सुस्पष्ट, सटीक, आत्मविश्वास, तथ्यपरक और अकाट्य तर्कों से परिपूर्ण विचार रखते हैँ हमारे आदरणीय गुरुदेव संजय दीक्षित जी.. आपके जैसे व्यक्तित्वों के हाथ में तो देश की कमान होनी चाहिए 🙏🙏
पाकिस्तान का एक मात्र लक्ष्य भारत पर इस्लामी शासन है, और ये बात वहां का बच्चा-बच्चा जानता भी है। पता नहीं इकोनॉमी, विकास जैसी बातें कर कैसे लेते हैं ये लोग।
Sir I have a small request to you. Please do not use salutation of 'saab' etc for people like Jinna etc. It subconsciously affects their image in viewers' (and your followers') mind.
What a finest hour, two sane and even handed, gentlemen are discussing, the age old matter ( since we ordinary folks do not matter in this geo political affairs) across the border with the help of SPECTRUM.. We enjoy it... It is feast for people for both country... Bravo...
Very nice interaction between two learned and enlightened journalists who have extensively studied the background of two nation theory. I expect many more like this from this channel. Keep it up.
We are still an unfortunate country for centuries, shouldering a lot of such separatist and communal ideologies’s burden. I have high respect for people like Patel Ji. With their efforts, we were saved from a hell like situations. Wish we will be able to give a better country to our coming generations which we dream or our ancestors dreamed after independence
Best thing about sanjay ji in all nationalist intellectuals is he never hesitate to told the bitter truth, even if he is giving interview to foreign youtube channels
RSS & Modi Ji has learnt from new Saint and seems to follow his UPDESH about Hindu and Hindutva. Jai baba rahuldev Ji ki. Jai ho RSS & central govt ki.
@@twinklestar8275 islam ka to pata nahi lakin Yati narsimhanand ji Ankur Arya ji khatra ma hai mujahid dekhraha hai ki jab yatiji dasna mandir sa nikla😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
The parity of the Indian Rupee vis-à-vis the Pakistani Rupee reflects their management business sense and their priorities. The huge 30% of minorities in India are a huge liability on the Indian economy who though can work out business well, directly divert their money and are responsible for the drug trade, black money and do not contribute to the Exchequer. They divert Hindu and other communities' youth into this making them complicit. This is the hard cold Truth. A third party Audit on this with comparison of Indian practices to Islamic is always welcome, but fear a violent response to even third party audit results.
Dr Shakil Chaudhary is perhaps the most balanced and well informed journalist from Pakistan. That was an excellent dialogue between you and Sanjay Dixit. It would be useful, if you could give some indications of the rights of a lower riparian country. Which right of a lower riparian country allow it 80% of the total water. It is essentially US influence which allowed Paksitan to get 80% of the water.
A minority cannot force partition, that is true, in real sense muslims in Undivided India, were not a minority at all, Jinnah's ideology screwed the future of the muslims of this sub continent. Those who supported Pakistan never went to Pakistan, & those who never wanted Pakistan, were forced to become Pakistanis, because they were born in the present day Pakistan. Jinnah had sowed the seeds of hatred, which will take centuries to heal. May Allah, give common sense to Pakistanis..
#Br Ambedkar Darul Islam- land of Islam Darul herb- land of war Every country where Muzlims resides (lives) but are not in power is Darul herb( land of war) for them & aim of every Muzlim civilian or soldier is to transform this Darul herb into Darul Islam.
🕊I’m the grand daughter of Ch. Khaliquzzaman (& Dr Salimuzzaman Siddiqui is my grand Uncle) I agree he should have stayed in India & stucked to his commitment but there was a reason for it. I’m eternally grateful to your unbiased explanation Shakil Ch. Sahib he had a reason for it.
Sanjay Sir Jii Dil SE app ku Mera namaskar ..whaa Kya bat hai ..mera Dil Kush hogaya Sir Jii ..Kitna deep knowledge app ka sir ??? App too forien minister ka teem nahii too.. Modi jii Ka govt policy's ka advice Cometie me hona chaheye app ku .. great 👌👌👌👌 Sir Jii app too .
