People need to stop using Liverpool and Coutinho as an example. Coutinho was 26 when Liverpool sold him and they got 140 Million! Plus Liverpool fans wouldn't put up with the Glazers so we wouldn't be in this position anyway
Garnacho doesn’t suit the system and if you can replace him with someone that’s better suited like a Nuno Mendes and Gyokores then as painful as it is to part ways with a youth prospect in the long run it’s better for the team. Plus, I think Garnacho wants to leave otherwise he’ll shut down his agent from pushing this through.
Will be a red flag if we sell players like Garnacho & Mainoo, while Amorim is stuck with deadwood like Shaw, Casemiro, Mount and Rashford. A million pounds a week for those 4 and they never play
Under Fergie England players were our heroes. This time around they are causing many problems. Phil Jones, Luke Shaw, Mount and Rashford. Rashford is more interested in his charity than playing for United badge.
Gary Nevilles comments now cant be trusted because he is on the payroll of Ineos by being on the board of the new stadium. He hasnt said one bad thing about them despite what has happened.
He's still a legend and done more for us than gobshite goldbridge can even dream of. Are you really trying to say one of our most successful captains doesn't want us to get back to the top. Give your head a wobble
As much as we love, Sir Alex, we need to acknowledge that when the previous owners gifted him the racehorse, sir Alex fought for the breeding rights and in doing so the previous owners went to court (McManus and Magnier). And during this division, the Glazzers saw an opportunity to increase their holdings in the club. We are in the position We are in with the Glazzers because sir Alex allowed them to get a strong hold after this event. The two previous owners felt disrespected by Sir Alex, after gifting him a racehorse, and allowing him to keep a percentage of the winnings. (I can't remember if it was all of it or not) and then Alex had to take it further, trying to get the breeding rights, this is when the Glazzers took over. they saw a division and they conquered it
Nobody mentions that having Garnacho and Mainoo from the academy means we have saved £100m that we would have had to pay for players of their standard. If they are sold and we buy multiple cheaper players worth less means we are not getting better but diluting the quality of the squad - mid table outlook....
The sheer arrogance of Woodard and his cronies shocks me more and more….they ignored suggestions from managers about players and handed out ridiculous contracts to mediocre players…they thought they knew what was best…
I honestly don’t see it as a disgrace if we sell Garnacho. Talented player but he doesn’t scream wow to me as a 20 year old. Maybe that’s just me, but I only have an opinion.
Comparing Garnacho going to Scholes if he was to leave is absolutely nuts. Obviously they wouldn’t want Scholes to go because he was world class. You’re reaching.
He’s not comparing Garnacho with Scholes as players. He’s comparing letting Scholes, as one of our best players (ever) go and letting Garnacho, one of our better players (currently) to leave.
@@MiaDior-j4r Difference is, no one has considered Amad for sale, and just penned the new contract. But yeah, when it comes to impact, you can compare them.
Anybody saying that this kid has no talent is clearly clueless...😂.... We need to support the manager on what he wants... People can have opinions but also people can have no common sense either😂
He don't horrible first touch can't receive the ball to feet in any pressure zones can't properly beat a defender 1v1 average pace no physicality no football iq can't shoot no weight of pass he excels at nothing
Just imagine this time when the transfer window shuts and a lot of these content creators have been telling us that Manchester United are in talks with this person and that person and then when the first of febuary comes we basically sign nobody
@adenfawcett426 I am not complaining I really do hope United do sign some players some quality players but just imagine if we signed the next Fellaini a position that we don't need filling
If Garnacho doesn’t suit the system let him go. Fans need to stop getting so attached to players and actually judge them on what they are, not on what they hope for them to be.
If he didn't like Garna or Rasmus then he'd calling for them to be sold since they've been underperforming, but because he likes them he'll defend them to the moon and back.
For me it's about age. The young lads can still be taught. You dont teach adults cus they become stubborn at that age and won't just accept criticism and new ways of doing things easily
15 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา +1
He's learning how to play in the new system. Amorim confirmed he was and is improving.
Garnacho is a brilliant player that needs to be nurtured. He’s proved in the last two years how good he is, yes his form has dipped a bit in the last few games which is expected of a young player who had to step in to rescue the team on numerous occasions. He’s only human and he needs a break every now and then. I am absolutely certain that the club will live to regret it if they end up selling him. We are not a selling club, we need to build the team around him, Mainoo, Hojlund, Ugarte and Yoro.
Who in their right mind thinks selling players who are on huge contracts and are either underperforming, not very good or always injured is easy ? "Clear out the deadwood" is the cry, who the F wants our deadwood ?
Garnacho is inconsistent, does not have great technical ability, does not suit the system (is neither a wing back nor an inside attacking option) and if upwards of 60m can be brought in, then its an absolute no brainer. Trust Amorim. Trust the process. Stop the player FC Mark.
