@@idkbro1696 if gta 6 comes out next year that’s about 12 years between gta games… it’s all because they’ve made a killing with the micro transactions on gta online. It’s not gonna get any better.
I'm 99.9% sure everyone wants the game to start with Dutch and Hosea raising Arthur, meeting John, then building the Gang up through Crime, deals, etc. Then, the game finishes with the Blackwater Mission.
At this point Rockstar should just ignore the fans lmao Imagine how good RDR2 would've been if the fans didn't rush the devs. Mexico, Expanded Ambarino, Guarma, New Austin, more side/main missions, etc.
@@goofygooferson7834 nah the story before rdr2 would be a lot more interesting. First of all that would kinda be the peak wildwest era. Second of all we will probably find out what happened in black water. Second if we continue with Jack he’ll probably join ww1 and it’ll turn into a world war story which doesn’t represent a cowboy game. Besides all cowboys are basically dead at jacks time. Understand that the chance of them continuing his story is like 3%
Arthurs back story would be too boring, it wouldnt be able to make a game. Jack fighting ww1 would be horrible, again, too boring its not even related to the wild west which is what the rd series is.
Plus neither of those can be called red dead REDEMPTION because arthur redeems himself in rdr2 and it wouldnt make sense to go so far back into the story as rdr2 is based off johns backstory
@@Killfleshso a man who’s mother died when he was a kid, who also watched his dad swing from a noose because he was an outlaw, and was swept into a gang at the age of 14 isn’t interesting? That’s not even mentioning the waitress he had a kid with (whom were both killed, with the boy being only 1 years old) or the fact he had a mixed relationship with his dad, remarking “it weren’t soon enough” after saying he watched him die - yet he wears his dads hat. I agree that maybe it’s an odd choice, and Arthur already got his redemption, but you can’t say it’s boring.
i hope red dead 3 shows the earlier history of the van der linde gang before it’s decline, and the final mission before epilogue could be the blackwater massacre, with the playable character being someone that died in it. Thus leading to arthur escaping up north in the epilogue, right before they get to colter.
you got red dead revolver, but it’s in like 1870s or 1880s. but for some reason, it feels like the most “western” red dead. the way the revolvers sound too sound just like a class western movie
@@Lolbitgamer308we could just keep playing as the character we control throughout the whole game, idk why Rockstar makes it seem like we need to play as someone new after the main story is over
@@nyckny2500 I mean realistically if we follow red dead's pattern we would have to play as Mac and when he dies at the end, we switch to Arthur, the issue with that is after the blackwater incident all of the gang members B lined north, it wouldnt work out if they let us just play and roam around the map bcuz that doesn't follow the red dead story anymore
Same or the “jack in the mafia” “jack in ww1” it needs to be a new set of characters or one character, prime Wild West years 1860s, new part of the country. These people have no creativity.
Just like when we played Red Dead Redemption 2 and didn't know Arthur, who was a completely new character and not like Dutch and Bill in Red Dead Redemption 1, I think in Red Dead Redemption 3, we also need an unknown charismatic and powerful character that wasn't mentioned in Red Dead Redemption 2 to carry out our mission And also, he can be like Arthur, who was an older brother to John Marston, an older brother or a father figure to Arthur.. This person can be a third partner to Dutch and Colm, whose name is unknown, or if we play as Dutch or Hosea, the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 3 can be dedicated to Arthur during the events of Red Dead Redemption 2. But in my opinion, Red Dead Redemption Redemption is enough until this point, and the next Red Dead should be Red Dead Revolver with the legendary character Red Harlow, so we can see more of his power.
No no, I want an alt universe where Micah was good and some of the other characters like maybe Hosea and Charles were bad, and Strauss was also never there so Arthur never got TB.
@@oulo5019 yeah I don't think we need that right now a red dead during the prohibition days would be genius considering we could probably meet AL FREAKING CAPONE
@@FinW.idk it’s the type of game where you play it for 10-12 hours and get bored of it, if paradox truly focused on the game it can be a hit, but the game is kinda limited
@EdouardPicard0224 How would the map work though? We've already seen New Austin and West Elizabeth twice, I can't imagine they'd put those in again. And after the Blackwater heist it seems like they made a beeline to the mountains, so I'm not sure how that would work with Arthur exploring after the main storyline.