Why would Hindustan not respect or disown B R Ambedkar? He was a son of the soil, we don’t disown our sons. As best as I read about Abdus Salam who won Nobel Price in Physics was a Ahmedi Muslim and when he got the 1st rank in 12th grade or in college, the news of his attaining that was already communicated to people in Jhang and the Hindu shop keepers who usually would shut their shops after lunch didn’t because the son of the soil made them all proud and they wanted to greet him in the streets. This was in Jhang in present day Pakistan. The Nobel laureate talks about this in his memoirs and he said he was moved by this and has quoted it. We don’t disown our sons who made Hindustan and made us proud. Be it Ambedkar, be it Abdul kalam or be it Vikram Sarabai or be it JFR Jacob. These were all Buddhist, Muslim or Parsi or Jew.
Sanjay ji, it reamins an interesting subject of study as to how Punjab, NWFP, Balochistan and Sindh, which did not support Indian Muslim League in a major way and did not have deep anti Hindu culture like in Bengal became a den of fundamentalist Political Islam, Gazva-e-Hind and pivot of international Islamic terrorism.
Sir I have some important questions for discussion for both critical patriot and Jaipur dialouges, which are obvious but strangely avoided. 1. If partition was inevitable, why nehru, jinnah and Gandhi couldn't arrange for a phase wise transfer of population over say 10 to 15 yrs, so that affected people could sell, exchange or arrange for their land and property in a legal and transparent manner. Sudden loss of livelihoods and property was the main cause of partition riots in both the countries and yet it was largely avoidable. And that it was allowed was a criminal act for both the leaderships. We can blame the British for partition, but they were technically correct, morally or ethically however wrong. The responsibility for the riots lies on the shoulders of our ancestors and their irresponsible leadership. So what were the invisible reasons for the partition course of action. 2. Pakistan was created on the ideology 'of the Muslims, by the Muslims, for the muslims and in the name of islam' - the British and present India were more than generous in giving more than 20% land and resources to equivalent amount of Muslim population. Yet Pakistan accepted 2/3 of the Muslim population and left 1/3 of the Muslim population to whatsoever fate with the Hindus. So the question is why did they do that - the logical thing to pursue would be all Muslims to Pakistan and all non Muslims to India. And a peaceful partition could have achieved that without destroying economy and bloodshed. Why were things started and left halfway. And if halfway is the new normal then what is the logic of pak's claim on Kashmir or its Muslim population. 3. Indian's Uber law and the Kashmir issue: India abides by a never mentioned super law and that is "All relevant parameters (social, economic or otherwise) being equivalent, no law shall be passed, and which when applied in reciprocal is unacceptable to an entity, individual, gender, community, religion, state, country and ad infinitum. This is my personal observation, but I am yet to see an exception to the same. And whatever exception remained are being progressively repealed. Article 370 is one of them. If Pakistanis don't like the law, they don't need weapons, abusive language, etc just convincing logic. Now, to the dispute of kashmir and playing devils advocate. A. Why should ladkh and Jammu - non Muslim areas join Pakistan to start with. Like Bengal or Punjab why should it not be partitioned. And if Pakistan accepts kashmiri Muslims, then the same logic loop of the remaining muslims of India applies. B. UN resolutions were for the whole of JK. So what is pak stand on Chinese capture of askaichin. C. By what logic does pak explain gifting shakssam to China from disputed territory. D. Pak transplants Punjabi Muslims in Azad Kashmir/ Pok, but demands that non Indian can settle in kashmir - By what logic.
Shakeel Bhai, Sanjy Ji ! Jinko Allah ne samajh di aur jinko apni janambhumi, culture se prem tha wo India wapas chale gye. Prominent logon ka zikar hota hye, ghareebon ka khin shumar nhi hota
Relations with Pakistan will never be normal when one side peddles lies and misinformation forever. Staying with truth and facts allows nations to solve bilateral issues. When one side selectively looks at problems, history or writes history to its own convenience, then hell breaks lose. Will Pakistan change, no. Change will be forced on it by US, Arabs, India, IMF, FATF and other means.
