@javierbayon741 you can say what you want but you can't up and threaten someone's life. Like saying you have a bomb at an airport or threaten an individual. Other than that you can say you hate the president, Republicans, Democrats, Democracy, that you're a communist. All without getting spirited away by the government. We have free speech we just have to take responsibility for what we say.
he most likely would get suspended and cops will pay him a visit, and his online activities will get monitored, but he won’t get arrested or send to gulag. I know cuz my relative did the same thing and got said treatment.
OBVIOUSLY the theory works. China has had the fastest growth in human history. Entirely due to the political make up. They got free speech in Mexico 😂😂And look at the place. I'll erase a few civil liberties if the government kept the people safe and employed
nope, sad to say he was jailed for 8 yrs as this clip went internationally viral.... last heard... maybe you could reconfirm? as i really hope i heard wrongly here.
@@guessmoments probably you are right... if it was just not viral probably he could get with stern talking. But since we are watching this right now then everyone needs to show how strict they are with the boy in order to prove their compliance to the party. Thus the teacher, the students, the uni, the police and the judge will be mor hursh even for just some words...
Alot of them know whats wrong in the system, but they'd rather not voice it out, because it seems like some of them are brainwashed specifically those that stopped him😮💨 But who knows, they might be trying to silence him to save him
I befriended a Vietnamese student who was studying at University of Washington. He was amazed that everyone could disagree on politics but still get along.
lovely communists making it seems like they're actually for the people. I'm pretty sure Karl Marx did NOT wanted enforced conscription or compulsory nationalism..
It’ funny all replies bad things about Vietnamese communism party are all gone away!!!! Why didn’t they let people know what did they do to a young boy at their 16 years old when he has a different political viewpoint
He was very brave to say this in front of his classmates and teacher. Standing up for yourselves is better than staying quiet about things that you don't agree with. That's just my opinion
True. However in a place like China. You’d be ghosted and hated in social media if you did something like this. After all the brainwashing of China has been evidently long.
You said this cause you are in complete different,comfortable situation, and I too agrre with him. But his situation is different - he live in dictatorship REGIME, and he Has much more to loose than we in our comfort.
I totally support young students who don't give a freakin fuck and speak loudly and proudly with their honest opinions about what they feel and think. School is to guide you for being a super human and the best version of yourself is not for sheeps who follow the crowd and do nothing for humanity just sitting like an idiot watching time passing by. Be brave and change this world with your honest words, go for it! I know u have the guts 👊
First : Stop having babies! If you have more than 1, then we'll make sure you don't! Now : Please, make more babies! ;_; We need more young people to subjugate and brainwash because all the old people cannot work ;_;
The Tiananmen protestors were Maoists themselves, protesting against the reforms that took away the "iron rice bowl" of the Mao era. If you dig hard enough you'll find pictures of them carrying portraits of Mao, Sun, etc.
@@TonySoprano-oo8wd There literally were anti-Zionist mass protests in almost every major university campus across the US. Wtf are you drivelling about?
@FunnyStory-c6rthey don’t arrest people in China for speaking out against communism. Believe it or not, free speech isn’t much different there than in the US
@@youtefhyspeak the truth. It is important now more than ever in human history. That man said what his heart believed in, and if he somehow turns up dead or missing or worse, it was definitely the ccp silencing him. Dont even be sarcastic, because what if these silly youtube comments one day are among the last few traces of truth available to record the history by? What if the propoganda and control take a turn for the worse, and the people and their voice become their only weapon? Dont even be sarcastic about this stuff. It isnt funny. Speak the truth. This guy was not suicidal or depressed, he was oppressed. And if anything happens to him for speaking out against the communist party, it was the communist party itself, getting rid of a dissident. It's fucked up, fuck the ccp. Pray for chinese citizens.
@@youtefhy a normal person who wants freedom would definitely do that, take example of national heroes (I'm not saying he's a national hero) national heroes didn't sacrifice their life to "ruin it and die" but rather to free their nation from something
@@g_qb5371 everyone else in the classroom is normal, they might even believe in the same things as this moron here, the problem here is that after he protests, so what? Now he’s in jail and nothing has changed.
When I was at UCLA, my international roommate from China one day came back from the library with multiple books that were banned in China, and he told me he was going to read all of them before he had to go back. Lol
@@SE-gs6gdThey aren't banning books here. Way to just eat propaganda. All they're doing is removing indecent books from public school libraries. You can still go buy the books.
It was probably higher, and it happened during Mao. They're not starving now, but... there is inequality. No surprise. USA and other countries are not much different.
@@StevenMacQuarrieThey're not starving now because they're dead, smartass. And people in China are not starving today is all thanks to Deng Xiaoping's economic reform.
@@wanderingghost7324 he has a point, the communism is just a “face” for modern China after Deng. Now, in reality it is no less capitalistic than the common example, America. It still has authoritarianism to it though undoubtedly. Both China and America capitalise on things, however in certain things they just capitalise differently.
@JohnSmith-e3d8g your username is John Smith… if you love capitalism so much have you read ADAM Smith? At the very least the wealth of nations? No. You haven’t. Because not a single right wing capitalist I’ve ever met understands the socioeconomic theories they stand behind. They just blindly disparage communism without having any understanding of what they’re talking about.
@@AlfyannnFirst they came for the Communists And I did not speak out Because I was not a Communist Then they came for the Socialists And I did not speak out Because I was not a Socialist Then they came for the trade unionists And I did not speak out Because I was not a trade unionist Then they came for the Jews And I did not speak out Because I was not a Jew Then they came for me And there was no one left To speak out for me.
@@crazychinese7315 give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime. But ofcourse, It would be naive to believe that is all that's required, particularly for developing and oppressed nations.
@@Datwaltuhdawg unlike the Europeans who just took all the fish for themselves and positioned the lake so no one else can fish in it.. actually. i will not be surprised if shxt like that literally happened in the history, because, you know, Europeans
I am Vietnamese I read Chinese history since my high school years suggested by my father. I like Chinese culture but I honestly think Chinese communists destroys thousand year old Chinese culture. A small example of modern Chinese history, when Vietnam was under French rule and China was fighting Western colonialists, a young Vietnamese revolutionary name Pham Hong Thai tried to assassinate French Indochina governor Martial Merlin at Victoria hotel belonging to English sector. He failed. Pursued by police he threw himself on the Châu Giang ( 珠江, ) river. It was in 1924. Chinese revolutionaries located his body and even built his solemn grave to show respect of his patriotism. His grave is now still in Guangzhou, southern China. Chinese education today teaches students hatred and excessive patriotism.
This is not communism but authoritarian capitalism . Marx ideology actually encouraged culture as it was what made us humans and fullfiled. Hé fought against inequalities and wanted workers to have right .
Students are encouraged to report on each other. So the 'laughter' you see from other students, is the knowledge that this guy just threw his life away. The university probably expelled him.
@@DUFFAL02 he knows what he's talking about. Such a communist state have never existed where people were not expected to report on each other. Eastern Germany under Soviet occupation is a great example of that. With 16,4 million people population they had 260 thousand agents working for secret police service and they had files on 5,6 million people. So one agent was looking after approx 20 people, kept track of them, reported on their activities, investigated their private lives and activities. A third of population was under constant survivalence. And those are very conservative numbers, because the second thing communists are known for is covering up each other. They would snich on everyone around but they would always cover other communists like an organized crime group. Which they in fact are.
@@user-dn1dy bất mãn với chế độ khác với chống phá xuyên tạc nhé, tôi khá chắc là trong Nam nhiều người bất mãn lắm nhưng mà vẫn sống tốt, vẫn tuân thủ luật pháp
No, probably not. As long as they as their lives are not actively being ruined by the government, Chinese people don't care who's in charge. They probably just see that student as a nuisance.
he will be cyberbullied on social medias, they will find out all of his relationships and threaten them also, and call him a traitor to the country, idk if this also the same in China, but it's currently happening in Vietnam right now, which is disgusting.