@@Hellish_666 it won’t be his redemption. If it follows the red dead story like it normally would everything would still end the same. Difference is we’d be playing from Dutch’s prospective until the blackwater massacre then I’d say that’s when it should end and then you play rdr2 and then rdr1
No we already have so much backstory already given to us in rdr1 and rdr 2 i think rockstar games making rdr 3 with young dutch forming the van der linde gang would be exhausting i mean im not saying its a bad idea but all good things need to come to an end and i personally think this would give rockstar an opportunity to create a new story for the rdr universe
@@ggflexx1437rdr3 starting a new story doesn't seem right, just like rdr1, rdr2 also gave us too much backstory which cant be abandoned, especially blackwater massacre. They have been whining about that ferry job for two games, and yet we are still not aware what really happened in that robbery.., Rdr3 being the final prequel to whole van der linde gang's story would be perfect end to a story. If they want to make more western games they are just gonna start another franchise by leaving this one as history.(just like they did with red dead revolver to start red dead redemption)
@@himanshukaushal3885 and then after rdr 3 poeple are gonna want a backstory on how dutch started the van der linde gang as a story for rdr 4 then after that poeple are gonna want a backstory on uncle in his younger days (red harlow) as a story for rdr 5 then after that poeple are gonna want a backstory on young arthur before he joined the van der linde gang as a story for rdr 6 see where im going with this
@@himanshukaushal3885 i wouldnt agree that rdr is only specifically made for the van der linde gangs story keep in mind that the words in the titles symbolizes john and arthurs fate Red- Symbolizes blood Dead- Symbolizes death Redemption- Symbolizes someone who has comes to terms with their situation and has made peace with their past self just like john did when he made the ultimate sacrifice to save abigail and jack in rdr 1 the same thing goes with arthur when he sacrifices himself to save john (depending on what you choose) So although the last 2 rdr games correlates with the van der linde gang i think it would just be exhausting and a waste of opportunity to make another rdr game about the van der linde gang and not to mention that we already see almost all gang members present in the game except for jenny and the things the gang did in rdr 2 is mentioned alot in rdr 1 by john and we even see alot of these mentions in rdr 2 so i think rockstar games should make a new story for rdr 3 with a character who has alot of moral dilemmas just like john and arthur and who is also trying run away from their problems and their past but ultimately ends up paying the price of redemption by getting killed and afterwards we play as a new character just like in rdr 1 and 2
@@ggflexx1437 welp obviously if there is next RDR it's gonna have much bigger story and gameplay. So beginning of van der linde gang can be easily included in the game. Talking about uncle, people just like to think he red Harlow, no one's interested in his backstory, folks just wanna know his real identity. I don't think R* would focus on same gang for two generations of games just to introduce a new one in third. You and me don't know what they cooking and we never will, untill R* make announcement themselves. It's just my guess, If they had introduced new story and gang in RDR2 it would have made sense but It just seems out of rhythm to introduce new story in a 3rd installment.
@@TheSundanceKidWatsonIn rdr2 you can find New York City and San Francisco cigarette cards, if it was in the gta universe it would be Liberty City and San Fierro
I'd love to see red dead become a series like GTA. Lots of games, nothing but quality, every iteration holds up as much as the last-or at least almost as much.
Red dead 3 needs to go back in time not further cause then it would be a whole different game so either this, young dutch building the gang or a whole different story during the height of the old west
@@agentsjk9632 yeah. But I wanted some mission like in The good, the bad and the ugly, where Hosea and his fellas are just trying to pass by some city and are caught in the middle of a conflict they just don't care about. And it would be fun to play some """spy""" missions like John does in the firts Red Dead, at Mexico
@@jessepinkman8847So the peaky blinders is just a joke? Ofc they did, gangs were at their finest in the 1900s, especially during the liquor prohibition!
If this were to work we’d have to play as one of the Callendar boys,(or both), since RDR protagonists all have to die in the end. The game could end with the blackwater massacre
@@legion4te epilogue would probably be arthur inbetween the couple days of the black water massacre and the events of rdr2, camp could be somewhere in the grizzlies but not far up as colter
@@SaariumDetaI was thinking Arthur but it's like new Vegas where are you are forced to not complete the game to be able to free roam endgame, the final mission could be like that and force you to make a hard save before you start it because the final mission just go straight to the credits
@@SaariumDeta before you end the game you get to free roam is Arthur and your camp remains but you get a frantic feeling because everyone is packing up and talking about what just happened, then, finally in the final mission your camp gets attacked while you try to escape
Jack being a mobster in the 1930s would actually be a good Red Dead Redemption 3. Like they could have a story where he tried to avoid gang life but just like his father he's going to fall into it
Yo tengo una idea que pocos comentan, Mac Callander es la mejor opción, se ve que la mayoría de la banda lo quería y aparte no tiene ninguna apariencia ni tenemos idea de cómo era lo que da más libertad y por lo que dice Hosea en un diálogo de la banda Mac tuvo una especie de Redención pues dice que antes era salvaje y despiadado pero que en sus últimos días fue mucho más tranquilo y sereno
Nah, I want another prequel. Free roam as Arthur, meet Davey and Mac Callander, Jenny Kirk, find out what happened in Blackwater. A Red Dead Redemption in a more future world would be disappointing considering how the first two are based on the Van Der Linde gang.
That would take place in the 1870s if you remember Dutch and Hosea mentioned fighting for the Yankees during the American Civil war. Also their story would run concurrently with Red Harlow and Landon Ricketts . They could start with those two storylines. They could split the stories up and you could play the start of the Van Der Linde gang and Red Harlow or Landon Ricketts stories .
