣😂🤣😅😂😂😂
Those three are the worst.
@@SirAbyss dei hires
All of them are great justices. You need conflicting ideas and interpretations for this to work well. It has been a liberal court for many years and now it is mostly conservative. It will go back to liberal someday. Packing the court is dishonest.
Kentanji couldn’t even define what a woman is, pathetic Dems.
It may not feel like it, but it’s a DARK day in America. 😢
America as we know it 🇺🇸 will never be the same.
Scotus literally just declared their first ever 🤴 King Biden. 🇺🇸 USA is now in its pre-monarchy infancy, and
SCOTUS has officially initiated their part in Project 2025 in declaring KINGSHIP. 👑
RIP The office of the presidency of USA 🇺🇸 7/1/24
Welcome autocracy fascism plutocracy & dictatorship
Good Luck North America you’re gonna need it.
@@jahhebrew4968 yes We have a president that has mental and cognitively unable to continue carrying out his duties and a vice president. That was a DI pic. This is a dark day.
It very much feels like it. Dark days have begun, even though their roots started in the 1970's. I listened to Robert Reich detail the predictable fall of America
So sad... sooo much corruption in the court
That’s y Trump chose to appeal to the SCOTUS his walking ticket 😡
Whichever side of politics you're on you have to see the way the Supreme Court is built needs to be fixed.
We need to fix our Supreme Court! They are Bias in the law. Regular citizens have lost rights to save our country
@@pdjhh no it works just says it’s supposed to.
@@45lclevergun so if 5 of them get killed in an accident when Dems are in they can load it with dems and vice versa?
Not mine, but I'll use it anyway.
"If you've ever wondered what you would have done during the rise of Fascism in the 1930s? You're doing it now."
The six GOP justices should face serious charges for sedition, abuse of authority, aiding and abetting the insurrectionists and treason. And for violating their oaths to uphold the constitution and the rule of law.
I like this. You are so right. All of us are guilty. However, some of us do not have the means to call out the ignorance, e.g., a bully pulpit or money to affect change. All we have is the vote. But too many of us are ill informed or dumb to realize when we are voting against our best interest.
But we all knew something like this could happen, BUT we played it off, "it could never happen in the US". Thank you to the media and congress for doing nothing.
There were dozens, probably hundreds, maybe even thousands of members of the media who did a lot and tried hard to affect more than they did... including reporters and anchors at MSNBC and other legitimate networks, writers at the Washington Post and New York Times, and many others including innumerable bloggers, TH-camrs, etc., but they lost out to the Faux News Propaganda network and their ilk. There were many in Congress who tried, too; but the fact that nearly every Congressional Republican has been complicit with this extremist takeover of the government defeated those efforts, as well. Plenty are fighting, we're just outnumbered, or when we're not outnumbered we're outmaneuvered, and when we're not outnumbered or outmaneuvered... they fight dirtier than we do...
Suddenly America really does have a two tier system of justice
America died today.
MONEY influences the countries politics while the common poeple pitted against one another.
It will rise like the Phoenix.
Good ALWAYS prevails over evil.
Severely injured and on life support....
A little over 3 years ago
United States of Russia 😔
From the UK, sorry American citizens but you are gonna lose all your rights come November if you allow Trump to get in…do the right thing for yourselves and the world and vote Blue
I’m an American and I totally agree w/ you.
@user-nc2fx5oy2d yes it is our business because the US always interferes in ours and everybody elses.
@user-nc2fx5oy2d that’s brilliant. Another American that forgets they are a citizen of the world.
@@jonholland6067THIS!💯 Same type who doesn't have a clue about OPEC or how wars in other countries affect our economy 🙄
I am 69 years old and have two kinds of cancer. I simply cannot imagine being a young woman looking forward to the blossoming of my career, in the United States. I would leave the country.
Gifts and bribes. Selfish people who don't give a rats for future generations. Explain this one to your grandkids, by God.
How do you sue the Supreme Court for making an unconstitutional ruling?
How do stupid demorat voters manage to exist?
just because democrats don't like it doesn't mean it's unconstitutional.