@@toara you might not know but there were/are a lots of cases that people get cyberbullied, threatened, or even jailed, because they criticize the system in Vietnam, and right know there's witch hunting season happening in VN which target Southern Vietnamese Celebrities because they performed for Vietnamese people in the US and there was an old Southern Vietnam flag is in the picture, or even something that they said or do 10 or 16 years ago, even though the current Vietnamese goverment itself always talk about wanting to restore the relationship between two sides, they still hiding behind those so called fanpages admins or influencers to spread their propagandas and hatreds toward people who disagree with them.
While China no longer has free secondary education, one of the biggest issues with "free" secondary education is that it's generally controlled by the govt as a way to indoctrinate youth before they get to be free thinking adults. Regardless of the tuition, China has been forcing assimilation through fear and indoctrinating for decades. It happens even in the U.S. This kids parents either taught him well covertly or he's broken the spell himself. Unfortunately, SOMEONE is going to be severely punished for his outburst, if not several someones.
Our liberal college institutions are indoctrinating at the same rate as China. Try saying you believe in American ideas and you will be called a racist. American college's PRAISE Marxism and promotes communist philosophy. You would be hard pressed to find a college that promotes our government and traditional values.
not a viable conclusion. if the country is a functioning liberal democracy (not the US) there is no reason to assume their youth gets indoctrinated. on the contrary, they learn to embrace human rights and their civil liberties including how to think independently. critical thinking is central for a country who wants responsible citizens. e.g. in the US the public education system is poorly funded and fails in doing so. narrow-minded dumbasses are produced en masse without the ability to detect blatant lies from politicians.
paid secondary education aint safe from indoctrination either. my college reconstruction history class was tryna tell me the black panthers were terrorists. i would of believed it if i wasnt built like this guy. and i would have to do dozens of classes just like it to get a "normal" degree. but here in the us im fine cause im free to drop out and still land a great job and career. i left all academic classes behind and now im taking auto mechanics instead. in china they dont get that kinda freedom unless they study abroad, i pray for them and especially him, cause while i can complain about the us i know he "cant complain" about china
It's easy to judge them from a country where you can say almost anything with zero consequences.. Their futures, their lives and their families could be at stake here. I don't think you'd be so eager to speak up if, for example, you know they would come to your house and take your mother away because of it....
@@Nebol Judging!? Can't you see they're all cowards and even standing up for their abusers instead of by his side? All the more they should resist and fight for their civil liberties because "their future, their life, their families" must be protected that you yourself say they have!
@@Nebol it's true that it's difficult to judge them for remaining silent due to the reasons you gave. It's not difficult to judge them for arguing with him and defending the CCP though. There is a big difference between not speaking against your oppressor and speaking in defense of your oppressor and talking shit to your champion
One of my co workers migrated from China to Hong Kong, he said he tried so hard for so many years so he doesn’t have to live like those in China. But now they are making Hong Kong worse than China and he’s so disappointed
I love how American propaganda work 😂 Chinese literally will own everything in 5 years. Made a joke of American hegemony yet you still criticize their methods and models 😂😂😂😂 US has over 3 million homeless perhaps they should take example from china 😂😂😂😂 what’s most funny, people making fun that are living in a cancel society that nobody is free to state their true opinion 😂😂😂😂😂😂 in US is you publicly say you are a communist you will lose your job and get canceled at least this kid is not canceled 😂😂😂😂
Hong kong was british owned until recent years, it was totaly different to mainland china, hence why so many hong kongers are leaving to the uk because they dont want to be part of china when the agreement is up@@valentijnrozeveld3773
People always get this wrong so bad. China isn’t communistic, it’s a dictatorship. Communism isn’t really do-able, mainly because of greed. Chinas Regime is terrible, but it isn’t communism.
It was so nice to see a difference between my Chinese coworkers who were party members and those who were not. No cognitive dissonance among the nonbelievers
I’m gonna give my personal experience for free; I went to a Chinese university and I remember they have to take those classes YES OR YES, also I remember during dinner with the teachers for the finals or midterms they always try to convince the students to get into the party. Most of my friends just say yes yes yes to the teacher but they don’t really care about politics, and then get into the party because also that gave them advantage trying to get a job after college
@mini6164 it's the parents who indoctrinate. Right and left. It's not the government's job to raise my kids in their values. It's mine to raise them with my values.
They poor guy though, yes he showed great bravery, but what will happen to him now? I fear for his safety. Will his bravery lead to more freedom? How do we help him?
@@NiMareQ the thing is of Someone say something about CCP ( and i mean only Chinese people) tend disappear or never heard again they may been send somewhere or Killed but people never know and if something happend like being killed or death they often try/do go to there family and Pay them to shut up or even let them Sign a contract to be silent/get something in Return and even if that Doest work they Literly Dismissed and blame it on the person who died like a Suicide case or own blame like they Love telling Lies only to make there country look ""perfect, paradise, the strongest without flow" but love show fake thing, grappig things from other countries telling they have worse yet not showing the real contents and often making Falls news report like they "saved" a falling bus or helped people in the rain/flod while it all stages
See that social / peer pressure ? That's how it is ... the society is already hardwired to such ideology and even if they're dissatisfied, nobody dares to speak out because none want any trouble for themselves. That's self censorship
Brave young man speaking up to whats right. He should be careful though cause we all know what happened to the young students who did that back in 1989
The crazy part is most of these kids already have their mind brainwashed with those things and most of them laughing at this brave men like he's the crazy one. 💔
they're laughing because you would too if you were at university and someone just stood up and started speeling about his political views lmao do you genuinely think that anyone gives a shit if you're not a communist? there's literally nothing stopping him from moving to the US if he's so upset
@@bombcat5517They have become apathetic and spineless, that's why they are at ease and comfortable with uncle xi controlling every aspect of their existence.
I respect the dude. That's opening his eyes, he's the first of his kind to realize all these years, the people that were in charge due to chinese people never gave a shit about their people and he realized But yeah, all his classmates are still brainwashed So I hope there's more people in china like him slowly growing because I want the whole Damn world to wake up and say no to the elites and fight back in short, he's already one person, but when you have a thousand over the elites, What are they gonna do today? They're gonna be scared because thousands of people finally opened their eyes and turned against the government
How are they brainwashed? They are just not stupid enough to end their career over their own opinions, this guy is an idiot for doing this, hes just implying that he wants to ruin the rest of his life.
What's the thing that the US and China have in common? Students from US can stand up and shout loudly that they don't like Republic. Students from China can also stand up and shout loudly that they don't like Republic
How is it sad? They are laughing because they know the person who is shouting is a moron, they could also believe in the same theory as him but arent stupid enough to say that out loud, he now probably ruined his life now, for what? calling out a government?
I’ve done the same thing when I was at high school in 2008. The principal had a formal chat with me and said don’t do it again if you don’t want to get into troubles. One year later I took Gaokao exams and went to SYSU without any issues.
I admire the balls on this kid, but the smart thing to do is likely to just remain quiet about your criticisms. Not having free speech sucks, but self-preservation takes priority.
get his ass to a first world country. also, he looks healthy and mentally stable, he is not suicidal and doesn’t seem to have any health issues whatsoever.
