Almost had an aneurysm when I heard that. So we can just do whatever we feel regardless of right/wrong or even legality? I'm sure that man has lots of interesting feelings regarding her, but the law doesn't allow him to act on them.
@@aixpert291Exactly. Not only do they jail but suspend DL, passports etc. She needs to pay that money back. The man needs to have it garnished from her paychecks.
@@aixpert291If she did this to an employer or a bank, there would have been definite legal consequences for theft if she didn't return money that isn't hers. This is theft.
The fact that the man had to even hire an attorney shows the judicial system is broken, the state should’ve represented the man for free just like they represent the woman for free when she filed for child support
I overpaid by 3,000+ and was told that the state I live in is a "windfall state" and that any overpayment is water under the bridge. It's gone and I will never get it back.
Yea but I wouldn't hold it against him. A lot of fathers just give up and never correct these things at least the judge wanted to do more research for the correct interest rates the OAG applies in these cases.
This man likely had his wages garnished and sent directly to the state. Absent a termination order, the garnishment will continue unabated until the order has been adjudicated. Unfortunately, this means that he has a credit to his account and the recipient is unable or unwilling to compensate. Men need to watch when nearing the end of support obligations and be proactive with their attorneys in a timely filing of a termination order request to prevent overpayment. The state won’t repay an overpayment, and in some cases like Pennsylvania, consider it as a gift. Good luck trying to recoup that money. The pandemic caused a lot of problems in these cases as hearings were postponed while wages were still garnished.
@@brucesmith9144 well at the end is not loss money if that goes to your son or daughter...but does really go to your son or daughter? in this case didnt, since the kid was emancipated
@@jalamela1480that would and should have been adjudicated during the initial order. Women always say that when they go to child support court that's why the judge makes the determination. Stop being naive.
I think the judge was trying to help her out and she didn’t realize it! She could have said all the financial burden of the funeral falls on me and she wouldn’t have had to pay for anything.
this case is infuriating. not only did the judge & the AG offer the women multiple opportunities(bordering on coercion) to claim she was destitute so she could get out of returning the overpayment. It's a perfect example of how men are treated unequally. If the man owed back child support do you think the AG's office would pander to him. no, he'd go to jail. WAKE up men! the child support system needs to be revamped to treat everyone equally regardless of gender
No it wont happen, because most women dont make any money, they dont make enough money to cover child support, thats why children are automatically awarded to the mother.
@@mandawood9756I totally agree with you on that. I don't know how they get away with being so obviously biased. I can't ever finish watching them because I get so mad on behalf of those men as those judges let those women sit there and blatantly lie. They even get caught in their lie and still get away with it! It's crazy!
Don't know Webster but Aguilar....... man lord knows I can't stand how he imposes biased judgments. Then he can't keep his personal thoughts and smiling at his judgments against males.
If the father was the who was owing her $$ he would have been ordered to reimburse her within immediate effect or asap ! The double standards wouldn't STOP......
The Attorney General doesn’t want it to be repaid because they will have to refund their fees. People need to support their kids but the State should not profit from it.
I wouldn't suggest the money shouldn't be repaid because the dad didn't start this procedure earlier but it is odd that a dad in this situation doesn't try to stop the payments as soon as the child hits 18.
My comment earlier that the system is modeled to degree a person needs a lawyer, not shocking. And how when it is so plain he overpaid are attorneys fees $5000 . Disgusting. Legal theft.
It's called child support bc it's for the child. It's not for the mom's emotional or physical needs. . Then she says she doesn't have a problem paying it back but chose not to. That's being vindictive
She shouldn't have to pay it back it's nit her fault the people at child support can't do their job properly because child support should automatically stop in most states
The state should pay dad back since that’s who sends the withholding order to hr and the state should figure out how to get the funds back from the mother ON THEIR OWN. Why they can’t garnish her accounts like they garnish the fathers🤷🏾♀️
@@paulam.foreman4413The state gets back 60% of all collections for CS from the fed. I would say the idea isn't that bad considering we are already supporting these single mothers
Yes and no. I used to think it should be monitored more but at the end of the day if child lives with mother and dad just has visitation EOWeekend then no it shouldn’t. And visa versa, some of these cases get so complicated bc adults can’t coparent or one parent is still hurt and wants to punish the other parent by controlling the children and blocking access.
Why the hell are these people trying to make excuses for her? A hardship? They dont ever care about hardship when a man homeless and unemployed and they shouldnt. So i dont know why they were trying to give her so much slack.