@@mahidsahariarmazumder2658 Don't be ridiculous, they wouldn't do that. There can sometimes a be a persuasion though... Manager likes a player even though he's not a first eleven player. Manager sort of would like to keep him (think ETH with Scott). Management say, look we can sell this player for x amount and that frees up ffp space to buy you two players for the first eleven. Manager says, do it.
@@creepingbrain when eth signed for utd he had it in his contract that signings cannot happen or leave without his say, amorim does not have that in his contract. So yes the owners can sell a player without getting Amorim’s approval. They can consider his opinion but they ultimately can do whatever they want with selling players.
We won't get anywhere as a club if we don't clear out the deadwood - Garnacho's technical ability is so poor. Scores a couple of goals & Mark's getting excited. This is why we're 14th. Our standards have dropped
Yeah Garnacho is deadwood right do you believe what you're saying? Not overpaid Rashford, Casemiro old Evans, Eriksen. Overpriced Zirkzee, Antony etc. Fanbase is clueless you don't deserve Garnacho
What positive thing have Ineos done? Lay off people? Quit donating to club charities? You seem to forget that Ineos is a MINORITY stakeholder. They have to answer to the Glazers. But you keep singing Kumbaya.
Putting garancho in the same bracket as rashford is disgraceful. Rashford is bad for the club in every metric and has no one that wants him. It’s the complete opposite for garnacho
You say ineos shouldn't sell garnacho. But what if he wants to go to play for napoli to play under conte? He is argentine who would know about Maradona being a hero of napoli. Its a big pull for him. It's a 2 way thing and it would surprise you Mark that napoli might be a bigger club to a young argentine. He might actually be a human with feelings! He's not one of our best players either. He has potential yes but we are a club that needs a huge clearcut and not in any specific order. Nearly all players shouldn't be here in a year or two. If we are having complete reset then I'm happy if Amorim is happy.
They don't want to sell him at all. It's just marketing. This way, United seems less desperate about selling Rashford, increasing the chances of him leaving and potentially get a better price.
Why is hard to understand that the club clearly has to sell someone and Garnacho doesn't fit the system and can get good money. The older players are not going to get alot of money.
Maybe that’s Gary’s opinion because he doesn’t rate Garnacho or Rashford. Amorim has said similar things about Rashford and it looks like he’s going. Managers will always talk positively to the media but what is said behind closed doors is different.
IMO Garnacho doesn’t have the technical ability to play the LF role. Probably doesn’t have the commitment/enthusiasm to play the WB position either. He’s another great counter attacking player and that doesn’t suit Amorim, getting £60/£70 is good business
We are where we are, enough of what shoulda could have been...I'm just tired of hearing where and who united should have been sold to....I supported full sale but we didn't! We can only shout and hope glaneous would do the right things going forward.
Mark, you always underestimate the Italian league. I know you say you love Italian football and all that, but you always speak about Serie A like it was a farmer league. European competitions show quite the opposite. The only two aspects the Prem is superior to Serie A on is the way it’s packaged (stadiums, overall appeal of the product, etc.) and pace - which btw doesn’t necessarily translate into better football. This is just my opinion
What silly arguments, had Elanga, Sancho, Angel Gomes, Pellestri and Avarez reached full potential? We sell young players all the time. This guy is obsessed like Garnacho is gonna turn into Lamine Yamal in 5 years. He's an average replaceable player. Bring in the best players, who cares about age? Weirdo.
Selling mainoo or garnacho is ridiculous they are plain to see future super footballers ....it's mental and you just know united will sell them to a rival that will destroy us in a cup at the most devastating time possible.....it's hard to justify what's going on at united lately it's like someone is kamakazi destroying the club .....it's getting unbearable and unsupportable
We signed Sancho for 75mil. We are going to get 25mil off Chelsea. That's your Garnacho or Mainoo theory completely exposed! Young players. You're buying or selling potential & that's it. There are no guarantees
Garnacho is more of a raw talent and if he can learn to play a lot better in the build up and in possession while united have to probe in the situations where united are dominating the ball against teams who defend. Then he has the potential to be a great player. At the moment he's a excellent counter attacking player with raw pace and skill which is great but he needs to be a bit more like Yamal and Saka in possession when the space isnt there, and be just as effective. Personally I think he can become the more rounded player that United would like.
Barca will not sell Yamal for 200M ! INEOS will be the worst Manager of funds and Asset if they sell Garna for 70M Pounds!!! That will be the most erroneous thing a Club will make in History!!!