When I visited Germany, I had a conversation with a Chinese guy studying in a German university. Even though he can do everything and say everything he wants, even though he lives a way better life by studying in Germany and having a really high-paying part-time job there (compared to what he would be paid in China), he still believes that China is a better country and the communist regime is superior. We also had a conversation about why he thinks other people view China in a negative light. His response was pretty simple: Western propaganda. While that can be the case in some instances, since countries like the US would greatly benefit from weakening China, he was unwilling to accept that sometimes, the Western media could be right and China can make mistakes. He also didn't believe that propaganda exists in his country. He told me that if he can't fall for propaganda and even if China was to spread propaganda, it would be for the greater good. I was surprised by one thing though: he told me nothing is truly "banned" in his country since most young people would use VPN and pirate Western media from Chinese sites that the CCP won't crack down on. I wasn't surprised by that, since my country does the same (even our prime minister mentioned how he downloads files from a Bulgarian piracy site), it was the fact that they know what a VPN is and they won't get in trouble for using one. Places like North Korea banned VPNs, so I always assumed China did too (he even made a joke about China not being North Korea). Although I knew that there's propaganda in China, I never knew how bad it was until I talked to an actual victim of brainwashing. We had a lengthy conversation (most of it about table tennis, food, and our future) and ne never struck me as a liar. He genuinely believed what he was saying. I wish him the best. He was really smart, so I hope he succeeds in life. It's just sad to see an intelligent young man being a victim of brainwashing since his birth. Same goes for all Chinese and Macedonians: you're not a dumb nation for believing the propaganda. You were lied to from your childhood, so it's understandable that you will hate me and won't share the same opinions as me. Read, travel, talk to people and try to learn from all of that. Open your mind to different opinions and perspectives and when you find out you were wrong, don't be ashamed to admit it. We learn our entire life, contradictions in our point of view are bound to appear, so embrace them rather than shutting them down.
He must be fairly young, you have to understand that we were bombarded with political propagandas since 7/8 years old in China. A lot of nationalism in the education. Some people are more naive than others when it comes to things like this, some might came to a realization at later stage of life, I know I did when i was in college. For him, who knows, but most educated adults I know don’t buy these BS. People are more concerned with their own families and personal development.
Do you believe that the earth has billions of years and that humanity is the fruit of Evolution? Do you believe in the survival of the fittest? Do you believe in the relativity of truth? If yes to these questions, it's because you've been taught from your youth that these are true. Your outlook on the world and your life are based on what you believe in, even are societies.
I think it's not entirely brainwashing, it is also values and history. 1. Westerners seem to have a hard time accepting that there are people who don't value freedom and individuality as much as they do. Like you mentioned, Asian societies value "greater goods" more. Also see the relationship of government x people differently from that of the west. In Asia, the government is the parent/father, the society is the children. It is expected for a parent to tell what the children must do, but they must do it with the best intentions at heart. It's Confucianism. 2. China used to be the leading society for cultures, science, and technology for thousands of years, until The West put them on their knees using opium. Chinese calls this "a hundred years of humiliation". Hence their resentment towards the west, and their ambitions to do things their own way, not the western way.
@MissNulis I'm really sick and tired of western people who believe they are living better life because they have more freedom and individuality. And they also bring wars to countries who don't believe in their lifestyle. Really makes me wonder what is in their head.
They probably support China’s ideology, considering China’s average iq is significantly higher than that in the US. They understand how communism works unlike people who’ve read zero theory in this comment section.
@@fchicod US and ISRAEL care for their own country and their people and they don't claim territories more than what the law legally allow...the CCP doesn't care about anything but themselves,selfish and "super duper"according to trump greeeeeeeddddddy...
You don’t understand anything lmao, US propaganda is wild. He’ll be totally fine. They don’t just make you disappear in China, there is freedom of speech.
Yea I openly hate communism too. Only difference is I can freely speak still. AND I WILL FIGHT TO KEEP IT THAT WAY. I HAVE NEVER EXPERIENCED COMMUNISM, NOR DO I EVER WANT TOO. the stories are enough for me
Fun fact China isnt communist it is an authoritarian capitalist regime. No country ever reached marx communism and if you actually Read the book you would know mark fought for freedom of speech , the workers and against inequalities he even predicted the destruction of the planet because of endless growth. Capitalism propaganda angainst communism exist and this is why they only teach about Marx and other philosophy from the greatest mind like Socrate, Épicure,etc in Canada but not in the US because the system would fall
Same thing happened in vietnam here. A 17 year old guy who managed to get into the olympic academic competition spoke out against the Party, and he imediately got to do business with the police force. Poor guy is just showing his thoughts, thus showing us all there is a certain restriction on freedom of speech here in vietnam
is vietnam still a communist country like china?? but how come there are so many big companies invested into the country if there is no change in the regime?
@@guessmomentsYou are assuming companies care about political divides more than making more money. As for is it still communist... yes it is. But there are some sections of university students who are "moving away" from their parents political views, and lets put it at that.
@@guessmoments Yep, in some of these cases they would be forced to make an official apology video to the party. Which is widespread on social news. And since people know who they are, their face, what they did...good luck getting any work at all. And consider how small of a country for such a big population...and the Asian "shaming" culture...further insults by neighbors and countrymen.
Is this a Marxist I smell? It's never really "true" communism is it. Everytime it inevitably turns into a dystopia it's always "fake" communism. Give me a break
If all the bad guys say they are one thing, everyone calls them that thing, and no one else is calling themselves that thing. That thing is just what the badguys are, regardless of the made up definition of what that thing wants to be, is.
I should’ve said this during my micro and macro Econ courses in the United States of America: I don’t believe in capitalism I’m sick of being sold capitalism as the end-all be-all of economic theory!
I don't really like chinese government either but their philosophy and marxism are two different things. Nowhere in marx does it advocate for dictatorship and censorship, and it certainly doesn't call for bureaucracy of business leaders.
Right !!!! So much false information about Marx philosophy by capitalist propaganda which force us to consume products MADE IN CHINA destroying our planet . Capitalism isnt better and communism doesn't ban freedom
It’s just a guy who hates studying politics. The fact that he can say this in the class means they have quite freedom of speech. Also China’s becoming global power, economically and militarily. Living standard’s improving. My rant, haha, my point is rebellious guys are everywhere regardless of whether they are right or wrong. The America is more chaotic, violent and hateful. Every personal opinion is personal. I wanna know more about OP, is he an expat? Or a Taiwanese who dislikes China?
Yeah, meanwhile western country should definitely at least learn about marxism, because right now our economic ideology is shit. And were they really learning about marxism? I feel like it would only point out a lot of contradictions between actual marxism and modern society in China 😅
that's what I was thinking. So many of these commentors are from USA and would never be allowed to learn marxist theory genuinely and they're being fed their own propaganda along with the most n*zi thing, the pledge of allegiance to the flag AT SCHOOL. Yet they think they're free and have no propaganda, but every country has an ideology and it is reflected in their education. Thinking you're free and there is no koolaid to drink, means you already drank it.
Ooooooh, I thought I'd never see a comment like that. People always harp on Marxism and Communism as if this was what China is. China is NOT COMMUNIST. It's essentially a Capitalist Authoritarian hellscape.
Sure, westerners should learn what Marxism is to identify it and realize what a trash theory of value it is. I can spend thousands of hours on a piece of art, but if no one wants it, it is effectually worthless. Just ask Ubisoft.
Right ! Lol people thinking its the case are stupid . They need to Read the book about marxism! In Canada we learn about those in philosophy and also how capitalism is destroying our society .
As a Chinese myself, China is definitely far from perfect, but it also more definitely has a lot if good sides. I was born and raised in a different country because my parents left it and we went back to visit when I was young, but I might go back in the future sometime and actually visit it again now that im wonder
i never been to china or anything but from what i seen their culture goes hard. i got too much beef with the ccp to visit, they would see me as a terrorist cause i been reppin hong kong and taiwan, i know i would barely last a day if i even make it off the plane. im sad about that cause its such a cool country and a trip would be so much fun
Sorry about the music, I can't seem to change it...