LADY YOUR MORALS ARE F'ED UP!! She can't be serious as to why she doesn't feel like she should pay the money back. Lady get off the damn gas, do what's right and pay the money back. The nerve of her to say it's for emotional needs. SMH!
Unbelievable that her only excuse for doing this was "emotional needs". There was a reason the father stopped seeing his kids. Most likely because of her. He did not get the benefit of the love of those kids while she did. If her kids were a burden, that's on her. She's the one who raised them. If they were troublesome it's because of her. Her problem is that she's butthurt because of it all and gladly took advantage when he kept paying for the kid after 18. You don't get to say later that he wasn't in the child's life. That choice was made by her when she put him on child support. If he had been in the child's life they would've had joint custody and been 50/50. In which case he wouldn't have paid child support. You can't have your cake and eat it too.
He should appeal that ruling. It's ridiculous that she only has to repay 6000. What about attorney fees? He racked up over five thousand in attorney fees, so he is left with a couple hundred after it's all said and done?
So it's our fault she slept with a man who is a bad father according to her ??? It's her fault she had a kid with this guy, not ours, so pay the money back. That AG, like most, is corrupt
Child Support/Family Court reform is definitely needed at this point! For a mother/woman to say I am not going to pay back the money that was sent after the child 18th bday is crazy! No jail/prison time, no garnishment of wage, or lend on any property that she possesses is in insane! Because if this is a man/father/non custodial parent, all the things I mentioned he would force to do or pay!
It just shows how convoluted the justice system has become! Simple cases get so bogged up with legal jumbo that one is almost forced to hire a lawyer because judges don’t like dealing with regular people maneuvering through the system!
@@cmd1007Judges were lawyers. They fraternize and run in the same circle as those lawyers. Heck, some maybe even went to the same law schools. It's all about the MONEY.
Why didn’t he file to have the support stopped years ago? Dang if I had money taken out when child care was over I’d be getting in front of a judge asap
Same thing happened to the comedian 'Earthquake' he overpaid child support by 10's of thousands of dollars. He took her to court & the judge put it on the backend so that he'd be finish paying support 6 months early. Plus his son was already living with him the last few years. She tried to appeal claiming that she coildn't maintain her household without that income.
If the state was garnishing his checks. They are responsible for the repayment. They knew the record showed the child turned 18. The garnishments should've stopped upon the child turning 18 automatically. Then the state should go after her for accepting and using money illegally. Any hardship she has because of families medical issues is not his problem. He was only responsabile for the child alone. Not for paying family bills or funerals
This was a sad case, but the correct outcome. Mr. Guy was pissed that Miss Williams put him on child support, so he distanced himself from their son, who ultimately paid the price of not having a meaningful relationship with his father. Sad for their son, but oh well for Miss Williams. Return the money, sis; you picked him.
Truth be told, she is probably one of those single mothers who wants the child all to herself and only wants the money. She probably withheld the child from his father.
@@carolesmith4864 I was thinkin' the same thing. You never know about these situations, but I wouldn't say I like it when children pay the price for parents who are trifling and stuck on stupid.
Because the kid stops needing things at 18. I know someone who received two payments after the child reached 18. That man refused to do anything extra for that child for 18 years but took her to court for the two payments. Luckily she showed where she used it to pay for housing fees and a new laptop for the child because he was going to college. She also showed where she had to take out a student loan in her name for the child’s college tuition. The judge looked that man in the face and told him he ought to be ashamed and dismissed him smh
@@guccilady1017parents should take care of their kid, without question but, the days of women getting a pass for bad behavior should be over! She knew better and still did wrong. Have the same energy for her as you do for men when they don't do right.
@@guccilady1017 you are just ignorant. Men always get the raw end of the deal, sometimes it's warranted. I vet her azz paid that $ or go straight to jail 😂😂😂
@@guccilady1017 turns out when you are a spiteful woman that leaves a man, robs him of his kids, and takes his money under threat of jail the men don’t want to do anything “extra” for these no good women. The judge ought to be ashamed, as should most of you horrible women.
Wow! The A.G. is a moron!!! Let's see, "do you have close family members with health issues?" How is that HIS problem to pay for??? "Did you help pay for funeral costs?" For her deceased Aunt. Again, how is that HIS problem to pay for??? "I have a nephew i have custody of." Last time, how is that HIS problem to pay for??? Thankfully, this Judge knows his job and follows the law.