If the manager wants a to player to go he’s not going come out in a interview and press conference and to let the other clubs know that which would be idiotic
the thing abt selling mainoo is that it’s a similar situation with milan n tonali, sold their talent to get signings in n have regressed since their scudetto
on my FM24 rashford and anthony were decent for me but when rashford and anthony where in there 30s saudi came in and i accepted it but amad and garnacho where my main starters on the wide area ugarte and colyer were my pivot mainoo and gore as the 10s and up front it was rasmus/evan ferguson backline of martinez ligt and scalvini and dioga costa and i loved that team mainly bring through the youth cant wait to do that on FM25
The top clubs dont sell their best players before the club has gotten use out of the player... Amad, Mainoo, Garnacho are the better players at rhe club....
I like Garnacho. He's brave and talented and isn't afraid in the big games. United however (under Amorim) seem to want clever 10s supported by attacking fullbacks rather than the 433 stuff that has dynamic wingers (garnacho so far). Whether Garnacho stays or not will come solely down to if he can be (or wants to be) top class in that 10 role. It's a big ask for him. If he goes elsewhere he'll go any play in that wide dynamic position. He'll do well but it doesn't mean to say we "should've kept him" But selling your best wingers must only be done if you're sticking with Amorim and he's 523/343. So the club MUST fully commit to the manager long term.
Your so rite it’s literally the same as this time last year! Mainoo will sign a new deal and be lauded as a new signing, collyer be introduced the same way so frustrating oh well come on tnite!
Your opinion on this Garnacho thing just depends on how much you rate him. I don’t think he is even as good as Greenwood. We need the money whats the point crying
Amorim actually expressed his dissent for gernacho using the sweetest terms. It is well evident if you compare his visions for mainoo and Gernacho. He is clearly appreciative of mainoo but not on gernacho
We need the money now , if get a good deal for more than 70M , take it , as long we are moving in the right direction , we were ran badly , there's no changing that now , Sell and make the team better ,then we wont be in a position to sell talent anymore , maybe next season. if the 70M is used to make the team better , then do it. If you indebt , you sell your most valuable assets , to be in a better position.
Controversial take but Elanga is still not good enough for Utd. Perhaps a bench player and I will concede, he's better than Anthony. All this, "we should not have let him go", I don't agree with. Also would he have developed to what he is now at Utd?
I understand that maybe malacia isn’t good enough in the long run, but why are we looking to sell our only leftback, he did a decent job against arsenal and defended well, if we aren’t going to get a leftback in i dont understand, if we sell malacia to get a better leftback then im on board but I dont believe we will buy anyone before we pass june with these owners
hey mark im super relaxed about the garnacho naples situation. why does nobody see that the story about garnacho and naples is only spinn of the media! naples has signed billing from bourmouth so they cant sign garnacho aswell. the media just love to write about united.
The words and actions from Amorim are honest and he is focused on the improvement of the players he has in his Man U player pool. Players come and go. He is focused on the Present. INEOS a portion now of the Glazer long history of $ mismanagement and loss. Thus without concern for fans, players and coaches they have selfishly sucked the life out of the club we love. So much discussion has consumed us about $. As Mark has said “It is all about the Glazers”. Let us hear something about just how strategically Maino and Ugarte are succeeding together and the harmony between Deligt and McGuire are molding a solid wall at the back. Please can we resist so much talk of Glazers and more about players and coaches making this team great again.
Ruben says good things abt Rashford what's your point? Garnacho is inconsistent mason mount is a championd league winner stop talking nonsense at garnacho's age mason was way better!
Neville , for transparency, should disclose any and all personal business ties with RatFink & HidEOuS. His output as a "mouthpiece", could then be assessed....😈
A player can always get stats but can they develop into something more than they are. While Garnacho plays for Argentina, he’s not as physical and/or as technical as most other South American player. RASHFORD never learned to play as a 10 or proper 9. There aren’t too many positions on a pitch for Garnacho except LW or RW.
I think we made a big mistake not signing Spurs signing Bergvail. When he turned 18 we literally scouted him were really impressed an all we’d to do was wait so annoying
Mark, Garnacho has a bad first touch, a poor shot, weak left foot, he’s weak on the ball and is not that fast. Makes poor and selfish decisions. If he doesn’t get to run in behind the defense, he’s limited. He’s got to then that run and then make the right decision to pass or execute an effective shot. Credit to Amorim, he’s making him pass instead of shoot.
I feel all these Garnacho and Mainoo rumors are to keep us distracted from the fact they aren’t really doing anything…forget about incomings, no exits so far either…
I don't think we should sell Garnacho at all... but if Antony was worth £86 million ($108 million)!!!!, Garnacho is worth at least £100m. Take nothing less, end of. LUHG.
Regarding the putative transfer of Garnacho, interested clubs expect Man Utd to donate their players. In addition, are Liverpool selling Conor Bradley, Harvey Elliott or Curtis Jones?