The main problem of Pakistan is the biased education. For the upholders of the Ideology of Pakistan, the existence of Pakistan is defined only in relation to Hindus, and hence the Hindus have to be painted as black as possible. The pre-Ideology textbooks (before the Zia era) did not contain animosity towards Hindus even though Pakistan was born of the bloody riots of the partition. The early textbooks, mostly written after the partition, were free of the pathological hate that we see in textbooks today. For example, the early history books contained chapters on not only the oldest civilizations of Moen jo Daro, Harappa, Taxila, etc., but also the early Hindu mythologies of Ramayana and Mahabharata, and extensively covered, often with admiration, the great Hindu kingdoms of the Mauryas and the Guptas. The books indeed showed biases when discussing the more recent history of the politics of independence, but still one found text-books with chapters on M.K. Gandhi, using words of respect and admiration for him. Even in the somewhat biased history of politics of independence, the creation of Pakistan was reasoned on the intransigence of the All-India Congress and its leadership rather than on “Hindu machinations." Some books also clearly mentioned that the most prominent Islamic religious leaders were all bitterly opposed to the creation of Pakistan. Such was the enlightened teaching of history for the first 25 years of Pakistan even though two wars were fought against India in this period. The print and electronic media often indulged in anti-Hindu propaganda, but educational material was by and large free of hate against Hindus. Then came the time of replacing Indo-Pakistan history and geography with Pakistan studies, and defining Pakistan as an Islamic state. The history of Pakistan became equivalent to the history of Muslims in the subcontinent, starting with the Arab conquest of Sindh and swiftly jumping to the Muslim conquerors from Central Asia. Simultaneously, a trend started in the 1970s of stressing the Ideology of Pakistan. This involved creating an ideological straitjacket in which the history of Pakistan, especially that of the Pakistan movement, was to be rewritten with utter disregard for truth. Pakistan was told to have been created to establish a truly Islamic state in accordance with the tenets of Qur’an and Sunnah. The Ulema who had bitterly opposed the creation of Pakistan were turned into heroes of the Pakistan movement. The Quaid-i-Azam was turned into a pious practicing Muslim. And Hindus were hated and denigrated. A few examples of the expression of this hate in some recent curriculum documents and textbooks are given below. Curriculum documents cite the following as learning objectives: • [The child should be able to] understand the Hindu and Muslim differences and the resultant need for Pakistan • Develop understanding of the Hindu-Muslim Differences and need for Pakistan. • Hindu-Muslim Differences in Culture…India’s evil designs against Pakistan (the three wars with India) • Identify the events in relation to Hindu-Muslim differences, which laid the foundations for Pakistan. Until, such vicious propaganda is ended, there can be no Peace. Change your Education system and Pakistan will progress. Education, education and education..........
Dil se tasleem na kiya and Akhand Bharat are very old statemen. Now support to such things is diminishing in Pakistan . The young educated generation of Pakistan don't have feelings of hostility with India . They want cordial relations with Indians and India. We always discuss the attitudes and versions of extremists on both side and ignore the sentiments of young educated people.
Mujhe lagta yeh Pakistan Channel and host come to Indian channel to increase their views. People in India find out about them and then go to their channel to increase the view.
Pakistanyon samjho baat ko. Tumhara problem Imran ya hukamran nahi. Tumhari problem islam aur Kuranovirus hai. islam quran aur muhammad ki sachhai batane par Bharat pakistan Bangladesh k muslim bhadak kyu jate hai? islam ki sachhai inko gali kyu lagti hai? Kya islam quran aur muhammad ki sachhai chhipayi gayi hai unse?
Sirf Pakistan nahi. If you look at archeological records then middle East is like cradle of human ingenuity. Mesopotamia or today's Iraq has so many finds like oldest writing, use of wheel etc... But see what Islam has done to the middle East... Even gulf nations like UAE of today prospered when they found oil and used western methods and personel to harness it and then followed monarchy model and allowed capitalism to flourish unhindered on their lands...
Huzoor ka khilaf agar kisina kaha to uski gardan kaatdi jaayegi nabi ka izzath par compromise nahi bro agar huzoor ka khilaf bas criticise karna hai to karo lakin agar abuse kiya to uski bas ek hi saza hai sazaa a mouth agar wo muslim hojaaye phir bhi death penalty ya har muslim maanta hai
ہندوستان دی سن سنتالی وچ دو حصیاں یعنی مغربی ہندوستان (عرف الباکستان) تے مغربی ہندوستان (عرف انڈیا) وچ ونڈ دے ذمےدار سرخ (روسی) سامراج ، سفید (برطانوی) سامراج تے اوناں دے مقامی سہولت کاراں مثلا مسلم لیگ، کانگریس، تے کیمونسٹ پارٹی وغیرہ سن-
@13:39 Venkata Dhulpia Book "Creating New Medina" a must read book .. Ambedkar was biggest supporter of 2 nation therory we wanted all Muslim to be thrown in pakistan
Sanjay sir aap jihnna ko jihnna sahab kyon bolte hn ..🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤..jisky wajah se bantwara hi nhi balki lakhon logo ka blood bath Hua tha. Or ghar se beggar bhi huye the.😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
चौदह सौ साल पहले अल्लाह नाम को कौन जानता अल्लाह किसी पुस्तक मे इस झूठे नाम का कोई जिकृ नही ओम वेदो मे आदि सृषटि से अनंत तक रहा,चैनल को लाईक शेयर सब्सक्रिप्शन प्लीज,,,
Hats off to you Sanjayji for ur deep knowledge in the History of India. Also enjoy the show Deen ki Dawat. Jai Hind. Vande Mataram 🙏🙏
Ll Plp0p
Pp
Pp pp pl 🙏🙏 pp ppp
सीरिया. लीबिया. इराक. यमन. सोमालिया. अंग्रेज. के. मुस्लिम.. प्रेम .ने. बनाया. हिन्दू
नहीं. कम्यूनिस्ट ने
Wah!!! Sanjayji ne hath jodkar bola thank you!!! That’s the true Bharat.... very knowledgeable very firm yet polite!!!!! Har Har Mahadev!!!