Im prettry sure rdr3 will take place before rdr2 because we could experience how we robbed black water and the burned village near valentine and get to see or play as dead gang members like mack callander and davey
I just remembered Arthur mentioned that John left the gang for a whole year and came back later they might show us what happened when he did that but I kinda hope it explores Arthur’s backstory more
Sadly the actor who played Arthur has confirmed Arthur’s story is done and has been told and rockstar won’t be doing anymore Arthur Morgan stuff in rdr3 sadly.
@@brentbuntin6019I doubt that was ever stated, and if so send me the link and proof, because Roger Clark and Rockstar are on good terms and Red dead isnt red dead without the Van Der Linde gang, so i cant see the next game not being about them
You could put Jack in WWI and have an introduction in France, fighting in the trenches and then move to a setting between urban and the wild west, and try to mix mafia with outlaws (which are more or less the same).
If there is a 3rd RDR (in my opinion) it should be about Sadie and her bounty hunter years in South America, or maybe a Mafia/Modern era, like mid 1950s.
Loooooook If anyone thinks a red dead game in 1920 is a good idea they are literally brain dead. Red dead is known as a old west game. And defacing it will piss everyone off.
@@zenito97I don’t know that that would be a terrible idea for a spin-off game though. Jack getting drafted and sent to Europe. Very different to rdr but I feel like a lot can be tweaked and translated to fit a wildly different environment.
Wdym it has been in the talks for a bit, it can still be based in somewhere before urbanisation starts happening around America so we can have a Wild West and city setting
RDR3 should be Jack going to Chicago/New York to get rid of the mafia, indirectly becoming a cop and creating another family, he gets old and sees a grandson named Max Payne. 👀🔥🍿
It would make sense, if you consider max would be born in 1965 (considering he’s 47 by the time of max Payne 3 set in 2012) then Jack would be able to live long enough to meet Max, that would mean Jack was only 70 (easily old enough to act out the Irishman)
@@BeachbaIICS Jack would be the last cowboy, and the only one in the city 🔥👏 part 4 should be the gabg origins tho maybe in California around the gold rush
I wanna play as the Calander boys and be able to switch between them like GTA and show a redemption arc just like Arthur Morgan but the gang wasn’t able to realize they changed true sadness,
No we have Grand Theft Auto…A single driveable car in the red Dead Series and they’ll have a whole nother problem on their hands as devlopers car mechanics etc so stick to old format
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5gjVpYQ9DWQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](/img/tr.png)
![ЧТО БУДЕТ ЕСЛИ ПРОЙТИ ЗАПРЕЩЕННЫЕ МИССИИ - RDR 2 [Выпуск #17]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SpaYlinagMo/mqdefault.jpg)
![GTA и RDR - Одна вселенная? [Теория]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KddNOpZbwWg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Evolution of Red Dead Redemption [2004-2023]](/img/n.gif)
We need a Dutch in his prime, raising young Arthur and forming the gang
Yessss
No. We need Dutch and Colm, from their understanding, to rivalry. Where you can play as both
@@earnem4175 Nah
@@muhammadeyssa23648 Yss
@@earnem4175 Nah
I will cry if it becomes a mafia game. I want cowboys 😭
??? Savez-vous ce qu'est le RDR ?
Rdr é literalmente um jogo de máfia 🤷
@@Suyzitos esse cara n deve saber o que é rdr haha
@@taldogabriel__7060 rsrs
@@Suyzitosthe famous far west mafia, of course
Imagine rdr goes thru time periods and eventually get to GTA 😂
I guess modern times lost all redemption or something💀💀
the rdr universe is linked with gta
That's a terrible fucking idea, the rdr series is about the death of the wild West not fucking la noire
Yooo, the Gulf War chapter of Red Dead Redemption 57 was fire! 🔥 🔥
@@ahmedalbreiki5336no in gta New York is “Liberty City and Liberty State”
In Red Dead it’s New York.
Red dead redemption should ALWAYS stay in the Wild West.
I mean, RDR2 didn't and it was a beautiful game
@@I_want_White_Cheddar_Popcorn uuuuuhhhh tf you talking about???
@@I_want_White_Cheddar_Popcorn I’m sorry forgive me I misspoke. I meant cowboy/outlaw time period.
Having a Red Dead game not during the Wild West times is like having a COD game taking place in the 9th century
imagine call of duty with muskets and sabres
Imagine COD but all weapons are single shot and take half a minute to reload lmao
That would be dope to be honest though. Make it actually challenging
Cod should make a spartan game
Los dos red desd redemption estan inspirados en la caída del salvaje oeste con la llegada de la civilización asi que tiene mucho mas por explotar
Coming to you in 2055
Oml fr tho
That soon?! We've been waiting on gta6 since 1932
By then I’ll reach level 1000 in red 2 I’m only 400 rn 💀
@@Dayvakiini thought u can only be up to lvl 100
We are waiting on gta6 the whole ottoman empire from 1299 and we are still waiting
Red Dead will forever be a western.