@@skyboy1956it is indeed unconstitutional. Republicans that actually understand this should be appalled.
@@skyboy1956 I'm not a Democrat but I don't like it. How many more out there who doesn't like it.
@@antoinefigafetta6405 What's wrong with the ruling?
This is absolutely heartbreaking. No other words can express my feelings. God help this country.
🤣
Don't give up/in - Rise UP and VOTE 💙 SUPPORT BIDEN 💙 SAVE DEMOCRACY 👊🇺🇸⚖️🗽 4 more years 💙 donate to BIDEN 🎉 💪🌊🌊🙋♀️ be pro-active 🎉
I'm feeling exactly the same
@@CentralKentuckyElevators what?? What kind of ignorant comment is that?
Amen
It's an outrage every oath taken in this country has to be changed for one man
President should now dismantle the Supreme court as a newly found official Presidential act. He has the power now. He should use it for retribution!
Exactly, the SCOTUS justices have legally deligitimized the court.
We cannot let him win. Period.
That's how we all got here
You're attitude is the reason this is happening. If you Dems just let the people decide if trump is reelected or not this case would never have never been created. But you just had to open the floodgates. You threw political sham court cases at him and drove his numbers up and now we have a constitutional crisis. Good job protecting democracy 👏👏👏
Well he will.
😂😂😂😂
I agree we can not let Biden win again
Very bad news shame on you supreme Court 👎👎👎 save democracy vote Biden 2024💙💙💙💙💙💙
It's not bad, Biden can take out Trump and say he posed a national security risk. It's an official act...
😂😂😂 wish it were that simple...
I can't wait for this generation of hypocrites to be gone! "small government" and "liberty" for me but not for thee.
@@user-tc4tz8ww1z So much hate in your heart.
lol!!! Biden …
Wieviel Geld haben die Herren und Damen des Supreme Court bekommen für dies voller Schande Urteil Um einfach die Verfassung zu Fälschen Kommt nie nach Deutschland Die Deutschen wollen Trump nicht Er wird ein blaues Wunder erleben .
As a veteran this immunity ruling sickens me.
I'm a successful Viet Nam draft dodger and this ruling is right on. I dodged the Viet Nam draft because there's no difference between Biden/Harris and LBJ/McNamara. I've seen this before. We are on Russia's doorstep via Ukraine and we are going to war if Trump doesn't win. Why do you think they reinstated the draft? Why are people so stupid?
I think the 3 dissenters need to speak out publicly. They need to start spilling the beans on the other 6
Great idea 💡
Absolute Presidential immunity is a way to ignore the Constitutional rights of everyone effected by a President's actions
It’s no longer a presidency. It’s a dictatorship.
Thomas Jefferson said, “Whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government” in 1776.
So in your minds any prosecutor should be able to bring charges against any President?? We've seen how that goes! Ask who's destroying democracy again... ##^ people the president is accountable under the Constitution to Congress it's called impeachment proceedings!!!
By the way, Obama ordered the execution by drone strike on two US citizens one was a 15yo should he be prosecuted??
Right
Like the 16 year old boy obama murdered with a drone strike on a wedding party?
You should probably learn the difference between effected and affected before pretending you're outraged about something else in your miserable life.
Hey that's a thought. Biden find seal team 6
He cant even find his own thoughts 😂
@@theretroinggamer1630 I'm not agreeing with you, but giving that much power to someone who has incoherent thoughts is even more dangerous. Don't forget, this ruling is a double-edged sword
@@theretroinggamer1630that’s Donald who feeds you lies Russian bot
Really... the justices in the majority need to be dismissed for lack of mental soundness
Since when was paying off some one to keep quiet is part of a presidents job. Or even worse ignoring votes when you don't like the result. That is not part of a presidents job.
Where's Mitch McConnell on this ruling? He said trump is responsible for the insurrection.
He is chuckling away as though he just watched Kristi Noem shoot some more puppies. Thank you for the call-out, my friend. 💙💙💙
Moscow Mitch?
He back tracked
Mitch McConnell is the same guy that stopped Merrick Garland from getting on the SCOTUS! America dodged a nuclear bomb with that move!