I admire both, Sanjay Dixit and Shakil Chaudhary. Both are calm and engage in civilized discussion.
संदीप दीक्षित सर जी आपको सुनना बहुत अच्छा लगता है
No regrets that I have not lived in the times of Chanaky bcoz I am lucky enough to be walking on the earth in the times of Shri Dixit.
सुस्पष्ट, सटीक, आत्मविश्वास, तथ्यपरक और अकाट्य तर्कों से परिपूर्ण विचार रखते हैँ हमारे आदरणीय गुरुदेव संजय दीक्षित जी.. आपके जैसे व्यक्तित्वों के हाथ में तो देश की कमान होनी चाहिए 🙏🙏
Sanjay sir, very well elucidated. It was a wonderful interview with a Pak journalist, I hope people across the border watch it too. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Hats off to you Dr Sanjay Dixit and your deep thinking, knowledge your book ' unbreaking India' have read twice. Well researched well documented book
पाकिस्तान का एक मात्र लक्ष्य भारत पर इस्लामी शासन है, और ये बात वहां का बच्चा-बच्चा जानता भी है। पता नहीं इकोनॉमी, विकास जैसी बातें कर कैसे लेते हैं ये लोग।
@AARYAN बिल्कुल सही अल-तकिया ही है । 😂
भाई. लालची. कम्यूनिस्ट पाक. बचे. दुनिया के
Kamunist.Apna. देश. बनाते. भारत. पाक
कश्मीर. के. हथियार का. कमिशन. अवाम को
बारूद. का. धूवा
भाई. लालची. कम्यूनिस्ट पाक. बचे. दुनिया के
Kamunist.Apna. देश. बनाते.
Al takiya
Dixit ji your knowledge is power of people.
Sanjay Bhai Namaskaar 🙏, aap ne doodh ka doodh aur pani ka pani kar diya aaj,
VANDEMATRAM
संजय जी इसी तरह आप पाकिस्तानी चैंनलों में जाकर उन्हें असली इतिहास से अवगत कराते रहे भारतीय पक्ष को सुस्पष्टता से रखने के लिए धन्यवाद 🙏
Shakil Saab- you are an exceptional, truthful and brave individual. Sanjay JI is our gem.. Enjoyed the discussions. More power to both of you.. ❤
Noiiiiccceeeee sirji jai hind 😘😘😀😀❤️❤️🙏🙏🤍🤍🤩🤩🤗🤗
Sir I have a small request to you. Please do not use salutation of 'saab' etc for people like Jinna etc. It subconsciously affects their image in viewers' (and your followers') mind.
Zinnah should be addressed as a promoter of Divided India. He doesn't deserve any respectful addressing after what he did to our great nation.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@dhiranprajapati647 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Urdu language me hindi ke ji Jaisa Saab lagate
Ise tehzeeb kehte hain or koi tehzeeb tehzeebwala he dikha sakta. Let’s not give points to a scholar.
What a finest hour, two sane and even handed, gentlemen are discussing, the age old matter ( since we ordinary folks do not matter in this geo political affairs) across the border with the help of SPECTRUM.. We enjoy it... It is feast for people for both country... Bravo...
Very nice interaction between two learned and enlightened journalists who have extensively studied the background of two nation theory.
I expect many more like this from this channel.
Keep it up.
We are still an unfortunate country for centuries, shouldering a lot of such separatist and communal ideologies’s burden. I have high respect for people like Patel Ji. With their efforts, we were saved from a hell like situations.
Wish we will be able to give a better country to our coming generations which we dream or our ancestors dreamed after independence
Very bold statements Sanjay ji, I heartily salute u sir.