Boy Texas must have messed up pretty bad. There are a lot of cases where dads have over paid and the greedy women want to keep it. Time to pay women and Texas you need to do better
Texas is a “mothering” state. A friend of mine spent $60,000 in attorney fees to get his child back from a woman that was prostituting herself for drugs with her child in the car/home. He had documented proof, but it wasn’t until he paid for her hair to be tested for drugs that he got any foothold.
@@Dahverin-kk4onit is Texas fault because this issue comes up and they ignore it every year …men advocate groups in Texas have been going to politicians for get laws changed and they won’t!
@T.Hang11 I don't think she understood the question. If she had it, she wouldn't be in court wasting her time. The check would have been in the mail long ago.
@@nattydreadlocks1973 really..I guess we interpret it differently..watching the video she just doesn’t want to pay because she feels like it’s her right to keep the money. We can differ in opinion
@T.Hang11 Anyone who has lived more than half a century, like myself, knows that this lady does not have the money to repay. Otherwise, she would have already done so.
They tried their damdest to let her keep that money and coach her through it her ignorance one him the day. Im disgusted with this family court trying to rob this man
I don’t know if it’s the state where I live, but my husband overpaid and he’s receiving checks from the state still to this day and his daughter is 25. It’s sad what these fathers have to go through. I know what we went through and what he did as a father and was still dealt a bad hand. Mom tried 18yrs to keep her away. She’s 25 now and we can’t get rid of her so just be mindful, kids don’t stay kids forever.
@@d3lan011 I disagree. Women do most the work to get childern here. If you want your child to have your last name, marry her so everyone has the same last name 🤷🏾♀️
@prettyangel0921 To speak about that: the mother wouldn't do that work if she didn't get the specimen to start the process. And how do you explain to your son that you gave time your last name instead of his father's, who is paying CS. There is more than one side to the story, but we only hear the woman's side.
The fact that this mother is on disability is a joke. Way too many able-bodied people get checks every month for 'disability'. The amount of government money that's wasted is outrageous.
I wouldn't care about any of those issues she was talking about... Can't get money you know you weren't supposed to get then try to justify it by saying it takes more than money to raise a child....
My ex-husband overpaid $23,000 to his ex-wife, over the course of 5 years. When the state audit found it, the state sent a letter asking if he wanted to make a “gift” of it to the mother since it would be a hardship for her to pay it back. She knew it wasn’t her money.
She should have taken it to trial and got a jury. She would have been able to show he never paid child support until age 9 on. I have seen it done so many times. He probably would have owed her more than that $13,000. She should not have let the judge intimidate her with “I can only talk about 2011 on”.. the child was around before 2011.
Why wasn’t the CS payments automatically stopped, everything is computerized today. It should be programmed in to stop the payments as soon as the child turns 18. If he wants to continue to support him, that’s on him to do so.
This is why the system should have an automatic termination date entered into the system so no payments are received after the age of 18 or the date of a projected completion of HS. Just like women have rights there need to be laws that's for men as well.
Child support normally terminates by operation of law when the child turns 18 and graduated from high school in most states. Child support agencies rely on parents to notify them of the graduation date in order to stop any withholding order. This lady has no legal right to this money. She thinks she deserves the money because she feels wronged by Dad. You can hear the anger in her voice. Revenge isn’t a valid, legal excuse.
Emotional and Physical needs is paid out in Alimony or Spousal Support. Not your adult child who can now work to support himself. She had 18 years to prepare for this SMH.
If you as a man get custody, you put Mom's azz on child support out of principle. Open up a savings account for your child and just deposit the proceeds.
It's about time these woman start paying back this money...
Agreed
Agreed
Make a video on it, the comment section does nothing
They can't because these women use child support to trick on dirty filthy bummy dudes. That's what no one's talking about
and be the ones to pay taxes. it's income.
So she "feels" that she should keep it because of emotional reasons? What a greedy woman!
Truth.
That's called stealing.
Almost had an aneurysm when I heard that. So we can just do whatever we feel regardless of right/wrong or even legality? I'm sure that man has lots of interesting feelings regarding her, but the law doesn't allow him to act on them.
Woman scorned
You hear her , her child if he yo child only then you should have no problem paying dude his money back it's your child you made it by yourself
SHE SAID IS NOT A HARDSHIP..
WHY DO THEY KEEP SAVING HER?
PAY THAT MAN!
Bet she never paid him back.