He's sitting on trump knee
I would assume Biden now can take advantage of this ruling and have an official conversation with the justice department to take out Trump. Or as another official act, ask Judge Merchan to give Trump a maximum prison sentence on July 11th.
Exactly
No. The decision is specific to Trump. That is clear in Roberts' written opinion. It will not apply to anyone not approved by this SC majority. Trump will not be sentenced on July 11. That has been moved to September. It is likely that a mistrial will be declared then and the record will be expunged. Trump will never be convicted of anything, ever.
You know I was just thinking the same thing. First of all thank you for expressing on TH-cam what I have been thinking all along. I've been wondering why Binden hadn't said nothing about this new ruling by the Supreme Court. Then I thought to myself and my conclusion is that the ruling is so absurd that Binden didn't even entertain the thought. IT IS UNAMERICAN!
not quite.
scotus (aka roberts) said this new immunity will be decided in the future by scotus.
so if biden tries anything: "NOT IMMUNE"
if trump breaks even more laws: "IMMUNE"
(scotus opinion LITERALLY says that they are the arbiter of this bs - but lower courts are free to flail however they choose before scotus "decides" whether they're wrong)
@@dean3279 was it a crime when Franklin Roosevelt rounded up confiscated homes, businesses, personal property, and put the Japanese into prison camps?? Was it a crime when harry Truman confiscated the United States steel industry, put it under government control? Was it a crime when Bill Clinton attacked a country and started a war the night before his impeachment? Is it a crime that Barack Obama and Joe Biden violated federal law by opening the southern borders they weren’t charged with crimes because they had immunity. And until Joe Biden was elected president and corrupted the justice department for partisan purposes no, Attorney General would’ve ever thought to go after these former presidents, even though they were crimes.
Today we are officially a kangaroo nation.
At least ONE member of the Supreme Court has a brain and a conscious; a woman.
I am no sheeple, I am a free thinking conservative, someone who puts more weight on tradition and moves forward with caution. Conservatives BY DEFINITION are NOT radicals. trumpers, magats and trump are not conservative, they are chaos. trump wants to tear up everything, he is a radical. he is also massively self-centered, making him a poor choice for leadership/government.
You are a rare breed these days.
And I am wholly in agree with your assessment
Neocon, thanks for the last 3 years. You think your opinions are more important than the countries welfare? You are self centered.
Trump sucked the first time he was President. Let's try for another term. 🙄
Abslolutel_
Tell that to your buddies then, don’t preach to us what we already know on an MSNBC comment page
Uncle Joe. Call in the hit. Guaranteed immunity.
Hits 😅 might as well replace those judges too
🦭 team 6️⃣ 🤝 Maralago
Just cancel the election
Exactly! Good for the goose, good for the gander. 😏
@TaylorSmith-wl5rjLooks like you've been sniffing the orange traitor's dirty diapers too long 😅
Political and Legal System in America is rotten to the core.
This law is retroactive?! That’s totally nuts!
Anticipating the irony of Fourth of July posts celebrating patriotism while endorsing sovereign immunity for the head of state. Cognitive dissonance at its finest.
There's nothing to celebrate this 4th of July.
Not feeling the "Independence" at all. It's more like we've all been fuc&ed by the fascist federalist society and the billionaires.
SCOTUS has officially initiated their part in Project 2025 in declaring KINGSHIP. 👑
RIP The office of the presidency of USA 🇺🇸 7/1/24
I thought of this, too. How everyone would be celebrating the 4th , with their collective heads in the sand, as if our freedoms aren't disappearing before our eyes due to rampant corruption. It's a pitiful time to be an American. I am sickened. No longer proud of this country and just sad really. No false celebrations here.
🕊️ democracy died
🤫Biden should stack the Supreme Court with four more judges As an official presidential act he can do that now that he won’t be held accountable and has full power and immunity. 🤔
…pretty much
Scotus declared their first ever 🤴 King Biden. 🇺🇸 USA is now in its pre-monarchy infancy, and
SCOTUS has officially initiated their part in Project 2025 in declaring KINGSHIP. 👑
RIP The office of the presidency of USA 🇺🇸 7/1/24
Welcome autocracy fascism plutocracy & dictatorship
Good Luck North America you’re gonna need it. 🧐
Justice Sotomayor gets full points for plain speaking/English…
AMEN
Well. We have been told & shown how these people have been working on this coup for years.