People need to stop using Liverpool and Coutinho as an example. Coutinho was 26 when Liverpool sold him and they got 140 Million! Plus Liverpool fans wouldn't put up with the Glazers so we wouldn't be in this position anyway
There will be a very big uproar if Utd sell Garnacho or Kobbie. The Fans will SCREAM INEOS OUTTTTTT
It's called ffp this channel is becoming foolish.
Garnacho doesn’t suit the system and if you can replace him with someone that’s better suited like a Nuno Mendes and Gyokores then as painful as it is to part ways with a youth prospect in the long run it’s better for the team. Plus, I think Garnacho wants to leave otherwise he’ll shut down his agent from pushing this through.
I thought all this player fc nonsense would stop especially as Amorim won't put up with it
Players would not have said anything about selling players. You are sounding stupid. Man u got rid of bigger players under fergie .
Transfer window is so dry we’ve been talking about Garnacho for three days
All this transfer talk to end up and sign no one
And talked about rashy for one week also.
These shows could go for 5 minutes, the rest is just repeating what he said in the first 5 minutes
@@DavidMike-y2kfeels like 5 years 😅
Genacho is lazy
Gary Neville's opinions are like his property portfolio: for sale
Ferguson had it right: Typical emotional Neville.
Will be a red flag if we sell players like Garnacho & Mainoo, while Amorim is stuck with deadwood like Shaw, Casemiro, Mount and Rashford. A million pounds a week for those 4 and they never play
You're listing players who are largely unsellable.
Closer to 1.5m a week
Under Fergie England players were our heroes. This time around they are causing many problems. Phil Jones, Luke Shaw, Mount and Rashford. Rashford is more interested in his charity than playing for United badge.
hi mark i'm done with the glazers and ineos we need to get louder and start protests
Totally agree,protesting should never have stopped Ratcliffe is a ruthless business man and has enabled the Glazers to stay as owners
GLINEOS OUT.
@@kevingood4644ineos out for what?
Protests don't work we've found that out.
fans fill the stadium every week like sheep
Gary Nevilles comments now cant be trusted because he is on the payroll of Ineos by being on the board of the new stadium. He hasnt said one bad thing about them despite what has happened.
Gary is for Ineos not Man United. Like a RAT.
He's a FAKE
He's still a legend and done more for us than gobshite goldbridge can even dream of. Are you really trying to say one of our most successful captains doesn't want us to get back to the top. Give your head a wobble
💯
He might have signed a disclaimer, just like INEOS have.
As much as we love, Sir Alex, we need to acknowledge that when the previous owners gifted him the racehorse, sir Alex fought for the breeding rights and in doing so the previous owners went to court (McManus and Magnier). And during this division, the Glazzers saw an opportunity to increase their holdings in the club. We are in the position We are in with the Glazzers because sir Alex allowed them to get a strong hold after this event. The two previous owners felt disrespected by Sir Alex, after gifting him a racehorse, and allowing him to keep a percentage of the winnings. (I can't remember if it was all of it or not) and then Alex had to take it further, trying to get the breeding rights, this is when the Glazzers took over. they saw a division and they conquered it
Nobody mentions that having Garnacho and Mainoo from the academy means we have saved £100m that we would have had to pay for players of their standard. If they are sold and we buy multiple cheaper players worth less means we are not getting better but diluting the quality of the squad - mid table outlook....
Garnacho is from the Atletico Madrid Academy!
Our previous board have also fucked up by giving players big contracts and wages.
The sheer arrogance of Woodard and his cronies shocks me more and more….they ignored suggestions from managers about players and handed out ridiculous contracts to mediocre players…they thought they knew what was best…
I honestly don’t see it as a disgrace if we sell Garnacho. Talented player but he doesn’t scream wow to me as a 20 year old. Maybe that’s just me, but I only have an opinion.
Can’t believe Ineos are having a dry January
More like dry 25
I can, sadly
Comparing Garnacho going to Scholes if he was to leave is absolutely nuts.
Obviously they wouldn’t want Scholes to go because he was world class. You’re reaching.
He’s not comparing Garnacho with Scholes as players. He’s comparing letting Scholes, as one of our best players (ever) go and letting Garnacho, one of our better players (currently) to leave.
@@paulgraham1465the better example would be amad. Garna is not that great.
@@MiaDior-j4r Difference is, no one has considered Amad for sale, and just penned the new contract. But yeah, when it comes to impact, you can compare them.