Exactly…they were trying to give her a way out. BS man
Even if it WAS a hardship. Tough shit! Pay it back or jail, like they would have done if he owed.
@@aixpert291Exactly. Not only do they jail but suspend DL, passports etc. She needs to pay that money back.
The man needs to have it garnished from her paychecks.
@@aixpert291If she did this to an employer or a bank, there would have been definite legal consequences for theft if she didn't return money that isn't hers. This is theft.
They acting real uncomfortable about holding this woman accountable 😅
The fact that the man had to even hire an attorney shows the judicial system is broken, the state should’ve represented the man for free just like they represent the woman for free when she filed for child support
Its not broken its by design
Femenist destroyed families
Yep!! Ridiculousness!
You pointed out a great fact. Even the law is biased against men when it should be equal justice and equal protection of both genders under the law.
I overpaid by 3,000+ and was told that the state I live in is a "windfall state" and that any overpayment is water under the bridge. It's gone and I will never get it back.
Child support, not ex-wife support.
I bet that none of that money went to that kid.
It said the kid emancipated himself. That means she was a HORRIBLE "mother".
She wrote the kid an IOU for some of the child support check and probably still hasn't paid the kid back.
It most likely fed some lame dude with track stains, stinky feet and chemical dependency issues 😂😂😂
@@LeeePowers An IOU would mean she knows that money wasnt for her. That's accountability, which baby mommas are allergic to.
You know it didnt
The judge has no idea how the men get repaid but he knows how to take the men money.
Yea but I wouldn't hold it against him. A lot of fathers just give up and never correct these things at least the judge wanted to do more research for the correct interest rates the OAG applies in these cases.
Facts
This man likely had his wages garnished and sent directly to the state. Absent a termination order, the garnishment will continue unabated until the order has been adjudicated. Unfortunately, this means that he has a credit to his account and the recipient is unable or unwilling to compensate. Men need to watch when nearing the end of support obligations and be proactive with their attorneys in a timely filing of a termination order request to prevent overpayment. The state won’t repay an overpayment, and in some cases like Pennsylvania, consider it as a gift. Good luck trying to recoup that money. The pandemic caused a lot of problems in these cases as hearings were postponed while wages were still garnished.
@@brucesmith9144 well at the end is not loss money if that goes to your son or daughter...but does really go to your son or daughter? in this case didnt, since the kid was emancipated
@@KaiserM3😂😂😂 that money in her stomachs
Listen to these men stammer and struggle with their words. She was overpaid $13000+ and she knew it. Now pay the man.
Agreed
$5000 lawyers fees to collect $13,000.
Legal theft.
He didn’t pay the first 10 years of the kids live, so I think they’re even.
@@jalamela1480good try .lmfao.. deadbeat single moms are everywhere guys
@@jalamela1480that would and should have been adjudicated during the initial order. Women always say that when they go to child support court that's why the judge makes the determination. Stop being naive.
A nephew, a funeral...what does that have to do with the child support
They always try to give the woman an out. It's bullshit.
I also wonder
Right
She is probably getting some kind of assistance for the nephew!
I think the judge was trying to help her out and she didn’t realize it! She could have said all the financial burden of the funeral falls on me and she wouldn’t have had to pay for anything.
this case is infuriating. not only did the judge & the AG offer the women multiple opportunities(bordering on coercion)
to claim she was destitute so she could get out of returning the overpayment. It's a perfect example of how men are treated unequally. If the man owed back child support do you think the AG's office would pander to him. no, he'd go to jail.
WAKE up men! the child support system needs to be revamped to treat everyone equally regardless of gender
No it wont happen, because most women dont make any money, they dont make enough money to cover child support, thats why children are automatically awarded to the mother.
Not defending anyone but she shouldn't have to pay a dime of ot back because it shouldn't be her responsibility to make sure payments stop coming
@@austink3169really? Why dont you pay her then ?
@austink3169 that's BS. There is no way to justify that.
Only in America the greatest country they say 😂😂😂
She’s wrong. A prudent person would return the money.
FACTS
Agreed
Blappa blappa blappa. The sound of a flat tire in the rain.
She’s not wrong. She’s a woman. This is their natural state. I’m not even bashing. If you’ve not dealt with a woman before you wouldn’t know
Women are revengeful and is doing it out of hate
The judge was so scared to make her pay even though she was wrong. The judge was fumbling all over his words.
It's hard for women to do the right thing against another woman.
@@MrMakemusicmike The judge wasn’t a woman.