Let’s be realistic it will be atleast 15 years before we see a red dead 3
No way
maybe not that long but honestly 8-10 years isint unrealistic
@@idkbro1696 if gta 6 comes out next year that’s about 12 years between gta games… it’s all because they’ve made a killing with the micro transactions on gta online. It’s not gonna get any better.
@@idkbro1696 8 years between the last 2
@@chuckwheeler6298it took 5 years from gta5 to rdr2. So saying 14 years after gta 6 is stupid
imagine deadeye evolved throughout many anscestors which then leads to Micheal from gta V
great theory
Darkviparau has made this joke a couple times, I guess it could explain why micheal has it. Seems like something rockstar would do
From Arthur Morgan, to John Marston, to Max Payne, to Michael DeSanta. Quite the cast.
Puede ser canónico RDR2 son de la misma empresa de GTA5
@@pablo_giustinianiI thinh its Jack Swift Red Harlow and then arrhur
I'm 99.9% sure everyone wants the game to start with Dutch and Hosea raising Arthur, meeting John, then building the Gang up through Crime, deals, etc. Then, the game finishes with the Blackwater Mission.
Yeah and have those old wild west towns and guns everywhere. Very cool if you ask me
At this point Rockstar should just ignore the fans lmao
Imagine how good RDR2 would've been if the fans didn't rush the devs.
Mexico, Expanded Ambarino, Guarma, New Austin, more side/main missions, etc.
that is literally impossible because after the final mission what would you be playing
@@gameplaysmiados4129 I don't know, but it would be a decent idea.
@@gameplaysmiados4129well maybe make it the ending of epilogue and then regular roam after finishing
They need to do a sequel for Red Harlow the true OG
Mafia game series gonna have mad competition 😊
If this was actually real then maybe,
But even if it was real I think rockstar would have a hard time topping the mafia series 😅
@@friendly_sniperbruh ☠️
Imagine a younger Arthur as Dutch builds the gang to its peak in his 20s
Just announced there gonna make a remake of the first rdr
Nah they need Jacks story to be finished and then no more red dead after that
@@goofygooferson7834 what are they going to do send him off to WW1? That’s about all I can think about that would happen for him.
@@Runner-fz5qg Jack would be a draft dodger mate. Why would he serve the same government that killed his family
@@goofygooferson7834 nah the story before rdr2 would be a lot more interesting. First of all that would kinda be the peak wildwest era. Second of all we will probably find out what happened in black water. Second if we continue with Jack he’ll probably join ww1 and it’ll turn into a world war story which doesn’t represent a cowboy game. Besides all cowboys are basically dead at jacks time. Understand that the chance of them continuing his story is like 3%
I’m going to be pissed if the third game comes out to be with cars and stuff, it’s not the same without the cowboy stuff.
agree
Cars and stuff that's gta fren
#metoo
It's an ai concept I think supposed to be Hosea
Who said that RDR is a series about cowboys?
Ain’t no way you’re just gonna steal the Empire of sin background and no one’s gonna say something
The dud in the middle looks like Oppenheimer
It's from a game called Empire of Sin
It's gonna go from a cowboy game to a peaky blinders game lmao
🔥
@@krainellshit you mean
That’s the cover art for a completely different game
It would suck
well, the first game ends in 1914... that just 10-15 years apart of the MAFIA Golden Era
It'd either be Arthur's backstory or Jack fighting in WWI
Only Arthur’s backstory jack in ww1 would destroy the Wild West feeling
Arthurs back story would be too boring, it wouldnt be able to make a game. Jack fighting ww1 would be horrible, again, too boring its not even related to the wild west which is what the rd series is.
Plus neither of those can be called red dead REDEMPTION because arthur redeems himself in rdr2 and it wouldnt make sense to go so far back into the story as rdr2 is based off johns backstory
@@Killfleshwhat about it would be boring?
@@Killfleshso a man who’s mother died when he was a kid, who also watched his dad swing from a noose because he was an outlaw, and was swept into a gang at the age of 14 isn’t interesting? That’s not even mentioning the waitress he had a kid with (whom were both killed, with the boy being only 1 years old) or the fact he had a mixed relationship with his dad, remarking “it weren’t soon enough” after saying he watched him die - yet he wears his dads hat.
I agree that maybe it’s an odd choice, and Arthur already got his redemption, but you can’t say it’s boring.
For those who don't know, this is a mafia game
i hope red dead 3 shows the earlier history of the van der linde gang before it’s decline, and the final mission before epilogue could be the blackwater massacre, with the playable character being someone that died in it. Thus leading to arthur escaping up north in the epilogue, right before they get to colter.
It would lose all suspense if it did that. That wouldn’t be fun at all.
All I would really want is a TRUE Wild West game in the 1860s or 50s
you got red dead revolver, but it’s in like 1870s or 1880s. but for some reason, it feels like the most “western” red dead. the way the revolvers sound too sound just like a class western movie
Yeah, maybe including the civil war
Landon rickets or red Harlow.