@@Matt-fe6wu that's the hypothetical scenario I was creating
Anybody saying that this kid has no talent is clearly clueless...😂.... We need to support the manager on what he wants... People can have opinions but also people can have no common sense either😂
He don't horrible first touch can't receive the ball to feet in any pressure zones can't properly beat a defender 1v1 average pace no physicality no football iq can't shoot no weight of pass he excels at nothing
@@KING.Millis.2501yeh because someone with no talent can score the greatest over head the premier league has ever seen lol
@@Andytate3000every dog has its day . Keep glazing tho you will realise soon .
@@Gaeul-j3j I can't believe how backwards you are.
@KING.Millis.2501 😂... Are you talking about you're playing style? 😆.. you're obviously clueless and don't have a good judge of talent...
For christ sake mark...
Do you really think you know better than amorim the kind of players he needs for he's system?
My God
yet again Goldbridge is moaning about things that have not happened, you are once again TRYING to make content that is not happening
I am surprised you haven’t had the usual “well don’t watch it then” comment 😂
Just imagine this time when the transfer window shuts and a lot of these content creators have been telling us that Manchester United are in talks with this person and that person and then when the first of febuary comes we basically sign nobody
@@supersonicwbrfm3402 well complain then ,but complaining before the end is useless, it is just his agenda
@adenfawcett426 I am not complaining I really do hope United do sign some players some quality players but just imagine if we signed the next Fellaini a position that we don't need filling
Love Neville but Mark’s spot on, if INEOS weren’t there he’d be much more vocal about the cost cutting measures
Rahim sterling was sold by Liverpool for 50 mil to Man city …he was 19
Convert that 50mil now and it will be worth more than 90mil
@@SalimAnas-mc6jx Convert Palmer going for £40 million Nacho must be worth £20 million
Sterling wanted to go
Garnacho is a better player now than when palmer was at city, put garnacho in a Chelsea team and see what he does
@Ashleypeyton5738 Lol some player fc guys are so funny
If Garnacho doesn’t suit the system let him go. Fans need to stop getting so attached to players and actually judge them on what they are, not on what they hope for them to be.
So you would rather keep players that never play and cost a million a week combined stupid.
Facts
If he didn't like Garna or Rasmus then he'd calling for them to be sold since they've been underperforming, but because he likes them he'll defend them to the moon and back.
For me it's about age. The young lads can still be taught. You dont teach adults cus they become stubborn at that age and won't just accept criticism and new ways of doing things easily
He's learning how to play in the new system. Amorim confirmed he was and is improving.
Garnacho is a brilliant player that needs to be nurtured. He’s proved in the last two years how good he is, yes his form has dipped a bit in the last few games which is expected of a young player who had to step in to rescue the team on numerous occasions. He’s only human and he needs a break every now and then. I am absolutely certain that the club will live to regret it if they end up selling him. We are not a selling club, we need to build the team around him, Mainoo, Hojlund, Ugarte and Yoro.
No way we sell Garnacho , his potential is elite. People seem to think he’s 27 years old and washed
Elite lol if Palmer went for £40 million Nacho is worth £20 million
Nice shade at marcus lol, and garnacho isnt near elite.
@@Dan-cg4xj the comment was his potential is elite not that he is elite now. That fact is quite clear to see in my opinion.
@@user-cl2oe6jg5i ok ? His potential is also nowhere near elite 😂 like it’s the same sht lmao
What is garnacho actually good at…
Who remembers Adnan Januzaj
Mark their is no guarantee that he's going to do well in Italy
There are no guarantees that he eill move there and no garantee tomorrow we all be alive…🤦🏽♂️
There are no guarantee you eill sell if you keep rising his value, and no guarantee you’ll be alive tomorrow…🤦🏽♂️
Ineos need to start delivering some positive news
Like what 😂😂😂 all we got is spin spin spin
@ so true
@@TheSensoryGamer It's not raining in Manchester today how's that
Who in their right mind thinks selling players who are on huge contracts and are either underperforming, not very good or always injured is easy ? "Clear out the deadwood" is the cry, who the F wants our deadwood ?
Selling Garnacho is not the problem. Selling Garnacho AND keeping the likes of Casemiro, Antony, Luke Shaw and Mason Mount are.
Garnacho is inconsistent, does not have great technical ability, does not suit the system (is neither a wing back nor an inside attacking option) and if upwards of 60m can be brought in, then its an absolute no brainer. Trust Amorim. Trust the process. Stop the player FC Mark.
Garnacho has the best stats of all this season. Goals and assists are important.
Amorim wants to keep him mate
ETH said with the mctominay deal he didn't want to sell him but the club felt they would get good value for him
Stop f'ing crying about Garnacho. Surely they speak to Amorim about transfers and if Amorim has given the green light, ACCEPT IT. Trust your manager.
Amorim can say no and ineos can still go ahead and sell him. You do know that right?
The blind trust of these owners is laughable
@@mahidsahariarmazumder2658 Don't be ridiculous, they wouldn't do that.