We didn't know, weren't paying attention, didn't understand, were too busy living/surviving, put trust in the wrong people.... or just didn't care.
Abdication = void; which must be filled.
I believe that President Joe Biden should put this new ruling to the test!! Who's with me?
"When Fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross" ....possible Sinclair Lewis quote
7/1/24 🪦 office of the presidency of USA 🇺🇸
Here it is.
Sinclair Lewis didn't actually say that; we don't know the author. However, he'd agree with it, and it's obviously true.
@@ibeetellingya5683 not sure, some sources say yes, others no, but not going to make a big deal, we get the point and changed the source statement to soothe the soul
Fascism has been here since biden has been in office
Justice used to be blind . Now it's despicable.
And DEPLORABLE.
Could it be high time then for Biden to use some of this newly found presidential immunity to resolve the burgeoning headache called trump once and for all? Could he not unleash his new found powers of immunity against some of those who have been attempting to impeach him? I know it's not in Biden's nature or character to make such flagrant abuse of his position, but just 'sayin'. Maybe time to fight fire with fire. The electorate has arrived at high stakes gambling for their's and the countrie's future.
It's more like - "Justice used to be blind, now it's one-eyed."
WINNER 🎉 🏆🥇🫡🇺🇸
Well obviously Biden needs to get rid of his opponent as he is allowed to under the law.
More importantly Trump can’t be allowed back into the white house.
Thank God Justice Sotomayor, Justice Kagan and Justice Jackson are there! Thank you, we really need you! Please don't give up. I will pray for you and us.
Those 3 need to be replaced immediately,
Pray to who? 😅😅
@@kenc7120😅
Alito and Thomas should have recused, it makes this decision invalid. Go with it Biden.
One that was never a judge, and one that can't define what a woman is!!
WE are the MAJORITY!!!
We must vote and bring everyone we could to vote Blue this November.
Our posterity is watching us!
At this point i don't care if Alito's wife hung underwear upside down.
Justice Sotomayor, Jackson & Kagan are both standing between we the people & dictatorship
Well I think Biden needs to get started on his official acts.
This leaves one option. Trump must be stopped at any and all cost.
You sound like a fool
It looks like anything goes.
If the president can commit crimes whats to stop anyone else?
TAKE.
BIG.
MONEY.
OUT.
OF.
POLITICS.
FULL STOP.
National, state, and local election funds for ALL candidates, funded by a few extra MANDATORY tax dollars from ALL taxpaying Americans.
Everyone gets a stipend. ABSOLUTELY ZERO OUTSIDE CONTRIBUTIONS. Outside campaign contributions become illegal, punishable by SEVERE penalties.
Take money out, problems get solved. We should NEVER have allowed the mega-rich to have legalized bribery.
Okay Biden fix that you can now.
Good grief! If we do all that, the Democrat party will evaporate.
How about a 6-month campaign period, too?
@@movierunUnited, we stand. 💙
Big money removed then who will the DNC get to donate?
Republicans get 70% from the working class.
Without law, what options does that leave? At what point do we as the majority say enough?
We are all, supposedly entitled to an impartial jury, if we end up in any other court. But scotus, the highest court in our nation, are held to no such standard. Their impartiality, is neither assured, or even considered. Shameful!!
The man with the smile of a clown is given a free hand to commit crime according to the High Court judges of the conservative party in America shows the world that Law has no meaning in America, how shameful 😢😮
The man with the smile of a clown?! LOL. Are you kidding? When BIDEN smiles, he looks like the Joker from Batman. Is something wrong with your eyes?
What to me is astonishing is that, when distinguishing between official and unofficial acts, a court may not take into account the motive with which a presidential act is undertaken. (Opinion page 18) This means that a President can utilise official duties with impunity. He can utilise an official act specifically to eliminate a political rival and his motive is not even relevant. Surely the motive with which a President acts should be a cardinal consideration?