@@TommyA66I don’t really count red dead revolver as one, because of how long ago it was made, though a red dead revolver remake would be dope
@@TommyA66”you got red dead revolver” it’s a PS2 game that can’t even compare to modern games. Completely brain dead response that lad
If rdr3 ain’t end with the black water massacre I’d flip tbh
But you gotta play as someone at the end
@@Lolbitgamer308 That's a god damn good point, made me rethink everything
@@Lolbitgamer308we could just keep playing as the character we control throughout the whole game, idk why Rockstar makes it seem like we need to play as someone new after the main story is over
@@unavailabIe_ what if you play rdr3 as one of the gang members that died in blackwater then finish playing as Dutch
@@nyckny2500 I mean realistically if we follow red dead's pattern we would have to play as Mac and when he dies at the end, we switch to Arthur, the issue with that is after the blackwater incident all of the gang members B lined north, it wouldnt work out if they let us just play and roam around the map bcuz that doesn't follow the red dead story anymore
Istg if I see anymore “we should play as Dutch and see him make the gang” or “it should end with the black water massacre” I’m gonna go crazy
Same or the “jack in the mafia” “jack in ww1” it needs to be a new set of characters or one character, prime Wild West years 1860s, new part of the country. These people have no creativity.
John: well junior its your turn to play
We don't need rdr3, we need Arthur without tuberculosis and the old gang without miach
Miach!!! 😂
replay it and don’t let Arthur contact Thomas, he will live healthy and happily.
@@amazingdanyMiach your a Rat!
Just like when we played Red Dead Redemption 2 and didn't know Arthur, who was a completely new character and not like Dutch and Bill in Red Dead Redemption 1, I think in Red Dead Redemption 3, we also need an unknown charismatic and powerful character that wasn't mentioned in Red Dead Redemption 2 to carry out our mission And also, he can be like Arthur, who was an older brother to John Marston, an older brother or a father figure to Arthur.. This person can be a third partner to Dutch and Colm, whose name is unknown, or if we play as Dutch or Hosea, the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 3 can be dedicated to Arthur during the events of Red Dead Redemption 2.
But in my opinion, Red Dead Redemption Redemption is enough until this point, and the next Red Dead should be Red Dead Revolver with the legendary character Red Harlow, so we can see more of his power.
No no, I want an alt universe where Micah was good and some of the other characters like maybe Hosea and Charles were bad, and Strauss was also never there so Arthur never got TB.
A mafia red dead redemption would be the worst thing that could happen
I want cowboahs 😡
Yeah! Rdr is about the death of the wild west, about how the law tamed the west, not Mafias.
I would love to play as Jack around WW1
Rdr3 with the ending being the blackwater massacre
That or the black water massacre becomes a DLC
They won't because then people will want to see before the black water heist and so on. They're deff not making a RDR3 for at least 10 years
@@nooneyouknow9376years already passed for rdr2 , maybe in 2028 with the launch of ps6
Need another prequel playing as Dutch in his prime
No
@@oulo5019 yeah I don't think we need that right now a red dead during the prohibition days would be genius considering we could probably meet AL FREAKING CAPONE
No
Hosea though tbh
@@TH-camboi12 that's "Red Dead Retribution"
People really don't know that this is the cover of the Mafia Empire game😂
Empire Of Sin 2020
@@Brad0stW game, hated on way too much
@@FinW.idk it’s the type of game where you play it for 10-12 hours and get bored of it, if paradox truly focused on the game it can be a hit, but the game is kinda limited
@@homersimpson6585 yeah it gets very old quick but if you have that mafia itch, it can scratch it to a degree
But my horses... My beautiful horses... MY FUCKING HORSES
We getting RDR 3 before GTA 6 😭
We need young Arthur after his father dies and then meeting Hosea and Dutch
I like this but play as arthur dad, he dies and the epilouge is you playing young arthur and being raised by dutch and hosea
no redemption?
@@Dext3r0usred harlows dead redemption
@@C.Ocowboynow thats a good idea
Charles Smith would be an awesome protagonist imo 😎🚬
We play as Mac Callander, before the events of Blackwater, and in the last mission he sacrifices himself for the gang to flee Blackwater.
Yeah i reed about that teory, it would be a great history
@@Ghost-gr4qj read* theory*
Pretty much, and in the epilogue you're gonna play as Arthur before he reaches the others in colter. The RDR formula.
@EdouardPicard0224 How would the map work though? We've already seen New Austin and West Elizabeth twice, I can't imagine they'd put those in again. And after the Blackwater heist it seems like they made a beeline to the mountains, so I'm not sure how that would work with Arthur exploring after the main storyline.
You would know how he dies and his death wouldnt be eventful, terrible idea
Red dead lll should just be on how uncle got lumbago.