There can sometimes a be a persuasion though...
Manager likes a player even though he's not a first eleven player.
Manager sort of would like to keep him (think ETH with Scott).
Management say, look we can sell this player for x amount and that frees up ffp space to buy you two players for the first eleven.
Manager says, do it.
@@creepingbrain when eth signed for utd he had it in his contract that signings cannot happen or leave without his say, amorim does not have that in his contract. So yes the owners can sell a player without getting Amorim’s approval. They can consider his opinion but they ultimately can do whatever they want with selling players.
@@mahidsahariarmazumder2658 Doing that would undermine the manager. They're not going to do that.
We won't get anywhere as a club if we don't clear out the deadwood - Garnacho's technical ability is so poor. Scores a couple of goals & Mark's getting excited. This is why we're 14th. Our standards have dropped
Your correct and tht fact tht the ones representing these kids we hype soo much arecausing trouble wanting a payday
We 15th
Are you daft you prat?
Yeah Garnacho is deadwood right do you believe what you're saying? Not overpaid Rashford, Casemiro old Evans, Eriksen. Overpriced Zirkzee, Antony etc. Fanbase is clueless you don't deserve Garnacho
he is lazy
Mark. You've been a big hypocrite these few days. contradicting.
Ineos have done well compared to the last few seasons.
Fuvking hell ….done well ? Ffs
These few days you mean years?
What positive thing have Ineos done? Lay off people? Quit donating to club charities? You seem to forget that Ineos is a MINORITY stakeholder. They have to answer to the Glazers. But you keep singing Kumbaya.
Putting garancho in the same bracket as rashford is disgraceful. Rashford is bad for the club in every metric and has no one that wants him. It’s the complete opposite for garnacho
You say ineos shouldn't sell garnacho. But what if he wants to go to play for napoli to play under conte? He is argentine who would know about Maradona being a hero of napoli. Its a big pull for him. It's a 2 way thing and it would surprise you Mark that napoli might be a bigger club to a young argentine. He might actually be a human with feelings! He's not one of our best players either. He has potential yes but we are a club that needs a huge clearcut and not in any specific order. Nearly all players shouldn't be here in a year or two. If we are having complete reset then I'm happy if Amorim is happy.
They don't want to sell him at all. It's just marketing. This way, United seems less desperate about selling Rashford, increasing the chances of him leaving and potentially get a better price.
Why is hard to understand that the club clearly has to sell someone and Garnacho doesn't fit the system and can get good money. The older players are not going to get alot of money.
IF Garnacho is going to get sold we need to get the highest price possible AND have a sell-on clause for the future in case he reaches his potential
Maybe that’s Gary’s opinion because he doesn’t rate Garnacho or Rashford. Amorim has said similar things about Rashford and it looks like he’s going. Managers will always talk positively to the media but what is said behind closed doors is different.
IMO Garnacho doesn’t have the technical ability to play the LF role. Probably doesn’t have the commitment/enthusiasm to play the WB position either. He’s another great counter attacking player and that doesn’t suit Amorim, getting £60/£70 is good business
We are where we are, enough of what shoulda could have been...I'm just tired of hearing where and who united should have been sold to....I supported full sale but we didn't! We can only shout and hope glaneous would do the right things going forward.
Amad is the only player I would be against selling. Couldn't give a toss about the rest.
Mark, you always underestimate the Italian league. I know you say you love Italian football and all that, but you always speak about Serie A like it was a farmer league. European competitions show quite the opposite. The only two aspects the Prem is superior to Serie A on is the way it’s packaged (stadiums, overall appeal of the product, etc.) and pace - which btw doesn’t necessarily translate into better football. This is just my opinion
Mark is Italian interesting if he follows or not
He talks , as many , all bollocks! As there are more Farmers in the U.K. probably !
He is what??? 🤦🏽♂️
What silly arguments, had Elanga, Sancho, Angel Gomes, Pellestri and Avarez reached full potential? We sell young players all the time. This guy is obsessed like Garnacho is gonna turn into Lamine Yamal in 5 years. He's an average replaceable player. Bring in the best players, who cares about age? Weirdo.
And if they’re so bad why trying to block them from going to competing PL clubs. Hmmm
We are 15 th and we are worried about selling a player? 60 million with add ons leading to 70 and beyond? I like it.
yes he is lazy and does not pass
What a stupid take. Almost all of them are lazy and don't pass.
Garnacho is literally ballon dor potential, why would you sell him at this early stage
Napoli don’t like it as onow the real value of Garnacho, plus you are in the deadend zone of your League, no more than 40 Mlns., or you can keep him!
Eh?