Informative video👍.
Best thing about sanjay ji in all nationalist intellectuals is he never hesitate to told the bitter truth, even if he is giving interview to foreign youtube channels
Nice and efficient presentation 👌, we are proud of you mr Sanjay Dixhit ji 🙏
I want to see Sanjay Dixit as next Prime Minister of Bharat.
Let him create a new party. And people in crores will join him.
😳
@@dixitsanjay2005 🤣🤣🤣
🤣😂🤣
Anchor was surprised to hear Sanjay ji...
He never expected Sanjay ji is so knowledgeable... Salute to Sanjay ji former IAS .
Unbreaking India is an outstanding book. Well written
Good way of Collaboration. I have seen this video on Shakil's channel yesterday.
Shakilji & DIXITJI ....Both are digging the old mines.....still lots of GOLDEN SECRETS are brought out...⚘🕉🇮🇳⚘🙏👍
Dixit .Ji ... As usual hitting sixers
RSS & Modi Ji has learnt from new Saint and seems to follow his UPDESH about Hindu and Hindutva.
Jai baba rahuldev Ji ki. Jai ho RSS & central govt ki.
DIXIT G well done. You have demolished all his arguments correctly.
Pranam Guruji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Love the way Mr. Shakil Chaudhary started getting uncomfortable at 47:00 while hearing about the water treaty and Quaran quotes.
😊😊🙏🤣 shayad pal bhar ke liye unhe bhi laga kahi Islam such much khatreme to nahi?🙏
@@twinklestar8275 islam ka to pata nahi lakin Yati narsimhanand ji Ankur Arya ji khatra ma hai mujahid dekhraha hai ki jab yatiji dasna mandir sa nikla😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
@@rehanahmedsyed3855 sach batana teri jali na bolna jali na
@@kbhaveshkumar4448 sach bataraha hu bhaiyya
PAKISTAN should read MOHAMMAD by VASIM RIZVI.
This would give them insight about ISLAM.
Islam needs to be reformed to bring peace in the World.
The parity of the Indian Rupee vis-à-vis the Pakistani Rupee reflects their management business sense and their priorities. The huge 30% of minorities in India are a huge liability on the Indian economy who though can work out business well, directly divert their money and are responsible for the drug trade, black money and do not contribute to the Exchequer. They divert Hindu and other communities' youth into this making them complicit.
This is the hard cold Truth.
A third party Audit on this with comparison of Indian practices to Islamic is always welcome, but fear a violent response to even third party audit results.
Thank you Shakil saheb.
पाकिस्तान में भी इतनी डिबेट्स होती है भारत में गान्धी पर चर्चा करो तो मिर्ची लग जाती है.
kisko lagti h
Sanjay ji many thanks to you Sir.
Great discussion 👍
Very nice explanation Sanjayji!
Dr Shakil Chaudhary is perhaps the most balanced and well informed journalist from Pakistan. That was an excellent dialogue between you and Sanjay Dixit.
It would be useful, if you could give some indications of the rights of a lower riparian country. Which right of a lower riparian country allow it 80% of the total water.
It is essentially US influence which allowed Paksitan to get 80% of the water.
A minority cannot force partition, that is true, in real sense muslims in Undivided India, were not a minority at all, Jinnah's ideology screwed the future of the muslims of this sub continent. Those who supported Pakistan never went to Pakistan, & those who never wanted Pakistan, were forced to become Pakistanis, because they were born in the present day Pakistan. Jinnah had sowed the seeds of hatred, which will take centuries to heal. May Allah, give common sense to Pakistanis..
From what you wrote, the one that needs common sense is Muslims who still to this day support Pakistan while living in India.
#Br Ambedkar
Darul Islam- land of Islam
Darul herb- land of war
Every country where Muzlims resides (lives) but are not in power is Darul herb( land of war) for them & aim of every Muzlim civilian or soldier is to transform this Darul herb into Darul Islam.
War doctrine
🕊I’m the grand daughter of
Ch. Khaliquzzaman (& Dr Salimuzzaman Siddiqui is my grand Uncle) I agree he should have stayed in India & stucked to his commitment but there was a reason for it. I’m eternally grateful to your unbiased explanation Shakil Ch. Sahib he had a reason for it.
Yasmeen Sahiba!
Ch. Khaliq Sahab was a prominent personality. 💞
@@sheikhsaeedakhtarsa3087 Thank you very much.
@@yasmeenzaman847 felt much Honoured, respected madam! 🥰
Aapke comments bhot balanced hote hain Yaseen sahiba…
When Muslim will leave India and go to Pakistan, its been 75 years.