@@a.k.446 You don't get it lol
@jusker25 what did I miss? The comment said women against woman.
@@a.k.446 he’s calling the judge a girl that’s the joke
The judge tried SO hard to help her. He all but coached her to say that paying the overage back would be a hardship.
But at least she didn't lie.
PAY that man. Pay that man his $+ interest+ attorney fees
Lucky for dad it wasn't "judge" Webster or Aguilar
Absolutely. They’d have gaslighted the dad and said too bad so sad and try to get the support reinstated.
@@mandawood9756I totally agree with you on that. I don't know how they get away with being so obviously biased. I can't ever finish watching them because I get so mad on behalf of those men as those judges let those women sit there and blatantly lie. They even get caught in their lie and still get away with it! It's crazy!
Don't know Webster but Aguilar....... man lord knows I can't stand how he imposes biased judgments. Then he can't keep his personal thoughts and smiling at his judgments against males.
That PART! That part, right there.
Absolutely
The judge is still showing her mercy. That’s crazy.
If the father was the who was owing her $$ he would have been ordered to reimburse her within immediate effect or asap ! The double standards wouldn't STOP......
The Attorney General doesn’t want it to be repaid because they will have to refund their fees. People need to support their kids but the State should not profit from it.
because even if they did women will still try to do it if they are broke
That’s so very true. Give the man his money. The woman will be whining if the roles were reversed.
Wish i could hit the Like button 100X. Spot on!
She's a thief, plain and simple.
Intelevision thief
Gotta give her a little credit for not making up lies like the AG tried to get her to do
How do you know she’s not lying in court? You just assume she’s telling the truth???
Correct! The AG was trying to lead her with suggestions on types of hardship to claim. Despicable.
No people dont get credit for doing whats expected dont lie in court.😂
If she had the money in her bank account and she lied that would have been a criminal charge
@@kevinking1750Or maybe women need to be treated a little harsher in the family court system since they've been abusing men using it for so long
Why do women always say my child? Its their child not my child, the child has 2 parents!
Your right. And I will add if it is "her child" only, then use "her money" and don't take his.
@@DrEricSmithakaDjHawkk345683
Boom
Right... WTH
She said she didn’t take it but, she spent it………🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️
I've saw cases where the judge would blame the dad for not filing a modification and let the mom keep the money. This man was lucky
That yertle the turtle looking judge in Texas immediately comes to mind.
I wouldn't suggest the money shouldn't be repaid because the dad didn't start this procedure earlier but it is odd that a dad in this situation doesn't try to stop the payments as soon as the child hits 18.
@@StephanieSwan666 Did you not watch the video?
@@StephanieSwan666 It's being done through wage garnishment. Plus, the courts are slow in fixing their mistakes.
My comment earlier that the system is modeled to degree a person needs a lawyer, not shocking.
And how when it is so plain he overpaid are attorneys fees $5000 .
Disgusting.
Legal theft.
Talk about trying to lead a horse to water. The judge was trying to help her say that it was a hardship. What a crooked system.
I don't think the judge did they but the AAG certainly did.
It's called child support bc it's for the child. It's not for the mom's emotional or physical needs. . Then she says she doesn't have a problem paying it back but chose not to. That's being vindictive
She shouldn't have to pay it back it's nit her fault the people at child support can't do their job properly because child support should automatically stop in most states
@@austink3169How many times did you make this clown comment? 🤡
The state should pay dad back since that’s who sends the withholding order to hr and the state should figure out how to get the funds back from the mother ON THEIR OWN. Why they can’t garnish her accounts like they garnish the fathers🤷🏾♀️
So the taxpayers let me get this right. The taxpayers should pay back the father for what the mother receiving spent. Please elaborate
Because the law allows it for child support owed but not for other circumstances like payback is my guess
No she knew It was wrong she should pay him back for all of it no one cares if the man has hardships
@@paulam.foreman4413The state gets back 60% of all collections for CS from the fed. I would say the idea isn't that bad considering we are already supporting these single mothers
Can't garnish wages if Mom isn't working
🧑⚖️ Spite is NOT a legal justification for keeping such a large child support overpayment.
This is why child support should be placed on a card that can be monitored to ensure she's actually spending it on the children..
Exactly
That’s a great idea.
Naw
Yes and no. I used to think it should be monitored more but at the end of the day if child lives with mother and dad just has visitation EOWeekend then no it shouldn’t.