It's ok dude. Hope you're safe.
@@TonySoprano-oo8wd YEEEAH, I'll believe that when I see some proof, thanks.
@@MultiZavira google is free 👍
@@TonySoprano-oo8wd There's are tens of millions of Americans who openly criticize Israel daily 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Wake up dummy
@@TonySoprano-oo8wd u get arrested for causing damage to people or property, lol
A Chinese student in US told me he came to US to study because he didn’t want to forced to learn Chinese party propaganda
He’ll just be forced to learn another set of propaganda
@@CSqrdX At least we can vote
@@CSqrdX Really. Give me an example
@@zodo2476 No, he can't. He's probably an alien with a green card or asylum seeker. He can't vote until naturalized.
@MahanFan1 true, the liberal demoncratic party is trying to turn the country upside down
Please don’t get disappeared, he is so brave
I really hope so too. We need the youth of china to realize this.
@@TonySoprano-oo8wdArrested in Germany for calling a fat politician fat, too. It’s cause the entire west is going communist
@Catherine.Dorian. yup! No need of zog and commies
@TonySoprano-oo8wd hope you're joking because no you can't. We aren't the UK.
@@hectornieves537 google is free you know
Unlike here he doesn't have the right to say what he feels. I pray he and his family are safe.
You can't say anything in the west either the only thing you can do is pick multiple ice cream flavors
@@javierbayon741 Cancel culture is not the same as ccp censorship
@javierbayon741 you can say what you want but you can't up and threaten someone's life. Like saying you have a bomb at an airport or threaten an individual. Other than that you can say you hate the president, Republicans, Democrats, Democracy, that you're a communist. All without getting spirited away by the government. We have free speech we just have to take responsibility for what we say.
In China you get sent to the gulag for criticising their Communism, in the United States you get sent to the gulag for criticising israel
@javierbayon741 You're on drugs if you think American censorship is anywhere near China's.
he most likely would get suspended and cops will pay him a visit, and his online activities will get monitored, but he won’t get arrested or send to gulag. I know cuz my relative did the same thing and got said treatment.
OBVIOUSLY the theory works. China has had the fastest growth in human history. Entirely due to the political make up. They got free speech in Mexico 😂😂And look at the place. I'll erase a few civil liberties if the government kept the people safe and employed
nope, sad to say he was jailed for 8 yrs as this clip went internationally viral.... last heard... maybe you could reconfirm? as i really hope i heard wrongly here.
@@guessmoments probably you are right... if it was just not viral probably he could get with stern talking. But since we are watching this right now then everyone needs to show how strict they are with the boy in order to prove their compliance to the party. Thus the teacher, the students, the uni, the police and the judge will be mor hursh even for just some words...
@@justinemot2282 To be frank, i really hope i am wrong.
@@guessmoments do you have this guy’s name? I have no way of knowing cuz this shit will get instant censored on chinese social media😂
Those nervous smiles say a lot.
Same here
PEPSI, one of the symbols of capitalism society - in a communism study lesson. Hypocrisy of communists in its best
Alot of them know whats wrong in the system, but they'd rather not voice it out, because it seems like some of them are brainwashed specifically those that stopped him😮💨
But who knows, they might be trying to silence him to save him
It can be terrifying to speak up under totality
China is not even communist. It is a state-capitalist dictatorship. There is no money, state or class in communism.
Get his ass to America ASAP
The land of the free 🇺🇸
@@Akasunanossasori home of the 500k hospital bills 💔
Nah, China needs all of the ones like him they can get. Turn their country around.
@@Lmafaooo he can atleast sh1t about that withou the fear of disapearing.
@@Lmafaooo cringe ccp bot
Remember, if you ever complain about politics in the US, remind yourself that you can actrully complain
yeah also you can misgender someone and... huh
@@jbertuccistill better than an authoritarian society
Just don't complain about big companies like Boeing and Amazon
@@jbertucciYou can misgender whoever you want. People will just think you're an asshole, but that's not the same thing as censorship.
@@jbertuccithat’s also freedom of speech - other people use theirs to hit you back
I befriended a Vietnamese student who was studying at University of Washington. He was amazed that everyone could disagree on politics but still get along.
lovely communists making it seems like they're actually for the people. I'm pretty sure Karl Marx did NOT wanted enforced conscription or compulsory nationalism..
Go Huskies !
It’ funny all replies bad things about Vietnamese communism party are all gone away!!!! Why didn’t they let people know what did they do to a young boy at their 16 years old when he has a different political viewpoint
I'm assuming that was along time ago. Ive seen politcal debates in college ending with indivuals literally crying.
I never understood that
And he was never seen again
How do you know?
@@BudiBudi-oe4kz🤦
@@angelbabies7 So? Having problems answering questions, I see.
It was a joke.
@@BudiBudi-oe4kzI can't tell if your a shill, part of the .50 army, or a digital slave. Either way you know you're being obtuse.
He was very brave to say this in front of his classmates and teacher. Standing up for yourselves is better than staying quiet about things that you don't agree with. That's just my opinion
yeah, if you can afford it or do it in a country with civil liberties honouring human rights. China does not belong to that group of countries.
True. However in a place like China. You’d be ghosted and hated in social media if you did something like this. After all the brainwashing of China has been evidently long.
Unfortunately the dictatorship will get him
Unfortunately the dictatorship will get him
You said this cause you are in complete different,comfortable situation, and I too agrre with him. But his situation is different - he live in dictatorship REGIME, and he Has much more to loose than we in our comfort.
That guy’s ancestors are totally smiling down on him, what a guy
He's also going to meet them in a couple of days. 😢
The ancestors might have been worse and only cared that he worked for those with the bigger stick.
@@genericscout5408ok shtjingpingy follower😂😂😂😂
I dont know but somehow this remind me of skyrim lol
@@genericscout5408which is probably the best thing common folk could do.
I totally support young students who don't give a freakin fuck and speak loudly and proudly with their honest opinions about what they feel and think. School is to guide you for being a super human and the best version of yourself is not for sheeps who follow the crowd and do nothing for humanity just sitting like an idiot watching time passing by. Be brave and change this world with your honest words, go for it! I know u have the guts 👊
Now, that's the people we need to help escape the borders of Mainland China!
Kids like him are the true gems of his ancient ancestors.
sometimes they just do not have the funds or visa to do so
@@WuLetaoAhs They don't need that. They could even be easier to track down by the CCP if they bring those things with them.
Agreed...the spirit of Hong Kong & Tianamen yet lives
@funkychinaman7118 and yet the vast majority of Chinese support their government it is only a small minority who disagrees
Bring him to Indon
It's sad how many felt this way and was massacred in 1989
What a tool. You don’t even care to learn the real history
First : Stop having babies! If you have more than 1, then we'll make sure you don't!
Now : Please, make more babies! ;_; We need more young people to subjugate and brainwash because all the old people cannot work ;_;
The Tiananmen protestors were Maoists themselves, protesting against the reforms that took away the "iron rice bowl" of the Mao era. If you dig hard enough you'll find pictures of them carrying portraits of Mao, Sun, etc.
FYI, they were pro Mao Zedong and were protesting against Deng Xiaoping's government. The protesters were communists.
@@SomeBody-rm6hfthey were run over by tanks. They had to wash the remains away.
He's cooked
@@TonySoprano-oo8wdInfo?
he probably in some chinese gulag now.
@@TonySoprano-oo8wdno, you can’t
@@buqa5670 google
@@TonySoprano-oo8wd There literally were anti-Zionist mass protests in almost every major university campus across the US. Wtf are you drivelling about?