Dicksetji wah pacastan walo ka pronunciation kafi majedar hota hai
जय श्री राम जय हिन्दू राष्ट्र जय हिन्द
Sanjay Sir Jii Dil SE app ku Mera namaskar ..whaa Kya bat hai ..mera Dil Kush hogaya Sir Jii ..Kitna deep knowledge app ka sir ??? App too forien minister ka teem nahii too..
Modi jii Ka govt policy's ka advice Cometie me hona chaheye app ku .. great 👌👌👌👌 Sir Jii app too .
Namskar sir 🙏 ji aap dono logo ko
🇮🇳🙏 Vande Mataram , Jay Hind ,
Bharat Mata ki Jay 🙏🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩
Once again an outstanding show.
Good civilized talk, no attempt of force feeding
Salute for sanjay sir ji
Excellent sanjayji good diplomacy
Children Day 14 November ko manana bahut badi bewkoofi hai aur bacho ke saath ghor be-imani hai.
Issko THARKEE DIWAS ke Roop mae manaye.
THARKEE DIWAS 🤣🤣
Wah Pundit Dixit g, you are incredible.
Why would Hindustan not respect or disown B R Ambedkar? He was a son of the soil, we don’t disown our sons.
As best as I read about Abdus Salam who won Nobel Price in Physics was a Ahmedi Muslim and when he got the 1st rank in 12th grade or in college, the news of his attaining that was already communicated to people in Jhang and the Hindu shop keepers who usually would shut their shops after lunch didn’t because the son of the soil made them all proud and they wanted to greet him in the streets. This was in Jhang in present day Pakistan. The Nobel laureate talks about this in his memoirs and he said he was moved by this and has quoted it.
We don’t disown our sons who made Hindustan and made us proud. Be it Ambedkar, be it Abdul kalam or be it Vikram Sarabai or be it JFR Jacob.
These were all Buddhist, Muslim or Parsi or Jew.
Verghese Kurian
*Sir kal Islam haar gaya*
Great sanjay dixit sir
sanjay sir you are too good
6:25 well answered sir
Fantastic discussion
Enlightening discussion
Bahut behtar
Sanjay ji, it reamins an interesting subject of study as to how Punjab, NWFP, Balochistan and Sindh, which did not support Indian Muslim League in a major way and did not have deep anti Hindu culture like in Bengal became a den of fundamentalist Political Islam, Gazva-e-Hind and pivot of international Islamic terrorism.
Sir I have some important questions for discussion for both critical patriot and Jaipur dialouges, which are obvious but strangely avoided.
1. If partition was inevitable, why nehru, jinnah and Gandhi couldn't arrange for a phase wise transfer of population over say 10 to 15 yrs, so that affected people could sell, exchange or arrange for their land and property in a legal and transparent manner. Sudden loss of livelihoods and property was the main cause of partition riots in both the countries and yet it was largely avoidable. And that it was allowed was a criminal act for both the leaderships. We can blame the British for partition, but they were technically correct, morally or ethically however wrong. The responsibility for the riots lies on the shoulders of our ancestors and their irresponsible leadership. So what were the invisible reasons for the partition course of action.
2. Pakistan was created on the ideology 'of the Muslims, by the Muslims, for the muslims and in the name of islam' - the British and present India were more than generous in giving more than 20% land and resources to equivalent amount of Muslim population. Yet Pakistan accepted 2/3 of the Muslim population and left 1/3 of the Muslim population to whatsoever fate with the Hindus. So the question is why did they do that - the logical thing to pursue would be all Muslims to Pakistan and all non Muslims to India. And a peaceful partition could have achieved that without destroying economy and bloodshed. Why were things started and left halfway. And if halfway is the new normal then what is the logic of pak's claim on Kashmir or its Muslim population.
3. Indian's Uber law and the Kashmir issue: India abides by a never mentioned super law and that is "All relevant parameters (social, economic or otherwise) being equivalent, no law shall be passed, and which when applied in reciprocal is unacceptable to an entity, individual, gender, community, religion, state, country and ad infinitum. This is my personal observation, but I am yet to see an exception to the same. And whatever exception remained are being progressively repealed. Article 370 is one of them. If Pakistanis don't like the law, they don't need weapons, abusive language, etc just convincing logic.
Now, to the dispute of kashmir and playing devils advocate.