And visa versa, some of these cases get so complicated bc adults can’t coparent or one parent is still hurt and wants to punish the other parent by controlling the children and blocking access.
@shelley7596 these women spend it on their eyelashes and fake nails for emotional reasons like she stated
So hardship can prevent her from paying?? does it work the other way around? smh this system is grossly predatory.
Sadly hardship won’t keep you from paying child support. It’s jail or pay
Absolutely not. Men get the steel bracelets if they can’t pay. Very unfair system
She isn't liking it when she is at the paying end.
Seems like the judge was trying hard to get her to tell him a legal reason not to pay the man back
If it was the father who had to pay, he would have to pay the entire amount plus court fees and atty fees
The state should refund him immediately and then the state should get the money back from the mother.
Why do men never get financial forgiveness?
Because the system is rigged against men.
Why the hell are these people trying to make excuses for her? A hardship? They dont ever care about hardship when a man homeless and unemployed and they shouldnt. So i dont know why they were trying to give her so much slack.
Look at all these guys who have paid for a child THAT WASNT THEIRS!!
LADY YOUR MORALS ARE F'ED UP!! She can't be serious as to why she doesn't feel like she should pay the money back. Lady get off the damn gas, do what's right and pay the money back. The nerve of her to say it's for emotional needs. SMH!
This is the majority of women. This isn't rare at all.
This woman makes no sense.
She’s a typical thief
She Feels, that's All that Needs to Be Said.....
She’s sounds stupid
Unbelievable that her only excuse for doing this was "emotional needs". There was a reason the father stopped seeing his kids. Most likely because of her. He did not get the benefit of the love of those kids while she did. If her kids were a burden, that's on her. She's the one who raised them. If they were troublesome it's because of her. Her problem is that she's butthurt because of it all and gladly took advantage when he kept paying for the kid after 18. You don't get to say later that he wasn't in the child's life. That choice was made by her when she put him on child support. If he had been in the child's life they would've had joint custody and been 50/50. In which case he wouldn't have paid child support. You can't have your cake and eat it too.
He should appeal that ruling. It's ridiculous that she only has to repay 6000. What about attorney fees? He racked up over five thousand in attorney fees, so he is left with a couple hundred after it's all said and done?
@carolesmith4864 I think you may have misunderstood, the $6000 is only for attorney fees, he will get the entire judgement plus that.
I believe the 6000 was a different case and a different guy, the person speaking said Ms Chelsea and the other defendants name was Ms Williams.
they keep trying to give her an out to not repay shame on the judge and aag
Retired child support administrator here. I don't live in Texas. This was a fair ruling for dad.
So it's our fault she slept with a man who is a bad father according to her ??? It's her fault she had a kid with this guy, not ours, so pay the money back. That AG, like most, is corrupt
He was probably alienated from his son
@@sammyjo8109yea keep believing dat buddy
Child Support/Family Court reform is definitely needed at this point! For a mother/woman to say I am not going to pay back the money that was sent after the child 18th bday is crazy! No jail/prison time, no garnishment of wage, or lend on any property that she possesses is in insane! Because if this is a man/father/non custodial parent, all the things I mentioned he would force to do or pay!
Open, shut, plain ,simple, yet attorneys fees are $5000.
Legal theft.
Pickled pigs feet
He's way underpaid.
It just shows how convoluted the justice system has become! Simple cases get so bogged up with legal jumbo that one is almost forced to hire a lawyer because judges don’t like dealing with regular people maneuvering through the system!
@@cmd1007Judges were lawyers. They fraternize and run in the same circle as those lawyers. Heck, some maybe even went to the same law schools.
It's all about the MONEY.
Attorneys have to get thier blood money.
Why didn’t he file to have the support stopped years ago? Dang if I had money taken out when child care was over I’d be getting in front of a judge asap
Same thing happened to the comedian 'Earthquake' he overpaid child support by 10's of thousands of dollars. He took her to court & the judge put it on the backend so that he'd be finish paying support 6 months early. Plus his son was already living with him the last few years. She tried to appeal claiming that she coildn't maintain her household without that income.
😮😮😮😮
She should have done the right thing and helped stop garnishment. Instead, she was spiteful.
The judge tried hard to figure out a way to let her off.