I think it's safe to say, that an official act cannot break the law, and not be unconstitutional.
@@R0MANS109 If that was the case then immunity would not be required for an official act
I agree, they have gone too far.
…Correct ☑️
Scotus declared their first ever 🤴 King Biden. 🇺🇸 USA is now in its pre-monarchy infancy, and
SCOTUS has officially initiated their part in Project 2025 in declaring KINGSHIP. 👑
RIP The office of the presidency of USA 🇺🇸 7/1/24
Welcome autocracy fascism plutocracy & dictatorship
Good Luck North America you’re gonna need it.
So much for no one is above the law
Who knew that having valid criminal liability be connected to successful impeachment would be a more restrictive outcome for the president than what we got?
Biden should stack the courts with 4 more judges.
As an official presidential act he can do that now that he won’t be held accountable and has full power and immunity.
…pretty much
Scotus declared their first ever 🤴 King Biden. 🇺🇸 USA is now in its pre-monarchy infancy, and
SCOTUS has officially initiated their part in Project 2025 in declaring KINGSHIP. 👑
RIP The office of the presidency of USA 🇺🇸 7/1/24
Welcome autocracy fascism plutocracy & dictatorship
Good Luck North America you’re gonna need it.
Now everyone must vote 💙💙💙 to Save the USA!!!
And turn the whole country into Portland, Oakland, NYC, DC, Chicago, Detroit, Baltimore, etc, etc, etc.
Voting blue is what tanked our economy and let in 11 million illegals
I guess maga has no reason to whine then if biden does whatever he wants
Corruption in the supreme court judges 😡
Its perfect. Now Biden can get rid of Trump without any problems
He can’t because SCOTUS is ran by a bunch of conservatives. This ruling only benefits the fascists
Ignore the constitution...this is ignoring the Magna Carta
The Magna Carta was annulled less than a year after signing...Then another one was created which lasted a couple of years before being annulled. There were about 5 of them by the end of the century....
Justice?. Ask your corrupt attorney general. Corrupt system and corrupt Biden. Almost 100 years old and still in office . Why ?. Stealing with Hunter?.
GOOD POINT! IF ENCOURAGING A RIOT AND THE INTERFERENCE WITH THE ORDERLY BUSINESS OF CONGRESS IS NOT A CRIME THEN WHAT IS? WHY ALSO IS IT EVEN NECESSARY FOR A PRESIDENT ELECT TO EVEN TAKE AN OATH OF OFFICE WHICH THE SUPREME COURT HAS NOW RENDERED MEANINGLESS? 🙂😄😀
Your caps lock key sticks.
Is the Supreme Court retaliating for accusing them for accepting unreported gifts?
Bingo. They have a lot of power right now and they will punish us for daring to speak out. We will keep doing so.
They do understand this decision is not only for Trump right??? 😢
Yes this decision is for Trump only because they know President Biden will not abuse his power.
They won't enforce challenges equally if a liberal decides to test the limits
Joe already said he won't dirty his hands with such rough labourer work.
TDS will not allow!
no, they really dont.
Sotomayor 👍🏻👍🏻
Pack the courts
Any person that has sworn to uphold the constitution, if they break any part of it they should be at LEAST be ousted from their position, PERIOD!!!
The Supreme Court’s Ruling would also apply to President Biden wouldn’t it?😕
The ruling applies to all Presidents present and future. The difference is Biden will not abuse his power but Trump will. We must vote for the president who will protect democracy!
@@elainecole1223oh okay.
And Obama too. That means he won't be held accountable for drone bombing civilians all over the world. Among other delightful crimes.
elainecole1223, your president went after Trump for documents that he's protected under the PRA. He raided his residence over documents he's protected under. Don't tell us he won't abuse his power. He already did.!
@@elainecole1223 😅🤣😂🤣 Biden won't abuse power! Good one! The 10% guy who's been in China's pocket since Day 1. 😅😂🤣😅
This is horrible, and despicable!! This is corruption at its worst!!
calm down, the Democrats probably won't win in November.
Actually it is democracy, careful what you wish for.