I pray for that student and his family 😢
@FunnyStory-c6rthey don’t arrest people in China for speaking out against communism. Believe it or not, free speech isn’t much different there than in the US
Reminder he's not suicidal, or depressed guys
Yes he is lol, saying that is just saying i want to die and ruin my life.
@@youtefhyspeak the truth. It is important now more than ever in human history.
That man said what his heart believed in, and if he somehow turns up dead or missing or worse, it was definitely the ccp silencing him.
Dont even be sarcastic, because what if these silly youtube comments one day are among the last few traces of truth available to record the history by? What if the propoganda and control take a turn for the worse, and the people and their voice become their only weapon?
Dont even be sarcastic about this stuff. It isnt funny.
Speak the truth.
This guy was not suicidal or depressed, he was oppressed. And if anything happens to him for speaking out against the communist party, it was the communist party itself, getting rid of a dissident.
It's fucked up, fuck the ccp.
Pray for chinese citizens.
@@youtefhy a normal person who wants freedom would definitely do that, take example of national heroes (I'm not saying he's a national hero) national heroes didn't sacrifice their life to "ruin it and die" but rather to free their nation from something
@@g_qb5371 everyone else in the classroom is normal, they might even believe in the same things as this moron here, the problem here is that after he protests, so what? Now he’s in jail and nothing has changed.
@@g_qb5371 in fact China has a reputation of shutting down protests, so this is even more useless
Freedom has to start with someone standing up
If this is true than why does the US wants to crush anyone who wants freedom?
"freedom" isn't all it's cut out to be.
@@amirillodude dude
“If you don’t stand up for something, you will fall for anything”
They have an Industrial Scale of Harvesting folks who 'Stand Up'
that's how low CCP china had been for a while now
When I was at UCLA, my international roommate from China one day came back from the library with multiple books that were banned in China, and he told me he was going to read all of them before he had to go back. Lol
thats what i wanna do if one day im in the states😂
Well they're banning books here so......
@@SE-gs6gdThey aren't banning books here. Way to just eat propaganda. All they're doing is removing indecent books from public school libraries. You can still go buy the books.
@@SE-gs6gd only in dumbass states. Us blue ones still have our libraries full.
@@SE-gs6gd Which ones?
The voice of 30 million Chinese people that died of starvation.
More like 80 million.
It was probably higher, and it happened during Mao. They're not starving now, but... there is inequality. No surprise. USA and other countries are not much different.
@@eddybarajas5115no, more like 150 million, all killed by Mao himself
@@StevenMacQuarrieThey're not starving now because they're dead, smartass. And people in China are not starving today is all thanks to Deng Xiaoping's economic reform.
300*m decades centuries
Good for that kid not wanting to be indoctrinated, unlike some of his fellow classmates.
Meanwhile capitalism has indoctrinated millions of people every day thinking it provides freedom
his classmate prbably agree with him but they are smart enough not to commit suicide like that
Why'd I first read "yellow classmates"? 💀😆
@@snobbingas189 Yeah!
Better yellow than Communist Red. 😉👍
@@BudiBudi-oe4kz I'm a bit of a yellow fellow myself
The truth of the matter is that China stopped being Communist during the time of Deng Xiaoping.
Did you live in China or are you just learning things through a textbook?
Chinese women killed communism
True but they still respect the communist ideal and policies of Mao and the country is actually officially communist.
@@wanderingghost7324 he has a point, the communism is just a “face” for modern China after Deng. Now, in reality it is no less capitalistic than the common example, America. It still has authoritarianism to it though undoubtedly. Both China and America capitalise on things, however in certain things they just capitalise differently.
@@Star_Steyrnoch How about the tyranny of the CCP?
And he was never seen or heard ever again
You have no idea what you’re talking about
Really hope he's not an adult yet but seems he was. He'll be on a watchlist at least and they'll get him on a minor offence and bury him in prison 😢
@JohnSmith-e3d8g your username is John Smith… if you love capitalism so much have you read ADAM Smith?
At the very least the wealth of nations?
No. You haven’t. Because not a single right wing capitalist I’ve ever met understands the socioeconomic theories they stand behind. They just blindly disparage communism without having any understanding of what they’re talking about.
@JohnSmith-e3d8g你们真是脑子有病。
And that student (and his family) were never seen nor heard from again.
Good
@@AlfyannnFirst they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me.
@@Datwaltuhdawg now you know how a third world country feels
@@crazychinese7315 give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime. But ofcourse, It would be naive to believe that is all that's required, particularly for developing and oppressed nations.
@@Datwaltuhdawg unlike the Europeans who just took all the fish for themselves and positioned the lake so no one else can fish in it.. actually. i will not be surprised if shxt like that literally happened in the history, because, you know, Europeans
RIP poor guy 😢
Western propaganda got you good
It so sad that he was never seen again.
I am Vietnamese I read Chinese history since my high school years suggested by my father. I like Chinese culture but I honestly think Chinese communists destroys thousand year old Chinese culture. A small example of modern Chinese history, when Vietnam was under French rule and China was fighting Western colonialists, a young Vietnamese revolutionary name Pham Hong Thai tried to assassinate French Indochina governor Martial Merlin at Victoria hotel belonging to English sector. He failed. Pursued by police he threw himself on the Châu Giang ( 珠江, ) river. It was in 1924.
Chinese revolutionaries located his body and even built his solemn grave to show respect of his patriotism. His grave is now still in Guangzhou, southern China.
Chinese education today teaches students hatred and excessive patriotism.
I have been teached in china education before, and I have never been told to hate other races.
@@youtefhy Are you sure? Search on youtube clip entitled: Kill Americans - China's new education campaign in school.
i think patriotism is good, but only when it comes from your own soul. if its without free thought or forced in any other way, its worthless.
This is not communism but authoritarian capitalism . Marx ideology actually encouraged culture as it was what made us humans and fullfiled. Hé fought against inequalities and wanted workers to have right .
@@pixazelz this is so accurately articulated. It's dictatorship not communism. The 'dictating party' named themselve communist.
He is braver than I was when I studied in college.
Students are encouraged to report on each other. So the 'laughter' you see from other students, is the knowledge that this guy just threw his life away. The university probably expelled him.
I did see people immediately text people on their phones. I hope he and his family are okay.
You have no idea what you’re talking about
@@DUFFAL02 he knows what he's talking about. Such a communist state have never existed where people were not expected to report on each other.
Eastern Germany under Soviet occupation is a great example of that. With 16,4 million people population they had 260 thousand agents working for secret police service and they had files on 5,6 million people. So one agent was looking after approx 20 people, kept track of them, reported on their activities, investigated their private lives and activities. A third of population was under constant survivalence.
And those are very conservative numbers, because the second thing communists are known for is covering up each other. They would snich on everyone around but they would always cover other communists like an organized crime group. Which they in fact are.
@@someonesuspicious4444even in UK they have set up Chinese spying posts to spy on Chinese who left China to live abroad
I hope at least some of the students stood with him
Yeah, he had the freedom of speech to say that. But the more important thing is his freedom AFTER speech...
Wow! I feel sorry for this kid. Now he’s going to jail for life or disappear 😢😢😢 just horrible. He couldn’t take it any more.
The CCP after seeing the clip: "yea his organs look removable."
Evidence? Trust me bro!
Evidence your a$$@@ericmacrae6871
@@ericmacrae6871 Oh dude, you're hilarious at parties. Keep it up king 🤡!
He's a Chinese Communist Party member. They find him hilarious.
@greghyun2003 yes it is very funny to create lies to demonize a country while actually ignoring real atrocities
In Vietnam, we are also forced to learn those stupid subjects.
ghét thì được, nhưng đừng chống phá, trung quốc khác việt nam.
Same here lol
@@narcis-xamlul và không được có quan điểm riêng của mình?