A. Why should ladkh and Jammu - non Muslim areas join Pakistan to start with. Like Bengal or Punjab why should it not be partitioned. And if Pakistan accepts kashmiri Muslims, then the same logic loop of the remaining muslims of India applies.
B. UN resolutions were for the whole of JK. So what is pak stand on Chinese capture of askaichin.
C. By what logic does pak explain gifting shakssam to China from disputed territory.
D. Pak transplants Punjabi Muslims in Azad Kashmir/ Pok, but demands that non Indian can settle in kashmir - By what logic.
एक वीडियो पाकिस्तानी दीनदार टीम की सेमी फाइनल धुलाई पर भी बना दीजिये।
Shakeel Bhai, Sanjy Ji ! Jinko Allah ne samajh di aur jinko apni janambhumi, culture se prem tha wo India wapas chale gye. Prominent logon ka zikar hota hye, ghareebon ka khin shumar nhi hota
Sirs, is it possible to publish a "UrdU" version of UnBreaking India" to be released in🇵🇰☪️🇵🇰
Relations with Pakistan will never be normal when one side peddles lies and misinformation forever.
Staying with truth and facts allows nations to solve bilateral issues. When one side selectively looks at problems, history or writes history to its own convenience, then hell breaks lose.
Will Pakistan change, no. Change will be forced on it by US, Arabs, India, IMF, FATF and other means.
हार्दिक अभिनंदन
A@13:00 as per "Creating new medina" Pakistan was build to replace turkey
A good discussion
जय हिंद जय भारत🙏
गुरुदेव🙏🙏
जय श्री राधे कृष्णा 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Jai hind.
The main problem of Pakistan is the biased education.
For the upholders of the Ideology of Pakistan, the existence of Pakistan is defined only in relation to Hindus, and hence the Hindus have to be painted as black as possible. The pre-Ideology textbooks (before the Zia era) did not contain animosity towards Hindus even though Pakistan was born of the bloody riots of the partition. The early textbooks, mostly written after the partition, were free of the pathological hate that we see in textbooks today.
For example, the early history books contained chapters on not only the oldest civilizations of Moen jo Daro, Harappa, Taxila, etc., but also the early Hindu mythologies of Ramayana and Mahabharata, and extensively covered, often with admiration, the great Hindu kingdoms of the Mauryas and the Guptas. The books indeed showed biases when discussing the more recent history of the politics of independence, but still one found text-books with chapters on M.K. Gandhi, using words of respect and admiration for him.
Even in the somewhat biased history of politics of independence, the creation of Pakistan was reasoned on the intransigence of the All-India Congress and its leadership rather than on “Hindu machinations."
Some books also clearly mentioned that the most prominent Islamic religious leaders were all bitterly opposed to the creation of Pakistan.
Such was the enlightened teaching of history for the first 25 years of Pakistan even though two wars were fought against India in this period. The print and electronic media often indulged in anti-Hindu propaganda, but educational material was by and large free of hate against Hindus.
Then came the time of replacing Indo-Pakistan history and geography with Pakistan studies, and defining Pakistan as an Islamic state.
The history of Pakistan became equivalent to the history of Muslims in the subcontinent, starting with the Arab conquest of Sindh and swiftly jumping to the Muslim conquerors from Central Asia.
Simultaneously, a trend started in the 1970s of stressing the Ideology of Pakistan. This involved creating an ideological straitjacket in which the history of Pakistan, especially that of the Pakistan movement, was to be rewritten with utter disregard for truth. Pakistan was told to have been created to establish a truly Islamic state in accordance with the tenets of Qur’an and Sunnah.
The Ulema who had bitterly opposed the creation of Pakistan were turned into heroes of the Pakistan movement. The Quaid-i-Azam was turned into a pious practicing Muslim. And Hindus were hated and denigrated. A few examples of the expression of this hate in some recent curriculum documents and textbooks are given below. Curriculum documents cite the following as learning objectives:
•
[The child should be able to] understand the Hindu and Muslim differences and the resultant need for Pakistan
• Develop understanding of the Hindu-Muslim Differences and need for Pakistan.
• Hindu-Muslim Differences in Culture…India’s evil designs against Pakistan (the three wars with India)
• Identify the events in relation to Hindu-Muslim differences, which laid the foundations for Pakistan.
Until, such vicious propaganda is ended, there can be no Peace. Change your Education system and Pakistan will progress. Education, education and education..........
