I never usually participate in the comments but I really felt the need you let you know that you're doing great! These are so useful for my uni exams revision when I need the context behind some of the ideas! Super concise, explained extremely well and entertaining animations. :D Very much appreciated!
Thx for the stuffs. It was quick and accurate enough. In fact Chinese history is complicated but your channel has softened it upto some extent. Please keep up the good work.
Seems like with your videos I'll be able to pass finals this Monday. There's been a lot of gaps in my notes and your videos helped to fill them out. Thanks :)
Thanks mate, excellent video, on one point, some the practices of the Taiping Govt sound more like American Evangelicals with a bit of socialism throw in. Another question if I may? In the various Chineses culture's how much weight are given to dreams, in the individuals direction in life and purposes? Thank you again.
A very good attempt at a very touchy subject. An interesting auditing of the Taiping state. This is why a separation of state and religion is probably a good idea. To be fair, he tried. But he successfully found out another way to not do things. We are starting to accumulate a lot of these. But we still don't really have any real ideas about what is the right thing to do. Isn't that a pain?
Awesome content. Please include in your description a link to the previous and next videos in the series! I have to rely on youtube algorithms or search currently. Am I missing your links somewhere? The algorithm says the next video is #1 but I know there's a #3 somewhere.
Thanks for this excellent video. I've watched a few videos on this topic and I'm wondering -- how did the approx. 20 million deaths happen? Were these killings mostly the responsibility of the Taiping gov't, the Qing gov't, or a combination of the two? This very shocking statistic is generally not discussed in detail in the discussions I've seen.
Both, the Taipings committed genocide against the Manchus while the Qing authorities committed genocide against the Hakkas. However, the largest factor was that the rebellion destroyed the infrastructure, economy and agriculture in nearby areas, killing off millions of people by disease and famine. Both sides waged total war, irreversibly harming civilian populations in the process.
Áve María, grátia pléna, Dóminus técum. Benedícta tu in muliéribus, et benedíctus frúctus véntris túi, Iésus. Sáncta María, Máter Déi, óra pro nóbis peccatóribus, nunc et in hóra mórtis nóstrae. Ámen.
@Protestant Well just to be clear, old Testament is as much a part of the Bible as the new one right? If you want people to read, study and follow the word of the Bible, that includes the older more wrathful "eye for an eye" God... Right?
after be defeated by Qing Empire, some of Taiping's remaining escaped to Vietnam and Laos. Soon after, they begin corrupt and become a huge gang of robber. They killed, raped, looted the North Vietnam and Laos until 1885, when French Army defeated both of them and Qing Army. Religion alone isn't enough to made you became a good guy. That is the lesson.
Very good informative video, I will have my students use this for our AP World Class. I really like your sense of humor.
I never usually participate in the comments but I really felt the need you let you know that you're doing great! These are so useful for my uni exams revision when I need the context behind some of the ideas! Super concise, explained extremely well and entertaining animations. :D Very much appreciated!
Thank you! I'm glad that I was able to help :)
Thx for the stuffs. It was quick and accurate enough. In fact Chinese history is complicated but your channel has softened it upto some extent. Please keep up the good work.
have an exam tomorrow on this topic, thanks a lot mate! excellent content! :)
Seems like with your videos I'll be able to pass finals this Monday. There's been a lot of gaps in my notes and your videos helped to fill them out. Thanks :)
great job man, you did well with this one
Really awesome video! Learned a lot!
Amazing video, thanks so much! Definitely helpful in IB exams :)
Awesome video ! It really help me on my studies ! 谢谢你!
This is a really good video, thanks because this reallyy helped me so much!
All'right Friends, very good,thank 's!!!
I appreciate your honesty, good stuff
great one. i wish anyone should start these kind of informative historic videos in the Indian context!
soooo helpful in teaching my students. thx!!!
Great video!!!!
Nice.
"Well, unless you were the Manchus. If you were the Manchus YOU HAD TO DIE." Lol.