Exactly bro, and the people are too blinded by the propaganda to realize it
@@user-dn1dy bất mãn với chế độ khác với chống phá xuyên tạc nhé, tôi khá chắc là trong Nam nhiều người bất mãn lắm nhưng mà vẫn sống tốt, vẫn tuân thủ luật pháp
I’m sure many of the students in that class feel the same way. He was the only one brave enough to say it.
Nope, you can actually say that in China, believe it or not.
No, probably not. As long as they as their lives are not actively being ruined by the government, Chinese people don't care who's in charge. They probably just see that student as a nuisance.
And he was never seen ever again
He will kicked out of school.
His parent will be fired at their job
And...
he will be cyberbullied on social medias, they will find out all of his relationships and threaten them also, and call him a traitor to the country, idk if this also the same in China, but it's currently happening in Vietnam right now, which is disgusting.
@@MrAnonymous2438 When was there a similar case to this in Vietnam?
@@toara you might not know but there were/are a lots of cases that people get cyberbullied, threatened, or even jailed, because they criticize the system in Vietnam, and right know there's witch hunting season happening in VN which target Southern Vietnamese Celebrities because they performed for Vietnamese people in the US and there was an old Southern Vietnam flag is in the picture, or even something that they said or do 10 or 16 years ago, even though the current Vietnamese goverment itself always talk about wanting to restore the relationship between two sides, they still hiding behind those so called fanpages admins or influencers to spread their propagandas and hatreds toward people who disagree with them.
@@MrAnonymous2438 wait theres communism in vietnam?
@@MrAnonymous2438 What makes you think this isn't happening in China when they are the authors of such treatment?
RIP to that young man. Hopefully he inspired a few others in that classroom and whomever happened to see this video.
Yes I am being inspired to realize how evil capitalism is to continually being shove propaganda to hate about China
While China no longer has free secondary education, one of the biggest issues with "free" secondary education is that it's generally controlled by the govt as a way to indoctrinate youth before they get to be free thinking adults. Regardless of the tuition, China has been forcing assimilation through fear and indoctrinating for decades. It happens even in the U.S. This kids parents either taught him well covertly or he's broken the spell himself. Unfortunately, SOMEONE is going to be severely punished for his outburst, if not several someones.
Our liberal college institutions are indoctrinating at the same rate as China. Try saying you believe in American ideas and you will be called a racist.
American college's PRAISE Marxism and promotes communist philosophy. You would be hard pressed to find a college that promotes our government and traditional values.
not a viable conclusion. if the country is a functioning liberal democracy (not the US) there is no reason to assume their youth gets indoctrinated. on the contrary, they learn to embrace human rights and their civil liberties including how to think independently. critical thinking is central for a country who wants responsible citizens. e.g. in the US the public education system is poorly funded and fails in doing so. narrow-minded dumbasses are produced en masse without the ability to detect blatant lies from politicians.
paid secondary education aint safe from indoctrination either. my college reconstruction history class was tryna tell me the black panthers were terrorists. i would of believed it if i wasnt built like this guy. and i would have to do dozens of classes just like it to get a "normal" degree. but here in the us im fine cause im free to drop out and still land a great job and career. i left all academic classes behind and now im taking auto mechanics instead. in china they dont get that kinda freedom unless they study abroad, i pray for them and especially him, cause while i can complain about the us i know he "cant complain" about china
Indoctrination is far better than people learning from their psycho parents.
But now he won't be seen or heard from again.
In a room full of cowards this one has spine
It's easy to judge them from a country where you can say almost anything with zero consequences.. Their futures, their lives and their families could be at stake here. I don't think you'd be so eager to speak up if, for example, you know they would come to your house and take your mother away because of it....
@@Nebol Judging!? Can't you see they're all cowards and even standing up for their abusers instead of by his side? All the more they should resist and fight for their civil liberties because "their future, their life, their families" must be protected that you yourself say they have!
@@BudiBudi-oe4kz You haven't been in their situation so best you just shut your mouth.
@@Nebol it's true that it's difficult to judge them for remaining silent due to the reasons you gave. It's not difficult to judge them for arguing with him and defending the CCP though. There is a big difference between not speaking against your oppressor and speaking in defense of your oppressor and talking shit to your champion
Statistically you'd be one of them too. You are lucky that you aren't
One of my co workers migrated from China to Hong Kong, he said he tried so hard for so many years so he doesn’t have to live like those in China. But now they are making Hong Kong worse than China and he’s so disappointed
Hk is part of china
I love how American propaganda work 😂 Chinese literally will own everything in 5 years. Made a joke of American hegemony yet you still criticize their methods and models 😂😂😂😂 US has over 3 million homeless perhaps they should take example from china 😂😂😂😂 what’s most funny, people making fun that are living in a cancel society that nobody is free to state their true opinion 😂😂😂😂😂😂 in US is you publicly say you are a communist you will lose your job and get canceled at least this kid is not canceled 😂😂😂😂
Hong Kong is a city in China.
Hong kong was british owned until recent years, it was totaly different to mainland china, hence why so many hong kongers are leaving to the uk because they dont want to be part of china when the agreement is up@@valentijnrozeveld3773
Hong Kong is china
music a lil loud
Yeah thanks I will edit it
Bro will never be seen again 💀
Man hes so generous donated every organ in his body even tho he was healthy such a human
I fear for his safety.
Communist in a capitalist society: 😭🍼
Capitalist in a communist society: 🪦
True af
People always get this wrong so bad. China isn’t communistic, it’s a dictatorship. Communism isn’t really do-able, mainly because of greed. Chinas Regime is terrible, but it isn’t communism.
You can be capitalist in China, just pretend you are communist in theory. China is effectively capitalist now.
@@nondualtruthhuh
@@mjama2132its true
-1,000 social credit
Bro is not buying black myth Wukong 😂
It could be the last time he's seen.
It was so nice to see a difference between my Chinese coworkers who were party members and those who were not. No cognitive dissonance among the nonbelievers
I’m gonna give my personal experience for free; I went to a Chinese university and I remember they have to take those classes YES OR YES, also I remember during dinner with the teachers for the finals or midterms they always try to convince the students to get into the party. Most of my friends just say yes yes yes to the teacher but they don’t really care about politics, and then get into the party because also that gave them advantage trying to get a job after college
In the US, we call them Democrats.
@@peterl545 do you guys have to take that classes without exception over there?
@@peterl545gosh you're sad
@mini6164 it's the parents who indoctrinate. Right and left.
It's not the government's job to raise my kids in their values. It's mine to raise them with my values.
@@elwinrobert7602 yeah I get it, my mom is an extreme republican but anyways my brothers and I are not 😂
They poor guy though, yes he showed great bravery, but what will happen to him now? I fear for his safety. Will his bravery lead to more freedom? How do we help him?
cant, he was sentenced to 8 years jail a few days later
well... he's unalive now. unfortunately ccp has done such a good job hiding tiananmen square that these poor students don't know to be afraid
Really?
@@NiMareQ the thing is of Someone say something about CCP ( and i mean only Chinese people) tend disappear or never heard again they may been send somewhere or Killed but people never know and if something happend like being killed or death they often try/do go to there family and Pay them to shut up or even let them Sign a contract to be silent/get something in Return and even if that Doest work they Literly Dismissed and blame it on the person who died like a Suicide case or own blame like they Love telling Lies only to make there country look ""perfect, paradise, the strongest without flow" but love show fake thing, grappig things from other countries telling they have worse yet not showing the real contents and often making Falls news report like they "saved" a falling bus or helped people in the rain/flod while it all stages
Link pls
Tiananmen square is just western propaganda.
@@goodnightmyprince6734 Show proof he isn't. China doesn't get benefit of the doubt on these things.