Nawr bro just slapped rdr3 on empire of sin cover
Rdr3 is so far better than gta 6
rdr2 will be better than GTA 6 like gta 5 isnt even close
Found the time traveller
Idk I want to see another prequel they 100% to stick to the wild west theme
Yessssssss just YEEEESSSSS
Or they maybe could go for another story instead
@@12swz37 red Harlow can return
Yeah, i too prefer 100% a prequel with the wild west era at its peak in the 1860s or 50s
@@marquitust2874small IT was kinda upsetting how dead the west is on this game
rdr3 should take place during the civil war, imagine how sick it would be to have a mission similar to the scene in the good, the bad, and the ugly
Bro that’s the cover for Empire of sin 😂
Imagine playing as young Dutch and you gotta go recruit the gang and survive
Sounds like one piece lore
RDR is about Redemption, Dutch will never be the protagonist
@@Hellish_666 it won’t be his redemption. If it follows the red dead story like it normally would everything would still end the same. Difference is we’d be playing from Dutch’s prospective until the blackwater massacre then I’d say that’s when it should end and then you play rdr2 and then rdr1
*Friends, I did one arm muscle ups* *Please support*
I'd honestly love to play as Hosea, too
We need black water and the young gang… young Hosea, young Dutch and my little boi Arthur
No we already have so much backstory already given to us in rdr1 and rdr 2 i think rockstar games making rdr 3 with young dutch forming the van der linde gang would be exhausting i mean im not saying its a bad idea but all good things need to come to an end and i personally think this would give rockstar an opportunity to create a new story for the rdr universe
@@ggflexx1437rdr3 starting a new story doesn't seem right, just like rdr1, rdr2 also gave us too much backstory which cant be abandoned, especially blackwater massacre. They have been whining about that ferry job for two games, and yet we are still not aware what really happened in that robbery..,
Rdr3 being the final prequel to whole van der linde gang's story would be perfect end to a story.
If they want to make more western games they are just gonna start another franchise by leaving this one as history.(just like they did with red dead revolver to start red dead redemption)
@@himanshukaushal3885 and then after rdr 3 poeple are gonna want a backstory on how dutch started the van der linde gang as a story for rdr 4 then after that poeple are gonna want a backstory on uncle in his younger days (red harlow) as a story for rdr 5 then after that poeple are gonna want a backstory on young arthur before he joined the van der linde gang as a story for rdr 6 see where im going with this
@@himanshukaushal3885 i wouldnt agree that rdr is only specifically made for the van der linde gangs story keep in mind that the words in the titles symbolizes john and arthurs fate
Red-
Symbolizes blood
Dead-
Symbolizes death
Redemption-
Symbolizes someone who has comes to terms with their situation and has made peace with their past self just like john did when he made the ultimate sacrifice to save abigail and jack in rdr 1 the same thing goes with arthur when he sacrifices himself to save john (depending on what you choose)
So although the last 2 rdr games correlates with the van der linde gang i think it would just be exhausting and a waste of opportunity to make another rdr game about the van der linde gang and not to mention that we already see almost all gang members present in the game except for jenny and the things the gang did in rdr 2 is mentioned alot in rdr 1 by john and we even see alot of these mentions in rdr 2 so i think rockstar games should make a new story for rdr 3 with a character who has alot of moral dilemmas just like john and arthur and who is also trying run away from their problems and their past but ultimately ends up paying the price of redemption by getting killed and afterwards we play as a new character just like in rdr 1 and 2
@@ggflexx1437 welp obviously if there is next RDR it's gonna have much bigger story and gameplay. So beginning of van der linde gang can be easily included in the game.
Talking about uncle, people just like to think he red Harlow, no one's interested in his backstory, folks just wanna know his real identity.
I don't think R* would focus on same gang for two generations of games just to introduce a new one in third.
You and me don't know what they cooking and we never will, untill R* make announcement themselves.
It's just my guess,
If they had introduced new story and gang in RDR2 it would have made sense but It just seems out of rhythm to introduce new story in a 3rd installment.
😢I want Red Harlow to be the protagonist of the 3rd, he only participated in the first one and after that he never came back
we've had mexico and america, now we need canada
Jack probably wouldn’t go into ww1 since he has beef with the military for killing his dad and would probably try to escape recruitment
Jack ended up moving to México and fight along with the Mexican Revolution..
Jack went to London and became and author. You can find his book in gta5, it's an Easter egg
@@williamweiland3195its also not canon to the story line, its just that, an Easter egg.
@@veil9326 But what if
@@CrimsonDarkclawbut what if nothing. If it ain’t canon, it’s nothing, gta and rdr aren’t in the same ‘universe’
I just need Jack's journeys to New York
Damn same to me
Liberty City you mean?
@@TheSundanceKidWatsondifferent universes
@@TheSundanceKidWatsonIn rdr2 you can find New York City and San Francisco cigarette cards, if it was in the gta universe it would be Liberty City and San Fierro
But franklin has a book called red dead written by J marston aka Jack, so technically they would be in the same universe?
RDR3 would be a metaverse, you are able to run your own shop and make profit in it.