Well made video!! I love learning about 19th century China. Do you know of any movies with English sub's on this topic. Thanks
Lovely channel
I'm wondering why your videos have so few views, they are really good
nossa valeu ai muito bem explicado estava precisando de informações e vc me ajudo
Thanks mate, excellent video, on one point, some the practices of the Taiping Govt sound more like American Evangelicals with a bit of socialism throw in. Another question if I may? In the various Chineses culture's how much weight are given to dreams, in the individuals direction in life and purposes? Thank you again.
That is why countries that banned Christianity survived colonialism.
Obrigado !!!!!!!!
Heavy loaded
You gotta give us something on the Taisho era in retrospective
can you make a videos about decline of qing dynasty...not many youtubers talk about eastern history...that made me very disappointed..:(
A very good attempt at a very touchy subject. An interesting auditing of the Taiping state.
This is why a separation of state and religion is probably a good idea.
To be fair, he tried. But he successfully found out another way to not do things.
We are starting to accumulate a lot of these. But we still don't really have any real ideas about what is the right thing to do.
Isn't that a pain?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_of_church_and_state
Awesome content. Please include in your description a link to the previous and next videos in the series! I have to rely on youtube algorithms or search currently. Am I missing your links somewhere? The algorithm says the next video is #1 but I know there's a #3 somewhere.
대단하십니다역사드래곤님
영상 잘봤습니다 역사룡님
Thanks for this excellent video. I've watched a few videos on this topic and I'm wondering -- how did the approx. 20 million deaths happen? Were these killings mostly the responsibility of the Taiping gov't, the Qing gov't, or a combination of the two? This very shocking statistic is generally not discussed in detail in the discussions I've seen.
Both, the Taipings committed genocide against the Manchus while the Qing authorities committed genocide against the Hakkas. However, the largest factor was that the rebellion destroyed the infrastructure, economy and agriculture in nearby areas, killing off millions of people by disease and famine. Both sides waged total war, irreversibly harming civilian populations in the process.
Good job man. But seriously, how old are you?
I'm turning 15 this Wednesday.
***** 0.0 Omg. You're so intelligent at such a young age! Happy early birthday and keep up the good work!
+The Dragon Historian I'm 16.
ruben g Thanks man! I hope to keep doing this throughout my high school career.
***** No problem and word of advice, take AP classes and Dual enrollment. But you probably already know that. Good luck in High School.
Are you sure Guangxi population is predominately Hakka? Do you have any sources to prove your bold statement?
Áve María, grátia pléna, Dóminus técum.
Benedícta tu in muliéribus, et benedíctus frúctus véntris túi, Iésus.
Sáncta María, Máter Déi, óra pro nóbis peccatóribus, nunc et in hóra mórtis nóstrae.
Ámen.
A question, are you able to speak Mandarin? Your pronounciation sounds like that of a native speaker.
Excellent. Except the Christian booklet was 500 pages and written by a Chinese convert.
As a Christian I am left speachless...
Thanks a lot Taiping..... this embarrasses me because I'm Christian.
ruben g me too
@Protestant Well just to be clear, old Testament is as much a part of the Bible as the new one right? If you want people to read, study and follow the word of the Bible, that includes the older more wrathful "eye for an eye" God... Right?
You can low up your speed so that we all can learn easily
The failure to capture Shanghai resulted in the loss of (incoherent mumbling)...
+Michael Sweeney That's why the captions are there.
재미있네요
after be defeated by Qing Empire, some of Taiping's remaining escaped to Vietnam and Laos.
Soon after, they begin corrupt and become a huge gang of robber. They killed, raped, looted the North Vietnam and Laos until 1885, when French Army defeated both of them and Qing Army.
Religion alone isn't enough to made you became a good guy. That is the lesson.
When was the last time China won a war outside of their continent? Lol
Commenting so the comments could be 69 and likes 420
Nice to see Trump in there.
Hakka
Nem fala rápido jk