Love the man's courage. He is a true citizen of China.
Yeah not the government but the nation, they are destroying a Great history
I would Say a True Freedom Fighter, and even a True patriot, because, a True patriot wants to ser his country prosperous and in Liberty,
We need more Americans with this man’s courage to speak out in American university against the corruption and wickedness in the U.S. system
I’m Chinese and I’m a hongkonger, I am a 10 yr old and I actually hate the party, it’s so lame.
@@tomchan4915 Nice bro keep strong
See that social / peer pressure ? That's how it is ... the society is already hardwired to such ideology and even if they're dissatisfied, nobody dares to speak out because none want any trouble for themselves. That's self censorship
Brave young man speaking up to whats right. He should be careful though cause we all know what happened to the young students who did that back in 1989
I'm sure this guy was punished severely.
He was educated on the downfalls of democracy
That boy's social credit score just plummeted. He's not suicidal, I repeat, he's not suicidal. 😢
There is no social credit score. Did they teach you this in class?
@@fungames24 they believe every anti china media lol
Yes he is suicidal, why else would he speak out smh
fr what the heck is a social credit score? never heard of it before
And we never saw him again 😢
Get this man out of there, he is not safe
Poor fellow couldn't take it anymore. I hope he can find peace where ever he may go now.
He's gonna find peace with Buddha unfortunately 🙏
he was jailed for 8 yrs i last heard
May God protect this young man
-10,000 social credit score.
This is how Communism was born in the first place. Bold and crazy folks shouting out loud in its name. The world needs such talents now.
The crazy part is most of these kids already have their mind brainwashed with those things and most of them laughing at this brave men like he's the crazy one. 💔
they're laughing because you would too if you were at university and someone just stood up and started speeling about his political views lmao
do you genuinely think that anyone gives a shit if you're not a communist? there's literally nothing stopping him from moving to the US if he's so upset
@@bombcat5517They have become apathetic and spineless, that's why they are at ease and comfortable with uncle xi controlling every aspect of their existence.
same is happening in europe. the genz is alrdy crazy washed..
It’s wild because you’re the brainwashed one
He sounds like a friend I would of liked in high school. 💯
I respect the dude. That's opening his eyes, he's the first of his kind to realize all these years, the people that were in charge due to chinese people never gave a shit about their people and he realized But yeah, all his classmates are still brainwashed So I hope there's more people in china like him slowly growing because I want the whole Damn world to wake up and say no to the elites and fight back in short, he's already one person, but when you have a thousand over the elites, What are they gonna do today? They're gonna be scared because thousands of people finally opened their eyes and turned against the government
How are they brainwashed? They are just not stupid enough to end their career over their own opinions, this guy is an idiot for doing this, hes just implying that he wants to ruin the rest of his life.
He now is in a "re-education" camp getting... "re-educated"
What's the thing that the US and China have in common?
Students from US can stand up and shout loudly that they don't like Republic.
Students from China can also stand up and shout loudly that they don't like Republic
And they both follow capitalism which is destroying our planet
Badass. Sucks that they're gonna make him apologize publicly or send him to re- education camp.
And the other young people are just laughing it’s sad to see honestly
How is it sad? They are laughing because they know the person who is shouting is a moron, they could also believe in the same theory as him but arent stupid enough to say that out loud, he now probably ruined his life now, for what? calling out a government?
I’ve done the same thing when I was at high school in 2008. The principal had a formal chat with me and said don’t do it again if you don’t want to get into troubles. One year later I took Gaokao exams and went to SYSU without any issues.
厉害
Why did you do it?
@@Mimi-xh9tk Because I didn't like CCP. Now I'm in Australia and dislike CCP less than how I did after years. My opinion is neutral now.
@@haonanma228 Whereabouts in Australia?
I admire the balls on this kid, but the smart thing to do is likely to just remain quiet about your criticisms. Not having free speech sucks, but self-preservation takes priority.
get his ass to a first world country. also, he looks healthy and mentally stable, he is not suicidal and doesn’t seem to have any health issues whatsoever.
Why do you want the first world country to indoctrated this child?
What free first world country do you suggest? Britain?
His healhty organs will get to a first world country indeed. 😅
😢....and then comitted the unthinkable...😂.
Bro is dead
Why not help him escape first before you conclude?
@@BudiBudi-oe4kz
By doing WHAT?
@@synthwavecat96 Try reading again, smartass!
@@BudiBudi-oe4kzleast obvious wumao lol
@@wayfarer6464 Wrong!
Then I never won't be able to say "TAIWAN IS A COUNTRY!" here, muthafckr!
중국은 발전한 북한입니다. 저 사람은 아마도 인체의 신비전에 전시되고 있을 겁니다.
Jesus😰
That dude would be welcomed in America with open arms
When I visited Germany, I had a conversation with a Chinese guy studying in a German university.
Even though he can do everything and say everything he wants, even though he lives a way better life by studying in Germany and having a really high-paying part-time job there (compared to what he would be paid in China), he still believes that China is a better country and the communist regime is superior.
We also had a conversation about why he thinks other people view China in a negative light. His response was pretty simple: Western propaganda.
While that can be the case in some instances, since countries like the US would greatly benefit from weakening China, he was unwilling to accept that sometimes, the Western media could be right and China can make mistakes.
He also didn't believe that propaganda exists in his country. He told me that if he can't fall for propaganda and even if China was to spread propaganda, it would be for the greater good.
I was surprised by one thing though: he told me nothing is truly "banned" in his country since most young people would use VPN and pirate Western media from Chinese sites that the CCP won't crack down on. I wasn't surprised by that, since my country does the same (even our prime minister mentioned how he downloads files from a Bulgarian piracy site), it was the fact that they know what a VPN is and they won't get in trouble for using one.
Places like North Korea banned VPNs, so I always assumed China did too (he even made a joke about China not being North Korea).
Although I knew that there's propaganda in China, I never knew how bad it was until I talked to an actual victim of brainwashing.
We had a lengthy conversation (most of it about table tennis, food, and our future) and ne never struck me as a liar. He genuinely believed what he was saying.
I wish him the best. He was really smart, so I hope he succeeds in life. It's just sad to see an intelligent young man being a victim of brainwashing since his birth.
Same goes for all Chinese and Macedonians: you're not a dumb nation for believing the propaganda. You were lied to from your childhood, so it's understandable that you will hate me and won't share the same opinions as me. Read, travel, talk to people and try to learn from all of that. Open your mind to different opinions and perspectives and when you find out you were wrong, don't be ashamed to admit it. We learn our entire life, contradictions in our point of view are bound to appear, so embrace them rather than shutting them down.
He must be fairly young, you have to understand that we were bombarded with political propagandas since 7/8 years old in China. A lot of nationalism in the education. Some people are more naive than others when it comes to things like this, some might came to a realization at later stage of life, I know I did when i was in college. For him, who knows, but most educated adults I know don’t buy these BS. People are more concerned with their own families and personal development.
Do you believe that the earth has billions of years and that humanity is the fruit of Evolution?
Do you believe in the survival of the fittest?
Do you believe in the relativity of truth?
If yes to these questions, it's because you've been taught from your youth that these are true. Your outlook on the world and your life are based on what you believe in, even are societies.
I think it's not entirely brainwashing, it is also values and history.
1. Westerners seem to have a hard time accepting that there are people who don't value freedom and individuality as much as they do. Like you mentioned, Asian societies value "greater goods" more. Also see the relationship of government x people differently from that of the west. In Asia, the government is the parent/father, the society is the children. It is expected for a parent to tell what the children must do, but they must do it with the best intentions at heart. It's Confucianism.