Selling mainoo or garnacho is ridiculous they are plain to see future super footballers ....it's mental and you just know united will sell them to a rival that will destroy us in a cup at the most devastating time possible.....it's hard to justify what's going on at united lately it's like someone is kamakazi destroying the club .....it's getting unbearable and unsupportable
We signed Sancho for 75mil.
We are going to get 25mil off Chelsea.
That's your Garnacho or Mainoo theory completely exposed!
Young players. You're buying or selling potential & that's it. There are no guarantees
I don’t think Barcelona will be selling yamal even though they’re in financial crisis
😂😂😂 Garnacho ain't half the player Yamal is.
Yamal is younger and miles better than garnacho bro 😂
He isnt a player that could be a good player. He is a special talent which is obvious! Garnacho might be a great player, that is the difference.
Garnacho is more of a raw talent and if he can learn to play a lot better in the build up and in possession while united have to
probe in the situations where united are dominating the ball against teams who defend. Then he has the potential to be a
great player. At the moment he's a excellent counter attacking player with raw pace and skill which is great but he needs
to be a bit more like Yamal and Saka in possession when the space isnt there, and be just as effective. Personally I think
he can become the more rounded player that United would like.
Barca will not sell Yamal for 200M ! INEOS will be the worst Manager of funds and Asset if they sell Garna for 70M Pounds!!! That will be the most erroneous thing a Club will make in History!!!
We complain that most of our players are bad, and then when they are all up for sell, we complain that we have turned into a selling club. 😂😂😂
Right? Haha sell every single player idc. I want all new players bar Amad, Mainoo, Ugarte, maz, and the CBs.
💯
If the manager wants a to player to go he’s not going come out in a interview and press conference and to let the other clubs know that which would be idiotic
the thing abt selling mainoo is that it’s a similar situation with milan n tonali, sold their talent to get signings in n have regressed since their scudetto
a lot of united fans were opposing qatar and vehemently supporting INEOS. let them witness this.
I don't believe Amorim considers Garnacho to be indispensable.
Of course not, just pretending to raise his prize, useless!
on my FM24 rashford and anthony were decent for me but when rashford and anthony where in there 30s saudi came in and i accepted it but amad and garnacho where my main starters on the wide area ugarte and colyer were my pivot mainoo and gore as the 10s and up front it was rasmus/evan ferguson backline of martinez ligt and scalvini and dioga costa and i loved that team mainly bring through the youth cant wait to do that on FM25
Sell him, we don't want any ffp issues. We need a 10 & wb anyway.
You’d think Rashford would jump on the Milan offer after pulisic went out with an injury
I think its only a game with the owner’s the way the manager says he keeps him and then the won’t buy anyone until the summer
Well said mark.
After the Arsenal game Bidiyer value has gone up why isn't he on the market Mark?
Haven't you realized yet that if you are kicking the same story to death for the past three/four days then you have nothing to say?
The top clubs dont sell their best players before the club has gotten use out of the player... Amad, Mainoo, Garnacho are the better players at rhe club....
I like Garnacho. He's brave and talented and isn't afraid in the big games. United however (under Amorim) seem to want clever 10s supported by attacking fullbacks rather than the 433 stuff that has dynamic wingers (garnacho so far). Whether Garnacho stays or not will come solely down to if he can be (or wants to be) top class in that 10 role. It's a big ask for him. If he goes elsewhere he'll go any play in that wide dynamic position. He'll do well but it doesn't mean to say we "should've kept him" But selling your best wingers must only be done if you're sticking with Amorim and he's 523/343. So the club MUST fully commit to the manager long term.
Your so rite it’s literally the same as this time last year! Mainoo will sign a new deal and be lauded as a new signing, collyer be introduced the same way so frustrating oh well come on tnite!
Højlund cost us more than wat they want to sell Garnacho for
Your opinion on this Garnacho thing just depends on how much you rate him. I don’t think he is even as good as Greenwood. We need the money whats the point crying
Gary Neville saved Carragher from the sack when he spat on a girl and loves PM two tier Kier
How old was Elanga when he was sold?
Amorim actually expressed his dissent for gernacho using the sweetest terms. It is well evident if you compare his visions for mainoo and Gernacho. He is clearly appreciative of mainoo but not on gernacho
Garnacho aint good enough and does not fit into Amorims system, sell, we need better players in this side that suit what Amorim is trying to implement
Oh yes look around our team yes yes yes garnacho really really really needs to go before some players …. Right ?
Rashford not ill. Hes playing the game. He's pathetic
Lost all respect for Rashford sulking and wanting a new challenge but happy to pick up his obscene weekly wage
It does add up. You bang on about these player not being good enough. Mov3 this lot out to bring better players in
this is just spin imo glazers want us to thank them that they didnt sell to napoli
We need the money now , if get a good deal for more than 70M , take it , as long we are moving in the right direction , we were ran badly , there's no changing that now , Sell and make the team better ,then we wont be in a position to sell talent anymore , maybe next season. if the 70M is used to make the team better , then do it. If you indebt , you sell your most valuable assets , to be in a better position.