10/10 would buy
Red dead 3 should be set further in the past
It would be about Gang’s years in Blackwater I think
I agree
How we need something new
It should be that, then we can get the blatant rip off of mafia definitive edition
@@BeachbaIICS it would be just a mafia rip off
They were in blackwater for as long as any chapter of the second game tho...
I'd love to see red dead become a series like GTA. Lots of games, nothing but quality, every iteration holds up as much as the last-or at least almost as much.
Both series takes 20 years for new game
@@aguuug5139it wasnt always like that for gta tbf
We need rdr3 to be dutch forming the gang at the start and then the end its like the black water massacre
Hear me out gold rush cowboy gang in the 1840-1850s making a living
RDR needs to have young Hosea as main character, during the Civil War
Not in the civil war but rather in the creation of the gang and his relationship with Bessie
@@mxlh_3134 sure. But I guess the civil war as a background would be cool. Basically not a game ABOUT the civil war. But a game WITHIN the civil war
Red dead 3 needs to go back in time not further cause then it would be a whole different game so either this, young dutch building the gang or a whole different story during the height of the old west
Or just after the civil war, when restless soldiers became outlaws.
@@agentsjk9632 yeah. But I wanted some mission like in The good, the bad and the ugly, where Hosea and his fellas are just trying to pass by some city and are caught in the middle of a conflict they just don't care about. And it would be fun to play some """spy""" missions like John does in the firts Red Dead, at Mexico
Imagine jack trys to recreate his own vander linde gang🤯
Marston gang
It would be world war
Think jack in the army would work better. Gangs didn’t exactly work well in the 1900’s.
@@jessepinkman8847 That would be cool to
@@jessepinkman8847So the peaky blinders is just a joke? Ofc they did, gangs were at their finest in the 1900s, especially during the liquor prohibition!
rdr3:young dutch,young hosea, and young artur
I don't care as long as I get to see Mexico again
If this were to work we’d have to play as one of the Callendar boys,(or both), since RDR protagonists all have to die in the end. The game could end with the blackwater massacre
Yeah, that would be a good idea, but then what would the epilogue be? We need a gap between games for an epilogue
@@legion4te epilogue would probably be arthur inbetween the couple days of the black water massacre and the events of rdr2, camp could be somewhere in the grizzlies but not far up as colter
@@SaariumDeta that sounds lame
@@SaariumDetaI was thinking Arthur but it's like new Vegas where are you are forced to not complete the game to be able to free roam endgame, the final mission could be like that and force you to make a hard save before you start it because the final mission just go straight to the credits
@@SaariumDeta before you end the game you get to free roam is Arthur and your camp remains but you get a frantic feeling because everyone is packing up and talking about what just happened, then, finally in the final mission your camp gets attacked while you try to escape
Un rdr dove sei un nativo americano e combatti con la tua tribù contro il governo e i fuori legge degli Stati Uniti
Peaky blinders 😂
I'm just saying that there are about 20 years of Arthur, Dutch, and Hosea that we haven't seen
Jack Marston in WW1 😎
We need more information about Lumbago 😂😂
i feel like we should know exactly what it is with how much uncle talks about it😭
It's lower back pain
Jack being a mobster in the 1930s would actually be a good Red Dead Redemption 3. Like they could have a story where he tried to avoid gang life but just like his father he's going to fall into it
Cant wait for them to expand to more towns and more options to the game
We need a young Dutch, Arthur, and John, while Hosea is like in His late 30s early 40s
It can be from start of van der Linda gang and end to black water robbery
But we can’t have RED DEAD REDEMPTION without any redemption
Yo tengo una idea que pocos comentan, Mac Callander es la mejor opción, se ve que la mayoría de la banda lo quería y aparte no tiene ninguna apariencia ni tenemos idea de cómo era lo que da más libertad y por lo que dice Hosea en un diálogo de la banda Mac tuvo una especie de Redención pues dice que antes era salvaje y despiadado pero que en sus últimos días fue mucho más tranquilo y sereno
Jack in ww1 would go crazy
Rdr3 being about the rise of mobsters in the early 1900s would go hard ngl
Nah, I want another prequel. Free roam as Arthur, meet Davey and Mac Callander, Jenny Kirk, find out what happened in Blackwater. A Red Dead Redemption in a more future world would be disappointing considering how the first two are based on the Van Der Linde gang.
That would take place in the 1870s if you remember Dutch and Hosea mentioned fighting for the Yankees during the American Civil war. Also their story would run concurrently with Red Harlow and Landon Ricketts . They could start with those two storylines. They could split the stories up and you could play the start of the Van Der Linde gang and Red Harlow or Landon Ricketts stories .
The civil war took place in the 1860s and Dutch werent even 18 during that, it would make sense if it was hosea who went through the war.
Main game is the gang and have Landon and Harlow as dlc
Im prettry sure rdr3 will take place before rdr2 because we could experience how we robbed black water and the burned village near valentine and get to see or play as dead gang members like mack callander and davey
I honestly would like to either see jack go to chicago and join a gang mafia or him fight in ww1
We either need dutch and hosea forming the game, or a continuation of jacks arc
the first one doesn't have redemption and jack's arc is when the west is tamed
@@Dext3r0us 🤓☝️
imagine a game about Charles in Canada or Sadie in South America.