Nice conversation
Sanjay ji u r right Pakistan shoukd not b any treated a normal nation & we too proclaim total @& permanent war stage Lest be ever prepared
Excellent
Nice video. 👌🙏
Dil se tasleem na kiya and Akhand Bharat are very old statemen. Now support to such things is diminishing in Pakistan . The young educated generation of Pakistan don't have feelings of hostility with India . They want cordial relations with Indians and India. We always discuss the attitudes and versions of extremists on both side and ignore the sentiments of young educated people.
Dear sanjay sir, pls try to bring hasan nisar sir from pakistan in your show. He is very blunt. It can be a good show.
Hasan Nisar will never speak against Pakistan army. He supports separatists in J&K.
Keep it up ❤️❤️❤️❤️
My concern is... Will more and more Pakistanis watch this....bigger question is will zimmy Hindus in India watch and wake up?????
Mujhe lagta yeh Pakistan Channel and host come to Indian channel to increase their views. People in India find out about them and then go to their channel to increase the view.
Exactly.. We shouldn't watch these programmes.
Interesting
Pakistanyon samjho baat ko. Tumhara problem Imran ya hukamran nahi. Tumhari problem islam aur Kuranovirus hai.
islam quran aur muhammad ki sachhai batane par Bharat pakistan Bangladesh k muslim bhadak kyu jate hai?
islam ki sachhai inko gali kyu lagti hai?
Kya islam quran aur muhammad ki sachhai chhipayi gayi hai unse?
Sirf Pakistan nahi. If you look at archeological records then middle East is like cradle of human ingenuity. Mesopotamia or today's Iraq has so many finds like oldest writing, use of wheel etc... But see what Islam has done to the middle East... Even gulf nations like UAE of today prospered when they found oil and used western methods and personel to harness it and then followed monarchy model and allowed capitalism to flourish unhindered on their lands...
@@milind8783 India ki bhi problem islam hi hai hamesha se
@@NatrajChaturvedi they used Indian Engineers, entrepreneur and labours as well
Huzoor ka khilaf agar kisina kaha to uski gardan kaatdi jaayegi nabi ka izzath par compromise nahi bro agar huzoor ka khilaf bas criticise karna hai to karo lakin agar abuse kiya to uski bas ek hi saza hai sazaa a mouth agar wo muslim hojaaye phir bhi death penalty ya har muslim maanta hai
@@rehanahmedsyed3855 isliye bola islam chod insan bane. Is arbi muhammad ki gulami thik nahi hai
ہندوستان دی سن سنتالی وچ دو حصیاں یعنی مغربی ہندوستان (عرف الباکستان) تے مغربی ہندوستان (عرف انڈیا) وچ ونڈ دے ذمےدار سرخ (روسی) سامراج ، سفید (برطانوی) سامراج تے اوناں دے مقامی سہولت کاراں مثلا مسلم لیگ، کانگریس، تے کیمونسٹ پارٹی وغیرہ سن-
Namestay from India sri ji
🙏👍
@13:39 Venkata Dhulpia Book "Creating New Medina" a must read book .. Ambedkar was biggest supporter of 2 nation therory we wanted all Muslim to be thrown in pakistan
Why did these Muslim Leaguers remain in India?
Sanjay sir aap jihnna ko jihnna sahab kyon bolte hn ..🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤..jisky wajah se bantwara hi nhi balki lakhon logo ka blood bath Hua tha. Or ghar se beggar bhi huye the.😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Bro sarcasm waala sahab hai 😂
Jinnah saanp.
Shri-ram/ Ali- Fatima / Khadija-Fatima/ yajooj- majooj/ Essa- Imam Mehdi basically belongs to oldest religion sanatan Ishwar.
Correct…tum Hindu ki hi oladain ho
It's time sir
GOOD
Yeh shaqil hai to chaudhary kyu 😀
Kyunki Converted lagta hai
@@Amit_xx , Jai Bhavani, phir kahi aur ja kar kare chaudhrygiri 😀
Wo "Hindu" hai to Urdu kyu bol rahe hai?
@@Abdullah-uv9nk urdu tere baap ki h kya....pehle Google kr urdu kha se aaya
@@TheKP74 His ancestors must be Hindu but after 1940s he got converted
Islam haar gya bahut bura hua vro 🤣🤣🤣🤣
चौदह सौ साल पहले अल्लाह नाम को कौन जानता अल्लाह किसी पुस्तक मे इस झूठे नाम का कोई जिकृ नही
ओम वेदो मे आदि सृषटि से अनंत तक रहा,चैनल को लाईक शेयर सब्सक्रिप्शन प्लीज,,,
Sanjay Dixit a true speak person