Controversial take but Elanga is still not good enough for Utd. Perhaps a bench player and I will concede, he's better than Anthony. All this, "we should not have let him go", I don't agree with. Also would he have developed to what he is now at Utd?
I am glad when the transfer windows clodes. Then we have facts!
I can see us letting Garna go for 60 and a sell on clause, then buying him back for 80 in 4 seasons 😂
That's a good deal btw
The Glazers are giving the bank 60m every year in debt repayments, just imagine what we could do with all that money over the last 20 years, 1.2B 😮.
Maintain the blady stadium... its now the theater of potential law suite
The Glazer debt is £24m a year at the moment. Since the refinancing of 2016 it's been £19m a year on average.
Not what i heard on stick to football, Neville said he thought it was wrong to sell garnacho
We're not doing nothing other than selling a bunch of quality and loaning some deadweight....
I understand that maybe malacia isn’t good enough in the long run, but why are we looking to sell our only leftback, he did a decent job against arsenal and defended well, if we aren’t going to get a leftback in i dont understand, if we sell malacia to get a better leftback then im on board but I dont believe we will buy anyone before we pass june with these owners
Why don’t we do what Barca does with their young talent 🤷
Ive you ever thought he wants to leave 🙄
Who does these fans really rate ?
I've just watched the overlap and he said garnacho and mainoo shouldny be sold
hey mark
im super relaxed about the garnacho naples situation.
why does nobody see that the story about garnacho and naples is only spinn of the media!
naples has signed billing from bourmouth so they cant sign garnacho aswell.
the media just love to write about united.
The words and actions from Amorim are honest and he is focused on the improvement of the players he has in his Man U player pool. Players come and go. He is focused on the Present.
INEOS a portion now of the Glazer long history of $ mismanagement and loss. Thus without concern for fans, players and coaches they have selfishly sucked the life out of the club we love. So much discussion has consumed us about $. As Mark has said “It is all about the Glazers”.
Let us hear something about just how strategically Maino and Ugarte are succeeding together and the harmony between Deligt and McGuire are molding a solid wall at the back.
Please can we resist so much talk of Glazers and more about players and coaches making this team great again.
Ruben says good things abt Rashford what's your point? Garnacho is inconsistent mason mount is a championd league winner stop talking nonsense at garnacho's age mason was way better!
Ten hag Got rid of Elanga you are so biased
Neville , for transparency, should disclose any and all personal business ties with RatFink & HidEOuS. His output as a "mouthpiece", could then be assessed....😈
Will be gutted if Garnacho goes hes gonna go on to be a baller
A player can always get stats but can they develop into something more than they are. While Garnacho plays for Argentina, he’s not as physical and/or as technical as most other South American player. RASHFORD never learned to play as a 10 or proper 9. There aren’t too many positions on a pitch for Garnacho except LW or RW.
If we get rid of garnacho that will come back and bite us
Glineos will not buy any player in this January window, only looking at the spread sheet if they sell Garnacho
I think we made a big mistake not signing Spurs signing Bergvail. When he turned 18 we literally scouted him were really impressed an all we’d to do was wait so annoying
There is only gernacho here, we need a left back badly at any cost. It's player fc going on.
Mark, Garnacho has a bad first touch, a poor shot, weak left foot, he’s weak on the ball and is not that fast. Makes poor and selfish decisions. If he doesn’t get to run in behind the defense, he’s limited. He’s got to then that run and then make the right decision to pass or execute an effective shot. Credit to Amorim, he’s making him pass instead of shoot.
Gotta keep this story going for content and outrage.
It will be a mistake of monumental proportions to sell Garnacho. He is a generational talent with his future fully ahead of him.
Spot on today Mark!
I feel all these Garnacho and Mainoo rumors are to keep us distracted from the fact they aren’t really doing anything…forget about incomings, no exits so far either…
We should be speaking about Glazers and Ineos together! GLANEOS out!!!
Imagine selling garnacho and the Glazers deciding to take dividends
My God hes still talking about NEXT Rashford, This day in a row same stupid topic
I don't think we should sell Garnacho at all... but if Antony was worth £86 million ($108 million)!!!!, Garnacho is worth at least £100m. Take nothing less, end of. LUHG.
Just because we were dumb enough to pay more than double what Antony was worth doesn't mean we can expect other clubs to do the same with Garnacho
Regarding the putative transfer of Garnacho, interested clubs expect Man Utd to donate their players. In addition, are Liverpool selling Conor Bradley, Harvey Elliott or Curtis Jones?