This is great for America. Trump 2024🇺🇸☺️
Hoping other judges across America will speak out against this. The Supreme Court has been corrupted by dark money. trump an honest businessman? 💙🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲💙
@@sergiocable
Only if Hannibal Lecter is Trump's running mate and Joan Rivers is Trump's press secretary grandma.
Work on that old timer. 😎
Get those corrupt judges out of there.
When people choose $$ over the American people, this is what happens. Welcome to the new America if we can even call it that anymore
Watching on from downunder with a question - can Biden now order a seal team to take out his political opponent? Is that the reality of the SC's ruling?
Yes.
Yes.
Yep
He could but I really don’t think he would like the response if he decided to do something like that
yes. I think Trump is considering a different color of makeup, one not so bright and orange....to easy of a target. Those SEALS are pretty accurate from afar.
Yes Rachel it does indeed mean a president can now direct his AG to do absolutely anything without legal repercussions
Like joe is doing with djt.
@@kelperdude Joe isn't, Trump will.
Obama took out a guy with a drone without a court .Yes a American , who's family said he was innocent .
Isn't' that exactly what Bkden is doing now?
Get real dudes - lying and cheating and distorting and bribing can only go so far. That time is over.
Interesting that MSNBC is bringing back the dead horse Rachel.
@@jemezname2259 Are you blind, deaf, mute, dumb, and have no sense of smell?
The d.c. court should hold open evidentiary hearings, making public all evidence and testimony available for scrutiny.
With tears of blood, under the blindfold, Lady Justice weeps!
These judges are insane
No democrats are!
They owe him. He gave them their positions.....
Four million in gifts certainly can sway one's decision.
@@b.t.2795 corrupt country.
@@lopresti4559bye! 🇺🇸
Might as well, just do away with the law if this is the path we are now on. So sad. So annoying. Very dangerous too.
This is some of the scariest news. You can't assume these justices, politicians and leaders have not been influenced by those who have the power over them. Follow the money!
This ruling means Biden has supreme power in the US. Go Joe
6 lawyers for a criminal at the highest court of the land. What a terrible situation we are in. This is our reckoning.
you don't like it then go back to your own country you ruined and that you don't want to live in.trump is no criminal., the charges were bogusm and the supreme court knew it.
Our reckoning has been the last 4 years
I keep saying be careful what you wish for!!!! Sotomayor is probably the smartest judge with this bunch !!! They really don’t know what they have done!!! He may get rid of one or all of you !! My opinion
@@theretroinggamer1630 BS. Trump either claims the great economy under Biden for himself (four years after he was voted out, sure sure!), or he blames the "worst economy ever" (DAX says different and he knows it!) on Biden. It's always the best and the worst economy at the same time, depends on who he currently thinks is responsible for it.
Aren’t the state elector documents under each state authority and never under the authority of the president?
SCOTUS is an effin' joke.
yep, Biden had the ability to balance the court and did nothing. That decision will cost America and the world for generations!
As a veteran, my soul has been ripped out of my body. The thought of all of us who gave everything for this country 7 traitors including a former president that have never served or sacrificed can throw it all away without even a second thought is outright disgusting.
Unite your fellow veterans around you and speak this as much and as often as you can. Thank you very much
What kind of veteran believes in locking up political opponents and calling in seal teams to get him. What a disgrace you are
You pretty over dramatic . Did your brothers fight and die so political opponents could be put in jail over corn stars. I'm sure there real proud.
A republic, if we can keep it.
Already lost. Long live the king!
@@Shih47 KING TRUMP!
I guess we can’t 😥
❤❤❤
All the judges in the United States of America need to walk out and go on strike.
I hope Biden can also use this to his advantage as well.
More proof that you do NOT need to be smart to be a lawyer, or judge.
Well, this isn't about brains. It's about corruption.
That’s very lawyerphobic of you
Now that SCOTUS declared Biden a KING 👑 he should get to work and appoint four more judges to the Supreme Court abolish life appointees and set term limits immediately with his new found power.
Some of the SCOTUS members got a “do not recommend” designation from the Am. Bar Assn. They were approved anyway.
@@user-sw7my6kp7g obviously, you do because you don’t understand the ruling.