2. China used to be the leading society for cultures, science, and technology for thousands of years, until The West put them on their knees using opium. Chinese calls this "a hundred years of humiliation". Hence their resentment towards the west, and their ambitions to do things their own way, not the western way.
@MissNulis I'm really sick and tired of western people who believe they are living better life because they have more freedom and individuality. And they also bring wars to countries who don't believe in their lifestyle. Really makes me wonder what is in their head.
Wow skopia has communism. I didnt know 😢
That's not the fault of communism or capitalism, it depends how the government educate their future generation
What an edgy guy, lol. Notice all the smirks. You can tell the other students are like "we know, bro, but you're not supposed to say that out loud."
Edgy like indie/grunge or edgy like crazy?
It's hard to tell from the backs of their heads.
They probably support China’s ideology, considering China’s average iq is significantly higher than that in the US. They understand how communism works unlike people who’ve read zero theory in this comment section.
It does not matter. Chinese communist party isn't communist either.
Terrorists Party?..😂
@@neilcalonia2882authoritarian capitalism
China's economical system is actually pretty close to national socialist one. Won't touch ideology.
@@neilcalonia2882These are the USA and Israel 😂
@@fchicod US and ISRAEL care for their own country and their people and they don't claim territories more than what the law legally allow...the CCP doesn't
care about anything but themselves,selfish and "super duper"according to trump greeeeeeeddddddy...
Only problem is... he's going to be invited to tea.
You need more people like him to step up to that crap. I hope he is ok, not in jail or something else.
He is standing in the face of Death. The other students are already too far gone
Blud is gonna disappear💀
You don’t understand anything lmao, US propaganda is wild. He’ll be totally fine. They don’t just make you disappear in China, there is freedom of speech.
China is going anti communism and USA is going communism... Hilarious
China? Some people are China? US? Some leftist are the US?
USA going to become communism? More like USA owned by zionism
USA is a joke.
@@NiMareQ I'm from the US, don't say my side is a joke. Our side fights against communism. It's the dumb, leftoids in this country that are the joke.
@@NiMareQ So are you.
so braved to say it out loud.
The very same thing, almost identical is happening in Vietnam, and people still refuse to admit Vietnam is the lil China
how bad is it? i know vietnam has human rights problems but i always thought people there had more room to disagree
It's joever for bro
Yea I openly hate communism too.
Only difference is I can freely speak still.
AND I WILL FIGHT TO KEEP IT THAT WAY. I HAVE NEVER EXPERIENCED COMMUNISM, NOR DO I EVER WANT TOO.
the stories are enough for me
Why do you openly hate communism?
Fun fact China isnt communist it is an authoritarian capitalist regime. No country ever reached marx communism and if you actually Read the book you would know mark fought for freedom of speech , the workers and against inequalities he even predicted the destruction of the planet because of endless growth. Capitalism propaganda angainst communism exist and this is why they only teach about Marx and other philosophy from the greatest mind like Socrate, Épicure,etc in Canada but not in the US because the system would fall
@DUFFAL02 It is a garbage ideology for idiots
Someone better check on that kid..
Same thing happened in vietnam here. A 17 year old guy who managed to get into the olympic academic competition spoke out against the Party, and he imediately got to do business with the police force. Poor guy is just showing his thoughts, thus showing us all there is a certain restriction on freedom of speech here in vietnam
is vietnam still a communist country like china?? but how come there are so many big companies invested into the country if there is no change in the regime?
@@guessmoments 在中国投资的大公司更多，这世界并不都和西方一样，有的地方同性恋就是死刑，有的地方自由恋爱会被荣誉杀，有的地方宗教规范就相当于法律，中国和越南政治体制和西方不一样但只要有利可图上述这些地方资本都会进入。
@@guessmomentsYou are assuming companies care about political divides more than making more money. As for is it still communist... yes it is. But there are some sections of university students who are "moving away" from their parents political views, and lets put it at that.
@@butterlord6358 Yes, there are, but all ended up taken away and jailed like this fella here. jailed for 8 yrs i last heard
@@guessmoments Yep, in some of these cases they would be forced to make an official apology video to the party. Which is widespread on social news. And since people know who they are, their face, what they did...good luck getting any work at all. And consider how small of a country for such a big population...and the Asian "shaming" culture...further insults by neighbors and countrymen.
Pray for his safety 🙏🏻
Because in china these words can cause his death
this is china ,not north korea. In North Korea, just watching K-drama is get death penalty
this is china ,not north korea. In North Korea, just watching K-drama is get death penalty
The sadder thing is, it’s not even real communism
"Real communism" will never be because communism doesn't work.
Is this a Marxist I smell? It's never really "true" communism is it. Everytime it inevitably turns into a dystopia it's always "fake" communism. Give me a break
If all the bad guys say they are one thing, everyone calls them that thing, and no one else is calling themselves that thing. That thing is just what the badguys are, regardless of the made up definition of what that thing wants to be, is.
@@galenc1606 nope. You could call it what it is in most cases, fascist dictatorship. It’s not communism, so it’s not communism simple
Not the theoretical Communism, you mean. 🤔 Because what is happening in China is real. 🙄
I should’ve said this during my micro and macro Econ courses in the United States of America: I don’t believe in capitalism I’m sick of being sold capitalism as the end-all be-all of economic theory!
I wonder where he is today.. Or if he is at all.
I don't really like chinese government either but their philosophy and marxism are two different things. Nowhere in marx does it advocate for dictatorship and censorship, and it certainly doesn't call for bureaucracy of business leaders.
Right !!!! So much false information about Marx philosophy by capitalist propaganda which force us to consume products MADE IN CHINA destroying our planet . Capitalism isnt better and communism doesn't ban freedom
He was never heard from again.
It’s just a guy who hates studying politics. The fact that he can say this in the class means they have quite freedom of speech. Also China’s becoming global power, economically and militarily. Living standard’s improving. My rant, haha, my point is rebellious guys are everywhere regardless of whether they are right or wrong. The America is more chaotic, violent and hateful. Every personal opinion is personal. I wanna know more about OP, is he an expat? Or a Taiwanese who dislikes China?
N9
Yeah, meanwhile western country should definitely at least learn about marxism, because right now our economic ideology is shit.
And were they really learning about marxism? I feel like it would only point out a lot of contradictions between actual marxism and modern society in China 😅
that's what I was thinking. So many of these commentors are from USA and would never be allowed to learn marxist theory genuinely and they're being fed their own propaganda along with the most n*zi thing, the pledge of allegiance to the flag AT SCHOOL. Yet they think they're free and have no propaganda, but every country has an ideology and it is reflected in their education. Thinking you're free and there is no koolaid to drink, means you already drank it.
Right ? Marxism is not what China is following lol
Ooooooh, I thought I'd never see a comment like that. People always harp on Marxism and Communism as if this was what China is. China is NOT COMMUNIST. It's essentially a Capitalist Authoritarian hellscape.
Sure, westerners should learn what Marxism is to identify it and realize what a trash theory of value it is.
I can spend thousands of hours on a piece of art, but if no one wants it, it is effectually worthless. Just ask Ubisoft.
You got guts kid. I'll give you that.
Well China isn’t actually communist 🤷🏼♂️
Right ! Lol people thinking its the case are stupid . They need to Read the book about marxism! In Canada we learn about those in philosophy and also how capitalism is destroying our society .
As a Chinese myself, China is definitely far from perfect, but it also more definitely has a lot if good sides. I was born and raised in a different country because my parents left it and we went back to visit when I was young, but I might go back in the future sometime and actually visit it again now that im wonder
i never been to china or anything but from what i seen their culture goes hard. i got too much beef with the ccp to visit, they would see me as a terrorist cause i been reppin hong kong and taiwan, i know i would barely last a day if i even make it off the plane. im sad about that cause its such a cool country and a trip would be so much fun