Sadie
@@alienationark yeah sadie you know sadie the girl rescued in chap1 that's sadie meet sadie
Rockstar games after like 7.6 hours after i die :
We need a trio of Dutch, Arthur, John and the gang's prime
I just remembered Arthur mentioned that John left the gang for a whole year and came back later they might show us what happened when he did that but I kinda hope it explores Arthur’s backstory more
Sadly the actor who played Arthur has confirmed Arthur’s story is done and has been told and rockstar won’t be doing anymore Arthur Morgan stuff in rdr3 sadly.
@@brentbuntin6019I doubt that was ever stated, and if so send me the link and proof, because Roger Clark and Rockstar are on good terms and Red dead isnt red dead without the Van Der Linde gang, so i cant see the next game not being about them
What we need is dutch raising morgan and john like brothers in a way to respect the first and second game. This or tie in red dead revolver somehow
RDR3 will be the back story of Van Der Linde gang
Imagine RDR3 takes place in a parallel universe where Arthur lives 🤯
The life of Saidie Adler as a BH
Rdr3 taking place in a mafia-like environment would be awesome, I’d be killing with the Chicago typewriter
it would be nice but I doubt rockstar would make a western into a mafia games besides they already have LA Noire.
@@freddyfuller-em6ddLA Noire was not a mafia game lol.
I want RDR3 to be about Pearson and the cut-throat way he carved his way into creating the first supermarket chains of the 20th century.
You could put Jack in WWI and have an introduction in France, fighting in the trenches and then move to a setting between urban and the wild west, and try to mix mafia with outlaws (which are more or less the same).
A prequel with Hosea as a protagonist would be awesome
Rdr3 Arthur’s father as the main character, with the epilogue being a young Arthur joining Hosea and Dutch
If there is a 3rd RDR (in my opinion) it should be about Sadie and her bounty hunter years in South America, or maybe a Mafia/Modern era, like mid 1950s.
We got gta for modern era
And we got L.A. Noire to work as a franchise for environments set in 40s-50s
Loooooook If anyone thinks a red dead game in 1920 is a good idea they are literally brain dead. Red dead is known as a old west game. And defacing it will piss everyone off.
It will be difficult to imagine that in 1920 they live during the First World War
@@zenito97I don’t know that that would be a terrible idea for a spin-off game though. Jack getting drafted and sent to Europe. Very different to rdr but I feel like a lot can be tweaked and translated to fit a wildly different environment.
Wdym it has been in the talks for a bit, it can still be based in somewhere before urbanisation starts happening around America so we can have a Wild West and city setting
Fr if it goes anymore into the future it just becomes gta
@@gandalftheserb exaccctttllllyyyyy
You sir, are a fish 🐠💯
Yo, hear me out: The young Landon Ricketts.
Rdr3 jack during father hood
So it would take place in the 1920’s
At that point it would be like a Mafia game
@@darkshadowgamingiiThe Mafia games are set in the 30's,and 60's if i remember correctly.
Terrible idea lol
@@skxlter5747 man get a life
When 2k Czech And R* Vancouver Teams-up: Madness bro👍👽🖒
This not RDR3, this Empire of Sin
Nah men, that's what L.N. Noir covered
RDR3 should be Jack going to Chicago/New York to get rid of the mafia, indirectly becoming a cop and creating another family, he gets old and sees a grandson named Max Payne. 👀🔥🍿
It would make sense, if you consider max would be born in 1965 (considering he’s 47 by the time of max Payne 3 set in 2012) then Jack would be able to live long enough to meet Max, that would mean Jack was only 70 (easily old enough to act out the Irishman)
Fuck no, I want a cowboy game
@@BeachbaIICS Jack would be the last cowboy, and the only one in the city 🔥👏 part 4 should be the gabg origins tho maybe in California around the gold rush
@@BeachbaIICSthen go play rd2 or rd1
@@Justsomerandomdude397 I did and what I saw was society turning to modernization while the last outlaws fight for survival.
I want a full cowboy game
I wanna play as the Calander boys and be able to switch between them like GTA and show a redemption arc just like Arthur Morgan but the gang wasn’t able to realize they changed true sadness,
Caliber brother’s multi protagonist game that has Arthur in epilogue would be way sicker
RDR 3 would be a Red Harlow prequel.
chronologically it's mafia time
It's not a red dead game if it ain't about cowboys and gunslingers
That's my honest opinion 😕
yes bro
@@xkw9988 yes bro is mafia and not cowboys
No we have Grand Theft Auto…A single driveable car in the red Dead Series and they’ll have a whole nother problem on their hands as devlopers car mechanics etc so stick to old format
Imagine rdr3 will be a prequel to Rdr2 and you get to play as Dutch and form the gang