Something they never do for men
If the state was garnishing his checks. They are responsible for the repayment. They knew the record showed the child turned 18. The garnishments should've stopped upon the child turning 18 automatically. Then the state should go after her for accepting and using money illegally. Any hardship she has because of families medical issues is not his problem. He was only responsabile for the child alone. Not for paying family bills or funerals
This was a sad case, but the correct outcome. Mr. Guy was pissed that Miss Williams put him on child support, so he distanced himself from their son, who ultimately paid the price of not having a meaningful relationship with his father. Sad for their son, but oh well for Miss Williams. Return the money, sis; you picked him.
Truth be told, she is probably one of those single mothers who wants the child all to herself and only wants the money. She probably withheld the child from his father.
@@carolesmith4864 I was thinkin' the same thing. You never know about these situations, but I wouldn't say I like it when children pay the price for parents who are trifling and stuck on stupid.
@@carolesmith4864, common occurrence.😔
Child support the father when you do that
The fact that she's only doing this to backstab him is what bothers me.
She should have to pay it all back.
Because the kid stops needing things at 18. I know someone who received two payments after the child reached 18. That man refused to do anything extra for that child for 18 years but took her to court for the two payments. Luckily she showed where she used it to pay for housing fees and a new laptop for the child because he was going to college. She also showed where she had to take out a student loan in her name for the child’s college tuition. The judge looked that man in the face and told him he ought to be ashamed and dismissed him smh
@@guccilady1017parents should take care of their kid, without question but, the days of women getting a pass for bad behavior should be over! She knew better and still did wrong. Have the same energy for her as you do for men when they don't do right.
@@patricksimmons3491 you let that hurt go and stop being bias towards men Patrick
@@guccilady1017 you are just ignorant. Men always get the raw end of the deal, sometimes it's warranted. I vet her azz paid that $ or go straight to jail 😂😂😂
@@guccilady1017 turns out when you are a spiteful woman that leaves a man, robs him of his kids, and takes his money under threat of jail the men don’t want to do anything “extra” for these no good women. The judge ought to be ashamed, as should most of you horrible women.
Wow! The A.G. is a moron!!! Let's see, "do you have close family members with health issues?" How is that HIS problem to pay for???
"Did you help pay for funeral costs?" For her deceased Aunt.
Again, how is that HIS problem to pay for???
"I have a nephew i have custody of."
Last time, how is that HIS problem to pay for???
Thankfully, this Judge knows his job and follows the law.
Boy Texas must have messed up pretty bad. There are a lot of cases where dads have over paid and the greedy women want to keep it. Time to pay women and Texas you need to do better
It's not TX fault that these woc are so amoral, loose and bogish
Texas is a “mothering” state. A friend of mine spent $60,000 in attorney fees to get his child back from a woman that was prostituting herself for drugs with her child in the car/home. He had documented proof, but it wasn’t until he paid for her hair to be tested for drugs that he got any foothold.
@@Dahverin-kk4onit is Texas fault because this issue comes up and they ignore it every year …men advocate groups in Texas have been going to politicians for get laws changed and they won’t!
Texas seems to be one of the worst.
The state tried to give her a lifeline by leading her to say she has a hardship but her ego prevented her from saying what he said to say
The damn entitlement, men be more careful who you have a child with.
This Judge reminds me of Uncle Phil.
You know she’s not right. Why isn’t she on camera
Hiding from embarrassment
If its not a problem for the BM” to Repay the “BD” Overpayment of Said Child Support…..Girl Give that Man his Money!🤷🏽♀️
She ain't got the money.
@@nattydreadlocks1973Really? She said it wasn’t a hardship though to pay him back. I must have heard wrong 😅
@T.Hang11 I don't think she understood the question. If she had it, she wouldn't be in court wasting her time. The check would have been in the mail long ago.
@@nattydreadlocks1973 really..I guess we interpret it differently..watching the video she just doesn’t want to pay because she feels like it’s her right to keep the money. We can differ in opinion
@T.Hang11 Anyone who has lived more than half a century, like myself, knows that this lady does not have the money to repay. Otherwise, she would have already done so.
If she was bitter before, she's about to turn acidic after this 😂 Shout out to all the mothers and fathers taking care of their responsibilities
The judge. Should be fired. Man needs his money. Returned
Judgement should not be reduced.
They tried their damdest to let her keep that money and coach her through it her ignorance one him the day. Im disgusted with this family court trying to rob this man
I don’t know if it’s the state where I live, but my husband overpaid and he’s receiving checks from the state still to this day and his daughter is 25. It’s sad what these fathers have to go through. I know what we went through and what he did as a father and was still dealt a bad hand. Mom tried 18yrs to keep her away. She’s 25 now and we can’t get rid of her so just be mindful, kids don’t stay kids forever.
He was trying to give her an out but her ego is so big she won’t admit she’s struggling
This should have been an open closed case. Pay the man
This brother has to actually fight to get money he overpaid back smh America
now we know why he left her.....
That’s why the courts should require an itemized list of how child support is spent.
Why is it always MY child imagine the hateful things she has told this child about the father.
So....she took the extra money and she didn't give the boy his father's last name out of spite. That boy is going to have a tough life w/ her around.
It doesn’t matter the reason to not give the boy his last name. If we didn’t get married my baby will have my last name.
@@prettyangel0921 Highly disagree w/ this take. A son needs his father's last name.
@@d3lan011 I disagree. Women do most the work to get childern here. If you want your child to have your last name, marry her so everyone has the same last name 🤷🏾♀️
@prettyangel0921 To speak about that: the mother wouldn't do that work if she didn't get the specimen to start the process. And how do you explain to your son that you gave time your last name instead of his father's, who is paying CS. There is more than one side to the story, but we only hear the woman's side.
@@d3lan011 the last name has nothing to do with his last name. Dna has to do with CS
Funeral cost other family expenses are totally irrelevant to this child’s child support pay the man back the money you owe him
Looking at the videos I would never marry anyone again. There is no benefit in it for the man at all, none!
It is no wonder this guy ran away from this lady.
The fact that this mother is on disability is a joke. Way too many able-bodied people get checks every month for 'disability'. The amount of government money that's wasted is outrageous.
So many people on disability these days
You don't know her medical history. Getting on disability is extremely hard.
Put her in prison, when she gets out after 7 or 8 year's, then she can pay it back..
I wouldn't care about any of those issues she was talking about... Can't get money you know you weren't supposed to get then try to justify it by saying it takes more than money to raise a child....
My ex-husband overpaid $23,000 to his ex-wife, over the course of 5 years. When the state audit found it, the state sent a letter asking if he wanted to make a “gift” of it to the mother since it would be a hardship for her to pay it back. She knew it wasn’t her money.
Please tell me that he got his money back
I would have told them no.
@@dcpsujag he’ll naw
These women use these kids as pawns for their benefit
She should have taken it to trial and got a jury. She would have been able to show he never paid child support until age 9 on. I have seen it done so many times. He probably would have owed her more than that $13,000. She should not have let the judge intimidate her with “I can only talk about 2011 on”.. the child was around before 2011.
Give the man his money.
What a crock!! They are looking for any excuse to let her keep money she wasn’t suppose to even get.
Why wasn’t the CS payments automatically stopped, everything is computerized today. It should be programmed in to stop the payments as soon as the child turns 18. If he wants to continue to support him, that’s on him to do so.
Why is the state fighting so hard for her to keep that money?
This is why the system should have an automatic termination date entered into the system so no payments are received after the age of 18 or the date of a projected completion of HS. Just like women have rights there need to be laws that's for men as well.
Now the court doesn’t know how to go bout paying the guy back, Amazing
Give back his money woman you owe him.
She didn’t even bother to check into the over payments. She just took it.
My ex wife paid overage. A year latter they cut me a check. Shes a Karen.
Child support normally terminates by operation of law when the child turns 18 and graduated from high school in most states. Child support agencies rely on parents to notify them of the graduation date in order to stop any withholding order. This lady has no legal right to this money. She thinks she deserves the money because she feels wronged by Dad. You can hear the anger in her voice. Revenge isn’t a valid, legal excuse.
Extra 5k for being evil
Emotional and Physical needs is paid out in Alimony or Spousal Support. Not your adult child who can now work to support himself. She had 18 years to prepare for this SMH.
This was a straight foward case. They lady even admitted to everything. This attorney is overcharging for his representation.
Now , that was justice
I feel so happy for him , almost like I was awarded 13k
Bout time these judges tell these woman their feelings aren’t enough
If you as a man get custody, you put Mom's azz on child support out of principle. Open up a savings account for your child and just deposit the proceeds.
These western black women are something else bro
I'm happy for my brother rn. He's also starting to receive payments for overpaying these past few weeks. Hopefully my turn is next to receive mine
Emotional support ends with divorce. That's a husbands concern, not the ex.
You can tell they are trying their best to get the woman off the hook. Just pay the man his money back, this double standard is getting sickening!
I feel like they're conferencing her to lie. She owes the money. She said she could pay, so pay the money.